Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: Semil Shah on The Biggest Mistakes VCs and LPs Made Over the Last 24 Months, Why LP Churn is Coming, Core Lessons on Scaling from $1M Haystack Fund I to Today and How To Find, Win and Manage LPs as an Emerging Manager About this episode Semil Shah is the Founder of Haystack, one of the leading pre-seed and seed firms of the last decade. Among Semil's portfolio include the likes of DoorDash ($DASH), Instacart, Hashicorp ($HCP), Opendoor ($OPEN), Figma (acquired by Adobe), Carta and many more exceptional companies. Semil's first fund is marked between a 30 and 40x fund, astonishing. In Today's Episode with Semil Shah We Discuss: 1.) The Makings of Semil Shah: What is Semil running away from? What is he running towards? What does Semil know now that he wishes he had known when entering venture? What is Semil's biggest advice to managers raising their first funds now? 2.) Fund Sizing: Growing vs Staying Disciplined: Question from Hunter Walk: How does Semil determine the right size fund to raise with each fund Question from Satya Patel: Why have you resisted increasing AUM? In the last episode Semil mentioned a three-year deployment cycle for the fund, did he stick to it? What are the benefits and drawbacks? What investing mistakes did Semil make over the last 3 years that he wishes he had not made? 3.) The Secret to Fundraising for a Fund: What is Semil's biggest advice to emerging managers on finding new LPs? What works? What materials do managers need to have in place for a new fundraise? Deck? Dataroom? What are the most common mistakes VCs make when pitching LPs their funds? How does Semil follow-up with potential LPs post-call? What works? What does not? How does Semil suggest creating a sense of urgency for LPs to commit to a fund? How does Semil feel about giving preferential terms to convince LPs to commit to the first close? 4.) The Current Landscape: For VCs: How will the current landscape impact emerging managers' ability to raise? What advice would Semil give to them? Raise smaller? Kyle Harrison said on the show recently, “differentiation will kill 80% of venture firms, especially the so-so ones”. Does Semil agree? Who is set to struggle? Who is set to thrive in this environment? For LPs: What does Semil think are the biggest mistakes LPs made over the last 2-3 years? How will they respond in this market cycle? If Semil were handed an endowment fund, how would he allocate today? Does Semil agree, we will see a denigration of venture returns to those of PE like multiples? Why? For Founders: How does Semil advise founders on raising today when everyone says they are investing but very few really are? How does Semil advise founders on how to think about valuation inflection points with respect to raising capital? Items Mentioned in Today's Episode: Semil's Favourite Article: Master of Play Semil's Most Recent Investment: Impart Security
Transcript 13,690 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Tashi Corp, where we invested in the first round and that was just a huge win. I think it was like the 25K turned into something like 30, 35 million bucks.
0:08 Harry Stebbings? Welcome back. This is 20 VC with me, Harry Stebbings. Now, today's show is my favorite type of show. Two managers sharing war stories in deep discussion. And there's no one better than Semil Shah. Join me in the hot seat for this one. For those that do not know, Semil is the founder of Haystack, one of the leading pre-seed and seed firms of the last decade. Among Semil's incredible portfolio is DoorDash, Instacart, Open Door, Figma, Carter and many more. Semil's first fund is marked between a 30 and a 40X. And I want to say a huge thank you to Satya Patel and Hunter Walk at Homebrew, Anand Dayar and Nakul Mandan for some amazing questions, suggestions today. A real team effort on the schedule. But before we move into the episode today, Harvard Management Company is constantly seeking out the next generation of great investors and entrepreneurs.
0:53 Harry Stebbings? HMC has managed Harvard University's endowment for nearly 50 years and was one of the first institutional investors in venture capital. Their experience and long-term investment horizon make some ideal partners to get world-changing ideas on a path to viability and success. They work as a true partner, providing insightful perspectives to help managers succeed. I personally have had the pleasure of working with the HMC team and can say that they are truly exceptional partners and savvy investors. Whether you are launching your first fund or your fifth, HMC welcomes the opportunity to partner with both developing and established managers. Have an idea you want to share with the team? Just send it to [email protected] . And speaking of amazing partners with HMC there,
1:36 Harry Stebbings? Mercury is building full-stack banking for startups. Apply in under 10 minutes from anywhere for FDIC insured bank accounts, physical and virtual debit cards, domestic and international wires, and integrations with Gusto, Stripe, QuickBooks, Plaid, basically every other tool your startup uses. They also offer unusual features like API access, custom team management, and their newly launched Mercury Treasury, a cash management product for high-growth startups. And they'll even help you build your startup with Mercury Raise, which is so cool. It's a program to connect you to Silicon Valley's top Investors head to mercury.com forward slash signup to apply. And finally, Market X. Market X provides investors with a streamlined platform to access, evaluate,
2:20 Harry Stebbings? and exit global growth stage to pre-IPO technology companies. Plus, Market X allows you to learn from global experts and get intimate interviews with startup executives behind the companies you're investing in. Their track record includes the likes of ByteDance, Airbnb, SpaceX, and many more incredible companies around the world. In addition, Market X enables individual investors and private fund managers to create their own syndicates, helping every investor to become a professional VC. And since their inception, Market X has covered over 300 pre-IPO companies and have worked with more than 50 growth to late-stage portfolio companies. In 2021, they had five IPOs and acquisitions alone. Visit marketxventures.com and check out their YouTube channel, Market X Ventures.
3:03 Harry Stebbings? But that's enough from me, so now I'm so excited to hand over to Semil Shah, founder at Haystack.
3:13 Speaker 02 You have now arrived at your destination.
3:16 Harry Stebbings? Semil, this is gonna be the best podcast you've ever done. You've done a few with me, you've done a few with other people, so this is gonna be the best. We've started before with how you got into venture, so for anyone that hasn't listened to that, fuck it, they can listen to the last episodes. I wanna go deep with you, my friend. We're gonna go with we're all a function of our histories, and so we're all running towards something and we're running away from something. What are you running away from first, and then what are you running towards?
3:43 Speaker 00 In a professional context, what I'm running from is just the fear of not being able to participate in the way I want to in the ecosystem. Way before we met, there was like a long period of time where I would even confide in my wife and say like, "Hey, I don't know if we'll live in the Bay Area and make it here." So, over those 10-plus years, I've had lots of industry friends move out of the Bay Area, when I say like involuntarily, and a lot of personal friends, especially through COVID and the fires, move. And I do love living in California. I feel like it's the only place I can live and do what I wanna do.
4:16 Harry Stebbings? When did you start to believe that would be possible and that you would be? Able to do it.
4:20 Speaker 00 Kind of like 2015, 2016, but there was probably like a two to three year period where I just wasn't sure. And then you see other people drop off. Again, people drop off voluntarily, but it's when you have people who leave involuntarily. And you start to see that and it builds up. I sort of run away from that.
4:38 Harry Stebbings? What are you running towards, my friend?
4:40 Speaker 00 Someone that you and I have talked about, someone like Roger Erenberg, where you can try to become the investor of record and an important company and an important partner to a founder early, and then you show up on the S1 and people are surprised. That's just you're running towards is like a lot of us as investors, for the most part, we can't do what entrepreneurs do. We choose not to do what entrepreneurs do. We have the best job in the world. And so to get a chance to be close to one, to sort of steal a line from the Reagan speech and touch a face of God is an amazing opportunity.
5:11 Harry Stebbings? I totally agree. My favorite is the Roosevelt, the man in the arena quote is one of the best, I think.
5:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, totally.
5:17 Harry Stebbings? I want to dive straight in today. I spoke to many mutual friends, which was great fun. And I want to start with the firm itself being Haystack and Hunter Walk, obviously from Homebrew. He asked, how do you decide what each fund size for Haystack will be? Let's start there.
5:32 Speaker 00 Well, remember the first four, I was never able to reach the target of what we wanted to raise. They were always underwhelming in that sense, or what's the opposite of oversubscribed?
5:42 Harry Stebbings? Underparticipate.
5:43 Speaker 00 Under subscribed. And so for the last two, they were just marked at 50. And so to answer Hunter's question, I thought of 50 and the first $50 million fund as enabling us to get to a 10% position in pre-seed seed rounds. And then in COVID, I felt like a lot of LPs were going to support us regardless of what we're doing. And Fund Five at that 50 million stake was working. So I just thought, let's not complicate things. Let's literally use the same documents, the same size. It's a rinse and repeat strategy and I clearly communicated that to everyone because the model was working. I just took the path of least resistance there rather than introducing more variability. We probably could have raised a lot more, but I just felt, hey, it's an easier pitch to go back to people when they can't meet you and can't meet the portfolio.
6:27 Speaker 00 Our next funds, by the way, will Honestly grow, but I still think for what we do, it's got to be under a hundred million dollars.
6:34 Harry Stebbings? Pre-seed rounds have gone. I never see a round that's less than three on fifteen. Do you agree? What do you do? Do you see something different?
6:42 Speaker 00 I think there are classes of rounds. I mean, this gets into this black hole of what is a round and what do you call it? Where I've sort of given up. I think that one thing we can talk about is these pre-seed rounds where they're traditionally four, five, eight million dollar cap rounds where people are raising under a million. I think over the last 10 years, just simply because of inflation, those have all doubled. So to your point, the three on fifteen does feel like a medium entry point. And then if you want to do the math and you want to own 10% of everything and have 25 names, you quickly get above with reserves over a hundred million dollar fund. I've tried to keep it under a hundred million for a variety of reasons. One is we don't want to make a promise to LPs and founders that we have to own 10 plus percent of every company
7:23 Speaker 00 or lead every deal. And then also just the percentage that we would hold at exit if we're lucky enough to be part of an exit. It may not be meaningful enough if the fund is over a hundred million dollars.
7:33 Harry Stebbings? I totally get you. So if we think about the fifty million dollar funds, what's the average ownership in those funds?
7:39 Speaker 00 We've been able to get close to seven percent initial entry ownership in the last two funds. And it's been going up. I would say it's like a slow march. What I call it is like we slowly creep up the cap table. But one of the things I'm really proud of with Haystack is if you look at the activity of all the deals over 10 years, I would say there's a tight clustering between eight and fifteen million dollars as the entry point and the rounds being three million dollars or less. So to your point, Harry, I think that is a sweet spot, maybe a deal for a good founding team. I think the problem comes in is like, how much evidence is there on the three and fifteen? I think we went through this period where a lot of entrepreneurs were getting credit for having done nothing yet and getting three and fifteen to start. The problem is now the gap to get the 10 million dollar check is so wide. So what's right entry point at seed?
8:24 Speaker 00 And I would argue that's changing to teams that already have a product in market where there's some de-risking there where you can bridge a gap from the seed to A.
8:31 Harry Stebbings? I was analyzing the portfolio that I have the other day. I looked at seeds and I looked at those that haven't really worked. And all of those that haven't really worked have often And been head of product at Twitter, head of product at Twitch, head of product at amazing company, the hottest of hot seed rounds with Andreessen, Sequoia, Amazon, you name it. And they all just moved really slowly. They were very competitive, five on 25 rounds. None of them really went anywhere. Have you found the same with that profile of deal?
9:00 Speaker 00 We avoid a lot of those, to be honest. By the way, the logic for doing them for these big funds is applicable. Like, it makes sense to me, but I think for a fund like ours, which is small and constrained, they'll get to take those type of shots. We maybe say we do three or four of those if we have a relationship per fund, but we're not able to do that as a matter of just normal business. What you're saying we can unpack a lot, which is, are those hot seed rounds necessarily indicators of entrepreneurial value creation? Probably not. Are they best suited to like, understand what's at the cutting edge of product development or infrastructure? Probably, but I think it goes back to this more philosophical question, which is, are talented people also entrepreneurial?
9:43 Speaker 00 And I don't believe that. I believe there's tons of talented people who are not entrepreneurial. And there are a bunch of entrepreneurial people who don't have the requisite talent. Really, what we're trying to do is trying to find that overlap of who has the talent plus entrepreneurial ability. I'm sure you've seen in some of these rounds, Harry, because the rounds are so competitive and people are fawning over them and people believe that they're going to create the next big thing. There's sometimes lack of urgency, there's lack of direction, there's lack of passion.
10:09 Harry Stebbings? I agree with those things, but the trouble is, when you have the head of product at your Twitters or your big companies, when they talk about product, they do just talk with such gravitas and experience and wisdom compared to a first time founder or any kind of less domain experience founder, where you're just like, holy shit, back up the truck on these people. So my question to you is, and it's such a shit question, but how do you try and identify the overlap of talent and entrepreneurialism?
10:35 Speaker 00 Again, this is just a very philosophical point and I could be entirely wrong. Roger, we both went to University of Michigan, so he just recently, about a month ago, invited me back and interviewed me, which was surreal, for like, three hours and we talked about this point. I said, which was possibly like a politically incorrect way of saying this, but I just felt that a lot of people that knock on our door with this amazing product experience or amazing experience, you don't get the sense that they sometimes, again, I'm not trying to cast all of them this way, that they really want it, that they're really hungry. And I also believe, again, this is just personal, that most people who have an entrepreneurial gene in their sort of hard coding have expressed that in some other way before they've knocked on our doors.
11:18 Harry Stebbings? Brad Gerstner on the show said the other day, I ask everyone, how did you make money the first time?
11:24 Speaker 00 Yeah. And that's what I'm getting towards where we try to interview the person to get to know them and how they got here. And then you're testing for overcoming adversity. It doesn't need to be in business, enduring pain, passion that they've devoted. There's a hundred things you could evaluate where you could say, okay, this person expressed some bit of hustle, some bit of grit, some bit of handling adversity. Again, it's not all that you need to get there, but it feels, you need to feel a little bit of that as an investor. Because what you're doing is you're kind of trading off talent sophistication, artistic endeavors with grit and hustle. You can't just have a hundred on one end and zero on the other, or vice versa. There needs to be a bit of a blend.
12:05 Harry Stebbings? David Goggins said, you want to back people who are uncivilized. And the trouble is with your heads of products at Twitter, they're often quite civilized.
12:12 Speaker 00 A lot of people will say also now that like, once you make it through to like certain organizations and you are in this PM role, you do have more of like a political job than you do a breaking glass job.
12:25 Harry Stebbings? No, I completely agree. Politicalization of leadership. I actually spoke to Brian Armstrong about it the other day on the show. That was like the seed trend that I noticed. The series A trend that I noticed there was the hot As absolutely do correlate to hot Bs. Weirdly, the hot seeds often don't. Hot As very commonly move to hot Bs. What you've seen as well.
12:44 Speaker 00 Overall, I think your observation is correct. I think there's a ton of capital that wants to follow the signal and validation of like a premium or competitive series A.
12:55 Harry Stebbings? We mentioned that you could have raised more. I'm going to push your thinking here. You should. Raise more fifty and a hundred. It is a difference, but it's not a huge difference at this stage. It gives you more lines of diversification. I get if it's fifty versus two hundred or two fifty, then we're talking about big bandwidth differences. But actually fifty to a hundred, it's still in the same ballpark. Why have you resisted scaling AUM?
13:18 Speaker 00 I think it comes down to like ownership and exit where I've done enough of these small funds on a small base that have been wildly successful and accretive. And I just see how much dilution comes in, how long it takes, what the return profile is. It leads me to just think that we would need to start out, if we had a hundred, hundred fifty million dollar fund, owning fifteen percent of everything that we do. There's a possibility where, Harry, your question is right on, where you'd say, okay, in this environment now, why don't you wait, do the three million dollar checks for the fifteen percent ownership and do the small A's and compete? I think it also changes what you need to bring. You have to lead every deal. If you're competing for that entrepreneur, you have to bring a certain set of things to the table.
14:03 Speaker 00 And I'm not sure I'm ready to make that promise versus leading a few deals. And then also what we tell entrepreneurs sometimes is we can sit in the driver's seat and lead the deal. We can sit in the passenger seat and be a co-lead or the second biggest check. Or we can be in the backseat as the third check, but that's basically it. We don't do party rounds and things like that. So I like that flexibility and it enables us to play with the entrepreneurs we want to play with.
14:25 Harry Stebbings? What percent of deals do you lead?
14:27 Speaker 00 I would say if you look over the last three years, we've maybe led ten deals.
14:32 Harry Stebbings? Tenish deals. If I was competing against you, I would say to the founder, which we don't because we're wonderful friends. We don't compete with anyone similar. That's our game, right? I would say to the founder, Semil is amazing. I love Semil, but look at these deals. He can be a passenger and so let me lead it and let's put him as the passenger. Do you worry that by being willing to do both, you put yourself in a position where you can be pushed to the passenger seat by anyone you're competing against?
14:58 Speaker 00 Not really, because I kind of have a zen approach about it, which is our job is to teach the founders how to interact with investors and raise capital over successive rounds. Part of that should be to choose the best partners for you. I kind of learned this from a Brad Feld interview. And he just said, like, I mentioned some deal that they did that they lost maybe to True. And he was like, I thought it was great. He was like, I'm friends with everyone at True and the entrepreneur is really happy. So we're fine with that. I'm also fine with that.
15:27 Harry Stebbings? Why? I think this is the game of intense competition. I remember Peter Fanton telling me the best people are hyper competitive and hyper curious. And if I lose money, I should be upset.
15:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, you don't want to, but I think of it as like flipping it a little bit, which is if we try to lead everything, we would lower the quality of the portfolio that we're in. Being able to be flexible suits my personality. So it fits me, but then it also enables us to move around. So we've been tracking someone to do a deal. It's actually one of these three on fifteens that you mentioned, pre everything, but it's someone who's a known quantity in a really interesting sector. We actually had a friend who's just got a fund based in that sector. And so we sent it to them. And we tell the entrepreneur, like, we'll give you a term sheet if you want a term sheet from us, but we think you should talk to these three groups because they're right in the wheelhouse of what you do. The entrepreneur was super happy with that and is probably going to work with one of them.
16:20 Speaker 00 By being flexible, we get to work with who we want to work with. On the cases where we do lead, to come back to your original question, Harry, I think speed wins and conviction. So we will lead deals that we want to lead and we're just closing one now. We're technically leading, but someone else is putting in a bigger check. And we cut back a little bit to bring in a friend who really wanted to come in. I think of this as like, we're always trying to co-invest with people that we know, and these are repeated gains. It's better over the long run to pick the entrepreneurs you want to work with and collaborate with those syndicates over time, rather than trying to box out your territory on each one. I think going back to your previous question of if I had a hundred, a hundred fifty million dollar fund, that whole collaboration layer of how we work would change,
17:00 Speaker 00 which would then set off a chain reaction of how the deal flow would change and how we would have to operate with the companies would change. Then you look back over 10 years where there's tons of DPI, tons of IPOs. On paper, Haystack looks like I can't believe it. Would you risk all that magic of meeting entrepreneurs early in order to have more money? It's just better to raise the next fund and. Go for it again.
17:21 Harry Stebbings? I get you. My question is, how low will you go on ownership?
17:24 Speaker 00 I would say we stop around 5%. So if you look at like what we tell the entrepreneur is, look, we're trying to own 5 and 10% to start. We want to earn the right to maintain that over a few rounds. And we'll never own more than you as a founder. We'll always give you advice. You will be voting our shares. That's kind of a non-threatening way of sort of coming at an entrepreneur.
17:45 Harry Stebbings? In Europe, that's an uncomfortable position, if I'm honest, because you have the leads, Excel, Index, Sequoia Europe, and they always want 15 minimum. And then they have normally that 5% for angels. You're very much in no man's land in that position. Do you find the same for you?
18:02 Speaker 00 No, because I think like the US market, there's so many seed funds, there's so many Series A funds, there's so many top-tier funds. Our job isn't to invest when Excel, Lightspeed, Greylock invest. Our job is to invest around before that.
18:17 Harry Stebbings? I'm just being multi-stage move earlier and earlier while they're doing precedes.
18:21 Speaker 00 They are, but the reality at the same time is they're more attracted to the more experienced people coming out of these big orgs, whereas most of what we do are first-time founders, maybe not as startup-petregreed as those. And also, these funds are really big and slow, so they're not going to be able to move and prosecute the things in the same way that they say on Twitter.
18:41 Harry Stebbings? I find because the chat sizes are so small to them, they don't really give a shit and they do it in seconds.
18:47 Speaker 00 We have tons of examples of ones where they didn't move fast.
18:51 Harry Stebbings? I got this from one of your teammates. They listened to our last shows and they said about you saying three-year deployment cycle for the fund. Did you stick to the three-year deployment cycle, Samuel?
19:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, no, I knew you would stick to that and I was thinking about it. So what I kind of concluded over that time and what I told our LPs is that for the seed market, I felt the thing we could promise is 24 to 30-month deployments and then doing new funds. And I would say that since we last spoke, I would say it's closer to 24 than 30. But I didn't try to make a promise of 36. I didn't think it was possible.
19:26 Harry Stebbings? Samuel, at 24, you're still 12 months longer than most managers in the last. Cycles though, don't worry. Well, that's really.
19:31 Speaker 00 That's crazy to me. I don't know how you go back to LPs unless you have a really deep relationship or history of returns when you deploy that fast in this environment.
19:42 Harry Stebbings? I think it's a challenge. Given that, a lot of people regret the speed of their investing there. As we said, doing it in 12 months for many. What investing mistakes do you think you made over the last three years that you wish you hadn't have made?
19:53 Speaker 00 I think in Fund Four, I always worry about the carnage in that fund. And I knew there was going to be turbulence because it was the first time was really going for ownership. And I knew in going for ownership to our earlier part of the conversation that there is a trade off in quality when you're trying to make a move on just getting into a round versus getting a certain percent of ownership. We made a lot of errors of selection, me, in that fund.
20:16 Harry Stebbings? Was it an error of selection being picking or access being adverse selection? You just chose what you could get the ownership in?
20:24 Speaker 00 I think it's a mix in that fund. I would say 20% adverse and 80% poor selection. That really course corrected in the next two funds where I feel boom, it just hit again. I remember an LP telling me a long time ago, just when I was starting, that typically they stay with good managers for five funds and they assume that three of them will be so-so, maybe two to three X funds. One of them will be a complete turd and one of them will be spectacular. I kind of knew going into that one that this was going to be a change in motion. This is 2017 to 2019. That's a fund I look back on as where mistakes were concentrated.
20:58 Harry Stebbings? What do you put that fund that in your head? Is that a two X, a three X?
21:01 Speaker 00 The good thing about all of this is that we have five to 10% positions in three or four really amazing companies that all could be public, actually, at some point. There's a ladder to get out of this. That's pretty exciting. But if I look back on it as a player looking over the game film, that's a fund I look over and say, oh, I wish I had made this play different. I wish I had done this different.
21:23 Harry Stebbings? Do you give a shit about loss ratios, Samuel?
21:25 Speaker 00 No, I think at seed it's just par for the course where that's going to happen as virtue of being in this position.
21:32 Harry Stebbings? Is venture more a game of picking or more a game of access, do you think?
21:35 Speaker 00 For the early stage, I think it's both. You need access to creative people. You need to select from the ones that come your way. I think it's really hard to generate that access in a repeatable way and it's super hard to select. So I think it's equal.
21:49 Harry Stebbings? I spoke to many of our friends again before and specifically it was Nakul who told me about the instrumental impact you had on his fundraiser. Broadacious. And so I want to kind of go through the life cycle of raising a fund. Nakul told me you introduced him to 50 plus LPs. I love that. Most people did two or three. Semil gave me 50. So my question to you is, what's your biggest advice to emerging managers? On just finding new LPs? What works? What doesn't? Cause it is a game of discovery.
22:17 Speaker 00 People in the last three or four years and I miss this wave. It's like I got married right when Tinder was taking off. Bought two cars right when Uber was taking off and I didn't live in the city. So I just missed these waves. And I started my fund before Angelist, but I think in the last three years with the capital acceleration, you have people who their first debut fund or their second funds are actually pretty big and they don't have investment experience. A lot of people didn't go through the proof of concept funds like I went through. Then they go knock on the door of Notre Dame or somebody else and you sort of wonder, why are you doing that? Again, my advice may not really click with people because they don't want to go through that. But I think one is on Angelist now, there's really no excuse not to have some kind of track record before you go talk to an institutional.
23:01 Harry Stebbings? It takes time, Semil. Like the truth be told, like you're not going to know if you're a good investor for 10 years. So I could show you a lot of great logos that I've built through Angelist. It doesn't really show much.
23:12 Speaker 00 It just becomes a specific thing you can point to that you can have a richer conversation with. You could say, hey, look, for two years I've made these 20 angel investments. Here's how much money I put in. Here's how much money other people gave me. Here's who followed on. It's just a richer conversation with an LP and a more substantive conversation than saying, hey, I just want to deploy 50 million bucks. So that would be number one. Using Angel List, again, for people who don't want to wait and go, I would just say you have to have other GPs vouch for you. The only way they vouch for you is if they see you work. The only way they see you work is if you're an executive in one of their companies or you're around to deal with them. So it was easy for me to, like you had mentioned, Anand Ayer and
23:54 Speaker 00 Knuckle Man and then me making like a lot of impactful intros for them. That was easy to do because I had worked with them a lot, but it's hard for me to do that with someone I haven't worked with.
24:03 Harry Stebbings? There's also things like whenever an LP committed to my first funds, I'd be like, Semil, thank you because you like it. Who are three people with a similar mindset to you that you think would share your excitement for what I'm doing? And then they commit to names. And once you commit to names, I'm going to hound you for intros to those names.
24:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:21 Harry Stebbings? At one flywheel.
24:22 Speaker 00 I also think that's the hustle part, but I think closing the deals are harder. What I coach a lot of emerging managers on is like, okay, if you go meet an institutional LP, they're predisposed to passing on your first fund, primarily out of the fact of they probably don't think you're going to raise your first fund or deploy it well if you do. So they just want to wait for the second one to just make sure you've actually raised the first one that you've stuck with it, that you like it. Cause it is kind of a lot of busy work is painfully. So it kind of logically makes sense that a lot of the people, for example, I introduced Knuckle to, I was like, think of them as a fund two LP because they probably don't even think you're going to raise your target for this fund.
24:56 Harry Stebbings? Do you know, I meet two new LPs every single week, even when I'm not raising, because I think if you ever meet them when you're raising for the first time, you've got no chance.
25:05 Speaker 00 That is smart to do because I do think relationships matter. And then obviously the diligence you go through, I go through is way more than what an entrepreneur goes through. That's the other thing too, of just having all of your ducks in a row. You have to have some kind of reputation where people call around and name check you.
25:22 Harry Stebbings? Do you have decks? Do you have blurbs? Do you have, what do you have supporting material wise?
25:27 Speaker 00 I think all of that is your mix of collateral that you're going to use to convey messages to different people at different times. I have a one pager for every new fund we raise, which is on one page, everything you would want to know and link to. That's like not super sensitive. Obviously we have a deck and a data room, but now we're at a point where we just copy and paste. A new data room into Dropbox and do all that. We try to reduce all the friction.
25:50 Harry Stebbings? What do you think are the biggest mistakes that GPs make in fundraises?
25:53 Speaker 00 You alluded to some, right? Which is just talking to people when they're raising, not really having a richer conversation about what they're trying to do and why. Again, the decks or the presentation just show a lot of pontification. So I think people, most VCs or emerging managers especially are not good fundraisers because they don't really have a north star to where they're going and why. And it kind of makes sense because it takes a while to develop that. But at the same time, it's not as inspiring for someone to let go of their dollars.
26:22 Harry Stebbings? I've done a lot of LP checks. The GP decks I see are just shit. Why now? No one articulates that why specifically now is the right time. You, much more than me, you're a V1 OG compared to me. But like in the like solo capitalists with me with like Josh Buckley and Rocky Grimes, like this was a personalization of capital. There was strategic shifts in venture that led to this, I think. I clearly articulate why now. I see a ton also, which is, oh, I got into Pipe Series B. I got into Hopin Series B. Name your company Series B, and now I'm doing a seed fund as a former operator. And it's a lack of correlation between prior track and where you want to go.
27:00 Harry Stebbings? And then the advisor page, brilliant advisor page, get fucking rid of it. None of these advisor pages make any difference. Like ridiculous.
27:08 Speaker 00 I think that if you're not getting name checked by institutional LPs and other people aren't talking about what you're doing, it's almost impossible to raise institutional capital, whether it's a $3 million check or $30 million check from an LP. So really that should be the first for an emerging manager is how do I get in the chatter zone of these LPs? And that's different than just having a deck. So you could argue the deck is one of the least important things in the hierarchy of things you would need to do, which is do good deals, help entrepreneurs and other investors in the ecosystem. Have people talk about you as like a unique person or someone who's uniquely helpful or uniquely insightful. And then it's okay, they want to meet you. And then you could be like, oh, well, here's my little deck.
27:49 Speaker 00 Honestly, for like an emerging manager, the deck probably doesn't need to be more than five to 10 slides.
27:54 Harry Stebbings? I've never done a deck.
27:57 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, I mean, again, your body of work is different. So your deck is all the
28:02 Harry Stebbings? Set out here.
28:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. People wanted to support you. You were in that chatter zone. So you showed the ability to help, the ability to connect with people, the ability to get in the chatter zone. Again, I don't think people can extrapolate from what you did.
28:16 Harry Stebbings? I was also lucky. I had track really pre-institutions. Like you said, that my first fund was like eight million. It was like your proof of concept fund. Can I ask, the big challenge that I hear from a lot of GPs is, there's a lot of people around the hoop, but they're not quite getting in the hoop. How do you create urgency with LPs to get them to a conclusion? Do you have any tips on this?
28:38 Speaker 00 I wouldn't say I'm great at this. So green and salt. I think like at a certain point in your career and as an adult, you have to just be willing to walk away and accept a no in different formats. One way we do it is we kind of just say, hey, Julie Smith, LP, hey, if we don't hear from you past this day, we're just going to assume that's not a fit for you. That's okay. But it's not waiting around the phone for someone to call. It's more, we're going to move in this direction. Most LPs have plenty of time to decide. You don't wait for a response. You just sort of move forward on your own timeline.
29:12 Harry Stebbings? A lot of people, kind of like a sales cycle, I guess, in enterprise sales, think that it might help to offer preferential terms in terms of carrying or in terms of fees. Have you ever done that? And how do you advise managers on preferential terms for first close, second close?
29:27 Speaker 00 I haven't done that ever. And not a lot of people have suggested that. So it's not probably something I would advise people to do, only because it could set a weird precedent over time. That being said, I think to get off the ground, sometimes people have to make deals. And so what I would just say is, think about it in the sense of, how do you survive and thrive? So the first point is, how do you survive and get off the ground? You probably need to do what it takes to get the plane off the runway. I wouldn't sit here and say, do it this way, do it that way. It's just like, okay, if you don't take off and leave the runway, then we don't have anything to talk about. Once you're in the air and can stabilize, I would move away from preferential terms. Basically, if you're trying to offer Preferential terms to get the jet off the runway and get some thrust.
30:10 Speaker 00 That's fine, but just don't have it be successive in future funds. Gate it to that one fund.
30:15 Harry Stebbings? Very tough to do. I totally agree. That's a challenge because you're right. It does set a precedent. Cass, what do you advise managers who say, I've got a big check, but they do also want to buy part of the GP? How do you advise those managers where it's also a bit of a sale of the GP as part of it?
30:30 Speaker 00 It really depends on who that person is and what the timeline is. Let's say a really well-respected and eminent foundation came to you, Harry, in 2018 and said, we want to put you in business with a $200 million fund and we'll do 75 of it and we'll introduce it to everyone we know. If they take part of your carry as a GP, not the management company where the fee income goes through, right? And you could say, well, normally I was going to have 20 points of carry, but now maybe I'll have 16. But to get the $200 million fund, that name and all the network, you could say, yeah, for one fund, okay. Now, the problems could be the other 125 million that come with the 75 may also warrant that same thing. And so you'd have to operationally tell them, hey, we're just doing this for our anchor, right?
31:15 Speaker 00 And some other people may say, well, I don't like that or whatever. I think the problem comes in is when that's in perpetuity. To get off the ground, you may have to spend some, the jet fuel is more expensive.
31:24 Harry Stebbings? What terms do you go out with and how do you feel about kickers on funds?
31:28 Speaker 00 We haven't done those yet, although I'm thinking about that now, but I don't have a lot to do.
31:33 Harry Stebbings? I don't do them either. I always say like, listen, if we do a great 5X fund, 6X fund, we shall make a load of money. Let's not be greedy. And I find institutions really appreciate that, but more and more people do it and they don't seem to get pushback.
31:46 Speaker 00 It's not a topic I know well, to be honest.
31:48 Harry Stebbings? Did you go out with 2 and 20?
31:49 Speaker 00 I follow a lot of honestly what USV does of like try to learn. I think they're the best pound for pound fund in the world, both operationally and in every way. And I think Fred has been on the record of just saying they just do a standard 2 and 20 in every fund. So I haven't really seen the need to deviate from that.
32:07 Harry Stebbings? When you look at your fundraising journey in hindsight and with the many years of wisdom that you have now, Samuel, what's the biggest mistakes that you've made?
32:15 Speaker 00 This was actually the one. Question I was thinking about in the shower this morning where I was okay, I know Harry will ask this question.
32:20 Harry Stebbings? I think you learn from mistakes.
32:22 Speaker 00 Yes, I think there are two and one was a minor little warning and one was a major shift in my own psychology. So the minor one is I remember that not to out this person, but I would say a major leader of a major successful fund who spent a lot of time with me, who's been on your show, who introduced me, they only have 24 LPs and they're all endowments and foundations and introduced me personally to the head of this one huge university. And I thought, holy cow, this is for the fund four that was supposed to be about 30 million. They end up being like 22. I thought, oh my God, I've never gotten an introduction like this. I've already had three funds. They do smaller funds.
33:04 Speaker 00 I had met this person before. I knew that this GP's annual meeting is every year in Q1 at the Rosewood. So I have all this stuff on my calendar because I know when these meetings happen. And I sent her an email. I was literally across the street at a meeting and I was like, hey, I know you're across the street. It would be great to get together while you're here. In five minutes, she wrote back, sorry, really busy, sent for my iPad. That was sort of a warning of you could have really good track record, an amazing introduction. You've already met this person. They've already done small funds and this person literally doesn't give a shit.
33:40 Harry Stebbings? I find that very rare. Amazing track, met them before, blah, blah. The thing that I find really gets it. I would introduce the other day by OG of OGs to one of their biggest, they're basically done and in. So I'm surprised that with the great intro, she was still like that.
33:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, I appreciate the response and I appreciate the brevity, but for me it was more of a warning.
34:01 Harry Stebbings? What do you take away from that though, that like, fuck?
34:04 Speaker 00 You know, luckily that happened because it was in January, they host our annual meeting in January. And I had just started that campaign in January. So I felt like I got this omen early. Whereas like, I was probably in my head thinking, oh yeah, I'll meet her on this trip. And so it went 180 real quickly. Okay, this will be difficult. So I felt it was kind of a gift in terms of the timing. The bigger mistake is thinking. Being naively that all LPs will, once they've committed to you, want to see you succeed and want to just be along for the ride if you stay true to what you said you're gonna do. It's interesting because I've had to, fire is the wrong word. I don't think of it that way, but I've blocked two LPs from investing in future funds.
34:45 Speaker 00 And I think both of the behavior in what they did and how they did it, I just felt, hey, I don't work like that. What did they do? One person asked for a phone call, asked before we were raising the next fund for all these terms. I remember I was driving along the Embarcadero and I was like, hey, it sounds like you really want all this stuff now. I'm happy to talk about it. When we raised on five and he was, we won't even be in it unless we get all this stuff now. I was like, okay. And then I just thought about it and then I talked to the colleagues and they were like, yeah, he doesn't change his mind. He just went rogue and he wants all these things. And I just thought, hey, I just don't work like that. But I just feel these things are gifts because then you end up cherishing and valuing more of the LPs who treat you well.
35:28 Speaker 00 And I guess the point I'm trying to make here is that once people get the funds and go in, you just think that everyone's going to support you. And people can have very different motives or ways of revealing information or asking for things. A mistake I think that I made was not being open minded to that. So there was more of a surprise.
35:45 Harry Stebbings? Have you had LP gen?
35:46 Speaker 00 No, these two we let go of really for behavioral reasons. Everyone else has been super great, but I think everybody in our position should expect churn moving forward for a variety of reasons. So churn is coming.
35:59 Harry Stebbings? Okay. Talk to me about that. Why is churn coming? And then also for emerging managers today, moving to Zay, why is it going to be harder to raise?
36:07 Speaker 00 Churn is coming because I think, one, most GPs don't understand how different LP business models work to begin with. But right now, the liquidity profiles of these endowments, foundations, family offices, et cetera, could be wildly idiosyncratic. Certain endowments and foundations could have gotten really liquid in 19, 20, 21. A number of them haven't gotten liquid and they don't know where their portfolios sit. So I think it's going to end up becoming two kind of opposing forces clashing. See a lot of institutional capital constrict out of conservatism and the lack of visibility into what they own that's already on the ground.
36:45 Speaker 00 Because they haven't been able to see it. But then on the same side, you'll also see a realization that a lot of their capital in these larger funds will be stranded capital that they may not see a return on.
36:55 Harry Stebbings? Australian capital is what capital? How do you define that?
36:58 Speaker 00 It's either stuck in a portfolio company that doesn't have product market fit, or it's stuck in a fund that will deploy it. But the fund size may be so large that it's impossible to get over the hurdle.
37:08 Harry Stebbings? One of the things that concerns me is the misalignment of incentives within the LP landscape whereby they say, hey, we'll do Andreessen and we'll take agreed lower multiple. Because we won't get fired for doing Andreessen, but we will get fired for putting 10 million into haystack if Semil suddenly goes off the plot. That worries me.
37:28 Speaker 00 That hasn't been my experience. I think most people have barbelled. And so the people who get caught are the people in the middle. Now, that was what I would say a year ago. I think right now, most LPs I've talked to feel like the bigger funds that they're in, they're more worried about those positions because of the market contraction. Whereas I think for you, for example, you're on fund two now, right?
37:47 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, fund two and three, we raised two at a time early in a series A and B.
37:51 Speaker 00 So when you go out for your third vintage, assuming your funds are a similar size, you're going to be more in demand because these LPs now are now downshifting to the smaller vehicles. Because they realize that they would rather incinerate $10 million with you than $100 million in a larger fund.
38:08 Harry Stebbings? People forget this, though. We're seeing this whole new generation of LPs. We see it in Europe with a huge amount of European corporates with huge balance sheets, wanting to enter venture, realizing bluntly the lack of innovation they have within their incumbent structures. A more controversial one, but with commodity prices changing the way they have done, I've seen a massive rise in Middle Eastern interest from Saudi, Kuwait, Qatar, with bloody oil prices three, 400% higher.
38:34 Speaker 00 I think what you're saying, Harry, is it's true. There's lots of capital that's hungry to go into venture. And I think the question is, how do those people decide where to put it? Or how do you as a GP go grab it? Historically, the case has been that the endowments and foundations who have been in venture capital for the longest period of time are your stickiest partners. That being said, for you, for me, for a lot of those people, they haven't even lived through a recession. You have to be well over forty, fifty years old to have actually lived through a recession as an adult. All the dips that we've had have been pretty narrow in terms of their duration.
39:10 Harry Stebbings? Sam, who struggles in this environment moving forward? Which is the cohort that struggles? Which is the cohort that thrives?
39:15 Speaker 00 On the fun side, people who can pair the magic of meeting entrepreneurs early and getting the ownership early with the firepower of putting enough wood behind the arrows at work. It's probably these funds that are in the billion to four billion range, so to speak, where they'll have a lot of firepower if they have that magic. I also think you'll see a lot of hundred to two hundred million dollar seed funds start to fill that seed series A gap in a more pronounced way. There'll obviously be winners in that. Like, if you think about initialized in the last decade, there's probably one starting now that'll have a rise like that now. Thrive started in the last decade. So I think there are opportunities for these folks to go make deals and put it on the line.
39:58 Harry Stebbings? I think the winners will be Chanel and it'll be Walmart. Chanel, it's a very boutique product for a very specific customer base. It makes you feel a certain way and you either opt in or opt out. And that is your USV, it's your benchmark, it's even your ribbon in terms of the specificity of the product. And then I think the Walmart is Sequoia, Andreessen, dare I say it, Tiger. T, walls of cash, which are relatively infinite and carry you life cycle. I think the ones where I'm like, is when you're seven hundred to one point five. No brand or middle tier brand, lots of partners, bloated decision-making structures. There, I think you have the real pain.
40:41 Speaker 00 I guess the reason maybe I would have a slightly different perspective here is that I think so much of this can pin on one deal. You probably had DuVos on and he famously talked about getting off the Excel train in the pre-Facebook fund. They were going through a lot of hard times or. Peter Fenner is giving interviews about this. So I think it just takes one deal to completely change the trajectory of some of these funds. And so I always keep that in mind. It's too hard to predict what's going to happen. We can predict in a fundraising sense what will happen, but in the deals and what's going to work. Like I think about a round that's happening now, this company, Replit, right? Very unique, exciting company. A lot of people are talking about it. I don't think a lot of people have thought about the seed or Andreessen did the A. It was like a $4 million seed A check, whatever you want to call it.
41:25 Speaker 00 It only was started four or five years ago in terms of the, sorry, the investment going in. Some of this can change over time.
41:32 Harry Stebbings? How much are they raising?
41:33 Speaker 00 Oh, I have no idea, but it's just such a unique company that people are talking about. I'm not close to it. I'm just saying it's an interesting company. And what if you're the series B investor in that company in a no name billion dollar fund? They could totally change the trajectory of your franchise.
41:48 Harry Stebbings? I'm writing a note now to Ping Amjad to see what we can do. For personal money, that sounds like a good place. And I'm hoping it's repriced, given where we are at the market. So yeah, absolutely savage.
41:58 Speaker 00 I'm only calling that out to just illustrate that we can pontificate about who will have fundraising success or pain with, I think, some good precision. I think it's impossible to know who can catch a tiger by the tail.
42:11 Harry Stebbings? I agree with that. I think also the interesting thing is lagging, like track is a lagging indicator. And I mean this nicely, but you look at maybe older firm brands like Mayfield, where you may look and think a slightly more challenged brand for a firm and not a hot brand. But actually Lyft, Hashi Corp, Tonal, they're going to be showing some pretty great distributions.
42:30 Speaker 00 We know a couple of LPs have been long time Mayfield investors who are extremely happy.
42:35 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, this is my book, brilliant returns, brilliant returns. And so you also have that, which is the 10 year lag on the numbers, which will give you another 10 years moving forward and forward indicators. Totally agree with you.
42:47 Speaker 00 Look at Crosslink. I mean, no one really talks about Crosslink. I don't even know if you've had an investor from Crosslink on 20 minute VC, but they ended up owning over 20% of Chime through like a pretty modest deal. Cause no one was looking at it.
42:59 Harry Stebbings? Wow, I did not know that, but no, I haven't had anyone from Crossing on the show, but fuck 20% of Chime. Well, well done. Is coming quite pressing for you. Tell me, while the LPs, GP's fucked up a lot over the last years, as we said, where did LPs make mistakes, Semil?
43:14 Speaker 00 I think that everyone in the ecosystem has committed sins. We can talk about what those main sins are. I think on the LP side, the sin was going along with fund size escalation and allowing and enabling those firms to allocate within those funds. So I believe in having separate vehicles for separate activities because that's the best governor. And so I think when you have the blind pool of capital going all over the place, it really puts a burden on the management of that firm to allocate it properly. And I think it's really hard to do. So I think that's the biggest sin that LPs have committed.
43:50 Harry Stebbings? So I'm just being devil's advocate here. Let's pretend we're on a partnership here. What can we do? We want to continue being in this franchise. We're either in or we're out. If we're out, that's tough for the relationship. So I get you, but I don't see what can be done to remedy it in a very boring environment.
44:06 Speaker 00 I agree, and it's easier to say that today than a year or two ago. I think what I've heard from LPs is some of them picked a few to go stay on the train and a number of them last year dropped off. A number of endowments, foundations, fund of funds who were longtime investors in like top tier funds that had gone really big have for a variety of reasons just said, hey, we're great. Thank you for all the returns. Thank you for the partnership. It's time to move earlier for us. I'm not saying that LPs should have abandoned all those, but I think they probably stand on too many trains than they should have.
44:37 Harry Stebbings? I find that they often actually have adverse selection because of rigidity of bucket allocation. And what I mean by that is we need a series A fund in New York. That's what we're missing. So they find a series A fund in New York in that quarter that is raising at that time and it's crap. Maybe you should have just allocated to the best managers that you see. And I find that kind of bucket thinking really a big problem often.
45:02 Speaker 00 It's funny when you mention it that way because I know what you're talking about and I've never heard it put that way.
45:06 Harry Stebbings? Oh, I have often.
45:07 Speaker 00 Yeah, maybe the canonical example of this is the sector focus fund is like, hey, I want to play this sector because I think it's going to work out that way. I think in some cases it makes sense for early stage because you're filtering more at early. But I tend to believe, and again, this could be not true in the future, but I feel like if you look at the big, important companies and outcomes, when they go public, they have three or four venture capital firms that we recognize on the cap table, and I don't think that's an accident. I think that there are a set of funds, maybe 50 to 75, that in partnership with other funds and entrepreneurs, know how to guide a company towards a big outcome or a public offering. I would just say to the bucketed approach, unless it's really early and bespoke,
45:49 Speaker 00 it probably doesn't really make sense because you would assume the best investors will catch the best things at seed A or B. That's the flypaper that you're buying.
45:57 Harry Stebbings? The other truth is, I think there's a utility value to board members that resembles a barbell, which is Fanton Gurley at the A, Alfred Lin at the A, Roloff Bosa at the A, Amazing Pat, Great at the A, great, and then your pre-IPO people who are amazing for setting you up for getting on the public markets. I find actually the middle, I'd rather have amazing operators who are functional leads at the best companies in the world than having like a series C or D investor that doesn't.
46:26 Speaker 00 But remember, if you're an LP and thinking about this bucketed approach, most LPs don't live in the Bay Area or they're not in the market. They're not talking to founders. They're not talking to VCs all the time. And they just have to map it out. Most of them have to present a strategy or a map of how they cover what they want to cover. So it kind of makes sense why they do that. It doesn't make sense to you and I because we know all the people.
46:48 Harry Stebbings? And that is why they listen to 20 VC and that's why I have a job and get paid so much money. Fantastic. Thank you, guys. I do want to ask, Samuel, I'm starting Shaw Endowment Fund and you're in charge. How do you run the venture allocations for Shaw Endowment?
47:03 Speaker 00 I'd probably do it the way you alluded to earlier, which is if I were an LP not living in the Bay Area or New York, I'd probably go spend a month in each location, get an apartment or Airbnb for an entire month, hang out with lots of people after hours, name check lots of people and place money with the people that the network told me were the most interesting. Now, that's for early. And then I would probably recruit somebody who has VC deal experience to help go do directs on top of it and to stay close to the winning graduating companies. And then I would probably try to get into using my network, five to 10 franchises where I feel you want to be. Be part of their ecosystems.
47:44 Harry Stebbings? I don't think you can get access to the best. I have so many like, oh, I want to put in a 10 million check into Sequoia. And I'm like, well, if you can write 250 in 24 hours, then you might get a chance. And it'll be split across all the different funds. Otherwise, good luck. There are amazing people, though, in a load of big franchises who are sitting on carry that's just been halved, if not more, in pretty tough partnerships with politics. I would say, hey, you are a rock star. Let's put an anchor in the ground. I'm going to anchor you. I'm going to put 30 of your 100 million fund. Let's go do this and build a franchise. I'll do that with five people and put people in business. I think that's a much better one. And then on top of that, I get young, hungry hustlers, not like VC direct people,
48:28 Harry Stebbings? to just go get drunk on with the GPs and team members of these funds to know exactly what is happening. I find there's this complete wrong LP conception that the bigger your check size, the closer you are to the direct deals. It's not that at all. I'm sure you and me are the same. It's just if you have a great relationship with them and if you respect and like them, you show them the deals. Do you know what I mean?
48:48 Speaker 00 Yes, I agree. One thing I think we should talk about before we wrap up too is like when I mentioned we all committed sins, right? Okay, we talked about the sins that LPs committed. What are the sins VC committed? I think the biggest one, in addition to like fund size escalation for fee grab and AUM, is this lowering the threshold for having each financing be an actual true checkpoint for an entrepreneur. A lot of people just deployed capital like a speculative real estate and it's just stranded in these companies now. I'm sure you've seen this too. There's probably multiple, multiple companies with like over $50 million of cash with no product market fit. This is wild.
49:26 Harry Stebbings? But I'm seeing now, I've seen four this month where the Series Bs are saying, hey, preemptively, we fucked up, but give us our cash back and we'll give you a million each. So you'll get a million secondary, but give us our money back.
49:39 Speaker 00 I mean, that should happen more. I think a lot of traditional VCs are loathe to do that for reputational reasons. I would just say from the founder's side, their cost of time right now is probably pretty great. So like, we may start to see that. And then what are the original sins that the founders committed here is I think that a lot of them didn't have their own discipline about creating the checkpoint and milestones for themselves. They didn't get into a habit of bringing certain investors along for the journey or keeping them updated. We have a few entrepreneurs over the years who really want to get better at their updates and metrics and really tune that every month. And we have some where they just don't think it's important and don't think it's important to bring us along for the ride. And then they don't realize it's really hard to socialize
50:22 Speaker 00 it with other people if we're not part of the story. So I think that is a sin that will come home to roost for a lot of founders.
50:28 Harry Stebbings? What happens now? Can these companies just slow die?
50:31 Speaker 00 I think it's kind of Darwinian, honestly, is if you can't respect the dollars that you've taken and you can't give those people a transparent, brief view into what you're doing and allow them to guide you in a polite way, then you're probably not set out for the journey. And I think we've had a lot of people who on both funds and as founders of companies or hopeful founders of companies do that, take the money without really thinking about how do I respect the investment that someone made in me. And that manifests in a lot of different ways. Reporting is one way.
51:05 Harry Stebbings? How many of your companies, percentage wise, give you company updates?
51:08 Speaker 00 I would say the overwhelming majority, but we talk about that in the diligence investment process. And then we actively try to get them on a cadence, like early part of the month, first of the month thing, because then that triggers a conversation for the month, right? And some people, frankly, it's impossible to get them to do it. Again, it's okay. It's not like required, but then it's hard for us to advocate for you if we're not in the know.
51:30 Harry Stebbings? I totally get you. And I agree. I think if you don't send the updates, then you're halved in terms of recommitments for next round. So totally with you.
51:37 Speaker 00 That's an example of not respecting the money. Just to put a finer point on it, the sin that certain GPs have made or certain founders have made that I think will cost them now in this new environment is if you didn't respect where the money came From and treat it like a some sort of light partnership. It's going to be really hard to advance. And that's why I think it's sort of Darwinian, which is the new environment now calls for not only capital efficiency, product led growth, hustle, integrity, grit, all of that. I think it also calls for this as well.
52:06 Harry Stebbings? We want you to grow faster than ever and spend less than ever. Very simple rule, rule of business from the VC. I could speak to you all day, Samuel, so I'm going to move into a quick firearm before I completely kill 20 minute. We should just rename it like 80 minute VC. It's ridiculous.
52:21 Speaker 00 That was great. Help the conversation. Yeah, go for it.
52:23 Harry Stebbings? Let's start. We've done this many times. What's the new favorite book and why? Any that you've read recently and loved?
52:28 Speaker 00 Oh, man, you know what else? I shared an article with a lot of people recently that is available on the internet. So it's an article, but it's about one of the famous game creators on the New Yorker from Nintendo. And it talks about how he grew up in the woods in Japan and saw all these amazing natural things in the wild. And that ended up becoming the landscape in which he painted on for his video games. And I thought that was really interesting because so much of people playing on computers like us or working online, we forget about that. And like so, so many people are gamers and love gaming as well, more casual gaming. But it's just interesting that this guy's whole inspiration came from being outside.
53:07 Harry Stebbings? What worries you most about the venture landscape today?
53:10 Speaker 00 The thing that worries me the most is the portfolio of risks that are around us. In addition to like the lower money supply, I saw Scott Menard, who was the Guggenheim CIO, said that this is the lowest M2 since the depression. So there's less cash around and much more risk around. And so it feels like we're just in the early innings of this like administration of pain, or the game hasn't even really started. So it feels like it will be quite prolonged.
53:36 Harry Stebbings? How much did you cut your book back to your LPs in the remarks?
53:40 Speaker 00 We're doing that right now. I would say doing that literally in Q3 for the Q3 report, Harry, where we have as virtue of our LPA, we obviously have to have a professional third party audit. So we're doing that audit with the firm and remarking the portfolio now. If we had talked two weeks later, I probably could give you like a firmer answer.
53:59 Harry Stebbings? Think they should be remot.
54:00 Speaker 00 Twenty percent, thirty percent, fifty percent, seventy percent. I spend a lot of time talking to a variety of LPs and GPs about this. There is no consensus on this. I think I would just bucket it, which is get seed in early where you don't really know yet, even if you have a great Series B that you've seeded where it is. You do have to pick some methodology and stick with the number and go, but I don't think I could say this is the right number or not. That being said, let's say you're a growth fund, Meritech, where your entry, they're a great fund, everything they're investing in has product market fit, they're larger checks, they probably need to comp everything they have against public comps to go company by company. And so I think it just really depends what your portfolio mix is like.
54:40 Harry Stebbings? You have a career in politics, my friend.
54:42 Speaker 00 No, but I mean, it's, I'm not trying to give a political answer. It's just like, I don't know what it is. Is it twenty five percent? Is it fifty percent? Is it eighty percent?
54:50 Harry Stebbings? Fifty, fifty, you got a cool.
54:52 Speaker 00 I think if you and I were in the bar and we would say, oh, you have a three X fund, Samuel, what is it now? I'd probably say it's one and a half X one. I don't think that's out of bounds.
55:02 Harry Stebbings? Who's the most underrated angel in the ecosystem, do you think?
55:05 Speaker 00 Maybe you know him, Charlie Songhurst.
55:07 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, love Charlie.
55:08 Speaker 00 I think he has an amazing ability to find interesting entrepreneurs and connect with them very quickly.
55:14 Harry Stebbings? I also think Charlie invests in five hundred or eight hundred or a thousand entrepreneurs. Diversification makes picking easier.
55:21 Speaker 00 Yes, yes, but he is a true angel that way. Has he been on your show?
55:24 Harry Stebbings? No, I love Charlie dearly. I would love to have him on the show. He's always very coy and shy about it, but I'd love to make it happen.
55:31 Speaker 00 And then this is more of a, he's a close friend for many years. But I think Scott Belsky, if I were an early stage.
55:37 Harry Stebbings? Oh, yeah.
55:39 Speaker 00 That would be my topic.
55:40 Harry Stebbings? Love Belsky and Fidel, actually. Tony Fidel's fantastic.
55:44 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah.
55:44 Harry Stebbings? Such a man. What's been the single hardest moment of the Haystack journey, my friend?
55:48 Speaker 00 I think the first four fundraises were really hard because it just were continuous. I think in those first four, I only took like six months off. And I was too naive to know, like, the angel list syndicates weren't up. There wasn't this rush of people and it was the only real option I really had. That's probably been the toughest part where finally in Fund Five got over that hurdle.
56:09 Harry Stebbings? Did you doubt that you'd be able to do it every fund?
56:12 Speaker 00 Oh, I still think that way. I still paranoid about being able to raise capital and deploy well every day.
56:17 Harry Stebbings? What's been your single biggest returner?
56:19 Speaker 00 Just in terms of pure gross volume.
56:22 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, gross cash back.
56:24 Speaker 00 It's been Filecoin.
56:25 Harry Stebbings? Wow. You share the multiple?
56:27 Speaker 00 I don't know what the exact multiple is because it fluctuated a lot, but I can give you some of the analysis. Don't know the multiple because there were like so many sales, but essentially met the founders when they were in Y C. Remember meeting him, asking for a couple of meetings. He's obviously brilliant. I didn't understand everything he was doing. I had some friends co-investing. So we invested 50K at the eight million cap or something, then he didn't raise for a while. And then U S V and I think Blue Yard invested, I think, three million dollars total in a small seed round. And then in 2017, I think there was the I C O. So they had raised, it's public, all this is public, like 150 plus million in the I P O.
57:09 Speaker 00 And then they went on a journey to build their product. As part of that, we got tokens as part of being equity investors. So all the equity investors got tokens. And then basically in the first year of the pandemic, when they were about to release, they like completely shot up. And so a lot of equity token holders were able to every month sell those tokens because we had such a huge position. We would sell the max every month for months to go. Now the price of that has gone down. I mean, the return would have been absolutely insane, but it was still been probably the most accretive thing.
57:42 Harry Stebbings? How much were you able to take out?
57:44 Speaker 00 I have to look at the number, but I want to say it's over 10.
57:47 Harry Stebbings? It's pretty good for a 50K check. That's tasty, my friend.
57:50 Speaker 00 It was a three million dollar fund. Well, I don't know the exact numbers, but it was pretty asymmetric. Probably the other one is HashiCorp where we invested in the first round and it was just a huge win.
58:01 Harry Stebbings? That was a 50K check.
58:02 Speaker 00 25.
58:03 Harry Stebbings? 25. What did that turn into?
58:04 Speaker 00 Well, we distributed the shares right at lockup. That's when the market crashed. But I also felt we weren't trying to juice our numbers at that point. I think it was like the 25K turned into something like 30, 35 million bucks.
58:16 Harry Stebbings? Whoa. How big was the fund?
58:19 Speaker 00 A million.
58:19 Harry Stebbings? What? That is insane.
58:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, that fund had Instacart, DoorDash, HashiCorp, and it still has two billion-dollar companies that are still growing in there. So it's crazy.
58:32 Harry Stebbings? What's that fund marked at, do you think?
58:34 Speaker 00 Somewhere between 30 and 40 something. No one cares because the base is super small and you get lucky. And then as the fund sizes get bigger, the multiples will go down, right? Unless you hit something. I think it's like going back to the jet fuel comment. That was a jet fuel to get off the runway. But in a way, the people I talk to today, they don't really care about that today. It's like, what are you gonna do tomorrow?
58:54 Harry Stebbings? Tell me, my friend, what's the biggest miss? And how did it change your mindset?
58:57 Speaker 00 The biggest miss was OpenSea. I had known Nick DiMano for a long time, like Knuckle and Anand. I helped him raise some of his fund and introduce him to tons of LPs because I thought Nick was doing a fabulous job. He's the opposite of a tourist in crypto. Because we were so helpful, he would send all the deals he was doing to us. And he sent us OpenSea three times. Now, I don't know if OpenSea will end up, who knows what it'll be, right? But for a period of time, I had spent time with Devin. I had looked at the numbers. I didn't understand. I just thought it was about gaming. We didn't talk about NFTs earlier. And it was just sitting right in front of me, like, why is this working? I think the last round I looked at was like a 28-post extension. And because I didn't understand it, I just let it go rather than just looking at what was working.
59:39 Harry Stebbings? I think we can overthink things. Sometimes you don't need to understand it. Just go where it's working. Our customers are using and loving.
59:46 Speaker 00 Of course, this was during my Fund 4 vintage, which was littered with mistakes. So there were mistakes of commission that I mentioned, and this was a mistake of omission.
59:54 Harry Stebbings? I don't have any sympathy for you after hearing about Filecoin and HashiCorp. There is zero sympathy. That is...
1:00:00 Speaker 00 You know what's funny, though, is like athletes on the field, I end up, and I'm sure you do too, we end up thinking more about that than HashiCorp.
1:00:08 Harry Stebbings? 100%. I think we should. Yeah, no, I mean, I lost money earlier this year for the first time. And I told one of my LPs, I was like, it should hurt. It really does. If it ever becomes okay to lose money or to miss something, you need to wise up.
1:00:21 Speaker 00 Again, yeah, that goes back to my respect for the dollar.
1:00:24 Harry Stebbings? Penultimate one, my friend. What's the best investment advice you've received?
1:00:28 Speaker 00 Paul Martino, DGD, do good deals. I think the business is that simple. And I think we can complicate it with all sorts of different things. But it all comes down to that.
1:00:37 Harry Stebbings? And that came from Martino?
1:00:39 Speaker 00 Martino.
1:00:39 Harry Stebbings? I love Paul. The man is obsessed with poker. Every time he's in London, it's like, where are you saying? The W near the casino?
1:00:46 Speaker 00 That's where I got these chips, Harry.
1:00:48 Harry Stebbings? I love that.
1:00:49 Speaker 00 All Martino. And so I made these poker chips for shares that we get in companies through acquisitions. So this one, this company where I passed on the seed round in a friend, that was going to be a huge mistake, but we ended up getting, can you see that?
1:01:01 Harry Stebbings? What is it? Rubrik?
1:01:02 Speaker 00 Rubrik. Then there was in Fund One, we had an acquisition to Datadog. And then this is one of my favorites. We own shares in WeWork, but not at the 40 billion price. But I created the poker chips through Martino to show like how random the business can be.
1:01:15 Harry Stebbings? Tell me, my friend, final one. What was the most recent publicly announced investment? And why did you get so excited?
1:01:20 Speaker 00 Wow, we haven't been a part of publicly announced ones recently. I think, oh, in part, Security, which is a team that left Signal Sciences, that was doing a new way of collaboration across security teams. And we like this idea of collaboration. But again, it was a bet on the people, right? And so they may take it in a different direction. But we just thought they had a mastery of product. They weren't trying to raise too much money. They were the entrepreneurs we like to work with, which is they use us for very specific advice. And then they sort of move accordingly and they reference really well. So we're really excited about that category overall and just working with the in part team.
1:01:54 Harry Stebbings? Samuel, I love you. I love this. This was so much fun.
1:01:58 Speaker 00 Oh, thank you so much.
1:01:59 Harry Stebbings? Putting up my waywardness, but you're a hero, my friend.
1:02:02 Speaker 00 All right. Well, I hope you enjoyed it. I did as well.
1:02:06 Harry Stebbings? What I hear, that was so much fun, Stu. If you want to see more from us, you can check out our YouTube channel by searching 20VC. You can go to 20vc.com to see more. But before we leave you today, Harvard Management Company is constantly seeking out the next generation of great investors and entrepreneurs. HMC has managed Harvard University's endowment for nearly 50 years and was one of the first institutional investors in venture capital. Their experience and long-term investment horizon make some ideal partners to get world-changing ideas on a path to viability and success. They work as a true partner, providing insightful perspectives to help managers succeed. I personally have had the pleasure of working with the HMC team and can say that they are truly exceptional partners and
1:02:48 Harry Stebbings? Savvy investors, whether you are launching your first fund or your fifth, HMC welcomes the opportunity to partner with both developing and established managers. Have an idea you want to share with the team? Just send it to [email protected] . And speaking of amazing partners with HMC there, Mercury is building full stack banking for startups. Apply in under 10 minutes from anywhere for FDIC insured bank accounts, physical and virtual debit cards, domestic and international wires, and integrations with Gusto, Stripe, QuickBooks, Plaid, basically every other tool your startup uses. They also offer unusual features like API access, custom team management, and their newly launched Mercury Treasury, a cash management product for high-growth startups.
1:03:32 Harry Stebbings? And they'll even help you build your startup with Mercury Raise, which is so cool. It's a program to connect you to Silicon Valley's top investors. Head to mercury.com/signup to apply. And finally, Market X. Market X provides investors with a streamlined platform to access, evaluate, and exit global growth stage to pre-IPO technology companies. Plus, Market X allows you to learn from global experts and get intimate interviews with startup executives behind the companies you're investing in. Their track record includes the likes of ByteDance, Airbnb, SpaceX, and many more incredible companies around the world. In addition, Market X enables individual investors and private fund managers to create their own syndicates, helping every investor to become a professional VC.
1:04:15 Harry Stebbings? And since their inception, Market X has covered over 300 pre-IPO companies and have worked with more than 50 growth to late-stage portfolio companies. In 2021, they had five IPOs and acquisitions alone. Visit marketxventures.com and check out their YouTube channel, Market X Ventures. But that is enough from me, so thank you so much. We have an incredible episode for you on Wednesday, and I hope you love the show. Stay with Semil.
Previous 20VC Rising Star: Why Founders Should Expect More From Their VCs | How To Know Pre-Investment Whether a VC Will Be Valuable and How to Get the Most Value Out of Them | Is There a Misalignment Between Founders and VCs with Oana Olteanu, Partner @ SignalFir Next 20VC: Why Operating Experience Becomes Irrelevant Fast and Operators Often Give Bad Advice to Founders, Is Silicon Valley Really Dead? Are Gen Z the Most Entitled Employees? What Will Happen to a Generation of Pre-PMF Companies with $50M in the Bank with Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated