Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal The Truth About the Conjuring's Ghost Hunters About this episode Ghost hunting couple Ed and Lorraine Warren transformed twentieth century America into an enchanted land dotted with haunted houses, cursed objects, and portals to hell. Their exploits are the basis for the Conjuring movie franchise. They are the originators of the Annabelle doll. They are the most famous demon hunters ever. Who were the Warrens? Did they make it up? Or did they believe it all?
Maddy and Anthony's guest today is Professor Joseph Laycock from Texas State University. He was our guest last week on our episode about the Amityville Horror. Joseph is the author of: The Penguin Book of Exorcisms and co-author of The Exorcist Effect: Horror, Religion, and Demonic Belief.
Edited & produced by Freddy Chick. Senior Producer is Charlotte Long.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers. Now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries. And I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Anton and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:50 Speaker 02 This is Steve Covino from Covino and Rich. Quick trivia, fellas. Every guy listening is a contestant. Answer honestly to yourself. You got a belly and a little chest? Gassed by the afternoon, no drive left in the tank? You lack that confidence and mental edge? Those are classic signs that your testosterone's been sliding. And nothing drags it down faster than extra weight. So why not take matters into your own hands? Strip off the weight that tanks your testosterone with Bioma GLP-1 Booster. Every serving is packed with science-backed ingredients that crank up your natural GLP-1 production. Visit bioma.health/GLP1 and use code CRSHOW for 15% off your first order.
1:35 Speaker 00 It's February 1976. A few weeks ago, George and Cathy Lutz abandoned their new home at 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, in horror.
1:48 Speaker 00 They began desperately seeking help, or rather, but we know them better now, desperately seeking for people to amplify and authenticate the tales they would tell.
2:01 Speaker 00 It's a crisp winter morning and now, standing at the bottom of the drive of that same 112 Ocean Avenue, are a middle-aged couple, Ed and Lorraine Warren. Ed is a heavy-set man with sunken eyes and a white jacket. Lorraine holds herself very straight, although there's a hint of nervous energy about her.
2:26 Speaker 00 At first glance, they seem ordinary, predictable even, respectable certainly. You would never guess that they will become some of America's most famous demon hunters. Despite their somewhat bland appearance, the Warrens are master storytellers who understand well the power of their trade. Beside them now is a local news crew along for the ride. In the decades that follow, cameras will continue to document the Warrens and their strange, shared occupation. And they welcome it, acting out their made-for-TV lives under the scrutiny of the lens. Over the course of their careers, they will unearth untold numbers of so-called demons
3:12 Speaker 00 and cases of alleged possession, catch supposed ghosts on camera, and testify in court to the presence of the devil. They'll amass a museum's worth of haunted memorabilia, help launch a multi-billion-dollar film franchise, and answer thousands of cries for help from families across America. But who were the Warrens? Were they cynical con artists? Or did they, in fact, believe it all?
4:08 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome back to After Dark. My name's Anthony.
4:12 Speaker 00 And I'm Maddie.
4:13 Speaker 01 And guys, before I do my proper actual job and introduce this topic and our guest, this is wild to me because I would count myself as a horror film fan. And I think I know the odd thing or two about horror films, but actually what I'm learning is that these all like feed into one another. All these American big 70s movies that have so shaped how we understand horror today, they all inherit from one another and they're all kind of part of the same moment. But anyway, look, I need to get off my job and then we can talk about all of those things. So last week, you know, we spoke about the story of Amityville, the most haunted house in America. We talked about the murders that took place in that house and how those murders then
4:55 Speaker 01 went on to secure a legacy of haunting for the location. But in today's episode, we are going to be talking about a story that's connected to that, but by two names in particular, and they are husband and wife ghost busting duo Ed and Lorraine Warren. Now, we learned in our Amityville episode about how the Exorcist had such a huge impact on American paranormal beliefs. And when we're looking at the progression of those beliefs, the Warrens are the very next step in that story. And I'd like to give you a quote here, and then I'll introduce the person who's written that quote. But I just think it's so interesting, and it's not, it's not something I was aware of. So let's, let's go with this first. So the quote says, "To understand how
5:40 Speaker 01 a new American mythology formed in the decades following the Exorcist, it is important to know as much as possible about who the Warrens were. They transformed 20th century America into an enchanted land dotted with haunted houses, cursed objects, and portals to hell." Now, that is from our guest today and our guest in the previous episode, Dr. Joseph Laycock, who is the Associate Professor of Religious Studies at Texas State University, and author of, as we've said in our last episode, the most well titled books, The Penguin Book of Exorcisms, and co-author of The Exorcist Effect: Horror, Religion, and Demonic Belief. Joseph, thank you so much for joining us once again.
6:22 Speaker 03 Have me back.
6:23 Speaker 00 So excited to get into the Warrens because as Anthony said, I do think they are absolutely fascinating. I'm looking at an image and I think this kind of sets the tone. So I'm going to describe it and it is from a case that we're going to get into later on in the episode. But I just want to give listeners a flavour of of what to expect.
6:37 Speaker 03 This is wild.
6:39 Speaker 00 Yeah. So I'm looking at a photo of what looks like the interior of a large, maybe a church, maybe a museum space in America. And there are people lined up in a queue. Most of them are just looking at their phones and there are barriers, metal barriers to keep them in place. And there's a table that's draped in cloth and on that table is, well, what I can only really describe as the stable from your grandma's nativity kit.
7:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:05 Speaker 00 It's got a crucifix below these little wooden eaves and it's probably, I don't know, about half a metre high, half metre wide, something like that. And there's another crucifix inside and inside there's electric light that's kind of pinky purply and the surprise object.
7:19 Speaker 03 Wait for us.
7:20 Speaker 00 Drum roll. Not a baby Jesus, but a very large, very plastic dinosaur. It's, it's, that's the tone. That's where we're going in. I'm absolutely gripped already. So, Jo, not only welcome back to After Dark, but what on earth is happening?
7:37 Speaker 03 So I've seen that plastic dinosaur with my own eyes and it was at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Connecticut at the Ed and Lorraine Warren Paracon. So this was an all day event, sort of celebrating the Warrens put on by their son in law. It was attended by about 5,000 people and the main attraction were these supposedly cursed objects from the Warrens cases that had been brought out from their museum of cursed and haunted objects in Connecticut.
8:08 Speaker 00 Absolutely phenomenal. I'm very jealous that we didn't go to that.
8:11 Speaker 03 I know.
8:12 Speaker 00 We need to do something like this ASAP. So, Jo, if we met Ed and Lorraine Warren at the height of their fame, at the height of their powers, who were they? What kind of people would we come across?
8:24 Speaker 03 So they presented as this ideal American couple, you know, a devoted Catholic husband and wife.
8:31 Speaker 03 Ed presented himself as a demonologist with this sort of advanced training and expertise on the nature of demons and ghosts and other types of supernatural creatures. And Lorraine presented herself as a psychic. She actually claimed that she had been tested for psychic abilities at the University of California in Los Angeles and that she was sort of an off the chart psychic. And so the division of labor is she would come in and get impressions about the types of history and entities going on in your house. And then Ed would apply his expertise and say, ah, Lorraine detected this, therefore this is the nature of your problem and this is how we're going to fix it together.
9:10 Speaker 00 Do we know exactly how many cases they were involved with? Because it it seems that the scale of this is is pretty phenomenal.
9:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, they were very, very busy. We don't know, and I'm sure they exaggerated. So by 1972, they were already claiming that they had had 2,000 cases. And in a tabloid column that they had, they even said, send us your cases and we have a cash prize if we like your case the best, right? So currently, the Conjuring franchise has been taking their their cases and making them into to movies. This is currently a billion dollar franchise, a billion with with a B. And they have no danger of running out of stories about the Warrens anytime soon. So I think it's going to continue to be lucrative for a very long time.
9:56 Speaker 00 So, Joe, tell us who the Warrens are, because they don't start off their careers, their their careers together as paranormal investigators, do they? They have a slightly different artistic bent, let's say.
10:09 Speaker 03 So the Warrens are from Bridgeport, Connecticut. They actually met at a movie theater where Ed Warren was working as an usher. Ed went off to go fight in World War II. They got married while he was still enlisted. And then in the 1950s, they tried to make a career as artists. And Ed's favorite subject to paint was haunted houses. So they would drive around New England and find spooky looking houses. And Ed would paint it and then Lorraine would sort of charm the owners and try to sell them a painting of their Own house and also see if there were any sort of spooky stories or phenomenon associated with the house.
10:47 Speaker 03 They formed the New England Society for Psychical Research, which I'm not really sure it did much, but it sounded kind of scientific. And then after The Exorcist came out, there was this huge demand of people who wanted an exorcism, who thought they were fighting something demonic in their house. But the Catholic Church was not in a place to help and would sort of direct them to therapists or mental health services instead. So this really created the marketplace for the Warrens to thrive. So they became as lay Catholics, not priests, the people that you could go to if you thought you needed help with the supernatural.
11:25 Speaker 01 And I'm looking at one of their early paintings now. I will say this painting is quite evocative in one sense. It's relatively rudimentary. If you know the Red Barn murder mystery, think of a building like that. It's red, it's wooden, it's quite peaked. It's covered in snow and there's some mud on the roads. It's not, it's not a bad painting. I wouldn't say by any stretch of the imagination, it's a masterpiece, but it's a very big leap from a plastic dinosaur in a case. And it just, I don't know, there's something in this that says storytelling, whereas the other thing seems exploitative. So what I'm interested in, I suppose, Joseph, is what's the the context that they go from these painters of houses to demon hunters?
12:08 Speaker 01 What's the context for this in the in the 1960s?
12:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, so we should talk a bit about Vatican II, but Vatican II from 1963 to 1965 totally changes the Catholic Church. So prior to that, all Catholic masses would have been in Latin. And they also probably would have begun with a prayer to Saint Michael to cast out Satan. And after that, they changed a lot of things. So mass is now done in whatever language the community speaks. And a lot of the things that were deemed superstitious by the public, so things like rosaries, cult of the saints and so forth. This was all toned down and they said, everybody is probably going to go to heaven, even if they're not. Catholic. So for progressive Catholics, this was great for more traditionalist Catholics,
12:55 Speaker 03 which included the Warrens, they really felt that their religion and their way of life was under attack, and especially on the issue of the devil and demons. So Ed Warren was one of the Catholics who said, I can't believe that I went to a Catholic priest, the person charged with protecting us from evil, and he told me Satan isn't real. He told me Satan is a metaphor. So we have to get everybody to believe in the devil again. And when I saw that plastic dinosaur at the Mohegan Sun Casino, the enclosure said, accept the existence of the devil. Those words were written above the plastic dinosaur. So a big part of what
13:36 Speaker 03 the Warrens were doing was this kind of pushback from lay Catholics that no, no, no, the devil is very real, and it's the job of the church to protect us from the devil.
13:45 Speaker 00 It's really interesting that what we're seeing with the Warrens is in some ways similar to the Amityville Horror story that we have discussed in in our previous episode, Joe, in that there is religious belief, there's superstition mixed in with that, separate and overlapping. And then there's popular culture. And it's what we see again with the Warrens, and when they become involved in Amityville, that they are, as you say, kind of part of this this traditional Catholic faith, but they utilize television and modernity in order to get that message out. So can you tell us a little bit about how they become involved in that case
14:30 Speaker 00 and what they do? And because they take a TV crew around with them, don't they? This seems like a pretty bold step forward from just itinerantly painting haunted houses and attempting to sell them to the owners.
14:44 Speaker 03 So the Warrens absolutely wanted to be famous. They wanted everyone to know who they were and about all their cases and so forth. And they got involved with the Amityville Horror because they were already in contact with a journalist who thought, you know, what would Make this an even better news story is if I could invite the Warrens out here and they could perform a seance inside the Amityville House. So that's what happened. They came out and they did a seance in front of news cameras. And Lorraine Warren said that she was not only a Catholic, but that she was a psychic. And so she could kind of use her psychic abilities to learn something about the nature of the disturbances in the house. So that really became one of their biggest
15:27 Speaker 03 cases. And when they made the Amityville Horror Two, the Warrens were consultants on that film. And I really think they spent a lot of the rest of their careers looking for a similar sort of media event, right? What could be the next Amityville Horror? And and by the end of their careers, you know, they had flyers if they were going to come give a lecture and that said that they were, you know, chief investigators in the Amityville Horror case. So they really, really hitched their wagon to to that story.
15:57 Speaker 01 And of course, we've done an episode previously on the Enfield Poltergeist. And they were momentarily, I suppose, not very involved in that case, but they did show up. They did a day, I believe it was at Enfield, but came away with very little. But this, in in one sense, you could say, Joe, that all of this is a little bit harmless, that, you know, they're turning up, they're claiming to be whatever. But there is a darker, more exploitative side to this. And and it feeds back to, as everything does eventually, that haunted dinosaur in the case that Matty described at the the top of this episode. Can you tell us a little bit about this? It's the the case of David Glazelle? Am I saying that correctly?
16:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, the the Glazels. Yeah, it's a complicated case. But you have these brothers called the Glazels. And the whole family had just watched The Exorcist on cable. This is in the 1980s. And the youngest, David, begins to act strange, and his mother interprets that this is a sign of demonic possession. And the mother and her daughter had also attended a talk recently by the Warrens. So they start to try to get the Catholic Church to perform an exorcism. And by the eighties, the Catholic Church is sort of in this transitional period where they're saying, well, okay, we're starting to do exorcisms, but it's still very kind of embarrassing and we don't want to, you know, overdo it. And you need the permission
17:24 Speaker 03 of a bishop to perform a true exorcism. But there are loopholes to this. And so they began performing what they called minor exorcisms. So they said, I don't have the permission of my bishop, so I can't do a proper one like you see in the movie, The Exorcist, but I can really strongly pray for you and bless you and try to protect you from evil. So they start doing these kinds of off-brand exorcisms over David. And, you know, what skeptics have said is if you tell a small child, there's a demon inside of you over and over again, you are psychologically priming them to behave in very strange ways. So it's almost a sort of self fulfilling prophecy. Now, the other thing that makes this case very complicated is there is a young man named Arnie Johnson, who is living with the
18:08 Speaker 03 family and who is dating the Glatzl's daughter and is very much in love with her. And she gets into an altercation with her boss and Arnie Johnson ends up stabbing the boss in this kind of argument where the boss is very drunk. And so he goes to the Warrens and the Warrens sort of come up with the story that the demon has jumped out of David Glatzl and into Arnie Johnson, and that's what made him commit this murder. And that this happened because Arnie Johnson challenged the demon that while David was thrashing, told the demon, leave that boy alone, come in to me. If you have seen The Exorcist,
18:50 Speaker 03 this is literally what happens at the end of The Exorcist. And now it was happening in real life. So the Warrens try to go to Arnie Johnson's murder trial and they actually find a lawyer who tries to say, my client is not guilty by reason of demonic possession. And a judge says, you cannot plead that in American law. And the Warrens begin saying, well, we have all these Catholic priests who can come in and testify. And the judge says, you don't understand, you could have the actual demon here on the witness. Right? There is no mechanism in our court for this. And so they they finally decide to plead insanity instead. And actually, Arnie Johnson turned out to be a model prisoner.
19:32 Speaker 03 And I think only served five years of his sentence, married his fiance and has been, you know, a model citizen ever since.
19:41 Speaker 00 It's fascinating, isn't it? That again, that intersection of now we've not only got popular culture and real life kind of interplaying in that way, but now we've got the law as well and the discussion around whether you can claim demonic possession in legal terms. In terms of the warrants turning up at that trial, Joe, do you see that as a publicity stunt? Do you think they had genuine interest in the case and wanted Arnie to be let off for the murder? Did they see him as genuinely having been possessed by a devil and therefore innocent of a crime? Or was their presence just a way of bolstering their own popularity and their own profile?
20:21 Speaker 03 Well, I don't think it has to be one or the other. You can't see beliefs, but I have no evidence to think that they didn't really believe Arnie Johnson was demonically possessed. But certainly Ed Warren expressed being very excited that this is it. We're finally going to get to prove in a court of law, this is all real. And I think for him, this was very personal, right? Because lots of people said, you know, the Warrens were just con artists and that this was all sort of silly and they were tricking people. And even people from Ed Warren's own church, right? Said there isn't really a devil. So I think he saw this as an opportunity to really prove all of these people wrong in the most sort of authoritative way that he could.
21:11 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow.
21:30 Speaker 01 Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
21:52 Speaker 04 Everyone talks about how challenging it is to raise kids, but what about protecting them? Outlet covers, kitchen cabinet locks, baby gates? Where do you even start? Well, protecting your home and auto is a great place to start. Progressive offers customized coverage options so you can be sure you have the right coverage. They're basically the baby gates of insurance. Get a quote at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers, not available in all states.
22:22 Speaker 05 As the saying goes, if these walls could talk. And on the Betwixt the Sheets podcast, we make it our business to discover what happened behind closed doors and even more importantly, in the bedrooms of people all throughout history. Kings, queens, mistresses, servants, and everyone in between. We also get up close and personal with medieval aphrodisiacs, lethal Victorian makeup routines, and look at the scandalous lives of beloved children's authors. Nothing is off limits. In other words, it's the best bits of history with me, Dr. Kate Lister. Listen to Betwixt the Sheets, the history of sex scandal and society, twice a week, every week, wherever it is that you get your podcasts. Brought to you by the award
23:07 Speaker 05 winning network, History Hit.
23:19 Speaker 01 There were loud voices who were very much saying that they were manipulative and that they were abusive. And I have another quote here from horror author Grady Hendricks, and it's quite interesting. Grady Hendricks says, "For the record, I could not have a lower opinion of a human being than I have of Ed and..." And Lorraine. I don't think they were well intentioned. I don't think they were good people. I think they saw situations and exploited them, and I think they did untold harm to people. You can't go into a place where people are undergoing the kind of emotional and psychological and even physical trauma that people who are in some of these situations are and say, oh yeah, well, I know
24:01 Speaker 01 the answer. These are demons. It's quite a damning, it's quite a damning insight, you know, depending on what side of this argument you were to take.
24:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, great. And Trix was not a fan of the Warrens and a lot of people that we spoke to who knew them personally kind of regarded them as being cynical con artists. The Glatzl brothers had a plan to write a book basically saying that, you know, the Warrens kind of ruined our lives, right? You know, one of us had sort of minor mental health crisis and the Warrens made that exponentially worse and it kind of tore our family apart also that they could make a buck. Now, recently, there was a Netflix documentary about the Glatzls and I think that they decided not to publish their book and that they had kind of better sort of financial opportunities working with Netflix. So that's one example of this. There was also a book written about the Warrens
24:54 Speaker 03 cases called Satan's Harvest about a very disturbed individual that they were trying to treat for demonic possession, who ended up actually murdering his wife and was arrested for basically sexually molesting his daughter. And Ed Warren tried to say, well, but that was not really this man. That was an incubus demon in his shape. To me, that really seemed like a smoking gun, that they were kind of sometimes using a belief in demons to excuse pretty inexcusable behavior. So, so that line was certainly crossed in a few cases at least.
25:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, their ethics seem at best very questionable. Joe, I want to ask you about evidence because we've seen the presentation of the haunted dinosaur and we know that they took film crews with them. Did they ever fake evidence? Or did they simply put forward the idea that something invisible that you couldn't tangibly prove was happening? I'm thinking in particular about a photograph of a ghost that they are associated with.
25:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, they did fake evidence, right? So Ed's first book that he put out, it came out in 1973, the year The Exorcist came out. And he said, because I am such a highly respected demonologist, the church has shown me secret documents about the actual true story that The Exorcist is based on. And, you know, begins to say, and I know who this girl actually was and so forth. Well, we now know it wasn't a girl, it was a boy, right? So there's no charitable interpretation of that. He was simply lying and saying that he had access to things that he did not have. One of the sort of trophy photos that the Warrens really were proud of and felt proved that their investigations were uncovering something is a photo from a seance at the
26:42 Speaker 03 Amityville Horror House of what looks like a sort of pale child's face poking out. And they say that this is a ghost that they've sort of captured on camera. What skeptics say is this is probably a neighbor's child who has ventured into the into the seance because there were a bunch of news vans parked out front. I spoke with Matt Baxter, who accompanied Ed Warren for the show Sightings in the 90s. They were at an allegedly haunted house and they were saying, can you hear things on the roof? I think the demons are dropping things on the roof. And he sees this rock roll off the roof. And then Ed Warren comes around from the other side of the building. And he finally says, Ed, this is not a proper investigation. I think people are faking evidence.
27:26 Speaker 03 I think you threw a rock on the roof. And Matt says that Ed took him aside and said, listen, all these people are crazy. They would never have called us in the first place unless they were crazy. So just play along. So there are lots of cases like this where I think they probably faked evidence. They may have also actually believed that supernatural things were happening. So this could be a case of what's sometimes called a pious fraud, right? Where they said, well, it's so important that people know the truth about the supernatural and about demons, that it's actually worth it to occasionally fake evidence if that is the lie that will help them see the truth.
28:03 Speaker 01 There seems to be, and also in popular culture, Joe, there seems to be a never ending array of cases that are linked to the Warrens somehow. We talked about NPL, we talked about the Amityville, but like they're all coming back to the Warrens somehow. Is there a particular case that you find sticks out a bit for you?
28:21 Speaker 03 The case that baffled us the most is probably their most famous, and that's Annabelle, this allegedly haunted doll. Annabelle is on display in their museum, and the actual Annabelle is a sort of off-the-rack, raggedy and doll. And it's in another one of these enclosures, like the plastic dinosaur. It has a devil tarot card taped to the glass for some reason. And it says, you know, "Warning: Never, ever open this." So Annabelle was brought to the Mohegan Sun Casino, and that was what everybody wanted to see. It was sort of throngs of people trying to get as close as possible to Annabelle. And they were actually selling Annabelle vodka, which was vodka that had been put in the basement with Annabelle.
29:06 Speaker 03 And the door that says "never, ever open," they opened that up so that these bottles could sort of absorb as much evil energy from Annabelle as possible. And it was selling for $200 a bottle. The bottle came with gloves to protect yourself from the evil, but then if you proceed to drink it, that would seem to defeat the purpose of the gloves. But people were purchasing them. The story of Annabelle is that these nursing students were experiencing kind of haunting phenomena, and they came to believe that this was a sort of lost spirit of a child living in their house. The spirit asked them, using a Ouija board, if it could live inside this doll, if it could live inside Annabelle.
29:50 Speaker 03 And then things only continued to get worse, and people were reporting scratch marks when they visited the home, and Annabelle was moving by itself. And when the warrants were called in, they said, "This was never a dead little girl. This was always a demon. It tricked you. You used the Ouija board. You violated the law of invitation because it asked permission to live in a doll, and you gave it that permission. So now we're gonna have to come, and we're gonna have to take this doll to our museum where we can house things like this, and sort of get all the evil out of your house." This was the only case that we looked at by the warrants where we simply could not confirm that any of this ever happened. All of the other cases, these are at least real.
30:31 Speaker 03 People, their real locations. But with Annabelle, you know, we looked at different versions of the story and the names are inconsistent. Uh, there's no locations, there's nothing to anchor this to reality. So we were forced to at least suspect that they maybe just went to a toy shop and bought a doll. And invented this entire story from from whole cloth. But you know, there are other dolls in Ed Warren's museum. We even found an old article from nineteen eighties. Where he is talking about cabbage patch dolls, which were a big fad toy in the nineteen eighties. And saying that these are conduits for evil and that he's had to. Uh, exercise and and bury numerous cabbage patch dolls. So.
31:15 Speaker 03 But but in a way, I think that Ed Warren, as an artist, kind of saw a potential here, right? That I can't be the only one who thinks dolls are creepy. And and he was quite right about that.
31:26 Speaker 01 It really is fascinating because we come to a lot of these histories. From, you know, Middle Ages up to relatively modern histories and stories. And, you know, the podcast is called After Dark and there's always this dark element to the history that we look at. But sometimes the darkness lies in places that we don't necessarily start out looking. So for instance, in this case, we talk about. Demons, we talk about, and we think that's the darkness. We think whatever, you know, the the Amityville horror ghosts and slime coming through the walls, that's that that's the dark. But when you drill down into it, sometimes it's the the human actions and interactions and exploitative.
32:06 Speaker 01 Elements to people's nature and sometimes that's the actual real dark underlying some of these human histories. But keeping that in mind, Joe, I'd I'd love to know. What you think? The Warren's legacy is because it's really profound, actually. We're left with this very pop culture. You know, ghost busting duo. Image of them from the Conjuring movies, let's say, or from from whatever iterations they've also come across in the twenty first century. But but what do you think their legacy is in terms of that kind of historio paranormal world?
32:42 Speaker 03 I think that the Warrens have really changed the way that we think about the folklore of things like haunted houses and demons. So when Ed Warren said he was a demonologist, he did not do any sort of formal study of theology or history, and he admitted that. He said, "My, my training is from the School of Hard Knocks," right? But he would sort of come up with these ideas about how demons work. So one of these is what he called the law of invitation. So he said, "If demons are harassing you, it's always your fault. You did something to invite them in." And often, that would be the Ouija board or something like this, right? That's still a way that a lot of modern Americans think
33:27 Speaker 03 about demons. The other thing that they would do is if you thought you had a haunted house, that there was maybe a spirit of the dead in your house, Lorraine would say, "The spirit here has never walked the earth in human form." And that was how she described demons. So that actually made your situation much, much scarier, right, to bring the Warrens in. It's not grandma is looking for her lost glasses or something. It's a demon. It's the worst thing that you can imagine. And, and so this kind of image of Ghostbusters sort of crossing the country, hitting all of these locations where demons are on the loose, or there are portals to hell, and then using this elaborate toolkit of sort
34:12 Speaker 03 of Catholic folk religion and psychic powers and fringe science to stop them, you know, this is kind of a new folklore. So when I watch shows like Supernatural about two brothers crossing America in a black Impala fighting monsters, I think this is all the legacy of, of the Warrens. I think they have sort of created a unique idea of America as a supernatural haunted landscape.
34:39 Speaker 00 The thing that most interests me about the Warrens is how charismatic, I suppose, they must have been. And I'm very interested in hoaxes anyway. I'm writing a book at the moment about hoaxes in the 18th century. And in the cases that I'm looking at, it's very much personality and individual led. It's about stepping into the internal logic of the worlds that these people occupy that they believe are real and often, as you've laid out, Jo, are capable of producing a hoax and carrying out a hoax, but also believing elements of it. And it's not one or the other often. And I just wonder what it was in your mind about the Warrens that drew people to them and that allowed them to operate
35:23 Speaker 00 in this way? Because as we heard in the opening introduction of this episode, they didn't look particularly unusual. They looked like many, many other white, middle-class respectable people in America. So what was it about them that allowed them to step into this role?
35:46 Speaker 00 I was gonna say light, but it's into the darkness, really.
35:48 Speaker 03 What everyone who met the Warrens said was they remind you of your parents, right? That they're Rockwellian, American nuclear family. And that's how they presented themselves. And they cultivated that image very, very well. And I mean, literally, everybody said this. So I spoke with people who had worked with the Warrens, writing books for them. And even if they came away with very negative feelings about the Warrens, said, you know, when I first met them, they truly seemed like the perfect American couple. And I even knew someone from college who met Lorraine Warren near the end of her life and said the same thing, that these were sort of my idealized parents, right? And I'm a child
36:32 Speaker 03 of divorce, and they seem kind of like the perfect parents that I never had. So if you're frightened as a child who comes in and chases the monsters away, it's your parents. So there's almost a psychological element to the way that they were able to help people who were actually, in many cases, quite scared and didn't really feel like they had anyone else to turn to.
36:55 Speaker 01 And therein, I suppose, is the place to wrap this particular conversation up. If you've enjoyed this episode, please go back and listen to our previous episode with Joe, where we talked about the Amityville Horror in more detail. It really feeds into some of the discussion we've had in this episode, too. Tell your friends about Outer Dark and leave us a five-star review wherever you get your podcasts, because that helps other people to find us. Until next time, happy listening.
Previous Banshees: Herald of Death Next Inside the Victorian Asylum Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated