Pod Insights Y Combinator Podcast #35 - The Technical Challenges of Measuring Gravitational Waves - Rana Adhikari of LIGO About this episode Rana Adhikari https://twitter.com/RanaXAdhikari is a Professor of Physics at Caltech and a member of the LIGO team, who were the first to measure gravitational waves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_observation_of_gravitational_waves.
Their detection papers are available here https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/page/detection-companion-papers.
Transcript 13,569 words · 2 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hey, this is Craig Cannon and you're listening to Y Combinator's podcast. Today's episode is with Rana Adhikari. He is a professor of physics at Caltech and one of the members of the LIGO team, who are the first to measure gravitational waves. So, Rana and I met at the YC Research Conference. Shout out to Michael Nielsen, thanks for the intro. And while there, Rana gave a talk about LIGO and their effort to parse all the data they're collecting. And he was actually looking for help, and they still are looking for help. So if you're interested, you can reach out to Rana on Twitter, at Rana X Adhikari. I'll link that up in the show notes. And just two quick announcements before we get going. The first is that YC is going on a fall tour, where we're going to be doing a bunch of office hours and Q&A sessions all over the world.
0:44 Speaker 00 And that's at blog.ycombinator.com. And the second is that YC applications are open for the winter 2018 batch. So that link is ycombinator.com/apply. Alright, here we go. What is LIGO?
1:00 Speaker 01 LIGO is a huge project aimed at being able to take the bending of space that we think is happening all the time, and turn it into some kind of signal that we can use and measure. Yeah, it's a transducer. It's like having a voltage meter or a microphone, but it's like a microphone for space.
1:22 Speaker 00 Can you do the beginner's explanation of what it actually is? What the device actually is?
1:27 Speaker 01 Yeah. So we think, or we now know, based upon Einstein's relativity theory from 100 years ago, that there isn't a real force of gravity, like there is a force between magnets or between charges or things like that. But instead, the way that gravity works is that it curves space. And so it's a lot like imagining what happens when you're jumping up and down on your bed and somebody else is jumping on their bed. I guess, because if this happens to you all the time, then this is something you're familiar with. But whoever's heaviest makes a big impression in the bed, and then whoever is littler has to account... What kind of analogy is this?
2:12 Speaker 01 Whoever's littler has to account for the depression in the middle of the bed, and just they're jumping accordingly. And you tend to slide into the biggest dimple in the bed. So those who do trampolines or jumping up and down on their bed, understand how, yeah, well-trained and understand how gravity works. So to detect this on the earth is incredibly hard. And people have long ago measured the curvature of a space due to the earth and due to the moon and other planets and that sort of thing. And so we well understood that in fact, space is curved. But we had no evidence to support the idea that the curvature of space could travel through space as waves.
2:55 Speaker 01 The detection of gravitational waves, for you know, for decades had been debated in the scientific community. People thought it was just imaginary, that it was waves of thought, people called it, because they thought it was just, you know, waves of mathematics. It was just some equation you wrote down, but it didn't make any sense. It was just kind of a nonsense thing. And some decades ago, people realized it was real. And then some crazy people said, hey, let's try to measure this, even though it was millions of times not, I mean, like, factors of millions not possible.
3:36 Speaker 01 But luckily, through a, this is just something I'm not capable of, but through a combination of optimism and courage and not knowing the right answers to several equations, they were able to start up the field and start to look for these things. If, I think if they had known how tough it would be, or that it was going to take 55 years to have success, probably no one would have started. And so now, here in the modern times, the way we do it is we use the tool of laser interferometry, which is, for those of you who are interferometer aficionados,
4:19 Speaker 01 it is a Michelson-type interferometer with a lot of extra stuff added onto it. For those who are not, the concept is simple. It just has to do with interference. So you take a laser, like a laser pointer, but much more expensive and therefore much more stable.
4:36 Speaker 00 Is it a billion dollars now into the project?
4:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:40 Speaker 00 Roughly.
4:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, the laser itself is cheaper. Um, you can do, probably you could do the whole thing with a hundred thousand dollar laser.
4:48 Speaker 00 Okay.
4:48 Speaker 01 That's about the laser cost. Uh, you split it in two and you send it in two separate directions. And then when the waves come back, they interfere with each other. And you look at differences in that interference to tell you, um, the difference in, um, how long it took for one beam to go one way and the other beam to go the other way.
5:09 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
5:10 Speaker 01 And so this, uh, the, the way I said it was really careful there because, um, there's a lot of confusion about the idea of there, these are waves and space is bending and everything's shrinking and how come the light's not shrinking and so on. We don't really know, there's, there's no real difference, uh, between the ideas of space and time warping. It could be space warping or time warping, but the only thing that we really know is what we measure. And that's the mantra over the, of the true empirical person, I guess. We send out the light and the light comes back and interferes. And the pattern changes and that tells us something about effectively the delay that the light saw.
5:53 Speaker 01 And it could be that the spacetime curved so that the light took longer to get there. But you could also imagine that there was a change in the, in the time in one path as opposed to the other instead of the space. But it's a mixture of space and time, so it sort of depends on your, your viewpoint.
6:12 Speaker 01 Um, but this warping of spacetime is what's measured and we turn it into a real signal by putting the interference of the, of the two beams onto a usual photo detector. That's like, um, like a solar cell that you would use. And so it turns light into electricity and that's the whole thing.
6:32 Speaker 00 And then you measure it in by looking at waves.
6:36 Speaker 01 Uh, well, that the whole measurement is right there in the electrical signal out of the photocell.
6:41 Speaker 00 Okay. And so then, how how do you go about converting it to, I mean, I've seen a bunch of these like, sound, um, sounds of things you've measured. How do you go about that process?
6:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's the same as, um, like an electrical instrument. If you have an electric guitar, uh, when you play whatever you're playing on there, um, it generates an electrical current in the pickup coils of the guitar. And that signal comes out through a little cable and goes into an amplifier.
7:09 Speaker 00 Hmm.
7:10 Speaker 01 And then that's directly makes sound. And the same for us.
7:13 Speaker 00 Okay.
7:14 Speaker 01 So the photo detector detects a signal which turns into electricity. And then we take that electricity and we drive a speaker and then it makes sound.
7:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
7:24 Speaker 01 So there's no, uh, I I can understand what you're asking. That that seems like a little weird. How is it that the wave from outer space can directly get turned into a a signal in a speaker? It happens to be, and then I think this is a whole another topic to discuss. It happens to be that the waves that we're detecting and the waves which are easiest to detect are exactly in the human audio band.
7:52 Speaker 00 Hmm.
7:53 Speaker 01 So the waves that you and I can hear with our ears, that's the that's the whole frequency range for gravitational waves that we can detect. Um, they gravitational waves happen at all frequencies, but they're really loud right in this band.
8:10 Speaker 01 And so our detectors are aimed for this band because we expected the audio band would be a good place. But our technology also happens to be, um, only capable of detecting things in this band. For a lot of technical reasons, which I can, I can tell you about, um, that happens to be the case. And so it is, it is a little weird, but the signals directly make sound.
8:32 Speaker 00 Hmm. So what I wanted to to talk about then, I I saw in one of your talks, I guess it was from last year, you're talking about creating new kinds of mirrors to focus rather, the mirrors that you had created focused the like the vibrations to certain parts of mirrors, but you're working on creating new mirrors to detect other things.
8:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, exactly.
8:54 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:55 Speaker 01 The
8:58 Speaker 01 When I first heard about it, it was...
9:04 Speaker 01 I was gonna say, when I first heard about it, I thought maybe it was unbelievable, but I have to say, I don't think ever, when I first heard about this project, I don't think I understood enough to even understand that it was impossible. So I never went through this disbelief-belief period. I just kinda slowly merged into it. But a lot of people with good reasons say it's impossible to make these measurements. And the reason is, if you imagine zooming into where the black holes are in outer space, they're like a billion light years ago, a few billion light years ago. And the universe is only 13 billion light years, 13 billion years old. So it's a good fraction of the size of the known universe away.
9:50 Speaker 01 And if you get close to these black holes, the amount, as they're merging and eating each other, the amount that the space is warping is enough so that, like this water glass, it would be shattered, but it would be stretched, if it was stretchable, to, you know, like this. It would be a huge stretching. But the wave, as it propagates to us, like waves do, they get attenuated. So imagine the stretching has a lot of energy in it, but as it spreads out, the amount of energy has to be conserved as it propagates. And so the amplitude of the wave, as it comes to us, gets reduced like 1 divided by the distance.
10:32 Speaker 01 And so the energy, or the energy in the wave goes like 1 divided by the distance squared, like any other kind of radiation. We measure the amplitude instead of the power. We measure directly the stretch rather than the heat or something like that. So we're able to look a lot deeper into the universe than you would naively expect. Because our signal only decays like 1 over the distance instead of the distance squared.
11:01 Speaker 00 Okay.
11:02 Speaker 01 So the wave comes to us and by the time it gets to us, because it's billions of light years, the squeezing and stretching is much less than 500%. It's more like a part in 10 to the 21 or 22. So that means if you have, the whole Earth, for example, is about
11:27 Speaker 01 10,000 kilometers in size. And so that the whole Earth will be only stretching by about 1/100 of a micron. I don't even know how to imagine that. What's a micron? A micron is like the wavelength of light. Or my hair is, the diameter of my little hair I have here is about 100 microns. So it's 10,000 times smaller than the width of this hair.
11:56 Speaker 00 It's how much the entire Earth would stretch.
11:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:59 Speaker 00 When it was hit with a gravitational wave that you initially measured.
12:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:04 Speaker 00 Okay, which was a large one.
12:05 Speaker 01 Which is a very large one. We've not seen anything of that size since then, since that first one. And so that's such a tiny distance. Our detectors are big, they're four kilometers, so they're not 10,000, unfortunately. If I was in charge, I would drill through the center of the Earth and there would be mirrors. I would have put a big L in the center of the Earth and then there would be mirrors on both ends.
12:31 Speaker 00 And be ideal.
12:32 Speaker 01 We would, that would be ideal and that's what we would use, but I'm not yet in charge of everything.
12:37 Speaker 00 But then, okay, so to divert a little bit. Can you explain how the Fabry Pro interferometer works? Like, because it's not, it's four kilometers, but it's also kind of like bounce back and forth at the same time, right?
12:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:50 Speaker 00 So effectively, it's actually longer? The laser travels a longer distance?
12:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's right. So the... What's it like? It's the Fabry Pro cavity means rather than just send the laser beam down, we send it into a thing which has two mirrors into it. And just like, I don't know if everybody does this, but when I was a kid, I wondered, here's his bathroom mirror and what if, you know, I can see my reflection? And then if I go into the fun house, like during Halloween, I can see multiple reflections and what if you put two mirrors together? And you set a flashlight and then you took it out? Would it bounce around infinity times and explode the mirrors? And, you know, I've always tried, you know, I wondered about it and it turns out, no, sadly.
13:39 Speaker 01 You cannot destroy the universe by facing two mirrors together.
13:43 Speaker 00 One kid didn't figure it out.
13:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. And it, and the reason is because the, at each mirror surface, a little less than a hundred percent of the light gets reflected back. Some of it gets turned into heat or things like that. And so the Fabry Pro optical resonator is just two mirrors facing each other. And one of them
14:05 Speaker 01 has a finite transmission. So it's set up so that, let's say, one percent of the light comes out and 99% goes in. Or no, 99% gets reflected and 1% goes through. That's the hundred percent. And so when you set it up at first, you have these two mirrors and you put in a beam from this side, let's say. And only a little bit gets in. And so that little bit gets in and starts bouncing around. But by the time it comes back, you're already putting in more laser light. You're constantly putting in more laser light. And that builds up constructively with the waves, electromagnetic waves you're sending in. And slowly the power builds up in the system just through this little leakage. And it builds up until the point where the amount coming out is about the same as the amount going in.
14:51 Speaker 01 And at that point, you have like, let's say a few hundred times more laser power in this system than if you had just sent in a single beam. And that's, that's not so challenging. It's easily doable and it gives you basically a factor of 200 extra sensitivity than you would get.
15:10 Speaker 00 So the extra power of the laser generates more sensitivity?
15:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's just, just like you said it, though, it's, it's effectively like the laser bounces a bunch of time.
15:19 Speaker 00 Okay.
15:20 Speaker 01 And so, um, you can imagine, um, here's this spacetime which is curved. So now the laser has to travel through this curved path. And so it's a little bit longer of a distance. And when it goes down and comes back, it picks up a little bit of extra phase shift. It's just a delay. And now that's through one round trip. And if you do 200 round trips, you get 200 times the phase shift. And so that's what we do.
15:46 Speaker 00 But does that net out 200 times the noise as well?
15:49 Speaker 01 Um, yeah.
15:52 Speaker 00 It does.
15:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. So, uh, the more, the more times you go around and, uh, the more you, you pick up the signal from the mirror motion.
16:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:02 Speaker 01 And so the signals noise, you know, trying to get below the fluctuations of the mirror, don't actually get better by building up more power in the system. And in fact, if, um, it can even go the wrong way. At some level, at some point, the quantum mechanical fluctuations in the, the number of photons that are in your system, um, becomes so large that the mirrors are shaking. And so the more power you have, it just gets worse. And so there's a limit to how, how much power you want to put in there before you get into trouble.
16:35 Speaker 00 Okay.
16:36 Speaker 01 But so, so, so you might reasonably ask, why do you do it then if it doesn't help? It, it helps, um, it helps just in building up the signal. And if you're limited by the, uh, fluctuations of the mirror motion due to the environment or something like that, then more power is not any good. But most of the time, in most cases, when people are doing, uh, precise measurements with lasers, they're limited not by the mirror motion by, but by the noise due to the fact that the, uh,
17:10 Speaker 01 They have a finite number of laser photons. So if you just take a laser and put it on to a photo cell and you listen to it with your speakers, which you can do, it sounds kind of like a hiss. And that hiss is because quantum mechanically, the energy of the light is sort of is in the discrete packets, which we call photons. And so if you have a one watt laser or something like that, you have some many billions and billions of photons. But you you end up with a hiss level of noise due to the basically the quantum nature of the light that you can't get beyond. And increasing laser power builds up your signal.
17:53 Speaker 01 So if you double the laser power, you double your signal. But your noise due to these random photon fluctuations only goes up like the square root of that power.
18:04 Speaker 00 Okay.
18:04 Speaker 01 So you win a little bit for that particular noise.
18:08 Speaker 00 And why not just have a super powerful laser?
18:12 Speaker 01 We do. We do have super powerful lasers.
18:14 Speaker 00 Okay, but you need it to be even stronger.
18:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. It is tough to build a super powerful laser.
18:25 Speaker 01 Trying to think of how to put this in context. So the people who have worked with these lasers will understand why we do it this way. If you have, these days, like if you have fifty thousand dollars in your pocket, you can go on to the internet and buy yourself a scientific research grade laser that's a couple of watts and will work fine for you. And we end up with a 200 watt laser. And there's no such, you can't buy anything like that these days. You can buy lasers that have that much power, but their frequency is not very stable. And our laser is used as the meter stick for doing the the measurement. It's like each wave of the laser is one tick on a meter stick.
19:10 Speaker 01 And if you have an unstable laser, that means these little waves, instead of being very precise, are jiggling all over the place. And so your meter stick, it would be like having a meter stick where the the tick marks are kind of dancing around. You can't use it to measure anything.
19:25 Speaker 00 Right. And it's so precise because like, just so I don't mistake it, the the first, the two black hole measurement, how much did it move?
19:36 Speaker 01 About uh ten to the minus eighteen meters, which means one billionth of a about the size of a atom. It's small.
19:46 Speaker 00 So yeah, you can't do that.
19:48 Speaker 01 You can't do that. So you have to, there's no laser in the world which is good enough to measure this. And so we take the best laser in the world that we can find and then we stabilize it and make it about uh ten million times more stable than what you can buy. And then it's, it's kind of just barely good enough. And we're gonna have to do better if we wanna do better.
20:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, so maybe that makes sense to like, what changed between LIGO and advanced LIGO? Was it a shift in, in the machining or what did you do?
20:18 Speaker 01 Uh, we got a bunch of new, younger people who are really smart. That is, that is by far the, the biggest effect.
20:30 Speaker 01 And, and because they were, uh, yeah, like miraculously, they showed up
20:37 Speaker 01 just at the right time, you know, in this, they, they showed up for graduate school in like twenty ten or twenty eleven, right when we happened to need them.
20:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
20:46 Speaker 01 You know, without, without knowing about the timing, they just showed up.
20:49 Speaker 00 Yeah.
20:49 Speaker 01 And they finished some classes and then they decided to ship out and live at these remote.
20:55 Speaker 00 Louisiana.
20:55 Speaker 01 Sites in Louisiana and Washington.
20:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
20:58 Speaker 01 And they, they just figured it all out. They just, day in and day out, they just figured out every problem and solved it.
21:03 Speaker 00 And so what, yeah, what like, what are some concrete examples?
21:07 Speaker 01 I mean, there were some engineering changes in going into this, this new detector, which was um ten times more powerful laser. And we isolated the mirrors a lot better from the environment and the mirrors are much higher quality. They're super beautiful and uh much heavier and really good. So there's a bunch of these technical things which were changed.
21:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:27 Speaker 01 But, and each one of them on their own worked really well because the engineers who were constructing them did a great job. The, the problem was when trying to put it all together and, you know, these things just never reveal themselves when you're sitting in a little room and designing your widget, but. You put it in a suitcase and carry it on the airplane and try to bolt it on to the four kilometer billion dollar machine. And then it's just like total disaster.
21:55 Speaker 00 Well, because when, yeah, when I first heard you talk, you were talking about, you know, like deer getting close to the, yeah, the tube and all these things. And how do you isolate?
22:04 Speaker 01 These things just don't matter at all here in our labs at Caltech. You've measured one thing or two things, but the, the full problem of putting it all together. And what's the problem? That only shows up when you have, you know, hundreds of kilowatts of laser power and giant mirrors. And it's all running together. For, for example, um, I would say, I mean, it's still one of the toughest problems that, and it's not completely solved. Is, uh, it has to do with the interaction between the laser beam and the mirrors. And normally, when you think about these things, you say, well, the laser beam goes out there and it bounces off that thing and it comes back. And that's all there is to it. And maybe the mirror is shaking around, so that's a problem.
22:47 Speaker 01 But in fact, there's so much laser power that when you, it's weird to think about, but there's so much laser power. When we hit the mirror, it moves the mirror. Yeah. And the mirror, if you, to imagine it is about this big.
23:04 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
23:04 Speaker 01 And it is 40 kilograms, which is, is that like a hundred pounds?
23:09 Speaker 00 Eighty something, but yeah.
23:10 Speaker 01 Anyway, some number of pounds. Who knows what pounds mean? It's 40 kilograms, which is heavy. It's like a little person. And, um, in the previous LIGO, 20 years ago, I would just pick up a mirror and you could carry it in and put it in. But there's no longer any of this like, yeah, I'll pick this thing up and carry it around.
23:30 Speaker 00 Bring it over in your truck.
23:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's way too expensive and way too heavy. But this super heavy thing, we're hang, hanging from handmade glass fibers, which are super thin. And it's sitting there and swaying around. And when the laser power hits it, it just moves. And even more annoyingly.
23:50 Speaker 01 When the mirror moves a little bit like this, the laser beam at the other end, four kilometers away, it moves. And so then that mirror twists a little bit like this. And now the reflected beam moves a little bit. And these two things are talking to each other through this, the pressure from the radiation, the laser light.
24:09 Speaker 00 Right.
24:10 Speaker 01 And that's super annoying and it doesn't, it's not a thing that you can test if you're in a tabletop. You have to put the whole thing together. You can simulate it and calculate it as we did.
24:21 Speaker 00 Right.
24:21 Speaker 01 But when you put it together, it's a lot more trouble than expected. And that took a long time to solve.
24:28 Speaker 01 Uh, it's still not solved.
24:29 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:30 Speaker 01 It kind of works, but um, when we start increasing the laser power, a lot of these interactions happen, which are really troublesome. And luckily we have a fresh stream of new people coming into grad school.
24:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:45 Speaker 01 And if they, uh, we, we, we hope they, they, they remain as, as good as the people we've had so far. If that doesn't work out, we're in trouble.
24:56 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, so what do you suspect will be the changes that, that suspend the mirrors in a way that the laser doesn't move them?
25:04 Speaker 01 Oh, they're just going to. I don't think we have any way of doing it. What we're doing right now, uh, we have a, just a sophisticated feedback control system that we measure the light beams which leak out of the system at a bunch of places. We detect it and then we, we have a, a system of, uh, something like 20 feedback loops which, uh, push, puts forces on the mirrors to try to keep it aligned and keep this from being such a problem.
25:31 Speaker 00 Hmm.
25:32 Speaker 01 The trouble is, um,
25:35 Speaker 01 well, you know, we're trying to detect gravitational waves which are tiny. And so when you do some, you imagine like this, let's imagine like this is the, the mirror and this little.
25:49 Speaker 01 There's this little ting, which is about how long the gravitation wave lasts like this. And now, now we're trying to control the pointing of this thing because it's getting steer on by the beam. And so I have my feedback control like this, trying to hold it on. But you can't do this if you're just.
26:09 Speaker 00 It screws the whole thing.
26:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, it just screws up the whole thing if you're applying too much feedback because you mask the signal that you're trying to detect.
26:15 Speaker 00 Right.
26:16 Speaker 01 And so we're in, we're in a place where we would like to figure out how to better optimize our feedback controls. So that they don't mask the gravitation wave signal so much. And luckily, there is a community which thinks about how to optimize control systems. And they've been a great help to us, but we're now at the limit. I don't know, we're at the limit of what I understand. And so I'm looking for someone who knows more than me to help us improve this situation better. And I hope some of our modern learning techniques and signal processing techniques can be used for this.
27:01 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, I mean, I want to talk to you about that as well. Like, how are you, what techniques are you applying right now to the data and what do you hope to apply in the future?
27:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's a, there's a whole menu of things. We basically, everything that we can find, we just read a lot of things on the internet. And everything that sounds clever, we want to use it. So since 10 years ago or more, we have been trying every single kind of linear subtraction. So we have, I don't know, let's say tens of thousands of sensors which are measuring the environment and the move and the motion and these feedback controls and all kinds of things like this. And we take each one of those and we compute the optimal Wiener filter, which is the, yeah, it's the optimal filter that you can apply to the sensor signal and subtract it from the data.
27:54 Speaker 01 And so we use it, in some cases, we calculate the filter and then directly drive the mirrors. So that in hardware, we remove the noise before it's actually made. So we do that with a lot of things. And so we remove, you know, so.
28:13 Speaker 01 By about a factor of a hundred, um, some large noise sources that way in the, in the hardware. And we do it in the hardware because um, they would, they would mix in some sort of nonlinear way back into the data. So it's better to clean up the data in the hardware in the analog because there's sort of no, there's no dynamic range limit in analog. There's no number of bits, more or less, it's atoms. So there's a lot of bits.
28:40 Speaker 01 Once we get into the data, um, there's still more we can do. So we do some more linear subtraction of noise. And we're able to improve the data a little bit by factors of a few. Okay. Um, but now we've reached the limit of what you can do with linear noise subtraction. And we need some um, better ideas on how to do the next thing. And the next thing involves um, nonlinear regression. So one of the uh, things I'm working on right now is how to take basically uh, a huge data.
29:21 Speaker 01 Depends who you're talking to. When you say huge data set, it doesn't really, huge data set for me, but not huge data set for a lot of other people, I guess. Um, we have thousands of signals which are recorded at, which are 16 bit and recorded at 16 kilohertz. And we, some of these signals, not all of them, will combine in some sort of, via some sort of nonlinear function. And show up in our main data stream where we look, like to look for the gravitation waves. So for example, it might be like um, the cosine of one signal times another signal plus another signal. And then that whole thing squared or cubed or something like that. So it's not super strange. So it's, it's the kind of thing you can imagine doing on a laptop. Hmm.
30:05 Speaker 01 But it's a little tough to search through the full space of sensors. And so we haven't, we just haven't done it yet. Hmm. But I think a lot of the, the uh, things that are masking the lowest frequency gravitation waves, which come from the biggest black holes. That data can be cleaned up quite a lot if we were to come up with better techniques for doing it. And I, and I think it's all doable.
30:33 Speaker 00 Hmm.
30:34 Speaker 01 It just, I personally haven't found the algorithm to do it. Um, but we're working on it.
30:41 Speaker 00 Because there have been three now in the past handful of years, right?
30:46 Speaker 01 Right. There was one in September fifteenth of twenty fifteen. And then there was one, um, on Christmas Day of that year in the evening around nine o'clock. And, um, then for almost a year, we shut down to improve a lot of things in our detector.
31:05 Speaker 00 Wow.
31:05 Speaker 01 From
31:07 Speaker 01 Feb- most of twenty sixteen, basically.
31:09 Speaker 00 Okay.
31:10 Speaker 01 Uh, and then we turned back on November, December of last year.
31:14 Speaker 00 Hmm.
31:14 Speaker 01 And then we had another detection in January.
31:17 Speaker 00 But do you suspect there have been many more that you just can't parse?
31:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I think in our data, there must be. Probably we could double the number of signals we have right now if we were to. And that's my, that's my guess. It could be much more.
31:34 Speaker 00 Okay.
31:35 Speaker 01 And, and the reason is, um, you know, this, imagine, if you imagine, this is my only prop. So I'm going to use, this, this works for everything. So if you imagine this is, this lip is a black hole here. When I do this, if I can hold it right. Yeah, let me hold this part.
31:56 Speaker 01 All right. This is not cooperating.
31:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, there you go. It rings a little bit. And that, that ringing frequency has to do with something complicated about the vibrations of this thing in the water that's in it. The black hole, however, is a really, really simple animal. The mathematics are really complicated.
32:14 Speaker 00 Hmm.
32:15 Speaker 01 Or depends who you ask.
32:17 Speaker 00 It's pretty complicated.
32:18 Speaker 01 Yeah. It's, yeah, I would say it's really simple. It's more challenging. This is, this is about as challenging as the mathematics for the black hole. The, the physics are stranger, but, um, complicated things are complicated. Anyway, the black hole that's just sitting there not spinning. You can easily compute the frequency at which it rings.
32:40 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
32:41 Speaker 01 And it has to do with the amount of time it takes light to travel around the border. So, once you know the size of the black hole, if you're looking at it, or if you know its mass, you can compute the frequency at which it's going to ring. So it's sitting here, and let's imagine I throw like this glass into the black hole. As this glass gets really close to it, the black hole horizon will be perturbed a little bit like this.
33:04 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
33:04 Speaker 01 As it swallows this new piece of mass, and then that perturbation immediately settles down and there's a little wave that travels around the edge of the black hole. And then that gets radiated out. And that radiation is what we detect.
33:17 Speaker 00 Hmm.
33:17 Speaker 01 So when the two big black holes merge together, the same thing happens. They form a bigger black hole. But now, since the thing's bigger, the frequency of the ringing will be bigger. Just like if I made this cup two times bigger, this frequency would be two times lower. So the bigger something is, the resonant frequency is lower.
33:35 Speaker 00 Okay.
33:37 Speaker 01 So the biggest black holes, we can't find right now because this kind of technical noise, feedback and the vibrations from the environment are bigger than the fundamental quantum physics limits of measurement. And that, all of that data is being measured by other sensors, microphones and things like that. So it's a data, it's a data science job right now to figure out how to take thousands of standard sensors that you can buy off the shelf.
34:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
34:08 Speaker 01 And mix that data somehow with the gravitational wave data stream in a smart way that removes this kind of foreground noise and allows you to find the deeper signals.
34:20 Speaker 00 But it's all modeled, because that's what I was wondering.
34:23 Speaker 01 It's unmodeled.
34:24 Speaker 00 Yeah. Because when I saw the first announcement of the two black holes, I was wondering like, oh, did they just, have they just been looking for this pattern of waves? Or what of this pattern the whole time? And so that you kind of have like a guidebook like, okay, if we see this, it means that.
34:40 Speaker 01 There's a bunch of different variables which characterize the black holes.
34:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
34:44 Speaker 01 I made it sound simple, but they can be spinning and depending on their orbits and that sort of thing. There's a lot of parameters, like maybe several parameters that go into it.
34:53 Speaker 00 Okay.
34:54 Speaker 01 But in the end, it's just some parameters. So we might have a five or 10 dimensional waveform space that we search through. But it is just a big catalog of waveforms, little, little wavelet looking things. And so for all the signals that can possibly come from black holes.
35:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
35:10 Speaker 01 We think we can, we can search for them just by compares, comparing with a known template.
35:16 Speaker 00 Really? And so that's just the, the wavelength and the amplitude?
35:22 Speaker 01 Uh, well, the frequency evolves as the signal comes in. So when they're far away, you know, when they're first born, maybe they're a million years before merging. And so they're far apart and they just spin together like this. And as they get closer, eventually there's a little whoop and then they pop together.
35:41 Speaker 01 So we, but we know what that frequency evolution is based on their masses and how they start.
35:46 Speaker 00 And so then do you think in addition to, you know, paying more attention to all the other measurements that you're doing, there's going to be a hardware innovation? Like what, what happens next?
35:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think,
36:01 Speaker 01 you know, hopefully someone will watch this podcast and then say, have I got the solution for you? And I'll just get a, a piece of, someone will send me a link to their GitHub and then that will have the whole answer.
36:14 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:14 Speaker 01 And then we'll, we'll break this thing wide open this year or next year.
36:19 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:20 Speaker 01 And then, and then we'll be back more at the fundamental limits. So you asked before about this mirror, new mirrors.
36:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:27 Speaker 01 Sort of thing. And again, using the universal prop here. So with this, if I do it, so that rings for about a second. And that has a frequency of 500 hertz. And so that means the, the energy stays pretty well localized in the vibration of the glass and doesn't go someplace else. Um, and this is, I don't even think mine, this is something I found in this hallway.
36:59 Speaker 00 Right.
37:00 Speaker 01 But it's an okay piece of glass, but it's not meant for.
37:05 Speaker 01 I don't know, it's not meant for scientific purposes. And the mirrors we have are more like,
37:14 Speaker 01 they store the energy better, something like
37:20 Speaker 01 about 10,000 times longer. So if I were to ping one of those, those would last for, you know, hours. They would just keep ringing and ringing. And that has to do with the, that tells you a little bit about how well you can measure the motion of that mirror using lasers. And the reason for it is because of the, the motion of the atoms and the thermal energy in the system. So when you come down to it, if you've removed every other noise from the outside world, and you just have a thing sitting there. Because it's sitting at a finite temperature, its molecules are bouncing around like this and it's shaking. And that, there's, that's just sort of a thermodynamic limit that you can't get past.
38:02 Speaker 01 But the question is, is there a pattern to the way that they're moving or are they just moving randomly? And if you have something like this, dumpy old glass, it's pretty much moving randomly, except for there will be a lot of energy in the different harmonics and tones that you can make. So if you measured this thing, you would notice that there would be a lot of oscillations that have a certain frequency.
38:23 Speaker 00 So is that how you can, you can measure something, actually rather, the laser is also affected by the gravitational wave?
38:33 Speaker 01 It is, yeah.
38:33 Speaker 00 Right. So is the, the resonance of the mirror, that's the reason why you can measure it? Because you can shoot it after and it's still resonating? And you pick it up?
38:44 Speaker 01 No, no, it's, it's just that we just look, we just ignore the frequencies at which the mirror resonates. So the mirror resonates at a few specific tones like,
38:59 Speaker 01 You can think about it like waves on a string. If you have a guitar or violin, depending upon how you fret it. I don't understand violin. Anyway, instruments with frets, I understand. So depending on where you fret a guitar string, it plays a different tone. And it just has to do with the length of the wire and the tension.
39:16 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
39:16 Speaker 01 And the same for the mirror. The mirror depends on something like how heavy it is and how how fast sound travels from the mirror. And so if you have a mirror that's really, really pure, then all of that thermodynamic energy is focused in just a few frequencies. And so it's just sitting there. And if you and if you shoot it with a laser or with a very expensive system, you can hear the thermodynamic vibrations of the molecules in the mirror. And in fact, that's what we hear most of the time.
39:48 Speaker 00 Hmm.
39:49 Speaker 01 And so if you listen to the LIGO data stream, there are these high frequency ringing going on all the time. And it's all the mirrors just constantly vibrating thermally.
39:59 Speaker 00 And so, okay.
40:01 Speaker 01 So we just don't, we just don't look for gravitational waves at those very specific frequencies, but they're very narrow. So it's just like doing the removal of like the power line harmonics.
40:13 Speaker 00 Yep.
40:13 Speaker 01 We have all of that, so we have to remove it. So if you have a hum filter, as you do when you record music, for example, you do the same thing. So we have hum filters that remove
40:23 Speaker 00 Right.
40:24 Speaker 01 all the lines that are happening.
40:26 Speaker 00 That's kind of like why you're measuring everything, right? Because it's like, if you can detect it, then you take it out. That's therefore not a gravitational wave.
40:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:35 Speaker 00 And so do you suspect that you're picking up, picking up anything that you you can't even define right now? Or like, are you lumping things in as gravitational waves that might not even be?
40:46 Speaker 01 I don't think that's
40:46 Speaker 00 That's unlikely.
40:47 Speaker 01 That's unlikely. That's, I mean, it's always a worry.
40:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:50 Speaker 01 We're really Paranoid about that kind of thing because you you just hate to be like the boy who cried wolf. Say I have a have gravitational wave and then you find out six months later that it's ah it's just a misbehaving refrigerator that was located. We bought the same fridge in Louisiana and Washington. I'm sure we did. I'm sure there's something going on like that. And so those problems we've been finding for for decades, things like we bought the same electronics board from the same manufacturer and it has a crystal that happens to
41:26 Speaker 01 radiate at a certain frequency and those two things are kind of synchronous at two different places. And once in a while, um, you'll get like three crystals beating with each other, which will produce Oh my. Something in the audio band. And there's, there's thousands of stories like that, which we all forget because you do it, you find it, and then you take the thing out and you smash it with a hammer. Yeah. You have a party because you found some terrible thing. Do you have like a wiki of known bugs? Yeah. Chronicling all this stuff? Uh, no.
41:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think it's just, um, stories. Okay. It's mostly stories. Because that's like most of the job, it sounds like. It is, it is. You're just like, find anything, get rid of it. All the time, all the time. That is all. And it and it's just, it's gotten to the point where we all feel like we're
42:17 Speaker 01 telling UFO stories because we've already found all the easy things years ago. And now the things that are limiting us are the weirdest mechanisms. And you come back, you spend a day, you know, like working late, it's like 2am. And then everybody kind of comes back together and they're like, what, what happened? What'd you find? And then you start telling this crazy story and you say, it seems like if I stand in this part of the room and then she stands over there, uh, and then we turn the mirror like this, this kind of hooting, screeching noise happens. And everyone's like, you're crazy. That is, there's no science in that. It sounds like a superstition. Yeah. I don't know what to tell you. It's 2am. We've been working on this all day, but this is what happens. And then you say, all right, let's, let's go get some sleep and think, think about this.
43:01 Speaker 01 And all the problems are of that sort now. Okay. Um, but luckily we have people who are obsessed about these kinds of Yeah. Problems and they're going at it and finding them and solving them. And this summer, um, or our last summer, we found, um,
43:22 Speaker 01 Another one of these problems that is like.
43:28 Speaker 01 It reminds me of some kind of sci fi horror movie.
43:33 Speaker 01 Trying to think of what it is, it's like. There's this really bad movies from the eighties called They Live.
43:39 Speaker 00 I haven't seen it.
43:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, they have two professional wrestlers, I think are the actors in it. Anyway, that it's terribly bad, but at one point.
43:53 Speaker 01 One of the guys says like, you need to put on these glasses because if you put on these glasses, you can see. Who the aliens are, they mostly look like people and you put them on.
44:01 Speaker 00 Okay.
44:01 Speaker 01 And so the guy puts it on and then he starts looking around, it's like. All of his friends and everybody he knows, just like he doesn't want to know, it's too much. And. We found a problem like that last year, which is that.
44:17 Speaker 01 The light which which bounces off of our mirrors. Mostly keeps going back and forth in these optical resonators that we have. But something like a few parts per million of the light shoots off in some other direction. And then it shoots off, hits some unknown thing. And then some few parts per million comes back and then interferes with the main system. And so then.
44:43 Speaker 01 It's something like, there's basically an infinity.
44:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's like a disco ball. You can imagine like a disco ball is lit and then the light beams go everywhere. That's an extreme case, but at the part per million level, our mirrors, as wonderful as they are, acting like disco balls. And so little bits of light are heading off in all directions. And when the light comes back from those places, it has picked up a little of the vibration from whatever thing it hit. And so finally, at some level. A bit we're measuring the acoustical vibrations of the entire. Eight kilometers of metal tubing of our system. Because there's a little bit of light hitting those things and coming back and then, you know.
45:28 Speaker 00 Right. Yeah, I mean, that's kind of like the rub of you create these like perfect sealed systems. But now it's sealed.
45:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:35 Speaker 00 And so you just throw marble around and just going.
45:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, it just keeps going.
45:39 Speaker 00 And so, yeah.
45:41 Speaker 01 We've got to take care of it. So we've been here at Caltech and also at MIT, we've been thinking about what to do about this. And so we've come up with
45:53 Speaker 01 some designs on what to do. And basically, we've taken some of these substances, which are the, you know, like the blackest, darkest things you've ever seen. And we're going to put them in our system.
46:05 Speaker 01 To block these places where the light beam goes.
46:07 Speaker 00 How do you put it? Yeah.
46:08 Speaker 01 We're going to open up the vacuum system and walk inside. We're going to put on full clean room suits and then walk inside and put these things in.
46:16 Speaker 00 Where?
46:17 Speaker 01 All over, every place that we can find. I never want to see this again.
46:23 Speaker 00 What kind of substance is it? I don't, I don't fully understand.
46:27 Speaker 01 Well, like my shirt before washing was very black.
46:31 Speaker 00 Yeah.
46:32 Speaker 01 Now it's kind of gray.
46:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
46:33 Speaker 01 But what you mean, are you asking why are things black?
46:37 Speaker 00 No, I'm not.
46:38 Speaker 01 That's a good question.
46:38 Speaker 00 You can, you can answer that though.
46:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
46:40 Speaker 00 No, it's like Spinal Tap.
46:43 Speaker 01 No, it's, it's a real, it's a real, it's an honest scientific question.
46:46 Speaker 00 No, is it like a paint that you're putting on stuff? That's what I'm asking.
46:50 Speaker 01 It's all, yeah, it's a bunch of different, so each
46:55 Speaker 01 these are the kinds of trivia questions that I know. And then I wonder why, you know, what have I done with my life that I know the answer to these things? In the, in the array of different blackening things, there are the things that you think are black, which are black sort of to your eye. But then you shoot a huge laser at it and you use a really sensitive detector to sense it. And then you find out it's not so black. It's really gray. And so there's a bunch of garbage you can buy online, which says that it's the best, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Most of it's junk.
47:28 Speaker 01 So we have a couple of engineers in a building over here who have been exhaustively and carefully looking at every single thing that that is promised to be black on the internet. And then, you know, it's like a Mythbusters episode over there.
47:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
47:42 Speaker 01 And they're, and then finally have come down to a few different solutions. And so some of them are. I don't think I could accurately describe all of them, but some of them are black like uh. It's basically glass like this, but um like colored glass like uh.
48:02 Speaker 01 Missing the word for it. They have it in churches. What do you call it?
48:05 Speaker 00 Oh stained glass.
48:05 Speaker 01 Stained glass.
48:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:07 Speaker 01 So you have glass and then when you're making the glass, you put some other stuff in it. And it comes out a different color, right? And so you can make, you can, I don't know what I'm doing. I'm sure they don't do this. But I, I don't know, make glass. So I don't understand, but I, I imagine it's like this. You have this molten glass and then you.
48:23 Speaker 00 It's like food coloring.
48:24 Speaker 01 Magic pixie dust.
48:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:26 Speaker 01 And you put in some stuff and it's perfectly absorptive for the wavelength of the laser you're looking.
48:33 Speaker 00 Oh, okay.
48:33 Speaker 01 That you care about. So.
48:34 Speaker 00 Got you.
48:35 Speaker 01 Uh, red stained glass, for instance, lets through red light, but it absorbs green. So red stained glass is really good if you have a green laser.
48:41 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
48:42 Speaker 01 Uh, we have an infrared laser, which is, uh, if you imagine this is the whole rainbow from. Purple, violet, anyway, violet to red.
48:54 Speaker 01 Then our laser is sort of over here. So it's.
48:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, anyway, imagine the rainbow and there it is. It has a wavelength of one micron.
49:03 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
49:04 Speaker 01 And so for it, um.
49:07 Speaker 01 Some of the things that look black don't work, but if you have a special kind of welder's glass, it really works. Welder's glass is good as, good at absorbing. Pretty much everything with a longer wavelength than green.
49:19 Speaker 00 Hmm.
49:20 Speaker 01 So that's one of the best materials to use for blackening. And then you can also get these so-called nano tube things like. Vanta, Vanta Black. I don't remember all the various black names, but they're all trademarked.
49:32 Speaker 00 Okay.
49:32 Speaker 01 There's a bunch of stuff, which is essentially, uh, you know how you can get lost in a forest? It's like that for light beams also. So if you take a thing and you put a bunch of spaghetti looking nano tube things. Then the light goes in and bounces around like a hundred million times.
49:47 Speaker 00 And this is on your.
49:48 Speaker 01 Okay. And so it loses all of its energy.
49:50 Speaker 00 Got you. Okay. And so then do you, do you also expect that like you're going to build more, um. More interferometers that are longer?
50:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:01 Speaker 00 Um. To clean it up?
50:04 Speaker 01 Oh, to clean it up.
50:06 Speaker 00 Or in general, like, do you suspect that like? The, the next version is eight kilometers.
50:10 Speaker 01 I don't really know, but.
50:11 Speaker 00 Okay.
50:12 Speaker 01 Um, it is a good question. It's actually, that's a really interesting question about if longer will clean it up. I'll have to get back to you on that. That's probably a few days of computing for me.
50:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, indeed, if we make the interferometers longer, like 10 times longer.
50:29 Speaker 00 Yeah.
50:29 Speaker 01 That's dramatically good. I mean, it will cost a lot of money. But that would take us from being able to measure things which are sort of.
50:44 Speaker 01 I would say.
50:47 Speaker 00 Right.
50:49 Speaker 01 With the current systems, you know, as big as they are, if we put in like our best technical hacks into them that we can imagine, we could maybe get to the place where the universe was about of
51:04 Speaker 01 one fifth or one sixth of its current age. So we could look back something like 10 billion years into the past, which is pretty great.
51:15 Speaker 01 But if we built systems which were 10 times bigger,
51:19 Speaker 01 it's hard to do anything better than just make the system bigger. The bigger you make it, the bigger the signal gets. And a lot of people have thought about the idea of making a 40 kilometer system, which you can put, there are several places in the US, for example, which have.
51:37 Speaker 00 E-Charmas 40K?
51:38 Speaker 01 Yeah. So big, open spaces, which are unused. And if we could find a place like that and get the funding to build something like that, it would be traumatic, not traumatic. I hope not traumatic, dramatic.
51:53 Speaker 00 We'll see if the laser gets out.
51:54 Speaker 01 Yeah. It would be dramatic. It would be wonderful. We would be able to find signals from basically the all the way back. I mean, there would have.
52:04 Speaker 00 Really?
52:05 Speaker 01 Yeah. We would find the first stars in the universe and they were collapsing, if they exist, which I think they do. But it would be so dramatic, we'd be able to measure things like.
52:18 Speaker 01 How did spacetime evolve from those early times? And did the universe start from a different number of spatial dimensions? And sort of unpack as it expanded and become three dimensional? Did it start different? And did it go through a phase where it like an extra dimension came up? And then collapsed again? And who knows? We'd also like to know, does gravity travel through the three dimensional space? Or is it something like there's another spatial dimension which only gravity can see? And so something from that far back into the universe may have. I don't know how to draw this. I don't think this.
52:59 Speaker 00 The cup can't do it.
53:00 Speaker 01 The cup.
53:00 Speaker 00 You have to dump the water out of the cup.
53:02 Speaker 01 The cup can do it. The cup can do it. Watch, watch this. So imagine that we're living on the surface of this cup.
53:08 Speaker 00 Sure.
53:08 Speaker 01 And this is effectively like our three dimensional universe.
53:11 Speaker 00 Sure.
53:12 Speaker 01 Now, if I empty the cup, then when I go like this, the signal has to travel around the border of the cup. But because there's water inside, when I go down here, some of the vibration gets into the water and comes out this other side. And so there's sort of this boundary on which we're used to everything taking place, which is the three dimensions that we're familiar with. But there could be a fourth dimension, which is something like this bulk, the inner part. And in that dimension, gravity could travel faster. So it'll look like it's going faster than the speed of light. But that kind of stuff.
53:52 Speaker 00 This is kind of blowing my mind. I'm trying to figure it out.
53:54 Speaker 01 It sounds like, yeah. It sounds like there's just a crazy person who you found on the streets. Who's just telling you stuff about other dimensions.
54:01 Speaker 00 Just think about it, man. 10 billion years ago, man.
54:04 Speaker 01 10 billion years ago, there's other dimensions and they're half dimensions. And maybe we unfolded from a flower. It's all on the table. I'll tell you. In the late nineties, when I was starting grad school, everything felt like it was pretty much wrapped up.
54:21 Speaker 00 Hmm.
54:21 Speaker 01 The, the word on the street was like, well, thanks for showing up, but we've got this all wrapped up now. And, uh, everything makes sense and the universe is exactly like we predicted it. We have a few loose ends to tie up. And this is the, the same thing that people were saying, um, in the late eighteen nineties also. They said, we got it all. We figured it out. We got magnets. We've got electric fields.
54:46 Speaker 00 Got a telescope.
54:48 Speaker 01 That's all there is. There's nothing else out there. And then there was this weird quantum thing that people, they, there was some data, but they were like, that's not real. That's just some nonsense. It's going to go away. And we're back into that period now where everything's back on the table. The universe is so strange and so far inexplicable that if you have got an idea, that's a crazy idea, then your crazy idea is just as good as my crazy idea.
55:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
55:14 Speaker 01 And let's put it to a test. If it's a, if it's a hypothesis which is testable, we ought to test it.
55:21 Speaker 00 So then, does it make sense to build an infrometer in space like people have been talking about?
55:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, of course.
55:29 Speaker 00 I know it sounds cool.
55:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's a plus.
55:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
55:33 Speaker 01 That's a plus that it sounds cool. Um, it makes sense for a lot of reasons, I would say. Um, on the ground, kind of, we're, we're limited to measure things that are, um, that have a signal frequency which is more than five or 10 hertz or something like that. So we can go a little bit below the human audio band.
55:57 Speaker 00 Okay.
55:57 Speaker 01 But not much. And the reason for that is that the earth is just vibrating all the time.
56:01 Speaker 00 Hmm.
56:01 Speaker 01 And you talked about these animals before. The animals are going to be a problem. Um, The the clouds are a problem. I mean, eventually, the gravity from the clouds and the gravity from beavers and hummingbirds and whatever. I mean, who knows what is out there? But you can imagine, Washington State, there's not a lot of animals out there, but there's tumbleweed, and those things are fierce. If you have never been chased by a tumbleweed mini tornado, then you're lucky. And in Louisiana, there's a lot of animals. And, okay, you could build bigger buildings, but eventually, the gravity from
56:41 Speaker 01 the gravitational fluctuations from the dirt and from the air clouds. I mean, eventually, it's just too much gravity fluctuation on the earth. We just can't get past it. So we can remove every other kind of noise, but we can't go putting vibration sensors in all the clouds or something like that. That's kind of Not yet. We're getting to the Baron Moonchowson kind of crazy level. So we could go to the moon, but the moon's not all that quiet. And the near-Earth orbit is not also, not really that good Okay. for vibrations. And it's, it's not a place you want to put a stable system. So to have a space inertometer, it's got to be on a
57:22 Speaker 01 far out kind of orbit that you can get to with things like SpaceX Falcon Heavy. And so there's a project called LISA, which is aimed to launch in sixteen years, sixteen, seventeen years from now. And that will put a system, a triangular inertometer in space, which is several inertometers. And that will measure gravitational waves at around a millihertz. So super low frequency. But those, at that, at that level,
57:57 Speaker 01 there's almost no vibration out there, and they should be able to measure things all over the universe in super, super hi-fi. So we're measuring things with a signal-to-noise ratio of tens, and we hope to get to signal-to-noise ratios of thousands, which is really good. But they would be hundreds of times better than that. And it would be like
58:23 Speaker 01 It's one of the, if you're a real, depends if you're a real connoisseur of violin or cello or some of these things. Different musicians have a different finger signature a little bit. So when they're playing, you can, you can hear things like the way that
58:42 Speaker 01 their, their finger moves on the bow or the way that their finger moves on the string. You feel like a little bit of the friction. So you can hear these little, like it's tiny. Slide, a little bit, yeah. A little bit of the slide, but you hear these little things which change the character of the music. And you know, if, if you leave one of these instruments sitting for too long, the sound, you know, like some of these instruments like to be played. They warm up a little bit, the wood warms up and then becomes more like a warm instrument. And if you, if you listen to it on, I don't know, like a eighties cassette deck with a Walkman, you're never going to hear that stuff. You need to have a full hi-fi system and some good cans and then you, then you really,
59:26 Speaker 01 you feel it, you hear it, you know, you need, uh, these are kind of the things in the live performance that you'll never get, uh, otherwise. I've been to the Berlin Philharmonic and that is, that's what I'm talking about. If you want to understand about why we need better gravitation wave detectors, you go and you, you sit there in like row five or 10. And these are some of the best musicians in the world and they'll play pieces that you know, but you've never heard like that until you're, and there's no recording that's ever going to do it because you, you feel, you feel it in your chest and you feel it all over your body, the sound, and it's a kind of richness that there's no way to record.
1:00:10 Speaker 01 And that's the kind of feeling that we want to get from what's happening out in space. And for that, we need an exquisite hi-fi system to get these little things. And it's not just for the pleasure of, oh, look, that black hole did exactly what we predicted. It's more for. We'd like to find out where the laws of physics break down and where something new pops up. If we want to find out other extra dimensions and new kinds of particles and is space and time really just a illusion? And then there's really a microscopic graininess to empty space and these weird kind of things.
1:00:49 Speaker 00 That's kind of the underlying question because I like, I mean, you'd said so many reasons before, but I wonder what the pitch was in the beginning, like, why? Why do this? And like, obviously, it's, you know, quest for knowledge, which is great.
1:01:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:01:02 Speaker 00 But like, is, were those the concrete answers that people gave? Like, why are you doing this? Why make it bigger? What do you do?
1:01:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think for everybody, there's a different reason for it. There's a whole spectrum of reasons. So, um, I'm just, I always tell people the thing that I'm most interested in, which is, I think, gravity. We've never been able to use it as a real probe of what's going on in the universe. What's the universe made out of? What is all this stuff? Why is space empty? Why is space so stiff? And why are there quantum fluctuations in empty space? And how come the universe ended up looking the way it does? Why are the galaxies so far apart? And how come there are galaxies? Why don't they just have a bunch of planets?
1:01:47 Speaker 00 Just floating around.
1:01:48 Speaker 01 Yeah. Why planet, how come planets are smaller than, I mean, just, it's like endless number of questions about the whole, not really the stuff in our universe, but the, the structure of everything. And why did it end up like this? It could have been any number of things. And then we don't even know what space is made out of. What's empty space? It sounds like a question that's, that's stupid and doesn't have any meaning to it. But, you know, if you're, um,
1:02:18 Speaker 01 I don't know, imagine like two sturgeon floating around in the water. They're like a hundred years old and they've gotten used to it. They don't really ask anymore, what is water? But, you know, we know, we can take it out and look at it in a microscope and it's got flagellums and all kinds of stuff and it's made out of H2O, which we can study. And it has a real microscopic character, which is important and we need to understand it. And for those fish, it doesn't really matter. It just seems like a continuum. It's just everything is that stuff. But there is a whole deep structure to it and space may be like that. It's just this whole.
1:02:58 Speaker 01 You know, it's like opening the curtain on the real universe and what's really going on. What is the structure that we're living on? It could just be this weird framework where we've never imagined. And asking, and then you can, I think a totally legitimate question is, so what? And let's say you find like you, we've revealed the true structure of space time. And it's a bunch of leprechauns down there building space or I mean, who knows? Yeah. Some crazy thing. Just black paint. And then, yeah, and then so what? What does that do for me? Is that going to relieve the traffic in LA? Yeah. Yeah, no, probably not. So really, really, it's, it's a curiosity driven research.
1:03:43 Speaker 01 We're trying to figure out how to find out, reveal the unknown and what's going on. And these, these big science projects are really expensive. Hmm. And a lot of people are involved and they work at it. And then, and then you really wonder, so what? They've found out stuff like there's this particle or not that particle, or this star did something one billion years before, you know, it's six billion years old and not five billion or whatever. But um, I, I think if that really was all that there is to it, you could certainly make the legitimate argument that, uh, look, our society has got a lot of problems that we need to solve.
1:04:23 Speaker 01 And then how much, how much of our resources are we going to put into pure curiosity driven basic research, which doesn't have any kind of finite timeline payoff? And we've got real things we want to solve here. There's people going hungry. What are we going to do? And I would say to that, um, when you look at the history in the last hundred years, and uh, why has, you know, why has wealth increased and standards of living increased all over the world? You know? And the reason for it is, is that people have been investing a lot in basic science for, for hundreds of years. And the reason that the US
1:05:07 Speaker 01 Became the leader in this is the government said um soon after World War Two. That that we got to be serious and put our money into this because. There is really a huge payoff and we don't really care what you're researching, just do something. I mean, find something that excites you and do it and do it really well and. And if you're interested in engineering and science and technology, we are going to support that because. We we've shown decade after decade that it's a huge. Uh hugely profitable payoff investment wise.
1:05:43 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:05:43 Speaker 01 It pays off in gadgets and learning and uh wealth for the country in the long term. And it's never fails. So you'll always have uh.
1:05:54 Speaker 01 You know, you you'll always be funding something which turns out to be a dumb idea and then. Okay, so it doesn't work out, but.
1:06:04 Speaker 01 You know, to find a really great idea, you might have to. Test out ninety nine dumb ideas and you might not understand why they're bad until you do it.
1:06:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, but relative to the outcome, I think it makes a lot of sense. Cool, um I think that's a. We have a couple of questions from Twitter, so we can transition into those.
1:06:22 Speaker 01 Fantastic.
1:06:22 Speaker 00 Get those ones.
1:06:23 Speaker 01 I love Twitter.
1:06:24 Speaker 00 All right, Dennis Thornton asks, what would happen to Earth if there was a black hole merger closer to home than the three detected? Say where Sagittarius A star is now.
1:06:36 Speaker 01 Hmm.
1:06:38 Speaker 01 Um, that's not close enough to really do anything to us, but you could imagine it being even closer.
1:06:45 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
1:06:46 Speaker 01 Um, so uh, let's see, if it's too close, it just eats the earth and that's not interesting. We're just dead, but there's some range of distances at which other things could happen. So you could imagine, for example, um it being out by um. Oh, I'd say like at the next star system like Alpha Centauri or something like that and. So we can, we can compute it. Like the ones we detected were at, let's say, uh, several hundred million light years. And Alpha Centauri is only four light years, I believe. So it would be stronger by that factor of a hundred million.
1:07:31 Speaker 01 And which sounds like a lot, it is a lot, but that means that that motion of ten to the minus eighteen meters would have been ten to the minus ten meters. Which for us would have been a, like a hardware destroying level of signal.
1:07:46 Speaker 00 Really?
1:07:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, we would have just had electronics overload and saturate and we would have just ignored it because we would say it's way too strong.
1:07:54 Speaker 00 The levels are too much, yeah.
1:07:55 Speaker 01 It can't be right. But it would not have done anything like disrupt the tides or knock the moon out of orbit or anything like that. It would have to be extremely close for something like that.
1:08:07 Speaker 00 Right, and so close that we might even already.
1:08:11 Speaker 01 We would see it with our optical telescopes.
1:08:13 Speaker 00 Really?
1:08:13 Speaker 01 For sure, for sure, for it, for it to hurt us.
1:08:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, and it also would have been, it would have happened already, right?
1:08:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, you could imagine, uh, I'm trying to think of all the nightmare disaster scenarios. So, uh, let's say, let's say, uh, a, a pair of black holes gets formed in some weird three-way encounter in a nearby cluster. And then it gets shot out, um, and it's traveling at like a million meters per second. So it's like a, like a one percent the speed of light. And it's shooting at us and it's coming at us from some strange direction so that we don't see it because it's occluded by something else. I don't know what that would be.
1:08:52 Speaker 00 Sure.
1:08:52 Speaker 01 Something, um, I can't simulate the whole solar system in my head, so I don't, I can't figure out the answer to this. But let's say it's coming from out of the plane and then eventually we see it, it's like occluding some stars.
1:09:04 Speaker 00 Right.
1:09:04 Speaker 01 And so I'm, I'm thinking of this Hollywood movie that we would make.
1:09:07 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah.
1:09:08 Speaker 01 Just on this idea. So it's coming to us and, and the binary is doing this as it's traveling. And as it's come, like it's going to merge right when it hits this solar system somehow. And I don't know what we would do to stop this.
1:09:22 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:09:22 Speaker 01 I don't know what that would be, but, um.
1:09:26 Speaker 01 It could, it could, I mean, we could compute something like that. And then that thing would really be bad because it would stretch space by, like I was saying, like hundreds of percent, right? When it got close to us. And the black holes themselves would be about the size of LA. And so they would be effectively like tiny pinpricks, but you know, might be like 50 or 100 kilometers in size.
1:09:49 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:09:49 Speaker 01 And they would be able to, I don't think the earth would get destroyed. However.
1:10:00 Speaker 01 So I can't say this with a high confidence, but the earth, again, using this.
1:10:07 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:10:08 Speaker 01 The earth is a physically resonant system. And this thing has a quality factor of a few thousand, meaning it's just like a few thousand oscillations when I ring it. That's why it lasts for a second. So the earth is like that also, except for the vibration frequency is about 30 millihertz. So 30 times, uh, once per 30 seconds. And so if the gravitational, if the binary black hole pair came cruising through our solar system and right when it was coming through, if it happened to be going once per 30 seconds.
1:10:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, it could excite the acoustic modes of the earth.
1:10:46 Speaker 00 That would be bad.
1:10:47 Speaker 01 It would be, um, it would like be bigger than the 9.5 earthquake in Chile, which happened in the early 60s and kept the earth ringing for months. I don't know what would happen exactly, but I can imagine if we had 10 times bigger than the world's biggest earthquake, it could hurt us in terms of earthquakes and tsunamis.
1:11:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:11:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:11:08 Speaker 00 Or we would find out what the inside of a black hole looks like if we got too close.
1:11:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. All right. That's an interesting question and one I should, I should compute.
1:11:18 Speaker 00 All right.
1:11:18 Speaker 01 I will answer on Twitter.
1:11:19 Speaker 00 Perfect. Okay. So we got one more then. Um, this is from, uh, Margin Collector.
1:11:26 Speaker 00 Is the current method for detecting gravitational waves, uh, the best idea out there or only the best practical way?
1:11:34 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:11:35 Speaker 00 Given the tech.
1:11:36 Speaker 01 It is not the best idea out there. So there's, and a number of ways. I mean, one way is making things longer, as people said, but I, what I gather from this question, um, I'm, I'm reading between the lines here, but is there some like?
1:11:52 Speaker 01 There's a good Elon Musk story where I think his analogy is like,
1:11:58 Speaker 01 you know, we take New York City in the 1800s and it's all horses. And then we ask, like, what's going to happen to the output of all the horses? Once New York City scales to 20 million. You can't just scale everything by saying, we'll have like more horses and we'll have so many more street sweepers or something. Eventually you shift to a new technology like cars. And so it's the same like the normal answer, I think people would give to, are we using the best technology is, oh no. You know, next year we're going to use double the laser power and a mirror that's even double.
1:12:32 Speaker 00 Make it longer.
1:12:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, but like in The Simpsons, they said, you know, eventually these humans will make a a board with a nail so big through it that they'll destroy themselves. So, yeah, it's not a, it's not the right way to go. If you ask in a hundred years from now, will people still build Michelson laser interferometers and do the same thing?
1:12:52 Speaker 00 Right.
1:12:53 Speaker 01 I have a hard time believing that's true.
1:12:55 Speaker 00 Right.
1:12:55 Speaker 01 And one of the exciting possibilities out there, so there are ideas with using acoustic detectors and space detectors and using the timing of signals in space and so on. But in this frequency band, in the audio frequency band,
1:13:13 Speaker 01 I think me and some of the
1:13:19 Speaker 01 people who think about the quantum mechanics of this kind of detector have been thinking about, how far are we, if you think about pure, the pure mathematics of how information is propagated through spacetime? Like, what's the information carrying capability in terms of number of bits of space? You have this much space and how many bits can you send before space collapses on itself? And like with fiber optics, you have a limit to the number of bits you can send, which depends on your modulation bandwidth and the amount of laser power you can put in the fiber. And eventually, if you put too much laser power in there, you get stimulated beyond scattering from the glass and so on. It's kind of a bandwidth limit there, which is, which is pretty high. It's plenty for YouTube, but it's, it's still, there is a limit.
1:14:03 Speaker 01 And, and we have been thinking about the same kind of thing. And why aren't we doing better? Or where is all the signal to noise ratio going? When you think about the wave coming from outer space.
1:14:14 Speaker 01 We think probably the quantum fluctuations of spacetime itself are probably at the Planck scale, which is ten to the minus thirty-four meters. And the signal, like I said, is around ten to the minus eighteen or nineteen or something. So there's a signal to noise ratio of ten to the fourteen or fifteen there. And I'm telling you, we're only getting tens. So there's a ten to the thirteen and the signal to noise is lost from converting from spacetime to laser light. That doesn't seem a good thing. There's got to be, since that's the biggest chunk of where we're losing it, we should be doing something better to transduce the spacetime curvature into an electrical signal. And it might be that light is not the best thing.
1:14:58 Speaker 01 But even with light, we can do a lot better than what we're doing. And not just by making things heavier and doubling this or switching the colors or something. There's a, there's an idea which is around, which is called coherent quantum feedback. And that takes this idea of, it takes this problem, I would guess, I would say of the pressure from the light moving the mirrors around and turning it into an advantage. So like I described before, the beam bounce, the beam pushes this thing and then this thing pushes back and that changes the light. Well, you can, you can take this instability and essentially turning it into a system where
1:15:39 Speaker 01 quantum mechanically, the mirrored laser system has positive feedback. A lot like a, yeah, like an audio system. You've heard like when musicians practice sometimes. Or, I mean, it can be bad. So when people have feedback, they're standing too close to the. Like two mics next to each other. Yeah, exactly. But as we know from Jimi Hendrix, feedback can also be a wonderful thing. And he turned it into a fantastic thing from just an annoyance. So we'd like to do the same thing. So we'd like to take this mechanical, optical instability that comes from the laser system interacting with itself and turn the entire four kilometer plus four kilometer L-shaped thing into a unstable feedback system.
1:16:24 Speaker 01 So when the spacetime fluctuation comes in, it excites this instability, you know, instability in our system. And then we detect the signals in a much stronger way. And so rather than think about it like the laser light goes and measures the space and comes back, it's almost like. We have this eight kilometer L-shaped laser tuning fork that picks up the spacetime signal.
1:16:51 Speaker 00 Right, so it's optimized for that one particular length, and so it just goes wild when it hears something.
1:16:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, but, in fact, I mean, you can optimize it for a single frequency, but the thing we've been thinking about just in the last month or two is how to optimize, make it optimum for a wideband. So we want to make a wideband unstable system.
1:17:16 Speaker 00 To be determined.
1:17:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think we have got 95% of the problem solved.
1:17:24 Speaker 00 Oh, wow.
1:17:25 Speaker 01 And on paper, but still, still, our aim is to try to build something like this this year, and once we figure out how to do it.
1:17:36 Speaker 00 Just like a scale model, you mean?
1:17:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:17:40 Speaker 00 Like you implement it at, oh, okay.
1:17:41 Speaker 01 On the Caltech campus, we have a 40-meter-sized system.
1:17:44 Speaker 00 Oh, okay.
1:17:45 Speaker 01 And it is a 1/100 scale of the real LIGO detector, and we want to build this in. So we have little mirrors and little lasers, and they seem big to us, but they're really little. And we're going to build up this instability and see how sensitive we can become.
1:18:03 Speaker 00 Very cool. Okay, cool. Thanks, man. All right, thanks for listening. So as always, we're posting the video and transcript at blog.ycombinator.com, and this time, we're also posting a pretty cool video of two black holes colliding, which is technically not a video of the black holes colliding, but it's more of a composite from the data turned into a video. Regardless, it's pretty cool. And so, yeah, that's at blog.ycombinator.com. And as always, please remember to rate and subscribe to the show. Okay, see you next time.
Previous #34 - Elizabeth Iorns on Biotech Companies in YC Next #36 - Your Whole Goal Is to Not Quit - Courtland Allen of Indie Hackers Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated