Vision Pros Live Podcast
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
What's your vision? Featuring Stanley Fish. Podcast Session 1.
2,587 words · 3 speakers
Wow, and it's that's so interesting. You said you've been teaching for sixty plus years.
Ah, yes.
And you have written your first book, so I'm going.
No, no, this is book number twenty-two.
What?
Yeah.
Book number twenty-two. Yeah, talk to me.
If you live this, if you live this long, uh, you do a lot of work. You have twenty-two books.
Okay.
Some of them, some of them on, uh, English literature, some of them on legal, uh, legal matters, and a few of them on higher education, uh, and how higher, higher education works.
Uh, and especially how, uh, free speech and academic freedom operate, or should operate, on college campuses.
Yeah, okay. Wow. And I know that that was something we had spoken about recently.
Freedom of speech and, and considering in five days you'll be starting classes and everything will be intact. Tell me more about that.
Well, my position is simply that there is no freedom of speech, uh, on college campuses, and there shouldn't be. Uh, that is, if you take the phrase academic freedom, and you forget about the word freedom, or at least don't emphasize the word freedom, uh, which is such, uh, you know, such a powerful word, word in our culture, and realize that academic is an adjective which tells you what kind of freedom is being either asserted or defended here. And the answer is academic freedom. Then you ask the question, what is academic freedom? And the answer is academic freedom is the freedom to do the academic job,
which means that if you're a teacher, what you're free to do is follow the syllabus that you and your department. Have legitimated. You are not free as a teacher to go outside the syllabus and start talking to your students about your personal views, whether they be political or economic or anything else. So there's no freedom on the part of the instructor, who must follow the evidence of the material that he or she is teaching and not introduce extraneous matters. Because once you start pronouncing, or as we sometimes say, bloviating, and sending your views out to the students,
no, you're no longer a teacher. You're a political agent, some kind of polemicist. But the students themselves also, at least in my understanding, have very little, if any, freedom. Because their freedom is the freedom to go along with the instructor's questions and to interrogate the materials of the class. The student is not free to choose those materials or to complain about the teacher's methods. The student is in an apprentice position. Remember, the student is being educated and is therefore not the educator. And then this also extends to university administrators,
who should not be using their microphones as university administrators to pronounce on political or social matters in the world as if simply because they had an advanced degree, they had general wisdom on every subject under the sun. So my message is always to academics, stick to your knitting. Do what you've been trained and paid to do. And don't make the mistake of thinking that you're a wise person. If you're any good, you're a competent person. That is, you know your job and you know how to do it.
So I think the word freedom is unfortunate when it's used in the phrase academic freedom, because it suggests to people something wide open, that people can say whatever they like. And as far as I'm concerned, in the academy, what you say has to be dictated by your subject matter. And if you do something else, you're not doing your job. How about that?
Yeah, how about that, Dr. Fish? I, I totally am hearing what you're saying. And as a previous college student myself, it's, it's, um, it's very interesting to hear you talk about how they go off the syllabus and go into things that they're actually not supposed to be teaching.
Yeah, let's say I'm, let's say I'm, let's say I'm teaching a course on American political theory since World War II.
And I'm surveying all of the things that have happened and all the various movements that we've, that we've gone through. At the end of the semester, my students should not have the slightest idea of what my own political beliefs are. Because that's not the purpose of a class, to introduce them to my beliefs. They should have an idea, if I've been any good at what I'm doing, in telling me what the primary political movements of the last forty or fifty years have been. And I think that's, again, what I mean by stick to your knitting. Do your, I have a three-part mantra. A, do your job.
B, don't try to do someone else's job. You know, the job of a preacher or of a psychoanalyst or something. And C, don't let anyone else do your job. Don't let governors, legislators, donors, or even parents into your classroom. Keep your classroom academic. And at the end of the course, your students will have learned something. But what they won't have learned is what you personal believe, personally believe, because that's not part of the package.
Wow, you know, that's a, it's, this is a really good conversation to have via, you know, on a podcast because it is often believed that teachers are, are definitely inputting their personal uh opinions, whether it be about politics or the, whatever topic they're teaching on. So I do have the question of wondering, what are, what is the, where's the line between free speech and responsible?
You know, and just in, in regards to all of this, where is, is there a line?
Well, certainly there's a line in the academy, that is, in, in, in the academic world. And, and I've already see, uh, I think indicated where it's, it's drawn. You're free to speak on matters uh that are related to the course and the materials. Otherwise, you're not free. But freedom of speech in the, in, in our democratic society is quite a different thing. Because the assumption there is, the more voices, the better. And the more people who are participating in the fashioning of our laws, the better. So there you want everyone to be able to have a megaphone, although really only the richest
of people have the largest megaphones. But you want, you want at least theoretically the possibility of every citizen who has an opinion to be able to voice that opinion and perhaps influence the course of political affairs. Now, if that were the rule in the academic world, it would be a disaster.
An instructor would never get past the first five minutes of the first day of class because he or she would have to listen to every silly opinion every student in the classroom had.
Now, in the, again, political, in the political context, we should listen to everyone's opinions, even the ones that we might think were silly. Because that kind of what we might call universal participation in the process is what goes on in a democracy. It's not got, it's not what goes on in a college classroom.
Yes, well, I mean, it's, it's, it's such a, it's interesting because it's such a touchy topic, right?
It is a touchy topic. Remember last, last year, presidents of major universities, Harvard, Columbia, University of Pennsylvania, lost their jobs. Because, first of all, they made the mistake of going before a congressional committee, asking them questions. If, if I had been a president of the university, and I almost was once, but if I had been a president of the university and got a call from a committee of Congress asking me to come in and explain myself, I would have said, "I have a dentist appointment." Or, or something like, "I'm, I'm, I'm going on a religious retreat," or something like that.
I mean, these, these, I can't believe how incredibly dumb these people were to walk into that situation and assume that they could get out of it alive, which they did not. And it's because they couldn't answer questions about freedom of speech on campus in ways that were clear and accessible. It is a fairly technical subject, and so they were putting themselves at a disadvantage. But then, in the spring, when all of those protests around the Israeli Gaza and Gaza War became part of the campus scene, all of these questions became very urgent and heightened.
And there, the issue was, to what extent should students and perhaps some faculty have the right to protest? And my answer may not surprise you, to no extent whatsoever. The right to protest is not, is, again, a political right. It belongs to you as a citizen, as you're operating in the political structures of our society. It's not an academic right. So if you protest, disturb the workings of the institution, you should be thrown out of campus and perhaps expelled.
Wow. And because you have taught so long, do you believe that there is external pressure that has caused academic freedom to change?
Yes, there have always been external pressures. That is, The academy is kind of like a ripe target. It's visible. Colleges and universities, unless they're online. But colleges and universities occupy large tracts of land. Their buildings are kind of tall and grand. Everyone drives past them, even if they don't enter those buildings. Therefore, the investment that people have in education leads them to think, "I can do this better than they can." So from the beginning, in the 19th century in the United States,
it was members of the church who wanted to take over universities and push them in a direction that they thought proper. Later, it was large corporations that wanted the university and its curriculum to reflect their desires. Later, still, it was various movements, social movements, social justice movements, etc. There are always, the point is that there are always constituencies that want to step in and tell you as an academic how to do your job and what your job should be. And my message is, don't let them.
Yeah, yeah. And so with the many years, and I know I keep saying it, but you have come from, you know, so many years of teaching and stuck with teaching. Is there a comparison to the US and different countries, in your opinion, regarding academic freedom?
I'm sure there is. I don't know enough about other countries, but I do know that our universities and colleges are the beacons of the educational world, and students from other countries wish to come to the United States. So that says something. I think, I do think that the... What I would call the robust, a robust ethic of academic inquiry, which is a phrase I like better than academic freedom. A robust ethic of academic inquiry is very much alive in the United States, perhaps more so than in other countries. But our colleges and universities are, in fact, the envy of the world.
There's no doubt about it.
Yes, yes. And as you, as you begin teaching this year and things start going, what are you, what do you pose as your future challenges in this? Because, because so many other instructors are expressing their opinions in class and you, Dr. Fish, know your A, B, and C. Do you think that that may affect how many people choose to come or stay into your class because of that?
Well, it's, it's possibly so. It's possibly the case, although I don't know.
Now, as for others, there are others who have decided or have been persuaded that it's their job not only to teach the courses they're assigned to teach, but to save the world. And I once wrote a book this back in 2008 called, "Save the World on Your Own Time." Meaning, look, you're paid by a college or a university, often funded by the state, to teach this subject or that subject, to meet with students, to assign papers, to correct those papers. That's what you're supposed to do. If you have an extraordinary desire,
or if you have a desire to save the world, to go out and do good works, there's nothing wrong with that. Do it after school and on weekends. And if that's not enough, get out of the academy and go to do the work you really want to do. Or as I've sometimes put it, the academy, love it or leave it.
Hmm, that's a good one. That's, that's a good one right there. So it's, it's, I see that you have much passion behind your teaching and that you have really...
Thought about a lot of things and I do love your A, B, and C. A, do your job. B, don't do someone else's job. And C, don't let anyone else do your job.
Right.
And that, I believe that that can go in probably every career field possible.
That's right. And in fact, in most other career fields, you know, when I was, when I was a dean at University of Illinois, I went to talk to the state legislature. Because they were always cutting our budgets and saying, we shouldn't be teaching these courses, but we should be teaching those courses. And I said, look, most of you as state legislatures, only state legislatures for a certain part of the year, you're part-time legislators and you have businesses, corporations, doctors' offices, factories. Suppose I were to walk into one of your places of business and say, after about forty-five minutes of walking around, here is the way I think you should do things. You would throw me out and you would be right.
And yet, you're sitting up here in Springfield, Illinois, never having been in my classroom, and telling me how I should do things. So I said to them, look, if you want me to listen to you, come and sit at my feet in my class for fifteen weeks and then maybe I'll let you say something.
I love that. You, it seems like you've been in several positions when it comes to education.
Yes.
Because I don't want to take too much more of your time, I have one of my favorite questions. What are the greatest joys of what you do?
Well, the greatest joys of what I do is unpacking material that might seem dense and inaccessible. And navigating or teaching students how to navigate through those materials so that at a certain point, they feel both that they've entered a new world and that they are competent citizens in that new world. If by the end of the course, my students feel that they could then turn around and teach the course, then I will be extremely pleased.
Thank you for being here today. I'm really happy that you tuned in to Vision Pros Live. I'm looking forward to seeing your reactions as these episodes continue to move forward. This is going to get more and more fun. We'll have more and more engagement as well. We'll invite people to participate in the show and thank you for giving us your time and attention. Have an excellent time building out your vision and becoming a vision pro yourself.
Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated