Skip to content

The Ridley Scott Movie Rankings and ‘The Dog Stars’

The Big Picture

Hosted by Amanda Dobbins and Sean Fennessey

1h 59m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins, joined by Chris Ryan, review Ridley Scott's 30th feature film, The Dog Stars, starring Jacob Elordi and Josh Brolin. The hosts analyze Scott's signature shooting style of deploying multiple cameras, the film's post-apocalyptic tone, and its tonal shifts compared to the original Peter Heller novel. Alongside the review, they cover recent movie news including the passings of icons Dolly Parton and Tim Curry, the casting rumors for the next James Bond, and Ryan Gosling's developing Flintstones project. The episode concludes with a comprehensive, debate-filled ranking of Ridley Scott's entire 30-film directorial catalog from Exodus Gods and Kings to Alien.

  • Audiences can expect a visually pleasing but narratively uneven post-apocalyptic thriller in Ridley Scott's The Dog Stars. 22:50
  • Viewers should note that shooting with multiple cameras simultaneously can sometimes compromise actor performance depth. 31:55
  • Listeners can anticipate a massive debate over ranking legendary filmographies like Ridley Scott's. 1:57:19
  • Fans of classic science fiction can rely on Alien remaining the undisputed peak of Scott's career. 1:36:32

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Mental Health Disclosure

    The hosts open the episode with a personal story about depression and a call to seek help.

  2. 0:37
    Caplyta Prescription Ad

    A brief pharmaceutical advertisement explains the benefits and risks of the antidepressant Caplyta.

  3. 1:31
    Applebee's Late‑Night Promotion

    A commercial segment promotes Applebee's half‑price appetizers available after dark.

  4. 2:17
    Show Introduction and Ridley Scott Focus

    Hosts Sean and Amanda introduce the episode, announcing a discussion of Ridley Scott's new film and a ranking of his movies.

  5. 2:56
    James Bond Casting Rumors

    The conversation turns to the speculation over the next actor to play James Bond, listing potential candidates and discussing expectations.

  6. 22:02
    Ridley Scott’s Dog Stars Overview

    The hosts give a synopsis of the film, its cast, and its setting, noting its post‑apocalyptic premise.

  7. 40:00
    Dog Stars Critique and Production Style

    A detailed review of the film’s strengths and weaknesses, including comments on its pacing, visual style, and use of multiple cameras.

  8. 40:35
    Conclusion and Future Episodes Teaser

    The hosts wrap up the episode, hinting at upcoming topics and thanking listeners.

  9. 46:26
    Dog Stars Narrative Breakdown

    The hosts dissect the plot and character arcs of Ridley Scott’s Dog Stars, noting its disjointed storytelling and unclear motivations.

  10. 48:40
    Ridley Scott’s Recent Filmography Analysis

    The conversation shifts to Scott’s body of work over the last decade, evaluating his production style and narrative consistency.

  11. 51:56
    Character Analysis: Jacob Elordi and Supporting Cast

    Discussion of Elordi’s portrayal, the depth of his character, and comparisons to other actors in similar roles.

  12. 54:46
    Business Model and Legacy Debate

    Hosts debate how Scott’s production company and commercial ventures enable his continued high-budget filmmaking and whether this affects his legacy.

  13. 56:53
    Final Top 10 and Closing Reflections

    The hosts finalize their top ten list, reflect on Scott’s career trajectory, and wrap up the episode with final thoughts and sign‑offs.

  14. 1:00:00
    Ranking Ridley Scott’s Films

    The episode moves into a ranking exercise, with the hosts debating placement of films from 30 to 1, highlighting disagreements over titles like House of Gucci and A Goodyear.

  15. 1:31:10
    Reordering Gladiator 2 and Napoleon

    The hosts debate where to place Gladiator 2 relative to Napoleon and Goodyear, ultimately deciding on a spot between the two.

Highlights

  • 2:27

    Reviewing The Dog Starsinsight

    The hosts introduce Ridley Scott's new post-apocalyptic thriller starring Jacob Elordi, framing it as a major cinematic event.

  • 21:40

    Production Backgrounddata

    Sean Fennessey details the notable crew and cast changes on The Dog Stars, noting the shift from longtime DP Darius Wolski to Eric Messerschmidt.

  • 31:59

    Shooting with Ten Camerasinsight

    Chris Ryan explains how Ridley Scott now directs using multiple cameras simultaneously like a live television director, altering actor preparation.

  • 58:07

    Final Rankings Revealeddata

    The hosts complete their exhaustive countdown of all 30 Ridley Scott films, placing Exodus Gods and Kings at the bottom.

  • 1:15:12

    The Third Act Twistdebate

    The hosts debate a major third-act invention not found in the original novel that completely alters the movie's dystopian vibe.

  • 1:36:32

    Crowning Achievementinsight

    The hosts unanimously crown Alien as the absolute best film in Ridley Scott's massive catalog.

Quotes

  • “Dolly Parton, who passed away yesterday, as did the actor Tim Curry.”
    Sean Fennessey · 3:26
  • “when they were inducted into the rock and roll, or he was inducted into the Rock and Roll Music Hall of Fame.”
    Amanda Dobbins · 4:48
  • “I remember seeing him as darkness in Legend at a young age, which is a real kind of gateway movie for me in terms of both fantasy and horror.”
    Sean Fennessey · 7:29
  • “The most surprising name that I saw was Jack Barton, who is another actor on Heartstopper, a show I don't watch.”
    Sean Fennessey · 8:55
  • “And you know, one question that I see online a lot is like, how does Ridley keep getting”
    Sean Fennessey · 54:34
  • “Yeah. I mean, this was true in Exodus Gods and Kings.”
    Sean Fennessey · 58:07
  • “Whereas I feel like it's, I think it's a little worse than House of Gucci and Napoleon and Gladiator two, but not like that much worse.”
    Sean Fennessey · 59:04
  • “I mean, look at all of these films.”
    Sean Fennessey · 1:01:26
  • “The first hour of this movie is incredible, uh, the second hour.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:33:53
  • Caplyta 0:37–2:26

About this episode

Sean and Amanda are joined by Chris Ryan to discuss the newest release from his guy Ridley Scott in ‘The Dog Stars’ starring Jacob Elordi and Margaret Qualley. They share their takeaways from the movie, debate Elordi’s performance and evolution as an actor, and assess where the film fits within Scott’s career. Before diving into ‘The Dog Stars’, they reflect on the passing of Dolly Parton and Tim Curry, celebrating their remarkable careers and discussing what each of them meant personally. Then, they check in on the latest James Bond casting race and debate the strongest candidates among the six remaining contenders, before touching on Ryan Gosling’s developing ‘Flintstones’ project and whether it means Chris’s king is officially dead. Finally, Sean, Amanda, and Chris take on the daunting task of ranking all 30 films in Ridley Scott’s vast filmography. (0:00) Intro (1:16) Dolly Parton and Tim Curry (5:51) The next James Bond (15:46) Ryan Gosling ‘Flintstones’ spin-off (19:23) ‘The Dog Stars’ (50:33) Talking Ridley Scott (1:02:53) The Ridley Scott Movie Rankings Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins Guest: Chris Ryan Producer: Jack Sanders Editor: Jamie Yukich Production Support: Sarah Reddy and Lucas Cavanagh It's on Prime. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:59:53

23,503 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Goodyear
  • Napoleon
  • Hannibal
  • Covenant
  • Kingdom of Heaven
  • Grand Junction
  • Duelist
  • The Martian
  • The Counselor
  • Body of Lies

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated