Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal BONUS: Hear a chapter of Anthony's new book, Queer Georgians About this episode Hear a chapter of Anthony's new book, Queer Georgians: A hidden history of lovers, lawbreakers and homemakers. It's out now!
For more information, clickhere. https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/460692/queer-georgians-by-delaney-anthony/9781529927689
Anthony tells listeners why he wanted to write this book, and introduces a special chapter, exclusive for After Dark listeners!
After Dark will return to its normal programming on Monday (Sunday for subscribers).
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers. Now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries. And I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Anton and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:51 Speaker 02 Hi, it's Danny Pellegrino from Everything Iconic. Twelve celebrities, one Don and cold, hard cash. From the producers of The Traitors comes The Mob, a new Hulu original series. The iconic Parker Posey hosts this unique reality competition show where 12 celebrity contestants shake down in an Italian villa to win a share of up to $250,000. Watch The Mob, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
1:24 Speaker 00 Hello, everyone. Now, today, we've got some bonus content for you. We will be back with our usual programming, though, from Monday.
1:32 Speaker 01 We've never done this on After Dark before, have we? What a time to be alive. But we have gone into bonus land because, you may have seen, if you follow me on social media, that my book, Queer Georgians: A Hidden History of Lovers, Lawbreakers and Homemakers, is out now. I actually feel sick. So as a special treat, we have a chapter exclusive for After Dark listeners. And thank you so much to the History Hit and After Dark team because they've been so supportive about this launch. But we just wanted to let you hear a little bit of Queer Georgians.
2:02 Speaker 00 Okay, before we actually hear the chapter, and I literally cannot wait. I'm actually buzzing with excitement. Please, can you just tell us a little bit about what this chapter's about? And also, and this is something we've been chatting about for about two years, but for the listeners, tell me why you wanted to write this book in particular.
2:19 Speaker 01 Okay, we'll start with the chapter and then I'll come to the next bit of the question. So this is chapter 10 that you're about to hear. So we're actually coming towards the end of the book here. And it tells the story of George Wilson and his wife Elizabeth Cummins. And George is a person who was born to another name and gender, someone we would potentially identify today as trans. And this is, I think, in this moment in time when our trans brothers and sisters are really under scrutiny and really under legal duress and violent legal duress. It's important to highlight that these people have existed for centuries. There is a certain tech billionaire who has called transness and gender identity a woke mind virus.
3:04 Speaker 01 And that's something that is a 21st century invention. Well, these people, these people who are archivally provable, as they are in this chapter and as they are in this book, show that that is absolutely not the case. Just factually, that is not the case. So I just wanted to highlight that history in this particular excerpt. But also, it's an adventure story. There are ships, there are drunken revels, there are trials, you know, prison. And we are left, as you'll hear, with this kind of cliffhanger of sometimes history doesn't give us all the answers. So you're left to kind of imagine what life might have been like. But I won't give too much away. In terms of the book, well, you know, I did my PhD as well, you know, Maddie, because we've known each other since then.
3:46 Speaker 00 And he never stops going on about it. We've all got PhDs here, pal.
3:50 Speaker 01 And when I did my PhD, it was about queer domesticity. And that was the gateway into this. So this, the book is Queer Georgians, or if you're listening in North America, Queer Enlightenments. I just wanted to broaden the spectrum a little bit. So we look at love, the law, how same-sex attraction or gender nonconformity interacted with the law, and homes, how same-sex attracted people made homes together. And I think not many people know that. So I'm trying to concentrate on some of the joys in queer history. We know an awful lot about the tragedies, and they're in the book too. But there were joys and there was love and there was frivolity and there was campness and there was colour and there was fun and laughter and all these things. And I really wanted to- Bring that to the forefront in queer histories and let people know that queer histories are not a 20th century invention. We have had queer histories for as long as we've had
4:33 Speaker 01 people. So I'm hoping to roll it back a little bit.
4:36 Speaker 00 Yeah, I remember you saying to me quite early on in the book writing process that you wanted to include those histories of joy and positivity, as well as acknowledging, obviously, all the horror and the tragedy and the oppression and all the frustration and anger that we feel looking at those now. But tell me, in terms of writing the book, how was it spending time with these histories, uncovering them and doing bloody hard work in the archives? Because one thing we all know about queer histories is they are sometimes very difficult to read in the archives. Sometimes they're hidden in plain sight and people just haven't looked at them, haven't bothered to acknowledge them. But often, there are gaps. What was it like? Was it frustrating doing that, uncovering this history and then putting those into your own words?
5:15 Speaker 01 You know what it was? It was surprising that some of the things that I came across were so blatantly obvious. I was like, why has this been ignored?
5:23 Speaker 00 Why has somebody picked up on this?
5:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was the most surprising thing. So it wasn't that difficult. It was like, well, it's here. I'm literally reading it. And that's when I went to Alex, my editor, I said to him, you know, it's one of those things that if you know, you know. So like, I know what a queer life looks like because I live one. And so when I see it in the archive, I knew what I was looking at. So maybe it was just a case that I was the first queer person who looked at these things. So I looked at some of those details differently than somebody else. I think maybe my own lived experience helps to inform what I found in the archive. And so, yeah, there were gaps and there are frustrating gaps. But you can find that in any history. But for me, I was like, there is so much here. How come this hasn't been looked at before? And how come these people haven't been explored before? So that was the surprise. And what a nice surprise, I suppose.
6:03 Speaker 00 Hmm. One thing that strikes me about this book is just how normal and widespread these same-sex relationships were, all these amazing queer lives that have been forgotten largely and written out of history until this book. And you've uncovered amazing things that people didn't previously know, as well as returning to very famous cases of queer histories. What is your favourite discovery from this book?
6:27 Speaker 01 Oh, I think what I am most pleased with, what I hope like is a bit of a service maybe, is the Chevalier Dion, who if you Google the Chevalier Dion now, you will be told that it's a triumphant trans history and the archive doesn't support that. I thought I was about to write another trans history. There are trans histories in this book which are amazing and celebratory. And that's what I thought I was writing when it came to the Chevalier. But actually, the Chevalier's gender expression is far more complex than that. And it all ties back to the French crown, an espionage ring and blackmail, basically. And it's so much more complex and messy. And it means that the Chevalier had to turn around and explain to the spymaster at the
7:11 Speaker 01 time, and his French spymaster saying, I know why these rumours have started about me. And it's because I'm still a virgin, I'm not attracted to either men or women. And that's seen as not very manly. And so now the French crown wants to impose female dress on me to discredit me. Because he was, the Chevalier was trying to discredit the French crown through selling letters between the crown and himself. So it is not the history that I thought, but hopefully, I don't know, it's difficult because she also, the Chevalier also leans into that lie later in her life when she needs to financially. And she uses the lie that people created about her. But if I'm maybe able to restore a bit of that identity. And then, of course, there's my final chapter 11 is Mary Jones.
7:56 Speaker 01 And she's just the most inspirational woman that, she's incredible. But we'll talk about her another day. But there's a lot of inspiration in this particular chapter, too.
8:06 Speaker 00 Before we hear chapter 10, can you tell people who've whetted their appetite listening to this, where they can buy the book and if there's going to be a book tour?
8:15 Speaker 01 Can I just say, it's so weird doing this because it feels like I'm a guest on the podcast. And it's just like, this is odd being talking about this.
8:22 Speaker 00 But it's so exciting because I think, you know, this is an important thing to remember that we don't just do this podcast, we also both write books.
8:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:30 Speaker 00 You know, if listener, you have enjoyed After Dark in the two years that we've been doing it, and we hope to do it for many more years. If you enjoy it, and maybe if you're not a subscriber to History and you enjoy it for free, please do buy our books. You know, it's a lovely way of supporting the work that we do and. This is such an important and exciting book that Anthony's written. It's really, really significant and lovely and joyful. And you absolutely should go and do that. So where can they?
8:55 Speaker 01 Well, they can do it. If they're listening in the UK or Ireland or Europe, the book is out on the 4th of September. So it's out now. You can buy it in any of the bookshop retailer places, whatever they're officially called.
9:07 Speaker 00 One of those bookshop retailer places.
9:09 Speaker 01 Or online, wherever you like. If you're listening in North America, then the book comes out and it's called Queer Enlightenment, just to avoid any confusion with the state of Georgia. And that comes out on the 7th of October. Again, it's also available through online retailers. So it's out in the world or it's starting its journey in the world now, which is very, very exciting. And it's also vomit inducing. So.
9:30 Speaker 00 It's terrifying. Yeah, you're putting something of yourself and your passion out into the world. If people want to come and see yourself and your passion in person.
9:39 Speaker 01 Yes, my address is.
9:40 Speaker 00 Yes, Anthony's home address. No, but you are doing tour dates, right?
9:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I have book tour dates in the UK for 2025. In Ireland, I'm doing a very special kind of music concert tour of Queer Georgians, which I can't divulge too much of, but that'll be in 2026. And hopefully some North American dates in 2026 as well. So there's lots going on, but for now, for 2025, my book tour details are all on my social media page, Anthony Delaney History. And come and see me, get the book signed. I've had lovely chats already, so this has been one of the highlights. That's where you get out and talk to people. And you guys, listeners of After Dark, have been the people who have been turning up. Like you guys have been amazing.
10:23 Speaker 00 You guys are loyal.
10:23 Speaker 01 So yeah, it's been really special. So I'll see you on the road, hopefully.
10:30 Speaker 01 I don't know why I'm so nervous to introduce this, but this is chapter 10, A Not So Singular Case. And you're about to meet George Wilson and his wife, Elizabeth, who are setting out on an adventure that will utterly change their lives. And part of this adventure will mean that we encounter them in a way that they had hoped never to be encountered. But in meeting them, as we do, we learn so much about lives that some people have doubted ever existed at all.
11:21 Speaker 01 Chapter 10. A not-so singular case. Hope. Swelling on perpetual waves carried George Wilson and his seventeen-year-old wife Elizabeth towards their new life.
11:36 Speaker 01 Beneath his excitement, however, George was ill at ease. The cause of his unrest was a secret, for sometimes it is our lot in life to keep secrets. But Wilson was resolved. He would not remain burdened. He would tell Elizabeth the truth. So, as the pair approached North America, Wilson gathered every ounce of his courage. George Wilson and Elizabeth Cummins had been married only a few days previously, on Friday the 6th of April 1821, in the Barony Parish of Glasgow, Scotland. George attended alone, but Elizabeth's family had turned out in force to bless their union.
12:19 Speaker 01 Indeed, the newlyweds had been introduced by Elizabeth's father, James Cummins, who was superintendent at the Glasgow factory where George worked.
12:30 Speaker 01 Almost eighty thousand Glaswegians, out of a population of one hundred and fifty thousand, were employed in the city's cotton industry, which boomed thanks to an ever-growing Atlantic trade. Most of these employees were women and children. Factory hours were long and the working environment treacherous, with the loss of appendages, limbs, and lives far from uncommon. Of course, if factory conditions were tough, it was nothing compared to the conditions in which enslaved people toiled to procure the raw cotton wool across the Atlantic. This was then imported by Scottish merchants and eventually spun in Scottish factories, just like the one James Cummins oversaw.
13:15 Speaker 01 When Cummins had learnt that Wilson had no family of his own, he must have taken pity on the young man, and seen fit to introduce him to his wife Margaret and their manny children. They enjoyed dinners together and played cards on several occasions. Whether Cummins had ever intended Wilson to become his son-in-law is unclear, but once Elizabeth Cummins met George Wilson, sparks led to flutters and vows were soon exchanged. The newlyweds would soon leave Glasgow bound for a new life. They knew that they would never see Scotland again, but the promise and opportunity of North America had proved too alluring. The Wilsons will have undertaken their voyage on a packet ship.
14:00 Speaker 01 Whilst steamships were not unheard of, the wind-powered packet still dominated Atlantic travel in the early 19th century. The packets were so named because they transported letters and packages throughout the British Empire, but they might transport other goods, including paying passengers too. As a result, packet ships had the innovative distinction of operating under a regulated and advertised departure schedule, though they were designed with sturdiness and the threat of an Atlantic storm in mind, rather than speed. We do not know exactly which packet ship Elizabeth and George made their voyage of hope on, as records for that year are incomplete.
14:42 Speaker 01 But it is thought that they left Glasgow within a couple of days of being married, and likely set sail from a Scottish port two or three days after that. It is possible, therefore, that they made their way south to Dumfries, where, on the 12th of April 1821, six days after the Wilsons had married, the Thompson Packet was scheduled to set sail for Pictoo, Canada, with Captain Lookup at the helm. On board were eighty passengers whose names are now lost to time. We know that the journey took thirty days and was recorded as having reached its final destination around the twelfth of May. Whether or not Elizabeth and George had boarded the Thompsons specifically, their
15:25 Speaker 01 journey across the Atlantic would have been much the same on any scheduled departure from Britain. On board their packet, George and Elizabeth would have travelled steerage, the cheapest option available. A ticket for steerage passage cost about five pounds, or four hundred and sixty pounds today. But despite being a lucrative commodity, the number of steerage tickets assigned to each ship was strictly limited. To regulate potential excess, custom housemen tallied the overall measurement of each boat and designated passenger numbers accordingly. Provisions for the journey would then be inspected to ensure that they were sufficiently
16:06 Speaker 01 plentiful and of decent enough quality to last the projected length of the voyage. Elizabeth and George will also have been inspected for lice or other signs of contagious disease before departure, as an outbreak at sea could lead to catastrophic outcomes for passengers and crew alike. Despite these seemingly civilized precautions, which in any case were not always observed, contemporary accounts of transatlantic steerage travel tells us that a month aboard a packaged ship was akin to living in a floating hell. To access steerage, the Wilsons would have climbed down a ladder through the hatchway, often the only source of light for their quarters.
16:49 Speaker 01 If the sea was particularly high and waves sprayed violently across the deck, the hatchway and the steerage passengers beneath would be contained and kept dry by placing a lid over it. During such times, which were not rare in the tempestuous North Atlantic, steerage was plunged into utter darkness.
17:11 Speaker 01 Thus, confined in a space eighteen feet square and seven feet high, passengers blinked back the blackness and held on for dear life.
17:22 Speaker 01 steerage passengers typically slept in bunk beds. One account tells us that passengers crept night and morning in and out of their berths like ants about their business. Around them, from the ceiling, hung the stuff of life: hats and hams, bonnets, onions and frying pans, boots and red herrings. Everything swayed with the interminable nauseating metronome of the sea. Boxes and other containers were nailed to the floor to secure them in place. These were filled with valuables, but also acted as chairs and tables as well as cupboards. A crossing was not a silent affair either.
18:05 Speaker 01 Outside, the sea hammered and rolled, thundering at our wooden walls for admittance. The creaking of the ship's wood might have gone unnoticed at first, given the fear and excitement that ensued once the packet initially set sail. But as the voyage went on, each creak, groan, squeak and yawn from the timber world around them bored deeper into the brain. Children wept, putts and kettles clanked, and the crew above caused a ruckus with their hallooing at the forecastle every few hours. George and Elizabeth kept a daily diet of rice pudding, as it easily withstood the length of the journey. This they would have boiled on deck when the weather was good enough.
18:50 Speaker 01 Otherwise, the Wilsons and their like had to content themselves with crunching hard biscuits in the dark depths of steerage. However, no sooner did clouds clear off and the sun break through than all troubles were forgotten. Onboard the trusty packet.
19:09 Speaker 01 In those golden moments, George and Elizabeth were permitted to explore the deck. They may have taken walks together round the jolly boat, looking at the cow, or sheep, or pigs, or poultry the packets transported. They may have read, or simply looked up into the great blue skies overhead. That is not to say that steerage passengers had free rein on deck. George and Elizabeth's movements would have been curtailed by chalk lines that designated areas for the exclusive use of first and second-class passengers. It was whilst aboard their package ship, maybe on one of those pleasant sunny days, that George Wilson offered the story of his old life up to his new wife, and to the sea,
19:54 Speaker 01 so that he might be free of it and begin again. That day, surrounded by the vast Atlantic Ocean, he told Elizabeth that he had not always been a man. Historian Jen Manion has identified George Wilson, given his marital status and gender performance, as the first designated female husband found living in the United States. Female husbands, as we saw in the last chapter, might include many variants of gender non-conforming people, but the vast majority that made international headlines were people assigned female who trans-gender, lived as men, and married women, as Manion details. The term was common in print media during the 18th and 19th centuries on both sides
20:38 Speaker 01 of the Atlantic, and indeed contemporary newspaper reports would eventually come to refer to Wilson as a female husband too, as we shall see. We do not know how Elizabeth reacted to George's news; we only know that when the Wilsons finally reached Canada, they disembarked and continued on together. The Wilsons were but two of the many millions of people who emigrated to North America from Northern and Western Europe across the next century. From 1820 to approximately 1957, 13 million people travelled to the United States alone, for example. The vast majority of them came from Ireland—4.6 million—
21:22 Speaker 01 and Great Britain—4.5 million—for various and often overlapping reasons, including desperate necessity, economic opportunity, and the perceived religious and political tolerance available at the end of their voyage. But in the context of this audiobook, it is clear that they also travelled for another overlooked reason. Some migrants went to America because their queerness compelled them to. We've already seen how William Courtney, ninth Earl of Devon, absconded to New York in 1811, when his same-sex attraction drew unwanted legal attention back in England. Here, too, bridging the queer class divide,
22:04 Speaker 01 George Wilson ventured west in search of an identity he felt he might not fully realise in Scotland. This is no coincidence. In the 17th century, the American colonies inherited a version of English law regarding the regulation of sodomy, namely the Buggery Act of 1533. However, following independence, 19th-century American legalies had effectively tongue-tied itself into silence on the matter. Sodomy was illegal, make no mistake, but it was also seen as an act not fit to be named amongst Christians. If you could not name it, you could not prosecute it.
22:44 Speaker 01 This perceived legal loophole also extended to other ideas relating to gender nonconformity more broadly, which, in turn, marginalised sexuality beyond the jurisdiction of criminal enforcement. For a moment in time, in America, sodomy law regulated itself into extinction. This was that time. And this is why George Wilson, Kitty Courtney, and others deliberately made their way to the United States in moments of potential crisis.
23:36 Speaker 01 Were they on board the Thompson, the Wilsons would have arrived at Pictou, a picturesque port town in Nova Scotia, on the 12th of May 1821. The region had been given its settler name, meaning “New Scotland,” by the Scottish explorer Sir William Alexander, who was awarded the land by King James VI of Scotland and I of England in 1621, with little regard for the naming customs and homesteads of the indigenous Smikma peoples, who had inhabited and cultivated the land for countless generations previously. Many Scots settled there, and George and Elizabeth would have been comforted by the lilt and rotic hours of the familiar accent as soon as they disembarked.
24:21 Speaker 01 Although we know they arrived in Nova Scotia, it is difficult to track the Wilsons’ whereabouts for the next several years. Various later accounts would claim that they settled in New Limerick, Canada, or New Harmony, Indiana. We do know that during this time Elizabeth’s father, James, joined them, and the industrious trio set up home together under the same roof in Nova Scotia. It isn’t until 1827 that the Wilsons reemerge in the archive, this time in Patterson, New Jersey. James and George found themselves back in the cotton factories, working at the Clark and Robinson Cotton Mill. Soon, however, the pair would lose their jobs, and the three of them would make for
25:04 Speaker 01 New York, where they settled at 47 Forsyth Street. Forsyth was one of a set of streets on the Lower East Side named for heroes from various American military and naval conquests. These also included Christie, Eldridge, and Ludlow. I can’t imagine, though, that George, Elizabeth, and James spent much time thinking of this legacy when they settled there in the 1820s, if they knew about it at all. It was the promise of work that had drawn them there. George found employment at Joseph Barron's factory at 171 Water Street, a half hour walk from Forsyth. Whilst the genteel classes could afford a comfortable life far from the noise and dirt
25:49 Speaker 01 of industry, the labouring classes lived close to where they worked for ease of access. Barron was a furrier, so George would have been employed in the making of fur goods. That was, however, until a fire broke out one December night in 1835 at 173 Water Street, and decimated the surrounding businesses, including Barron's fur factory. We cannot say with certainty what the immediate impact of the fire was for George, but it appears that Barron got himself and his employees back on their feet again quickly, because by the summer of the following year, George was still employed by him. Back on Forsyth, modest but decent accommodation had been raised by speculative builders to
26:34 Speaker 01 accommodate a growing number of journeymen and factory labourers. But whilst the Wilsons may have found relatively good accommodation there, conditions were still far from ideal. Behind the street lay a maze of alleyways, crowded with industrial workshops. The two to four storey, mostly wooden houses that lined the street were still multi-occupancy. The area near the Bowery nearby stank of dead flesh from slaughterhouses and tanning yards, whilst more and more stinking bodies crammed into the streets around them on a weekly basis. Pigs roamed free, defecating and copulating hither and thither.
27:16 Speaker 01 Meanwhile, modern conveniences such as coal stoves, gas lights, ice boxes and other improvements were reserved for the classes above the Wilsons. Instead, after the workday was done, Forsyth was illuminated by candlelight and community.
27:34 Speaker 01 Women hollered from windows to one another, passing information and gossip above the din of the street below. Local residents called on their neighbours unannounced and looked after their friends' children, or rather, assigned their own children to look after their friends' children, in the streets with the pigs. The women sewed and laundered and cooked and fought and did what they could to get by, sometimes supplementing their husbands' income with work of their own. They survived because the alternative was unthinkable. The men, like George, when not working, liquored. Whiskey was provided by employers to factory men in order to spur them on through the often hopeless monotony of their daily grind, and a refreshing beer might be offered in
28:17 Speaker 01 the summer months to cool the rising heat. The cost for their employers was less than a cup of tea or coffee, so it was a worthwhile expense. Outside of work, George will have enjoyed the brotherhood of his New York co-workers at one of the thousands of taverns or saloons that had been approved by the city, alongside others that had not. Here, men drank whilst exchanging stories of their domestic frustrations and learnt about the availability of new work opportunities. George was very much welcomed into this manly fold. His contemporaries saw no reason not to include him in their homosocial bonding. We know that he partook in this everyday act of male bonding because it was liquoring
29:01 Speaker 01 that eventually brought him to the attention of the authorities one summer night in 1836. The corner of Pearl Street and Chatham, one Friday night, likely the fifth, but records differ, August 1836. The night air was warm and frivolity was high. A local policeman kept his beat. Buildings on this block had been destroyed in a revolutionary skirmish on the 20th of September 1776.
29:31 Speaker 01 However, by the first decades of the 19th century, the scorched remains of Pearl Street had risen, phoenix-like, from the rubble, and the street was now lined with sturdy, brick-faced, federal-style homes and businesses. Pearl and Chatham was a busy and popular intersection, and business owners and residents slept somewhat more soundly, knowing that their neighbourhood was worth protecting. At an unrecorded hour, as he approached the corner of Pearl and Chatham, our policeman happened across what he thought was a drunken sailor slumped on the ground. George Wilson had liquored particularly hard that night, and the pavement must have seemed the most restful spot on which to gather his strength for the walk home.
30:16 Speaker 01 He was only a couple of streets over from Water Street, where he worked, so he had likely been out with the boys from work. As the constable approached George, he had no idea that the sailor he'd stumbled across was about to make headline news right across America. Vagrancy laws in New York sought to rid the city of individuals who were found inexplicably loitering or "out of place", just as George had been that night. These laws were purposefully vague. In attempting to enforce them, authorities sought to avoid social disturbances and reinforce class hierarchies as and when they saw fit.
30:57 Speaker 01 Public drunkenness was a fine example of an offence that could get you arrested under this legislation in New York in 1836. Interestingly, these same vagrancy laws were often applied to individuals suspected of gender or sexual non-conformity, but in George Wilson's case, it was his drunkenness and not his gender that inspired our policeman to scoop him up and escort him to the nearest "police office", as it was termed that night. There, the sailor could sober up and, if this was his first offence, would be on his way soon enough. By the time George arrived at the police office, he had realised the potential extent of his troubles.
31:41 Speaker 01 In a desperate attempt to avoid questioning that might expose his former identity and to avoid implicating Elizabeth, he had decided to lie. Initially, he told the processing magistrate, Mr. Lowndes, that his name was James Walker, and said that he was Irish, not Scottish. Walker claimed that he was 30 years old, though it was observed that care and trouble have left the furrows of more advanced age across his face. Walker also gave his address as Tillery Street, Brooklyn, another misdirection. Despite his obfuscation, the arresting officer and Lowndes suspected all was not as it seemed with prisoner Walker's backstory.
32:25 Speaker 01 One report claimed the magistrate had become suspicious because "of the softness of the prisoner's voice", leading the authorities to believe that Walker might not be the man he claimed. Whatever the case might have been, they soon suspected that they had caught a female in man's attire, although she was sunburnt and appeared somewhat masculine. Faced with their continued probing, George soon felt that his former self was too precarious a thing to hide. To throw Lowndes and the other arresting officer off the scent, Walker admitted that he had indeed been lying. He confessed that his "real name" was Jane Walker.
33:08 Speaker 01 This was another invention, but George quickly concocted an elaborate backstory for Jane, in the hope that she might elicit pity from the magistrate and ensure a speedy release. Jane's story was one of disappointed love. She had been on a promise from a young man back in Ireland. This young man had, apparently, left Ireland's shores, like so many did, and arrived in Quebec. Eventually, after about two years, he sent Jane the money he had promised so that she could join him there. This she did diligently, George revealed, but when she got to Quebec, her old flame was nowhere to be found.
33:49 Speaker 01 Jane, wishing to maintain her dignity and defend herself in this new land, set upon assuming the garb of a man in order to survive. This she had accomplished by working on the docks, in the hope of one day stumbling across her lost love amongst the other labourers there. It was quite the romantic yarn, heroic even. Despite this, Lowndes could hardly just release Jane Walker now. She had lied before. Was she lying again? Lowndes therefore summoned either a female prisoner or a surgeon, depending on your source, in order to carry out an inspection that would attempt to establish the facts behind Walker's latest confession.
34:33 Speaker 01 It was swiftly concluded that Jane Walker was a woman. Lowndes gave Walker a firm talking to about the evils of throwing aside her feminine dress and placed her back in the cell overnight. And that might have been that. Jane Walker might otherwise have spent the night in the cells and, having been directed to re-adopt female attire, been released. Jane Walker might have become nothing more than a lovelorn footnote in the annals of American immigration. But all chance of that vanished when, on the next morning, Saturday the 6th of August, Mrs Elizabeth Wilson approached Mr Lowndes, magistrate, in search of her missing, presumed
35:16 Speaker 01 drunk, husband Mr George Wilson. Mr Lowndes was, by all accounts, slightly baffled by the appearance of this decently dressed Scottish immigrant. He had not detained any man called George Wilson the previous night, he said, but having spoken with Elizabeth a little longer, it dawned on Lowndes that the prisoner Elizabeth wished to see was none other than Jane Walker. If Lowndes had understood correctly, Elizabeth had been legally married to his Jane for over fifteen years. On receiving this information, the magistrate ordered the prisoner to be brought up for a second examination.
35:58 Speaker 01 George is recorded as having been quite confused when confronted with his wife in the magistrate's office. One can imagine the wave of anxiety that overtook him momentarily, and then the frustrated anguish when Elizabeth looked at him in vexation and rage on hearing her husband's sex was discovered, refused to speak to him, and went away. Lowndes then informed his prisoner that Elizabeth had furnished him with additional details concerning the prisoner's real name and their marriage. George, sensing there was nowhere left to hide now, told the magistrate that he was not Irish, but had been born to Scottish parents at number 20 Atherton Street, Liverpool.
36:42 Speaker 01 George stated that the name he had been given at birth was George Moore Wilson, and that George is a name commonly given to females in England. George elaborated that, in consequence of being ill-treated by her friends, after George's mother had remarried, she ran away from them, put on boy's clothes, and made her way to Scotland. Wilson had spun so many tales that Lowndes asked for proof that this version of his life contained some truth, and so a marriage certificate was produced. This, the prisoner already had secreted about his person if contemporary newspaper reports are to be believed. According to these reports, the document read: Glasgow, 2nd of April, 1821.
37:27 Speaker 01 Certificate: That George Wilson, cotton spinner of Brighton, and Elizabeth Cummins, residing there, have been three several Sabbaths lawfully proclaimed in the barren church in order to marriage, and no objection has been offered. The above parties were lawfully married by me, John Marfontaine, minister. When the story inevitably leaked, as all good stories do eventually, hacks were suspicious of this certificate. "Wilson has told two stories," they observed. "It would not be at all surprising if this marvelous marriage should turn out to be a sham affair got up within a few days past." The details of the certificate quoted in The Pennsylvania
38:11 Speaker 01 remain curious. The first question has to be, why did a labourer carry confirmation of his marriage on him? Had George and Elizabeth agreed on this as a strategy? Should George's identity ever be questioned? But the details of the document are sketchy, too. For instance, Wilson and Cummins are thought to have married on the 6th of April, 1821, not the 2nd, as stated here. Brighton should read Bridgeton, formerly a Quoad Sacra parish and part of the larger parish of Barony in the suburbs of Glasgow. That was a far cry from Brighton in the southeast corner of England. And here's the other thing. There is no record of a minister, John Marfontaine,
38:55 Speaker 01 administering to his Glaswegian flock at this time or any time in the National Records of Scotland. And so even I began to worry about the authenticity of their marriage. George Wilson had understandably lied to magistrate Lowndes to protect his gender identity and his family. But in lying, he had muddied the archival waters. Where had this certificate come from? Who had issued it? Perhaps he and Elizabeth Cummins had not married at all, as people suspected. For some reason, the prospect that they had not married irked me. The Wilsons owed me nothing, obviously, but I needed to know if they had duped the heteroregulated system,
39:38 Speaker 01 surreptitiously inserting themselves within it. So much we know about George and Elizabeth comes from disparaging third-party accounts that I'd felt their marriage certificate was the one piece of archival evidence which actually reflected them, on their own terms, simple and all as it was. So for their marriage certificate to suddenly emerge as bogus felt like we were losing the one concrete piece of evidence in their archive. The reality was, though, that this document, as it appeared in The Pennsylvania, could not be trusted as proof of their marriage. I would have to dig a little deeper. If George and Elizabeth had legally married, there would be one readily available document
40:22 Speaker 01 lying in a Scottish archive, waiting to confirm it. An entry in the Barony Parish Papers from 1821. And so, I return to the archive once more.
40:54 Speaker 01 Initial searches threw up nothing. Plenty of Wilsons, but no George Wilson, and not a trace of an Elizabeth Cummins at all. I persevered, training my eyes on the spider-like writings scribbled across each of the pages. Finally, I came to the 2nd of April, 1821, the date when they had supposedly married, according to the Pennsylvania. I checked each entry for that day, and can confirm there was no Wilson-Cummins wedding. "Maybe it was not altogether surprising," I told myself, as I disappointedly continued examining the entries for the next day and the next.
41:35 Speaker 01 Maybe it was too much to hope that they had truly succeeded in infiltrating the system. It was then I found them. There they were, in black and white, on the 6th of April, 1821, not the 2nd, George Wilson married Elizabeth Cummins. They had been married. They had fooled the system. Their entry in the Old Parish Registers, 662/REF160/23 of Barony, is straightforward and to the point, but it corrects some of the misinformation that has been passed down to us over these last 200-odd years. The reported date of their marriage was out by four days, and in place of the elusive
42:19 Speaker 01 John Marfontaine, they had instead been married by John McFarlane. The entry in full reads: "George Wilson, cotton spinner, Bridgton, and Elizabeth Cummins, residing there, married 6th of April by the Reverend John McFarlane." It still didn't explain the inconsistencies of the marriage certificate printed in the Pennsylvania, but their marriage really had been legally formalised in April 1821. As Magistrate Lowndes attempted to get to grips with the interweaving elements of Wilson's stories, George sat calmly.
42:55 Speaker 01 Perpetually taking snuff, attired in striped pantaloons, a plaid stock and a grey roundabout. The life he and Elizabeth had worked so hard to build together over the last fifteen years, had come tumbling down about him in less than fifteen hours. Wilson worked the snuff between his fingers before sharply inhaling it. He rubbed the residue across his teeth and into his gums. What more could he do? The Pennsylvanian tells us that when it came to George Wilson's trial, Justice Hobson caused considerable merriment during the proceedings when he asked how many children they had since their marriage.
43:36 Speaker 01 Despite these gibes, Elizabeth Cummins, who had been summoned to attend, is recorded as having "treated the affair with the greatest nonchalance." If these proceedings phased her, she would not show it. Ultimately, George was found guilty under the vagrancy act, which covered both his drunkenness and his gender misdirection, and was again remanded. It is not known for how long he was held, though such sentences tended to be mercifully short for first-time offenders. If he was released, or if he ever saw Elizabeth again, that's it. That's all we know. It is here that we must abruptly take our leave of the tenacious George Wilson and
44:21 Speaker 01 the resourceful Elizabeth Cummins as they slip out of the primary source material. That is how it sometimes goes with history. We are bound to the information that has survived. Regardless of where their lives took them next, and despite contemporary claims to the contrary, it should be noted that there is nothing singular about the case of George Wilson. There were George Wilsons across America and the world, each working in his factory, labouring at his dock, taking himself a wife just as our George had done. The only difference is that our George Wilson had come to the attention of the authorities and, as a result, made it into the headlines.
45:02 Speaker 01 Though in truth, not even his discovery marks him out as unique as the later queer histories of Charles Hamilton, similarly tried under English vagrancy laws, and John Smith and New York Tinsmith, who also fell prey to New York's vagrancy laws demonstrate. But there's a frustration in this ending nonetheless, is there not? This history feels somewhat unresolved, as if the Wilsons ought to have provided us, for some unknown, petulant reason, with a happy ending. It was whilst thinking on this that I suddenly realized that, maybe, that was exactly what they had left us with. Remember, George and Elizabeth had never wanted to make headlines.
45:44 Speaker 01 They never wanted to endure the media scrutiny that followed George's arrest. They had wanted to avoid the jibes, the debate, and the deeply personal and intimate intrusion that followed. They had simply wanted to get on with their invisible, everyday lives. To work, earn money, and exist in the world on their own terms. Though we can never know for sure unless new evidence comes to light, it is my hope that their sudden archival departure denotes their happy return to that sought-after obscurity. A return to the mundanity of their lives before George had had a little bit too much
46:27 Speaker 01 to drink that August night in 1836. That's my hope for them. And what's history without a little hope?
46:45 Speaker 02 Hi, it's Danny Pellegrino from Everything Iconic. Twelve celebrities, one Don, and cold, hard cash. From the producers of The Traitors comes The Mob, a new Hulu original series. The iconic Parker Posey hosts this unique reality competition show where 12 celebrity contestants shake down in an Italian villa to win a share of up to $250,000. Watch The Mob, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
Previous Dark Side of Ancient Rome's Colosseum Next Who was the 'Man-Monster' Of New York? Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated