Pod Insights Voices of Search // A Search Engine Optimization (SEO) & Content Marketing Podcast SEO For Academic Journals About this episode Katherine Watier Ong, founder of Wo Strategies, discusses the challenges and strategies for maximizing search visibility for academic journals. She highlights that many journals are new to SEO and rely on platform developers, often leading to missed opportunities. Ong shares a case study where fixing a crawl trap led to 40,000 new keywords and 1,500 on page one. She emphasizes the importance of keyword research, strategic internal linking, and addressing technical issues like indexation and canonicalization. Ong also stresses the need for change management, training staff, and leveraging evergreen content to improve search performance. Show NotesConnect With: Katherine Ye Ong: LinkedIn // WebsiteThe Voices of Search Podcast: Email // LinkedIn // TwitterBenjamin Shapiro: Website // LinkedIn // TwitterSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 The Voices of Search Podcast is a proud member of the I Hear Everything Podcast Network. Looking to launch or scale your podcast? I Hear Everything delivers podcast production, growth, and monetization solutions that transform your words into profit. Ready to give your brand a voice? Then visit ihereverything.com. Welcome to the Voices of Search Podcast, a member of the I Hear Everything Podcast Network. Ready to expedite your company's organic growth efforts? Sit back, relax, and get ready for your daily dose of search engine optimization wisdom. Here's today's host of the Voices of Search Podcast, Tyson Stockton.
0:43 Speaker 01 Hey, what's going on? My name's Tyson from Previsible and joining me today is Catherine Watier-Ang, who is the founder at W O Strategies. W O Strategies is organic traffic marketing partner and trainer to science-based organizations. They collaborate with you and your team to ensure that you have the skills and strategy necessary to grow your organic traffic with the goal of getting scientific answers into the hands of your customers. Yesterday Catherine and I talked about training clients on using AI in their content workflows and today we're kind of switching gears and picking up where we left off yesterday to talk about SEO for
1:24 Speaker 01 academic journals. With that, here's my conversation with Katherine Watier-Ang, the founder at W O Strategies. Catherine, welcome back.
1:34 Speaker 02 Hi, yeah, it's great to be back.
1:36 Speaker 01 I love digging into these kind of like niche facets because I feel like you always uncover like little unique challenges and things, whether it's in like the operational elements of SEO or it's in the actual technical challenges they have. But today we're talking about academic journals and we were just touching on the subject. We're talking about kind of how some of these journals were like actually being monetized or having this business value. But from a broad, I guess, spectrum, what would you say is kind of like the greatest challenge that most academic journals have in maximizing their search visibility?
2:22 Speaker 02 With a few exceptions, because there are a few where I could tell they have some SEO help, but most of them are absolutely brand-new to SEO and they assume that the platform they're on and the developers that are hired by that platform are handling it and that they will magically be found because they have high authority. And I will tell you, I've worked with three federal agencies and now four academic journals, which are well, like, all of them are names you know. There's no magic to appearing just because you have decent brand authority. You still have to write something that is actually related to somebody's burning question, à la
3:03 Speaker 02 keyword research. You know, you still have to match those two things. Like, I remember, and this is not academic journals, but I remember when I was working with fisheries, it's the most government thing ever, they shipped me their whole list of acronyms, asking if any of them should be optimized for. And the one that still makes me laugh is they had ACL on the list, which to them means something to do with a fish. I was like, "We are not optimizing for that. That is definitely related to knees and not related to whatever fish committee you're talking about."
3:33 Speaker 01 But the search volumes are...
3:35 Speaker 02 I know. It is the most government thing ever. But, I mean, that's the thing. They've got very smart people. They're creating stuff that's either paid for by our tax dollars but is not being found because they don't have an SEO. And I've had people in forums too that are like, "Well, why are you helping out our federal website?" I'm like, "Because I helped build HealthIT.gov from the beginning." And I will tell you, we got sandboxed for six months. We had to build links. It took a while to build traffic, just like any other brand-new website. There's no magic.gov fairy dust that happens. It builds more links because it's a federal agency, naturally, but it doesn't have any magic, you know? And same with academic journals. Like, they've been around for a long time. They originally were in paper, they're now online. I mean, one of the ones that I helped migrate had
4:18 Speaker 02 18 different subdomains. We're migrating into one domain. And one of them has been publishing since the beginning part of the century, 1903. And all of that's been digitized, right? I mean, there's big websites. You can see the text... Technical part. So like I have a case study on my website. It was actually the first journal I worked with where and I was as I was digging into the audit. I discovered the bane of my existence. So they had relative links and they did not have a four or four getting triggered. And it was part of the search function. So it kept generating extra folders onto the URL. So these URLs became longer and longer and longer with all these fake folders. And it was just a crawl trap. Google bot was literally getting nowhere and the developers were contentious with the client as well as me.
5:04 Speaker 02 And they did not want to make any changes. I said, listen, I have the entire audit. Do this one thing. Fix this one problem. Within a month, forty thousand more keywords on Google, fifteen hundred on Google page one, just because of fixing the crawl trap.
5:17 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:18 Speaker 02 Right? There are these things that like totally get in their way and they have no idea. They have no idea. So I usually come in and fix those things, right? We get a little bit of a lift and they're like, wow, Catherine was, you know, got this great fix going, whatever. And then we work on the harder things, which is okay, all of you, because these are big organizations. What do you want to appear for? And what are you willing to track and rank tracking tool? And that is so hard. I'm on year five with one. I think next year we're finally going to tackle it. Year six.
5:49 Speaker 01 Interesting.
5:50 Speaker 02 It's really hard because it's like, it was hard with the feds too. You got all these people with all these missions and like, you know, all the different teams and and none of them have been held accountable for any of this either. Cause you know, once you track it, then somebody might actually get in trouble if something happens with that ranking, right? And so it's just this radical change for them. Everybody I'm working with is brand new to SEO. And so all of this is has a lot of change management pieces to it. You know, we talk about how to adjust people's job descriptions so that they're supporting the overall new SEO focus kind of thing. And what would be the carrot and the stick and yeah, that kind of stuff on top of let's maybe hire you somebody internally or train the person I'm working with directly so that they have got the knowledge.
6:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I feel like from that too, it sounds like, you know, you hear some SEOs kind of talking about how, you know, certain journalists or reporters could have an adverse impression of SEO of confining or constraining their creative process. It feels like probably in this area that that is kind of a big challenge in the just kind of navigating through bureaucracy and internal politics.
7:05 Speaker 02 I mean, a little bit. This is why I usually do the training directly with those people. So we, and it's like two different trainings, three-ish hours kind of stuff, right? So we, we go slow. I give them all the data for them to follow me because yes, I have to rework how they're writing and they might think what they're writing is poetry. Great, but it's not found, right? So there's a problem because the idea is not to write something no one's going to find. The idea is to write something that's actually going to be shared and distributed, regardless of whether it's the, you know, federal agency or the academic journal. Now, with the academic journal, they have a unique challenge in that they have to follow Google Scholars regulations. And if they're on a platform, there's a bunch of platforms that
7:48 Speaker 02 are partnered with Google Scholar and most of that is handled. The platform itself handles the direct link to Google Scholar. But they hire me because they're having trouble with Google Search, the big Google, where they get most of their traffic from. So yeah, they have a Google Scholar audience, but it's tiny. And this big Google Search audience is the one that they're usually challenged by. But some of the regulations, particularly around site maps are different. So Scholar asks for one thing and it absolutely conflicts with what would be best for big Google Search. And I've had conversations with John Mueller directly on some of the Slack channels. Not able to solve it. We're trying, but it's still a known problem. The other known problem is that they do a call for papers and it's usually strategic, right? So it's like, I want to know more about gain of function
8:33 Speaker 02 for H1N1, right? That kind of thing. And they don't give much more guidance than that. And then they don't edit much when it arrives. Like they have an editing process, but it's not an SEO. Like it's not possible to SEO edit what's been submitted, right? Maybe, maybe, maybe they could tweak them meta description. And that's probably about it. So for some of the journals, it's also about like, what is something that you own that could be more evergreen that we could strategically create and maintain? That would help your overall mission? Is it a collection page? Is it a podcast? Is it blog post stuff you're doing? And if you don't have any of that, you probably need a little bit of that. Cause otherwise your traffic is up and down depending on the popularity of the thing.
9:15 Speaker 02 So one of my journals was publishing a lot of COVID research. And was doing really well until Google switched the algorithm there in the middle where it was only WHO, CDC, do you remember those days where like that was a managed? Like only these websites that Google has picked as showing for COVID stuff? And that hit them.
9:34 Speaker 01 Hmm.
9:35 Speaker 02 Cause their stuff was not getting shown anymore, even though it was high authority stuff. They just weren't on the list that Google was showing.
9:41 Speaker 01 Yeah. And you also, you have like, and it totally makes sense where it's like, you have such a variety of authors, whether it's, you know, people within academia, you have grad students, so you have wide range of writers. And so it's more of how do we showcase and highlight this other complete work that we're not able to touch? And as we were saying that too, my mind immediately went into collections. That was like the first thing that.
10:09 Speaker 02 Right. Collection landing pages, right? Yeah.
10:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
10:11 Speaker 02 Which are harder to rank for, but if you want to follow a journal that clearly has got some SEO help, nature does some really innovative stuff. Where I'm like, you can just tell as an SEO, you're like, hmm, that was optimized strategically, right? Um, so they're doing some great stuff along that lines, but, um, but one of my journals just doesn't even, when they rolled out their design, they don't really have much. They don't have the resources to support something that like a, honestly, a blog or a podcast would be great. Um, and they don't have either. They literally just have these collection landing pages they can play with, which makes it very limited.
10:46 Speaker 01 Interesting. Now, like kind of switching over to the more technical side, and I think you touched on these a little bit, but I would go out on a limb and guess that some of the, let's call them maybe like the big three problems or opportunity areas is in indexation, crawl efficiency, and internal linking?
11:10 Speaker 02 Yes, yes. And their internal linking is usually not strategic. The platforms don't understand the signals that big Google search uses for canonicalization, unfortunately. So they're not linking to the canonical URL, or they're linking to all of the four, which is not helpful.
11:27 Speaker 01 Sorry, really quickly, just because you made a reference to the four kind of before we jumped on, for the listeners, can you give that kind of context?
11:36 Speaker 02 Yeah. So what happens is they usually publish an abstract first, which is like a little summary, and then they roll out the full page. And then when they roll out the full page, there's always a PDF. And then oftentimes, there's like an online readable PDF thing that we block, so only humans can use it. But technically, four-ish copies of the same thing. And the rules for scholar in search are conflicting. And I can see in Google Search Console that, you know, these URLs just fight it out. One surges, and then the other one surges. And it's a huge, huge challenge, one that I've not solved yet and still working on. But yeah, indexation, like everyone in the industry is like, you know, Google doesn't index everything anymore. I'm like, yes, they don't. And I've got high
12:19 Speaker 02 authority stuff written by an expert that's not getting indexed. I think there's a little tiny line where Google says it needs to have search demand. Like, they only index things they think people are searching for. And I kind of wonder sometimes if that's hitting some of these articles.
12:37 Speaker 01 Hmm.
12:38 Speaker 02 Because they're pretty niche. I work with a microbiology, you know, association. And, you know, for a certain audience, that's important stuff to find. But general public, probably not. So I kind of wonder. But yes, indexation is a huge, huge problem. And the platforms, like I said, they just don't understand the signals that help indexation and canonicalization, and how important those two are together. And so like, you know, making sure all the URLs are in the site map is usually an ongoing problem. And then one of the clients I worked with this last year was actually not on any of the platforms, which is an option too. Fisheries has a journal and was not on any of these platforms. And then they have their own problems. Because they can need to get into Scholar on their own and all sorts of things can go haywire.
13:21 Speaker 02 Particularly this one had just a whoever developer, not a platform. I just love that. It's like, what's 2024, right? The end of 2024. And I found hidden text and hidden navigation in 2024. What year is it?
13:38 Speaker 01 Oh, that's, that's a fun throwback.
13:40 Speaker 02 I know. It was, it was great this year. Um, clearly I'm a search geek because I'm giggling about it, but, um, but yeah, so there's always technical stuff they're not aware, which is why I highly recommend every journal that works with me that I train one person on technical SEO. And that's a longer training because I cover all of the basics, basically, so that you can start troubleshooting stuff on your own. But I think it's super important.
14:04 Speaker 01 Now, a while back I did an episode and I apologize to who he was because I can't recall his name on the spot here. So, um, I'll have to dig it up and give you a shout out on LinkedIn, but he was an SEO working for a university in California, um, Cal Poly. And so it's where I went to grad school. So I was like, oh, cool. Like familiar with these guys.
14:26 Speaker 02 Yeah.
14:27 Speaker 01 And in talking with him about kind of, again, him working on SEO in this kind of like his niche of for a university, he was calling out and going into like how governance was such a key kind of lever for him because he said, you know, you're herding cats with all these different content sources and creators within the university, whether it's teachers or faculty or students or whatever. And so I think it was like a year or so into his tenure there. He kind of switched his focus from doing the cleanup work to governance laws to kind of prevent them.
15:11 Speaker 02 Right.
15:11 Speaker 01 Is that something that you've seen come up in the academic journals or is it more similar to like a?
15:17 Speaker 02 It's something I'm constantly trying to get them to do with the editor staff.
15:22 Speaker 02 Oh yeah, it's, it's something I'm constantly because they have a workflow when you submit. It in academic journal. There's other stuff they ask for, right? You can't just willy nilly create whatever. And there's an opportunity, I think, there to add in SEO elements, right? Or allow the journal staff to edit your, the stuff that becomes the snippet, the title and the description, right? At the very least, either one or the two. But, you know, the journal that I'm here, on year six of, last year, we finally started talking to the editors, year five.
15:52 Speaker 01 Oh, wow. So that's, yeah, you have like elements of
15:55 Speaker 02 They move slow.
15:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, like government infrastructures.
16:00 Speaker 02 Yeah. And they particularly have their own beefdoms. That one in particular has, historically, it created all these different, again, paper, right? All eighteen different paper journals. And they independently did their own call for papers. And some of, like, from my perspective, if I don't particularly know the science per se, I know the journals are competing against each other on the same topic, in the same organization.
16:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I feel like too, I mean, going to that point is with any type of like academic journal or article that's like a peer reviewed articles, you're gonna have multiple variations of a similar topic on purpose.
16:43 Speaker 02 Yes, that too.
16:44 Speaker 01 You are trying to disprove these previously established hypotheses.
16:49 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:49 Speaker 01 So the competition between articles has to be, and I mean, and I guess too, if you're looking at legacy, you're probably having more backlinks to those older articles, which then probably leaves you at the challenge of how do you elevate newer articles? Like, is that something that you also kind of run into?
17:10 Speaker 02 We don't even get there because we're so stuck on all the other stuff. Right? Because like I said, it's year six and we're finally maybe gonna pick some topics, right? Topics for the evergreen stuff. I mean, because there was a lot of technical, all of these people I migrated. So there was a lot of technical reclaiming some backlinks, whatever. And so finally, we're moving toward, yeah. I mean, this is also one where my point of contact moved on to another association. As she should, she was there for fifteen years. But, so like, there was all So kind of that stuff going on and they had a restructure and a new CEO and whatever. So there's like other factors going on, but I'm stoked that we're actually going to attempt to tackle this. Strategically, what do you want to appear for and what can you actually rank for? Because as, as I talked to my point of contact, they had developed all these pages over this last year without talking to me.
17:56 Speaker 02 And because we had a very small retainer doing other stuff, mostly analytics. And I was like, huh, fascinating. I know for sure that topic you're not going to rank for. Like one of those big ones that has websites to do nothing but talk about the topic, right? Like, how are you as your, you know, this is a microbiology association and I know that it's important to them. But it's literally a topic that full websites cover, you know? Which was similar to National Cancer Institute. So they never did competitor analysis. And they were initially targeting the big cancer types. And I did an analysis in the breast cancer space and I actually said, don't target that. It's too competitive. You've covered 260 cancer types. Start with the least popular where you could actually rank. Because their competitors are people like Healthline with the nine people on the SEO team.
18:42 Speaker 02 And WebMD that's been doing SEO since before Google. And here they are, barely have an in-house in SEO, right? Kind of beginning. I'm like, whoa, let's take the liver disease and the breast cancer off the, off the plate and let's put in glioblastoma.
19:00 Speaker 03 Time for a one minute break to hear from our sponsor, Previsible. So you're looking for SEO help and you got a couple of options. You could start replying to spam from agencies that claim they can get you to rank number one on Google. You can pay an hourly rate for a consultant who will inevitably nickel and dime you with hourly charges. Or you can work with a cookie cutter agency to quickly launch a strategy less project with low success rate. None of those sound very good. Now, do they? Well, that's where Previsible's integrated consulting model comes in. Previsible draws from a collective 40 years of SEO and digital marketing experience to unlock your organic growth opportunities. They build custom solutions that combine strategy, technical expertise, content and reporting to effectively operationalize SEO for your business.
19:46 Speaker 03 Previsible's four-stage approach ensures that your SEO programs thrive by starting off with a strategy-first approach. Then they support you in your efforts to create quality content, help you identify technical issues, and most importantly, they'll work with your cross-functional teams to integrate your SEO strategies to make sure that your SEO budget actually drives results, not just your agency's bottom line. So join brands like Yelp, eBay, Canva, Atlassian, Square, all who rely on the SEO consultants at Previsible. For more information, go to previsible.io. That's previsible, P-R-E-V-I-S-I-B-L-E.io.
20:28 Speaker 01 Interesting. So a common, I guess, perspective that you've been hearing more and more within the industry is preference towards different, I guess, strategies in content. And before, and Bernard Wong has been on this, I mean, I know he's talked about this a few times, before you had kind of like the legacy, and I think he termed it as like skyscraper content, where you have your table of contents and you're covering everything about that topic to show that you're holistically addressing it. And, you know, he's advocating more for firsthand experiences, net new things that you're adding to the knowledge graph or the
21:10 Speaker 01 database on whatever entities you're touching on. Academic journals by nature have a component of that, where they should, in theory, all be either adding something net new to the community. Do you feel like, like, are you optimistic on the, what the future can hold for academic journals? Or are you kind of like?
21:37 Speaker 02 I mean, there's so much opportunity to strategically, um, now I don't think this is actually happening. But if you've got a couple of articles that are gonna launch in the next month, and you know there's a larger interest in them beyond like a tiny scientific community, right? And if you wanted to, you could also, you could watch them, make sure they get indexed, which is not happening now, but when it publishes, make sure it's in the index. And two, strategically promote them. So you could do things like embargoes and social media campaigns and paid search and social media promotion strategically around an article launch. And then you'd get a wonderful snowball effect and hopefully your server stays up
22:19 Speaker 02 because I've lost three websites in my history by doing this approach. Um, but there is that opportunity. So if they're gonna launch a new, I don't know, like, what if it's the sterilizing COVID vaccine? Right? There's some sexy stuff that's coming out, or I think it's actually some dork I like science. But there's, you know, like, for instance, I just shared on, um, Blue Sky the other day. They have developing, I think it's University of Virginia, is working on a test to measure whether or not COVID is hanging in the air. So I could like walk into a coffee shop and know whether or not I was walking into a cloud of COVID.
22:49 Speaker 01 That's kind of wild.
22:50 Speaker 02 That's cool and fascinating.
22:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:53 Speaker 02 And how much more visibility would that get if somebody launched that strategically versus just publishing it? Now, there's probably rules around publish, pushing some authors versus not authors. There's some politics there. It has to do with their author agreements. So we're talking about reorganizing their rules of operation a bit. But it's a huge opportunity.
23:15 Speaker 01 And it wouldn't be such a terrible thing to get a little more academic journals in social media instead of the standard clickbait. So that would be a win-win.
23:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, which is why they're all on Blue Sky. Because on Blue Sky, they don't suppress the links. So if you're all SEOs, you're not on Blue Sky, she's on Blue Sky. So if you've been paying attention on every other social platform, if you put a post out there with a link, your post does not get a lot of visibility. If you put a post out without the link, you get more visibility, right? Because they suppress the ones with the links.
23:47 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
23:48 Speaker 02 Except for Blue Sky.
23:49 Speaker 01 Interesting.
23:50 Speaker 02 So, yeah, there was actually, um, one of the journals, I forgot which one, wasn't like New York Times, it was like Fortune or something, and they were talking about how much more traffic they're now getting from Blue Sky than they ever got from Twitter, because the links are not getting suppressed. You're gonna see a lot more journalists wandering over to Blue Sky. And delightfully, you're also seeing cutting-edge news happening like it used to on Twitter, and that was the thing I liked on Twitter. So, you know, you've got the North Korea/South Korea thing that was just happening today and yesterday, and it's barely covered anywhere except on Blue Sky. You actually get the commentary and you can understand the conflict and stuff.
24:25 Speaker 01 Ah, that's super fascinating.
24:27 Speaker 02 But all SEOs should go to Blue Sky because of the link thing.
24:30 Speaker 01 Yep, for sure, for sure. Last, last question I want to throw at you, and it's gonna be a hard pivot.
24:36 Speaker 02 Okay.
24:36 Speaker 01 You mentioned a little bit back, kind of, we're not there yet with this client, and you mentioned some of the kind of, hey, we're just getting to this point after year six. So for me, that automatically kind of flags, one, a positive of just like longevity with clients, but then it also shows you're playing the long game. And I think a common frustration from SEOs out there are not being able to get things done because maybe it's organizational blockers, budget demands, whatever it may be. But it feels like, just kind of through some of your comments, that you're looking at it as the long game and you're kind of working through that.
25:19 Speaker 01 Would you have any tips for the listeners out there, kind of maybe some of the younger SEOs, of how do you have that focus on the long game? How do you keep motivation, persistence? Like, how do, how do you have that right mindset to then be going down that?
25:38 Speaker 02 I have a lot of tolerance. So I just mentioned I spent five years at a PR firm. So I started there because I met my future boss elsewhere, and I wanted to work for him. So that's, I started moonlighting as a consultant, helped them write this proposal that helped them win the business promoting electronic health records. And I built out healthit.gov and the digital strategy and... Helped build a website and stuff. But what I didn't realize I was doing, because I was really just focused on working with Tim, because I'm very fond of him, was I was putting myself in a place where generally to work at a PR firm, you start as an intern, coming from PR education, right? So you got PR at school, you do an intern and then you build your way up. There's a few people that are hired externally at the senior level.
26:22 Speaker 02 For the most part, that's the feeding for everybody in PR, which means I went to school for marketing, of which PR is an arm, right? But there's like all these arms, just PR is one of them. These kids have never got that background. This took me three years to figure out. So here I am, I was the first hire doing digital marketing and analytics. For the first year, I was it globally for SEO or analytics. I touched 65 clients my first year. And every conversation, I was like, who's the target audience? What's the goal? And I got deer in the headlights. They were like, we don't even know what you're talking about. We just want to generate impressions. Wait, wait, wait, I want to put analytics in there and drive the conversion. They're like, what? What's a conversion? I mean, the whole conversation. So what I ended up doing, because I eventually built a team of nine,
27:07 Speaker 02 is I took a calendar on the wall. And every time we had a tiny little movement from another team that seemed like they were starting to get it, we wrote it on the calendar. Because every conversation was challenging. It was a slog because you're doing change management. You're trying to change the environment of the organization. And now I work with clients that are similar. They've been doing this stuff this way for a long time. And I'm coming in usually because somebody high up like the CFO or CTO has brought me on board because they want to make sure that they're not losing traffic. Either they've lost traffic or they're going to move or whatever, right? Usually they've had a moment of crisis. So I've got, from up high, I've got, you know, support for what I'm doing.
27:51 Speaker 02 But it's changing their workflow. It's changing their entire focus of what they're doing. And that's tough. I've been through some change management when I worked internally. I know what that's like as an employee. It's slow. It's tough. You need to keep working with upper management to rework the, you know, job descriptions and what people get rewarded for and all that kind of stuff. And that takes time, you know? Takes a long time to put all that kind of stuff in place. It's not, it's not quick. I'm not walking into an internet-first business. These were not internet-first businesses, right? They were paper-first.
28:27 Speaker 01 That's such a good call out too, where it's like for especially some of the people that have been at these companies for so long. And given the nature, I would say it's probably not uncommon to come across people, you know, working for these journals for 10, 15, 20 years. That it's like their world is changing and they're having to adjust and update and whatnot, which over time sometimes get more difficult.
28:54 Speaker 02 Which is why I try to train them because I don't want them to feel like they're going to lose their job. And I will say now that I've trained a ton of people because I trained a lot of people, catch them, trained the team, seven of the team and nine, so seven were straight from college. Um, so I trained a lot of folks in my career and I will say, based on my catch them experience, not everyone's trainable.
29:13 Speaker 02 There are some people where it's like a lost cause, but I would say that more like three quarters of the people are trainable. Like if they have the desire, if they have the interest, if they're curious, obviously as an SEO, you have to be curious. You could maneuver and train people. Um, like I had one of my first clients when I first started my current business. I'd met at a search show, this is dating me, it was SES Chicago, so it was like forever ago. Um, but she sat next to me and she was panicked because she was a social media person, like cute cat, social media type person. And she was told, this is, she was working at a big ag publisher, millions of pages. She was told that she was supposed to do SEO and she was there panicked about how to figure this out. So I told her since Bruce Clay was there, I said, you know, I started with Bruce Clay's training, that would be a great place to start.
29:59 Speaker 02 So she did that, but then she came back to me and she's like, I actually want you to help me, Catherine. I honestly was there to save her job. And so we worked together on a technical audit and I trained her and coached her for a year, but she's still employed there. She's now in the development department, still doing SEO. And the last time I talked to her, she was like deploying schema using Google Tag Manager. See, that's the stuff I love. I actually saved her job, right? She's still there. She's thriving.
30:28 Speaker 01 Yep.
30:28 Speaker 02 So my focus is to just, the internet's not going away. Like I know these people started from print, but come with me. It's not that hard. I have a formula of training you on SEO where you will get it, I promise.
30:41 Speaker 01 And it's such a, to that piece too, it's also such a rewarding element to then help someone else either, I mean, in your situation, save a job or get a promotion. That's sort of just like progression that you can see in those individuals. And I feel like I've been a broken record on this subject. But I feel like, and this is being on a soapbox a little bit, but it's like, I am a huge proponent in pushing kind of SEOs to embrace and lean further into empathy. And oftentimes, it's like, too often as SEOs, we're always frustrated of how engineering won't pick up this ticket.
31:23 Speaker 01 But it's always in the sense of like, I get it, so why don't they get it? They should just listen to me on it. But it's maybe there's an understanding of it. Maybe you didn't make your business case clear enough. Like, maybe there's also a problem in how it's being presented to them. But I think both what you're saying, it starts with that, like, okay, where is this person coming from? How can I meet them?
31:45 Speaker 02 Yes, I was floored at hedging because I just told you, these kids come from school and an intern, and then they're like some associate level, right? So they've never done anything on the outside. And I was director of marketing at a organization, right? And I hired consultants. And I was actually at a startup inside the Points of Light Foundation. I was hired number one. So I know what it's like to attempt to manage all of the marketing and sales by yourself. And like, your life is just bonkers. And when a consultant calls you, you have to like, triage that amongst everything else you've got going on. Anyway, I would walk around and see, both see it on email and phone, that these PR kids, if the client didn't call them back, they were trained to harass them. Basically, they would like, keep calling and emailing and whatever.
32:29 Speaker 02 And I'm like, have you ever thought about what they're doing with their day? Oh, it was aggressive. I mean, I would get it too. They would try to track me down in the same way because it was like, part of the culture there, but I was like, wow.
32:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's tough.
32:40 Speaker 02 Have some empathy for your client. They, they have to go to their own internal meetings and then the HR thing that everyone's required to go to. And you know what it's like when you stack your day working at somewhere, right? And you do not have infinite time to answer phone calls from all your consultants.
32:56 Speaker 01 Especially the cold calls.
32:58 Speaker 02 Yeah.
32:58 Speaker 01 There's nothing worse than the cold calls.
33:01 Speaker 02 Unbelievable. Anyway, yeah, that was striking to me because I was the opposite. I was like, okay, I have a feeling, I have, I have a sense of what you're doing. I'm one of many, many things you're trying to balance at the moment, right? Let's be respectful of your time, too.
33:15 Speaker 01 Couldn't agree more. And I think in general, I share a lot of your same kind of, I guess, fundamental philosophies and how to approach this, how you lean into the education aspect. I think, again, more and more that we can advocate that, the better for the industry and the community at large.
33:35 Speaker 02 Also, there's a need for more well-trained SEOs in the industry, I would argue. I don't think we're saturated yet. I still think there could be more.
33:45 Speaker 01 More training, more education, and SEOs out there, don't forget to lean into empathy because it's something we don't do enough.
33:53 Speaker 02 Exactly. And related to that, I cover soft skills on my podcast. You have a perfect lead into that. So feel free to check out the podcast on my website. You can just find it at digitalmarketingvictories.com. But we cover, or we're attempting to cover all of the soft skills that are critical for you to be successful as a digital marketer.
34:12 Speaker 01 Absolutely. And again, be sure to check out that. We'll actually go ahead and throw that into the show notes, too, so you can have a reference there. But with that, that's going to wrap up this episode of the Voice of Search Podcast. Thanks again to Catherine from W O Strategies for joining us. And again, if you'd like to get in touch with her, you can find a link to her LinkedIn profile in the show notes. You can find her on Blue Sky. You can also check out her company's website at w o strategies.com. And again, be sure to check out her podcast for some of those soft skills in SEO.
34:48 Speaker 03 Okay. Thanks to Tyson Stockton, our guest host. If you'd like to get in touch with Tyson, you can find a link to his LinkedIn profile in our show notes. You can contact him on Twitter where his handle is Tyson underscore Stockton. Or if your team is interested in SEO consulting or organizational education, you can always head to their company's website, which is previsible.io. That's P R E V I S I B L E dot I O. Just one more link in our show notes I'd like to tell you about. If you didn't have a chance to take notes while you were listening to this podcast, head over to voicesofsearch.com where we have summaries of all of our episodes and contact information for our guests. You can also subscribe to our weekly newsletter and you can even send us your topic suggestions or your marketing questions, which we'll answer live on our
35:30 Speaker 03 show. Of course, you can always reach out on social media. Our handle is @voicesofsearch on LinkedIn, Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, or you can contact me directly. My handle is @benjschap, B-E-N-J-S-H-A-P. And if you haven't subscribed yet and you want a daily stream of SEO and content marketing insights in your podcast feed, we're going to publish an episode every day during the work week. So hit that subscribe button in your podcast app and we'll be back in your feed tomorrow morning. All right, that's it for today. But until next time, remember, the answers are always in the data.
Previous Training Clients On Using AI In Their Content Workflow Next Raising SEO Security Awareness Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated