Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: Why The Best Entrepreneurs Are Cockroaches, What Everyone Underestimates About Customer Acquisition & What You Don't But Need To Know About Payback Periods with Josh Buckley, Founder & Chairman @ Mino Games About this episode Josh Buckley manages a $50m early-stage fund and as an angel has built a portfolio that includes the likes of Clearbit (Chairman), Rippling, Boom Supersonic, Lattice, Embark and many more incredible companies. Josh is also the Founder & Chairman @ Mino Games, the gaming studio he scaled to $20m in annual revenue and raising $40m in funding for the company. In Today’s Episode You Will Learn: 1.) How did Josh make his way into the world of startups at the age of just 15? How did that lead to becoming the youngest YC founder ever? 2.) What does Josh mean when he says, "the best entrepreneurs are cockroaches"? How does Josh think about capital efficiency today? Does Josh agree with Bill Gurley in stating the biggest challenge today is "the oversupply of capital"? How does Josh advise his portfolio today on raising big rounds? Capital efficiency? Burn rates? 3.) As both a fund manager and founder, what have been some of Josh's biggest takeaways from now investing in 100+ companies as an angel? How has investing impacted Josh's operating mentality? What are the benefits of angel investing? What are the potential dangers? What advice would Josh give to founders entering the world of angel investing? 4.) What are the biggest elements people underestimate when it comes to CAC? What have been Josh's biggest lessons on the volatility of CAC over time? How are we seeing the platforms evolve and develop their tech and pricing? How important is channel diversity to Josh? What is balanced? What is not? What have been Josh's biggest lessons when it comes to payback period and it changing over time? Items Mentioned In Today’s Show: Josh’s Fave Blog/ Newsletter: Paul Graham Blog As always you can follow Harry, The Twenty Minute VC and Josh on Twitter here!
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Harry Stebbings? We are back and welcome to the 20 minute VC with me, Harry Stebbings at H Stebbings 1996 with two Bs on Instagram. But to our episode today, and I have been a big fanboy of this individual's angel portfolio for a very long time. And then we met through Twitter DM. Now, I've interviewed over 2,000 managers and this guest, I believe, is one of the top five I've met. Truly special and also now a very dear friend. And so with that, I'm very excited to welcome Josh Buckley. Now Josh manages a 50 million early stage fund and as an angel has built a portfolio that includes the likes of Clearbit, where he's also chairman, Rippling, Boom, Supersonic, Lattice, Embark and many more incredible companies. Josh is also the founder and chairman at Minogames, the gaming studio he scaled to 20 million in annual revenue and raising 40 million in funding for the company.
0:44 Harry Stebbings? But before we dive into the show today, I'm sure you've heard about it, but my word, this is a product I love, Carter. Carter simplifies how startups and investors manage equity, track cap tables and get valuations. Go to Carter.com/20VC to get 10% off and more than 800,000 employees and shareholders use Carter to manage hundreds of billions of dollars of equity. And Carter now offers fund admin, so you can see real time data in the Carter platform and work with Carter's team of experienced fund accountants also in the background. Go to Carter.com/20VC to get 10% off. And speaking of companies that have taken our ecosystem by storm, I have to talk about Brex, the company which built the corporate card for startups and who is the fastest company to reach unicorn status in history.
1:27 Harry Stebbings? Brex founders, Henry, Ian and Pedro, built a payments business in Brazil, but kept getting rejected for a corporate card in the States. So they built Brex with no personal liability, up to 20 times higher card limits and huge rewards like 7X points on Uber and Lyft, 4X on Brex Travel and 2X on SaaS software. If you're a VC backed startup based in the US, see if you qualify for a Brex card today at Brex.com and get Cardfees waived for life by entering the code HARRY during signup. And finally, you have to check out Rank Science. Rank Science is the easiest way to grow organic traffic and get your content ranking higher in Google. Their AI powered platform uses real time search data and natural language processing to help you craft content that is highly relevant to search intent and maps directly to what users are searching. For customers with lots of landing pages,
2:12 Harry Stebbings? you can leverage Rank Science's SEO A/B testing platform to easily test which HTML changes cause an uplift in search traffic. Also, as an added bonus, their platform also allows marketers to make SEO enhancements to websites without eating up precious engineering resources. Rank Science is used by hundreds of companies to grow organic traffic, from startups to publicly traded companies, including the likes of BuildZoom, Goldbelly, Sweetness and Career Karma. Go to rankscience.com/20vc for your first month free. But you've heard quite enough from me, so now I'm very excited to welcome the very dear friend that is Josh Buckley.
2:50 Speaker 01 You have now arrived at your destination.
2:53 Harry Stebbings? Josh, my word, I've been so looking forward to this one for such a long time. So thank you so much for joining me today, Josh.
2:59 Speaker 02 Thank you so much, Harry. The pleasure is mine.
3:01 Harry Stebbings? Oh, it's very kind, but I do want to kick off today with a little bit about you, Josh. So tell me, how did you make the move from Kent in the UK, love having another Brit on the show, by the way, to running a 40 million run rate gaming company and really being one of the leading angels in the US? How did that change and transition come about?
3:16 Speaker 02 Well, thanks again, Harry. It's an honour to be on the show. So I grew up in Kent and I was a kind of a quiet, shy geek growing up. And around the age of 10 or 11, I got my first computer and I started playing some video games, games like Diablo and Habbo Hotel. What I became enthralled by was not just the games, but the actual community and the virtual world aspect of these games. And I really kind of wanted to be a creator of one of these games, not just the person playing it. I wanted to be the orchestrator behind the scenes. So around the age of 12, I actually taught myself to code and I learned PHP and I started doing different types of projects. So I started freelance programming for other people and I was earning about a hundred dollars an hour at the age of 12. And these people didn't actually know I was 12 years old, which was a funny thing. They probably thought I was a 35-year-old contract programmer.
4:00 Speaker 02 Eventually started to make my own games. So fast forward to the age of 15, I made a virtual world, which was basically a clone of another game I was pretty addicted to. Within about a year, it grew really fast to about 100,000 users. I was running a remote team of about 12 people and I had to learn a lot of hard lessons about management and running a big game in a big code base. And I was going through high school at the same time, so it was incredibly high pressure and stressful. So after about 12 months of running this thing, and it became a pretty significant business for a 15 year old, I had a lot of people approach me to buy this thing off my hands. And I actually agreed one day to sell it to a company in Texas for six figures at the time. And the funny thing was, my parents didn't even know I had started this game.
4:40 Speaker 02 So one evening, I had to go downstairs to my parents and get them to sign the contract, selling my game. So I walked downstairs and it was about 11pm at night. My dad straight away said, Josh, why are you still up? You have a maths exam in the morning. So I just silently handed him this contract piece of paper. It was too much to explain, but they were kind of in shock. They saw this big number and they gave me a big hug and were obviously very proud and let me spend all the time I wanted on the computer after that. Basically, I used the money for kind of two things. I started travelling a lot, so I started going to the US for conferences, I went to Asia, and just started meeting all these amazing people. And then I started angel investing in friends. So I made a lot of friends through online forums, IRC channels, who were all these interesting, impressive people who just love to create, just like me.
5:23 Speaker 02 And I started just cutting them small checks, so I made maybe a half a dozen or 10 angel investments. A lot of them flopped, but one or two of them started to really do well. For instance, I was the first investor in a company called DailyBooth. DailyBooth was a website where you could take a photo of yourself every day. Got accepted into Y Combinator in 2009, when I was, I think, maybe 16. And basically, it started to rapidly grow, raised a Series A from Sequoia Capital, and touched the lives of millions of people. And what DailyBooth showed me was how a small, tiny idea that my friend John had could turn into something big that raises millions of dollars, touches the lives of millions, and just makes a real dent in the world. So that raised my level of ambition for what I wanted to do next. And it opened me up to this network of people in Silicon Valley and outside of the kind of small town I was used to.
6:08 Speaker 02 These people that just thought 10 times bigger and actually had the capacity and capability of getting there. So when I turned 18, I really didn't want to go the kind of traditional route of going to college and getting a normal job, which I think was generally expected at the time. I went straight to Y Combinator, and I think around the time I was one of the youngest people to get in. I was 17, turning 18. And I met with Paul Graham, and because I'd already kind of interacted Through some of my investing, like DailyBooth that got into Y Combinator, I got accepted into the program and when I was eighteen, moved to Silicon Valley, Santa Clara to be specific. And honestly, it changed my life. I mean, it was this magical place with, you know, all these stars, all these amazing companies that have been built. And it just rewired my brain in a way that was much more optimistic, more ambitious and really hungry to learn.
6:51 Speaker 02 Like in my Y Combinator class, I just looked to my left and my right and everyone was just so smart. And it just made me hungry to get better every day. And that became a focus from there. It really rewired how I was. During Y Combinator, we had a plan to basically launch a game. So we launched this game, which was basically like Pokemon for the iPhone. And it was a thrilling ride. We went through Y Combinator and we won the hot startups in our batch we raised at the time, which was a high valuation, which was an eight million dollar cap. I know it's very different today. We became one of Andreessen Horowitz's first seed investments. We launched the game and it became a top fifty grossing app in the US App Store, fifteen million downloads. Everyone was knocking on our door. It's incredibly exciting time, let's say, where we have Minnow Games, which is thriving, we're in hypergrowth.
7:34 Speaker 02 Have a game that's again touching millions of people's lives and it's becoming an amazing business.
7:38 Harry Stebbings? I mean, I absolutely love that as an introduction. I mean, Josh, also rarely do I feel really shit about my age, but hearing that, I was like, really? Great. Well, thank you again for making me feel shit. I didn't, I didn't know I was quite that young. But I do want to start on something that we've chatted about before, Josh, and it was, it was pretty striking when you said it to me. Cause you said to me that from all the kind of experiences you've had so far with Minnow, that the best entrepreneurs are cockroaches, they do whatever it takes. So I'd love to hear about maybe your personal experiences and what you meant by the best entrepreneurs are cockroaches.
8:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. So, you know, I've heard this analogy of cockroaches thrown around a lot about entrepreneurship. And it definitely resonates with my experience with the fact that, you know, you just can't kill a cockroach. I think at least the number one rule of success with, at least I take with businesses, you just need to survive first to get there. And our story with Minnow has been almost the opposite of Up Until The Right. I think, you know, from the outside, stories can always look just like you're always succeeding, but on the inside, it's kind of felt like the opposite for us. Sure, we had a lot of momentum early on created something that entertained millions and millions of people and generated a lot of revenue. However, a couple of years into the business, we actually, we launched this game, raised a couple of million in funding. And we started to hit a ceiling of how quickly we could scale.
8:53 Speaker 02 Our unit economics started to invert and basically we realized that the game we had launched is going to flop and we have to close it. And we also realized that we were burning through our funding pretty damn fast. We needed to make some key changes. So we went through this period, which Y Combinator terms as the trough of sorrow. And it was a really, really hard time. We realized we had a couple of months of money left and our prospects looked pretty bleak. You know, I became pretty depressed and honestly wasn't sure at times like what to do. And I like took a deep breath and realized we have a choice. We can either return what fraction of the money we've raised back to investors and kind of embarrassing and kind of a bit defeat. Or we can commit to seeing this through and let's take what we have and let's really just try and give it everything we've got.
9:35 Speaker 02 Ultimately, we went for the latter. I just really didn't see giving up as an option, kind of never fully crossed my mind. So we realized that the cost of scaling up this game in San Francisco was prohibitive. It was going to cost us way more than we had in the bank to launch something that we knew would be a new scalable business. So ultimately, we looked at our numbers in San Francisco and just realized it was not feasible to launch a new game in San Francisco. We didn't have the investor appetite to do it either. And I looked at peer gaming companies around the world and realized that their cost basis was so much lower. So we ultimately decided to commit to building our studio somewhere else. So it was a really hard decision and basically we looked around the world. So we looked at South America, we looked throughout Europe and we ultimately decided on Montreal, out of all places. For two or three primary reasons.
10:18 Speaker 02 The first was that it had a huge base of talent for making video games with EA, Ubisoft, et cetera. About 10,000 engineers in the gaming industry. The cost of living was four or five times lower than San Francisco. And then we had these amazing tax credits from the government. So when we saw these facts, we were like, it was crazy for us to continue operating our studio from San Francisco. And we ultimately approached our team very quickly after and said, hey, unfortunately, we have to close our San Francisco studio. And we're moving our lives to Montreal. And we left a lot behind there and we brought about a third of our team over, two thirds of our team, we decided to.
10:50 Speaker 02 Actually help find new jobs and at first it was incredibly hard. We didn't, we didn't know anybody in Montreal. I don't even speak French. I still don't speak French. It was an incredibly hard move and you know, I left friendships and relationships behind which were hard. But that was the kind of hard decision that I had to make to commit to seeing this through. We realized that we had no choice.
11:10 Harry Stebbings? Can I jump in and ask you a point say you were, you know, nineteen, twenty, in many cases had the weight of the world in terms of responsibility, people's careers on your shoulders. Did you ever think I'm only one person, I'm only a boy in some cases. Did you, how did you deal with that intense pressure at such a young age? Advise me.
11:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, so luckily this happened in about twenty sixteen when we made the move. So I was probably what twenty five, twenty four. Before that, I mean, it was, it was still, it was not an easy ride leading up to that. I would say that really what helped me in those hard times was having a great set of people around me. And people who had gone through it before, but also people that I had real relationships with, not just professional relationships. And then the second thing was just taking one step at a time, like realizing that like, okay, this is really fucking hard. And this is what going through hell is like. It's kind of like the Winston Churchill quote, like if you're going through hell, just keep going. I think the one thing I realized was that you just can't stop. You just need to kind of keep putting one foot in front of the other.
12:04 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally get you in terms of that. Just keep going. I, I do want to ask it because you know, that was the challenging times and now kind of coming out through it and on the other side. The business is doing very, very well. And my question to you is, in the plentiful funding environment that now we're currently in, why did you not raise big when it was clear that things were starting to change and all was working well?
12:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's a great question. So at the time, it was not always clear that it was doing well. When we launched our first game, it was around the time that Zynga had actually went through the IPO, late twenty eleven. And they essentially didn't do so well. The stock started to plummet and the investor sentiment around, around our startup and around our market was pretty cold and bleak. I think the investor interest kind of depends in part around your market, how fast it's growing. And we just didn't have that kind of interest. You know, we spoke to hundreds of investors and just realized that we weren't going to attract that kind of interest. So ultimately we decided, okay, we're going to have to get to breakout growth without raising. Huge amounts of external capital. And then when we have a game that actually works, we'll be able to just skip a few rounds of financing. And that's essentially the route we took.
13:07 Speaker 02 We had to be a lot more scrappy, had to be relentlessly resourceful, as Paul Graham says, and get to a stage where essentially the business is at breakout growth. And a couple of months ago, we did that. So we validated a new game. The unit economics were incredibly favorable to us. And we decided to bring on about thirty million dollars in debt to allow us to scale to the next stage of the business. And now we're operating in a much more slightly less efficient way of growing, where we're hiring many people every week and just being more aggressive on every front because we realize our strategy dictates speed to market and just getting things done as quickly as possible.
13:40 Harry Stebbings? No, I mean, I absolutely love listening to the pretty atypical journey, really, that you've taken with Minnow. I do want to ask one question before we move on to the next, probably being customer acquisition, one of my favorites. You have a very interesting perspective wearing both the founder and then the angel hat. And I had Bill Gurley on the show and he said the single biggest challenge that investors face today is essentially the oversupply of capital. I'm interested, given both hats that you wear simultaneously, how do you think about the oversupply of capital? And would you agree with Bill as to the extent of the challenge that it is?
14:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. So I would agree with Bill. I think, you know, it's a really great time to be an entrepreneur fundraising today, but it's a hard time to be an investor. And I also think that, you know, many new founders today only know the funding environment like this. It's almost like being a spoiled rich kid born into a rich family. Sometimes it can really help to go through the struggle of struggling to actually, you know, make your payroll, et cetera. I think it teaches a certain level of discipline that can really help and also hone in the fact that you need to nail your business. I also think that capital only solves a few of your problems. The way I view it is it's just fuel and you need to be driving in the right direction and build your car to get there first. I think when the cycle changes, we may find that a lot of companies are actually caught with their pants down
14:51 Speaker 02 and they may not have the actual formula or unit economics for a business that will actually scale.
14:55 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, how does that then mean that you advise your angel investments so far? In terms of capital efficiency, in terms of resource allocation, maybe how much they raise? Does that change what advice you maybe give to them today?
15:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think I advise my companies to... Investments to basically be highly aware of the environment and cycle we're in. And the fact that tomorrow's fundraiser is not promised. So if you're taking a strategy which is aggressive on the funding side, which can often be very valid. You need to be aware that you need investors to support you tomorrow. And you need a business engine that actually supports that strategy.
15:27 Harry Stebbings? Totally agreed in terms of the business engine. I mean, one element that's core to any business engine state is customer acquisition costs in particular. And it is something that I'm super passionate about. And I know we've chatted about it before. And you said to me before that people underestimate customer acquisition costs. So what in your mind, Josh, are people maybe underestimating with regards to CAC and how CAC changes over time?
15:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. So I just look at the data. We spend tens of millions a year at Minnow on marketing. And the one thing that we've seen ourselves and other companies and investors underestimate is how CAC saturates. So as an example, someone might buy a hundred thousand or a few million dollars in ads and think they know the CAC for their business. And based all their internal projections, offer this arbitrage a play. However, there's two forces which I don't really see people talking as much about. The first is just how quickly your CAC saturates in your internal market relatively. So we call it internally our golden cohorts. Like the users or the customers you buy today are going to be the cheapest you'll ever buy. And then the algorithms behind networks will start going for the second cheapest, the third cheapest.
16:29 Speaker 02 So for every X million dollars of your spend you may be buying on these networks, your CAC may double, for instance. And the second force at play is essentially the market wide CPMs are just compounding. The number we've seen is about forty percent a year. And that's just because of a number of factors around the algorithms of new competitors coming into the market. I mean, you're competing against Walmart, insurance companies when you're buying across Facebook, Google, et cetera. And they just have totally different business goals to average performance marketing spend. The way we view it is the cheapest marketing you can do in performance marketing is today and always today. And there's just no real secrets to CAC. And that's kind of why we think there's a whole cottage industry around it. Because people are trying to find the answers, but unfortunately, there's just some hard truths around spending in these networks today.
17:10 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, I tweeted the other day, it really frustrates me how pre-seed investors will ask startups, what's your CAC, what's your LTV and expect predictable, reliable, data-driven response. Back. I got quite a lot of pushback from this, saying that I shouldn't be frustrated by it. And actually, it's very helpful in terms of determining the mentality of the founder. Would you agree with the pushback there? Or would you say that actually placing a focus on CAC and LTV as a metric at pre-seed or in their very early seed days is too early? How do you think about that when investing?
17:38 Speaker 02 I think it really depends on the business and also the stage and also the category of the business. In general, I would agree with you that both the data around CAC and LTV is far too early at the pre-seed stage. I think until you've started to kind of push more than seven figures of scale between both the CAC and LTV metrics, you really don't know those numbers and you could be off by a couple of those in magnitude, frankly. Every number can be completely skewed at a small scale. So I think it's probably in the investors, like, I think it helps to actually know how the entrepreneur is thinking. I would heavily caveat those numbers with assuming that they are so far off.
18:10 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, no, I agree with you. I also had one super interesting guest on the show recently and then they said that successful marketing is almost like being a VC in the way that you sprinkle a lot of bets in terms of the bets being channels. And then you observe, wait for one to kind of rocket ship, so to speak, one of the channels, one of the bets, one of the investments, and then you double down in that. Would you agree with that analogy? And then I guess my next question is, how do you think about channel mortality and how quickly you shift between channels?
18:36 Speaker 02 Absolutely. So I think that's absolutely the approach we take with marketing. You need to really, if a large part of your strategy with growth is paid marketing, channel diversity is a key point. I think you really don't want to be concentrated in a single channel. And that's one thing I look at when I'm investing in companies that have paid marketing as a core part of their business.
18:54 Harry Stebbings? What's concentrated? I know that's a ridiculous question, but like, is 50% too concentrated? Is 70? What would concentrate or concern you?
19:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. So I see a lot of businesses where about half their spend is in Facebook marketing and maybe another half is through Google. That's pretty heavily concentrated now. The problem with that is that there's never been a single update in digital advertising that's made buying cheaper. The advertising algorithms on these major platforms like Facebook and Google are getting hyper-efficient and every update just makes them more expensive. So, you know, over the eight years I've been buying, it's just become eight years more expensive. And I think it's really important to spread your bets because it's A huge amount of risk being tied to you having your business growth being tied to this one platform or two platforms. So today we're buying across maybe twenty different platforms and I think it's incredibly important to spread your bets as such.
19:42 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, think back over your angel portfolio and I don't know if it's sensitive name wise and if so, not to why, if not awesome, love to hear about it. But when you think back over kind of analyzing the CACs of your past investments, what most impressed you with one of them? Is there a case where you think I remember this deal and their CACs were incredible, the LTVs on their cohorts were so exciting? Which one stands out to your mind in that perspective?
20:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. I would say the first thing I would really care about is that excites me are businesses that don't actually have to rely on CAC. And that's obviously the holy grail. If you have something that's viral or spreads itself or spreads via word of mouth, that's always key. Ideally, your paid acquisition is just supplemental to that. Of course, not everyone has that and you can still create an incredible business without that. I can't name names specifically, but some of my direct to consumer businesses have amazing payback periods. They make, they're completely profitable on their first purchase. And as a result, they're just able to grow so incredibly fast because they can recycle capital like nobody's business. You know, their payback period is less than a month. So they're able to recycle a small amount of capital and quickly grow into a bigger business.
20:42 Harry Stebbings? Can I jump on the payback period there? Cause you said to me before that payback period doubles. I think it was you said it doubles every five million you spend. Walk me through that. Why do you think that is? And has that been the case with you in particular?
20:53 Speaker 02 This has been a data point that we've seen across a couple of different games. We think applies maybe not to apples to apples across different markets. The reason why your payback period grows as you spend more is essentially that you're exhausting the most relevant people or customers for your business. Because these algorithms and targeting on these networks is so efficient, the first five million dollars you spend are going to be the first X amount of people that are most likely to buy your product. After that, Facebook, Google, et cetera, are going to find the like next rung down. So as a result, these people are less likely to click on your ads, they're less likely to convert. So your payback period comes down as such and benchmarks we've heard thrown around are roughly doubling every five million in spend.
21:31 Speaker 02 And of course, there's many ways we work to counteract this, such as increasing your LTV as such, if you have the tools available, looking at the data, adjusting, testing. Creatives, it's a lot you can do, but I think it's a good rule of thumb and I think it's really important to keep in mind.
21:45 Harry Stebbings? No, it's a fascinating observation. I do want to touch on a couple of elements to do with the angel investing in particular. It's a super interesting thing in terms of kind of doing it simultaneously. And so I'd love to hear, how does investing alongside operating? How does that alter your operating mentality, both positively and negatively when you think about that?
22:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. I think being an angel investor over the last six or seven years has really helped me shift to have a high level fifty thousand perspective around my strategy and business. Because I take a look at companies through that lens, so I actually look at my own company through the investor lens. It helps me zoom out and see the five year view. It also helps me see how other companies are operating. And often it's also raised my ambition levels, you know, when I talk to say a Blake at Boom and hear the level of ambition he's taking towards his business. It really makes me think, am I thinking big enough? And oftentimes I'm not, and it's really inspiring to readjust that way. I think the challenge I find is making sure I can manage my time effectively and focus properly.
22:39 Harry Stebbings? Do you advise more founders to do it? And then if so, what advice do you give them in terms of making that first check, entering the industry as a founder, making their first entrance into the angel investing arena?
22:49 Speaker 02 Generally, I would advise against doing so. I think it's great if you have opportunities to do so. And if you have the capital and you have the deals in front of you, I think it's absolutely worth doing. What I'd advise against is splitting your focus too much. I think running a company on its own is incredibly tough. And you really should be spending all of your energy on actually finding that product market fit and something that can scale. I think once you have the team in place and the executive layer and everything ready, then I think you're able to spend a bit more time looking at deals and opportunities.
23:19 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally agree with you in terms of the split time there. I do have to ask, in terms of the takeaways for you from having this kind of dual role, have there been some really big tangible takeaways in terms of the last five years building the incredible portfolio you have? Have there been some real takeaways for you from that investing experience?
23:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, you know, early on, I pretty much just followed my intuition with investing. I think some investors specifically focus on certain theses or markets, et cetera. I really just have followed my intuition with founders early on and just look for people that had a strong fit with their market and understood their market inside out. People that I would learn a lot from. And to be honest, I've been incredibly surprised by how great my results have been with early-stage investing. Some of my early deals have really started to compound into great results and I've just really enjoyed it the whole time. But it's been a very intuitive process with meeting with founders.
24:05 Harry Stebbings? I think there's a common notion, though, that, you know, in the valley, there's hot deals and the hot deals translate into the best companies. When you look at your portfolio today, in terms of today's hot companies, they are pretty much them in terms of, you know, your Clearbits and your Booms of the world, your Riplings of the world. I mean, the list really does go on with your portfolio. So I guess my question is, have you seen a trend that the hottest companies translate into the best companies?
24:27 Speaker 02 Yes, I remember we were talking about this and I definitely, as we know today, the environment is incredibly hot for early-stage companies. And I was looking at my own portfolio and actually found that many of my most successful deals were actually not very hot at the seed stage. It was actually a struggle for them to raise their first rounds. These were some of my most successful outcomes. And I also look at companies like Airbnb, Uber, et cetera. They were also not very hot in their early rounds. And what that really informed me was I want to be incredibly driven by the founder and not just the market. I think great founders can navigate many markets and many opportunities. And it also teaches me to think from first principles and ignore a lot of the heat around deals that I see today.
25:05 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally agree with you around the deal heat element. We said that kind of advice that you give to other angels. I do want to discuss the actual topic of advice itself, because when we chatted before about the prominence of advice today and it being given so widely. You said a large chunk of advice you get is BS, to put it bluntly. So starting on that, why do you feel this? And how do you approach that advice gathering?
25:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. So, look, I think advice is amazing and it's in large part what makes a lot of Silicon Valley great. What I struggle with sometimes is received wisdom. So advice alone is just completely contextual. It's like a sample size of one person's personal experience of what worked or didn't work for them. And I often hear a piece of general advice shared. I have examples of this where I could have someone vehemently argue the opposite advice of something that I've heard through Twitter or something else. So oftentimes, I'll just invert someone's advice to see if that still holds true. I think a key piece is really just to break down advice and Understand, does that person have like their own perspective and why? Why are they coming from this point of view and angle etcetera? But in general, I think it's important to basically take as much advice as you can in,
26:10 Speaker 02 really bring it with context and you really have to understand the kind of tree of knowledge and the, or a better analogy might be the kind of layers of a knowledge on an onion which apply. So make sure you don't just slot in this advice without understanding all the surrounding context of it.
26:23 Harry Stebbings? You said there about the inversion of advice and I absolutely love that. It's a super interesting experiment to completely invert the advice and then see the outcome and how it translates. In terms of like examples who may be but conventional wisdom, who do you think maybe most exemplifies this in a very positive way? And what's been some of your learnings from watching them maybe go about this non-conventional strategy?
26:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. So I sit on the board with Alex at Clearbit and I would say he's probably one of the people I've seen most who have but convention around advice. He happily solicits a lot of advice and he has amazing advisors and investors around him. But he makes his own decisions happily from the ground up and many of them would be considered pretty unconventional in Silicon Valley. Whether it's the decisions around the talent he hires, his fundraising strategy or company bonding events. You know, they have amazing chefs at Clearbit, they take these amazing trips together. He also really optimizes the company around profitability, which you know, some advise much more aggressive growth strategy. In hindsight, I think all of his decisions have been working out extremely well. I mean, Clearbit's an amazing business and I think he's part of his own path, which many founders would be, may choose to more blindly follow different advice.
27:25 Harry Stebbings? I'm really pleased you said about Alex at Clearbit because I did speak to him before the show and he said, you have to ask Josh one question and I don't know the context here, so maybe you can help me. But he asked, are you going to fulfill the revenue bet you made with him?
27:40 Speaker 02 So maybe a little context, Minnow Games and Clearbit had a little bet between Alex and I around which company would make the least revenue in, I think it was last year. And the loser would have to do an embarrassing bet, which I probably can't repeat on the show. And it was extremely motivating to get our game launched last year. So unfortunately, we didn't launch our game and so we lost the bet. But I would happily take Alex up on a bet again for this year. I'm pretty sure we're gonna do some laps around Clearbit.
28:05 Harry Stebbings? Well, you said it here first and Alex is coming on the show very shortly, so I'm. Going to put it to him and then
28:11 Speaker 02 Please do, please do.
28:12 Harry Stebbings? But I do want to finish, Josh, with my favourite being the quick fire answer. As you know, I say a short statement and you hit me with your immediate thoughts. Are you ready to dive in?
28:20 Speaker 02 Let's do it.
28:20 Harry Stebbings? So what's your favourite book and why should we be reading it?
28:23 Speaker 02 Uh, my favourite book is Poor Charlie's Almanack from Charlie Munger. It really drove for me a love of learning, a love of mental models. It really taught me about the compounding nature of knowledge. It's probably the book that just got me reading a lot more books.
28:35 Harry Stebbings? Uh, love it. Uh, it's one of my favourites too, I have to admit. Tell me, biggest strength and biggest weakness, if you were to do thirty seconds on each.
28:42 Speaker 02 The biggest strength is probably determination and relentlessness. I think I, you know, I don't think everyone would have moved to the cold in Montreal to keep their business alive. I think probably on the weakness side, I think I probably have unattainable expectations of myself and I think that can lead to pressure on myself and those around me to an extent that's probably unnecessary. I would love to kind of tame those expectations.
29:02 Harry Stebbings? Totally unfair of me because it's off schedule, but I'm too intrigued. When you have great milestones and great achievements for you and for the team, do you take a step back and appreciate those, attaining those milestones? Or do you kind of suffer, I think probably like many entrepreneurs where they always just want the next and they're never happy? How do you think about that appreciation element?
29:19 Speaker 02 You know, I would really love to be the kind of person and I aspire to be the person that stops and smells the roses, but by by nature, I'm definitely more of the latter where I'm always thinking about what's next. Some form of hedonic adaptation where as soon as I've met the goal, it's always on to the next one. And I think it's really important when we're trying to build our team to celebrate a lot of these small wins more and more. It's definitely not my nature so much.
29:41 Harry Stebbings? How does success in games translate to other fields?
29:44 Speaker 02 Uh, great question. I, I think success in games translates to a lot of other fields. I think it, games are one of the hardest types of business to create. They're competitive, there's hundreds of thousands of new games launched every year. And a lot of the consumer mechanics we see today at the top of the app store or top of consumer businesses were started in successful games, maybe five or 10 years ago. There's so many lessons I've taken away, whether it's merchandising, economies, data science, incentive design, et cetera. And there's just so many disciplines that you need to master to succeed in games. I think would really translate well into other business and we're actually seeing so happen.
30:14 Harry Stebbings? I, I remember actually Rahul from Superhuman said the same on the show, so it's super interesting to hear. I would love to know. Also, especially now with being in Montreal, what would you like to change about Silicon Valley and VC? Having now had that external perspective as well?
30:28 Speaker 02 Absolutely. So I still spend a lot of my time in San Francisco and Silicon Valley. And I think it's one of the most amazing places in the world. It's a real jewel and I don't see that changing. One thing that I would really like to see change, that I wish was different, was more diversity of thought. When I'm in Silicon Valley, it feels like a very homogenous kind of echo chamber, where people can think the same, dress the same, value the same things. I'd really like to see that mixed up more and I think it would be a great thing for the Valley in general.
30:52 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, no, I totally agree with you there. Okay, investor updates. I'm sure you've written them before. You've also received them as an angel. What makes the best when format? What's the advice?
31:03 Speaker 02 Yeah, so basically I think a regular cadence is really helpful. So probably some of the best investor updates I see are in a monthly cadence. They really kind of keep it on a rigid schedule and they have the key numbers. They have the trends around those numbers and they have the goals. They also have the highlights and lowlights around the business and really that's it. I think they keep it really direct and to the point. I think having a regular schedule around it just keeps investors informed of the business and you create that close communication going.
31:28 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally agree with you, but I do want to finish on my favorite one and probably the most exciting is the next five years for you. What's in the roadmap, Josh?
31:36 Speaker 02 Absolutely. So at Minnow, we're just looking to bring daily joy to around a billion people a year. That's what's our driving force going forward. And I think it's going to take us a little while to get there, but that's what drives us and gets us up every day. And for myself, I plan on continuing to do that and also just working with amazing founders every day as an investor.
31:52 Harry Stebbings? Listen, Josh, as I said, I've wanted to do this episode for such a long time. It really has been such a pleasure to have a fellow Brit on the show. This is so exciting for me. But thank you so much for joining me today, Josh.
32:02 Speaker 02 Thank you so much, Harry. It's been great.
32:05 Harry Stebbings? I mean, my word, that was such a pleasure to do with Josh. And as I said at the beginning, he really is such a special early stage investor. I'm very excited to see the times ahead there with Josh and the new fund. You can find him on Twitter at Josh Buckley. Likewise, it'd be great to see you behind the scenes on the show. You can do that on Instagram at H Stabbings 1996 with two Bs. But before we leave you today, I'm sure you've heard about it, but my word, this is a product I love, Carter. Carter simplifies how startups and investors Manage equity, track cap tables and get valuations. Go to Carter.com/20VC to get 10% off. And more than 800,000 employees and shareholders use Carter to manage hundreds of billions of dollars of equity.
32:43 Harry Stebbings? And Carter now offers fund admin, so you can see real time data in the Carter platform and work with Carter's team of experienced fund accountants also in the background. Go to Carter.com/20VC to get 10% off. And speaking of companies that have taken our ecosystem by storm, I have to talk about Brex. The company which built the corporate card for startups and who is the fastest company to reach unicorn status in history. Brex founders Henry C and Pedro built a payments business in Brazil, but kept getting rejected for a corporate card in the States. So they built Brex with no personal liability, up to 20 times higher card limits and huge rewards like seven X points on Uber and Lyft, four X on Brex Travel and two X on SaaS software. If you're a VC backed startup based in the US, see if you qualify for a Brex card today at Brex.com
33:28 Harry Stebbings? and get card fees waived for life by entering the code Harry during signup. And finally, you have to check out Rank Science. Rank Science is the easiest way to grow organic traffic and get your content ranking higher in Google. Their AI powered platform uses real time search data and natural language processing to help you craft content that is highly relevant to search intent and maps directly to what users are searching for. For customers with lots of landing pages, you can leverage Rank Science's SEO A B testing platform to easily test which HTML changes cause an uplift in search traffic. Also as an added bonus, their platform also allows marketers to make SEO enhancements to websites without eating up precious engineering resources. Rank Science is used by hundreds of companies to grow organic traffic, from startups to publicly traded companies,
34:10 Harry Stebbings? including the likes of Build Zoom, Goldbelly, Sweetness and Career Karma. Go to RankScience.com/20VC for your first month free. As always, I so appreciate all your support and I can't wait to bring you a fantastic episode with the founder, Jason Brown at Tally on Friday.
Previous 20VC: Ash Fontana on The 5 Core Characteristics That Make Data Valuable, What VCs Can Learn From Italian Craftsmen and Howard Marks & The Importance of Vertical Integration In Scaling Today Next 20VC: Why Startup Valuations Are Not As Overpriced As You Think, How To Determine Whether An Investor Is Truly Aligned To Your Mission and What 2 Traits Make The Truly Special Board Members with Jason Brown, Founder & CEO @ Tally Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated