Pod Insights WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk The Channel Dash: The Battle of The Narrow Seas (Part 3) About this episode Why were Swordfish pilots sent outnumbered against the heavily guarded German capital ships? What happened with the land based artillery manned by army units around Dover? When did Coastal Command and Nore Command units get involved to try and stop the German ships?
Join Al Murray and James Holland for Part 3 of this new series as they look at the audacious plan by the Nazi German Kriegsmarine to move their surface fleet out of Brest, right under the noses of British defences along The English Channel in 1942.
Start your free trial at patreon.com/wehaveways and unlock exclusive content and more. Enjoy livestreams, early access, ad-free listening, bonus episodes, and a weekly newsletter packed with book deals and behind-the-scenes insights. Members also get priority access and discounts to live events.
A Goalhanger Production
Produced by James Regan
Editor: Charlie Rodwell
Exec Producer: Tony Pastor
Social: @WeHaveWaysPod
Social Producer: Harry Balden
Email: [email protected]
Membership Club: patreon.com/wehaveways
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. Sign up to our Patreon to receive bonus content, live streams, and our weekly newsletter with money off books and museum visits as well, plus early access to all live show tickets. That's patreon.com/WeHaveWays.
0:23 Speaker 01 Are you looking for support in your weight management journey? Zepbound Tersepatide may be able to help. Zepbound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity, or some adults with overweight who also have weight-related medical problems to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off. Zepbound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15-milligram injection. Zepbound contains tersepatide and should not be used with other tersepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Zepbound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens, or reuse needles. Don't take if allergic to it,
1:07 Speaker 01 or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer, or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop Zepbound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia, if you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking Zepbound with a sulfonel urea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979, or visit zepbound.lily.com.
1:54 Speaker 02 Hey Spotify listeners, when you travel with American Airlines, you'll enjoy comfort and convenience at every altitude. Before takeoff, unwind in the Admirals Club Lounge, with curated self-serve offerings of hearty bites and refreshments. In flight, stay connected with high-speed Wi-Fi, sponsored by AT&T. Your journey is designed to feel easy, from the moment you check in to the moment you arrive. No matter where you're going, American gets you there. Book now at aa.com.
2:19 Speaker 03 Stonefire naan is made with real buttermilk and ghee. It's the perfect flatbread for any occasion.
2:25 Speaker 04 I put out Stonefire naan with dips at every dinner party.
2:28 Speaker 03 I make naan-grilled cheese when my daughter has friends over.
2:31 Speaker 04 I use Stonefire naan to reward the humans who do my bidding. Right, it's perfect for camping trips. Dance for it, feeble mortal. Sorry, is he talking to me or... Dance, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
2:45 Speaker 03 From our tradition to yours, Stonefire. Together we naan.
3:00 Speaker 00 The look on his face shook me. It was the face of a man already dead. I'd known it was a vital man, alive and eager for anything. Now his eyes were dialed, his face grey, almost haggard. The sort of vacant, lifeless face you read about but never expect to see. He barely recognised me, although his mouth twitched automatically into the semblance of a grin and an arm lifted in a vague wave. It shocked me as nothing had done before, nor has done since. And that's Tom Gleave describing Eugene Esmond, the commanding officer of 825 Naval Air Squadron, on his way to his swordfish to take off at 12:25 on February 12, 1942.
3:37 Speaker 05 That doesn't sound very good, does it?
3:38 Speaker 00 It doesn't sound good! And, uh, uh, we are in for, I'm afraid we're in for an episode of that sort of thing. Welcome to We Have Ways of Making You Talk, with me, Al Murray, and James Holland, as we come to, uh, part three of the Channel Dash, "The Battle of the Narrow Seas", and-
3:54 Speaker 05 This is proving difficult for me, I'm not gonna lie.
3:59 Speaker 05 Tom Gleave, great man actually, Battle of Brim veteran, but also was involved in writing the official histories.
4:04 Speaker 00 This is no wilting violet of a fighter man. This is a man who knows aerial combat inside out. So for him to say that about Esmond, I think is really quite telling. So here we are. This is Operation Cerberus versus Operation Fuller, the big showdown. Preparation versus improvisation. On the German side, meticulous planning. On the, on the British side, not quite so meticulous.
4:30 Speaker 05 Meticulous planning, but, but in the wrong way.
4:33 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah. Well, well, what the Germans also do, they exercise very, very great and powerful operational secrecy, but everyone does actually know what they're doing. Whereas the British operational secrecy and no one knows what they're doing. There's a lot of bad luck on the British side, as we saw in the first half of the sort of dash, the first sort of, first sort of 18 hours.
4:51 Speaker 05 God damn that cloud.
4:52 Speaker 00 And also that fused radar set in pilot officers Windsor's Hudson. The weather's getting a casting vote and everything, right?
5:01 Speaker 05 Yes. A little recap, I think is important, don't you?
5:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think so. So as we saw in the last episode, the capital ships, the battle fleet, the Scharnhorst, the Prince Eugen and the Gneisner now left Brest at around 2130 hours after sitting tight during an air raid.
5:15 Speaker 05 That was bad luck.
5:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, I know. I mean, just even that. The last recce plane goes over and sees them still in port, rather than sees them having left. They're steaming full tilt for German waters. They sailed when the Admiralty has neither predicted nor prepared for. There is no contingency in place for basically the Germans being, coming through the strait to Dover in daylight. They haven't prepared that. No one. Because who would do that? It makes no sense. No one has done this for centuries. It's too dangerous. It's too audacious. It's too impossible. But.
5:51 Speaker 00 So far, Germans have gone unspotted. It's plain sailing even, despite plenty of radar plots that morning. Confusion, poor communication in terms of hierarchy. And here's the thing, Jim, Lee Mallory that morning is on ceremonial duties.
6:05 Speaker 05 Ah, of course he is.
6:06 Speaker 00 And will not be interrupted by a call from a group captain trying to alert him to the Channel Dash.
6:12 Speaker 05 I mean, the thing is with Lee Mallory is he just continues to dig himself into an ever deeper hole, as far as I'm concerned. Every time I kind of, I think, oh, maybe I've been a bit harsh on him. Something else comes to light that makes me think, nope, he really was crap.
6:29 Speaker 00 After this series, we're going to do a wash up for Patreon members. And there's some extra Lee Mallory fan red meat in that, in that episode, if that's what people fancy.
6:41 Speaker 05 And just saying that we have way best six, we will be doing the worst commanders in the West.
6:47 Speaker 00 Worst in the West.
6:48 Speaker 05 And we're not limiting it to Army. Just saying that.
6:51 Speaker 00 There's disjointed comms between the different commands within the RAF and between the Navy and the Royal Air Force, overloaded phone lines. So the RAF and the Admiralty haven't been able to see, let alone counter the fleet that is literally sailing right under their noses. And what's interesting, the German fighter cover, the doughnuts of Messerschmitts and 109s, over the, over the fleet, has not attracted the attention it's due. They're just sort of going, well, they must, there's something funny going on. Maybe they're, who knows? And the problem is, is Hitler, who said the British will be unable to respond to such a prize. He's right, but he hasn't, he didn't dare dream that the British would be this slack.
7:29 Speaker 05 Hitler being right also really hurts. I mean, you know.
7:33 Speaker 00 Even if it's, even if it's probably for the wrong reasons. So, Operation Fuller has been authorised around about 11.30 on, on the morning of February the 12th.
7:42 Speaker 05 And Operation Fuller is pretty, is pretty full on, isn't it? Let's face it.
7:46 Speaker 00 In theory, on paper, lots of assets, right? The big guns at Dover.
7:51 Speaker 05 And they really are big guns.
7:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, they really are big guns. And we'll, but we'll get to the gunnery. 825 Naval Air Squadron, which is six Swordfish torpedo bombers, which have moved. Moved up from Leon Solent.
8:02 Speaker 05 Only six.
8:03 Speaker 00 The rest are at Leon Solent, right? But by the time.
8:05 Speaker 05 Okay, so it's a flight.
8:07 Speaker 00 Yes, it's a flight. So what you've actually got is you've got a load more at Leon Solent, but they don't have the crews. They're understaffed and they just don't have the people. And also, doing 90 knots to catch a fleet sailing at 30 is actually quite a tall order. Swordfish's range isn't what it could be and all this sort of thing. This squadron though, 825, has been reformed post the Bismarck action and is full of fresh crews. So Eugen Esmond, who we'll meet later on, who's in charge, has been bringing them up to speed and we'll give a proper look at Esmond later. Then Coastal Command has three squadrons of Beauforts, one that's in Cornwall, in case the Germans go around the into the Atlantic and go around the long way, one in Scapa and one at RAF Coltishol, which has flown down that morning
8:52 Speaker 00 from RAF Leukas as part of reorganisation in order to be on hand for the battle fleet. But there aren't any torpedoes at Coltishol because it's a fighter station. And there are Hudson's too from Coastal Command. Bomber Command on paper has more than 200 aircraft, but the number's going to be more like 100 available to it. Wellingtons, Hudson's, Manchesters. And the idea is they're going to attempt to attack the battle fleet on the if and when. Bomber Command have done really well actually against Brest. It's the Bomber Command are the reason that Syliax's fleet is fleeing the French port. You know, it's 25 raids in November, between November and January. This relentless stuff, but they're no good against ships in motion. So a ship that maybe has struck a mine and is disabled, they'll be able to hit that.
9:36 Speaker 00 But you've got to find the ships, you've got to penetrate the fighter screen, the flak. And also you've got to have clear orders about where they are and what you're trying to achieve, right? Which is an essential part of Operation Fuller. And then of course, Fighter Command, under the command of friend of the show, Sholto Douglas. 11 Group under Traffordley Mallory, they're on hand to escort whatever's going to happen as long as they have clear orders and information about the sorties ahead of them. Basically, I'm getting my excuses in early. The Royal Navy, they've got motor torpedo boats at Dover with accompanying motor torpedo boats at Ramsgate. Destroyers to come out of Harwich as part of the NOR Command, which is one of those long gone Royal Navy commands.
10:20 Speaker 00 Named after Sam Bank in the Thames Estuary.
10:22 Speaker 05 Well, I mean, the thing is to have a command, you've got to have ships, haven't you?
10:27 Speaker 00 Yes.
10:28 Speaker 05 So I go mothballing them, you've got to have them active.
10:30 Speaker 00 They've got to actually be active. You can't, you can't, I mean, these destroyers, they're all, they're all, they're not the latest kit, but they're not mothballed. They are at least active and they're actually, they're all on sort of sea trials and exercise and stuff when this goes on. So they're actually at sea. So they've not got to sail from Harwich. Critically to the Fuller plan, many people think Dudley Pound, who's at First Sealy Order, he's decided the home fleet will stay at Scapa Flow. He's not letting it out. They're concerned about the turpits. They don't want the turpits breaking out. You know, maybe the Channel Dash is a feint to get the turpits out. There could be that possibility. And also there is fresh sensitivity to the danger of air power after the loss of the Prince of Wales in the Far East.
11:11 Speaker 00 That's what they're really, really worried about. Even though the Japanese, of course, have a specialist anti-shipping bomber team that did that. They're not fully up to speed that. They're just really, really worried about that. And of course, which is at odds with the fact that the RAF know how hard it is to hit ships. But, but basically, you know, the, the blow to naval prestige is always in their mind, just as Nelson's always in their mind, Imperial naval prestige. Now though, we reached the point where Ciliac's and his fleet have been spotted. The operational code word Fuller has been issued. Go, go, go. Let's do it, Jim.
11:44 Speaker 05 Yep.
11:45 Speaker 00 Or rather.
11:46 Speaker 05 Well, yes. So 11:30 hours that morning.
11:52 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:52 Speaker 05 We met Wing Commander Bobby Constable Roberts.
11:57 Speaker 05 How can he be called anything else?
11:59 Speaker 00 Can't be called anything else.
12:00 Speaker 05 At Ramsay's headquarters in Dover, who's already told the 825 Naval Air Squadron Swordfish to bomb up. He explained his reasoning later. One, it was important to try to cripple the enemy as quickly as possible where it could be reasonable to expect large surface units to destroy him. Two, to have attacked with the Beauforts would have meant separate fighter escorts as the Swordfish could fly at not more than 90 knots. While the Beauforts would have extreme difficulty in flying at less than 150 knots. For the Swordfish, it would have meant a two and a half hours flight under constant enemy fighter attack to reach enemy ships. Three, casualties were a foregone conclusion. And there was more chance of picking up survivors if the battle took place within a few miles of our shores.
12:44 Speaker 00 What, you think the British war rappers made of captain manor rings? No, sir.
12:50 Speaker 05 I mean.
12:51 Speaker 00 Do you remember Tovey's signal before Bismarck? Yeah.
12:54 Speaker 05 You know, got to lose a battleship, got to lose a battleship.
12:56 Speaker 00 So at noon, Vice Admiral Otto Ciliaks decides that as they're approaching the Dover Straits and haven't been attacked yet, right? They might as well make smoke. Why not? They've done, they've done 360 miles unmolested. They've got 200 to go. They've been joined by the flotillas that have come down from Zbigniew of S boats and stuff. Um, and so with the destroyers, the fleet is quite the target, right? Although actually, this will present a problem in itself because, because there's so many enemy vessels in this flotilla. At 12:15, Admiral Ramsay signals.
13:33 Speaker 05 All measures prepared in my command to counter the enemy move have been put into operation, but the Germans have calé Dover line already.
13:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, incredible.
13:42 Speaker 05 Holy moly. So Ramsay has got two means of launching torpedoes at the battle fleet. The MTBs at Dover, this is the motor torpedo boats, so fast ones, they can do 30 knots, but more than that, up to nearly 40 knots. And 825 naval air squadron at Manston, but it's not a squadron, as we said, it's only six swordfishes. It's two subflights, isn't it? And the latter, as we've already been discussing, have been tipped off and are girding their loins accordingly. Feeling sick inside and knowing that, that this is a flight they're unlikely to return from.
14:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. We keep talking about the Navy and the Royal Air Force. It's time for the army to get, to, to roll up its sleeves and get involved here. It's Corps Commander Coastal Artillery Brigadier Rawle of Four Corps, who has coastal artillery guns. And the enemy are now known as Plot E29D. This is the plot that was first logged at 10:50 hours at Fairlight in Hastings. And then Liddon Spout reported it at 11:29. This is the plot they've now decided on is the surface fleet. So Ramsay orders Rawle, who's at Dover Castle, to engage.
14:47 Speaker 05 And presumably at this point, you know, everyone's going, what? This, you know, we, we were so prepared, we were so ready for this and this is just absolutely crazy. How can this be? Do you think there's a bit of kind of, you know, heads going a bit kind of, no.
15:01 Speaker 00 Oh, completely. I mean, the, the thing is afterwards, there's a lot of finger pointing, but basically there's this kind of complete funk descends over everybody. And and they end up in a summer their fears situation. I mean, so the Dover defenses do open fire, we'll get to that. The men are on a training drill when the orders come to engage. So they're at the guns. The guns report they're ready at 12:03. So pretty much, pretty much straight away. So the radar at Liddon's bout has the ship's plot, as we said, E290. And then the guns have got a 10-centimetre K-type radar, which hasn't got such a long range. And that starts looking for them. And at 12:15 hours, so 12 minutes after they're ready, they've got to
15:43 Speaker 00 fix. And that radar's range is 32,000 yards, and it picks them up at 32,000 yards, which is just outside the guns' range. But it means they're coming into range. They're going to be right under the guns.
15:58 Speaker 05 Oh, okay. Good.
15:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So this should, this should, this should square off, right? It's the Southfallen Battery. It's four 9.2-inch Mark 10 guns. They have an effective range of 31,500 yards, which is 17.9 miles.
16:14 Speaker 05 Jeez.
16:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, I know. These are powerful pieces of ordnance.
16:18 Speaker 05 Can I just make a point? Isn't this the whole point of Guns of Navarone?
16:22 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:22 Speaker 05 That you can't sail under naval, you know, coastal guns?
16:24 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yes, this is a reverse Guns of Navarone situation.
16:27 Speaker 05 How can they possibly escape from this trap?
16:31 Speaker 00 And what we don't have is a German David Niven slitting the throats of various people in the magazine at the Southfallen Battery.
16:38 Speaker 05 No, so they haven't got a problem.
16:40 Speaker 00 Here's the other thing. There are even bigger guns at Wandstone, 15-inch naval-style guns, right? But these are no good for moving targets. They traverse too slowly. They can't lay those guns onto shipping, right? They're good for lobbing shells over the Channel, but not for what we've got here. So it's down to the lads at Southfallen. 12:19 hours, they fire first half a half salvo. The problem is summed up as the bearing was erratic due to the lack of target discrimination. In other words, it's such a big radar trace, this big flotilla, that they can't pick a target out from the mass of ships.
17:18 Speaker 05 What's wrong with binos?
17:19 Speaker 00 Well, visibility five miles, James. So they're firing essentially blind on radar. Fan Bay Langdon and the Breakwater Fort, the Sixtins positions, they fire as well. And as far as they can tell, the round splash short of the German column, as far as they can tell, but they can't tell. It's poor weather, heavy smoke from the escorts as well, cloud obscures the line of sight. And essentially, no accurate fall of shot is recorded. So they don't even know how much they're missing by. Right? And the core problem here, the plotting the guns with the radar is there's too many signals coming from the fleet's image and also
17:59 Speaker 00 the radars knew, they have never tried to do this before. They have never tried to lay guns on and judge the shot purely by radar location. Just not been done. And without eyes on, it can't be done. Right? So the station log starts at 12:28 hours, "Core Commander Coastal Artillery decided that as no fall of shot had been observed, the battery should fire four gun salvos without waiting for fall of shot observations. Orders given to this effect. 12:30 hours battery salvo, additional thousand yards added as no fall of shot observed." And they stop at 12:52. They fired 33 rounds. No hits recorded. Little wonder they're firing blind. So that's
18:45 Speaker 00 that's the army's contribution, Jim.
18:47 Speaker 05 I'm also thinking, why in the guns of Davarone don't they just make smoke and go free?
18:55 Speaker 00 Whereas we've seen radar plotting is difficult, but I mean, it's this enormous flotilla is making it harder. But basically, they're trying something they've never, never done before.
19:03 Speaker 05 Well, it's hard not to feel a little deflated, isn't it?
19:05 Speaker 00 Yes, exactly. And this, this gunnery also attracts the attention of some Stukas, which rock up to strike near and disrupt British observation posts. And there's counter battery fire from the Germans because they know where the guns are.
19:18 Speaker 05 And they've got those French guns, haven't they, which they captured in 1940? Don't forget our old friend, the Prince Eugen. You know, they've been watching shells aimlessly splotching into the ocean, you know, behind them. The gunnery commander called Vettel Capitaine Paulus remarks, "Well, that wasn't much, was it?" Smoke bastard.
19:39 Speaker 05 Anyway, so now we're getting down to the, now we're getting down to it, aren't we? Should we take a break now before we do that?
19:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, why not? Let's take a break before the fleet air arm intervene. We'll see you in a tick.
19:52 Speaker 02 Hey Spotify listeners. When you travel with American Airlines, you'll enjoy comfort and convenience at every altitude. Before takeoff, unwind in the Admirals Club Lounge with curated self-serve offerings of hearty bites and refreshments. In flight, stay connected with high-speed Wi-Fi, sponsored by AT&T. Your journey is designed to feel easy from the moment you check in to the moment you arrive. No matter where you're going, American gets you there. Book now at aa.com.
20:17 Speaker 03 Stonefire Naan is made with real buttermilk and ghee. It's the perfect flatbread for any occasion.
20:23 Speaker 04 I put out Stonefire Naan with dips at every dinner party.
20:26 Speaker 03 I make naan grilled cheese when my daughter has friends over.
20:29 Speaker 06 I use Stonefire Naan to reward the humans who do my bidding.
20:32 Speaker 04 Right. It's perfect for camping trips.
20:35 Speaker 06 Dance for it, feeble mortal.
20:38 Speaker 04 Sorry, is he talking to me or?
20:40 Speaker 06 Dance. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
20:43 Speaker 03 From our tradition to yours, Stonefire. Together we Naan.
20:49 Speaker 02 Does checking your bank statements feel like digging through a dusty attic full of forgotten subscriptions and old free trials?
20:57 Speaker 02 Experian can help take the pain out of cancelling by handling it for you. Think of it as Operation Get Your Sanity Back. Over 200 subscriptions are cancelable. So get started in the Experian app and see how much you could save. Results will vary. Not all subscriptions eligible. Savings not guaranteed. Paid membership with connected payment account required. See experian.com for details. Experian.
21:21 Speaker 00 Welcome back to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. We met Almarion James Holland. I've got to say, Jim, Corvette and Capitaine Paul are saying, well, that wasn't much, was it? I mean, if this was the other way around, if the boot was on the other foot and that was a British gunnery commander, you'd be patting him on the back for stoicism, wouldn't you?
21:36 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, but that's the key point you've just made. If the boot was on the other foot. I mean, it isn't. He's German and he's getting away with it and my hackles have been raised.
21:48 Speaker 00 Now, on this show, we, I think it's fair to say, we are absolute diehard fans of the fleet air arm. We think that they're, certainly their first phase of the war efforts are absolutely extraordinary. I've got everything in the mucopostive world, drama, guts, grit, tactical and strategic effect, the odd cock up, like trying to sink Sheffield.
22:09 Speaker 05 Basically, these guys are tops.
22:11 Speaker 00 They're tops and they're getting in an aeroplane that, by this phase of the war, and certainly against German fighter cover, this is an extremely short straw to have drawn, to be flying swordfish in daylight.
22:24 Speaker 05 Across the channel.
22:25 Speaker 00 Bertram Ramsay has been in agonies about ordering the swordfish attack because he knows he's ordering the crews to their deaths because it's daylight and he knows that they've been preparing for a night time attack and that's the only way the swordfish are going to possibly be effective. So he asks Constable Roberts, Wing Commander Bobby Roberts, to talk to Esmond and say to him that it's up to him whether he wants to go ahead with the attack or not.
22:47 Speaker 05 Oh God, but that's a terrible thing to say because, you know, Esmond can't say no, can he?
22:53 Speaker 00 No, no, he can't. And Esmond says he'll go ahead anyway, it's his duty.
22:56 Speaker 05 Oh God, he should know, that's such a terrible, terrible thing to do.
23:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. And it might feel like the right thing to do and these are brand new crews. Most of them are on their first sortie, I think, so.
23:09 Speaker 05 That's terrible.
23:11 Speaker 00 So Ramsay then calls Dudley Pound, asking permission not to have to give the order to Esmond and his men. And Pound responds, "The navy will attack the enemy whenever and wherever he is to be found." So, that's it, their fate's sealed. It's not a suicide mission as such, Jim, but it's a suicide mission, right?
23:34 Speaker 05 Yeah, I'm not a fan of Dudley Pound. I think he's going to be on that list as well.
23:40 Speaker 00 But given, but here's the thing, right? Make no mistake, this is the one part of the Fuller Plan that really is completely vulnerable to the daylight switch that the Germans have forced onto the Fuller Plan. Because let's be honest now, they're not doing the Fuller Plan because the Fuller Plan's geared for night. So they're not doing Fuller. Fuller's gone out the window completely. This is some improvised thing. This is the part where they should be able to go, no, we're sucking it off.
24:04 Speaker 05 This is a terrible, terrible thing to do, to say to Esmond, well, it's up to you, you don't have to go. What's that sketch? I mean, it's that sketch, isn't it?
24:12 Speaker 00 Yes, it's here. We needed, at this, at this stage of the war, we needed futile gesture. Get up, get up over Germany, take your kite off Germany and don't come back. Eight two five naval air squadron, six ferry swordfish mark two by plane. So the mark two is a bit more powerful.
24:24 Speaker 05 Yeah, but you're splitting hairs, aren't you? I mean, it's a swordfish.
24:26 Speaker 00 They're due a 10 aircraft Spitfire escort from 72124 squadrons, but it's scattered by heavy cloud. Only part of the escort arrives.
24:33 Speaker 05 Question here.
24:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:35 Speaker 05 What the heck is the rest of fighter command doing?
24:37 Speaker 00 Well, they're all, they're all waiting for orders.
24:39 Speaker 05 Okay, why, why didn't he scramble 15 squadrons?
24:43 Speaker 00 Just to attack the fighter cover. I don't know, Jim. You do the escorting, but you also aggressively assault.
24:49 Speaker 05 This is your chance to have your, your air combat. This is your chance to use your superiority to shoot down German planes.
24:56 Speaker 00 No, Jim, not, not today.
24:57 Speaker 05 What the heck?
24:59 Speaker 00 Lee Mallory's got to do some inspections this morning. Anyway, let's talk about Eugene Esmond though. Let's look into him because, because he is one of the,
25:06 Speaker 05 All right.
25:06 Speaker 00 He's one of the cast iron characters of this story. So he's, he was born on March the first, 1909, Thurgeland, Yorkshire. He's of Irish nationalist heritage. He's one of 10 children for Dr. John Joseph Esmond and Aile O'Sullivan. And they are Irish nationalists. He was educated by Jesuits, Stonyhurst College in Lancashire. So, you know, he's got duty, discipline and faith running right through.
25:31 Speaker 05 I would question their, the commitment of their Irish nationalism.
25:34 Speaker 00 Well, yes, because he joins the Royal Air Force in 1928.
25:37 Speaker 05 Well, and goes to Stonyhurst College, you know, a bastion of the empire and all the rest of it.
25:41 Speaker 00 But he's an Irishman. He's an Irishman. And I think when we talked about, yeah, I mean, it was many, many podcasts ago when we talked to Joseph Quinn about who's joining the various British services in between the wars and, and why Irish people are going in. I think it's quite interesting that he fits into that picture. So he joins in 1928, becomes a fighter pilot. He flies aerobatics at Hendon with 43 squadron, not unlike Douglas Bader with, with 29 squadron. You know, those great, those great air shows where they'd all fly in sync together.
26:12 Speaker 05 They're called an air pageant.
26:13 Speaker 00 That's right. It's all they can think to do with their fighters at the time. In 1931, that squadron is flying Hawker Furies, which is quite the machine, but Esmond has been transferred to RAF Gosport to join the nascent fleet air arm. So he becomes a naval man. And Gosport is set up for carrier landing, training, torpedo attack methods. And it's also part of the Royal Navy's effort to redigest Air Force men into the Navy because. The the the original Royal Naval Air Service was was was swallowed up by the Royal Air Force when it was formed in nineteen eighteen. And this is the Navy's effort to to to to draw out its own strand. And you know, this is well ahead of time, having aircraft carriers. This is cutting edge stuff.
26:54 Speaker 05 Yes.
26:55 Speaker 00 He's posted to Courageous. She's been recommissioned and she's she's part of the home fleet. So this is the air people in the Royal Navy getting their way, which we talked about when we talked about the Fleet Air Arm before Taranto. And she is great, one of Courageous's jobs. And we talked about how i- i- in the Bismarck series about how the Hood's job is to go round advertising British power, showing British hard power and technical industrial might all over the world. That's Courageous's job and she goes round the world showing off how incredible carriers are and that, you know, planes landing and they do it, they do it for people to see planes landing on the carrier and it's all very sexy. At the time, he's flying the Blackburn Dart, which is a rather.
27:36 Speaker 05 Yeah, so it looks like a bulldog.
27:38 Speaker 00 It's an ugly plane.
27:39 Speaker 05 It looks like a squat and kind of stub-nosed and not very attractive.
27:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, he clashes with his boss and this is a, Esmond is a single-minded man, sticks to his guns and but during his time with the Fleet, this time with the Fleet Air Arm, he develops a reputation for being a truly brilliant flyer and the best off and on man in the Royal Navy. So he's the best carrier landing guy of all.
28:02 Speaker 05 Right.
28:02 Speaker 00 When his time with the Fleet Air Arm ends, there's no job for him in the RAF. The um, he can't get a permanent job as a pilot.
28:09 Speaker 05 Is that because he's an Irish national?
28:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, and he's not a Cranwell guy, you know, he's not, you know, this is the same time as they're trying to keep Barter in the RAF and he's got no legs, right? So he goes into the RAF Volunteer Reserve, A Reserve, at the end of nineteen thirty-three, but he has to find work as a pilot. And in his last six months, he gets, he gets time on every type he possibly can, particularly multiple engine, engine types. So then has a job with Imperial and flies for its subsidiary, Indian Transcontinental Airways.
28:35 Speaker 05 But he's a nationalist, he's an Irish nationalist.
28:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, I know. Look, it's work.
28:41 Speaker 05 Mine's called a work, right?
28:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, and he's a brilliantly skilled pilot, vastly experienced. Um, and when he comes back to the Fleet Air Arm in nineteen thirty-nine, he has five thousand five hundred fifty hours in his logbook. I mean. Wow.
28:57 Speaker 05 Wow. So can I suggest that the Royal Navy wrap him up in kit gloves and make sure that they use him and his vast experience to the maximum capability?
29:08 Speaker 00 I think what they should do is build a training school around him where he teaches people how to become the best off and on types the Royal Navy could possibly have. These warbirds of liberty, boys, that were your American pinups, he is an all-Irish hero for you. The short fellow, there's a fantastic picture of him with the other fleet air arm officers in their white socks, shorts, trousers, shirt combo that they wore.
29:34 Speaker 05 Yes. No, he's an attractive, he's got an attractive face, a twinkly face, hasn't he? You know, he looks like a smiley, good-humoured, genial fellow.
29:41 Speaker 00 Yeah. In 1941, he's commanding 825 Squadron, again, on Victorious. And of course, May the 24th, after the Hood goes down, his nine Swordfish, in the disgusting weather in the North Atlantic, they'd go out to strike the Bismarck. And unsuccessfully, but he's gazetted with a DSO in July 1941, and he picks that DSO up the day before the Channel Dash.
30:06 Speaker 05 With all smiles.
30:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, he's come back from London that morning with his DSO, with his ribbon, right? They've been rerouted to Manston, as we said, they've been redeployed at Manston, because Victorious has gone off and 825 Squadron's being reformed, and they've now moved to Manston. And of course, if there's German fighters in the picture, this is a different kettle of fish, right? Anyway, at 12:25 hours, they set off. There's meant to be two squadrons of Spitfires. The actual escort, when they arrive, is 10 Spitfires, the majority have been misrooted. The weather works against them. It's a difficult business, because the Swordfish fly so slowly that, you know, the Spitfires have to do funny loops and fly with their flaps down. And let's go through
30:49 Speaker 00 these crews, because just say their names. Eugene Edmonds is in H, followed by Swordfish L, W5907, piloted by Charles M. Pat Kingsmill, who's crew of Sub Lieutenant R. Mac
31:05 Speaker 00 Samples, um he's a, he's his obs and leading M and DA Don Bunce, who's his telegraphist air gunner. Swordfish G is skippered by Sub Lieutenant Brian Rose with Edgar F Lee, who we'll, we'll see in a bit. And leading M and A L Ginger Johnson and the second for subflight, and these are all, these are all new guys. Lieutenant J C Thompson is in Swordfish F with his obs R L Parkinson. Um, leading M and E Topping is his tag behind him becomes Swordfish K. With Sub Lieutenant C R Timberwood, I mean, come on, Timberwood. Sub Lieutenant E H Fuller Right is his observer, leading M and Wheeler is his tag. And this last four Swordfish to leave is M W five nine seven eight.
31:50 Speaker 00 It's captained by Sub Lieutenant Peter Bly, who had won his flight with a toss of a coin. Because there are seven pilots in naval, in eight two five naval air sports squadron and six Swordfish. So when the moment comes, as I say, they toss a coin and Sub Lieutenant Bly calls and wins and Bennett stays behind.
32:10 Speaker 05 Damn it, you lucky Blighter, you're going to go to your immediate death.
32:14 Speaker 00 Heads or tails?
32:15 Speaker 05 I mean, I've, I've, I would, I would say that's losing, isn't it? Surely.
32:19 Speaker 00 You'd think, but you know, for the honour, Esmond leads his formation at very low altitude through the heavy flak towards the German ships. At near Cap Grenay at around thirteen twenty hours. It takes the best part of an hour to get there. Huge swirl of fighter planes.
32:32 Speaker 05 Of course there is.
32:33 Speaker 00 Gallant has prepared this cover for them. They buzz around them, vast flak response. Fighter planes coming in with their undercarriage down, their flaps deployed in order to hit the Swordfish.
32:44 Speaker 05 That's amazing, isn't it?
32:45 Speaker 00 Yep. Cause you come over a couple of hundred knots, whoop, like that, you know? Um, and that's until you figure out how to do it. British Spitfires, they do what they can to draw the one oh nines and one nineties off, but it's too much. Eight two five naval air squadron is doomed, right? The lads who come from Hornchurch never see the Swordfish they've been sent to escort. So there's, there's aircraft, aircraft.
33:06 Speaker 05 Never seen them at all.
33:07 Speaker 00 Uh, never seen them. Esmond leads this first subflight. Lee is the observer in the plane behind him and he's our witness, basically, flown by Sub Lieutenant Rose. They watch Esmond going in, even as the rear gunner in his own plane, in Lee's plane, even as he is killed. Ginger Johnson is killed. A fighter coming through.
33:29 Speaker 05 But yeah, okay, so they are killed by fighters.
33:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's got blood all over him. So, so the various eyes on, and Lee's our primary witness, and Kingsmill, say that Esmond's aircraft, they're trying to maintain formation. His plane seems to be badly hit before descending to launch its torpedo. The left wing comes away and Esmond, they see Esmond hit by machine gun fire, killed by machine gun fire by a pair of 109s, which are flown by Leutnant Egon Meyer of Jaggerschwerter II Richtofen, and his wingman Feldwebel Wille Stratmann. The left wing comes off and his plane crashes into the sea. And what's interesting is, a couple of decades later in accounts, people say they see him get his torpedo away.
34:11 Speaker 05 But that seems unlikely, doesn't it?
34:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. The reports for the next couple of days don't confirm this, they say. But they basically say, this is horrendous. Sky's full of fire, swordfish are torn apart.
34:21 Speaker 05 Yep.
34:22 Speaker 00 You know, and one of the things about the swordfish, because of fabric, it can take the odd hit, but not this much. So then, Rose and Lee are shot down. Lee manages to get the dinghy out, get his injured pilot into it, and the gunner goes down with the shattered plane.
34:38 Speaker 05 So Pat Kingsmill, he's in Swordfish L, isn't he?
34:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, and he says, go on, Jim.
34:43 Speaker 05 "We were still flying straight towards the enemy and a plane becoming more difficult to handle with every second. I never grasped then just how smashed up we were. We'd been riddled in dozens of places. There was a huge splash in the sea close by. They were throwing their big stuff at us now, laying 11-inch shells in our path, hoping to smash us down before we reached the firing distance. Now we must be almost there. I wrenched at the controls, brought the tattered swordfish into firing position. Looming out of the mist was one of the target ships, the Prince Eugen, which looked enormous. Somehow I lined the plane up against her. Everything was so confused, I cannot even remember pressing the torpedo release. But with the torpedo gone, we stood some chance of getting out in one piece. The controls were dreadfully sluggish,
35:28 Speaker 05 but I brought the swordfish around and yelled for samples to give me a course back. As I came round and away, I had a fleeting glimpse of the second flight just above me, heading for the welter of fire as I was trying to leave." Crikey. So then the second subflight, including, yeah, including the pilot who'd won the toss to go, Sub Lieutenant Bly, are also shot down and destroyed as they press in their attack. Thirteen crew are killed. And of the six survivors, only two are unhurt.
35:57 Speaker 00 Leon Bunce, who'd been in Kingsmill's plane. Basically, there's, nothing's known of the second subflight. No one saw it. No one survived from it. They're all gone. And Esmond is, Esmond is gazetted on the 21st of April, um, uh, 1942, um, with the Victoria Cross. Um, but, but basically, we'll tell the story of, of his Victoria Cross in our, um, wash up for, um, uh, which will be up on the Patreon. But what you've got to know is a Victoria Cross, what does that tell us, Jim?
36:24 Speaker 05 Uh, it's all going really badly wrong. Yeah.
36:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly.
36:30 Speaker 05 War drift. I mean, you know.
36:32 Speaker 00 Yeah. On, um, um, you know, and this is the fleet, uh, the fleet RM, air arm only have two Victoria Crosses from the war. And, and this is, this is one of them. Ciliaks, or is it the Captain Hoffman? There's some disagreement, remarked, it went into Ciliaks' diary, but no one's quite sure who may have said it. Though swordfish did fail to get their torpedoes away. The English are throwing their mothball navy at us now. Apparently. That's the fleet air arm attack gone wrong.
36:58 Speaker 05 Smug bastard.
36:59 Speaker 00 Yeah. What next for Operation Fuller? Or rather, what is also going on at the same time? Because everything is happening everywhere all at once. And join us for our next episode as the Battle of the Narrow Seas continues. Subscribe to our Patreon, become a member, and you can enjoy the full juice of this disaster as it plays itself out.
37:24 Speaker 05 Well, I mean, I personally, I, I think we need a break because I need to just calm down a little bit. I'm, I'm feeling quite upset.
37:30 Speaker 00 We'll see you soon. Thanks for listening.
37:34 Speaker 05 Cheerio.
37:34 Speaker 00 Cheerio.
37:47 Speaker 03 Stonefire naan is made with real buttermilk and ghee. It's the perfect flatbread for any occasion.
37:52 Speaker 04 I put out Stonefire naan with dips at every dinner party.
37:55 Speaker 03 I make naan grilled cheese when my daughter has friends over.
37:58 Speaker 06 I use Stonefire naan to reward the humans who do my bidding.
38:02 Speaker 04 Right, it's perfect for camping trips.
38:05 Speaker 06 Dance for it, feeble mortal.
38:07 Speaker 04 Sorry, is he talking to me or...
38:09 Speaker 06 Dance, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
38:12 Speaker 03 From our tradition to yours, Stonefire. Together we naan.
38:17 Speaker 07 When you're building a company, you learn that trust is what closes deals. You may have the best product, but buyers won't sign without proof that your product is secure, especially if it has AI. Vanta gets you compliant fast with SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, and keeps you secure with continuous monitoring. Hyperbound, a YC-backed startup, used Vanta to unlock the Fortune 100 in under a year. Snowfire got audit-ready in a month and closed a multimillion-dollar deal. Trust matters. Get started at vanta.com.
38:46 Speaker 02 Does checking your bank statements feel like digging through a dusty attic full of forgotten subscriptions and old free trials?
38:55 Speaker 02 Experian can help take the pain out of canceling by handling it for you. Think of it as Operation Get Your Sanity Back. Over 200 subscriptions are cancelable. So get started in the Experian app and see how much you could save. Results will vary. Not all subscriptions eligible. Savings not guaranteed. Paid membership with connected payment account required. See experian.com for details.
Previous The Channel Dash: Hide & Seek (Part 2) Next The Channel Dash: Out The Frying Pan (Part 4) Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated