Pod Insights The Big Picture The Diane Keaton Hall of Fame About this episode Sean and Amanda open the show by briefly discussing the disappointing opening weekend box office performance of ‘Minions & Monsters.’ Then, they honor legendary actor Diane Keaton by celebrating what made her such a special star, and they build her Hall of Fame, selecting their favorite performances from her illustrious career.
(0:00) Intro
(0:58) The disappointing box office performance of ‘Minions & Monsters’
(8:38) What made Diane Keaton so special?
(36:28) The Diane Keaton Hall of Fame
Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins
Producer: Jack Sanders
Production Support: Lucas Cavanagh
It’s on Prime.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 27,781 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters.
0:07 Speaker 00 Tremfya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tremfya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tremfya, proper training is required. Tremfya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis, serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremfya today.
0:52 Speaker 00 Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit tremfyradio.com.
1:16 Sean Fennessey? I'm Sean Finacy. I'm Amanda Dobbins. And this is The Big Picture, a conversation show about Diane Keaton. Today on the show, we are building a Hall of Fame for Diane Keaton, one of the great actresses to emerge from the new Hollywood who had a film career that lasted more than half a century and includes several of the greatest American films ever made. We will dive right into some movie news and her entire career right after this.
1:38 Sean Fennessey? This episode of The Big Picture is presented by Amazon Prime. One of the best things about streaming is that you never just pick a title, you pick a feeling. And Prime makes that easy. With great entertainment and fast shipping that brings the moment to life, Prime helps you experience the feeling you're craving, shows you can't wait for, and deliveries you don't wait for. One click away. From streaming to fast shipping, it's on Prime.
1:58 Sean Fennessey? Okay, Dobbins.
1:59 Amanda Dobbins? Hello.
2:00 Sean Fennessey? Since you're dressed like Diane Keaton, uh, this is your episode and so it's fitting that we discuss the Minions before we talk about it.
2:07 Amanda Dobbins? You're just absolutely dumping all the responsibility on me. That's fine. I'm ready to offer a qualified defense.
2:13 Sean Fennessey? So...
2:13 Amanda Dobbins? Of the box office performance of a, the eighth, 12th, 49th installment of a franchise.
2:19 Sean Fennessey? I think it's the seventh.
2:20 Amanda Dobbins? That I'm spiritually, but not financially or professionally connected to in any way.
2:25 Sean Fennessey? Minions and Monsters opened over the July 4th weekend. How was your July 4th weekend?
2:29 Amanda Dobbins? It was great and it was filled with things that were not going to the movies.
2:33 Sean Fennessey? That's true.
2:34 Amanda Dobbins? Which is, I think, an issue for many Americans. I went to several parties, thanks to everyone. I, I didn't host any. I went to many parks. I watched many soccer games.
2:49 Sean Fennessey? Mm-hmm.
2:50 Amanda Dobbins? I didn't, I didn't attend the local Cineplex. So, nor did anyone else.
2:55 Sean Fennessey? Nor did I. And if I'm not going to the movies, that's a bad sign. Um, I think there's a lot of variety of factors, but yeah, Minions and Monsters came in five day cumulative $61.4 million. That's the lowest in the franchise's history. Only $36.4 million over the three day period. We didn't review the movie. It was released last Wednesday. I guess maybe we'll have a somewhat larger discussion of it, um, later in the month. I will say, as a non-Minions person.
3:19 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
3:20 Sean Fennessey? I found it very, very amusing that after years of being ignored by critics and the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.
3:28 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
3:29 Sean Fennessey? Minions and the Despicable Me franchise finally made a movie that is like a Where's Waldo full of movie references for nerds like us.
3:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
3:38 Sean Fennessey? And they were roundly rejected by general audiences. There's something kind of delicious about that.
3:42 Amanda Dobbins? And it, it's sad. Again, I, I do think the timing was spectacularly bad.
3:48 Sean Fennessey? It was.
3:49 Amanda Dobbins? Uh, and...
3:49 Sean Fennessey? And two weeks after Toy Story 5 as well.
3:51 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. And, but the World Cup got really good this weekend.
3:55 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
3:55 Amanda Dobbins? You know, like, we were all sitting there in front of, on Saturday and Sunday night, the, so, some of it, I agree, is timing. And I guess even movie nerds did not want to abandon their 4th of July holiday plans. Don't forget Taylor Swift's wedding.
4:09 Sean Fennessey? Sure, that was another cultural event that captured the imaginations of millions.
4:13 Amanda Dobbins? Certainly crowded out of the space and many of the people who have spent the last weeks, and let me say... To everyone who sent me a Minions meme, including the young woman performing in Minion E's at one of the premieres, including the interview with Pierre Cofan, talking about how Dua Lipa is a major part of Minions' influence and they even sing some Dua Lipa songs, I think. Listen, I see you. I appreciate you. I felt seen. But even those people stopped sending me Minions memes and started sending me Taylor Swift guest list updates. So, you know, the attentions were elsewhere.
4:47 Sean Fennessey? They didn't capture the cultural zeitgeist. Now, I have a question for you about this.
4:51 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
4:52 Sean Fennessey? We have been discussing over the last six, 12 months about how all of these historical franchises from the 21st century are starting to fall away in the consciousness. Now, the Minions, there haven't been as many Minions movies as Jurassic movies or as Marvel movies.
5:05 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
5:06 Sean Fennessey? But this is the seventh one. Like, is this also just a franchise getting long in the tooth?
5:10 Amanda Dobbins? I think yes, though also you just put it up against dinosaurs and superheroes. So then tiny yellow Tic Tacs. They're like, hey.
5:20 Sean Fennessey? I'm not equating them in terms of stature.
5:23 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
5:23 Sean Fennessey? But...
5:24 Amanda Dobbins? Well, that's good because they're quite small.
5:26 Sean Fennessey? But these are mega billion dollar franchises. This is a mega billion dollar franchise.
5:29 Amanda Dobbins? Absolutely. We are at the end of one generation and the dawn of another, which I think coincides, you know, pretty neatly with you and I are old and the next generation of people is rising and they don't care about the yellow Tic Tacs.
5:44 Sean Fennessey? Well, I wonder...
5:45 Amanda Dobbins? Or references to cinema, or a cameo by George Lucas.
5:48 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, that's true. Well, that's, but again, that was for us. That wasn't for them. What does George Lucas even mean to 20-year-olds who were seven when the first Minions movie came out, or maybe even younger than that? That's part of it, too, is sometimes the kids who are born on this stuff, they grow out of these franchises. I don't know. It could, it could, it's probably a lot of what you're describing, though, which was that this was a very active and busy July 4th weekend for a lot of people. Not a lot of people went to the movies. You know what hung in there, though? Disclosure Day with a very small drop of 27%, which I thought was interesting.
6:17 Amanda Dobbins? Right on.
6:18 Sean Fennessey? I know that because I own Disclosure Day in my movie fantasy league and picked up some extra points over the weekend by sticking around in the top five.
6:25 Amanda Dobbins? You also endured some, like, live comment section coming at you. We both did at one of the many barbecues hosted by our friends, and that's fine, you know?
6:32 Sean Fennessey? Yes. A lot, a lot of stray shots at Steven Spielberg.
6:35 Amanda Dobbins? We love to talk about movies.
6:36 Sean Fennessey? From people who are less talented than Steven Spielberg. But who do make movies?
6:40 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
6:40 Sean Fennessey? Very, very interesting experience.
6:42 Amanda Dobbins? Who I like a lot.
6:42 Sean Fennessey? The great people.
6:43 Amanda Dobbins? And I love their children too.
6:44 Sean Fennessey? Wonderful people.
6:44 Amanda Dobbins? But they were, they were just, people, people love to podcast at us.
6:47 Sean Fennessey? The schadenfreude running.
6:48 Amanda Dobbins? And I was like, sir, I'm just trying to finish this can of Negroni.
6:52 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, let me just ask you one quick meta question.
6:55 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
6:55 Sean Fennessey? Cause I think Diane Keaton is one of the great meta stars in a lot of ways. Her persona became her personality, or her personality became her persona, or whatever. When you're at a social function.
7:03 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
7:04 Sean Fennessey? And you're Amanda Dobbins of The Big Picture and myriad other podcasts.
7:09 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
7:10 Sean Fennessey? But let's just say, for, for these purposes, The Big Picture.
7:14 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
7:14 Sean Fennessey? And someone's like, I've got some movie takes for you. A friend, someone you care for.
7:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
7:18 Sean Fennessey? Are you like, I will turn on podcast persona?
7:23 Amanda Dobbins? No, no, no, I, I sit back and relax. And I'm honestly like a little bit annoyed. A, a non-movie example of this is that when Taylor Swift got married this weekend and the press release went out, do you know Tree Payne sent out a press release detailing?
7:37 Sean Fennessey? Sure.
7:38 Amanda Dobbins? Certain specifics from the wedding.
7:40 Sean Fennessey? How cool is it that we all know who Taylor Swift's publicist is?
7:42 Amanda Dobbins? Really, really cool.
7:43 Sean Fennessey? In this dystopian nightmare.
7:44 Amanda Dobbins? Well, some of us have gotten threatening emails from her before. So, anyway, as it's, as it's happening and I'm, you know, logging on to the jam session doc and making my notes or whatever, and my beloved long-suffering husband sitting next to me offers an opinion about, he thought that Friday was a weird day to get married. And I was pretty rude. I was like, I don't, I'm not working right now. I'm prepping and I don't need your opinion. So for my loved ones, I'm pretty rude.
8:11 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
8:11 Amanda Dobbins? For everyone else, but that's really just Zach. I, I don't think I would do that to anyone else. And then I did apologize. Um, although I said, I think Friday, a, a wedding on Friday is the least weird part of this wedding.
8:22 Sean Fennessey? I can't disagree with that, I gotta say.
8:24 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
8:24 Sean Fennessey? Sometimes I really feel for Zach.
8:28 Sean Fennessey? It's just not nice.
8:30 Amanda Dobbins? I apologize.
8:30 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
8:31 Amanda Dobbins? I, when I'm wrong, say that I'm wrong. And I said, I'm really sorry.
8:34 Sean Fennessey? Well, you were right.
8:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
8:36 Sean Fennessey? You can, you can be right about that opinion, but it's how you deliver your rightness, right? That's the challenge.
8:40 Amanda Dobbins? And I was, I was focused. It, you know, he also, like, he came into my space. It was like the one time that he asked me to read a piece, to like, pick which lead he wanted. And my hands went towards the keyboard and there was just like an eh sound and I was never allowed to edit anything again because I went into his space. That's not allowed.
8:58 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
8:58 Amanda Dobbins? So we got to know the rules.
8:59 Sean Fennessey? That's fair.
9:00 Amanda Dobbins? But for someone I'm not married to, personally or professionally, I just let them talk. This happened recently where a bunch of people were talking about the drama at a, at a party and I, they weren't like, they were new acquaintances. So I just sat back.
9:14 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
9:15 Amanda Dobbins? And let it go.
9:15 Sean Fennessey? Nothing to be gained there.
9:16 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And just let them talk and I was like, oh, really interesting.
9:20 Sean Fennessey? The worst version for me, and I say this with affection, is uh, when everyone knows what I already think because they listened to an episode.
9:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
9:27 Sean Fennessey? And then they just want to, they want to rebuttal.
9:30 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
9:30 Sean Fennessey? Even if, even if they agree, they just want to rebut all the points, which you know what? It's a, it's an occupational hazard of this wonderful profession of ours. Um, all right, let's, let's pivot away from, from this frivolous chit chat and let's get down to the, the real, real work. Because this has been real work, what we've been doing to honor the great Diane Keaton.
9:47 Amanda Dobbins? I don't think that we understood what we were taking on when we put this on the calendar.
9:52 Sean Fennessey? No, so Keaton passed away last fall and we've taken some time to do this. And I think we both knew we wanted to do it.
9:59 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
9:59 Sean Fennessey? I also knew that I had quite a few holes um, in terms of covering Diane Keaton's career because it's not just that it's been so long. And as we've talked about, folks like Robert Duvall and Robert Redford who've passed in, in the last year or so. I think I knew I had some, some, some blind spots with those actors. But I know with Diane Keaton that she has really not been, the films that she's been making have not been a primary focus of mine for the last 15 years.
10:23 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
10:24 Sean Fennessey? And I actually didn't realize quite how many of them there were. And yet, despite that, despite having moved to like,
10:31 Sean Fennessey? A kind of Redbox era where she's making a lot of films that are, if not direct to streaming or VOD, feel like they are. I don't think she ever really lost status. Like, she never really got diminished in terms of her iconography and how celebrated she was. And so like, it seems like a pretty interesting threading of the needle there, where it's like, people like me are like, I don't know what Palms is. I guess that's a movie, but I still-
10:55 Amanda Dobbins? Palms, not Palms, yeah.
10:57 Sean Fennessey? Not Palms. These are Palms. Palms are like pom poms. You know, I know she means a lot to you, but have you thought about her this century, I guess?
11:05 Amanda Dobbins? No, I mean, you mentioned that she so quickly became Diane Keaton as a person and as a larger-than-life figure. And that is through all the work in the 70s and the 80s, but really Annie Hall, right? And I mean, we can all see how I'm dressed. And so there was something visual about the way that you thought of Diane Keaton that she continued even through all the Redbox era. And what, you know, she added on hats at some point and like the big glasses. But there was something that was still always aesthetically Diane Keaton, even if she was in a movie that you've never heard of with Richard Gere and William H. Macy and Susan Sarandon. Did you watch that one?
11:48 Sean Fennessey? Weddings and Other Disasters, is that what that's called?
11:51 Amanda Dobbins? I don't remember. Or maybe it's, maybe I do. And Love and Other Disasters is the Jeremy Irons one?
11:57 Sean Fennessey? Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah.
11:58 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, listen, this is the thing. And I volunteered to be Captain Redbox. And I think I saw it all.
12:05 Sean Fennessey? Okay. Well, we're gonna have plenty of time to talk about all of it.
12:07 Amanda Dobbins? So you're watching all of this. And it is virtually like, those movies didn't happen in terms of cinema history. But she's still making her diet, you know, she has her mannerisms. She's very recognizable as a physical performer. And she played into the Diane Keaton of all, of it all. There was like an aura maintenance that she did until the end of her life that I think helped.
12:33 Sean Fennessey? Do you think that you will eventually evolve toward hats and oversized glasses?
12:38 Amanda Dobbins? I thought about getting a hat last week. And I was gonna, I was gonna go for the Something's Gotta Give bucket hat. I do feel on like the spectrum of hats, bucket hats are more where I'm bucket hat and baseball cap as opposed to, you know, bowler hat.
12:54 Sean Fennessey? But- Bowler hat would be a bold choice.
12:57 Amanda Dobbins? Or I mean,
12:58 Sean Fennessey? Have you just walked in one day wearing a bowler hat with a cane?
13:01 Amanda Dobbins? I have to be honest, I do. I'm not, you know, I'm not a milliner. So I think that's what it's called.
13:05 Sean Fennessey? You're not a milliner?
13:06 Amanda Dobbins? But so I don't know the terminology for the various. It wasn't a fedora that she gravitated towards. Um, I did some of the seventies and eighties stuff that I revisited.
13:17 Sean Fennessey? Mm hmm.
13:18 Amanda Dobbins? I was just like writing notes, like full on style, just absolutely dynamite.
13:23 Sean Fennessey? One of the most influential.
13:26 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
13:26 Sean Fennessey? Uh, fashion figures in film history without question. Um, but also very difficult to replicate. I say that with no disrespect to what you're attempting today, but she had a singularity. That was.
13:38 Amanda Dobbins? This is an homage. No one can be Diane Keaton. Many have tried and failed spectacularly.
13:43 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, it's interesting too, because, you know, in the early stages of her career, she's obviously not dressing like Diane Keaton. So we'll talk about these first few films that she made. And she's just a strikingly beautiful woman. Like she's just, she's a beautiful actress.
13:54 Amanda Dobbins? Unreal.
13:54 Sean Fennessey? Um, who, I think because of the influence that she made on the people who were making movies for her in the late seventies, started to build movies around her essence. Which is, you know, something you might hear about like Greta Garbo. But you don't hear as much now about modern movie stars where the sort of like, not just how they dressed off screen, but kind of what their personalities were. They're kind of that very particular je ne sais quoi that she had that where people were like, how do I get who you really are into the movie?
14:25 Amanda Dobbins? Right, right. It's also a little bit because of the types of movies that she was making, but also the time period in which she was making them, which, you know, she starts in 1970, in, in films anyway, and is going through the women's lib movement, if you want to call it that.
14:47 Sean Fennessey? Sure, I will call it that.
14:48 Amanda Dobbins? I'm just like, we're not there yet. I just want to let you know.
14:51 Sean Fennessey? They were liberated and now we're equal. You're free and it's 50 50.
14:56 Amanda Dobbins? Right now on camera, do you know whether we have an equal rights amendment?
15:00 Sean Fennessey? Uh, we don't have one.
15:01 Amanda Dobbins? Correct.
15:02 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
15:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. Okay, good. You learned that since the last time I popped into you. Um, but so she is often playing.
15:08 Sean Fennessey? But I'm working on a new one.
15:10 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, good. Thank you.
15:11 Sean Fennessey? It's called 75 25. You get 25%.
15:14 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, good. But so she's often doing playing contemporary roles. I was thinking about her in terms of, in comparison to Meryl Streep, who is like, kind of similar, a little bit younger, but in age range and coming up in a similar time period and a similar part of, you know, Hollywood history. And Meryl does a lot of period pieces. And Diane Keaton is sort of, is reflecting more often than not, what a, what a woman, or, you know, at least like the most beautiful, affluent, educated woman you've ever seen in your life, it was doing in the US, more in New York City in 1975, 1980, 1987, et cetera.
15:56 Amanda Dobbins? So you see people, the movies start being modeled around her, but her also navigating the world that she is surrounded by. In interesting, if not always accurate ways.
16:10 Sean Fennessey? Well, it's a great comparison that between the two of them. Obviously not just because we just watched all of Meryl Streep's films for an episode earlier this year, but because Streep is best known for transformations, accent work, and for frequently playing real people. And as far as I could tell, across the 50 plus movies that Diane Keaton made, she only played a real person one time in her entire career. Just Louise Bryant in Reds. I think, I think that's right. Maybe there's one or two that I'm forgetting, but I don't think so. And you could say on the one hand, well, Diane Keaton was not as much of a transformational, transformationist actress, right? On the other hand, it seemed like maybe filmmakers saw her as what you're describing, which is like a very contemporary, a modern woman.
16:53 Sean Fennessey? And that there was something kind of not very iron lady about Diane Keaton. And so why would you cast her in a movie like that? Doesn't seem like she was even drawn to those parts either, if you read interviews with her. And so even though those two actresses, kind of more or less, kind of, you know, Diane Keaton starts before Meryl Streep, but they kind of are similar stature through the, through the early 90s, I would say. And then things start to shift where Meryl becomes kind of the goddess of dramatic film.
17:18 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
17:19 Sean Fennessey? And Diane Keaton is still very active and working, but maybe doesn't hold the same, I don't know, sort of like gravitas among critics and the academy.
17:29 Sean Fennessey? But I like that. I liked that going through, especially that stretch, like all the way through 95 or 96, where it was like, this isn't just some dopey biopic of a person that you could just read the Wikipedia of. Like, sometimes the movies weren't good, but I was watching The Good Mother and I was like, oh.
17:46 Amanda Dobbins? What's happening here?
17:47 Sean Fennessey? This is a weird movie. That's interesting that you chose to do this. And so you think that her career is like only these totemic, major American movies, and a lot of them are for the first 15 years. But then she's kind of in the wilderness of creativity where she's just relying upon writers and filmmakers to generate something for her that she can fit into.
18:12 Sean Fennessey? So she's a very present figure in my life as a movie watcher. Because my wife's favorite director is Woody Allen.
18:17 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
18:17 Sean Fennessey? Or Woody Allen and Hitchcock, really. But she had always had Woody Allen movies on.
18:22 Amanda Dobbins? I remember.
18:23 Sean Fennessey? For the first 20 years of our relationship. And so I've seen a lot of these movies over and over again, just like in proximity to Eileen cooking dinner. And, you know, she's a major icon for Eileen, too. And so she's a little bit like wallpaper to me as a person. I mean that with no disrespect. But like, she was just kind of always around in our life. And it was interesting to kind of try to pull myself out of that wallpaper feeling. And I know she's a huge actress for you, and you know, we talked about Something's Gotta Give last year with 25 for 25. So I kind of like reset my brain on who she is. You know what I'm saying?
18:59 Amanda Dobbins? In a similar way, to the extent that, you know, because she is Woody Allen's foil in so many of their movies together. And she's kind of like the stand-in for Woody Allen. And then she moves on, but keeps doing romantic comedies, or, you know, comedies about people and relationships and talking and not character work, not stunts. And then she leads into the next generation or two of romantic comedies, or at least, you know, movies starring women talking about feelings. So that is the lens, and that's how I know her as well. Even though, again, I was really startled to see her filmography post 2015.
19:42 Amanda Dobbins? But, so same, where she's just kind of always existed. And I guess that's another way in which Meryl kind of looms large, because they're from the same generation and Meryl is, you know, has always been. The like the woman from The Iron Lady. Or some version of it. And Diane Keaton has always been like this slightly neurotic and daffy, but always capable. Like aspirational woman in like in a in a comedy or just in a normal movie, in a in a movie about people.
20:17 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, yeah, yeah. She she frequently plays middle class or upper middle class people, too. She doesn't play like she's not an iron. She's playing a hobo in Ironweed, opposite Jack Nicholson. You know what I mean? When she goes opposite Jack Nicholson, he's playing Eugene O'Neill. So it's an interesting kind of persona that she crafted for herself. She's from Los Angeles. She was born in 1946. She was raised in, I think, Santa Ana mostly. Her mother was Mrs. Highland Park, something she talks about and frequently in interviews. She studied at Santa Ana and Orange Coast College, and then she studied at Neighborhood Playhouse under Sandy Meisner. And that hugely informed the kind of actress that she was, and she talks about this all the time, about being an actor of reactivity, of looking what the other person is giving you while performing and bouncing off of that.
21:02 Sean Fennessey? And so that's an interesting thing, because a lot of actors who use the Meisner method and work that way oftentimes are only as good as their scene partners. And so in some of her films, you can feel her like not being as alive as you want her to be, because she's like, maybe I'm not having a good time making this movie. And then other times, you're like, well, this is the most electrifying scene in movie history that I'm watching right here. So it's an interesting thing. She did start on the stage. She was in the first production of Hair in 1968. She was effectively in the chorus. She was like a vocal performer. And she talked in many interviews about how she was like, I liked these songs. I didn't really know what was going on.
21:44 Sean Fennessey? But then one year later, she gets cast in a Broadway production of Played Against Sam, which was eventually adapted into a film, and she was cast opposite Woody Allen. And that's where they met and started working together and created this very long partnership. And he is the most significant creative collaborator. They've made eight movies together over the years.
22:04 Amanda Dobbins? Who's number two?
22:06 Sean Fennessey? Number two is Nancy Meyers, of course. She wrote three films for her and directed one. Would have liked her to direct one more.
22:13 Amanda Dobbins? With.
22:14 Sean Fennessey? With, I would, I could have gone, looking, going through the filmography, I was like, I could have gone for one more Nancy and Diane movie.
22:20 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
22:20 Sean Fennessey? You know?
22:21 Amanda Dobbins? Well, but then again, instead of the Nancy, instead of Diane, she just used Meryl.
22:25 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, which I like.
22:26 Amanda Dobbins? I really like it, too. Meryl's obviously not the problem in that film.
22:31 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, okay. There are problems? And then, of course, she made three movies with Francis Ford Coppola.
22:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
22:37 Sean Fennessey? Three Godfather films. And I don't think she recurred with any other directors. Is that possible? Maybe the book club director did that? Was this the same fellow direct both book club movies?
22:48 Amanda Dobbins? I am Googling Book Club 2 right now, which I saw in theaters, so I come by this honestly. But, yes, yes. Congratulations to Bill Holderman, who directed Book Club and Book Club.
22:59 Sean Fennessey? That's right.
23:01 Amanda Dobbins? The next chapter, of course.
23:03 Sean Fennessey? She, of course, yeah. She notably did not work with many of the hallowed new Hollywood figures. Never made a movie with Scorsese, never made a movie with Altman, never made a movie with Friedkin. She almost made a movie with Spielberg that fell apart, though they have a very interesting connection that I'm not sure if you're aware of. No Kubrick, no Polanski, no Milos Forman. She didn't work with any of those directors. And I wonder if it's because a lot of those people often made movies not set in the modern times.
23:32 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
23:33 Sean Fennessey? And that she was a very modern woman, and they didn't necessarily fit into the kinds of films that they were working on. Okay, what defines her as a star? We talked about her persona and her style.
23:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
23:43 Sean Fennessey? What else do you think makes a Diane Keaton performance?
23:47 Amanda Dobbins? Well, so when she, at the Oscars this year, went in the end memoriam segment, it was, I believe, Rachel McAdams who introduced her, and she was, she was referenced over and over as a comedian, which I think she was first and foremost, and probably the most celebrated and respected of, of her generation in terms of people like who did comedy. But the way that she did comedy is what made her so special, because. She understood that comedy is just another vessel to, you know, another way to emotions. And so she is sort of playing things for laughs, but I wouldn't say that, she knows that she's funny.
24:33 Amanda Dobbins? But what she is doing is she is processing emotions through absurdity and comedy, which many people, including myself, do. As opposed to, you know, through tears and wailing and, and, and beating your chest and the, and, and closing yourself off from the world. So I like, she does plenty of drama and I think, and is very good in a lot of it. But most of her comedy roles also have a lot of drama in them. And I think that they are what she is remembered for when we think of, you know, the way that Diane Keaton acts is just like a,
25:09 Amanda Dobbins? a pathos in being funny that, um, that opens it up to everybody.
25:14 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I, I think she has become a bit underrated as a dramatic actress because so much of her iconography is indebted to those comedy roles. And also because you pointed this out to me, this was a really good note, that she's so similar to De Niro. In that De Niro has made a lot of movies in the last 20 years where you're like, Robert De Niro made this movie?
25:32 Amanda Dobbins? Including a movie with her, did you watch that one?
25:35 Sean Fennessey? Certainly did not.
25:35 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
25:37 Sean Fennessey? And, but like, we're willing to forgive those movies. We don't really think too hard about those movies. We're like, yeah, but he made The Deer Hunter, like, it's okay. And, and for her, it's very similar where it's like, you know, she made Annie Hall, or she made Manhattan, or she made, you know, on down the list that we'll talk about. But going back and either re-watching or watching for the first time, some of the more dramatic films that she made. I think maybe because some of those movies in the eighties didn't really work. They weren't financially successful. And she was also kind of pivoting her career a little bit where she starts directing more. Eventually she has a, she has a family, like she starts making some of those choices. And you can see her kind of not getting the respect. Also, she's a woman who's just getting older in Hollywood, right?
26:20 Sean Fennessey? So maybe doesn't have as many opportunities, or maybe she's being, she's going up against the Meryl Streeps and the Jessica Langs and the Sissy SpaceX. And all of her contemporaries who were maybe considered like more heavyweight dramatic actresses. But I loved a lot of the stuff she does in the late seventies and early eighties. I think she's really, really good in that, in some of that's more steely material, too.
26:38 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but she's, the big, the big exception for me is Reds, which she's just like electric and, and perfectly balanced against Warren Beatty, and then against Jack Nicholson, and it's kind of the fulcrum between the two. And that, there are no laughs in that. Like, that is just straight up. That is, we are, we're saving the world and saving each other in an, in an earnest, dare I say, boomer sort of way. Love Reds.
27:03 Sean Fennessey? Were you laughing a lot during Looking for Mr. Goodbar?
27:06 Amanda Dobbins? No, but that, at the end, you're like, what the hell is happening here?
27:10 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, no spoilers.
27:11 Amanda Dobbins? You know, so there, but there is something, there is something surprising and naturalistic about that performance that, you know, in, in Reds, she's like wearing a corset, you know, and she's very good at it.
27:24 Sean Fennessey? God bless.
27:27 Amanda Dobbins? You ever worn a corset?
27:28 Sean Fennessey? What do you think?
27:30 Amanda Dobbins? I don't know. I thought maybe for your back, like, you know.
27:33 Sean Fennessey? I've worn a brace.
27:34 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, then you're, you're pretty close.
27:36 Sean Fennessey? I've never been, you know, stitched in.
27:38 Amanda Dobbins? Tied in?
27:38 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
27:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, that's tough.
27:40 Sean Fennessey? That's not something. I also don't have many people helping dress me every day. Do you have that?
27:45 Amanda Dobbins? I don't. I actually, I don't really like it when people, like, I don't like having my hair played with. I don't really like being fussed with in any way, but I did.
27:52 Sean Fennessey? We share that.
27:53 Amanda Dobbins? After a C-section, they recommend that you wear a brace to like support.
27:57 Sean Fennessey? No kidding?
27:58 Amanda Dobbins? Well, yeah, because things are like a little loosey goosey. And I did sometimes have Zach or like a doula like pull it tight. So I've had that experience.
28:06 Sean Fennessey? Must be nice.
28:06 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. No, it really hurt because I just had surgery. It's fine.
28:12 Sean Fennessey? Great. Speaking of loosey goosey, one thing I also noticed in reading some interviews with her is that she was very, didn't think she was a very good improviser and didn't like to improvise, but she did like to be what she called loose with the script.
28:24 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
28:25 Sean Fennessey? Which means, one of the great things about her as a performer is she has a very particular series of vocal affectations, where she gets kind of like startled in the middle of a sentence, or stammers, or you mentioned crying, she could just like hit a tear note and then pivot back to seriousness very quickly. And she had a real dexterity with her own emotions and her own like, even like patternistic phrasing within a script. And she talks about this a lot in a lot of interviews about working with Nancy Meyers, who's a very, very rigorous writer, who is very Preston Sturgis, where it's like it's every word matters. And she talked about the push-pull of trying to do her thing inside of someone's more tightly woven corset of language.
29:07 Amanda Dobbins? Right. You know, it's the, it's the Fincher Sorkin, the, the people coming, you know, the skills coming against each other is what makes it better.
29:14 Sean Fennessey? Which is great.
29:14 Amanda Dobbins? I think she also does that in terms of just behaviors on my rewatches. And even a couple of movies I saw for the first time, there, there are things that she does on screen. The most, the most famous one that I only noticed because Nancy Meyers, like Instagram about it once, was in Baby Boom, when she, she picks up the baby at the airport and then gets out of the car and she holds the baby under her arm like a sack of potato, potatoes. And Nancy Meyers said that was not in the script. That was not something that like Diane Keaton just instinctively knew that that would both be really funny and communicate something about the character. But there were other.
29:50 Sean Fennessey? Not the safest thing I've ever heard.
29:51 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, that's, that's the point. She just inherited a baby out of nowhere. So, and you know, she's a high-flying management consultant or something.
30:00 Sean Fennessey? Absolutely.
30:01 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. Like we all were in the late eighties. Um, there's another scene in the, what's the Mel Gibson movie?
30:08 Sean Fennessey? Mrs. Sawful.
30:10 Amanda Dobbins? Mrs. Sawful, when, spoiler alert, at some point she has reason to part with a ring. And the way that she decides just to get the ring, like there's, it's not planned, you know, maybe it's written in the script that she gets rid of her ring, but you can imagine anyone else doing it like this very like symbolic, you know, like now is the moment has come when I'm, and she just like tosses it off to the side in a perfect, perfect Diane Keaton way. So I, she, like, as you said, and some of it's the Meisner method, but the. She's just in the moment and doing her thing.
30:46 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I think charisma is an overused word for movie stars, but she also has a thing where, you know, she fell in love with many of her co-stars. She really, like, a lot of filmmakers became ensorcelled by her. She has, like, she just has something.
30:57 Amanda Dobbins? We, we use a lot for men, but not that often for women, which I think, I think it's completely accurate here. But she did kind of have that thing in a, in an era of movies, you know, not that movies have caught up, but where, like, everyone else on this league, in this league, in this era, was a man, except for Meryl Streep.
31:18 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
31:18 Amanda Dobbins? And she just, she had something that brought them all in and made everyone want to look at her.
31:24 Sean Fennessey? One thing that I noticed going through some of the films, too, is that, you know, all the way throughout her career, she's frequently playing the wife or the girlfriend. You know, in some of the best movies of all time, she's stuck with those roles. And in some bad movies, she's stuck with those roles. But it does feel like Woody Allen, in particular, was inspired to just write better parts for her.
31:42 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
31:43 Sean Fennessey? Because he's kind of casting her, like, in Love and Death, she's just like the girlfriend. You know, she doesn't, she's very funny in that movie, but she doesn't have, like, a deep reservoir
31:51 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
31:51 Sean Fennessey? of complexity. She's just the hot girl that he really wants to be married to. And you can feel him, like, almost challenging himself because he's inspired by her, because she is such a, a unique person, and a singular personality, that I think because he writes parts that improve her screen persona, she then gets to do more challenging things over time, too. Like, she gets to kind of transform into the woman who can dress like that
32:16 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
32:16 Sean Fennessey? confidently on screen. And that's also unique. Um, and we can talk about the, the complicated legacy of these Woody Allen movies, too. I think we probably have to.
32:25 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
32:26 Sean Fennessey? Because she is, she's someone who, like, stood by him through everything. She always, till her last days, was like, he was a very special person to me. He gave me extraordinary, I was in love with him. He gave me extraordinary chances.
32:35 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
32:36 Sean Fennessey? And obviously, talking about Woody now is much more complicated than it was some years ago.
32:41 Sean Fennessey? Okay. The other thing I wanted to point out about her before we go through the list is that she was a film director.
32:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
32:47 Sean Fennessey? She directed many movies. She directed music videos. She directed some stuff I did not realize she directed.
32:54 Sean Fennessey? And that's also unlike the female stars of her era. I was looking at like the real, kind of like, rock solid movie, female movie stars of the 1970s. Streep, Faye Dunaway, Jane Fonda, Goldie Hawn, Ellen Burstyn, Ally McGraw, Raquel Welch, Pam Grier, Susan Sarandon, Vanessa Redgrave, Glenda Jackson, Jessica Lange, Sissy Spacek. None of these people directed movies.
33:15 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
33:16 Sean Fennessey? And maybe they wanted to and they weren't given the opportunity. That's certainly possible. But Diane Keaton.
33:21 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
33:22 Sean Fennessey? She directed a documentary about the afterlife called Heaven, which is fascinating. She directed two Belinda Carlisle videos. She directed an episode of Twin Peaks.
33:31 Amanda Dobbins? Excuse me, you just, you yada yadded Heaven as a place on Earth.
33:33 Sean Fennessey? Wonderful song and video. I've got nothing against it. She, she directed a very strange episode of Twin Peaks in season two, which, when things are kind of going off the rails. But you, when you watch, um, when you watch Heaven, that documentary, which the DP of that movie is Frederick Elms, who was David Lynch's DP in the 1980s on a lot of stuff. And that's a very David Lynch documentary. And then she made this TV movie called Wildflower, which is the first known performance, as far as I can tell, of Reese Witherspoon on screen.
34:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yup.
34:03 Sean Fennessey? It's also shot by a Polish cinematographer named Janusz Kaminski.
34:06 Amanda Dobbins? Heard of him.
34:07 Sean Fennessey? In 1992, when Steven Spielberg was getting ready to make Schindler's List, he was looking for, to work with a new cinematographer, someone who understood that part of the world. And he called Diane Keaton and said, "Who did you work with on Wildflower, which I saw on the Lifetime network and really liked?" And she said, "Janusz Kaminski," gave him his phone number, and Keaton, Spielberg has made movies with Kaminski ever since.
34:29 Amanda Dobbins? Incredible.
34:29 Sean Fennessey? That's an amazing data point.
34:31 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
34:31 Sean Fennessey? It's just a fascinating thing. So like, as a filmmaker, she has great influence on cinema history.
34:36 Amanda Dobbins? She, so, do you, are you aware of her late in life, like, interior design Pinterest?
34:41 Sean Fennessey? A little bit, only through you.
34:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and, you know, like, I have the interior design book.
34:47 Amanda Dobbins? But she's clearly a very visual person, right? Like, and is clearly very exacting in terms of how she sees the world, what speaks to her, how you put things together. And, you know, film is, is a visual medium. So it makes sense to me in that, in that way, that she's always been drawn to, um, to, to arranging things just so. And then the other thing is that she had kids much later in her life, which I would just, you know, you mentioned everybody else. I think that it is probably easier to direct films if you're not
35:14 Sean Fennessey? Hundred percent.
35:15 Amanda Dobbins? in charge of having small children.
35:17 Sean Fennessey? And it's after baby boom, when she's sort of like, she realizes in the early 90s that she wants to have a family. She doesn't, she doesn't really think she wanted to have a family before that, right?
35:24 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I think so. And I, but I think she, she adopted like in her 50s, I believe. So, um, you know, that's, that's how it goes.
35:31 Sean Fennessey? She's a real one about that, too. She's like, it's the hardest thing in the world, raising children. If you read an interview, she's very frank about that. But, and you know, after that film Wildflower, which was a TV movie, she did go on to direct, um, two more feature films that were released, Unstrung Heroes and Hanging Up. So, yeah, I mean, four Academy Award nominations. She, of course, won Best Actress for Annie Hall. I could find a couple of places where she should have gotten more.
35:54 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, of course.
35:56 Sean Fennessey? Many, many Golden Globe nominations. You know what I didn't see was Amelia Earhart, The Final Flight, where she played Amelia Earhart. Did you watch that?
36:01 Amanda Dobbins? I didn't, because that wasn't in the red, that's a TV movie. There's also, there was another TV movie late in her career that was only released in the UK, so I didn't make it to that.
36:12 Sean Fennessey? What was it called?
36:13 Amanda Dobbins? Arthur's Whiskey?
36:14 Sean Fennessey? Oh, yeah, it's, it is, it is streaming.
36:16 Amanda Dobbins? It is streaming? All right, okay, well, I'm sorry, I didn't get there. But otherwise, I think I got to most of the, almost all of it.
36:22 Sean Fennessey? I counted 57 feature films, and she had two, four, six, seven TV films. The TV films, some, some, some of the things that she made are not available. That's the other thing. Like, I'm looking at Sister Mary Explains It All, for example. I couldn't find that one. A couple of things are just not streaming. And when I make a big show about
36:41 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
36:41 Sean Fennessey? physical media and whatnot, this is a little bit of what I'm talking about, you know? Great actors work, not available in the world. Uh, anything you want to say before we start going through the filmography now?
36:51 Amanda Dobbins? I'm excited. I'm nervous. How much like, what are your preconceived notions right now? Of what do you think is going to be in it?
36:57 Sean Fennessey? I, I didn't do this. I didn't, I didn't pre haul. I tried to not pre haul. I,
37:03 Amanda Dobbins? I don't either.
37:04 Sean Fennessey? I don't know what your relationship is to the Woody movies. We've, you know, like there's, Annie Hall is a forever movie, automatic, whatever. So that goes in no matter what. But the other ones, you could make the case that these are the most important movies of her career. You can make the case that they're not aging well.
37:17 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. Yeah. But you can't also, we can't put eight movies by one director in Hall of Fame.
37:22 Sean Fennessey? I think it's a question of how many do you want to put in, right? Like, is it, is it two? Is it four? Is it, I don't know. We're gonna find out. So let's begin.
37:30 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
37:31 Sean Fennessey? After appearing in Played Against Sam, she gets cast in her first movie. It's called Love and Other Strangers.
37:36 Amanda Dobbins? Lovers and Other Strangers.
37:37 Sean Fennessey? Lovers and Other Strangers. It's a romantic dramedy about a young couple. And all of the crazy people in their family around them. It's probably best known for launching Richard Castellano, who she would soon co-star with again in The Godfather two years later.
37:55 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
37:55 Sean Fennessey? He was Academy Award nominated for this movie. She's, she's got a solidly sized part. She's the sister of the lead, who's Bonnie Bedelia.
38:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. So first of all, Bonnie Bedelia. You waited too long to say that.
38:05 Sean Fennessey? So hot. In 1970, she was so hot.
38:11 Amanda Dobbins? And continued to be. Diane Keaton at that wedding, I found myself freeze framing it, being like, I would like to look at this eyeshadow. And how can I, it's just so beautiful. She looks very cool. I mean, she's just not the major part of this.
38:25 Sean Fennessey? She, you can see that she already is pretty comfortable on screen. She has this kind of semi daffy, semi confident persona, pretty much locked down from the first movie, which is really interesting. The movie itself is pretty forgettable.
38:35 Amanda Dobbins? And also she's again, this is a movie about two people. It's centered around weddings. So two people who are about to get married. And then comparing and contrasting all the different relationships surrounding them. And so she is the married, but wants a divorce because her husband didn't remember her birthday. You know, like dissatisfied. It's 1970, you know, the,
38:54 Sean Fennessey? Women's Lib.
38:55 Amanda Dobbins? Exactly.
38:55 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. So I've heard.
38:56 Amanda Dobbins? Second wave. Here we go.
38:58 Sean Fennessey? That's gonna be a red, I would say.
39:00 Amanda Dobbins? I agree.
39:01 Sean Fennessey? And that takes us right to The Godfather.
39:03 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
39:04 Sean Fennessey? 1972.
39:05 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. So Godfather, Godfather Part Two and Godfather Part Three.
39:09 Sean Fennessey? You want to talk about all of them right now?
39:11 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I thought we couldn't.
39:12 Sean Fennessey? You say none of them go in.
39:13 Amanda Dobbins? I thought that we couldn't act the Robert Duvall rule, which is that I believe one and two. And then Tracy also tried to put three in because he made the wise decision to not be in three.
39:25 Sean Fennessey? Yes, which I thought was entertaining. Diane Keaton did not make that choice.
39:28 Amanda Dobbins? She didn't make that choice.
39:29 Sean Fennessey? She appeared in the film.
39:31 Amanda Dobbins? Not a big no person, as I understood it.
39:34 Sean Fennessey? Well, she had weak spots, you know, I think she was very, and she, she's talked about working with Coppola and the difference between working with Coppola and other filmmakers and what she was able to get away with with other filmmakers. And that Coppola was an extremely formal filmmaker and the sets were very formal and controlled. And The Godfather movies and her are so interesting to talk about, long running bit, unwereatchables about how Bill thinks. It's changed over time.
39:58 Amanda Dobbins? So for a while, I remember that because I'm kind of team Bill on this.
40:02 Sean Fennessey? It's a terrible take.
40:03 Amanda Dobbins? No, no, no. So he thinks that Kay doesn't make sense as a character. I think, and I'm supported in this by my friend Meg Spillane and the entire Spillane family.
40:13 Amanda Dobbins? That Keaton is miscast as this. Now, I'm not saying we can't put it in the Hall of Fame.
40:19 Sean Fennessey? I'm, I just, I find this to be terrible. I find what Bill said to be terrible. I said, we think, find what you should do. She is, she is the perspectival character. She is the outsider brought into this world.
40:30 Amanda Dobbins? I understand that.
40:30 Sean Fennessey? A WASP-y person introduced into the Sicilian way of living in this crime family. And she is, her fluster and frustration and her being, you know, set aside at critical moments in the story is so key to unlock, if she's not in the movie, if a character like that is not in the movie, played by someone like her.
40:48 Amanda Dobbins? So I, the character is essential.
40:52 Amanda Dobbins? The, the, I just do not believe that Diane Keaton, for all of her fluster and daffiness and, you know, I don't know what's going on, is that, that clueless or that weak of a person. And, and Keaton doesn't play it as someone who's being weak on purpose. Like, Keaton does not play it as a, I'm pretending not to see what I know is happening. So, and the movie has organized her, around Michael, closing the door and her being like, oh my God, can I believe this? Well, yeah, I can't because you're Diane Keaton. You know what's up. And so that's always-
41:23 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, that's you bringing it to the movie ex post facto. This is her second film. She did not have a confirmed screen presence at this time. So you have to consider the contemporaneous release of the movie and what we think about her when we watch the movie. And when we're watching this movie, in all likelihood, unless you saw her on Broadway or in Hair, you were like-
41:39 Amanda Dobbins? You just think she's a waspy girl?
41:41 Sean Fennessey? That's what she is. Yeah. So, to me, that's, it makes sense in retrospect and we can have retrospective opinions all the time. We do it regularly.
41:47 Amanda Dobbins? Also, it was an abortion, Michael, an abortion. That's too loud. But the scene when she can't see them in the kitchen in Godfather 2, she's lights out amazing. And that's why Godfather 2 is so good. So-
41:58 Sean Fennessey? If you wanted to make the case to me that she, the Godfather should not go in, but the Godfather 2 should go in, to me, that it was an abortion, Michael, scene is amazing. Now, it's amazing because it is like, it's surfacing finally the thing that you're thinking while you're watching Godfather 1. In Godfather 1, you're like, this girl can't be this stupid. She has to get out of here immediately.
42:18 Amanda Dobbins? It's not this, I want to be clear. Love and respect Bill Simmons. Number 16 Limitless, number 1 Devil Wears Prada. On this matter, it is not the character, it is not the script, it is not Diane Keaton, the person who I love and admire. It is that I think Diane Keaton does not fit the role.
42:35 Sean Fennessey? Okay, we're gonna yellow the Godfather, which is the funniest thing you could ever do in a Hall of Fame conversation.
42:40 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I would agree in the Godfather 2 then, but that's fine if you want to like, build up the tension.
42:45 Sean Fennessey? Where do you stand on Play It Again, Sam? 1972, same year.
42:47 Amanda Dobbins? Um, I had never seen it till this last week. And this was the one where I was suddenly just like Googling, you know, double-breasted blazers. Here we are, I already had this.
42:55 Sean Fennessey? She's already digging into her style.
42:56 Amanda Dobbins? And she looks, but it's also, it's not costumey yet. She is just dressed to the nines and looks awesome. I liked it. I mean, I, I too love the film Casablanca and, you know, based my life on it. And we're at the 60s and I had the opportunity to write a play and then make a movie that's like making me into Casablanca. Sure. Great way to spend my time. I don't know if it needs to go in.
43:27 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I, I, it's an interesting question. So it's the rare movie starring Woody Allen, not directed by Woody Allen. Herbert Ross directed the movie. It is based on Woody's play that he co-starred with Keaton with three years earlier. It's a very nicely made movie. Owen Roysman shot it. It has all of this like, kind of interesting framing because Humphrey Bogart, not played by Humphrey Bogart, plays this kind of angel on the shoulder of the Woody Allen character and who's a film critic, who is recently divorced and is being encouraged to start dating again by Humphrey Bogart and also his wife's, his friend's wife.
44:09 Sean Fennessey? If we put it in, it would be about like, this is the union point of Allen and Keaton. It's, it's a good movie. I don't know if it's a great film.
44:17 Amanda Dobbins? Right, but it's the play that brought them together anyway. So we're a kind of couples that, you can yellow it, but I don't think.
44:23 Sean Fennessey? We'll yellow Play It Again, Sam. Okay, 1973 Sleeper.
44:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
44:28 Sean Fennessey? Now, one of my mom's favorite movies.
44:34 Sean Fennessey? At the time, I think considered a revelation, one of the early Woody Allen movies. A sci-fi spoof satire in which he's cryogenically frozen and awoken many, many hundreds, thousands of years later, only to discover an absurd society in which he is operating as a robot to survive.
44:58 Sean Fennessey? Diane Keaton. This is where I'm like, he's just writing a part for the girl that he thinks is pretty and funny.
45:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
45:05 Sean Fennessey? And not writing for the great Titanic actress Diane Keaton. I think this movie holds high esteem amongst people who were alive when it came out. But it was never one of my movies for Woody, and I love many of Woody's movies.
45:17 Amanda Dobbins? And I think that's beautiful for the people that were alive when it came out.
45:21 Sean Fennessey? So we're just gonna red sleeper.
45:23 Amanda Dobbins? Well, you, do you wanna yell at it again?
45:25 Sean Fennessey? Not really.
45:25 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, it was your mom's, it's, you know.
45:27 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
45:27 Amanda Dobbins? I'm not gonna, we don't even be rude.
45:29 Sean Fennessey? No, she's not making this list. This is our list. This is our Hall of Fame. I, it's just that there are other Woody movies that I would wanna fight for. So I would just red sleeper.
45:37 Amanda Dobbins? Okay. Godfather Part Two, green.
45:40 Sean Fennessey? I agree. Godfather Part Two is green.
45:41 Amanda Dobbins? Would you like to just-
45:42 Sean Fennessey? It was an abortion, Michael, let me just tell you something about that. I read all about it. Keaton and Pacino were madly in love with each other multiple times over their lives.
45:50 Amanda Dobbins? I know.
45:50 Sean Fennessey? They, they got together, they broke up, they got together, they broke up. They've both called each other the loves of their lives. That scene in particular, they completely ripped up the day that they were shooting it. I think she said they shot it for like eight hours, that it took a lot of rehearsal to figure out how they wanted to do it. Most of it is Pacino entering psycho silent mode, where that, you know, that image of him with his eyes widening, and the camera holds on him a lot while she's giving her performance and explaining what happened to their child. I think it's great, and I've always thought was great. But the thing is, is that the Godfather, you gotta remember, is a pot boiler. It's like melodramatic material.
46:27 Amanda Dobbins? I don't have a problem with the script.
46:30 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
46:30 Amanda Dobbins? And I, you know, abortion is a weird word to yell just phonetically, you know? So I understand the, but it was an abortion! Okay.
46:38 Sean Fennessey? Women's lib is about being able to say that word out loud. So get on board, cuz I'm here to liberate, alright?
46:45 Amanda Dobbins? I don't think in 74 it was. I think that was before, you know, it got turned on and then turned off again.
46:52 Sean Fennessey? Who turned it off?
46:55 Sean Fennessey? 1975 Love and Death.
46:57 Amanda Dobbins? It's not funny, but I can like Dainke and I only I laughed my pain.
47:01 Sean Fennessey? Um, but do you think Love and Death is funny?
47:05 Amanda Dobbins? This is the the Russian one?
47:06 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
47:07 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
47:08 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
47:08 Amanda Dobbins? I think it's funny. I don't think it needs to go into the Hall of Fame, but I think it's funny.
47:11 Sean Fennessey? That's interesting. Okay.
47:12 Amanda Dobbins? Do you want to put it in?
47:13 Sean Fennessey? Well, this is sort of what I'm talking about with the Woody thing. So Woody is
47:19 Sean Fennessey? at the beginning of his career, he's kind of riffing on genres.
47:21 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
47:22 Sean Fennessey? Right? He's like, oh, I really like Casablanca and Bogart movies. I really like sci fi. I really like, uh,
47:27 Amanda Dobbins? He and Mel Brooks are doing the, you know, the same thing at the same time in different ways.
47:31 Sean Fennessey? Now Woody eventually evolves out of this approach. He starts doing other stuff.
47:35 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
47:36 Sean Fennessey? He continues to be, you know, inspired by like Bergman and Fellini, but everything gets a little bit more high minded. And then he settles into his own style of just like people in apartments in New York.
47:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
47:47 Sean Fennessey? This is, I guess this is kind of one of his last.
47:53 Sean Fennessey? I guess like Mad Magazine style movies, uh, where he is at the center of one of several Russian novels slash Russian plays.
48:01 Amanda Dobbins? What is your favorite Russian novel?
48:04 Sean Fennessey? Hmm.
48:07 Sean Fennessey? I mean, I've read Crime and Punishment, if that's what you're asking.
48:10 Amanda Dobbins? I haven't.
48:10 Sean Fennessey? You know, I've read Brothers Karamazov.
48:12 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
48:12 Sean Fennessey? Um, both of those were in college and I haven't thought about them since.
48:16 Amanda Dobbins? Did you take a Russians class?
48:17 Sean Fennessey? I read some Gogol.
48:18 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, nice. Okay.
48:21 Sean Fennessey? I did not take a Russians Russian class, Russian lit class. I mean, it's very intimidating.
48:26 Amanda Dobbins? I agree. I've always found it sort of insurmountable, except for Anna Karenina, which I famously have read and thought was quite good.
48:31 Sean Fennessey? I haven't read Anna Karenina. Um, I would like to one day. Uh, I don't know. I mean, I, as a person who's like very trapped by my own ethical quandaries, I think they're interesting.
48:41 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
48:42 Sean Fennessey? But it's a little late for me, I think, to start digging in.
48:45 Amanda Dobbins? I know. I would like for it to happen for me, but I just, I don't know. When I, I don't know when that's gonna happen.
48:50 Sean Fennessey? I think Woody was at the ripe old age of 25.
48:52 Amanda Dobbins? I haven't watched season four of The Bear, so I'm just not gonna get to the great Russian works.
48:56 Sean Fennessey? If that is really the the Thunderdome for you, you're in a lot of trouble with a lot of things.
49:00 Amanda Dobbins? Or season five? What season is it?
49:02 Sean Fennessey? It's season five now, I believe.
49:03 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. I watched the last one. They yell at each other at the restaurant at the end, you know? Forks closed by Olivia Colman. I saw it.
49:11 Sean Fennessey? Okay. Thanks for weighing in on that. Love and Death, yellow or red?
49:15 Amanda Dobbins? Yellow.
49:16 Sean Fennessey? Okay, thank you for yellowing it. We'll return to it. 1976, I Will I Will For Now.
49:22 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, this is another one I had not seen.
49:24 Sean Fennessey? Nor had I. I didn't know this movie existed.
49:26 Amanda Dobbins? I didn't either.
49:28 Sean Fennessey? This is, you gotta consider, this is after three Woody Allen movies and two Godfather films. She chooses to make this movie.
49:35 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but did you see Elliot Gould in this movie?
49:37 Sean Fennessey? Well, yeah, I mean, I suspect that's why she wanted to make it. Elliot Gould's a big star at this point. It's a marriage comedy. About two people who are kinda going their separate ways in an attempt to salvage their marriage. They attempt an experimental approach to be a little bit more loose in their arrangement, would you just say?
49:54 Amanda Dobbins? Sort of, but then there are also ground rules. Fascinating to watch after the invite and it's, you know.
50:00 Sean Fennessey? Very connected.
50:01 Amanda Dobbins? There's a lot going on there.
50:02 Sean Fennessey? Absolutely. And this is the time of Bob and Carol and Ted and Alice and this kind of like evolving notions of post 68 free love and what is a modern relationship. But the tone of the movie and the filmmaking are pretty bad, like a pretty dopey.
50:14 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
50:15 Sean Fennessey? And it's, it's not very sophisticated, but they, they, they both have a lot of star power.
50:19 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and, and they do have chemistry, even though her character in particular, it's so, this is 76 when it's released. But, you know, they, they go to sex therapy at some point. And there are a lot of jokes at the expense of her prudishness and she's uncomfortable. And it's not really quite as updated as some of her other characters will be.
50:44 Sean Fennessey? It's true.
50:44 Amanda Dobbins? Or it's reflective of the time.
50:45 Sean Fennessey? But he's a premature ejaculator.
50:47 Amanda Dobbins? That is true, which they, that was also an incredible moment for Zach to walk into the, to the room while I was watching it. He was just like, hey, what's going on here?
50:55 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
50:56 Amanda Dobbins? And then he was like, is that Elliot Gould talking about premature ejaculation?
50:59 Sean Fennessey? Two things to recommend this movie, which is absolutely read and is that there's no chance it's going in. And I didn't even watch this to prepare for the 76 movie draft, because I was just like, what is this? No one likes this movie. One, Paul Sorvino as the lawyer best friend who sings opera throughout the movie and is very entertaining. I really enjoyed him. Two, Victoria Principal on fire. Just very, very, very hot as like the woman who lives in the building, like the apartment next door. The movie itself, I think is very. Forgettable and there's a reason why we had not seen it before. 1976, again, Harry and Walter go to New York. Another film with Elliot Gould as well as James Caan and Michael Caine in this movie.
51:35 Amanda Dobbins? Heard of them.
51:36 Sean Fennessey? A period drama set, I guess, turn of the 20th century.
51:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
51:40 Sean Fennessey? About two rascallian criminals who help a famed thief rob a bank. Rob one of the most, um, what's, what's, what's, what's it called when you can't break into something?
51:53 Amanda Dobbins? Impenetrable?
51:54 Sean Fennessey? Impenetrable, I guess. Maybe that's not the word I'm thinking of, but, uh, Michael Caine plays the thief. Gould and Caan play the, uh, the, the low level criminal slash vaudeville and entertainers. And Diane Keaton plays a journalist.
52:06 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
52:07 Sean Fennessey? And this movie stinks. It's directed by Mark Riedel. Apparently it had a really good script by W. D. Richter, who went on to write a lot of great movies, directed a couple of cool movies too.
52:17 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
52:17 Sean Fennessey? But apparently that script was massacred.
52:21 Sean Fennessey? I think James Caan used to call this movie, when he was still with us, Harry and Walter Take a Dump. I should tell you a little bit about its reputation.
52:32 Amanda Dobbins? Also, another, uh, shining example of women doing journalism in movies.
52:36 Sean Fennessey? Mm-hmm.
52:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, which is just a very storied, um, very illustrious group of women setting an example for all of us.
52:46 Sean Fennessey? Do you think that's because men are comfortable empowering women in those roles, especially in films in the 1970s, because they think women are always asking annoying questions?
52:59 Sean Fennessey? Could be, right? What, what, what other job would they be doing if they had to have a job? Okay, Harry and Walter.
53:06 Amanda Dobbins? No.
53:06 Sean Fennessey? No, out. 77 Annie Hall.
53:08 Amanda Dobbins? Yup, green.
53:11 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. I forgot how long it takes to get to Annie Hall in Annie Hall.
53:14 Amanda Dobbins? Right. I mean, he's talking about himself for a while, but you know, it's, it's a Woody Allen movie.
53:18 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. It's Alvy this and Alvy that for about 35 minutes. Um, and then she shows up. And, you know, I wouldn't say that she's. She's not, she's not doing the Diane Keaton persona as much in this performance, if you know what I mean by that.
53:34 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
53:34 Sean Fennessey? Because she's a little bit of like a magic pixie dream girl. And the movie is very comic, but also played very straight. And like, it's often about not just them coming together, but them coming apart.
53:45 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
53:46 Sean Fennessey? So it's, it's a kind of an interesting artifact because it informs everything that she does after this, but I wouldn't say it's like everything she does.
53:52 Amanda Dobbins? Well, it's where it starts.
53:53 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
53:53 Amanda Dobbins? And it's so she, I mean, she has not, she doesn't have anything to play against yet in terms of Annie Hall. And I think for the rest of her life, she, you know, she wins an Oscar for this performance. Like she is Annie Hall, you know, we're all wearing the ties and the vests. And so she and we, the audience, are watching her against this particular performance. But this, yeah, this is a little more, you know, again, naturalistic to when, when they're sparring or when they're doing lobsters, they're, they're just kind of doing it.
54:23 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, it almost feels like documentary.
54:24 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
54:24 Sean Fennessey? It's like handheld camera and everything is, you know, so he starts working with Gordon Willis and like these films take on this slightly more elevated artistic feeling. And her performance is terrific and it's totally like, it's the birth of a, of a major star. I just found it interesting how it's not quite as, it's not as dopey as the early stuff or as daffy as the later stuff. You know what I mean by that?
54:47 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, well, it's, I mean, to the, to our point about Woody Allen as her most important collaborator, which is absolutely true, and they're kind of finding their thing together in real time in this. And so I think he's creating a situation in which she is learning this whole new mode of performance.
55:04 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
55:05 Amanda Dobbins? And of comedy. And then again, you know, as time goes on, you start to iterate on it.
55:09 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I agree. Annie Hall, easy one going in, 1977, the same year she makes Looking for Mr. Goodbar. Now, this is based on a very famous novel at the time. About a young, single woman who is a teacher who teaches disabled kids, blind kids, deaf kids to learn how to read, write and speak. And she is-
55:35 Sean Fennessey? Interested in exploring her sexuality.
55:37 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
55:37 Sean Fennessey? Let's just put it that way.
55:38 Amanda Dobbins? Once again, women's lip.
55:39 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. And I commend her for pursuing these ideas on screen. This is a really unusual movie.
55:47 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
55:47 Sean Fennessey? And it has, like, its reputation has waxed and waned over the years. It's very bracing.
55:55 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
55:56 Sean Fennessey? Because of the ending that you talked about, and if you haven't seen it, you know,
55:59 Amanda Dobbins? And also I-
55:59 Sean Fennessey? skip over this part.
56:00 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and also I think because of, again, we all grew up with like a different Diane Keaton and a different understanding of both sexual freedom and also what's safe to do in New York City at night.
56:17 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
56:17 Amanda Dobbins? Which, again, I'm laughing because I'm, you know, because it's messed up. So I think that it's a cultural artifact, this movie, like, and as much like sociologically as it is in terms of, you know, the cinematography or her performance, but it's fascinating. And that it's Diane Keaton doing it-
56:35 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
56:35 Amanda Dobbins? Really is essential in a way that I'm like, this should definitely be yellow and maybe it should be green.
56:40 Sean Fennessey? I think it's one of her great performances.
56:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
56:42 Sean Fennessey? The movie is kind of uneven. It was not seen for a very long time because it has an extraordinary soundtrack and there were a lot of music rights issues. And it's a great snapshot of this combination of disco and rock in New York because she's going to clubs all the time.
56:56 Sean Fennessey? The stuff that doesn't work for me is there's so much flashback material that's like, here's her trauma. Like, this is a really unkind way of framing it, but it's kind of like, this is why this woman appears to be a whore. Like, that's, it's kind of like, really silly, the way that it tries to psychologize-
57:11 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
57:12 Sean Fennessey? -a woman just wanting to have different kinds of romantic and sexual experiences. If you made a movie like that now, you wouldn't include any of that stuff. You'd just be like, this is a woman who's trying to figure her life out and who she's really interested in being with and spending time with. And it takes some really gnarly turns, but her performance in the movie is great. And it is very different, basically from like, anything else that she does.
57:34 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
57:34 Sean Fennessey? Can you think of another movie that is even like a character that's in a similar vein to this one?
57:38 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, I'm scrolling through the Redbox era, but the answer is no. There were a couple-
57:45 Amanda Dobbins? Late period ones where it's a little bluer than I expected, but not to this level.
57:49 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, there's a, she's.
57:51 Amanda Dobbins? Let's yellow it.
57:51 Sean Fennessey? Let's yellow it.
57:52 Amanda Dobbins? For now.
57:52 Sean Fennessey? I, I think we'll come back for a green personally.
57:55 Amanda Dobbins? Well.
57:56 Sean Fennessey? Even though.
57:56 Amanda Dobbins? If you, do you want, listen, make your calls, shoot your shot, you know?
58:01 Sean Fennessey? Well, we got a lot of stuff to get through.
58:02 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
58:02 Sean Fennessey? Seventy seven through eighty two, when she passed, I tweeted this, I was like, this is one of the great period. This is one of the great runs for an actor in Hollywood history. The films that they have in a row. So seventy eight is interiors, new another Woody Allen film, Woody's like real foray into Bergman-esque drama. A very straight laced movie about three sisters and their relationships and their dynamic, their relationship to their parents, to their significant others and to each other. Keaton plays a poet.
58:29 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
58:29 Sean Fennessey? Um, who is the sort of, I think she's the eldest and she's sort of like the one to whom the others are compared.
58:35 Amanda Dobbins? She's not the narrator, but she's the stand in as close as you can be to the observer because she's obvious, she's a part of the family and is dealing with a lot of this stuff. But it's the other two sisters who are really the one other sister and the parents who are going through it. And so she's, you know, doing the, the reactivity thing, but she's like a little on the sideline.
58:58 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, yeah. And it's a much more somewhat muted performance. The movie is weird. It's like sometimes it's very quiet and other times it's very hysterical. I like this movie. It is often considered one of Woody's masterpieces. It's not one of my favorites, though.
59:10 Amanda Dobbins? I like it, but I sort of have a soft spot for the, the Woody Allen movies that Woody's not in, so.
59:16 Sean Fennessey? Aha, interesting. I'm more than happy to yellow it.
59:19 Amanda Dobbins? No, no, I don't think we're gonna have room for it, but I like it.
59:22 Sean Fennessey? Okay. All right, so red for interiors, nineteen seventy nine, Manhattan.
59:29 Amanda Dobbins? I guess, do you have to? Do you have to?
59:31 Sean Fennessey? Well, let's talk about her in it.
59:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
59:33 Sean Fennessey? Okay. So the movie is obviously about the Woody Allen character going through this crisis of who should he be dating? And he's very attracted to this young girl, which is part of the reasons why this movie is both famous and infamous. Very celebrated at the time, a very big hit, one of the most gorgeously filmed movies of the nineteen seventies. Keaton plays the wife of his very dear friend, who's played by Michael Murphy, and they fall in love.
59:56 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
59:56 Sean Fennessey? And they begin an affair. And he thinks that he has kind of found this illicit love in his friend's wife. And there's a very wonderful scene where she tells him that she's going, wants to go back to her husband. That I think is like among her best performances.
1:00:15 Amanda Dobbins? Mm hmm.
1:00:15 Sean Fennessey? And, and he's very funny in the scene and doing Woody stuff and she's not breaking. Like she doesn't, that's one of the great things about her as an actress is she never tries to like get on his level comically. She's doing her own thing.
1:00:28 Sean Fennessey? She's, she's not the reason to watch the movie. It's kind of a weird one for a Hall of Fame. You know, it's a very legendary film that has been made complicated by contemporary history.
1:00:38 Amanda Dobbins? Right. She is more central to the film than Meryl Streep, who was also in this movie. And, but I, we didn't put it in Meryl's Hall of Fame, even though Meryl kind of walks away.
1:00:49 Sean Fennessey? She only has two scenes.
1:00:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but they're great and she's a great counterweight. Everyone is like perfectly cast in what it is. I, you know, I, I understand the problems with the, the film then and now. I mean, that's another interesting thing there. Cause I rewatched another, when we get to it, I'll remember. I mean, Woody, I'm pretty weird about sex, even without all the other stuff that's going to, so you're watching it and you're like, hmm, is everything okay here? But.
1:01:17 Sean Fennessey? This is the real like, the flag is waving and you're like, what the fuck?
1:01:21 Amanda Dobbins? But, but that's the point of the movie. And when it's contained to a film, you know, it's, it's what makes it interesting.
1:01:27 Sean Fennessey? I know, we were just talking about a big movie that we just saw and it's a little bit of a like, when an artist tells you something, believe them thing, you know?
1:01:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I mean, totally, I agree. I mean, I guess she's, she's not that central to it. So.
1:01:39 Sean Fennessey? I will say yellow, we're gonna have a lot of yellows that we're gonna have to come back to. Annie Hall and the Godfather Part Two seemed like obvious. And I think this next one is very obvious as well.
1:01:48 Amanda Dobbins? Reds.
1:01:49 Sean Fennessey? Reds, which is this mega film, co-written and directed and produced by Warren Beatty. It's his epic portrait of Jack Reed, the journalist who was there for, you know, 10 days that shook the world and the Bolshevik revolution and this. Changing, hopeful potential for socialism or even communism around the world or in the United States. And it's this kind of globe trotting historical piece. And she plays Louise Bryant, a writer journalist at that time. And they have this kind of torrid epic, on again, off again, you're my forever person, but are you love affair?
1:02:26 Amanda Dobbins? But also, Jack Nicholson is over here putting Eugene O'Neill and absolutely just shredding apart everyone's life.
1:02:34 Sean Fennessey? Well, I was one of the single greatest movie scenes.
1:02:37 Amanda Dobbins? If you were mine, I wouldn't. I mean, come on.
1:02:40 Sean Fennessey? I know. And she, you know, the, it's really interesting because she's dating Warren Beatty.
1:02:45 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:02:46 Sean Fennessey? You can almost feel the real person falling in love with Jack Nicholson in the scene.
1:02:51 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:02:51 Sean Fennessey? Their performances are so good that they seem like not performances.
1:02:54 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:02:55 Sean Fennessey? And this is a very different kind of part for her. It's a real performance. It's not, she's not relying on any of her stuff either. And but it's different from Looking for Mr. Goodbar.
1:03:04 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I mean, so much of it is in still shots of her reacting or just looking at the camera and feeling all the emotions and, and, and not spoken, which is not really what you associate with Diane Keaton or with the filmmakers she usually works with, you know, very dialogue heavy gesturing and, and just been all over the place. But no, she's really emoting. And it's all you need in those scenes, also lit beautifully. So.
1:03:34 Sean Fennessey? It's an amazing film. It's one of the craziest things about this movie is that it did not win Best Picture.
1:03:38 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:03:39 Sean Fennessey? And Beatty won for Best Director, but Chariots of Fire won Best Picture this year.
1:03:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:03:44 Sean Fennessey? Which is.
1:03:45 Amanda Dobbins? They had to run on the beach.
1:03:46 Sean Fennessey? Fucking weird that that happened. If you haven't seen Reds, I cannot recommend a movie more. It is a big, gigantic.
1:03:53 Amanda Dobbins? It's three hours.
1:03:54 Sean Fennessey? Quarter house of a movie. Yeah.
1:03:55 Amanda Dobbins? Magical.
1:03:56 Sean Fennessey? But it's fantastic. So Reds is green.
1:03:58 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:03:59 Sean Fennessey? Had you seen Shoot the Moon?
1:04:00 Amanda Dobbins? I had not.
1:04:01 Sean Fennessey? Okay, so.
1:04:04 Sean Fennessey? Big one for us, I would say.
1:04:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, this was tough. Tough sit, yeah.
1:04:07 Sean Fennessey? This is a movie, one of the harshest and most direct films about divorce. Diane Keaton and Albert Finney play a couple who have three children, four children, many children, four children.
1:04:19 Amanda Dobbins? Four, I think.
1:04:21 Sean Fennessey? And when we first meet the couple, Finney is a novelist and journalist who is about to be celebrated with a book award of some kind that is televised. Did you pick up on that? His children are able to watch? I'm not sure if they're airing book awards on television these days, or if they ever did.
1:04:38 Amanda Dobbins? But the iHeart Podcast Awards.
1:04:40 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, we gotta get those on NBC.
1:04:43 Sean Fennessey? And the movie is about, you know, he's already having an affair and they're falling out of love. And they're, I think their characters in the movie are basically at the period of life that we're at.
1:04:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:04:53 Sean Fennessey? And which is the place where a lot of people end up getting divorced, which is when you have a lot of young kids and you're really stressed about your career and money and does my partner still care about me? And who am I in this world?
1:05:04 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:05:04 Sean Fennessey? And the movie's super duper frank about their feelings for each other, about what's pulling them away from each other. Albert Finney, you know, I don't know if we're doing the Albert Finney Hall of Fame anytime soon, but he's ferocious in this movie. She's tapping into something a little different. This is the first time where I felt like
1:05:24 Sean Fennessey? she wasn't a young ingenue in a movie.
1:05:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:05:28 Sean Fennessey? You know?
1:05:28 Amanda Dobbins? Well, some of it is just, you know, situational. Yeah, you get saddled with four kids.
1:05:33 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, but and she's still, you know, she's still, she's in her early 30s, I think, when she makes this movie, right? She's pretty young, but she's made to be playing older in a way.
1:05:41 Amanda Dobbins? Right, and she's also, I mean, she is a mother in the Godfather movies, or chooses not to be in the case of Godfather 2, that one time.
1:05:49 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, that was her choice.
1:05:52 Amanda Dobbins? Even though it wasn't legal.
1:05:54 Sean Fennessey? That's right.
1:05:54 Amanda Dobbins? Then or now. And depending on what state you're in, because what a special place.
1:06:00 Sean Fennessey? Jersey, was she in Jersey?
1:06:01 Amanda Dobbins? I don't really know. I mean, they were in Cuba for all I know. It's Godfather 2.
1:06:07 Sean Fennessey? These are fictional characters.
1:06:09 Amanda Dobbins? But for the most part, she's not playing people who are saddled with like a quote unquote "traditional American domestic" life, but by which I mean like a mother of two children.
1:06:20 Sean Fennessey? Yep.
1:06:22 Amanda Dobbins? And, you know, this is also, again, 70s, 80s, so that is more a more quote unquote "traditional" portrayal in movies of what an American woman does. And yes, it feels different. This was tough for me. You know, it was one of those, it's not, not that it's bad or that she's bad, it was just uncomfortable.
1:06:41 Sean Fennessey? It's very bracing if you're a C.O.D., if you're a child of divorce, this movie was released the year I was born. I would say, I didn't watch my dad do the things that he doesn't, that Albert Finney does in this movie to his kids, but there's a couple scenes that are really traumatic and really confrontational. I think the ending is kind of a mess, and it kind of brought the whole movie down for me a bit. And I thought I had seen it, but maybe I hadn't seen it. I'm still trying to sort through it. Maybe I saw like parts of it on cable when I was growing up, but not the whole thing. It's Bo Goldman's first script, and he was kind of basing it on something that's interesting to look at. It comes out five years after Looking for Mr. Goodbar, and it's kind of like, a lot of these people that got together in the 70s and they're like, ah, we actually, we shouldn't be together.
1:07:21 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:07:21 Sean Fennessey? And we're creating hell on earth because we did end up getting together and having kids.
1:07:25 Amanda Dobbins? Right. And also, everyone's gotten a lot less uptight about the, the, the legal ramifications of this, at least.
1:07:33 Sean Fennessey? That's right. That's right. And this was at a time when, yeah, there's just a ton of divorce happening in the United States. Good film.
1:07:40 Amanda Dobbins? Not going in.
1:07:42 Sean Fennessey? Two, two, two Globe nominations for Keaton and Albert Finney. You don't think it's going in? You think you got, you got, you got a lot of work?
1:07:49 Amanda Dobbins? Yellow it. You can yellow it.
1:07:50 Sean Fennessey? Okay. I think it's a good performance.
1:07:52 Amanda Dobbins? I got, I mean, I got some other things.
1:07:54 Sean Fennessey? What did you think of Peter Weller?
1:07:56 Amanda Dobbins? Um, I was, I spent the whole time trying to be like, what do I know Peter Weller from? And then, what do I know him from? Remind me.
1:08:04 Sean Fennessey? He's Robocop.
1:08:05 Amanda Dobbins? No, there was something else besides Robocop. But I, that's, I was taken aback by that as well.
1:08:10 Sean Fennessey? Uh, 1984, The Little Drummer Girl.
1:08:12 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:08:13 Sean Fennessey? I hadn't seen this.
1:08:15 Amanda Dobbins? Well, now you have. But you still haven't seen the TV series starring Florence Pugh, directed by Park Chan Wook.
1:08:21 Sean Fennessey? I haven't.
1:08:22 Amanda Dobbins? Have you read the novel?
1:08:23 Sean Fennessey? I haven't.
1:08:24 Amanda Dobbins? Adapted from a John LeCrae novel.
1:08:28 Sean Fennessey? What a crazy movie.
1:08:31 Amanda Dobbins? So how much of that is just this story seems real crazy? And how much of it seems is based on the the execution of the the themes and characters?
1:08:42 Sean Fennessey? Um, I think the execution is like, uh, it goes awry.
1:08:50 Amanda Dobbins? Sure does.
1:08:51 Sean Fennessey? I do think there's some real flaws in the design of the story.
1:08:54 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
1:08:55 Sean Fennessey? Um, the movie is about um, an actress, an American actress, living in London, who is very, has sympathy towards the um, the Free Palestine movement, the in the dispute between Israel and Palestine. She's very pro Palestine. She's going to um, you know, rallies and and speaking engagements where she's hearing more about this. And this is happening in a world where she's sort of being surveilled by, uh, I guess the IDF, for lack of a better phrase. Um, the Mossad?
1:09:27 Amanda Dobbins? Mossad, I think.
1:09:28 Sean Fennessey? Um, and she gets drawn into their plan to disarm and capture a well-known terrorist, freedom fighter, whatever, however you want to describe this character, by flipping her sympathies, but because it's it's known that she is a sympathizer to the movement, that she would be able to infiltrate that world. But it's very confusing because she's sort of being like pressured into taking this role.
1:09:59 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:10:00 Sean Fennessey? Because why? Like, that that part of the story like never really lands. And it's an interesting performance for Diane Keaton because she's playing an actress who has to keep giving these performances inside the movie. She's a very batty woman who's like, looking for love and she sort of falls in love with this Mossad agent who draws her into the scheme. But then she has to, it's a really weird movie.
1:10:19 Amanda Dobbins? So two catastrophic things happened uh, in 1984. Number one, Diane Keaton got that perm. And number two, she was given the role of the little drama girl, which if I thought she was miscast in Godfather, I mean, that's nothing. That's even, that's an agree to disagree.
1:10:35 Sean Fennessey? I really thought you were gonna say, number three, I was born.
1:10:39 Amanda Dobbins? Well, it's important to who you talk to. Um.
1:10:43 Sean Fennessey? Terrible haircut. She's definitely miscast.
1:10:46 Amanda Dobbins? She's just out of her. So, I mean, I, I am thrilled to have you trying to explain Little Drummer Girl.
1:10:53 Sean Fennessey? Did I get that right?
1:10:54 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, more or less, but it's, it's.
1:10:55 Sean Fennessey? It's a really strange story.
1:10:57 Amanda Dobbins? Well, it's just, you know, Licorice writes like spy, spy craft movies, and this is about
1:11:04 Amanda Dobbins? two competing spy agencies or, you know, a spy agency and then they're the objects of their spying and they're using this young woman and her ideology like as a pawn. And it's about how, you know, like, is anyone right? Is anyone doing, you know, using any, doing anything for quote unquote, good? Like, but it's about also her impressionability and the impressionability of young people and about how ideology can be so easy, easily manipulated or can be malleable. And so, you know, when you have a very young Florence Pugh playing that, or when it's in a novel, which also, I mean, that's the other thing. It's very hard. It's a very Baroque novel
1:11:49 Amanda Dobbins? that gets, it's hard to be condensed into a film. But I think Diane Keaton is just not
1:11:56 Amanda Dobbins? vulnerable or believable enough.
1:11:59 Sean Fennessey? I feel like she has the flightiness that you would need for someone who would kind of like, the thing that I just don't understand, and maybe, maybe the Park Chan adaptation will help me make it, make more sense. I'm probably not going to read that novel at this point in my life now, having seen this, the movie and.
1:12:12 Amanda Dobbins? Pretty good.
1:12:13 Sean Fennessey? Seen the story.
1:12:13 Amanda Dobbins? You should absolutely. Do you know, so you know who plays the agent who recruits her, the Israeli agent?
1:12:18 Sean Fennessey? Did Alexander Skarsgard? Yeah.
1:12:19 Amanda Dobbins? Sure is.
1:12:20 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, many people are saying he seems like he's in Mossad. Um, I.
1:12:25 Amanda Dobbins? Daniel Craig was in Mossad in Munich.
1:12:27 Sean Fennessey? Exactly. Thank you for making my point. We keep doing this Hollywood. Anyhow, I think.
1:12:33 Sean Fennessey? I just couldn't, Klaas Kinski is in this movie. I thought he was very, at least entertaining.
1:12:37 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
1:12:37 Sean Fennessey? As the sort of chief Mossad strategist who's, who's kind of forcing her to do this work, but not holding her against her will, but like not blackmailing her. Like, there's just something about the mind game.
1:12:51 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:12:51 Sean Fennessey? That never really clicks.
1:12:52 Amanda Dobbins? Correct.
1:12:53 Sean Fennessey? In the film.
1:12:53 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:12:54 Sean Fennessey? And if that doesn't work, then the movie doesn't work.
1:12:55 Amanda Dobbins? That, that is the movie.
1:12:56 Sean Fennessey? There are times when I think her performance is interesting. I'm spending a lot of time on this because I'd never seen this movie before. So this is me unpacking it. But Eileen and I watched it together and we were just like, what?
1:13:03 Amanda Dobbins? Right. Yes.
1:13:04 Sean Fennessey? Why?
1:13:05 Amanda Dobbins? Well, but I'm, I'm sorry. Once you see the perm, you're just like, what?
1:13:08 Sean Fennessey? I know. I know. She makes a lot of bad choices. The movie though, the, the story, La Carre's story, does still have a tremendous amount of resonance though.
1:13:15 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:13:15 Sean Fennessey? Which is the sort of like, the sort of pointlessness of it all.
1:13:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:13:18 Sean Fennessey? You know, the sort of, you get to this feeling of like, no one can win and there's, why are we spending all of this time, pain and life toll on this?
1:13:28 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:13:28 Sean Fennessey? Conflict because no one can, will move one inch.
1:13:31 Amanda Dobbins? I recommend both the novel and the, the mini series. I mean, that's the other thing where that's, I think it's six hours because again, it's hard to consolidate something this intricate into a movie and they didn't really succeed.
1:13:43 Sean Fennessey? I'm sorry to make you spend so much time on a red.
1:13:45 Amanda Dobbins? No, no, I mean, I'm excited to talk about it. Um, the perm also applies to the second film in 1984, Mrs. Sophol, which she kept. Did you notice that? She still has that perm.
1:13:54 Sean Fennessey? It didn't occur to me because I didn't watch them together, but that makes, that's a really good point.
1:13:57 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:13:57 Sean Fennessey? And that's not a contemporary, contemporary haircut as, as far as I can tell.
1:14:00 Amanda Dobbins? No, I mean, it's an 80s situation.
1:14:02 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:14:02 Amanda Dobbins? For sure.
1:14:03 Sean Fennessey? By the way, Little Drummer Girl was directed by George Roy Hill.
1:14:06 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. You know, people were trying.
1:14:08 Sean Fennessey? Crazy mess. Just a crazy mess. Um, 1984, Mrs. Sophol, directed by, uh, Gillian Armstrong, the Australian filmmaker. And this is a movie about a warden's wife who falls in love with a prisoner.
1:14:22 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:14:23 Sean Fennessey? And.
1:14:24 Amanda Dobbins? Well, but who is, who is the prisoner played by?
1:14:27 Sean Fennessey? Is, is Mel Gibson.
1:14:28 Amanda Dobbins? In 1984.
1:14:29 Sean Fennessey? Very, very handsome Mel Gibson.
1:14:31 Amanda Dobbins? Once again, it's like a before we knew.
1:14:33 Sean Fennessey? Yep. She loves a problematic male co-star.
1:14:37 Sean Fennessey? And her, and her brother, his brother, Matthew Modine.
1:14:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:14:39 Sean Fennessey? And they hatch a scheme to escape.
1:14:43 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
1:14:43 Sean Fennessey? And they do escape.
1:14:45 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:14:47 Sean Fennessey? Interesting movie, not ultimately successful, in my opinion. I think she also, again, just like Little Drum Girl, this is a challenging part. Kind of sympathizing and believing and understanding this woman. And again, making herself a person who's very vulnerable to the wiles of a dangerous man. And that's like two movies in the same year where she does that.
1:15:07 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:15:08 Sean Fennessey? And Shoot the Moon is a little bit of this too. Shoot the Moon is a little bit of like, how did this man get me in this position where I have become a prisoner of my own life?
1:15:15 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:15:15 Sean Fennessey? And just thematically, I find that interesting.
1:15:18 Amanda Dobbins? Well.
1:15:18 Sean Fennessey? Cause her career takes a different turn, you know? She pivots away from these kinds of parts and becomes more about her own independence.
1:15:25 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:15:25 Sean Fennessey? But in this period of time, she's kind of weirdly reflective of the Reagan, like
1:15:30 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:15:30 Sean Fennessey? Homemaker Nancy Reagan, like this is the vision of women after the seventies.
1:15:35 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, and also, I mean, again, the roles that are available to you that I think you're either, I'm thinking about Meryl Streep does at this time where she's just like a bad mom or like a mom that failed in like 40 different time periods and 40 different iterations. And she, and Diane Keaton meanwhile, is just a woman who, you know, got done dirty by all the men around her, but weren't they handsome?
1:15:58 Sean Fennessey? They were handsome. Mel Gibson's very hot in the movie.
1:16:00 Amanda Dobbins? You like really get it. And again, there are moments in this movie where I think all of the, um, the warden stuff and kind of the establishing, you know, reasons for her wanting to leave makes sense, but are stodgy. And, and once again, you're like, you're Diane Keaton, look at you, why would you do this even with this perm?
1:16:20 Sean Fennessey? She's married to Edward Herman.
1:16:22 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
1:16:22 Sean Fennessey? He's a bit more boring for her.
1:16:24 Amanda Dobbins? Who was also in Reds with her. There's a lot of, you know, people keep popping up.
1:16:28 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
1:16:28 Amanda Dobbins? But, you know, once she goes off with Mel Gibson, and like I said, she like throws the ring away and there are these moments of connection and, and really just chemistry between her and Mel Gibson where I was like, okay, I see, I see what you wanted to do here. It's not going in.
1:16:42 Sean Fennessey? I'm glad I watched it for the historical record, but it's red. 1986 Crimes of the Heart.
1:16:50 Sean Fennessey? Now.
1:16:52 Amanda Dobbins? This is our first Sam Shepard, but not our last.
1:16:55 Sean Fennessey? I, I didn't love this one.
1:16:57 Amanda Dobbins? I didn't either.
1:16:58 Sean Fennessey? This was a, now you're, you're the southerner here.
1:17:00 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, well, listen, this is just, you know, this is darker Steel Magnolias, right?
1:17:07 Sean Fennessey? It is. Um, I mean, it's very stagey. It's based on a play. I have a little bit of Bruce Beresford.
1:17:16 Sean Fennessey? He's like a, he's like a, he's like a black licorice for me a little bit. I love Tender Mercy is a movie he made, but like, you know, he made Driving Miss Daisy and Double Jeopardy. And a lot of stuff that I really don't like. And this is, I thought, very saccharine and very like overperformed. She plays one of three sisters. The other sisters are Jessica Lange and Sissy Spacek. Obviously all great actresses. But it's just a lot of like post Tennessee Williams.
1:17:45 Amanda Dobbins? I, I mean, there was a whole raft of these in the.
1:17:49 Sean Fennessey? Fried Green Tomatoes was in this mix.
1:17:51 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, there's, isn't there an Altman one where they all get back together at a diner? All the women. And it's just like a lot of southern women come back for one weekend. And often Sam Shepard's there, which you can't complain about. And, um, and none of them leave the weekend truly fulfilled, but maybe they better understand each other.
1:18:11 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I'd love to know what Tracy Letts thinks about this play because it was a Pulitzer Prize winner. Beth Henley's play. Um, it's just not a very filmic movie. You know, it doesn't really have a lot of style and I'm not sure Diane Keaton screams Mississippi to me. Just putting that out there.
1:18:29 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, it's a good point.
1:18:30 Sean Fennessey? Jessica Lange, Sissy Spacek, sure.
1:18:31 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, and she's doing her best with it, but she's also, she's tasked with doing Mississippi and like sad outcast sister. You know, she's the loser sister.
1:18:40 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:18:41 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, I guess they're all losers in their own way, but.
1:18:43 Sean Fennessey? They're having some struggles.
1:18:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, she is the one who just stays at home taking care of people. So.
1:18:49 Sean Fennessey? I would make this red.
1:18:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, of course.
1:18:50 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:18:52 Speaker 03 Did you know that psoriatic arthritis may progress over time and could cause permanent joint damage if left untreated?
1:19:03 Speaker 03 Listen to what it sounds like to be a million miles away.
1:19:11 Speaker 03 Trimfyia gusalkumab, taken by injection, is a prescription medicine for adults with active psoriatic arthritis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Imagine being a million miles away. Explore the possibilities. Ask your doctor about Trimfyia. Tap this ad to see new joint data and learn more about Trimfyia, including important safety information.
1:19:51 Sean Fennessey? This episode of The Big Picture is brought to you by Amazon Prime. What pairs with a good comedy? The cozy blanket arriving with Prime. What pairs with a nail-biting thriller? Snacks arriving with Prime. What pairs with the big game on Prime Video? That new couch arriving with Prime. Whatever feeling you're after, Prime helps bring it to life with great entertainment and fast shipping that delivers what the moment calls for. From streaming to fast shipping, it's on Prime. This episode is brought to you by LinkedIn Ads. Ever invest in something that seemed incredible at first but didn't live up to the hype? Marketers know that feeling. They optimize for the numbers that look great, impressions, reach, and reacts. But when they don't show revenue, well, that's a not-so-great conversation with the CFO. LinkedIn has a word for that: bullspend. Instead, why not invest in what looks good to your CFO?
1:20:36 Sean Fennessey? LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. So, cut the bullspend, advertise on LinkedIn, the network that works for you. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/thebigpicture. That's LinkedIn.com/thebigpicture. Terms and conditions apply.
1:21:05 Sean Fennessey? 1987, she has a small cameo as a singer in radio days. A reunion with Woody Allen, that is not going in, that's red. 1987, baby boom.
1:21:14 Amanda Dobbins? Yes. Did you re-watch this?
1:21:15 Sean Fennessey? I didn't, but we did it on the Nancy Meyers episode, which I guess is almost five years ago, which is kind of crazy.
1:21:20 Amanda Dobbins? That's insane.
1:21:22 Sean Fennessey? But I like this movie. I think it also features, well, one, this is, this is it, right?
1:21:26 Amanda Dobbins? This is where it starts.
1:21:28 Sean Fennessey? Diane Keaton.
1:21:28 Amanda Dobbins? Yes. This is the, she's with Nancy and, and Charles Shire, her, um, her ex-husband and her producing and writing and directing partner for many years.
1:21:40 Amanda Dobbins? This is, so, you know, new, new team kind of establishes her and, and I guess sets the template for all of the romantic comedies to come.
1:21:51 Sean Fennessey? I think so.
1:21:51 Amanda Dobbins? And once again, Sam Shepard is here. Um, the story is that she is a yuppie in New York and, you know, career focused and then inherits a baby, like you do. And she gets elbowed out of her job because they don't support working mothers. I'd like to thank everyone here in this room and at home for supporting working mothers.
1:22:13 Sean Fennessey? That's right. I do.
1:22:14 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, you guys are allies. We thank you. I saw Lucas throw the double thumbs up.
1:22:18 Sean Fennessey? You're goddamn right. Good job, Lucas.
1:22:20 Amanda Dobbins? Not one thumb, but two.
1:22:22 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:22:22 Amanda Dobbins? And-
1:22:23 Sean Fennessey? You want Women's Lib 2.0.
1:22:26 Amanda Dobbins? But James Peter, who is also working at her company, is not a, an ally. And so she moves to Vermont, buys a beautiful dilapidated house.
1:22:37 Sean Fennessey? For what reason? We don't know.
1:22:38 Amanda Dobbins? With the baby and then-
1:22:40 Sean Fennessey? Would have avoided that if I were her, given what transpires.
1:22:44 Amanda Dobbins? And then has to create a new life, which eventually involves hooking up with Sam Shepard, the local pediatrician and, because all pediatricians and/or sports surgeons look like, uh, Sam Shepard.
1:22:56 Sean Fennessey? As you're learning.
1:22:57 Amanda Dobbins? And then, uh, becomes an applesauce empire, uh, like, uh, starts an applesauce empire.
1:23:02 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:23:02 Amanda Dobbins? And so, and the end, she can have it all because she has the baby. She has a, a, a career and she has a really handsome doctor.
1:23:15 Sean Fennessey? Yep.
1:23:15 Amanda Dobbins? And, and that kitchen's really good in Baby Boom also, just to, to locate it for everyone.
1:23:22 Sean Fennessey? I rewatched some parts of this last night, just to kind of remind myself of its vibe. And, you know, I don't, I don't know if you think this is the most famous scene, but her meltdown in front of the well, in front of the man attempting to fix her well. I think it's one of the funniest things she's ever done. And it's like, it's so unbridled. And it's so, you know, she's very tight in a lot of movies. That's the thing about her, right? That neurosis that you're talking about. And she kind of like lets go. And she starts melting down in front of this guy. And she's very funny despite melting down. And like, you can, very gestural, very like making a lot of noises, like, ah, like stuff like that.
1:23:56 Sean Fennessey? And the person that she reminded me of most was Albert Brooks. You know, that there's like, a certain kind of comic person on screen who can get away with this, who we like when they do this. And it's interesting, she works with Meg Ryan a little later in her career. And like, she's trying to get Meg Ryan to give a Diane Keaton performance, and she can't get her to do it, which is really interesting. But she's great in this. I think this is obviously a green.
1:24:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, it has to be.
1:24:19 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. And a big hit. And like, kind of like, set the template for the, really the rest of her career.
1:24:23 Amanda Dobbins? And, you know, and again, it's like, it is reflective. I find this fascinating to watch. You know, like, my mom in 87 was also, like, in corporate America, trying to be like, it's, it is another time capsule. And what it reflects is not realistic or ideal in either case. But it's amazing stuff. Really fascinating. If you haven't seen it in a while, it's a really rich text.
1:24:48 Sean Fennessey? Same year she directs that movie Heaven, which I think is worth checking out. I think if you can see it for free on YouTube or Canopy right now, I of course bought the Blu-ray. It's 85 minutes. It's just a reflective documentary in which she interviews regular people and asks them what they think happens when you die. And it's intercut with this hyper fast-moving series of images and sequences from early movie history. And she uses it as, it's almost, it feels like, um, like a precursor to YouTube or TikTok or something, the way that it's edited together. It's really interesting and not at all what you would expect from her. I just, as an artifact of her life and interests, I think it's very much worth checking out. Not going in the Hall of Fame. 1988, The Good Mother. What the fuck?
1:25:30 Amanda Dobbins? Yikes.
1:25:31 Sean Fennessey? Yo, okay, let's talk about it really quick.
1:25:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:25:33 Sean Fennessey? Cause it's not going in, it's red, The Good Mother. Um, it's directed by Leonard Nimoy, who of course was Spock on Star Trek.
1:25:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:25:39 Sean Fennessey? And he directed two Star Trek films in the 1980s. And then he directed a movie called Three Men and a Baby, which was a big hit in 1987. And they were like, this guy knows how to make movies with little kids. Let's give him this movie. And this movie is about a woman who is divorced, who has custody of her six-year-old daughter. And they have a very, very close relationship. And she, the, the mother played by Diane Keaton is like a little socially awkward. And she meets a man, um, played by Liam Neeson, and they fall in love. They fall in love and she discovers her sexuality. They have a very physical relationship. Then one day.
1:26:15 Sean Fennessey? You guys know about this movie?
1:26:17 Amanda Dobbins? You know what happens in this movie?
1:26:18 Sean Fennessey? No, no idea. I have never heard of this movie.
1:26:20 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
1:26:20 Sean Fennessey? Um, one day Liam Neeson's in the bathroom.
1:26:24 Amanda Dobbins? Uh huh.
1:26:25 Sean Fennessey? And a little girl, Molly, goes in the bathroom.
1:26:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:26:29 Sean Fennessey? And it's pretty, it, it's not shown explicitly, but made clear that he reveals to her his private parts.
1:26:37 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:26:37 Sean Fennessey? And that she maybe touches them.
1:26:39 Amanda Dobbins? But doesn't she, isn't she curious?
1:26:40 Sean Fennessey? She's curious, yeah, of course. She's, he's not forcing her to do anything.
1:26:43 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:26:44 Sean Fennessey? But she's six.
1:26:45 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
1:26:46 Sean Fennessey? And.
1:26:46 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, yeah, listen.
1:26:47 Sean Fennessey? The reason that this happens is because Keaton and her daughter take a bath earlier in the movie and he's present for that.
1:26:53 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:26:54 Sean Fennessey? And he thinks that Keaton's character is trying to live a slightly more evolved vision of like comfort with her own bodies.
1:27:00 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:27:01 Sean Fennessey? But then this leads to the six-year-old sharing this information with her birth father.
1:27:05 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:27:06 Sean Fennessey? Who becomes outraged.
1:27:07 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and then it becomes just.
1:27:09 Sean Fennessey? And then it's like Kramer versus Kramer, you know? Um.
1:27:14 Sean Fennessey? What a weird movie.
1:27:17 Sean Fennessey? And played very straight the whole time. The whole time it's a crisis drama, you know? It is like.
1:27:21 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, no one can, no, there's no levity. There's no, you know, no evolved parenting whatsoever. Certainly no evolved legal systems.
1:27:30 Sean Fennessey? No, um, I'm, is it, who, who are the, who are the, uh, who, who are the lawyers? I'm trying to remember who played the lawyers in the film. I think it's Jason Robards.
1:27:42 Sean Fennessey? And shoot, who is, oh, and Joe Morton are the two lawyers. It crazy, strange film. Ralph Bellamy is in this movie. It's an artifact.
1:27:53 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:27:53 Sean Fennessey? Of a different time, of a panicked time in our culture. This is not something I would do.
1:27:59 Amanda Dobbins? You, yeah.
1:27:59 Sean Fennessey? In any direction.
1:28:00 Amanda Dobbins? I think.
1:28:00 Sean Fennessey? There's not a thing done in this film I would do.
1:28:05 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, I think that I agree.
1:28:07 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:28:07 Amanda Dobbins? Across the board, but this is an interesting one. I mean, I don't, I think this would be unwise and basically everything everyone's doing. But I don't know what to do. My kids just run into my room while I'm getting dressed now.
1:28:21 Sean Fennessey? Well, that happens, of course.
1:28:22 Amanda Dobbins? Well, sure, but like, at what age I'm gonna be like, is, you know?
1:28:25 Sean Fennessey? But not, but it'll be like, come over here and touch this.
1:28:28 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, that's true.
1:28:29 Sean Fennessey? Come on.
1:28:29 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I, I, I agree with you.
1:28:32 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:28:32 Amanda Dobbins? I agree, but that's the provocation.
1:28:34 Sean Fennessey? We can move on from the good mother. 1990, the Lemon Sisters. Uh, I watched this on YouTube yesterday.
1:28:40 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, I rented it from Vidiots.
1:28:42 Sean Fennessey? Uh, did you really?
1:28:43 Amanda Dobbins? I did.
1:28:43 Sean Fennessey? Good for you.
1:28:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:28:44 Sean Fennessey? Supporting our local video store.
1:28:45 Amanda Dobbins? Uh, I thought it sucked.
1:28:47 Sean Fennessey? It's really bad. Now, it's a little hard to judge this one, so.
1:28:51 Amanda Dobbins? But her clothes are so good. And I want to dress just like her, even though she is playing, once again, the saddest of three friends.
1:29:02 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
1:29:03 Amanda Dobbins? Not sisters, in this case, who lives in Atlantic City and is maintaining her dead father's quote unquote, TV museum. Which is just a bunch of stuff that was, uh, on a 50s or 60s TV show once upon a time.
1:29:19 Sean Fennessey? Yes, um, these three women who are friends, Carol Kane and Catherine Grody, are like a musical trio.
1:29:28 Amanda Dobbins? Mm hmm.
1:29:29 Sean Fennessey? On Elliot Gould in this movie again.
1:29:30 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. But it's now they've cast him as Dad Elliot Gould. It happened so fast.
1:29:35 Sean Fennessey? It does.
1:29:36 Amanda Dobbins? I was like, this was only 10 years ago.
1:29:37 Sean Fennessey? I know. Well, that is what happened to his star in a lot of ways, you know?
1:29:40 Amanda Dobbins? I know.
1:29:41 Sean Fennessey? One day you wake up and you're Rachel Green's, uh, father and on television. I didn't think this was very good either. However, this is a somewhat early Miramax movie that was shelved for like two years and effectively killed Joyce Chapa's directing career, who made Smooth Talk in 1984, which is a very good movie adaptation of a Joyce Carol Oates story. And then like Joyce Chapa like never made another feature film. So I, let's just say for the sake of argument, Harvey Weinstein did this.
1:30:08 Amanda Dobbins? I was gonna say.
1:30:08 Sean Fennessey? Um, it's red.
1:30:10 Amanda Dobbins? Put two and two together. Also notably features Diane Keaton singing and dancing, which we'll come back to.
1:30:17 Sean Fennessey? Yes. Not the first time we've seen her on screen doing this, but she does a bunch.
1:30:20 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:30:20 Sean Fennessey? Um, just like Meryl.
1:30:22 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
1:30:23 Sean Fennessey? 1990, The Godfather Part Three. I think it's red.
1:30:25 Amanda Dobbins? I think it's red.
1:30:26 Sean Fennessey? I think she actually gives a good performance and definitely doesn't embarrass herself in this.
1:30:29 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but what are you gonna do?
1:30:30 Sean Fennessey? What are you gonna do? 1991, Father of the Bride. Now.
1:30:34 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. Okay, so we already have Baby Boom, and she is, though she...
1:30:38 Sean Fennessey? Wow.
1:30:39 Amanda Dobbins? What?
1:30:40 Sean Fennessey? Don't keep going. This is great.
1:30:41 Amanda Dobbins? So I think this is one of the great films of my lifetime.
1:30:45 Sean Fennessey? Is this really her movie, though?
1:30:46 Amanda Dobbins? It's not her movie. You know, once again, it was July 4th this past weekend, so we all posted the George Banks, AKA Steve Martin, hot dog and hot dog one speech, which we just have not resolved.
1:30:57 Sean Fennessey? It's the six and eight. Yeah.
1:30:58 Amanda Dobbins? I just, well, now for me, it's five and six. Like, we're closer.
1:31:02 Sean Fennessey? Five and six, yeah.
1:31:03 Amanda Dobbins? Well, you know, for him, I think it's eight and 12.
1:31:06 Sean Fennessey? Oh, okay, okay.
1:31:07 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, they're doing all...
1:31:08 Sean Fennessey? But they're doing it on purpose.
1:31:09 Amanda Dobbins? They're doing all sorts of permutations. Of course they are. It's like the Apple, you need a new cord thing, 35 years before Apple, or whatever. It's absolutely infuriating. Incredible, incredible performance. And then that scene does lead to he's arrested by the grocery store cops. And Diane Keaton, as his wife, Nina, comes to bail him out of jail. And they have like a nice moment. She is a good foil, and she's a good mom, but the movie is called Father of the Bride, so. She also looks so hot in it and.
1:31:43 Sean Fennessey? She's pretty young when she makes this movie.
1:31:45 Amanda Dobbins? She's my ish age, which is like, that's tough when I realize that.
1:31:49 Sean Fennessey? The way she's being styled, and I'm sure she has some say in this, but you know, the color of her hair. She lets her hair go a little gray. She's not, she's not fighting to be a glamorous.
1:32:00 Amanda Dobbins? No, she wears a, she wears a suit for the, for the wedding.
1:32:03 Sean Fennessey? And she's very like willfully being a mom.
1:32:08 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:32:08 Sean Fennessey? And kudos to her for that. Uh, okay. So Father of the Bride is red. I'm stunned. I'm stunned.
1:32:14 Amanda Dobbins? We can't yellow it just like out of.
1:32:15 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, out of respect, but I thought you would maybe make the case for Father of the Bride, part two.
1:32:19 Amanda Dobbins? Well, we'll come to that. We're not, we're not there yet, but we'll come to it.
1:32:23 Sean Fennessey? Okay. Well, yellow Father of the Bride out of respect for all the fathers out there.
1:32:28 Amanda Dobbins? Have you watched that movie since you, since Alice showed up on the scene?
1:32:34 Sean Fennessey? Since I became a father of a daughter?
1:32:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:32:36 Sean Fennessey? And maybe one day a bride?
1:32:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:32:38 Sean Fennessey? Uh, no.
1:32:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, fucking get ready. Bill, maybe me do that rewatchables when I was like seven months pregnant. Just like crying on a Zoom.
1:32:46 Sean Fennessey? That's the best.
1:32:47 Amanda Dobbins? It was wonderful. It's, it's just an absolutely beautiful movie, a masterpiece.
1:32:52 Sean Fennessey? 1993 Manhattan murder mystery. Now this is a beloved movie.
1:32:55 Amanda Dobbins? I was, I mean, if we're gonna make the case, how many Woody's do we have right now? We just have one?
1:33:01 Sean Fennessey? I think just Annie Hall, a lot of yellow.
1:33:03 Amanda Dobbins? I like this because it's a different phase of, of Diane Keaton, but it still also keeps the Keaton and Woody Allen thing, and she's as much the star of it as he is.
1:33:16 Sean Fennessey? Absolutely.
1:33:18 Amanda Dobbins? It's very funny.
1:33:20 Sean Fennessey? I, I.
1:33:21 Amanda Dobbins? What a great pantsuit.
1:33:22 Sean Fennessey? I think it's green.
1:33:23 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, great. Me too.
1:33:25 Sean Fennessey? I mean, this is a kind of a Daffy comedy about two people who think that there are terrible murders happening in their building, living in New York City. It's kind of a little bit of a like, what if these people stuck together and 20 years later they became the slightly annoying couple who live next door to you in New York, you know?
1:33:40 Amanda Dobbins? The aspirational in that way.
1:33:41 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, very, very annoying sort of person if I didn't watch them in a movie, but very happy to be watching them in a movie.
1:33:49 Sean Fennessey? Okay, that was easy. 1993, again, look who's talking now. She's the voice of Daphne.
1:33:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:33:53 Sean Fennessey? You've seen that movie?
1:33:54 Amanda Dobbins? I did. I think I saw this in theaters.
1:33:56 Sean Fennessey? I think I did too.
1:33:57 Amanda Dobbins? Is Daphne one of the dogs?
1:34:01 Sean Fennessey? Hmm.
1:34:02 Amanda Dobbins? Daphne, yeah, right? Dog, right. That's what they, uh.
1:34:07 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I mean, good job.
1:34:08 Sean Fennessey? OK, right. 1995, she directs but does not appear in Unstrung Heroes.
1:34:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:34:13 Sean Fennessey? Which is based on the true story of Franz Lids, who is a journalist and writer. And he, it's a story about his own life where his mom became very sick and his father, who was a brilliant man, sent him to go live with his uncles. And so in the movie, it's Andy McDowell's his mom, John Turturro's his dad. Maury Chaykin and Michael Richards play his uncles. And I'm doing this all off of memory.
1:34:37 Amanda Dobbins? Wow.
1:34:37 Sean Fennessey? And it's pretty sentimental. This is gonna sound weird because there's a lot of problematic people throughout her career, but Michael Richards is very good in this movie. And the two uncles are very eccentric. Her, Maury Chaykin's character is sort of a hoarder. Michael Richards's character is a little bit of a conspiracy theorist. But it's mostly about a young boy. It's cool that she adapted this. Franz Lids is not a huge fan of the movie of his own life. It's a little complicated, not what you want.
1:35:12 Amanda Dobbins? I don't think this is going in.
1:35:13 Sean Fennessey? I agree. 1995, Father of the Bride, Part Two. No, four years later, four years.
1:35:17 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. So to catch people up, Father of the Bride, Part One, Steve Martin and Diane Keaton's daughter, George and Nina Banks's daughter, Annie, gets married.
1:35:28 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, Kimberly Williams.
1:35:29 Amanda Dobbins? I think you'll find she's now Kimberly Williams Paisley.
1:35:32 Sean Fennessey? I won't acknowledge that.
1:35:34 Amanda Dobbins? You're in this Pete Sampras era?
1:35:35 Sean Fennessey? Yes, that's right. Were they together?
1:35:37 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, yeah, for years, like when Sampras was like really.
1:35:39 Sean Fennessey? So Bridget Wilson came in and dropped the elbow and ended it? That's nice. I would allow that to happen, too.
1:35:44 Amanda Dobbins? So now she's married and she and the freelance technology consultant, which is code for unemployed, are expecting a baby. And it turns out that George and Nina are as well. And so they are pregnant, they're almost identically pregnant. Also. George has sold The Perfect Home in San Marino, but that's actually in Pasadena, that the first wedding was held at. And so now he has to figure out how to repurchase his home and also how to be a dad in his mid 40s. But this is most memorable for a scene in which Kimberly Williams Paisley and Diane Keaton,
1:36:28 Amanda Dobbins? with gigantic baby bumps, are led in prenatal aerobics by Martin Short. Do you remember this scene?
1:36:36 Sean Fennessey? Of course.
1:36:37 Amanda Dobbins? Well, it's literally the only thing I thought about for six months each time I was pregnant, trying to do any sort of movement.
1:36:43 Sean Fennessey? Frunk?
1:36:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and it's just like, you've got this, you know? I mean, it's the original, You Got This Mama, but I played for laughs. So that scene is very good. The movie is quite charming, not as magical as the first. I'm not going to fight for it here. We can yellow it, but...
1:36:58 Sean Fennessey? What happens if you accidentally get pregnant at 49?
1:37:02 Amanda Dobbins? I think, I think we call Kay from Godfather 2. You go to the... No.
1:37:10 Sean Fennessey? It would be a challenge. Because Vankin's 49 when she makes this movie.
1:37:14 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, I mean, science is amazing, as are people who carry children, you know? So like, anything's possible. It's not possible in the cards for me. That's just really not... I don't, I can't do it again.
1:37:26 Sean Fennessey? Okay, I'll do it. I'll carry, I'll carry the baby.
1:37:27 Amanda Dobbins? You think you could?
1:37:28 Sean Fennessey? Carry the child?
1:37:29 Amanda Dobbins? You just like, I mean, putting aside like, basic, basic like biology questions or physi...
1:37:35 Sean Fennessey? Do I have the strength?
1:37:37 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I worry about your back.
1:37:40 Sean Fennessey? I don't think, I mean, if you were thinking I was gonna say yes, I wasn't. I can, I can barely carry a beach umbrella at this point in my life. Um, okay, I, I don't think that movie's gonna go in, but that was a sterling explanation.
1:37:54 Amanda Dobbins? However, we're about to get to 1996 First Wives Club.
1:37:56 Sean Fennessey? Okay, let me just, I'm not gonna yuck your yum, but My First Wives Club, very beloved, and a massive hit. Very important movie in her career.
1:38:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:38:06 Sean Fennessey? And I think that kind of sets the template for most of the 21st century in terms of like, the style of movie that she starts making, not the persona per se, but the style.
1:38:19 Sean Fennessey? Why don't you speak?
1:38:19 Amanda Dobbins? Go ahead. We're waiting. Pregnant pause.
1:38:24 Sean Fennessey? Well, we yellowed many superior films.
1:38:28 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
1:38:29 Sean Fennessey? You know what I'm saying?
1:38:30 Amanda Dobbins? Superior in what way?
1:38:33 Sean Fennessey? From the perspective of a 43-year-old man who hosts a movie podcast.
1:38:38 Amanda Dobbins? In a cineast sort of way?
1:38:40 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. I mean, look, my mom got divorced in 1994, and this movie came out in 1996. And she was like, this film matters.
1:38:47 Amanda Dobbins? I would say of all of the text messages I get from people who think that I have any say over what is ever scheduled on the rewatchables, this is number one requested by like a mile.
1:39:00 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:39:00 Amanda Dobbins? Everyone is just like, when are you gonna do First Wives Club?
1:39:03 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:39:04 Amanda Dobbins? Why? And I'm like, well, there are a number of reasons that I don't have an answer to that. But-
1:39:09 Sean Fennessey? Give us 12.
1:39:12 Amanda Dobbins? So it is so popular, and we do consider box office, and there is sort of, you know, baby boom, and then into the father of the brides, and into first wives' clubs. She's kind of suddenly at, what, almost 50, the center of like box office filmmaking for the first time in a while.
1:39:30 Sean Fennessey? She's one of the biggest female stars of the time. Now, it's a team-up movie, though. It is kind of the Avengers of middle-aged female movie stars.
1:39:37 Amanda Dobbins? Goldie Hawn and Ben Miller. But listen, who is front and center for You Don't Own Me?
1:39:42 Sean Fennessey? She is.
1:39:42 Amanda Dobbins? It's Diane Keaton.
1:39:44 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:39:44 Amanda Dobbins? So that clip alone, which is wonderful, to me, puts this in the Hall of Fame. I think you gotta do it. I think you have to do that over Father of the Bride and Father of the Bride Part Two, personally. I understand-
1:39:59 Sean Fennessey? Wow, that's so interesting. I anticipated it going in.
1:40:02 Amanda Dobbins? I like, I understand that Manhattan is a quote-unquote "superior" film.
1:40:08 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:40:08 Amanda Dobbins? Does it honor women in the same way?
1:40:09 Sean Fennessey? Get that on the record.
1:40:09 Amanda Dobbins? Does it honor wom- does it?
1:40:11 Sean Fennessey? Put that on the poster of the First Wives Club 4K.
1:40:15 Amanda Dobbins? Do any of these movies exist in 4K besides like The Godfather?
1:40:19 Sean Fennessey? Uh...
1:40:20 Amanda Dobbins? Manhattan, I'm sure.
1:40:21 Sean Fennessey? No, none of the Woody movies are available in 4K. I guess maybe Annie Hall's available in 4K, but not in the US. I mean, you can imagine there's some concern about promoting the Woody films these days. I don't think any of these movies are in-
1:40:34 Amanda Dobbins? Is there a Nancy Meyers film on 4K?
1:40:36 Sean Fennessey? Oh, looking for Mr. Goodbar is Vinegar Syndrome. Put out a beautiful edition of it. It's really good.
1:40:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. Because what happens to her in that movie?
1:40:42 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, well, maybe that's why. Something's Gotta Give comes to 4K later this year.
1:40:48 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, that's exciting.
1:40:49 Sean Fennessey? Yes, it is, especially because it was never released on Blu-ray. It is only available on DVD.
1:40:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, well, you, you know, I think that maybe the gatekeepers are finally opening their eyes.
1:40:58 Sean Fennessey? They've been listening to you.
1:40:59 Amanda Dobbins? I guess.
1:41:00 Sean Fennessey? First Wives Club is green.
1:41:01 Amanda Dobbins? Great.
1:41:01 Sean Fennessey? 1996 Marvin's Room.
1:41:03 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:41:03 Sean Fennessey? Which we recently discussed on the Meryl Streep Hall of Fame. This, Diane Keaton gets an Oscar nomination for this film. Now, I didn't revisit this this time either. So you'll have to remind me about this movie.
1:41:13 Amanda Dobbins? So she's the sick one, right?
1:41:16 Sean Fennessey? She's the sick one.
1:41:16 Amanda Dobbins? And she's like the nicer one. And so Meryl is taking up more space. But Diane Keaton is kind of more the, I, I, I didn't rewatch it for this. I only rewatched it for Meryl. And I remember being impressed by her. I mean, like, oh, you don't normally see Diane Keaton like this, certainly after the run from Baby Boom on of playing big broad comedy.
1:41:43 Sean Fennessey? Right.
1:41:44 Amanda Dobbins? And like, it's softer and emotional and she's surrounded, you know, it's Leo, it's all of these big people. But I don't, it wasn't memorable enough that I'm like, we actually have to put it in.
1:41:57 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I've only seen it once. I remember thinking it was perfectly fine. It's probably a little bit of the thing where she's got The First Wives Club and Marvin's Room in the same year. And she's like back, back. You know, she's not playing the fifth lead of The Father of the Bride Part Two. Like, she is at the absolute center of movie culture. And she's playing someone with leukemia. And that's the kind of thing that, you know, affords some sympathies when voting time comes around. I, I would read it. I, you know, I think it's, even though it's an Oscar movie, it doesn't, it's not a, not a big one.
1:42:24 Amanda Dobbins? I'm, I'm fine with that.
1:42:26 Sean Fennessey? The Only Thrill, we both watched for the first time for this podcast, which is yet another film with Sam Shepard. This is her third movie now with Sam Shepard.
1:42:34 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:42:35 Sean Fennessey? Crimes of the Heart and Baby Boom. And she plays a middle aged woman who falls in love with this guy. And they talk a lot about movies.
1:42:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, they do. And also about distributions. So I texted you when he was explaining a Sony Betamax player to her.
1:42:52 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:42:52 Amanda Dobbins? So you could watch movies at home.
1:42:54 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I never had a Betamax at home.
1:42:55 Amanda Dobbins? I obviously didn't either, but I was just like, wow. This is the only time I want to hear anyone talk about physical media at home. Distribution is when it's Sam Shepard. And then the movie kept going. She has to move. They don't really talk anymore. Other people find love. I guess it's not going in.
1:43:14 Sean Fennessey? This movie is a soggy piece of bread. That's Red for the only thrill. 1999 is the other sister.
1:43:19 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:43:21 Sean Fennessey? She plays the mother of a disabled girl who falls in love with a guy. And memorably portrayed by Juliette Lewis and Giovanni Ribisi in parts that would never be played by those actors in 2026.
1:43:33 Amanda Dobbins? I turned this off because I was just so uncomfortable. But it's not going in.
1:43:38 Sean Fennessey? Another problematic artifact of Diane Keaton's filmography. Not Going In, That's Red.
1:43:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:43:43 Sean Fennessey? It's a sweet movie. It's got its heart in the right place. It's just not, they shouldn't, they shouldn't have done this. Yeah, they just shouldn't have done that. 2000 Hanging Up, this is a movie that she both co-stars in and directs.
1:43:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, that I saw in theaters because I support women directors and I have the entire millennium plus one year because 2000.
1:44:02 Sean Fennessey? We're proud of you for that. This was, did not, this transpired in the previous millennium, but that's okay.
1:44:07 Amanda Dobbins? Plus one year.
1:44:08 Sean Fennessey? The movie is based on Delia Efron's novel and which I, is it something of a, of a autobiographical piece or is it entirely created? I don't know how much is inspired by their actual father, but it's co-written.
1:44:22 Amanda Dobbins? I think that they're, I mean, they're always borrowing as we know.
1:44:25 Sean Fennessey? Yes, right.
1:44:25 Amanda Dobbins? Everything is.
1:44:26 Sean Fennessey? The movie's co-written with, with Nora Efron and directed by Keaton. And if it, it's like, it's like the Efrons are a little drunk. You know what I mean? Like, it's like someone who doesn't quite have like all their faculties.
1:44:42 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, it's true. It's a, it's a, to me, fascinating artifact because, you know, you have the Nancy Meyers, Diane Keaton track in the 90s and then you've got the Nora Efron Meg, Meg Ryan track. And both have something to do like aesthetically with Woody Allen, but they're, they're exploring them in different ways.
1:45:03 Sean Fennessey? Yes. Kind of like deconstructing.
1:45:05 Amanda Dobbins? Exactly.
1:45:06 Sean Fennessey? The Woody Allen idea.
1:45:07 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. And so, but they're kind of, they're running parallel. And then this all comes together. I know. And it, and it's too confusing when it's all together. It doesn't quite.
1:45:17 Sean Fennessey? Movie is not good.
1:45:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:45:18 Sean Fennessey? There's a, there's a very good Walter Matthau. Performance in this movie as a father.
1:45:23 Amanda Dobbins? You would say that.
1:45:24 Sean Fennessey? Is losing his marbles. He's just very funny. He's very funny. It's his last.
1:45:29 Sean Fennessey? It's not a good Meg Ryan.
1:45:30 Amanda Dobbins? It's not a good Meg Ryan.
1:45:31 Sean Fennessey? Um, Diane Keaton doesn't have a whole lot to do. Um, she, she, both she and Lisa Kudrow are kind of sidelined for most of the movie. It's mostly Meg Ryan's movie. I, but this is kind of when things are kind of slipping a little bit for Meg Ryan, I would say. And, uh.
1:45:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, this is after, You've Got Mail is 98 and then, yeah.
1:45:47 Sean Fennessey? Um, so yeah, I would say it's red, even though she directed and stars in it. 2001 Town and Country.
1:45:53 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, this is when we, I start, I have to start clicking through every single one to remember which is which.
1:45:58 Sean Fennessey? I, I, I, I got you up until.
1:46:00 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, I've.
1:46:01 Sean Fennessey? I'm gonna basically check out of this podcast circa 2008. So.
1:46:05 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I think everyone's, oh, this is the one that's written by Buck Henry.
1:46:08 Sean Fennessey? This is one of the craziest movies of all time.
1:46:10 Amanda Dobbins? I'm like, this is insane. This movie's insane.
1:46:12 Sean Fennessey? So it wasn't originally written by Buck Henry. He was paid millions of dollars to rewrite it during production. And he famously talked about buying a home with the paycheck he got from rewriting this movie, which stars, uh, Warren Beatty. It's his last movie until Rules Don't Apply.
1:46:30 Amanda Dobbins? Which you famously loved.
1:46:31 Sean Fennessey? I, I certainly do. Um, I love Warren Beatty. I also love Gary Shandling. I also love Diane Keaton.
1:46:36 Amanda Dobbins? Goldie Hawn.
1:46:37 Sean Fennessey? I like Goldie Hawn. I wouldn't say I love Goldie Hawn. Nothing personal. You know?
1:46:41 Amanda Dobbins? It's like, that's the thing where you, like, that's what I like about you, but also I think that's a wrong taste. But you're a little resistant to the, to the Daffy Blonde thing and thank you, you know, because.
1:46:53 Sean Fennessey? It's not my speed.
1:46:53 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but also.
1:46:54 Sean Fennessey? She's very talented.
1:46:55 Amanda Dobbins? Goldie Hawn.
1:46:55 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I know she's beloved, just not really my thing. Um, the movie, this movie's terrible. This movie is entirely about how
1:47:04 Sean Fennessey? boomer men's central preoccupation is their own dick. That's the whole movie is like, these guys are only interested in what they're able to conquer sexually.
1:47:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:47:13 Sean Fennessey? But it's set in this like farcical world of, uh.
1:47:18 Sean Fennessey? Sixty year olds who are like obsessing over whether they're cheating on someone or being cheated on. And it's super overwritten and silly and not funny.
1:47:30 Amanda Dobbins? There's it's farcical, but there's nothing funny about it.
1:47:33 Sean Fennessey? It's really bad. It's a famous huge bomb.
1:47:35 Amanda Dobbins? He's an architect, so they're they're hopping from like fancy place to fancy place. And like the the crown molding in every home is spot on. And then no one's alive behind the ice.
1:47:46 Sean Fennessey? Production design and costuming is fantastic. And this movie, everything else sucks. A movie costs like a hundred and twenty five million dollars. And it's basically just a.
1:47:54 Amanda Dobbins? It's quite bad. Not going in.
1:47:56 Sean Fennessey? Uh, it's it's red.
1:47:57 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
1:47:57 Sean Fennessey? Plan B. Didn't see it.
1:48:00 Amanda Dobbins? Hold on.
1:48:00 Sean Fennessey? Two thousand and two.
1:48:02 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, I saw this when it came out, but I didn't revisit it. Okay.
1:48:06 Sean Fennessey? This is a sequel to that scene from The Godfather Part Two.
1:48:12 Amanda Dobbins? No, she kind of joins the mob, sort of by accident. And then Paul Sorvino is also in it. This this I remember. And this is where.
1:48:17 Sean Fennessey? Reunion of Paul Sorvino.
1:48:18 Amanda Dobbins? And some of the hats come in.
1:48:20 Sean Fennessey? I think this movie has been kind of deleted.
1:48:23 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:48:24 Sean Fennessey? Like, it's not really available in too many places. I guess it was released on DVD. But it does not have a big footprint. It's definitely. And this this starts to happen more and more where this is going to come up again. Actually, you know what I don't have on my list here, but maybe I should have.
1:48:37 Amanda Dobbins? What?
1:48:37 Sean Fennessey? I think I skipped over Running Mates. You know about Running Mates?
1:48:41 Amanda Dobbins? No.
1:48:42 Sean Fennessey? It's it's another movie that's been kind of deleted. And I don't know why it's actually not listed here, but nineteen ninety three. It's directed by, um, oh, uh, oh, my goodness. Who is the director of the film? I can't remember. It's Ed Harris and Meryl Streep or Ed Harris and Diane Keaton. He's playing a senator. She's playing a woman who he meets and they fall in love. And it's unclear if they can be together because he's a public person. And I tried to.
1:49:06 Amanda Dobbins? Directed by Michael Lindsay-Hogg.
1:49:07 Sean Fennessey? Michael Lindsay-Hogg. Thank you.
1:49:08 Amanda Dobbins? Two thousand nineteen ninety two.
1:49:10 Sean Fennessey? Yes. I don't know why it's not on the list here. It should be on the list, but. I couldn't find it.
1:49:14 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
1:49:15 Sean Fennessey? I just couldn't watch it.
1:49:16 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I absolutely couldn't. I didn't know that it existed.
1:49:17 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. So, and there are a few movies like this where like in her career, they're just really hard to track down. I'm sure there's a DVD copy or VHS copy of Running Mates floating around somewhere, but you never hear about that movie.
1:49:28 Amanda Dobbins? Michael Lindsay Hogg absolutely owned in the Peter Jackson Let It Be.
1:49:32 Sean Fennessey? Well, yeah, he shot the original Get Back footage.
1:49:34 Amanda Dobbins? No, I know, but then he's just in, it's really good stuff. That's all.
1:49:37 Sean Fennessey? Uh, Plan B is red. 2003 Something's Gotta Give.
1:49:40 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:49:40 Sean Fennessey? Is there anything you need to say about this other than its greenness?
1:49:43 Amanda Dobbins? Hmm.
1:49:44 Sean Fennessey? You're on the record.
1:49:45 Amanda Dobbins? I, that's true. I am on the record. I think that it's another example of, like, this is clearly where Nancy Meyers logs on the most, and I think it is, if not literally autobiographical, like, the most autobiographical of hers, the most Woody Allen-esque of hers. So it uses what, you know, Diane Keaton learns in that tradition. I think, you know, it's well-known that they had dialogues about how much improvisation or how much of Diane Keaton she could bring to the script, but it works beautifully. And, um, it would have been hard not to pick Keanu Reeves for me personally, but, you know, it works out in the end.
1:50:24 Sean Fennessey? Well, it's a wonderful way of like closing up the Reds thing, you know?
1:50:28 Amanda Dobbins? It is. It is.
1:50:29 Sean Fennessey? Where Eugene O'Neill walks out on her and they're both kind of devastated in Reds. And, and this movie, they get to be together and they're so wonderful together.
1:50:36 Amanda Dobbins? The Hampton's doctor turns out to be quite handsome. Who would have thought?
1:50:40 Sean Fennessey? You didn't marry a doctor, I noticed.
1:50:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
1:50:43 Sean Fennessey? It's interesting. Um, Something's Gotta Give is green, of course, and, you know, she gets an Oscar nomination for that.
1:50:50 Amanda Dobbins? She should, but it's the, I think it's the only Oscar nomination for Something's Gotta Give. I don't think screenplay was nominated.
1:50:56 Sean Fennessey? I think you're right. I think you're right.
1:50:57 Amanda Dobbins? Which I think is a mistake.
1:50:58 Sean Fennessey? She said that she's effectively playing Nancy, but one thing to keep in mind, and I've been told this by a couple of people now, is that one of the reasons why, maybe starting circa 1998 through this period, is Diane Keaton was simultaneously a very established star and star persona, and also very particular about how she wanted to appear in movies. She doesn't make a lot of period movies. She's often wearing Diane Keaton clothing.
1:51:20 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:51:21 Sean Fennessey? Very notable. She looks, as you pointed out, at the top of the Conversation like herself a lot. And that was important to her.
1:51:26 Amanda Dobbins? This one, you know, something's got to give is is a combination. This famously launched coastal grandma 25 years later, which is just wearing Gap clothes in neutral colors. But that's okay. Welcome teens.
1:51:39 Sean Fennessey? So funny though, because again, she's like 56. She's not that old.
1:51:43 Amanda Dobbins? No, it's true.
1:51:44 Sean Fennessey? Like, that's 12 years older than me. So to be like coastal grandma.
1:51:50 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, I mean, that's my
1:51:50 Sean Fennessey? Getting close to coastal grandma. And famously is nude in this film and looks hot.
1:51:54 Amanda Dobbins? She does. And that's it's a it's a it's a quick shot. You know, they do it. They do it. It's tasteful.
1:51:59 Sean Fennessey? Maybe I paused it.
1:52:02 Sean Fennessey? Why not? What's wrong with that?
1:52:04 Amanda Dobbins? This, I mean, this is from Tik Tokers.
1:52:06 Sean Fennessey? I'm admiring her.
1:52:07 Amanda Dobbins? Don't know that what something's got to give is. That's great. That's beautiful.
1:52:12 Sean Fennessey? 2005, the family stone. A lot of people like this movie. I don't care for it. What do you think?
1:52:16 Amanda Dobbins? I find myself rewatching this like every Christmas at some point. And I don't it's just on. And then I'm like, oh, no, I got to get to the point where Sarah Jessica Parker says, like incredibly racist things at the dinner table. And then I got to get
1:52:28 Sean Fennessey? That's your favorite part?
1:52:29 Amanda Dobbins? Well, no, but that dinner table scene. And then I got to get to the part with Claire Danes showing up. I got to get to the part with Estrada, you know? And then I'm like, wow, I've seen this movie. And then, you know, Luke Wilson is like pretty hot and getting stoned in the attic.
1:52:42 Sean Fennessey? Could have been Harrison Ford.
1:52:44 Amanda Dobbins? You know, it's like.
1:52:48 Amanda Dobbins? So and I I think about this movie way more than I should for it being an not very good movie. And she's pretty mean in it. She's another mom of five or six kids, I think, including Rachel McAdams. Rachel McAdams pretty mean to her. This is a nice moment at the end with the famed framed photograph. I don't know. I guess it's not going in, but it's I think.
1:53:08 Sean Fennessey? You'd like to leave Manhattan on the sidelines and get the family stone in?
1:53:12 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, I did my homework for this. So I'm prepared.
1:53:17 Sean Fennessey? I'm just going to say, you know, we've got quite a few movies left to go. We're going to have to move quickly through.
1:53:22 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, you always do this. Sorry that I I spent hours and hours.
1:53:26 Sean Fennessey? I'm not trying to wrap you up. I'm just going to say, I just wanted to count up how many greens we had.
1:53:30 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
1:53:30 Sean Fennessey? Okay, you don't hold on, hang in there, mama. 1234567 greens right now. And I know you have at least one more green on your mind as we go through this.
1:53:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but we can talk about that. Like, I'm not going to say that we need to put that above Manhattan. Okay.
1:53:47 Sean Fennessey? My just want to say. I did see 2007's Because I Said So.
1:53:52 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
1:53:52 Sean Fennessey? And I think it's one of the most deranged films in her filmography. Here's the plot of this movie. Uh, Diane Keaton is the mother of three girls.
1:54:01 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:54:02 Sean Fennessey? Father's out of the picture.
1:54:03 Amanda Dobbins? Who are the three girls?
1:54:05 Sean Fennessey? Lauren Graham.
1:54:06 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:54:06 Sean Fennessey? Who's married, happily married. Piper Perabo.
1:54:09 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:54:09 Sean Fennessey? Who I can't tell if she's married or not, but she's got a very active sexual life.
1:54:12 Amanda Dobbins? Doesn't she get married at, doesn't it start with both of their weddings? I think they both get married. I think at first it's Lauren Graham's wedding, then Piper Perabo's wedding.
1:54:21 Sean Fennessey? That would be right.
1:54:22 Amanda Dobbins? Cause it's, you know, they're setting a precedent.
1:54:25 Sean Fennessey? The third daughter is played by Mandy Moore.
1:54:26 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
1:54:27 Sean Fennessey? And Mandy Moore can't be older than 23 years old in this movie.
1:54:29 Amanda Dobbins? No.
1:54:29 Sean Fennessey? And the whole movie is premised around this Diane Keaton desperately needing this 23 year old girl to get locked down.
1:54:34 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:54:35 Sean Fennessey? To get married.
1:54:36 Amanda Dobbins? Because she needs some order in her life.
1:54:37 Sean Fennessey? This movie's in 2007.
1:54:38 Amanda Dobbins? She's an aspiring caterer also.
1:54:40 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:54:40 Amanda Dobbins? You know, or I'm sorry, like.
1:54:41 Sean Fennessey? She's 23. They're treating it like it's like 1500s.
1:54:45 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, I, I agree with you.
1:54:47 Sean Fennessey? What is the, what are the fucking sexual gender politics of this movie?
1:54:51 Amanda Dobbins? So Diane Keaton goes about this by auditioning prospective suitors.
1:54:57 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
1:54:57 Amanda Dobbins? For her daughter.
1:54:58 Sean Fennessey? And.
1:54:59 Amanda Dobbins? And she rejects Tom Everett Scott from that thing you do.
1:55:03 Sean Fennessey? No, she, she thinks Tom Everett Scott is like the best choice and he's a D-bag architect.
1:55:08 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
1:55:08 Sean Fennessey? And Gabriel Macht comes in and this guy's a fucking charming music teacher who's teaching like elderly people and eight year olds how to play the guitar.
1:55:16 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:55:17 Sean Fennessey? And Diane Keaton's like, no, no, no, he's not okay. This movie is fucking deranged. It's the, one of the most like.
1:55:23 Amanda Dobbins? You can't, you just can't compare like the, the presence and the chemistry of Gabriel Macht to Tom Everett Scott. I'm sorry.
1:55:32 Sean Fennessey? What, who's your preference? You prefer Tom Everett Scott?
1:55:34 Amanda Dobbins? Listen.
1:55:34 Sean Fennessey? You're sick in the head.
1:55:36 Amanda Dobbins? No.
1:55:37 Sean Fennessey? This movie is the most flashing green light of Gabriel Macht of all time. And they're like, would you consider Tom?
1:55:42 Amanda Dobbins? Also, but he's just like.
1:55:43 Sean Fennessey? She's banging both of these guys throughout the movie.
1:55:45 Amanda Dobbins? Well, that is her right.
1:55:46 Sean Fennessey? I agree.
1:55:47 Amanda Dobbins? It's 2007.
1:55:48 Sean Fennessey? I agree.
1:55:49 Amanda Dobbins? And the women are liberated.
1:55:50 Sean Fennessey? But both men find out about this and they're like, you whore. Like this is the craziest movie. This movie was not made in like 1984.
1:55:57 Amanda Dobbins? It was really, and this is, I think, this is the, one of the ones where I was like, this is a lot bluer than I need it to be for Diane Keaton talking to her three adult daughters about sex.
1:56:07 Sean Fennessey? Well, there's a scene in which Mandy Moore vividly recalls the exact experience of having an orgasm to her mother.
1:56:14 Amanda Dobbins? Yep.
1:56:15 Sean Fennessey? Is that something you would do?
1:56:16 Amanda Dobbins? No.
1:56:16 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:56:16 Amanda Dobbins? It's very strange. I don't think that it should go in.
1:56:19 Sean Fennessey? Okay, it's red.
1:56:20 Amanda Dobbins? I just don't think Gabriel Mark has a lot of chemistry, you know?
1:56:23 Sean Fennessey? I watched this movie and that's when I was like, Amanda, I might need you to take over for 2010 through 2024.
1:56:28 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, I did. So, Mama's Boy.
1:56:30 Sean Fennessey? Didn't see this.
1:56:31 Amanda Dobbins? Yes. So, this is a movie starring Diane Keaton and John Hader.
1:56:37 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, Heater.
1:56:37 Amanda Dobbins? Heater, yeah. And then who is her boyfriend? Oh, yeah, and sure, then Jeff Daniels. So, basically Jeff, John Heater is an older Napoleon Dynamite, but weirder, less charismatic, and won't leave home.
1:56:53 Sean Fennessey? Weirder than Napoleon Dynamite?
1:56:55 Amanda Dobbins? Well, like, he just doesn't have the riz, you know? And Napoleon Dynamite, whatever you want to say about him, like, he has the riz.
1:57:02 Sean Fennessey? He had riz?
1:57:03 Amanda Dobbins? Yes! They made a whole movie about him.
1:57:05 Sean Fennessey? Wow.
1:57:06 Amanda Dobbins? So, so he doesn't have riz.
1:57:09 Sean Fennessey? Would you bone Napoleon Dynamite?
1:57:10 Amanda Dobbins? No, but you're rooting for him, and you're not really rooting for John Heater. Even though, so Anna Faris plays his love interest, and she works at a, I don't know, she's an aspiring musician, so Anna Faris, like, gives a very funny, like, half-assed musical performance, you know?
1:57:27 Sean Fennessey? Enjoy that.
1:57:28 Amanda Dobbins? Forever and Always, Justice for Anna Faris. Diane Keaton just tries to get her lazy son to move out of her house. And then things go right. It's not going in.
1:57:37 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
1:57:37 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, my God. Did you see Mad Money?
1:57:39 Sean Fennessey? No.
1:57:39 Amanda Dobbins? Okay. Mad Money. So, what happens is, is when I Google these, then Mad Money, the gym, you know, they're all borrowed from more familiar. So, the SEO is really not, I just lost my shoe, things are going, okay.
1:57:52 Sean Fennessey? Hang in there. This is what it takes to host this show.
1:57:55 Amanda Dobbins? Do you know who directed Mad Money?
1:57:58 Sean Fennessey? Elon Musk.
1:57:59 Amanda Dobbins? Hallie Curry.
1:58:00 Sean Fennessey? Oh, I knew that. The writer of Phil and Louise.
1:58:04 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, this stars Diane Keaton, Queen Latifah and Katie Holmes. And, and then who is her husband? Who is her husband? It's Ted Danson. And Ted Danson, you know, squanders the family finances. So Diane Keaton gets a job at the Federal Reserve, I think, some sort of financial institution. And she sees how they dispose of money. And she's like, well, that isn't fully disposing of the money. So I'm going to hatch a crime plan with Queen Latifah and Katie Holmes. And we're going to steal all the shredded money. I'll be honest, I tuned out a little bit during the specifics of this. But it's okay, but it's sort of, you know, like a
1:58:44 Amanda Dobbins? a Langley Mission Impossible 1996 heist, except not at all thrilling and doesn't make sense. And then they do get a lot of the money back and then they get caught. But then it's okay. Not going in.
1:58:57 Sean Fennessey? It's not going in. So you're going to do that for all of these movies?
1:58:59 Amanda Dobbins? As many as I can remember, I saw Smother. So Smother is another TV movie. That, and it's another one of a mom and a son. And the dynamic is unusual in that it's
1:59:11 Sean Fennessey? How so?
1:59:11 Amanda Dobbins? Well, in this case, Dax Shepard has a very overbearing mother played by Diane Keaton. Liv Tyler is in this, is in this movie as well as the person that Dax Shepard is romantically involved with and someone else who I thought was too good for this. Anyway, it's, it's not good because Diane Keaton just like can't let go. And so now she's just, she's kind of in weird mom territory.
1:59:34 Sean Fennessey? Yes, well, it's two movies in a row where she that are, that are very similar. So that's also red.
1:59:38 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, that's red.
1:59:39 Sean Fennessey? I mean, 2010 is Morning Glory.
1:59:40 Amanda Dobbins? Morning Glory, which I think is a wonderful film. Kind of one of the last, like, classic romantic comedies starring Diane Keaton and Harrison Ford as Newscasters pass their prime who are brought in to rehabilitate a morning show that is produced by Rachel McAdams with the help of her boyfriend CBS producer, not CBS producer, though it is effectively CBS, 60 Minutes-esque producer Patrick Wilson.
2:00:08 Sean Fennessey? Your boy.
2:00:09 Amanda Dobbins? My boy.
2:00:09 Sean Fennessey? Your boy.
2:00:11 Amanda Dobbins? So it's very, it's charming, funny, written by Eileen Brush McKenna. It's mostly focused on Rachel McAdams, but Diane Keaton is playing kind of like the, like over the hill, but with it, like a little daffy, a little mad, very funny chemistry with Harrison Ford. Also gets annoyed when he completely steals her show, as he does. I don't think it has to go in.
2:00:35 Sean Fennessey? I see the floor to you on this.
2:00:37 Amanda Dobbins? It can be yellow, or it can be blue.
2:00:38 Sean Fennessey? I like this movie, but haven't seen it in 16 years.
2:00:42 Amanda Dobbins? Let's just yellow it.
2:00:43 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
2:00:43 Amanda Dobbins? And it can be my blue.
2:00:44 Sean Fennessey? Out of respect.
2:00:45 Amanda Dobbins? Though, like, people now, when they ask me for recommendations of Little C and romantic comedies, they're like, not Morning Glory, we know. So maybe my work there is already done.
2:00:52 Sean Fennessey? Okay. 2012 Darling Companion, I did see this movie.
2:00:55 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, which one is this?
2:00:56 Sean Fennessey? This is Lawrence Kasdan, Kevin Kline.
2:00:58 Amanda Dobbins? Oh my god, I forgot, yes.
2:00:59 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, this movie's kind of a mess.
2:01:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, so the, the dog.
2:01:04 Sean Fennessey? They have, Diane Keaton sees a dog on the highway that's been gravely injured.
2:01:12 Sean Fennessey? While she's with her daughter, played by Elizabeth Moss, they pick up the dog, they adopt the dog, and then the dog becomes a part of their family.
2:01:17 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:01:17 Sean Fennessey? They go on a vacation after their daughter's wedding and a log cabin vacation, I guess, with their in-laws, and the dog runs away and disappears. And then the whole movie is about the search for the dog. That's The Darling Companion, or is it? Is it the love in our lives that we need to rediscover and relight the flame?
2:01:34 Amanda Dobbins? It's true.
2:01:35 Sean Fennessey? And the film answers that question thuddingly.
2:01:39 Amanda Dobbins? It was quite boring.
2:01:40 Sean Fennessey? I didn't really like it very much, so that's red.
2:01:41 Amanda Dobbins? It's not going in.
2:01:42 Sean Fennessey? I didn't see The Big Wedding.
2:01:44 Amanda Dobbins? The Big Wedding is a remake of a Swiss-French film. So maybe you should check it out.
2:01:51 Sean Fennessey? I just want to say.
2:01:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:01:54 Sean Fennessey? I'm really pleased with what the Swiss are doing. Big problem is we're on a plane, well, in the, in the, in the World Cup.
2:01:59 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:02:01 Sean Fennessey? Cause you know, my grandfather born in Switzerland.
2:02:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, you've made us aware. Your media family and friends incredibly aware.
2:02:08 Sean Fennessey? Yes, everyone's aware. The Swiss matches, well, we're on a plane tomorrow. So the TVs need to work.
2:02:15 Amanda Dobbins? Well, just stream it. If the TVs don't work, then you just stream it, then the wifi's gotta work.
2:02:19 Sean Fennessey? Wifi's gotta work.
2:02:20 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:02:20 Sean Fennessey? Can't miss that.
2:02:21 Amanda Dobbins? I have to watch like three David Cronenberg films, but that's, that's what you'll be doing.
2:02:25 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. Just watch one. You don't need to know one. No spoilers. Go ahead.
2:02:31 Amanda Dobbins? So this is De Niro's in this one.
2:02:33 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, we gotta get home for the USMNT match.
2:02:35 Amanda Dobbins? I know, Katherine Heigl, Amanda Seyfried, Toe for Grace. And so it's another one of these things where there's weddings, you know, a young couple is being married and then Diane Keaton plays one of the parents who is having to make amends with or conceal parts of her own relationship in order to make things okay for the next generation. It's supposed to be funny. It's not really, I think she's married to De Niro. Yeah, and then, and then some other things might happen. It's not particularly amusing and it should not go in.
2:03:10 Sean Fennessey? Okay, right.
2:03:11 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:03:11 Sean Fennessey? And so it goes. I mean.
2:03:13 Amanda Dobbins? I saw all of these. I watched everything. So this one, so this was, this is the Rob Reiner.
2:03:19 Sean Fennessey? Yes, I wanted to watch this. This is Michael Douglas and I just didn't have time to watch this.
2:03:22 Amanda Dobbins? And Rob Reiner and he, this is.
2:03:26 Sean Fennessey? This is on Netflix right now.
2:03:28 Amanda Dobbins? Michael Douglas is a real estate agent, a racist real estate agent.
2:03:32 Sean Fennessey? Racist.
2:03:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, he says many offensive things and is kind of profiling all the couples who come to look at the home that he's selling, which spoiler alert, turns out to be his own home. And then Dankin's his neighbor. And then Michael Douglas in a sort of baby boom grandfather situation inherits a grandchild. Not inherits, but like his estranged son drops him off and Diane Keaton forms a relationship with the daughter, with the grandchild and then with Michael Douglas. And then I can't remember if they sell the house and they do end up together.
2:04:08 Sean Fennessey? Here's the thing, the goal of these segments are not for you to entirely recap the film.
2:04:12 Amanda Dobbins? So red, okay.
2:04:13 Sean Fennessey? Just give us something about the quality of her performance and whether or not it should go in.
2:04:17 Amanda Dobbins? She's just kinda on the side, lost.
2:04:20 Sean Fennessey? Also, how funny is it when these movies, they come out at the end of these people's careers and it's like, and so it goes. What does that mean?
2:04:26 Amanda Dobbins? Well, that's why I'm Googling all of them because I can't remember. Okay, Five Flights Up.
2:04:31 Sean Fennessey? This is Morgan Freeman.
2:04:32 Amanda Dobbins? She stars with Morgan Freeman and this is about gentrification and also real estate.
2:04:36 Sean Fennessey? Weird. What a year, 2014. She's really interested in this.
2:04:39 Amanda Dobbins? Well, because gentrification is innately tied to real estate.
2:04:42 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
2:04:43 Amanda Dobbins? And this is the one I-
2:04:44 Sean Fennessey? And where do you stand on gentrification?
2:04:45 Amanda Dobbins? This is the one where I sent you the screenshot of the painting because Morgan Freeman is a painter.
2:04:49 Sean Fennessey? Oh, sure. Yeah.
2:04:50 Amanda Dobbins? And he's working on a portrait of Diane Keaton that is revealed at the end of the-
2:04:55 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, great.
2:04:56 Amanda Dobbins? The movie and I like it. This is, this is a 2014 film, so I don't think the painting is AI. I think someone has sort of like painted a photograph of Diane Keaton.
2:05:05 Sean Fennessey? But were it made today.
2:05:06 Amanda Dobbins? To look like a painting of her, but it is clearly what has been fed into all of the large learning machines in order to create the art that we see all around us in films. Uh, it's a horrifying sight. She's fine in it. She, I mean, a lot of them, she's just kinda showing up and like, you know, doing one or two Diane Keaton like vocal tics. And one moment where she's like, well, I didn't really think it was gonna happen like that, you know? And she brings in like 30 minutes of emotion and you're like, why did you want to do this? Not going in. Love the Coopers. This is another ensemble thing. This is Christmas. Okay.
2:05:45 Amanda Dobbins? I watched all of them. Okay. Okay. So this is one where it's Christmas and she's the matriarch of the family and they're gonna split up.
2:05:54 Sean Fennessey? They're completely coming apart at the seams.
2:05:56 Amanda Dobbins? But-
2:05:57 Sean Fennessey? Kickoff is in one hour.
2:05:58 Amanda Dobbins? But I know, I'm sweating, but, but I said I would be Redbox captain and I do my homework. So here I am. So they don't want to spoil Christmas with a, um, a divorce. So they go through it.
2:06:11 Sean Fennessey? Who doesn't want to spoil it?
2:06:12 Amanda Dobbins? Uh, Diane Keaton and her husband, played by John Goodman.
2:06:16 Sean Fennessey? John Goodman. I love John Goodman.
2:06:17 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, it's a stacked cast. Alan Arkin, Marisa Tomei.
2:06:21 Sean Fennessey? You've said listen like 40 times this episode.
2:06:22 Amanda Dobbins? Olivia Wilde, Jake Lacy. Olivia Wilde and Jake Lacy are-
2:06:28 Amanda Dobbins? She's single for reasons that pass understanding June squibs in this. Timmy shows up for five minutes.
2:06:34 Sean Fennessey? Tim Shalhoub.
2:06:35 Amanda Dobbins? Timothy Chalamet.
2:06:36 Sean Fennessey? Tim?
2:06:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yes. And then.
2:06:38 Sean Fennessey? I didn't know that.
2:06:39 Amanda Dobbins? And then.
2:06:39 Sean Fennessey? I've got a hole in my Chalamet resume.
2:06:41 Amanda Dobbins? So I think that they, I don't remember honestly, I think they do stay together. John Goodman and Diane Keaton at the end.
2:06:49 Sean Fennessey? So is.
2:06:49 Amanda Dobbins? But she's like, yeah.
2:06:51 Sean Fennessey? Let's talk about the title for a second.
2:06:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:06:53 Sean Fennessey? Is it, shouldn't it be love, comma, the Coopers? Or is it just like, oh, I love the Coopers?
2:06:57 Amanda Dobbins? I think it's supposed to be both.
2:06:59 Sean Fennessey? Like, I love the Cooper family.
2:07:00 Amanda Dobbins? But so anyway, so.
2:07:01 Sean Fennessey? punctuation here.
2:07:02 Amanda Dobbins? No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, I'm not dead yet because the entire movie is narrated by Steve Martin.
2:07:09 Sean Fennessey? What?
2:07:10 Amanda Dobbins? Can you explain, can you guess Steve Martin's relationship to this family? Which is revealed at the end of the movie.
2:07:18 Sean Fennessey? He's their doctor.
2:07:19 Amanda Dobbins? He's their dog. Okay.
2:07:24 Sean Fennessey? Bravo. That was worth it. Okay. 2016 Finding Dory. She plays the voice of Dory's mom, I believe, Jenny. Uh, I took my daughter to see this last year at Vidiot's and I wept.
2:07:35 Amanda Dobbins? Good. Okay.
2:07:36 Sean Fennessey? I just gotta say, I thought it was very nice. No, I don't.
2:07:38 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:07:38 Sean Fennessey? Um, but I, it's not, doesn't need to go in the Diane Keaton Hall of Fame, but, and it's a unnecessary Pixar sequel.
2:07:45 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:07:46 Sean Fennessey? I still, I still wept.
2:07:46 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. Yeah. That's becoming a bit of a theme with you, but anyway.
2:07:49 Sean Fennessey? Well, I like Pixar. What can I say? Uh, and I like Pixar sequels and I'm okay with them. 2017 Hampstead started watching this and decided, no, thanks.
2:07:56 Amanda Dobbins? Wow. You don't care about Donald Brennan Gleason finding love with Diane Keaton and also a bit of real estate? And overriding the corporate real estate entrance, interest, once again, a movie about real estate as represented by Leslie Menville.
2:08:11 Sean Fennessey? I, I enjoy Leslie Menville and I did get to see a little bit of her while watching it. I felt that this was an excuse for Diane Keaton to spend three months in England.
2:08:20 Amanda Dobbins? That seems like a great reason to do anything. I, it's not going in.
2:08:24 Sean Fennessey? Okay. Red.
2:08:25 Amanda Dobbins? She's a widow. She's playing a lot of widows and loner people at this one.
2:08:29 Sean Fennessey? 2018 Book Club.
2:08:31 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:08:32 Sean Fennessey? I've seen Book Club.
2:08:33 Amanda Dobbins? This was a thing.
2:08:34 Sean Fennessey? It was a big thing. It was a successful movie. And I keep saying this reset the future for the kinds of movies that she made. But you know, like every 10 years she makes another movie where it's like, don't forget about Diane Keaton, who's a big star. And this was one, and this is at a time when the box office is really booming. And there are always alternatives where it's like, this is an underserved audience for basically women over 50. The movie massively over indexed for women over 50, probably women over 30, to be honest with you, because.
2:09:00 Amanda Dobbins? Book Club. And it was based on, they read Fifty Shades of Grey.
2:09:02 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
2:09:03 Amanda Dobbins? So it was smart. Yeah, it's sort of, it's Girls Trip Aged Up.
2:09:06 Sean Fennessey? Yep.
2:09:07 Amanda Dobbins? And, you know, it's not unlike the first wives' club template where it's just you get together a group of women of a certain age. You like sing together.
2:09:17 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
2:09:17 Amanda Dobbins? And she kind of got away from that and was trying to do rom coms with some of the greatest male actors of her generation. And they were all quite poor. So instead she decides to do this. It's good.
2:09:27 Sean Fennessey? It's a big team up too, because it's the first time that she works with Jane Fonda and Candace Bergen.
2:09:32 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
2:09:32 Sean Fennessey? And, you know, three real mega stars in the 1970s coming together. And Mary Steenburgen is the fourth as well. Plus Andy Garcia, Don Johnson. You know, I don't remember it being very good. I remember it being like, bad. It's fine.
2:09:43 Amanda Dobbins? It's not. And if, I remember Book Club Two more fondly, so we can get to that anyway, in a bit.
2:09:50 Sean Fennessey? Zag for sure.
2:09:51 Amanda Dobbins? So it doesn't need to go in.
2:09:54 Sean Fennessey? 2019 Poms.
2:09:56 Amanda Dobbins? Poms, which you pronounce like, you're just throwing me off. I keep.
2:10:00 Sean Fennessey? Like palm free.
2:10:02 Amanda Dobbins? Palm fronds is what I hear when you say it.
2:10:04 Sean Fennessey? Fronds?
2:10:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, but it is like palm, like, but it's not like palm free. Yeah. Uh, anyway, Poms.
2:10:11 Sean Fennessey? Are you correcting me on pronunciation?
2:10:13 Amanda Dobbins? Chris is the pronunciation problem. Okay. Like, I'm fine. I'm like, you know, I.
2:10:18 Sean Fennessey? You got your gut French down.
2:10:20 Amanda Dobbins? I miss as much as I get right, but that's, that's life. Okay. So I texted you at 10:12 last night. And I said, right now is when I learned that this movie is not 80 for Brady.
2:10:31 Sean Fennessey? Yes, she's not in 80 for Brady.
2:10:32 Amanda Dobbins? She's not in 80 for Brady, but Jane Fonda is.
2:10:35 Sean Fennessey? Correct.
2:10:35 Amanda Dobbins? Yes. And so I was bringing the book clubs together. Anyway, this is about, this is another women of a certain age. Team up together this time at a retirement community, um, because they need to rediscover their love of life through cheerleading.
2:10:50 Amanda Dobbins? She does another dance performance at the end. Cause the elderly cheerleaders, you know, overcome all the various obstacles facing them. And they're, you know, all that stands between them and cheerleading and they perform at the local, regional, whatever championships. So it's kind of bringing on, but for seniors. And she's front and center and she does like a funny comedy dance thing. Like she leans into the physicality of all of it and it is quite funny. Does she look like the Spirit Fingers guy, like choreography while doing it? Yes, but that's the point.
2:11:26 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
2:11:27 Amanda Dobbins? Not going in. No.
2:11:29 Sean Fennessey? 2020, Love, Weddings and Other Disasters.
2:11:32 Amanda Dobbins? I think maybe the single worst movie that I saw out of all of them.
2:11:35 Sean Fennessey? I was surprised to learn this film existed when I started researching this.
2:11:38 Amanda Dobbins? So I think it was ultimately released in December 2020, which should tell you something. And I believe that this has a 4% on Rotten Tomatoes.
2:11:48 Sean Fennessey? 4%.
2:11:49 Amanda Dobbins? I've never seen it. That's why I noticed it. 1, 2, 3, 4. And it stars Jeremy Irons, among many other people whose names I don't remember. And it's really about other people getting married and then he's the wedding planner and she is there. I think she gets set up on a date with him. But so first of all, it's asking me to believe that Jeremy Irons is a wedding planner. Oh, she's blind. Sorry. I forgot about that.
2:12:17 Sean Fennessey? I was wondering as you were speaking, what are these other disasters from the title?
2:12:22 Amanda Dobbins? That's not even the disaster. That's not a disaster. That's a fact of life.
2:12:26 Sean Fennessey? I'm not trying to silence you, but we don't need to talk about this movie anymore.
2:12:30 Amanda Dobbins? Well, anyway, you asked me to say something about performances in each of the movies.
2:12:34 Sean Fennessey? She's blind. That's something.
2:12:35 Amanda Dobbins? You know, she's, she's playing a blind person.
2:12:37 Sean Fennessey? Did she adequately perform as a blind person?
2:12:39 Amanda Dobbins? Well, then she explains a whole art project that she does where she like, she does photography by sound and then.
2:12:48 Sean Fennessey? That's a thing.
2:12:48 Amanda Dobbins? That's fairly convincing, but I would say that Jeremy Irons as the OCD wedding planner was like the bridge too far for me. So Diane Keaton wasn't really the problem here. Mac and Rita?
2:12:58 Sean Fennessey? 2022, Mac and Rita. She plays Rita. Who's Mac?
2:13:02 Amanda Dobbins? Mac is her younger self.
2:13:08 Sean Fennessey? What in the world?
2:13:10 Amanda Dobbins? So this movie?
2:13:12 Sean Fennessey? With a different name?
2:13:14 Amanda Dobbins? So this movie is directed by Katie Assleton and this and it's set, it's a girls weekend in Palm Springs. And this young woman, Mac, she's 30s and she's just a little bit lost in life.
2:13:25 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
2:13:25 Amanda Dobbins? And so.
2:13:26 Sean Fennessey? Who portrays her?
2:13:27 Amanda Dobbins? I have forgotten this young woman's name. I thought that she was perfectly nice, perfectly good. This was a movie that was not good, but not incompetent.
2:13:34 Sean Fennessey? Elizabeth Lael?
2:13:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. But like.
2:13:37 Sean Fennessey? Who dis?
2:13:38 Amanda Dobbins? It, it was not, it, it didn't.
2:13:40 Sean Fennessey? Oh, she's the star of Five Nights at Freddy's.
2:13:42 Amanda Dobbins? Sure. It didn't work, but it wasn't bad, if that makes any sense. I feel like I watched so many movies that I felt were truly, and previously.
2:13:50 Sean Fennessey? I like Katie Assleton.
2:13:51 Amanda Dobbins? Love weddings and other disasters that this anyway, just didn't work. But Simon Rex is in it briefly. And so she goes to, you know, she has some sort of aura reading thing in the desert in a tent with Simon Rex. And then she gets out of the tanning bed and she's her 70 year old self, as played by Diane Keaton, who is honestly the least effective part of the film. She's trying, but Taylor Page, very funny in it.
2:14:18 Sean Fennessey? 2023, we're almost done here. Maybe I do.
2:14:21 Amanda Dobbins? I did watch this. Oh, this is, this is, oh, sure. Reunion with Richard Gere. And also Susan Sarandon and William H. Macy. And this is another one where the young people are getting married and the old people have some things they need to work out. She and Gere are kind of interesting in it. It's not their problem, but it's a bad movie.
2:14:42 Sean Fennessey? Okay. So that's not going in.
2:14:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:14:43 Sean Fennessey? Maybe I do the big wedding, love weddings and other disasters. This seems to be a theme. She's.
2:14:49 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
2:14:49 Sean Fennessey? Going back to these things.
2:14:50 Amanda Dobbins? Book Club 2, they're also going to a wedding.
2:14:53 Sean Fennessey? The next chapter.
2:14:54 Amanda Dobbins? Book Club, The Next Chapter. And so they're going on a bachelorette trip to Tuscany. And I remember that Diane Keaton like gets a full makeover and she buys all of these fantastic, very ask Diane Keaton dresses. So that's fun that she gets to do that. And also at a vineyard, I think at the rehearsal dinner, there's a kind of cast movie wide performance of Laura Brandon against Gloria, which is a underrated song, in my opinion.
2:15:19 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
2:15:21 Sean Fennessey? That's red. 2024 Arthur's Whiskey. You didn't get a chance to see this film.
2:15:25 Amanda Dobbins? Did you?
2:15:25 Sean Fennessey? I didn't.
2:15:26 Amanda Dobbins? I was, so I failed us.
2:15:27 Sean Fennessey? So that's, we're gonna just say red because we have to. And then 2024, her final feature film, Summer Camp. Did you watch this?
2:15:34 Amanda Dobbins? I did. So this is, well, I said I would do the work.
2:15:38 Sean Fennessey? That's great.
2:15:38 Amanda Dobbins? I did the fucking work.
2:15:40 Sean Fennessey? I'm proud of you.
2:15:40 Amanda Dobbins? This-
2:15:41 Sean Fennessey? I've not seen a collection of consecutive reds like this in all my time doing this episode.
2:15:45 Amanda Dobbins? This is another, you know, girl's trip, but they, it's friends who used to go to camp together and they go back to camp to, to refine, to find themselves.
2:15:56 Sean Fennessey? Okay. What'd you think?
2:15:58 Amanda Dobbins? I'm not a camp person. And I, you know, I, neither is Diane Keaton, really. Did you like, did you go to like, summer camp?
2:16:05 Sean Fennessey? Day camp. I never, I only did sleepover camp for basketball. I did sleepover.
2:16:09 Amanda Dobbins? Well, that's training camp. That's different. That's serious.
2:16:12 Sean Fennessey? I don't, I wasn't quite at that level of performance, but that was the only time I slept away.
2:16:17 Amanda Dobbins? This is like sleepaway camp, which is like, you know.
2:16:20 Sean Fennessey? You know, I like the film Sleepaway Camp, which is a wonderful horror film that maybe you should get yourself up on if you're gonna talk about teenage sex and death in camp.
2:16:27 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I think currently I'm not because you scheduled it for while I'm on vacation.
2:16:31 Sean Fennessey? Well, that's when the film's coming out.
2:16:32 Amanda Dobbins? At some point, well, you know, I saw it in May.
2:16:35 Sean Fennessey? Pre-record some thoughts. We'll play them on this episode.
2:16:38 Amanda Dobbins? Summer camp's not going in. I don't really think Diane Keaton was a huge summer camp person either.
2:16:43 Sean Fennessey? Okay. The Hall of Fame.
2:16:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:16:45 Sean Fennessey? Right now, we've got seven greens and two, four, six, eight yellows.
2:16:49 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:16:50 Sean Fennessey? Three of these yellows must be turned green.
2:16:52 Amanda Dobbins? Okay. So Looking for Mr. Goodbar, yes.
2:16:54 Sean Fennessey? I fully agree. Looking for Mr. Goodbar, yes.
2:16:57 Amanda Dobbins? Why don't we just put Godfather in with Godfather Part Two under the Robert Duvall umbrella?
2:17:02 Sean Fennessey? I think you have to.
2:17:03 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:17:03 Sean Fennessey? I think it would be incomplete.
2:17:04 Amanda Dobbins? But that's fine. But that's just one.
2:17:05 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
2:17:06 Amanda Dobbins? That's, that's how you guys did it.
2:17:07 Sean Fennessey? Is that how we did it? We just counted it as one film?
2:17:09 Amanda Dobbins? Yes. Am I incorrect on that?
2:17:11 Speaker 04 No, that is correct.
2:17:12 Sean Fennessey? Okay, then, then let's do exactly that.
2:17:13 Amanda Dobbins? Listen to that whole episode.
2:17:14 Sean Fennessey? Thank you very much for supporting Tracy Lutz.
2:17:19 Amanda Dobbins? I almost was like, should we call Tracy right now, like live and be like, what should we put in the Diane Keaton Hall of Fame? But I, he, you know?
2:17:26 Sean Fennessey? He and I spoke about whether or not this should be something he should participate in, but he, he did say to me, I can at least share this, that he was not very up on a lot of the later films.
2:17:35 Amanda Dobbins? Right. Well, neither were you.
2:17:37 Sean Fennessey? I knew that's, and I still aren't. Okay. So play it again, Sam. Yay or nay?
2:17:43 Amanda Dobbins? Nay.
2:17:44 Sean Fennessey? I say nay. Manhattan.
2:17:47 Amanda Dobbins? Yay.
2:17:47 Sean Fennessey? I think so.
2:17:48 Amanda Dobbins? I, I, listen.
2:17:49 Sean Fennessey? Now that gets us down to one more spot.
2:17:51 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:17:52 Sean Fennessey? See, I don't.
2:17:52 Amanda Dobbins? Father of the Bride.
2:17:53 Sean Fennessey? Maybe we should.
2:17:54 Amanda Dobbins? What?
2:17:54 Sean Fennessey? I think I, would you rather have Shoot the Moon or Manhattan?
2:17:59 Amanda Dobbins? Hmm.
2:17:59 Sean Fennessey? Cause she's, she's the show in Shoot the Moon.
2:18:03 Amanda Dobbins? I'm fine with that, but, but you can't be like, thank you for spending so much time talking about this movie and not put Manhattan in then as a result. That wasn't, that wasn't my decision.
2:18:14 Sean Fennessey? We still have two blues to choose.
2:18:16 Amanda Dobbins? So you'll do Manhattan as blue?
2:18:18 Sean Fennessey? Well, that's, that seems problematic.
2:18:19 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, I was gonna say.
2:18:21 Sean Fennessey? What, what do you, Jack, is that, what do you think about that?
2:18:23 Speaker 04 That's not problematic. Come on.
2:18:25 Sean Fennessey? I don't think so either. Uh, I really like Manhattan. I've always really liked it as a movie, even though it's got some very funky stuff going on. So we'll say Father of the Bride is in.
2:18:35 Amanda Dobbins? Okay. You want to, do Shoot the Moon instead of Manhattan if you want.
2:18:37 Sean Fennessey? Maybe we'll do Manhattan.
2:18:38 Amanda Dobbins? We've got Annie Hall and Manhattan Murder Mystery. Like, we have, we have a lot of things here.
2:18:43 Sean Fennessey? This is her most significant collaborator.
2:18:45 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:18:46 Sean Fennessey? And, and in three different registers, I would say.
2:18:49 Amanda Dobbins? And you're right. And we do also have three Nancy Meyers. So.
2:18:54 Sean Fennessey? That seems appropriate.
2:18:55 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, great.
2:18:56 Sean Fennessey? And then maybe Shoot the Moon is my blue.
2:18:58 Amanda Dobbins? Okay, that seems fair.
2:18:59 Sean Fennessey? What do you think about that?
2:18:59 Amanda Dobbins? I'm, I'm good with that and I will.
2:19:01 Sean Fennessey? Would you do Morning Glory as your blue?
2:19:03 Amanda Dobbins? I will probably do Morning Glory as my blue, even though some people say that I've already let that message be known. Let me reinforce it.
2:19:11 Sean Fennessey? I think this is right.
2:19:13 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
2:19:13 Sean Fennessey? What do you think about this? I'm gonna, I'll read it off to you. The Godfather 1 and 2 exist in one slot, which is cheating, but it's okay. Annie Hall, Looking for Mr. Goodbar, Manhattan Reds, Shoot the Moon is my blue, Baby Boom, Father of the Bride, Manhattan Murder Mystery, The First Wives Club, Something's Gotta Give, and your blue is Morning Glory.
2:19:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:19:33 Sean Fennessey? This feels correct.
2:19:34 Amanda Dobbins? I think that's right. And that's what, 30, that represents 30 years of a 50-year career?
2:19:44 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, and then what happened?
2:19:47 Amanda Dobbins? Watch every one of those movies.
2:19:48 Sean Fennessey? I mean, more than 30 years. It's almost 40 years.
2:19:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:19:51 Sean Fennessey? Nearly 40 years. Um, and then she made a lot of other movies.
2:19:55 Amanda Dobbins? What movie of the ones I described are you most curious about?
2:19:58 Sean Fennessey? None of them.
2:19:59 Speaker 04 I like, I like the one with the dog narrator.
2:20:02 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, yeah.
2:20:03 Sean Fennessey? Love the Coopers. Yeah, that had a good cast.
2:20:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:20:05 Sean Fennessey? Maybe I'll check that out.
2:20:06 Amanda Dobbins? I don't think that you should.
2:20:07 Sean Fennessey? I would also like to be full on Rob Reiner. Like, I'd like to see all the Rob Reiner movies. So maybe I'll watch that one. Maybe I do where you said Michael Douglas is a racist real estate agent.
2:20:18 Amanda Dobbins? Well, he's certainly, yeah, he's insensitive. Yeah.
2:20:20 Sean Fennessey? Insensitive. Well, there's a fine line there.
2:20:22 Amanda Dobbins? Well, it's not really that.
2:20:23 Sean Fennessey? Did you call him a racist or not?
2:20:24 Amanda Dobbins? Really, it's the character. It's not really that fine of a line.
2:20:27 Sean Fennessey? Got it. Um, any closing thoughts on Diane Keaton? Wonderful star of stage and screen.
2:20:35 Amanda Dobbins? A legend. This is one of the ones where even where I was watching the ridiculous movies. I mean, sometimes that was a little bit of a chore, but otherwise this was a delight. And it was a different type of movie than normally we get for a Hall of Fame.
2:20:50 Sean Fennessey? Will you be screening The Good Mother at any preschools in the near future?
2:20:55 Amanda Dobbins? As you know, I don't really organize any preschool events, so I just, I'm just grateful for those who do. And I show up and then I don't accuse anyone of anything.
2:21:05 Sean Fennessey? Well, that just about does it. We're, we're going to Toronto. That's, that's what we're doing for the rest of this week. Fortunately, we have pre-recorded an episode about one. I certainly, one of my favorite movies of the year. I think one of yours as well.
2:21:17 Amanda Dobbins? Absolutely.
2:21:17 Sean Fennessey? The Invite, Olivia Wilde's new movie.
2:21:19 Amanda Dobbins? Go see it. Don't listen to the podcast until you see it.
2:21:22 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, we, we spoke, spoke around spoilers for a bit and then really spoiled the movie and got into it because it is really a rich text. Um, and I've been thinking about writing about this and I'm going to pick your brain about it a little bit when we get off. But I think about writing about, and maybe we can bleed this into the show. The millennial movie masterpieces.
2:21:41 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, okay.
2:21:41 Sean Fennessey? Because that movie.
2:21:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:21:43 Sean Fennessey? Is very millennial.
2:21:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
2:21:44 Sean Fennessey? And we're getting to the phase now.
2:21:46 Amanda Dobbins? We've reached our era. Yeah.
2:21:48 Sean Fennessey? It's like, people are in their 40s.
2:21:49 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
2:21:50 Sean Fennessey? And they're making movies. They're making the movies they want to make.
2:21:52 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:21:52 Sean Fennessey? That's a movie clearly that Olivia Wilde wanted to make for very specific reasons. So, anyway, we can give that some thought.
2:21:59 Sean Fennessey? And yeah, we'll be crossing the border. Hopefully, they'll let you back in the country. You think they will?
2:22:04 Amanda Dobbins? I did this morning put my passport in my bag, so I wouldn't forget it.
2:22:07 Sean Fennessey? Very smart.
2:22:07 Amanda Dobbins? Because like, five times. Last week, I Googled the adapter power bolt situation. We're all in the clear and ready to go.
2:22:13 Sean Fennessey? Good job.
2:22:14 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. Do you know what province we're traveling to?
2:22:17 Sean Fennessey? Uh, Ontario?
2:22:19 Amanda Dobbins? Correct.
2:22:19 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I did know that.
2:22:20 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:22:22 Sean Fennessey? I gotta study the provinces for, so when I get there, I'm not... What happens? If you don't know, they murder you? What do they do?
2:22:28 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, very Canadian.
2:22:29 Sean Fennessey? They kill you publicly. Uh, I'm excited about that. Thanks to our producer, Jack Sanders, for his work on this episode. Thanks to Lucas Cavanagh for the production support. As I said, we will have the invite coming on the show on Friday. See you then.
2:23:00 Speaker 05 Coca-Cola. For the big, for the small, the short, and the tall. Peacemakers, risk takers. For the optimists, pessimists. For long-distance love. For introverts and extroverts. The thinkers and the doers. For old friends and new. Coca-Cola. For everyone. Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you.
2:23:30 Speaker 06 We just moved into our new house and I didn't realize just how close we were to the neighbors. That's when my friend told me about Blinds.com. Blinds.com isn't a medication, but it can improve how you feel about your home. Customers who shop at Blinds.com experience excellent customer service, from consultation to installation. Side effects include increased privacy and better sleep. Talk to your partner today and see if Blinds.com is right for you.
2:23:54 Speaker 07 Shop Black Friday all month long at Blinds.com. Don't miss huge deals dropping every week.
Previous The 2026 Movie Auction Returns! Next ‘The Invite’ Is a Hilarious Social Nightmare, With Olivia Wilde! Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated