Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: The Future of Subscription Media, Why Startups Need To Stop Blaming Facebook and Google & How Founders Should Think Through Customer Acquisition Channel Dependencies with Alex Mather, Founder & CEO @ The Athletic About this episode Alex Mather is the Founder & CEO @ The Athletic, the startup bringing you in-depth sports stories you won't hear anywhere else. To date, Alex has raised over $139M with The Athletic from some of the best in the business including Founders Fund, Bedrock, Y Combinator and Emerson Collective to name a few. Before founding The Athletic, Alex spent an incredible 5 years as part of the hyper-growth @ Strava serving Vice President of Product Management and Product Design. In Today’s Episode You Will Learn: 1.) How Alex made his way into the world of tech and startups with Strava? How did his time at Strava lead to his founding The Athletic? 2.) With the scaling of The Athletic to over 500 people, how has Alex seen his leadership style change and adapt? What does he need to improve? How did having children impact how he thinks about management? What lessons did he take from Strava on what worked for community building? 3.) What was it like raising money for a subscription media business back in 2016? Who was the first person to really take a bet on Alex and The Athletic? What value adds does Alex think are the most important for VCs to provide? What are the biggest investor misconceptions around media? 4.) How does Alex see the future structure of the media landscape? What elements of media is Alex most concerned about right now? Does Alex view Substack as competition? What does Alex believe will be the 2 ways to succeed in media moving forward? 5.) What have been the biggest customer acquisition learnings for Alex from The Athletic? How does Alex feel about platform reliance for customer acquisition with Facebook? What does it take to successfully acquire customers on Facebook at scale? Items Mentioned In Today’s Show: Alex’s Fave Book: The Kingdom of God is Within You As always you can follow Harry and The Twenty Minute VC on Twitter here! Likewise, you can follow Harry on Instagram here for mojito madness and all things 20VC.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Harry Stebbings? So I've done over 2,750 episodes of the 20 Minute VC, but never before have I been challenged to a Peloton race before an episode. It is safe to say it certainly broke the ice and this guest is just fantastic and I've really enjoyed getting to know him. And so with that, I'm very excited to welcome Alex Mather, founder and CEO at The Athletic. The startup bringing you in-depth sports stories you won't hear anywhere else. To date, Alex has raised over $139 million with The Athletic from some of the best in the business, including Founders Fund, Bedrock, Y Combinator and Emerson Collective, to name a few. And before founding The Athletic, Alex spent an incredible five years as part of the hyper growth story at Strava, serving as Vice President of Product Management and Product Design. I'd also want to say a huge thank you to Eric at Bedrock, Michael at Strava, John at Damassia and Deepen at Courtside.
0:44 Harry Stebbings? Some amazing question suggestions here. It really was a team effort there. But before we move into the show today, I'm sure you've heard about it, but my word, this is a product I love, Carter. Carter simplifies how startups and investors manage equity, track cap tables and get valuations. Go to Carter.com/20vc to get 10% off. More than 800,000 employees and shareholders use Carter to manage hundreds of billions of dollars in equity. And Carter now offers fund administration, so you can see in real time data in the Carter platform and work with Carter's team of experienced fund accountants. Again, go to Carter.com/20vc to get 10% off. And speaking of amazing products you've heard about with Carter there, last month I had Jeff Seibert and Wayne Chang on the show from Digits.
1:27 Harry Stebbings? Simply put, they're two of the best founders that I've ever met and they're creating the most intuitive financial software that you've ever seen or used, automatically analysing your company's spend and visualising it for you as it happens. Honing on recent activity, trends, anomalies, or any question that you have in just a few clicks. And unlike every other financial software, the integrations is not weeks, it's just a few clicks. I have to say the product is absolutely beautiful, which is not something I ever thought I'd say for financial software, but you have to check it out and you can do so at digits.com, that's at digits.com. And finally, did you know there will be 1.4 million job openings for developers in 2020 alone? Well, that's when my friends at Terminal come in. Terminal is a remote teams engine for fast-growing companies.
2:10 Harry Stebbings? Getting you with global talent to deliver the product building powerhouse your business needs to grow. They provide services and infrastructure in a complete solution that allows businesses to build and scale their remote engineering teams from the ground up without sacrificing experience or quality. From workspaces to community to on the ground support, they take the guesswork out of remote so that you can really thrive. But really, don't take my word for it. Just ask high growth businesses like Gusto, Chime, Earnin and Hims, all trusting Terminal with their remote teams and you can find out more today at terminal.io. That's quite enough from me there. So now I'm very excited to hand over to Alex Mather, founder and CEO at The Athletic.
2:53 Speaker 01 You have now arrived at your destination.
2:57 Harry Stebbings? Alex, it is such a joy to have you on the show today. I've heard so many great things from Eric Bedrock, from Michael Strava, from John Ademasiya. So thank you so much for joining me today, Alex.
3:06 Speaker 02 Thank you, Harry.
3:06 Harry Stebbings? Not at all. I've been excited for this one, I have to say, but I'm also the biggest fanboy of both Strava and The Athletic. So I'm going to pretend like this isn't a fanboy moment for me. But tell me, how did you make your way into the world of startups and tech? And how did you really found the game changer for sports, news and media with The Athletic?
3:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, for me, I started as an engineer early on in my career and kind of actually all goes back to the Palm Pilot. I was pre-med in college, I forget what class I was in, and a gentleman came into our classroom. And I went to Penn State and he came into the classroom and said, hey, everyone, I'm launching a new program at Penn State called IST. And if you try some of our classes, we'll give you this thing called a Palm Pilot and you can write computer programs for it. And I remember in high school, writing some simple programs for my TI 85 calculator. And I was like, oh, that's cool. I'll check it out. And I just felt at home in that world. And I became an engineer through that experience and loved it.
4:05 Speaker 02 And as my career went on, I got into design and worked at Xfinity TV, building out a lot of the underlying tech and user experience around things like HBO Go and stuff. And we're just so passionate about building stuff for consumers. Really enjoyed building stuff enterprise and I moved out to the West Coast and joined Strava. I was an avid cyclist, like just loved it. I loved California. I loved just getting on my bike and riding. And Strava felt like such a natural place to work and I was lucky enough to be employee number seven there. The first sort of design and product hire and built out those teams over the years at Strava. And helped grow that company from 1500 users to over 10 million.
4:48 Speaker 02 And it was a subscription business and just became so passionate about subscription as a business model. And I'm sure we'll get into it in the course of this conversation, but subscription is just one of these things that allows you to focus directly on the consumer. And I just fell in love with that model and cycling and running were a personal passion. And as I got more experience at Strava, I felt that I could take this business model into something of my own. And I'm also a passionate sports fan, whether it be the Philadelphia Eagles here in the US or Spurs in the UK. I love sports and thought, hey, media is an opportunity. It looks like subscription hasn't really been attempted by many companies and there could be an opportunity in sports. And off we went.
5:31 Harry Stebbings? I mean, I have to say, I liked you so much before hearing about Spurs. I'm a Chelsea fan, so I mean, this interview is now over. No, that's amazing, Tiaran. I'm with you. I mean, in terms of the subscription element, for me, it's just the accountability that it places on the provider to continuously offer the best products and really having to maintain that quality and standard. So totally with you on the love of the business model there. You mentioned Strava though. And I spoke to obviously Michael, the founder before the show, and he asked a specific question. He said, what are some things that you had to learn or even unlearn as the founder and CEO of The Athletic? Really kind of from your time learnt with Strava?
6:06 Speaker 02 My time at Strava was so, so good. I look back at that with such fond memories of learning how to build a subscription business. And one thing that comes to mind for me is focus. There is a little bit of a curse when you're so passionate about what you're working on in that you see every idea as worthy of deep exploration for your team. And so there were definitely a few years. There at travel where we were running around trying to build so many things at once, whether it be nutrition or finding a route to ride or things like that. What I came back to as we got better in the company was focusing as many people in the company on a shorter list of things that have an objective as opposed to like, oh, that would be cool.
6:49 Speaker 02 That would be cool. That would be cool. Kind of like a dog, you know, squirrel, squirrel, squirrel. So that to me is a big one. And the second one that I might add on is this idea of inclusivity versus exclusivity. And if there are any cyclists listening, cycling can be a very exclusive sport. And it's probably one of the downsides of the sport. It's very complicated. It's a dangerous sport. And there's a culture around it and it can make people feel like they're on the outside if they're not as dialed in to all the little tricks or culture aspects. And at some moments in the company's history, we were probably a little too exclusive. We should have talked to more of the weekend warriors versus the folks already riding 200 miles a week. And I think that that lesson to me has really carried into the athletic and saying,
7:34 Speaker 02 but not just for the fan who knows every person in the farm system of a baseball team or the development program of a soccer team, right? It's for everyone. How do you build for everyone and make it feel like a place for everyone? And so really, really dialing that in has been something that I've taken from Strava to the athletic.
7:52 Harry Stebbings? I mean, there's a couple of things I just have to unpack there. And so sorry for going off schedule ahead of time, but you mentioned there in terms of like determining where to spend and prioritize your time and where to focus. I'm intrigued. How do you think about resource allocation today? I always think the best CEOs are fundamentally the best resource allocators. How do you think about prioritizing and focusing resources today? And what drives those decisions? You expanded into UK very recently, very quickly. What drives the prioritization decisions that you do take?
8:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, it is the fundamental question of an early stage or even mid-stage startup, which is like, you can waste your time on so many things. And I think the way I look at it is, what is unique about us? What are the unique characteristics of our company? Where we can absolutely differentiate, whether it be a user experience, whether it be a market expansion. So if I take the example of the UK, we really felt, hey, one of our biggest advantages as a company is how quickly we move and how well we're capitalized. And so we said, there was a board meeting in March of last year or something, maybe it was late February, and we said, let's do it. And 119 days later, we had 55 full-time employees in the UK and we were launching.
9:06 Speaker 02 And so we set out to do something. We went over to the UK and hired 55 of the best journalists, editors in the country and moved with unbelievable speed and focus, because we had already hired so many people in the US, we knew exactly what we were looking for. And so those advantages, they seem small on paper, but here we are a year later and we're well north of 100,000 paying subscribers in the UK, building a really great product for fans all over the world. And that's an example of us saying, hey, this is one of our biggest advantages, knowing that we can move quickly and have all this capital. Let's go and compete with companies that are over 200 years old. And we look at that broadly and say, well, what are other advantages?
9:49 Speaker 02 Well, we've got 500 folks in our newsroom, right? That are some of the most amazing sportswriters and editors in the world. How do we combine them with our tech team and the Silicon Valley DNA and build really cool experiences? So really for us, it's like, let's focus first on how we're different and how we can win that way. Because all the other stuff can come when it comes. I think that really getting at what makes you different is going to put you on a path that hopefully will create a bigger, more durable company.
10:18 Harry Stebbings? I have to say, Alex, I didn't know it was fifty five in terms of the talent acquisition in the UK. Have to also say, what's the biggest challenge about like scaling to fifty five people in the UK when you're based in the US in a hundred and nineteen days? Is it the actual like discovery and acquisition? Is it the culture maintenance? What's the biggest challenge of scaling up so fast?
10:36 Speaker 02 Well, I think the challenges are almost always different as you go into different countries. And I think in the UK, we went in thinking folks would be more conservative in how they think. That was totally incorrect. We were worried about costs. We were right around where we thought it would be. So that was incorrect. Where we learned there were problems were things like garden leave, right? Folks have like things in their contracts that are very specific to the UK. So we had to wait a while for a lot of people. But overall, the challenge mostly was just flying back and forth. I had had a child for four months prior and just back and forth, back and forth. It was grueling, but absolutely worth it and a blast.
11:16 Harry Stebbings? I mean, I am horrified that you never emailed me and we never went out for many, many more meetings. But there's always, there's always a next year in a post-COVID world. I'm really interested because that's a big evolution in the business itself. I'm a very person-driven guy. I want to focus a little bit on your leadership style. When you think about the evolutions of the business, how have you seen your personal leadership style change over the last few years?
11:38 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, I've been the CEO for four and a half years. And the major thing I can say is the job changes every single month, every hour some days. What made sense at ten people, it makes absolutely no sense now. And I think the thing that I really focus on now is just looking at it as a craft, like anything else, and really being committed to being great at it. And that means reading, learning, talking to the people on the team, talking to other CEOs, talking to investors, learning as much as I can. And the biggest shift now, going from zero to five hundred and fifty employees, is I used to write code and thankfully they don't let me anymore.
12:19 Speaker 02 But now my job is communication and all day long I must focus on communicating. And that is absolutely. Absolutely a full time job. Sometimes it doesn't feel like it, but building out the channels of communication in your company. Making sure everyone feels focused, everyone feels energized, everyone feels just like we're building something meaningful, durable, you know, all those things, that's the job. And every bone in my body wants to get back and write code. And I'm pretty antisocial generally and like my job is communicating and making sure of all those things happen. And that is an insane challenge.
12:58 Harry Stebbings? With this uncharity of communications, I'm really intrigued. When you look back over the scaling of the business, what's worked in terms of those communications and what hasn't?
13:07 Speaker 02 I look at this and say, I have to be myself. And so the way I communicate is passionately, honestly, transparently, sometimes to a fault, directly, sometimes to a fault. So all these things, I think it has to be natural. If you're faking it, if you're trying to be someone you're not, it's just not going to work. And so all those aspects and my co-founder Adam, you know, we share a lot of these aspects, which is wonderful in that we are really, really transparent with our staff. We keep them up to date. When the pandemic hit, for example, every other week, we're doing deep all hands where we're showing them the metrics of the business right away, giving them insight. And folks in journalism have never been given this access.
13:51 Speaker 02 And we're just including them in for the ride so they understand how we're thinking, why we're doing X, Y or Z. And those are just some of the things that have really helped me just be me.
14:01 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally agree in terms of that authenticity. In terms of the communications, I spoke to John Adamassia before, and he said, being a successful entrepreneur requires vision that sometimes borders on stubbornness and yet being open to feedback and continuous improvement. And so he asked, can you think of a time maybe when you made a mistake? And the steps that you took to rectify it?
14:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, this one is pretty easy. Early on in the company's history, I did a wide-ranging interview with the New York Times. And we were young. I think we had five or six people at our headquarters, maybe twenty people on our newsroom. So quite small. And I said some things that blew up on Twitter, made me the sort of center of attention in a negative way. And it all came from a place of perhaps a little too much confidence. And I think as a founder, there's this crazy moment where you go from just a person writing code, convincing investors to give you money, to being of interest to the world. And it's a little bit like a high school athlete getting on ESPN for the first time and they stumble with their words
15:05 Speaker 02 and they don't know exactly how to think about what they need to say. And here I was pitching and being really confident. There's this crazy aspect to how you have to convince people that you see this massive vision and it's a situation where then you go to the press and some of that confidence bubbles out. And it's not really something that plays well in this modern media environment. And it was a massive lesson for me. And I told the company recently about this. And I was sobbing every night for a week, thinking I really damaged the company that we were building, that I embarrassed the people who I had hired. And I felt so terrible about that.
15:46 Speaker 02 And I said, I'm just going to take this problem on and learn how to interact with the press in a meaningful way. And I would just give any entrepreneur the advice of investing in comms. Someone who's wonderful on the comms side and Taylor Patterson on our team is just amazing. Keeps me honest, keeps me trained. And dealing with the press is a job. And you have to have a strategy and you have to take it seriously. It's the opposite of going and just spouting your mouth, right? In the same way that you prep for a pitch to a VC, you have to prep for a pitch to the press. And I take that job very seriously now.
16:23 Harry Stebbings? And look at you now, killing a twenty-minute VC interview. But I am probably the least intimidating journalist and I'm not even a journalist because no one would probably fucking hire me. But other than that, I did a final question on you. You know, you mentioned having a baby recently. I'm always fascinated by, you know, I couldn't look after a goldfish, so a baby's a... But like, how does it change how you think about operations and your operating mentality now having a baby?
16:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, there's the obvious time management stuff, but the thing that is really shocked me about having a child and I had a son, his name is Gabriel. And everything I do now, I think about what he would think about me if he knew. And I have to live up to what I aspire to be for him in a way that perhaps I didn't expect. And I don't ever want him to be disappointed in me. The thought of that, it just breaks my heart. So that's probably the biggest change for me is really holding up to the standard that I think I need for him.
17:19 Harry Stebbings? I'm sure, but I'm sure it really drives the right decision-making framework. And so it's a very powerful one, I'm sure. I do want to touch on an element, though, that is very central to the show being fundraising. And you mentioned, obviously, kind of the chest pumping that founders need in terms of successfully raising. And the gruny, the Atlantic's not in like a traditionally sexy space for investors, which is probably dev tools or anything API centric or anything in that realm. And so a question from Eric Bedrock was actually, what was it like raising for a subscription media company back in 2016?
17:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, Eric should know because I pitched him, but it was very difficult. Very few investors had an interest, quite frankly. And some of the reasons like subscription at that moment in time in 2016 felt subscale. Oh, subscription, that means people have to pay you, that's not going to get big enough, right? Media was definitely out of style. You had some previous media companies at that moment in time that were in a spot of bother. And perhaps like just the category itself was a little bit off limits. And the biggest issue, I think, was just media requires humans, not just humans, journalists. And those two things with investors and journalists, it's not the obvious match, right? And I remember at that time that someone had written about power law and that was like in a blog.
18:32 Speaker 02 And so everyone was like cheaping around that and they just couldn't see like a $500 billion company. So we were cast aside by most people and understandably that makes total sense. But I think of it as a big advantage, really, in that if few investors are interested, if you can cross that hurdle, it creates an incredible moat for you. You because you can be the pioneer and that is one of our core values at the company, which is just like be the pioneer and convince others to follow. I think of that as one of our bigger modes that we've had years and years of a head start of most folks in media because no one believed in what we were doing. And the folks who did, hopefully, we're going to make it worth their while.
19:11 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, because it requires this like inflection point of yes from someone, that first big check, that first big seed. Can you remember that moment when you got the first lead seed? He was like, yeah, I see this $10 billion company. Here's the whatever lead check for the seed round. Can you remember that moment and what was it?
19:27 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, I can. I mean, Michael Horvath, the founder of Strava was our first check, but it was a smaller check. And then the next check was Charles Hudson at precursor. And Charles is amazing. And he went through a completely different process than anyone we talked to at that stage. And he learned about us as people as opposed to the idea. The idea was still very, very, very small and unproven. And so he did his research on my co-founder Adam and I, and that was really cool. And I'll never forget when he said, yes, any entrepreneur will say this, but like, it really gives you wings. You start to believe in yourself. There's so many moments early on where you don't necessarily believe in yourself sometimes because you've gotten so many no's in a row. And then even one yes can carry a thousand no's.
20:11 Speaker 02 And that was just such an amazing moment.
20:13 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, no, absolutely. And I have to say, I love Charles and had him on the show. He's been incredible to me as an advisor. So that makes me very happy to hear. And I didn't actually know he was the first in the lead for that. So that's awesome. Another one of your investors is Founders Fund and they have a different view in terms of investor value add. And they take the view that investors can't really add much value to their portfolio. I'm interested. How do you feel about this and what do you think about that?
20:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, I would say that like, I look at them subtly different than that categorization. I would say like, they believe mostly that founders can drive biggest returns because they have the biggest ideas and that the more investors meddle, they tend to destruct value rather than create. And what's amazing about Founders Fund is they believe in you as a founder and they trust you as a founder. But that doesn't mean they just disappear. They hold you accountable. They have an incredibly high bar and they're all so different and smart. And it's a situation where when you want them, they tend to be some of the best folks to talk to when you need advice, but they're not necessarily just lobbing it to you every time you talk.
21:19 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally agree. And yeah, I've never met so many people with such high queues in such small place in one area. So I totally agree with you there. I I do have to ask, you mentioned kind of the board decision earlier to go into the UK. And board is something where actually I've got a lot of insecurity myself, Alex, because like I am pretty young. And I got my first board seats kind of eighteen months ago. Now I've got like four. And I just want to be the best board member that I can be, quite frankly. My question to you is like, help me out here. What can I do to be the best board member? And what can I do to build that relationship with you, the founder, to be the best and the one you really go to?
21:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I'm a big listener of your pod. And so I'll try not to repeat a lot of the things I hear from folks on this one. And the thing that I would add to the dialogue is just care. You know, if you're on a board, you're smart enough, you've seen enough, you can recognize patterns quickly. Those are all like baseline attributes of a board member. Yes, you'll get some folks with lots more experience. But I think one of the most valuable things on a personal level is you can tell so quickly when the board member cares about the company, about you as a founder, about the journey. And the difference between someone who cares and someone who doesn't is so meaningful to the founder. Because this is our life, right? This is everything to us.
22:33 Speaker 02 And when you care, you tend to be honest when you need to, but always have a little spoonful of sugar. And the incentives just all start to make sense when you both care. So that's what I would add.
22:44 Harry Stebbings? I totally agree. I also find it makes it just way more enjoyable when you really care and have that deep trusting relationship with the founder in that respect. I do want to move on to kind of a final element, though, before we do the quick fire. And it's more of a macro picture on kind of the subscription media landscape more broadly. Because I spoke to Chris at Substack on the show before, and he suggested the future was one in which there'd be these mega platforms, your New York Times, your huge incumbents of the world, and then there'd be the incredible niche creators, writers, bloggers, you name it. And everything in the middle would quite simply die in kind of no man's land. Would you agree with him in terms of this binary split?
23:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I listened to your talk with Chris and I generally agree. I think I've chatted with him and Hamish as they've built their amazing company. And I generally agree with his statement. And what's interesting is we're on the other side of that. We are the empire as opposed to the rebels or the Amazon as opposed to the Shopify, right? And you do see that unfolding and I think it's a really great conversation. So on one side, you absolutely have the rebels and they're all over the place. And some of them are doing X, some of them are doing Y, and they're building their own businesses for themselves. And to me, it's about scale versus margin. And we think about what we're doing is a margin business, right? We build an incredible bundle for sports fans and hopefully a bundle that can't be replaced.
24:00 Speaker 02 And we hope to build a very profitable business off of that, a large profitable business off of that. Most categories can't get margin or scale like sports. And so the rebel model to me makes a ton of sense. I think many categories that you don't need 600 people will be in the thousands of people hopefully over the next couple of years. And sports is just one of those areas where the empire makes sense. I'm a big Star Wars fan and I always liked the empire. I thought the costumes were cooler, their modes of transportation way cooler. And I think there is a place for both. I really do believe that. And we're in the business of building out empires in the media sense. The Athletic being a global sports brand for millions and millions of subscribers.
24:43 Harry Stebbings? Can you help me understand the margin element? Is that in terms of analyzing cost of content creation? And then, you know, subsequent like consumer acquisition on the back of that piece? How do you think about margin on a granular basis? I'm really interested.
24:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, if you think about when you build a platform, and I'll use Substack as the example. Substack takes a cut of the revenue from the folks using their platform. And I think Apple has proven that model to be very, very lucrative if you can get scale and you're taking a cut. But you need scale to build a venture scale business, incredible scale, frankly. On our side, we own the entire experience. And so we're capturing a lot more of the value of our smaller category. We don't cover everything, we just do sports, but we own every penny from the customer. And so to us, it's like about margin from the customer as opposed to building out a much bigger platform that is cutting or skimming a part of that revenue.
25:38 Harry Stebbings? Got you totally. Can I ask, would you see Substack as competitive? Because I always think with new subscription models today, I'm, as we said, love the accountability, love the model itself. But in my mind, there's always a limit to how many a single consumer can have. And I asked this of Chris on the show with Substack, how many Substacks will someone have? You won't pay for 25 Substacks.
25:56 Speaker 02 Sure.
25:57 Harry Stebbings? Question to you is like, is Substack competitive to you in terms of, I love this writer who's just left the Daily Telegraph sports section and I'm paying for him over The Athletic? Is it competitive? I don't know.
26:08 Speaker 02 I don't think so. I mean, you know, if you look at a single writer at a single moment in time, perhaps, you know, on the margins, but we're building a massive bundle for a very specific category.
26:18 Harry Stebbings? Yeah.
26:18 Speaker 02 And we like where that stacks up versus a single writer on Substack. And I think if you look at what happened with Substack, to just take a second to look at that business, and it's a wonderful product, a wonderful founding team, and they're much more competitive with, say, Medium. And we don't necessarily look at them as competitors. They're probably capturing the opportunity that Medium had and missed. And we look at Substack and say, hey, if there is a great writer that left The Telegraph and is writing on Substack and they get to a certain scale, then heck, we're going to reach out and try to get them on our platform. And they may not join, they may say, hey, I really want to be on my own and I like that. But we have an art department, we have a legal department, so you can do deeper journalism, right?
27:02 Speaker 02 We have editors that can guide your stories into better places. We can give a writer the ability to not have to write every day to really drive that subscription value. And for many folks, the economics work better under The Athletic than they might on Substack. Now, for others, it might be the complete opposite. So I don't see it as a competitive force at all.
27:24 Harry Stebbings? No, I totally get you and I see the benefits there. Final one before the quickfire. It's like, we said about kind of how the landscape changes there. When you look at it moving forward five to 10 years now, are there elements that really concern you in how you see the landscape evolving?
27:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, what is so frustrating to me in media is just this kind of ridiculous focus on blaming Google and Facebook for the woes of media. And I see that as a problem. I really do, looking forward. And I think it's easy to blame others. I'm a big fan of Ben Thompson, who isn't, right? And he's obviously nailed it on this topic, but like, we should be paying Facebook and Google as media companies, not the other way around. If you can't make your business thrive in this world where Facebook and Google exist, that's on you. Stop whining, like, start figuring it out. You've had thirty years. The internet isn't new. And to me, that's where I see a major opportunity for The Athletic within it all, which is, we're not whining.
28:20 Speaker 02 We're figuring it out. We don't have all the answers, to be clear, but we're dedicated to figuring out how to make Facebook and Google work for our business. And how we can exist in a world that's now. And I think too many media companies are focused on ten years ago. And they're run by executives thinking ten years ago. And taking money from Facebook and Google has not worked out for anyone. So I worry about these companies thinking they're winning the war when they've won a small battle of receiving money from Facebook and Google. I think that's gonna hurt them way down the road. And I think that that could be a big problem in media. Folks are counting on Facebook and Google for revenue.
28:58 Harry Stebbings? Listen, I totally agree with you. So I said that was the last question, but just one more, I promise. Speaking of like reliance on Facebook and Google there, bluntly, I always question tax, especially I get very nervous when it's so predominantly focused on Facebook. For you as a media subscription business, does it work from a unit economics perspective to have like customer acquisition strategies centrally focused around Facebook? Or do you find actually bluntly the tax are just too high now on these platforms, given just how kind of proliferated they are?
29:27 Speaker 02 We have had an incredible amount of success using platforms like Facebook, Instagram, Google to acquire users. And the cool thing that we're doing, and I think that this is where hopefully more companies will go, which is, how do you use your content to grow your business? Well, mastering these platforms in terms of you controlling your Destiny there is how to do it and we pay these companies, we advertise and the way we do it is we look at things like in the first twenty minutes of an article being out to the public. How's the conversion? How many people are clicking on the paywall? How many people are looking at our plans page? How many of our subscribers are scrolling down the article? How many subscribers are clicking the article in their feed?
30:06 Speaker 02 Right? All these little signals, they all add up to information that we can then use to say, well, this article is worth putting money behind. And then we can go put more money and we're starting to automate a lot of it. So within minutes of an article being out, we can learn, is it worth putting money behind? And then it's automatically posted to Facebook and we learn in the first couple of hours if it's working on Facebook. These are examples and like we have an entire team dedicated to this. And this is what I believe is like what's necessary to survive and grow in a world where Facebook, Google, other platforms own the customers' time. And it's been really effective with us and frankly, the CAC has been very workable. When you're a subscription business, you know, you're generating revenue off your subscribers and so it works for us.
30:49 Speaker 02 It may not work if you're an advertising driven business, but absolutely works for us.
30:53 Harry Stebbings? I mean, that's so good to hear and I love to hear about kind of just the data centrality and basically the science behind the marketing element there. And totally with you in terms of needing to do that in the world of Facebook and Google state. I do though, as I said, I promised I would move into it. I've got so many more questions, but I promise I would. So I'd love to do the quick fire round. So I say a short statement, you hit me with your immediate thoughts. Sixty seconds per one. Ready to rock and roll, Alex?
31:14 Speaker 02 Let's do it.
31:14 Harry Stebbings? Okay. So favorite book and why?
31:16 Speaker 02 So this is not my favorite book, but it is the book that I'm rereading right now and I think it's super relevant and it's a very old book. The Kingdom of God is Within You by Leo Tolstoy. And I remember reading it a decade or so ago and being fascinated by it and it's about nonviolent resistance. Leo Tolstoy became obsessed with this concept of nonviolent resistance and it wound up being the foundation of Gandhi and much of the civil rights movements in the sixties. And so it's been a really thoughtful read for me and really like internalizing some of the things going on in the U S right now and it's been a wonderful read.
31:48 Harry Stebbings? Wow, absolutely. Something incredibly intellectual. Beats my Fifty Shades of Grey at least. So congrats on that. Tell me, Alex, the biggest strength and biggest weakness as a leader for you?
31:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, this one is so easy for me and it's both a strength and a weakness and anyone who's worked with me in the past will validate this. It's my passion. It is absolutely what drives me forward. It's what makes me a good leader. It's what also gets me into trouble ninety-nine percent of the time.
32:12 Harry Stebbings? Totally. I always find the biggest strength is also your biggest weakness. So totally agreed there. What do you most like to change about the world of tech in the valley, do you think?
32:19 Speaker 02 So to me, I'd love to see more pragmatism over principles a little bit, which is like thought is becoming too much of a religion right now. And I really love just, we talked to our newsroom about this a lot, like ad nuance, don't take nuance away. And how can we solve problems without just picking a side, right? Everything feels a little bit too bifurcated for me and there's so much nuance. And how can we get more complicated and solve problems by working together on things? And I think it comes down to pragmatism over principles.
32:56 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, no, and I love that as a saying. I think that's a book in the making. Tell me, what do you believe that most around you disbelieve, Alex?
33:02 Speaker 02 That most people are good and mean well.
33:04 Harry Stebbings? Wow, that's a nice one. It's very nice to have such optimism to that question. I'm not used to it. Tell me, the biggest challenge in the scaling journey of The Athletic?
33:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, I mentioned this earlier, but it's committing to the job of communicating all day long. I mentioned I'm pretty antisocial by nature and I think the job of communication is so important. And I have to repeat myself 50 times a day and I think everyone should just have all the context that I have. But I'm learning just how hard the job is of communicating to so many people.
33:36 Harry Stebbings? Penultimate one here. You said about kind of learning from others earlier. Who's the biggest mentor to you and what's been the biggest takeaway from that relationship?
33:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, so lately it's definitely Michael Horvath, the founder and CEO of Strava. And I think it's a really simple lesson and I mentioned it in relation to the board discussion too. And it's caring for the business you're creating, caring for the people you hire, caring for your customers, caring for every part of the thing that you're giving to the world and really, really making that a priority.
34:06 Harry Stebbings? Final one. We mentioned the incredible growth in the UK. Fifty-five, I can't believe 55 people in 120 days. But next five years for you and for The Athletic, what does that picture look like, Alex?
34:16 Speaker 02 Yeah, to me, it's two things. It's first, as you mentioned, we went into the UK pretty quickly is how do we bring The Athletic to more people in the world? Sports is such a unifier, and I think this pandemic has given us a taste of what life is like without sports. And I'm sure you missed watching Chelsea.
34:33 Harry Stebbings? For sure.
34:33 Speaker 02 I watched yesterday. But like, you know, this idea that we're covering the world's most popular sports, how do we bring what we're doing to more people? That's number one. And number two, and this is the thing that I'm most passionate about long term with our business, is so few companies are obsessed with how people consume news. And I believe that we're going off the rails with how people consume news, whether it be Twitter, Facebook, or these platforms. I think these platforms are an unbelievable negative for how people consume news for all the obvious reasons. And we're a company that is committed to innovating on how people consume news. And we've invested most of our capital into the newsroom to date,
35:17 Speaker 02 but we've started to really dedicate ourselves to investing in ways, or I should say, new ways to consume news. And we'll have a lot more to say about that later this year, and I can't wait for the world to see it.
35:30 Harry Stebbings? Alex, this has been so much fun. As I said, like a huge lover of The Athletic for a while now, so I was super excited for this one. But thank you so much for joining me today.
35:37 Speaker 02 Thanks so much, Harry.
35:40 Harry Stebbings? As you can tell, I absolutely loved having Alex on the show there. And if you'd like to see more from Alex, which is a must, you can find him on Twitter at A Mather. That's at A Mather. Likewise, it'd be great to welcome you behind the scenes here. You can do that on Instagram at H Stebbings nineteen ninety six with two Bs. But before we leave you today, I'm sure you've heard about it, but my word, this is a product I love, Carter. Carter simplifies how startups and investors manage equity, track cap tables, and get valuations. Go to Carter dot com forward slash two zero V C to get ten percent off. More than eight hundred thousand employees and shareholders use Carter to manage hundreds of billions of dollars in equity. And Carter now offers fund administration, so you can see in real time data in the Carter platform and work with Carter's team of experienced fund accountants.
36:22 Harry Stebbings? Again, go to Carter dot com forward slash two zero V C to get ten percent off. And speaking of amazing products you've heard about with Carter there, last month I had Jeff Zeibert and Wayne Chang on the show from Digits. Simply put, they're two of the best founders that I've ever met, and they're creating the most intuitive financial software that you've ever seen or used, automatically analysing your company's spend and visualising it for you as it happens. Honing in on recent activity, trends, anomalies, or any question that you have in just a few clicks. And unlike every other financial software, the integrations is not weeks, it's just a few clicks. I have to say the product is absolutely beautiful, which is not something I ever thought I'd say for financial software, but you have to check it out, and you can do so at digits.com, that's at digits.com. And finally, did you
37:05 Harry Stebbings? know there will be 1.4 million job openings for developers in 2020 alone? Well, that's where my friends at Terminal come in. Terminal is a remote teams engine for fast-growing companies, connecting you with global talent to deliver the product-building powerhouse your business needs to grow. They provide services and infrastructure in a complete solution that allows businesses to build and scale their remote engineering teams from the ground up without sacrificing experience or quality. From workspaces to community to on-the-ground support, they take the guesswork out of remote so that you can really thrive. But really, don't take my word for it, just ask high-growth businesses like Gusto, Chime, Earnin, and Hims, all trusting Terminal with their remote teams, and you can find out more today at terminal.io.
37:47 Harry Stebbings? As always, I so appreciate all your support, and I can't wait to bring an incredible episode on Monday with Chamath at Social Capital.
Previous 20VC: 8VC’s Joe Lonsdale on How To Foster Contrarian Thinking Within Venture Partnerships, Why The Best VCs Are Company Builders & Why It Is Not Possible To Build Multi-Billion Dollar Companies and Have Worklife Balance Next 20VC: Chamath Palihapitiya on Why IPOs and Direct Listings Are Broken, Turning Social Capital Into A Combination of Berkshire Hathaway, Koch Industries and The Red Cross, Why Forecasts Are Worthless, What Creates True Defensibility & Why You Have To Be Pr Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated