Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: The Future of War: Are We Ready & What Needs to Be Done | China, Russia and Trump: What Happens Now | Raising $828M to Build the Defence Champion of Europe | Torsten Reil, Co-Founder @ Helsing About this episode Torsten Reil is the Co-Founder and Co-CEO of Helsing, a new type of defence company providing artificial intelligence to protect our democracies. Torsten has raised over $825M from the likes of Prima Materia, Elad Gil, Accel and General Catalyst. Previously Torsten founded NaturalMotion, one of the UK's most successful games and technology start-ups. Torsten was named as one of MIT's Top 100 Innovators and is a member of the Munich Security Conference Innovation Board. In Today’s Episode with Torsten Reil We Discuss: 1. The World Around Us: China, Russia and Trump: What will happen between China and Taiwan? What will happen between Russia and Ukraine? How will a Trump administration impact the US’ commitment to fund European defence? What conflict do people not pay enough attention to in the world today? 2. Are We Ready and What Needs to Be Done: Are the west ready to fight against our adversaries as we stand today? What do we need to do to equip ourselves? What needs to change in our defence budgets? Where do they need to go? How does the procurement process for defence need to change? 3. The Future of War: Why does Torsten believe the future of war is contactless? In the next wave of defence, what are the most important elements for allies to own? What elements concern Torsten the most? What role does AI and autonomous play in the future of war? 4. Is Europe F********: Why does Torsten believe that Europe’s biggest problem is ambition not capital? Why does Torsten believ that we put too much weight on the location in which companies are founded? Why does it not matter? How does Torsten respond to the statement that we do not have the depth of experienced talent in Europe to recruit?
Transcript 15,265 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 When we started Helsing in March 2021, we actually put one of our slides that we thought there were going to be two galvanizing events. One of them was going to be an invasion of Ukraine by Russia, the other one an invasion of Taiwan by China. There is a big wave coming towards us. It is autonomy and software in defence, and it's unstoppable. The thing that we have to avoid is the Tesla moment for the defence sector. If we collectively, including the primes, don't understand that and don't adapt, the same thing is going to happen to defence as happened to the car industry. Where are we in three years with Russia, Ukraine? What happens in China and Taiwan? Again, I think it's plausible that there will be-
0:35 Harry Stebbings? I mean, my word, those intros have gotten good. This is Harry Stebbings and I am so excited to welcome one of the great entrepreneurs of Europe to Hot Seat today, Torsten Rial. Torsten is the co-founder and co-CEO of Helsing, a new type of defence company, providing artificial intelligence to protect our democracies. Torsten has raised over $825 million from the likes of Prima Materia, Elagil, Excel and General Catalyst, to name a few. I also had wanted to make this show happen for a long time. Torsten does not do podcasts, and so this one meant a huge amount to me. But before we dive in, what do Henry Ford and AI have in common? Neither could change the world without automation. In the future, there will be two types of businesses, those that have
1:18 Harry Stebbings? automated and those that wish they had. UiPath, the undisputed leader in automation, is taking us into the era of agentic automation. UiPath's new AI agents don't just follow rules, they think, they make decisions, they work alongside the world's most powerful software robots, already trusted by over 10,000 businesses. If agentic automation sounds new, just think of UiPath as more growth, not more overhead platform, or happier customers, happier employees platform. Whatever you want AI to do for your business, agentic automation with UiPath will make it happen. Try UiPath's new AI agents for free at UiPath.com. The future of automation is both
2:01 Harry Stebbings? agentic and robotic, so don't get left behind. And speaking of transforming your business with cutting-edge technology, let's dive into another game- Atio. Atio is the next generation of CRM. Setting up Atio takes less than a minute and in seconds of syncing your email and calendar, you'll see all of your relationships in one place, all enriched with very valuable data. Atio also lets you build Zapier-style automations, gives you powerful reports, and works perfectly for any go-to-market motion from PLG to sales-led. And Atio is designed for the next era of companies like yours, and companies like yours shouldn't have to deal with inflexible, one-size-fits-all CRMs.
2:44 Harry Stebbings? So join industry leaders like Eleven Labs, Replicate, Modal and more to scale your startup beyond the next level. Head over to atio.com/20vc and you'll get 15% off, that's 15% off your first year at atio.com/20vc. And if Atio helps you stay ahead by streamlining your relationships and operations, today I want to talk about a venture fund making waves with its unusual model. I'm talking about the Fundrise Innovation Fund, which is democratizing venture capital as a public venture fund. For example, most of the AI revolution is being built and funded in the private markets. Companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, Databricks, these are incredible multi-billion dollar companies,
3:29 Harry Stebbings? but they're inaccessible to 99% of investors until they go public. Well, those days are finally over. Visit fundrise.com/20vc to check out the Fundrise Innovation Fund's impressive $150 million portfolio for yourself. Carefully consider the investment material before investing, including objectives, risks, charges and expenses. This and other information can be found in the Innovation Fund's prospectus at fundrise.com/innovation. This is a paid sponsorship.
3:59 Harry Stebbings? You have now arrived at your destination.
4:02 Harry Stebbings? Torsten, I've wanted to do this for a long time. Thank you so much for joining me today.
4:07 Speaker 00 Very good to see you. Thanks for having me.
4:08 Harry Stebbings? Now, I want to start with lessons from Natural Motion, actually. So, over a 15-year period, you built the company before selling to Zynga. And I just wanted to start with, what did you do the first time that worked and you took with you to Helsing?
4:23 Speaker 00 It was a long journey. Natural Motion started as a spin-out out of university, out of Oxford, and we were trying to create physically simulated creatures controlled by neural networks, which was a crazy idea at the time. This was the time, I think, of the Pentium processor or something. It's hard to do computationally, but it worked quite well. And we ended up using it and licensing it for visual effects in big Hollywood movies like Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, Spider-Man, then for big video games like GTA IV, GTA V. That worked quite well, but it only worked, I would say, okay in terms of revenues. You know, as a founder, you want to get to a hockey stick movement eventually, and that wasn't the case with the technology business. It was growing, but it was growing reasonably slowly. And I think one of the things that we did do well
5:07 Speaker 00 was that we recognized that growth wasn't as strong as we wanted to. And we took a big risk and pivoted the company to doing games ourselves. So, you know how people say, focus, focus, focus? We did focus, but only up to a point. At one point, we said, this isn't working the way we wanted to. So, let's pivot to actually making games ourselves. And we were very naive about how easy it was going to be. We watched Rockstar work, and we were big fans of Rockstar games. And we thought, well, we should give it a go as well. And ended up making games for iPhone, which worked out very well. We got a lot of support from Apple. Ended up creating CSR Racing, which was one of the largest iPhone games at the time. And at that point, the company did take off. And this kind of approach to risk-taking and going all-in
5:52 Speaker 00 stayed with me and I think stayed with Helsing now. We are big believers of focus, just doing very few things. And when things don't work, we try to adapt very quickly.
6:01 Harry Stebbings? If that's what works that you've taken with you to Helsing, there are things that naturally don't work and you want to discard. What didn't work that you're like, no, leaving that behind?
6:11 Speaker 00 I think one of the things that I I didn't quite appreciate was how important hiring is. And I know everyone says that is team is the most important thing and hiring should be your priority. But to really do it, to really do everything you can to get the very best people requires a different mindset and actually requires a lot of time in your calendar as well. With Natural Motion, we had a lot of great people, but we also eventually got, I think, into a rhythm of of maybe hiring people that were just there to add headcount, to get certain things done, to accelerate a project. And the reality was that almost never happened. In fact, what happened was that if you added more people, complexity went up, the company slowed down. It became much harder to manage. We had to fix it a couple of times with with quite large changes,
6:55 Speaker 00 including rifts, just to get the company to work again. And when we started Helsing, we made a commitment from the beginning that that wouldn't happen to us and that we would focus on hiring and really getting the really exceptional talent from the very beginning. And it transformed, I think, the company. I mean, Helsing is now a company that isn't even that large, but we we try to just hire people that are exceptional. And we do everything we can to get those people into the company. We hustle like crazy, whether it's on LinkedIn, whether it's through network. I mean, we won't give up until we we get the person that we want.
7:27 Harry Stebbings? How big is Helsing now?
7:28 Speaker 00 It's about three hundred and fifty people.
7:30 Harry Stebbings? Okay, three hundred and fifty people. Exceptional people, by very definition, are exceptions. My point to that being is they're not a certain size whereby you have to accept good because there are not that many exceptional people.
7:42 Speaker 00 Actually, I think there are a lot of exceptional people. Three hundred and fifty people isn't that many. It is possible that at three and a half thousand and maybe at ten thousand, you start to have to make compromises. But I'm not sure how a larger company has to grow in terms of headcount. In in our experience, that the top performers do the work of many people. They give the company a light-footedness that otherwise wouldn't be there and the speed that otherwise wouldn't be there.
8:03 Harry Stebbings? How quickly do you know when someone is exceptional?
8:06 Speaker 00 Quite often, within thirty minutes of an interview. That's what I usually try to achieve.
8:10 Harry Stebbings? What are the clearest signs?
8:12 Speaker 00 I think it's just a feeling. The thing I always look forward is is effortlessness. You know, not trying too hard, just being so kind of on top of the detail of everything that kind of the effortlessness shines through. That's the main thing I I look for.
8:25 Harry Stebbings? I look for unwavering imbalance.
8:27 Speaker 00 Okay.
8:29 Harry Stebbings? In any area of life, I just want the spikiest point. Like, what did you do that was truly exceptional? And it could be an anything. But if you have that capability to go so all in on something, I want to know why and the mindset behind it.
8:40 Speaker 00 It's interesting. I never ask questions in interviews like that. I don't have a set of questions. I just try to get into the flow.
8:46 Harry Stebbings? Really?
8:46 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:47 Harry Stebbings? And you don't find those commonalities in the questions that you ask?
8:50 Speaker 00 No, and I find them quite often too staged and people, I always think people can tell when a question is staged. And so they're not themselves. So it's easier for me to just go with the flow and kind of see where it goes.
9:01 Harry Stebbings? I heard this quote, it was actually Mark that told me this, and I think it's, you've said it before. But if you have two good people, replace them with one outstanding person.
9:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, this is about talent density. We do a founder offsite every three months. And we make kind of decisions about how we want to run the company. And one of the decisions that we made was that we, we really do everything to go for talent density. And that means really taking hiring seriously, but also taking performance management seriously. And making sure that only people that are Helsing people are, are at Helsing. And that means very often that we try to reduce the number of people overall. We, we found that the most performing teams are really small in the company. You can achieve a lot, particularly around software with three to four exceptional people. And so we'd rather have a team of four exceptional people than eight good people.
9:50 Speaker 00 It makes everything easier. It's also cheaper, by the way, even though you pay above market rate, it's cheaper to do it that way.
9:55 Harry Stebbings? Can you just talk to me about the structure there? So you have lots of three to four people teams. We just had Nick on the show from Revolut and he spoke about running 27 bets at the same time. And each team having eight to 10 people, three to four million pounds each. And then they manage that in kind of alignment. How do you structure those small teams and then monitor performance?
10:16 Speaker 00 First of all, we don't have a large number of small teams. We have, I would say a handful that work on particular projects. And then sometimes, you know, you're rarely around something and it can become a little bit bigger. That's happened over the last few months as we were working on particular projects. But what we try to do is identify areas. That we know needs to exist. We put a small team on it. We try to allow people to self-select as well, obviously, so that you have a team that communicates well, that is highly performant, and then they work on the task. And they may actually move off it eventually, and another team takes over. But that's worked really well for us.
10:48 Harry Stebbings? How do you performance manage well? And what've been your biggest lessons in doing that?
10:52 Speaker 00 First of all, I think you need to want to performance manage. Performance management is exhausting. You have to have difficult conversations with people. Sometimes they work out and they become better. Sometimes, you know, you decide to part ways. First of all, you have to have the mindset that this is necessary for a company.
11:06 Harry Stebbings? Do you need to do one-on-ones?
11:08 Speaker 00 No, I don't do any. One-on-ones work for people. I think that I'm used to them, that have structured them properly, and that work with people who need guidance in their development. The people I work with are usually senior and don't need that much guidance. If I need a one-to-one with them every week, I think something's probably going to, probably going wrong. I also think that there is a tendency for one-on-ones to clog up the calendar. You have a lot of them. You tend to repeat a lot of things. I used to do them religiously, by the way. I just stopped doing them. It hasn't, it hasn't had a negative impact.
11:36 Harry Stebbings? So I interrupted that, you there. So you need to want to performance manage, and a lot don't because it's hard. You have to have hard conversations. What else?
11:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, so this is something I noticed when I, when I was mainly angel investing in startups, is that eventually you get a certain number of people who are not a good fit for the company, and they clog up the system, the company. They make everything harder. They create pockets of unhappiness because they feel maybe neglected or not understood, or they don't fit into the culture. And you kind of tolerate it quite often as a founder. You tolerate it up to a point where you think, this doesn't feel like my company anymore. Like, what happened? That happened to me in natural motion, by the way, at some point. And it's really painful for a founder. But the reality is that if you want to counteract that, you have to make performance management one of the main things that you do from the beginning. You have to commit to it early on. And that means
12:26 Speaker 00 that you have to do the performance management, but probably as importantly, you have to also do what we call performance management calibration with all the leaders. So what we do at Helsing is that every quarter, we get one cohort, so one quarter of the leaders together, and they go through all the performance ratings that they gave their people and their teams. And then the leadership team. Listens to it and gives feedback, not necessarily on the person, but actually to the way they rate the performance and help them calibrate it against what good looks like at Helsing, either because they've been too harsh or vice versa, because they've been too lenient. And we do this religiously and it creates a culture of, I think, a well-calibrated performance system. And you need that because otherwise you end up with a lot of unfairness
13:11 Speaker 00 and also with not enough scrutiny, to be honest.
13:13 Harry Stebbings? When you put someone on a performance improvement plan, it does not work from there. Agree or disagree?
13:18 Speaker 00 I've seen actually quite a lot of people turn around, including at my previous company as well, on a performance management plan. So it's not a foregone conclusion.
13:25 Harry Stebbings? I heard about Helsing Speed beforehand from a lot of your investors. What is Helsing Speed?
13:30 Speaker 00 Helsing Speed is something that I nicked from Zynga. Zynga had Zynga Speed and Helsing Speed is basically-
13:36 Harry Stebbings? Incredibly creative.
13:37 Speaker 00 Very creative. And we, as the founders, felt very early on that speed was one of the most important things. When we started, I mean, a couple of things. When we started, we wanted to be fast because we needed to be fast. We had to catch up. I mean, it felt already, we started the company in 2021, that something was brewing, that geopolitical kind of tectonic plates were shifting, and we felt that we had no time to lose. The reason we raised quite a bit of money from the beginning was because we wanted to make sure that we could be fast. And, you know, speed became one of the main things for us. So, everyone's a way of blitzscaling, you know, the book. But you can summarize it quite quickly. There are sometimes situations when capital is available where it's okay
14:19 Speaker 00 to be inefficient, so that you can be effective, basically, and very fast. And we embraced it from the beginning. We tried to get recruitment up and running really quickly, which was crucial for performance culture. You need to basically always have pressure on the pipeline of good people coming in in order to be able to manage other people out and so that you end up with a pool of people that are amazing. And so we wanted to shortcut that and found a third party that, I wouldn't say overstaffed, but staffed very well so that we could get people in. Did a whole bunch of other things just to be fast, knowing that eventually we needed to settle at a different kind of level and not be inefficient, but be efficient and effective at the same time.
14:55 Harry Stebbings? I think a lot of founders will kid themselves that they- Are in this situation where blitzscaling is necessary, they need that cash and it's okay to be inefficient in order to be effective. When it's actually not the case, how do you think about when it is the case versus when it's not?
15:07 Speaker 00 So I think you need to make a commitment early on that it is usually a transitionary, so a temporary period. We wanted to do it for the first six to 12 months. So with recruitment, for example, we used a great third party and then eventually we moved into in-house.
15:21 Harry Stebbings? How much did you raise for your first round?
15:23 Speaker 00 So the seed was eight and a half million euros, but then we were lucky to have Daniel Eck and Prima Materia invest a hundred million euros four months later or so.
15:31 Harry Stebbings? How on earth does that happen? With respect, we both love Daniel and Shaq.
15:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:35 Harry Stebbings? But like eight to a hundred is a relatively atypical path of funding.
15:40 Speaker 00 Well, Daniel came into the into the seed round, he was an investor in our seed round, the eight and a half million. And within two or three months, I think he developed so much conviction that he asked like, I would like to lead you a series A, how much? How much money do you need? And I said ideally 100 million euros and he gave us the money through Prima Materia who've been who've been amazing to work with. It allowed us to do the speed thing that I just mentioned, but a couple of other things as well. It's it allowed us to to really focus on top talent very early on. And the and the second thing that allowed us to do is is to not go for innovation, you know, projects in defence for incubators and, you know, little grants here and there. But because we were quite well funded, we we could go for programmes of record, so the official large programmes, which were hard to get and very risky.
16:25 Speaker 00 But we were well funded enough that we could we could just take the risk and that worked out very well.
16:30 Harry Stebbings? Is Helsing a company that only a serial entrepreneur could found when you look at the capital requirements?
16:35 Speaker 00 I'm not sure about that. It it does make it easier. I would say Helsing is a company that you can only co-found. You need to have multiple founders.
16:42 Harry Stebbings? You said about the tectonic shifting plates in the geopolitical landscape that you saw that made you want to move fast. What did you see that very few other people saw in the tectonic plate shifting?
16:53 Speaker 00 I think the watershed moment was the annexation of Crimea in two thousand and fourteen by Putin. And as importantly, the reaction or lack of reaction by European and and Western governments in general. And we obviously acknowledged it and took note, but we didn't really understand the threat. And the danger even back then that that created was that you essentially allowed someone with territorial ambitions to do more. And it felt like the clock was ticking until that was going to happen. And so when we started policing in March two thousand and twenty one, which now feels like a very different time. We actually put in our, one of our slides that we thought there were going to be two galvanizing events. One of them was going to be an invasion of Ukraine by Russia, the other one, an invasion of Taiwan by China.
17:37 Speaker 00 So we got the Russia-Ukraine invasion right. What we got wrong was the timing because we thought it was going to happen in two thousand and twenty five. But in the event, it happened eleven months after we put that slide together. Ever since then, we we feel like it's sadly, it is rational to be pessimistic at the moment. And it feels like this hasn't quite fully sunk in, you know, across our democratic societies.
17:58 Harry Stebbings? In two thousand and fourteen, the annexation, we didn't understand or we didn't really prioritize enough. I struggle to believe we don't understand, Austin.
18:06 Speaker 00 I think we probably intellectually understood it, but we didn't really want to think through the consequences. Because the consequences were that we needed to start thinking about defence again, about conflict, all the suffering that comes with it. And we didn't want to think about it. We thought it might go away. And actually, that happened for many years afterwards as well, and and even to some extent now. And I understand it, I understand it emotionally as well. But I think it's intellectually lazy to not take the next step and think about what actually is required to protect our democracies.
18:35 Harry Stebbings? Before we go into what's required, what happens from here?
18:38 Speaker 00 The question is whether we are prepared again to think it through and commit to the next steps, which are an increase in defence spending, even if it is expensive, even if that means making sacrifices elsewhere. Because the sacrifice that otherwise we'd have to make is is potentially so large, it's the right thing to do. That I'm not sure is happening at the moment.
18:56 Harry Stebbings? I mean, Keir Starmer has actively said we will not have an increase in defence spending.
19:00 Speaker 00 Well, I think most governments are actually committing to an increase over time. So we are at, I think roughly, probably 2% right now on average in NATO. That's quite low historically. It's been through the Cold War, it's been 3% to 6% or so. But if you look at Poland, Poland has gone from, I think, 2.1% or so to 4.6, 4.7 within just a few years. So it's clearly possible. Whether every country is going to act at that speed remains to be seen. I think there are budget pressures everywhere. We understand them. And you have to convince a lot of people to actually re-channel so much money towards defence. It's not easy, I get that, but I think it's going to happen.
19:33 Harry Stebbings? How do you think the Trump administration changes the European funding requirements in this situation? Because he's actively said before, you are not pulling your weight.
19:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think we've already been on that trajectory, I think, starting from 2016, where obviously similar arguments were being made. And with the Ukraine conflict, defence spending has gone up. You know, sometimes part of the general budget, sometimes it's part of separate budgets, like Germany, the 100 billion. So that's already happening. I think the need for European sovereignty has clearly become even more important. So I think we're just going to go further down on that vector. It might just be that we're going to have to go faster.
20:06 Harry Stebbings? The need for European sovereignty has become more important. Can you explain that to me?
20:11 Speaker 00 Again, I mean, it's been clear for many years now that we cannot rely on partners to secure and protect Europe, at least not over a long period of time. I think right now that's still there, but I think over time, there just won't be, I think, the capability even of partners, and as it looks, also not the willingness to do so. And quite frankly, I think, as a continent as Europe, which is still rich, we should have that kind of pride. We should want to protect ourselves. We should not need to rely on others. We should be equals in a partnership, and that's what our partners want as well. And so it's natural, I think, that we need to go there anyway. We've just been so used to a different kind of situation that we just need to unlearn it now and think about security ourselves.
20:54 Harry Stebbings? Will Trump pull out of Ukraine?
20:57 Speaker 00 I don't know. I don't think anyone knows. You know, it's clear what he talked about. It's clear that he's made certain statements, but we'll see. We'll see what's going to happen.
21:05 Harry Stebbings? Many people think that we are on the cusp of a defence spending boom. Do you think that's actually realistic? You mentioned there the 2%. We all appreciate it needs to go higher. Is that rational and are we at the cusp?
21:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'm not sure whether it's a boom or not. I think we'll see some countries increase their defence budget a little bit. We'll see others, I mentioned Poland, increase it drastically. And particularly the countries that are most exposed to the eastern flank, to the NATO eastern flank, are more likely to increase their defence spending. It's already happening. It's happening in Scandinavia as well. Other parts of Europe may or may not increase it as much. That I think we'll have to see. I'm not sure I would call it a boom. I think it's an increase that will go into fixing a lot of things that are broken at the moment. And then some of that increase will go into new equipment spend as well, but only some of it. And of that, there'll be a proportion that will need to go urgently to what's called new defence, defence technology. But that will only be a part.
22:01 Harry Stebbings? Who do you determine who you sell to versus who you don't?
22:05 Speaker 00 You mean which countries?
22:06 Harry Stebbings? Yeah.
22:07 Speaker 00 I mean, it's a bigger topic, but the question is whether you should stop at export laws or whether you should give it more thought. And what we did from the beginning at Helsing is we made a commitment to ourselves, but also to the outside world that we would take ethics really seriously. There are two reasons for it. Is one of them is, as a company that's based in democratic countries, we believe we have, we have a special responsibility to think about ethics and how our technology is used and who we make it available to. Secondly, we want to attract, we want to be a broad church. We want to attract all kinds of different people with different political views, backgrounds, et cetera. And to accommodate those people, you need to give everyone in the company the commitment that we think together carefully about the pros and cons of certain decisions.
22:51 Speaker 00 Decisions always have to be made eventually by, by the founders, but the decision process, you can include everyone. And that's what we've done from the beginning. So we have many ethics workshops, which are extremely well attended. We now have to have to break them up into several subgroups.
23:06 Harry Stebbings? What ethical elements come up that you did not expect to come up? Because there's obviously like the obvious, don't sell to bad people.
23:12 Speaker 00 Sure. First of all, even the complexity around who do you sell it to is interesting because they're very obvious ones that we'll all agree on. But then there are ones in between which are...
23:22 Harry Stebbings? Who do we, sorry, who do we agree on? It's like China.
23:25 Speaker 00 North Korea.
23:25 Harry Stebbings? Iran, North Korea.
23:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, for example, that that we would agree. And then there are this where it becomes a bit more complex. One of the main reasons we we we do these workshops is that we get everyone to contribute to the decision process, but also for everyone to build what we call this ethics muscle. Because for me, everything was kind of, there were breadlines, everything was black and white and it was kind of easy. The more you dive into a particular topic, the harder actually it becomes to make these calls and the more complex it becomes. And that is something that we didn't just want to decide kind of in a small group of people or some small ethics group. We wanted everyone to contribute to it so that everyone had buy in and understood the pros and cons. Not everyone may agree with the decisions that we eventually take, but everyone can see how we arrived at those decisions.
24:07 Harry Stebbings? What decision did you take that was most unpopular?
24:10 Speaker 00 I don't think decisions have been particularly unpopular unpopular yet. We just recently announced that we are building strike drones and we build strike drone software as well. And that is, you know, fraught with all kinds of complexities and that you have to think about around the ethics. Side of it, both in terms of technology usage, how it's used, et cetera. And that is something that everyone contributed to the thinking around this. And we managed to shine a line light on areas of technology development that I can't go into sadly, that actually we probably didn't think about that much before. So the other important part is that if you have a lot of, I think, intelligent, engaged people, look at the ethics problem around technology usage, conops and the concept of operations. You just shine a light on kind of any kind of remaining area.
24:55 Speaker 00 And so you just have much better coverage of of all the questions that you have to do.
24:59 Harry Stebbings? Before we go to this very important news, so you don't sell to those three, who are the ambiguous, like who's the like?
25:06 Speaker 00 Well, the easiest way to look at clear and not clear is to check out the Economist Democracy Index. That's what we used initially.
25:13 Harry Stebbings? The Economist Democracy Index.
25:14 Speaker 00 Exactly. So the Economist releases a list every year and it ranks countries according to how democratic they are, with ten, I believe, being the highest one, going down to zero. And so the ones at the top are easy, the ones at the bottom are also easy. And then it starts becoming more complex in the middle because you have some countries, even in the EU, where in the past they haven't been kind of ranked that highly. But then governments have changed and they've ranked more highly again. So. It basically becomes a moving target. And then there are also considerations around, are they parts or are these some of these countries that are maybe in the gray gray zone, part of democratic alliances that become important for democracies to survive and protect themselves?
25:54 Harry Stebbings? How do you think about the transience of right and wrong? And what I mean by that is like, you know, when when Israel terrible, the seventh happened, it was like, the world got behind Israel. And now we've seen the backlash against what's happened in Gaza. And one could argue that they fought back with too much force. And what was a worthy customer may become an unworthy customer.
26:14 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think these complexities are there with any conflict. And eventually it becomes it becomes complex and there is no right or wrong. I'm always aware that this sounds like a cop out. And this is what I've always been afraid of is that when you say it's complex, it sounds like a cop out, but it isn't a cop out. It is actually complicated and complex. And you also need to weight certain components in a way that can be arbitrary. And and so every conflict, I think, has these kinds of complications and it's our responsibility to navigate it. Again, we could just lean back and say there's export law that makes it really easy. But I think if you want to have people really engaged with these kinds of technologies and capabilities in a company, you need to go further than that. You need to build a view that goes beyond just what is quite static export law.
26:58 Harry Stebbings? Has there ever been a case where it's like, there's European sovereignty and supporting Europe and making sure that we get great provisions of, you know, amazing equipment versus actually the money is to be made elsewhere, money is to be made selling in the US in other countries. And actually, you have a balance between European sovereignty and revenue optimization.
27:16 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, I mean, the Helsing was founded to support Europe and to be a European company, also to be a European lighthouse company and a company that helps Europe protect itself. So that's always the number one thing. And if kind of people ask like, what is it you want to, you know, where do you want to be in five years with Helsing or what is it you want to achieve? It's it's very simple. We we want to make Europe safer. We want to be able to point at the difference that we've made in terms of the geopolitical security of this continent. That is the goal of the company. Everything else has to follow from that. Obviously, it needs to be a company that's large enough so that it has leverage, that it can deploy a lot of equipment, that it can work with some of the most complex systems like the Eurofighter that we're that we're working on. But that's all it means to an end.
28:01 Speaker 00 The goal is always to protect Europe.
28:04 Harry Stebbings? I do want to stay on the drones because otherwise I'm going to discuss Europe but a little bit later. On the drones side, it's a massive introduction moving to hardware as well. It's a big new chapter for the company. Why did you decide that now was the right time to make this big new change? Just talk to me about that.
28:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, Helsing is a software company, is a software-first company, always has been and always will be. Almost everyone is a software engineer. That's where we've come from. That's how we hired. And, you know, we are in a large, in a number of large contracts. For example, we, you know, working with Saab on the Eurofighter Electronic Warfare Upgrade Programme, that's pure software, you know, our contribution. And software can make a massive difference. In this particular case, AI can, because we can start to read the intent of shape-shifting anti-aircraft radar systems. And so software plays a huge role. And we always said it creates a 10x multiplier in terms of capabilities. That's still the case, that will always be the case, and we will always do those software programmes. So software and software contracts work in defence, even though some people say it
29:03 Speaker 00 is impossible, it clearly is possible. However, there are some areas where software needs to be, it needs to have a hardware carrier. With a Eurofighter, we have a combat aircraft as a carrier, and that's great, and we're not building a Eurofighter. But with drones, you need to think about drones differently in order for them to have the effect that you want them to have, which is basically precise mass. So you want to be able to have a large number of drones extremely precise to provide a deterrent that doesn't exist at the moment. And so for that, you need to have large numbers of drones, you need to have the ability to manufacture those drones in a way that isn't the case right now. Most drone companies right now build small numbers of quite exquisite drones, they're quite expensive, sometimes a bit of a boutique business where people really care about the
29:48 Speaker 00 hardware and the carbon and everything else, but that's not what we need. What we need is really scaled up production. And so when we looked at what's required in terms of capability, we couldn't certainly on the Western market, we couldn't find anyone who was able to produce these large numbers. And so that's when we started to look at can we build these kinds of drones ourselves and can we think about it differently from a software first point of view, meaning that we can shift a lot of the complexity from hardware into software, we can simplify the hardware and we can manufacture it in much larger numbers at at lower prices. And that's what we did with the HX2, which we just announced a couple of days ago.
30:25 Harry Stebbings? How does the company need to change with the integration of hardware? Respectfully, you said it's a software first company with software engineers. Hardware is an entirely different ballgame.
30:33 Speaker 00 It is and it isn't. So it is in that there are many areas where you need to have hardware experts and we've built an amazing team that obviously, you know, deals with things like the design, the components, but also the supply chain. And that's different from software. But you can think about hardware as software as well. You can you can optimize a lot of parts of hardware by shifting complexity into software and you can also test hardware in software. And so we spend a lot of time building infrastructure for the entire company around simulation platforms, for example, AI infrastructure platforms, et cetera. And some of that technology is also applicable to hardware. So we've developed our drones extremely fast and we've tested them extremely fast. And the reason we're getting to that kind of iteration speed, and it is all about iteration, just iterate, iterate, iterate,
31:18 Speaker 00 is because we can move a lot of the testing into software. And only when we get to a certain point, we move it into hardware, we test it in hardware and then we go back into software again. So these two things, if you do it well, which we're trying to do, are extremely interlinked. And the best hardware companies, I think, are software companies and vice versa.
31:36 Harry Stebbings? What can you not test in software that has to be tested in hardware?
31:40 Speaker 00 Software can, with the right simulation environment, go really far. But there will be some things that maybe you didn't expect that aren't covered in your simulation. That happens in particular when when you're deployed, as our drones are in Ukraine, then, you know, the Realities of conflict with all things that you that you just didn't anticipate. And so that's something that you you have to test.
32:00 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask you, I spoke to someone the other day, I was looking at a defence company, and they said, the challenge is compliance, especially around drones, that a lot of governments cannot buy single use drones because of the single use nature of it. My question to you is, to what extent does compliance become an inhibitor to government procurement?
32:17 Speaker 00 It is an inhibitor, like many other things as well. But for the complaints that we have about procurement and everything else, a lot of these rules are also there for a reason. Are they always applied in the right way and in as timely a way as, you know, ideally would be possible? Probably not, but the rules quite often make sense.
32:33 Harry Stebbings? What's the craziest rule?
32:35 Speaker 00 I think there are lots of rules and it's frustrating. But if you enter defence as a company, that is what you've signed up for. And so you'll rarely hear us complain about how slow procurement is, et cetera, because people want to do the right thing. The procurement officials also want to do the right thing. And by the way, I think politicians do too. It's just that eventually you end up with a system that's gone over a long time where the incentives aren't quite aligned with the realities of conflict.
32:59 Harry Stebbings? Well, this is my point. Are they incentivised to innovate? Or are they incentivised to continue longstanding relationships with primes where there is zero risk of job loss if it goes wrong?
33:08 Speaker 00 I think the system probably incentivises the latter, but that doesn't mean that there aren't individuals, actually across different forces, in procurement agencies, but also in politics, who really want to innovate. It does exist.
33:20 Harry Stebbings? How could the structure of the system be changed where innovation and procurement of new innovation is encouraged, not job loss avoided?
33:28 Speaker 00 So there are all kinds of, I think, little things that you could do. But what we are suggesting is that you introduce a mandatory 20% on new defence companies for defence equipment. That is the easiest way of doing it. So if you reserve of your defence equipment spend, so not the stuff on maintenance and everything else, but actually defence equipment. If you reserve 20% of that to new defence companies, which you can define, that is a shortcut to actually realigning incentives.
33:53 Harry Stebbings? What is the current spending on new defence companies?
33:56 Speaker 00 I think it's less than 1%. It's incredibly low.
33:58 Harry Stebbings? And so a shift to 20%, a shift to 20% though is just Helsing. I mean, there are not that many other defence startups.
34:05 Speaker 00 Not at scale, no. I mean, they're they're smaller ones.
34:07 Harry Stebbings? Yeah.
34:07 Speaker 00 Um. But not at scale.
34:09 Harry Stebbings? We we mentioned the compliance element there. What are the other hardest elements of selling into government that are not often discussed?
34:16 Speaker 00 There are many. The first thing is that you um you also have to have relationships with governments, with the right decision makers. You have to have a government relations team that deals with all of that. And in Helsing's case, it's not just one country, it's it's it's several. And so we're active in the UK, in France and in Germany, just recently opened an office in Estonia, and and there'll be more over time. So we have to have those relationships with various governments. You have to then think about how do you deal with lobbying from industry? So not not every prime in in in the defence industry is is yet our friend. I think we are, we want to reach out to all of them, but not everyone sees us friends yet.
34:52 Harry Stebbings? Who's your friend and who's not your friend?
34:55 Speaker 00 Well, probably Saab is a friend, for example. We work very closely with them. Um. Their shareholders in Helsing as well, clearly close friends. Others, I think it can fluctuate. I don't mean this in jest. I I think we all genuinely need to work together. I think we all have bigger fish to fry and defence primes will always have a role. We don't think that they they will disappear. Um. In fact, actually, I think they will, they will grow if we do things right. The thing that we have to avoid is the Tesla moment for the defence sector. If there there is a big wave coming of new technology and it's all around autonomy, software and AI, essentially, again, precise mass. If we collectively, including the primes, don't understand that and don't adapt, the same thing is going to happen to defence as happened to the car industry.
35:38 Speaker 00 The new wave was electric, software and autonomy.
35:41 Harry Stebbings? What does that mean if it happens? Why is that such a challenge?
35:44 Speaker 00 We're going to be faced with a large number of autonomous systems from our adversaries. That's going to be the focus that they're going to take. And and by the way, it's quite likely that they won't have the same ethical red lines that we as democratic societies should have. So they have, from a functionality point of view, I think they'll they'll have the ability to take shortcuts that we don't want to take. We have to earn the luxury, basically, to to be able to really care about ethics, and that means that we have to have technology leadership overall.
36:11 Harry Stebbings? Do we underestimate the capabilities of Russia and Iran specifically?
36:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think so. I mean, they're quite clear for everyone to see Iran is producing a large number of drones already. They've been using and working on the Shahed, for example, for a long time. They've licensed that design to Russia. Russia's now manufacturing it itself. Software is getting better over time. Russia has the Lancet, which is a capable strike drone, quite different from a Shahed, which I think they've developed themselves. And the software for all of these is getting better as well. We're going to be faced either through Russia alone or through partners like Iran with adversaries that are committing to precise mass, large number of autonomous systems that we're going to have to counter one way or the other. And you can counter them, but you can't counter them with the current systems that we have. You can't just have exquisite exquisite systems like tanks,
36:59 Speaker 00 artillery guns, that are not particularly well-connected, that take a while to to take a shot. You need to work basically at the speed of software. You need to interconnect all of these systems, but crucially, you need to have precise mass on your own side as well. You need to have the ability, however horrible that sounds, to have thousands and tens of thousands of strike drones to deter.
37:19 Harry Stebbings? Do governments understand this?
37:20 Speaker 00 I think some governments are starting to understand it. I think governments at large probably haven't understood it. There is a big wave coming towards us, and it's it is autonomy and software and defence. And it's unstoppable. And we're just going to be forced into that race.
37:33 Harry Stebbings? When you say like autonomy, software and defence, can you unpack just how you see the future of warfare and conflict with AI and autonomy in mind?
37:41 Speaker 00 We can already look at Ukraine and look at the trends there. And the trend, even at the beginning, there were some drones that were being used. Remember the the TB2s, for example, from Turkey. Over time, that's evolved towards more and more drones. Initially, it was to make up for lack of artillery munitions. Now, actually, the drones themselves have such good success that more and more are being built. And I believe Ukraine is is building one and a half million FPV drones, the small first-person view drones a year. I think Russia is building roughly the same. So there's already a a shift towards mass and reasonably precise mass. What hasn't happened yet is that those drones are scalable, but that will happen in terms of their usage. At the moment, you have one operator operating one drone. It's going to happen quite quickly that that's going to change, and you'll be able
38:25 Speaker 00 As a single operator to control multiple drones. And that trend, I think, we'll see playing out as early as next year. It's not long now because the algorithms are all coming. And we know this because we have those algorithms too.
38:37 Harry Stebbings? You said they're about drones having success. How do you measure success?
38:41 Speaker 00 I think it's the ability to hit a target. It's hitting a target that itself uses electronic warfare. So it tries to jam the signal of the drone. These are some of the bigger problems right now that Ukraine is facing and that NATO will be facing in a peer conflict as well, or any other country in a peer conflict. So drones themselves, if they're just remote controlled drones, eventually have the problem that they can be jammed. That's GPS jamming, so it doesn't know where it is. Or it's comms jamming, which means that the control inputs to the drone or the video feedback from the drone to the operator is jammed and therefore you can't use it. So this is the problem. I mean, there's a jamming station, the frontline every few kilometres right now. So it's almost impossible to get around jamming at the moment.
39:22 Harry Stebbings? The thing that Matt from Andro's taught me is actually the different economies of conflict. And what I mean by that is that you can send one very expensive million pound drone in and it can be shot down with a fifty thousand pound missile or whatever that is. And you can continuously have this miss economies or mismatch in cost versus kind of breakdown.
39:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:42 Harry Stebbings? How do you think about that?
39:43 Speaker 00 It's the same thing with strike drones and tanks and artillery. A tank costs several million pounds, euros. A strike drone is much, much, much cheaper. Depending on how things play out, you need one or maybe two or three strike drones, even with countermeasures to actually overcome a tank. That's basically the danger, same as true for artillery systems. They become very hard to defend. And the problem with mass, especially precise mass, is that you can solve almost every problem with saturation. So even if there were countermeasures, say on the tank side.
40:12 Harry Stebbings? So what do you mean you can solve every problem with saturation?
40:14 Speaker 00 It means that basically instead of sending one, you send five. If they're cheap enough, you can just do that. And at some point, you just over saturate defenses of an expensive system and it's still very cheap to do it that way. If you just think about the economics of it, you still have a really strong asymmetry. And so it'll become harder and harder unless you find a way to really counteract these systems, which is hard to send expensive tanks and artillery systems into battle. When on the other side, there are strike drones that are much, much cheaper.
40:41 Harry Stebbings? Is the future of war contactless in terms of like human contact?
40:45 Speaker 00 Ultimately, yes, I think ultimately, again, you can already see the first signs in Ukraine. Some areas of the battlefield are essentially no-go zones for humans because you have drones buzzing over you all the time. I think that gives us a kind of a first indication how conflict is going to evolve. It'll be impossible, and I think ethically extremely problematic to send humans into a battlefield that is facing large numbers of autonomous intelligence systems on the other side.
41:09 Harry Stebbings? What is the point of a battlefield? I know that sounds like a very strange and glib statement, but if it's just an empty landmass area where you have drones flying conflict against other artillery, what are we doing here?
41:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, it's it's usually not done in a way that there's some kind of sequestered field and, you know, you work it out and then whoever wins wins the conflict. Obviously, it tends to be related to obviously physical proximity to areas that matter. You know, whether it's ports, certain routes, obviously, or other important landmarks. That's where battlefields tend to be located.
41:39 Harry Stebbings? Honestly, to also listen to you and I'm I'm quite scared. Like, when you think about autonomous swarms of drones, it is pretty terrifying. Does it scare you and is it right to scare?
41:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think it should be disconcerting to all of us. I think we should think about it and think about the implications and we should think. And I don't think this is happening enough. I think we should think about how we want this technology to work so that we can still stay safe, but we don't have to compromise on our ethical standards.
42:04 Harry Stebbings? Are we seeing a change in public perception around defence spending?
42:09 Speaker 00 I think so. So if I look at polls now, I think for most countries, population agrees that more needs to be spent on defence. I think when it then comes to looking at what is going to be cut, I think people probably will differ. And being very concrete will make, I think, that kind of view a little bit harder. I think overall populations get it. Whether politicians currently have the courage to actually implement it is a different matter. I think in some countries, probably that's going to happen. We talked about Poland earlier, in others, it's taking longer.
42:36 Harry Stebbings? If I were to say, here you are, UK Defence Budget, this is yours and you are my new Defence Minister, how would you allocate it?
42:43 Speaker 00 Again, 20% to new defence. It sounds self-serving, but it's absolutely required. If we just keep buying the same kind of equipment that we've bought before, if we don't network it, if we don't give it AI, if we don't produce precision mass, we won't be able to deter and we won't be able to defend ourselves in a conflict.
43:00 Harry Stebbings? Our primes delivering what they should be. And Matt Grim very articulately said that they simply just take too long.
43:06 Speaker 00 They probably do take too long. I think they're incentivized in different ways. And the US is different to other countries. Every country is different. And the various primes are different as well. In general, they're not incentivized to spend a lot of their own money on R and D. It's probably less than 5% or so. For a company like Helsing, it's almost all of it. I mean, we pre-finance almost everything. And that's why we raised quite a bit of money because we need to be able to spend on developments before we actually. Because first of all, we have to prove that it works. And we can't wait for governments to eventually get it and then fund it. And then in eight years, we have a system. We need a system in eight months, basically. Or let's make it a year or two years.
43:43 Harry Stebbings? So one, we have 20% to new defense. What else?
43:47 Speaker 00 I think, again, procurement needs to be reformed. Everyone knows that. The reason we don't talk about it that much is because it will take a long time to do it. It needs to be obviously faster, probably less constrained. And the incentives need to be aligned more again towards speed, which they're not right now, which makes it harder for the individuals there to do what's right for, you know, that particular.
44:06 Harry Stebbings? How do we align it to speed? You're the defense minister who will listen to this.
44:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, first of all, I think you you simplify the processes, but you also make sure that, you know, you actually set deadlines that are quite tight in terms of when you actually produce something. And then, you know, you try to work with companies that want to work very hard and fast. And you incentivize other companies that maybe, you know, have a different way of working to to do the same. Primes and hardware need to work together with software to be really effective for future conflicts.
44:34 Harry Stebbings? What does the market composition look like in the future? Because at the moment, we just have primes, basically. What does that market composition look like in the future?
44:41 Speaker 00 I think it will be similar. There will be primes and then there'll be suppliers.
44:45 Harry Stebbings? How many new primes will there be?
44:47 Speaker 00 A very small number, extremely small number.
44:49 Harry Stebbings? So for all those doing defense funds, building defense portfolios, is defense in itself a category? Or is it the classic, like, if you want to invest in Helsing, don't do the next Helsing, just do fucking Helsing?
45:01 Speaker 00 So I think what happened is that the VCs that really get Defence, and there are a number, have already kind of made their bets on Defence companies. There is now kind of a second or third wave of VCs that go into Defence and fund technology teams, which is fine in a way. But my question to those VCs would be like, wow, what is the exit route for those companies? Who's going to buy them? You or Anduril? Yeah, but we can't buy all of those companies. And also the question is whether we would buy them at VC valuations. I mean, the exit opportunities for companies are either an IPO. For that, you need to be a prime. You need to be multi-domain. You have to have all of the foundation of, you know, having built software infrastructure, everything around security, physical security, cybersecurity, government relations, export
45:45 Speaker 00 law, compliance and everything else. That all has to happen. And then you have a shot. I thought building a customer success team was hard.
45:53 Speaker 00 It is. I, I, Defence is so complex. I, like, having built a games company, which I thought was pretty hard. Defence is just on a different level. Impossible, I think, if you don't have a founder team that already has experience in some of the, some of the areas. Are the majority of VC dollars going into Defence companies today going to go to zero? I think for some of the more fragmented tail, maybe not to zero, but I think they're going, going to go down. Where is the biggest opportunity to deploy dollars in Defence today? I mean, I'm biased, but I think it is around those companies that have got to scale, that have programmes of record and that are basically active in a conflict. The difference between a company that, first of all, maybe R and D contracts and has a programme of record, that is already a big difference because getting over that hump of getting a programme of record is.
46:37 Speaker 00 Why is a programme of record huge? What is a programme of record? It's, it's, it's an official programme by a government that has a certain size rather than, and I mentioned the Euro five electronic warfare upgrade. That was, that was officially awarded, companies pitched for it and eventually consortia pitched for it and eventually consortia won it, which is Sabanas in the end. Those happen regularly and they tend to be quite large. They run over several years. By contrast, they are innovation projects, which is quite often almost a parallel track to all of this, where there are smaller pots of money to prove that certain forces or nations can do innovation in Defence. The problem is, you may kind of get 500K from, from one of these projects. And you win it and you and you show to your VC, we've we've made revenues.
47:19 Speaker 00 The jump from there to actually program of record is is huge because all of the apparatus that's required to pitch for these programs, to have, again, the government relationships, some of the lobbying that's required, compliance, again, export law, I mentioned it earlier, that isn't required for these innovation projects. So these kind of teams have a feeling, I've now taken the first step, now the next step is a program of record, not realising it's a completely different kettle of fish. And again, I had to learn all of this because for me, it was natural.
47:45 Harry Stebbings? For those that make the transition, what will be needed for them to make the transition successfully?
47:50 Speaker 00 They need to build the teams around it, and this is where one of the problems lie. There's a scarcity of talent around go-to-market, government relations, even compliance and other things, even security, to be honest, in defence. So all of these companies would be competing for a very small pool of people. It's just impossible to turn them all into primes. It's just not going to happen. Coming back to the innovation side, you end up with something that looks like product market fit and you think it's great technology, you've shown it and it can do something, maybe take a drone down or something. But I had to learn that that is just a very small part of building a prime. It's like one eighth maybe or something is product market fit. Then you have to do all the rest. And for that, you need to build the infrastructure to build the prime, which Andrew has done, for example, it's a good example. We've we've done it too, we're certainly in the process of doing it, and you know,
48:35 Speaker 00 still a ways to go. But but I think that's what's underappreciated. And it's it's not underappreciated with VCs that know about defence, but with, I think, VCs that are maybe as distant to it as I was when I was previously in the gaming industry. I I think for them, they quite often don't don't get what it takes to actually build a large company.
48:51 Harry Stebbings? Do you think naivety is a wonderful benefit in entrepreneurship or a danger?
48:55 Speaker 00 Hundred percent, hundred percent. And most founders will say, had I known how hard this is, I would never have tried.
49:00 Harry Stebbings? Had you known how hard this is, would you have tried?
49:02 Speaker 00 Helsing, yes, yeah. With Natural Motion, I went through some really tough times.
49:07 Harry Stebbings? Why Helsing yes, Natural Motion no?
49:10 Speaker 00 There's several reasons, but the main reason now is that three founders, it's easier to build a company, even when you go through really difficult times, because you have each other to rely on, you have each other as a sounding board. It sounds a bit kumbaya, but it's very important.
49:24 Harry Stebbings? Kats, what's been the hardest moment where you needed them to get through it?
49:28 Speaker 00 Well, we've been through hard moments like throughout the company, but but like really difficult times were over the last few weeks when we had to wail into existence, a hardware platform, having come into it, not knowing much about it, having to do it in record time, having to think about supply chains and everything else around it. I mean, that's difficult and and you do it while there's lots of noise in the market and all kinds of other things and you still have to build a company. And it's time consuming, there are lots of setbacks and it is much easier to do it if you have several shoulders rather than just one, to get through all of this stuff. And and there'll be more setbacks happening, like with every startups, you you just don't know what's going to happen. And there'll be, you you know what it's like with a startup, that's what I experienced at Natural Motion, you're already on the floor, you've already been punched in the
50:12 Speaker 00 face several times, and then another one comes, and then another one comes, which you didn't expect. Those are the worst, is when you're kind of already, fuck, I'm done, and it's relentless. The only thing I would say is that with Natural Motion, we got out of it eventually, even out of, we had some situations that were very hard to get out of, we still managed to do it. And it wasn't some kind of.
50:32 Harry Stebbings? Now the Natural Motion journey's over, can you share one that's like an, oh shit?
50:37 Speaker 00 One was when we did our integration into GTA IV with our technology euphoria, which was an animation runtime engine. We had already optimized the hell out of it. And we had great optimization people for gaming consoles. But GTA was, IV was an amazing game and really pushed the consoles to its to its limits. And I felt the technology was great, but there was a point where we got a call from Rockstar saying, we don't have the performance budget for for your engine anymore. So you either runs another 10 times faster, or we can't use it. And I remember putting the phone down and thinking, we are fucked. And and like, I was sure we're fucked, because we'd already optimized everything. This was one of those moments where a a number of our engineers eventually went to Edinburgh to work directly with a team there, until they somehow.
51:20 Speaker 00 How managed to get that performance gain and the engine stayed in there and it was the beginning kind of of of natural motion proper because it was such an important game and it made everyone proud. It's also taught me about how exceptional engineers can make crazy things happen. And I was convinced this wasn't going to work out and they made it happen. Like to this day, have so much respect for great software engineers, the best software engineers, they make all of us look good.
51:45 Harry Stebbings? I spoke to Shaq before the show and he told me I had to ask a question really focused around a quote of yours, which is capital isn't the problem. Ambition is when it comes to Europe and our current state.
51:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, so I think people complain about all kinds of things about Europe and and and general startup environments. I don't think that there is a lack of capital in Europe, certainly not seed, serious A, sometimes even serious B. You could even argue there's too much. What's missing is to some extent operational knowledge because we haven't had as many startups that became big as the US, specifically Silicon Valley has had. But I think more important is ambition, is ambition specifically on the side of a founder, ambition combined with aggressiveness. And that aggression, that lack of aggression, that lack of ambition holds almost everyone back. And it's still acceptable to build companies and sell them at a value of one hundred million. And I understand why, because it's life changing for everyone, but it's actually not what Europe needs.
52:39 Speaker 00 We need much bigger companies that actually create sovereignty around some of the key areas in ways that just currently don't exist. And for that, you need to have founders that have that ambition, first time founders, or you need founders that are second time or third time founders who've already learned a lot. And go back and and do it one more time because quite often you're actually much faster the second time around for for reasonably obvious reasons. That doesn't happen as often in Europe as it does in the States from what I can tell. And I always wonder why that is and sometimes maybe it's because Europe is a really nice place to retire and lots of things that you can do with a house in Italy or whatever and and and not work. But that is not good. We need all of those people back to start a second or a third company.
53:18 Harry Stebbings? How do we change that?
53:19 Speaker 00 The founder community needs to talk about it more. It's a mindset thing. I personally think we all have a contribution to make and a contribution to make to society as founders. I think we have a responsibility to actually contribute. Some of that contribution is to help Europe become sovereign, in particular around key technologies.
53:35 Harry Stebbings? Do you fear that we are falling further and further behind?
53:37 Speaker 00 So I think we are falling behind, but that trend isn't new, that that already started a few years ago. And part of the reason we wanted to build Helsing was to show that you can build a company in Europe fast to scale in deep tech and just provide a shortcut. Actually, this is doable. And we wanted to show that it's doable, including the fundraising. So I think Europe is falling behind, but it doesn't have to be that way. So the things that we have in Europe and particular talent, we have incredibly good talent, including on the engineering side. We hire almost exclusively from Europe at the moment and the talent is amazing. The talent pool is amazing. People's attitudes are amazing. There's none of this nine to five mentality. People really want to make a difference and they work hard and they work intensely wherever that's required. So I think that's a myth.
54:22 Harry Stebbings? What role does US capital play in this journey for European companies? You obviously took money from GC, from Eliac Gill, from some big US players, I think Excel as well. What role does US cash play?
54:33 Speaker 00 It plays an important role, I think, later on. The ability for European investors to provide growth capital, that's lower than it is in the US. But I don't think that's a problem. In fact, in many ways, I think that's probably a feature, not a bug. Because I think exposure to US culture, but also investors is extremely useful. I was lucky to have it. Natural Motion Benchmark is one of our investors with Mitch Lasky as our partner. Part of the reason why we eventually took off was also Mitch and the way he thought about how big this company could be. How should I should think about portfolio, not think too small, that was extremely helpful. And so I think that injection of US mentality to European companies at the right point is extremely helpful.
55:16 Speaker 00 And the cap table, true for Helsing as well, it's still Europe dominated. You know, we did our seed round, you know, entirely from European investors. Then Daniel and Prima Matera came in, again, European. So later on, you know, we took American money, but the company is still a European company.
55:32 Harry Stebbings? Is there anything you think people don't see about Europe from the outside? We have a huge US audience. The US just loves to say, hey, you guys don't work. You love to have espressos and have work-life balance, not ambitious, sell for a hundred million. Is there anything they should know that they don't know?
55:47 Speaker 00 I I think it's pretty clear that the current narrative is a caricature of Europe. There are some elements of truth in it, but they've been extremely exaggerated over the over the, in particular, over the last six to 12 months. I think if you if you go on X.
55:59 Harry Stebbings? But when you look at where Europe is today, and I I try and be positive, I'm in London. I built a career in London, I built a business in London, I'm staying in London. My challenge is, when you look at the German government, when you look at the French, when you look at the British, we're all just becoming further and further dependent on state subsidies, increasing public employment, and we're becoming more and more uncompetitive.
56:20 Speaker 00 That is a trend right now. E- even three and a half years ago, when we started the company, that that trend was already there. The question with all of these situations is, what can we do to change it? What are you doing to change it? We felt we had agency by looking at, for example, the problem of European sovereignty and specifically around defence. And we felt as founders, you have the privilege of having a massive lever, which is, if you can build a successful company in this space, you can actually make a difference. I'm pretty sick of people just commenting. I mean, there's a, you know, there's like, there's a whole LinkedIn economy built around just complaining, same is true on X, and just commenting. And those comments were, they were worth nothing. None of the commentary is worth anything. The only thing that matters is if people actually, you know, do something.
57:02 Speaker 00 That is, start a company, build a company, it's go into politics, start a new party, whatever it is. But the current attitude of just complaining is, drives me crazy.
57:10 Harry Stebbings? All right, okay, point taken. All right. Come to my studio, fucking point fingers. No, I I completely agree. I was actually at a dinner the other evening and they were talking about, you know, policy and it was kind of a rich person's dinner talking about policy and it really pissed me off because it's like pontificating means nothing.
57:27 Speaker 00 Exactly.
57:27 Harry Stebbings? Actually, just build companies, investing companies, support your founders, be founders, just do it.
57:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's interesting. I also think that people over-index on the environment and and about having the right regulatory settings and tax and and everything else around it. I actually think none of this stuff really matters that much. I think what really matters is founder quality and founder ambition. For a country to be successful, they should attract the most aggressive founders and everything else is a lot less important.
57:54 Harry Stebbings? I spoke to Matt Clifford before the show and he provided a great question. He said- That I had to ask, Helsing is one of the first deliberate European tech sovereignty companies. Which other ones do we need in which sectors?
58:05 Speaker 00 Certainly companies in energy, energy sovereignty is a huge issue. Some of that, you know, may be in conventional technologies, some of it maybe in computer, in future technologies like like fusion. We need sovereignty ideally around semiconductors. It's going to be very hard to achieve unless there are big changes in in technology and various other areas. Obviously, defence is another one and a few others. I'm not sure whether they will be able to create those companies kind of in the next two or three years to a point where they provide sufficient sovereignty. But I'm very sure we can do it over the next five to 10 years.
58:37 Harry Stebbings? Where are we in three years with Russia, Ukraine? Has Putin invaded Lithuania, Belarus, Finland?
58:43 Speaker 00 It is very hard to predict. We just don't know how things are going to pan out over the next few months and a couple of years. But I think we do have to take the threat to the NATO Eastern flag seriously. I think we have to take it much more seriously than we are doing it right now in in the UK and in Germany and in other countries. I think Scandinavia, the Scandinavian countries take it a lot more seriously, as do the Baltics. We take it extremely seriously and I think we should listen to them. I think the threat is extremely plausible in the next few years.
59:10 Harry Stebbings? You mentioned China, Taiwan earlier. It's the second needle moving moment in the kind of inception of Helsing. What happens in China and Taiwan?
59:18 Speaker 00 Again, I think it's plausible that there will be a conflict. I don't think it's 10 years away if it happens, it's probably quite a lot sooner than that. But it depends on how the next, again, few months and years are going to pan out. Again, I think there is a danger and it's obviously clearly stated goal of China to reunite, as they as they put it.
59:35 Harry Stebbings? Does Trump reduce the potential for global conflict?
59:39 Speaker 00 As people have stated, there there was no new conflict, you know, under Trump's last administration. And so if you go by that, then it would reduce it. But there are other players obviously involved as well. We don't know what kind of capabilities are being developed in North Korea, how someone feels on a particular day. The danger that we have And I think something that is hard to control is accidental escalation. For example, at the beginning of the Ukraine war, I think there was a danger of escalation, potentially even a nuclear escalation. I think that eventually settled. The situation became more readable for everyone involved.
1:00:10 Harry Stebbings? Why was there the potential for nuclear escalation?
1:00:12 Speaker 00 Because we were in a new conflict that was moving extremely fast. We were in uncharted territory in terms of Western support for Ukraine, in terms of what weapons should or should not be used, what would be the reaction on the other side. It was hard to predict and everyone was kind of feeling their way into the situation. I think those are situations that are fast moving and also where there's limited information, where things can escalate quickly accidentally, even though neither party wants it. That is very hard to predict. These are very nonlinear events when they happen. And so that's why it's hard to predict whether a conflict is going to happen under a particular administration or not.
1:00:47 Harry Stebbings? What are you worried about that we haven't discussed or is not discussed enough?
1:00:51 Speaker 00 We are not sufficiently alerted to the danger of conflict. We've lived in conflict for forever, basically, and then had a period of time where there wasn't one. And I think we, I'm worried that we don't take it seriously because we don't want to think about it. And by the way, I don't want to think about it either. It's not nice to think about conflict, but we're not taking it seriously.
1:01:10 Harry Stebbings? That's a buggy founder, the defence company then, isn't it? I mean, no offence, I don't want to think about conflict. Well, you know, that one's on you, dude. Stay in enterprise SaaS, we're doing AI sales tools here. So, you know, final one I just want to ask, which I always find really interesting. I hope it's okay for me to ask. With natural motion, you sold, you make a little bit of money yourself. I think mindset to finance is fascinating. How do you think about your relationship to money? Does money make you a better founder? Does money make you happy?
1:01:39 Speaker 00 I think money can give you security. To me, that's by far the most important thing. So not having to worry about money makes a big difference in terms of how, I think, you lead your life in general, but also what risks you take with, let's say, your next company. In order to build a successful company, you have to take risks. You know, being safe on the money side makes it easier. I don't, it's not the only thing that you require, but it does contribute to it.
1:02:02 Harry Stebbings? What little things make you most happy? I think about this a lot and it's like an espresso in the pot.
1:02:07 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was just saying, a self-made espresso. We just bought a new espresso machine. A long walk every day makes me happy. Can't put a price on that.
1:02:14 Harry Stebbings? Listen, I'd love to do a quick fire round. So I say a short statement, you give me your immediate thoughts. Does that sound okay?
1:02:19 Speaker 00 Sounds great.
1:02:19 Harry Stebbings? So what do you believe that most around you disbelieve?
1:02:22 Speaker 00 Most people believe that that the environment in terms of taxation, regulation, et cetera, has a big impact on whether you can build successful startups in the country. I don't think it does. It's minor compared to attracting the right founders. So I think the discussions that people have around how can we make a particular country a better place for entrepreneurs who are already there, I just don't think it makes a difference.
1:02:44 Harry Stebbings? What's the single hardest element of being CEO of Helsing?
1:02:47 Speaker 00 It's the fact that the company needs to shed its skin every 12 to 18 months because it's progressing at such a pace that you just have to think about the org structure again, you know, repeatedly. You have to think about whether your processes are the right ones, whether you're talking to the right people.
1:03:02 Harry Stebbings? What did you not see in org structure change that you wish you had seen?
1:03:05 Speaker 00 The biggest unlock for us was to have these quarterly founder offsites where we basically reflect and think about what's working and what isn't working and how do we change it? Never did that previously and stuff just gets warmer and warmer until it's too hot.
1:03:20 Harry Stebbings? The heaviest things in life are not iron or gold, but unmade decisions. What's the biggest unmade decision?
1:03:26 Speaker 00 I actually, I'm not sure I agree with even with the statement. I think it's perfectly, there's this trope that, you know, and any decision is better than no decision. And I've never believed that. I think there's sometimes you have to make a lot of decisions as a founder all the time.
1:03:40 Harry Stebbings? Well, I think no decision is a decision.
1:03:42 Speaker 00 So this is the thing, if you, if you make conscious decision not to decide on something because you don't have the information right now that you're required to make it, I think it's totally fine. And I think people should make much more use of that rather than randomly going, I'm going to go for this one. It's just one of the many things that LinkedIn screwed up. There are so many pieces of wisdom on LinkedIn that are wrong.
1:04:01 Harry Stebbings? You just go through LinkedIn every day going bullshit, bullshit, bullshit.
1:04:04 Speaker 00 It's just like all this work, work smart, not hard stuff, being a servant leader.
1:04:08 Harry Stebbings? Why is work smart, not hard bullshit?
1:04:11 Speaker 00 Because you need to do both, clearly. You're always outcompeted by someone who works smart and hard. If you're a work smart, not hard person.
1:04:18 Harry Stebbings? Why is servant leadership bullshit?
1:04:20 Speaker 00 You need to lead a company and you should not be afraid to say that. If you're the founder of a company, we made the decision for Helsing as well that we are a founder-led company and we are all here to basically serve the company, to make the company successful. That's what we do and the founders provide the vision and the direction. And if you like it, great. If you don't like it, you have to work there.
1:04:41 Harry Stebbings? What have you changed your mind on in the last twelve months?
1:04:44 Speaker 00 I used to think that you needed to make sure that there was always a degree of process when teams work together on something and including something new. I have now learned that it's possible with exceptional people, just let them get on with the job without any stand-ups, any predictions on deadlines, nothing. You just let them get on with the job in a fast-changing environment that we had to deal with, for example, over the last few months. It is probably the most efficient way of actually making progress rather than being structured about it. And then eventually you have to move to structure, obviously, but I probably wouldn't have thought that two years ago.
1:05:18 Harry Stebbings? See of any other company for a day, which company would you choose?
1:05:22 Speaker 00 Probably ByteDance and I would shut down TikTok immediately. It's crack cocaine for basically our societies. It is.
1:05:30 Harry Stebbings? Respectfully disagree. Social media is crack cocaine, but it's also not. If you go to my social media, it's protein recipes, it's gym workouts, it's inspirational content that's made me a fit, a healthier human who doesn't drink and has a great relationship with his mum. I proactively choose the content to be good for me, just like food is poisonous or very good for you.
1:05:53 Speaker 00 But if it is very compelling, which yours is, it becomes a, it becomes something that people will consume too much, I think.
1:06:00 Harry Stebbings? Same with food.
1:06:01 Speaker 00 Same with food. I think food can be dangerous too, but I think TikTok is a lot more dangerous than hamburgers. Large parts of society are wasting so much of their time on something that has been highly tuned. I mean, I'm saying this as someone who used to make games and we know what dopamine loops look like. TikTok loop is the best and you cannot get out of it.
1:06:18 Harry Stebbings? Why is it the best?
1:06:19 Speaker 00 Because it has just the right combination of timing, the flick, the content that immediately comes up. It's perfectly tuned and obviously they have all the metrics to know what content to show you. It is super addictive. It's incredibly dangerous. It also obviously becomes a potential tool for manipulation, political manipulation, whether that's happening or not. But it is extremely powerful if you wanted to to use it. And then thirdly, it has the same problem as all social media. The content that works the best is the content that's the most extreme. And so we have a problem of basically radicalizing political views where just almost by definition, radical content will just work better.
1:06:52 Harry Stebbings? Do you believe Twitter is better under Elon Musk?
1:06:55 Speaker 00 It's very different. I think.
1:06:56 Harry Stebbings? How would you say it's different?
1:06:57 Speaker 00 There are different people on there now. I think other people have left. You know, maybe you get a broader spectrum of views. It's hard to tell. I think the the jury is out on that, but it does feel different.
1:07:07 Harry Stebbings? Would you invest in Twitter at forty four billion?
1:07:09 Speaker 00 If you care about the platform that much, then you know, maybe it's it's the right thing to do if you have the cash available.
1:07:15 Harry Stebbings? What do you know now that you wish you'd known when you started Helsing?
1:07:18 Speaker 00 I think we wish we had known that the Ukraine war was going to happen that quickly.
1:07:23 Harry Stebbings? What would you have done differently?
1:07:24 Speaker 00 We would have focused all of our efforts on specific systems to deal with the problems in hand, which are now the ones that I I talked about earlier. It's electronic warfare resistance, GPS independence, being resilient to comms jamming. And we were working on those systems, but not just. We were working on other systems too. And we were building a technology foundation, you know, that we're now using, obviously in the company. It's good that we have it, but had we known that this conflict was imminent, I think we would have shifted priorities and I think we could have done more right at the beginning. In the end, I think we were able to contribute, but you know, we needed to spool up all of these systems and a lot of knowledge.
1:07:57 Harry Stebbings? Torsten, what question have I not asked or that you're never asked? Should I have asked?
1:08:03 Speaker 00 Well, one question I have asked myself the other day, which I don't get asked that often is how does a founder group work together that's equal? How do you make it work? Because as a founder, almost by definition, you all have to be ambitious. Everyone is different. Everyone will always have a bit of an ego as well. How do you make it work that actually it works together? And it it it worked well for us naturally, but it's quite interesting to think about what are the reasons that it works?
1:08:28 Harry Stebbings? What are they?
1:08:29 Speaker 00 The way I boil it down is is is respect, is mutual respect. You know, chemistry and everything else is important as well, but if you truly respect the quality of of your co-founders and what they contribute and. Job that they do and that they're, you know, 10 out of 10 people, then everyone finds their role and their roles are shifting sometimes too, right? Like, it's not like, you know, to your point of specialization earlier, it's not like, you know, one person has this role, the other one person has that role. We have our different emphases, but we, we tend to chip in and be involved in all kinds of things, including obviously in, in the management of the company and the scaling. We, we all do that together.
1:09:01 Harry Stebbings? Torsten, I am so grateful to you for putting up with my very prime questions across different industries. You've been fantastic. So thank you so much for joining me today.
1:09:10 Speaker 00 No, thank you. I enjoyed it.
1:09:12 Harry Stebbings? I mean, I've wanted to make that show happen for such a long time. Torsten is one of Europe's great entrepreneurs. If you want to watch the full episode, of course, you can find it on YouTube by searching for 20VC. But before we leave you today, what do Henry Ford and AI have in common? Neither could change the world without automation. In the future, there will be two types of businesses, those that have automated and those that wish they had. UiPath, the undisputed leader in automation, is taking us into the era of a genetic automation. UiPath's new AI agents don't just follow rules, they think, they make decisions. They work alongside the world's most powerful software robots, already trusted by over 10,000 businesses.
1:09:53 Harry Stebbings? If a genetic automation sounds new, just think of UiPath as more growth, not more overhead platform, or happier customers, happier employees platform. Whatever you want AI to do for your business, agentic automation with UiPath will make it happen. Try UiPath's new AI agents for free at UiPath.com. The future of automation is both agentic and robotic, so don't get left behind. And speaking of transforming your business with cutting edge technology, let's dive into another game changer. Atio. Atio is the next generation of CRM. Setting up Atio takes less than a minute and in seconds of syncing your email and calendar, you'll see all of your relationships in one place, all enriched with very valuable data.
1:10:37 Harry Stebbings? Atio also lets you build Zapier-style automations, gives you powerful reports and works perfectly for any go-to-market motion from PLG to sales-led. And Atio is designed for the next era. Of companies like yours and companies like yours shouldn't have to deal with inflexible one size fits all CRMs. So join industry leaders like Eleven Labs, Replicate, Modal and more to scale your startup beyond the next level. Head over to ateo.com/20vc and you'll get 15% off. That's 15% off your first year at ateo.com/20vc. And if Ateo helps you stay
1:11:18 Harry Stebbings? ahead by streamlining your relationships and operations, today I want to talk about a venture fund making waves with its unusual model. I'm talking about the Fundrise Innovation Fund, which is democratizing venture capital as a public venture fund. For example, most of the AI revolution is being built and funded in the private markets. Companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, Databricks, these are incredible multi-billion dollar companies, but they're inaccessible to 99% of investors until they go public. Well, those days are finally over. Visit fundrise.com/20vc to check out the Fundrise Innovation Fund's impressive $150 million portfolio for yourself. Carefully consider the investment material before investing,
1:12:01 Harry Stebbings? including objectives, risks, charges and expenses. This and other information can be found in the Innovation Fund's prospectus at fundrise.com/innovation. This is a paid sponsorship.
1:12:12 Harry Stebbings? As always, I so appreciate your support and I can't wait to bring you an incredible 20 growth on Friday.
Previous 20VC: Salesforce Founder Marc Benioff on The Future of LLMs | The Future of Agents | The Future of Labour | Management Lessons from Steve Jobs Next 20Growth: How to Scale to $30M ARR Bootstrapped through Content and Brand | The Ultimate Equation to Success in Sales and Why Most Founders Suck at Sales | Why You Should Overpay People and What That Means with Guillaume Moubeche @ Lempire Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated