Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: Why 75% of Active Investors Will Disappear in the Next Few Years, The Death of "So So" Venture Firms is Coming, The Rise of Blackstone of Venture Firms and What That Does To Venture Returns, How the World of LPs is Broken and more with Kyle Harrison About this episode Kyle Harrison is a General Partner @ Contrary and one of my favorite writers on the venture space with his blog, Investing 101 2.0. Before joining Contrary, Kyle worked in the ranks of some of the biggest and best names in venture, starting with a spell at TCV before moving to Coatue and making his final stop at Index. Across firms, Kyle has led or participated in investments including Ramp, Pave, Anduril, Gitlab, Databricks and Snowflake to name a few. In Today's Episode with Kyle Harrison: 1.) From Film Lover to Technology Investor: How Kyle went from creating a professional services marketplace around film to joining the ranks of TCV and investing in breakout technology companies? What was Kyle's biggest takeaway from TCV? How did it impact his mindset? What was Kyle's biggest lesson from working with the Laffont's at Coatue? How did it change the way he thinks about price and market sizing? Why was Index such a transformational school of venture for Kyle? How did that experience change how he thinks about what it takes to be a great investor? 2.) The Death of So So Venture Firms: Why does Kyle believe many of the "so so" venture firms will die? What does Kyle believe makes a venture firm "so so"? Who is vulnerable then? How does Kyle think the lifespan and "death" of venture firms will change in the next decade? 3.) The Rise of "The Blackstone of Venture Firms": How does Kyle define "the Blackstone of VCs"? Who are they? With increasing fund sizes will we see VC returns denigrate to PE returns? How is the world of family offices changing the venture environment? Will we see more or less money flood into venture over the coming years? Of the incumbents, who has done "The Blackstone" model well? Why? Who has failed? Why? 4.) The Rise of Community in Venture: What does "community" really mean to Kyle? Why does he believe it will play such a prominent role in the way the best invest in the future? How have existing players failed to build, sustain and productize communities? What are the best opportunities for new entrants to create and utilise communities to invest? Items Mentioned in Today's Episode: Kyle's Favourite Book: Reinventing Knowledge: From Alexandria to the Internet
Transcript 10,809 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Harry Stebbings? You are listening to 20 VC with me, Harry Stebbings, and I'm thrilled today to be joined by one of my favourite writers on the venture space and also a brilliant investor in the form of Kyle Harrison, general partner at Contrary. If you had not checked out his blog, Investing 101 2.0, then it is a must. And Carl has really cut his teeth in the world of venture, working in the ranks of some of the biggest and best names, including spells at TCV. Carl then moved to Co2 and made his final stop at Index before moving to Contrary. Across firms, Carl has led or participated in investments in companies including Ramp, Pave, Anduril, GitLab, Databricks and Snowflake, to name a few. And I'd also want to say a huge thank you to Mark Goldberg at Index, Bryce Roberts at OVC and Rex Woodbury at Index for some amazing questions suggestions today.
0:43 Harry Stebbings? But before we move into the episode today, holiday gifting for your friends and family can be hard. And for your business, it can be even harder. And Open helps companies of all sizes deliver better gifts and they make it super easy. Their platform is filled with best-in-class brands. There are no bad gifts ever. They source locally and operate globally. You don't even need an address. Simply send an email or DM with a unique gift link. Ready to put the ease and joy back into your company's gifting? Head over to andopen.co/20vc. That's andopen.co/20vc to get started today. And speaking of amazing tools, which really take complex processes and make them super easy.
1:25 Harry Stebbings? Angel List has been a key partner for me in managing my investments. I love using the Angel List platform because it abstracts away all the complexity and operational burden of fund management. Whether you're running SPVs, a traditional venture fund like me, or even a rolling fund, Angel List has you covered. The team is also just exceptional. They're great, great partners. I'm also super excited about their new product though, Angel List Stack, which is purpose-built for founders. With Angel List Stack, you can create a fundraising-ready startup in just a few clicks. Angel List handles all your companies in corporation, banking, cap table and fundraising process, all in a single place. This allows founders to really focus on building. If you're a founder, you can launch your company at stack.angellist.com/20vc. Whether you're a founder or a funder, you're in great hands.
2:10 Harry Stebbings? Hands with Angel List. And finally, from websites and online stores to marketing tools and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business. There are three things for me that really stood out about Squarespace. First, mobile optimized websites. All websites are optimized for mobile. Content automatically adjusts beautifully, so your site looks great on any device. Second, email campaigns. Squarespace makes it super easy to grow and engage your audience with Squarespace email campaigns, so you don't need any other tools or providers. Such a relief on that one. And finally, SEO tools. You've got to be found on search engines. And Squarespace takes the guesswork out of SEO, so you'll get found by more people more often. And if that wasn't good enough, head over to Squarespace.com/20vc.
2:56 Harry Stebbings? Not only do you get a free trial, but when you're ready to launch, use the offer code 20vc to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or a domain. But now I'm so excited to hand over to the one and only Kyle Harrison, General Partner at Contrary.
3:14 Speaker 01 You have now arrived at your destination.
3:17 Harry Stebbings? Kyle, I'm so excited for this. I heard so many great things. I also love your writing. It's one of my favorite pieces of writing in venture. So first, thank you so much for joining me today.
3:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, thanks for having me.
3:27 Harry Stebbings? Not at all. I've been excited for this one, especially when I saw your suggestions for the show. But I want to start with a little bit on you. So many great firms you've worked at, but how did you first make your way into the world of venture? And most recently come to be a GP at Contrary?
3:39 Speaker 02 My journey is very circuitous. I didn't know anything about venture startups growing up. I was obsessed with film. And so when I got to school, my original major was actually filmmaking. My magnum opus that I created, you can still find on YouTube, was Pokemon Love Song. So I was very into film and videos and I was paying for college, doing wedding videos and commercials and things like that. So that focus on film was a big part of my life. And then eventually got to the point where I had too many clients. And so I just started farming them out to other creatives. I'd take 2% on whatever they would make. And before I knew it, I realized I was much better at getting jobs than I was at making videos. And so I kind of transitioned to that as a full-time job. And I joke that I was running a creator marketplace long before it was cool. But I had
4:20 Speaker 02 I built this really crappy website. I expanded to graphic designers and photographers and I was helping them get jobs and do all these different things. So that was my first exposure. I didn't even know to call that a startup. You can ask my wife for the entire time I ran it. Basically, I called it a project. I was just working on a project because I was so used to a job being a very different thing. Eventually, I ended up selling that business and I was trying to figure out what to do next. I was talking to a friend and they said, well, what did you like most about running your company? And I said, I love being this resource for these passionate people who are running their, building their own businesses. And I love that they could rely on me and I could go help knock down walls for them or find answers for them or whatever. And my friend said, well, that's sort of what venture capitalists do. And I said, well, I don't know what those words mean when placed together. And I sort of stumbled backwards into the world of venture. I'd been running my company in Utah.
5:04 Speaker 02 Worked for a seed fund called Kickstart in Utah, and that was kind of my education in venture. But that's what led me out to the Bay Area. Eventually, I wanted to see more than just seed investing. I wanted to see lots of different companies. And so jumped to the Bay Area and worked at firms like TCV and Co2 and Index. And eventually Contrary is where I decided to hang them a hat and be able to put my fingerprints on something and actually help build something.
5:26 Harry Stebbings? It's rather a shame you don't actually have one of these because then we could both be kind of hanging up. Got to love a TikTok audience, but I do, I'm doing a very weird thing today because normally we obviously have a quick fire at the end. But you've worked, as you said, TCV, Index, Co2 in quite a short amount of time, Kyle. So my question to you is, we're going to go through each one and just go for one lesson from each and how it changed your mind in a quick fire. So if we start with TCV, lesson and how did it shape your mindset?
5:54 Speaker 02 TCV, then Co2, then Index. It's a real smattering of opportunities. TCV, I was very drinking from the fire hose. When I was there, it was very much like a private equity style of investing. It was really looking for diamonds in the rough. And the people at TCV were never afraid to get their hands dirty. For me, that really changed my perspective of what it means to be an investor. I never really liked the memification of venture because my whole career, I've had this like, we do the work attitude that I learned at TCV. I don't ever feel like I would passively say, hey, let me know how I can be helpful. I just started doing stuff and then I go to the founder and I say, hey, I did. This and that and is that your top priority? If not, redirect me. What else can I do? And that was definitely a big part of TCV.
6:35 Harry Stebbings? So that's TCV. What was the learning from Index?
6:38 Speaker 02 Well, let's do Co2 because that was the order. I feel like I actually like my journey in order. If I could have written the book, this is how I would have written it.
6:45 Harry Stebbings? Hit me, Co2, what was the lesson from Co2?
6:48 Speaker 02 Again, it's very hedge fund style of investing, right? If TCV was the private equity, Co2 was the hedge fund. Hedge funds are very intense. They're very competitive inside and out. But one of the most eye opening things that I learned was not just, hey, we get in and we do work, but we do work in markets that matter and after opportunities that matter. At Co2, I learned this idea from Thomas LaFonte. He called it TAM arbitrage. It's this idea that if you can do the work and understand the market better than anyone else and appreciate that it's actually bigger than anybody else gives it credit for, that can help you pay higher prices. Sometimes that can come back to bite you, but if markets really do turn out to be larger than anybody else gave them credit for, not only can you pay higher prices, you can get more aggressive with burn. You can grow more quickly. You can experiment a lot more because you have a more fundamental understanding of the market. And it's kind of the Buffett-ism, right?
7:33 Speaker 02 If a good manager meets a bad business, it's the reputation of the business that remains intact. I think the same way about a market. If a really good founder goes and tackles a really crappy market, that market's still going to be crappy. The question marks are going to be around that founder's ability to tackle a market if it's not big enough.
7:47 Harry Stebbings? Final one then, Index. How did that shape your mindset?
7:51 Speaker 02 The way that I think about Index, it's a little bit different. For me, I felt like Index was like graduate school in venture capital. Venture, if I had to sum it up, venture is meant to be studied. And while I was at Index, there were good and bad things. I started to appreciate how much you have to actually treat your effort as something to be studied and learned from postmortems. And there is an actual psychology and study that every firm should apply to what they do, good and bad.
8:18 Harry Stebbings? You know, one of the biggest bits of bullshit advice I think there is, which is, don't worry, no one really knows what they're doing. To me, this is complete crap. People do know what they're doing, which is why they're often where they are. And you should learn from them and seek them out. Do you agree or do you take the ever changing circumstance and time you do you style?
8:36 Speaker 02 Everybody knows what they're doing. The reason people say stuff like that is that, ah, nobody knows what they're doing. We're all just kind of making stuff up as we go. Is everyone's trying to soften the blow of being wrong, but there are people who are exceptional at what they do. And there are people that are repeatedly really bad at what they do. And I think the biggest difference between those people is that the people who get really good are the people who learn and grow and pay attention to how they do stuff. And then they get better at it. And so those people do know what they're doing. Not only what they're doing, what they're trying to accomplish. But they know they're capable of their craft and their skill because they've studied it. I feel like that makes the biggest difference.
9:10 Harry Stebbings? I want to start on the current landscape that we have in venture today. And you've said before differentiation is going to kill the long tail of so-so venture firms. What did you mean by this?
9:21 Speaker 02 So Josh Wolfe made this prediction back in February. He said that in his prediction, between fifty and seventy-five percent of active investors in the private markets are just going to disappear within the next few years. What is a so-so venture firm? What is differentiation really? People are starting to care more and more about the holistic character of these institutions that they work with. People care a lot more about what the identity of this firm is. And I think founders are progressively going to look for more distinct characteristics in the firms that they work with. And I define that as differentiation is how capable is somebody externally able to articulate you as a firm? And if you can't answer that question very clearly, it's going to get harder and harder and harder.
10:02 Speaker 02 And so I think the ways that firms look to differentiate themselves is going to get progressively more interesting.
10:07 Harry Stebbings? I think that what we're seeing actually is kind of the disarming of firm power and the migration towards individual and partner power. And so the ways in which firms differentiate themselves, I actually don't think will change very much. Or I don't think will change as significantly as the ways in which partners will try to. Recent example of this is Logan Bartlett, obviously, who's done actually a very good job building his personal brand. But I think it's the partner characteristics that will change much more rapidly and significantly than firm. And I think we're seeing that now with founders choosing partners, not firms.
10:38 Speaker 02 I would agree with that. And this was one of my first articles that really blew up was the unbundling of venture capital. And the evolution was sort of this three. Three phases of how firms have been structured. There are subtle changes that are happening. You have these monolithic brands, the old school sixty, seventies, eighties, whatever. You've got the Kleiner Perkins and the Sequoias and stuff like that. And you almost abstract away the partners. It's focused on this, almost like a bank, this monolithic institution. The next phase of that progression was sort of what I call these fiefdoms, Andreessen's crypto arm, right? Or Sequoia China or whatever. You have these sort of pockets that exist. But by and large, they have a Chris Dixon who is the leader of that fiefdom. Progressively, that has continued to abstract even further to the point where now what I prefer to do in my writing is the renegades of venture.
11:22 Speaker 02 But my definition of what it means to be a renegade in venture does not have to mean that it's this like radically different model or it's venture debt two point O or whatever. It doesn't have to be crazy. It is a Logan Bartlett, right? It is somebody who is changing the way that they define themselves. You are a perfect example of that and what you've built with your firm. I mean, you have a vibe. It's more about these vibes that people feel.
11:44 Harry Stebbings? I want to know about so so venture funds. I want to understand what do you define as so so venture firms? What makes them average to you?
11:51 Speaker 02 I joke, it's kind of the line where they say, we know that half of our marketing budget is wasted. We just don't know which half. Probably eighty percent plus of venture funds are not great. We just don't always know which ones they are. In my mind, the characteristics that I look at when I think about like, what does it mean to be so so? The three buckets that kind of come to mind for me, I mean, one is it's pretty straightforward. It's economic performance. And Doug Leoni said this to you last September. It's a quote that I use a lot where he talks about the two most important things are number one, performance and number two teamwork. But if we don't have number one, nothing else matters. So it doesn't matter what three or four or whatever is, performance is critical. And and there are firms out there and it definitely, it takes a long time for these things to sort of catch up with you.
12:31 Speaker 02 But there are firms out there that even in this massive bull market that we've had, they have not returned enough capital to be able to justify the carry that they've paid out to partners. Like there are economic models that are going to crumble under the pressure of the market that we're going into now. The other piece of it is cultural. Culture can kill firms. There's definitely examples of that. And I think that there are even many well regarded firms that outside in people would think are great, but internally they're eating each other and eventually that. Spills out into the work, it impacts their performance. And then the third just being branded is what we're talking about. This is also a Logan Bartlett joke, right? As we talk about how as VCs, we invest in these firms that have durable competitive modes. When venture firms have, it's largely brand, right? It's largely that competitive advantage that comes from a brand.
13:15 Speaker 02 But I feel like in my mind, it's this idea that market correction in particular, it didn't take very long for a lot of bad behavior to start coming out. The bull market has hidden a multitude of sins of venture firms haven't had to be super aggressive in certain ways. Within a few months, you started seeing things like firms jeopardizing a company's survival, holding up funding rounds, demanding specific provisions be met, whatever. That behavior is going to get out too. Like, we're talking about the positive side of building a brand, but the negative side of brand and bad behavior, that can kill you too.
13:42 Harry Stebbings? I think it's threefold. It's fundamentally discovery. Do you have an innovative way to continuously and reliably discover the best generation of companies? Great example of this would be a Y Combinator on the very early stage, a Sequoia on the very early stage with their innovations around scout programs around ARC. I think they've actually productized discovery continuously very, very well. Discovery is number one for me. Picking and winning is number two. Do you have an innovative way? Or do you have a better decision-making process around picking and winning? Benchmark in particular. When they all want to win a deal, their circulation around a founder and their convincing is unparalleled. And then helping, how do you help founders in a better and more scalable way?
14:23 Harry Stebbings? I think performance is an output and it's the inputs there which make the output what it is. And I think my biggest concern today is actually what we should be concerned about, Carl, which is these so-so venture firms are going to continuously get funding because they're still getting DPI on Lyft IPO-ing last year and sending cash back to their investors, even though they're shit and the last time someone went to them for funding was in 2012. And so what next question is, I get you on everything that you said and I agree with everything that I said. We're on the same page, but it takes so long for a venture firm to die and they've delivered DPI. Will they not just continue with another 10 years?
15:01 Speaker 02 I don't disagree with that. I wrote this article a few months ago called The Death of a Venture Fund. I went and interviewed a bunch of people. It is actually inspired by Roloff and he was talking about this exercise that they do at Sequoia where they say, "All right, the group of us in this room, imagine that we presided over the decline of Sequoia. What happened? What did we do wrong?" That sort of pre-mortem evaluating what could cause the death of a firm like Sequoia. I dug into that and I think venture has a lot of main character energy, number one. Number two, we're getting to internet time. So maybe it took multiple decades for a firm to die in the 60s and 70s and whatever 80s. I think that that pace is going to increase. Information gets disseminated more quickly. Companies scale more quickly, for better or for worse, venture firms have an impact on them.
15:44 Speaker 02 All of those things are going to happen faster and faster. The thing that we have to do is to skate where the puck is going to be or whatever, right? But I think the rate of death can increase. It's not going to be-
15:54 Harry Stebbings? The rate of death, sorry, the rate of death only increase in velocity if the structure of funds changes fundamentally.
16:02 Speaker 02 I think it's a question of like LP perspective. LPs are fundamentally very stable and secure and Sally principle, right? Same as last year, what have we done?
16:11 Harry Stebbings? And loyal. When people send cash back, they feel obligated to then return cash back for the next fund. It's very difficult for the LP, to be fair on them, to get three X funds returned and then go, "Thanks Kyle, not coming back for the new one." It's very hard to do.
16:26 Speaker 02 I think that is the reason for me why I am more interested in trying to build something. I think that the difficulty is unseating anybody who is really powerful.
16:36 Harry Stebbings? Once you get to that Andreessen stage, it is joyous because you get to the LP mindset of, "It doesn't matter about performance, I just won't get fired and I get credit for being in them." Once you're in that hailed ground, it is absolutely joyous. The reason for this is LP incentive structures. They're largely salaried and bonused. They're not really aligned in terms of carry, performance-based. And so of course you would invest in and get a 1.6 X and do contrary and potentially get a 7 X. Because they might get fired if you guys break up and hate each other. If Andreessen doesn't work out, they got into Andreessen, well done, well done. Shame it didn't work out. So what do we need to see change in terms of LP incentives to fundamentally change this?
17:19 Speaker 02 I think that the sources of wealth will change. It's actually the family office circuit is a fascinating world. The ways that people make their money and the people who are brought in to help manage that money. For whatever reason, I've kind of stumbled into this family office institutional allocation world on Twitter. And you pay attention to what those folks are saying. And progressively more and more family offices, the way they allocate their capital, they want to do things differently. I think we're still at like the very earliest inflection point. But I feel like some of those things are going to start to change in terms of the way that people want to manage that capital. I do see the like, we want to try direct investing angle. I think there's enough folks that get burned that it's not something that is like, becomes a consistent part of their strategy. I think it's like an ebb and flow thing.
18:01 Speaker 02 And I think that you're seeing a lot of these pretty well-established institutional people start to take over some of these shops. And I think that there's gonna be an upset. Again, the question is where is that going to shake out? What is it going to look like? My hope is that there is something changing. It feels like there's enough indications that something is changing.
18:17 Harry Stebbings? Again, Contrary does a 50x fund, shoots it out of the park and here's your family office today, Kyle. How would you structure it and what would you do in terms of your approach to direct fund investments? How would you do it?
18:29 Speaker 02 So number one, there is diversification, right? I do actually think that there is an opportunity to invest in lots of different things. I really liked the episode you did with Will. You talk about the sort of venture firms that aren't really venture firms. And so I think that number one, there is a more disciplined approach to diversification. Number two, when you think about allocating capital to venture, some of the things that you talked about, right? Which is looking for allocators that have these characteristics of being able to identify their unique funnel. But I think the biggest thing for me would be focusing on where the biggest pockets of high-quality people are congregating. Still always the halo effect where any founder, regardless of their previous affiliations, are going to go where those halo effects exist. For me, it is all about allocating to who has access to these pockets of people, these communities of people.
19:14 Speaker 02 And how are they building really deep, long-term relationships with those folks? Because I feel like a lot of firms right now benefit from here and there, deep relationships that continue to compound. But it's not just about how do you take a top of funnel of all companies? But how do you build a product that stays close to those people throughout their lives? Because I think there's a really exciting opportunity to be able to identify multiple points along an individual's life cycle. To be able to engage with and allocate capital different ways beyond just, hey, how do we have the best top of funnel?
19:41 Harry Stebbings? I want to touch on the network and the community there because you mentioned it. You said before, it will get more focused on deep personal relationships as a landscape and as a like, what will make one win? What does more deep personal relationships actually mean? What does like community actually mean in venture? The kind of fluffy words respectfully that are thrown around a lot. How do you actually think about it in practice?
20:03 Speaker 02 The idea was sort of born out of this article by David Perel called Naked Brands. And he goes through all these examples of ways that different sort of industries are changing. So he talks about like fashion and sports and media and how people are progressively transitioning to trust more in people that they can empathize with versus just like brands that they can trust. So it's like progressively less about Coca-Cola and more about like LeBron James or whatever. This essence of vibes that people give off. But the idea, I think, is that every individual investor, every firm, like they're trying to articulate, what job are you hiring me for, right? This sort of jobs to be done framework from Clayton Christensen. I think that those deeper personal relationships are going to come from the way that people present themselves online and then being able to attract
20:47 Speaker 02 the right people that want to have a relationship with you.
20:49 Harry Stebbings? Who do you think has done that best?
20:51 Speaker 02 I'm not going to toot your horn. You're doing pretty good. The move into TikTok was spades. That was pretty good. There's also this element of community. I think that there are people who do community really well. I look at Y Combinator and there's no question that they've built a generational community. Folks like Gary and Steph stepping into that role, like I think that they're going to continue to just be amazing. The opportunity that exists right now is to create like an ongoing relevance in the relationship that you have with somebody. It's not a one and done kind of thing, right? Even Y C, most people talk about it like, yeah, I was in the summer 2020 cohort or whatever. But to stay relevant, like that's a relationship. To be part of a program, it's sort of you're in it and then you're out of it. And oh, what fond memories we have. To stay relevant throughout someone's life, that's having a relationship with them because you continue to be relevant to them.
21:35 Speaker 02 Candidly, I don't know that anybody is doing that well.
21:37 Harry Stebbings? I think about it in terms of frequency, which is frequent and often and then infrequent but like higher quality. And then we look at these two different landscapes. The one I admire the most is the infrequent because it's hard to do infrequent brand well. And when we look at who does that well, it was Bill Gurley when Bill Gurley was writing and obviously now he tweets more. But he released few posts, but when he did, they were seismic. Ravi Gupta at Sequoia releases few posts, but when he does, they really, really hit. Same with Pat Grady and both at Sequoia, but he did fifteen lessons from ten years at Sequoia. It fucking hit so well. Again, very infrequent. On the frequent side for me, Elizabeth at Hustle Fund.
22:20 Harry Stebbings? She has scaled quite a following, very sustainably with a lot of volume, consistently done very well. I think those two for me, like three, really stand out. I'm intrigued. I think venture funds brand themselves terribly. Do you agree and why do you think yes or no?
22:37 Speaker 02 I think that the center of gravity has shifted, to your point, largely to the individual investors. And I think there's very few firms that have kept up with that shift in the center of gravity. Firms that are trying to push forward the almost celebrity, if you will, of the individuals. That's a powerful dynamic. I think it's one of the reasons why anybody with a reasonably sized Twitter following probably gets at least job interest, if not a job offer from Andreessen, right? Like they recognize that sort of micro celebrity appeal of being able to hire anybody who has even remotely a sizable following. So I think that they are trying to tack on to that shift. I don't think anybody has done it well because it feels uncomfortable. Like it feels uncomfortable to have this like quote unquote brand.
23:20 Speaker 02 When today, most of the way that people want to interact with institutions is they want to interact with people knowing that the institution has something that has backing, right? But it's like that person represents the vehicle in that stuff. You don't want to necessarily be interacting with this faceless, monolithic brand. But most firms' marketing efforts have not kept up with that shift in gravity.
23:39 Harry Stebbings? I do just want to ask one final thing on the communities. I agree on like the YC of the world, but that's one very distinct. Have we really seen other venture firms try and build communities? And if so, what's the difference between those that have worked and those that haven't?
23:52 Speaker 02 The short answer is, we've seen them try. We haven't seen very many succeed. Some examples of this, Andreessen has some of these where they have Slack channels where they'll take the CROs of all their companies and dump them into Slack channel. It's not a good community. It's an attempt at trying to coalesce people into buckets, but it's not a good attempt. And so your question around like, what does it mean to make a successful community? In my perspective, and obviously I'm biased, contrary is, this is just our bread and butter. I mean, before we had a fund, we had a community of about a hundred future founders that we had met and were working with. And so we've always tried to emphasize this people-centric community. The reality of why it works is just like any product, if the customer is an afterthought, it's not going to hit. Like, it's not going to be a very good product if it's secondary to something else. Even from a community
24:37 Speaker 02 perspective, you talk about people's scout programs and stuff, those scout programs can be powerful. I think that you're going to see a lot of dilution in the value and quality of those scout networks progressively over time. And I think the biggest reason for that is because it is an afterthought. We plant this community with the hope that it leads to something else, which is deal flow or whatever. You're not necessarily super incentivized to make that community experience as high quality as possible. You're incentivized to get it to lead to something else. And then contrary, we talk about this a lot, where we are as focused on our community members as we are our portfolio founders, because we hope that eventually, one day, they become both, right? The focus is on people who will eventually be founders. We're going to help them at every phase of their career, so that when they become a portfolio founder, it's not that we suddenly shifted
25:21 Speaker 02 and we're like, oh, great, now we can stop exuding all this effort on them as community members and now really focus on them as portfolio founders. I don't think anybody has done that well, because community has always been an afterthought, not the core product.
25:32 Harry Stebbings? Y C, Y C obviously went from six hundred to now I think they've halved the batch size and they've got Gary back. I think this is like the biggest sign of strength from Y C. Are you with me? Do you think they've just completely regained all power from the unbundling? Because we did see this kind of splattering of the unbundling of accelerators, which I think now power retained concentrated centralized. Do you agree?
25:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think there's nothing like it. I think the biggest thing is that it's a compounding effect. No firm compounds the way that Y C does because it's so expansive and so involved in all these different aspects and can bring people into the, in these different ways. But I think like that compounding effect on Y C is not going anywhere.
26:11 Harry Stebbings? It's been kind of compounding effects and power. There was something that we went back and forth on before on emails and it was your concern about the Blackstone of innovation. I think it was really interesting kind of phrasing. What did you mean by the Blackstone of innovation? Why are you concerned about it?
26:26 Speaker 02 So I read the biography of Stephen Schwartzman, the founder of Blackstone a couple of years ago. And there's this quote that really struck me where he talks about how they build businesses. And the idea was basically like, if we come across the right person to scale a business in a great investment class, why not? We can apply our strengths, our network, our resources. They're so focused not on being like a very, we're not just a private equity firm, we're not this, we're not that, we're everything. And now they're effectively a holding company for financial asset class, right? Eight hundred billion of A U M, they've got private equity, real estate, hedge funds, credit funds, whatever. They think of it almost like exposure. I don't remember who, but somebody said this idea that like eighty percent or something of building a business is kind of the same thing across the board.
27:08 Speaker 02 It's that twenty percent that's super unique to the company and the market and the circumstances that is kind of the secret sauce. And if that is true, I feel like Blackstone has done a really good job of figuring out what the eighty percent is. Is they've just built this infrastructure that kind of A W S of raising capital and deploying capital towards X Y Z strategy. They figured that crap out and then they just focus on, hey, how do we go find that person who represents the secret sauce? That twenty percent and we plug them into the infrastructure, we let them go nuts and we just scale to this big thing. And I think that the firm that closely, most closely resembles that in venture is Andreessen. The way that they have approached.
27:42 Speaker 02 Things like gaming and crypto and biotech and so like that, but that's sort of them saying, hey, we have this fundamental infrastructure of brand, of thought leadership, of capital raising, whatever, portfolio support, whatever, if that's valuable. They have that infrastructure. And if they can take, to your point, if they can take 1.5, 2X return thresholds, people can park their money there and they can go take big bets, giving Adam Newman money for round two. It's just sort of this like massive calculus of we have this infrastructure, how do we bring in capital and deploy it at scale? Tiger, to some extent, tried to do that, though they may not have nailed the 20% specialty.
28:19 Harry Stebbings? Is this good for our ecosystem?
28:21 Speaker 02 One of the reasons I characterize it is something that concerns me because I think that capital allocation and portfolio construction, like those are macro activities. I have heard large multi-stage firms talk about things like, hey, you know, we've got 15% of the portfolio allocated to fintech. I'd like to get some more allocation in that. It's almost a hedge fund ask in the way they think about where are they allocating their portfolio and stuff. That's a very macro game. Company building is micro, especially in the earliest stages. It's people, it's lives, it's families, it's customers, it's jobs. And it's appropriate to have a certain level of abstraction when you're thinking about like, hey, like at the end of the day, this is a capitalist exercise. We're trying to take in capital and maximize the outcome of capital. Like, that's okay. It's okay to have that abstraction.
29:03 Speaker 02 At some point, if that abstraction gets so far removed from this sort of fundamental company building aspect. I think that you start to get into some dangerous territory because I mean, when those companies fail, when they get tons of capital and all this thing, and it's an exercise in portfolio construction and capital allocation and all this stuff. When those companies fail, it's a blip on the macro. That's okay because it's 35 billion of AUM or 800 billion of AUM or whatever. But on the micro, it's everything for a lot of those folks. And I think that abstraction causes some breaking points.
29:31 Harry Stebbings? I think also there's two things that are fundamental, which are hard to maintain, but I think many challenge to do so. Is number one, like you mentioned there with Blasto, find amazing people and move with them. I don't think all of the firms that we've mentioned, find amazing people and move with them. They move to the space that they like and then look for people. Very different, I think. And then number two, I think. Is the temporal diversification of product expansion, which sounds very nerdy. But what I mean by that is like earning the right to do the next financial product. And not doing five in two years, because what you do to your morale is fuck it overnight bluntly. And if you do it state, if contrary adds a new vehicle every three years.
30:11 Harry Stebbings? You can stage your culture progression in a much easier way than here's five new products. And I think that's a core challenge that I think some people have faced. My question to you here, though, is like, it gets to a stage with also fund sizes, Kyle. Where it's almost easier to raise two billion than it is two hundred million. And the reason I say that is because there is a pool of LPs, as you know, the pension funds of the world. Who need to move a hundred million, can't get into Sequoia, struggle to move that much into Famer's Fund, for sure. And so where do you go? There's not that many places. And so you have this finite supply of homes for your hundred to two hundred and fifty million. This is where it makes sense. Do you agree with that analysis?
30:54 Speaker 02 I agree with that. I think that one of the reasons for that is that for a long time, there was kind of this arbitrage in venture. Where especially, I mean, the internet is sort of the thing that this was the massive multiplier on all of these outcomes. And so nobody appreciated venture as a place where large amounts of capital could be effectively allocated to maximize returns. I think there was an arbitrage that existed where people could, they had shockingly big outcomes. And over time, people have realized how big those outcomes can be and have paid more and more attention to it, which has attracted more and more capital. One of the reasons I get concerned about, and I understand the fundamental math that people are doing to say, hey, if I can allocate X amount of capital. If I can expect a certain rate of return, this is a place where I can park money and that's okay.
31:37 Speaker 02 The reason I am worried about the sort of excess capital is because there aren't really like guardrails or good standards of excellence before. It's again, this idea that enough money can hide a multitude of sins. Like, we've seen it over and over again of bad products, bad go to market, bad unit economics. Like, they can all be covered up just by having enough cash. And to your point, it's not that there's a lot of cash and it's being allocated to good managers who are going to do their best to invest that in really good companies. It's to whoever will take it to try and get exposure to this market. I worry about that for sure, because it also, it muddies the water for everybody else, right? When everybody has so much cash. We're seeing this pullback now with this market correction. It's sort of tapered some of that. But I don't think that that's going away. I don't think that people are just gonna say, oh, never mind. Venture is actually not that great of an asset class. Back to bonds and real estate.
32:22 Speaker 02 I think that people recognize that there are still large outcomes to be had here. And so there's still gonna be that excess of capital. And what we do with that and how companies react in that world, it's something that every company has to worry about.
32:33 Harry Stebbings? What are the biggest changes that you've seen post the correction that we've had over the last six months? I tweeted the other day about some trends I've observed. What are some big changes you've seen?
32:42 Speaker 02 The first one that comes to mind, what I would describe as suspension of your own criticism. I think we went through such a phase of people just pumping everything they possibly could, rampant intellectual dishonesty, all these different things. I thought that it would be more humbling for more people. I think that there's been this sort of like suspension of criticism. People are desperately trying to avoid having to come to grips with what they did over the last couple of years. That worries me a lot because I think that this is a great opportunity to sit back and reflect on what should we have done differently? What could you have done differently, whatever? So I think I expected a little bit more of the mea culpa, and there's not been much of that at all.
33:22 Speaker 02 The second thing I think is that companies are more thoughtful about what matters most in the way that they build their business from a storytelling perspective. I think that before it was just this idea that, hey, like, if you have a pulse and you have some indication of an interesting market or whatever, there's gonna be enough people that get jazzed. I've had a lot more conversations with founders, both in and outside of the portfolio, where we're talking about what should I focus on my business? And how can I articulate that to investors to indicate the quality of my business? It's not just about the big picture story, but it's about where should I be focusing to be able to articulate my story of why my unit economics are working? Or why my market is sizable, or why I do have product market fit, or whatever?
34:05 Speaker 02 There's more of that, where I feel like a lot of that was just swept under the rug because it was so focused on like how I tell just the biggest story I possibly can. That's another thing that comes to mind recently that I've seen.
34:14 Harry Stebbings? Have you seen pricing change?
34:15 Speaker 02 I have seen chickens with their heads cut off running around trying to figure out what the right price is. It's insane to me, the conversations I've had, especially because most of my bread and butter. Is not necessarily the pre-seed seed stuff. Contrary has done that by and large. I joined Contrary to help build out our ability to invest more in like Series A, Series B, Series C. And those companies that I'm working with, there is no rhyme or reason. There's no valuation. There's no thought process. There's no, there's certainly not a acceptance of down rounds for the most part. Beyond the very late Sage folks that are just engineering capital raises at this point. But in the stages that I work at, there's certainly not been an acceptance of down rounds. I'm shocked by the number of times I have a conversation with different founders.
34:56 Speaker 02 And I explain venture math, basically, like very, very back of the envelope, simple stuff where it's like, listen, if your valuation is this and your revenue is this, and if I look at the next five to seven years, and you have to go from where you are to hundreds plus millions of revenue, there's going to be a dilution along the way. So my ownership is going to be X. And when you get to that point, if you look at the public markets, they're trading at these ranges. And then you'll trade at those ranges. This will be our return. And that's the factor. Like if I can't get that math to work. Granted, there's so many ifs in that statement, but just doing the math is the sense check that you do to say, does this make sense?
35:34 Speaker 02 And for people who are doing these deals at multiple billions of dollars for companies that are generating sub 20 million of revenue or whatever, that math is really, really, really difficult to get to. And the number of founders who are like, that's just not a way that they think about things always surprises me because it's different math. But that's the math that people were sort of just like fudging and ignoring for the last couple of years. But it's a reality that's going to punch a lot of people in the face.
35:57 Harry Stebbings? Question, did you invest too fast in this boom period? And did you lose price sensitivity?
36:02 Speaker 02 I think at different points in time, I invested too fast. Price sensitivity, I think, is the thing. I would say that my bigger mea culpa that I look at is appreciating the weight of gravity of what it means to build a massive company. The number of models that we built to be able to justify certain valuations. The number of them scaling to over a billion dollars of revenue over the course of four or five years to say, well, if they scale to over a billion in revenue, then this is the return and it can be a very healthy return. And that's our base case. It's like, that's an insane base case. When I step back and think about how many companies in the literally hundreds of thousands of startups in the world, how many of them have scaled to over a billion dollars of revenue? Two hundred, three hundred or something, right?
36:47 Speaker 02 Like, it's a tiny fraction of companies that have truly gotten to that massive scale. And so when you step back and think about that, I think that was the thing that like I used too easily to just say, well, if we can paint the most optimistic financial picture, anything makes sense. And now I often find myself reflecting that and thinking like, I want to go compare this to like the companies that actually went up against gravity and did have to scale year after year after year after year, achieving growth rates and adding new customers and launching your product lines and something like that. What did that look like? And much more often than, I mean, it's crazy, the number of things that we've seen, Wiz talked about this and Deal talked about this, and there's a bunch of these companies that are like, hey, one of the fastest companies to get to a hundred million of ARR or whatever. And that's great. There are companies that can be those massive scalers, but by and large, when you look
37:31 Speaker 02 at those companies that have sort of defied gravity, they almost never do it in these explosive nonlinear paths. They're just compounders, like very quickly they get to that sort of maybe thirty, forty percent growth, and then they just crush it for a long time. You have the snowflakes of the world, but even Snowflake you look at, right? They're getting to two billion of revenue, insane, massive growth, eleven quarters of over a hundred percent growth. Eventually it tapers off and it's just, have you built an effective compounding engine or not? And I think that for me, that price insensitivity translated into not respecting or being reverential to how truly difficult it is to build one of those massive companies.
38:08 Harry Stebbings? Listen, I want to move into my favorite, which is a quick fire, Kyle. So I say a short statement, you give me your immediate thoughts. Does that sound okay?
38:15 Speaker 02 Sounds great.
38:15 Harry Stebbings? So what's your favorite book and why, Kyle?
38:18 Speaker 02 So I have on my personal website, this thing I call my Quake Books, the books that shook me. And so my most recent addition to that is this book, it's called Reinventing Knowledge by Ian McNeely. It got me obsessed with this idea about the Republic of Letters, basically just the study over history of the world has been changed largely through people writing personal letters, really smart people trading personal letters. And so now I'm obsessed with this Republic of Letters 2.0 where Twitter DMs are going to change the world.
38:44 Harry Stebbings? Who is the most underrated angel in the ecosystem and why them?
38:48 Speaker 02 So my favorite person to work with lately is Amjad Massad, the CEO of Replit. I mean, I think the guy is an oracle, like there's just a shortage of ambition in the world. And every founder could benefit from having Amjad on their cap table because he just brings such an ambitious perspective.
39:02 Harry Stebbings? How did you get involved in the Roma app community? I heard this was one I had to ask.
39:06 Speaker 02 I have been an obsessive note taker in my life. There's a scripture that I jokingly quote, it's whatsoever you record on earth shall be recorded in heaven. Like I am a dogmatic note taker and I'd never found something that worked the way my brain works. And I was watching this YouTube video with Thiago Forte and he was interviewing Connor. And I felt like I had stumbled on a prophet. I DM'd him, I had to talk to him, our first call, very unorthodox. It was, he was shotgunning whiskey and Red Bull and lighting a cigarette with a blowtorch. Definitely one of a kind founder call. I mean, I went on to do a hundred personal Rome tours because I just love the product so much. And I'm still to this day, an hourly active user.
39:42 Harry Stebbings? Tell me, what's your biggest miss and how did it change how you think?
39:45 Speaker 02 So back in the day, we passed on Coinbase, 1.5 billion. Still absent, you know, you look at the market cap, it's definitely a big up and down. For me, the reason I think about that pass specifically, that missed opportunity, the failure was a failure to imagine a colossal shift in user behavior. How big those shifts can be when they happen. And there's still a question to be had about what is going to happen. You know, we went through this crazy bull market, there was a lot of speculation. I think that it's still around to stay. For me now, when I think about my like, what do you have to believe equation? I try frequently to ask myself, what's something that I strongly believe right now? That I am probably wrong about and to try and constantly call into question those. Because I had such a strong belief in the consumer shift not happening for Coinbase and I think it has.
40:29 Harry Stebbings? Tell me, what's your biggest hit so far and how did it change how you think?
40:33 Speaker 02 For me personally, the biggest impact of an investment that I have made was a company called TeamShares. And it reminds me of a quote, I think it was with you, Keith Raboy, talking about, I measure success based on how many of my, my peers think I'm insane or laugh at me. So when I invested in TeamShares, it was a couple of people that idea. The idea was to basically buy small businesses, turn them into ESOPs and scale them. Almost like a holding company at scale with services and people thought of it as such, it was just like a private equity play or whatever. But effectively, it was this fintech mechanism to be able to make employee ownership of not tech companies, but of salt of the earth types of businesses and increasing that equity ownership that exists. And there was so much skepticism about that and that has, I mean financially, it's been very rewarding of an investment.
41:15 Speaker 02 But also just seeing this, what felt like to a lot of people a laughable idea, just execute incredibly well. That has reinforced my perspective as an investor to think about what are the things I actually believe in, not are just the things that I think people won't laugh at me about.
41:27 Harry Stebbings? Is the growth market better or worse in 12 months and why?
41:31 Speaker 02 The growth market is likely to be better in 12 months. Only if you see that shift, I talked about with founders, there has still, I think, not been a reality check of what valuations really mean fundamentally. If that reality check continues to occur, like I think if progressively founders recognize what that means, I think that the growth market can improve. It's going to come down to earth, valuations are going to be a lot lower. It's still going to be hard to fundraise, but it's not going to be what it is right now. What it is right now is you have two sides of the party. One, still convinced that they can get a billion dollar valuation. Before it was three to five million of revenue could get you a billion dollar valuation or pre-revenue. Now it's like, but we've got 10 million, we've got 15 million, we want a billion. That mentality. And then you've got a bunch of investors that are, again, sort of chickens with their head cut off, running around, having no idea how to price anything.
42:14 Speaker 02 Both of those things I think are going to improve over time. Investors are going to get more thoughtful about valuations. Founders are going to be more thoughtful about what does valuation mean to them? And what is success versus what they wish they could get?
42:24 Harry Stebbings? I find we're seeing like two different worlds in in growth, which is the 98% and the 2%. The 98%, it's a desert, you cannot raise, really challenging and hard. And then the 2%, there's this real concentration of capital or flight to safety, where there's very, obviously very brilliant companies, not Figma, but your Figma-esque of the world, which are guaranteed, as much as you can say guaranteed, to be very generational defining companies. And they will continue to be able to raise at very high prices, maybe a 10% discount, but not really. And you're seeing actually a concentration of capital to the 2% there, where it's much more concentrated. Do you agree with that?
43:00 Speaker 02 That's what I have seen. I think that there has yet to be a Company like that because even when you look at some of the high profile failures that we've seen, I don't know that any of them were, oh, my gosh, they were just the darlings, the high flying. I mean, even when people talk about stuff like Theranos, there's very few sort of traditional VCs involved in those. Like, it's very rarely the darlings. I think the only way that that fight to safety like gets rock is if there is something where you're like, I thought this was a, just a darling, like, everybody was convinced that this was a generational company, and it just absolutely imploded. I don't think we've seen that, which reinforces for people that fight to safety.
43:33 Harry Stebbings? What would you most like to change about the world of venture?
43:35 Speaker 02 I wish there was a better way to de-risk those earliest days of starting a company. I think that there are a lot of ambitious people sort of trapped in a systemic risk intolerance because of their circumstances or whatever, and I wish that we could lower the bar for that risk curve. It's scary because as a capital allocator, I have to think about risk management, and I have to be thoughtful about different risks. I try as hard as I can to not let my biases that exist, they exist for everyone, stop me. But I wish that we could de-risk that sort of journey into being able to build something.
44:02 Harry Stebbings? Final one, what's the most recent publicly announced investment, Kyle? And why did you say yes and get so excited?
44:08 Speaker 02 So I had the privilege of getting to lead an investment in Pave while I was at Index, and then to very quickly jump over to Contrary and be able to invest at Contrary as well. So Pave for context.
44:19 Harry Stebbings? The same round?
44:20 Speaker 02 The same round, yeah.
44:21 Harry Stebbings? I love that. That's brilliant.
44:23 Speaker 02 Worked it perfectly. So I'm a huge fan of these businesses that can take massive, critical corpuses of data and make them accessible and actionable, and then make it possible to build, they're going to become a new foundational layer upon which to build new things. So you think about like some of the investments I made, Ramp does this with expenses and receipts. Paki called it the transaction layer of a business. Toasted this on the restaurant ops side, Persona does this with user identity. So Pave does it with compensation data. So they've built this just massive database of compensation data for tech. And now that data, like, they can build on top of it in terms of like compensation planning and offer letters and all these different areas to give people more visibility into what the job market looks like. And over time, when you have that real time lens on the labor market in tech,
45:08 Speaker 02 the opportunities are pretty compelling. That's really difficult data to sort of wrap your arms around.
45:12 Harry Stebbings? What's the data entry and acquisition strategy there? Because obviously with Ramp, you have the core card and you have the core account, which then lends to the flow of the data, which is the transaction data, which you can then act on. Here, unless they're like the payroll provider, I don't understand where the data acquisition strategy on internal team salaries and compensation is.
45:29 Speaker 02 Their sort of Trojan horse is a give to get data model. So if you plug in any, and you could do this with your firm, any company can do this, where if you plug in your HRIS to be able to offer up your salary data and your cap table management to offer up equity data, you get access to their benchmarking module. So you can see all these different cuts of different salaries and stuff like that. So that's the data ingestion, is this sort of give to get, completely free. They've got over 600 different venture firms that are partners to be able to pull it, roll it out to their portfolio. It's on that foundation that they then build things that they monetize on, like compensation planning and stuff like that.
46:02 Harry Stebbings? Carl, listen, as you can tell, I've so enjoyed this. I love kind of freewheeling conversations like this. So thank you so much for putting up with me and I so appreciate the time today, my friend.
46:11 Speaker 02 Thanks for having me. It was fun.
46:14 Harry Stebbings? I love that as a discussion. As you can tell, I had quite a few thoughts there on Carl's ideas and it was really nice to have such a free flowing one away from the schedule. I want to thank Carl for being such a great guest on the show. If you'd like to see more from us, of course you can on twentevc.com. But before we leave you today, holiday gifting for your friends and family can be hard and for your business, it can be even harder. And Open helps companies of all sizes deliver better gifts and they make it super easy. Their platform is filled with best in class brands. There are no bad gifts ever. They source locally and operate globally. You don't even need an address. Simply send an email or DM with a unique gift link. Ready to put the ease and joy
46:53 Harry Stebbings? back into your company's gifting? Head over to andopen.co/20vc. That's andopen.co/20vc to get started today. And speaking of amazing tools, which really take complex processes and make them super easy, Angel List has been a key partner for me in managing my investments. I love using the Angel List platform because it abstracts away all the complexity and operational burden of fund management, whether you're running SPVs, a traditional venture fund like me, or even a rolling fund. Angel List has you covered. The team is also just exceptional. They're great, great partners. I'm also super excited about their new product though, Angel List Stack, which is purpose Built for founders. With Angel List Stack, you can create a fundraising-ready startup
47:35 Harry Stebbings? in just a few clicks. Angel List handles all your company's incorporation, banking, cap table, and fundraising process, all in a single place. This allows founders to really focus on building. If you're a founder, you can launch your company at stack.angellist.com/20vc. Whether you're a founder or a funder, you're in great hands with Angel List. And finally, from websites and online stores to marketing tools and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business. There are three things for me that really stood out about Squarespace. First, mobile-optimized websites. All websites are optimized for mobile. Content automatically adjusts beautifully, so your site looks great on any device. Second, email campaigns.
48:17 Harry Stebbings? Squarespace makes it super easy to grow and engage your audience with Squarespace email campaigns, so you don't need any other tools or providers. Such a relief on that one. And finally, SEO tools. You've got to be found on search engines, and Squarespace takes the guesswork out of SEO, so you'll get found by more people more often. And if that wasn't good enough, head over to Squarespace.com/20vc. Not only do you get a free trial, but when you're ready to launch, use the offer code 20vc to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or a domain. As always, I so appreciate all your support, and I can't wait to bring you a phenomenal episode on Monday with Emil Michael, former Chief Business Officer at Uber.
Previous 20 Sales: How To Structure The Interview Process for All Sales Reps, The Must-Ask Questions When Identifying Potential Sales Talent & The 3 Biggest Mistakes Founders Make When Hiring Their First Reps with Lauren Schwartz, VP of Enterprise Sales @ Fivetran Next 20VC: Uber's Journey to Becoming the Most Valuable Private Tech Company in History, Raising $3BN From Saudi in Just 60 Days, Uber's $30BN Mistake in Food Delivery, Why Recent Uber M&A Will be the Worst in Tech & Mastering Negotiations and Deal-Making with Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated