Pod Insights Y Combinator Podcast Why Investors (including YC) Can’t Fix Your Company About this episode Dalton Caldwell and Michael Seibel on common pitfalls in the advice from different types of investors and why you, the founder, are ultimately responsible for the success of your company.
Apply to Y Combinator: https://www.ycombinator.com/apply/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hey Dalton, your pre-product market fit, do you have five-year financial projections?
0:04 Speaker 01 That's a great example of that. Financial projections may be a good idea later stage, but to even ask me if I had financial projections, I was like, what's a financial projection?
0:15 Speaker 00 This is Michael Seibert with Dalton Caldwell, and today we're going to talk about why investors, including YC, can't fix their company.
0:24 Speaker 01 For some folks, it's like telling them that Santa Claus isn't real, you know, and you're like, they're like, hey, we finally get some time with you, you know, no one wants our product. What should we do? Here's some, here's our designs. Can you help me design this so growth takes off? And I have to tell them the unfortunate news, which is, I have no idea.
0:46 Speaker 01 And like, I went through this through too, when I was a founder, that I really believed that once I raised from the top investors, they would tell me whatever secrets they were holding out on the world.
0:58 Speaker 00 What's unfortunate is that there are a lot of investors out there who aren't former founders, right? Who haven't really lived these mistakes themselves.
1:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, if you haven't been humbled by having a crappy startup like we did, that failed a lot, like we did,
1:18 Speaker 01 it's easy to sort of like, think you're hot shit.
1:23 Speaker 00 It's easy to think that your advice can make companies work, that like you are the magician. And what's interesting is that over the years, a lot of YC founders will kind of start following the advice of these people, and they'll make very, very common errors. And you can almost track it back to like, oh, I kind of understand the type of person who was giving you this advice, because I see what you're doing now, and like, this matches one-to-one. So, one of the most common types of investors is the investor with a finance background. Someone who's like never run a company, never operated in a company, and pure finance.
2:01 Speaker 01 When all you have is a hammer, everything's a nail, and so if what you know is money, the solutions usually involve money. So, raising more money, spending more money, throwing money at the problem, right?
2:13 Speaker 00 Hey Dalton, your pre-product market fit, do you have five-year financial projections?
2:18 Speaker 01 That's a great example of that. Financial projections may be a good idea later stage, but to even ask me if I had financial projections, I was like, what's a financial projection? Like, Michael, how, how many years in your startup did you learn what a balance sheet and shit was?
2:35 Speaker 00 Long time. Actually, and I resisted it. I resisted it. Our C O O Kevin was like, this is important for you to learn. I'm like, you know what's important for us to learn? How not to lose money every month before we die? And the balance sheet is not really telling us that. It's um, it's that we make no money and we spend money. So that's what, that's what the problem is.
2:54 Speaker 01 And you know, for these folks, I get it, right? You, you spend time in spreadsheets, especially if you're doing stock market investing or private equity investing. It makes sense that your weapon is money and you move money around to, that's your leverage point. That's your point of leverage. What's the downside of, of internalizing that too much, man?
3:13 Speaker 00 I mean, we see this all the time, which is like scaling negative economic economics, or spending a ton of money in advertising with ever, ever worse payback periods or no payback period ever. It's really like getting people to work on things that are not making their product good.
3:33 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I think what's Remember Patrick Collison was talking about this when he came to speak at a bath recently, where he's like, listen, let me, let me be blunt.
3:42 Speaker 01 Too many founders treat product as an afterthought. They're basically trying to do financial engineering and the product is like delegated.
3:52 Speaker 00 I think what's also tricky is that like this strategy isn't always wrong. Like for successful companies, there is usually a point where throwing money at it is a good idea. It's just kind of knowing when to give that advice and when not to. It's when you always give that advice is when things get really tricky. All right. Here, here's the second type that's, that's common in the investing world. The big company exec. The person who's, you know, seen, seen companies at a thousand plus people and have a lot of experience and have done like great work in those companies and now become investors.
4:24 Speaker 01 Folks with big tech experience are really great at taking a successful product and scaling it further or refining a product. Okay? It just is pretty different when you were employee number, you know, a hundred or 200 at Airbnb or Google or Facebook, than employee number five. And as we spoke about in a prior video, our, our friend and colleague, Paul Buhat, you know, number 18 at Google, had, was like the king of dirty hacks. And in a lot of ways, you know, when we would interview former Googlers and he was in the room, he would, he wasn't on, he didn't love some of the instincts of folks that, it was the same
5:07 Speaker 01 company that they worked at, but the, the tactics that they brought to bear when you were employee number 1,000 to scale up one of these core products was pretty different than the folks in the first 20 employees. And so generally with these folks, it looks more like scaling up process, it looks more like scaling up hiring and kind of sometimes taking for granted that getting any users at all isn't really hard. Like I talked to about folks a lot about this in the Batchman, like what failure usually looks like for a lot of our companies is they get zero real customers. Yeah. Zero. It's not that the failure was they couldn't get a series A, it's that they just like bombed, like complete disaster. And so if you have too much of this
5:52 Speaker 01 mentality of like big company PM, it doesn't even occur to you that you can fail that badly.
5:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
5:59 Speaker 01 What do you think?
5:59 Speaker 00 I think it's tricky because all too often, this group of folks are giving founders the advice of hiring executives before product market fit. It's like you need to build up the company. It's like, marketing doesn't work. We need a marketing executive. Like, like, um, the, the engineering team isn't productive enough. We need a VP of engineering. And, and more often than not, in this pre-product market fit phase, the mistake is that there's the wrong person in the company, not there aren't enough people. The mistake is like, you've got an engineer that no one wants to work with, or no one's measuring any of the marketing results, right? It's like, those are the mistakes, not like you don't have a department for it, or an executive
6:41 Speaker 00 to run it. Whereas, you know, we go right back to the first one, right? When a company is scaling and growing, post-product market fit, like hiring more people is essential. So like, once again, we get this weird dichotomy.
6:55 Speaker 01 Think about the zero to one, think about the first five employees of Facebook and the first five employees of Instagram, before, when it was a startup, before they got acquired. The first five employees of YouTube, when it was a startup, before it got acquired, versus the really awesome people post-acquisition, who had to step in and scale that thing. Those people are awesome. Hallelujah. They're super valuable. And if they weren't around on the, in the zero to one stage.
7:24 Speaker 01 Watch out. Get what I'm saying? Like, like, it's a very different muscle to build. Scaling Instagram post acquisition, if you were on that team, than being, getting the first hundred users when you were the founder of Instagram. Right?
7:38 Speaker 00 Very.
7:39 Speaker 01 And there's a whole lot more, actually, supply and demand, there's so many more people that helped scale Instagram than there are people that founded Instagram.
7:46 Speaker 00 Yep.
7:46 Speaker 01 Right? There's just lots, so there's, there's lots of folks that have lots of experience scaling products. And it's, you just don't meet as many that are, that did the zero to one.
7:56 Speaker 00 Yeah. So the next category is the successful entrepreneur in the non, in a non-tech industry. And, and this is really common, this is really common internationally in like new founder ecosystems where like the people funding them maybe didn't make their money in tech. What's the common kind of advice given here?
8:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, this one's tricky. Where if someone made all their money investing in real estate or in strip malls or franchise, McDonald's franchises or something, like just something that is not remotely a tech startup. They will often ask for crazy terms that would make sense if they were investing in like a franchise store. They may ask for more control and they may be really stressed out all the time that you're going to lose their money. And so a lot of the trickiest investors, is a nice way to say it, that I've seen. The, the Y C founders are like, oh, why did I take their money? It'll just be someone who's totally well meaning, but they treat this
8:57 Speaker 01 like an investment in a Subway franchise and that you're the manager of the Subway franchise and they're gonna call you and yell at you. Or something, that you're gonna lose their money as opposed to letting you do your tech startup.
9:08 Speaker 00 And that's really just like. They really, these folks are like, you can't be mad at them. They're just taking the principles that they learned to make their money. And applying them to a different industry, right? And it's like.
9:21 Speaker 01 Totally.
9:22 Speaker 00 In some ways, these are people you can be mad at the least because it's like, at least they're, they were successful themselves and they're like taking things that worked for them, right? Like, they're not reading this shit on Twitter. But it is tricky because like, I think what we've learned is that industries are just different. Like, you know, maybe there's some common principles, but like in general, software companies look really different than a lot of other companies out there. So, all right, here's the next investor type. The junior investor, the person who just got started, looking to make a name for themselves, still early in their career. Oftentimes, having to really have a win pretty quickly to cement themselves in this career. What's the most common type of advice these people give?
10:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think this one is tricky. I think a good mental model is to put yourself in their shoes. I think when you're a new investor or you're newly hired at your job, you're not in a position of power inside of the place that you work. Or you're not in a position of power with your investors because they went and raised money from someone else. And so to show weakness or to like screw up their first few investments is very bad for their career. And we know lots of people that basically don't last in the industry because their first investments were bad. Like, it's kind of a career suicide to become an investor, not have any other track record, and then make some bad investments. Like, you're not going to make it, okay?
10:48 Speaker 01 And so basically, these folks are very optimistic that it's gonna work, that you're gonna make it work, that you should totally go raise more money. Because their KPIs, that if you raise money and they can mark up their investment, it makes them look good so they can go tell their colleagues or their investors, "Hey, I invested in this company and it went on to raise more money at a better valuation than I invested at. I'm really smart." Right? And so the thing to understand is that's their KPI. And so in your interactions with them, they will often just really encourage you to fundraise and to keep doing that a lot. And that everything's working great and you do have product market fit and you should scale faster.
11:28 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:29 Speaker 01 Right?
11:31 Speaker 00 And it's interesting because...
11:34 Speaker 00 Another example of like, they're not trying to hurt your company.
11:39 Speaker 01 No, they're good. They're good people. They're nice people.
11:41 Speaker 00 Yeah. In many ways, they're like some amongst the biggest cheerleaders for your company. It's just that like your company at this stage probably has some really broken shit that has to be dealt with. And so unfortunately, it's harder for them to kind of go and spend the time in the dirt with you on that stuff. Cause it's gonna kind of break their illusion. And um, hey, you know, it's, it's, it is what it is.
12:04 Speaker 01 And it's, it's rough. Like if you were a company where it doesn't make sense to raise for a very long amount of time. It may be the right thing that you want to do, but may not be great for them. If their whole thing is to prove that they're great investors really fast, so that they can keep their jobs.
12:22 Speaker 00 So the next category investor we see a lot is the influencer slash famous person.
12:29 Speaker 00 What do you, when I think about this kind of person, this is the person that would come to Y C demo day and everyone would freak out to get them on their cap table.
12:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, celebrities.
12:38 Speaker 00 They just, yeah, they just get, you know, infinite access.
12:43 Speaker 00 How do you think that they try to help founders who are, who are struggling?
12:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I, I think that you really understand distribution if you're an influencer, because that's your game. Is building up your distribution network, which you can monetize a bunch of different ways, right? If you have a million, you know, Instagram followers or a million TikTok followers, you can make money off that and you get it. You're savvy. And so I think these people are very savvy and realize they can kind of treat startups like other ad deals. Of being like, give me some stuff and I'll promote you. And so a lot of times these folks will like ask for advisor shares or they'll ask, they'll just ask for things. And again, they've been, that's how they got big. They're, you know, they know, they know what they're doing.
13:29 Speaker 01 And it can be so tempting to do it to think that like celebrities tweeting about your thing is gonna fix all your distribution problems. And like, maybe in some cases they do, but most of my experience, both personally and with founders in Y C. Is the founders kind of feel like they got a raw deal on these and that the, the clicks they get from the, from the posts or whatever.
13:53 Speaker 01 Were not as helpful as they had hoped. That is a nice way to say it.
13:57 Speaker 00 And you know what's weird about this Dalton is that the the best, most reputable influencers and famous people in tech world, they don't promise distribution. Like they say, I'll try to help, but like I think the founders set expectations way too high. Like it's the founder, once again, looking for the silver bullet, someone else solved the problem for me. And um, man, silver bullets don't exist. All right, we got two more types here. So two more types. Type one is other founders. So this is becoming a lot more common nowadays, right? Like founders investing each other's companies. It's, you know, some people have seen success doing this, others not. But what's the advice that, you know, most often you're going to get from another founder to help you when they're on your cap table?
14:41 Speaker 01 Usually when you get advice from other founders, it's heavily based on their personal experience. Duh. But like the downside of that is if they're really, if they really struggled fundraiser with fundraising personally, all their advice is going to be them basically telling you, don't do what I did. Or if they struggle with distribution, all their advice is going to be around, you know, like they're almost like, they have a lot of feelings about what happened to them. Again, this is, we were founders too, dude. Like a lot of my advice was heavily based on my personal experience and it only, it took years of me working at Y C to sort of break out of that trap.
15:23 Speaker 01 Which is to not be so autobiographical in the things that I'm telling people, you know?
15:27 Speaker 00 I think this is something that like people don't understand enough. Is like how much we are learning from the founders that we're working with and how much we are condensing their learnings and delivering it to the next generation of Y C founders versus how much we're condensing learnings personally that we got in our own companies. I think that's like very counterintuitive to to most people. The last one is the extremely young investor, right? The, the, just out of college, writing a check. Sometimes this person's in college, writing a check. And, and kind of trying to, to build a, a career in our world. Different from the, this person often is different from the like junior investor.
16:12 Speaker 00 Cause this person's usually not working at a VC fund or they're a big fund like that. They're usually kind of a scout or some kind of, in that kind of role. What's the, what's the advice they're often giving?
16:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, look, these people are super sweet and they're super exciting, you know, to talk to. I just think that like, the same way that the founder realizes that their job is to play the part of a founder. And so they like, watch movies about how founders are supposed to act and like read books about it. And they sort of are being like, am I doing it right? Am I a founder now? Like, I think you kind of see this with these investors where they just, they read what other investors say and do, and they sort of like say and do whatever it is they read. And so like whatever the hot new trend is, whatever people are tweeting about, whatever like latest essay they've read, they just sort of like repeat that. And see if, and hopefully no one notices that that's what's going on.
17:09 Speaker 00 Which is, which is how people learn in school, right? So it kind of makes sense, like it's exactly the same. So, you know, one of the interesting things here to kind of wrap up is that we make mistakes, like we screw up. There is a YC partner, common, bad advice kind of mode. And, um, you know, we were talking about this before the show. And I think you said it right, which is like, the kind of lean startup, don't hire, don't spend too much money, like talk to your users, put a shitty MVP out in the world path, is the path that works for everyone in all cases. I think sometimes we can fall into that trap, but there are many examples that doesn't apply, right?
17:53 Speaker 00 Like, what are your thoughts on, on, on where YC partners ourselves, we can get tripped up and, and give bad advice?
18:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that. The biggest critique I would have of ourselves is that sometimes it works right out of the gate. And sometimes you can spend two years building a product in a cave and never talk to a single user. And it's perfect and you immediately get product market fit. Sometimes that happens.
18:26 Speaker 00 Yep.
18:26 Speaker 01 I think that we just, we have, we have enough data points that it seems like insane of us to ever recommend that strategy statistically. Like it's like, it's like, hey, oh, you have cancer. Oh, well, you know, if you, you know, go on a water fast, that might fix it like maybe. Um, I think that it just feels a bit hard for us to recommend making a strategy to not do those things. But we have enough data points of Y C companies. We see companies that can't bootstrap or can't launch an M V P. And have to go build something in a vacuum for two or three years.
19:04 Speaker 00 Yes.
19:04 Speaker 01 And sometimes it works.
19:06 Speaker 00 Yes.
19:07 Speaker 01 Right?
19:08 Speaker 00 The best Y C partners are very careful with how forcefully we give the Y C advice. Because like, the longer you're here, the longer you have a kind of running record of the time I told someone to do it like this and the opposite worked.
19:23 Speaker 01 Yep.
19:24 Speaker 00 And so, you know, honestly, to, to.
19:26 Speaker 01 But to me, you know what the lesson is there, Michael? The founders that made it work believed in themselves and they knew that we couldn't fix it. Like they actually internalized the whole meta point of, of this video, or at least what I'm trying to get across with it, which is like, you know, they, they took bits and pieces, they, they, they, they took information from the outside world. But they took personal accountability that they're the ones who are going to have to make it work.
19:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
19:48 Speaker 01 And they weren't counting on blindly following anyone is being the way it ain't, right?
19:53 Speaker 00 Nope. And, and especially in including us. Yeah. I think that the big takeaway here is that. As a founder, it's your job to figure out how to best use these people who are here to help you. All these investors who are here to help you, it's your job how to figure out how to best use them. They all have your interests in mind, but none of us can tell you exactly what to do to win. None of us. And like, it's funny because at the YC kickoff, the first thing we say is that, you know, we're experts in failure. We know a lot of paths to not take. But if you want us to sit next to you at your desk and tell you everything to do to win, to become a billion dollar company, we can't do it. And we actually ask them, we're like, hey, and if you want to leave YC right now,
20:38 Speaker 00 we'll, we'll take, we'll give you our shares back. Like, we don't want you to come in here with any false pretenses. Like, this is a hard problem. Most people don't succeed. And like, you're going to be able to deserve 99.9% of the credit if you figure it out. Because you figured it out.
20:56 Speaker 00 All the rest of the people around who helped you, they didn't figure it out. Dalton, before we close, you know, we've talked about a number of examples of when investors give advice and it kind of pattern matches to where they come from, but might not apply to you at this time. What are some of the pieces of advice that you've gotten from investors that have really made a huge difference? Like, what is, what's been some examples of great investor advice? Because, you know, I think you and I both have these.
21:24 Speaker 01 I think the best investor advice I ever got as a founder is that I was swimming in my head with too many ideas at once. And I had too much data and that someone from the outside could look at everything and be like, oh, this is working. They could take, they could take all of this like consternation and like complicated stuff. And like, I can think of a couple of times in my life when someone was just like, this is working. You should do more of this. And they were right. And it added a ton of value. Or conversely,
21:59 Speaker 01 This is bad. You're failing.
22:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:03 Speaker 01 And again, I was full of excuse, like, like my brain was full of like a thousand different threads going in a different direction, but to have someone synthesize that into something very simple was super helpful, dude. I got great advice like that when I was a founder.
22:18 Speaker 00 Number one, number one piece of advice we ever got was from, you know, someone who had experienced big companies, guy named Gideon Yu. And we had just gotten Justin TV profitable and we were very proud of ourselves. Um, and we, the first year, we really tried to monetize, we made eight million dollars in annual revenue, which I think now would qualify us as like a deck of corn or something.
22:43 Speaker 00 And he came to talk to us and he basically said, folks, look, you should be happy. Congratulations, but your company sucks. If you don't change stuff, it's all going to die. And all the work you put in so far, no one's going to remember what you did.
22:58 Speaker 00 And what was great is like, there was no like, and so you should do this. It was just more like, and that's, that's my current status of your company in a nutshell. And it's exactly what we needed to hear. We just like, the best investors point out the problem. They don't give you a solution. They just point out the problem. And they, we knew it. We knew that was the problem too. It's just when someone says it to you, you're like, oh crap.
23:21 Speaker 01 But isn't that funny? Cause again, like so many incentives in life are set up. To be nice or to tell people that they're great and they should stay great and everything they're doing is great and they're taking over the world. But weirdly, again, if I think back to like the founder advice that I got and same with you, it's actually when people were kind of hard on us.
23:39 Speaker 00 Yep.
23:39 Speaker 01 That I, that was actually what was helpful.
23:42 Speaker 00 Yep. Well, you know, it was crazy. One of the reasons why I think Gideon felt so comfortable giving that advice is that he had no interest in investing in us at all. Yeah. Literally had no interest. And you know, that's a counterintuitive thing, right? Like, wow, it's like really. You can get a lot more honesty out of somebody when they're not financially incentivized to kind of blow smoke up your ass to, you know, to say nice things. So. All right.
Previous What Does It REALLY Mean To Do Things That Don't Scale? Next Things That Don't Scale, The Software Edition Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated