Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: Ryan Caldbeck on Why The Business Model of VC is Broken, Who is To Blame, How The Best Funds Will Use Data Intelligently Moving Forward & Whether We Are In A Consumer Bubble Or Not? About this episode Ryan Caldbeck is the Founder & CEO @ CircleUp, the startup creating a transparent and efficient market to drive innovation for consumer brands. To date, Ryan has raised over $50m with CircleUp from some friends and prior guests of the show including USV, Collaborative Fund and Canaan Partners just to name a few. Prior to CircleUp, Ryan spent nearly 7 years investing in consumer products with the likes of TSG Consumer Partners and Encore Consumer Capital. As a result of Ryan's success with CircleUp he has been recognised as a "Titan of Retail" by Bloomberg and "40 Under 40" by the San Francisco Business Times. In Today’s Episode You Will Learn: 1.) How Ryan made his way into the world of consumer investing and what the realisation moment was for him that the market needed a solution, CircleUp? 2.) Why does Ryan believe that venture capital has a fundamental problem? What is it about the economics of funds that Ryan has a problem with? Who is to blame for this situation; the LPs who fund it or the AUM hungry VCs? Why does Ryan believe the majority of micro VCs are micro as that is all they could raise? Is that really fair or true? 3.) Why does Ryan fundamentally believe the LP ecosystem and mechanism for backing funds is inherently broken? What is so wrong with current LP incentives? What does Ryan believe can be done to encourage more risk-taking and innovation from within the LP class? 4.) Recognising the antiquated nature of much of VC, what does Ryan believe the future of VC looks like? How will we see the use of data impact both sourcing and investment decision-making? Where does Ryan believe it has the most potential? Where is data so sparse that it will be challenging? How does Ryan believe the best managers of the future will use data? 5.) Consumer brands and DNVBs are riding high today, does Ryan believe we are in a consumer bubble? What does Ryan believe is so wrong about how the majority of the current crop of VCs analyse consumer businesses? How should they be analysed? Why does Ryan believe consumer exits will be smaller? Is it fair to say consumer is more capital intensive and largely sells for 1.6-1.8 EBITDA? Items Mentioned In Today’s Show: Ryan’s Fave Book: The Hard Thing About Hard Things As always you can follow Harry, The Twenty Minute VC and Ryan on Twitter here! Likewise, you can follow Harry on Instagram here for mojito madness and all things 20VC.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Harry Stebbings? You are listening to the 20 Minute VC and Founders Friday with me, Harry Stebbings, at H Stebbings 1996 with two Bs on Instagram. But why am I so excited for our episode today? Well, you know how you can be notified when a certain individual tweets on Twitter? Well, I have that enabled for only two people: my partner Fred Desta, at F Destin, and then our guest today, I think one of the best there is on Twitter, and you guessed it, I'm thrilled to welcome back on the show Ryan Caldbeck, founder and CEO at CircleUp, the startup creating a transparent and efficient market to drive innovation for consumer brands. To date, Ryan has raised over $50 million in funding with CircleUp from some friends and prior guests of the show, including USV, Collaborative Fund, and Canaan Partners, just to name a few. And prior to CircleUp, Ryan spent nearly seven years investing in
0:44 Harry Stebbings? consumer products with the likes of TSG Consumer Partners, Encore Consumer Capital, and as a result of Ryan's incredible success with CircleUp, he's been recognised as a Titan of Retail - what a title - by Bloomberg, and 40 Under 40 by the San Francisco Business Times. But before we dive into the very special episode we have with Ryan, and I want to spend a minute to talk about Brex, the first corporate card for startups. Brex founders Enrique and Pedro built a payments business in Brazil, but found themselves rejected for a corporate card when they were in Y Combinator. They decided to build Brex with instant online signup, no founder liability required, and limits 10 to 20 times higher than standard cards. Pretty incredible, I know. And you can sign up for Brex today and get fees waived by entering the code HARRY during signup.
1:27 Harry Stebbings? Honestly, it really is such a special service. And with Brex in place, we now need a team to really use the cards, and that's where Terminal comes in. Terminal is a startup that appreciates hiring amazing developers is really hard, plus it's even harder if you're only looking in a 25 mile radius of your office. So Terminal is your dedicated partner in rapidly standing up world-class remote technical teams. How do they deliver both speed and quality? Well, Terminal does this by focusing on everything necessary to successfully source, set up, and support these teams. From physical elements like beautiful workspaces and equipment, to ongoing resources like HR, payroll, legal, professional learning and development. But don't take my word for this. Take the word of Eventbrite, former 20 VC guest Hims, and DialPad, all of whom customers and
2:10 Harry Stebbings? Lovers of Terminal and you can find out more today at terminal.io. Finally, we now have the team in place. So as a founder or operator, your next crucial job is people operations. That could be hiring execs, developing managers, retaining that top talent and building a high performing culture. And that's where Lattice comes in. Lattice is the number one people management solution for growing companies, helping the likes of Asana, Reddit and Cruise build a really strong company culture. And with Lattice, it's easy to launch 360 reviews, share ongoing feedback, facilitate one on ones, set up goal tracking and even run employee engagement surveys. And Lattice is the only solution that combines both performance management and employee engagement. So operators can really make sure top performers are happy. And Lattice is giving away three months of Lattice free to 20 VC listeners.
2:53 Harry Stebbings? Just go to lattice.com/20vc. That's L A T T I C E dot com forward slash two zero VC. Build an award winning culture with Lattice, the number one people management solution. But now it's time for the episode and I really couldn't be more excited to welcome back Ryan Caldwell, founder and CEO at Circle Up.
3:17 Speaker 01 You have now arrived at your destination.
3:20 Harry Stebbings? Ryan, it is such a pleasure to have you back on the show for a very special round two. My word, I have been loving your tweet storms. So this really is such a pleasure. So thank you so much for joining me again today, Ryan.
3:31 Speaker 02 Absolutely. Thank you so much for having me, Harry. I love what you're doing with 20 minute VC.
3:35 Harry Stebbings? Well, you're very, very kind and I so appreciate that. But I'd love to start today with a little bit on you. And for those that maybe didn't get a chance to listen to round one, tell me, when you were a little boy, was it the dream and aspiration career wise to co-found and found Circle Up? And how did that really come about?
3:51 Speaker 02 It definitely was not. To be candid with you, I knew nothing about technology, certainly nothing about investing. I grew up in a small town in Vermont, 2,000 people in the town. And the kind of dream that I had came about when I was about 15, 16 years old. And JetBlue, the airline, moved into Burlington, Vermont, which is the biggest city in Vermont, and started a new route to New York City. And there's a big newspaper article about it. It was a really big deal in that town back in the early 90s. And, you know, for me, There was just something that hit me when I read that article when I was fifteen, sixteen years old in our kitchen in Vermont. And what hit me was, gosh, wouldn't it be amazing to create something that made this many people happy? That concept was what inspired me to try and build something that I thought would help other people to thrive, help other people be
4:36 Speaker 02 happy. And that is what eventually led to Circle Up. But everything else about Circle Up was certainly not part of the vision growing up in Vermont.
4:44 Harry Stebbings? I mean, I absolutely love that lightbulb moment. That really is a cracker. And I love it when you have real clarity to those moments of realization. But I do want to start today, Ryan, with something that deeply troubles me to hear from you, given obviously my love of the wonderful world of venture, which is what you said to me before being, Harry, venture capital has a problem. I mean, such a cliffhanger to leave me on there, Ryan, but I want to start there and almost let you riff here. So what in your eyes are the biggest problems of VC today?
5:09 Speaker 02 So let's dive into what I mean by the issues. First, on little innovation, the way a hundred million dollar fund operates today looks basically identical to the way it operated twenty, twenty-five years ago. You have three to five partners that go around to cocktail events, demo days, trying to network for deal flow, making decisions based on their own heuristics. The second thing that I mean is that there are huge profit pools here. You think of these firms, these VC firms, as little companies that effectively have EBITDA margins of thirty to fifty percent. That effectively means if you raise a hundred, one hundred and twenty-five million dollar fund, and you're one of the co-founders, you're walking away individually with twenty to forty million dollars in five, seven years. That's a heck of a return. To quote Jeff Bezos, your margin is my opportunity. What I
5:54 Speaker 02 think will happen is that innovators are going to attack those profit pools and the lack of innovation. So how are they going to do that? I think they're going to try and give the same product for lower fees. I think that, or I think that they will try and give a different product. And how will they give a different product? They might create funds that specialize in certain geographies or certain industries, or they might create funds that use data in new ways, or they might create funds that help companies post-close like Andrew Horowitz, or perhaps have a distribution angle to help a startup get their brand out there, perhaps through a podcast, as an example. But what we think is that the old Stodgy firms that have kind of rest on their laurels for so long, that'll be hard for them to continue to be successful over the long term.
6:37 Harry Stebbings? I mean, I couldn't agree with you more there in terms of certain cases of kind of AUM hungry VCs. But before we kind of discuss maybe some of the solutions in more depth, I'm interested in terms of accountability. Is this solely the fault of the AUM hungry managers? Or does one blame the LPs and the LP mechanism for allowing this behaviour to occur and really supporting it with their dollars?
6:58 Speaker 02 Perhaps. I mean, it definitely takes two to tango here. In terms of the LPs, there are some who have the courage and capacity to try something new. Those are the LPs that will thrive. Also, an old expression in investing from many decades ago that said, I don't get fired for investing into IBM. The 2018 equivalent of I don't get fired for investing into IBM is I don't get fired for investing into this old stodgy VC firm. That's kind of lost its way, but the brand has been around for 30 years, right? So we can both think of some firms that even recently are kind of blowing up, haven't seen any innovation, returns have gone down for them year after year. But LPs are scared that if they take a chance, they might get fired. Playing it safe means sometimes going with old brands.
7:42 Speaker 02 And so from that perspective, I think that the LPs are partly to blame.
7:46 Harry Stebbings? It's an interesting mechanism because it's kind of inherently flawed in the way that I spoke to an LP the other day. And he said, Harry, I'm unwaveringly confident in your ability to do a fireback snap. But also there's a higher chance of this not working out and this fund not having that sustainability than in a stodgy old firm. So I will have moved on from my current position in five years. So if I invest in a stodgy ex-firm, at least no one will know. And if I invest in you and it doesn't work, someone will know. Do you think the LP mechanism is broken?
8:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, so that's exactly right. And by the way, that quote is an identical quote to what we hear in other large, stodgy industries that have had very little innovation. And people are just trying to keep their job. That is the risk. And so how do you change that behaviour? Well, I think you have to start with changing incentives. Right now, many, not all, but many of the LPs, their compensation is almost entirely salary. The bonus based on performance doesn't. Really move the needle for them that much. Think of industries where it's almost all salary based. You try to keep your job. That's it. And so how do you keep your job? Yeah, you invest into old stodgy businesses that are going to be safe. And that's fine. There's a portion of LP capital that should be kind of just safe.
8:56 Speaker 02 But alternative assets are higher risk and LPs need to lean into that risk. If they're looking for the returns that have historically come from alternative assets.
9:06 Harry Stebbings? I couldn't agree with you more in terms of kind of leaning into the risk. We mentioned some of the ways that people can innovate there. I'm interested by one in particular, which is kind of the integration of data. How do you foresee maybe the integration of data into VC workflows? And why do you think it maybe has most potential?
9:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's actually a Wall Street Journal article in the past week about private investors using data more. We think that's the future, like to be for disclosure, we're an investment firm powered by technology. And the technology finds evaluates companies. So clearly I'm biased. But that bias comes because I bet my career that that was the future of private investing. I think data and tech will be used to find and evaluate companies and to help them post close in the private markets. I think that that trend will start outside of early stage tech and outside of Silicon Valley. So it'll start first in an industry where there's a ton of data and where business models are largely the same. So what I mean is in tech, the business models are wildly different.
10:03 Speaker 02 There's also not a lot of data, particularly for early stage tech companies. You're often dealing with a CS major from Stanford who's got a 15 page PowerPoint deck and you gotta make a bet. That's a hard place to use a lot of data. Unless the data is effectively like correlation ventures, you're just making a bet on who else is in the round. That's fine, but that's not really what I'm talking about. This will start also in industries, geographies, asset classes where there's a problem to be solved. So I'm thinking of areas outside of Silicon Valley. Silicon Valley, there's no secret on who the investors are and who the best companies are. But you can imagine that there may be in other geographies, whether it's Indiana or Mumbai, where it's harder for investors and companies to connect efficiently.
10:45 Speaker 02 Then, so first, you know, you've got that problem to be solved and then you think about, okay, where Where can we get the data in private equity? There's a lot of data in another industry like consumer products. There's a tremendous amount of data. So those are the areas where I think that data and technology will disrupt the workflow first. Over time, we do think that the concept of private investing based solely on human heuristics, that will die off over time. But it'll start first in industries where there's a problem to be solved, where there's a lot of data and business models are largely the same.
11:13 Harry Stebbings? I have a big question for you here on the data and the sourcing element towards data. Is that data, generally speaking, doesn't fundamentally understand nuance and ambiguity, and in a lot of cases anomalies. If one looks at the likes of the Collison brothers coming out of a small town in Ireland with no Stanford degrees behind them, no Google experience behind them. The pattern recognition from the data wouldn't suggest that they would create a $10 billion company. How does one think about ambiguity and nuance hindering the effects and impact of data when there is little data anyway?
11:43 Speaker 02 And you just hit on one of my core issues with doing this in early-stage tech. I just struggled to see how data could be used to have predicted Uber in 2009, 2010. There was never an Uber before that, or Stripe as the example, or whatever it is. Even in industries where, if you look at Facebook, there was MySpace before that, or before Google, there was a couple other search engines. There weren't 500, there weren't 1,000 other examples where there's enough training data to train models to understand what success looks like. There might be two or four. That's a reason why I really struggle to understand how this could be successful in tech. But in other industries, it is working really, really well. So consumer and retail as an example, when the next restaurant hits,
12:25 Speaker 02 there's 1,000 other examples of restaurant companies that have been successful. You know, when the Halo Top Ice Cream, which is now a couple hundred million dollar revenue company, hit, there was already examples of food and more specifically ice cream companies that have been successful. That allows us to build models to predict their success much more effectively than at least I can envision on how to do it in tech. I never want to say never. I certainly don't want to be quoted in the future as not having seen the vision, but I struggle to see how it is applicable in early-stage tech in the near future.
12:55 Harry Stebbings? No, I completely agree with you on that struggle. And the next element though, Ryan, that you know I'm caveating here. You know I love you and I think the world of you and Circle Up. But this next one made me interestingly irate. Which is when I saw on Twitter, you tweeted micro VC funds and the element of them having small funds because they just can't raise bigger. And I immediately thought to the likes of floodgate, baseline, founder collective, the multitude of examples that suggest stellar returns. And actually, that's just not true. How do you think about and explain that one?
13:29 Speaker 02 First of all, there's a lot of studies that suggest that returns go down as funds get larger in EU. There's a ton of studies that show that. The other thing I would say is what I have typically seen is that a fund will start, let's call it a 500 million dollar fund, it'll do really well, then we'll raise a much larger fund and it'll keep moving up market. And the reason they move up market is that the fees for larger funds always outweigh the performance of smaller funds. The people running these funds have incentives to raise larger funds. There are exceptions. And you've mentioned a couple of exceptions. In I tweet storm, I mentioned some others. Union Square Ventures, Benchmark, or some other exceptions to what I said. There are absolutely investors out there that want
14:11 Speaker 02 to stick to their knitting and stick focused on smaller funds where they know that the performance has been fantastic, work with entrepreneurs in a certain stage. And I think that's terrific. But by and large, I also see a general trend towards investment managers trying to raise larger funds to collect those fees.
14:30 Harry Stebbings? No, I agree with you. And I couldn't debate that one because it is true, but there is still a subset. I completely agree. We did mention, though, in the consumer discussion, the element of data and how it's applied to consumers. So I do want to touch on consumer because as you know, from listening to the show, Ryan, I'm a complete nerd when it comes to all things brand and DNVBs and consumer more broadly. With that in mind, though, we've seen this explosion of VC investment into the space. Starting at the top, I have to ask, are we in a consumer bubble today, Ryan?
14:58 Speaker 02 Yeah. So what I have seen that worries me a bit is VCs that don't have a background in consumer, trying to get into consumer and not having the discipline, due diligence to those companies. As consumer businesses. What I'm seeing a lot of is tech VC firms putting a ton of money into companies in the consumer space that should be very capital efficient, that should be able to be successful and get profitability without raising a lot of money, but will also have smaller exits candidly than a typical tech VC firm. And that's what's key. So we see a VC firm that candidly doesn't know what they're doing, give a mayonnaise company a hundred million dollars. That terrifies me. That mayonnaise company shouldn't raise a hundred million dollars.
15:43 Speaker 02 Candidly, they shouldn't raise ten. These companies in the consumer space, they tend to get to profitability by raising four to eight million dollars, not fifty to eighty million dollars as they do in the tech space. Consumer companies are more capital efficient on average than tech companies are. But the problem is when you have a tech investor that wants to write really big checks, often because they work for a large firm, just that's because that's what they're used to. They then over capitalize a company. The other thing that happens is they put a huge valuation on it. We saw that with Honest Company. Where Honest Company is a good company, it just got stuck in a post-money trap. It got passed over for acquisition and now is in a little bit of a recapitalization mode with Caterton because it raised too much at far too high of a valuation.
16:25 Speaker 02 So I think we've got an industry in consumer, there's a lot to love, but I think tech VC firms need to be very cautious to diligence these companies and to investment these companies in a different way than they're used to doing in the tech space.
16:39 Harry Stebbings? I have to ask, you said post-money trap there. What do you mean by post-money trap? And how do you kind of see that one playing out? And how should founders think about that?
16:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, so in the in the tech world, oftentimes, not always, but oftentimes a tech VC can believe if I bet on the right winner, it'll own eighty percent of the market. If it owns eighty percent of the market, that means the valuation and exit will be huge. A billion, ten billion, it'll be a big number. In consumer, tastes are fragmented. Tastes have been fragmenting because of personal preferences, because barriers to entry have declined. As tastes fragment, the winners are smaller. If the winners are smaller, the exits are smaller. If the exits are smaller. You can still make money, but you have to be disciplined when you come into the business. The valuations you use on the in need to be reasonable. And that's not what we're seeing from tech VC firms.
17:32 Speaker 02 From tech VC firms, and we're seeing the Manny's company with a $900 million valuation and $15 million revenue. That math doesn't make any sense. It's offensive. They're not going to have a successful exit. They will have an exit at some point, but it'll be a massive down round. And so what we think needs to happen if investors play in this space, they need to find ways to systematically deploy capital across a lot of companies at earlier stage, a lower valuation. Then these companies don't raise as much money. The exits are still really healthy. You can invest a 10, sell it for 100. That's a great exit, as long as you can invest in a bunch of them and deploy it systematically.
18:05 Harry Stebbings? Do you really think there's a VC business there then? Because having that reliability of having several hundreds is extremely tough. And having a couple of hundred exits in most cases for funds simply isn't enough.
18:17 Speaker 02 Some very, very smart people disagree with me, and there's some smart people that agree with me. It's a kind of controversial point, but I absolutely think that there is a huge investing business. Now, you had a key word there, which is VC, right? Like, I don't think that the investing market in consumer will look like what it does in Silicon Valley or other tech hubs. It'll look very different in consumer. In consumer, you need to find a way to deploy $1 to $5 million into each of a lot of companies. That's the answer. You can't be looking to invest $50, $75 million into an early-stage consumer product company. You're going to get just killed for that because the exits won't be big enough to justify that capital or the valuation that is implied by that capital. So how does that happen?
19:02 Speaker 02 Well, we think it's a different model, candidly. We think it's a model of developing systematic approach to private investing. So if you're familiar at all in the public markets with AQR, Two Sigma, Renaissance Technologies, any of the public quant funds, we think that is the solution in the private markets to being able to invest into a lot of these companies with little relatively smaller checks than what you typically see in tech private investment.
19:26 Harry Stebbings? So if I push back on one element towards the raising too much and the dangers of doing so. I speak to many consumer founders and they go, sure, I get you on capital efficiency, Harry, but we don't have free and open distribution today. And I have to compete with the incumbents of this universe to acquire customers on insane cost customer acquisition channels. How do you respond to this? And how do you think about that lack of free and open distribution today?
19:51 Speaker 02 So, look, I think what we're really talking about in that question is in part, there's kind of two main channels. There's online and then there's offline. And what we see in the offline world is a flood towards innovation. Retailers are desperate to bring innovation on their shelves. That was not true 10 years ago. Those barriers to entry have declined dramatically. What used to be called slotting fees have declined dramatically, meaning you used to have to pay $800,000 to get it on the shelf of a retailer here in the US. That has changed in many instances. The reason is that retailers, online and offline, recognize that if you're only competing on price, you're going to get killed by Walmart, by Amazon. It's really hard to do that.
20:33 Speaker 02 You need to deliver value to the consumer in another way, possibly through innovation. Innovation isn't coming from the large CBG companies because they don't spend anything on R and D. It's coming from the small ones, so they're all looking for that innovation. Now, a different part of your question was around the cost, effectively it was around the cost to distribute products online. This is another area where I think tech VCs get it very wrong. Most tech VC firms look at D to C, direct to consumer, as a way to scale a business efficiently. That is completely wrong. It is not a channel to scale a business. It is certainly not a channel to scale a business efficiently. D to C is a great channel to test new products because you can cycle through products much more easily than you can in the offline world.
21:15 Speaker 02 But if you think of most D to C, not all, but most D to C companies, they've had to raise a ton of money because getting customers to their D to C website is very expensive. It turns out that almost every D to C company eventually realizes when they get to 50, 100 million revenue, gosh, we've got to start building our own stores or, you know, selling these products offline because the online channels are just too expensive. And that's not intuitive to a lot of tech investors because they don't spend time in the market. So I think- That the avenues available for small innovative companies to scale their business are more present, more open today than they ever have been in history. It is an amazing time to be a consumer entrepreneur and to be a consumer investor. But it takes an understanding of what this market really is.
21:58 Speaker 02 This market is not just a D to C market. It is an omnichannel market. You need to be able to understand how to scale a business offline and online and what each channel is good for.
22:08 Harry Stebbings? I couldn't agree more in terms of that sustainability of channel and being aware of kind of the mortality of channel. I did have a VC on the show the other day that went against the tide of many VCs chasing consumers saying, man, it's just not interesting. It's CapEx intensive, it's low contribution margin. And after all of that, you sell it for 1.6 EBIT. How would you respond to that, Ryan?
22:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's interesting. There's a couple of points in there. I think first, when we say it's capital intensive, I'd love to come on the show with that guest and maybe we could have a fun debate together. But on the capital intensive point, what I'd probably ask about is where that data comes from. When you look at the history of tech companies, tech companies raise on average more than $50 million to get to profitability. Consumer companies raise on average about $5 million to get to profitability. Full stop, that's a pretty powerful point. Tech companies have their manufacturing plant in-house. And this isn't a politically correct thing to say, but that is what the engineers, product managers, data scientists are built. They are building a product. In consumer, you outsource that.
23:14 Speaker 02 Very, very rarely do you own your own manufacturing plant. Typically, you outsource it. I'll give you an example. Skinny Pop popcorn had raised $500,000 in total to get to $80 million in revenue. Halo Top has raised less than $2 million to get to a couple hundred million dollars in revenue for that ice cream company. RX Bar, a snack bar, raised $10,000 to sell for $600 million to Kellogg's. Those are pretty powerful examples. I don't think we'll ever have an Uber that will have an exit for 50 to 100 billion. But conversely, you'll never find a consumer product company that needs to raise a billion dollars. That's the CapEx point. The low contribution margin point. To be candid with you is really just an accounting point. And what I mean is typically tech investors look at gross margin and say, we've got a high
23:59 Speaker 02 contribution margin product. They don't include the manufacturing plant. So they exclude the salaries of their engineers, data scientists, et cetera, which make tech companies very low margin or cash negative businesses. In consumer, the manufacturing plant is included in COGS. At the end of the day, consumer companies have higher net margins and are more profitable than tech companies. That's why they need to raise less money. In terms of the valuation point, I think that that's actually right. Consumer companies tend to go for a lower valuation. The valuations of consumer companies also tend to fluctuate much less. The standard deviation of consumer company valuations is dramatically lower than the standard deviation of tech valuations. And if you look over the last 15 years, tech valuations tend to follow the economy pretty directly. So what you're really doing in tech investing often is you're trying to time the market
24:45 Speaker 02 in terms of your valuation. That's why we see an overall downturn in the market in tech. People pull back in tech investing. They don't pull back in consumer investing. It's always pretty darn steady. It churns out people eat regardless of what's happening in the market. So that's what I'd say, but I'd love to have that debate publicly because it's a fun one.
25:02 Harry Stebbings? Well, I will certainly put it to him and see what he says. Should be an interesting response. But I do want to dive on one more topic before we go into the quick fire round, Ryan. So I want to start on some of the lessons learned from the circle up journey and touch on maybe some of the mistakes that caused those learnings. If we begin on fundraising, talk to me, what was some of the early fundraising mistakes and lessons for you?
25:23 Speaker 02 The fundraising lessons learned? Yeah, I've learned a lot, to be frank. I mean, I've learned about how necessary it is to have a CEO make an intro to you. I've learned about how important it is to make sure that your story is tight when you're talking to an investor. I think though that probably the most important thing I've learned in terms of fundraising is to make sure that investors are aligned with your vision, your mission and your values. By and large, I think we've done a really good job of that. We have made mistakes before, though, and those mistakes are really, really painful when they happen. I think there's a lot of fundraising advice out there around the decks, et cetera, but the most important thing I've learned is just getting alignment over that vision, mission and values.
26:05 Harry Stebbings? Couldn't agree more in terms of that alignment. And the alignment, as you tweeted, before the investment and to really stress test that, I think is important. Once the funds are raised, you can build your team with the capital. You've built an exceptional team with Circle Up, but in that process, what lessons did you learn in kind of team assembly? And how do you think the best CEOs really build the best teams?
26:26 Speaker 02 So I think I'm a big believer that CEOs can be great with a lot of different approaches. So first of all, I don't know if we're doing a great job, to be candid with you. I mean, the story is not yet complete on Circle Up. We try really hard. I think we've got really smart, high ethical, hardworking folks. We've got a lot to build here. So I'll tell you what we've done. I think that they've worked pretty well for us, but this is the type of topic where a lot of people did a lot of different approaches. I believe in frameworks. I think frameworks help teams row in the same direction and they help empower team members to run, to not feel micromanaged, to understand what the sandbox is they should be playing in and to go build.
27:08 Speaker 02 I think a mission can be a framework, a mission that is clearly stated. I think a set of values is a framework. I think OKRs, objective and key results, are frameworks. One of the things that we learned really early on that's important in terms of building your team is creating a framework on what to look for in hiring. We at Circle Up look for five things. We look for work ethic, integrity, intelligence, pride in what you do and teamwork. Those are the five things we look for. And because everyone here is aligned on what we look for, when the founders, myself and my co-founder Rory, are not in a meeting, are not in an interview panel, the other folks know what we're looking for. And that helps us get folks in that are all aligned
27:51 Speaker 02 with our culture. I tend to find the concept of, oh, that person's just not a cultural fit, to be a really bad estimate of when that Successful. I've got great friends that wouldn't be a fit here at Circle Up and I've had amazing teammates here at Circle Up that may not be the person that I'm hanging out with on a Saturday. But they are amazing teammates and to find the amazing teammates, we found it to be important to align on that framework.
28:14 Harry Stebbings? I love the kind of focus on framework there and I haven't heard that kind of quite so explicitly stated before. But I would love to ask, maybe when the framework doesn't work out and there's questions around a potential individual, how do you determine when a stretch VP is really a stretch to fall?
28:29 Speaker 02 Well, it's an interesting question. I got advice, I'm sure probably everyone has, that when you're thinking about whether or not to let someone go, to fire someone, the decision's already made. And that point is absolutely true. When you're having that consideration in your head, it has gone far enough and you need to just make the decision. So there's different symbols of that. Certainly someone who breaks our values, the values that we have here at Circle Up and we have them clearly laid out actually literally on our wall. That's a nonstarter. Then it comes down to impact, impact in a way that is consistent with our mission and vision. And so we work very clearly to define objective key results for everyone on the team so that they know what are we asking them to contribute?
29:13 Speaker 02 If they're contributing it in a way that is consistent with our values, with our mission and vision, then they're doing a great job. If they're not, then we need to have a conversation about whether or not it can improve and if it can't, we need to part ways. But one of the benefits of using these frameworks is that it helps to take out personal bias. It helps to take out not all, but a lot of the ambiguity that typically comes with those performance decisions, both in hiring and in letting someone go.
29:37 Harry Stebbings? I do have to ask, Ryan, I want to move into a quick fire round now. It's, as you know, I'm sure, my favorite element of any interview itself. So I say a short statement and then you give me your immediate thoughts. Does that sound good?
29:48 Speaker 02 That sounds great. Let's do it.
29:50 Harry Stebbings? So your favorite book and why? What must I be reading?
29:52 Speaker 02 The Hard Things About Hard Things. Ben Horowitz just did an amazing job of laying out what a entrepreneur's journey is actually like without any kind of fluff or polish.
30:04 Harry Stebbings? Why will Amazon lose to Instacart for grocery delivery?
30:07 Speaker 02 Offline retailers need Instacart to work. Amazon is too much of a threat. Instacart is closer to a partner.
30:15 Harry Stebbings? Love it. If you had to make a career decision, who would you call for advice?
30:18 Speaker 02 My dad. He has always been an amazing guiding light for me and making decisions based off of my values and kind of thinking about what'll be good for me and my family for the long term.
30:30 Harry Stebbings? We mentioned the insane amount of companies that've got huge, huge funding reserves in the consumer space. What happens to all of them? Is it a graveyard?
30:38 Speaker 02 Consumer companies, typically it'll be a graveyard. There'll be some exceptions. Unilever Bots, Dollar Shave Club, because they needed the capabilities of D to C. That'll happen a few more times, but many times they will be sold for half of the last round valuation.
30:52 Harry Stebbings? Preference stack. What should most founders know?
30:55 Speaker 02 When you raise a lot of money, it requires you to have a bigger exit. That narrows your possibilities for outcomes and it looks more like you're threading a needle. When you only raise a little bit of money, you and your investors can make a lot of money by having a smaller exit.
31:11 Harry Stebbings? What common advice do you hear that you most disagree with, Ryan?
31:15 Speaker 02 Common advice that I either hear implicitly or explicitly is around trying to go to cocktail events and network with other CEOs, other intermediaries, et cetera. Basically burning the candle at both ends. I'm a big believer in sleep, to be candid with you. And I think I think I am better and a lot of entrepreneurs that I know are better when they're actually able to get eight hours of sleep.
31:37 Harry Stebbings? Next five years for you and the exciting roadmap ahead. What is it, Ryan, other than mojitos with me?
31:43 Speaker 02 We're building a technology that will find and evaluate private companies in the consumer space. And what we'll do next year is build a systematic private VC fund. Systematic, meaning it will find and evaluate companies based off of data in the private markets. And that's never been done before.
32:00 Harry Stebbings? I mean, such exciting times ahead, Ryan. You know how I feel about you and Circle Up. So really, thank you so much for joining me again today and it's been such a pleasure.
32:07 Speaker 02 Thank you again so much, Ari. It was an honor.
32:11 Harry Stebbings? Now, if you only do one thing after listening to that episode with Ryan, go and follow him on Twitter. Do it now. It's at Ryan underscore called Beck. That's at Ryan underscore called Beck. As I said, it really is my favourite account to follow. Always so much great information there. Likewise, we'd love to welcome you behind the scenes here. You can do that on Instagram at H Stebbings 1996 with two Bs. I really would love to see you there. But before we leave you today, and I want to spend a minute to talk about Brex, the first corporate card for startups. Brex founders Enrique and Pedro built a payments business in Brazil, but found themselves rejected for a corporate card when they were in Y Combinator. They decided to build Brex with instant online signup, no founder liability required, and limits 10 to 20 times higher than standard cards. Pretty incredible,
32:52 Harry Stebbings? I know. And you can sign up for Brex today and get fees waived by entering the code Harry during signup. Honestly, it really is such a special service. And with Brex in place, we now need a team to really use the cards. And that's where Terminal comes in. Terminal is a startup that appreciates hiring amazing developers is really hard. Plus, it's even harder if you're only looking in a 25 mile radius of your office. So Terminal is your dedicated partner in rapidly standing up world-class remote technical teams. How do they deliver both speed and quality? Well, Terminal does this by focusing on everything necessary to successfully source, set up and support these teams. From physical elements like beautiful workspaces and equipment to ongoing resources like HR, payroll, legal, professional learning and development. But
33:35 Harry Stebbings? don't take my word for this. Take the word of Eventbrite, former 20 VC guest Hims and Dialpad, all of whom customers and lovers of Terminal. And you can find out more today at Terminal.io. Finally, we now have the team in place. So as a founder or operator, your next crucial job is people operations. That could be hiring execs, developing managers, retaining that top talent, and building a high-performing culture. And that's where Lattice comes in. Lattice is the number one people management solution for growing companies, helping the likes of Asana, Reddit and Cruise build a really strong company culture. And with Lattice, it's easy to launch 360 reviews, share ongoing feedback, facilitate one-on-ones, set up goal tracking, and even run employee engagement surveys. And Lattice is the only solution that combines both performance management and employee engagement, so operators can really make sure top
34:20 Harry Stebbings? Performers are happy and Lattice is giving away three months of Lattice free to 20 VC listeners. Just go to lattice.com/20vc. That's L A T T I C E dot com forward slash two zero VC. Build an award-winning culture with Lattice, the number one people management solution. As always, I cannot thank you enough for your support. Really, it means so much to me and I cannot wait to bring you a fantastic set of episodes next week.
Previous 20VC: The 2 Core Roles Played By The Best Seed Investors Today, What To Look For In Potential Co-Investors & Why Seed Funds Can Grow Ownership in Their Best Companies Across Rounds with Ron Bouganim, Founder @ Govtech Fund Next 20VC: Why The Engineer Will Replace The MBA As CEO, Why The Peace Dividends From The Autonomous Car Wars Will Generate More Value Outside of Transport & Why Old and Boring Industries Are The Most Exciting To Build In with Avidan Ross, Founding Partner @ R Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated