Pod Insights Y Combinator Podcast Elon Musk & The Midwit Meme About this episode Dalton Caldwell and Michael Seibel on the midwit meme, how it applies to startups, and the best example: Elon Musk.
Apply to Y Combinator: https://www.ycombinator.com/apply/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This is the the beauty of the midwit meme is the the genius and the idiot come to the same conclusion. So what is the idiot approach? Like, that's actually how you can divine the genius approach is you're like, what would an idiot do?
0:16 Speaker 01 Everyone can reach for the idiot approach. Everyone has the intellectual capacity to reach for the idiot approach.
0:21 Speaker 00 If I didn't know anything.
0:24 Speaker 01 This is Michael Seibel with Dalton Caldwell. Today, we're going to talk about how overthinking is sometimes a founder's biggest mistake. So Dalton, this video was triggered by this amazing meme that you made on fundraising advice. But before we get to the meme, because I think it's like one of the best memes I've ever I've ever seen for fundraising advice. Let's start in general. Let's start in general.
0:51 Speaker 01 How can overthinking be bad? And when can overthinking be bad?
0:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, I think that what people think being a founder is is what they saw in like watching the Facebook movie or or popular television where, you know, you're like coding a lot and, you know, you're making deals and screwing over your friends. Just kidding. But but in reality, it's a lot of feeling lost and being not sure what to do and feeling stressed out a lot. And you're worried all the time. And so you tend to overthink everything and every decision you kind of think in circles over and over and over again. Because you don't have a boss, you don't have constraints when you're a startup founder, right? There's no one really telling you what to do, so you're on your own.
1:38 Speaker 00 And so when you the experience of being a startup founder is to always be overthinking everything.
1:45 Speaker 01 In this way, there's a bit of advantage to being young, right?
1:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, like you and I experienced this ourselves as founders where we were young when we first started. And this is the beauty of not knowing anything. The beauty of not knowing anything is that you think everything is easy. And none of the innumerable reasons why something might be hard or your startup might fail even occurs to you. You're like, oh, yeah, I'm, I'm 22, like, everything's easy. I can figure this out, right? And so again, this, this is like the, the midwit meme, right? Where if you don't know anything, your approach looks a lot like the approach of people that are really good founders. And the worst place to be is that you know just enough to know why the things you're trying are hard and the odds are stacked against you. And that freaks you out. And so you think about it a lot, right?
2:35 Speaker 01 So Dalton, one of the most perfect examples of this is actually Elon Musk. And why I think it's so perfect is that depending on how you tell the story, Elon looks like the dummy or the idiot, right? Like, I'm sorry, the dummy or the genius, right? Depending on how you tell the story and it almost doesn't matter, right? Cause he's winning. But you know, to me, the first example that I always loved is that, you know, I read some book about the starting of SpaceX and it started with Elon going to Russia, trying to buy like rockets. And like the Russian government being like, there's this American billionaire guy who wants to buy rockets and kind of not believing it.
3:19 Speaker 01 But Elon just looking really serious. So they like considered it and like they eventually said, no, but like, he got to talk to people about buying rockets from him. He's just a dude with money.
3:29 Speaker 00 He was like, go to Russia, buy rockets. Like that's the, those are the extremes. Is that genius or stupid? I can't tell.
3:35 Speaker 01 I can't tell.
3:36 Speaker 00 And, and like with Tesla itself, like to me, the midwit is, is electric cars are good. That's the extreme. Electric cars is good or on both. In the middle, it's like, no one has successfully done a startup car company since the 50s. And every, you know, if you look at all prior attempts to build an electric car, like there's all these words.
3:53 Speaker 01 And the infrastructure you need. Yeah, yes. And I think the, the one that we find most funny, which we'll see, this video, we'll see if we send, send a test of time is, is the boring company, right? Drilling holes under the ground so that you can drive places faster is very clearly the idiot one, but like, it could be the genius one too.
4:15 Speaker 00 It's exact, it's a beginner's mind idea, which is like, traffic is bad. What if we dug a hole under the ground? To get to downtown Las Vegas. And what's funny is you read all the critiques of this, like the Midwest stuff is like, wow, bus systems already exist and it might be much more efficient to optimize transportation. You know, there's lots of words in the middle of that, but you know, drill tunnel to avoid traffic is certainly at the extremes.
4:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:43 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:43 Speaker 00 And you kind of see him approach all of his problems this way where you can imagine it being the same sort of ideas that we like. Mars is cool. Like, yeah, Mars is cool. Like this is the kind of stuff we come up with as teenagers. Like a lot of his ideas.
4:57 Speaker 01 Yes. And the, the hard work is in the implementation, but the idea isn't very complicated. And like the V1 is kind of simple minded.
5:09 Speaker 00 And if he was an over thinker, he would do, he would rule all the stuff out. All this stuff is like, obviously a bad idea. And anyone in the Midwest territory would rule out all these ideas.
5:18 Speaker 01 Yes.
5:18 Speaker 00 Right?
5:19 Speaker 01 Yes. And they still do.
5:22 Speaker 01 They still do. It's, you know, it's the Tesla short seller, right?
5:27 Speaker 01 Let's go through some examples of, of the Midwest meme and you have to start with the meme that you made for Y C founders. So just to provide context, we're in the part of the batch where Y C founders start getting nervous about fundraising. And whenever a founder gets nervous, they start overthinking. And whenever they start overthinking, they assault us with office hours on topics. And Dalton created this meme so that we could fight back. What does the meme say?
5:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, what the meme is simple. It's the, the naive founder is like, oh, I'm going to raise the amount of money I need to succeed. I need, I need, here's the amount of money I need to raise for my series A. I ran a model and it's, you know, $800,000. So that's what I'm going to raise. That is the like naive approach.
6:14 Speaker 00 The really smart three, three, three time founder, someone that's done this before is like, I need to raise $800,000. So I'm going to do it. And then the midwit is the one who wants to ask fifteen questions and try to construct the perfect round and be afraid that some of them may not have enough allocation for value add investors and they want to not have a signaling risk. They talk a lot about signaling risk and there's like all these factors where I'll be talking to someone and it will be like fifteen levels deep in a hypothetical for an offer that they don't have.
6:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:48 Speaker 00 Right? And that's, that's the midwit, man, is that like you're screwing yourself by overthinking all this stuff. Instead of just being like, hey, I need X dollars. I'm gonna raise it and I'm gonna get back to work.
7:01 Speaker 01 This comes up a lot with MVPs. One of the questions that I love getting from a founder is before we launch our MVP, how do we know we're gonna be able to survive the onslaught of traffic and users that will come on our launch day? What's, what's midwit? What's the midwit play? What's the midwit meme for, for your MVP?
7:23 Speaker 00 I mean, yeah, the, the, the two extremes of the midwit meme are launch something fast.
7:34 Speaker 00 Build something fast and put it out. And the midwit one is like, whoa, I don't want to get a bad reputation that my thing was buggy and we only have one shot to launch and you know.
7:43 Speaker 01 Like what about the press? We gotta do a press launch. Doesn't it have to be an event?
7:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, I, I don't want people to see my idea and copy it. So it's gotta be perfect.
7:52 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:53 Speaker 00 That's one.
7:53 Speaker 01 And then do we do, do we do like a TechCrunch post or is it better to try to get the New York Times or like what about Hacker News?
8:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:01 Speaker 01 We need to get all three. So how do we coordinate them together?
8:05 Speaker 00 We wanna, we wanna be featured in the New York Times. And so how do we optimize for that? Or, oh, what should we name the company? How about, I don't.
8:13 Speaker 01 Yes. We have to rebrand because there's a name that's kind of similar to ours. We don't want people to be confused. How about co-founders? I hear this a lot. Like, I, I am a business person and I'm good at sales. I need to find a marketing co-founder and an engineer, like a CTO, who's already managed 50 people because we're going to grow fast. Like, how, how, how does co-founders?
8:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:38 Speaker 01 How do you see this thing go?
8:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, Dalton, um, I'm open to the idea of a co-founder. I just haven't found the right person. And what I really am looking for is someone with at least five to seven years of experience at Google, who made it to at least a level seven. And so, you know, I'm looking, I haven't found the right person yet, but we're looking for it.
8:59 Speaker 01 Yes. When we find them, I'm, I'm totally open to bring out a co-founder when I find that one.
9:05 Speaker 00 But first, we're going to raise money and then I think that'll attract a better co-founder.
9:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
9:09 Speaker 00 So again, the, the point we're kind of making is not that any one of these ideas is the one people say. It's that it's thinking in circles and having a thousand different reasons.
9:20 Speaker 01 Yes.
9:20 Speaker 00 That it's that the person that should be your co-founder is no one that you currently know.
9:26 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. And then, and let's talk about the other sides of the equation, right? The, the, on the dumb side, the founder's like, it's fun to work with my friends, so I'm just going to start with my friend, right? On the smart side,
9:38 Speaker 00 Justin Khan likes to put a camera on his head.
9:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, let's go.
9:42 Speaker 00 This is our guy.
9:44 Speaker 01 Like, We were drinking buddies.
9:45 Speaker 00 Why did they pick you as your, as their co-founder? Wasn't it like?
9:48 Speaker 01 Well, because I, I helped them find an apartment and open up a bank account.
9:51 Speaker 00 This guy, this guy helped us find an apartment. All right. He's the co-founder of Twitch. Done.
9:56 Speaker 01 There you go. Done. And then like, the super smart, experienced founders, like, oh, having a co-founder is viable for emotional support. And this is going to be tricky. And like, they have all the like sophisticated reasons. Same answer. Same answer. I love that. Okay. Next, this is a classic one, especially because you have to deal with so many admissions questions. Applying to YC, Dalton, what is, what is the, what is the Jedi founder move to apply to YC versus the midwifed founder?
10:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, the, the extremes of this and the midwifed meme are I filled out my application and submitted it. Like, like, I applied. And the midwit founder is like, gee, I don't know if now is the right time to apply. I don't know if we're ready. Oh, I'm gonna, I'm gonna write a draft of my application and send it to fifteen people and I'm gonna get feedback on my application. And I'm going to like, you know, oh, I need an introduction to alumni and I need to talk to alumni.
10:56 Speaker 01 I need recommendations. Yeah, recommendations from strangers that don't know me.
11:02 Speaker 00 I, I'm gonna do a lot of research, like you see, you talk to people that like, put months of effort into their application to Y C strategy.
11:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
11:12 Speaker 00 Not correlated with success. And then you talk to people and they're like, oh, yeah, I just like filled it out in thirty minutes. So you got in.
11:21 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I spent all that other time working on my company.
11:27 Speaker 00 And to be clear, we're not saying do a bad job on your application. We're just saying, trying to tweak out on this is like something that you can spend tons and tons and tons of time on. I'm not sure that's a great allocation of resources.
11:42 Speaker 01 No, you didn't. And I think that's like maybe the essential point here is that like, we want you to spend time on the important stuff for your startup. Like, we're trying to get you to avoid spending time on the things that won't help you.
11:57 Speaker 01 That's the idea. That's the idea. All right. Next, and, and here's, here's kind of a classic one is product market fit. Dalton, do I have product market fit? And how, what's the midwit approach to?
12:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, the, the midwit approach for this one is to be not sure if you have it and create fifteen different metrics and like a complicated series of thoughts that maybe you have it or you have early product market fit. Versus the extremes of this meme.
12:30 Speaker 01 Early product.
12:32 Speaker 00 Everyone's got early, yeah. The, the extremes of this are like. Am I overwhelmed with demand? Like you know it when you see it. Like you don't have to think very hard when you have it. It's sort of like hits you over the head when you have product market fit.
12:45 Speaker 01 Dalton, I think the extremes in the meme is like, did I sleep last night?
12:52 Speaker 01 I didn't sleep last night.
12:53 Speaker 00 Do I have time to wonder if I have product market fit?
12:56 Speaker 01 That's yes, yes.
12:57 Speaker 00 If you have time to wonder about it, if you're like, gee, do I have product market fit? Let me, let's pontificate on this. That probably means you don't.
13:04 Speaker 01 Yes, let's do some, let's make some reports. So, so we talk about all the situations where maybe overthinking is not a good idea. But you also describe, you know, there are certain situations, you call them trap door decisions, when maybe you want to think a little bit harder than the, before making a move. So what are some examples of those?
13:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, so, um, legal issues. Don't break any law, like saying you didn't know there was a law is not a great legal defense. Um, regulatory issues, similarly, oh, I didn't know that I couldn't launder this money. Um, probably not great. You may want to overthink that and look into it. Um, things that affect people's health and wellbeing. Yeah, you should overthink that. You should really spend the time worrying about people, right, man? Like.
13:58 Speaker 01 Let's not be fast and loose if we're building an online pharmacy. Let's, let's measure twice, cut once.
14:05 Speaker 00 Totally.
14:05 Speaker 01 And, and I think that, um, what really good founders do is they are very good at figuring out, are they dealing with something like that or are they not? Cause even within legal, right? There's certain things that are like, oh, this is like whatever. And there's certain things that are like really bad.
14:22 Speaker 00 Michael, should, should I file patents for all of my IP?
14:26 Speaker 01 Exactly.
14:27 Speaker 00 That's a classic overthinking.
14:28 Speaker 01 Absolutely not.
14:29 Speaker 00 Probably not.
14:31 Speaker 01 So I think that like.
14:34 Speaker 01 The framework here is really twofold. One, don't overthink when you don't have to. And then two, um, remember that like, most of the work, most of the work is not in these overthinking games. Like, most of the work are not in these over-optimizing games.
14:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's action.
14:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:57 Speaker 00 Taking action and not thinking, right?
14:59 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. It's launching, it's getting the first customer, it's selling, it's like, it's doing these things yourself. And that's counterintuitive because I think that founders understand that startups are really hard. So they assume you need complex strategies to succeed. And it's like, ah, that's a hard thing. It it it makes sense when I say it, right? This is hard. We would need a complex strategy, right? How do you respond to that? It's like, what actual kind of strategy do you need?
15:28 Speaker 00 I think if you haven't seen really successful startup companies, either personally, like where you were the founder of one, or you know people and you saw them go through it.
15:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:40 Speaker 00 It's hard to believe how silly these things are when they start. Like, I think unless you've literally witnessed it personally and you've seen the silly shit that goes on and like how, what it really takes to get big, your brain rejects the idea
15:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:58 Speaker 00 that that's actually how these companies got built. You're like, no, not true. It had to be like lots of strategy meetings and whiteboarding, you know, flow charts and, you know, um, Gartner, magic quadrants of like, like, like, I think you really, your brain won't allow you to see that, actually, here's a nice way to say it, is you know the term beginner's mind? You wanna have a beginner's mind.
16:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
16:25 Speaker 00 That's what the Midwit meme is. And a beginner's mind is like, I guess I'm gonna build a product and I'm gonna give it to people. I guess I'm gonna deliver burritos. You know, that's that's a beginner's mind approach.
16:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's the game. And so you might find yourself after watching this video asking yourself, what do I need to unlearn?
16:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, how can I have a beginner's mind? Because again, this is this is the the beauty of the midwit meme is the the genius and the idiot come to the same conclusion. So what is the idiot approach?
16:59 Speaker 00 Like, that's actually how you can divine the genius approach is you're like, what would an idiot do?
17:05 Speaker 01 Everyone can reach for the idiot approach. Everyone has the intellectual capacity to reach for the idiot approach.
17:10 Speaker 00 If I didn't know anything.
17:13 Speaker 01 So with all that being said, um, have fun and don't overthink it too much. Don't overthink it too much and make sure that you have a little bit of something in your head that's asking yourself, is this the thing that's really important? If not, I can move on. If not, I can move on. All right. Thanks a lot, Charlton.
17:34 Speaker 00 Thanks.
Previous Things That Don't Scale, The Software Edition Next Most Important Lifestyle Habits Of Successful Founders Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated