Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: The Memo: Sequoia's Alfred Lin on Why Chasing GMV Leads To Bad Behaviours, How To Approach Competition and Capital Efficiency & The Core Importance of Understanding the Difference Between Input and Output Metrics About this episode Alfred Lin is a Partner @ Sequoia Capital, one of the world's most renowned and successful venture firms with a portfolio including the likes of Google, Airbnb, Whatsapp, Stripe, Zoom, Doordash and many more. As for Alfred, he has led deals in the likes of Airbnb, Doordash, Instacart, Reddit and Houzz to name a few. Prior to the world of venture, Alfred was Chairman and COO @ Zappos for 6 years leading to their acquisition by Amazon. In Today’s Episode You Will Learn: 1.) How Alfred made his way into the world of venture and came to be a Partner @ Sequoia? How Alfred first met DoorDash? Where did the meeting take place? Who was there? What were the first impressions? 2.) Market: How did Alfred breakdown the food delivery market when doing the diligence for the investment? How did Alfred forsee the market changing over time? What were some unexpected elements of the market Alfred did not forsee? What does Alfred look for in markets; size or growth? 3.) Competition: How did Alfred analyse the competitive landscape for food delivery at the time? Why does Alfred believe that great companies are not built by focusing on the competition? What does Alfred mean when he says, "you have to be customer-obsessed and competitor aware"? 4.) Traction: Does Alfred agree with Sarah Tavel in the dangers of chasing topline GMV? What negative behaviours can chasing GMV trigger? What does Alfred mean when he says, "founders have to be able to distinguish between input and output metrics"? 5.) Acquisition: What does Alfred believe DoorDash did so well in terms of acquiring drivers more efficiently? How did they retain them so effectively? What allowed DoorDash to compete so effectively when it came to merchant acquisition? What were some of Alfred's biggest takeaways when it came to DoorDash's customer acquisition journey? As always you can follow Harry and The Twenty Minute VC on Twitter here! Likewise, you can follow Harry on Instagram here for mojito madness and all things 20VC.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Harry Stebbings? This is the 20 Minute VC, but this is a new type of show on the 20 Minute VC. So, starting from today, we're launching The Memo, a monthly show where we invite VCs who've led rounds for some of the best and biggest companies in the world. And we focus the show around the investment memo that they wrote at the time of doing the investment and unpack what changed, what worked, what did not work, what was surprising, and so much more. And we could not have a better guest for our first episode of The Memo, as we welcome Alfred Lin, discussing his leading Series A round for DoorDash with Sequoia. As for context, Alfred is a partner at Sequoia and has led deals in the likes of Airbnb, DoorDash, Instacart, Reddit, and Houzz, to name a few. Prior to the world of venture, Alfred was chairman and COO at Zappos for six years, leading to their acquisition by Amazon.
0:41 Harry Stebbings? But before we dive into the show today, Rippling has helped thousands of startups automate their HR and IT, from employee payroll and benefits to devices and apps. Now they're helping startups access better health, coverage, and HR with their newest product, the Rippling PEO. So state-by-state compliance is a pain, and if you've hired employees in other states, or your employees have relocated to other states because of COVID, you know what a pain registering with and maintaining each new state unemployment insurance office is. Employees paying too much for HR and benefits, the Rippling PEO can solve these challenges. As soon as you hire someone out of state or an existing employee relocates, Rippling automatically registers your startup with the appropriate unemployment agencies and keeps you compliant with all local
1:25 Harry Stebbings? regulations, from minimum wage to sick leave. My word, that's a ton of complexity off your plate, so you're free to focus on building your startup. Visit rippling.com/20vc to learn more and schedule a demo with some special discounts. And speaking of incredible products there with Rippling, Exodus is leading the world out of the traditional financial system by building beautiful and user-friendly blockchain products. With its focus on design and user experience, Exodus has become one of the most popular cryptocurrency apps. It's supported on both desktop and mobile, allowing you to sync your wallet across multiple devices, so you can really have access to your funds anywhere. You can instantly exchange around 100 different cryptocurrencies straight from your wallet, interactive charts even let you view an asset's price history, and your portfolio's performance over time.
2:10 Harry Stebbings? And maybe the best part, Exodus is actually integrated with the Trezor hardware wallet, making advanced security easy for everyone. Visit Exodus.io for your free download or search Exodus on the App Store or the Play Store. And last but by no means least, do you wish you were early in some of the biggest and best performing IPOs of 2019 and 20? Bit of a silly question there, of course you do, but our crowd investors were, and now you can join them in what's next. With rCrowd, accredited investors have access to invest directly, easily, and most importantly, early. rCrowd investors have benefited from rCrowd companies IPOing, like Beyond Meat, or even being bought by companies like Intel, Nike, Microsoft, and Oracle, to name a few. Today, you can join rCrowd's investment in NanoLock Security, a company offering IoT cyber
2:55 Harry Stebbings? protection, including billions of low-end devices that other technologies cannot protect. NanoLock is the only device-level protection that has near-zero power requirements and is agnostic to the operating system. You can get in early on NanoLock and other really unique opportunities at rcrowd.com/20vc. The rCrowd account is free, just go to rcrowd.com/20vc. But that's enough from me. So now I'm so excited to head into our first-ever episode on the memo with Alfred Lin at Sequoia.
3:30 Speaker 01 You have now arrived at your destination.
3:33 Harry Stebbings? Alfred, this is such a joy to do. I've wanted to do this one for a long time. So thank you so much for joining me today.
3:38 Speaker 02 Well, thank you for having me on the show. I'm really excited to be with you today.
3:41 Harry Stebbings? Well, that is very kind of you, but we're going to dive straight in today and we're going to unpack the original DoorDash memo you wrote back in 2014. So I want to start with the story and some history and context. So how did you meet the team? Where was the meeting? Paint that picture for me, if that's okay.
3:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, happy to do that. But let me take you back a little bit further than that, because my fascination with food delivery goes back earlier than me meeting the team. I joined Sequoia in 2010, in late 2010, and I was trying to come up with a differentiated investment theme. Early 2011, at the TED Global Conference, I listened to a talk by Jeffrey West about the mass migration to cities, due partly because cities are Just more efficient than other parts of the world. So, growing up in New York City, I was always frustrated that services like that I saw in New York weren't available in the Bay Area, where there was a good public transportation system, reliable taxis, or basic delivery services, including restaurant delivery.
4:36 Speaker 02 And I love food, and I've always been annoyed that food delivery wasn't more available. And actually, between 2011 and 2013, we evaluated opportunities to invest in Grubhub, in Caviar, in Postmates, and TaskRabbit, because I was fascinated with this space. We passed on each of those opportunities, not partly because we're somewhat concerned about market size, but more importantly, we felt like we didn't find the right founder-market fit for this opportunity. And we wanted to look for founders who are obsessed with the operational details of the business and pursued operational excellence. And we found that when we met Tony and we realized that there was founder-market fit here.
5:14 Harry Stebbings? So, talk to me, how did you meet Tony? Where did you meet him? And how was that first meeting?
5:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, we met Tony right after, so a few of us were doing office hours at YC. For lunch, we got to order from DoorDash. I really enjoyed ordering from a variety of restaurants rather than dining at the typical, unappetizing buffet line. So, we met Tony and Andy and Stanley and Evan later that afternoon to listen to their pitch. And their pitch was to become the FedEx of local. We met them in 2013, this is around 2013. We took a few meetings after that, but unfortunately, I guess we failed to dream with them and we passed on the C round in 2013. And so, that was kind of unfortunate, but we stayed in touch. So, I kept in touch with Tony and had, you know, got updates from him every few months. And in 2014, I was sitting next to him at a dinner, a networking dinner.
6:04 Speaker 02 This is an Asian-American founder and VC networking dinner that Aileen Lee had sort of organized and Sequoia was sponsoring. And I happened to sit next to Tony, and I was struck by just how observant and detail-oriented Tony was, as he was systematically breaking down the restaurant that we were at. It was Chef Chews in Los Altos, and systematically breaking down why they're so efficient. And then he did the same thing About DoorDash's operation into, you know, what are the simple, repeatable tasks that you have to get right? So after that dinner, I just, I went back to Sequoia and got the team spun up and we went into high gear to pursue the opportunity. And a week later, we led the Series A. We missed the seed, but, um, but we made it up by leading the Series A
6:49 Speaker 02 and we invested in every single round after that.
6:51 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, when you look back at like not doing the seed, as you said, did the Series A and what an incredible journey it was. When you look back at not doing the seed, are there any takeaways for you from kind of moving forward in terms of when you meet teams like DoorDash? And how you engage at the seed? And did that impact your mindset at all?
7:06 Speaker 02 Well, I think that the most important thing at the seed level is to find great founders attacking a large market. And we were looking for sort of founder market fit and we found that in the seed. And we were bogged down by what, like things that you need to prove out later in the Series A or the Series B or the Series C. We're bogged down by questions. Is this a service for, for rich people? Would it actually work in the suburbs versus in the cities? You know, those kinds of things, you can have a conversation about them, but you're not going to know the answer. And we did have conversations about this stuff. And part of the reason I was so attracted to Tony and his sort of attention to detail was that, well, actually it's way more competitive
7:48 Speaker 02 in the cities, but the, the cities are not as laid out nicely as they are in the suburbs. And I was like, wait a minute, what do you mean by that? Well, if you go to New York City, like the restaurants are all over the place and you have to get the food all over the place. But in the suburbs, yes, you got to get the food all over the place because the, the people are living all over the suburbs. But it turns out that almost every single suburb has these strips where most of the restaurants and even most of the stores are. So in actuality, there is a density like rule in suburb. And, you know, it's true, like in Palo Alto, there's University Avenue and then there's California Street. And those were, where the main drags are.
8:29 Speaker 02 And that powerful insight is what allowed Tony to say, we're going to focus on the suburbs. And it turned out to be the winning strategy over a long period of time.
8:38 Harry Stebbings? I mean, it absolutely did. It's fascinating to hear about that kind of importance of density on the supply side. I do want to touch on the market firstly because you mentioned kind of passing on a couple of the other incumbents in the space. You know, sometimes because of market size and market thinking, Sequoia often has a market first mindset. I love some of Don Valentine's early talks on market. I'm interested, when we kind of go to the memo, how did you break down the market when doing the evaluation for the investment? And how did that look like for you with DoorDash?
9:04 Speaker 02 So the memo just briefly talks about the takeout volume as of today, and only 15% of that was delivery. And I think the reason we sort of laid that out was, you know, you can sure dream about markets in different ways. You can start with the initial market that you're going to address, or you can talk about the sort of restaurant market, which is closer to 600 billion or something in that range. You can't address all that. So as a startup, you have to figure out what is the market that you're addressing at the beginning. We think about that and the takeout market is, the delivery market is a delivery market. So it's pretty easy to go size and find out. And there are other companies that have gone public, like GrabHut in their S1, how big their their takeout volume was and how much was being done on delivery.
9:49 Speaker 02 But the notion was that if delivery was more efficient, then the delivery market would be as big, if not bigger than the takeout market. And so you just need to sort of think about like, well, is the initial market big enough and is it growing? And I think we're not attracted by just large markets, we're attracted by the market dynamics. And it's more important for us that you think about the wedge into this larger market called restaurants or food in general. But specifically, where are you going to go attack? And remember, Tony's whole notion was not just food delivery, right? But he wanted to build the FedEx, his initial pitch was the FedEx of local. And he wanted to deliver almost everything, but he was going to start out in food.
10:31 Speaker 02 Because if you can deliver a pizza before it gets cold or an ice cream before it melts, and he's, he used that all the way back at the seed, then you can see your way into delivering almost anything.
10:42 Harry Stebbings? Absolutely, Ken. Too interested not to ask there, how did you think about, and with the benefit of hindsight, how did you think about and how did you advise and work with him in terms of the right time to expand beyond pure food to, as we said, the FedEx vision over time?
10:57 Speaker 02 These things are always both an art and a science, right? We started in Palo Alto, we then expanded, you know, sort of almost all of the Bay Area. We then go into San Jose. So there's the geographic expansion. And today, we are in more than food, but the majority of the business is still in food. I sometimes tell founders, like, the sort of desire to expand into other categories is sometimes a sign that you don't love your core business. I mean, if you think about great companies, they've scaled with their core business for a long, long period of time. And it's always much better that your customers pull you into a different area than if you just want to go into a different area. And so that's the balance that we sort of tell management teams.
11:42 Speaker 02 Like, you don't want to be successive breeds a desire to expand. And Jim Collins talks about the undisciplined pursuit of more. We try to dissuade that. If you're being pulled by the customer or pulled by the market, that is a great sign. If you're pushing because you have aspirations of building an empire, that is less good of a sign.
12:01 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask just pure advice now, Alfred? Like, I totally agree with you there. But when you have these supremely ambitious founders who want it all and want it now, how do you advise them in a constructive, not patronizing, but kind of constructive way that actually, you know, this is strategically the right decision?
12:17 Speaker 02 Well, I start with the notion that what's the scale of your ambition just in your core business? Like, are you leaving your core business because it's not that interesting to you? Or is the business not as big as you thought? Like, why do we need to expand? If you can just do this well, why do we need to expand? And then the other sort of question I ask them is, how much increasing advantage do you gain? Like, I think if you go into an adjacent market that is pretty close and you leverage all of your strengths, that is a much better way of expanding into a new market than to go to a new market where there is, you have no advantage from your core business. And then the other thing, which is why I talk about customers pulling you, is like, is it actually better for the customer experience?
13:01 Speaker 02 If you're expanding a slightly different category or market, is it a better customer experience? If it's a better customer experience, the flywheel will carry you into that expansion. As opposed to saying, I'm going to push into this new area.
13:14 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, while we're on the market, you know, you've had the benefit of hindsight now in terms of consumer behavior, in terms of market evolution. When you look back, there are elements where, in terms of kind of the market evolution, there are elements you really didn't expect.
13:27 Speaker 02 Are you asking specifically about this market?
13:29 Harry Stebbings? Yeah.
13:30 Speaker 02 I think that the market evolution was probably a lot more competitive. I think we we expected. I don't think great companies ever are built by focusing on the competition. We tell our companies to be competitor aware but customer obsessed. So if you just focus on the customer, what do you do to sort of improve the customer experience? And continue to sort of retain your customers in an increasing advantage? I think the level of competition was a sign of too much money in the system. Back to the be competitor where you can't compete in a marketplace if a bunch of your competitors raises a bunch of money and you do not.
14:09 Speaker 02 And while we think capital is secondary, it is needed in competitive market situations. The primary thing, though, always to me is making sure you have a differentiated business model, superior unit economics and a differentiated strategy to win. And I think Dora Dash won because they did have a differentiated strategy, which is focused on the suburbs. They had a differentiated strategy on focusing on the merchants as well and on selection. So those were two-pronged on the strategy that were quite different. And then they just had better retention and better unit economics. And so when you have that common, all of those things right, then capital becomes fuel.
14:51 Speaker 02 And so when you have a hot burning fire pouring fuel on it, it just accelerates and leverages it. When you don't have that hot burning fire and you're just pouring gasoline, it's kind of wasted money.
15:01 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, how did they have a differentiated strategy around merchant selection and what was that?
15:06 Speaker 02 Differentiated strategy around merchant selection is just having the largest selection. There's always these debates about like, I always hear about the paradox of choice. The paradox of choice is an individual. Issue, not a population issue. And on the population level, you and I might both love sushi, but our favorite sushi restaurants could be very different. And that's multiplied across all of your customers. So some people fail to see that the largest selection, you know, always wins. And having selection was quite important from the very, very beginning for DoorDash. The other thing is like, how far are you willing to go? So maybe there's a great sushi restaurant in your local neighborhood. Are you willing to expand the radius?
15:49 Speaker 02 So that you can take that sushi restaurant to a place a little further. That was also a differentiated strategy, but you can only do that if you're more efficient, if you can batch more efficiently, if you have good prediction about how you route your customers, et cetera, et cetera. And DoorDash was always very much focused on making sure that they were routing orders properly, estimating time properly, so that they can batch properly, et cetera.
16:15 Harry Stebbings? Totally with you. In terms of kind of the efficiencies there, I mean, that often distills down into kind of superior unit economics. And you touched on it slightly. And in the memo, you know, you speak about the unit economics. And so I'm interested, how did you get comfortable with the unit econ? And kind of especially kind of the customer acquisition costs in relation to the contribution margins?
16:33 Speaker 02 Well, I think that what is happening at the time, and then there's the reality of the situation, is going to look very, very different. The unit economics at the time, at a seed or a series A, is a sort of just a check on how thoughtful the founders are. And the management team is on exactly how they think about the business. If you see that the unit economics is all messed up, they don't really quite understand what's going on, and it's very, very sloppy, you know, then you kind of question whether they're operating the business at the lowest level. They're good operators, they're focusing on operational excellence. And of course, it's always messy at the beginning. But it's just a like magnitude of how things are going to to play out later.
17:17 Speaker 02 And you also have to understand that the customers that you have at the beginning are, they're the early adopters, they're more likely to pay you more, order more, et cetera. So you also have to think about it from the standpoint of the unit economics may actually get worse and how much worse you have to sort of think through and be prepared for. And those are conversations you have with the founders to see how scrappy they are, how thoughtful they are and et cetera, et cetera. But at the beginning, like if you ask me like about unit economics, it's really mostly about AOV. It's mostly about how often someone orders, it's about retention, it's at the higher level. It's about the GMV before you can talk about your take rate, before you can talk about gross
18:01 Speaker 02 profit, before you can talk about contribution profit. But you ask these questions and see whether the person you're thinking about partnering with quite early, whether you can riff with them, work with them, et cetera. And I've always found working with Tony, riffing with him on these ideas to be quite intellectually stimulating and we can build on each other. That's the dynamic that you want to see. And back to Tony having founder market fit, he worked at a restaurant when he was younger with his mom. He knew every single part of how a restaurant works, the unit economics, not of his business, but also of a restaurant and the issues at a restaurant where they have more capacity in the kitchen than they have capacity in the front of the house to seat people.
18:43 Speaker 02 You can only turn a restaurant maybe two times for a meal, but you have more capacity in the kitchen, therefore they can actually make food for delivery. So those are all the sort of kind of things where like, huh, well, unit economics doesn't actually have to get worse because there are a whole bunch of things, there are puts and takes, like yes, maybe it'll cost more to acquire the next user, but there are a whole bunch of other levers that you can pull to improve the unit economics.
19:08 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, in the unit economics journey of the company, you know, obviously unit economics got like significantly better over time and continue to do so. Question for me is like, were there inflection moments where an unlock was occurring that allowed them to get better? Or is it kind of steadily getting better over time? How does that journey go from, you know, where it is to much, much better?
19:27 Speaker 02 The journey is always a bunch of like, you know, it's like sailing, you like tick and tack, you go, you sometimes sail sideways if you want to talk about cap. The early days of DoorDash, they printed out flyers and when they deliver an order, they just blanketed the neighborhood with flyers about DoorDash. And that was actually quite cheap to get consumers. That's not scalable. So, you know, that's scalable to a point. That's not super scalable. They have to find other ways. You know, you're always looking for new ways of finding a channel that allows you to scale and scale efficiently. And then that channel gets used up by either you or your competitors. And then you have to move on to the next channel. And then maybe everybody goes away from the the channel
20:11 Speaker 02 that looks like it's super saturated. And then finally, that becomes more normalized and you can go back to that old channel that you were you thought was super saturated. In some ways, it never ends. It's a constant sort of cyclical cycle of wanting to experiment and learning how to do more things more efficiently. The other thing that is quite interesting to me is that the best companies also know that if they run the business more efficiently, they can actually outspend their competitors. I mean, so if you are more efficient, then I can outspend my competitors because they're my competitors at some point will not be profitable. And that was always something we talked about is like, make sure you have met the much better unit economics
20:52 Speaker 02 because rationally, we should be able to spend more than our competitors to grow.
20:57 Harry Stebbings? Does that still hold true in the insanely capital-rich environments that we're in today?
21:02 Speaker 02 It's true if people are rational. And so I say that as a statement of if people are irrational, then that's not going to be the case. And you're asking a very, very good question, right? Like, when I worked at Zappos, every single marketing dollar had to pay back on the first order because we didn't have a lot of access to capital. Well, if that works with a little bit more money, you can allow the payback period to take one month. Okay? So at some point, everybody just pushes it from zero months to one month to, you know, six months, 12 months, 18 months. But at some point, if it's going to be 10 years, it doesn't work. This is not the transitive property. So that if you could go from zero to one, one to two, two, three, you should go for infinite. At some point, it has to pay back. And so there has to be.
21:47 Speaker 02 Some level of rationality to it.
21:49 Harry Stebbings? It kind of goes to the kind of sentiment of, you know, growth above everything else. And I, you know, it's interesting, kind of moving to kind of the traction. Specifically, you know, I had Sarah Tavel though on the show recently, and she said chasing GMV and top line will lead you in the wrong direction. I'm interested with this kind of growth at all costs discussion that we're having here and that kind of GMV leading you potentially in the wrong direction. Do you agree and how do you think about that?
22:11 Speaker 02 Well, I would never disagree with Sarah and the way she phrased it, I think is is a very true statement, which is chasing, chasing GMV. And it will lead you to the wrong direction because it'll lead you to the wrong behaviors. I think that that is something that I would like, you know, every founder to understand. You should figure out ways where the customer pulls you as opposed to chasing the customer down to force them to use your product. Look, you need GMV, right? Like in some sense, GMV for a marketplace, for a commerce company, for a consumer company is a sign of usage, right? Like if you don't have GMV in a marketplace, there is no usage. I always tell founders to break down their GMV into smaller and smaller pieces until they get into their input metrics.
22:56 Speaker 02 You know, when I was at Amazon and at Zappos, we always talk about the difference between input metrics and output metrics. GMV is an output metric. As an operator, you want to focus on the input metrics, things that you can control. Those are around number of merchants and selection. There's a number of customers that you decide to acquire. The AOV and how you can increase AOV. So you take GMV, it's it's AOV times the number of orders. You can take orders and decompose that to orders per customer times the number of customer. You can take customers by old customers coming back plus new customers that you acquire. You break this down into smaller and smaller metrics that sort of sort of multiply up into what GMV is. And you want to make sure that those input metrics are actually really healthy.
23:40 Speaker 02 And if they are, then you should keep pushing GMV. If they're not, then you should go fix the thing, the underlying issues. And I think that if you're just looking at GMV, you're doing yourself a great disservice because you don't really understand the underlying components of GMV.
23:56 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, if we apply that to DoorDash and we think about the input metrics that maybe were incredibly compelling in the input metrics, which made one pause and go, maybe we need to go back to the drawing board. Are there one or two on each side that were striking or you remember specifically?
24:11 Speaker 02 You saw a memo, we broke it down into from GMV to retention to the cohorts. And the cohorts were were just really sticky, even at the early days. We don't see that very often. I've seen that in very few companies where that's the case. You know, you either want large AOVs that happen infrequently, but when you're top of mind when when it happens. Or you want the opposite, where it's like, OK, the orders are small, but you want a lot of frequency, a lot of use. This is going to be a small AOV business with a lot of frequency and a lot of use. But you know, it's going to be a small AOV. You just need to make sure that that second statement of lots of frequency and the third statement, lots of use. You know, stickiness happens.
24:55 Speaker 02 And so when we broke down the business at the Series A, you could see that. That remained to be true from the A to the B, the C, the D. Everybody who invested in the business saw that. And it was the thing that sort of gravitated a lot of investors to like, wow, I have never seen this before.
25:16 Harry Stebbings? Tell us on the flip side, with that input metrics where you were like, huh, we need to work on this and we need to rethink a strategy around this.
25:23 Speaker 02 The input metrics and there are things that, you know, sort of they needed to work on. And but we felt like that those are doable things like quality, right? Sometimes when you say that it's going to take 30 minutes, it took 45 minutes. Or you showed up and the order has everything except the fries. And those type of things are going to happen. This is an atoms business. It's not a bits business. There's no error correcting code on the other side. So you have to develop your own error correcting code to make sure that the order doesn't have any errors. And, you know, sometimes you you actually have to be quite creative. Some of the people who are good process people in a bits world, they create these like great like sort of academic processes. But then there's a human involved.
26:06 Speaker 02 And so you have to create processes where there is a certain level of human error or human and take that into account and to correct for that.
26:15 Harry Stebbings? In terms of kind of moving into the physical world and, you know, it being a three sided marketplace, before we move into the Do you just have to ask, you know, in London specifically, you know, when we look at the likes of Deliver and many other players, driver acquisition is one of the most challenging battles there is. With hindsight, what did DoorDash do so well in terms of driver acquisition? That really allowed them to scale in the way that they did, do you think?
26:36 Speaker 02 Well, at the beginning, they had a differentiated strategy with driver acquisition. It was people who wanted to be a driver for a service, but they they couldn't drive for that service because they didn't have the right car. So you can take all those people. And then the other example is there are drivers who don't actually want to drive other people. They actually prefer to deliver packages. And so in the early days of DoorDash, they were focused on a different set of drivers than everybody else. On merchant acquisition, there was a lot of talk about how they would go down to the strip in these suburbs and try to like, understand the dynamics and the sort of the market power of each restaurant. And who are the influencers?
27:20 Speaker 02 And try to get the influencers on board. And then then there was the partner versus non partner sort of method of acquiring them. It's like, we're gonna send you a bunch of orders and we're gonna show you how many orders we can send you. And then, hey, do you want to sign up with us? And so that was a differentiated strategy. And most of their restaurants now are partner restaurants. And it was really, really important for Tony because he had a heart for merchants, having grown up in the restaurant business, that they do right by the merchant. And that was really, really important to him. And on the customer side, I think that to build this kind of business, you need to sort of have both a really creative way of acquiring customers, like they did in the early days of just blanketing the neighborhood that they delivered to,
28:05 Speaker 02 to doing things at scale that were interesting. And one of the examples of that is the national merchant strategy, which was lots of customers wanted to order one of the top merchants. And their strategy was not to get just McDonald's. They wanted to get a hundred of these or the as many of the top 100 merchants, national merchants as possible, because that was what the customer wanted. Was the market pull expanding to get these originally that all their merchant acquisition were local restaurants. The reason they expanded into national selection was because the customer asked them to.
28:41 Speaker 02 That national brand selection and wanting to get a deep selection of those was actually one of the things that pulled DoorDash nationwide. If you wanted to work with Cheesecake Factory, they wanted you to deliver not just in Palo Alto, but all of their Cheesecake Factory restaurants. That was quite an interesting way to acquire customers because you could acquire customers through a partnership with the top 100 merchants.
29:06 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, in terms of expanding into new geographies in particular, how did you think about what it would take to get enough liquidity in the marketplace to really see the flywheel start? And what did that look in terms of a timeline, kind of the repeatable markets that you scaled into?
29:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, so we had great data from our expansion that like in Palo Alto, we get to a certain sort of number of customers and Palo Alto is profitable. And then you do that again and again and again across the cities and it was quite replicable across the nation. The sort of genius of the nationwide strategy is one of these merchants would be your dominant sort of volume for a period of time. And you knew that you could, you could seed that market quite quickly because you had a national merchant that was telling their own customers that now you, they can order on DoorDash. And so it was a seeding strategy that was quite ingenious when they started doing this, probably five years ago.
29:58 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, no, totally. Before we move into the quick fire, one final question is actually on Tony and it's like, you know, having the seed alongside Tony and working with Tony. How did you see Tony evolve and change and develop as a leader over the incredible journey that, that was DoorDash as a private company?
30:13 Speaker 02 Well, he certainly has grown a lot as a leader and I think the sort of thing I saw was I often find hard for a lot of founders is to figure out how to work collaboratively as a founder and a founding team to sort of take the mantle of being a CEO and lead as the CEO versus being one of the founders. And I saw that change happen relatively quickly, somewhere between the, the C to the A and somewhere past. The A and he sort of just kept stepping up. It wasn't just a division of labor. Hey, I do this. You guys do that. It was leading by sort of setting strategy, setting the tone, setting the culture.
30:54 Speaker 02 As I said, like some of the things that Tony said all the way back at the seed around the culture. He said back then too, like today you go to the S one of DoorDash. You'll see some of the things that he laid out about how DoorDash operates. Many of those things that he talked about, operating at the lowest level of detail, thinking about and not either or. Having optimism, but with a plan, those things weren't quite the same words at the beginning. But he was setting the tone back, all the way back when I started working with them. And I would also point out that founders start companies despite everybody telling them all the reasons why it's going to fail. So they almost don't listen and a CEO learns to listen and to listen very intensely
31:39 Speaker 02 and carefully and actively to everybody. But then they take all that information and weigh the different opinions and make up their own mind. And I think that's a quite important role to play. And I would say that's the role of a CEO, but it's also the role of almost every single executive.
31:56 Harry Stebbings? I do want to move into my favorite though, Alfred, which is a quick fire answer. I say a short statement and then you give me your immediate thoughts. So you ready to dive in?
32:03 Speaker 02 Sure.
32:03 Harry Stebbings? So what's a pre-parade and why do you do them in memos?
32:07 Speaker 02 Pre-parade is a, is the dream case. So it's pre. Amazon has this thing where they write this press release about the success of this beta product that they're about to launch. Write these pre-parade around investments that, you know, if all things go right, what are we going to celebrate, you know, 10 years from now? That's the pre-parade. And we want them in memos because we want the sponsor to sort of articulate exactly why this is a company of importance 10 years from now.
32:35 Harry Stebbings? Got it. And then in terms of the pre-mortem on the flip side, what was your pre-mortem here?
32:39 Speaker 02 The pre-mortem was pretty straightforward here, like the sort of, the downside is this is a company that is loved by their consumers because there is a consumer value proposition, but they're not. willing to pay for it and merchants are going to grovel about the take rate they can't invest in. And we were also very concerned about intense competition that drives the business to what we always talk about, which is economic profit is zero or worse. And you don't make great investments if the economic profit of the entity is zero. And so you could have this middling, hyper-local business that's great in only certain nice wealthy markets, but not a dominant player nationwide. And we worked very hard to make sure that that wasn't the case.
33:20 Harry Stebbings? Tell me, who's an unsung hero from the DoorDash team? And what did they do behind the scenes?
33:25 Speaker 02 I think the unsung heroes, there are many. I think the early operations team were a bunch of unsung heroes. They launched a bunch of cities. They went from market to market, trying to assess what was going on. They took a first principles approach to how each market is different from the others and tried to sort of get the seeding conditions right to get the markets up and running.
33:48 Harry Stebbings? And then the final one, and this one's probably my favorite here. And it's what's your favorite or most memorable story from working with the company? Did you always remember and hold dear to you?
33:56 Speaker 02 It's not a happy story. It's my favorite story because it talks to Tony's having optimism and with a plan. I think when we, you know, he had a hard time raising the seed because people didn't, there's no like richness of data, is this going to work everywhere? He had a fairly easy series A raise, in my opinion, because he had five term sheets and we were competing with five term sheets. And I had a jump on the competition, but it happened fairly quickly. He had a very easy series B raise and the series C and the series D were quite hard to raise. But I never saw Tony ever be dejected. He's like, my business is growing. I know the underlying metrics of my business is good.
34:39 Speaker 02 And he gained more conviction about the need to focus on inputs and rather than outputs. And in some sense, the company valuation is a vanity metric. It's an output metric. It's not that important because you're you're selling a small portion of the company when you're raising money. And you personally, as a founder, you're not selling any shares. So it's not like you're selling at this price. That you think is is bad, but the series C that Sequoia decided to lead was quite hard. I think the company had thought that because it had doubled or tripled GMV and the unit economics was getting better, that the valuation from the B to the C would be double or triple. And in fact, it ended up being a slightly flat round to a slightly down round.
35:22 Speaker 02 And he just did it and moved on and his focus was on the future. And so it's a story of resilience. That was the first story of resilience. And I really want to share the second story about working with the company that I really, really enjoyed, which is. The second story was in 2019, I thought this company was just on fire, firing on all cylinders, working very, very efficiently. Had hired good people, had the right team, Tony had surrounded himself with great board members as well. And then I saw him like take 2020 up a whole nother level. We were preparing to go public, we, the things were all great because of what had been done in before to make 2019 a great year.
36:04 Speaker 02 We're preparing to go public and when the pandemic happened, he went into a whole new level. And the team rallied to go to a whole new level. It wasn't clear when the pandemic happened that business would be good or bad. You could have a situation where with all the restaurants are closed and there would be no food delivery. So he worked hard to get the restaurants open. He looked around the world and saw exactly what had happened in different parts of the world. And there are parts of the world where they decided to shut down the restaurants just to keep them open. And then other parts of the world where they learned quickly, like in China, like with Meituan. And we obviously are also investors in Meituan from the very early days as well. About how exactly they were able to sort of pivot.
36:48 Speaker 02 So you learn from that, you applied it here, you got the restaurants to stay open. He helped the restaurants get their menus on DoorDash. It's like, hey, we've uploaded your menu, do you want to be on DoorDash? Just so that they can get the whole open for delivery sort of campaign going. He didn't care whether it was on DoorDash or it was on Uber Eats or on his competitors, on Postmates. He wanted to keep the restaurants open. He slashed. Missions for a period of time that totaled over a hundred million dollars during that time. And he made sure that dashers got P P E, did contactless deliveries. And he knew that the customer side would take care of itself. And so I'm really, really proud to be associated with this company that was firing on all cylinders in two thousand and nineteen.
37:33 Speaker 02 And then took it up a whole nother level when the pandemic happened.
37:36 Harry Stebbings? I mean, that really is incredible to hear on Tony and thank you so much for sharing that. But thank you so much for agreeing to do this, Alfred. This has been such a joy and I really appreciate it.
37:45 Speaker 02 All right. Thank you so much. It's really great to share this story with you.
37:51 Harry Stebbings? I mean, my word, I just love that episode and I want to say again, a huge thank you to Alfred for giving up the time today and for going so deep on that incredible story with DoorDash. If you'd like to see more from us behind the scenes, you can on Instagram at H Stebbings nineteen ninety six with two Bs. However, before we leave you today, Rippling has helped thousands of startups automate their H R and I T. From employee payroll and benefits to devices and apps. Now they're helping startups access better health, coverage and H R with their newest product, the Rippling P E O. So state by state compliance is a pain. And if you've hired employees in other states or your employees have relocated to other states because of Covid, you know what a pain registering with and maintaining each new state unemployment insurance office is. Employees paying too much for H R and benefits, the Rippling P E O can solve these challenges.
38:36 Harry Stebbings? As soon as you hire someone out of state or an existing employee relocates, Rippling automatically registers your startup with the appropriate unemployment agencies and keeps you compliant with all local regulations from minimum wage to sick leave. My word, that's a ton of complexity off your plate, so you're free to focus on building your startup. Visit rippling.com forward slash two zero V C to learn more and schedule a demo with some special discounts. And speaking of incredible products there with Rippling, Exodus is leading the world out of the traditional financial system by building beautiful and user-friendly blockchain products. With its focus on design and user experience, Exodus has become one of the most popular cryptocurrency apps. It's supported on both desktop and mobile, allowing you to sync your wallet across multiple devices. So you can really have access to your financial.
39:21 Harry Stebbings? Anywhere you can instantly exchange around 100 different cryptocurrencies straight from your wallet. Interactive charts even let you view an asset's price history and your portfolio's performance over time. And maybe the best part, Exodus is actually integrated with the Trezor hardware wallet, making advanced security easy for everyone. Visit exodus.io for your free download or search Exodus on the App Store or the Play Store. And last but by no means least, do you wish you were early in some of the biggest and best performing IPOs of 2019 and 20? Bit of a silly question there, of course you do, but our crowd investors were. And now you can join them in what's next. With our crowd accredited investors have access to invest directly, easily, and most importantly, early. Our crowd investors have benefited from our crowd companies IPOing like Beyond Meat
40:06 Harry Stebbings? or even being bought by companies like Intel, Nike, Microsoft and Oracle, to name a few. Today you can join our crowds investment in NanoLock Security, a company offering IoT cyber protection, including billions of low end devices that other technologies cannot protect. NanoLock is the only device level protection that has near zero power requirements and is agnostic to the operating system. You can get in early on NanoLock and other really unique opportunities at rcrowd.com/20vc. The rCrowd account is free, just go to rcrowd.com/20vc. As always, I so appreciate all your support and I can't wait to bring you actually an episode on Friday with an incredible Sequoia founder in Hubert at Product Board.
Previous 20VC: Evernote & mmhmm Founder Phil Libin on Why We are Beginning a Multi-Trillion Dollar Restructuring of the World, Why Shortcuts are the Biggest Mistakes Startups Make & The Future of Video and The Unbundling of Zoom Next 20VC: Why "Founder Insight" is Overrated, Why Big and Bold Product Visions Can Be Dangerous & Why Getting To Product Market Fit by Accident Can Lead to Danger with Hubert Palan, Founder & CEO @ ProductBoard Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated