Pod Insights Voices of Search // A Search Engine Optimization (SEO) & Content Marketing Podcast G2 data: 1/2 of global software buyers now start search on AI chatbots instead of Google About this episode 79% of global B2B buyers say AI search has changed research habits. Tim Sanders, Chief Innovation Officer at G2, oversees insights from 100+ million annual software buyers and has witnessed enterprise research shift from 29% to 50% starting searches on AI chatbots in just four months. Sanders reveals why buyers moved from "reference to inference" workflows, how G2 captures 60% of AI citations through verified review data, and the critical difference between calendar age versus cognitive age in modern buyer journeys.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 The Voices of Search Podcast is a proud member of the I Hear Everything Podcast Network. Looking to launch or scale your podcast? I Hear Everything delivers podcast production, growth, and monetization solutions that transform your words into profit. Ready to give your brand a voice? Then visit iHearEverything.com. Welcome to the Voices of Search Podcast, a member of the I Hear Everything Podcast Network. Ready to expedite your company's organic growth efforts? Sit back, relax, and get ready for your daily dose of search engine optimization wisdom. Here's today's host of the Voices of Search Podcast, Jordan Cooney.
0:44 Speaker 01 Seventy-nine percent of global B2B buyers say AI search has changed how they conduct research, proving that AI isn't a fringe tool anymore. It's front and center in how B2B buyers research software. That means eight in 10 buyers are using AI to gather, compare, and shortlist vendors before they ever click a traditional search result. But most companies are still optimizing for the old playbook, climbing Google rankings and hoping prospects find them there. Here's a rub. Today's buyers are not starting with search. They're focused on AI chat, and that's the key result in success. So here's the real question. How do you win awareness in a world where buyers discover software through AI and not blue links? I'm Jordan Cooney, and joining me today is Tim Sanders, Chief
1:29 Speaker 01 Innovation Officer at G2, home to one of the largest data sets on real B2B buyer behavior. G2 serves over 100 million software buyers annually and sees firsthand how enterprise research habits are shifting, not gradually, but rapidly. Today, Tim will unpack what G2 data reveals about how buyers are using AI search, why traditional SEO no longer guarantees discovery, and what companies need to do to win in this new era of GEO. Tim, welcome to the Voices of Search Podcast. Glad to be with you, Jordan. Awesome. Super stoked to have this conversation, partly because you have a long history in search, right? I mean, we're in a new era, and this new AEO, GEO, AI search
2:13 Speaker 01 era is certainly consuming most of the headlines. But you've got a lot of history with this. Why don't you tell us a little bit about how you got into search and some of your first experiences in the search world?
2:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I came by, I came by search, kind of honestly, I was an early user, mid 1990s Archie, Gopher, Northern Lights. For those of you my age, that might ring a bell. And then the great disruptor AltaVista, if you remember. I worked with Mark Cuban, his startup in Dallas, Broadcast.com. We were purchased by Yahoo in 1999. I went to Yahoo with the acquisition. And by 2001, I became Yahoo's C S O. And at the time, what I was really overseeing, Jordan, was the absolute disruption of the buyer journey as it went through things like direct mail, Yellow Pages, radio, TV and print.
3:09 Speaker 02 That's the first thing we saw, just get absolutely disrupted by the birth of search, mostly AltaVista became an inflection point for that first wave. And then we started to see digital advertising, which was my point of emphasis, digital advertising, banners, promotions, that kind of thing. Also make a little bit of headway, not a lot when I was there, but a little bit. But you could see the writing on the wall that the buyer journey was going to change and that effective ways of reaching them would change. Now, I was there when Larry and Serge, you know, came to us with their amazing invention out of Stanford, which was PageRank. And a real way to think about solving the keyword stuffing problem
3:54 Speaker 02 that it currently existed, making search a very low quality experience for end users. I remember we had a chance to invest in them. By the way, don't believe the story that we could have bought them for a million. That is not the truth. The truth is, we could have invested in them, we should have invested in them. Why didn't we do it? No one had made any money at search. We thought it'd be better just to hire them as a vendor. But we saw what happened by like 2003, 2004. Google came in with a very simple, elegant, user-focused solution. And they stole share from everybody, including Yahoo. And then over the next 20 years, I have to say, Jordan, I watched the twists and turns of how PageRank evolved, how the rules could change very quickly.
4:35 Speaker 02 But what I tended has been most of my time on as a consultant in my post Yahoo days was focusing on the things that don't change over time, like what are the longstanding practices you can have from a site structure and content standpoint that could create continuity in your search rate, right? So it's like, I do think a lot about what doesn't change so that we as marketers can make plans that are that are durable. I I did also see a lot of short term gamification that didn't work. Google was this really built on the idea of solving for gamification like keyword stuffing. So they've been very agile. However, the other thing I would say
5:18 Speaker 02 is much like everybody else, I became very dependent on Google Analytics and the ability to use databases to look up performance. And that's what's changed with with Answer Engine optimization or generative engine optimization is there is no great database yet to really look it up. You have to propagate it. And so that that presents a whole host of measurement problems, which which are top of mind to me, right?
5:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. That's the beauty of this. Like you've seen this transition and you've seen these these buyer journey transitions in the past. And I think that that's a really critical framing for many of our listeners, largely because the the focal point here is a buyer, right? It's a real person. And and as you're seeing and as you're researching this, I'm curious to know more about how you see enterprise business decision making buyer journeys changing with the introduction of AI search and this whole G E O A E O revolution that's going on.
6:19 Speaker 02 Think about it this way.
6:21 Speaker 02 The and and I have to say, I'm very focused on the B two B software buyer. So a lot of my research is pertinent to that. But I think directionally, it will be consistent for you, even if you're a consumer and not software B two B. From the buyer's standpoint, unless you're in procurement, which is a small percentage of buyers, unless you're in procurement, buying stuff isn't your job. Your job is like producing value and operational excellence and you have to buy stuff along the way. Right? So it's like, it's like I buy office supplies, but office supply buying is not my job. So you have to understand that it's a tax on our time. And what that means is that tools that come along that are faster and make us more productive, we will adopt.
7:03 Speaker 02 And we will especially adopt those if our scope of work is increasing, maybe because we work at a company where they've had reduction enforced. They've had a headcount freeze. We're really getting squeezed to do more with less. So what's happened is the software buyer outside of procurement has moved from reference to inference. Let me unpack that for you.
7:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, please.
7:24 Speaker 02 When you were buying software, it was like you went to the library of sorts. Now, the librarian would never do your job. The best they would do is point you to the stack of cards and point you to the periodicals or point you to certain reference areas for you to go look things up. You still had to do your job. That's Google. Google's the great librarian. And reference meant that you manually went to Google, you entered keywords, you got blue links, you begin to build a spreadsheet. You kind of created a shortlist eventually, and then the shortlist with you and the buying group, if there is one, helped you pick a winner and you bought that vendor. The process of just creating the shortlist from a standing start probably took you between five and 12 hours. That's what our research has seen at G2 over our buyer behavior reports.
8:07 Speaker 02 So it took somewhere between five and 12 hours, kind of painful, and it required many days. So if you looked at like the buyer journey from a calendar standpoint, a lot of that was that front end of all that reference work. Well, now they want to just do inference. What does that mean? Share the goal, share the pain, let AI do all the synthesis and let it do inference now to give you the shortlist. And that's what's changed.
8:31 Speaker 01 I gotta ask you a question on that real quick because I love this and I do agree on this inference point. But like many of these models hallucinate. I mean, the founders, even Sam Altman, you know, stipulates that, hey, 33 to 44% of the time, these models are going to hallucinate and provide something that's inaccurate. So.
8:49 Speaker 02 It's changes. Let me tell you how this works, Jordan. It's like hallucinations are confident errors, which are often the confabulation of data. The number one way to reduce hallucinations is less training or structure of the models and more context that we give the models. So hallucinations have been as much a skills problem on the part of the human as it has been a model problem. Well, I'm gonna walk you through some fun here, okay? I'm gonna go Sheldon Cooper Big Bang Theory on you now. So, you know, in addition to my work at G2, I'm an executive fellow at the Digital Data Design Institute at Harvard, and we geek out on stuff. So let me talk to you a little bit about hallucinations. So, machine hallucinations have been coming down probably 90% a year since 2022,
9:36 Speaker 02 about as fast as the price of intelligence is coming down. So the number of hallucinations is dropping dramatically. As we see new reasoning models, it drops even more because reasoning is iterative and quality prompts can reduce hallucinations by design. So someone who's got a good prompt skill can probably see continued 90% reductions. Hallucinations now, not every year, but every time a new model comes out. So it's reducing dramatically. When Altman said that, if he said it again, he'd probably say 3 to 5%. It really depends on the use case, Jordan. It really does. Right. You know, so that's the issue. So that's the number one thing. The number two thing, though, however, is let's talk about human hallucinations. I remember talking to the president of a very large bank and she said, you know,
10:21 Speaker 02 everybody came to her and said like, but the machines hallucinate. She's like, have you met my people? Right? Humans make confident errors. Now, if you look at academic research around confident errors, like the ability for a person to believe something that's obviously not true. Maybe they were subject to misinformation. Maybe they got duped. Maybe they're having a senior moment. Whatever it is, the human hallucination rate's been relatively stable from World War II.
10:47 Speaker 02 When they started measuring a proxy for it, probably starting in 1955, I think is the first study that looked at like human errors that were persuasive and very much believed by the person, even though they were absolutely untrue. And they weren't lies. It was errors. It was pretty consistent. It didn't really rise or fall. It kind of went up a little bit in the eighties and nineties with improvement in education, but just a little bit. And then after COVID, hallucinations had been on the rise. And then after misinformation from social media and now AI, they're actually rising, not falling. So there's an inflection point coming, Jordan. And it ain't far away. With hallucination rate of a human is going to be statistically higher than a machine and not by a small margin. And so I think
11:31 Speaker 02 hallucination rates is a red herring that a lot of us get duped into is giving us comfort of saying, well, I'm not worried about AI because it's not accurate. My AI is very accurate because I use adversarial AI. So when I run, for example, when I run an audit on a website to see what its AI crawlability issues are, and I get a return, you should see the sophistication of my markdown prompt at this point, based on a lot of iterations of it and then talking to the sources, then they say, no, that's wrong for this reason. And we tune, and we tune, and we tune, get a really good markdown file for that prompt. And then I run it on ChatGPT five extended thinking. And then I take the return and then I go to Gemini three pro and I say, this is your competitors claim, red flag, everything
12:14 Speaker 02 that's not true, we crawl it. And then we use that. My hallucination rate's almost zero on this stuff. So like, like now, when I go to a customer and say, here's our audit results, I feel about 90% of it's right. So, so we can, we, we, I know it's a long answer for you, but don't take comfort in hallucination rates because that, that was a, it's actually turning out to be more of a feature than a bug. It's also the source of great creativity and scientific breakthroughs.
12:40 Speaker 01 So let's bring this back, let's bring this back to buyers and enterprise buyers specifically, or B two B buyers, you know, which, which G two helps here, right? Because if hallucinations is inherently a feature, which, which I definitely agree with you, there's so much that we as humans. Humans need to understand to be great operators of AI. As buyers and decision makers in this journey to make a software or a tool, a product decision that we want to make, how is it that G2 is leveraging AI? Or how are you thinking about leveraging AI to reduce that time? That main pain point that you highlighted earlier, which is the amount of time and energy
13:23 Speaker 01 that this person who typically isn't hired to do the job of buying is now involved in this process?
13:31 Speaker 02 So let me give you an example using a mortgage loan. So think about like if you're a bank and you're approving a jumbo loan, which is not much different than buying a $200,000 a year CRM solution. It's a jumbo loan, high risk. There's probably 17 steps to approve a jumbo loan. Okay, humans used to do all 17. And then with machine learning and RPA, now humans probably do like six of the 17. A lot of the other stuff gets organized. But it didn't quite, maybe not even that many. Maybe they do 10 of the 17 still human. Why? Because RPA and machine learning is brittle. It doesn't apply to all the workflows. And then here comes large language models. They're very dynamic, they're stochastic, they coverage the whole thing. And so now what we're seeing in the world of mortgages,
14:16 Speaker 02 like at the end of the day, only step 17 is a human, where they took all of the machine generated predictions and they passed judgment. And that's the way the world works. It's how software buying is starting to work. So, you know, the users in 2024, they started to use ChatGPT as a way of just avoiding the long Google session to start to get like a granular list together so that they got that spreadsheet like piece done like in an hour or two instead of five hours, which was really like the biggest bottleneck. And then starting in 2025, they just started on ChatGPT. So one of the things we learned, we did an April survey on this and we talked to B2B software buyers and a really good enterprise sample size.
14:58 Speaker 02 And 87% said that AI search defined as a chatbot, not AI overviews.
15:05 Speaker 02 A chatbot. Eighty-seven percent says change the way I do researching. Twenty-nine percent said I start on the chatbot instead of Google now. We were like, wow, that's a big number. And then we did the survey again, August 29th, same, same end, same question, fifty percent. So, so there's a move that started, but what we're seeing is that they no longer use keywords, they do best of prompts. I want you to give me the best three CRM solutions for a medium independent hospital that will have an endpoint on mobile devices because they have a particular use case need. And they're one-shotting the shortlist. So they're taking the hour and making it minutes. And then that way, the
15:48 Speaker 02 human being might then use the chatbot. We've learned that they use it a lot to develop verification work for them. That's where G2 is getting all of our traffic. Because we just kind of confidential, confidentially, I'm on a podcast, Radix reports that sixty percent of the citations that come to G2 are coming from our best of guides. That's the best of software awards, all the listicles, all the grids, all of that stuff. Why? Because it prompt matches. Because the users are asking, give me the best three. And our best of guides win out over blogger best of guides because our best of guides are based on thousands and thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of customer reviews, and they're
16:30 Speaker 02 all verified. We require screenshots that you own the software. We have your LinkedIn profile. We know you're a real person. We really pulled away from Reddit because of that, after the entity update, which we can come back and talk about, which changed everything. So for us, we found a way to be part of the verification layer work the models do. Because the models now separate training, research teams based on use cases that connect with their business model. So when you look at OpenAI, Jordan, 2027, 2028, it's going to be clear as a bell that their top two sources of revenue are ads and shopping.
17:12 Speaker 02 That's it. They're not going to try to win the API token business for developers. You're going to build a big shitty business if you do that with low margins. Their multiple has to be like NUTUP meets Amazon for them to grow into their fundraising valuations. Why is this important? Because if shopping is going to be one of the top two revenue streams, then they peel off teams that just focus on returns that give purchase recommendations. And the dominant methodology they use for tuning for that is to avoid regrettable purchases. Now, for some of the listeners here, regrettable, I've heard about this before. Yes, you have. Facebook's turnaround came from an initiative Zuckerberg led. He got a really great set of insights from some experts
17:56 Speaker 02 that regrettable minutes on Facebook or any platform, Instagram, you name it, regrettable minutes are the number one signal of platform deterioration. So if you reduce regrettable minutes, you get more loyalty. Same occurs in the labs at places like OpenAI and Gemini. They want to avoid regrettable purchases because regrettable purchases will either create switching or reversion. They want this to be a one-way door. Once you start using ChatGPT to buy stuff, you never stop. That's why really important to them. What does this mean? They've changed the criteria by which they recommend a product. Those are called commercial citations. It's a different ballgame than background citations. When you're just asking it to give you the history of something that is really low risk,
18:38 Speaker 02 that is a different, it's an entirely set of different neural network activities. So anyway, long answer, but G2 is really dialing into that and how we can win the verification layer work.
18:51 Speaker 01 I mean, I want to come back to this whole shopping and buying experience in ChatGPT or AI in general. You know, we're recording just about a week after, you know, ChatGPT's announcement of ads and starting to pilot ads. So that's very exciting. But I want to come back to something that you mentioned earlier, which is G2 and citations. That G2 is one of the most prominent, visible cited resources when it comes to these B2B buying decisions.
19:20 Speaker 02 Almost 7%. A B to B citations. Yeah.
19:22 Speaker 01 Yeah. And this is, this is, this is, I think, a remarkable component because clearly there's a trust factor with G2.
19:29 Speaker 02 Right.
19:29 Speaker 01 And clearly that has been a signal that you guys have built and you shared this already through, through years of verification, process, trust with buyers. Here's my, here's my rub question, which is, I think, the, the, the major challenge that a lot of brands and businesses have in this, this AI discovery world, which is, if you're giving that information to an AI model, if you're building these guides, as you referenced, and they're citing and sourcing these, what's the purpose of G2? Why would a user ever really engage on G2 when I get all the information right in an LLM response?
20:08 Speaker 02 Well, you get the information, you just still need to verify the commercial citation. So let me give you this. So here's a way to think about it. We're going to have, well, we had a million human visitors from large language models in 2025. It's a big number. It's a huge number. Okay. And it was X higher than 2024 and it'll be X higher in 2026. Why is this the case? Not all citations are the same when it comes to traffic and click through. They're not the same.
20:36 Speaker 01 They're not.
20:37 Speaker 02 So common knowledge would say that a background citation, that's everything but the buy these three CRMs part of a return. Everything else is background citation. You don't have to verify it as a user because there's no risk. We've learned to trust it. We believe it. That's why the click through for our background citation is probably one quarter of 1%. Maybe a third of a percent of perplexity, which is not a player as much as they used to be. But it's a quarter of 1%. You're not going to see any meaningful traffic. Early research, and we're going to do real research on it this year. Early research on commercial citations, like these are the three CRMs you should buy and the citation for the three CRMs is G2 profile. That's the citations we get. Okay? That click through rate is somewhere between three and 15% depending on the price tag, the risk factor,
21:22 Speaker 02 and the nature of the user's distrust or trust in the model. So the answer is, they get everything they need from the model except verification layer. They click on the citation to get verification layer. That's why software review sites are a close second to AI chat for everything from creating the shortlist to making the final decision. So the user's trust with verify and that's what's making us part of the game. I think that. For freemium type software, they may directly then make a purchase. What you also have to understand is important here is that many returns, I mean, many like the majority of returns for a purchase recommendation don't link to the vendor unless the vendor's in the shopping deal with OpenAI. They'll link to the proof point, the review site, the gardener report, the blogger.
22:07 Speaker 02 Because again, they're trying to avoid a regrettable purchase and they want to make sure that you are satisfied with your purchase. So a lot of times what we're seeing is we get the traffic that the vendor used to get an organic search. And so, but the traffic that comes to us from language models is much higher conviction. They're much better down the cognitive process. So then if they come to a software vendor's profile on G2 out of that that environment to read the reviews. And then they click to go to the software vendor, the vendors are telling us much higher closing rate, much higher quality of traffic. So, so anyway, that's the long and the short of it is that the the user doesn't trust enough to then stop the session.
22:49 Speaker 02 Go to the trouble of looking up the vendor's site and contact and the salespeople, they still do some verification work and click through on that piece of the puzzle. And the other thing too, I'm going to add is that G2 is beginning to add, in addition to reviews, we're going to be adding more and more benchmark data. That actually measures things like hallucination rates and tool call reliability and other such technical metrics for agents. And because agents is a fast growing category, so we're seeing that that layer is going to be really important as well for the verification where models are going to love benchmarks. They already do when they recommend different AI solutions.
23:25 Speaker 01 So, so I mean, I love this, this, this frame of thinking, especially in how a user or a buyer is using this trust and verify process through, through a model and a response. We, here at Previsible, we did a study of 2 million LLM sessions, breaking them down by category, what ended up happening, how many events that triggered. And I think one of the most remarkable findings of that is the ratio of events to, to, to clicks. So when User does go and click, they have a much higher degree of activity on the site, whether it's signing up for newsletter, not always buying, right? I think we're always thinking about the final conclusion, but there's many sequences in between there.
24:10 Speaker 01 And I want to come back to that because this event and these events, I think are the verification that the trust is there, right? There's a reason why I'm going to follow that brand, or I'm going to download the report, or to your point on this benchmark piece, then I'm going to pull down that benchmark, I'm going to save it and I'm going to use that as a reference point as I continue my journey of making this buying decision. So I want to talk more about events and how G2 is a part of that event sequence in that citation that they were discovered in, in an LLM.
24:44 Speaker 03 Time for a one-minute break to hear from our sponsor, Previsible. So you're looking for SEO help? Then you've got a couple of options. You could start replying to spam from agencies that claim they can get you to rank number one on Google. You can pay an hourly rate for a consultant who will inevitably nickel and dime you with hourly charges. Or you can work with a cookie cutter agency to quickly launch a strategy-less project with low success rate. None of those sound very good, now do they? Well, that's where Previsible's integrated consulting model comes in. Previsible draws from a collective 40 years of SEO and digital marketing experience to unlock your organic growth opportunities. They build custom solutions that combine strategy, technical expertise, content and reporting to effectively operationalize SEO for your business.
25:30 Speaker 03 Previsible's four-stage approach ensures that your SEO programs thrive by starting off with a strategy-first approach. Then they support you in your efforts to create quality content, help you identify technical issues, and most importantly, they'll work with your cross-functional teams to integrate your SEO strategies to make sure that your SEO budget actually drives results, not just your agency's bottom line. So join brands like Yelp, eBay, Canva, Atlassian, Square, all who rely on the SEO consultants at Previsible. For more information, go to previsible.io. That's previsible, P-R-E-V-I-S-I-B-L-E dot I-O.
26:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, and I was fascinating. And so let's think about it this way. I'm sure if you've ever seen the Brian Johnston Don't Die document, or you follow any of this stuff, you hear people talking about the difference between a biological age and a calendar age. A calendar age is like, you know, I'm whatever years old based on the calendar biological age is I'm whatever years old based on like my bio statistics, right? So those aren't always the same. One of the ways to think about the buyer journey is
26:39 Speaker 02 research indicates that when the buyer comes to you as a software seller, they're coming to you earlier from a calendar standpoint, earlier in the process. But from a cognitive standpoint, they're much further along. So it used to be because of how long it took to like do the Google Blue link hell and then build the shortlist to have the meetings and arrive at the three and then actually go contact the three. That might've been like a 13 day process, but now it's a three day process. So three days in, they're talking to the vendor, but they're 90% through the funnel, meaning they've already got a shortlist. They've already got a rubric for how they're going to decide and they're just trying to do some tie breaking. That's what we see when you think about it then. So that person is not, they're fresher.
27:23 Speaker 02 So they haven't started to experience fatigue. So they are going to respond more to novel offers that may not necessarily be part of verification work. So what makes all the sense in the world that you're seeing them signing up for webinars and newsletters? Because they're fresher in the process and have more bandwidth to give it. They're actually still curious. So like, like nothing kills curiosity like time. So when you're further along in a calendar basis in a buying cycle, by the time you get to the vendor, you're like, damn it, just give me the contact information. At this point, I'm so tired of the subject. So I think that's a fascinating thing to think about is the difference between when buyer journey, calendar age versus cognitive age, because we do know that if you're using the model for synthesis, you're just much further along cognitively.
28:06 Speaker 02 And that doesn't mean you're set in your ways, but it does mean you're just much further along in developing an interest and an understanding deeply of that, of that purchase activity that you're in.
28:17 Speaker 01 This is, this is a really a critical piece of advice here, Tim. Largely because it's, it's not very well documented. How we think about users or buyers.
28:31 Speaker 02 Writing.
28:31 Speaker 01 And how we target them. We, we, we bucket these, these individuals in audiences or personas. Right? But when we really think about where they're at in that phase of the decision making. This, this, you know, this biological versus calendar perspective of where they're at in that buying journey. It can largely predicate how we think about our content strategies, what the messaging should be, how we build our webpages and our experiences. And then right where we should be targeting them. So let's talk about these strategies and let's dive into like, what are you seeing working? How are you understanding how brands are being successful in reaching consumers through AI discovery? What are some of the maybe tactics?
29:16 Speaker 01 You mentioned one of them earlier that G2 is leveraging to bring users into their journey to help them better be informed about B2B buying decisions.
29:26 Speaker 02 So when you think about what makes a model really effective, it's weights. I mean, that's the secret. Secret to ChatGPT five two is its weights. That's the secret to Gemini three. Whenever you look at model performances, they have their weights, you know, how, how inference is influenced by weights, which the humans determine based on all the data. That's the secret sauce. Okay. That's the secret sauce for marketers. How do you weigh traffic? What weights do you put in to your activities based on the source of traffic? So there's a sophistication we have to have now, almost like a model. And how we assign weights based on where the traffic came from and our, our inference about how far along they are in the process. Because of what we're really going to understand is not all traffic is equal.
30:11 Speaker 02 That's why, you know, when I see similar web and other stuff that's trying to measure ChatGPT's influence based on traffic, I go, are you kidding me? No, that, that's not measuring its influence. Right? So I think, I think that we have to make sure that we don't have a monolithic view. You of traffic. I mean, let's go back G two. Our traffic went down last year for not money citation work like content. Like the content that we produce in the category page top level. It's like we all suffered traffic and we turned it around. Can tell you in a minute, we're actually going to have more traffic now this year than we did last year. That's amazing for us. That's like was a major thing to figure out. We figured out a few ways to do it. Most of that traffic recovery is not only going to come from from from chat GPT and Gemini.
30:53 Speaker 02 It's going to be higher quality traffic for our buyers, but we figured that out and we can talk about that at a granular level, but weights are everything. Let me give you like another like neuro spicy piece of advice that'll really help the folks here.
31:07 Speaker 02 If you run an audit for AI crawlability on your site, yeah, it's going to come back and say you're blocking this. You're slowing down that and you've probably already done that. What you what you might be surprised is it's going to come back and say, hey, these gated reports are keeping the models from into our from models from crawling and then referring back to your reports outside of deep research sessions. And this is increasingly true because five point two and Gemini three, I'm afraid of chat GPT and Gemini. They've become kind of compute stingy. Now, I know they want to avoid a regrettable purchase. Now that they do index up by giving more compute to an enterprise user than a consumer user. But if you're coming in on chat GPT free, you get very little compute and they looking at PDFs on a vendor's website.
31:53 Speaker 02 No. Okay, but you say, no, we gated it. We made it a PDF for these reasons. We gated it for lead gen. We made it a PDF because the PDF it just goes viral inside an organization by email. What you have to do now is start to use the concept of expected value. Now, when you make fundamental marketing decisions. So let me let me reach back. This is not a background. This is my bookshelf.
32:17 Speaker 02 Okay, folks, I apologize. It's a thick book. It is a great book. If you haven't read this book, and I make no affiliate, it's a joke for the listeners, I make no affiliate, affiliate link in the show notes. Called On the Edge by Nate Silver, natesilver538.com, super forecasting, also the guy that went to the final table at World Series of Poker earlier in his career by using EV. On the Edge is about having an edge in every decision by using expected value calculations to take the emotions or the obsolescence out of a decision. So, so I've been working with marketers that say, okay, we need to run the EV on a gate and look at the expected value of the leads versus the expected value of AI visibility and make a better decision. So what's going on in
33:00 Speaker 02 a lot of organizations is maybe they've got a lot of JavaScript, JSON, JavaScript required rendering pages, terrible for AI credibility, but you're gonna have to spend calories to fix that and refactor those pages. You're gonna run EV on whether it's worth it. You might have, I mentioned before, PDFs that need to be republished in HTML or even better markdown. We've been doing that a lot at G2 across pages and seeing amazing AI visibility, chat GPT traffic come from that. All of that takes calories and expenses to do. You don't just do it because AEO is hot, you do it because the EV runs positive to do that. The expected value is actually greater than the cost. So I think more than ever, we need to become masters at EV. But here's the good news,
33:44 Speaker 02 folks. ChatGPT and Gemini are great at doing low hallucination EV work if you give it the right context.
33:53 Speaker 01 How frequently, in this world where we're making these EV decisions, right, and we're trying to become incredibly targeted to certain buyers and users at a phase in their journey, how are we, how are you thinking about the outcome metrics, the actual metrics that happen post the evaluation period? So let's say you guys run this campaign of building all these benchmark studies, you're gonna see that there's a value that There's an expected value that you're calculating that is something you want. But then there's this post regression of like, hey, did this actually do what I wanted it to do? How frequently do you think marketers need to be doing this?
34:38 Speaker 01 And at what variable are you making these kinds of changes? In what is largely a decision making process that maybe only happens once a year, or maybe once every few years when it comes to B to B buying?
34:51 Speaker 02 That's a great question. I'm going to go off on a limb here and talk a little bit about Toyota Lane and the great recalibration of how often they recalibrated machines inside manufacturing. So this goes back to like, gosh, the 1970s. Believe it or not, at Toyota, a high number of brakes didn't match. And so they had to do a lot of rework and it was a source of great quality. And what they found out was by using the five whys, which is a great technique to get to the root cause of a problem. They kind of got to the bottom of it and that was there's a recalibration you do in a factory in the laves. And you recalibrate it back to specification. And what happens is like, if the recalibration period's too long,
35:34 Speaker 02 then it starts to kind of drift a little bit and all of a sudden the brakes don't match. But the question was, do we recalibrate every day, every week, every month, every quarter? And that's where the statistical analysis was. Well, it depends on how fast the laves really moves. What they had to kind of get to is what's the rate of movement of these machines to vary from specification? And once they knew the rate of movement, they're like, oh, great. We only have to do it every two weeks. They would have dramatically overspent if they did it daily. They would have undershot the Six Sigma quality goals. It wasn't called Six Sigma at the time, if they did it every two or three months. So the big takeaway, because I used to work for Dr. Edward Deming. So I was like part of this whole Six Sigma movement. The takeaway from all that is that what you have to understand is like how fast the variables are moving. Because once you get an understanding of the variable moving speed,
36:19 Speaker 02 then you understand what the recalibration requirement is. Same works now for marketing. How quickly is your market adjusting? So let's go back to the benchmarks question. The reason G2 started the benchmarks is because our research, starting in 2024, led us to believe that as AI moved from Experiment to sustainable, think of it like Wi-Fi and electricity in an organization. It would transfer from being a business buyer like SaaS to becoming a central IT buyer like pre-SaaS. And that's what we saw coming. And so in 2025, the number jumped where it looked like about 50% of all AI purchases were originating out of central IT who is now writing the spec.
37:01 Speaker 02 And then our latest survey in August showed like 70% of all agents, their economic buyer is going to be IT. The business buyer is going to be their internal customer. So I went out and did over 40 interviews of IT leaders over the very short period of time to gather insights. And so we saw, oh my God, within a few years, the machines are moving to the point where MPS signals like reviews may not be sufficient for trust and verification layer work, because all of our interviews revealed that central IT cared less about MPS signals like ease of use or stated ROI, which they think is not an answerable question or customer satisfaction. That shit doesn't matter. Here's what matters.
37:43 Speaker 02 The benchmark for hallucination, the benchmark for tool call reliability, the benchmark for containment rate. That stuff matters to us. And we knew this because they spent all their time on like SEAL leaderboards or L M Arena. So we begin to see that movement. Well, the good news is that this is not going to go back and forth. Like the business isn't going to take back buying software next year. So it looks like the machines are moving rather slowly. So for us, I would suspect the cadence every measuring that might be annual or at the most every six months. No, that's not the case for every business. Some businesses are seeing really fast moving situations, like I think a great example CRM. CRM is a super dynamic space right now. And so as a result, the machines may be moving every quarter.
38:26 Speaker 02 So anyway, the long answer here is you have to really have your finger on the pulse of how quickly buyer mores and criteria are shifting and calibrated accordingly.
38:38 Speaker 01 I you brought up something in there that that really, I mean, a lot of that resonated, by the way, and but one of those components that that I want to glean out for our listeners is the value of a review. And there's a there's a lot shifting underneath us in this concept. And I think that over the past year, looking at 2025, the value of a review dramatically rose, right? As LLMs and
39:04 Speaker 02 Especially your recent review. We can talk about that in a minute. But review recency in particular has risen a lot because it reflects because the models value recent reviews because they reflect the latest capabilities.
39:16 Speaker 01 No question. And I and I fully agree. Recency, quality signals, like what you were talking about, like verified or trusted types of reviews.
39:26 Speaker 02 Token length of the review. I'll share some inside baseball. Token length matters. Yeah. Like, like a longer review that shares more detail that might share what the trepidations were going in, how they were that feels more like a story with an arc is going to sync better with the weights of both OpenAI and and Google DeepMind better, too. Yeah, so that's interesting. And we've we've been moving to a we bought a company last year called Unsurvey, and they have that interviewing process where the AI interviews a person, it can get a much richer conversation much more quickly. And then we turned on voice where you can just say the thing. And it's dramatically, I can't tell you how much, but
40:09 Speaker 02 it's a lot, increase the tokens inside the reviews and creative reviews that feel more like storytelling than blurbs, like the back of a book, like five, you know, buy this book, it's great. We wanted to get away from that because the models don't value that as much.
40:23 Speaker 01 And I love this because this is, I think, one of the big crossroads that we're facing in 2026, which is there is review, review frequency, and review value. But we're also quickly moving and shifting because these models are ingesting far more data and information that also contains valuable insights. You know, things like podcasts, what we're doing right now, video and video information about products and tutorials. And so this whole multimedia component is being layered on top of these review stacks. And I want to get your perspective in terms of where the future is going there.
41:03 Speaker 02 Okay, so. If you look at the chart for B to B, just look at B to B software queries and you see G2 leads by a mile, but you know, right behind that is YouTube. You wow, YouTube is a source. Why?
41:16 Speaker 01 Yes.
41:16 Speaker 02 First of all, um, many YouTube videos have a transcript. It's very important for OpenAI, for ChatGPT, that you have a transcript. ChatGPT, they're not going to watch your video. Gemini might. ChatGPT is not gonna, ChatGPT is gonna read the transcript. But the reason video is so compelling, Jordan, is that it becomes a forcing function for marketers to create answer-shaped, natural language content as opposed to message-shaped corporate-shaped content. Okay. So when we're creating landing pages, we have a messaging approach, problem, solutions, feature, benefits proof. But when we're writing an FAQ, we have compelling question, answer. Think about our conversation today. Think about the average video you might make
41:58 Speaker 02 with a customer. It's very much Q and A. So it creates that very answer-shaped content the models prefer in verification work. They're actually trained to understand that better. It also fits better within their allergy to corporate vendor messaging that might create a regrettable purchase. So I love YouTube video because you can't make corporate messaging out of one of these conversations. We're just talking to each other. You can't push me back to say the thing like your marketing team wants to always say the thing that the models are like. They're just trying to say the thing. So YouTube and podcasts are a forcing function for you to do what I consider one of the most three important things you
42:39 Speaker 02 do to win in AI search world. And that is to refactor content to be answer-shaped instead of message-shaped and to incorporate more natural language in, in what the models see when they come to you.
42:51 Speaker 01 Love this. I, I wanna, I wanna bring up one.
42:53 Speaker 02 But you have to produce the transcript. Make sure the transcript is visible to the bot or you've missed it completely.
42:59 Speaker 01 I mean, accessibility as a whole is one of the major. Trends and challenges that I think all of these models are going to have and in a landscape now where it's not a single monopoly, right? It's not just Google and Gemini, but it's going to be multi-pronged to some extent, right? It's going to be ChatGPT and Google in some instances. I do think there's probably buyer journey instances where Claude is going to be very heavily influenced as a part of it, right? Yeah, and so they're
43:26 Speaker 02 Five percent. Copilot, don't sleep on Copilot. Enterprise buyers, they get guardrails. All they have is Copilot chat and they're enterprise buyers. And I wouldn't sleep on it now. And I think of Copilot like from a fashion standpoint to Canadian version of ChatGPT, Canada always gets it, just like, you know, 18 months later. So even though Copilot is not as rich in inference as getting 5.2 GPT, it's close. So a lot of the things you figure out for ChatGPT will help you in Copilot. But I tell AEO and SEO marketers all the time, like, if you're enterprise and you sell to enterprise people, then you need to treat Copilot like an analyst. It may not be Gartner, it may not be Forrester. Okay, it's IDC.
44:10 Speaker 02 Treat it like an analyst, respect it, study it, understand how it lives and breathes.
44:15 Speaker 01 Yep, 100%. I have to, I have to close out our, our, our main part of our episode with this major question because I, I fundamentally think it's something that every traditional SEO, the new aspiring GEO, AEO marketers are all thinking about and trying to understand. And that is that when you think about these tactics and you think about whether it's how you influence reviews, how you increase your visibility, say, in, in video or video testimonials, there, there's this habit as humans to be like water and find the path of least resistance. And we, we try to go into the game of, of, of thinking of
44:59 Speaker 01 in the frame of mind of how do we manipulate these communities? How do we influence them and, and change their perspective? How do we get our, our brand positioned in a way that, that, that oftentimes Is not genuine, or is not factual, or is not real to the experience of the product or software. And we're seeing that now with the influence on Reddit and how much people are trying to gamify or change Reddit threads and communities. I'm sure G2 has strict policies on this and verification, as you mentioned earlier, of not just the reviews, but the content.
45:38 Speaker 01 As we think about this year ahead, how do we think about really creating genuine campaigns and efforts that reflect what human buyers want?
45:49 Speaker 02 Well, I'm gonna make another book recommendation here, too.
45:54 Speaker 02 So Seth Godin wrote this great book a couple of years ago called This is Marketing. And he said, "Best marketing message you can ever have is the following: People like you do this." So I think that what hasn't changed, Jordan, is the fundamentals still matter. And if you market from a place of empathy, that what you're trying to do is help the right buyer find the right product and never regret the purchase, and you make that your North Star, you're aligning with something that will probably be as enduring, especially in the purchase recommendation use case, as Larry Page's PageRank system, which to this day is still influential, right?
46:39 Speaker 02 So this kind of gets to, I wanted to make sure and point this out, too, is like, SEO has never been more important, because real-time research still relies on ranking to some extent outside of deep research. The fundamentals of SEO are transferring to success in AEO to a large degree, and certainly enough for us to continue to value it. We're treating AEO as a new swim lane, not a replacement. So I want to make that point. And so this idea of originating from a place of empathy has never been more important. Here's what's happening, though. You won't be banned from all the large language models like you can be banned from Google. That's the good news.
47:23 Speaker 02 The bad news is the latency between finding a hole in the system and it getting closed is shortening a lot. Like with Google, I saw things that occurred where these content click farms had like two years of unfettered success and then Google makes a change and they die. It ain't gonna be no two years. It's one model to the next. Because regrettable purchases are super easy to verify. For those of you listening, go Google the concept of verifier's law. Verifier's law says anything that's easy to verify will be conquered by AI.
47:58 Speaker 01 Love it.
47:59 Speaker 02 The regrettable purchases, easy to verify, just tell the truth. If you work at a company that offers a crappy service, find a new job.
48:08 Speaker 01 All right, love this. We're going to transition now to our lightning round. I'm going to ask you five questions from the topics that we discussed today. Quick response in about 30 seconds to a minute on each, all right?
48:19 Speaker 02 Tough for me, here we go.
48:20 Speaker 01 All right, here we go. What's the one buyer insight from G2's data set that most surprises marketing teams?
48:29 Speaker 02 The executives no longer drive the purchase of artificial intelligence because they've moved on to transformation and adoption. So focus on the CEO may be a miss. You may want to focus on the grunts in central IT.
48:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, man, knowing that audience.
48:47 Speaker 01 If you could change one common B2B go to market assumption about the whole new AI discovery world, what would that be?
48:56 Speaker 02 That keywords are the same thing as prompts.
48:59 Speaker 01 Oh, tell me more, tell me more, that is so powerful.
49:01 Speaker 02 Huge prompt problem, right? So, so, so, so the, the use of keywords will no longer be a reflection of how people in an answer engine environment prompt AI. And, and if you go to providers like Scrunge, who actually have panel data, people's prompts, you'll see such misalignment between like how a person asks for a solution. Like, like, we'll give you an example. Recently I adopted Willow Voice. It's, um, it's what the cool kids call voice keyboards. So I just click function, I say the thing, it's perfectly structured, it goes out, I don't type, I'm three times more productive. It's bigger for me than ChatGPT. But when we talk to one of their big competitors, the competitor is like, nope, we call it AI voice dictation and they just stick with it.
49:46 Speaker 02 And then they go in and they look at dictation and buy all the keywords and everything. And then we go get the prompt data and everybody in the ICP, which would be all the IT people that would lead to all the adoption across the enterprise, they strictly call it voice keyboard. So there was a tremendous misalignment. By the way, all the voice IT, all the IT cool kids, they never use Google. So you're not going to see it in AdWords in the keyword research. You're going to miss it. So the problem is like, all the early adopters have moved to chat GPT and they find their own way of talking about a thing in the prompt world that may not show up in the keyword word. If you rely too much on keywords and AEO, you're going to miss the mark. And worst of all, you're going to create false positives where because you're using the way you talk about it and the keywords you're focused on, you're going to think you're doing better than you are on your share.
50:30 Speaker 02 Because of course you're going to win that which you engineer for. So that's one thing I'd like to change.
50:35 Speaker 01 Love it, love it. Does AI visibility ever hurt a brand's conversion funnel? And if so, how?
50:44 Speaker 02 I don't think so. I don't think so. I don't think that AI visibility is going to make you less credible. I don't think coming back as one of the three recommended CRMs is going to hurt anything. Now, if someone else in that company is already in flight, it's just another verification signal for the humans internally. So I don't think there's, and I've heard about this before, especially from the vaunted guards of the old way. No, the answer is the fact that chat GPT recommends something is not going to cause info security to say, well, it must suck. Now, that being said, the way we talk about using AI can be bad. In other words, if a person says, I put together all my purchase recommendations with chat GPT, there is research that might indicate people around the table are going to roll their eyes and say lazy. It's slop.
51:28 Speaker 02 So, so there is the risk that the way we represent the AI research can cause it to be perceived as slop and discounted, especially by those that are in my category of boomer age, but that's more of a skills issue about how you talk about it. I'm rather transparent in how I use chat GPT. I'm responsible for my work. I've checked for hallucinations, but I never leave with, ah, just plug it into chat GPT because I know what the old folks think about that.
51:53 Speaker 01 Yeah. All right, we got two more here. What's the most underrated signal that enterprise brands should optimize for in AI responses?
52:03 Speaker 02 I think, and it's not so much of a signal, but it's a signal to the bots. I think that markdown language,
52:14 Speaker 02 key find, key takeaways from a page that are placed at the very top of the page, are going to create the most crawling and reference and training inclusion of your webpages than anything. So when you think about a really, and I'm talking about sales pages, I'm talking about product pages. So a small markdown file with the key four takeaways will dramatically improve the chances that your content is considered during test time.
52:42 Speaker 01 One that I think we didn't really talk about much, but is pricing pages. It's so complicated for, for, for business buyers and you're like, well, I don't know what this is. And how do I measure the cost of this in my team?
52:54 Speaker 02 Sometimes, sometimes the opaqueness of pricing gives the leverage to the seller. But you need to run EV because you have to now account for the fact that it creates confusion for the model. So this is another classic example of where expected value might like liberate you from like, no, no, no, no. Read the book. Never, what is that called? Never Split the Difference by Chris Boss. Like we've got to use negotiation tactics, maybe not.
53:16 Speaker 01 Yeah. Love that. All right. Last one here. If you could add one new media form to be more visible in AI platforms, what would it be?
53:25 Speaker 02 It would be video with transcripts for videos.
53:28 Speaker 01 Okay. And tell, tell me why? What, what, what makes transcripts for videos so valuable?
53:32 Speaker 02 Their answer shaped their natural language, they're human, they are perceived as real, and they match the, the, the language training for most models that goes back to the beginning of a model. So it's deep set.
53:44 Speaker 01 Awesome.
53:44 Speaker 02 It, it helps you get out of your own way as a corporate marketer.
53:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely.
53:50 Speaker 02 Right? Like, like who corrects a transcript layer to make it feel more consistent with our corporate brand bible? No one. That's why the models love it.
53:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's great. Okay, and that wraps up this episode of the Voices of Search podcast. Huge thank you to Tim Sanders, Chief Innovation Officer at G2 for joining us. If you'd like to contact him, you can find a link to his LinkedIn profile in our show notes, or you can find it on voicesofsearch.com. You can also visit his personal website, tim sanders.com. If you haven't subscribed yet, or would like a daily stream of SEO and content marketing knowledge in your podcast feed, hit the subscribe button in your podcast app or on YouTube, and we'll be in your feed next week. Okay, that's all for today, but until next time, remember, the answers are always in the data.
Previous Optimizing for Google vs AI search Next One buyer insight from G2’s dataset that most surprises marketing teams Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated