How AI Search Is Changing Brand Visibility and Advertising
Voices of Search // A Search Engine Optimization (SEO) & Content Marketing Podcast
- 1h 2m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores how AI search and advertising intersect, focusing on the changes brought by AI overviews and the rise of new advertising surfaces like ChatGPT ads. The guest, Philip Thune, CEO of AdTina, and the host, Tyson Stockton, analyze observable data from millions of daily searches and ad auctions to explain how organic and paid search strategies must evolve together. They discuss the impact of AI overviews on click-through rates, the unpredictability of new ad platforms, and why brands can no longer treat paid and organic search as separate disciplines. Listeners will gain valuable data-driven insights into how major brands are adapting their budgets, testing new ad formats, and preparing for the shift toward AI-dominated search results.
- Advertisers should get involved with ChatGPT ads early to gain experience before the platform matures and competition intensifies. 56:34
- Paid and organic search teams need to work closely together because AI visibility and ad placements heavily influence each other. 35:11
- Search teams must track a much wider variety of AI surfaces and engines beyond just traditional Google and Bing searches. 59:15
- Brands should monitor ad placement variance caused by automated bidding and daily budget exhaustion to understand performance shifts. 6:17
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Introduction and Host Overview
The hosts introduce the Voices of Search podcast, its network affiliation, and the episode’s focus on AI search’s impact on brand visibility and advertising.
- 0:46Impact of AI Overviews on Organic Click‑Through Rates
Tyson explains how AI overviews in search results reduce organic CTR by about 20%, affecting paid and organic search dynamics.
- 1:39ChatGPT Ads: Inventory, Relevance, and Experimentation
Tyson and Philip explore the challenges of limited inventory, lack of visibility into ad placement, and the need for experimentation on ChatGPT’s nascent ad platform.
- 3:34AI Overviews vs. Ad Placement Strategy
Discussion on how AI overviews shift ad placement below the top results and the implications for advertisers’ click‑through rates and CPCs.
- 13:37Predicting the Future of AI Search Advertising
Tyson outlines predictions for AI mode ad formats, Gemini’s potential monetization, and the broader evolution of search advertising beyond Google.
- 33:35Intersection of Organic and Paid Search in AI‑Driven Environments
The hosts debate whether AI search forces closer collaboration between SEO and paid search teams or drives them apart, concluding that integration is increasingly necessary.
- 43:47Closing Reflections on Rapid Change and Industry Adaptation
The hosts reflect on the pace of change in search, the need for agility, and the importance of embracing new technologies while staying mindful of evolving platforms.
- 45:18Lightning‑Round Q&A on AI Search Market Dynamics
Tyson answers rapid questions about market consolidation, the role of large incumbents, and the long‑term competitive landscape of AI search platforms.
- 49:10AI Search Landscape Shifts
Discussion of how AI search is reshaping competition and the pace of change in the industry.
- 49:52Specialization vs. Generalization in AI
Debate over whether AI companies should focus on niche roles or aim to be all‑purpose solutions.
- 52:26Managing Rapid AI Innovation
Exploration of the challenges of launching new AI features quickly while keeping teams and clients aligned.
- 55:54Keeping Pace with AI‑Driven Search Updates
Comparison of traditional algorithm updates to the fast, unpredictable changes brought by AI search engines.
Highlights
- 0:46
AI Overviews Drop Organic Clicksdata
The guest explains that when an AI overview appears, click-through rates for the top organic position drop from roughly 20% to less than 10%, cutting top-ranking traffic in half.
- 12:12
AI Overviews Reach 48 Percentdata
Data from AdTina shows that AI overviews now appear on 48% of commercial search terms in the United States, up dramatically from about 15% earlier in the year.
- 29:14
Unrelated Ads on ChatGPT Promptsinsight
Observable data shows that roughly 10% to 12% of the time on unlogged ChatGPT searches, ads appear for prompts that have no obvious connection to the product.
- 39:44
Ads for Third Parties on X Versus Ydata
The guest points out that when users enter an X versus Y comparison prompt on ChatGPT, an ad for a third competing brand appears 80 to 90% of the time.
- 40:45
Large Advertisers Skipping ChatGPT Adsdata
Despite managing large budgets, over half of AdTina's four hundred large global brand clients have not yet tested ChatGPT ads as of late 2026.
- 41:48
Unexpected Drop From Lower Bidsstory
When a client lowered their max CPC on ChatGPT ads from $10 to $8, the drop in clicks and click-through rate was much larger than a standard proportional decline.
- 1:02:13
AI Overviews Appearing on Brand Searchesinsight
The guest notes a surprising trend where AI overviews are increasingly appearing even when users type direct brand terms into search engines.
Quotes
“When an AI overview peers in search results, the click through rate for the top organic position drops roughly 20% to less than 10%.”
Unnamed speaker · 0:46 “Google's ad revenue, search ad revenue, it goes up double digits every year, every quarter very consistently.”
Unnamed speaker · 9:55 “So we can really end up having a full map of, you know, for any given sector that our clients care about of what's happening, who's winning, who's losing, who's declining, who's going heavy into a new area, who might be exiting an area, which is an opportunity for our clients.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:40 “So I think the industry is going there. I think it should go there.”
Unnamed speaker · 37:29 “I think the synergy between the two is there. I know your focus, right, is on the organic side, but I think you're going to get that more from clients like, hey, I need you talking to the paid side of the, of the house as well.”
Unnamed speaker · 41:43 “And dots and like, that doesn't make sense to me.”
Unnamed speaker · 49:10 “the best thing is that we can build things now really quickly.”
Unnamed speaker · 52:31 “So I think the hardest, I think the hardest thing,”
Unnamed speaker · 52:26 “And we have a new feature, how do we make sure the whole team knows how it works, why it's important, how to talk to our clients about it?”
Unnamed speaker · 53:48 “But even on brand terms, we're seeing an increase in prevalence of AI overviews.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:02:13
Sponsored segments
- I Hear Everything 0:00–0:28
- Previsible 29:52–31:23
About this episode
AI Overviews now appear on 48% of commercial queries. Phillip Thune, CEO of Adthena, supports roughly 400 global brands and tracks 20 million-plus Google searches and 1 million-plus ChatGPT prompts daily. He covers how to diagnose CTR and CPC shifts as AIO suppression versus competitor auction pressure, and how a max CPC cut from $10 to $8 on ChatGPT Ads degraded prompt relevance. He also covers unifying organic and paid visibility to allocate budget by surface, including blocking competitor ads on "X vs. Y" prompts where a third advertiser appears 80-90% of the time. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
11,927 words · 4 speakers
Topics
- AI
- search
- ChatGPT
- ChatGPT ads
- AI overviews
- SEO
- Claude
- Microsoft
- Copilot
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated