Skip to content

Anne Bonny and Mary Read (Radio Edit)

You're Dead to Me

Hosted by Greg Jenner

28m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Greg Jenner, historian Hannah Cusworth, and comedian Kemah Bob explore the lives of 18th-century pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read on the podcast You're Dead to Me. The episode traces how both women grew up dressing as men—Anne in Ireland and South Carolina to assist her lawyer father and manage a plantation, and Mary in England to secure an allowance and later fight as a soldier in Flanders. The guests discuss how they eventually gravitated toward the Caribbean, joined Calico Jack Rackham's crew, and operated outside conventional societal norms before their capture in 1720.

The discussion critically examines the romanticized view of female pirates by highlighting the violent colonial context of the Caribbean. Hannah Cusworth explains that the wealth circulating in pirate waters, and the plantation system supporting it, was underpinned by the enslavement of African people and the dispossession of indigenous populations. While Anne and Mary are often celebrated as icons of female rebellion and queer identity, the episode argues that romanticizing their exploits risks ignoring the brutal imperial economies that made their piracy possible.

  • The primary historical source for Anne Bonny and Mary Read is Captain Charles Johnson's 1724 book A General History of Pirates, which historians recommend taking with a large pinch of salt. 4:57
  • Pirate crews operated under a code and offered a more egalitarian social structure compared to the harsh discipline of the British Royal Navy. 16:56
  • Women in 18th-century American colonies like Jamaica and South Carolina often held significantly more wealth and property agency than their European counterparts. 12:18
  • Both Anne Bonny and Mary Read avoided immediate execution upon capture in 1720 because they successfully claimed to be pregnant. 21:55

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Sponsor Ads

    The episode opens with a brief sponsor message and a playful introduction to the show.

  2. 1:49
    Greg Jenner Introduces Pirate Episode

    Host Greg Jenner sets the scene, announcing a deep dive into the lives of Anne Bonny and Mary Read.

  3. 3:56
    Pirate Theme and Audience Engagement

    Greg launches the 'So What Do You Know?' segment, inviting listeners to test their knowledge of the pirate duo.

  4. 5:44
    Early Lives of Anne Bonny and Mary Read

    The hosts discuss the uncertain childhoods of the two women, drawing on Captain Johnson’s accounts.

  5. 11:05
    Journey to the Caribbean and Motivations

    The narrative explains how both women fled to the New World and the socio‑economic context of the Caribbean.

  6. 13:15
    Pirate Life and Social Structure

    Discussion of pirate culture, the code, matelletage, and the relative egalitarianism aboard ships.

  7. 18:29
    Meeting of Anne and Mary on the Ship

    The episode details how the two women met, their disguises, and the complexities of gender and sexuality at sea.

  8. 20:40
    Capture, Trial, and Fate of the Pirates

    The hosts recount the pursuit by Captain Barnett, the trial, and the divergent outcomes for the women.

  9. 25:15
    Legacy and Historical Context

    A reflective segment on the women’s legacy, the Caribbean’s brutal reality, and the importance of contextualizing pirate history.

  10. 27:42
    Closing Remarks and Episode Wrap‑Up

    Greg signs off, thanks guests, and promotes future episodes and resources.

Highlights

  • 6:18

    Disguised as a Boystory

    To hide his illegitimate daughter, Anne's father dressed her as a boy and claimed she was a male relative training to be a paralegal.

  • 9:55

    Unusual Gender Presentationinsight

    Mary continued to dress as a man even when situations did not require it, working as a sailor and soldier.

  • 16:01

    Short Pirate Life Expectancydata

    The average life expectancy for a pirate during this era in the Caribbean was a remarkably brief two years.

  • 17:43

    Matelletage Economic Agreementsstrategy

    Matelletage was an economic arrangement between crewmates where they split spoils equally and inherited each other's riches if one died.

  • 22:53

    Conflicting Fates in Prisonstory

    Mary Read died of a fever in a Jamaican jail around her expected childbirth date, while Anne Bonny's ultimate fate remains a historical mystery.

  • 25:15

    The Caribbean Colonial Paradoxinsight

    The episode highlights the paradox of celebrating female pirates while ignoring that Caribbean wealth was built on violent plantation slavery.

Quotes

  • “Anne Bonny and Mary Reed have become icons of female rebellion, of queer identity, of living outside the rules.”
    Unnamed speaker · 25:15
  • “The Caribbean at this time really is defined by empire and enslavement by many ways, and historians have kind of called it like the birthplace of modernity for lots of these things that we're more familiar with today.”
    Unnamed speaker · 11:05
  • “So if you were a pirate, your average life expectancy was two years.”
    Unnamed speaker · 16:01
  • Whole Foods Market 0:06–0:34
  • Claude AI 1:28–1:44
  • Toast 28:56–29:48

About this episode

Greg Jenner is joined in the 18th-century Caribbean by historian and curator Hannah Cusworth and comedian Kemah Bob to learn about the swashbuckling lives of pirates Anne Bonny and Mary Read. These women and their adventures on the high seas have become the stuff of legend, helped along by the sensational account of their lives written shortly after their capture. Though they are famous for the short period they spent together on a pirate ship, dressed as men to hide their true identities, the two had very different backgrounds. Anne was the well-off and rebellious daughter of a merchant and plantation owner in Carolina, while the working-class Mary already had experience dressing in men’s clothing and working as a sailor and soldier. This episode traces their biographies, exploring their upbringings, romantic entanglements (with men and each other), and time aboard the pirate ship captained by the infamous Captain 'Calico Jack' Rackham, as well as their ultimate fate. And it looks at the wider context of the Caribbean, the transatlantic trade in enslaved Africans and the Golden Age of piracy which shaped their lives and choices, and asks what place they have in queer and trans histories of the period. This is a radio edit of the original podcast episode. For the full-length version, please look further back in the feed. Hosted by: Greg Jenner Research by: Naomi Weaver Written by: Naomi Weaver, Dr Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow, Dr Emma Nagouse, and Greg Jenner Produced by: Dr Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow and Greg Jenner Audio Producer: Steve Hankey Production Coordinator: Gill Huggett Senior Producer: Dr Emma Nagouse Executive Editor: Philip Sellars

Transcript

0:00
28:03

5,753 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Claude
  • Carolina
  • South Carolina
  • Jamaica
  • Claude Design
  • BBC.com
  • The Atlantic
  • Claude Pro
  • A General History of Pirates
  • Port Royal

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated