Pod Insights Y Combinator Podcast Silicon Valley's Cargo Culting Problem About this episode When it comes to building a startup you’re never doing it entirely from scratch. Inspiration and ideas can come from a variety of places, including other successful startups. But there’s a thin line between borrowing smart ideas and copying them blindly - otherwise known as Cargo Culting.
In this episode Dalton and Michael break down the problem with Cargo Culting and offer advice on the right way to draw inspiration from other successful companies.
Apply to Y Combinator: https://yc.link/DandM-apply
Work at a Startup: https://yc.link/DandM-jobs
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 The idea that superficially copying Uber and copying the things that they said in interviews, pretending that you're Travis, whatever, doesn't work. It's just like wearing a black turtleneck does not make you
0:12 Speaker 01 Steve Jobs.
0:13 Speaker 00 Yeah. That does not make you Apple. That is cargo culting.
0:15 Speaker 01 Yes.
0:19 Speaker 01 This is Michael Seibert with Dalton Caldwell, and today we're going to talk about cargo culting.
0:26 Speaker 01 We encounter this way too much in our life. So there's classic variety, and then there's new age, modern cargo culting. Let's start with classic. What's classic cargo culting?
0:38 Speaker 00 Well, let's start with what is cargo culting? What are we even, what are these guys talking about? All right. So the history of the term, as I understand it, is when you superficially copy something without understanding why you're copying it,
0:53 Speaker 00 that is cargo culting. I think the history, if someone looks this up in Wikipedia, is like, folks would create a fake airfield so that the planes came back. And so it was something that looks like a landing strip?
1:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:02 Speaker 00 Because they wanted the airplanes to come back.
1:03 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:04 Speaker 00 So they didn't really understand why the planes were coming. So like, oh, if we make a fake landing strip,
1:07 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:07 Speaker 00 then the airplanes will come back. Okay? And so in this classic cargo culting mentality, it's just, I'm going to copy something. I don't know why.
1:17 Speaker 01 Yep.
1:17 Speaker 00 I'm going to copy it, and then I will be as successful as the thing I'm copying, right? Anything to add there?
1:22 Speaker 01 Well, I think in the classic variety, what's essential is the thing that you're copying is good.
1:27 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:28 Speaker 01 We're not, no one would debate whether it's good or not, right? And, and so we're just debating how you copy it.
1:34 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:35 Speaker 01 I think what's funny about this modern, new age cargo culting that we'll get to later is that like, we could even just debate whether the thing you're copying is worth copying at all.
1:43 Speaker 00 Fair.
1:44 Speaker 01 And so then it becomes this like, kind of double-sided, you're screwing yourself. But let's just go with classic. In the classic variety, what goes wrong in cargo culting is because you don't understand, really deeply understand the product that you're copying, you miss some like obvious things.
1:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:58 Speaker 01 And I like your like, you know, airport example, right? Where it's kind of like, yeah, if you make a landing strip in the middle of the jungle, Airplanes won't land there. You're missing the It's part of the
2:09 Speaker 00 There's something larger going on.
2:11 Speaker 01 The whole system. And I think founders did this. I think we
2:16 Speaker 00 Definitely we did this.
2:17 Speaker 01 Of this. And so let's talk about kind of the companies that were classically cultivated in our era.
2:23 Speaker 00 Well, the first and most obvious one was Google.
2:25 Speaker 01 Yes.
2:26 Speaker 00 Everyone in the 2000s was obsessed with Google.
2:29 Speaker 01 Yes.
2:30 Speaker 00 It was the best startup.
2:31 Speaker 01 Yes.
2:31 Speaker 00 And so, you know, everyone you talked to was like, well, Google did this. Or are you the next Google? Or well, this is how Google did it.
2:37 Speaker 01 Yes.
2:38 Speaker 00 And so all these ideas that may or may not have been good ideas, we were kind of trained.
2:44 Speaker 01 Were obviously the right.
2:45 Speaker 00 Were things to copy. So the most obvious one is just like the office culture of having an open office and like
2:51 Speaker 01 Yes.
2:51 Speaker 00 Bright colors and like free snacks and like all this like super Googly stuff.
2:56 Speaker 01 Yep.
2:57 Speaker 00 That was considered like you, if you wanted to do a real startup, you had to be like Google, right, man?
3:01 Speaker 01 Not only that, that's what made Google great was the lack of offices.
3:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, you're right. No cube farms. That's why it was considered key to their culture. Like this is actually, there was arguments that copying down to the T, every aspect of the Google office culture was key to building a successful startup.
3:19 Speaker 01 Exactly. Exactly. I think the other thing was this kind of flat org.
3:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, no managers.
3:24 Speaker 01 Engineers don't need management and da, da, da, da. Another classic one that I love was just they like hire as many smart engineers as possible. If you ever come across a smart engineer, no matter what.
3:35 Speaker 00 Yep.
3:35 Speaker 01 Give them a job offer, you'll find a way to use them. I think it's funny because like, this is what we came up like.
3:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
3:41 Speaker 01 Like this was conventional wisdom.
3:43 Speaker 00 There was other examples more silly than that. It was like the name of your startup needed to be cute.
3:47 Speaker 01 Yes.
3:48 Speaker 00 Or like drop vowels. Remember Flickr started this where there was no E in it? And so it would be, you need a Google like logo.
3:54 Speaker 01 Yes.
3:55 Speaker 00 That looked like primary colors and had like a shiny, remember what was the term? Like you would put like a lens flare on your logo.
4:02 Speaker 01 Oh my god.
4:02 Speaker 00 Do you remember this? Everyone did this. Go look at logos back in like 2006.
4:06 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:06 Speaker 00 And that was because Google and these other startups
4:09 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:09 Speaker 00 Had lens flare on their logos and they had cute names.
4:12 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:13 Speaker 00 So you had to do it.
4:14 Speaker 01 Well, and I love it because it's like obvious in the pursuit of building the world's best search engine. The logo styling. Was essential. I mean, really, it was a vital step. So number two, of course, Facebook, even closer to kind of our generation. They're the ones that brought you the going viral.
4:33 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah.
4:34 Speaker 01 How is your thing gonna go viral, Dalton?
4:37 Speaker 00 How's it gonna go viral?
4:39 Speaker 01 They're the ones who brought you the, where's the share button?
4:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:42 Speaker 01 You have to have a share button on everything. What else did, what else was the Uber, not the Facebook classics?
4:48 Speaker 00 I think just trying to not make any money directly from users and build up as big of a user base you can.
4:56 Speaker 01 Yep.
4:57 Speaker 00 And then build an ads business. Obviously, everyone was trying to do this. But Facebook really, we were constantly told by everyone we knew, and again, we believed it, that following the Facebook playbook was what was right for every business, no matter what type of business.
5:09 Speaker 01 No matter what. Charging your users was against the rules.
5:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, because you wanted to get the most user data possible. You wanted to get the biggest database of users.
5:16 Speaker 01 Of course. And then the, nobody cares about privacy. What was the, there was a quote where it was like, privacy is...
5:23 Speaker 00 Doesn't matter. I forget. They were like... Anyway, everyone that was blindly following what they did
5:28 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:28 Speaker 00 was trained to ignore all of those
5:30 Speaker 01 Yes.
5:31 Speaker 00 matters.
5:33 Speaker 01 Then maybe the last one, even more modern. Uber.
5:36 Speaker 00 Yeah.
5:37 Speaker 01 This was the fun one. I think it started with
5:41 Speaker 01 spend as much money as possible. Which I love because Uber was a successful company.
5:46 Speaker 00 It's great.
5:47 Speaker 01 And the idea that we could boil down a key strategy, spend as much money as possible, but that was the takeaway.
5:52 Speaker 00 They wrote a book about it. It was called Blitzscaling.
5:55 Speaker 01 Spend all the money as fast as it comes in. What's funny about maybe these Uber ones that are slightly different from the Facebook and Google ones is like, I don't think Uber even did these things.
6:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:06 Speaker 01 Like, Cargill culting can kind of take on its mind of its own.
6:09 Speaker 00 Exactly. And again, to be really clear on the point, Uber did a great job of what they did.
6:13 Speaker 01 They nailed it. Yes.
6:14 Speaker 00 It's the folks that were like, well, Uber did X, so we should do this.
6:18 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:18 Speaker 00 Without really understanding why Uber did the things they did.
6:21 Speaker 01 No.
6:21 Speaker 00 They would superficially... Scale the way they scaled, burn the way they burned.
6:25 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:26 Speaker 00 Ignore laws, the way they ignore laws.
6:28 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:29 Speaker 00 Ignore unit economics.
6:30 Speaker 01 Go to as many cities as possible, as possible, yeah.
6:32 Speaker 00 And so it was, it was these superficial wannabe Ubers.
6:37 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:37 Speaker 00 That did the silliest stuff versus Uber itself, where, you know, that worked pretty well, right?
6:41 Speaker 01 Now, let's be clear, all these businesses worked.
6:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:45 Speaker 01 So let's talk about it, right? Like, for Google, this was great advice.
6:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:51 Speaker 01 Right? For Google, hiring as many really smart people was essential because they were trying to do something really hard.
6:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think that the conventional wisdom pre-Google was that search was a commodity.
7:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:02 Speaker 00 And that Yahoo was good enough.
7:04 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:04 Speaker 00 And that incremental engineering breakthroughs in search wouldn't matter. And Google disproved that, where it was actually a hard technical problem.
7:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:12 Speaker 00 And they were able to put those engineers to work. Also, historically, this was right after the dot com bubble crashed. So they were able to hire some great talent.
7:19 Speaker 01 Amazing people.
7:20 Speaker 00 For, that was available because the dot com bubble just crashed.
7:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:23 Speaker 00 And so if you really look at the decisions they made in context of history, it made a ton of sense.
7:28 Speaker 01 It made a perfect sense.
7:28 Speaker 00 But how many people did we know that blindly copied the Google playbook and it did not? They did not replicate Google's success, did they?
7:35 Speaker 01 No, no. They weren't even trying to do anything near as hard. I think in Facebook's case, another perfect example of like, not charging users was really smart. Right? They understood they could build an amazing ad business.
7:48 Speaker 00 Yep.
7:48 Speaker 01 They understood that scale was the only path to it. And like, Facebook is an amazing ads business, right? Like, that was really smart for them. Not clear that every business should be an ads business.
8:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, and when you think about it, how many Facebooks are there? And how many people that were blindly copying the Facebook cargo? You know, how many people that were cargo-culting Facebook succeeded?
8:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
8:11 Speaker 00 Not many, again, maybe it's more than zero, but wow. That was more of like a one-shot epic company than something that people could just blindly copy and be just as successful as Facebook.
8:21 Speaker 01 The second Facebook-style profile you had was delivering infinitely less value.
8:27 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:28 Speaker 01 Than the first one you had. I would also argue that people, you know, Facebook and this whole going viral, it's a lot easier to try to make your product go viral if users spend two hours a day using it. Right?
8:39 Speaker 00 Yes.
8:39 Speaker 01 That, day one Facebook, people were spending two hours a day using it. If people use your product five minutes a month, it's a lot harder to go viral.
8:49 Speaker 00 Yes.
8:51 Speaker 00 You need some different tactics. You can't just copy Facebook blindly and hope it works.
8:55 Speaker 01 So it's like going viral was a great strategy for Facebook. Is it a great strategy for you? And the last with Uber, I think like the hilarious thing about Uber is that most of the common beliefs about Uber just weren't true. People who were investing in Uber were looking at markets where Uber was doing very well in unit economics and purposely funding them to expand quickly. It wasn't people looking at Uber serving no markets well, burning money left and right and saying, oh, let's just throw more of our money on the fire. And it was weird to watch founders just be like, well, you know, we should expand our business to 17 cities when it's not working in one.
9:34 Speaker 00 Yep.
9:35 Speaker 01 When like, you remember the first time you did Uber? Like, I do. It was a huge moment. It like, it literally was so valuable. Like, it was immediately successful in San Francisco. And so this idea that like, oh, Uber just like, nobody liked it and like, they just burned a bunch of money and somehow got successful. It's like, this doesn't make any sense.
9:54 Speaker 00 The idea that superficially copying Uber and copying the things that they said in interviews, pretending that you're Travis, whatever, doesn't work. It's just like wearing a black turtleneck does not make you
10:06 Speaker 01 Steve Jobs.
10:07 Speaker 00 Yeah. That does not make you Apple. That is cargo culting.
10:10 Speaker 01 Yes. Whereas like, if you built a thing that people would use multiple times a week to get to the most important things in their life, like work or their loved ones.
10:18 Speaker 00 That's pretty good.
10:19 Speaker 01 That's really valuable.
10:20 Speaker 00 So hard to replicate this stuff, right, man?
10:22 Speaker 01 It is. Copying is hard. You have to be really smart to copy well. So, we talked about this classic cargo culting. And at least with the classic cargo culting, you're copying successful companies. What concerns me more and more nowadays with the explosion evaluations is that we see a lot of founders copying companies that haven't succeeded yet. And this is what's really scary to me is that like, some founder will be like, well, we have to do it this way because some are coming to this. And I'm like, oh, why are they good? It's like, well, they're a billion dollar company.
10:56 Speaker 00 They just raised a series B and they just did this. Like, they heard, they read some fundraising announcement.
10:59 Speaker 01 And then I asked them, well, how much revenue were they making? And the most common answer is, I have no idea. And it's like, so you're basing like a huge chunk of your company's strategy.
11:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, your strategy. You're the CEO of a company. Let me get this straight. You're the CEO of the company.
11:14 Speaker 01 Yes.
11:14 Speaker 00 You're telling me the strategy you're betting the farm on.
11:17 Speaker 01 Yes.
11:17 Speaker 00 Is based on you read a fundraiser announcement and you have no other context.
11:21 Speaker 01 Oh.
11:22 Speaker 00 But like a podcast interview with a founder.
11:25 Speaker 01 And it has a lot of GitHub stars. It's one thing to try to copy something that's working. Like you might get lucky and win.
11:33 Speaker 01 Like, if you copy something that's not working, I don't even know, what are we doing here? And I think that unfortunately, these valuations have gotten people all messed up in the head. Like, they think that if investor thinks it's worth a billion dollars, it's working.
11:49 Speaker 00 Well, again, just to be super concrete, how many people do we see that were influenced by WeWork and building WeWork for X?
11:55 Speaker 01 Oh, my God.
11:55 Speaker 00 And their entire strategy was based on WeWork.
11:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:58 Speaker 00 We saw the same thing, Zoom Pizza.
12:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:00 Speaker 00 Like robotic pizza making. And so you'd see these things where it eventually turns into like, you know, sadly a flame out for the founders, but there were a lot of people that were copying these companies blindly.
12:09 Speaker 01 Because they raised a bunch of money.
12:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:11 Speaker 01 And I think this is part of this kind of certainly weirdly bigger trend of like, people doing the modern cargo culting amongst startups. Where they're like, oh, if my startup looks, is gonna, is gonna be real, it has to look like other startups.
12:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's like the superficial, they're really focused on how people will perceive the startup superficially.
12:32 Speaker 01 Yes.
12:33 Speaker 00 Like the logos thing we were talking about.
12:34 Speaker 01 Yes, yes.
12:35 Speaker 00 Like, what are some examples of the superficial things that you want to do to pretend to be a startup?
12:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I have to raise money, right? I have to have good advisors. Maybe someone, God forbid, told me I should have a patent, right? I have to have an amazing pitch deck. I gotta be able to pitch my company anywhere. Maybe a couple of conferences I get invited to, some press. And these are things that founders do to impress themselves, to impress other founders.
13:02 Speaker 00 Yep.
13:02 Speaker 01 The user is not essential.
13:05 Speaker 00 Has nothing with the product or something caused for users.
13:07 Speaker 01 No.
13:07 Speaker 00 It's all the superficial.
13:09 Speaker 01 Yes.
13:09 Speaker 00 Facade.
13:10 Speaker 01 Yes.
13:11 Speaker 00 Of this looks like a startup that looks like other startups that raised money.
13:15 Speaker 01 So let's think about, because we've talked about cargo culting on three levels, right? We're like, okay, garden variety cargo culting, that's still really bad as you cargo go Google. Then we're like, okay, the modern thing is to cargo cult the modern unicorn that has very little revenue. And now the super, super modern is just to cargo cult the other struggling startup.
13:34 Speaker 00 I love when someone references a startup that we know and we're like,
13:37 Speaker 01 No!
13:40 Speaker 01 Yes. And I think that like, maybe the base conclusion here is that you have to do some copying. You cannot innovate everything. But I think that like, I like when founders start with, what does the user want? Starts with, who are the companies the user's paying for, paying today to provide this service? And what can we learn from those companies? And then like, what can we learn from those companies writing the service who are successful? Okay, now let's think through it. And I think once you think through it through the user's eyes, you can tell which things are essential. Do people care about the Google logo? Or do they care that they get search results that are good?
14:19 Speaker 00 Hey, how about that?
14:20 Speaker 01 Fast, right? Do they care about the Facebook, I don't know? Or do they care that their friends are on there and they get updates quickly? Like, do they care about, you know, what city Uber just expanded to? Or do they care that like Uber shows up in five minutes in their city? So I think when founders start with the user, they won't go into this cargo culting. I think when they start with the, like you said, fundraising announcement, it's almost impossible.
14:48 Speaker 00 Look, the metaphor I use for this is, think about the difference between plagiarizing a paper that you read. Imagine you're like, hey, I gotta turn in a report. And what you do is you go and Google for things and copy and paste blindly all the stuff. You copy and paste three different things, just put it in your paper and submit it.
15:06 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:07 Speaker 00 That is not evidence of original thinking.
15:09 Speaker 01 No, no.
15:10 Speaker 00 Versus you go read a bunch of places.
15:12 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:12 Speaker 00 You digest the information, you synthesize it into your own original work.
15:16 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:16 Speaker 00 You maybe cite the sources of what you're learning from.
15:18 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:19 Speaker 00 But you actually took the time to digest and process these things. Same thing with the music industry, where if you plagiarize a song, that's a problem.
15:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:27 Speaker 00 Like if you just rip off someone's music, you will get sued, right? But if you listen to a lot of music and you get influenced by some of the sounds you hear and you integrate these new sounds into the new music that you want to put out.
15:38 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:38 Speaker 00 Totally cool. That's how, that's literally.
15:40 Speaker 01 That's the game.
15:40 Speaker 00 That's music. That's the music business is that everyone's being influenced by everyone else. And so again, the really important thing to tease apart is copying completely without thought or any original thinking or original work versus being influenced and borrowing good ideas to integrate into your own thing, right?
16:00 Speaker 01 Doesn't the thing that suck about startups is that you do have to think about a lot of things?
16:05 Speaker 00 There isn't just like.
16:06 Speaker 01 You can't just copy and paste. There isn't just a checklist. You do have to think carefully. But I think that's why really smart people are attracted to it. Because like you have to think really carefully. Yeah, it's an amazing test of your skills. All right. Great chat.
16:22 Speaker 00 Great. Thanks.
Previous Setting KPIs and Goals with Divya Bhat | Startup School Next Will OpenAI Kill All Startups? Page updated October 12, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated