Pod Insights WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk Winston Churchill, Dominic Sandbrook, & Philippe Sands About this episode Was Churchill the greatest Briton of all time? Why are people like Boris Johnson so keen to be seen like Churchill? How did Nazi war criminals start new lives in places like South America?
Listen to these exclusive extracts from Dominic Sandbrook, Tim Shipman, and Philippe Sands' talks from last year's We Have Ways Festival on whether Winston Churchill was the greatest Briton, and how some of the worst Nazi war criminals managed to evade capture and help dictators like Pinochet perpetrate their own crimes.
Start your free trial at patreon.com/wehaveways and unlock exclusive content and more. Enjoy livestreams, early access, ad-free listening, bonus episodes, and a weekly newsletter packed with book deals and behind-the-scenes insights.
Get your ticket for We Have Ways Fest 6 here!
Get your WHW Merch here!
A Goalhanger Production
Produced by James Regan
Exec Producer: Tony Pastor
Social: @WeHaveWaysPod
Email: [email protected]
Membership Club: patreon.com/wehaveways
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. Sign up to our Patreon to receive bonus content, live streams and our weekly newsletter with money off books and museum visits as well, plus early access to all live show tickets. That's patreon.com/WeHaveWays.
0:24 Speaker 00 Hello there, it's Al Murray here, co-host of WW2Pod We Have Ways of Making You Talk for all your Second World War needs. Now, do you want a sample of the amazing history talks that we have on offer this September at We Have Ways Fest VI? Perhaps you even came to the festival last year, but you couldn't get to every talk you wanted to hear. It is an enormous FOMO trap. Well, here at We Have Ways HQ, we are hard at work putting up all the past talks on our Patreon page in a collection just for our subscribers. We've just uploaded an amazing array of talks from 2025's Headquarters Tent with some of the world's most engaging historians on topics as diverse as Japan, aviation and
1:06 Speaker 00 the family stories submitted by you, our listeners. A highlight of the festival for me. Now is a great time to subscribe and get loads of extra content. You can enjoy ad-free listening, why not, priority access to new series and ticketed events, regular live streams where you can watch me and Jim War Waffle on your screen at home, a weekly newsletter with book and modelling discounts, that's right, scale modelling, and bonus episodes. All that and more at patreon.com/WeHaveWays. Patreon.com/WeHaveWays. Now, as a taster, we've prepared an extract from two of the talks we've just uploaded. Listen as Dominic Sandbrook and Tim Shipman debate if Winston Churchill was the greatest
1:50 Speaker 00 Britain, and also a fascinating talk from Philippe Sands' Hunting Nazis in South America. Enjoy.
2:01 Speaker 01 I think he is the greatest Britain and I don't mean that he's the best or I don't mean he's the one who always made the most considered decisions and I don't mean by that that Churchill is perfect. So the poll that was done, the Greatest Britons poll in 2002, when you look at the names in that kind of top 10, so you mentioned Brunel that Clarkson was promoting, Horatio Nelson, Elizabeth the First and so on, they're all complicated characters with dark as well as light. That's certainly true of Churchill. But I think Churchill has a couple of things. Clearly Churchill stands for something bigger than himself, which is the story of British resistance in the world wars.
2:44 Speaker 01 I think Churchill also has become a kind of... because of his shape, because of the look and the sound of him, he's a brilliant avatar for Britishness, the kind of bulldog spirit and all of this kind of thing. But, you know, when we did a series on the rest of history about young Churchill, what was so striking for me, reading his book My Early Life and telling the story of him at Harrow and in South Africa and all of this stuff, was the remarkable humanity of the man. Everything is in technicolor, everything is larger than life, he's extremely funny, he's complicated and sometimes he's difficult, but he's often extremely generous.
3:27 Speaker 01 He's endlessly curious, I mean this is one of the amazing things about Churchill. When he was a very young man and he was sent out to India, he decided to kind of educate himself by reading all the great books. And he wrote afterwards, you know, he was delighted for the first time to open Plato's Republic and he said, "You know, there's lots of good stuff in here and most of it I've actually thought of myself already." And I think, you know, especially, so for those of you who haven't read Churchill's Book of My Early Life, which is one of the first books he wrote, it's a really funny, enjoyable read. And that's not necessarily true of a lot of politicians' books. You're probably the only person here who's read Liz Truss's memoir.
4:12 Speaker 02 Every last word.
4:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:17 Speaker 01 Now, most politicians' memoirs are, they, they use sense the sort of pomposity or the vanity or whatever. But Churchill, of course, there's a bit of vanity, but there's a tremendous sort of, an irony, a sense of irony about himself and his own persona that makes him infectious. So in terms of the characters of British history, I think he's clearly up there as one of the most richly enjoyable. But also precisely because he stands for what's become a really defining modern myth, which is standing alone against the Nazis, Dunkirk, the Battle of Britain and so on. I think that puts him in a different league. And I think the only people that really compete with him are your Nelsons, Elizabeth the First, Alfred the Great, maybe there are one or two others. But in terms of elected politicians, I think he probably stands alone.
5:03 Speaker 02 Yeah, he's not our best Prime Minister, but he's our greatest Prime Minister, is how I would put it. He may not even be our best war leader, but he's, the whole picture is just amazing. You talk about the myth of, you know, 1940 and all the rest of it. But he was a constant myth creator, wasn't he? He was kind of very conscious of creating his own myths and, and where he emerged from, this sort of Edwardian kind of world where, you know, big ideas and, you know, big things, you know, Britain was running the world and it kind of cared about that stuff.
5:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, he did, absolutely. I mean, so-
5:35 Speaker 02 Just tell us about that. Tell us about, you know, was Churchill always going to be this kind of character? Did, was he a man of his time in that sense?
5:43 Speaker 01 It's a, it's a good question, I think. So he has a sort of, a sense that a lot of great politicians have, of being a performer on a stage, everybody looking at him and wanting to measure up, kind of diva quality.
5:58 Speaker 01 What did he say famously, "We're all worms, but I believe that I'm a glow worm." And he's sort of always tried to live up to that. For me, actually, one of the remarkable things about Churchill is that if you look at his boyhood, his background, so he's the son of Lord Randolph Churchill and Jenny Jerome, who are terrible parents. Lord Randolph is literally driven mad, possibly by sexually transmitted disease. Jenny Jerome is a monstrous person, an American heiress who marries Lord Randolph. They basically pack Winston off to prep school and then to Harrow. He's often, you know, there are stories, he's not allowed to come home at Christmas, for example, because it will interfere with his mother's affair with an Austrian diplomat.
6:44 Speaker 01 We have letters from him to his mother and father, begging them to come and visit him in Harrow, and they don't come. They in fact write it back to him and say, "Stop sniveling, you brat. You know, you're so wet, you're such a failure, leave us alone."
6:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's loads of good stuff in the Andrew Roberts book on this.
7:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, and the Andrew Roberts book is brilliant on this. And it's actually very moving, and you can see how with a different kind of character, Churchill would have had a tremendous sense of, he could have been a self-pitying, sort of victimhood, all of this stuff. But actually, there's an internal jollity to him, a zest for life, a jauntiness, and I think that propels him.
7:22 Speaker 02 But also a sense of destiny, isn't there?
7:24 Speaker 01 A sense of destiny. There's a wonderful story about him after, I think, even song at Harrow, with another boy, and they went downstairs and they were chatting, and this boy said to him, "What do you think you'd do when you grow up?" And Churchill, and Churchill said, you know, and this boy said, "Well, I'll be probably a diplomat like my father, or maybe a businessman." And Churchill said, you know, he sort of looked misty-eyed into the middle distance and said, "One day, London will be under attack, and it will fall to me to save London and the empire", and all of this. That's just how he spoke when he was 14.
8:02 Speaker 01 So I think you have to have the stage as well as the actor. And the stage is really important. Yeah. So obviously, when Churchill is born in 1874, Britain is top nation. You know, Britain does bestride the world like a colossus. And that means that in the, you know, the 1890s, for example, when he's a young man and he wants to cut his teeth, he is given these wonderfully exotic backgrounds against which to do it. The northwest frontier. He goes to watch the Americans fighting in Cuba. He famously goes to South Africa as a war correspondent. You know, this amazing story of going to South Africa. The sort of, the train is attacked by the Burghs.
8:45 Speaker 01 This shootout on the train where he takes command. He's taken prisoner and then escapes from prison. He's the most wanted man in the Burgh war. Escapes by hiding down a mine that just happens to be run by somebody who's sympathetic to the British cause. Then getting onto another train that takes him to salvation in Mozambique. So if any of you have seen the young Churchill film, you'll remember the scene when he escapes and then the train crosses the border and he's kind of shouting in the air for joy. I mean, this is all true. He mythologized it, of course, and turned it into great newspaper copy and then, you know, books and then the genesis of his political career.
9:29 Speaker 01 But it happened and it wouldn't have happened had he not had the extraordinary good fortune to be born at a point where Britain's world power gave him that possibility. And then I think the cause of the empire and of what he saw as Britain's great destiny, its adventure, its glory, that's what he stood for more than anything else. So when he changes parties, conservative to liberal and then constitutionalist and then back to conservative again, national government and so on. You know, Churchill is very hard to pin down politically. But the one thing that runs through his life and career like a thread is that commitment to the empire. And empire, I think, not in terms of... I think a lot of people get this wrong when they talk about Churchill and empire.
10:14 Speaker 01 I don't think he thinks of it in terms of oppression and subjugation. He thinks of it in terms of... Sort of technicolor adventures, excitement, exoticism and glory. And of course, he sees the colonial peoples. Often, he doesn't give them agency and he sees them merely as supporting characters in a drama in which he and people like him, other public schoolboys, will always have the leading roles. But I don't think it's an inhuman way of thinking about the world.
10:46 Speaker 02 Because this is the grief he gets these days, of course. He's cancelled all the time, you know, people chuck things over his statue outside my office. It's, you know, there's a generational kind of thing here, isn't there, with Churchill? People of sort of older than us remember the empire stuff. People of about our age grew up watching war films and sort of eulogized him for 1940. But it's harder to connect him to sort of people under 40 who didn't grow up watching Where Eagles Dare. I mean, why not? I don't understand personally, but.
11:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, but I think some of this is unfair, actually. So there are very few public figures of Churchill's generation about whom we know more. So almost everything, you know, when Churchill came to your house for dinner or when you met him, it was a great moment because he's an exciting personality. And he says very provocative, outspoken and often outrageous things. And so people would make a note of them. And often Churchill would be showing off. He would be trying to shock. So he would say, you know, things to sort of dinner parties of Edwardian liberals or something about Indians.
12:03 Speaker 01 And I think he would be doing it often deliberately to needle the more bien pensant members of the company.
12:08 Speaker 02 These days, he'd be writing a column in The Spectator like Ronald.
12:11 Speaker 01 Exactly. Well, I mean, we all know columnists who specialise in this. I'm not averse to doing it myself, quite frankly. And I think.
12:23 Speaker 02 One of the most read things, by the way, on The Spectator website in recent weeks was Dominic's claim that we fought on the wrong side in the First World War.
12:30 Speaker 01 Hold on, hold on.
12:36 Speaker 02 The headline may have gone slightly further than the copy.
12:38 Speaker 01 No. No, the headline did not go far enough.
12:44 Speaker 01 We should have fought against terrorists and regicides. We should have, if we had, our ancestral enemies are obviously, everyone in this room knows this, they are friends and neighbours across the channel. This was the chance. Finish them off once and for all.
13:09 Speaker 01 Who doesn't like, who doesn't like a Habsburg-era café?
13:12 Speaker 02 Exactly.
13:13 Speaker 01 Who doesn't like a nice evening with the Kaiser? What's wrong with you, Tim?
13:16 Speaker 02 And when you finish with the quiz tonight, take up arms and let's retake Calais.
13:26 Speaker 03 How did this book begin? There are many starting points, but basically, I think the real starting point is the summer of 2014. I'm in a small village in Austria called Hagenburg, the home of Horst Wächter. You will know Horst if you listen to the BBC series The Rat Line or the book. He is the son of Otto and Charlotte Wächter. Otto Wächter, a major Nazi governor in German-occupied Poland, based in the city of Lviv, hunted after the war for the murder of hundreds of thousands of Poles and Jews and Roma. Escapes, in fact, I've just been talking to the guy who runs SOE expeditions here, explaining
14:11 Speaker 03 how I followed in his tracks over the Dolomites and made my way from Innsbruck to Bolzano on exactly the route he had taken in 1949. And I think he wants to now do an expedition. And I said, yes, yes, I will take that expedition. It'll be brilliant, brilliant thing to do. 1,200 metres to 3,000 metres in the space of two days. And it's beautiful, it's an extraordinary place. So, Horst Wächter, the son of Otto and Charlotte, says to me one day, you know, my family have an archive. My parents kept all of their letters and all of their diaries and all of their photographs and all of their recordings and all of their everythings. Would you like to have access to it?
14:56 Speaker 03 Yes. Is the Pope Catholic? Yes. I would like to have access to it. So he says, "Come, come to my schloss, my castle, very dilapidated. He loves visitors, incidentally, and if any of you were to write to him and say, 'We would love to visit your schloss,' he would actually invite you to visit, and he would take you to the part of the attic which is dedicated to the Nazi period, and you will find his parents' books and diaries and letters and so on and so forth. He gives me access to everything. I use the material to write the Rat Line, the most extensive diaries and private archive of any senior Nazi that has ever been found.
15:40 Speaker 03 It's now publicly available and searchable on the website of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum. Just type in Wächter archive and you can just read the documents for yourselves, mostly in German, but they're there. In the middle of the archive, I come across a letter, three pages, typed, single space, sent to Otto Wächter, who is residing at that time in Rome, in a Vatican-run monastery, on the run from the British, the Americans, the Soviets, and anyone who's out to capture him and put him on trial for mass murder.
16:20 Speaker 03 And the letter is sent from Damascus, Syria. And it says to Otto Wächter, it actually refers to him as Herr Lieber, Lieber Herr Reinhard, because he used a pseudonym, Reinhard, describes life in Damascus and basically says, "Don't come to Syria. Don't escape to the Arab world. It's not a good place for Germans and Austrians. Head either to South Africa or to South America." Wächter dies, three months later, in mysterious circumstances in the Vatican Hospital in Rome.
17:03 Speaker 03 And he doesn't follow the Rat Line to South America. But I get interested in who the writer of the letter is. It's a gentleman called Walter Ralff. Who is Walter Ralff? In 2014, the name rang no bells, but in fact, I would later
17:28 Speaker 03 be pointed out, learn, that I did know the name Walter Ralff. He appears in a book that was a sort of cult book when I was a student in the early 1980s, by a great British travel writer called Bruce Chatwin. And many of you may have, some of you may have read In Patagonia. And if you've got a copy of In Patagonia, go to chapter 96. It's very short, and it's devoted to Walter Ralff.
17:54 Speaker 03 We'll come back to that chapter in due course.
17:59 Speaker 03 So I see the name Walter Ralff as the signatory of this letter to Wächter. I Google him. What do I learn? He had been in the German Navy in the 1930s. He was discharged for adultery. And he then joins the SS in 1937. And he works in the same office as Adolf Eichmann, Heinrich Himmler, Reinhard Heidrich, and so on and so forth. Then in 1941, he is given a special mission by Himmler and Heidrich to design and operate a series of mobile gas vans.
18:43 Speaker 03 Small vans that are fitted to hold up to 50 individuals who will be then driven in them to a location and gassed to death on an industrial scale. It's the sort of precursor to Belzech, Treblinka, Auschwitz, and the extermination camps using gas, killing 300, 400 people. And it operates for two years, until they replace the vans with the large industrial complexes for killing on an even more efficient and industrial scale. And Ralff is charged with operating those gas vans,
19:26 Speaker 03 which kill somewhere between 600,000 and 900,000 people in the space of about a year. And the details are pretty well known. He then... After that is over, heads to North Africa, where he becomes the SS man in charge of Tunisia, until the British retake what is now Tunisia. He's only there for eight or nine months. And he's then posted in Milan to head the Gestapo offices in that city and in that part of Italy, where he engages in further mass killing
20:09 Speaker 03 of Italian partisans, communists, leftists, Jews, and other political opponents of Nazism and Italian fascism. I've spent a lot of time in Milan on his trail. His name is still known today in Milan. And the building that he operated out of, there is a plaque which indicates that it was his office, right by the La Scala Opera House in Milan. So, very notorious figure. He's caught by the British in 1945 and is imprisoned. He escapes and he makes his way to Syria, Damascus,
20:53 Speaker 03 where he heads up a sort of Gestapo operation for the Syrian Secret Service. He's then thrown out of Syria and he decides he'll follow his own advice that he's given to Vechta and head to South America. So he flees with his wife Edith and his two young sons. And they make their way first to Italy and Genoa. And they then sail from Genoa to South America. And they fetch up in the small South American country of Ecuador and live in the capital city of Quito.
21:36 Speaker 03 His first job, unbelievably for the guy who designed and operated the mobile gas vans under the Nazi regime, is as a motor mechanic for the Mercedes-Benz concession in Quito, Ecuador. You couldn't invent these kinds of stories. Life is fantastic. And they make their life there and they expect to stay there indefinitely. Except that in 1956, they meet an absolutely charming, delightful Chilean couple who say to the Raufs, frankly, you're in the wrong country. You should be in our country, Chile. Big
22:18 Speaker 03 German community, we love people like you. And so the Raufs leave and they head for Chile, make a new life. One son enters the army military academy, another son enters the naval academy, and they become military officers. And the parents set up shop in the most southern town in the whole world. It's called Punta Arenas. Has anyone here been to Punta Arenas? Okay, so you'll know, it's sort of an amazing place. It really is worth going. If any of you have a chance to go to Patagonia, it's on the Chilean side.
23:01 Speaker 03 It really, you really feel you are at the end of the world. And I think one of the reasons he chose Punta Arenas was that he felt incredibly safe there. He becomes the manager of a king crab cannery. If you've been to Punta Arenas, you will undoubtedly have eaten something called centoya. They are these literally giant crabs. They're as big as this with their tentacles. They are huge. And there's millions of them around. And there was a fishery called the Pescara Camellio, and he becomes the manager of the Pescara Camellio. And in writing the book, I come to know a lot of the ladies who worked
23:45 Speaker 03 under his sort of directorship. They're now in their 80s, but they remember him very well. They were 16, 17 years old. And they describe graphically.
23:58 Speaker 03 How Ralph would operate, they said he was a very good manager, he had a filthy temper, got very angry sometimes, but he treated them well and respectfully. The tins of crab meat would come down the processing line, ready to be exported to Europe and other parts of the world. And sometimes there'd be bits dangling over the edges of the tin cans. And one of the ladies, Maria, explained to me how she, he would come up to the tin can and he would show them very delicately how you took the leg, you put it over, you took the leg over, you patted it all down.
24:38 Speaker 03 And she would turn to me and say, of course, he had experience doing these kinds of things. They all knew his background. And this is one of the great mysteries, how people could live in that context with someone with that background.
24:58 Speaker 00 Well, that was fantastic, wasn't it? Nothing really beats listening to experts with an audience as well. There's something about the audience that gets the juices flowing. Really brilliant to hear people at the top of the game talking about the things they're interested in. And of course, some robust opinion from Mr. Sandbrook of the Shire. Right, well, if you want to hear the rest of these talks, as well as ours, of other exclusive member content, subscribe now at patreon.com/WeHaveWays. That's patreon.com/WeHaveWays. We'll see you there on the other side of the subscription.
Previous The Visionaries: One War Ends, Another Begins (Part 6) Next A Buffalo Soldier In Italy Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated