Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: The Most Powerful Investor You Might Not Know | Why The Distinction Between Public vs Private is BS | The Misalignments Between GPs and their LPs | Portfolio Construction 101: Diversification, Capital Concentration, Loss Rates with Peter Singlehurst About this episode Peter Singlehurst is the Head of Private Companies at Baillie Gifford. As of 31st March 2022, funds under Baillie Gifford's management and advice totaled £277bn. The firm is owned and run by 51 of its senior executives who operate as a partnership, a structure that has endured for over a century. As for Peter, he has been with Baillie Gifford since graduating from Durham University 12 years ago and has backed some astonishing breakouts such as Wise, Grammarly and Zymergen to name a few. In Today's Episode with Peter Singlehurst We Discuss: 1.) Entry into Venture: How Peter landed his role with Baillie Gifford straight out of university? Why does Peter and Baillie Gifford prefer to hire young people without backgrounds or studies in finance? Why do they tend to be better investors? What does Peter believe are the basic building blocks that can be taught in investing? What cannot be taught and needs to be learned with experience and time? 2.) The Biggest Misnomers and Misalignments in Venture: Why does Peter believe the distinction between public vs private markets is BS? Why does Peter believe it is an advantage to invest at the same time in both public and private markets? Why does Peter think there is an inherent misalignment in venture between GPs and their LPs? 3.) Baillie Gifford: Constructing a Portfolio with £277BN: How does Baillie Gifford approach portfolio construction today? How many lines do they want to have in their portfolio? What is the right level of diversification? How does Peter think about sizing each position? How does Peter think about capital concentration across rounds vs first check being the largest? How does Peter approach outcome scenario planning? How does Peter think about downside protection and loss rates? 4.) Peter Singlehurst: The Investor: How has Peter's investing style changed over the last 10 years? What has gotten easier? What has gotten harder? What is Peter's biggest miss? How did it change his approach? What is Peter's biggest hit? What did he learn and take from this? How did the crossover funds change and impact the way that later stage venture was conducted? Item's Mentioned In Today's Episode: Peter's Fave Book: The Myth of Sisyphus Peter's Most Recent Investment: Grammarly
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Harry Stebbings? We are back and this is 20VC with me, Harry Stebbings. And today we bring you a show with one of the most influential and successful firms in the investing world that you might not have heard of. Welcome, Bailey Gifford. As of the 31st of March 2022, funds under Bailey Gifford's management and advice totaled £277 billion. They also have an incredible structure to the firm. It is owned and run by 51 of its senior executives who operate as a partnership. Now, this structure has endured for over a century, and I'm so excited to say joining me in the hot seat from Bailey Gifford is Peter Singlehurst, Head of Private Companies at Bailey Gifford, where he spent the last 12 years investing in some game-changing companies from Grammarly to Wise and Zymogen, to name a few.
0:41 Harry Stebbings? I'd also want to say a huge thank you to Neil Warby Parker for some fantastic question suggestions today. But before we dive into the show today, I want to talk about an incredible tool that I use every single day, Notion. Now, I am the worst for having 50 tabs open and constantly hopping between an endless array of tools. Do you feel me? Are you with me? Well, then Notion came into my life, providing one tool to do it all, with everything from seamless project management to easily organising 20VC's company information. A fascinating stat on Notion usage, more than 70% of companies who start using Notion stop using two plus other tools. And so Notion can even save you money, given how many other tools it can displace. Notion has a worldwide network of millions of users, creating templates, tutorials and new inspiration.
1:25 Harry Stebbings? The product's getting better and better every single day, and you always have the support you need. Learn more and get started for free at notion.soh. Take the first step toward an organised, happy team today, again at notion.soh. And speaking of foundational infrastructure like Notion there, Angel List has been a key partner for me in managing my investments. I just love using the Angel List platform because it abstracts away all the complexity and operational burden of fund management. Whether you're running SPVs, a traditional venture fund like me, or a rolling fund, Angel List has you covered. I'm also super excited about their new product, Angel List Stack, which is purpose-built for founders. With Angel List Stack, you can create a fundraising-ready startup in just a few clicks. Angel List handles your company's incorporation, banking, cap table and fundraising process, all in one single
2:10 Harry Stebbings? Place and this allows founders to focus on building. If you're a founder, you can launch your company at stack dot angel list dot com forward slash two zero VC. Whether you are founder or a funder, you're in great hands with Angel List. And finally, from websites and online stores to marketing tools and analytics. Squarespace is the all in one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business. There are three things for me that I just love about Squarespace. First, mobile optimized websites. All websites are optimized for mobile, content automatically adjusts. So it just is really beautiful on any device. Second, email campaigns. Squarespace makes it super easy to grow and engage your audience with Squarespace email campaigns. Say what? No other provider needed? Amazing news. Finally, SEO tools.
2:54 Harry Stebbings? Squarespace takes the guesswork out of SEO. So you'll get found in search by more people more often. And if that wasn't good enough, go to squarespace dot com forward slash two zero VC for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use the offer code two zero VC to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or a domain. That is quite enough from me though. So now I'm so excited to hand over to the one and only Peter Singlehurst, head of private companies at Bailey Gifford.
3:24 Speaker 01 You have now arrived at your destination.
3:27 Harry Stebbings? Peter, I'm so excited for this. I've been looking forward to this one for a very long time, actually. So I'm thrilled that we could do it and thank you so much for joining me today.
3:34 Speaker 02 Thank you for having me, Harriet. It's a pleasure to be here.
3:36 Harry Stebbings? Well, listen, I'm super excited for the discussion, but I do want to start on you because Bailey Gifford is a really fascinating organisation. So I want to hear, how did you make your way into the world of investing and come to be at Bailey Gifford and in the investing world?
3:48 Speaker 02 In short, somewhat by accident. My academic background was in philosophy. I did a masters in philosophy, looking mainly at 20th century European philosophers. Finished my masters, didn't really know what to do, but heard about this thing called investment management. This firm called Bailey Gifford didn't quite like the idea of living in Edinburgh. So I applied for the graduate training scheme, which is how pretty much all of our investors at Bailey Gifford start. A lot of people go and spend their entire careers here and it's a partnership owned by people who started their careers on the graduate training scheme. So when I first joined Bailey Gifford, it was really just the public market. Investment firm. I spent time on various public teams and then ended up on a team called the Long Term Global Growth Team within Bailey Gifford,
4:28 Speaker 02 which sort of does exactly what it says on the tin. And it was round about this time that we started seeing more of the businesses that we'd sort of always invested in, high-growth companies staying private longer. We sort of thought that maybe this was a structural change that was happening. We thought that maybe actually the process of analyzing these companies might be pretty similar to the process of analyzing a lot of the public companies that we'd always invested in, and that maybe we might be able to access some of these companies because, well, these were really the businesses we'd always invested in, these kind of pretty substantial, high-growth companies. We set off doing that from within a permanent pool of capital that we've managed for the last hundred and fourteen years, called the Scottish Mortgage Fund, confusingly named, it's got nothing to do with mortgages. It's a hundred-year-plus permanent pool of capital. And we set about trying to do things a bit differently.
5:11 Speaker 02 So being very long-term within this evergreen fund, being very low cost in terms of the fees that we charged our clients for investing in these companies, and doing it in such a way that was really joined up between our private and public company investing activities. So that's how we started doing this, and we created a dedicated team in two thousand and seventeen, which has continued to grow. We've continued to deploy more of our clients' capital into high-growth private companies, and I think increasingly we're cognizant that it's strategically important for how we invest for all of our clients, public and private. And I think that sort of joined-up approach is sort of integral really to how we operate.
5:46 Harry Stebbings? There is so much for me to unpack there. I want to start with actually something, though, that you said before we started this recording, which was, I don't consider myself a venture capitalist. That's pretty interesting to say, and it's novel for me to hear on Twenty VC. Why don't you consider yourself a VC, Peter?
6:02 Speaker 02 In my mind, venture capital means very early-stage investing. It means backing the sort of proverbial two people and a dog and an idea in a garage. And that's not what we do. We invest in, I guess, kind of mid- and late-stage, high-growth private companies, companies where you can have a real conversation about what the business model looks like and a company's competitive advantage. To me, that's sort of more growth investing, that's fundamental company analysis. And we're not operationally involved with companies either. So that's why I don't call it what we do. Venture capital. We're not sort of pretending or aspiring to do or be what those early stage investors. We're trying to be a bit different and we're trying to be a long term partner for our companies, transcending the private and into the public markets over timeframes that I think are unfamiliar to most investors,
6:47 Speaker 02 but are very familiar to us, given the longevity of our organisation and the philosophy that we've always pursued.
6:53 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, I mean, that 114 year timeframe really does trump most people.
6:58 Harry Stebbings? Before we dive into the public versus private kind of merging, I do want to touch on the background though, because you said about your background there and kind of studying philosophy. And then when we spoke before, you said very few people at Bailey Gifford have financial backgrounds. Why is that? And what do you think are the benefits of this mindset coming into investing?
7:15 Speaker 02 The belief that we have is that there are some basic tools that you need to do investing, what sort of an account's look like, how to do some sort of fairly basic valuation techniques. And we can teach those pretty quickly when people join. Then there's a whole lot of stuff that you can only learn through experience and doing the job. But what you can't teach is cognitive diversity. So the reason we hire from a range of academic backgrounds is because we bring in people with lots of different perspectives on the world, rather than hiring people who grew up dreaming of being fund managers, where you might well end up with a fairly narrow perspectives on the world.
7:50 Harry Stebbings? That's why Bailey Gifford never offered me a job. I do want to dive into the public versus private though, because to me, we joked before, but everything that I buy, you should short. I'm the world's worst public markets investor and they're so paradoxical in my mind. So tell me, why do you think that actually the framing shouldn't be so different for public versus private? Why do you not believe in segregating the two like this?
8:15 Speaker 02 I really think that the public private divide is an artefact of the financial universe, rather than anything that you would come up with if you were thinking about investment or company formation from first principles. When you think about what matters for a good business, a big addressable market, a great management team, a robust competitive advantage, a fantastic business model, well, these things are true, whether you're talking about private or public companies. And the only thing that changes when a business Goes from being private to being public is that its shares start trading in a slightly different way. I don't think there's really much information in that that tells you that you should delineate investing on those terms. So we just try to look for great companies and own them for a really long time. And try to break down what we believe is this artificial divide between public and private businesses.
8:59 Harry Stebbings? What are the benefits of being able to invest in both public and private to you and not having this quite blinkered mindset of public versus private?
9:08 Speaker 02 I think it's really a question of the whole being greater than the sum of its parts. There are enormous benefits that we get as private investors by working alongside our public market colleagues every day. We get an incredible sourcing advantage because we source through the hundreds of public companies and executives and founders that we work with. We get to benefit from the analytical insights of our hundred and twenty public market investors. And we can draw them into our privates, our analysis of private businesses. And then we get to bring the benefits of the scale of being a fairly large public market organisation. And supporting companies over their journey, not just privately, but potentially with greater sums of capital into the public markets as well. So it's enormously beneficial for us as private investors. For our public teams, they basically get a window into the future.
9:51 Speaker 02 They get to see the businesses that will be in the public markets over the next five or 10 years. And just get insight and understanding and relationships with those companies that you could never get if you weren't an active participant in the private markets. I think it's also beneficial for the companies we back because we can be this long term provider of capital over their journey. And it's beneficial for our clients because we give them continuity of ownership and access to these companies at low fees. Rather than maybe them being in a private market manager's mandate, disappearing out of that mandate when a company becomes public. And then reappearing in a public market manager's portfolio. I think really all this kind of boils down to better alignment, better alignment between ourselves and the companies we bank. But also with the clients whose capital we're responsible for.
10:33 Harry Stebbings? Do you think traditional financial funds are aligned to their LPs?
10:36 Speaker 02 I think they start off aligned, but I think that when you get into the tail years of limited life funds. I worry that you start to get misalignments of interest. I also worry that traditional carried interest structures can drive. Misalignments of interest because of the value that can flow to individual investors from crystallizing and exit, even if actually what you should really be doing is continuing to own that business for much, much longer because it's a company that can continue to compound for years and years and years.
11:04 Harry Stebbings? Why is that misalignment in the later ends of a fund's life, sorry?
11:07 Speaker 02 I think it's partly because you have these set of incentives around fundraising cycles. So you want a traditionally structured venture council or private equity manager incentivized to distribute capital. In distributing capital, they collect carried interest, so they take quite a lot of the returns. And then they go back to those LPs and they say, hey, we distribute to that capital. We're raising a new fund, can you put it into our new fund? And it's this sort of cycle of fundraising, distribution, collection of carried interest, which doesn't necessarily align with the sort of logic of investment returns of finding great businesses and owning them for a really long time.
11:41 Harry Stebbings? I want to touch on a couple of things that you mentioned before. You mentioned kind of fundamentals and first principles thinking. You mentioned market size. I'm always troubled by this. Should one do outcome scenario planning, thinking about how big this could be? Knowing that actually in your winners, you always underestimate how big it could be. So is it worth doing at all?
12:00 Speaker 02 I think it's worth doing within the context of probabilities. And this is how we think about valuation upside. We create scenarios in which we are deliberately contrived, where a company can be a very high returning business and a high returning investment for our clients. We think about the probabilities, all of the things that would have to come to pass for that to be the case. And then we look and test the probabilities that you would have to ascribe to that. But whenever you do that, there are many different things that go into it. It's the size of the market, but it's the financial characteristics of the company. It's the robustness of the competitive advantage, which will be a direct input into the returns the business can make, the amount of capital it will require, the returns on equity it can make. So I think it's trying to understand these things holistically and in the round, imagining that you will be an owner of this company for a really, really long time,
12:45 Speaker 02 rather than saying, well, this thing will go public and somebody will pay a multiple of X, Y, Z, which is higher than the multiple that I paid, and that's how I'll make money.
12:52 Harry Stebbings? Okay, I've learned over time to actually say what I think in shows because I used to just agree all the time. I don't really get it. And what I don't really get. Is the competitive advantage element because I think defensibility is built over time and in ways that you just can't anticipate. It could be data defensibility, it could be network effects that were unanticipated. So I look at businesses and I'm just like, is the founder a fucking machine? Yes or no? Because you just don't know what form of moat network will be built. So how do you think about the accuracy with which you can actually anticipate competitive advantage?
13:27 Speaker 02 I would actually completely agree with that. We are not trying to accurately nail down what a company's competitive advantage is or will be. Actually, if you look at the reports we write, the analysis that we do on competitive advantage, it looks more like meditative essay than a set of assertions. And we try to think about these things dynamically as well. It's not interesting to us what the company's competitive advantage is today. It's the set of hypotheses and the conviction you can have in that in how that competitive advantage can evolve as the company grows and how it can get better as it gets bigger.
13:58 Harry Stebbings? The other thing is like long-term financial partner. I love that. What if you lose faith in the company and the founder? It can happen and it's sad and sometimes you can gain faith and gain more confidence, but what happens if you lose faith? Are you on the hook for it? Like, how do you think about that?
14:13 Speaker 02 I mean, I suppose it slightly depends whether the company is still private or public. And if it's still private, we would not put more money into that capital. And if it's public, we would probably look to sell it. That sort of long-term hold is not unconditional. It's conditional upon execution, performance and the delivery of returns for our clients. In a way, though, those aren't the difficult ones where you've lost faith, like those are quite straightforward decisions. It's where you don't quite know why something isn't working out, whether it's not clear, whether it's the team or set of external factors, which will write themselves for whatever reason. Those are the really agonizing decisions. It's where it's not quite clear why something isn't working and you're faced with the question of whether to put more capital to work into those businesses.
14:54 Harry Stebbings? Cliff, what do you do then?
14:56 Speaker 02 You agonize.
14:57 Harry Stebbings? And which side do you tend to fall on more often? Concentrate capital, knowing that actually you backed it for a reason, continue to support or be cautious?
15:06 Speaker 02 I think we probably fall more often on the side of continuing. To back businesses and sometimes those are the best decisions we ever make and sometimes they're the worst decisions we ever make. But founders and companies will more often find us leaning on the side of supporting, though that's not unconditional. And there are plenty of examples where we don't support in those difficult circumstances. If we believe that the situation cannot be changed.
15:29 Harry Stebbings? One of the reasons I was so excited for this show is you've got to remember I've done like, you know, three thousand shows with VCs. So this is like a very different one for me, given Bailey Gifford being such a different entity. One thing that I was just thinking about last night is what does portfolio construction really mean to Bailey Gifford today? And how do you approach it?
15:45 Speaker 02 So when we take holdings in companies, we tend to take pretty standard position sizes. And those positions are ones that we intend to build on if there is continued deepening of our conviction in those companies. And I think that's a little bit different from a lot of other investment models where it's sort of put your capital in upfront at a given price. And then effectively minimizing dilution thereafter. We size positions with the intention and desire to continue to build on those as conviction builds and deepens. I think ultimately you only really ever understand a business by being a shareholder. So we feed that into our portfolio construction and of course then we don't add to those companies where we're not building that conviction.
16:21 Harry Stebbings? I totally get you on buying up. How do you think about though that a company will never be cheaper than this today? Grab all your ownership on first check.
16:28 Speaker 02 So I disagree with that because I think that probability adjusted upside of companies can often grow as they become larger. So even though ostensibly the price, yes, might be lower in a previous round. As I said, I think sometimes the probability of outsized returns can grow as companies actually become more valuable. Because they are executing and delivering and the likelihood of even further upside can go up in line with that. It's a sort of path dependency.
16:53 Harry Stebbings? Walk me through that, sorry. When you say the probability, you're saying they've de-risked enough elements to make it more probable to be an outsized returner? In which case you should concentrate capital as.
17:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think that's broadly right, but it also goes back to our question or discussion about competitive advantage. And if you're seeing competitive advantage deepen and compound, well, then that can also be something which I guess, yes, you could call it de-risking. But I think that we would sort of look at very closely in thinking about how the potential upside return. Funds for a company are evolving and changing as they grow.
17:22 Harry Stebbings? How do you think about diversification, given that structure and model then?
17:26 Speaker 02 Diversification is normally thought of in terms of downside risk mitigation. We would think about it much more in terms of diversifying to maximize the probability of capturing outliers. We also don't think about diversification in terms of traditional sectors. We try to think about it much more in terms of the underlying commonalities of businesses and we sort of group our companies accordingly. So you end up with companies in our sort of categorizations, which are ostensibly very, very different companies. So for instance, we would put two businesses like Tanium and SpaceX in the same category within our diversification thinking. Because we would view both of those companies as providing the underlying infrastructure
18:06 Speaker 02 for the continued evolution of communication technologies, either through endpoint security or through the provision of satellite broadband.
18:13 Harry Stebbings? But what does that look like then? Because traditional funds have like twenty five to thirty lines is what the majority say. But how do you think about that? When you sit down with your team, do you go, we are in eight companies and we don't have enough diversification on a per company basis. We need to put in twenty. Walk me through the diversification thinking on a per company basis.
18:30 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I mean, if you look at our funds, you're probably more like sort of forty, forty five companies within a portfolio. But you'll often see quite a lot of concentration within the top ten holdings as we as putting a sort of concentrate capital in those companies where conviction is building.
18:44 Harry Stebbings? How much concentration? I remember like Brian Singerman, set from Founders Fund, said the biggest enemy of great venture returns is capital concentration limits on a per company basis. Does it look like two or three having seventy percent of the capital? How does that spread in terms of capital distributions look?
19:01 Speaker 02 So it's not quite that concentrated. I think at times we've had sort of upwards of sort of fifty percent of any given fund in the top ten companies. Now, those will often be companies that we've invested in privately, that have gone public and have gone up a lot. Now, of course, some of that concentration has flattened off in the last few months, as you would expect. So that kind of level of concentration can be a bit movable, given that we continue to own these companies into the public market and those market prices of those businesses in recent times in particular can be rather volatile.
19:28 Harry Stebbings? We're going to get into the volatility, don't we? Don't worry. Speaking of kind of the diversification, one thing that I thought was super interesting as well is given your entry point is very different to mine. How do you think about loss ratio?
19:38 Speaker 02 So I think when we first started this, we thought that we would have a much higher loss ratio than we have done. Over the last ten years, we've deployed something like ten billion dollars into about a hundred private companies. We've had one bankruptcy of a company, which is nothing to be proud of for sure, but I think we thought it was going to be much higher than it was. Now, in a way, when you think about it, it's kind of quite logical that we should have those kind of low loss ratios because we're not doing super early stage investments. We're investing mostly in revenue generating businesses, real companies with real products. So it's a completely different downside at risk that we face compared to early stage investing. But nevertheless, we've been able to find a lot of companies that can deliver the source of returns and have the kind of growth that you would expect at the early stage.
20:20 Harry Stebbings? Okay, so I'm a precocious young member on your team who's just joined and I say, Peter, does that mean that we're not taking enough risk? Ten years, one bankruptcy. Are we really taking enough risk going after Alpha? If we've got one bankruptcy, I know they're revenue generating, but really?
20:36 Speaker 02 I think that's a completely fair question and we ask ourselves that all the time. I think ultimately it sort of comes down to looking at the companies that we have backed. And those companies growing in the way that we would have hoped and growing very, very quickly, and they are. I think that if we had a sort of stagnant portfolio of companies that were chugging away at ten percent year over year, then we would be really worried. But we're fortunate to have found companies that are able to grow very, very quickly.
21:01 Harry Stebbings? How many companies have actually, where it's like they've had acquisitions and I've got like fifty cents on the dollar back? And so it's like, it's not a bankruptcy. But when you look at that cohort, is there many in that cohort?
21:11 Speaker 02 Very few of our investments get acquired and that's partly because we steer away from any company where we get a whiff of them potentially being bought. I think it kind of comes back to what we're trying to achieve. We're not trying to find a company that can be bought for, you know, one or two X in a year or two. We're trying to find companies that over a five, ten, fifteen year view can go on to become five, ten, twenty times their current size. So that kind of skews us towards companies that we believe have the potential, but also where you have a management team. Has a level of ambition to keep the business independent and grow it independently rather than looking for an M and A exit.
21:46 Harry Stebbings? Speaking of kind of seeing that value, that ten, twenty, thirty X from here, I am fascinated. Given that as an entry point, how did the crossover funds invading growth, how did that impact your investing, your price discipline, your entry point? How did it change what you do?
22:02 Speaker 02 I think the way it really changed things, particularly last year, was it changed the timeframes that rounds were happening. And so we were seeing rounds happening last year at speeds that certainly wouldn't have enabled us to do our necessarily diligence. I don't think it was enabling anybody to do any diligence. And so we were walking away from rounds that companies we thought were really interesting, but where that kind of pace of capital last year, we just didn't think was enabling enough work to be done. I think the sad thing about that is the people that will suffer from that is the companies themselves, because they will have ended up with shareholders who don't fully understand what it is they've invested in. And that's kind of fine when everything's going great, but it's in difficult times, difficult times like we are in today,
22:42 Speaker 02 where I think that will end up being difficult for the companies who have shareholders who haven't really understood what it is they've invested in.
22:49 Harry Stebbings? Difficult times, Peter, I should have a bottle of tequila beside my desk. I do want to ask, we've seen some of the crossover funds, not naming names, but post some pretty horrific numbers. I wanted to hear your thoughts on how do you expect them to respond? Will they retrench and retreat from this high price growth investing market? Will they double down? How do you expect them to respond in the face of the volatility in public markets and their numbers being flattened?
23:15 Speaker 02 I think it's a really interesting question, and I think in many ways, the people that will decide the answer to that will be their clients, their limited partners. It'll be whether or not they can go on to raise successive funds that will determine how they conduct themselves in this market going forward. I wouldn't try to sort of second guess what the answer to that will be, but I think in many ways, it might not be in the hands of the investors themselves. It'll be in the hands of their end clients and the people to whom they have the responsibility of managing their capital.
23:42 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask you, when we look at a lot of new venture models today, a lot of it is pretty service heavy, especially for the big firms, and they use those fees to pay for the Operational intense businesses that they run providing these services. When we spoke before, you said, don't come to us if you need help. We're a financial partner. So talk to me, in a world of services and value add and heavy operational models, how do you think about not adding this operational value? And I guess, do you think VCs really add value?
24:07 Speaker 02 I think there are definitely some VCs that add an incredible amount of value. I would also say, though, that there's a sort of industry of using that as air cover to carry out collateral window dressing around so-called value creation in order to justify very high fees. But that doesn't take anything away from those folks that are actually genuinely very good at it. Um, I think we've always tried to be very clear about what we are and what we're not good at. And as I said, we're not sort of aspiring or pretending to be venture capitalists. And so we don't pretend or aspire to be able to help a very, very early-stage company, you know, advise them on their sales and marketing strategy. It's not to say, however, that there aren't things that we can be helpful with. And I guess if you look at our heritage, it comes from the public markets. And I think what we can be helpful with is helping companies transition into the public markets,
24:51 Speaker 02 in some cases with capital, but also with advice and guidance around what the public markets will be like, what they should expect. Normally, the way in which it manifests itself is that we are the voice around the table, telling our private companies, look, are you really sure you want to go public? You do realise that's a sort of one-way valve? And it's really hard being a public company. You'll get people owning your shares for all sorts of reasons that can be potentially completely misaligned with what you're trying to do. You'll have sell-side analysts jumping up and down on you quarter to quarter. It is going to be brutal. So ironically, given that you manage a fair amount in the public markets, normally we're the people telling our private companies to just be patient and don't rush off and go public.
25:27 Harry Stebbings? What do you think are the biggest misnomers or mistakes that people make in terms of their thinking around going public? When you're advising founders, what naiveties do you most often find that they have? And what's the reality?
25:39 Speaker 02 I think it's that they view the process of going public as trying to appeal to everybody. They want to sort of convince every investor they meet that they're a great company and that they should invest in them. The thing that I normally say to the founders of the companies that we back that are going to public is that they should actually treat the process of going public as much as an exercise of trying to put off the wrong Of investors. I really believe that a company's shareholder base can be a significant competitive advantage or a significant competitive disadvantage, depending on whether they get it wrong or right. And a successful IPO is really about trying to find a relatively small number of aligned shareholders in the public markets who can be partners and stewards of that business. And if you look at a business over the years like Amazon, I think one of the things that
26:24 Speaker 02 has given them license to continue to invest and grow is the fact that they've been owned by a relatively small group of fairly long-term investors. And that's enabled a degree of focus that you wouldn't be able to have as a public company if you were trying to please everybody in the public markets. You have to displease frankly, most public market participants if you're going to remain true to what it is you're trying to build.
26:45 Harry Stebbings? I mean this naively probably. Why would you ever go public in many ways? If you can have a great concentrated investor base without prying eyes, without the need to disclose information and build a great business with significant capital in private markets, why go public?
27:00 Speaker 02 I mean, I think that's a great question. And there are companies in our portfolios that they've been private for a long time. And I think they'll probably stay private for a really long time. A business like Epic Games has been private since nineteen ninety-two, and I don't think Tim Sweeney is about to rush off and take that business public. I think there are, however, good reasons and bad reasons. I think a good and honorable reason is to give employees liquidity. If you remunerate your employee base through options, these people put the best years of their lives into these companies. And it's only right that they should be able to get a bit of liquidity, pay off the mortgage, pay their kids' college fees and all of that sort of stuff. I think that's really honorable. I think a really bad reason to go in public is you've got early-stage investors who have funds coming to the end of their life and they want to distribute capital to their limited partners and collect carried interest and all of that whole circus. I think that
27:44 Speaker 02 there can be good reasons, but I think unfortunately, there are often a lot of bad reasons as to why companies go public.
27:49 Harry Stebbings? How do you and Bailey Gifford think of providing secondaries to funds? Is that something that you engage with often?
27:54 Speaker 02 No, we wouldn't ever do secondarys within funds. I mean, we will do secondary transactions within our portfolio companies. So it will help provide a bit of liquidity for employees. And in some cases, early-stage investors. It can just be a bit of a pressure release valve for companies. To enable them to then decide when they go public on their terms. So there are places for these kinds of secondary transactions, but there's this whole sort of brokered market for private companies that's very gray and very shady and that we steer quite clear of. Where we do do secondaries only ever in conjunction with the company and it's normally only ever in companies where we've put primary capital in and where we have a pre-existing relationship with the company.
28:33 Harry Stebbings? Before we do a quick fight, I want to double down on actually your style of investing itself. People change a lot as investors over the years. You've been with Bailey Gifford now for 12 years. When you think about how your styles change, what have been the most significant developments and at that moment or events that have caused these developments? Let's be reflective.
28:52 Speaker 02 I think that's a very interesting question. I suppose that there's quite a narrow way to look at it, which is I started off my career looking at public companies and then I started looking at private companies. But fundamentally, I think what I've always been doing is looking at great growth businesses. I guess in a way, the sort of more recent iteration or development is that it's no longer just about the companies that I research and the companies that I find. It's about being an investor now is really also actually about building a team that's able to invest. And I think that's a whole new skill set that, you know, I've had to learn over the course of the last five or six years because it is a different skill set.
29:28 Speaker 02 But ultimately, we can only be exceptional as a group of investors if it's more than just one person that's exceptional. You have to be able to build a team that is comprised of great investors where you have a safe environment where people can learn, develop, be vulnerable, make mistakes. And I very much think of the last five years of sort of building the private companies team within Bailey Gifford is actually quite an important part of my own growth as an investor.
29:51 Harry Stebbings? All right, let's double down on this. This is good. So I have the same experience building teams, investing. Two big lessons for me is number one, I often like shoot shit down pretty quickly. If I just know that I've seen the space for, and you know, when you just know it's not one for you, I shut it down. That done. Don't do that. You've got to give them the oxygen to come to it on their own. You can't shut things down and create an environment where they're nervous to bring it to you because you're too cynical is one for me. And then number two, sometimes, Peter, you're the boss of your team. I'm the boss. Of mine, you're going through the world of shit and then they come to you with some random little thing. And in your head, you're thinking, are you serious? Do you know what I've got on my plate? And actually you have to go, Peter, I'll be back in an hour. Really important that we have that chat that you wanted to have.
30:35 Harry Stebbings? Let me just deal with this. I've learned to not pass over my tension on to them in any way. Those are lessons for me. What are lessons for you?
30:43 Speaker 02 I think that point around sort of giving people oxygen is a really important one. I think that's kind of wrought through our organisation at Bailey Gifford though. So if you come up within a culture that enables and facilitates freedom to look at whatever it is that interests you from quite an early stage. It's kind of relatively straightforward to kind of pass that on within the team. The question of, of I think sort of how you can facilitate and kind of build, I suppose in a way it's about sort of building resilience within a team and sort of when you have those difficult times, you know, making sure that it's not something which kind of leads to a kind of internal stress within the team. I think just comes back to having really good communications within team, having people that are friends as much as peers and colleagues.
31:24 Speaker 02 And again, I think this kind of partly comes back to the way in which we've been built over a very long time as an organisation, which is the fact that if I look around this office, I've worked with pretty much all of these people my entire career. I've worked with them for a decade or more. I think that just gives rise to a kind of level of trust and a level of working together that we couldn't have if this was a sort of organisation where kind of people came in for a couple of years and then left. And if it was more of a kind of high turnover sort of model, I think that kind of trust really stems from the longevity with which people sort of stay at this organisation.
31:54 Harry Stebbings? You mentioned kind of the morale there in different times. I want to ask, it's a tough time right now for everyone, but especially for younger investors who are really questioning whether they're actually any good at this. What do you advise younger people who are really feeling insecure about whether they're any good and whether the last few years have just been an inflated period for them and it wasn't real?
32:14 Speaker 02 I think in times like this, it's really important to focus on the inputs. So that means focusing on investment philosophy. It means focusing on investment process. And I think you do need to sort of continuously test and evaluate as to whether those philosophies and processes are appropriate. But if they are, then now is the time to really focusing on those and making sure you're absolutely nailing the inputs into the process. Because share prices are outputs, particularly in the public markets, they are pretty uncontrollable. And if you were to be focusing on share prices, you would drive yourself insane. Most of the teams here are public market teams. You won't see a single Bloomberg terminal on the desks of investment teams. And that's because we're not sitting here looking at share prices. We're trying to understand the fundamentals of companies, understand what's signal, what's noise.
33:00 Speaker 02 And really try to focus on the long term evolution and development of these companies. Rather than obsessing what is happening with the share price bouncing around from day to day. Because that will be a fairly fast route to insanity.
33:12 Harry Stebbings? I agree with that, poor crypto investors. Tell me, sometimes inputs are wrong and we make the wrong decision. My question to you is, you learn a lot when things don't work out. Can you take me to a time when an investment hasn't worked out? And what were your biggest takeaways from that experience?
33:27 Speaker 02 So that company that I mentioned, the one that went bankrupt was a business called Intarsia. It was a company that was developing a therapy for type two diabetes. And when we invested in it, it was late stage in the sense of being in phase three trials. It was close to commercialization or close to regulatory approval and then close to commercialization. Now, in my analysis, I placed a very high probability on that working. And it didn't work. They didn't get regulatory approval and the company ran out of money and it went bankrupt. The lesson that I took from that was how to deal with probabilities at the extreme ends of the spectrum. There was something which was based on the clinical trial data, based on the base probabilities of success for similar therapies in that disease area. It looked pretty high probability and I placed a very high probability on it.
34:11 Speaker 02 What I learnt was that I should be very wary of anything that I believe to be high probability. What I also have learnt over the years is that when you're operating in the other end of the spectrum, low probabilities. The behavioural biases is to sort of aim again too low. And that the things which appear to be low probability actually often have a much higher probability than you might think. And the things which you think have a very high probability, sometimes actually have a much lower probability than you might think.
34:36 Harry Stebbings? How do you then fact check your probabilistic analysis? And as you said there, be wary when it's super probable. I can see this happening. How do you fact check it internally? Is it consensus driven investment decision making? Is it individuals? Walk me through that.
34:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, the fact checking thing is really interesting, isn't it? Because there aren't any facts about the future and all of these. History only plays itself out once, so you can't sort of replay these scenarios and actually say what the probability was because only one course of events happened. But sorry, that's somewhat tangential. Coming back to your question about decision making processes, we keep it pretty lean. The people who we make or who are the decision makers on the various pools of capital that we invest in, we speak to each other most days. When we need to make a decision, we sit down and we decide together. And again, I think this point that we've, many of us have spent a really long time working together, enables us to have quite open conversations. They're very high trust conversations. They're conversations where we can be quite vulnerable with each other.
35:31 Speaker 02 We try to keep it at that sort of personal and informal level, rather than having sort of, you know, large investment committees where everybody kind of sits around a table and pines on company X, Y, Z. We really try to sort of keep it quite small and nimble.
35:44 Harry Stebbings? What I want to ask is, you know, we spoke about the loss there. Winners also inform your perspective. How do you think, A, like, how do you think about your biggest winner? And how do you think that changed your view of investing?
35:54 Speaker 02 I mean, my biggest winner to date is still a public company. I was working on Tesla in 2012 and we went on to buy that for various strategies. So far, that one's done all right. I think what I really learnt there was not just intellectually, but behaviourally, what asymmetry really looks like. But I think also I really learnt that, and this is actually to something that one of my colleagues said the other day. He said that if you are sufficiently long term, even in your most successful investments, there will always be a time where you look and feel really stupid. And I think Tesla is an example of a company where there have been multiple periods over the course of that investment, where we as an organisation have looked and felt really stupid.
36:32 Harry Stebbings? Is that really hard in public markets though? Because I can look and feel stupid in private. And guess what? You're stuck with it. So no choice. But you, I mean, this is why I have so much respect for you. You, when you look and feel stupid, can sell anytime you want, pretty much. Is that tough, having that freedom to sell?
36:47 Speaker 02 I think it would be tougher if the sort of. Long term mode of investing wasn't so ingrained in how we think and operate as an organisation. And I think in many ways, this is kind of what made private investing quite natural for us. We sort of think of many of our public holdings as really as illiquid as many of our private holdings. Because if we're investing in a company with a 10 year view, probably shouldn't be doing anything two or three years into that investment journey. You should really be thinking of it as being pretty much as illiquid as any private holding. I think also being based outside of a lot of financial ecosystems really helps us. You know, we're based in Edinburgh in Scotland. Yeah, when we walk out of the door, there aren't a load of other fund managers or investment bankers or venture capitalists kind of walking down the streets.
37:32 Speaker 02 And that enables us to, I think in some ways, be a little bit isolationist from the rest of the financial world. There are good sides and bad sides to that, but there's one of the good sides is that it enables us to focus on what we're doing, on what we believe, rather than being too peer aware.
37:49 Harry Stebbings? Final one for you. We've touched on like the biggest win, we've touched on, you know, a loss. And I want to touch on like one that you didn't do a miss and how that changed your mindset and then we'll do the quick five.
37:59 Speaker 02 I mean, one of the ones we really missed was DoorDash. We had a few opportunities to invest in that privately. And I think one of the problems was that we were looking at Postmates at the same time. I remember looking at both and thinking, gosh, I just kind of can't draw a line between these two. I was getting too obsessed, in many ways, I was getting too obsessed with competitive advantage. And the thing that I should have placed a much greater weight on was the founder of DoorDash. And, you know, why he'd started the business and the level of commitment that he had to these small businesses, that he was wanting to help and kind of bring online and help reach a wider audience. And I think it was that kind of zeal that he had, which ultimately was the thing that I should have placed much greater weight on, rather than trying to be too clever about the competitive advantage between Postmates and DoorDash.
38:42 Harry Stebbings? Tony's special. I've loved this. This has been so much fun. I want to do a quick fire round. So I say a short statement, you give me your immediate thoughts. Does that sound okay?
38:50 Speaker 02 Sounds brilliant.
38:50 Harry Stebbings? So what's your favourite book and why, Peter?
38:52 Speaker 02 This is kind of like asking somebody who their favourite child is, but I'll try and answer it. One of the books that's influenced me the most is The Myth of Sisyphus by. Albert Camus. And given that I told you already that I'm a sort of reformed philosopher, that maybe that doesn't come as too much of a surprise. I think the thing that just resonates with me there is that life is fundamentally absurd, but that you can create your own meaning in life. And that that can be just as motivating as if there was some intrinsic meaning to life woven into the fabric of the universe.
39:20 Harry Stebbings? The Myth of Sisyphus, my favourite book is Venture Deals by Brad Fowles. And it's also the first time I've heard that on the show. Most people say sapiens, so this is great. What have you recently changed your mind on?
39:31 Speaker 02 And I don't think this is a particularly recent change, but quite a profound sort of change in realisation for me was a few years ago around the gaming industry. I had a fairly lazy and traditional view that it was a hit driven business. And as I came to really understand the ways in which digital distribution and in game purchases in video games completely changed the set of incentives for game developers and players and the potential longevity that could come from those businesses. It sort of opened up a new kind of world of investing for me as my beliefs about the gaming industry changed.
40:02 Harry Stebbings? There's one I'm adding, but I like it. How did becoming a father impact your investing and operating mindset?
40:09 Speaker 02 Oh, that's a tough question.
40:11 Harry Stebbings? I love how British you are. This is great. I'm so used to Americans. It's like, oof, tough one.
40:18 Speaker 02 I think that becoming a father makes you more empathetic, yeah, and a mother for that matter. I think that the way in which I sort of relate to people has, I think, changed after becoming a father. And I hope my colleagues find me a more empathetic person to work with on this side of being a father.
40:33 Harry Stebbings? What do you believe that many others don't believe?
40:35 Speaker 02 The dividing the world between private and public company investing is just meaningless. And that the world of company formation and investing would be a lot better if everybody stopped pretending that there was a meaningful divide between private and public businesses.
40:47 Harry Stebbings? What's your biggest insecurity as an investor today?
40:50 Speaker 02 I guess the way that we operate as a firm by design with sort of slight outsiders, both in terms of location, as already, you know, we already talked about. You know, we don't go around calling ourselves venture capitalists. And I think when you have that outsider, that mindset of being outsiders, it can lead to strength. I think there can be strength in difference, but that also comes along with. Insecurity from being outsiders within the industry that we operate in every day.
41:15 Harry Stebbings? What's the most memorable first founder meeting you've had?
41:17 Speaker 02 I mean, I think the memorable ones are the ones where you're sitting there listening to a founder. And as you hear them speaking, your view of what is possible for this business or your view of the world is changing. I would say the first time I spoke to Tim Sweeney at Epic Games, that was a real sort of aha moment as to what that business could become and what it was building. Or a business like Solugen based down in Houston, meeting Garab and Sean for the first time and understanding how what they had could really change the chemicals industry in a way that was really scalable. You know, those would be some of the meetings that really stood out for me.
41:49 Harry Stebbings? Final one, what's the most recent publicly announced investment? And why did you say yes and get so excited?
41:55 Speaker 02 I somewhat lose track of what's publicly announced and what's not. So I'll err on the side of one that I know is definitely publicly announced. We led around in Grammarly last year. It's a business that's known for being a spell checking tool, really. But actually, what they're doing is helping people communicate more effectively. It's a low profile company, a very high profile product, but a very low profile company. A very thoughtful leadership team. They're very long term, they're obsessed with the culture of their organisation. And it's fantastic product that just keeps getting better and better.
42:22 Harry Stebbings? Listen, it saves me every day. I adore Grammarly as a product and I mean, what a business it is. So thrilled to hear that. Peter, I've loved this. Thank you so much for being so open. Thank you so much for bluntly being so reflective as well. It's really lovely to be able to have such an honest discussion. So you've been a star and I've loved doing it.
42:39 Speaker 02 Thanks, Harry. It's been great to talk to you.
42:42 Harry Stebbings? If you couldn't tell, I just absolutely loved that discussion with Peter. What a wonderful, authentic, brilliant investor and mine. So appreciate him coming on the show. If you'd like to see more from us, of course, you can on twentyvc.com. But before we leave you today, I want to talk about an incredible tool that I use every single day, Notion. Now, I am the worst for having 50 tabs open and constantly hopping between an endless array of tools. Do you feel me? Are you with me? Well, then Notion came into my life, providing one tool to do it all. With everything from seamless project management to easily organising 20VC's company information. A fascinating stand on Notion usage, more than 70% of companies who start using.
43:20 Harry Stebbings? Notion, stop using two plus other tools. And so Notion can even save you money, given how many other tools it can displace. Notion has a worldwide network of millions of users, creating templates, tutorials and new inspiration. The product's getting better and better every single day, and you always have the support you need. Learn more and get started for free at notion.soh. Take the first step toward an organized, happy team today, again at notion.soh. And speaking of foundational infrastructure like Notion there, Angel List has been a key partner for me in managing my investments. I just love using the Angel List platform because it abstracts away all the complexity and operational burden of fund management. Whether you're running SPVs, a traditional venture fund like me, or a rolling fund, Angel List has you covered. I'm also super excited about their new product, Angel List Stack,
44:05 Harry Stebbings? which is purpose-built for founders. With Angel List Stack, you can create a fundraising-ready startup in just a few clicks. Angel List handles your company's incorporation, banking, cap table and fundraising process, all in one single place, and this allows founders to focus on building. If you're a founder, you can launch your company at stack.angellist.com/20vc. Whether you are a founder or a funder, you're in great hands with Angel List. And finally, from websites and online stores to marketing tools and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business. There are three things for me that I just love about Squarespace. First, mobile-optimized websites. All websites are optimized for mobile, content automatically adjusts, so it just looks really beautiful on any device.
44:50 Harry Stebbings? Second, email campaigns. Squarespace makes it super easy to grow and engage your audience with Squarespace email campaigns. Say what, no other provider needed? Amazing news. Finally, SEO tools. Squarespace takes the guesswork out of SEO, so you'll get found in search by more people more often. And if that wasn't good enough, go to squarespace.com/20vc for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use the offer code 20vc to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or a domain. As always, I so appreciate all your support and I cannot wait to bring you a fantastic set of episodes next week.
Previous 20 Growth: Shopify's VP of Growth on Why Standalone Growth Teams Operate More Efficiently than Integrated Ones, Why You Should Hire as Senior Growth Leaders as Possible and The Biggest Mistakes Founders Make When Making Their First Growth Hires Next 20VC: Why Being First Does Not Matter, Why Defensibility on Day 1 Does Not Exist, Three Core Elements To Move into Enterprise Effectively and What Makes Truly Great Product Marketing Today with Des Traynor, Co-Founder @ Intercom Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated