How Do I Give Feedback To An Employee When They Keep Making Mistakes?
- 28m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode addresses how to give effective feedback to an employee who keeps making mistakes. The hosts explain that leaders often blame employees for repeated errors without realizing they failed to provide proper training, just-in-time feedback, or clear operating systems. They argue that mistakes usually stem from three root causes: carelessness, a knowledge gap, or a systems gap. By categorizing the mistake, separating emotion from the facts, and using tools like screen-recording videos and checklists, leaders can guide their teams toward continuous improvement while building a healthy feedback culture.
- Identify whether a repeated mistake stems from carelessness, a knowledge gap, or a systems gap before addressing it. 3:03
- Provide just-in-time feedback immediately rather than storing up grievances for a six-month or annual review. 3:38
- Ask the employee to establish a checklist or new system to ensure the mistake does not happen again. 10:39
- Verify instructions by having employees repeat or output what you taught them to ensure comprehension. 13:30
Chapters
- 0:01Podcast Intro and Sponsor Ads
The episode opens with a brief intro, followed by multiple sponsor advertisements before the main Q&A begins.
- 0:59Question Introduction and Host Greeting
Omar Zenhome introduces the episode’s question about giving feedback to an employee who keeps making mistakes.
- 1:37Hosts’ Background and Teaching Experience
Omar and Nicole discuss their shared background as educators and how that informs their approach to feedback.
- 2:59Identifying Mistake Types and Feedback Timing
The hosts explain the three categories of mistakes and emphasize the importance of just‑in‑time feedback.
- 6:39Practical Just‑in‑Time Feedback Examples
Nicole and Omar walk through concrete examples of giving feedback to a marketer and a designer, illustrating knowledge and systems gaps.
- 10:39Building Systems and Checklists
They discuss creating systems, checklists, and ownership to prevent recurring mistakes and empower employees.
- 15:41Hiring, Role Clarity, and Managing Mismatches
The conversation turns to hiring the right fit, clarifying roles, and knowing when to let go of a poor match.
- 20:01Feedback Delivery Techniques and Emotional Tone
Omar shares strategies for honest, clear, and supportive feedback, including the use of praise and emotional neutrality.
- 24:55Public vs. Private Feedback Culture
They explore the benefits of giving small public corrections, fostering a culture where feedback is normal and constructive.
- 30:34Closing Recap and Call to Action
The hosts wrap up with key takeaways, encourage listeners to submit questions, and promote the next episode and subscription.
Highlights
- 3:03
Three Categories Of Mistakesinsight
The guest explains that most recurring workplace errors fall into one of three categories: carelessness, a knowledge gap, or a systems gap.
- 3:25
Just-In-Time Feedback As Investmentinsight
The host argues that if an entrepreneur only gives subtle hints instead of direct feedback, repeated employee mistakes are ultimately the leader's fault.
- 10:39
Putting Onus On Systemsstrategy
The host explains that after correcting a mistake, leaders should ask the employee what system or checklist they will create to prevent it.
- 13:30
Input-Output Teaching Methodstrategy
Drawing from their teaching background, the host recommends having employees repeat or demonstrate instructions right away to verify understanding.
- 14:29
Using Video For Detailed Feedbackstrategy
The guest suggests recording screen-share videos for complex feedback to convey tone and nuance, requiring a video response to confirm comprehension.
- 18:23
Cutting Losses On Wrong Hiresstory
The host shares that despite coaching and training, some employees lack the aptitude for a role, and keeping them creates an ongoing struggle.
- 27:08
Sunshining Mistakes Culturallystrategy
The hosts describe the Netflix practice of sunshining, where team members openly discuss mistakes to foster a company culture that embraces feedback.
Quotes
“People make mistakes. How you react to that as the leader of your company is what's going to make all the difference.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:10 “Just-in-time feedback, that's one of our mantras.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:38 “You need to verify that they actually got what you told them.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:56 “I want you to win. When you win, I win.”
Unnamed speaker · 20:05 “We want to see you win, and we’re comfortable having these conversations.”
Unnamed speaker · 6:08
Sponsored segments
- US Bank 0:01–0:28
- LegalZoom 0:41–0:57
About this episode
Giving feedback is one of the hardest parts of leadership. You want your team to improve, but you also don't want every mistake to turn into an uncomfortable conversation. When the same issue keeps popping up, it's easy to wonder whether you're being too patient, too harsh, or simply not getting through.
Transcript
6,710 words · 6 speakers
Topics
- Loom
- LZ Legal Services
- iXL Learning
- Webinar Ninja
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated