Pod Insights WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk Atlantic War: The Loss Of Three Aces (Part 6) About this episode How did destroyers and escort groups protect convoys from U-Boat attack? When did convoy HX112 encounter the U-Boat 'Wolfpack' of Kretschmer and Schepke? What is a 'Pocket Battleship'?
Join James Holland and Al Murray for part 6 of this deep dive on the war in the Atlantic, the most vital theatre of war in WW2 and the long-running campaign between the British Royal Navy and the Nazi German Kriegsmarine.
Start your free trial at patreon.com/wehaveways and unlock exclusive content and more. Enjoy livestreams, early access to podcast episodes, ad-free listening, bonus episodes, and a weekly newsletter packed with book deals and behind-the-scenes insights. Members also get priority access and discounts to live events.
A Goalhanger Production
Produced by James Regan
Assistant Producer: Alfie Rowe
Exec Producer: Tony Pastor
Social: @WeHaveWaysPod
Email: [email protected]
Membership Club: patreon.com/wehaveways
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 9,373 words · 10 speakers
0:02 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. Sign up to our Patreon to receive bonus content, live streams, and our weekly newsletter, with money off books and museum visits as well, plus early access to all live show tickets. That's patreon.com/WeHaveWays.
0:25 Speaker 01 The award-winning American Airlines Advantage program rewards more than travel. It takes your whole life to new heights. Earn miles when you fly, as well as with thousands of your favorite brands, and then redeem those miles for flights, upgrades, and experiences worldwide. Advantage members also enjoy earlier boarding and free high-speed Wi-Fi in-flight. Join for free and start earning towards your next adventure at aa.com/spotify.
0:55 Speaker 02 Born from the intensity of a night in the Eternal City, introducing Born in Roma Fragrances by Valentino. Feminine perfume Donna Born in Roma features juicy black currant, central jasmine, soft cashmerin, and warm vanilla. Masculine-leaning but unisex Womo has notes of fresh violet leaf, aromatic sage, green vetiver, and mineral salt. Shop holiday gifts at macys.com.
1:24 Speaker 03 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And, no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month, or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
2:04 Speaker 00 With binoculars firmly wedged on a steady bearing, I put Walker into a gently curving course, thereby putting every point of the compass under a penetrating probe. It worked. As her bow swung, a thin line of white water came into the lens of my glasses, a thin line which could only be the wake of a ship. There were none of ours in that direction. It had to be a U-boat. I shouted orders, increasing speed to 30 knots and altered course towards the target. Suddenly, the U-boat spotted us, and in a cloud of spray, he crash-dived. A swirl of phosphorescent water still lingered as we passed over the spot and sent a pattern of 10 depth charges crashing down. We could hardly have missed. It had been so quick, we must have dropped them smack on top of him. Then the depth charges exploded with great cracking explosions, and giant water spouts rose to masthead height astern of us.
2:48 Speaker 00 Two and a half minutes later, another explosion followed, and an orange flash spread momentarily across the surface. We had every reason to hope that this was our first kill. And that's Commander Donald McIntyre, fighting the Atlantic War. Welcome to We Have Ways of Making You Talk with me, Al Murray, James Holland. Episode six of our Atlantic War saga, the first phase of the Atlantic War, let's make that clear. And this episode is enticingly titled, The Loss of the Three Aces. But before we get to that, who was it? I was ventriloquising then, just Jim. Commander Donald McIntyre, who's that?
3:20 Speaker 04 There's these terrific characters that emerge in any war, isn't there? And in any parts of the armed forces. We talked about Peter Gretton. I think people may have heard of Johnny Walker, whose statue is there on the quayside on the Mersey in Liverpool. These epic men of the Atlantic War. And McIntyre's one of those. You know, he's a commander of an escort group. He's a career naval officer type, backbone of the wartime navy. 35 in March 1941, he's got a sort of roundish, genial face. He's joined the Royal Navy in 1926. Interestingly, and you'll like him even more because of this, he's a former pilot in the Fleet Aeron. Tremendous chap, but had an accident in 1935, and that left him unable to fly. So he went back to surface vessels. He'd been commanding HMAs Hesperus, which is an H-Christa destroyer, and one of the more modern destroyers since January 1940.
4:05 Speaker 04 Been involved in the Norwegian campaign, one of the destroyers causing havoc against Sir Kriegs Marina at Narvik and you know, like those hardcore review boat aces, McIntyre is one of those guys who's just got sea in his blood. But at the beginning of March 1941, he's given the command of the fifth escort group. And this me giving up his sleek and modern destroyer HMS Hesperus for another destroyer HMS Walker and Walker's a sort of old tin can and rusting at the seams and you know, very much one of those 1918 types. Very happy with the promotion and the opportunity to lead, but not so chuffed with Walker. I mean, you know, it's going from a Porsche to, I don't know, something not so good.
4:45 Speaker 00 Swings and roundabouts though, isn't it? He gets the promotion, but the ship isn't so good. But if he's commanding an escort group, that means he's the senior officer escort, an SOE, not to be confused with the other SOE. And not that anyone who is an SOE knows about SOE. So it's not confusing for a Donald McIntyre, is it? As the Royal Navy expands, they're milking out their experience across. So it tends to be that these SOEs are regulars. They're long service naval people and their first less tenants tend to be from the Royal Naval Reserve. And the rest of the officers on the ship for the RNVR, the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve, because they've got different gradations of reservists within the Navy and different manpower pools, basically. You've got the RN, RNR, RNVR, and the badges on your cuffs, you're immediately identifiable.
5:30 Speaker 04 Yes, and not on epaulettes. You don't have epaulettes in the Navy. You have on your jacket, bands around your cuffs, and they're very distinct.
5:36 Speaker 00 Yeah. And they tell you which branch you're from. They're straight lines if you're in the Royal Navy. They're woven lines for the Royal Navy Reserve and they're wavy, the wavy Navy, the RNVR for the Volunteer Reserve. It's interesting because one of the things the Navy's doing is protecting its career officers with this. So there's a ceiling if you're a RNR and there's a ceiling if you're a RNVR. They are taking care of people who've given their lives to the Navy in the long term. But you would give him this job. He's really, really experienced. And this kind of convoy is 40 to 80 merchant vessels and every convoy route has a two or three code letters. So they have troop convoys to the Middle East, a WS, Winston specials, but most of them actually kind of tell you where the convoy's sailing. So HX is Halifax or HXF is Halifax.
6:19 Speaker 00 Sydney Cove, Nova Scotia, gives you SC rather than slow convoy. And if you're going west, you're ONF and ONS, fast and slow. So the code letters kind of tell you what the convoys are. In the last episode, we talked about how the training's been standardised, the methods have been shaken down so that everyone knows what's going on and everyone knows how you respond to different situations and what's expected of you. Because they're all relying on each other to behave as expected, aren't they? It's the truth. So there's a convoy conference at the start of a convoy. All of the officers are in attendance, Commodore and the masters of all the merchant vessels. That's a sort of three quarter of an hour convoy conference. That'll be followed by the convoy then meeting. So they have to gather, there's a sort of muster point, isn't there? You know, Halifax or Sydney Cove or whatever.
7:02 Speaker 04 And this evolves as the war progresses because, you know, in a convoy that's coming from Halifax, for example, you know, say you've got 40 ships coming from Halifax. They don't all originate from Halifax. They might come from New York or the Caribbean or from South America. But for the purposes of getting across the Atlantic, they then all converge. Form up out at sea in columns. Each column is approximately 600 yards, give or take, apart. And each ship is kind of 400 yards behind the other. You need them to be close enough to have that sort of safety of being close, but far enough apart that you're not going to crash into one another when the weather closes in. So it's obviously a balance and in charge would be the convoy Commodore, tended to be a retired RN Royal Navy type with a rank of Commodore RNR, Royal Navy Reserve.
7:46 Speaker 04 And the ships obviously are lined up to sort of create a box and the Commodore would be at the top of the centre column typically. The convoy Commodore is senior in rank to the senior officer escort, the SOE. But the Commodore of the convoy is to take charge of the convoy as a whole, subject to the orders of the senior officer of the escort. So in other words, the SOE trumps him effectively, once they're out at sea.
8:10 Speaker 00 There's an interesting sort of dynamic, isn't it? The guy calling the shots is the guy with the weapons is what it comes down to in the end.
8:16 Speaker 04 But everyone gets it, everyone understands it's standard. There's no complaints about this. You don't get any beef from the convoy commodore.
8:21 Speaker 00 He knows his role. And then they they station out front and out to the sides 60 degrees. And maybe two more off beam at the rear, kind of three to 4,000 yards away from the edge of convoy. And the idea is when there's something spotted, they can steam quickly to the crisis point or steam off, return and have an eye on everybody as well. Although, as we heard in the last episode, keeping an eye on everybody is quite difficult if the weather's rotten. A slow convoy goes at 7.58 knots, a fast convoy at 13 knots.
8:51 Speaker 04 Well, up to 13 knots. It can be above eight and no less than 13.
8:55 Speaker 00 Exactly. These are all figures that are aspirations rather than certainties, aren't they? And McIntyre's first convoy initially is going west. The convoy would steam in just two columns until they were clear of the Irish Sea. Then everyone tests their communications, so their lamps, radiocomms, they test their guns. And the escorts, they're still essentially still running their systems, making sure that everything works and training themselves as they sail out to embark on convoy.
9:19 Speaker 04 But they are a bit like sheepdogs, aren't they? Sort of beetling around the edges, you know?
9:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly, exactly, yeah. The fifth escort group is consists of HMS Walker, two V-class destroyers, the Vanak and the Volunteer, S-class size Sardonics and Scimitar. Go back and writing back to your mum and dad saying, I'm on the Sardonics. Like, what?
9:39 Speaker 04 Great name.
9:40 Speaker 00 The Flower-class corvettes Bluebell and Hydranger. So there's seven ships in this escort group in all.
9:47 Speaker 04 I'd much rather be on Sardonics than Hydranger, I've got to say.
9:49 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
9:52 Speaker 04 For so many different reasons.
9:55 Speaker 00 Well, and amongst amongst the reasons, not just the names, is that these are things of different shapes and sizes. So a V-class destroyer is the sort of the most serious of these vessels. Then you've got the short corvettes, which is sort of 70, 80 yards long. Then the destroyers are, you know, half as big again, 120 yards long. Corvettes are more manoeuvrable, but they aren't as fast. Destroyers can turn out 30 to 40 knots, some of them. The Corvette's sort of 18 to 20. So it's quite a shuffled deck, isn't it, that an escort group consists of? And of course, it's all difficult. And this is the thing, Jim, every single time we come to this, it's all really hard, isn't it? This is all really bloody difficult.
10:31 Speaker 04 It's really hard. As we discussed in the last episode with Peter Grettan, you know, at night, there's no radar for escort groups in the early stages. I mean, there is actually by this point, but the very early ones there aren't. It's only just coming in. So a lot of the navigation is by compass and by human eye, which has to be done with a ship rolling about all over the place, if it's winter. Control of the force is not easy at all. Escorts are still using high-frequency radio, which is obviously long range. So that's quite easy to be picked up by U-boats when you do use it. So you want to use your radio as little as possible. All radio signals, of course, have to be laboriously coded and decoded. Tactical signals usually during daylight only, using lamps and Morse. Communications at sea is clearly an area that needs urgent improvement, and it's on its way. But this is the start of the revolution here at the beginning of March. So actually, I
11:16 Speaker 04 think Vanek and Volantip do both have the Type 286M onboard radar. Walker doesn't. But he delivers the first convoy safely to the 90 degrees west point, then rendezvous with the eastbound convoy on the 15th of March. And this is convoy X112. And McIntyre and Co are warned that the U-boats are afoot. But we're going to park that for a minute, because what's going on with the pocket battleships? Still don't know what they are. And cruisers.
11:44 Speaker 00 Well, we always go over to that pocket battleship podcast we dreamed possibly existed, that's on episode 400 of the Admiral Hipper. You know, this is the wonderful thing about podcasting, is there will be someone doing that. What's interesting, though, is though the Atlantic War is the thing that the British are focusing their war effort on, because they can't do any of their other war effort without getting this right in the first place. It's the essential building block for any other form of success.
12:08 Speaker 04 That is so true. That is such a good point.
12:11 Speaker 00 It's the foundation. If you don't get this right, all your fighter sweeps and your strategic bombing campaigns can all go whistle. You've got to get this right in the first place. And the Germans are obviously- We've heard failing to read the room in this regard, they don't get it, but they can still cause the British real problems. They can still affect and give them frights, I think is possibly the sanguine way of looking at it. And the Admiral Hipper, which is a pocket battleship, and we're not going to get into what that might be, has slipped back out into the Atlantic with its pocket battleship capability, whatever that may be, and we're not going to get tangled up in that. It sinks a straggler from a slow convoy coming from West Africa, SLS 64, Sierra Leone Slow 64. It shoots up the convoy,
12:51 Speaker 00 sinks seven of the 19 ships. I mean, in a way, why doesn't it sink all 19 of them? What's wrong with this pocket battleship?
12:58 Speaker 04 In the narrative of this, everyone's terribly impressed by Admiral Hipper because it gets through the blockade, gets out to the Atlantic, sinks these seven ships. But I kind of think, it's only seven. I mean, each one's a tragedy for the crew involved. I get all that, but it's not that impressive.
13:11 Speaker 00 No. What is it about the other 12 ships that's unsinkable?
13:14 Speaker 04 Also, it's not like Force K sinking everything, is it? In November 1941, out in the Mediterranean, sinks a lot. That's impressive.
13:20 Speaker 00 But this is what happens when you have a pocket battleship, Jim. If it was a battleship, maybe we'd be telling a different story. Anyway.
13:25 Speaker 04 What is a pocket battleship?
13:27 Speaker 00 We're not getting into that. Go find the podcast. In January 1941, they're doing quite well with surface vessels. 64 merchant vessels go to the bottom, February another 100, 139 in March. They're chipping away at the shipping effort, and RAF Bomber Command are also trying to hit the U-boat pens that are being built in Brest, aren't they? And they're not really having a good go of it. It's not going well, that.
13:48 Speaker 04 No, but as Jane Gallowford Lowes has pointed out, they're doing a better job of mining it.
13:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. When you watch that animated map of all the bombing in the Second World War, one of the things that's really striking is how much stuff there is on the U-boat bases. It's just constant. Right from the minute the Germans set up there, there's constant air attack on it. So they're threatening it, they're making it more difficult, they're making it harder for the Germans to operate out there, even if they're not completely delivering a knockout blow.
14:13 Speaker 04 And they're mining it, as Jane pointed out, yeah.
14:14 Speaker 00 But we also have, let's put a pocket battleship to one side, Jim, and treat ourselves to a couple of actual battleships these, aren't they?
14:21 Speaker 04 Heavy cruisers.
14:22 Speaker 00 Oh, what?
14:23 Speaker 04 Are they heavy cruisers or are they battle cruisers?
14:25 Speaker 00 I don't know. I don't know.
14:26 Speaker 04 I think they're battle cruisers, aren't they? I don't know.
14:28 Speaker 00 I think they're battle cruisers. They're battle cruisers. I think they are.
14:31 Speaker 04 Or are they heavy cruisers?
14:32 Speaker 00 Maybe they're heavy battle cruisers. Maybe they're battle heavy cruisers. Maybe they're battle cruisers, brackets, heavy. I don't know.
14:38 Speaker 04 Pocket.
14:41 Speaker 00 They get out into the Atlantic and they get stuck in, they're harrying stragglers, they're disrupting convoy routes, they're playing cat and mouse with the home fleet. And getting away by a whisker all the time. I mean, they have a good run of luck, don't they?
14:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, but they don't achieve a huge amount.
14:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, but they don't get sunk, is the thing.
14:58 Speaker 04 They don't get sunk. Well done. I mean, what do you want, a sort of, you know, medal of chalky biscuit? I mean, I don't think that's that impressive.
15:06 Speaker 00 Well, what I'm trying to do, right?
15:07 Speaker 04 Trying to be even handed here.
15:08 Speaker 00 No, no, no. If you're the Royal Navy, your great worry is that the Germans finally get their act together with these capital ships and attack a convoy meaningfully, right? Or attack convoys meaningfully.
15:18 Speaker 04 Yes, exactly that.
15:18 Speaker 00 So all this activity has got people biting their fingernails.
15:22 Speaker 04 Can I just say what it says on that font of all wisdom, Wikipedia? It says, "The Scharnhorst was a German capital ship, alternatively described as a battleship or a battle cruiser." Even Wikipedia doesn't know.
15:34 Speaker 00 If Wikipedia doesn't know, we'll never know. Go in and edit it and change it to "pocket battleship cruiser heavy pocket." But the point is, is if you're the Royal Navy, this is your nightmare scenario, isn't it? Is these ships getting loose? And there's a lot of fingernail biting about it. Admiral Hipper gets back to the Baltic, "Good night now, Scharnhorst," go back to the breast. And these operations, the Royal Navy's having its nose snubbed. Because after all, capital ships are the thing that there was an arms race about before the First World War, that they've been the massive focus of politics and diplomacy in the interwar years. They would capture people's imagination, I think it has to be borne in mind. This is why Churchill's got his attention, doesn't it? The continued threat. As we saw in March of 1941, everyone's getting their act together, Derby House is running properly. So at the beginning of March, Churchill forms the Battle of Atlantic
16:19 Speaker 00 Committee, actually calling it that, with himself as chairman, yet another committee that he's chairing. And they meet once a week to kick around how they can improve things. And on the 6th of March, here it comes, a memorandum from Winston Churchill, distributing wisdom, 13 crucial steps that need to be taken. And what this leads to is closer cooperation with a 15-group coastal command with Western approaches. Interestingly, merchant vessels to be given anti-aircraft guns, and all Western seaports priority for anti-aircraft defence. And the 2.6 million tonnes of merchant shipping that's sitting idle in British ports. You what? There's a war on, right?
16:58 Speaker 04 But, but you know, it hasn't got an anchor fixed, or it's got some lights out on the main bridge, or just got put into a dock and it hasn't quite got out again, or it's one of those ships from a neutral country that hasn't quite sort of got itself together, doesn't quite know what it's doing. But it's a lot, isn't it? Five and a bit months' worth from Durnitz's plan.
17:16 Speaker 00 Exactly what I was gonna say, took the words right out of my mouth. One of the interesting things is Churchill says if it's a fast merchant vessel, it can sail independently, doesn't have to come in a convoy. The Admiralty don't like this, but Churchill just thinks in terms of this'll take speed up turnaround times, it'll save time.
17:30 Speaker 04 Because that's the problem with the ports.
17:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. It'll break some of the sort of log jam at the ports. It's risky though, because a U-boat could do 17 knots, so you're talking about something that can do 25 knots, aren't you, that will sail well clear of a U-boat and leave it behind.
17:43 Speaker 04 Yes, but you've got people like Wynne down in Lennon's Tomb, you know, the OIC, the Operations Intelligence Centre, you've got people like him who are seeing the patterns of how U-boats are operating. And what they're saying is, is with these fast independents, you go on a route that's not used by the convoys, you're unlikely to fall in, in a strike of U-boats.
18:00 Speaker 00 Attract attention to yourself, yeah.
18:02 Speaker 04 This underlines the point that we were making throughout this series about the whole problem of the ports, the chaos of the ports. Convoys are inherently inefficient because of the sudden burst of activity and the sudden kind of lack of activity. And getting this material to where it needs to be once it's reached port is as important as getting it to the port in the first place. So that's what he's trying to sort out. Because they've got to rearm, they've got to build more tanks, they've got to get tanks to where they want them and all the rest of it.
18:25 Speaker 00 And Churchill wants U-boats oft. He wants more dead U-boats, doesn't he? Because only six have been destroyed since the start of September, none since December. And we know that there are few out there anyway.
18:36 Speaker 04 Yeah, which is one of the reasons, to be fair.
18:37 Speaker 00 Exactly. It's one of the reasons you aren't sinking like them, because there aren't very many.
18:40 Speaker 04 I mean, if you've only got eight out at sea, it's quite easy to miss them.
18:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. So he wants improvements to escort training, but that's already happening. But he wants better weapons, better detection, better weaponry. And really, this has to be the priority for R and D. Attention needs to be turned on to this.
18:57 Speaker 04 And it is. It is. Absolutely is the priority.
19:00 Speaker 00 He says the U-boat at sea must be hunted, the U-boats in the building yard or dock must be bombed, the fucker wolf must be attacked in the air and in their nests.
19:10 Speaker 04 It's so Churchillian is to call it, call it nests, isn't it? And refer to the fertility of shipping.
19:14 Speaker 00 But there's a breakthrough, another breakthrough around the corner. And we don't really ever talk about Bletchley Park much. And sometimes we kind of poo poo it. But suddenly we have good news from Bletchley, don't we?
19:24 Speaker 04 Enigma materials have been taken from a German trawler, the Krebs, in January 1941. And then the hand cipher VEF is broken. And this means that by March 1941, Bletchley is able to teletype the first 10 decrypted naval enigma messages to win at the U-boat tracking room at the OIC. And the next day, they send 34 and many more over the ensuing days. And soon it's a kind of virtual flood. Now, the point is, a lot of this traffic is already out of date. That's not the point. So it's, it's not an immediate help. But what it does do is help win, get his picture about the BDO, how they're operating and all the rest of it. And gives them a much greater understanding of the strategy, tactics, modus
20:05 Speaker 04 operandi and stuff. So again, it's not just diverting convoys from U-boats, which is the traditional Robert Harris kind of imitation game view of, of Bletchley traffic, of that's going to save the entire universe. It is more that this decoding is adding to the intelligence picture. And anything that adds to the intelligence picture, in whatever manner, is incredibly helpful. And it's a big help. And the bottom line is, is just around the corner in March 1941, even better news is coming.
20:33 Speaker 00 And we're going to take a quick break and return with this twist in the tail. See you in a moment.
20:41 Speaker 01 The award winning American Airlines Advantage program rewards more than travel. It takes your whole life to new heights. Earn miles when you fly, as well as with thousands of your favorite brands. And then redeem those miles for flights, upgrades, and experiences worldwide. Advantage members also enjoy earlier boarding and free high speed wifi in flight. Join for free and start earning towards your next adventure at aa.com/spotify.
21:11 Speaker 02 Born from the intensity of a night in the Eternal City. Introducing Born in Roma Fragrances by Valentino. Feminine perfume Donna Born in Roma features juicy black currant, central jasmine, soft cashmerin and warm vanilla. Masculine leaning but unisex Womo has notes of fresh violet leaf, aromatic sage, green vetiver and mineral salt. Shop holiday gifts at macys.com.
21:39 Speaker 03 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
22:15 Speaker 00 Welcome back to We Have Ways of Making You Talk. Now, Jim, the stage is set for, well, things beginning to go wrong for the U-boat arm. Because actually, up to this point, we said in the last part, the British aren't sinking any U-boats. They aren't managing to do that. And admittedly, there aren't very many, which obviously makes that more difficult. There are fewer needles in the haystack than maybe people think. But the simple truth is, because there are so few needles in the haystack, once they start getting sunk, an arm that's relying on experten, essentially, on elite crews, elite commanders, is really, really vulnerable. To not just losing those people, what losing those people entails, which means your experience base is simply being ripped out from under it. And this is the story of this phase of the Battle of the Atlantic, isn't it?
22:57 Speaker 04 And it's an absolutely critical, crucial part of the entire story. So on the 1st of March 1941, there are still only eight U-boats operating in the North Atlantic, including a new type, which is a Mark II D Duck, the U-147. So five U-boats are patrolling between Iceland and Scotland, two others are patrolling the Rockall Bank, which is U-47 and our old friend. U ninety nine, which is Otto Kretschmer. So Gunther Preen in forty seven, Kretschmer in U ninety nine. And the eighth U boat, the U ninety seven is by this point out of torpedoes. So hanging around loitering for weather reporting only. There's absolutely no help that day from the Condors. But after dark, Eric Topp now in U five five two runs
23:39 Speaker 04 into the inbound convoy HX one oh nine. So we last mentioned Eric Topp, I think in the second episode when we were looking at Norway and Narvik and so on. He's now twenty five years old. So he's got his own boat. So he's no longer in U forty six, which if you remember was not a very lucky U boat. Lucky in so much that it survived and unlucky in terms of hits. And now he's commanding the new Mark seven C, the U five five two. And U five five two has headed out on its first patrol in mid February nineteen forty one. And this is a remarkable incident because this is his first time commanding a combat patrol. Though he knows the crew and they've been working up, obviously, and doing some trials and training and all the rest of it. So he knows them all by this point. But he's worried because as he heads out into the Baltic, his navigator seems very downcast.
24:21 Speaker 04 So Topp asks him what the matter. And eventually the navigator admits that he's left something behind, a keepsake from his wife from their wedding day, which had been his good luck charm. And Topp notes in his incredible sort of diary come journal, I sense that along with this talisman, his confidence in a happy, successful patrol had been left behind. So I gave the order to return to base. We picked up the talisman. And for the rest of the mission, the navigator remained cheerful and wholly reliable. This much I had learned from experience, the personal feelings of my men, faith, superstition, play a vital role in exercising commands successfully. I mean, it's just astonishing that you would do that.
25:01 Speaker 00 It really is. I hope they refilled when they came back. You know what I mean? They're prioritising operational effectiveness as well.
25:07 Speaker 04 As it turns out, it works out very well for him.
25:09 Speaker 00 Yes, it does. Yes. Not only did they find HX one oh nine, but they also sink Cadillac, a British tanker, which has seventeen thousand tonnes of fuel on board, which they strike with two torpedoes. Tanker vibrates, starts listing and then explodes, starts sinking. First lifeboat is swamped as it's let down too fast. 26 survivors in the second lifeboat, but the water is on fire. A number struggle to breathe, panic, jump overboard and drown. Only five crew survive and later picked up. So, I mean, your odds, your odds aren't great on a tanker, are they? If it goes up, you're in for a bad one.
25:39 Speaker 04 Top is a, is a new commander, but of the seven armed U-boats in the Atlantic at the start of March, two of the U-boats are commanded by major aces. These are your Messias and your Ronaldo's of the U-boat arm. This is Prehn and Kretschmer. And the, the trouble is the aces are starting to give a massively disproportionate sense of the strength of the BDU, the U-boat arm. And I think this is the fatal flaw. You know, the happy time has given them a false sense of success and they haven't bothered to ask themselves why the convoys are unescorted or whether the British might change their tactics on this in the future. And they're also just putting too much on these very, very few aces.
26:18 Speaker 04 A bit like the expert in the Luftwaffe, these handful, Fritz, Julius, Lemp, Kretschmer, Sheppke, Prehn, these four particularly, they're sinking vast amounts and way more than anybody else. So they're giving this disproportionate kind of sense of how successful they're all being. Anyway, on the 2nd of March, two Condors staging from Norway spot an outbound convoy. So, Durnitz directs six of the seven U-boats to form a north-south patrol line west of the Rokul Bank. So they're moving into position on the 3rd of March when they're consumed by a dense fog. And at any rate, they never find the convoy and Durnitz then makes an extraordinary decision. He concludes that the appearance of the Condors has encouraged the convoy to change course dramatically.
27:00 Speaker 04 And so after this, Durnitz bans the Condors from attacking convoys and insists that they spot and report only. And now from now on, make every effort to remain undetected.
27:11 Speaker 00 Oh dear God.
27:12 Speaker 04 What? Why would you do that?
27:14 Speaker 00 What an idiot.
27:15 Speaker 04 But another outbound convoy is reported by a Condor on the 4th of March. But again, it gets away, the convoy does, not least because Kapitän Leutnant Gert Schreiber in U-95 breaks radio silence, sort of underlines the difference between the best and the not so good. And so Durnis is furious, calling this an extremely clumsy mistake. You know, it's pretty mildly. So then Durnitz redeploy's now five U-boats, only five left in this group, so there's no longer eight, there's five, on the 6th of March on the Rockall Bank. Prehn then spots the convoy OB293, escorted by only two destroyers, the Wolverine and the Verity. And you may remember that Wolverine was the one that took Bill Tennant to Dunkirk.
27:56 Speaker 00 Yes, yes.
27:57 Speaker 04 So amazingly, at 6pm on the 6th of March, Prehn and Kretschmer meet in moderate misty seas. They pull up alongside each other, yell at each other from the bridge of the Conning Tower through megaphones. Can you imagine?
28:13 Speaker 00 The drama of that.
28:14 Speaker 04 But again, the fact that they're communicating to each other again is putting them on a higher plane, isn't it? He's not communicating with Gerd Schreiber, these two, they're the daddies, they'll have a chat, but no one else will. Is there a sense of slight hubris? I don't know, because just a moment later, they're nearly rammed.
28:32 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Because Wolverine and Verity have both got the Type 286M radar, they can spot U-boats on the surface and they crash dive and escape, then they're located again with the Aztec and their depth charged repeatedly. Kretschmer goes deep and slips away. I mean, the thing is, Jim, really, if you're Durnitz, what you should be doing with these captains is getting them off U-boats and into training people, spreading this expertise, using it, not putting it at risk.
28:57 Speaker 04 But he can't, he can't afford to. This is his moment, because no one's listened to him when he said he wants more U-boats.
29:02 Speaker 00 And he's painted himself into a corner, because even though no one's listened to him, he's still been saying, yes, yes, I can do that. Of course we could pull that off, because that's what you have to say to Hitler.
29:09 Speaker 04 Can I just point out that these guys have been on active service since the start of the war. It was October 1939, 14th of October 1939, that Günther Prehn sneaked into Scapa Flow and sank the Royal Oak. And here he is, in the same U-boat, on the 7th of March, 1941. He hasn't had a break. I mean, of course, he's had a break, they have shore leave and all the rest of it, but there's a relentless pattern. It's not a six-month tour or anything like that. They're still at it, and so is Kretschmer.
29:34 Speaker 00 Nor are they spreading their experience. They're hogging it to themselves as well. You know, as you say, they're hanging out together, these guys, rather than spreading the expertise and instincts. So on the early hours of the 7th of March, Prehn and U-47... As well as the new crew in U70 attack the convoy. U70 hits one, damages the second, Prehn hits the Norwegian merchant vessel, the Terje Viken, although she's empty and doesn't sink.
29:56 Speaker 04 So struggles on.
29:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, Jochen Matz in U70 hits another vessel, the Dutch tanker Maidrecht, but only damages it and was so close that the Maidrecht skipper is able to ram U70 and smash the conning tower. She gets away, but not for long because Camellia, the destroyer, has seen her and she's repeatedly depth charged. So in all, U70 is struck by 54 or attacked with 54 depth charges. She's flooding and starts sinking. So Matz blows the ballast tank, surfaces and he opens the conning tower because although the conning tower's been smashed up, the hatch still works. And the release of the pressure blows him and four others up into the air and into the water and then U70 sinks with Artibus fishing out Matz and 24 others from the water. That is absolutely incredible.
30:42 Speaker 04 Isn't that amazing? It's absolutely amazing. But again, Matz is a new boy. Okay, so this is his first combat patrol and he's come a cropper. And this is because he's not experienced. So he fires too close to Maidrecht. It's like schoolboy error effectively. Doesn't know what he's doing. Surfaces too quickly. It's just hopeless. Anyway, so that's the end of U70. And what happens to U47 and U99 that day is not 100% certain. Kretschmer definitely gets away, but Prehn doesn't. So both of them are repeatedly picked up by the combination of the radar and the Aztec on Wolverine and Verity. And Wolverine and Verity pick them up and they just repeatedly depth charge both U99 and U47. And they're just completely done over. Kretschmer later reports that he's held down under the water for about
31:26 Speaker 04 nine hours, just can't escape. Because the other point is, is when you're under the surface, you can only move really, really slowly. And that's for two reasons. A, you don't want to peer on the Aztec if you're moving. And secondly, because you don't know how long you're going to be under. And the longer you're under, the more you're using your batteries. So the faster you go, the more you use your batteries. So you don't want to move very quickly. As a U-boat commander under attack, you've got a lot of decisions to make and you're second guessing your enemy, of course, all the time. But anyway, U47 gets hit at some point on that day. Officially, it's claimed by HMS Wolverine, but this is still debated, but it doesn't really matter. The point is, is that Prehn's last signal was on the morning of the 7th of March. And after that, Nothing was ever heard from him or his crew ever again.
32:08 Speaker 00 Well, so he's at the bottom somewhere.
32:10 Speaker 04 Yep, but a week later, it's convoy HX112, which we tantalisingly left you on when we first introduced Donald McIntyre. And, you know, you remember they had escorted that convoy out and they were picking up HX112 on the way back. And they'd successfully rendezvous with the convoy. And here they are, they're approaching Scotland and this convoy is now protected by McIntyre's escort group number five. And just before midnight, on the 15th of March, 1941, McIntyre is on the bridge of HMS Walker. When the night is ripped apart by a blinding flash of flame and then a second explosion. And this is the 10,000 ton tanker Adona being hit.
32:52 Speaker 04 And it's the first time McIntyre and his crew have ever seen such an explosion at sea. And they assumed no one could have survived. They hear the alarm bells clanging, action stations, and in the glare of the burning ship, McIntyre peers through his binos for any signs of a U-boat. And the only instrument to help him was his Aztec. But the problem, of course, is with the 120 series of Aztec. It's only got a range of 2,500 yards in perfect conditions. And of course, conditions are rarely perfect. And not in the Atlantic at night in March. So also the Aztec cone only effective to about 16 degrees below the level of the surface. So no great depth. So you can drop your depth charges, but they're generally dropped much more at hunch rather than any kind of precise pinpointing.
33:34 Speaker 04 And also depth charges don't go more than about 120 metres. So U-boats, you know, if they're quick enough, can dive lower than that. And again, you remember that story of Teddy Suren and U48 on the surface of Bristol, the Bristol Channel. It was 135 metres, wasn't he? So he was all right. But the bottom line is, it's kind of sort of needle and haystack stuff, really.
33:51 Speaker 00 And they can't find him. But Cimatar, however, has spotted the U-boat, which is U110, which is a new, super new Type 9B, commanded by Fritz Ulyas Lemp, who we met earlier in the story. Cimatar tries to ram it. I mean, the eagerness of these destroyers and corvettes and escort vessels to ram U-boats, they just love the ramming.
34:12 Speaker 04 Ram the bastard.
34:12 Speaker 00 I suppose you know it's going to work. It's a fruitless search, but U-boats have been deterred that night. There's no further attack because after all, stopping them attacking is as effective as sinking them in the immediate, right? Isn't it? There's a respite at dawn, but MacIntyre's worried about what's to come. The convoy's obviously been rumbled. They know by now that U-boats are operating in packs. They know they're operating mainly at night. So daylight is one thing. It's preparing for dusk and nearing dusk, Cimatar, and Cimatar's really on it on this convoy, reports with its lamp, with a lamp that a U-boat's been spotted six miles ahead. It's not Lemp, it's Jokim Sheppka in U-100.
34:48 Speaker 04 This is one of the super aces.
34:49 Speaker 00 Yeah. And so here we go again. A super ace is now at risk. And if you've only got eight subs and two of your aces go, that's a quarter of your expertise at the bottom of the ocean. That's what we're looking at here. So MacIntyre orders full of speed ahead for Walker, joined by Vanek and Cimatar. As they get close, U-100 does the sensible thing and dives, but they sweep the area meticulously, thinking they're going to find it. But they don't find it, although they hopefully, they think that they've scared, again, they've scared the U-boat off, she won't be able to catch up with the convoy. But here comes the rest of the Wolf Pack. U-99, U-37, Kretschmer in U-99 begins the attack that night. He sails right into the middle of his convoy, which is his style, and fires torpedoes from eight tubes. One miss, but seven hit six merchant vessels.
35:32 Speaker 00 The first just after Walker had rejoined the convoy. MacIntyre says, "I was near to despair and racked my brains to find some way to stop the Holocaust." I mean, how do you like this drama, everybody? It is amazing. They spot the whitetail tail wake of a U-boat, give chase, relying on the Aztec, hoping the Aztec will catch something. They go up to 13 knots, chase down towards the sighting. Again, the U-boat crash dives, but almost too late because Walker's right over it, sees the phosphorescence. And this is the account we started the episode with. He drops a pattern of 10 depth charges. The charges go, they hear another explosion, the orange flash that was in his description. And is this their first U-boat kill? Well, no, because it's U-37, which is really badly damaged, but is able to slip away. Obviously gives up, thinks, well, it's odd this, I'll go
36:14 Speaker 00 home. And then in the meanwhile, U-110 and a fifth U-boat, in a way, here's the flaw in, um, Dernitz's Wolf Pack strategy.
36:24 Speaker 00 It's easier to find more U-boats, isn't it? If they're operating singly, that's the rub of it all. And if your blokes are so precious, you're really exposing all your assets in what you... It's literally put all his eggs in one basket.
36:37 Speaker 04 But it's fine, isn't it? If your convoys aren't escorted or escorted by kind of one Corvette and one aging destroyer, then it's not so much of a problem. But when you've got a fairly keen team, a proper escort group with radar, with more sophisticated kit, you're suddenly in a whole load of trouble, aren't you?
36:53 Speaker 00 Exactly. So U-110 and U-74, they see this initial explosion and they turn back, they go towards the sound of the guns. And what the escorts are doing is they're weaving around and firing star shells to illuminate the battle space because it's all about getting eyes on. Forty minutes after the attack on U-37, Walker picks up yet another Aztec contact, and this is Shepka in U-100, and he's trying to pick his moment, he hasn't fired yet. Walker calls to Vanek for help, they make repeated sweeps, more depth charge salvos. One of the issues with the depth charges, they do disrupt Aztec, so you can't overdo it. They call off the attack and they go back to pick up survivors from the SS JB White. But U-100 is in trouble. The depth charges have caused flooding, have smashed the instruments.
37:35 Speaker 00 And at 3am, Shepka has no choice but to surface.
37:39 Speaker 04 I mean, this is amazing. So he's picked up almost immediately by Vanek. Vanek using his Type 286M radar, there it is again. You know, just a bit of kit makes all the difference. It's the first confirmed radar contact with a U-boat of the entire war. And Walker is also speeding towards the U-100. So seeing this, Shepka orders his boat into a firing position, but engines wouldn't start. By the time they do, it's too late because Vanek is a rammer. And believing Vanek would miss, Shepka's up on the bridge, but it's a bad miscalculation because Vanek heads straight towards them. Abandon ship! Shepka yells, but a moment later, he's crushed to death as Vanek's bow smashes straight into
38:22 Speaker 04 the conning tower and U-100 sinks a few moments later. Have rammed and sunk U-boat, signals Vanek, and scooped up just six survivors.
38:33 Speaker 00 Like that with the lamp.
38:35 Speaker 04 Yep, yep, yep. McIntyre says, what a blissful moment that was. The successful culmination of a long and arduous fight. But Al, it's not over. This long night is not over because at 3.30am, Walker picks up another Aztec contact. Contact, contact! Calls out Backhouse, who's the Aztec operator, and McIntyre can't believe it. He says, you sure? And Backhouse is absolutely insisted. He goes, yup, this is definitely, definitely one. And it is. And this is U99 and this is Otto Kretschmer. It surfaces and finds itself within yards of Walker. They'd actually not been spotted as it happens. You know, it's dark, it's night and all the rest of it. They're full of the excitement of the loss of U100. But Kretschmer's not going to risk it, so he crash dives.
39:19 Speaker 04 And in the crash dive, of course, it leaves this white wake and the phosphorescence on the water. So they see it and immediately this is what's picked up by Aztec. And the chances are that had he held his nerve, he might well have got away. But anyway, you can't blame him for that. So Walker sweeps over the U99, drops a salvo of depth charges, which smashes U99's air, fuel and ballast tanks because it hasn't got low enough. And the problem with the depth charges that the British have is they don't go very low. So you need to dive super, super quickly and it's just caught as it's still going down is the truth of it. So water starts pouring in and they realise they've got absolutely no chance of survival whatsoever under the water. So Kretschmer orders them to surface, hoping they might still escape. But it's not to be. They're picked up by Vanek again, which signals to Walker.
40:04 Speaker 04 And McIntyre then hits the U99 with both searchlight and its four inch guns. You know, the firing's a bit wild, but U99 soon signals, we are sunking in Morse. That is absolutely brilliant.
40:19 Speaker 00 I love it.
40:20 Speaker 04 So Kretschmer has ordered abandoned ship and for the U-boat to be scuttled. You know, so Walker pulls alongside Lurz and Nets, helps the crew aboard.
40:28 Speaker 00 McIntyre says, some of them were in the last stages of exhaustion from the cold of those northern waters by the time we got them aboard. And the last man aboard is Kretschmer.
40:36 Speaker 04 Where's the movie? Where's the movie, Al?
40:38 Speaker 00 How many times are we going to be saying this, Jim? Where's the movie? Cyril Thompson, for heaven's sake. He's still wearing his prized Zeiss binoculars. One of only a few sets made on Durnet's orders for one of his great aces. Kretschmer tries to throw them in the sea at the last moment. He's not quick enough and McIntyre claims them as his, as a proper booty of war. I've got a lot of time for that. Kretschmer notices there's a horseshoe emblem on Walker and he speaks imperfect English. He says, "That is a strange coincidence. My ship also sailed under the sign of the horseshoe, but pointing down, not up." And McIntyre says, "Well, Captain, in our belief, a horseshoe that way up allows the luck to run out."
41:15 Speaker 04 Oh, God, come on! And Kretschmer gives him a wry smile, walks on past him into captivity.
41:22 Speaker 00 What's quite interesting, though, is what follows is because destroyers aren't very big, there's an issue. They've got survivors from the SS JB White and U-99 on the ship together. And it's impossible to stop the two crews fighting. And also, Bridge Four is formed later on and organised by two of the JB Whites officers, with them sat around the table playing cards with Kretschmer. And Kretschmer is great at cards as well and also says that he studied at Exeter University before the war and gives the impression of being largely apolitical and is resentful that the war has ever broken out.
41:55 Speaker 04 Anyway, they reach Liverpool a few days later, where they're met by Admiral Noble and Westers approaches staff. You know, it's just so exciting because don't forget there hasn't been a U-boat sinking since December or something. It's a long time and suddenly there's been several. So they're all there lining up to kind of cheer in the Walker and the Vannock and so on. And to see Kretschmer, you know, this is the thing they're all really keen to see. And so the silence as Kretschmer steps ashore and he pauses, looks at McIntyre and the group of officers, gives a slight nod and then is ushered away into a car by waiting guards. But, you know, in just a few days, three of the key aces have all gone. You know, and pre in a U-47, it's worth just spelling out what they've scored. Thirty-one ships, 191,919 tonnes.
42:38 Speaker 04 Just a reminder that Wanklin and Uphold is 128,000, the most successful single Allied submarine. Marine of the entire war in terms of tonnage sunk. Kretschmer and U-99, 39 ships, 246,794 tonnes. And Shepka and the U-100, 26 ships, 137,819 tonnes. I mean, that is a lot. And these are the three of the greatest U-boat aces of all time, and they've all gone. It is an absolutely crippling blow to the BDU, the U-boat arm, because they are literally irreplaceable. And this is the truth, is that the old pre-war experienced men, they're going. Just like by 1944, the expert and in the Luftwaffe are going as well.
43:20 Speaker 04 And this is the problem with having only 3,000 men in the U-boat arm in 1939. It's not big enough to expand or not big enough quickly. They haven't taken advantage of the moment where Britain is at its weakest, which is in 1940.
43:33 Speaker 00 And you'd think these guys are such precious assets, their expertise needs to be passed on to the next generation. But there they are doing whatever they like, tooling around in the ocean. And unaware that, as you've said, the British aren't going to stand still. And there seems to be this impression on the German side that they will. And of course they're not going to. Why on earth would they?
43:52 Speaker 04 I've got one little anecdote for you to end on, which is about Kretschmer. So Kretschmer joins the post-war navy, Shaun of Swastikas and all the rest of it. And he does pretty well. He ends up being an admiral. And in 1955, he's reunited with Donald McIntyre. And do you know what Donald McIntyre does? Gives him back his binoculars.
44:08 Speaker 00 No.
44:09 Speaker 04 He does. They meet and he says, I took these off you, you can have them back.
44:12 Speaker 00 Goodness me.
44:13 Speaker 04 How amazing is that?
44:13 Speaker 00 That is amazing. I mean, the other thing that's amazing is that the Germans, how do they think these U-boats are being discovered if they don't think there's radar?
44:20 Speaker 04 It's not that they don't think there's radar, they don't know about the cavity magnetron as an invention, as a concept.
44:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, but you know what I mean? They know they're clever and coming up with technical solutions to things. Surely they assume the enemy is doing the same? It's this very odd thinking that they have where they can't see beyond the end of their nose, really. It's very, very odd. I imagine Kretschmer ends up in La Tama House or somewhere, doesn't he? Being listened to and having his brains picked.
44:41 Speaker 04 Yeah, no, and he sits out the rest of the war as a prisoner, released in 1947. He was, by all accounts, apolitical and, as far as it went, a pretty good egg. But I mean, it's an amazing sequence, isn't it? To lose those three in such a short period of time, I mean. But there's another crippling blow waiting around the corner, isn't there? And we're going to be picking that up in a series that is coming very soon. Of course, this is the Hood and the Bismarck, that epic surface battle that takes place in the Atlantic in May 1941. So that's to come, people. But gosh, this has been good fun, hasn't it?
45:12 Speaker 00 Yes, absolutely brilliant, Jim. Thanks for taking us through all this. Absolutely extraordinary.
45:15 Speaker 04 It's been really good fun. Just an amazing episode. And again, it's making me rethink about, you know, how you consider those early stages of the war all over again.
45:23 Speaker 00 Well, thanks for listening, everyone. We hope you've enjoyed this series. I hope that in the process, many of you have subscribed to our Officer Class channel on Apple Podcasts, or even better, you've become independent company members at the Patreon and possibly even wondering which weekend the next Second World War Festival, We Have Ways Festival will fall upon. That'll be revealed at some point. Thanks for listening, everyone. Thanks, Jim. Cheerio, everybody.
45:44 Speaker 04 Cheerio.
45:50 Speaker 05 Stonefire Naan is made with real buttermilk and ghee. It's the perfect flatbread for any occasion.
45:55 Speaker 06 I put out Stonefire Naan with dips at every dinner party.
45:58 Speaker 05 I make Naan grilled cheese when my daughter has friends over. I use Stonefire Naan to reward the humans who do my bidding.
46:05 Speaker 06 Right. It's perfect for camping trips. Dance for it, feeble mortal. Sorry, is he talking to me or? Dance. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
46:15 Speaker 05 From our tradition to yours, Stonefire.
46:18 Speaker 07 Together, we Naan. Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes. A 2027 Jeep Cherokee, a Carnival Cruise vacation, gift cards from DoorDash, and Best Buy. Feel and play in the McDonald's app. Get your bag.
46:38 Speaker 08 No purchase necessary. 50 U.S. and D.C. age 18 plus. See play at MCD.com for rules and play at MCD.com/AMOE for info on playing without purchase by mail by November 2nd. Chance card game ends November 8th. Game ends November 22nd, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Haskett.
46:50 Speaker 02 We just moved into our new house and I didn't realize just how close we were to the neighbors. That's when my friend told me about Blinds.com.
46:58 Speaker 09 Blinds.com isn't a medication, but it can improve how you feel about your home. Customers who shop at Blinds.com experience excellent customer service, from consultation to installation. Side effects include increased privacy and better sleep. Talk to your partner today and see if Blinds.com is right for you.
47:15 Speaker 08 Shop Black Friday all month long at Blinds.com. Don't miss huge deals dropping every week.
Previous Atlantic War: The Turning Point (Part 5) Next How the Navy Learned to Fly: Stringbags (Part 1) Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated