Pod Insights WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk Nazis In South America About this episode What connects the Final Solution with a Chilean crabmeat factory? How were Pinochet and Mossad using Nazis? Did the war really end in 1945?
Join James Holland, Al Murray, and guest Philippe Sands as they deep dive into the ratlines of high-ranking SS war criminals who became influential advisors for South American dicatorships - and how they still cast a long shadow on the world today.
EPISODES ARE AVAILABLE FOR MEMBERS AD FREE - SIGN UP AT patreon.com/wehaveways
A Goalhanger Production
Produced by James Regan
Exec Producer: Tony Pastor
Social: @WeHaveWaysPod
Email: [email protected]
Join our ‘Independent Company’ to watch exclusive livestreams, get presale events, and our weekly newsletter book and model discounts.
Membership Club: patreon.com/wehaveways
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. Sign up to our Patreon to receive bonus content, live streams, and our weekly newsletter with money off books and museum visits as well, plus early access to all live show tickets. That's patreon.com/WeHaveWays.
0:24 Speaker 01 Modafinil from mod.com is changing the way high performers get energy. Modafinil is a prescription treatment that engages multiple pathways in your brain to achieve steady energy and alertness for 10 to 12 hours. And it's now available at mod.com to qualifying patients. Visit mod.com for a free consultation and get 10% off your first order plus free shipping with promo code SPOTIFY. That's promo code SPOTIFY at mod.com.
0:51 Speaker 02 PrizePix packs are here. Rip digital packs and get real basketball, football, and Pokemon cards on PrizePix packs. Available now nationwide. Once you see your pool, you have a choice to sell back instantly for real cash or ship it home. Cash from your sale will immediately be added to your PrizePix balance. It's just another way to run your game. New users, download the PrizePix app today and use code SPOTIFY to get $25 instantly in bonus packs when you buy your first $5 pack. PrizePix, run your game. 18 plus, eligible areas. Terms apply. Collect responsibly.
1:22 Speaker 03 Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. The message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.
1:43 Speaker 04 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.
2:04 Speaker 05 A Chevrolet refrigerated van trundled along La Alameda, which connected the Moneda Palace to the university. Near the ancient church of San Francisco, it turned right to enter the barrio Paris Landres, constructed around the intersection of two streets, Calais Landres and Calais Paris. The neighbourhood, once the garden of an ancient hermitage, was home to poets, writers and artists. The van moved over the cobblestones before coming to a stop before a low-grain stone building, number 38, referred to simply as Landres. Elsewhere, the street might have been London Strasser, or Rue de Landres, or Landres Street.
2:47 Speaker 05 Dun, dun, dun. What an amazing opening that is. Welcome, everyone, to We Have Ways of Making You Talk, with me, Almarion James-Holland. We are joined today by a very special guest, who is in fact now nosing ahead into the most frequently returned guest. Jim, who have we got? Who are we talking to and what are we talking about? Well, you know, he's definitely one of the greatest friends of the show. It is, of course, Philippe Sands. And that was the opening two paragraphs of 38 Landres Street, his new book, which is sizzling and compelling and full of, well, a key character in it is one of the badass lists of all badass Nazis, Walter Ralph. Welcome, Philippe.
3:26 Speaker 06 It's so good to be back. I can't tell you, there is no scale of happiness that is large enough. The joy of being with you two again. Literally my favourite podcast in history. No, I'm not. I'm not taking the piss. This is not being a barrister. This is from the heart.
3:45 Speaker 05 Well, it's great to have you back on and fantastic. We've been talking about this on and off for a number of years.
3:50 Speaker 06 We have, because you knew Mr Ralph well. Yes.
3:55 Speaker 05 I certainly went and interviewed his grandson in Santiago and visited his grave. I mean, he just keeps cropping up in my research and obviously now has become this sort of central figure in your new book. And wow, he's a...
4:08 Speaker 06 I came across him by accident and you and I then had discussions about him. I was doing research on one of the previous books, The Rat Line, in the archive of Otto and Charlotte Wächter. And I came across this letter written in 1949 in May, sent from Damascus, three pages, single-spaced, typed, basically telling Wächter, don't come to the Arab world, it's not a good place for Germans, they don't know how to work here. And suggesting that instead he'd go to South America. Wächter, Wächter of course died in Rome in mysterious circumstances. But I got intrigued by the author of the letter, one Walter Ralfe, Googled
4:47 Speaker 06 him, checked him out, saw that he had run the operation for the mobile gas vans in 1941 and 1942, working directly for Reinhard Heidrich under Himmler. And those vans were responsible for the killing of hundreds of thousands of human beings. He then flees after the war and ends up in Damascus. And maybe you want to pick up the story from there, James.
5:10 Speaker 05 Well, yes, except that he also, I mean, after his, his gas van hiatus, he's also in Tunisia, where he robs all the Jews of Gerba. And is, you know, that is the legend of Rommel's gold. It's nothing to do with Rommel whatsoever. It's Ralfe's gold that he's nicked from various Tunisians. And had gone down presumably somewhere in the, in the Mediterranean, and has been the subject of novels and school books. I remember reading a French school book, you know, when I was doing French at prep school, there was a book called Le Treasure de Rommel, and it was all about this. And Ralph was there. Then he crops up as one of Carl Wolf's men in Italy.
5:45 Speaker 06 In the Hotel Regina.
5:46 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly.
5:47 Speaker 06 Next to, next to the Milan Opera House.
5:50 Speaker 05 Exactly. And there's a moment in the kind of dying days of, of April 1945, where Wolf has just come back from his latest foray into Switzerland, and he finds himself in an SS safe house, and is surrounded by partisans. So he puts a call into Walter Ralfe and says, come and rescue me. Ralph says, no. You know, I mean, it's just amazing. But yeah, you know, he, he's in the Middle East. And then he, he heads off to, after the war, he manages to kind of escape and wiggle his way out of it. I mean, he's the arch-wiggler.
6:21 Speaker 06 Well, so you've sent me some materials that was really wonderful and I got completely immersed and I I followed him. Basically, he goes from Damascus, where he's head of the security service, running, apparently it's the CIA reports, a Gestapo-like operation. Makes his way back to Italy, then takes a boat with his wife and darling children to South America and ends up in Quito, Ecuador, where the designer of the mobile gas fans becomes a motor mechanic in the local Mercedes-Benz car dealership. I mean, you couldn't invent it. They make a new life for themselves and then lo and behold, they meet some marvelous
7:03 Speaker 06 Chileans, including a couple that he and Edith become very friendly with. And the Chilean couple tell the Ralphs, you're in the wrong country. You should be in Chile. We like people like you. So in 1958, they hop off to Chile. They are unable to find gainful employment in Santiago. So they go literally to the end of the world to Punta Arenas. And there Walter Ralph gets involved in the king crab canning business and eventually becomes the manager of the Pescara Camello King Crab Cannery. He's arrested in 1962 in December to be extradited and sent back to West Germany for trial for genocide and crimes against
7:46 Speaker 06 humanity. But that process fails because Chile has a 15-year statute of limitations and he can't be extradited because the crimes happened 21 years earlier. So he heads back to Punta Arenas and resumes his work as the manager of the King Crab Cannery, does his work beautifully for 10 years and then miracle of miracles, life, you really couldn't invent such a story. On September the 11th, 1973, his mate from Ecuador, Quito, becomes president of Chile because it is none other than Augusto Pinochet. See, Philippe, I can see the attraction of going to South America if you're a Nazi.
8:22 Speaker 00 What's the attraction of Nazis to South America? Why, why, why are they, why are they so simpatico and prepared to shield these people? Now, you know, you say it's the end of the earth. Fair enough. That's where I'd go if I were one of the world's wanted men. But why, why are Chileans so attracted to these characters and prepared to accommodate them?
8:41 Speaker 06 Well, that's a big and complicated question. I want to be careful how I answer it. But there is a big German community in Chile, and there has been since the late eighteenth, early nineteenth century. And so lots of German names, lots of German restaurants, lots of German characters. If you go there, I've been there a lot. And there is also, one has to say, with a certain section of the community, but not all of the community, a sympathy, shall we say, with the aims of the National Socialist Party. And so he finds in that community, including in Santiago and Punta Arenas, some, you know, some comrades and some friends. And he feels quite at home and quite protected until his cover is blown by these proceedings in Santiago in nineteen sixty-two.
9:25 Speaker 06 And then he is all over the place. He's in every single newspaper. And the headlines in the local paper in Punta Arenas, in the Astral, are, you know, Nazi mass murderer in our midst. And the amazing thing is, most people couldn't care less. They just get on with it. It was a long time ago, they say. It was, you know, a different part of the world. It wasn't us. I've been down to Punta Arenas quite a lot. In fact.
9:48 Speaker 00 What's it like?
9:49 Speaker 06 Oh, it's, it's an amazing place. I, I used as my guidebook, a fantastic book published in nineteen seventy-seven by one Bruce Chatwin.
9:57 Speaker 00 Ah, of course.
9:58 Speaker 06 Who went to Punta Arenas and was there. And unbelievably, in chapter ninety-six of his fabulous book, In Patagonia, it is devoted to Walter Ralph. There is a man in Punta Arenas.
10:10 Speaker 00 No.
10:11 Speaker 06 Yes, Ralph features in, in Patagonia. He was notorious. Everybody knew him. I went down there. I went down there with Chatwin in hand. Turns out, it's very interesting, Chatwin mentions lots of people he met in Punta Arenas. Most of them never existed. They were inventions.
10:27 Speaker 00 Really?
10:29 Speaker 06 Yeah, I know. It's really incredible.
10:31 Speaker 05 Righteous license.
10:32 Speaker 06 But I also met many of the ladies who worked with Ralph in the king crab cannery. They're now ladies in their eighties. They're marvelous people and I I'd say to them, how did you feel about having this Nazi in your midst after? After all the news came out and they said, to be honest, all we cared about was finding a boyfriend. We were sixteen, we were seventeen, we heard he'd done these terrible things. The older people were appalled, but you know, he treated us well and respectfully. He he didn't have much of a sense of humor. He was tough. We knew what he had done. One of the ladies showed me how he would come down the production line with the king crab, you know, putting them in the tins and and if he found the legs of a king crab
11:15 Speaker 06 over the edge of the tin, he would show her how to delicately put them back in and pat them down. And of course, she looked at me and said, of course, he had experience with such things.
11:25 Speaker 05 God.
11:26 Speaker 06 She knew, she knew what he had done thirty years earlier in the nineteen forties. They all knew, they all knew.
11:32 Speaker 05 How extraordinary. But weren't bothered, weren't bothered. I mean, it seems extraordinary, doesn't it? All the.
11:38 Speaker 06 There was a generational change. She said, these ladies who are now all in their eighties, what wonderful folk. I mean, really wonderful characters. They all knew, but they said, you know, when you're sixteen, seventeen, you care about your job, you care about finding a boyfriend, you don't care about the old geezer. The older ones were were appalled and there were a lot of very dark jokes about throwing people into the oven that was used to heat the water to boil the crabs. No, it was black humor. They all knew, they all knew, everybody knew. And there were regular forays. People would turn up in Punta Reinas to try to find Walter Ralph and he would try to keep his identity secret.
12:18 Speaker 05 But everyone knew.
12:18 Speaker 06 Everybody knew. It's an amazing place. It is the city in the world that is closest to the Antarctic. It's as far from anywhere as you could imagine. What I became interested in, and this is the sort of detective part of the story, is whether Ralph was involved in any of the crimes perpetrated by.
12:39 Speaker 06 By the Pinochet regime after September the 11th, 1973. When I first started looking into it, there were many, many rumours. A lot of people would say to me, oh, yes, you know, Ralph, he worked with Pinochet. But there was no hard evidence. And one of the reasons there was no hard evidence was that the Pinochet's secret intelligence services, the Dina, had sort of learnt from the Nazi experience. You do not.
13:02 Speaker 05 Not to write everything down.
13:03 Speaker 06 Right. If you either write things down, or you don't write things down, or if you do write things down, you destroy the pieces of paper. And some of your listeners may remember that in September, 1976, the Dina, under the direction of Augusto Pinochet, ordered the assassination of the former Chilean president Salvador Allende's Ministry of Defence, Orlando Letellier, in Washington DC. He was blown up in a car bomb in Washington DC in September 76. That caused the Americans to finally turn against Pinochet in the sense that they ordered this kind of stuff to stop happening, certainly on US territory. And the Dina was wound up and Manuel Contreras, who was the head of the Dina and Pinochet's right hand man, ordered the destruction of the entire Dina archive.
13:46 Speaker 06 So there are, it is said, but this becomes significant later in the book, no documents identifying Pinochet's role or the role of others in what had happened. And so there are no documents to search which explore Ralph's putative connection with.
14:03 Speaker 05 Yeah.
14:03 Speaker 06 With Pinochet. So all of the cases in Chile that relate to the Pinochet era are essentially done on witness testimony. So I've had to spend 10 years tracking down witnesses. And in fact, I'm very grateful to you, James, because you introduced me in a sense to Walter Ralph Junior Junior, the grandson, and he's been terrific.
14:22 Speaker 05 He's charming as well, isn't he?
14:24 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely.
14:25 Speaker 05 He hasn't inherited his grandfather's evil genes.
14:28 Speaker 06 No.
14:28 Speaker 05 But Philippe, could I, can we just go back a bit? Because he gets arrested in 1962. Yeah, the Chilean government refused the extradition. So suddenly.
14:38 Speaker 06 The courts, the courts.
14:39 Speaker 05 Courts do, the courts does. Yes, yes. Good point. So the court does. And so he stays. And I remember that that letter, which I think must have wound up in the CIA archives, where he writes to a former SS friend. And yeah, and in it, he says, give me one good Waffen SS division and I'll soon lick this country in shape. You know, so he's obviously kind of sort of brooding around and, you know, what's the transition from crab canning to potentially thirty eight laundry?
15:06 Speaker 06 It's more than brooding around.
15:08 Speaker 05 I know.
15:09 Speaker 06 Every April, he celebrates the Fuhrer's birthday.
15:12 Speaker 05 Yeah.
15:12 Speaker 06 With a bunch of friends.
15:14 Speaker 05 Yeah.
15:14 Speaker 06 He's very careful what he writes. Let's just wind back a little bit.
15:18 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly.
15:19 Speaker 06 Reason he has got into so much trouble and the reason he has hunted down is basically a single document received in nineteen forty two from a colleague in Lodz, L O D Z, Litmożstat, in occupied Poland, which basically describes the successful operation with the gas vans of killing ninety seven thousand people in the space of just a few weeks. This document is addressed to Ralph. He receives it. He responds positively. And it becomes evidence, first in the Nuremberg trial in nineteen forty five.
15:52 Speaker 05 Yeah.
15:53 Speaker 06 And then much more significantly in the trial of Eichmann in Jerusalem.
15:57 Speaker 05 Yeah. Which is also nineteen sixty two.
15:59 Speaker 06 Yeah, also nineteen sixty two. And that document basically catalyzes West German prosecutors into action.
16:06 Speaker 05 Got it.
16:06 Speaker 06 So he has learned to not put things in writing. So I've got a lot of his correspondence now to his sister in West Germany and to his nephew, also in West Germany, who's in the in the West German navy. And the letters, I've come to understand, are very coded. He's very careful what he says. But there are plenty of references to the glorious days and to the past and to hoping it might come back. And he even says, after Pinochet seizes power in Akkutia, he writes to his nephew and says, I am now like a protected monument. And that form of words, of course, for us, is a hint about what. Really going on.
16:45 Speaker 05 Yeah.
16:45 Speaker 06 But he never goes into any detail about what has happened.
16:49 Speaker 05 Isn't that amazing?
16:50 Speaker 06 Extraordinary. So, so i- is it, is it the Eichmann trial that sets the West German government into motion?
16:56 Speaker 05 Yes.
16:57 Speaker 06 You know, that in, in, in West Germany, it's in fits and starts this kind of attempts at bringing people to book, isn't it?
17:02 Speaker 05 That's exactly right.
17:02 Speaker 05 Well, it's the Eichmann trial. It's Fritz Bauer who gets it. He realizes that there's no stomach for it in Germany. And so gets it, arranges for, for the trial to happen in Jerusalem. Is that right? Have I got that right?
17:11 Speaker 06 No, that, I think that's not quite right in the sense that, I mean, he was, Eichmann, as you remember, was kidnapped by Mossad, by Israeli officers and transported to Israel for trial. So there never was going to be a chance. I mean, there was some discussion, should we send him back to West Germany? And the answer was, no, we're going to put him on trial and then we're going to execute him.
17:28 Speaker 05 But my understanding was that Fritz Bauer, who's this sort of, you know, amazing German lawyer, West German lawyer.
17:33 Speaker 06 Yeah.
17:34 Speaker 05 Has recognized that there's no stomach for it in Germany, that everyone's sort of brushing under the carpet. And so realizes that the way to get this to international attention is to actually put on a Nazi war crime in Jerusalem rather than in Germany.
17:46 Speaker 06 That is also correct. I mean, the two stories are not inconsistent. I think he was very supportive of the Jerusalem trial. The arrest, well, the kidnapping of Eichmann in Argentina really freaks out Ralph. I mean, he, not a day passes after that, that he does not worry that the same thing is going to happen to him. And the evidence for that is, is fascinating. Every time he leaves his house, he has these two huge Alsatian dogs, which become very important later on in the story. I hope we can get to that. His, his wife in the meantime has passed away and he has hooked up, although the relationship is of an indeterminate nature with a lady called Nena Zuniga, his new girlfriend.
18:30 Speaker 06 Every time he goes out, he leaves Nena a note and says, I have left the house at X time. This is where I'm going and I will be back precisely at Y time. And if I'm not back. Send out the search parties. So he was constantly worried. The cannery had guards there to protect him and the Eichmann thing had a, had a very big impact on him. Very, very big impact.
18:57 Speaker 07 Wow. I mean, well, good. I mean, I like the idea of this, of Ralph being terrified of his own shadow, really. I mean, I go quite, quite comfortable with that.
19:08 Speaker 06 Well, let's, let's park, let's park the question of what Ralph did or did not do with Pinochet between 73 and 77. And let's just jump a little bit forward because I want to jump to 1979.
19:20 Speaker 07 Okay. Go ahead. After all, there is a book for people to read rather than simply a podcast to listen to. Am I right?
19:26 Speaker 06 There is. What we're, what we're skirting around is the main story, actually, which is what exactly did Walter Ralph do between 1973 and 1977 when he retired? Did he or did he not have a relationship with Augusto Pinochet? Did he or did he not get involved in the disappearance of hundreds, if not thousands of Chileans? Did he or did he not have a relationship with the Chevrolet C10 van that trundled along Landres Street? I'm just leaving these things out there. But let's, let's go to 77. He retires in 77. Okay.
20:05 Speaker 06 And then, and this you may not have, you may not have been aware of, in 1979, in June, he gets a phone call. An old friend is passing through Santiago.
20:16 Speaker 07 Yeah.
20:17 Speaker 06 And that old friend is none other, you've mentioned his name already, Carl Wolf.
20:22 Speaker 07 Yes, absolutely extraordinary.
20:24 Speaker 06 Carl Wolf, who was his boss in Italy and pinned two Nazi era medals on his beaming chest.
20:32 Speaker 07 Yes.
20:32 Speaker 06 Says, I'm in Santiago. Shall we get together?
20:36 Speaker 07 How about it?
20:37 Speaker 06 Oh, says Walter. Wonderful.
20:39 Speaker 07 And even though I stitched you up when those partisans surrounded your house.
20:44 Speaker 06 Wolf then says, actually, I'm with an old friend, a writer who's writing a biography of me, but he doesn't really reveal who the old friend is. Should we talk about the old friend now?
20:58 Speaker 05 Yes.
20:58 Speaker 06 Because I think your listeners will be very familiar with the name. The old friend is a journalist with the German magazine Stern by the name of Gerhard Heidemann.
21:10 Speaker 05 Yes.
21:11 Speaker 07 Yeah.
21:12 Speaker 06 What's he most notorious for, Gerhard Heidemann, in 1982, three years later?
21:17 Speaker 07 The Hitler Diaries.
21:18 Speaker 06 The Hitler Diaries.
21:20 Speaker 07 How extraordinary.
21:21 Speaker 06 Ends up doing time for his role in the forging and sale of the Hitler Diaries.
21:26 Speaker 05 And he also gets all Wolf's papers.
21:30 Speaker 06 Well, so let's take it slowly. Wolf and Heidemann turn up in Santiago. They spend four days with Walter Ralf. I approach Heidemann to ask to be able to listen to the recordings or read the transcripts of those meetings. And Heidemann declines. He just does say, if you want to pay me for access, but he's talking about tens of thousands. So I just politely declined. He has subsequently sold the entire archive
22:00 Speaker 05 That's right.
22:00 Speaker 06 to Stanford University.
22:02 Speaker 05 Right.
22:02 Speaker 06 And I have just been to see the archive in Stanford University. It is beyond unbelievable.
22:08 Speaker 05 I remember, sorry, just to interrupt, but, but I remember when that was up for sale. I was just thinking, I don't have that money. I mean.
22:14 Speaker 06 Right. So it's, it's available now. It's not yet fully digitized. You can't yet go online, but it is, it includes the entirety of the visit by Wolf and Heidemann to visit Ralph, to visit Klaus Barbie in Bolivia, and to look for Bormen and Mengele. They spend four days with Ralph. They record the conversations. They transcribe the conversations. But it is, I mean, you guys could do a whole session just on the transcript of that meeting.
22:44 Speaker 07 Wow.
22:45 Speaker 06 And then they carry on to see Barbie in Bolivia. I've got the photographs.
22:50 Speaker 05 I mean, it's just, well, you've got a photo in the book of. Wolf and Ralph in the Bavarian restaurant in Santiago.
22:57 Speaker 06 Yeah, but you should see the photographs of Wolf with Barbie. Those are incredible. Anyway, what happens next? Heidemann ends up going back to West Germany. I carry on with my research and I end up in a library archive in Jerusalem, Israel, where I come across a book in Hebrew with fifty pages about Walter Ralph and and the visit of Wolf to Santiago in nineteen seventy nine. So I get the fifty pages translated and you could knock me over with a feather as to what I discover. Now, this is breaking news, guys, okay?
23:38 Speaker 06 Breaking news on the We Have Ways History Podcast, the first time I have ever talked about this. Okay, but it is in the book, all the detail. What do I discover in these fifty pages? I discover that when Gerd Heidemann returned to Hamburg from his visit to Walter Ralph, he then contacted his minder and his minder was a senior agent at an agency called Mossad, because it turned out that Gerd Heidemann was a secret agent for Mossad.
24:09 Speaker 05 What?
24:09 Speaker 06 And
24:10 Speaker 05 Amazing.
24:10 Speaker 06 He was charged with identifying the location of Ralph's whereabouts and reporting back the details, which he does, photographs, maps, accounts. And six months later, Mossad send out a hit squad to assassinate Walter Ralph. It's all in this
24:29 Speaker 05 Yeah.
24:30 Speaker 06 book in Yehudavashem in the in the library in Jerusalem, but only in only in Hebrew. And let's just say again, minor spoiler alert, the matter is resolved by the arrival of a very nasty Alsatian dog.
24:48 Speaker 06 Alsatian dogs played
24:49 Speaker 05 The key part in Walter Ralph's life.
24:52 Speaker 06 Walter Ralph's life, yeah. If you go backwards a little bit to 1975, Walter Ralph is distraught when one of his dogs dies. And the Camellio family, and I've spoken to a member who remembers the incident, who was a young boy at the time, the Camellio family bought Ralph a new dog, a, an Alsatian puppy. And young Camellio, Eduardo, who's now sort of in his 60s, remembers seeing Walter Ralph cry as he was given this new dog. And this dog, five years later, will have a huge role in saving his life. It's an incredible story.
25:36 Speaker 06 We need to take a quick break right now. We'll be back in a second.
25:41 Speaker 02 When you're building a company, you learn that trust is what closes deals. You may have the best product, but buyers won't sign without proof that your product is secure, especially if it has AI. Vanta gets you compliant fast with SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, and keeps you secure with continuous monitoring. Hyperbound, a YC-backed startup, used Vanta to unlock the Fortune 100 in under a year. Snowfire got audit-ready in a month and closed a multimillion-dollar deal. Trust matters. Get started at vanta.com.
26:09 Speaker 03 Hey, Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. Now, I don't know if you've heard, but Mint's premium wireless is $15 a month. But I'd like to offer one other perk. We have no stores. That means no small talk. Crazy weather we're having. No, it's not. It's just weather. It is an introvert's dream. Give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.
26:32 Speaker 04 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan. $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.
26:39 Speaker 02 PrizePix packs are here. Rip digital packs and get real basketball, football and Pokemon cards on PrizePix packs. Available now nationwide. Once you see your pool, you have a choice to sell back instantly for real cash or ship at home. Cash from your sale will immediately be added to your PrizePix balance. It's just another way to run your game. New users, download the PrizePix app today and use code SPOTIFY to get $25 instantly in bonus packs when you buy your first $5 pack. PrizePix, run your game. 18 plus in eligible areas. Terms apply. Collect responsibly.
27:14 Speaker 07 Welcome back to We Have Ways of A Q Talk. Jim and I are talking to Philippe Sands.
27:19 Speaker 06 I mean, the simple point here is we thought that the Nazi era in a set where you know, you guys know it wasn't, it was dead and buried. It was all over, but of course it wasn't. These characters got out and about and the central story in this book is on the question of what Ralph did or did not do with Pinochet. And of course, up until now, we have no hard evidence that any of the Nazis who escaped to South America had any involvement in the work of the generals in the dictatorships that emerged from the mid 1970s in that part of the world. And without going into too much detail, what I can say is we now have hard evidence. Yeah.
28:01 Speaker 06 Eyewitnesses, witness testimony of a senior Nazis' very direct role in crimes committed after 1973. And that's, I think, very significant at a historical level, but I think it's also very significant for your podcast because it basically is a way of saying these are not only matters of historical interest, they had continuing consequences.
28:25 Speaker 07 Yeah.
28:25 Speaker 06 Thirty years after the end of the war in a very real way.
28:28 Speaker 07 Yeah. Yes, Nazism and its and its and its methods don't simply come to a full stop in the summer of 1945. I mean, this is so fascinating, Philippe, and the sort of tentacles of Nazi legacy should find themselves in a crab canning factory at the end of the earth, but nevertheless then be drawn back to the centre of power, I think, is extraordinary.
28:52 Speaker 06 Well, the tentacles sprout everywhere. You'll have read about the Crab Canary in Punta Arenas, but I wonder whether you had previously come across, I think Jim probably has, a place called Colonia Dignitad, Colony Dignity. This is about three hours south of Santiago by car. It's an estate, an agricultural estate, that was purchased by a former Wehrmacht nurse, I think he was, called Paul Schaefer, an old Nazi, but of a very low Grade kind of level. He fled West Germany and then the Arab world with allegations of paedophilia surging all around him and ends up in Chile where he sets up an estate
29:36 Speaker 06 uh for Germans of a certain view i- in South America and they bring in a lot of orphan Chilean children and it becomes a centre for two nasty things. It becomes a centre for paedophilia and it becomes a centre for, if you like, neo Nazism and support for the Pinochet regime in the mid nineteen seventies. Now, this is a place where people were taken to be disappeared during the Pinochet era. Uh I've been there. It's one of the nastiest places I've ever visited and I've seen a lot of nasty places. And you meet some of the folk who are living there who were kids in the time of Paul Schaefer.
30:18 Speaker 06 They remember Pinochet visiting. They remember Manuel Contreras visiting. They show me around to the torture centres, to the places where bodies were disposed. But what is most shocking of all is that this place is now a hotel and a restaurant. I I mean, it's literally.
30:36 Speaker 05 Well, you just can't believe it, can you?
30:38 Speaker 06 Charing government has just passed legislation to close this place down. But the boys who are now older men will explain, yeah, there were loads of Nazis around. We met lots of people who were old Nazis and this was a centre for them. And i- it's it's really a shocking place. There is a six part Netflix series. I think it's called The Colony.
30:57 Speaker 05 Yes.
30:58 Speaker 06 If you're interested in this, it's really worth watching. It's shocking. It's absolutely shocking.
31:03 Speaker 07 This brings us to the question of, you you know, as you say, legislation's been passed to shut this place down. It's how is Chile grappling with this part of its past? Because sort of Pinochet is i- in a way, one thing, but Nazi involvement is sort of another, you know. Uh uh although, as you've made it quite clear, they're completely entwined. How how how can you, how do you address this in your, because this is more a more recent part, this isn't the German. Problem of how do you digest what your great grandparents did. This is sort of alive, isn't it?
31:37 Speaker 06 It's very interesting. Jim introduced me to Walter Ralph Junior Junior, the very lovely grandson. And he is very clear, he sort of, he recognizes what his grandfather did in the nineteen forties. He says, I accept it. What he won't accept is the idea that his grandfather may have had a role in the crimes perpetrated in the nineteen seventies.
31:59 Speaker 07 Right.
32:00 Speaker 06 And this is still a subject that is incredibly touchy in Chilean society. In fact, the book comes out on the second of April in Chile. I will be there for the launch in Santiago, in Punta Reinas and Valparaiso. And I'm very curious to know what the reaction will be because society is very divided. It's very interesting. You'd be amazed if you go and you're driven around by a taxi driver of a certain age. He will tell you, yeah, I know all about Walter Ralph. I've had many taxi journeys. My test is always talking to taxi drivers. They all know the name. I had one, one moment where I was being driven to the former headquarters of the Dina, now a university building.
32:42 Speaker 06 And we were talking about Walter Ralph, I and a former Dina agent who had something to tell me about Walter Ralph. And the taxi driver at a certain point interrupted and said, may I be permitted to join this conversation? And we said, of course. And he said, yes, I remember Walter Ralph very well. I, I know all about him. And we said, how do you know all about him? He said, well, I lived through that period. Everybody knew about Walter Ralph and it really is very present. It's, it's quite shocking, actually. It's, it's quite shocking. But people don't really want to talk about it. And one of the things I'm interested in with the material that I've managed to uncover by talking to former agents and others who came across Walter Ralph is what the reaction will be.
33:22 Speaker 06 Will it be silence or will there be a desire to really engage with these issues in a country that remains very divided?
33:31 Speaker 07 Gosh, you're I mean, you're going to be able to visit again, Philippe. That's my my my next question, you know, you're not you're not going to end up cancelled by the sort of right wing side of things in Chile, are you?
33:45 Speaker 06 Well, it's worth putting the rest of the story in context. I mean, the book is about two men. It's about it's about Ralph in Chile in the seventies. But it's also about the arrest of Augusto Pinochet in London in October nineteen ninety eight. And of course, the issue that I was interested in, I was involved in that case.
34:02 Speaker 07 Of course.
34:02 Speaker 06 As you as you may remember.
34:04 Speaker 07 You got rung up by by the dictator, didn't you?
34:06 Speaker 06 I got rung up by his lawyers on the morning of the thirtieth of October nineteen ninety eight, two weeks after he had he had been arrested and charged with genocide and crimes against humanity. And his claim was that he had immunity as a former head of state for any acts that were official acts while he was president. I was in Paris when I got the call. I was actually heading to the cemetery at Pontin for a ceremony at my grandfather's grave. He had just died. And I met my wife at the gates of the cemetery, very large, beautiful wooden doors. And I said to her, to be, I have to be honest here. I said to her with some excitement, Pinochet's lawyers have been in touch. They want me to argue that he is immune from the jurisdiction of the English courts.
34:50 Speaker 06 And my wife said, will you do it? And I said, well, you know, I'm embarrassed that we've got tough ethical rules of conduct. We've got something called the cab rank principle. We're like taxi drivers, we're toddling along and someone wants to use our services. We can't say we don't like the cut of his jib. We don't like this person's politics. You've got to act for them. Well, she said, yes, I know all about the cab rank principle. You need to understand that my wife first is American and thinks the cab rank principle is rubbish. And secondly, she is the daughter of a refugee from the Spanish Civil War who ended up in Tottenham, England. And so is not very keen on people like Franco and Pinochet. And she expressed her views on the cab rank principle. I said, yes, but I will, I will do it. And she said, well, you can do it if you want to do it, but I will divorce you tomorrow if you do it.
35:32 Speaker 07 So that was that.
35:33 Speaker 06 That was that. We're still married.
35:35 Speaker 07 Yeah. So it was obviously the right decision.
35:37 Speaker 06 Twenty seven years later, was it the right decision? No, it wasn't. Of course it was the right decision.
35:43 Speaker 05 I remember talking to various people. I remember going to the Ralph grave in that beautiful, beautiful cemetery, which was just, it was just gorgeous and lots of sort of bougainvillea everywhere and really colourful. It was incredible kind of tombs all over. I mean, you know, the other place would like it is like that extraordinary place in Calcutta. But I also talked to that chap who was a German Jew called Rudy Hyman.
36:09 Speaker 06 Oh, my word. Carry on, Jim.
36:12 Speaker 05 Well, he was extraordinary and he absolutely swore, but you know, he was in his nineties and still a architect and he'd worked for the British in the, in the Second World War, so he said.
36:23 Speaker 06 He showed me the photographs. I went to see him.
36:25 Speaker 05 Yeah. And he swore that he had been recruited to report, to watch, to basically spy on Ralph and report his movements.
36:33 Speaker 06 Did you talk about politics with him?
36:35 Speaker 05 Not really.
36:36 Speaker 06 Well, you would have discovered that he was rather partial to Auguste Pinochet. When I saw him, there was a presidential election underway between one Mr. Boric on the left and Mr. Cast on the right.
36:52 Speaker 05 Amazing.
36:53 Speaker 06 Mr. Cast's daddy was a member of the Nazi Party in Germany.
36:57 Speaker 05 No.
36:58 Speaker 06 And was reputed to have carried forward his views until more recent times.
37:03 Speaker 05 Amazing.
37:04 Speaker 06 Rudy Hyman was going to vote for Mr. Cast.
37:08 Speaker 05 What? What? I mean, when I met him, he was absolutely, you know, he was remarkable because he looked an incredible Nick for his 92 years or however old he was when I met him. You know, he was still working as an architect. He had worked for the British, in British Intelligence, you know, in the field. He was a field intelligence officer, he said.
37:25 Speaker 06 Well, he was. I saw the photographs. He showed me all the photographs. I spent a couple of hours with him and the conversation was going in a swimmingly excellent direction.
37:36 Speaker 06 Until he revealed his rather positive feelings for Mr. Pinochet and his even more positive feelings and intention to vote for a man whose father was a Nazi and who had recently called for the pardoning of all people convicted of crimes during the Pinochet era. I had to say, I, in the end, as you will have noticed, left Mr. Hyman out of my book.
38:04 Speaker 05 Yes, because he doesn't feature in your book.
38:05 Speaker 06 He doesn't feature, and he doesn't feature because I felt I could not write about him without revealing that aspect of the conversation. In fact, he didn't have a direct role in relation to Ralph. I quizzed him, I used my best barristerial techniques.
38:22 Speaker 05 Well done.
38:23 Speaker 06 To really tease out what had he done and not done, and it turned out that he hadn't done very much.
38:29 Speaker 05 No.
38:30 Speaker 06 But the main problem was, he was voting for the son of a Nazi, and the son of a Nazi who has views that are, I mean, it's not, you know, there's nothing, as you know from my work with Nick Frank and Horst Vechter, I've got nothing against sons of Nazis, they're decent folk. But Mr. Cast the candidate remained, shall we say, sympathetic to Daddy's ideals.
38:52 Speaker 07 So why on earth could he be voting for him? Because?
38:55 Speaker 05 Because he's a German Jew.
38:56 Speaker 07 Smack a firm government or something, and the sort of arguments that would...
39:00 Speaker 06 It's back to the Cold War period. I mean, Allende was a communist, Boric is on the left, it's basically the old Cold War fears of the rise of communism, Marxism, socialism, call it what you will, and that was what was motivating him. And coming back to your questions, the country is divided, and one of the reasons Walter Ralph was able to have a relatively decent life in Chile was that he was embraced by a large number of people, including his employers at the Pescara Camellio, who knew all about what he had done, basically didn't really have much of a problem with it. That's the, that's the reality of the situation.
39:37 Speaker 05 Well, anyone who wants to can go on YouTube and you can look at grainy footage of the funeral of Walter Ralph. And there they all are, standing by the grave doing their hitless sleeps. It's just astonishing.
39:46 Speaker 06 Well, I went to visit the pastor who conducted the funeral, you know, you know me, I leave no stone unturned.
39:52 Speaker 05 No, of course, quite right, too.
39:53 Speaker 06 Pastor Wagner from the German Lutheran Church, who didn't know the Ralph family until the sun turned up and said, Father has died, will you bury him? And Pastor Wagner told me he didn't know about Ralph's background and therefore was rather like a barrister and the cab rank principal, perfectly happy to bury this fellow. And of course, only as the processes were underway, did he become aware, he said, of Ralph's background and all the complexities. But reading between the lines of my lengthy conversation with him, he was, that did not stop him. In fact, I did, I did question him about one aspect. I was told an amazing story by a former Foreign Minister of Chile, who told me how in 1984,
40:38 Speaker 06 after Ralph was reported to have died, he received, the Foreign Minister of Chile received a request from the Israeli Minister of Foreign Affairs to inspect the corpse of Ralph, to check that it was him and that he was well and truly dead. And the Chilean government apparently gave permission for the said inspection to take place and confirmed the identity of the corpse as that of W. Ralph. Pastor Wagner told me he had no knowledge of that intervention and was not consulted on it. But the individual stories, as all stories on your wonderful podcast are, you couldn't really invent them. I mean, they're really mad, aren't they? They're mad.
41:21 Speaker 07 I suppose the pastor had to take the funeral because he wasn't under the threat of divorce, was he? I suppose.
41:27 Speaker 06 As I interviewed Pastor Wagner, his lovely wife
41:31 Speaker 07 Oh, right.
41:32 Speaker 06 sat next to him, holding one hand and with her eyes, I could sense was imploring him to be very careful what he said.
41:44 Speaker 07 Exactly.
41:47 Speaker 06 It was a very protective spouse, and this is often the case.
41:51 Speaker 05 What happens to Walter Ralph Junior, to produce Walter Ralph Junior Junior, who's so genius.
41:57 Speaker 06 Walter Ralph Junior is also said to have worked for the Dina. He is identified, I mean, in order to get to the bottom of what happened between Ralph and Pinochet, in the absence of documents, I had to find people who may have seen or heard things. And I did put a lot of time into that with great help from some remarkable Chilean journalists and writers who were, who I really want to pay tribute to. And I was introduced to two characters, Samuel Fuenzalida, who was a Dina guard at Landres 38, where a lot of the torture happened. Incidentally, I had also met a man who claimed to have been personally interrogated and tortured by Walter Ralph at Landres 38.
42:41 Speaker 06 And then I met another man who was the young butler, El Mosito, at the home of Manuel Contreras. And they described to me many things that they saw, including the presence of Walter Ralph in some of these episodes. And so, you know, it is possible now to work out what exactly his role was. And, and the details are, as your readers will find out, pretty horrific.
43:10 Speaker 07 Gosh. Well, thanks, Philippe, for joining us today. I think this is, I mean, as you, as you were saying a moment ago, this does show that the end of the Second World War, James and I have just, just completed a volume about the end of the war, you know, how it doesn't represent a full stop of, of any kind at all. It's a dispersal. And after all, Nazism is a, is a, is a faith as much as anything, isn't it? If you're, if you're a true believer, you take
43:37 Speaker 06 It with you wherever you go, right? I mean, it goes on and on, Al. We're speaking on the day that I've been reading an interview in various papers by the daughter of Elon Musk, describing Elon Musk as having done a Nazi salute in that famous photo that we've all seen. In her opinion, I don't know whether she's right or not, she describes that as a Nazi salute. I mean, she doesn't get on with her dad, and so she may have reasons for wanting to so describe it. But it does go on and on, and I think that's one of the aspects that's really interesting. Incidentally, I'm very, very thrilled that I will this year be able to be with you at your Yes. Ways with Words Fest in person. Yes.
44:19 Speaker 06 And it's gonna be really exciting for me to meet your listeners.
44:23 Speaker 05 You're good. Well, prepare to be mobbed, and they're all gonna want to.
44:25 Speaker 06 Yes, you will be mobbed.
44:26 Speaker 05 What I will say, though, is that the people who come to We Have Ways Fest are to a man and woman and child, all absolutely delightful. And there is a, despite we're kind of sort of commemorating and brought together by something so catastrophic and awful, which is the Second World War, there is an extraordinary joyousness to the entire occasion, where everyone is just so happy that they're there for this unadulterated weekend, where they're going to be with mates and listen to things that they find interesting and see things that they believe are interesting. And it's just a wonderful, wonderful gathering. I mean, you'll absolutely love it.
45:01 Speaker 06 I'm really looking forward to it. And one thing I do want to do, actually, I've got some pretty amazing photographs and even a bit of video that I'd really like to play when we have the conversation, because it's stunning video of a journalist apprehending or coming across Walter Ralf. Oh, amazing. In nineteen eighty, which I think is not available broadly.
45:22 Speaker 05 Amazing. It's also a fabulous book, so I urge everyone to go and get it. One thing, though, just before you, before we call off, Philip, you mentioned off air at the beginning that the Chevrolet van that I read out to start the episode was inspired by a conversation with John Le Carre.
45:40 Speaker 05 You sort of slightly left that dangling.
45:42 Speaker 06 Yeah.
45:44 Speaker 05 I'm wondering what, what, what writing tips I can garner from you via, via you from John Le Carré for my, my own work.
45:52 Speaker 06 Yeah. Well, you've, you've redangled it. I have had many wonderful things in my life and one of the many wonderful things was that my neighbour for 20 or more years, this man called David Cornwall, AKA John Le Carré. I first met him in the early 2000s in a, in our local pub. I didn't know who he was and we became friends. And over the years, I would increasingly have a role. Every single one of his novels has a truly disgusting lawyer in it, in case you haven't noticed. Literally, check every single book. He hated lawyers. And my role was to review the manuscript and check that the abominable lawyer was accurately portrayed.
46:36 Speaker 06 So he would turn up at the front door, holding a manuscript printed out on his home computer and would just say usual procedure. And he had not put a little sticky in with, you know, page 293, where the five lines describing this appalling human being were laid out. And so I'd have to read the whole thing to find the five lines of the disgusting lawyer.
46:57 Speaker 05 Amazing.
46:57 Speaker 06 We would talk a lot then about how he wrote and how it was that he would take very dense material, complicated, dense, technical, often material, on the world of espionage, on the dark world as he.
47:10 Speaker 05 Or in my case, the Battle of the Bulge.
47:12 Speaker 06 Yeah, and make it accessible. And he was very interesting. He, I learnt to respect readers and listeners. He said, readers are really smart. They come to know how you write and they come to understand that every word that you have put in your book is there for a reason.
47:28 Speaker 05 Yes.
47:29 Speaker 06 And they think they're smarter than you and they want to work out in advance what it is that is going to be the big reveal before the author reveals it. And he said, one of the techniques I use fully is I put in little clues in the early pages and the readers are trying to work out what the clue is there for. And what it means. And you'll have found it in the Rat Line where I very early on make a passing reference to Otto Vektor's desire to swim in the River Tiber. Yes.
47:59 Speaker 05 Yeah.
48:00 Speaker 06 And here, the clue, without giving too much away, is the refrigerated vans.
48:05 Speaker 05 Yes.
48:06 Speaker 06 That you read out right at the beginning, Jim.
48:08 Speaker 05 Yeah, brilliant. I love that.
48:08 Speaker 06 That is plagiarized and stolen and taken from the wonderful, my wonderful former neighbour. But I mean, there are too many coincidences. Another of my neighbours signed the arrest warrant of Augusto Pinochet, literally my next door neighbour, our garden's a butt. And another neighbour was, was the judge whose relationship with Amnesty International caused such a problem in the Pinochet proceedings, Lord Hoffman. You may remember, there was a whole palaver about that trial and the House of Lords had to set aside its ruling that Pinochet did not have immunity, when it turned out that one of the judges had a continuing relationship with Amnesty International. And therefore, the judgment had to be set aside and they had to start again.
48:52 Speaker 06 It, it is a bonkers story. I mean, fact is stranger than fiction. There's no question.
48:57 Speaker 05 Yeah, amazing.
48:58 Speaker 06 You couldn't invent such a story and get away with it, probably.
49:01 Speaker 05 No, no, no, no, it's extraordinary. It's terrific stuff and, and.
49:04 Speaker 06 Absolutely.
49:05 Speaker 05 You know, the, these Nazis, they are, are grotesque, but they are compelling. You have to say that. I mean, you know, for just that awfulness. Carl Wolf ending up in the Bavarian Restaurant in Santiago is just, it's just amazing.
49:17 Speaker 06 Well, Carl Wolf in the company of the man who forged the Hitler Dior.
49:20 Speaker 05 Yeah, well, this, in our new book, there are two chapters devoted to the final duel between Wolf and Kautenbrunner, who, needless to say, absolutely hated each other's guts. And it's just, you know, I've been writing about Wolf on and off a year. So it's just fascinating to see him pop up again.
49:36 Speaker 06 You need to do.
49:37 Speaker 05 Some research in Stanford.
49:39 Speaker 06 Well, you know, you need to do a podcast from Stanford. You need to go there and you need to do it from there. I've got a lot of the stuff which I'm, I can share with you. I happily give it all to you. I took so many pages of photographs.
49:49 Speaker 05 That'd be amazing.
49:50 Speaker 06 But it's not yet digitized, but you need to go there.
49:53 Speaker 05 Okay.
49:54 Speaker 06 And you will find things. You're a really, you will find stuff that I'm not aware of its significance.
50:00 Speaker 05 Right.
50:00 Speaker 06 In the conversation.
50:01 Speaker 05 Yeah, amazing.
50:01 Speaker 06 You will, you need to do a whole thing from Stanford Archive.
50:04 Speaker 07 Another thing on our list of to-do list, Jim, with the second one, it's me. Thank you so much, Philippe. Thanks, everyone, for listening. We will see you at We Have Ways Fest with Philippe, indeed.
50:17 Speaker 06 You will, indeed.
50:18 Speaker 07 On the 12th and 14th of September. Thanks, everyone, for listening. Cheerio.
50:22 Speaker 05 Cheerio.
50:22 Speaker 06 Bye.
50:39 Speaker 03 Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile with a message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.
51:08 Speaker 02 PrizePix packs are here. Rip digital packs and get real basketball, footfall and Pokemon cards on PrizePix packs. Available now nationwide. Once you see your pool, you have a choice to sell back instantly for real cash or ship it home. Cash from your sale will immediately be added to your PrizePix balance. It's just another way to run your game. New users, download the PrizePix app today and use code SPOTIFY to get $25 instantly in bonus packs when you buy your first $5 pack. PrizePix, run your game. 18-plus eligible areas. Terms apply. Collect responsibly.
51:39 Speaker 04 When you spend enough time around great companies, you notice that the best ones treat trust as a growth strategy, not a box to check. Vanta helps companies build and prove trust from day one. Its Agentic Trust Platform connects compliance, risk and trust at enterprise scale. Vanta delivers a 526% return on investment over three years and pays for itself in just three months. Learn why over 16,000 of the fastest-growing companies use Vanta at vanta.com.
Previous Fighting With The French Resistance Next Dead Presidents: FDR to Truman Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated