Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of You're Dead to Me explores the history of cultural fandom between 1700 and 1900, recorded live at the Hay Literary Festival. Host Greg Jenner, historian Dr. Corinne Throsby, and comedian Stu Goldsmith discuss how intense emotional connections to authors, actors, and texts flourished alongside the rise of mass media, print technology, and literacy. The panel examines early celebrity culture, fan mail sent to figures like Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Lord Byron, and elaborate fan pilgrimages and merchandise crazes, such as David Garrick's Shakespeare Jubilee. They also highlight how fans built communities and explored their identities through creative practices like collaborative clubs and commonplace books, challenging the stereotype that historical fandom was merely passive or hysterical.
- Understand that the word fan derives from fanatic, originating to describe intense religious fervor before being applied to popular culture. 6:52
- Recognize that early literary figures like Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Lord Byron received thousands of emotional and confessional fan letters. 10:34
- Note that celebrity merchandise has a long history, including mulberry wood souvenirs from Shakespeare's jubilee and ceramic portrait statues. 18:36
- Use commonplace books as historical examples of early social media where readers collected and shared favorite literary passages and autographs. 24:10
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Advertisements
The episode opens with a BBC ad break and a Whole Foods ad before the host introduces the show.
- 1:38Host Introduces Show and Guests
Greg Jenner welcomes listeners, explains the focus on historical fandom, and introduces his academic and comedy guests.
- 5:03Defining Fandom and Its Historical Roots
The hosts discuss what fandom means, its etymology, and evidence of fan culture from ancient times to the 18th century.
- 6:00Early Fan Mail and Celebrity Interaction
The conversation turns to early examples of fan letters, focusing on Byron, Rousseau, and the emotional intimacy of 18th‑century fandom.
- 13:32Positive Fan Communities and Commonplace Books
The discussion highlights collaborative fan clubs, Pickwick societies, and the use of commonplace books as early social media.
- 14:42Fan Culture in the 19th Century: Merchandise and Pilgrimages
The hosts explore 19th‑century fan practices such as collecting memorabilia, visiting literary sites, and the rise of fan clubs.
- 27:20Closing Remarks and Listener Engagement
The hosts wrap up, thank guests, and encourage listeners to explore more episodes and engage with the show.
Highlights
- 5:09
Defining Fandom and Its Bad Rapinsight
The guest explains that a fan is someone with an emotional connection to a person or cultural product, noting that fandom has been dismissed since the 17th and 18th centuries for being associated with women and young people.
- 8:35
Tracing Fandom Back to Mass Mediainsight
The historian argues that modern fandom required the rise of mass media, starting with daily newspapers in 1702 and expanding printing technology that allowed readers to feel a personal connection to authors.
- 13:11
Early Fan Mail and Emotional Therapydata
The guest discusses how 18th-century readers poured their hearts out to authors like Rousseau, often treating letter-writing as a form of self-exploration and therapy.
- 18:28
Souvenirs and Early Fan Merchandisedata
The panel explores the extensive 18th-century market for celebrity merchandise, including mulberry wood toothpicks from Shakespeare's tree, engravings, and ceramic statues.
- 21:25
A Dangerous Parasocial Extremestory
The hosts discuss the darker side of fandom, recounting an extreme 1816 incident where a delusional fan shot at actress Frances Maria Kelly after she rejected his imagined relationship.
- 23:08
Pickwick Clubs and Meta-Fandomstory
The guest shares how Charles Dickens' serialized novel inspired fans to form global Pickwick clubs, which in turn inspired characters in Louisa May Alcott's Little Women to start their own.
- 24:10
Commonplace Books as Social Mediainsight
The guest explains how 19th-century commonplace books functioned as early social media, where readers copied favorite quotes, collected autographs, and advertised their social circles.
Quotes
“A fan is someone who has an emotional connection to either a person or a cultural product.”
Unnamed speaker · 5:09 “Fandom as we know it couldn't exist without mass media.”
Unnamed speaker · 8:35 “Occasionally, it's about wanting to have sex with the person that you're writing to.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:58 “It's easy to think that creating your social profile is a peculiarity of the internet age, but commonplace books, which are really one of my favourite forms of fan activity, were the social media of their day.”
Unnamed speaker · 24:05
Sponsored segments
- Whole Foods Market 0:06–0:37
- GoTurkiye 0:33–1:32
- BBC Sounds 27:24–27:45
- Work Life 30:44–31:32
About this episode
Greg Jenner is joined by Dr Corin Throsby and Stuart Goldsmith to look at early cultural fandom in the 18th and 19th centuries. Although many consider Beatlemania to be the start of what is now considered fan culture, Greg and his guests consider some much earlier and often hilarious examples of the birth of fandom. This episode was recorded live at the 2022 Hay Festival. This is a radio edit of the original podcast episode. For the full-length version, please look further back in the feed. Research by Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow Written by Emma Nagouse and Greg Jenner Produced by Emma Nagouse and Greg Jenner Assistant Producer: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow Project Management: Isla Matthews Audio Producer: Abi Paterson
Transcript
5,388 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- The Comedian's Comedian
- Hay Literary Festival
- University of Cambridge
- Blackbeard the Pirate
- Ancient Medicine
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated