Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the history of werewolf trials in sixteenth and seventeenth-century Europe, examining how mythological creatures crossed over into real-life legal accusations, torture, and executions. Hosts Antony Delaney and Maddy Pelling discuss specific historical cases, such as the 1521 trial of Michel Verdun and his accomplices in France, the 1589 trial of Peter Stump in Bedburg, Germany, and the 1691 trial of Theus of Caltonbrun in Livonia. The hosts analyze the heavy overlap between werewolf accusations and witch trials, noting how both relied on alleged pacts with the devil, confessions extracted under torture, and deep-seated rural anxieties about protecting livestock, crops, and children from external threats. The discussion highlights how these trials served as sensationalized true-crime narratives of their day, while also reflecting broader cultural anxieties surrounding gender, mental illness, and male violence.
- Early modern werewolf trials frequently shared common motifs with witch trials, including alleged pacts with the devil and brutal executions. 38:12
- Unlike the female-coded accusations typical of witchcraft, werewolf accusations in Europe were predominantly leveled against men. 5:43
- Publicized pamphlets and broadsides about werewolf trials functioned as the sensationalized true crime stories of the early modern era. 41:07
- Some defendants, such as Theus of Caltonbrun in 1691, openly admitted to being werewolves without claiming any association with the devil. 48:42
Chapters
- 0:00Introduction and Podcast Promotion
Hosts open the episode, promote new History Hit documentaries, and set the stage for the werewolf trials discussion.
- 1:50Setting the Historical Context
The hosts explain the 16th–17th century backdrop, the rise of werewolf accusations, and their relation to witch trials.
- 3:27Folklore and Transformation Mechanics
Discussion of how werewolf lore varied over time, including physical transformation, magical belts, and the link to the devil.
- 9:03The 1598 Trial and Print Culture
Exploration of how pamphlets and broadsides spread werewolf stories across Europe, turning them into sensational true‑crime tales.
- 22:16First European Trial: 1521 France
Hosts examine the earliest recorded werewolf trial, its accusations, and the reliability of demonological sources.
- 31:21Peter Stump of Bedburg, 1589 Germany
A detailed look at the infamous Cologne case, the alleged pact with the devil, torture confessions, and execution.
- 47:57Conclusion and Reflections
Wrap‑up of the episode, reflecting on the overlap with witch trials, mental illness, and the enduring myth of the werewolf.
- 50:40Werewolf Myth vs. Pack Reality
Hosts discuss the common lone wolf image versus real wolf packs and how folklore misrepresents werewolves.
- 51:25Protectionist Themes in Folklore
Exploration of werewolves as protectors of crops and livestock, and the idea of magical defense against famine.
- 52:01Trial Outcomes and Judicial Attitudes
Analysis of historical werewolf trials, judge reactions, and the legal consequences faced by accused individuals.
- 53:08Break & Guest Interlude
Short break followed by a brief interlude with Dan Snow, providing a humorous contrast to the main discussion.
- 54:26Historical Context of Trials
Hosts examine the early modern period, the spread of werewolf stories through pamphlets, and the unclear source material.
Highlights
- 12:29
Coexistence of Religion and Magicinsight
The hosts reference Keith Thomas's text Religion and the Decline of Magic to explain how religious institutions and magical beliefs uneasily coexisted during the early modern period across Europe.
- 13:57
Oils and Wolf Skinsinsight
Early modern imaginations attributed physical transformation into wolves to various methods, including donning a dedicated wolf skin or rubbing a mysterious magical oil onto the skin.
- 23:29
The First European Werewolf Trialstory
In 1521 France, a traveller fought off an aggressive wolf and followed a blood trail that led directly to the home of a local shepherd named Michel Verdun, who bore matching wounds.
- 31:21
In 1589 Germany, a wealthy widower and farmer named Peter Stump was accused of being a werewolf, committing murders, and cannibalism, ultimately facing extreme torture and execution.
- 38:50
Execution of Family Membersdata
Unlike standard witch trials where relatives were rarely targeted by association in the same way, Peter Stump's daughter and mistress were also executed alongside him.
- 48:19
The Livonian Werewolf Trialstory
In 1691, an elderly Livonian man named Theus of Caltonbrun stood trial and testified that he and other werewolves descended into hell to fight Satan and protect community crops.
- 52:05
Judge Rejects Supernatural Claimsstrategy
Rather than condemning Theus of Caltonbrun as a dangerous werewolf, the presiding judge dismissed the supernatural claims as a waste of time and sentenced him to lashes for promoting superstition.
Quotes
“Peter's flesh is torn with red-hot pincers, his bones are shattered one by one.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:05 “This, instead, is a true story of accusations, arrests, trials, and bloody executions”
Unnamed speaker · 2:08 “which is why we're talking about it, because it's so very easily overlooked as a bit of a nonsense,”
Unnamed speaker · 4:06 “is a pact with the devil, in terms of this early modern werewolfery.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:18 “I'll reference a book that we've all read at undergrad, and actually I was obsessed with the idea of it.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:25 “Which is very on-wolf-like, because that's not how actual wolves operate.”
Unnamed speaker · 51:01 “I think this is, again, this gendered aspect.”
Unnamed speaker · 59:24 “And I think this is, again, this gendered aspect.”
Unnamed speaker · 59:24
Sponsored segments
- History Hit 0:04–0:48
- Heart 19:59–20:36
- Dan Snow's History 20:39–21:32
- Dan Snow's History Podcast 53:27–54:19
- Afterdarkhistory.com 1:03:00–1:03:14
About this episode
You've heard of the witch trials, but have you heard of the werewolf trials?! This fascinating history takes us to back to the 16th and 17th centuries, when panic spread through villages in mainland Europe leading to a number of people being tried and executed as werewolves. What evidence did they have? How did they believe you turned into a werewolf? And why did one man in 1691 claim to be a werewolf fighting evil? This episode was edited by Anna Brant. Produced by Stuart Beckwith and McKenna Fernandez. The senior producer was Freddy Chick. Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe. You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK. All music from Epidemic Sounds. After Dark is a History Hit podcast. History Hit is part of Little Dot Studios, a Certified B Corp™ Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript
11,403 words · 4 speakers
Topics
- Europe
- Twilight
- Dog Soldiers
- France
- Germany
- Latvia
- Estonia
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated