The Dark Side of the Brothers Grimm Fairy Tales
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal
- 58m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In this episode of After Dark, hosts Anthony Delaney and Maddy Pelling examine the dark, complex origins behind the famous fairy tales collected by the Brothers Grimm in 19th-century Germany. The hosts explore how Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm gathered these stories not by wandering rural villages as popular culture suggests, but largely by relying on upper-middle-class social circles and female informants, particularly women from lower or middle-class backgrounds like Dorchin Wilde and Dorothea Weinman whose contributions were routinely sidelined. Through detailed breakdowns of Hansel and Gretel, Cinderella, and Rapunzel, the hosts contrast the familiar sanitized adaptations with the violent body horror, starvation anxieties, and patriarchal control present in the original texts. Ultimately, the episode sheds light on how romantic nationalism, folklore collecting, and the erasure of women's intellectual labor shaped the fairy tales told today.
- Understand that the Brothers Grimm did not travel the countryside collecting tales themselves, but relied heavily on oral stories told by women. 6:55
- Recognize that the initial 1812 publication of Kinder und Hausmärchen was primarily targeted at adults interested in romantic German nationalism and identity. 10:20
- Note that the original version of Cinderella features the stepsisters mutilating their own feet by cutting off toes and heels to fit the golden shoe. 40:57
- Keep in mind that folkloric tropes like deep forests often reflected genuine historical anxieties regarding starvation, outlaws, and exposure. 29:36
Chapters
- 0:00Intro and History Hit Announcement
Hosts introduce the episode and promote History Hit documentaries.
- 0:53Episode Overview and Grimm Brothers Intro
Hosts explain the focus on Grimm Brothers’ original tales and set the stage for the discussion.
- 3:22Who Were the Brothers Grimm?
Hosts give biographical background on Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, noting their upbringing and early interests.
- 6:37From Law to Folklore: Their Early Collection
The brothers shift from legal studies to collecting folk tales, publishing their first anthology in 1812.
- 8:40Cinderella: A Darker Fairy Tale
The episode explores the Grimm version of Cinderella, noting its harsher themes and the role of the stepmother.
- 17:32Women as Storykeepers
Discussion of how women—nannies, servants, and collectors—provided the Grimm Brothers with their material.
- 21:25Hansel and Gretel: Dark Origins
Hosts recount the Grimm version of Hansel and Gretel, highlighting its grim elements and moral lessons.
- 47:46Rapunzel Preview
Hosts introduce Rapunzel, hinting at the forthcoming discussion of its original narrative.
- 49:08Rapunzel’s Enslavement and Tower Isolation
Rapunzel is taken by Mother Gothel, raised as her own, and locked in a tower with no doors, illustrating themes of confinement and control.
- 51:10Reunion, Blindness, and Happily Ever After
The prince regains sight through Rapunzel’s tears, they reunite, and the story concludes with a traditional happy ending, despite earlier hardships.
- 52:21Critique of Female Agency in Fairy Tales
Hosts discuss how women in Grimm stories are portrayed as chattel, lacking agency, and how these narratives reflect broader gender dynamics.
Highlights
- 3:55
Who Were the Brothers Grimm?insight
The hosts introduce Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, born in the 1780s into a Calvinist family in Hesse, who abandoned law careers in favor of romantic poetry and medieval folklore.
- 6:55
Relying on Female Storytellersinsight
The hosts debunk the myth of the Grimm brothers roaming the roads, explaining that they depended entirely on women like housekeepers, nannies, and family friends who passed down oral traditions.
- 12:33
Parallel to Samuel Johnsoninsight
The hosts compare the arduous, lifelong task of compiling folklore to Samuel Johnson's creation of the English dictionary, noting the sheer exhaustion of maintaining such massive anthologies.
- 20:36
The True Source of Hansel and Gretelstory
The hosts reveal that the tale of Hansel and Gretel was provided to the Grimm brothers by Dorchin Wilde, a pharmacist's daughter who eventually married Wilhelm Grimm.
- 21:25
Famine and Parental Abandonmentinsight
The hosts discuss how the original plot of Hansel and Gretel reflects real historical anxieties about starvation and famine in Germany, where parents resorted to abandoning children they could no longer feed.
- 34:34
Dorothea Weinman's Massive Contributiondata
Dorothea Weinman, a Huguenot tailor's widow, contributed 36 tales to the Grimm collection, yet the brothers simplified her identity in credits as a simple peasant woman to bolster folk authenticity.
- 40:07
Pigeons Exposing the Bloody Slipperstory
In the original Cinderella, the prince sets a trap with pitch on the stairs, and when the stepsisters mutilate their feet to fit the golden shoe, pigeons warn the prince that the shoe is full of blood.
- 50:38
Rapunzel's Pregnancy and Isolationstory
The hosts explore the darker narrative of Rapunzel, where the sorceress discovers Rapunzel's secret pregnancy by the prince, cuts off her hair, and casts her out into the wilderness to fend for herself.
Quotes
“They are not necessarily suitable for children to read.”
Unnamed speaker · 9:59 “The Grimm Brothers are standing on the shoulders of women.”
Unnamed speaker · 19:44 “The forest is this place of kind of wild abandonment.”
Unnamed speaker · 29:36 “The father agrees in order to escape.”
Unnamed speaker · 49:03 “They're almost not characters in the story, right?”
Unnamed speaker · 52:44 “Those are the real heroes here. Thank you to the Grimm Brothers for setting them down in print, but let's not forget the women behind them.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:00:22
Sponsored segments
- History Hit 0:00–0:48
- Dan Snow's History Podcast 26:45–27:25
- After Dark 1:00:49–1:01:24
About this episode
When the studious, unassuming brothers Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm left home for university, little did they know their fairy-tale collections would take Europe by storm. We've all heard of Cinderella, Hansel and Gretel, and Rapunzel. But how well do we really know them? From severed limbs, blinded lovers, and some good old-fashioned cannibalism, these deliciously dark tales continue to entrance and horrify audiences today. Join Anthony and Maddy for a very After Dark-coded story time, as they explore and dissect the origins of these disturbing 'children's' stories. This episode was edited by Hannah Feodorov. Produced by Hannah Feodorov. The senior producer was Freddy Chick. Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe. You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK. All music from Epidemic Sounds. After Dark is a History Hit podcast. History Hit is part of Little Dot Studios, a Certified B Corp™ Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript
11,647 words · 4 speakers
Topics
- Disney
- Grimm's Law
- Great Vowel Shift
- Gottingen
- Berlin
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated