Pod Insights WHAT WENT WRONG Out of Frame: In Cold Blood | Movie vs. Book About this episode When the town of Holcomb, Kansas opened its doors to renowned author Truman Capote in 1959, they had no idea their story would change the way True Crime was written forever. Join Chris and Lizzie as they explore the real case behind the novel ‘In Cold Blood’ and its 1967 film adaptation, plus find out where Capote may have twisted the truth, and the shocking lengths film director Richard Brooks took to recreate the murders of the Clutter Family. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 11,090 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Chris Winterbauer? Life can be a lot sometimes. Traffic, taxes, and that dreaded text that just says, "Call me." Why not go where life is good? Escape to Pluto TV. Turn off all your day-to-day problems and turn on the movies and shows you already love, from Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy to Dirty Dancing, from Alias to The X-Files. Channel Surf Live TV or browse the menu to find exactly what you're in the mood for. It's all free, no subscription, no credit card, no catch. The best things on TV are free, so escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
0:31 Lizzie Bassett? 12 celebrities, one Don, and cold, hard cash. From the producers of The Traitors comes The Mob, a new Hulu original series now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+. In this unique new reality competition show hosted by the iconic Parker Posey, 12 celebrity contestants are about to become members of a powerful family. For two weeks in a lavish Italian villa, they'll shake down and hustle to win a share of up to $250,000. And every good mob needs a Don. Whoever they choose to lead them will have absolute power deciding who stays and who gets taken out, who makes money and who walks away with nothing. In a game of power where loyalty and trust are the currency,
1:15 Lizzie Bassett? will the most powerful reality contestant in TV history be able to keep the family happy? And if they're overthrown by the mob, who will step up and become the new Don? Let the games begin. Watch The Mob, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
2:00 Lizzie Bassett? Hello and welcome back to What Went Wrong, your favorite podcast full stop that just so happens to be about movies and how it's nearly impossible to make them, let alone a good one, let alone maybe one of the most realistic true crime films ever made. We are talking about In Cold Blood today, both Truman Capote's groundbreaking 1965 novel and the 1967 film of the same name. And we're doing this because we're covering Breakfast at Tiffany's on Monday, which was, of course, based on the novella of the same name by Truman Capote. Now, since we're covering that film, which as we'll discuss was an extremely unfaithful adaptation of Capote's work, I thought it would only be fair to give his most famous work, In Cold Blood, its own episode, especially since the film is a very faithful adaptation,
2:42 Lizzie Bassett? perhaps in some ways, more faithful even than Capote's own account of the Clutter family murders. And it goes to some pretty extreme lengths in pursuit of its realism. Now, this is an episode in our out-of-frame series where we focus a little more on what happens just out of frame, off the movie sets and in real life than we do in our main feed episodes. And in this case, that means that we will be discussing the murders of the Clutter family on which In Cold Blood is based. And there is some explicit detail, so please be warned. If you're not someone who wants to hear about that, you may want to exit here. All right. I'm here, as always, with Chris Winterbauer. And Chris, what was your experience with In Cold Blood, both the book and the movie before today?
3:18 Chris Winterbauer? I thought I had seen this.
3:21 Lizzie Bassett? Me too.
3:21 Chris Winterbauer? And maybe I had seen portions of it. I don't think I'd ever sat and watched the whole thing all the way through. So I will just say it felt like a fresh, first-time viewing. And this movie is, at least from a technical perspective, absolutely phenomenal.
3:42 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
3:43 Chris Winterbauer? So just a couple shout-outs. I think that the black and white cinematography by Conrad Hall, who's one of the greatest cinematographers of all time, is just a true standout. It's some of the, it's some of the greatest stark, contrasty imagery, you know, you'll ever see.
3:59 Lizzie Bassett? Roger Deakins agrees, by the way. He has multiple times called this out as the best black and white cinematography ever.
4:05 Chris Winterbauer? It really may be the great. I mean, and it's, you know, there were fewer and fewer. This is 67. Black and white is, you know.
4:13 Lizzie Bassett? Out of the picture at this point.
4:14 Chris Winterbauer? And yet it evokes crime scene photography, I think, so well from the time I did take a look at some of the Clutter family imagery online. The music by Quincy Jones, I initially found a little jarring and then you realize what they're doing and it's so effective. At first, it feels almost like it's Mickey Mouse-ing with the John T. Walking bassline with the criminals and they're almost like doo doo doo doo doo doo, you know, with the clutters. And then the decision towards the end of act two to play the murders entirely without score.
4:42 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
4:43 Chris Winterbauer? Is very noticeable and I think extremely effective. And it's a stark contrast to Capote, the film, which we might talk about a little bit today as well. And I'll just mention the writing and the editing. So Richard Brooks both wrote and directed and the editor, Peter Zinner, great editor, who also edited The Godfather and The Godfather Part Two.
5:03 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, it's remarkable. The transitions in particular are incredible.
5:06 Chris Winterbauer? Yes, which have to be written into it. So it's, there are innumerable match cuts, either matches on action or matches on theme or tone. And so the movie just feels like it ping pongs between the clutters and our killers, Dick and Perry, or then the police, the KBI and our killers. And the last thing I'll say, so the casting, I think, is impeccable. I think Robert Blake and Scott Wilson are, you know, absolutely perfectly cast, to the point where it's, it's kind of difficult to watch Capote even. And I love Clifton Collins Jr. I think he's a fantastic actor. And obviously, Robert Blake, his, we'll talk about his history.
5:45 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
5:45 Chris Winterbauer? Following this film later. I think for me, the big difference between the book and the movie is obviously the focus, right? The book much more focuses on the clutters or the six victims, as you know, Capote describes it. Whereas the movie feels like it really from the beginning says, we're exploring the killers in this movie. And to me, it's why they feel almost a slightly different genres and that the movie feels like a crime movie more than anything else, whereas the book feels more like a horror book in some ways. Because the book establishes us in the perspective of the world that will be violated.
6:23 Lizzie Bassett? Right.
6:24 Chris Winterbauer? Which is Holcomb. And the movie establishes us first in the world of The Violators, which is Perry and Dick Hickok. Anyway, I loved it. I thought it was an incredible movie. This is a really complicated story. It's a very ethically and morally complex
6:39 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
6:40 Chris Winterbauer? area that we're entering into with Capote. And then the movie's decision to omit Capote entirely is fascinating, especially considering that his name is in the title. It is called Truman Capote's In Cold Blood.
6:50 Lizzie Bassett? I know.
6:51 Chris Winterbauer? And yet, Capote is missing and there is a composite journalist character instead. So, anyway, I'll leave it at that.
6:57 Lizzie Bassett? I wonder about, I mean, that's obviously intentional. I wonder if part of that was that Richard Brooks recognized some of the, I don't want to say manipulation.
7:10 Chris Winterbauer? Yes.
7:10 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I mean, manipulation is accurate, I think, of Truman Capote in terms of this story. And that actually inserting him in the part that he really, truly played in this into the movie would have made it a very different movie. It would have made it Capote, which I also rewatched Bennett Miller's, is it 2005?
7:30 Chris Winterbauer? It's either 2005 or 2006. It's that and Infamous came out back to back.
7:34 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. Both are very good. By the way, I prefer Capote. It is excellent.
7:38 Chris Winterbauer? Mm hmm.
7:39 Lizzie Bassett? That's a fun rewatch as well, if you have a little bit of time. Well, maybe not fun, but very interesting. So, similar to you, I thought I had seen this as well. I remember my mom talking about it. I also read In Cold Blood in high school and really loved it. I'm about halfway through a reread of it myself. I don't know that I agree that it completely centers the clutters. It does center Holcomb, for sure, and the, the community. There is an awful lot of focus on Perry and Dick in In Cold Blood as well. And as we know, Capote's own fascination was very much with Perry Smith.
8:12 Chris Winterbauer? Sure. Let me rephrase. For the first third of the book, the focus is the clutters.
8:17 Lizzie Bassett? Absolutely.
8:17 Chris Winterbauer? And then they're out, obviously. But then for the first third of the movie, the focus is really Perry and Dick and their approach to Holcomb.
8:25 Lizzie Bassett? There's almost none of the clutters in the movie.
8:27 Chris Winterbauer? Exactly.
8:27 Lizzie Bassett? Which, which. Like on paper, I don't love that. And yet I actually think it works very well in the context of the film because they don't spread themselves too thin at all. I think Brooks is very aware of how much he can cover in the time that he has. And what he achieves, I think also by removing Capote is potentially a more accurate portrait of Dick and Perry.
8:52 Chris Winterbauer? I think so. Certainly more than the movie Capote.
8:55 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, I think so, too. As you said, cinematography is stunning. I also really enjoyed the score. We'll talk about it a little bit. It's very disconcerting. It is a lot creepier than I expected. And I thought that the choice to hold the actual night in question, the murder, until almost the very end of the movie was very smart. And, you know, I wondered when it started, I was like, oh, my God, are they just going to skip the murders completely? Because they really just like zip right past it.
9:27 Chris Winterbauer? Which the book does as well.
9:28 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, but I think to do it on film is a little bit different. And I thought it worked very, very well. And I was also surprised by like, this felt very modern in terms of the things that they were showing and saying, like, it's pretty graphic.
9:45 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, they do extremely effective perspective work to put you into the mind of Perry Smith in particular.
9:52 Lizzie Bassett? Mm hmm. I loved the fantasy sequences with his mother and father.
9:56 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, his dad pointing the shotgun at him at the end, the way they did that. And it really, I think what Brooks does really well is he really sets up a question of, even though I knew Perry Smith was the trigger man going into it.
10:10 Lizzie Bassett? Right.
10:10 Chris Winterbauer? He very effectively makes you wonder which one of these guys did the killing. Because there's one that, you know, we know they have one shotgun. And I think that he very effectively sets up a question of, could it really be Smith? Because Hickok seems like the psychopath when the two of them are together.
10:27 Lizzie Bassett? Right.
10:28 Chris Winterbauer? And then he, of course, he turns around in the same way that I think, you know, something like The Sopranos is so effective. He gets you to root for Tony and then shows him to be the monster that we all deep down know he is. The same thing is achieved in this movie.
10:39 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
10:41 Lizzie Bassett? All right, well, we're gonna walk through the real case and how perception of it, and of course, the murderers, was forever altered by Truman Capote's novel, and then, I would say, again, by this film. This is really a story about adaptation and what gets lost in the pursuit of a great story, and how a real-life horror became a work of art, for better and for worse.
11:03 Lizzie Bassett? Today's episode is sponsored by Mars. You might not realize it, but Mars is behind so many of your favorite Halloween treats, and I'm not just talking about your candy bowl. Yes, Mars makes iconic candies like M&M's, Snickers, Starburst, my personal favorite, and Skittles. But they also have salty snacks, easy-to-make meal options, and even treats for your pets. There's something for everyone to enjoy this spooky season. David and I are too old to trick-or-treat, so we've been getting creative with our Halloween movie night spreads for our friends. I put together a char bootery board with some classic sweets like Rice Krispie Treats and Peanut Butter M&M's, and because I'm a salty girl, I added some Pringles and my all-time favorite snack, Cheez-It crackers. Scary delicious. For Halloween night, I'm making a spooky seven-layer dip using Ben's Original Ready Rice, because there is nothing that my kid loves more than a rice and bean dip. And don't think I forgot about our dog, Q. Mars knows he needs a celebration, too, so I
11:48 Lizzie Bassett? put together a special Halloween treat jar packed with Greenie's Original Pumpkin Spice Dental Chews and Pedigree Tasty Biscuits. He's agreed to share with the neighbors, because he's a very good boy. Find Mars products in a retailer near you or on Instagram at Mars Global, M-A-R-S-G-L-O-B-A-L, where you can shop everyday favorites and limited-time Halloween offerings. We recently moved into a new house and realized that our bedding desperately needed a refresh. So I took my own advice, and before spending all our money on a luxury bedding brand, I went to Quince. And let me tell you, we now have the crispest, coolest, most beautiful, organic percale sheets and duvet covers that we've ever had. I've bought quite a bit of bedding from Quince, and it's all super-high quality and has lasted for years without paying the brand markup. Now, obviously, you shouldn't stop at bedding. You should
12:33 Lizzie Bassett? also refresh your closet with elevated everyday essentials that you will wear over and over again. Think cozy Mongolian cashmere sweaters starting at $50, cashmere scarves, responsibly-sourced down jackets, and 14-karat gold jewelry. I genuinely love Quince, and I shop here for everything. I walked out the door the other day and really Every single thing I was wearing was Quince, down to my socks. Did I mention their socks are great, too? Find the fall pieces you'll reach for most at Quince. Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was what went wrong. It's the best way to support the show.
13:18 Lizzie Bassett? So let's start with the people who, as you mentioned, get almost zero screen time in the film, the Clutter family themselves. Now Herb Clutter was an extremely well-respected member of the community. This is the father. He was a successful wheat farmer in Holcomb, Kansas, to the point where he was actually appointed by Dwight D Eisenhower to the Federal Farm Credit Board. This guy was a seriously important person in Holcomb. He was not the richest man in town. That was actually his neighbor. He could always be counted on to lend a hand, but one interesting thing about him is he had a zero tolerance policy for alcohol. And he would actually require his workers to like sign a document saying that they would not drink while working for him and he would fire anybody that he caught doing it.
13:59 Lizzie Bassett? Nancy Clutter, the daughter, was 16 years old, daughter of Herb and Bonnie, and more on Bonnie in a minute. She baked incredible pies. She was a straight A student. She rode her old farm horse Babe. She helped the family out immensely. You know, you see snippets of this in the film, but it seems like she was one of those teenagers who was somehow able to sort of balance the weight of the world on their shoulders. Kenyon Clutter was 15. This is her brother. He was an avid hunter and woodworker. You do see this in the film at the very end when he references the hope chest that he's building for his older sister Beverly, which he really was building at the time of his murder. Herb and Bonnie had two other children who were not in the home at the time of the murders.
14:42 Lizzie Bassett? That's Beverly and Ivana, or Eviana, I think Ivana, who were 21 and 23 respectively. But it was Bonnie Clutter who probably suffered the most from Capote's portrayal of the family. In the book, she is painted as mentally and physically very fragile. And this is something that Capote said, you know, oh, was no secret in the town of Holcombe. It says she sleeps in a separate bedroom and she's basically a bedridden invalid who had been in and out of psychiatric inpatient care for six years. However, in the Sundance TV docu-series, Living Relatives of the Clutters pointed out 45 inaccuracies just in Capote's account of the family. And they said that his portrayal of Bonnie was the most inaccurate of all.
15:27 Lizzie Bassett? Now, it does seem true that she may have pushed through mental health and physical struggles. There's a lot of speculation that she may have had postpartum depression. She was absolutely not bedridden. She ran the clutter household. She was an active mother and wife. This really hurt the two remaining daughters, the way that he spoke about their mother, because it does seem like it was really not true.
15:52 Lizzie Bassett? Herb and Bonnie had built the house themselves just 11 years before the murders in 1948. And the nearest and only real neighbor was Alfred Stocklean, who had worked for the Clutters' farm. He, his wife, and their three kids lived in a house less than 100 yards from the Clutters' house. Now, according to Friends of the Clutters, quote, "Any family that was least likely to be murdered should have been the clutter family." On November 15, 1959, as you see in the film, Nancy's friend, also named Nancy, came to pick her up for church but was surprised when no one came to the door. So she and her father went to their other friend, Susan's, house to see if she knew where Nancy was. She didn't. And so they all went back to the clutter home together. They entered through an unlocked back door, and it was Nancy who found her friend murdered in her bed.
16:38 Lizzie Bassett? And her father, who had been waiting outside in the car, watched as his daughter ran screaming out of the house, yelling, "She's dead." Now, he came inside to try and call police immediately, but he discovered that all the phone lines had been cut. Nothing like this had ever happened in Holcomb, Kansas. No one locked their doors. It was a town of just under 300 people. Everyone knew everyone. In order to get there, you have to drive down a single lane, Route 56, past many other small, isolated towns. This is not even a place that you like, happened to pass by on the highway. And in fact, when the sheriff first received word that something had happened at the clutter farm, it came over the radio as, quote, "an accident." It was unfathomable to everyone that it could be a quadruple homicide.
17:20 Lizzie Bassett? Also, after news of the murders broke, the hardware store is sold out of locks. Now, when the local Garden City Police Chief arrived on the scene at 9:30 a.m., Herb, Nancy, Bonnie, and Kenyon were found pretty much exactly as you see them in the film. The attention to detail in terms of the crime scene photos and the film is pretty remarkable. Herb was in the furnace room. His throat was cut. Kenyon was in a nearby room in the basement. Nancy in her room and Bonnie in another. All had been bound and shot in the head. Now Bonnie still had two rings on. And Nancy was found with a gold wristwatch hidden in the toe of her boot. The theory there is that she had heard the intruders and had time to hide it before they found her.
18:02 Lizzie Bassett? You actually see a little bit of this in the movie because you see Perry walk by the staircase. Nancy walks by, sort of, almost imperceptibly at the top of the stairs, and it's clear that she's heard them. Herb was laying on a cardboard box. Kenyon's restraints had been loosened and a pillow placed under his head. Nancy had been tucked in. Someone had clearly tried to provide some comfort to the clutters. And a bloody footprint was found on the mattress box next to Herb. Some tire tracks outside. Everything was meticulously photographed. Now, this was way outside the scope of the local police, so the Kansas Bureau of Investigation was called in, and this is Alvin Dewey, played by John Forsythe in In Cold Blood and also
18:44 Lizzie Bassett? by Chris Cooper in Capote, and he is really wonderful in that. Alvin Dewey was set to lead the case, and it was very personal for him. He knew the clutters and Herb from church. Now, they questioned the stock lanes of the neighbors next door, who hadn't heard anything except for the sound of Nancy's boyfriend, Bobby Rupp's, car driving away at about 10:45 p.m. And poor Bobby Rupp was pretty much immediately a suspect. This is because Herb Clutter really didn't like him. Rupp was Catholic, the Clutters were Methodist, and Never the Twain Shall Meet, and Herb had encouraged Nancy to end things with Bobby repeatedly. Nancy had also been shot with her face turned away from the killer. That raised even more suspicion towards Bobby.
19:28 Lizzie Bassett? But as we know, and as the police soon figured out, he had nothing to do with it. But that didn't stop people from whispering about him. And this is really sad. He actually had to transfer schools at a certain point because people kept talking about him. So then suspicion briefly turned to the Clutters' remaining two daughters, who stood to benefit from a life insurance policy that Herb had taken out. But Alvin Dewey shut that one down pretty quickly, too. He was like, I do not think it's these kids. Dewey was smart, and he started to favor a theory that there had been two killers. After all, Herb and Kenyon were both really quite big. And it seemed kind of unbelievable that one person could overpower all four of them, especially with those two guys in the house.
20:11 Lizzie Bassett? But as Dewey put it, he struggled to understand, quote, "how two individuals could reach the same degree of rage, the kind of psychopathic rage it took to commit such a crime." Seventy-two hours later, they still didn't have a suspect, which was a huge disadvantage. But they did have photographs that came back from the crime scene. And sure enough, not visible to the naked eye, but very much visible on film, was a distinct second boot print next to Herb Clutter in the basement. So Alvin Dewey was right. There were two killers. But he still clung to a theory that it must have been some locals with a grudge. And that does end up hurting them a little bit in this investigation. Now, a $1,000 reward was issued for information leading to an arrest, and the tips came flooding in, most of them absolutely useless,
20:56 Lizzie Bassett? except for one that came from inside Lansing, the Kansas State Penitentiary. Now, Chris, how reliable are prison tips in this scenario?
21:08 Chris Winterbauer? You would want to take them with, you know, an enormous grain of salt. But the, in this instance, Floyd Wells, I believe, is the gentleman's name. You, it actually confirms Dewey's hunch, which is that there must have been some connection
21:24 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
21:24 Chris Winterbauer? to Clutter. His reasoning for thinking it must be someone local is how and why would an outsider target such a random person in the middle of nowhere? And Floyd Wells, as we learned, had done work for Herb Clutter.
21:39 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, he had. He arranged to be called into the warden's office under false pretenses so he wouldn't look like a snitch, but he was absolutely about to snitch on his former cellmate, 28-year-old Dick Hickok. So, one important difference right away in Capote's telling versus reality is that the KBI did not send an investigator to Dick's house as soon as they got his name. They actually waited five days because they were suspicious of this tip, and Dewey still thought that it was a local. So, to your point, yes, he does think it must be someone connected, but he also, I think, can't understand the motivation of someone doing this who doesn't know them. And this is a big deal because
22:20 Lizzie Bassett? had they gone that night when they got the tip, they actually may have nabbed Dick because he had gone back to his family's home. But he didn't, and he and Perry went to Florida, where it's suspected, although I will note, definitely not confirmed, they may have committed another family annihilation in Florida, another family of four. We're never gonna know. Basically, they did actually dig up the bodies and do DNA analysis on it, and it was inconclusive, but it also meant that they couldn't rule them out. There just wasn't, it had degraded too much to the point where they couldn't test it. But Floyd did not just name Dick. He actually gave the investigators two names when he explained what he had told his cellmate. He said, quote, "I spent considerable time with him," meaning Herb Clutter, "in his
23:03 Lizzie Bassett? office, where he had a desk and, I believe, a safe. This was the old house where the Clutters lived in 1949, just about the time their new house was completed. I distinctly remember Mr. Clutter paying a large lumber bill, and I thought he paid it in cash from the safe. The reason I remember is because Mr. Clutter made the remark to me that evening when we left his den that he'd paid out more than $10,000 that day."
23:28 Lizzie Bassett? After entering Kansas State Penitentiary, I celled with Dick Hickok. Hickok said he liked Western Kansas and maybe would try to get a job with the Clutters. I described the location of the house. I suspect I talked too much about the money Mr. Clutter had. Hickok talked a lot about Perry Smith, said after they got out of the joint, they could pull some jobs to get enough money for a down payment on a boat. I tried to talk him out of it, said he would get caught, but he said he had a plan and after the robbery would kill everyone there and leave no witnesses. Now Floyd is painting a rather rosy picture of himself here because it sounds like, what is a lot more likely is he told Dick, there's a safe in here, there's over $10,000 in it.
24:08 Lizzie Bassett? And he was supposedly going to get a kickback of $2,500 from the robbery after they had done it. But he did settle for a clean conscience instead in this scenario, when he realized that he had actually done it. Of course, the important things there are, one, he's describing their old house, not their new house. And he's referencing a safe that I think we'll never know whether or not that was actually there. It could have been there. This was 10 years before the murders actually happened. Later, we learn they did not have any cash in the house and that Herb Clutter explicitly paid for almost everything with checks. Now Dick and Perry, do you know how long they roomed together, Chris? In prison?
24:51 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, no, I don't know.
24:53 Lizzie Bassett? I always assumed it must have been a long time because of the connection that these two seem to have built. It was two weeks.
25:01 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, you know, I think in some ways it actually makes sense that it was last time because it wasn't enough time for them to want to kill each other.
25:07 Lizzie Bassett? That's true, or to really learn enough about each other to understand.
25:11 Chris Winterbauer? Exactly, it's just enough that they have an impression of one another and they come up with a very, you know, half-cocked plan.
25:17 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, that's a good point. And it was during this time that Perry did tell Dick about the time he supposedly murdered a man with a bicycle chain in Las Vegas, just for the hell of it. This is almost certainly not true, but Dick believed it hook, line and sinker. Now, in the movie, I think they give Perry a little bit more credit for this and they set it up almost as though it was like a breadcrumb he left for Dick to see if Dick was telling on him when they were captured. I don't think that's, I don't think he thought that far ahead. I think Perry was extremely prone to fantasy and this was one of them. Dick had grown up relatively normal, although he was always getting into trouble. He was smart, but a pretty bad student and definitely had a way with the ladies.
25:59 Lizzie Bassett? However, he really started to change after a massive car wreck at age 19, when he lost control of his car on the highway and was thrown from the vehicle, landing face down in a ditch. He had a dislocated jaw and severe head injuries that actually changed the shape of one of his eyes. Have you seen pictures of him?
26:17 Chris Winterbauer? Mm hmm.
26:17 Lizzie Bassett? You can see this pretty clearly.
26:20 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, he's as mangled as Perry's legs are, and they go to great pains to show that in the movie. It looks like his face has been knocked out of alignment, you know, is the way that's that's how Capote describes him as such. And Capote is an amazing writer and he's aligned, you know, when he smiles, it kind of pulls his face back into its all American boy position, you know?
26:41 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, even in the pictures, you can tell that this guy was quite handsome.
26:46 Chris Winterbauer? Mm hmm, like Scott Wilson, who plays him.
26:48 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, who is great. I really love Scott Wilson in this, but there is something, when you see him at certain angles, especially straight on, you can see that one eye is like an entirely different shape and size than the other one.
27:00 Chris Winterbauer? Mm hmm.
27:02 Lizzie Bassett? And of course, listen, this is not an excuse. We do know that severe brain trauma can absolutely change people's personality and also their ability to regulate themselves. His first wife, Carol, who was a 16 year old that he married at 19, said that he was a different person after the wreck. Now, it should also be noted, it does seem that Dick had a thing for underage girls. It seems he certainly knew that Nancy Clutter was going to be in the house and that may have been part of his motivation as well. Perry Smith was half Native American, half Irish. He was born into an extremely dysfunctional family with two alcoholics for parents. He did have an enormous amount of death and tragedy in his family, but I'm not going
27:44 Lizzie Bassett? to dwell on it quite as much as Truman Capote does. Now, he did serve in the Korean War. He suffered a life altering motorcycle accident that disfigured his legs and caused chronic pain. This is what you referenced with the scars that they show in the movie. And he was also a known dreamer who bought mail order treasure maps in prison and constantly talked about finding sunken treasure in Mexico. This was right up Dick's alley, too, who was sure if he could just make the perfect score, his life would turn around. Also, mail order treasure maps? Guys, why would?
28:17 Lizzie Bassett? Why would they sell them?
28:19 Chris Winterbauer? Why not?
28:19 Lizzie Bassett? Oh. Perry and Dick had both been jailed for burglary and smaller crimes, and it was Perry who got out first, on the condition that he never set foot in Kansas again. When Dick got out, he wrote Perry several times about what Floyd had told him, and finally got ahold of Perry, who immediately broke the terms of his parole and headed straight back to Kansas. Now, on December 15th, 1959, one month after the murders, Truman Capote and Nell Harper-Lee arrived in Holcomb, Kansas, much to the shock of the locals. Capote had read the New York Times headline, quote, "Wealthy farmer, three, of family slain." And he decided this is what he wanted to write about next because, quote, "Murder was a theme not likely to darken and yellow with time." True.
29:03 Lizzie Bassett? Now, we'll give more background on Capote in Monday's episode on Breakfast at Tiffany's, but here's kind of what you need to know today. His childhood had not been easy. He had never really known his father and was eventually raised by his mother's extended family in Monroeville, Alabama. This is where he met Nell Harper-Lee. And of course, Chris, who is the character in Harper-Lee's eventual novel, To Kill a Mockingbird, that's based on Truman Capote?
29:26 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, what's his name?
29:27 Lizzie Bassett? Um. Deal.
29:29 Chris Winterbauer? It's like the imaginative, yeah, like little guy.
29:32 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, Dill.
29:33 Chris Winterbauer? Dill, yeah, thank you. Yeah, they were, I always forget, they were childhood friends. They wrote stories together and performed them. He called them apart people, I think.
29:43 Lizzie Bassett? He said that they recognized an apartness in each other.
29:46 Chris Winterbauer? Right, that's what it was, yeah. And Harper-Lee was, if I'm remembering, she was a real tomboy and got into, I mean, Scout is very much, it feels like.
29:55 Lizzie Bassett? Her.
29:55 Chris Winterbauer? Her, and it's so interesting. It's such a, both of their books, this book and then Harper-Lee's writing To Kill a Mockingbird, or I guess it gets published around the same time, but such different approaches to stories of
30:07 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
30:07 Chris Winterbauer? murder and justice, or injustice and retribution. Anywho, very, very interesting perspectives.
30:15 Lizzie Bassett? I agree. She comes across to me as, as someone who was a lot more sympathetic in the way that she treated her own characters, I think. According to Charles Ray Skinner, a childhood friend of Lee's brother Edwin, quote, "Nell was too rough for the girls and Truman was scared of the boys, so he just tagged on to her and she was his protector."
30:35 Lizzie Bassett? At 11 years old, Capote started writing short stories and he just never stopped. He was a perfectionist. He would apparently spend an entire day just looking for the one right word that he needed to include. He's incredible.
30:47 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, and he has some of the greatest, some of the greatest sentence construction of, you know, any writer. I wanted to read one sentence if I could from-
30:56 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
30:57 Chris Winterbauer? There were a couple. Well, first of all, when you described clutter, one of my favorite descriptions of him, this is in the first part of the book, describing Mr. Clutter, commenting upon a generally recognized quality of Mr. Clutter's, "a fearless self-assurance that set him apart, and while it created respect, also limited the affection of others a little," which I think is like a perfect description, especially when we think of people who are, you know, revered in the community and a little bit set apart. And then the other one I wanted to read, because he could also be so bitchy.
31:28 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, big time.
31:30 Chris Winterbauer? And I, you know, I don't like Twitter, but I wish that we had gotten Capote on Twitter.
31:35 Lizzie Bassett? He would have crushed.
31:36 Chris Winterbauer? This is his description of the interior of the home. You know, he's describing people who are, we know are about to die. "As for the interior, there were spongy displays of liver-colored carpet, intermittently abolishing the glare of varnished, resounding floors, an immense, modernistic living room couch covered in nubby fabric, interwoven with glittery strands of silver metal, a breakfast alcove featuring a banquet upholstered in blue and white plastic. This sort of furnishing was what Mr. and Mrs. Clutter liked, as did the majority of their acquaintances, whose homes, by and large, were similarly furnished." And I love how just damning by saying, "this is simply what they liked,"
32:14 Lizzie Bassett? I know.
32:14 Chris Winterbauer? is so cutting. And he's very pithy, but, and he's also a deeply empathetic writer, as we learn, almost to a flaw.
32:22 Lizzie Bassett? I would say definitely to a flaw. I think he, you know, he's coming from the very cosmopolitan scene in New York, as we're gonna learn. And you mentioned he's an incredible writer. He is one of the greatest writers of all time, ever. He did go to some prep schools. He actually never went to college. He just kept writing. And he became a friend to really all the greatest socialites that New York had to offer. He eventually published his first novel, Other Voices, Other Rooms, in 1948. And Breakfast at Tiffany's had just been published in 1958, I think a little over a year before these murders actually happened. Capote was nervous about trying to get people in Holcomb, Kansas to talk to him, which, I mean, if you've never heard Truman Capote talk, go listen to a recording of Truman
33:07 Lizzie Bassett? Capote, you will understand why he was nervous, which is why he brought Harper Lee along with him. Now, you know, you're talking about the way that he described their living rooms. It is bitchy. It is a bitchy, you know, sort of New York socialite attitude coming into Kansas. He absolutely needed Harper Lee because she did not have that at all. She had just turned in her manuscript for Tequila Mockingbird, but it had not been published at the time that they went to Holcomb. So she was really completely unknown. And she did an enormous amount of work on In Cold Blood, a lot more than I realized. She actually laid the groundwork for most of Capote's interviews over the course of this book and functioned as a pretty indispensable research assistant.
33:50 Lizzie Bassett? And later, when the book was published, do you know what credit she got?
33:53 Chris Winterbauer? I don't.
33:55 Lizzie Bassett? She's featured in the acknowledgements.
33:58 Chris Winterbauer? That's Truman Capote.
34:00 Lizzie Bassett? It is. Well, their friendship started to kind of cool after that. She was pretty hurt, given how much work she put into this. Somewhat surprisingly, though, Capote actually formed a real and very lasting friendship with Alvin Dewey, lead agent for the KBI on the case. And this was initially by turning up the charm on Dewey's wife, Marie, and son Paul, who wanted to be a writer. And of course, they knew who Truman Capote was. Now Dewey was shockingly open with Capote about this case, to agree that I don't think any law enforcement officer would ever be today. He gave him access to case files, Nancy Clutter's diary entries. He vouched for Capote when people were reluctant to talk to him, including poor Bobby Rupp, who only agreed to be interviewed because, quote, "Al Dewey advised me to."
34:45 Lizzie Bassett? And by the way, this is happening before they have caught the guys that did it. He is opening up the investigation to Capote.
34:52 Chris Winterbauer? It's, um, you know, don't people lock their doors around here? They will tonight. I mean, it's the equivalent of that. He's, he's very trusting. He doesn't believe that there's any ulterior motive. What other motive could there be?
35:05 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, true.
35:06 Chris Winterbauer? You know, and as we'll learn, Capote effectively inventing a new form of storytelling through this book gives reason
35:14 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
35:15 Chris Winterbauer? for law enforcement to distrust people telling these types of stories.
35:20 Lizzie Bassett? Good point. Yeah.
35:23 Lizzie Bassett? Now, in terms of the actual night of the murder, what you see in the movie is pretty accurate. Dick and Perry arrived at the clutter farm around midnight on November 15th, 1959. They both lost their nerve as they were driving towards the farm when they saw a light flicker on in the farmhand's house. And at this point, they talked each other into it, basically calling each other's bluff. They drank a little bit and then they continued down the road to the farm. They got inside, they searched for the safe, didn't find it, woke up Herb and the rest of the family and insisted that they tell them where the safe was. But Herb insisted there was no safe. And Perry, in pretty much every account he ever gave, seemed to believe him. Dick did not.
36:05 Lizzie Bassett? Now Perry comes across as sympathetic at many, many points in, in Cold Blood. As we've said, I think less so than he does in the movie. But he definitely paints Dick as the investigator and the violent one all throughout. After all, Perry stopped Dick from assaulting Nancy. That is true, it seems. He was the one who placed the cardboard under her because he was cold, the pillow under Kenyon. But as we know, it was Perry who cut the phone lines and Herb Clutter's throat. And it was Perry who shot every single member of the clutter family. And by the way, that moment in the movie where he's going through Nancy's stuff and he drops the silver dollar, that's real.
36:46 Lizzie Bassett? He found himself, you know, crawling under the bed to get this child's coin, basically. As is this quote from Perry Smith, quote, "I didn't want to harm the man," referring to Herb Clutter. "I thought he was a very nice gentleman, soft spoken. I thought so right up until the moment I cut his throat."
37:02 Chris Winterbauer? Which appears both in Cold Blood and in Capote, but I prefer the way in which it appears in Cold Blood personally.
37:11 Lizzie Bassett? What is the difference?
37:12 Chris Winterbauer? They both occur as the culminating line following the reveal of what happened that night. So we see the flashback. But with Perry Smith, he's saying it to Alvin Dewey, John Forsythe, in the car in Cold Blood. And it is played more as a kind of terrifying self-revelation as opposed to Clifton Collins Jr.'s more tearful confession in Capote. And I appreciated that Brooks didn't feel like he was attempting to wring pathos from the moment. He was instead trying to show that they have wondered what unknowable evil could come into this home. And the most terrifying aspect to me is that it remains
37:54 Chris Winterbauer? unknowable even to Perry Smith in that moment. And I thought it was really effective. Whereas in Capote, it feels like it's played a little bit more in that more typical prestige-y kind of way with music and whatnot, et cetera.
38:07 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. And I believe Capote is more accurate in terms of who that is actually said to, that it is being delivered to Truman Capote. But of course, that in and of itself calls into question the nature of that quote.
38:20 Chris Winterbauer? Right. How it's been colored by his interpretation. Right.
38:23 Lizzie Bassett? So all told, Dick and Perry got about $40 from the Clutters that night, plus some items they stole and pawned. Altogether, they walked away with about $100, which is around $1,100 today. They went on the run. Their plans in Mexico fell apart. Meanwhile, Capote and Harper Lee were treated to dinner parties and borderline unlimited access to the investigation and people of Holcomb.
38:47 Lizzie Bassett? Once Dick and Perry were captured, Capote got also unlimited access to them as well. And by the way, in Bennett Miller's Capote, Truman is shown handing over $10,000 to the prison warden in order to get this kind of access. But the only evidence that this ever happened is an unattributed quote, apparently from Capote himself in Gerald Clark's biography, quote, "I went for broke and asked for an interview with this behind the scenes figure who was a man of great distinction and renown in that state. I'll give you $10,000 if you can arrange this, I said. I guess my offer was very tempting, and he just nodded his head."
39:19 Chris Winterbauer? Mm-hmm.
39:20 Lizzie Bassett? But according to The Guardian, Capote really didn't let facts get in the way of the best story. And given that Capote engaged a local law firm to help negotiate the terms of his access to Perry and Dick, an envelope full of cash almost certainly did not cross the desk of the warden.
39:35 Chris Winterbauer? I think Bennett Miller is an exceptional, one of the best directors.
39:39 Lizzie Bassett? I love him, yeah.
39:40 Chris Winterbauer? I also think Bennett Miller is not going to let the truth get in the way of a good story with some of these things as well.
39:46 Lizzie Bassett? No, of course.
39:47 Chris Winterbauer? And I love, I mean, as I've mentioned, Moneyball, one of my favorite films of all time.
39:50 Lizzie Bassett? I loved Foxcatcher, too, yeah.
39:51 Chris Winterbauer? Which also there, you know, are some questions about the way in which that, those relationships were portrayed, but.
39:57 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. Dick and Perry were sentenced to death by hanging after the jury deliberated for only 30 minutes. However, the case would drag on, of course, for five years through appeals and stays of execution, something Truman Capote really did not account for. He had developed an arguably too close relationship with Perry Smith over the course of their interviews, but now he had a big problem.
40:18 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
40:19 Lizzie Bassett? His manuscript was almost completely done, but he didn't have an ending because those stays of execution kept rolling in. And this tore Capote apart because as a human being, he didn't want his friend Perry to die. As a writer, he really couldn't afford for him to live. Finally, on April 14th, 1965, they were both executed with Truman Capote in attendance, and Capote was reportedly crushed. He was inconsolable on the flight home, and as we know from the rest of his life, he never really recovered from this.
40:51 Lizzie Bassett? From September to October of that same year, In Cold Blood was published as a four-part series in The New Yorker, and each part broke the magazine's sales records at the newsstands. And in January of 1966, the quote-unquote "novel" was published and shot straight to number one on the New York Times Nonfiction Bestsellers list, where it stayed for 13 weeks. And Chris, you referenced this, but Capote himself really promoted it as a new form of literature. It was the true crime novel. And the word "novel" is very important because that is exactly what it was.
41:22 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, there's an, he is giving an interiority to characters that would be impossible to actual achieve.
41:28 Lizzie Bassett? Right.
41:28 Chris Winterbauer? I actually, I don't want to mischaracterize this. I actually don't think that his portrait of, for example, Bonnie Klutter is unsympathetic at all. He may have mischaracterized the extents of her self-isolation, for example.
41:43 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
41:43 Chris Winterbauer? However, I actually think he does a fantastic job of exploring the nooks and crannies of relatively undiscussed things at the time, like postpartum depression.
41:54 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
41:55 Chris Winterbauer? A feeling of isolation and a lack of purpose, for example, in, in her home life once her, you know, children have grown. And then for, there's, it's just a brief sojourn, you know, when he discusses how she, she actually got a job in Wichita at one point, and actually enjoyed it so much that it felt un-Christian, or as if she was betraying her husband.
42:15 Lizzie Bassett? Her family, yeah.
42:16 Chris Winterbauer? And so she felt the need to return. Again, I don't want to speak to the accuracy. I don't know, her family would know, but I always found it sympathetic.
42:24 Lizzie Bassett? It is, 100%. It is. I mean, he's absolutely incredible at creating characters.
42:29 Chris Winterbauer? Yes.
42:29 Lizzie Bassett? He's incredible at descriptions, at understanding motivations.
42:32 Chris Winterbauer? Even just characters that come and go for just a moment. You know what I mean? The, the mailwoman of the, you know, of the Perry.
42:38 Lizzie Bassett? I know.
42:38 Chris Winterbauer? Who, you know, again, it.
42:39 Lizzie Bassett? But the problem is, if that wasn't true.
42:43 Chris Winterbauer? Of course.
42:44 Lizzie Bassett? And I'm not saying that there weren't kernels of truth in it. There were. There were more than kernels of truth to it, but it was enough that it really impacted the living daughters because it wasn't accurate.
42:55 Chris Winterbauer? And it's the tricky thing with this genre because he's saying it's a novel, but he's also saying it's based on this true story. It gets really murky really quickly.
43:03 Lizzie Bassett? Well, and here's something else that I actually didn't know before researching this episode. He never used a tape recorder in any of the interviews that he conducted.
43:13 Chris Winterbauer? And they point that out in Capote when, you know, I have 94% perfect recall, which
43:18 Lizzie Bassett? That's right.
43:19 Chris Winterbauer? How could we possibly know that?
43:21 Lizzie Bassett? You can't. So he relied on his recall, which, as you said, he claimed was anywhere between 92 and 96% accurate. The number depended on the day and the context of the conversation. And he said that he'd spent two years training himself on his near perfect recall. But as George Plimpton once said, he could recall everything, but he could never remember what percentage recall he had. Almost immediately after the book was published, Esquire actually sent native cans and Phillips Tompkins to Holcombe to retrace Capote's steps. And pretty much right away, he discovered that 92 to 96% may have been quite generous. He found several inaccuracies, most glaringly in the portrayal of Perry Smith. Capote Smith, as we have discussed,
44:01 Lizzie Bassett? is soulful, confused. He's sympathetic. He's violent, but perhaps understandably so. In reality, it seems he was probably an awful lot more conscious, calculated and deliberate when it came to murdering the clutter family. And to give you an idea of how much creative license Capote had taken, the final scene of the book features Alvin Dewey speaking with Susan, Nancy Clutter's best friend at the gravesite. Susan tells Dewey that she's in college now. Bobby Rep has grown up and married a beautiful girl. And it seems that the community is changing and finally moving on. Except this never took place. It was a complete invention by Capote, which he did admit before his death in 1984. This is not to belittle Capote's work,
44:44 Lizzie Bassett? which is revolutionary and changed both the way nonfiction was written and how it was received by the general public. However, he was pretty irresponsible with the way he positioned it as the truth.
44:56 Lizzie Bassett? In fact, when it was initially published, Capote insisted that every word in it was true. The New Yorker, of course, had employed a fact checker as well. But it was later discovered that this person was a close friend of Capote's, who had basically just double-checked names, spellings, and dates, not the way that it was written or how any of the scenes were recreated, which calls into question so much of what Perry Smith, quote unquote, "said," because so often it was said alone in a prison cell to Truman Capote.
45:31 Lizzie Bassett? Now, before The New Yorker even published the series, Hollywood was already circling the project for a feature film adaptation. And in fact, people wanted it so badly that fights broke out. Physical fights, Chris. Otto Preminger got into an altercation with his agent Irving Lazar at a bar when Lazar blocked him from acquiring the rights. And Lazar actually hit him over the head with a highball glass and faced criminal charges for it. But on June 12, 1966, Richard Brooks and Columbia Pictures won the prize after promising to stay completely faithful to the book. Capote got somewhere around $400,000, which is $4.4 million today, and a 30% cut of the box office profits.
46:12 Chris Winterbauer? The 30% is actually the much more noticeable number there.
46:16 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, that's a lot.
46:17 Chris Winterbauer? That's extremely high.
46:18 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. If you don't know who Richard Brooks was, he had directed Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Blackboard Jungle, Elmer Gantry. I mean, he was a 20-year veteran of-
46:29 Chris Winterbauer? Brothers Karamazov, the Yul Brynner one.
46:31 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. And he had actually been wanting to write a true crime film for a while. And so when this one came around, he took on the role of writer, producer, and director.
46:42 Lizzie Bassett? Now, he insisted they needed to keep the budget low, and he also wanted to cast unnamed actors. He told the LA Times, "If the picture were to cost a great deal of money, we would have to please too many people, thereby perhaps pleasing very few." He also insisted on black and white, which is cheaper, but also, as you pointed out, has that look of crime scene photos.
47:04 Lizzie Bassett? Soon word got out that the script, also written by Brooks, was gonna focus almost exclusively on Hickok and Smith, and the studio pushed for Paul Newman and Steve McQueen.
47:14 Chris Winterbauer? Wow. I mean.
47:16 Lizzie Bassett? Why?
47:17 Chris Winterbauer? I could see either Paul Newman or Steve McQueen, more Steve McQueen as Hickok.
47:23 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
47:24 Chris Winterbauer? But one of the reasons I think Robert Blake is such brilliant casting is not only was there maybe a darkness to him that was later revealed, he was a child actor.
47:33 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
47:33 Chris Winterbauer? And because he was a child actor, he not only fits physically the role extremely well, but it brings with it some baggage for the audience that I think is interesting.
47:45 Lizzie Bassett? What was he a child actor in, Chris, most famously?
47:48 Chris Winterbauer? Red Ryder. Wasn't that the big show?
47:51 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, but he broke out in a series of shorts.
47:55 Chris Winterbauer? I don't know.
47:56 Lizzie Bassett? Our Gang, also known as The Little Rascals.
48:00 Chris Winterbauer? That's right. I forgot. Yeah.
48:02 Lizzie Bassett? He was a little rascal. Yes.
48:05 Chris Winterbauer? Very good.
48:06 Lizzie Bassett? Well, so Brooks said, no way, to Paul Newman and Steve McQueen. He didn't want anyone recognizable in these roles because he wanted the audience to feel like they were watching something that blurred the line between drama and documentary, just the way the book had. 500 actors auditioned, eight finalists were whittled down, reportedly including Robert Duvall, who had broken out in 1962's To Kill a Mockingbird, but did not really achieve stardom until the 70s with The Godfather. And he reportedly told Dustin Hoffman that he lost the role because, quote, "There's one thing you can't fake, no matter how good an actor you are, and that's white trash. Thanks, Bob. You're rude." Instead, as we said, it was Robert Blake, who scored the role of Perry Smith. He had
48:48 Lizzie Bassett? been an extremely famous child actor, but despite working steadily, he had not broken out as a serious adult actor until this film, and I also don't think was super recognizable as an adult, because he didn't look like what he looked like as a kid. And he's small, too, which is right, because Perry Smith was quite small as well. He looks like him.
49:07 Chris Winterbauer? And I think he gives an amazing performance. I really do. I think, and Scott Wilson. They're both great.
49:13 Lizzie Bassett? It's very creepy.
49:15 Chris Winterbauer? It is. And they both, they really emphasize the difference between the characters. You know, Hickok is ultimately mostly bluster. Perry is ultimately not sympathetic and extremely disturbed.
49:27 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. Well, you mentioned Scott Wilson. He was a 24-year-old parking valet who had just played a small role opposite Sidney Poitier in In the Heat of the Night, and he, of course, got the part of Dick Hickok.
49:38 Chris Winterbauer? And he would later go on to play more Herb Clutter types in older age than anything else.
49:43 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, of course, on The Walking Dead.
49:44 Chris Winterbauer? Well, for, yeah, for one example, or Junebug, although he did play a very good villain in Scott Cooper's Hostiles at the very end of that film. He's very good in that movie, too.
49:55 Lizzie Bassett? He's great. Scott Wilson was awesome. Now, he got this part mostly because of Sidney Poitier. Sidney Poitier had really taken a liking to him on this movie, and he went out of his way to talk him up to Richard Brooks.
50:08 Chris Winterbauer? That's cool.
50:08 Lizzie Bassett? Quincy Jones, as well, who had composed the amazing score for this film, had worked on In the Heat of the Night. And Jones was one of the only jazz-based film composers working at this time. We talked about this. We both love this score. The way that it drops out at the end is so effective. It reminds me a lot of Bernard Herrmann's earlier works, like Psycho, particularly in the beginning. But then, his work in Taxi Driver actually reminded me of this, and I do wonder if there's a bit of sort of co-influence going on there.
50:41 Chris Winterbauer? It really puts you in the perspective of who, how these killers see themselves, these criminals see themselves.
50:46 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. You mentioned the bassline. That is played by extremely famous bass player Carol Kay, who is one of the most famous and prolific bass players of all time, a lady, I might add. Now, despite promising to stay as true to the book as possible, Richard Brooks, I think, may have recognized some of the artistic license taken in Capote's novel, because he started retracing The Murderer's Steps himself. And he did rearrange the story into more chronological order than it appears in the book. He purposely did not consult Capote, and encouraged the actors not to do so either, telling them not to read the book. He never gave them the full script, just the pages they needed for that day and the crime scene photos. This is so smart. In early spring of 1967, they started
51:31 Lizzie Bassett? filming, and Brooks was not kidding when he said he wanted this to feel like a documentary, because, Chris, I don't know if you know this, they shot at the real clutter farmhouse.
51:43 Chris Winterbauer? I did know that.
51:44 Lizzie Bassett? That's crazy.
51:46 Chris Winterbauer? After I watched the movie, I looked up the crime scene photos and it's jarring. I mean, down to the placement of the boot print on the cardboard mattress box. It is, the fidelity to the events seems to be extremely high.
52:04 Lizzie Bassett? I think it was in the movie. I think that Brooks really made an effort to be as close as he possibly could. They also shot in the Olaf House Hotel Room where Perry and Dick had plotted the robbery. In fact, the whole film was shot completely on location in and around Holcomb with one exception, which is the prison. That is because both the outgoing and incoming Kansas governors said absolutely not. So that is the Colorado State Penitentiary that you're seeing instead. But Brooks really took it to the next level when he cast the jury for the trial towards the end of the film. Chris, that is the real jury that convicted Perry Smith and Dick Hickok in the original trial.
52:45 Chris Winterbauer? Wow.
52:46 Lizzie Bassett? That's insane.
52:48 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
52:48 Lizzie Bassett? That's insane.
52:49 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah. Well, I mean, it's a, it's a brief moment, you know, as well. Yeah. It's so interesting because that, I will say, the only thing I didn't love, and I think this movie is incredible, Jensen's voiceover at the end that kind of takes over for the third act makes textual what I think was already there subtextually.
53:09 Lizzie Bassett? I agree.
53:10 Chris Winterbauer? And I just don't think we needed it.
53:12 Lizzie Bassett? I kind of think you don't need that character at all. Like, I understand they needed some kind of conduit for Capote.
53:17 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, they need someone for Dewey to talk to, I guess.
53:19 Lizzie Bassett? To another cop. Like, if you're gonna remove Truman Capote, I don't think you need this sort of composite character.
53:25 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
53:26 Lizzie Bassett? Now, the film was released on December 15th, 1967, to both critical and commercial success. It was nominated for four Academy Awards. In 2008, it was added to the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress. Scott Wilson went on to have a very long and successful career, as you pointed out. He's probably best known for playing Herschel Green on The Walking Dead, which he did right up until his own death in 2018. Robert Blake, on the other hand, as we have hinted, has a bit of a different legacy. He went on to star as Detective Tony Beretta on the successful TV series Beretta from 1975 to 78. And then he never really achieved the same level of success again, despite continuing to work until The Lost Highway in 1997. But it was 2001 that defined Blake more than anything else.
54:10 Lizzie Bassett? After a night out to dinner at Vitello's in Studio City with his then-wife Bonnie Lee Bakely, he left her in the car briefly and then, according to him, headed back inside the restaurant to retrieve his gun that he left in the restaurant. Meanwhile, Bonnie, outside in the car, was shot to death. He insisted he had nothing to do with her murder, but prosecutors claimed he had shot her himself after initially trying to hire hitmen for the job. Now, it should be noted, he was acquitted of the murder charges, but a civil jury did find him liable for Bonnie's death and ordered him to pay her family $30 million, which bankrupted him, and then I believe they dropped it to about 15 million. It's a strange case.
54:54 Lizzie Bassett? I, you know, it's not a situation.
54:56 Chris Winterbauer? She has a very strange history as well.
54:58 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, she does. I think she had like eight husbands prior to him.
55:01 Chris Winterbauer? Mm-hmm. During the, uh, kind of like a lonely hearts scam, I think, for a long time. Obviously, none of which is any justification for a murder.
55:09 Lizzie Bassett? No.
55:10 Chris Winterbauer? It's, but it is, it's a complex and strange history. And, and I believe the gun that he did have on him, they confirmed was not used in...
55:17 Lizzie Bassett? It was not. It was not. This is the thing is like, you know, on paper, when you hear the story, it's so bizarre and you think like, that doesn't make any sense. Oh, of course he did it. It's actually, it's pretty unclear. There was gun residue found on him, but it was not the gun that had been used to kill her. It was the gun that he left in the restaurant. I don't know. It's very weird. It's very sad and we don't know whether he did it or not, but he certainly, he never outgrew that reputation.
55:49 Lizzie Bassett? And that wraps up our coverage of In Cold Blood as we head into lighter fare with Breakfast at Tiffany's on Monday.
55:56 Chris Winterbauer? Well, you know, it should be noted that, you know, Breakfast at Tiffany's, among some of Capote's other work, but in particular that book, because it had been made into a movie, is a lot of what bought him access, right? In some of these, not just in Holcomb, but generally throughout his life. And as you mentioned, he befriended so many socialites. And then as the movie Capote really emphasizes, In Cold Blood is the last book that Capote publishes. It makes him the most famous man in America. It becomes his most famous book. And he never publishes another book. And then the epitaph in his unpublished final work, that was when he died, I think in 1984, I'm going to get the quote wrong, but it's something around, you know, "More tears have been shed over answered prayers than unanswered ones."
56:41 Lizzie Bassett? Which made me think of what movie that we just covered, Chris.
56:45 Chris Winterbauer? We just covered, we just, what did we do? Taxi Driver?
56:48 Lizzie Bassett? Willy Wonka. It's literally the final lines of Willy Wonka.
56:51 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, yeah, sure. Exactly. What happened to the man who got everything? You know?
56:55 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
56:56 Chris Winterbauer? He lived happily ever after. And it did, you know, much of what the movie Capote emphasizes for the back half is Capote being trapped in this Schrodinger's box of sorts where as long as Perry Smith and Dick Hickok are in limbo, his book remains in limbo. And so he has to root for their execution, since their exoneration is exceedingly unlikely. And the execution is probably the better ending for his book. And you realize, you know, how much he has warped himself. And he, at least in the movie, begins to realize that.
57:25 Lizzie Bassett? I think he did.
57:26 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah. And the quote is intended to suggest he got the answer to his prayers, which was the execution of Perry Smith. And more tears were shed over that than had it not happened. I don't, we don't know if that was his intention. I think Bennett Miller makes that connection.
57:41 Lizzie Bassett? Bennett Miller, Capote's at himself. And why not? Also, Capote versus the Swans was, I didn't make it all the way through because it was so depressing, but Tom Hollander's portrayal of Truman Capote was pretty great and it is worth watching. That's later, towards the end of his life, when he is losing so many of the socialite friends that he had made.
58:01 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, I will say I really liked rereading the book.
58:04 Lizzie Bassett? It's so good.
58:05 Chris Winterbauer? Watching the movie and then watching Capote. I didn't have time to re-watch Infamous. I actually think Toby Jones's performance might be the closest to actual Capote. If you watch just interviews of actual Capote, that might be because Toby Jones.
58:19 Lizzie Bassett? Well, he looks like him.
58:20 Chris Winterbauer? He looks so much like him. But my point is, I would highly recommend that people watch, even if you don't read the book, watch In Cold Blood and then watch Capote, really, like, back to back.
58:30 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, it's a really good companion piece.
58:32 Chris Winterbauer? It's so interesting to see how two different filmmakers take such different approaches to the same scenes in certain instances, to the same material. I love Capote. I think it's an exceptional movie and I think I prefer it in Cold Blood.
58:44 Lizzie Bassett? Interesting.
58:46 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
58:46 Lizzie Bassett? All right. Well, thanks for joining me on this. I really enjoyed diving back into this. I forgot how much I love Truman Capote. He is just one of the greatest writers ever to put pen to paper. He had a sad end, which we may talk about a bit on Monday, but we will dive into Breakfast at Tiffany's, which I'm not excited to watch because of Mickey Rooney, but I will, I will push through.
59:10 Chris Winterbauer? All right, Lizzie, thank you so much. We'll talk to you guys on Monday for Breakfast at Tiffany's.
59:20 Speaker 02 What Went Wrong is a Sad Boom podcast presented by Lizzie Bassett and Chris Winterbauer. Post-production and music by David Bowman. This episode was researched by Laura Woods and edited by H. Conley.
Previous Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom Next Breakfast at Tiffany's Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated