Pod Insights WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk The Election Landslide That Changed Britain About this episode What is a Khaki Election? Why did the Labour party win the 1945 General Election in a landslide? How did Clement Atlee beat Winston Churchill in the polls?
Join Al Murray and James Holland as they dissect the pivotal British election held in the closing months of WW2, in which the Conservative grip on power was overturned by the desire for a 'New Jerusalem'.
Listen ad-free on Patreon - sign up at patreon.com/wehaveways
A Goalhanger Production
Produced by James Regan
Exec Producer: Tony Pastor
Social: @WeHaveWaysPod
Email: [email protected]
Join our ‘Independent Company’ to watch exclusive livestreams, get presale ticket events, and our weekly newsletter - packed with book and model discounts.
Membership Club: patreon.com/wehaveways
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. Sign up to our Patreon to receive bonus content, live streams and our weekly newsletter with money off books and museum visits as well, plus early access to all live show tickets. That's patreon.com/WeHaveWays.
0:23 Speaker 00 Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goalhangers, the rest is football. This episode is brought to you by Wise. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate and easy transfer and no surprises along the way. Wise keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no mark-ups
1:07 Speaker 00 or hidden fees. So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee and get on with it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, Ts and Cs apply.
1:21 Speaker 01 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
1:34 Speaker 02 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than real pricing.
1:38 Speaker 03 Born from the intensity of a night in the eternal city. Introducing Born in Roma Fragrances by Valentino. Feminine perfume Donna Born in Roma features juicy black currant, central jasmine, soft cashmerin and warm vanilla. Masculine leaning but unisex Womo has notes of fresh violet leaf, aromatic sage, green vetiver and mineral salt. Shop holiday gifts at macys.com.
2:15 Speaker 04 There can be no doubt that socialism is inseparably interwoven with totalitarianism and the abject worship of the state. Liberty in all its forms is challenged by the fundamental conceptions of socialism. There should be one state to which all are to be obedient in every act of their lives. This state is to be the arts employer, the arts planner, the arts administrator and ruler, and the arts caucus boss. A socialist state, once thoroughly completed in all its details and aspects, could not afford opposition. Socialism is, in its essence, an attack upon the right of the ordinary man or woman to breathe freely without having a harsh, clumsy, tyrannical hand clapped across their mouths and nostrils. But I will go farther.
2:58 Speaker 04 I declare to you, from the bottom of my heart, that no socialist system can be established without a political police. Many of those who are advocating socialism or voting socialist today will be horrified at this idea. That is because they are short-sighted, that is because they do not see where their theories are leading them. No socialist government conducting the entire life and industry of the country could afford to allow free, sharp, or violently worded expressions of public discontent. They would have to fall back on some form of Gestapo, no doubt very humanely directed in the first instance.
3:33 Speaker 05 That was, of course, Winston Churchill. It is June the 4th, 1945 election broadcast.
3:39 Speaker 06 It's literally like he's in the room.
3:41 Speaker 05 And it's extraordinary, isn't it?
3:42 Speaker 06 Yeah. I've got to say, I think your Churchill impersonation's got better.
3:45 Speaker 05 I agree, over the many years, and it's the, you know, he couldn't do his arses.
3:50 Speaker 06 It's a slight lisp, isn't it? Not lisp exactly, a sort of catch in the mouth.
3:54 Speaker 05 He had to really work on his, on his voice and his oratorical expression. But that was, of course, Winston Churchill in 1945. And welcome to We Have Ways of Making You Talk, the Second World War podcast with me, Al Murray, and James Holland, former comedian, according to Private Eye, I am.
4:07 Speaker 06 Yeah, you're not anymore.
4:12 Speaker 05 Yeah, not anymore. I mean, and I think it's apposite that that was an article in Private Eye about Downing Street, and that we're looking at the car key election today.
4:20 Speaker 06 And yes.
4:21 Speaker 05 And I think.
4:22 Speaker 06 I just wanted to reassure you that I still find you funny.
4:24 Speaker 05 Well, that's, that's a relief. I mean, you know, you can always build on a fanbase of one and work up.
4:32 Speaker 06 I rest my case.
4:33 Speaker 05 But I think what's interesting about this part of the story of the Second World War, the Carkey election and the arrival of Labour as finally as a sort of credible political force in British politics.
4:44 Speaker 06 Because. Yes, because there'd been the two Ramsay MacDonald governments, one in the 20s and one in the kind of early half of the 30s. But there was a sense, wasn't there, that while the Labour had become the kind of main opposition, it was still a juvenile party.
4:58 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly.
4:59 Speaker 06 Is a phrase.
5:00 Speaker 05 And had not known which way to jump in the late 1930s. So openly pacifist elements of the party, other parts of the party that had sized the Nazis up, people very much on the left who wanted to accommodate would do what the Soviet Union, would use the Soviet Union as their compass really. So there is the terrible problem on the left when Molotov-Ribbentrop happens in August of 1939, where people on the.
5:22 Speaker 06 Oh, what do we do?
5:23 Speaker 05 On the far left, literally, what do we do? This isn't our war, you know, there is confusion, which is in the trade union movement as much as anywhere else. And of course, you know, the trade union movement is at this point the core to the Labour power as much as anything else and its ability to exert influence during the war itself.
5:38 Speaker 06 But also there's the horns of the buffalo, aren't there?
5:41 Speaker 05 Yeah.
5:41 Speaker 06 The right wing and left wing, that they almost meet again, they sort of curl around and kind of meet again. And the classic example of that is Oswald Mosley, who's a Labour MP, then probably goes over to the dark side and sets up the British Union fascist.
5:53 Speaker 05 Having slithered all over the place and, you know, one point is working with Maynard Keynes on a economic plan.
5:59 Speaker 06 Fascinating.
6:00 Speaker 05 Before Mosley goes fashe, does actually work with him. So there's the peculiar business with Mosley where to some extent he's done his homework. Anyway, the thing about the 1945 election though, it's characterised by lots of different things, isn't it? People think of it as people in the forces swinging it. Certainly there are people in the army who were very unhappy with the work of the Army Educational Board, getting the men to read the Beveridge Report, sitting down and having discussions about what, you know, the new country will be like after the peace.
6:27 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah.
6:27 Speaker 05 People at the top.
6:28 Speaker 06 That is really happening.
6:29 Speaker 05 That is genuinely happening. Of quite how much attention Tommy Atkins at the back picking his nose is paying or how much he's taking in these ideas, obviously we can never know.
6:38 Speaker 06 Well, no, and obviously the people that have been writing diaries and letters are going to be a little bit more kind of of a literary bent and more likely to read it. So it can give a sort of distorted view, but I've certainly read personal accounts of people in Calcutta, you know, getting it and reading it and accounts of people in Sicily reading it. Yeah.
6:57 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly. And and also the officers writing up these army educational board meetings tend to be socially social democrats in their leaning and tend to be leaning in the direction of a Labour government. But the thing to remember about the forty five election, and we got some, there's some polling data we'll look at in a minute. And obviously polling is very, very different in the nineteen forty s. It's Gallup mainly. It's very, very different to our our understanding of polling, the way they develop their samples, the way they ask their questions.
7:23 Speaker 06 Do they? In what way?
7:24 Speaker 05 Oh, it's in its infancy. They're just literally figuring it out.
7:27 Speaker 06 Right, okay.
7:27 Speaker 05 It's a brand new thing. You've got mass observation as well, and they're sort of running alongside one another. And the government are going to mass observation and asking.
7:35 Speaker 06 Well, we should just remind people what mass observation is. So this is set up by post graduates in the nineteen thirty s to gauge the mood of the British public.
7:44 Speaker 05 Yeah.
7:45 Speaker 06 And they encourage people to write diaries and keep diaries and hand them in and not that, you know, they get they get pseudonyms, which they're for each person. And they also do straw polls on the street, asking them sort of, you know, everyday questions. And these are, you can still read all these. All the collections are in the University of Sussex, but
8:00 Speaker 05 That's right.
8:01 Speaker 06 There are published books of them, and they're all just absolutely fascinating.
8:03 Speaker 05 Yeah, and they sit in pubs and listen to what people are saying. They do that as well. They do a lot of eavesdropping.
8:06 Speaker 06 Yes, they do that as well.
8:07 Speaker 05 Which I think is, you know, it's literally man on clapamomni bus, some of it, which I think's really, which is quite interesting. But this is all new and in its infancy. But what is clear is that people like Churchill, but they don't like the Conservative Party. And we know it's a national government. And of course, the great virtue of the nineteen forty s government is it is a national government. And Labour have at least, basically, you can argue that it's at least that installs Churchill. It's at least that goes, all right, fine, in May nineteen forty, the politician we can work with in the Conservative Party is Winston Churchill.
8:37 Speaker 06 Yes. So so what is it particularly about the Conservatives that the masses don't like?
8:41 Speaker 05 Oh, it's their war. They got us into this mess.
8:44 Speaker 06 So it's not that they're all posh red trousers.
8:46 Speaker 05 Well, it's it's all it's all tied up in that. After all, the Tory pitch is the right to rule, isn't it? Is that that we're the we ought to be the people who ought to be in charge, because we've always been in charge. It's a it's a class aspect. And also, yeah, it's their war. They're the party of appeasement. They're the party of the Great Depression, arguably, and the problems with poverty and squalor that Labour have been fighting against in the decades preceding the war. This is a chance to sort of reboot and restart and put the Conservative legacy behind people and Labour are doing this to go legit, to prove they can be part of a working government and the war is an amazing opportunity. But also in political thinking, the war is an opportunity to prove that planning works, that state intervention in the economy works, that, you know, essentially what we would
9:27 Speaker 05 call Keynesianism works, that it's a way of making society run more efficiently and that it's not an intrusion of the state, it's using the state for good.
9:36 Speaker 06 Right.
9:36 Speaker 05 And doing things more efficiently. Labour in their pitch in 1945 are very much talking about, you know, they're not saying socialism ideologically, they're saying it's the logical choice to make society run better, to improve your lives, you need a planned economy, you need things planned and not the way things have been done before, not the old way. And the Tories are absolutely tarred with being the old way of doing things.
9:58 Speaker 06 And what we should just remind everyone is it is the Conservatives obviously that are in power.
10:03 Speaker 05 Yes.
10:03 Speaker 06 They have been elected in power, first with Stanley Baldwin, then he resigns and Chamberlain takes over. Chamberlain is obviously the Neville Chamberlain is the Prime Minister when Britain goes to war in September 1939 and it is the Conservative Party that remains in power until the 10th of May.
10:19 Speaker 05 Yeah.
10:20 Speaker 06 When the 9th of May Chamberlain resigns, there is a new government that needs to be formed and the only way that can be formed is if it becomes a nationalist government, i.e. with representatives from all the three major parties, Liberals, Labour and the Conservatives.
10:34 Speaker 05 Yeah.
10:34 Speaker 06 And Churchill takes over as Prime Minister with a war cabinet of five men, which includes Lord Halifax, who is a Tory peer.
10:43 Speaker 05 Yep.
10:43 Speaker 06 So he's in the House of Lords. Chamberlain, who is obviously no longer Prime Minister, but is still a kind of titan of British politics and Conservative politics and two Labour men, Clement Atlee and Arthur Greenwood.
10:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's right.
10:56 Speaker 06 And the war cabinet changes over the course of the war and the wider government also changes over the course of the war. But Atlee and Greenwood remain in the inner sanctum of power in the nationalist government until 1945 in the Carquie election.
11:09 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's right.
11:10 Speaker 06 So that's just the context for this.
11:11 Speaker 05 Yeah, this has very much been, Labour have refused to work with Chamberlain up till, up till this point, have refused to come. Into a national government, once war breaks out, and this is their opportunity. So that, and it's very much their approval that get, that means that Churchill can be PM.
11:23 Speaker 06 Exactly.
11:24 Speaker 05 It is a coming together, the major political parties in the, in the British state, but it is also Labour going, okay, if you want to proceed, you're going to have to include us. And they're grabbing, grabbing them over because the thing to remember is these people are politicians and they're after power. Because of course they are, it's not.
11:38 Speaker 06 But they also proved very effective of it. And one of the things that, that's really important when you're going to form a government is you do need people who know what they're talking about. And you, you need people of experience. Without want to get too political, this is one of the sort of the headaches for reform is that they don't have anyone who has any experience. So should they suddenly in four years' time suddenly get to power, they wouldn't have anyone with any ministerial experience whatsoever. But, but you know, that, that is, you know, regardless of what one's politics are, that's quite an issue. But suddenly what you've got is, you know, Atlee and Greenwood and others prove themselves to be incredibly competent in, in the nationalist government. You know, they do really, really good stuff.
12:10 Speaker 05 Yeah.
12:10 Speaker 06 As do frankly, some of the Liberal ministers as well.
12:12 Speaker 05 But this is what's interesting about Churchill though is because although Churchill's a busted flush politically within the Conservative Party, he is deeply experienced. No, he was Chancellor of Exchequer, he was Minister for Armaments in the First World War and before that, and he'd been at the Admiralty. He is hugely experienced.
12:25 Speaker 06 And of the emissary, I think as well.
12:26 Speaker 05 Exactly. So he's coming in with competence. The fact that his party really doesn't like him is a different matter and it's.
12:32 Speaker 06 Yeah, he's an outlier, isn't he?
12:33 Speaker 05 Yeah. And he absolutely has to work to fix relationships with the party. Him being massively popular obviously helps and he has huge public popularity. Again, backbench MPs behave the way they always have done. If they've got a very popular leader, they'll back him, won't they? If the public really like the leader, they'll swing around behind him. And Churchill's relationship with the Tory party has to sort of alter. And in 1940, after all, he's not leader of the party until after Chamberlain's death. Chamberlain remains leader of the Conservative Party until he dies.
13:00 Speaker 06 Yes, he does. Yeah. In November 1940.
13:02 Speaker 05 Exactly. And then Churchill, all right, fine, I'll become a leader of the party.
13:06 Speaker 06 If I have to.
13:06 Speaker 05 Yeah. Yeah. And because Churchill's been picking, not only has he crossed the floor to the Liberals, he came back. So they, they really don't like him.
13:12 Speaker 06 Well, he starts his parliamentary career as a Liberal.
13:14 Speaker 05 Yeah.
13:14 Speaker 06 And he's, you know, he's a, you know, he's a home secretary, isn't he? In the, in the 1910s.
13:18 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
13:19 Speaker 06 He's, because he sets up Labour exchanges.
13:21 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's right. And he's responsible for National Insurance in its embryonic form as well with Lloyd George. Look, any. Politician who's been around as long as Winston Churchill will have worn many, many hats. But the fact is, is by 1940, you know, he's backed Edward the Eighth, he's backed Indian independence. He's refused Indian independence as an idea. These are toxic positions, one way or another. His stroke of fortune is he's right about Nazi Germany. He's right about the threat, you know. The way things move and change. Anyway, but the point is, if you look at the opinion polling data from 1943 to 1945, like Gallup, the Tories tend to be from July 43 all the way through to the election, or there's a swing up in the polling just before the Carke election. In July 43, they're on 33%, 31%,
14:03 Speaker 05 31.5 in December 43, January 44, 28%, 27.5 in February 45. So that they're having a rough ride and Labour tend to be around 47, 45%.
14:17 Speaker 06 Which is huge.
14:18 Speaker 05 Yeah, across that whole period. And in our system, first past the post, that's a great big express train coming at you, isn't it?
14:25 Speaker 06 That's amazing. The lowest they get to is 45%.
14:28 Speaker 05 Yeah.
14:28 Speaker 06 Percent. This is Labour.
14:30 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
14:31 Speaker 06 Lowest they get is 45% in June 1945 and January 1944.
14:36 Speaker 05 Isn't that interesting? Yeah, it's amazing, isn't it? And the Liberals, of course, have undergone this thing where the, where the party has imploded completely when, when the general franchise comes in after the First World War. The best they do is 15%, the worst they do is sort of 10.5%.
14:48 Speaker 06 Yeah.
14:49 Speaker 05 Which means the Labour lead is generally double figures. It narrows as the, as the end of the war comes and the election approaches. But then when the election actually happens, the lead widens again.
14:58 Speaker 06 13.5% lead.
15:00 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah. It's not a spoiler, this. Labour get 49.7% of the vote in the Carke election.
15:05 Speaker 06 I mean, that's a huge number. I mean, that's a landslide.
15:07 Speaker 05 That's a crushing landslide. It's quite clear that the public are now as radical as they ever have been.
15:13 Speaker 06 Well, economic crisis and war do tend to do, throw politics up into the air and.
15:18 Speaker 05 Well, but it's interesting that in this instance, they turn left, you know, other, other populations have turned right in, in those sets of circumstances, haven't they? Radicalized around a different, around a different issue. Basically, what the war's done is it's ended the sort of, the case against state intervention and state planning. There's a case against it the whole time in the 30s, the political arguments in the 30s. There's an idea that socialism is a bad thing. And by 1945, people think, well, maybe it's not. Maybe nationalisation is the way forward.
15:44 Speaker 06 Well, I think for so many people, you know, the concept of socialism is kind of, you know, just quarter of an inch left, you know, to the right of communism. Of course, it's not.
15:53 Speaker 05 Yeah.
15:54 Speaker 06 It's not, it's not as extreme as that. And socialism in 1945 is not, it's a very different beast. It's about slightly more centralised control. It's about greater share of wealth and so on.
16:06 Speaker 05 There's a lot of nationalisation in things.
16:09 Speaker 06 Yes. What is the principle behind nationalisation?
16:11 Speaker 05 Well, basically, you take the railways into public ownership. So you take them off the old L N R.
16:15 Speaker 06 Why would your voting man think that's a good idea?
16:18 Speaker 05 It's going to work better. I mean, this is interesting because 54% of respondents are in favour of nationalising rail. So that kind of maps pretty, that maps over the Labour 47%, doesn't it? It's higher. 26% of people are opposing. And this is in the era of is your journey really necessary? You know, where basically they're trying to tell you not to travel by train. I mean.
16:39 Speaker 06 Why?
16:40 Speaker 05 Well, because then you're clogging it up.
16:42 Speaker 06 Oh, I see.
16:43 Speaker 05 Only necessary journeys, Jim.
16:44 Speaker 06 Because there aren't that many cars. The roads aren't all Tom Macadam at this point. And they're just, the railways are just overwhelmed by the huge amount of people that are using them, going in and out of cities.
16:54 Speaker 05 But it's quite a sales pitch, isn't it? Is your journey really necessary? Please don't take the train if you could possibly avoid it.
16:59 Speaker 06 That's amazing.
17:00 Speaker 05 But you do have, 56% of the population, they want radical reform and they want society to be rebuilt. Once you're over half, it's irresistible, isn't it, politically?
17:09 Speaker 06 But how much do you really think the Beveridge Report makes a difference?
17:13 Speaker 05 Well.
17:13 Speaker 06 Because I know about the queues going around the sort of, you know, His Majesty's Stationery Office building in Whitehall, you know, waiting for it to be published and everyone wanting to read it. But, you know, does it have a really big impact?
17:24 Speaker 05 Yeah, it does. Absolutely does.
17:25 Speaker 06 It does, doesn't it?
17:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, and people who were able to listen to me have a real wormhole chat with Kit Covel about this. Is that it comes after Alamein, Jim.
17:31 Speaker 06 Yeah.
17:32 Speaker 05 Timing is everything in politics.
17:34 Speaker 06 And of course.
17:34 Speaker 05 The Beveridge Report materialises just after Alamein. So there's this feeling that we've turned a corner. We can win this. We know how to win now. And so we can look beyond.
17:45 Speaker 06 Yes, because it's published at the very. Beginning of January, isn't it? And it goes to the Parliament about that time. Yeah. November, I think it is, is when it's presented to Parliament, isn't it? Forty-two.
17:53 Speaker 05 So what you've got is this sense of we're now going forward. And so what is the piece to be? And, you know, it performs that dual function is that Jonathan Fennell talks about is that it performs a dual function. It says to the citizen and the soldier and his family what the deal is now, what what's to come. And Beveridge is very clever, like basically including everybody in the idea. So he does say, you know, this is the, it's not a bottomless pit. This is the thing you've got to pay into. So if you're a Tory, you aren't going, it's something for nothing. It's just one great big freebie.
18:21 Speaker 06 No, sure. And and how much do you think the kind of sort of flattening of of class structure had played a part in the war? Because, you know, suddenly you have got grammar school boys as officers and and so on. And you've also got public school boys in the ranks.
18:33 Speaker 05 I think that commingling is incredibly important. It's kind of like there's a social democratic experiment going on as a result of conscripting vast chunks of people.
18:41 Speaker 06 Yes, but I also wonder whether a lot of it is also to do with the interaction with other troops.
18:45 Speaker 05 Yeah.
18:46 Speaker 06 You know, I I mean, Australians and and New Zealanders are nothing like as deferential to officers as they are in the in the British Army.
18:53 Speaker 05 Yeah.
18:53 Speaker 06 Ditto Canadians.
18:54 Speaker 05 Yeah.
18:54 Speaker 06 And of course, particularly so Americans. And of course, what the British public and British Armed Forces are also seeing in the Americans is is a highly modernized world. I mean, you know, America is the most modern country in the world. Britain might have started the war with the largest empire and the largest trading empire and and consider itself top dog. But it's hard to sustain that when you're seeing Americans with their modern clothes, their modern kit, chewing gum, you know, nylons and lots of money.
19:19 Speaker 05 And also, your propaganda has swung wholly behind the Soviet Union.
19:24 Speaker 06 Right. From from a nation point of view, you're suddenly more left leaning.
19:27 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah. And you're saying the Soviet Union isn't so bad after all. And in fact, a great big planned economy is delivering incredible results. Look at their sacrifice. These left wing ideas are clearly something to believe in. And there's there's such sympathy for the Soviet Union. And we we talked about this, uh, the other day. You know, the idea that you'd turn the war around and fight the Soviets at the end of the Second World War.
19:46 Speaker 06 Yeah, forget it.
19:47 Speaker 05 Forget it, because people love them. They love them at this point and they love them. They so it's being exposed to all these other things. And also, I think you really can't underestimate. The shadow of the failure of Dunkirk, the initial ruling class entry into the war is a failure.
20:04 Speaker 06 And that comes on top of the First World War, the slaughter.
20:06 Speaker 05 Exactly.
20:07 Speaker 06 The, the ruling class leading, leading the nation into this, out of this golden age.
20:11 Speaker 05 Exactly.
20:12 Speaker 06 You know, Edwardian Britain, and you've got that, then you've got, then you've got economic downturns in the 1920s. You know, the general strike of 1926, then you've got the Wall Street crash and the, and the depression and the class divides in the 1930s are more stark than they've ever been before.
20:26 Speaker 05 Well, and they're the language of politics on the left as well, that they, they speak explicitly in class terms in a way that we don't anymore. Then, then, you know, the ruling class get you into another war and then Dunkirk is such a disaster and guilty men, you know, Michael Foot, after all.
20:39 Speaker 06 Yes, yes, yes.
20:40 Speaker 05 And the, the influence of guilty men, guilty men sets the tone, I think. And then the way the war runs and there are all these different things that are in the, in the mix of what leads the public in the, in the direction they're going. In January, 1945, although people are leaning against the Conservative Party, 72% of people are satisfied with the government's conduct to the war and particularly Churchill's personal popularity. So as they go into this election, they've got this terrible, terrible dilemma, the Tories, which is that people really like Winston Churchill.
21:09 Speaker 06 But they hate them.
21:10 Speaker 05 But they hate them.
21:11 Speaker 06 I, I wonder whether, whether what you're seeing in, in the carceral election of 1945 is this, is suddenly everything coming together.
21:18 Speaker 05 Yeah.
21:19 Speaker 06 The residual blame for the slaughter of the First World War, even though Britain came out victorious.
21:23 Speaker 05 Yeah.
21:23 Speaker 06 The, the kind of economic downturns in the 1930s, the, the sense even before 1939 that the British Empire is, is very much on the way, Free India and all the rest of it and so on, that reaches Britain. So you've got a softening of, of class structures already. Then you have the softening of class structures because of the democratization of the war and the fact that, you know, everyone's needed and so people are rubbing shoulders in a way that they perhaps weren't before the war. Then you have the kind of interaction with overseas troops, international troops, and especially so the Americans. And you've got the fact that you've had a Labour government, Labour politicians involved in the government. Add it all together and the sense that the world has changed irreversibly by the experience of the war. And after all, let, let's not forget it is the most cataclysm it was.
22:06 Speaker 06 The world has ever known and Britain has been in the forefront right from the start, right to the end. Add all that together, suddenly you've got a perfect storm if you're the Conservatives, you know, and it suddenly it doesn't seem quite so surprising after all.
22:19 Speaker 05 Well, that's a very good point though, Jim, that you say it is the most cataclysmic war. Because in my lifetime, the Falklands War is a thing I remember from when I was like 14, right? And that changed absolutely everything. And that's like five weeks.
22:29 Speaker 06 Safe Thatcher, didn't it?
22:30 Speaker 05 Safe Thatcher, completely. And embedded the Thatcherite revolution in government as a result. And that's very, very small beer by comparison.
22:38 Speaker 06 Led to Jilly Cooper novels and everything.
22:39 Speaker 05 Exactly. So, so basically what happens, there's going to have to be an election.
22:44 Speaker 06 Yeah.
22:44 Speaker 05 You have this incredible thing where Max Beaverbrook says to Churchill, he says, we should have a referendum, not call an election. Because he's only really talking to Beaverbrook and Brendan Bracken. That's where he's getting his political advice. He's not engaged with public opinion at all. He's not really been interested. Because he's got, as he sees it, bigger fish to fry, really. We all know why we're in this war. Too bad. I'm not going to pay attention to stuff. The public like him, but not the party. They feel it's time for a change. Everything's being skewed left by the experience of the war. So we'll take a break. We'll come back and look at the, what campaign strategies the party's adopted.
23:16 Speaker 01 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
23:30 Speaker 02 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
23:33 Speaker 03 Born from the intensity of a night in the eternal city. Introducing Born in Roma fragrances by Valentino. Feminine perfume Donna Born in Roma features juicy black currant, central jasmine, soft cashmerin and warm vanilla. Masculine leaning but unisex womo has notes of fresh violet leaf, aromatic sage, green vetiver and mineral salt. Shop holiday gifts at Macy's.com.
24:02 Speaker 07 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot designed to keep you connected. Powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
24:38 Speaker 05 Welcome back to We Have Ways Of Making You Talk, where we're getting to grips. We don't normally do politics, do we? So let's look at the campaign strategies that the parties adopted. So the Conservative Party's campaign is Conservative Party, what Conservative Party? They don't campaign. Churchill campaigns on a national ticket. He just leaves them out of the, you know, out of the whole thing.
25:00 Speaker 06 And the Conservative Party.
25:02 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly.
25:02 Speaker 04 Like you're...
25:03 Speaker 06 It's like sort of muttered very quietly.
25:04 Speaker 04 And his manifesto is Winston Churchill's declaration of policy to the electors.
25:09 Speaker 05 And the slogan is...
25:11 Speaker 04 Vote national, help him finish the job.
25:14 Speaker 06 So they just don't even mention the Conservative Party at all?
25:19 Speaker 06 Okay, that suggests they know they've got a problem.
25:21 Speaker 05 Oh, they know. They know. They know. They know. But they're thinking, he's so popular, right?
25:26 Speaker 06 And Max Beaverbrook is saying, don't do it because you're going to lose.
25:28 Speaker 05 Well, first of all, Beaverbrook, like I said, just thinks...
25:30 Speaker 06 Become a dictator.
25:31 Speaker 05 Become a dictator. I mean, yes, JR, our producer, just popped up. If you think of him as an independent candidate, he actually did very well versus party politics. Yeah, as a one man band, he plays the best tunes, doesn't he? But, you know, campaign meetings have him in his military uniform. He does mass rallies touring the country. Although there's a fair deal of heckling and booing and stuff going on, you know, it's quite lively. He has backing from Beaverbrook's papers, the Express, the Evening Standard, News of the World. And it's all about the dangers of Labour's welfare state and socialism.
26:02 Speaker 06 Yes, and a new Gestapo.
26:04 Speaker 05 And the Gestapo gaff, which we'll get to in a minute. And what's interesting, though, if you read it, don't read it because I've done it for you, ladies and gentlemen. It does include, this is interesting, "A promise to create a comprehensive health service, covering the whole range of medical treatment, from the general practitioner to the specialist, and from the hospital to convalescence and rehabilitation, and to reintroduce legislation for this purpose in the new parliament."
26:23 Speaker 06 So the idea that the Labour Party have hijacked the Beveridge Report and the Conservatives haven't is nonsense.
26:28 Speaker 05 Yeah, really. But Labour are more associated with those ideas. Labour are more associated with the idea of a clean sweep. They are better positioned and they've done a better job of positioning themselves. But they're better positioned.
26:38 Speaker 06 Got it.
26:38 Speaker 05 But it's interesting, you know, there is a pledge for a national health service. But what is lacking is it's not saying from the cradle to the grave. It's got none of the political... Greece around it to sell it in. And anyway, no one trusts the Conservative Party anymore. They they might trust him. And they ignore the record of the Conservative Party and leave it out. There's nothing, nothing in the manifesto about their actual record. It's whereas Labour are able to associate themselves with the success in the war of planning in a planned economy and and that idea. And then I think we can't leave the Soviet Union out of this in terms of the idea that maybe it does work, maybe socialism does work, because, look, they're winning.
27:12 Speaker 06 Yeah. And there is the Gestapo gap as well, which you mentioned in the
27:16 Speaker 05 Yeah, which I read in the thing at the start.
27:17 Speaker 06 When you, when you brought Churchill back into the room.
27:19 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly. There's lots of argument about how significant this is, but it does encapsulate how out of touch he is. You just can't.
27:26 Speaker 06 You can't talk in those terms, can you, at this stage after the
27:29 Speaker 05 No, you can't. And and things have been pretty fruity.
27:32 Speaker 06 The British are a mild and moderate people. They don't put up with people like Gestapo.
27:36 Speaker 05 Well, we don't do revolution and extremism, although part of the situation here is that it's Labour that's pulled the plug on the national government. After VE Day, there's a party conference at the end of May and they go, we can't, now the war with Germany is over, we cannot continue as part of this government. It's got to change. There's been too much water under the bridge. We've got to change. And they really, by the end of the war, they really hate being in coalition as part of the national government. The Labour, Labour people really don't like it. They find it frustrating. They're like, we need to be set free to do our own thing and the war is holding us up. And they very much feel like that. So when they, you know, they aren't going to wait for the end of the war in Japan, because after all, how long will that be? Just because, and it's the thing we've gone on about in our, in our victory in Europe stuff, just because we know it's three months, they certainly don't think that in May 1945. If you're a, you know, trade union official,
28:21 Speaker 05 you don't think that, you, you know, of course, you don't know about the
28:23 Speaker 06 Absolutely.
28:24 Speaker 05 Atlee, though, deals with the Gestapo broadcast the next evening, and it's really clever what he says.
28:29 Speaker 06 Yes, brilliant.
28:30 Speaker 05 It highlights the contrast between Winston Churchill, the great leader in a war of a United Nation, and Mr Churchill, the party leader of the Conservatives. So bam, there you go.
28:42 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah.
28:42 Speaker 05 That's who he is, folks. He's a Tory. You know, lots of people think, well, he's just, he's just basically torched his entire reputation as a national leader by coming down into party politics. He's no longer statesman, he's just another politician. And actually, lots of people all over the country remember as unreliable, as
29:00 Speaker 06 Yeah.
29:00 Speaker 05 difficult and having a tattered reputation in the 30s. I mean, it's interesting, though. Julian Amory is so impressed with this rebuttal, he thinks, he wonders whether he's a Conservative at all, you know? Chips Channon reports that his colleagues are cockerhoop at Churchill's speech. Because Chips Channon is wrong about everything.
29:18 Speaker 06 Absolutely everything, isn't he?
29:19 Speaker 05 He's completely reliable. If you want an arrow pointing at directly the wrong opinion, Chips Channon will be the man to fire it.
29:25 Speaker 06 Reliably, every time.
29:26 Speaker 05 Every single time. There's Cuthbert Hedlam, who's a veteran Tory MP from Newcastle. I mean, what's interesting is places we think of as solid Labour from way back are solid Tory. You know, working class, the working class Tory vote is a very real thing in the 1990s and 1930s. And he says he thought the speech might have not appealed to the sensible people, but nonetheless recognised there are a few, there are a few sensible people. And that the party's rank and file would no doubt welcome a good fighting speech. And there you have an example, and we, we, we've seen this in recent years where a leader appeals to his party, but not to the country. And then he's amazed when the country says, no, thanks.
30:05 Speaker 06 Yeah.
30:05 Speaker 05 We've had a lot of that in politics and speaking to your party in a time of a general election is generally a waste of time. You've got to speak to everybody, haven't you?
30:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, of course.
30:13 Speaker 05 So to see Churchill, who so many people regard as a consummate politician, making such a basic error, I think is quite, quite interesting. And there's Major David Renton, who's running as a National Liberal candidate in Huntingdonshire. He thought the speech was simply a joke.
30:29 Speaker 06 Amazing.
30:29 Speaker 05 There's mixed views. And the thing is, is no one really knows how this lands. Forty nine percent of the people are reported listening to Churchill's broadcast during the election, but we don't really know how it lands. And anyway, I think the thing we've seen in the polling data is people's minds are made up, right? You know, and you, you look at our last general election here, people had made their minds up that the Tory government, the Sunak government had to go. And so the sort of, the wobbles and errors, I mean, I think him leaving D day early made him look foolish, but he was already toast. And so the Gestapo gaffe, you can probably weigh like that, that Churchill, they've had it, the Tories have had it by this point.
31:06 Speaker 06 Yeah. Yeah, I can't see how this would have made it. I think this is just sort of, you know, it's icing on the cake stuff.
31:11 Speaker 05 Yeah, it underlines it, it, it doesn't it? And then Labour's campaign, it's an active campaign and it's focused on social reform, housing, debt, rebuilding the country.
31:19 Speaker 06 Well, let's not forget that, you know, half the country's in ruins. I mean, all the cities, it seems still great, huge amount of rubble.
31:24 Speaker 05 Yeah.
31:25 Speaker 06 You know, the last V2 is in March.
31:27 Speaker 05 Yep.
31:27 Speaker 06 Um, I think in Beckenham in Kent.
31:29 Speaker 05 Yep.
31:29 Speaker 06 You know, so it's incredibly recent that they've been under fire.
31:33 Speaker 05 Yeah.
31:33 Speaker 06 The country is rundown, worn out.
31:37 Speaker 06 Looking bashed about, a shadow of its former glorious past, and a party that's saying, you know, we're going to rebuild Britain in a kind of new, new world. That's exciting, isn't it?
31:45 Speaker 05 New Jerusalem.
31:47 Speaker 06 Yeah, New Jerusalem.
31:48 Speaker 05 Yeah.
31:49 Speaker 06 And so you completely see, they're also holding large meetings, aren't they? And they're canvassing industrial areas and union halls.
31:56 Speaker 05 That's right.
31:56 Speaker 06 And again stressing postal housing, job security, you know, a proper land fit for heroes rather than
32:03 Speaker 05 Yeah.
32:03 Speaker 06 The empty promises of
32:05 Speaker 05 The First World War.
32:05 Speaker 06 1918.
32:07 Speaker 05 Yeah, Bevins, you know, touring, Ernie Bevins, he's touring constituencies, he recounts the condition of the working man. So basically what he's saying is we're not going back to the 30s, we're not going back to poverty, we're not going back to the way things were. I think what's interesting though, is absolutely every single person in this election campaigning at that level, the people who've been cabinet ministers or been ministers, they know actually that when the peace comes, how broke the country is and how little room for manoeuvre they've really got. And they know that-
32:34 Speaker 06 The last thing you want to do is be in power.
32:36 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly.
32:37 Speaker 06 Let some other mug deal with it.
32:39 Speaker 05 Well, exactly. They know rationing's going to have to continue. They know austerity is going to be the order of the day. And yet they are also at the same time going around promising a new Jerusalem. So that's politics though, right? I think it's very interesting that all of these people know perfectly well, like what a fix they're in, what a bind they're in, but they're going to campaign for this bold future. And the Labour campaign centres on its manifesto, it's called Let Us Face The Future Together, and they build that idea around the Beveridge Welfare Programme of dealing with want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness, as he called them.
33:10 Speaker 06 And they're promising full employment, aren't they? Free secondary education, National Health Service, of course, famously, you know, finally introduced by Nye Bevins, nationalisation of key industries. And they're emphasising, you know, their own competence and their own unity, but also the fact that they have been in government, it gives them, you know, they've now got experience, you know, Atley and others who've been involved in the wider cabinet as well as the war cabinet, you know, they can bring that experience to bear.
33:36 Speaker 05 And their campaign also completely leans into the Tory dilemma. Cheer Churchill, Vote Labour is one of their slogans.
33:45 Speaker 05 I mean, it's cheeky. It's good, though.
33:47 Speaker 06 It's cheeky, but good.
33:48 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's all about winning the peace. Then the Liberal, the Liberal Party is Archibald Sinclair. And if people look up what Archibald Sinclair, Archibald Sinclair looks like, so archetypical of a smooth British Liberal politician from the middle of the 20th century.
34:02 Speaker 06 He was very good. He was very good as Minister for Air.
34:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. But basically, they campaign as moderates who've supported the national government. They run a low-key campaign. They're overshadowed by the two main parties. And it's the absolutely classic Liberal campaign, this. Sinclair loses his seat, but 800,000 more people vote Liberal. But because they've got first past the post, they're poor spread, they gain fewer seats. So it's the classic Liberal thing of they get a swing to them, but it amounts to nothing.
34:30 Speaker 06 Yeah.
34:31 Speaker 05 You know, so hanging over all of this, as I mentioned a moment ago, is that everyone knows, everyone in politics knows the country's broke. They know whatever promises they make are going to result in the continuation of rationing, price controls, and all the other wartime strictures the country's faced.
34:43 Speaker 06 They know they're in for a long haul.
34:44 Speaker 05 They know they're in for the long haul. But 84% of voters of poll before the election have made up their minds.
34:50 Speaker 06 That's amazing.
34:51 Speaker 05 It is, isn't it? It's incredible. One thing we need to talk about is the electorate. There's not been a general election since 1935. That's the other thing to remember.
34:59 Speaker 06 10 years.
35:00 Speaker 05 10 years. Chamberlain had no mandate, as we would see it. Churchill had no mandate, which is part of the argument for having an election, to refresh the mandate. There's 8 million new voters who've come into play since the last general election.
35:13 Speaker 06 Just so everyone knows, you know, Britain's population is about 44 million in 1945.
35:18 Speaker 05 Exactly. And it's people, men and women over 21, who could vote. As I said, the last general election was in 1935. So you've had a whole generation coming of age during the war, while these arguments we've been talking about have been playing themselves out. And I think that's really significant, too, into what happens in the electorate. And you need a residential qualification for election on January 31st, 1945.
35:35 Speaker 06 Yeah, well, that's a bit awkward, isn't it?
35:37 Speaker 05 Yeah, because people have been bombed out.
35:38 Speaker 06 Yeah. And also, and if you've been in the army for four years and you've been all round, you haven't got home.
35:43 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah. And two thirds of service personnel are entitled to cast a vote. And two thirds of those who are entitled to cast a vote do cast a vote.
35:51 Speaker 06 That's amazing, isn't it?
35:52 Speaker 05 Yeah.
35:52 Speaker 06 Because I guess if you've got to be 21 to vote. You've got loads of eighteen and nineteen rolls and twenty rolls.
35:57 Speaker 05 Exactly. So, so, so, which I think.
36:00 Speaker 06 They've been fighting for it, they're not allowed to fight.
36:01 Speaker 05 Exactly, which, which I think chips away a little at the idea that it's the services who win it. Because after all, there's a whole lot of people who are, who are in, who have no voice, which is, which is amazing. Particularly if you're now, from our point of view, eighty years later, painting it as a war for democracy. Well, hold on a minute, you know, Tommy Atkins, nineteen in Burma, has no vote. There's always ironies to, to look at. And then, for instance, so in Plymouth, you have fifteen percent of the electorate are service personnel. So that's enough to swing a seat, right?
36:31 Speaker 06 Yep.
36:31 Speaker 05 Lower rates elsewhere where the population's in flux, because after all, the population is in flux because people have been bombed out. They're moving and, and people are moving all the time because of the, having to move house because of the war. So of the twenty five million, eighty five thousand nine hundred and seventy eight men and women who voted in nineteen forty five, only one million seven hundred and one thousand, so six point eight percent were in the services.
36:53 Speaker 06 That's interesting, isn't it? I would have thought it seemed it was more than that.
36:56 Speaker 05 Yeah, well, but that's because, as I said, two thirds of the people in the services are entitled to vote, two thirds do vote. So that chips away at the, the bigger figure, right?
37:04 Speaker 06 Yep.
37:04 Speaker 05 And there's all these youngsters we were talking about. One of the arguments you will read is that nevertheless, it's the families a part of the picture. Labour has an advert of, one of their adverts is let them finish the job with new houses and jobs. You have this idea, and it's Jonathan Fennell who particularly makes this argument. It's not just the soldier who's voting, he's writing home to his family and saying, vote Labour please. He's writing to his family, his family are in, his family are also part of this phenomenon of the, of the army educational board educating people. You know, the sort of outbreak of socialism in the army. It's not just the soldiers, it's their families and it's the, you know, it's the, it's the idea that they're working towards something new together as a people. There's a cartoon of a Tommy in the Daily Mirror, offering a wreath labelled Peace and Victory in Europe, and he's all patched up.
37:48 Speaker 05 And he's saying here, here you are, don't lose it again. So there's very much this, this idea. There's a letter from an NCO in, in Italy that says.
37:56 Speaker 06 Yeah, I love this, this is brilliant, isn't it?
37:57 Speaker 05 Will you read it, go on?
37:59 Speaker 06 Yeah, for God's sake, if you have to vote before I arrive, don't give it to the government. Vote for the Labour candidate, even if he's only a rag and bone merchant.
38:08 Speaker 06 Well, we know how much Tommies were enjoying the Italian campaign.
38:11 Speaker 05 Yeah, well, there we are, there we are. It's interesting that this takes anyone by surprise, I think. People now go, how on earth could Winston Churchill lose an election at the end of the Second World War? Well, well, well, you know.
38:21 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, yeah. You've brilliantly unpicked this and, you know, it seems amazing that he could even have hoped to have won it.
38:27 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly. There's tons in play. And then, of course, and it's interesting though, isn't it? Britain can hold a general election in 1945.
38:34 Speaker 06 Yeah, no, no, it's really, really impressive, I think.
38:36 Speaker 05 It's extraordinary, isn't it?
38:38 Speaker 06 Yeah, it really is. It's, you know, because actually holding an election, you know, does require campaigning, but it also requires casting votes and, you know, those votes have to be organised.
38:46 Speaker 05 And electoral roll and.
38:47 Speaker 06 And electoral roll and all that kind of malarkey. With all the dislocation that's happened, it's absolutely incredible.
38:53 Speaker 05 Yeah.
38:53 Speaker 06 And it happens pretty seamlessly, doesn't it? All things considered.
38:56 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
38:57 Speaker 06 Yeah. So the candidates, there's a total of 1,683 candidates. They're standing for 640 seats.
39:04 Speaker 05 Yep.
39:04 Speaker 06 624 national.
39:08 Speaker 06 Conservative, 604 Labour, 307 Liberals, 23 Commonwealthers and 21 Communists. With a remainder, they're independents and independent Labour partiers and Scottish Irish and Welsh nationalists and what have you. But, but a sample of Conservative and Labour candidates suggests that there are quite a lot of common characteristics.
39:26 Speaker 05 Yeah.
39:26 Speaker 06 Overwhelmingly male, you know, Nancy Astor, you know, broke the mould in the 1920s, but hasn't done much more than that. Fewer than 5% of women. And relatively young, which I think is interesting. Average age 46.
39:37 Speaker 05 Yeah.
39:38 Speaker 06 That's actually younger than I would have.
39:39 Speaker 05 Yeah, yes, you think of them as old.
39:41 Speaker 06 50s and 60s because you'd have thought a lot of the 40s would be away, away in the war, wouldn't you?
39:46 Speaker 05 Yeah.
39:46 Speaker 06 Um, half had seen military service, which I, again, I think is, is interesting, isn't it?
39:51 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah. Well, 24 MPs lose their lives during the war in uniform, so.
39:56 Speaker 06 Including Flash Kellett, the former commander of the Sherwood Rangers Ermanshary when they go out to Palestine in 1940. He's killed in Tunisia in early 1943.
40:04 Speaker 05 Yeah. And then the outcome is Labour winner, historic landslide, 393 seats, the Conservatives 197.
40:11 Speaker 06 I mean, that's.
40:11 Speaker 05 It's entirely emphatic, 12 point slip swing, one of the largest ever. You know, the the analysis is that that Labour planned very well for this election and it's their appeal to post-war ideals. More convincing than the Conservative call to finish the war. It's about winning the peace, rebuilding Britain. You know, you've got Labour on 49.7% of the vote, as we said at the start, the Tories on 36.2% of the vote. The Liberals on 9% of the vote, losing losing seats. And in Churchill's seat in Woodford, an independent got 10,000 votes.
40:45 Speaker 06 That's absolutely amazing, isn't it?
40:47 Speaker 05 So there is pushback.
40:47 Speaker 06 It is a shock for Churchill, isn't it?
40:49 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah, absolutely. He's he's completely.
40:51 Speaker 06 Well, not least because it means he now has to come back from the Potsdam Conference and hand over to Atlee.
40:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, and all that power, you know, and his personal management of that level of the very high level of things, gone. It is as dramatic, isn't it, I think, as Roosevelt to Truman, this change?
41:06 Speaker 06 Yes, yes, and I and I think and I also think it's a not dissimilar scale in terms of both Churchill and Roosevelt have this enormous, you know, geopolitical understanding, they're men of the world, they understand international politics and how the world goes around. And they both have, you know, Churchill's strong arm slightly into the into the Atlantic Treaty, but but buys into the Rooseveltian post-war vision for a kind of long-term peace. There's absolutely no question about it, you know, champion of of freedoms and liberalism and all the rest of it. But Atlee is also, despite being in the war cabinet, is also, you know, first and foremost, a domestic politician, just as as Truman was,
41:44 Speaker 06 and has to kind of man up and kind of snatch the kind of the seriousness of the situation, the the critical burden that's fallen upon his shoulders as as the new prime minister. Very, very quickly and and does so, just as as Truman does so. So, yeah, I, yeah, I do think there's quite a lot of parallels. And, you know, he's also a very sort of genial fellow as well.
42:03 Speaker 05 Yeah, I mean, the main, I suppose the main difference between him and Truman is that because Atlee's been deputy prime minister right at the heart of it, he's exhausted. All the Labour people, one of the things that then plagues the Labour government as they go into the the late 40s, is they're all worn out. They're all absolutely knackered from from being in government at a time of such.
42:21 Speaker 06 Fossil intensity. And so they do end up out of steam, out of ideas and out of puff really.
42:28 Speaker 05 Because, yeah.
42:29 Speaker 06 And also because as we've said before, the war may have ended, but the economic problems that it's brought are only right there to then have to deal with.
42:36 Speaker 05 Well, I mean, clearly, I mean, Labour does the Conservatives a huge favour because they come back into power in 1950 or whatever.
42:41 Speaker 06 Yeah.
42:41 Speaker 05 And Churchill is elected and they've had a chance to kind of sort of take a deep breath and they haven't, you know, they haven't got to deal with the immediate aftermath of the Second World War and all the kind of horrors that come with that.
42:52 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's interesting, but honestly, that's, that's fantastic. I mean, that's a, that's a tour de force. It's just.
42:58 Speaker 05 Oh, thanks.
42:58 Speaker 06 So, so interesting.
43:00 Speaker 05 It is, it is, isn't it? And I think we often just leave it out when we're looking at the war. And I think sometimes, after all, what's going on in the Labour Party is different people are asserting themselves, like how important Michael Foot is to the sort of intellectual temperature of the, of the Labour Party. And then I remember him as a sort of ridiculed loony lefty in a donkey jacket from the, you know, the time of the Falklands.
43:20 Speaker 06 Yeah, with his, with his glasses and his shaggy hair.
43:22 Speaker 05 Yeah, and being seen. And I often, when I was looking into this and, and reading, there's a very good book by a guy called Phil Tinline called The End of Consensus, which is about Labour Party politics. Really, really interesting. Foot is such an important figure in all of this. And I often think that a big part of how mauled he was in the eighties, when he was Labour leader, was, was like revenge being served cold by old Conservative people who know how important Foot was to the landslide, you know?
43:49 Speaker 06 I, I think it's, I think it's absolutely right that we do this and look at this because I think the one thing that, that people should never, ever lose sight of is the interconnectivity between war economics and politics.
44:00 Speaker 05 Yeah.
44:00 Speaker 06 It is much as much the brotherhood as Alexander's brotherhood that he's talked about of air, land and sea, you know, in terms of how you portray your war. I mean, it, it is absolutely, they're all completely, completely interlinked. And we, we've both been doing our, our separate kind of work on this over the last few months and it's just been absolutely fascinating. But that, that was brilliant. That was really, really, really fascinating.
44:20 Speaker 05 Thanks, Jim. Thanks, everyone for listening. There's a sort of sidebar pod where I'll be talking to Kit Covell, who wrote an amazing book called Blue Jerusalem, which is about Conservative Party politics during the war. Some of it is bonkers.
44:33 Speaker 06 Well, I was sorry to miss out on that, but I can't wait to hear it.
44:35 Speaker 05 Oh, it's really great. It's really great. Thanks, everyone for listening. Don't forget, of course, that if you want to hear us talk about this, you know, live, like we're rock stars, and it's not unlike that, is it, Jim?
44:48 Speaker 05 They do come to We Have Ways Fest in September, September the 12th to the 14th, the Blackpit Brewery in Buckinghamshire, next door to Silverstone Race Track, where we have a whole weekend of people chewing this kind of cud, this exact sort of thing, as well as great big dirty green vehicles, the opportunities to buy clothing that might raise an eyebrow.
45:07 Speaker 06 Yep.
45:08 Speaker 05 All that sort of thing, living historians, entertainment, a few drinks maybe to be taken, and we look forward to seeing you there. WeHaveWaysFest.co.uk. Also, there's our new website, www-headquarters.com, isn't it Jim? It's a dot com?
45:22 Speaker 06 Yep, dot com.
45:23 Speaker 05 Basically, all of our World War Two activities corralled and put into, we've built a defensive perimeter out of biscuit boxes, not unlike Rorke's Drift, and we've put all of our, all of our World War Two activities inside that biscuit box perimeter. Do go and have a look and keep listening. Thanks very much, everybody. We'll see you soon. Bye bye.
45:42 Speaker 06 Cheerio.
45:48 Speaker 01 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
46:00 Speaker 02 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing. Sam's Club is the club for every holiday club. Guess who's joining the club this season? Walmart Plus. Yep, Sam's Club Plus membership now comes with Walmart Plus at no extra cost. Two memberships, one great price. Just 120 bucks a year can save you
46:17 Speaker 07 time and over $700. Want to get in on the membership duo of the century? Visit sam'sclub.com. Come join us. Sam's Club. Annual plan only. Auto renews. T and C apply. Estimate based on average combined Walmart Plus and Sam's Club Plus savings among members of both for one plus year versus not member or club member pricing slash fees. Excludes membership fees. See Walmart Plus terms and Sam's Club terms for more info. Now at Kroger, your points add up to more ways to save every trip. Use them your way to take dollars off groceries at checkout or save at the pump. You can even save up to $35 on your next fill-up. Same points, more choices. And with low prices on fresh, quality food, plus digital and personalised offers tailored to how you shop, your dollar goes further. Redeem your points online or in the app. Kroger, fresh for everyone. Restrictions
47:01 Speaker 07 apply. See site or store for details.
Previous Soviet Bloodthirst, Forgotten Fleets, & Top Hitler Books Next The Tory Party At War Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated