Pod Insights Y Combinator Podcast #109 - Samantha Bradshaw About this episode Samantha Bradshaw https://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/people/samantha-bradshaw/ is a researcher at the Computational Propaganda Project https://comprop.oii.ox.ac.uk/ and a doctoral candidate at the Oxford Internet Institute https://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/. She’s been tracking the phenomenon of political manipulation through social media.
You can find Samantha on Twitter at @sbradshaww https://twitter.com/sbradshaww.
The YC podcast is hosted by Craig Cannon https://twitter.com/craigcannon.
***
Topics
:53 - What is a bot?
2:53 - When computational propaganda began
3:53 - Changes in bot tactics since 2016
5:53 - Using bots for content creation
7:28 - WhatsApp and the upcoming Indian election
9:23 - Trends in computational propaganda
10:53 - How bots integrate into platforms
13:23 - Responsibilities of platforms to remove fake accounts
14:53 - The role of governments in media manipulation
18:18 - Fake news and selecting news that aligns with your beliefs
19:53 - Are platforms getting better or worse?
21:33 - Samantha's personal internet habits
23:03 - Sentiment around tracking in the UK vs the US
24:23 - The Mueller report and US midterms
29:18 - Canadian elections
30:18 - 2020 US elections
30:53 - Deepfakes
31:48 - Optimistic thoughts for the future
33:08 - How to help against computational propaganda
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hey, how's it going? This is Craig Cannon and you're listening to Y Combinator's podcast. Today's episode is with Samantha Bradshaw. Samantha is a researcher at the Computational Propaganda Project and a doctoral candidate at the Oxford Internet Institute. She's been tracking the phenomenon of political manipulation through social media. You can find Samantha on Twitter at S Bradshaw W. All right, here we go. So I want to talk about two separate things. So one is the responsibilities of these platforms and the responsibilities of governments. And then the other thing is bots, because I think a lot of people hear the word bots, but don't necessarily know what that means. So maybe we should start there and you can kind of contextualize what bots are actually doing right now. And then we can talk about, you know,
0:45 Speaker 00 how these corporations are interacting with their users and with governments. So what, how would you define a bot?
0:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I mean, a bot is essentially just a script or a piece of code. And I mean, bots can do a whole bunch of different kinds of things. Let me start here.
1:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:02 Speaker 01 So a bot, for example, could be a web scraper. Like, Google's search engine is essentially a bot. And what it does is it goes out and it crawls the internet in an automated way and then stores information about different pages. And so like, that's a really good bot that we need for the internet. Because if Google wasn't able to scrape and crawl pages in an automated way, it wouldn't be able to index them and we wouldn't have Google search. Other bots, and I think the bots that are being talked a lot about in the media and, you know, around all these questions about Russian foreign interference and elections and manipulating the media. These are bots that people design
1:46 Speaker 01 and they're designed to mimic human behavior in an automated way. So they might plug into Twitter or into Facebook and then they might like, share, retweet a whole bunch of different stories very quickly to give something a sense of popularity. Like, ooh, lots of people are really engaging with this, this content. They might follow people.
2:10 Speaker 01 Just to, again, sort of amplify that popularity, maybe around a particular person rather than an idea.
2:16 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:16 Speaker 01 Some of the more sophisticated bots might actually interact with real people. So they blend like chatbot technology. And, you know, we all have been to those customer service pages where the thing pops up at the bottom and says, hi, can I help you today? That's not actually a real person. That's another kind of bot, but it uses a lot of natural language to interact with people. And so that kind of technology can be plugged into some of the bots that we're seeing on social media platforms to actually respond to users in comment threads or post like a little comment about a story that's being shared.
2:54 Speaker 00 Yeah. And when did it become clear that governmental agencies or non-governmental agencies were using bots to manipulate, manipulate thoughts around politics?
3:04 Speaker 01 Yeah. So I think this phenomenon really came into media and public attention during the 2016 election.
3:12 Speaker 00 Yeah.
3:13 Speaker 01 But from some of the research that I've done here at the OII and on the Computational Propaganda Project, we know that these techniques have been experimented with by governments for a long time. We've had evidence of them going back to, you know, even the early days of social media platforms and using these kinds of tools to shape discussions mainly at home and in more authoritarian regime contexts as, you know, another tool of social control.
3:43 Speaker 00 Okay. And so now that you've been studying this for two years, so you, you came on in 2016?
3:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:49 Speaker 00 Okay. And so then, pre-election, you started doing this research and now there's a lot more attention paid to it. How have bot tactics changed?
3:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. So it's been fascinating to study this from the, you know, sort of inception of attention to this issue. Because even when I started this research agenda, you know, the whole focus was on Russian interference in the US election. But, you know, I just had this inkling that it was a much broader phenomenon and, you know, there's more. All kinds of these digital techniques being used that, you know, make use of automation and algorithms and trying to game them to manipulate public opinion. And so in terms of how I've seen this change over time, we're definitely seeing a lot
4:42 Speaker 01 of new entrants starting to experiment with this kind of technology. And, you know, in particular around elections, usually these new entrants might experiment with some of the more crude bots. So things that might just like, share and retweet certain kinds of stories or follow a politician. So they don't really engage with users very much. It's usually pretty easy to tell that these are bot accounts.
5:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, so it's trying to give the algorithm signal to show that something might be good, a person or a piece of content.
5:15 Speaker 01 Exactly, exactly. But they're, they're not very sophisticated with them yet. So we're seeing a lot of that evolve over time. We're seeing a lot more gaming of the algorithms as well and more of these kind of sophisticated techniques. So not just liking and sharing, but using specific keywords to get content trending, to try to get things at the top of Google's search algorithm, trying to get things at the top of YouTube to be recommended next, and trying to get some more of this organic reach and what, you know, the search engine optimizers have been doing for decades. You know, we're just seeing these tools now being applied to politics.
5:58 Speaker 00 And is it breaching into full-length content creation at this point?
6:03 Speaker 01 We're definitely seeing content creation, especially in more of the sophisticated operations. I mean, a lot of the stuff that's come out about Russia's actions in the US has shown, you know, a lot of content creation. It seems to just kind of be, you know, throwing stuff at a wall and seeing what sticks, but, you know, they're putting a lot of resources into finding out exactly what the buttons are to push in, in society and then creating content around those issues.
6:31 Speaker 00 And so that must be, so is that what's happening with WhatsApp? Or are these individuals that are just creating content and then getting them, posting them to groups?
6:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I think it's a little bit of both. On the one side, you do definitely have organized state actors who are involved in creating messages, figuring out what sticks and then spreading them.
6:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:51 Speaker 01 In other cases, it's, you know, just individuals who might have a particular political ideology. They just want to get messages to spread because, you know, that's what they believe in. Other times, you know, there's a whole economic incentive behind getting content to go viral, which is kind of what, you know, I talked about at the beginning. If you can get people to look at your content on a website, you can generate advertising revenue, the more people that click through, so.
7:20 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's kind of the more pure form of using bots. So could you contextualize how WhatsApp is being manipulated? Because this is a very non-US trend.
7:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:32 Speaker 00 Specifically with the Indian election coming up.
7:34 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm, and this is another interesting point about disinformation too, is that it's different everywhere you go.
7:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
7:41 Speaker 01 Because, you know, the people who want to manipulate public opinion, they're going to go to where the people are and the platforms that the people are using. So in the US, we tend to see a lot of these campaigns on Twitter and Facebook, because that's the platforms that the majority of people use. In contexts like India, more people are on WhatsApp and they use that, you know, more than other platforms. So that's where we're seeing a lot of these campaigns. In terms of how WhatsApp is actually being used, they're still not very much known about it from an academic standpoint. Just because of the nature of the platform, it's really hard to study because it's essentially a closed platform. You can't actively monitor a lot of the communications that happen on WhatsApp.
8:24 Speaker 01 There are certainly public groups that you can join and follow, but that doesn't give you like a whole good look of, you know, what's happening on the platform. And sometimes it can be hard to find the groups that you need to join to study them and stuff. But, you know, overall. People, I mean, we looked at WhatsApp in Brazil, for example. And in that study, we joined a bunch of different groups. We're looking at the kinds of images and the kinds of conversations that were being shared. And there were a lot of memes that were being used to push disinformation to people that were in that groups. And so in that way, it's, you know, kind of similar to
9:06 Speaker 00 So it is kind of like the Reddit Pepe sort of stuff we saw in 2016.
9:10 Speaker 01 Exactly. Yeah, yeah. A lot of mobilizing images to get people riled up and, you know, getting them to feel certain kinds of emotions.
9:19 Speaker 00 Okay. And so what are other creative forms that you've seen? Because in your recap of what you saw in 2017, you said that there were something like 48 countries you found this being used in, in 10 languages or something like that?
9:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:34 Speaker 00 So, yeah, how else is it being done?
9:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, so we're definitely seeing a lot more memes, a lot more bots on platforms, search engine optimization tactics.
9:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:45 Speaker 01 We're also seeing, you know, more videos on YouTube and more pictures on Instagram. A lot of these platforms that haven't necessarily been focused upon in the media, but they're very powerful platforms because of the way that they deliver content. You know, images and video can have a much more powerful effect on our psyche and how we, I guess, digest information. And what we see opposed to what we read tends to stick with us longer. So if someone was more likely to see a piece of fake news, they'll more actively remember it than if they read it.
10:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
10:24 Speaker 01 So we're seeing a lot more disinformation on these kinds of platforms. And it's not very well studied yet, but certainly needs to be.
10:32 Speaker 00 Gotcha.
10:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
10:33 Speaker 00 In terms of how bots actually work, could you break down how they are entering in these platforms at all? I think many people are curious about, like, you know, you hear bots, but then you think about, well, when I sign up for Facebook, like, I have to give all this personal information. So how are these systems engineered to infiltrate platforms with such scale? And further, like, do they even need that degree of scale to be effective?
10:59 Speaker 01 Right. So
11:01 Speaker 01 I think when we are talking about the platforms and how bots integrate, there's quite a big difference between like even Facebook and Twitter.
11:09 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:09 Speaker 01 So, starting with Twitter, for example, it's relatively easy to plug into the API, to scrape information, and to create an account on Twitter, you also don't need a real name. So you can use any kind of fake identity to create an account, which is why Twitter tends to have a lot more of these fake accounts that use some kind of automation. There are also a bunch of tools that allow you to automate your activity on Twitter, things like HootSuite and whatnot. So you can set timers on tweets and things like that.
11:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, and that was a signal you guys used, right? It was like over 50 posts a day, therefore a bot, or more likely to be a bot?
11:53 Speaker 01 Exactly. That was when we first started looking at this phenomenon back in 2015. We just had a very crude measure of, you know, over 50 tweets a day, you're probably an automated account because most people don't, you know, write that many tweets during a day. Maybe like if they're at a conference.
12:12 Speaker 00 Teenagers, yeah.
12:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, or if nothing else to do. But that's still quite a large number of tweets. So that's Twitter. Whereas Facebook, you still need to have a real name to create an account. Sometimes Facebook actually verifies your identity. I know this because I actually set up a fake Facebook account once. And, you know, this is a while ago and I just wanted to log into it recently. And I tried, but they wanted me to send them a piece of like ID, so like a passport or driver's license, things like that, to verify that this account was real. And I'm like, oh, I don't have anything with a fake name on it. So whatever, I'll just leave my fake account alone. It can die.
12:53 Speaker 01 But that also means that because it's so hard to create fake accounts on Facebook, the accounts that are fake might actually be a little bit more powerful because people don't expect there to be as many fake people on Facebook as they do Twitter. And so they might actually have more of an impact in the circles and communities that they've managed to infiltrate.
13:17 Speaker 00 Yeah. And so when it comes to the responsibility of a platform to get rid of fake accounts, where do you think it lies? Should they do anything? Or I think the consensus is they should, but what do you think?
13:32 Speaker 01 I definitely think they should. I think for a long time, there hasn't been an incentive for them to, because the more active accounts there are on these platforms, the more they're valued on the market, right? Because all of a sudden, there's this huge user base of people, people that these platforms can advertise to and sell that advertising space to. But as soon as you start saying, oh, millions of people are not actually real, they become devalued, right? So I think for a long time, there wasn't this incentive to actually go through and delete all the fake accounts.
14:15 Speaker 00 Yeah. So basically, the public market thinks more users equals more money, therefore good, keep going. But then on the advertiser's side, if you know, those views are from bots, you're also not getting what you want.
14:29 Speaker 01 Exactly. And I think this is where it has sort of flipped now, because advertisers are starting to realize, actually, these aren't real people. So why am I paying this much money to advertise to, you know, a piece of code that's not going to buy my product?
14:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. And so now that the Senate hearings are happening, and they're happening all over the world, when you're starting to see governments get involved, I know it happened in Germany around like a certain degree of censorship. What do you think is the right course of action?
15:06 Speaker 01 I think this is a really complicated problem that has so many dimensions to it. It's not just fake news or that kind of disinformation. You know, we've talked about the accounts and how those are problematic. We've talked about foreign interference and like these really coordinated campaigns against governments. There are so many different issues that are kind of connected in this, you know, media manipulation, social media manipulation bucket.
15:36 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:37 Speaker 01 When governments go after the content of what's being shared, I think that's a mistake. I don't think that's getting to the underlying problem that's sort of fueling the fake content or the disinformation to spread or to go viral in the first place. So things like NetDG, for example, when it was first introduced in Germany in, I think, 2017, early 2017, someone from the AfD had posted some horribly racist comment online. And of course, it got taken down immediately because NetDG essentially says Facebook or any platform has to remove content that breaks German law within 24 hours or else they'll face like 50 million euro fine.
16:23 Speaker 01 So because this broke the hate speech law, Facebook removed it immediately. But they also removed all of the content that was created around that tweet, all of the people that were calling this person out for making such a racist comment, all of the criticism on it. And so all of a sudden, you start to lose the vibrancy of this, you know, online political sphere.
16:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:51 Speaker 01 So I don't think going after the content is necessarily a good idea. We're already also seeing authoritarian governments adopt this law into their own into their own legal systems to silence dissent and to go after journalists who are publishing so-called fake news and whatnot. So I think it has a lot of unintended consequences and a lot more negative consequences and, you know, things like collateral censorship.
17:19 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:20 Speaker 01 In terms of what could be done, I think, you know, enforcing more transparency around the platforms and their operations and their algorithms is really important. Right now, all of these, you know, platforms, they're just black boxes and we don't understand anything about how these algorithms work and how they're tailored to deliver certain kinds of content.
17:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:42 Speaker 01 You know, complete transparency is also not great because if you perfectly understand what goes viral on Google, everyone will then know how to break it, right? But at least, you know, maybe understanding the intentions of the designer and like tracing those kinds of processes and those meetings and having those kinds of principles be more out in the public would be one way of starting to get that kind of in into understanding what's what's happening with these algorithms and in these kind of more closed black boxes.
18:16 Speaker 00 But what about in a world where, say, we could get rid of all fake news? How do you avoid the problem of us only wanting to see what we agree with?
18:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, and this is also part of the problem too, because, you know, fake news is not just a digital problem, but it's one of human nature. And there's a lot of research out there in academia that shows people do select news and information that adheres to their own beliefs, right? It's it's our, it's the selection effect. So that's where things like education and stuff come in, you know? And I know education is often used as the go-to, you know, solution to the problem, but it does have a really important role here in teaching us how to be good citizens and reminding us why democracy is important and why it's important to look at different
19:08 Speaker 01 sources and to be able to negotiate that public consensus with one another. You know, the system's not perfect, but I think we We've been focusing on how much it's been broken for so long that, you know, the positives have sort of been been lost in a lot of the conversations.
19:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think we were talking about this before, but I think the lack of optimism in online communication misses the the real optimism that exists in day to day life. And yeah, there's not really been a place for that yet. Or at least it doesn't do that well unless it's incredibly cheesy, kind of like life inspirational, life hacks, that sort of thing. So in terms of these platforms in the long run, like based on your research, do you think this problem is getting, things are getting better? Or do you think that they just, you know, combust with enough, you know, bots involved?
20:03 Speaker 01 I think we're already starting to see combustion happen, especially with Facebook. You know, a lot of my friends this year are starting to get off these platforms into deplatform, which might open up the market to new kind of models that, you know, aren't based on advertising and, you know, aren't completely monetized by digital advertising. Maybe we'll start to see different kind of business models prop up and maybe create a little bit more space in the market. Right now, it's just so consolidated too.
20:41 Speaker 00 Well, that's a separate, I mean, is that the the breaking up of Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram, is that that a topic of conversation here at the OAI as well?
20:51 Speaker 01 I mean, it's something that I think we all tangentially tangentially are thinking about and what that would look like and how that would actually be done. You know, I'm not an economist or an expert on any of this, but, you know, I do think that the consolidation of these platforms and the fact that there's no space for competition, like that's kind of locked us into these systems, which has then made the problem so much worse because now all of a sudden it's everyone that is being affected, opposed to, you know, just just the smaller.
21:26 Speaker 00 Right, so you have to be 100% in or 100% out, which is tricky.
21:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
21:30 Speaker 00 And so what do you, what have you been doing in terms of your personal internet habits to? I mean, you haven't checked out completely, obviously. I saw you have a Twitter account. Like, you're on.
21:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:41 Speaker 00 Uh, what do you, so what do you do?
21:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I keep using the excuse that, well, I study this, so I need to be on it to see, you know, what's happening. I might, you know, pick up on some change that I wouldn't have been able to actually see or understand if I wasn't on the platform. But I think I'm just a little bit more conscious around, you know, the kinds of information that I'm putting out on these platforms. I'm trying to be a little bit more conscious around like apps on my mobile phone and, you know, making sure that I'm restricting access to certain kinds of things. Just practicing a lot more digital privacy and better habits around that.
22:24 Speaker 00 Okay. Anything weird and ultra fringe, or just kind of basic good practice?
22:29 Speaker 01 I think I'm pretty, pretty basic when it comes to this stuff. Yeah. I haven't, you know, totally got the tinfoil hat on and, you know, disconnecting everything in my life because I'm worried about these issues to that extent. But I do think that, you know, especially these issues around privacy and data collection and how that relates to disinformation and, you know, even targeting messages based on the data about me. Like, I think that these are huge, that's another huge bucket of, of problems.
23:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
23:02 Speaker 01 So.
23:02 Speaker 00 And, and the climate here, do you feel it's the same as it is in the States? Because the UK's had CCTV everywhere for quite a while now. Are people more comfortable with that tracking or less comfortable, or the, or the same?
23:17 Speaker 01 Um, I think it's probably, I think they're probably the same.
23:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
23:24 Speaker 01 Um, you know, a lot of my British friends are still outraged when they find out that, you know, private companies have been doing X, Y, and Z with their data. Um, I think, you know, the difference around what private companies are doing and, you know, what governments do around surveillance, because everyone kind of knows what the government does. There are all kinds of. Laws that have been passed and debated. That's a little bit more transparent in terms of what they're collecting, or at least they give the impression, you know, of transparency around that. There's more of a public discussion where I think people are, there's still a shock factor around the fact that Facebook was, you know, storing private phone calls and private messages.
24:05 Speaker 01 And, you know, selling that data to other marketers without, you know, the users knowing. I think the shock factor still exists in that space.
24:16 Speaker 00 Okay, so to go back to the States just a little bit, I know this is happening everywhere, but yeah, I can be a little America centric or US centric. What are your thoughts on what will come of the Mueller report?
24:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't know, to be honest.
24:35 Speaker 01 I hope, I'm happy that the Mueller report at least brought to public attention a lot of the detail around what, you know, the IRA, the Internet Research Agency, was doing in the US. And that was a very credible source of information around, you know, the wide range of techniques, not just the digital, but, you know, even the real world activities that were going on. Whether or not it will lead to any outcome, I'm not sure. But the fact that it has at least made this information public,
25:15 Speaker 01 I think that's already like a win for me. And so, you know, whatever comes out in the future, like, you know, at least we have more information and more knowledge around, around the investigation.
25:27 Speaker 00 Okay. And then in terms of the midterms, have you guys crunched those numbers yet?
25:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, so when we looked at the midterms, actually, let me go back. Because we, we studied the 2016 elections and we studied the midterms. And in both these studies, we were looking at what people were sharing as political information and news online, on both Twitter and Facebook. In 2016, we found that Americans on average were sharing about a one to one ratio of junk news to professionally produced information.
26:01 Speaker 00 Junk news meaning fake or just not high quality?
26:04 Speaker 01 Not high quality. We have a like a five point definition that we tend to check off. And you need to have like four out of the five things. So things like counterfeit. Is it mimicking a real legitimate news source? Is it using like the Washington Post font or the BBC colors to give, you know, more credibility? Things like, do they adhere to any kind of journalistic standards? Do they publish corrections? The kind of language that they use, you know, are they using a lot of F bombs? And really, you know, hyperbolic language. So things like that. So it's not just fake news,
26:45 Speaker 01 but it's all of this other kind of low quality information that isn't necessarily helping our democracy. So yeah, in 2016, users were sharing junk news at a one to one ratio to professionally produced information. In 2018, when we redid this analysis during the midterm, the ratio of junk news actually went up. And so it went to like 1.2 or 1.3 to one. So that was-
27:12 Speaker 00 With the same amount of users or?
27:15 Speaker 01 So we controlled for the number of users. And we also in 2016 did a study on the swing states. And, you know, in actual swing state states, people were sharing more junk news compared to uncontested ones. We haven't done that same analysis now for 2018 midterms. But I think it would be interesting to see if it's also geographically distributed in terms of who's sharing what.
27:42 Speaker 00 The assumption would be that these people are more heavily targeted in terms of botnets, right?
27:48 Speaker 01 Exactly. Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's hard to say exactly for sure who or what is sharing that information. But we can see that, you know, by number, it's more concentrated in certain places than in others.
28:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, because I've been curious to see if that like the net number is just going to decline. So you could still find instances of fake news being shared, but more people become more skeptical and aren't checking it at all. Did you find that in the midterm study or is that just not part of it?
28:18 Speaker 01 So we didn't go into people's emotions or how they felt about sharing this kind of information. I think what we would have expected to see too was that it's declining. Because the platforms have been saying over and over that they've been taking steps to reduce the kind of disinformation and misinformation being spread.
28:38 Speaker 00 And it's not.
28:38 Speaker 01 And it's not. You know, we've done this study in other countries as well. So during the UK elections and Germany and France and Sweden, Mexico, all of those countries have much lower levels of junk news to professionally produced news shares than the US. The US is definitely a dramatic case here, but it's still interesting nonetheless.
29:02 Speaker 00 That's why. And what about Canada? You said there's something coming up this year?
29:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, we'd love to study the Canadian elections in 2019. You know, I'm Canadian myself, so I'd be really intrigued just to see what's going on. You know, Canada has always prided itself on being a very inclusive country. And you know, a lot of the junk news that we see in the US uses a lot of anti-immigration rhetoric and things like that. So just out of personal interest, you know, I think I'm worried, I guess. I don't think Canada is necessarily immune from those kinds of conversations. And I'm already starting to see some of the kind of populist narratives appear in my own news feed and
29:50 Speaker 01 in my own communities of friends. So I think it will be a really interesting case study.
29:56 Speaker 00 Okay. Because I imagine you see it here now with Brexit too, right?
29:59 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, definitely, definitely.
30:01 Speaker 00 Despite the vote already having happened, it's still common, right?
30:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, oh, it's still a thing. I think it will continue to be part of the political rhetoric in the UK for years to come, so.
30:16 Speaker 00 And so with the US in 2020, all signs point to this increasing.
30:20 Speaker 01 I would think so. The fact that we saw an increase already in 2018, you know, I don't think the platforms are going to be able to get their act together in time for 2020. And, you know, the US election is where we see a lot of new innovation in these, right, you know, manipulation techniques because millions and millions of dollars go into these campaign media strategies. So there's a lot of money to play around, to experiment, to innovate. So it's going to be interesting.
30:52 Speaker 00 This is terrifying. And so do you think 2020 or 2024 will be the year of deep fakes?
31:01 Speaker 01 I don't know. I think, you know, there's a lot of hype about deep fake right now. I don't know how, how real it's actually going to be. And, you know, we're already seeing, you know, a lot of the research agencies like DARPA and things like that, work on being able to detect when photos and videos have been manipulated. So I'm a little bit more optimistic that deep fake will not become a thing.
31:31 Speaker 01 Maybe in like low literacy media environments, there might be, you know, more, it might have more of an impact, but I like to remain optimistic.
31:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was gonna say like, so, so closing up, what are your optimistic thoughts for the future?
31:48 Speaker 01 My optimistic thoughts for the future? Geez, I don't know if I have any today.
31:55 Speaker 01 I've just been ranting about all of the, the problems and, you know, reminding myself after the, the Christmas break, why I really care about these things.
32:04 Speaker 00 Are there any signs of things improving?
32:06 Speaker 01 You know, I like to think that they are. I think a lot of governments are seriously thinking about this problem. You know, there are a couple of people that are really educating themselves around the issues that are at the intersection of technology and politics and society. You know, I think a lot of the time policymakers make laws without necessarily understanding.
32:30 Speaker 01 The technology and you know, there's a big gap there, but it does make me feel more optimistic when I see, you know, like Senator Warren or here in the UK, we have Damian Collins. They're really on top of their game and taking this in and thinking really seriously and deeply about what good regulation could look like. That's not going to just break the technology. So, you know, the fact that there is more energy around government regulation and proper government regulation, that makes me feel a little bit more optimistic.
33:05 Speaker 00 So if someone wanted to study what you're studying or try and help this cause, what would you tell them to do?
33:11 Speaker 01 I would just say be nice to each other on the internet, honestly.
33:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, because I think there's just so much anger in society right now. You know, we're seeing more and more polarization, like especially in the US. You know, that gap has been widening and widening for the past 20 years. And I think we just need to remember that we're all humans. At the end of the day, we might have different beliefs, but that doesn't make us, you know, evil or wrong or terrible people. We need to just be nice to each other and learn to talk to each other again.
33:42 Speaker 00 That's a great point. Yeah. So checking out isn't necessarily a net positive for the community.
33:47 Speaker 01 Exactly. Yeah.
33:48 Speaker 00 Cool. All right. Thanks so much, Sam.
33:49 Speaker 01 Thank you.
33:51 Speaker 00 All right. Thanks for listening. So as always, you can find the transcript and the video at blog.ycombinator.com. And if you have a second, it would be awesome to give us a rating and review wherever you find your podcasts. See you next time.
Previous #108 - Cindy Mi and Qi Lu Next #110 - Avni Patel Thompson and Kat Manalac Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated