Pod Insights Wholesaling Inc with Brent Daniels WIP 1915: Why Google PPC Beats Direct Mail (And How to Dominate All 4 Spots) About this episode Andrew Becker is with wholesaling powerhouse Brent Daniels! Brent shares his journey from losing everything in the 2008 crash to building a massive empire using the "Four-Headed Monster" of Google marketing. He reveals why inbound leads from Google PPC and SEO are the highest converting leads in the industry and how to dominate the four critical spots on the first page of Google to capture motivated sellers who are ready to act now. In this deep dive, Brent breaks down his internal sale...
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to Wholesaling Inc. Episode number 1915.
0:04 Speaker 01 If a lead comes in anytime, an inbound lead comes in, you have 30 seconds, 30 seconds to respond to it. And if they're calling you, you have to answer live.
0:14 Speaker 02 This is game changing information guaranteed to raise your real estate wholesaling business with actionable steps you can take immediately to navigate the ins and outs of wholesaling and start making money today. Join us as we put our guests in the hot seat and dive deep to dissect their strategies for success to enable you to duplicate their results. You're listening to Wholesaling Inc., the only show dedicated to making you a fortune in wholesaling.
0:43 Speaker 03 Hey, everyone, and welcome to another exciting episode. This, I think you're the biggest celebrity I've had on this show, Brent. A man that needs no introduction.
0:53 Speaker 01 No way, Tom Kroll, by far.
0:55 Speaker 03 Okay, okay, so top two, at least, top two or three. But Brent Daniels from Talk to People, thank you so much for being here, man. It's an honor to have you.
1:04 Speaker 01 Thank you, Andrew. We've gone back a long time. I was just, we were just talking about, you know, I was looking at text messages from seven years ago. And it's exciting to be on your show, exciting to see that, uh, that you're doing this and the growth and evolution of your business. And so I think we're going to have a fun time and hopefully give some instruction for people out there that have teams that are growing their business that love real estate. And hopefully they're doing it with a lot of friends. You know, because this business, uh, you're allowed to work with your friends, which is really cool.
1:34 Speaker 03 Unbeknownst to a lot of people, that is something that can happen. And you know, dude, what just resonated with me before we started the episode shoot, you said, we were talking about texting each other back in 2018. In my mind, that did not resonate that that was seven years ago, almost eight years ago now. That is, I just had like a, it blew my mind type of moment. I thought it was like two years ago. I'm really bad with dates though. So what does that say about me? So.
2:00 Speaker 01 Well, I think it's really true, Andrew. I think, I think that whole saying that, you know, we, we always overestimate what we can do in a year and underestimate what we can do in five. You know what I mean? I really think that that's true. And I think that there's big time income spurts when it comes to this business in, in real estate, whether that's due to interest rates or the economy, or our own egos, or our own evolution as, as leaders and entrepreneurs, whatever it is, there's certain years where you just make a tremendous amount. And then there's some years where you make a fraction of that.
2:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:33 Speaker 01 And so I think that one of the, one of the biggest goals that I have is try to, you know, kind of even out that curve or the turbulence, so to speak, and kind of fly above the weather as much as I can.
2:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:46 Speaker 01 So it's interesting, the things you learn being in the real estate business for 21 years now, and then as an entrepreneur for essentially 25 years. Now you really, you really learn how to really focus on what matters on a daily basis. And then, you know, if you can have a good day, you can have a good week, month, year, and then a good plan for whatever you want to build.
3:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, man. So let's, I want to dive into that, what you just said, because you have a ton of experience. Those of you that are in real estate that are listening have probably heard your name before. You're absolutely everywhere with just dropping fire and, and what you do every day. But for those of you who don't know, can you just give us a very quick 20 second, like who you are, what you're about, what you do?
3:29 Speaker 01 Yeah. I graduated high school in Gilbert, Arizona, and two, in the year 2000, I was given from my best friend, Mike Mahoney. I was given the book Rich Dad Poor Dad by his dad, his dad, Brian Mahoney, who was a successful entrepreneur. And it changed everything, you know, I was off, I was on my way to college. I think that, you know, once you turn 18, it's kind of like a fork in the road and what you decide to do. Do you work? Do you go to college? Do you become an entrepreneur? Do you work for somebody else? All those things, right? So I didn't know if I wanted to get into the medical field. I didn't know if I wanted to get into personal training. I didn't know if I wanted to get into, you know, being a coach or a teacher or whatever else. And this really put me on the path of being a, a real estate entrepreneur.
4:13 Speaker 01 And I think it's one of the most exciting businesses, but it's also a business that can quickly take everything from you. So, lost everything in 2008, got my real estate license in 04, lost everything in 08, crawled back out to about 2012, and then discovered what wholesaling was in 2012, 2013. And that's been my main focus for my real estate business since then, is finding really, really, really great ugly houses and turning those over to people that I respect, that are going to do really amazing work on those properties and make it a great home, or homes, depending on the, on the property type that, yeah, that we find. And so that's been
4:57 Speaker 01 my business. I think, I think that assigning deals, if you can do it in your state, is the golden ticket. It is the cheat code to reduce a lot of the risk, most of the risk in the business. But you gotta make sure that you're really good at marketing, you're really good at sales, and you're really good at disclosure.
5:13 Speaker 03 Yep. And Brett, when you were in from, I think you said 04 to 08 before you lost it, all your business kinda had to start over. What were you doing? Were you doing retail, like brokerage type of real estate?
5:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, retail, I was a real estate agent for a couple of years, and 04, 05 was really powerful. And so I thought that I was really good. And when you think you're really good, you want to expand. And so I wanted to start a brokerage, and I did that. And then, you know, the late, you know, kind of the third quarter of 2008, the economic world crashed, and I was over-leveraged. I did not listen to any of the real principles from Rich Dad, Poor Dad, and, and lost it all. And that was, that took a few years to get back to a place mentally and from a, from a confidence standpoint, to be able to go out and take massive imperfect action every single day. And the only thing that got me out, Andrew, was, was going out and
6:06 Speaker 01 talking to people. And that's why, that's the TTP, that's the motto. And, you know, if, if you're in any business, let alone real estate, and especially real estate, I should say, if you talk to enough people and make enough offers, you cannot lose. That is something that I know fundamentally.
6:22 Speaker 03 Yeah. Brett, you're gonna have to send me one of those shirts. I've seen you, like, every single time I run into you or see you, you have one of those shirts. So, send me one, dude. I'll wear it proudly.
6:33 Speaker 01 You got, I'm a simple man, you know, I was wearing, I was wearing button up shirts and polos and all these things that I would have to take to the dry cleaner every week. And I was just, it just annoyed me. And so I was like, why am I not in a position in my life that I could wear whatever I want?
6:48 Speaker 03 Love it.
6:49 Speaker 01 Once I got to that point, I just started wearing the same, you know, two or three different types of T-shirts every day and it's worked out.
6:54 Speaker 03 I have three different colors of this and I just rotated. So you'll see me wearing the same stuff too. So let's go back to you though. All right. So in 2012, you discovered wholesaling and for those not listening, this is an educational podcast. So describe what wholesaling is at just a very like high level.
7:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. So when you find a, a property owner that wants to sell a property and it needs significant amount of work, you can make an offer on that property. And you have a couple of different choices. Well, you have three main choices and they're called exit strategies in real estate. One is to buy and flip it. Where you buy it and you either just put it right back in the market as it is, or you put in some work and you flip it, right? You actually take ownership and then you sell it as quick as you can. The second one is you buy and you hold it, right? You keep it in your rental portfolio and it's kind of long-term wealth building. It's not going to make you rich, but it'll be good for long-term. We're talking 20, 30 years down the road.
7:50 Speaker 01 And then you have the third option, which is to assign your right to that purchase agreement or novations, if you want to get real in the weeds. But there, an assignment essentially says, hey, listen, I'm going to put this opportunity, this purchase, the ability to purchase this property out to a private group of investors that I know. If they want to pay me a fee to replace me in this agreement, then I'll take a look at that and decide if that is the best route for me to go. I'll either close on it and flip it, I'll close on it and hold it, or I'll just assign it to my, my investor friend or investor that I know and, and make a fee. And assignment fee is what that's called. So that's, that's really it in a basic level.
8:33 Speaker 03 Okay. So you put a, you get a house that needs a ton of work, maybe not, not suitable for a listing really. And then you say, hey, Mr. Owner, Mrs. Owner, I'll buy. Your house for four, it's off market. It's a private transaction. And then you turn around and say, hey, my friend or my buddy or whoever, I know you flip homes. I have this one on Main Street. I have it. Do you tell them what you have it under contract for? Or you just say, do you want to buy this at four fifteen or four twenty or whatever that is? And the difference between what you have it under contract for and what you sell it for is known as a wholesale assignment fee.
9:06 Speaker 01 That's right. Yeah. I mean, you, you can certainly tell them what you have it under contract for. They're going to see what it's under, under contract for. Right. When they get the contract because they're essentially replacing you in the contract. And if the numbers make sense, then they pay you the fee, which is, you know, kind of the total price that they're looking to pay would be the fee plus whatever the original purchase price on that agreement is. And so if it's a good deal, they take it down.
9:32 Speaker 03 So here's the million dollar question that a lot of people, I talk to a lot of people in real estate. So do you? How the heck do you find these deals? What are you doing? How are you marketing to them? Because at the end of the day, a lot of people also say wholesaling is nothing more. You're running like a marketing business, right? And there's profit systems. Where, where are you guys finding deals? And how are you doing this day in, day out?
9:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, since mid two thousand twenty-three, all from Google and Google has four.
10:00 Speaker 03 Can you expand on that? The Google.
10:01 Speaker 01 Yeah. So, so Google has four main ways for you, for property owners or any, any kind of business for the customer to reach out to you. One is the top of the page, which is sponsored ads, and that's commonly referred to as pay per click. Right? You pay Google to show up at the top of page one. And I'm telling you right now, there is not a more powerful position in all of marketing and advertising than the first page of Google. It is the most powerful.
10:30 Speaker 03 Amen.
10:31 Speaker 01 Said that weird, but it is the most powerful position to be in. And there's three spots. So the first spot is the sponsored. The second spot is something called Google My Business. And it's the map that pops up whenever you do a search for something. And so it'll have the local businesses, it'll have their, their reviews there, how many stars they are and their contact information. And then right below that is what's called. Engine optimization, these are the organic searches that pop up and there's techniques to show up in all three of those. The fourth monster of this four-headed monster is YouTube ads because Google owns YouTube. So we are masters of positioning those four spots for our business.
11:12 Speaker 01 And because of that, we have high-intent, highly motivated sellers that reach out to us because they're literally searching for somebody to buy their house and buy it with, I should buy it fast and all these other keywords that we target. And so when we get a lead in, Andrew, it is bananas. I mean, they're ready to sell right now. We're on the appointment right now. And it makes my acquisition team really, really, really happy.
11:35 Speaker 03 Very cool because what's happening here, Brent, someone is sitting down at their computer saying, I have a problem. In this case, their house is the problem and they're literally typing in, I need a solution to my problem. And you showing up on page one, whether organically via the SEO, Google My Business, or in the paid ads, the PPC, you are solving their problems, right? And what, what kind of problems, you know, for those who are thinking about getting into wholesaling, what are the types of solutions that you and your team offer to get them to ultimately go with you?
12:09 Speaker 01 So whenever somebody's selling pretty much anything, but especially property, there's three main factors, speed, convenience and price. And they only get to pick two. All right. If they want speed and convenience, they have to work on our price. Right? And so that's what we're looking for when we get leads coming in. Now, is it every lead? No. Is it one out of 10 leads? Sure. You know what I mean? And so nine of them, you know, they're looking for retail. They have their house in the market. It's not selling right now. So they reach out to us in hopes that they'll, we'll just buy it cash and we didn't see it on the market for some reason or whatever else. And that's fine. That's not who we, we work with. We work with the people that are like, I don't want to fix this up.
12:50 Speaker 01 This property is destroyed. I just want to sell it completely as is. I don't want to put it on the market for a million different reasons. People would never, why would anybody sell their property and not put it on the market with a Realtor? Because they don't like Realtors, because they're embarrassed by the way that the property looks, because they have a bazillion animals living inside that property, because they don't want to go through inspections on their property, because they want their cash in a week, not in a year. I mean, there's a lot of different reasons why people just want to sell their property and get that speed and convenience. And so that's why we try to, we do a deep discovery, Andrew. We do a deep discovery on that first conversation that says, what is your goal? What is your goal with this property?
13:31 Speaker 01 And once you discover what their goal is, then you can decide what kind of offer you're going to make. And usually for us, Andrew, it's one of two ways. Either we're going to give them a cash as-is offer, and I'm going to send out my acquisition team to go do that, or I'm going to say, I think your property sounds beautiful. I think that you want to get as much as you can out of this property. Sounds like that's your goal. Here's a really good real estate agent referral, or if you have a real estate agent, go put it on the market. Go sell it for as much as you possibly can, right? That's the two routes that we give people. These are the people that want to sell right now. They want their cash right now. They don't want any of the hassle. It's like turning in your car, right? Have you ever gone and got a new car, Andrew, and you turn in your old car and you know that they're going to make a profit on your old car?
14:17 Speaker 01 You know, it's not Kelley Blue Book. You know, if you go and put new tires and rims and you, and you make it smell great, you get the engine all, you know, every little part of it fixed up and you just make the car in perfect condition, you could privately sell it yourself. People take test drives. You can make sure and sell it and make more. But no, what do people do? They go, here's the keys. Let me grab all the, all my personal stuff out of the car. Good luck with it. Gone. That's what people do with houses. Every single second of every single minute of every single hour of every single day, people are doing that. And, uh, and that's, that's the world that we live in. That's the tiny little niche in real estate that, uh, that we work in.
14:58 Speaker 01 And about, you know, six to 10% of property owners in the United States will choose that option.
15:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's a great analogy. I never thought about explaining it that way, but yeah, I fully hear the keys. It's your problem now type of approach to it. So Brad, where are you doing this? Are you doing this in, you know, I know you're in Arizona. Do you do this for your own company in Arizona? Do you do it across the country? I know a lot of people do this nationwide. Like, what's your business model?
15:25 Speaker 01 Just Arizona.
15:26 Speaker 03 Just Arizona. Okay.
15:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, we played around with it, Andrew. We played around with doing some virtual and we've done it here and there. But my guys love solving big problems. My guys love going knee to knee, belly to belly, face to face. You know what I mean? There's just something that is just more fulfilling in their minds. And I understand this, if you can really know a person, really meet somebody, really go through, see their, see the way that they use their body, you know, in the way that they speak, the body language that comes out when you can, when you can meet somebody. And you can really see what the problem is. You can really understand what, what is really bothering them or not bothering them.
16:04 Speaker 03 Right.
16:05 Speaker 01 You know what I mean? And when you can do that and relieve people and make it a really smooth, easy, simple process for them, there's no better feeling in the world for us.
16:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, man. So I've heard a couple of things about PPC. We'll stay on this topic.
16:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:18 Speaker 03 Speed to lead is super important, right? And then having your systems and processes aligned are important too. Is that what you're also seeing?
16:27 Speaker 01 Listen, if a lead comes at any time, an inbound lead comes in, you have 30 seconds, 30 seconds to respond to it. And if they're calling you, you have to answer live.
16:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:38 Speaker 01 You have to answer the phone live. If, if it is a, like, if somebody just fills out a form on your website and you get that text message, you need to respond to that in 30 seconds or they're gone. All right. I mean, we've looked at it, Andrew. After a minute, it's the ability to get those people on the phone drops dramatically. After five, it's ridiculous. After an hour, forget about it.
17:02 Speaker 03 Right.
17:03 Speaker 01 So you need to go back with people in 30 seconds.
17:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, I actually think, I don't remember off the top of my head, but like Yale or Harvard published a study, not about PPC in real estate, just about like sales in general. And I was like, after an hour, your chances of converting whatever it is, go down by like 71%. But in real estate, oftentimes if someone's submitting a PPC lead or information on your site, you're probably most likely submitting it on multiple sites. That's why it's so important, right?
17:33 Speaker 01 That's right. Yeah, that's exactly right.
17:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, like what happens, your team specifically? So you have these ads going out to the world. Someone types in, I need to sell my house yesterday type of thing. Your team gets a lead. Can you walk us through like your internal process? Like, do you have technology helping you? Like what happens? You get a lead right now? Where does it go? How do you keep track of it? All that, all the internal process stuff?
17:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, so our, our phone numbers are all attached to call rail. And call rail is a, you know, just a software or online, you know, platform where you can buy the phone numbers for your businesses. And so when that happens, whenever a lead comes in, it goes to three of my guys. It goes to Chad, it goes to Ryan, it goes to Joshua. Whoever jumps on that first gets that lead. Okay? So one, they're hungry to get that lead because they, this is the, you know, this is their commission, right? This is how they, one, it's exciting for them. And two, this is how they feed their family and live their lives.
18:31 Speaker 03 So Brad, not to interrupt, but I just want to be very specific. So do you have a call rail number? It's basically like a tracking number that you put on your website or your landing page that people click on the PPC ad. Says, you know, 555 or whatever the phone number is. And then is it ringing all three of them at the same time? And it's kind of like first come, first served gets the lead? That's how that works?
18:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. Not only that, but most of the leads, Andrew, are going to be form fills. Right? So when the, when they fill in the form, it's going to be sent in and automatically sent through call rail to text them all. That lead and me. I mean, I'm on there, on there as well. Right? But the reason we do it through the, the call rail is because we can call back through that number and all. All those calls are recorded, which is great. And we want to hear that and work on it and train on that. And so it's mostly the form fills that come in. The, you know, when people fill it out on the website and then whoever reaches out first gets that lead. And then we start, you know, rocking and rolling and it's as soon as that comes in, it goes to our follow up boss CRM. So it's in there as well. Yep.
19:33 Speaker 03 Gotcha. And are you, so you're having these conversations with people. It's a competition amongst your three salesmen. Are you also, um, I hear this a lot from people, some people not so much, but are you offering on every single lead that comes in, unless it's like a case that makes absolutely no sense to offer. But how are you approaching that, even if it's like a high number that they want? Do you still make offers?
19:56 Speaker 01 It is, it depends on the discovery, right? Do they want speed and convenience? I'm not going to make an offer, Andrew, if it's somebody that their house is beautiful. They don't really need to sell it. They're just curious on what somebody's going to give them. And they're about to put it on them. They've already signed documents with the real estate agent to put it on the market tomorrow. You know what I mean? That's just silly. I mean, the whole, the more offers you make, the more money you make is not in our experience, yes, it's, it's right, but that's such a broad statement. It's silly. It's like, yeah, but are you making the right offers to the right people? That's what we're looking for. Yeah. Cause you can make offers to anybody and it's just going to insult them. And you're going to get bad, weird, bad Google reviews because somebody's wildly insulted
20:41 Speaker 01 that you offered them, you know, a number that would make sense to an investor, but certainly not to somebody that has a beautiful property that they have a lot of pride in. You know, we look for what, what is the problem? What is the condition? How fast do they want to sell this? I mean, most sellers want it done really fast. So yes, that's, there's a factor. But the bigger factor is, is this property destroyed? Is this property that somebody can go in and put some, they can put the work into the property and sell it for significantly more? Is it going to be a deal because of the condition of the property? That's what we're looking for. And so my guys are the, that run the Google ads, because I have a, I have a Google ads, uh, business
21:20 Speaker 01 and a marketing company, and they're really, really, really good at being obsessed with getting us leads to really ugly houses.
21:29 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:30 Speaker 01 That's the difference between, you know, some marketing companies that'll just, you know, get you a bunch of leads and marketing companies that'll get you leads for actual ugly house.
21:39 Speaker 03 Yes, that's the key there. Brian, I'm curious, you have your systems and your marketing dialed in big time. What are some of the KPIs or the data points that you are looking at in order to run and operate your business here?
21:54 Speaker 01 One is the live call answer rate, right? It needs to be, well, it needs to be 95% or higher. So if somebody calls in, somebody's answering that live. The only time we really screw that up is if it's like somebody that's hammered, that's calling at like 1:30 in the morning and they're like, you know, I mean, there's just like some random people that do that. I look at how many leads per deal, per closed deal, not like signed up contract. How many leads do you need to close a deal? How many do we need? What is the cost per lead? Which essentially will boil down to what is your cost per deal? And then how much do we make per deal? Are the real big KPIs that we're looking at? Because we want to make sure that we're getting a minimum of three to one on marketing spend to the
22:38 Speaker 01 amount that we make, but really pushing to be four and five if we can when it comes to inbound marketing.
22:45 Speaker 03 Okay.
22:46 Speaker 01 Yep.
22:47 Speaker 03 So you're tracking these numbers and what happens, like you're tracking them hopefully in like as real time as you can and they're leading indicators of what's going to happen next month or what's not going to happen next month. And then you can make data-driven decisions based on what you're seeing and pivot and tweak as needed, right?
23:03 Speaker 01 Right. I mean, the last, the last one there is how many appointments are we going on? I want to go on as many appointments as we can. How many appointments are we going on? And how many of those appointments do we close? Do we, do we actually get all the way through the finish line?
23:19 Speaker 03 Okay.
23:19 Speaker 01 And so those are really good tracking.
23:22 Speaker 03 Or like over the phone? Are you locking anything up over the phone? Do you do that? Or it's all in person?
23:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, we'll do over the phone if they're hours away. You know what I mean? Like three hours, four hours away? Because we kind of do all of Arizona, but our bread and butter is mostly Phoenix and Tucson. Those are the two major markets in Arizona. And so, yeah, we'll go on those.
23:44 Speaker 03 Cool. Well, Brian, this has been really awesome. We were talking about Tom Kroll earlier on this, on this show and we, you know, we met at a Tom Kroll, or not met, but ran into each other again in Nashville about a month ago.
23:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:59 Speaker 03 And I, I listen to his podcasts a lot and I stole something from him. So I'm going to use it here. Is there something that you have that you're willing and able to share? Whether that's like a document, a checklist, a book, a resource, whatever it might be. So someone can listen to this episode, not only hear your story and how you kind of operate in the Google space, but take whatever you're able to share with us or the listeners to better their life, to better their, whether it's business or personal, their community, something that, that you're able to talk about?
24:33 Speaker 01 Yeah. So TTPinsider.com, TTPinsider.com has a tremendous, if you're, if you're just getting started out or you need some resources when it comes to finding incredible real estate deals, you'll find it there. It's completely complimentary. You can get in there and get a ton of resources. Also, if, if, you know, Tom always told me, Andrew, they either turn you up or they turn you off. So if people have made it this far and enjoy the conversation, I do a live show every week on Wednesdays on my YouTube channel, the Brent Daniels YouTube channel. I've got the wholesaling Inc. Podcast. I got the wholesale hotline podcast. So any one of those, you're going to find a unlimited amount of resources when it comes to finding great real estate deals, whether it's off market or on market. There's
25:16 Speaker 01 some great opportunities on market in boring real estate markets like we're going through right now. And so I don't want anybody to close down the amount of marketing channels and the amount of avenues that they can explore when it comes to finding really great deals. Cause I really do love the real estate business. I think it's a business that is wildly approachable and it'll work if you do. And so again, if you talk to enough people and make enough offers, you cannot lose in this business.
25:45 Speaker 03 Nicely put. So that was TTPinsider.com.
25:48 Speaker 01 That's right.
25:49 Speaker 03 Okay. And we will, um, we'll include that in the description for those of you that did make it this long in the episode. Brent, it's been an absolute pleasure. I was super excited when this one got scheduled. I had it circled on my calendar for quite some time. So thank you so much again for being here, man. I really appreciate it.
26:05 Speaker 01 Thank you, Andrew.
26:07 Speaker 03 All right.
26:09 Speaker 02 That's all for this episode. Your next step to success is to continue the conversation over at wholesalinginc.com by joining the mailing list as well as get your chance to book a strategy session to learn the systems and become part of the tribe and work personally with one of our amazing coaches. We'll see you next episode with more ways to make you a fortune in wholesaling.
Previous WIP 1914: #ThrowbackThursday - 5 Minute Fire - How to Achieve Clarity and Discipline as a Real Estate Wholesaler Next WIP 1916: 70% of Your Income Comes in 6 Months - Why Most Wholesalers Go Broke - Part 1 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated