Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal Dark Side of Ancient Rome's Colosseum About this episode In today's episode, we're taking you inside the towering walls of Ancient Rome's Colosseum to find out the dark reality of what happened there.
From the sex appeal of gladiators, to the choreographed means of human sacrifice, and the eternal question: did they really have sharks in there?!
Joining Anthony and Maddy today is historian and Rome-based tour guide, Alexander Meddings, https://alexandermeddings.com/ to take us back to this world.
Edited by Amy Haddow. Produced by Stuart Beckwith. Senior Producer is Charlotte Long.
Please vote for us for Listeners' Choice at the British Podcast Awards! Follow this link https://www.britishpodcastawards.com/voting, and don’t forget to confirm the email. Thank you!
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube! www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers. Now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries. And I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Anton and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:50 Speaker 02 Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes. A 2027 Jeep Cherokee, a Carnival Cruise vacation, gift cards from DoorDash, and Best Buy. Feel the play in the McDonald's app. Get your bag.
1:08 Speaker 03 No purchase necessary. 50 US and DC. Age 18+. See playatmcd.com for rules and playatmcd.com/amoe for info and playing without purchase by mail by November 2nd. Chess card game ends November 8th. Game ends November 22nd, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Hasbro.
1:23 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to After Dark. Now, in today's episode, we are going right to the very heart of the drama in the ancient Roman world, the Colosseum. And here's Mari to tell you a little bit more.
1:36 Speaker 00 Beneath the Colosseum, it's dark. Down here, the air is thick with the stench of sweat and wild animals, their cries echoing from distant cages, deeper still into the amphitheatre.
1:51 Speaker 00 Sand falls from the wooden platforms overhead, their planks creaking with the weight of a baying crowd. The same sand that will soak up the gladiator's blood in the heat of action.
2:04 Speaker 00 Our gladiator stands in silence, waiting for his moment, knowing it must be close. Though what's waiting for him out on the arena floor, he has no idea. He tries to stay limber, under the weight of his armour, shifting from leg to leg, his sword heavy in his hand. A pulley groans, as slaves heave heavy ropes, and now, from its dark underbelly, the Colosseum, this magnificent and horrifying monster, begins to stir into life. Trapdoors slide open like the lid of a tomb, and our gladiator steps forward into sharp light, to whatever fate is awaiting him. His journey to this point has been shaped by violence, and it's only fitting that
2:49 Speaker 00 it will end in this, a monument to the Empire's absolute dominance over life and death. While the crowd screams in a heady mix of horror and delight, a bloody concoction of punishment and storytelling unfolds before them. Entertainment has never been so deadly. But this is not just a story of ancient games. This is a story about what a civilization is willing to sacrifice for spectacle. This is After Dark, and this is The Dark Side of Rome's Colosseum.
3:52 Speaker 01 Hello, it's Anthony.
3:53 Speaker 00 And I'm Maddie.
3:55 Speaker 01 Yes, she still is.
3:55 Speaker 00 I forgot who I was then.
3:57 Speaker 01 Just who she is, but she is still Maddie.
3:59 Speaker 00 I'm too excited to do this episode.
4:01 Speaker 01 I am actually really excited to do this episode. Because this episode, as Maddie was saying, there is all about the Colosseum. And actually, if you've travelled and if you've seen the Colosseum, then you know that it's often, very often, romanticised. But actually, it's got a really rich and often very grisly history. And that is the history that we are going to have to explore in this episode. Now, we can't do this alone, so we have been joined once again by historian and travel writer Alex Meddings. Alex, thank you for joining us again on After Dark.
4:27 Speaker 04 Thank you for having me back on.
4:29 Speaker 01 This is one of those ones that people, and I am including myself in this, that people probably think they know how we're going to discuss this. But actually, as I was reading the briefing notes for this episode, I was thinking to myself, I actually don't know the history of the Colosseum at all. It's a whole different thing than what I thought I was getting into. So I am really, really excited to chat about it. Alex, tell us about the world that the Colosseum is built in at this time, just to give us some kind of historical grounding before we get into the details of what we're going to be talking about.
5:02 Speaker 04 We're in the first century AD and we're towards the beginning of the Roman Empire, a period in which you have essentially one emperor who is in control of Rome at the political pinnacle, rather than the republic. So rather than a bunch of senators who are all making the decisions. And the Colosseum is built throughout the 70s AD, but really, we have to go back a little bit before to the reign of Nero to understand the context behind which the Colosseum was built. And so during the reign of Nero, a great fire breaks out in the year 64, for which Nero is held accountable by some sources. And this fire decimates about a third of the city, including the area where the Colosseum will later be built.
5:46 Speaker 04 And Nero uses the devastation here to build himself an enormous golden palace, known as the Domus Aurea, which you could still actually visit today in Rome.
5:57 Speaker 00 Because that's what everyone wants when their city is burned down, a giant palace for the emperor.
6:01 Speaker 04 A massive vanity project.
6:02 Speaker 00 Of course.
6:04 Speaker 04 And it was meant to be this splendid architectural achievement, which had a kind of revolving, rotating roof on the dining room, its own woodland and forest, and its own artificial lake in the valley between the Cilian Hill and the Opian Hill, which is where the Colosseum will be built. And when Nero falls from power, in the year sixty-eight, there is a revolt against him, and Nero is declared an enemy of the people and forced to commit suicide. After this, Rome enters a really tricky period. It enters a year of civil war, known as the Year of the Four Emperors, the year sixty-nine. And in this year, you have four successive emperors who hold on to power for often comically short amounts of time and end in comically grisly ways.
6:48 Speaker 04 And out of all of this, a family emerges called the Flavians, the Flavian Dynasty. You have a father called Vespasian, called Titus Vespasianus Flavius, and you have his son, known as Titus. And they've been away fighting against the Jews over in Jerusalem, Judea, putting down a revolt. And they come back to Rome and they have to try and ingratiate themselves with the Roman people after a period of very destructive civil war. And they realise that the best way to do this is to make a big gesture, a big propagandistic political gesture. And this gesture is to reappropriate the private land of Calicula, so to reappropriate
7:28 Speaker 04 this giant pleasure palace, which Nero built for himself, and to give it back to the people by building something for the public. And what they settle on is an amphitheatre, a venue where they can have lots of games and spectacles, and they can use these spectacles to promote their own dynasty and their own family.
7:48 Speaker 00 So would you say that this is not only a space of entertainment then, but it's kind of built as a political machine, that this is architecture for politics?
7:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, very much so. And so the emperor is going to use the Colosseum as a place where he can be seen and where he can set out his agenda on the sands of the arena below. So you've got somebody at the top, like a figurehead, who is determining the content that appears. And then you're getting people who are voluntarily entering this space for free, in both cases, and they're witnessing this kind of awful bloody material play out, which kind of plays upon their primal instincts. Now, in this space, the emperor appears, in the case of the Roman Empire in the Imperial Box, and he's giving the illusion to the people in this forum that they have a voice and they can use this space to communicate with the emperor, or communicate with this figurehead.
8:44 Speaker 04 But in reality, that's not really happening. But the important thing is the emperor is seen in this space. And it's also keeping people entertained and it's keeping them frightened because you're importing all sorts of beasts from the farthest flung reaches of the Roman Empire. And you're showing them to people for the first time, rhinos, hippos, lions. And you're kind of saying, there be dragons, very scary stuff, but here, under my protection, under the protection of the Roman Empire, you're safe.
9:12 Speaker 00 It's such a complex and fascinating space, isn't it? We know just in terms of like the actual size of it, the Colosseum stood about 50 metres tall, which was 165 feet, and can hold somewhere between 50,000 and 80,000 spectators. But even within that scale, there's something about the proximity of ordinary people to, yes, these extraordinary spectacles, these extraordinary creatures, these extraordinary athletes, these gladiators, but also to the emperor himself. And that there's, that must have been somewhat unusual, right? That you can come into a space where you are in that physical proximity and you can see the literal physical emperor. How often did that happen elsewhere in Roman public life?
9:55 Speaker 04 Quite rarely. You would see the emperor all the time on coins, even if you're not living in Rome, but throughout the empire, you're going to get his portrait appear on coins, sculptures, statues. But in Rome itself, not that often. The other place where you'll see him a lot, however, is the Circus Maximus, which is the main chariot racing track and by far a bigger venue than the Colosseum. If the Colosseum could hold about 50 to 80,000 people, the Circus Maximus could perhaps accommodate in the region of 250 to 300,000. Whoa. So about a third of Rome's population. That's ridiculous. Wow. And the emperor's appearing there too. And that was arguably a more popular sport, chariot racing, than gladiatorial combat. It's kind of like modern day football, whereas gladiatorial spectacles more like kind of
10:40 Speaker 04 boxing or tennis or like individual prowess. But yeah, the Colosseum offers a great opportunity for the emperor to show himself to the people. And how the emperor behaves in the Colosseum is kind of a marker of what kind of emperor he is. And so a good emperor should be involved and attentive to the wishes of the crowd, but not too involved. So for example, the likes of Caligula or Commodus later on are criticised because they have people in the crowd allegedly pulled out of the crowd and beaten up or murdered for criticising their favourite faction or gladiator or whatever. But you also shouldn't be not involved enough. Like Augustus and Julius Caesar are both criticised for bringing paperwork to do, which is generally doesn't
11:24 Speaker 04 go down very well. It's a little like Wimbledon Centre Court today, you know, on the BBC, like the camera pans in on the royal family in the royal box. Like, there's a balance that you have to strike between not kind of screaming, "Come on, Nadal", but also not
11:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, clapping politely, but yeah, absolutely.
11:42 Speaker 01 I love that. Alex, paint a picture then of if you were just an everyday person and you were walking into the Colosseum, what is around you? What is the impact that this space is having on you? Immerse us in that world before we get into the nuts and bolts of it.
12:00 Speaker 04 It's nothing short of spectacular. So it is enormous. It is colourful, which is something that we rarely take into account, the fact the ancient world was very, very colourful. And the Colosseum, in the kind of the archways that you have now, there would have been lots of colourful statues, sculptures, there'd have been a big winged statue of the emperor riding a chariot above the arch, we believe, as you entered. There's also the giant bronze colossus of the Emperor Nero, which is in the vicinity of the Colosseum, which in fact gives it its name. In antiquity, you'd have known it as the Amphitheatre Flavium, the Flavian Amphitheatre, or Caesar's Amphitheatre, but the Flavian Amphitheatre after the family
12:41 Speaker 04 that built it. It's enormous. I mean, you said yourself that it rises to roughly a height of like 50 metres or so. It has many different strata. And so you have different seating for different classes. And kind of the higher class, the more prestigious you are, you're going to be more towards the action at the bottom. And then the lower class you are, or if you were a woman, or a slave, which in which case you don't even really have a class, you're going to be right at the top. And it's almost a kind of Circular Panopticon, where you can just kind of watch everybody and keep check of everybody and what they're doing and see and be seen.
13:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, I love this idea that it's very much performative. Everyone is involved in this performance. It's a kind of like collective consent to be part of it, right? You're not just, it's not necessarily like going to the theatre today or something where you're just sitting in the dark and watching something that's unfolding lit before you. But this is, you are taking part in this as well. And let's talk about the arena itself, the actual arena floor, what's going on there, Alex. And I think we have to take a moment to acknowledge the catastrophe that was Gladiator 2. And I'm gonna ask you, I know the answer, but did they have sharks?
13:58 Speaker 04 They certainly didn't have sharks, no, because they couldn't get any saltwater in, which is the major, the major obstacle to that. They may have flooded the Colosseum during the inaugural games of the year 80. So it took about 10 years to build. The inaugural games are held in the year 80, under the reign of Titus. Vespasian has now died, so his son is ruling over the empire. And even today, academics and archaeologists bicker with one another about whether they ever flooded the Colosseum. Technically, they could have done before they built the underground, the Hippogam section, a year or two later.
14:39 Speaker 04 I doubt they did. I doubt they flooded it and put on these kind of grand naval battles. And I doubt this for two reasons. The first is that there was already a venue for this, not far away in a district known as Trastevere in Rome, where they had an enormous naumachia, a big naval stadium where you could do this. You could have aquatic gladiatorial combat fought on these big ships. So it makes little sense that it would have taken place in this venue. And secondly, if you've been to the Colosseum, you'll know that it's quite small, like the arena floor is not that big. And so if there were ship battles, it's going to be less the spectacle you saw in the second Gladiator film, and more kind of like blokes
15:21 Speaker 04 on a lilo in like a Benadorm pool, just kind of like going at one another with like spears.
15:28 Speaker 00 Brilliant. I mean, I would hate to see that too, but you know.
15:33 Speaker 00 Wow. Okay, so not like Gladiator 2. I'm sorry to anyone out there who really enjoyed it. I love Gladiator 1, but I have to say I did walk out of Gladiator 2 and it's now like the way that I judge people when I meet them. It's like an opening question. Did you enjoy Gladiator 2? Yes, we're not going to be friends. I'm so sorry. So it's going to be controversial, right? And then tell me, complain if you want to. What I think strikes me so much, Alex, is whether or not they were having these sort of flooded battle scenes is it's so kind of mechanized and constructed and there are so many sort of complicated moving parts to the arena. You know, I'm thinking about in Gladiator 1, obviously canon, historical text, you know, the trap doors coming up and those big tigers coming out and things like. There's a lot of kind of trickery and yes, spectacle.
16:17 Speaker 00 And am I right in thinking there was also kind of retractable awning? So presumably, so people didn't cook to death. I mean, you're talking to us now from Rome and it's very heartless.
16:27 Speaker 04 What I would do for a retractable awning right now.
16:32 Speaker 04 So there was a retractable awning to keep the people cool. Weirdly enough, you know, those who had the best seats at the bottom, closest to the action, would not have been protected by it. So actually, it was better to be up in the bleachers among the women and the slaves, funnily enough. And so I guess for the price of prestige, you also had to put up with the suntan if you're right there at the front. But that depiction in the first Gladiator film of the trap doors and the animals and all of the scenery and the stagecraft is spot on. That's really accurate. And so this whole underground Hippogam section is used for precisely that purpose. So to keep all of the stage sets, to keep
17:12 Speaker 04 the wild animals who are all caged up, and then to kind of raise them to the sands of the arena, to the harina, as it was called, the Latin for sand, which gives us the word arena today. And then all of these bloody spectacles would play out.
17:27 Speaker 01 Well, I have an image in front of me, Alex, which is a mosaic that one can find inside the Colosseum that represents gladiators fighting. And it really is remarkable in if you are a costume historian. Or if you are designing costumes for Gladiator one or whatever it might be. What a gift these images are. They are, I'll try and describe them, but it's it's kind of a hodgepodge of different scenarios. It's not necessarily one coherent image. But we have one guy in a tunic and he's also got bandages around his knees and his ankles and he's got a spear and he's spearing a leopard or some kind of a big cat. And that is a pretty fearsome looking cat, by the way.
18:12 Speaker 01 We also then have others kind of prostrate on the ground. They've got a dagger lying by their side. He looks like he's, you know, forlorn. We've got these incredible pieces of armor, like just like you do see in the first Gladiator film where, you know, it's coming down one arm and it's, it looks incredibly muscular and masculine. And then the head, the headpiece as well, more allusion to different knives and whatever there. Now, there is one fellow who appears to me to be upside down and I'm not entirely sure exactly what's going on. So I'm going to defer to you and Alex. I'm not sure if you, you have this image in front of you or if you know what I'm talking about.
18:45 Speaker 04 Yes.
18:45 Speaker 01 But, but he is upside down. Well, it looks like he's upside down, wearing a kind of a medieval tunic, but that is not what's happening. So tell me what is happening, Alex.
18:53 Speaker 04 I know you're spot on. So this is, I think, the figure Maddy Kinos on the left hand side. He's, he's dead, but they haven't quite grasped perspective in this mosaic. So they're not very good at illustrating that he's like laid flat out on the floor. It seems that he's been butchered by the guy on the right, whose name is Alumnus. And we know that he's won this particular encounter because he has a bloody dagger. And also he has Vic or Wick on the right of his name, which stands for Victor. So he's just won a victory against this, um, this other gladiator. Alumnus, it seems, is a, a Retarius. So he's a kind of gladiator that fights with a net, a trident, and presumably to get the, to get the job done, a dagger.
19:36 Speaker 04 And then it looks like he has toppled a Secutor figure or perhaps a more heavily armored figure. But as you say, you have the whole kind of range of gladiatorial types on display here. And on the right hand side, you also have the, the wild beast hunter. Which is kind of a separate spectacle from gladiatorial combat, but no less bloody. You have essentially sometimes trained huntsmen against animals and then sometimes just condemned criminals who were given a spear, wished all the best of luck and then sent out onto the sands.
20:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, let's talk about the kinds of people who were gladiators then, because in this mosaic, we have, as you say, we've got these names, these labels above the heads of all of these different figures. And I know that a lot of gladiators were almost celebrities of their day. They were sort of, you know, famous sportsmen, I guess, would be the analogy. And but they weren't all from the same background, were they? Some were enslaved, some were criminals. As you say, some were trained huntsmen who were brought in specifically for animals. So how on earth does anyone end up in this situation? Because presumably it's not a career that you would seek out.
20:44 Speaker 04 No, no, no. I mean, you're essentially condemned to die unless you're incredibly lucky and very, very good at fighting. And even then, your fate relies on the whim of an emperor or an audience. So gladiators are the lowest of below. They belong to a group of people we know as the infames. And these are essentially the likes of prostitutes, those who use their body and kind of advertise their body for public enjoyment and consumption. Actors, prostitutes. So gladiators are very much seen as the lowest of the low. And gladiators are largely formed of slaves or captured prisoners of war. For example, Spartacus is a Thracian. He's from kind of the area of modern day Macedonia, and he's captured in
21:28 Speaker 04 battle and made to fight as a gladiator. But yeah, you're spot on to say that there's also a kind of appeal of gladiators. There's a kind of sex appeal of them as well. So sometimes you get aristocrats who want to kind of dress up and have a bit of a go. You get the Emperor Commodus, who famously fights as a gladiator. And we must come back to that because it's really, really fun.
21:48 Speaker 00 Commodus is in Gladiator one, Commodus?
21:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, it is the same.
21:51 Speaker 00 Maki Phoenix, okay.
21:52 Speaker 04 The very same. And it's actually, again, a pretty decent representation of what the emperor, according to our sources, was like. Only the emperor that we have in our sources spent more time kind of beheading ostriches and shooting bears from the safety of the imperial box.
22:07 Speaker 01 It's niche, but somebody had to do it, I suppose.
22:28 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
23:10 Speaker 05 What started the civil war? What ended the conflict in Vietnam? Who was Paul Revere? And did the Vikings ever reach America? I'm Don Wildman, and on American History Hit, my expert guests and I are journeying across the nation and through the years to uncover the stories that have made America. We'll visit the battlefields and debate floors where the nation was formed, meet the characters who have altered it with their touch, and count the votes that have changed the direction of our laws and leadership. Find American History Hit twice a week, every week, wherever you get your podcasts. American History Hit, a podcast from History Hit.
24:10 Speaker 04 I feel for the spectators after just sit there watching him just spear a hundred bears from a distance.
24:14 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:15 Speaker 04 So, yeah, gladiators do hold this kind of sex appeal. And we have a text from... A juvenile satirist who writes about the wife of a senator who runs off with a gladiator. And he's described as this kind of forty year old with like a cauliflower ear and a permanently weeping eye from all of the combat and a scar disfigured face. But he's a gladiator. And so that's why she runs off with him.
24:43 Speaker 00 I completely understand that. I once went to an eighteenth birthday party in Bath when the entire Bath rugby team came in. And let me tell you, wow, cauliflower ears all round, but magnificent. So, you know, I feel like, I feel like I can understand that. I wanted to ask, you know, you talk about gladiators that are being in the same social class as sex workers. And I wonder, are gladiators made sexually available to fans essentially? Is that something that happens?
25:10 Speaker 04 It could be. Once you become a gladiator, you forfeit all of your rights, if you ever had them, that is. I mean, if you go from directly being a slave or a prisoner of war, then you never had the rights to forfeit in the first place. But we're told that gladiators had to essentially take a vow when they become a gladiator, similar to when you become a Roman legionary. And it's a very kind of Fifty Shades kind of vow. It's like, I vow to be beaten, burnt, whipped, and all of this for the pleasure of others. Once you forfeited all of your independence, you can then be pimped out by your lannister. You can be pimped out by the owner of the ludus of the gladiatorial barracks, or kind of living quarters in which you live. And so we do get examples of this. Gladiators can
25:55 Speaker 04 also be sold. They can be sold on. And so we're told that certain emperors had their own private collection of gladiators. Apparently Caligula had a group of gladiators that were trained not to blink, and some emperors liked to keep the company of them, and also do certain sexual things.
26:09 Speaker 01 To the blinkers. Okay, I'm not going to pretend to even have an interpretation for that. But we shouldn't. Well, okay, good. I'm in good company then. We shouldn't maybe be surprised by some of this. First of all, I love this idea of like, I'm seeing this blood soaked sand that you're describing in certain of these activities, Alex, but we shouldn't maybe be surprised because from the very launch of this venue or of the Colosseum, blood is very much part of what we're experiencing. So we're seeing sieges, we're seeing battering rams, chariots, mass killings. Talk to us about what some of those early launch festivities would have looked like.
26:55 Speaker 04 Well, historical context is quite important here, especially for understanding the religious aspect of these games. There is a kind of human sacrifice element that goes right back to where the Romans understood gladiatorial combat came from, which is that you have a kind of choreographed means of human sacrifice. It's a bit boring to just tie them up and cut their throat, but if you kind of make them dress up and go at each other with swords, then at least it adds a little bit of a spectacle to the whole thing. And so these inaugural games, which take place in 80 or 81, follow a really torrid time for the Roman Empire. So, under the reign of Titus, you had the eruption of Vesuvius and the destruction of Pompeii. You had another fire which tore through the city and you've
27:40 Speaker 04 had a plague. And so it was really important for the Romans that these games were spectacular and that you had lots and lots of death, because the more death, the more you stand a chance of appeasing the gods. And so we're told that 9,000 wild beasts are killed during the inaugural games, which take place over 100 days throughout that year, presumably not back to back, because it would get really stale, I think, even for a kind of committed Roman audience member.
28:11 Speaker 00 I'm trying to do the maths of like, how many animals that would be a day, but to sort of space it out, yeah.
28:18 Speaker 04 Yeah, because I mean, another source tells us that 5,000 died in a day, but then if it's 9,000 in total, five in a day, then you're slaughtering squirrels for the other, for the rest of the week. I mean,
28:29 Speaker 00 Mice or something, yeah, yeah.
28:31 Speaker 04 But there is, and it's important to stress, there is this religious aspect to the games. And so when we see films like Gladiator and you see the kind of audience who are formed of these, you know, men and women kind of standing together, you know, really enjoying the bloodshed and like spittle kind of coming out of their mouths and kind of shouting for who they want put to death. Yes, but then it's also reverent. So I think you've got something like a mix between Sunday mass, in which everyone's dressed for their best, wearing toga, and again, centre court at Wimbledon, only with more shouting out and a lot more violence taking place on the court or the arena below. And also the executions which take place that the kind of interlude of the games.
29:14 Speaker 04 So between the animal stuff in the morning, the animal hunts and the gladiatorial combat in the afternoon, you have public executions, which, again, a sacrifice.
29:24 Speaker 00 Is this just people being brought on and killed? Is there any kind of performance or choreography with that?
29:30 Speaker 04 It's very performative. And so the historian Tom Holland kind of rather beautifully described it as a mix between a snuff movie and the Cirque du Soleil. So it's like kind of extreme violence and then there'll be a bit of a story and then clowns will come out afterwards. And all of the executions that we know of from the inaugural games, because we have a very good source, which is the epigrammatist Marshall, who was an eyewitness. And he allegorically kind of describes what's going on. And what you have are reenactments of historical or legendary episodes with which everyone would be familiar, played out with a twist. And so it will be a bit like if we were to get somebody now dressed up as Bambi's mother
30:12 Speaker 04 and make them run around in a little glade and then either kind of shoot them with arrows or just like a giant like bear comes out and just like gauls the person dressed up as Bambi's mother. And we're like, oh, Disney, that's nice.
30:25 Speaker 04 So in this case of the inaugural games, they're playing on myth. And so you have, for example, a woman who is condemned to death, who plays the role of Pasiphae, who was the wife of King of Nausicaä and the Minotaur, who gives birth to the Minotaur. And we're told that she's made to couple with a bull and then is put to death, or possibly dies while coupling with a bull. They're playing upon a myth. We have no idea what that looks like in reality, whether she's actually being ravaged by a bull or whether it's a guy dressed up as a bull. Maybe it was actually very...
31:00 Speaker 04 Gairish and a bit amateurish and you have a guy in a terrible bull costume. We don't really know. Or maybe it's an actual bull, which sort of possibly had precedent in other parts of the empire, being Condomnatio ad bestias, being kind of condemned to be killed by an animal. You have another example of a guy who is dressed up as a famous Roman bandit, who was then crucified, and this guy is also crucified, but basically he's also having his innards eaten out, gored out by a big Scottish bear.
31:29 Speaker 00 Specifically a Scottish bear.
31:31 Speaker 04 A Scottish bear, Caledonian bear.
31:33 Speaker 00 No other bear will do.
31:35 Speaker 04 With an accent and a hunger.
31:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:38 Speaker 04 Deep fried organs, sorry.
32:03 Speaker 05 What started the civil war? What ended the conflict in Vietnam? Who was Paul Revere? And did the Vikings ever reach America? I'm Don Wildman, and on American History Hit, my expert guests and I are journeying across the nation and through the years to uncover the stories that have made America. We'll visit the battlefields and debate floors where the nation was formed, meet the characters who have altered it with their touch, and count the votes that have changed the direction of our laws and leadership. Find American History Hit twice a week, every week, wherever you get your podcasts. American History Hit, a podcast from History Hit.
33:01 Speaker 00 This is so interesting because I think it speaks to that, as you said, that combined element of performance but also punishment. And I suppose the enjoyment as a spectator would have come from seeing so-called justice done within your concept of the state and the society that you live in. And then also the entertainment factor.
33:22 Speaker 01 I had a question. We're talking about mythology and how that mythology is represented within the Colosseum. But the Colosseum also itself gives birth to a different type of mythology, but modern mythology-making nonetheless. And it's very, it's kind of a big glib in relation to what we've just been talking about. But I think it's worth people knowing what's invented and what's not. I'm going to just say four words and you can go from there, Alex. And those four words are thumbs up or thumbs down. That was five words because I put in an or, apologies. But talk about that thumbs up, thumbs down thingy.
34:00 Speaker 04 So this is the emperor during the Roman Empire, or before it would have been the sponsor of the games, a figure known as the editor, who is essentially channeling the will and the whim of the crowd and deciding who lives and who dies. So gladiatorial combat is very rarely to the death. I say very rarely, we really have no idea. But Mary Beard has done some stonking scholarly work and used gravestones to figure out it might be about one in six in every performance that takes place. Maybe one in six gladiators die either on the field of battle or afterwards from their wounds. But yeah, those that don't end up dying, the emperor can, and again, using this big public forum,
34:42 Speaker 04 can gain popularity by channeling the will of the people and doing something with the thumb to convey the message to the gladiator on the floor below. What they did, we don't really know. Whether it's up or down, we have no idea. They just did a thumb thing. And then... If this gladiator is condemned to die, something really, really sinister happens, which would have been a really good thing to have featured in the Gladiator movies, but never did. So yes, there's the idea that the gladiator, who is the victor, will kind of perform the coup de grace. So they'll actually, you know, butcher the one who's, who's lost the fight. But there's another figure who will come on to the arena sands called the Charon, who in mythology, he was the ferryman in Greek mythology, who would ferry the souls over the River Styx to the afterlife.
35:27 Speaker 04 And this is a really sinister figure who's kind of dressed as this kind of mythological, kind of devilish character. And he'll come on with a branding iron, a boiling hot branding iron and a mallet. And he'll hold the branding iron against the flesh of the gladiator to check he's not just pretending. And then he'll smash his head in with a mallet.
35:46 Speaker 00 Oh.
35:47 Speaker 01 Wow, that's a job. That is somebody's job. Okay, well.
35:51 Speaker 04 And just really sinister to watch. And again, depending on how well it's done, it might look really amateurish. Like if, you know, if it's a bit clownish, it's going to make it even more disturbing. If it's a bit of a tawdy costume.
36:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
36:02 Speaker 04 All of bright, bright pink slippers. I don't know.
36:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
36:04 Speaker 04 We don't have many descriptions, but.
36:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's so interesting to me that there's one person assigned to deal out this kind of level of death, that maybe that is useful even within this kind of circus of chaos and, and hacking people to death and hacking animals to death and all of that, that actually when all of that's calmed down and there just needs to be an end, that the ability to be able to call someone on who can do that, I think is quite important. I'm sort of obsessed with this figure. I mean, obviously very, very, very grim, but I think that kind of almost administrative, but also performative role is very, very fascinating.
36:39 Speaker 04 I should give a caveat. We have limited information for the existence of this figure. So it may be that they featured only in like one example of the games held on one occasion, or it could be that he featured every single time. The, the problem with our sources for the Colosseum and the games is that they're very patchy. And so we always run the risk of making this assumption that because it happened once, that must have been the prescription. So for example, when I give the, the order of play, in which you get the animal hunts first, and then you get the executions and then gladiatorial combat, that's what we know from the evidence, but they also presumably changed it up an awful lot. And again, Mary Beard makes a really good analogy here, but it's a bit like looking at a photograph of a graduate student on someone's mantelpiece, dressed in their robes
37:24 Speaker 04 and their mortarboard, and assuming from that that every single day, students dress like that.
37:29 Speaker 01 Yeah. I have adored your analogies throughout both of these episodes, Alex, I think they're so illustrative. But we've talked about the, we've talked about the piece of land that was Caligula's and then how taken over from Nero's buildings. We talked how this was for the people, for their entertainment, to kind of give back to them. We've talked about the blood and the sand and the animals and the gladiators. Talk to us about how it declines then. How does this massive thing that is supposed to be the celebratory point, or a coming together at least, for the people, how does this start to then die away? And literally, in some cases, crumble away?
38:08 Speaker 04 So I think the spectacle itself remains very popular. We, I think, give a little bit, a little bit too much weight to the role of Christianity in this. There is definitely a Christian backlash. So as Christianity is on the rise, as Christianity is adopted by more and more Romans, there's an idea that actually, human sacrifice is abhorrent and we ought not to be doing this. Even though there's no evidence that any Christians were themselves sacrificed in the Colosseum, nonetheless fed to lions. That tended to happen in the Circus Maximus, all of the Christian killing, or in various other circuses. So you even get examples of Christians who are quite into the games. Saint Augustine, a source from the late 3rd, early 4th century, tells us of a figure called Olympius,
38:53 Speaker 04 who would later become a bishop of Rome. And he goes along to the games early in the 4th century, and he promises not to look because the whole thing, you know, appalls him. But he's kind of there peeping through his hands like we do when we watch horror films. And he catches a glimpse of some blood shooting out someone's jugular, and then he's hooked. So then Augustine describes how, you know, you can see that fierce passion for this new sport in his eyes, and he can't take his eyes off it. So I think this has been overstated. And even though it's a little bit boring, I think the real explanation is money. So once Rome is sacked in the 5th century, in 410 in particular, and loads of stuff is looted, perhaps including the Colossus, the massive statue of bronze next to the Colosseum.
39:39 Speaker 04 It's hard to justify spending so much money on gladiatorial spectacle and wild beast hunts. And it cost a fortune. We have a good source called Simicus. He's a senator who's left quite a lot of writing. And he essentially tells us how much it cost him to put on a spectacle to get a few hundred lions and bears shipped over to Rome. And he also gets some Anglo-Saxon gladiators who inconveniently strangle each other to death before they're actually sent out onto the sands of the arena. So he feels kind of hard done by about that. Simicus clearly has no empathy as a person.
40:18 Speaker 04 So it's really expensive to put on these games. And once Rome has been sacked, you have to channel money elsewhere. You have to prioritise rebuilding. You have to prioritise defence spending. And so, yeah, it just becomes very expensive to put the games on. We're told that what really does it for gladiatorial combat is a final fight preceded over by the Emperor Honorius, in which a Christian by the name of Telemicus, a Christian monk, tries to go and stop the fight by getting onto the arena sands. He kind of like is a modern day streaker, but fully clothed. He kind of jumps over the barrier and he runs on to try and break the fight up. And he's killed by the crowd. We don't know how. There's no detailed description.
41:03 Speaker 04 So maybe stone to death or they're kind of throwing their food at him. No idea. The Emperor Honorius is apparently so disturbed by this and finds it so disgusting that he orders a ban of the games in the 400s. And then wild animal hunts stop in the 500s. And after this, yeah, the games at the Colosseum die down and the monument is used for other purposes.
41:26 Speaker 00 I have a final question, Alex, before we wrap up. And I know that one of the strings of your gladiatorial bow is that you take people on tours of Rome and you communicate the history that you spend so much time learning about and writing about to those people in those spaces. And I just wonder what your relationship as someone who lives in Rome is with the Colosseum and what it means to the city and to Romans today.
41:52 Speaker 04 It's the best surviving and the most impressive surviving monument.
41:58 Speaker 04 Arguably in the entire Roman Empire, but certainly in Rome, maybe the Pantheon also is on a par, like the temple to all the gods. And so it's kind of an icon of the city. But that's because it's the best surviving. Ancient Romans would have been impressed by many other structures. We're told that when, I think, the son of the Emperor Constantine visited Rome, he was especially taken aback by the Forum of the Emperor Trajan, by the Circus Maximus, and also, yeah, kind of by the Colosseum. That's all right as well. So, yeah, a lot of that is kind of an accident of chance, in the sense that the Colosseum's the best surviving structure. But what the Colosseum is today, I have a bit of an ambiguous relationship with it.
42:38 Speaker 04 What we show tourists now is the bare-bones skeletal structure of the Colosseum, bereft, I think, of a lot of explanatory notes and stuff that gives it context. Throughout its history, it's been used for many things. There used to be remnants of an arena floor, where in the 19th century, kind of European aristocrats on grand tours would go and frolic with locals and, you know, do all sorts of like after-hours stuff. And it was also, up until quite recently, a very green and becolic area. It had like hundreds of species of flora and plants, which were, many of which were bought in the fur of animals that were condemned to die there. And this is something that really came after the Age of Mussolini, which is basically
43:23 Speaker 04 the destruction of everything that, over the subsequent centuries, had built on top of Roman remains. All of that is destroyed in order to get to the heart of the Roman Republic and the Roman Empire and the old stuff, because that's the stuff that Mussolini was really into for his own, you know, political reasons, because he wanted to draw a parallel between himself and the emperors of old. We've destroyed quite a lot of stuff, which would have also been very interesting to see in the process of getting to these ancient remains. And, yeah, I think we could do a lot better than we do now in managing the Colosseum as an area of cultural patrimony and the kind of half-constructed arena floor that you have.
44:06 Speaker 01 Alex, where can people find you? Because if they are heading to Rome and they want to be shown around by an expert, I can think of nobody better to show around than I know. The next time I'm there, I'm going to be looking you up and seeing how best to get around this place.
44:19 Speaker 04 With pleasure.
44:19 Speaker 01 Where can they find you?
44:20 Speaker 04 The best place would be through my website, which is alexandermeddings.com. I also have another domain, appia with Alex, which is for tours of the Appian Way, which is kind of my specialism. And those, yeah, those would be the best ways, I think.
44:34 Speaker 01 Great.
44:34 Speaker 04 And you can kind of request tours from there.
44:36 Speaker 01 Alex, it's truly been so enjoyable to take both of these episodes. So we had this episode on the Colosseum and we've had the Caligula episode. And it's been so incredible to really feel immersed. And it goes to show that actually the fact that you are living there and experiencing these things on a, you know, daily basis almost, how that brings it to life for you. And the expertise that you bring to both of these subjects has just been so accessible and fascinating. I know the After Dark listeners will really respond to this. So thank you so much for taking the time to come in and talk to us. Thank you for listening, of course, as ever. Be aware, guys, we now have a YouTube channel. Go and have a look at our episodes over there. In fact, you can watch this very episode over there.
45:20 Speaker 01 You can see Alex baking in his flat because he's absolutely roasting over there right now.
45:25 Speaker 04 It is so warm.
45:26 Speaker 01 So go and check out our YouTube channel too. And of course, if you need to get in touch for any reason, you can get in contact with us on [email protected] . Once again, thank you for listening and until next time, happy listening.
Previous Gay Sex Scandal that Outraged the Georgians Next BONUS: Hear a chapter of Anthony's new book, Queer Georgians Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated