Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: Index's Danny Rimer on Investing Lessons from Hits like Figma, Discord and Etsy to Missing Snapchat, Airbnb, Facebook & Spotify | Why Valuation is a Trap and Market Sizing, Signalling and Sector/Geo-Specific Funds are all Noise About this episode Danny Rimer is a Partner @ Index Ventures and one of the most prominent VCs of the last two decades. Danny has led Index to be one of the top global firms on both sides of the Atlantic. Among Danny's incredible portfolio, he has led or been involved with Figma, Discord, Dream Games, Etsy, Glossier and Patreon. In Today's Discussion with Danny Rimer We Cover: 1. The Biggest Lessons from Missing Snap, Airbnb, Spotify and Facebook: How did Danny miss investing in Brian Chesky and Airbnb when Brian says "Index is the best investor that Airbnb never had"? What was Danny's biggest takeaway from turning down Daniel Ek and Spotify multiple times? Why did Danny turn down the chance to invest in Facebook at $10BN? What did he learn from this? Why did Index not lead Snapchat's Series B? How did that decision change Danny's mindset towards the concentration of positions in a fund? 2. The Biggest BS Rules in Venture: Market Sizing, Valuations and Signalling Why does Danny believe that "valuation is a mental trap"? Why does Danny believe that TAM is "noise" and should not be used to assess an investment? Why does Danny believe that stage, sector and geo-specific funds are BS? Why does Danny believe there are no IPO windows? Are IPO markets always open to the best? Why does Danny believe that signalling is BS and does not exist today? 3. Lessons from the Biggest Wins and Losses: What are Danny's biggest lessons from Index's $BN win in King (Candy Crush)? How did the Discord deal come to be? What are Danny's biggest takeaways from it? What are Danny's biggest reflections from losing 10s of millions on Nasty Gal? What is Danny's biggest advice to a new investor today? 4. Lessons from Two Decades Building Index into a Premier Firm: What specifically has Index done to enable them to do what no one else has done and win on both sides of the Atlantic? How did the Benchmark partnership shape much of how Danny has constructed Index today? Who does Danny view as Index's biggest competition? How has it changed with time? Why is Danny more bullish than ever on the UK despite Brexit?
Transcript 13,689 words · 2 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 The main thing is to keep the main thing the main thing. If the person's extraordinary, throw all theses out the window and just back the founder. One of our tenants is definitely that market-sized TAM is noise. I do believe that the best companies at that stage when they are ready to go public can go public in any market. I'm not a huge fan of sector funds. With sectors, you're not looking for the best companies, you're looking for the best company in that sector. Most companies create brands as a byproduct of a great product. So scarcity and brand really go hand in hand.
0:32 Harry Stebbings? Welcome to 20 VC with me, Harry Stebbings. And today's show is the type of show that makes me feel so lucky to do what I do. I always say I'm a student of venture, I'm building a firm and I should learn from the best in the world who've done it, seen what I'm going through and know how to execute. And so I could have no better guest than ours today. Danny Rimer, partner at Index and one of the venture greats of the last 20 years. At Index, he's led or been part of deals into Figma, Dream Games, Discord, Etsy, Glossier and many more. He's also a friend and has been an incredible supporter of 20 VC over the last decade. And so I want to say a huge thanks to him for his support and kindness over the last 10 years. But before we dive into the show today, we're all trying to grow our businesses here. So let's be real for a second.
1:17 Harry Stebbings? We all know that your website shouldn't be this static asset. It should be a dynamic part of your strategy that really drives conversions. That's marketing 101. But here's a number for you. 54% of leaders say web updates take too long. That's over half of you listening right now. And that's where Webflow comes in. Their visual-first platform allows you to build, launch and manage web experiences fast. That means you can set ambitious marketing goals and your site can rise to the challenge. Plus, Webflow allows your marketing team to scale without relying on engineering, freeing your dev team to focus on more fulfilling work. Learn why teams like Dropbox, IDEO and Orange Theory trust Webflow
1:59 Harry Stebbings? to achieve their most ambitious goals today at webflow.com. And speaking of incredible products that allows your team to do more, we need to talk about SecureFrame. frame provides incredible levels of trust to your customers through automation. Secureframe empowers businesses to build trust with customers by simplifying information security and compliance through AI and automation. Thousands of fast-growing businesses, including Nasdaq, Angel List, Doodle and Coder, trust Secureframe to expedite their compliance journey for global security and privacy standards, such as SOC 2, ISO 2701, HIPAA, GDPR and more. Backed by top-tier investors and corporations such as Google, Kleiner Perkins,
2:42 Harry Stebbings? the company is among the Forbes list of top 100 startup employers for 2023 and Business Insider's list of the 34 most promising AI startups of 2023. Learn more today at Secureframe.com. It really is a must. And finally, a company is nothing without its people, and that's why you need Remote.com. Remote is the best choice for companies expanding their global footprint where they don't already have legal entities. So you can effortlessly hire, manage and pay employees from around the world, all from one easy-to-use self-serve platform. Plus, you can streamline global employee management and cut HR costs with Remote's free HRIS. And hey, even if you are not looking for full-time employees,
3:24 Harry Stebbings? Remote has you covered with contractor management, ensuring compliant contracts and on-time payments for global contractors. There's a reason companies like GitLab and DoorDash trust Remote to handle their employees worldwide. Go to Remote.com now to get started and use the promo code 20VC to get 20% off during your first year. Remote: opportunity is wherever you are.
3:47 Speaker 00 You have now arrived at your destination.
3:50 Harry Stebbings? Danny, I am so excited for this. I just said to you beforehand, you know, I'm the luckiest guy ever because I would pay to have discussions like this. And also, you say incredible wisdom and I get the credit for a lot of it. So first, thank you for joining me.
4:01 Speaker 00 Thanks for having me back. You know, it was such a pleasure last time. I can't wait for being under, under this interview process this time.
4:09 Harry Stebbings? You know, I was I was much younger then, but I want to start with a little bit of actual kind of real background context. But when you think back to a 10 year old Danny, how would your parents or teachers have described you?
4:20 Speaker 00 They would have described me as very close to my mom, at my mom's side, very consistently.
4:28 Harry Stebbings? You can always trust a mama's boy.
4:30 Speaker 00 Exactly. So definitely a mama's boy. Already into art. I was definitely already looking at art books and talking about art and trying to learn as much about artists as possible. Hanging out and and watching as many James Bonds as I could.
4:46 Harry Stebbings? Favorite James Bond?
4:47 Speaker 00 You know, they're impossible to watch now. I'm trying to show them to my kids and they are so cancelled, it's absurd.
4:52 Harry Stebbings? Really?
4:53 Speaker 00 But, oh yeah, you can't watch them. But at the time, Goldfinger was was really pretty amazing.
4:58 Harry Stebbings? Sean Connor is my favourite by far. Weird one. Did you know that you would be successful? When you were younger, did you kind of have this inevitability of success?
5:06 Speaker 00 I knew that I was comfortable in being a little different and odd, but I didn't really thinking about it in terms of success. I was just gonna do my own thing. Slightly difficult to do when I had three elder brothers who were really focused on also doing their own thing.
5:23 Harry Stebbings? Did you and do you care what other people think?
5:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, of course. I care about whether or not they can see that I'm as transparent as possible and that I'm staying true to what I subscribe to.
5:37 Harry Stebbings? Does that change with success? That you care less?
5:40 Speaker 00 I think it's important from a personal standpoint to make sure that I follow through on what I'm about. And that I don't want to lose or I don't want to take for granted.
5:50 Harry Stebbings? You had many great influences early on in your career. One was Jim Bartstale. What are one or two of your biggest takeaways from that experience with him and learning from him?
5:58 Speaker 00 I really did get to learn so much from Jim. Two of the most pertinent ones, clearly one is what we've really adopted at Index from the beginning, which is, Danny, the main thing is to keep the main thing the main thing. You know, that has been so important to reflect on repeatedly.
6:16 Harry Stebbings? What was the hardest thing to turn down that was a distraction? It could be a growth fund, it could be an India fund, it could be a deal, it could, what was the hardest thing which you had to say no to, to keep the main thing the main thing?
6:29 Speaker 00 Reflecting back, not jumping on the bandwagon and going to China or India was was actually a really important lesson for us in maintaining our focus. So I would put it up there. I don't know if it's the most important one, but it's absolutely one that I that I remind myself frequently about. What was the second big takeaway? Another one that I talk to my entrepreneurs about all the time, the snake rules. So Jim was an incredible executive. You know, he was the COO of Federal Express during its heyday for 14 years. Then he became the CEO of AT&T, which was Macau Cellular. And then at the beginning of the internet, literally the first company of import was Netscape,
7:09 Speaker 00 probably the OpenAI of its day. And Jim was tapped to become CEO of Netscape. He had the pick of the pack of the smartest young talent joining, and they were running around trying to figure out what Netscape should be. Should it be an enterprise play? Should it be a consumer play? Should it do this partnership with Cisco and get paid? Should it reinvent, you know, the security socket layer and and build a company? Or should it create a new company called Verisign? They had so many people running around with so many opportunities that he was looking around and he was seeing that all these people, all these young folks, a lot of management consultants, a lot of business school folks, were constantly in meetings, constantly reevaluating the same thing. And so he created an all hands.
7:52 Speaker 00 And at the all hands, he said, folks, I grew up in Mississippi, and we have snake rules that are very important. And I want you to think about this. The first one is if you see a snake, you kill it. You don't stick around and look at it. You actually have to kill it because otherwise it's going to kill you. The second one, you don't play with dead snakes. In other words, they might have venom in them, they might still be alive. So as soon as you've killed it, don't play with it. And then he said the third one is all opportunities start up looking like snakes, which really made people scratch their heads. So he's really saying that your job is to make a decision. That's the concept of seeing a snake and killing it. You make a decision. The most important one is don't revisit that
8:37 Speaker 00 decision. Once you've made that decision, once you have commit, you're all in. It's not up for debate. It's not up for folks discussing it or disagreeing with it. Everyone is committed. And then the third one is, I do understand that it's going to be tough to make decisions because they look like opportunities. But your job is to assess them and make a decision.
8:58 Harry Stebbings? Different investing partnerships have different approaches to decision making. Given now the scope of the team and many different personalities, how do you think about the most effective decision making that you've landed on an index? And does that change by check size and stage?
9:12 Speaker 00 We have gone through so many iterations, but we actually landed on something which I probably would say stayed with us for over a decade, which is every investor has a vote. And we have a voting system that goes from one to four and from seven to 10. So you can't do a five or six. And you need a certain threshold of positive votes north of six to get an investment passed through the partnership.
9:40 Harry Stebbings? Do you worry about losing outliers?
9:42 Speaker 00 I think the voting is twofold. The first is to make sure that the partners who are really bringing a deal in have an enormous amount of conviction. So if they're coming in and it's like a seven, you know, it's going to be really difficult unless it's unanimous. Our best decisions, our best investments have always been unanimous. But really, the point is to see whether the partner has so much conviction that they're going to get us to be positive about it. And so the outlier is going to be welcome, but we're going to look at the partner who's bringing it in, the sponsor, to ensure that they really want to do this. They're not sort of saying like, I'm scratching my head. I don't know whether we should do this or not. If that's the case, we'll have a healthy conversation about it and unlikely we'll do it.
10:27 Speaker 00 But if a person comes in and it's crazy and we really are looking for that partner to show how excited they are, that will have a huge amount of influence on us.
10:38 Harry Stebbings? It was interesting, Brian Singerman said actually they deliberately don't have any form of investment committee or any investment meeting because you have to be so desperate to do a deal that you literally have to drag Danny out of the office, drag other people to get it, almost like create friction to doing deals. Because if you really want to do it, you have to really go out of your way to make it happen. Similar in some respects.
10:59 Speaker 00 Yes, absolutely.
11:01 Harry Stebbings? So don't play with dead snakes. What was the hardest decision that you've made that you found yourself revisiting most?
11:07 Speaker 00 There have been a number of opportunities that for a reason or another we passed or we didn't show up in the right way to win the deal. One is Spotify, another one is Snap, another one's Airbnb, another one's LinkedIn. Those are the four that we had real opportunity in some fashion or another to manufacture the opportunity for Index to be in the round. And we failed for different reasons.
11:33 Harry Stebbings? We're going to get to a couple of them, but that is painful in many respects. But I did have a nice chat to Shaq before the show.
11:39 Speaker 00 Okay.
11:40 Harry Stebbings? And he said, you are the person they wanted most, but never got.
11:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:44 Harry Stebbings? And reminded me that you have multiple opportunities.
11:48 Speaker 00 That does not make me feel any better.
11:50 Harry Stebbings? Literally, he was like, we so wanted him.
11:52 Speaker 00 Brian Chesky from Airbnb repeatedly loves to say, Index is the best partner that never invested in the company.
12:02 Harry Stebbings? Bugger. I have some of these relationships with founders that are like, it's like you're an investor, but you're not.
12:07 Speaker 00 Exactly.
12:07 Harry Stebbings? And I'm like, fuck.
12:09 Speaker 00 Exactly. And you regret it every day.
12:11 Harry Stebbings? We mentioned the decision-making process there before when we were chatting. You mentioned to me about the thesis-based approach that you have today.
12:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:17 Harry Stebbings? Can you talk to me about that and what that actually looks like in reality?
12:22 Speaker 00 In the case of Index, it is, it is a story of discipline. And it's a story about manufacturing discipline in as many different ways as possible. And so for us, creating investment theses are a way of making sure that we are building conviction and that we can support the conviction that we have. And so everyone is encouraged to have a major and a minor. When it comes to investment thesis on the major or the minor, it's taking a new approach at looking at a specific area. Whether we're right or wrong is actually less important. It's a way of sifting through opportunities and figuring out. What we're looking for and whether, once we see it, we're going to be able to pounce or not. So having that clarity around the thesis is helpful.
13:07 Harry Stebbings? So what would an example of that be, though?
13:09 Speaker 00 Okay, so an example that I would think about is when we decide that fashion might replace music as a social lubricant. So when I was growing up, you know, I could go to Nairobi and sing a Michael Jackson song and a guy who spoke Swahili would sing the same song and we would bond over that. And then with Spotify, actually, you know, music has become more pervasive, but albums have shifted. The focus on albums is less important. So we were thinking, maybe fashion becomes that lubricant. Maybe people are going to identify and become part of communities around the brands or around the style that they align to.
13:48 Speaker 00 So that led us to Net-a-Porter and then clothing and ASOS and Farfetch'd and Goat and Anina Bing. And so it was really helpful to have this crazy idea about fashion replacing music.
14:02 Harry Stebbings? Are people able to select their major and minor?
14:04 Speaker 00 Yes, absolutely. I mean, we want them to be really passionate about the major and minor, so.
14:09 Harry Stebbings? And then how do they pursue it? I'm interested, I'm building a firm too. So like, how do they pursue it?
14:14 Speaker 00 I've heard that you're building a firm.
14:16 Harry Stebbings? Do they do like, you know, lunch and learn style where they share their knowledge with teams? Or is it more isolated learning and development?
14:23 Speaker 00 It's a combination. I would say that probably you start by doing a lot of work on your own and making sure that you're actually committed to it and that it's going to stand the test of time. And then bring in colleagues and spar with them and bat it around. And then, once it's more mature, then pitch it to the partnership and see if they think this is a helpful thesis in terms of looking at things.
14:49 Harry Stebbings? What's the biggest challenge to having this approach? Like, I always take the view that I can't predict markets and if I could, I'd be a founder. And so I'm open to the creativity and whims of whatever brilliant founder comes in the door. What's the biggest cons of the thesis based approach?
15:04 Speaker 00 Probably being categorical on not backing certain founders that are phenomenal, but don't really fit the thesis.
15:16 Harry Stebbings? And is this not a game of anomalies? You mentioned Spotify. I mean, I think Daniel has been quite open before about saying that he went to series A investors and almost said, you have a CEO replacement because I'm not too keen on this job. Like, the best are often anomalies.
15:29 Speaker 00 Right. No, I agree with you. I mean, I think that in the case of Spotify, for instance, actually, I was able to know that Daniel was exceptional from the work that he did for a previous startup in his spare time when he was still a high school student. He built the backend in a matter of weeks. I knew that he was extraordinary. That was a big lesson is if the person's extraordinary, throw all theses out the window and just back the founder. But it was really more a case in that situation of having dealt with so many music opportunities and they were so challenging, you know, selling Last FM to CBS, being an investor in SoundCloud, being an investor in Juiced, which was a shit show, that by the time he came about,
16:14 Speaker 00 we didn't have the conviction to throw away all of our preconceived notions and just back him.
16:21 Harry Stebbings? This is going to be my big question to you, which I find more and more common. The founder is exceptional, incredible founder. God, I hate the market they're going after. Why did you choose property management or CRM or any of these kind of, aren't they, I think, quite difficult and challenging industries? But what do you do when you have a founder where you love them but hate the market?
16:40 Speaker 00 You know, that's probably been a big learning over the years. And I would like to think that Index has learned from its mistakes. I would say that we would back the founder, period.
16:48 Harry Stebbings? Regardless of stage?
16:50 Speaker 00 Well, it depends on the stage, obviously. But if it's seed and series A and you're talking about an exceptional founder, we would throw away any preconceived notions of market, especially if they already have a really good instinct of the team that they're bringing on board and clearly have a high bar for colleagues. I'd like to think that. We back that founder every time.
17:13 Harry Stebbings? It's been my biggest lesson to suspend belief on the market itself.
17:16 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:17 Harry Stebbings? Do you do market sizing?
17:18 Speaker 00 We do, absolutely.
17:20 Harry Stebbings? How does that look? Like you outcome scenario plan?
17:22 Speaker 00 I mean, we don't really do outcome scenario planning, but we absolutely try and get comfort on the size of the market. Sometimes it's helpful. Most of the time, it doesn't really mean much.
17:34 Harry Stebbings? My worry with it is like when you look at especially at Bessemer, who very kindly published their, you know, investment memos. You consistently underestimate the size of your winners. Twilio was 500 million to them. Procore was 300. Snap was 500. We always underestimate the size of our winners. And I worry that by almost doing market sizing, it can constrain our thinking. Which is my, as someone who hates Excel is the reason I don't do it.
17:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, you have a good excuse. I mean, one of our tenants is definitely that market size TAM is noise. That is a clear viewpoint that we learned early on that we were not going to be able to judge. As you said, you can't judge the market. And so therefore it's crazy to assess an investment based on the size of the market. I mean, one of the big lessons on Airbnb was when we were evaluating it, we were thinking, how many hotel rooms is Airbnb going to cannibalize? Rather than thinking, actually Airbnb is going to create an entirely new market. An entirely new amount of inventory that has never hit the market prior.
18:38 Harry Stebbings? Do you prefer category creation plays?
18:40 Speaker 00 I would say yes. As a firm, we love category creators. Yeah.
18:44 Harry Stebbings? The one thing I do want to touch on is you mentioned that you had seen many different music companies before, Last FM, SoundCloud. Hardest thing is, how do you prevent prior successes or failures impacting future decision making?
18:57 Speaker 00 It's really difficult. We're trying to get to the essence of why we made a mistake. So we really learn more from our mistakes, right, than our successes.
19:05 Harry Stebbings? Do you think we do or we just don't analyze our successes in the same way?
19:09 Speaker 00 It's a great question. I would suspect that we're pretty good at analyzing, at least as a firm, as a partnership, our successes. Probably have a tougher time than we should at celebrating our successes. I think, you know, anyone who's competitive and driven has a difficult time at celebrating successes. It's one of the aspects that I really focus on my entrepreneurs to do. They have such a high bar and such high ambition that they forget to really celebrate the success in the journey. And it's a tough journey, so you should really take advantage of those successes. I really do believe that we can get better and better at this craft. And the way that we get better and better is at analyzing our mistakes.
19:49 Speaker 00 And as an institution, understanding those mistakes and making sure that we don't do the same thing the next time. As uncomfortable as it may seem, we make sure that we don't fall into the same pattern the next time.
20:01 Harry Stebbings? What pattern do you think you most want to avoid?
20:04 Speaker 00 There are many, but clearly, TAM is one of those that always raises its head. And we always sort of like bash it down, remind ourselves how often we've gotten that wrong. So the other one is valuation. We always evaluate the multiple that we're paying based on the current snapshot of comps. Rather than thinking out, what is it going to be worth? If every company continues to grow and if this specific sector grows, what are the implications of it? Honestly, I hadn't really thought about companies being worth multiple trillions until Apple hit that trillion number. It was like, oh yeah, of course. So we're now into the hundreds of billions.
20:48 Harry Stebbings? I agree with you and I love that thinking and I hope I'm an optimist. But I'm not seeing that. You're seeing the languishing of Box and Dropbox and all the kind of traditional SaaS providers and software providers. And then you're seeing the pull away of the seven.
21:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:01 Harry Stebbings? And Nvidia is there and Microsoft's there.
21:03 Speaker 00 Well, it used to be five and now it's seven, right? And you're making it sound like Nvidia is a no brainer that's been around and valued at trillions for a long time. So I would say the reality is that set of highly valuable companies in the trillions, but also in the hundreds of billions is going to change, certainly the hundreds of billions ones. And the ones that are languishing probably is more a reflection of execution and product market fit, rather than the fact that they're languishing for other reasons.
21:34 Harry Stebbings? What outside bet do you have for the next multi hundred billion dollar company?
21:38 Speaker 00 The way that my mind operates, I try and sort of cancel out the noise and focus on the things that are really critical. So I don't really think about which companies are going to be worth hundreds of billions. I'm trying to think of how do I make so many index-backed companies worth tens of billions and possibly hundreds of billions. But clearly, I invested in Nvidia, I should have doubled down a lot more when I did a couple of years ago. That was a big mistake. Back to my equity analyst days, there are a number of companies that are reinventing themselves today that have not been public for such a long time, who are probably going to be worth hundreds of billions.
22:21 Harry Stebbings? Are you willing to take market timing risk? Different investors have different appetites to market timing risk. How do you feel about it?
22:27 Speaker 00 It's critical. No credit for being too early. However, what has been a truism, companies that are excellent can go out in any market. So I don't really believe in these IPO windows for exceptional companies. I think that the best companies can go out in any market, and they can even do stupid things. Google went out in the worst of markets and did a Dutch auction, which there was absolutely no need for. So many entrepreneurs want to reinvent Wall Street and the mechanism of going public in a similar way than they're taking on their sector. I wish they would leave that alone. That is such a distraction. But I do believe that the best companies at that stage when they are ready to go public can go public in any market.
23:11 Harry Stebbings? Are you willing to take market timing risk when investing in companies, be it VR, be it emergent categories where consumer adoption is a question mark, and where it is a real timing game and you have to be patient?
23:24 Speaker 00 Probably more patient on the technology and the amount of time that it takes to come to fruition, rather than a question of whether the market is going to be excited. I would call that a second derivative play. Not only does the product or service have to be excellent, but I'm also assuming that once the product and service is out there, there's going to be a new interest. In that product or service, I wouldn't do that. In the case of Figma, clearly it was going to take three years plus to come up with an alpha. But that was more a question of were they going to be able to deliver the product of significance enough to be relevant and to dominate the market?
24:07 Speaker 00 And Sketch was the best example of what Figma could become. So that was more a question of product development, but the market was clearly there. Rather than product development and I have to assume that the market's going to be there.
24:21 Harry Stebbings? Was Figma always a clear winner?
24:23 Speaker 00 I mean, nothing's always a clear winner, is it? Come on.
24:26 Harry Stebbings? No, Snap more so. Snap is one where actually there were little post-IPO, it's had challenges. But in the trajectory up, it did seem, and maybe internally, but internals have still told me, actually it looked pretty straight up and to the right. That's a weird one. But like, again, three years in the dark, respectfully, and we both know Dylan very well. But it's a long time. You must be sitting in the investment partnership going, has he come out with anything yet?
24:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, they were very clear on how much time. Maybe my ignorance is bliss in that one. You know, they were very clear on how long it was going to take to actually come up with the technology. And I had no reason of disbelieving them as the more and more I learnt about Evan and Dylan and the team that they were putting together, the better the team was and the more confidence I had that they were developing great product.
25:14 Harry Stebbings? Interesting to them, more confidence. One thing that I always oscillated on is reserves. How do you think about effective reserves and having done this so effectively? What are some of your big lessons?
25:25 Speaker 00 You know, we're very fortunate, right? Because we have a seed, a venture and a growth fund. And we've had the same in LPs for a long time. They give us enormous amount of latitude and it's the same folks who invest across multiple funds. As soon as we have signal that we think is better than our peers and that validates what we're betting on and that we can convince the team to take our money is as soon as we want to double down.
25:52 Harry Stebbings? Do you worry about signaling? It is the thing that all stage-specific firms use against you, well, not you, but any multi-stage. Firm, ah, the signaling risk is real. How do you back that back?
26:02 Speaker 00 It used to be more of a concern. I think there's so much money sloshing around and so many folks have so many different funds. That signal risk is more of the past. I mean, if you look at the continuum of entrepreneurial power versus investor power over the last couple of decades, it's only gone in the entrepreneurial direction. If you want to raise at this point and you are capable, you're going to be able to raise irrespective of who's been in previous rounds. It sounds self-serving, but I really feel like it's happened. It's really rare that we ever not get to invest because folks are concerned about signaling any longer.
26:41 Harry Stebbings? Do you think there's too much money in Manchester? You mentioned everyone has these different funds. Is there too much cash in the game?
26:47 Speaker 00 I think so. I think so. I think it's more a question of how thoughtful are folks being about putting that money to work? We've talked about this before. I'm not a huge fan of sector funds because I think that with sectors, you're not looking for the best companies. You're looking for the best company in that sector. I'm not a fan of impact funds because you're rationalizing a mediocre investment because you're doing something good for the world. I'm not a fan of like geographic funds because again, you're looking for the best companies in a geo. Those are all compromises on the caliber of entrepreneur and company that you're backing.
27:24 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, in terms of like the scaling of the different fund programs, how did you think about that? Because you could have raised much more, I'm sure.
27:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, we could have.
27:32 Harry Stebbings? Why did you not?
27:33 Speaker 00 First of all, because we have plenty of resources. It's more a question of making sure that we have enough resources to continue to back the entrepreneur. The second one, it would have probably changed the whole dynamic and culture of the firm.
27:46 Harry Stebbings? How so?
27:47 Speaker 00 Well, the larger the funds, the more folks you have to hire, the more partners you have around the table. Everyone at Index, we have very varied personalities, but we all really enjoy working with one another. And it's just relatively small crew that fits around a table. The more funds we have, the larger the organization. Strategists that we would have would have to have bigger teams and they also like being smaller. So it just changes the configuration and possibly it changes also the motivation. You know, we've always been focused on getting to carry as soon as possible. And the larger the funds, the longer it will take and the more attractive the management fee is. So it just doesn't sit right.
28:32 Harry Stebbings? Many people speculate in like the future eventually you'll have kind of the Costco's, which is like the large money providers, which is all the big brands that we know who scaled into asset gatherers, not disparagingly, but just raising huge funds.
28:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:45 Harry Stebbings? And boutiques, which is your specialist providers like a benchmark, a USV, even a Ribbit, which although large, but is very fintech focused and absolutely owns their niche. Do you agree with that? You're either massive or you're a boutique.
28:59 Speaker 00 I mean, of course, we're trying to wedge ourselves in between.
29:01 Harry Stebbings? Yeah.
29:02 Speaker 00 Right? That's the plan, but I agree with you. I think there will be asset aggregators and artisans. And what we're trying to be, what we talk about internally is scaled artisans. The parallel that, you know, obviously we have to come up with examples of how to think about it. And I do have Swiss roots, right? I grew up in Switzerland and Index started in Switzerland. So we were thinking that the Apple Watch is actually the most successful luxury watch out there. It has many more SKUs than Rolex that sells a million watches. However, from a profit standpoint, Rolex and used Rolexes are a much better business than Apple. Maybe we could be the scaled artisans.
29:40 Harry Stebbings? Interesting you said there about kind of the scaled artisans and Rolex in particular. I spoke to Georgia, one of your partners, and she said that Danny understands brand and scarcity better than anyone else. I thought it was a really interesting comment from her. What does she mean, do you think, by that? And how do you think about that?
29:57 Speaker 00 It's nice of her to say. Thanks for talking to Georgia.
29:59 Harry Stebbings? She said you're a total tosser too.
30:02 Speaker 00 Okay.
30:03 Harry Stebbings? That was off rack, George. But what did she mean by that?
30:07 Speaker 00 The technology space has been so lucrative. It's been such an incredible industry that most companies create brands as a byproduct of a great product or service. I really couldn't tell you what Google's marketing strategy has been from the get go. Other than a cool white screen with like a cool couple of colors with their logo and maybe a drawing, I really have no idea how they've impacted me from a marketing standpoint. And most companies that have been successful, be they enterprise or consumer in the tech space, the marketing has been a byproduct of a great product or service. Really, the exception to the rule would be Apple and probably Airbnb. And I scratched my head to try and think of others.
30:50 Speaker 00 So, given how deliberate an index is, we obviously are going to spend a lot of time thinking of branding and try and bring that to our entrepreneurs, force them to think about branding proactively, the concept of what you stand for and how you tell that story. It's very difficult to build a brand if it's diluted and you see it everywhere, unless that's your model, which is a franchise model. So scarcity and brand really go hand in hand. And then it's a question of how to appreciate those facets and how do you increase them and decrease them at certain points.
31:24 Harry Stebbings? It's also very hard to build a brand when you're halfway through. I think people forget about brand until way too late and then they're like, shit, I should have thought about this before and then it's way harder.
31:33 Speaker 00 I guess we're saying the same thing, Harry, which is most brands are not real brands. There are very few companies that have true brands.
31:41 Harry Stebbings? Well, I think brands are like you have people who are for or against them. You know, I think it sounds crazy, but McDonald's and Burger King actually are pretty good brands. People often, I'm a Burger King or I'm a McDonald's. Nike or Adidas, same thing. Apple or Android, same thing. People don't, when they don't feel, then we have a problem.
31:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's right. But it also takes a long time to get to that scale where your brand is actually relevant to people. Very few of our companies across the portfolio, and we have a pretty significant portfolio, and we thankfully have some great entrepreneurs, very few of them legitimately have brands yet. In fact, I'm not sure that any of them truly have mainstream brands.
32:20 Harry Stebbings? You said the word relevant there and it made me think of a show I did with Keith Raboy. And we talked about sourcing, selecting and servicing, like kind of three core pillars of venture. And he said his biggest weakness is sourcing, staying relevant. He's like, it's a young person's game. If I were to ask you sourcing, selecting, servicing, where are you strongest and where are you weakest?
32:41 Speaker 00 I think probably one of the things that Index is best at is the exiting part. Cause we spend a lot of time thinking about exiting.
32:49 Harry Stebbings? Let's just unpack that. It was going to be one of my questions, but like, true. But again, I was speaking to many of your LPs as well as part of this. They're like, I love Index. The DPI is real. I always hear, you know, I can't eat IRR and with Index, I don't need to. That should be a billboard or tagline, by the way.
33:05 Speaker 00 That's very kind. Thank you.
33:06 Harry Stebbings? Happy to provide you with ideas. But like, how do you think about when to sell?
33:10 Speaker 00 Back to the discipline, our LPs are, we have no family offices in sovereign wealth funds. They're all institutions and they're mostly nonprofits or their customers are nonprofits. So we're really trying to make sure that our fiduciary responsibility is creating the most amount of returns as possible because they're professionals at giving it away. We're not going to sacrifice the quality of the company based on anything but trying to create the most amount of carry as possible. When it comes to exiting, it really clarifies things, right? Like, we're just trying to make sure that we don't believe our own BS.
33:48 Speaker 00 We don't get emotional about our own entrepreneurs and that we stay true to creating the biggest exits possible. Or getting to a decision of exiting the company as quickly as possible when it's not working. So exiting is both for successes and failures.
34:06 Harry Stebbings? How does it differ? Talk to me about that.
34:09 Speaker 00 Well, in the case of a failure, you want to make sure that you're aware of that failure as quickly as possible. You've learned those lessons and you convince the entrepreneur to shut down shop and start something new with the scar tissue at hand.
34:22 Harry Stebbings? Would you rather they start something new with the cash that they've got, say 50% of the last round? Or would you rather, hey, let's just get a landing pad for this and return cash?
34:31 Speaker 00 I'm sorry to be so unclear about this. It's really going to be based on how much conviction they have on what they're starting up afresh. Rather than trying to come up with something because they feel like
34:44 Harry Stebbings? They have to.
34:44 Speaker 00 They have another shot at it or they don't want to disappoint people. We're not disappointed ever. If a company shuts down, they've given it their best shot. God bless. Thank you for letting us be part of the ride and let's move on.
34:57 Harry Stebbings? In your winners, will you sell in increments over time?
35:01 Speaker 00 Yes, we will. In our winners, it's a question of, first of all, just being disciplined about when to exit. Making sure that we are not sort of falling into the trap of thinking that because they've been successful, they will naturally be more successful over time. And making sure that we hold the partner who's associated with the company very honest by insisting that they have a one vote rather than the primary vote on deciding when to exit. That's a really tough thing, but it's made an enormous amount of difference. From Adyen to Datadog to
35:39 Harry Stebbings? When do you think you did it well and when did you do it badly?
35:43 Speaker 00 When it's a private sale, it's really difficult to do, right? Because the market is not clear, not as clear. It's more difficult to really have transparency on what's going on in the company. When I was talking about exiting, I was really talking about exiting when the company is public. From one investor to the next, that's difficult. Unless you're getting fully out, you know, in the case of End Clothing, we sold it to a private equity firm. That was a clear sale, but it's really tough when you're taking increments off as the company is growing. I mean, you might be very good at that. We're not even trying to do that.
36:16 Harry Stebbings? I think you're kind. I could have done that.
36:18 Speaker 00 I'm talking about when a company is public, just making sure that there's discipline around not optimizing because we think that they're going to be worth so much more the next year than they are today. But rather evaluating the company and I've been a recipient of this advice. Like, Denny, if you like it so much, you can keep the stock. Or if you like it so much, you can buy back that stock. But right now, we're making the right decision for our LPs.
36:44 Harry Stebbings? But when have you done it and in hindsight, you did it wrong? In other words, you sold and actually it skyrocketed, it continued to go up and what did you not see?
36:54 Speaker 00 The biggest mistakes that we've done as a firm is holding on too long rather than selling too early.
37:00 Harry Stebbings? Which one would that be?
37:02 Speaker 00 Another one where we sold too early was definitely Etsy. We didn't take into consideration the fact that Josh Silverman was going to come in and totally transform the organization and that obviously we left a lot of money on the table. At that point, we weren't on the board and so therefore we didn't have the same knowledge of the company. Back to your earlier question, I guess, not in all cases have we lost money by holding too long. It's been mixed, but it's mostly been holding too long.
37:30 Harry Stebbings? You mentioned Etsy there, we mentioned Figma earlier. The kind of hits that you have are incredible.
37:35 Speaker 00 It's all me, by the way. Has nothing to do with my partners or the companies.
37:39 Harry Stebbings? You are a true venture capitalist. What do you consider your biggest winner? I'm being crude, so I am asking for a name.
37:48 Speaker 00 I mean, I have so many stories, come on.
37:50 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, no, no, no, no.
37:51 Speaker 00 I don't, I don't know. I would like to think that my biggest winner is something that's gestating right now. There's no reason why they shouldn't be bigger. I mean, you know, Charmaine at Get Harley should be a huge winner. Tom at Motorway.
38:04 Harry Stebbings? Okay.
38:04 Speaker 00 Harry.
38:05 Harry Stebbings? We're going to choose one.
38:06 Speaker 00 I'm not going to choose one.
38:07 Harry Stebbings? What is your biggest takeaway from those? Going back to analyzing successes and failures and learning from them. When you think about, that's kind of what I'm going for, which is like, when you think about your biggest success, what is that? And then when you analyze it, what are the big takeaways from it?
38:22 Speaker 00 Big successes, you know, King was an amazing lesson in the sense that King was a company where the market really collapsed on them. So at first it was a, it was skill-based games on the web. That didn't happen. Then it was skill-based games on mobile, but it wasn't quite working. Then they had to reinvent themselves and be on Facebook, mobile games channel, and they had some successes there. It's such a great lesson of an incredible team, like Ricardo, Sebastian, and then eventually Stefan, who you know well, coming in.
38:59 Speaker 00 And just grinding away at excellence. That was an amazing story of success. It was also a lesson for Index because, you know, we wanted to lead that round. And then the Apex folks who didn't really play in our, in our space came in and offered a much bigger valuation, Michael Chalfin and Mike Rizman. And then we decided to make an exception to the rule and still put in a smaller check. So we were going to lead with 15 million, which at the time was a huge Series A. And they came in with 25 million and we had an opportunity to put in an incremental five million at their valuation. And we decided to hold our breath and do it. And it was clearly a great decision.
39:43 Speaker 00 That was really based on the team.
39:45 Harry Stebbings? When do you stretch on price versus when do you not?
39:48 Speaker 00 When we have conviction on the early rounds, there's a lot of room to stretch on price. In the later stage growth rounds, when the multiples are going to be more challenging to get, we have much more discipline on valuation.
40:01 Harry Stebbings? It's one thing to stretch on price. It's another thing to stretch on price and ownership. You can pay more.
40:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:06 Harry Stebbings? But just have the same ownership.
40:08 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:08 Harry Stebbings? That's one thing. But in that case, you were also stretched on ownership, but you were putting five in of that.
40:13 Speaker 00 Right. Well, you don't have Shardula as a partner. So Shardula is always like, do you like this company or not? Like, why are we not increasing our ownership even though it's a later stage round? I mean, you and I have talked about this. The dynamic of having peers around a table who think very differently from you, but are emphatic about their perspective and it's clearly different from yours. You just get to a better decision.
40:38 Harry Stebbings? Okay, so we have like King as an example there. How does that make you advise founders on when to give up versus whether to continue? As you mentioned, multiple iterations didn't work. Not it was a surprise, but like it was a multiple iterative moment when they hit the winner.
40:52 Speaker 00 It really depends on the story. In the case of King, they kept on reinventing themselves. They reinvented the team or members of the team. They reinvented the org structure. They reinvented the approach that we're taking to the market. So it was almost as though they were hitting the reboot button every 12 to 14 months with a new approach, getting further conviction about the market and about the fact that they were going to win, irrespective of what everyone else was saying. That is such a great team to continually give them more time to figure it out.
41:26 Harry Stebbings? How important do you think it is for an investor to have early wins in their career? You had quite a few early hits.
41:32 Speaker 00 The recommendation that I always give new partners who join, like Vlad from Airbnb just joined us. The visceral desire is to put points on the board, get involved, make a lot of investments, develop that muscle, meet as many company as possible, kiss every frog, et cetera. And my recommendation is always the antithesis of that. Take your time, make very few bets, really think through every meeting. Don't see that many folks unless the bar is maintained.
42:05 Harry Stebbings? But you don't have a bar.
42:07 Speaker 00 The bar is the index bar.
42:08 Harry Stebbings? I get that, but what I say is don't do many deals, but meet many people. Because you need to develop a benchmark of what great entrepreneurs look like. But even then, you'll probably be wrong. So don't do many at all.
42:19 Speaker 00 Right.
42:19 Harry Stebbings? But if you don't meet many, you're not going to build that muscle, though.
42:22 Speaker 00 Yes, you're right. You've got to meet a lot of people, but you have to make sure that your time is not equally distributed with those people.
42:31 Harry Stebbings? Agreed.
42:31 Speaker 00 So have enormous amount of time with folks who clearly are exceptional and try and limit the amount of time that you spend with folks who are still figuring out what they should be doing.
42:42 Harry Stebbings? Yes. We mentioned earlier Snap. I heard about Snap when I did some calls. I don't know if I'm allowed to say. Apparently it was a loss. Hit me. What happened?
42:52 Speaker 00 Well, it's clearly a loss. I mean, we didn't make the investment. That one was an unusual one.
42:56 Harry Stebbings? But did you try? Sorry, I'm being a dick.
42:59 Speaker 00 Please, please.
43:00 Harry Stebbings? Did you try and they chose someone else? Or did you say no?
43:03 Speaker 00 So what happened there was, to my recollection, we had the opportunity to invest, but we had a growth fund and we were unwilling to put the amount necessary to lock in the round. And so as a result of that, we didn't do the deal.
43:19 Harry Stebbings? Why were you unwilling?
43:21 Speaker 00 I mean, it was naivete, right? It was one of our first growth funds and it was gonna represent north of 10% of the fund in one investment. And we didn't think creatively on how we could justify that amount. I remember it distinctly as $61 million and we were willing to invest $40 million. And that incremental 21, we should have just said, yes, we're in for it and figured out on the back end how we were gonna do that.
43:51 Harry Stebbings? That's a hard one. Over 10% is a lot in a consumer social company, which has more volatility than an enterprise company. To your kindness earlier, give yourself a bit of credit on that one.
44:02 Speaker 00 Clearly, we could appreciate how brilliant Evan was.
44:07 Harry Stebbings? Was it really obvious?
44:08 Speaker 00 Brilliant. I mean, had such clarity on what Snap was and what it wasn't and how he was doing it. To my recollection, that was really a case of having full conviction about him, but did not having the courage of investing north of 10% of our fund in the company. And you know how I was talking about valuations? At the time, we thought the peak amount that a social platform would be worth was $1 billion because Instagram sold to Facebook for $1 billion. So we're like, okay, we're talking, how big can Snap really be fundamentally? You know, and YouTube was $600 million or, you know, how big can Snapchat truly be? Is it realistically going to be another social media platform?
44:53 Speaker 00 Can you be worth hundreds of billions as a social media platform? We were very naive about that.
44:58 Harry Stebbings? Hundreds of billions of dollars as a social media platform? Another discussion that I was told I had to go to, you're like, God, I wish you hadn't done all these fucking calls. Apparently, there was a discussion at Facebook at four to five billion and you guys decided not to do it.
45:13 Speaker 00 So, gosh, it's interesting what you're digging up here. No, we, so this was a funny one. So we raised the growth fund, the first growth fund. The first call was to Facebook. So Owen Van Natta and Chamath came to London and Gideon, and they presented, was the first company that presented. And we offered them what we thought was an incredible term sheet, which was to put in 50 million at 5 billion. And they came back and to their credit, went to Microsoft and they got an offer for 10 billion valuation. And they came back and said, look, we won't do five, but we'll do it at 10. And we said, absolutely no way. That's, there's just no way that we can justify doing it at 10.
45:56 Speaker 00 And so we passed on that. Thankfully, to Owen's credit, he felt so appreciative of the fact that we helped him get that Microsoft deal, that he ended up selling us some pretty significant secondary. And so it turned out to be a great investment for Index.
46:14 Harry Stebbings? To be fair, everything in hindsight looks, so he's like, oh my God, like, oh, but it's like, that was a nuts price at the time.
46:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
46:21 Harry Stebbings? I remember when Yuri did the DST round, I'm really going back here, but I mean, everyone was like 9 billion, this guy doesn't get it. And what an investment.
46:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
46:30 Harry Stebbings? What an unbelievable investment.
46:31 Speaker 00 I will, I'll never forget meeting Tomaj. He was at DST at the time and we met up and it was a year after we had done that Facebook investment and it was still pre-IPO. And we were exchanging notes and he asked me, so how have you been spending your year? And so I told him about the new companies that I was excited about and the new investments that we made. And I asked him, so how's your year been? What have you been doing? He's like, I've literally spent my year just trying to scoop up as much Facebook secondary as possible. And I promptly paid for that lunch and went back to the partnership and said, guys, we've wasted a year. That was a brilliant understanding of where to double down on value and where to spend your time.
47:13 Harry Stebbings? Do you think venture is about the hundreds of decisions you make per day? Or the ones two that you make a year?
47:19 Speaker 00 Clearly, the one or two that you make per year. So my wife, who's a spiritual student, but really she's a teacher more than a student, but she probably would not acknowledge that. You know, she talks about the fact that we are constantly at forks in the road. And really, our path is just making decisions at different forks in the road. So we make hundreds of forks in the road every day. And so whatever our path is, is based on this ledger of what we've done, whether we've gone left or right. And so a lot of luck and a lot of decision making, I think, is aligned with those forks in the road.
48:02 Harry Stebbings? I do want to go back to, you mentioned Ev just being naturally like incredible. What I worry about with founders is sometimes they look at these incredible leaders today and they go, well, I'm not that. And it's like they look at them at the end point or kind of 10 years in and go, well, I'm not that. Were there any founders that were maybe not obviously incredible? You mentioned Daniel being obviously incredible, Ev, but have turned into obviously incredible founders?
48:27 Speaker 00 By the way, what I would say about Evan is he spiked in certain areas. I mean, he was not great in other areas and I'm still not sure that he's great in the other areas. So I think it's more about having a really clear spike in a particular part of your personality or vision, rather than the full product. And part of the reason why at Index, we love working in the US and in Europe is that those spikes manifest themselves in very different ways. In the US, folks are super confident. And so, you know, they will not only spike in certain areas, but they're actually not that good in certain areas, but they'll still think that they spike in those areas.
49:09 Speaker 00 And so the level of polish and sophistication that you have to sift through is really significant. In Europe, of course, it's the antithesis of that, right? Like, they're not even aware. At how good they are in particular areas, let alone the fact that they're much better than they think they are in other areas. So it's really sifting through and being able to actually recognize that spike in Europe and celebrate that spike and get them to continue to focus on it.
49:38 Harry Stebbings? We're going to get to US and Europe. I just want to ask one more thing on kind of the deal reviews. We mentioned kind of, you know, not doing Snap and just not doing it. We mentioned some of the winners. In terms of actual like zeros, what was the zero that caused you the most lessons?
49:52 Speaker 00 It's more than one zero, but the one that I learned the most lessons from is probably Nasty Gal. This company that was in the US, it was an e-commerce company. Actually, the founder, Sophia, wrote a book that was really popular about her journey as as an entrepreneur. But what I learned about the Nasty Gal situation the most was the fact that I was trying my darndest to make it somewhat successful, just money back or an ongoing concern. Even though my partners were saying, Danny, please let this go. You were spending so much time thinking about it. I'm like, guys, I hardly have any more board meetings.
50:35 Speaker 00 They're like, yeah, but how much time at night are you thinking about this? You know, before you go to you go to bed, how much time are you trying to figure out how Nasty Gal is going to work? What is the first thing that you're thinking about when you wake up? And it was a big lesson that I had to just let go of the failure and move on. And that was the biggest lesson that I learned.
50:56 Harry Stebbings? Letting go of the failure and moving on.
50:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
50:58 Harry Stebbings? Why was that so difficult to do?
51:00 Speaker 00 Because it's difficult for anyone. I mean, that's part of the reason why I think that operators are not necessarily the best investors.
51:07 Harry Stebbings? But do you think because it was earlier in your career, it was more important to you not to have a big loss?
51:12 Speaker 00 OK, so great question. As I reflect on it, it was a big check that I had written. It was a growth investment. I had pounded the table on it. I got full support, unanimous support. So it felt good in the first round, but then I came back because the company needed more money. And I pounded the table there and the partners are like, hmm, you sure about this? And I did get a positive vote, but it was not the high average that I got on the first one. And so I felt responsible to the partners that I didn't put good money after bad. And not only did I put good money after bad, but the opportunity cost of spending time
51:54 Speaker 00 trying to turn around Nasty Gal versus focusing on the next great opportunity was very expensive.
52:02 Harry Stebbings? Did you let your emotions get in the way of your rational financial decision making on the reserves check?
52:08 Speaker 00 Absolutely, absolutely.
52:10 Harry Stebbings? Have you found a way to detach emotions from investing?
52:13 Speaker 00 The only way I can do it is by trying to remember all the mistakes that I've done as much as possible. Trying to remember what our true north is, what we're trying to do, and making sure that my partners keep me honest.
52:26 Harry Stebbings? Your best companies don't need you, agree?
52:28 Speaker 00 For sure.
52:29 Harry Stebbings? So why spend time on them?
52:30 Speaker 00 They don't need us to be a success, but our contribution can create another multiple. If I can take a certain 10x and make it a 12x or 14x, it's well worth the time.
52:43 Harry Stebbings? Georgia told me that you are one of the best for giving effective feedback. She's like, they don't often want to hear it, but he's very good at effective feedback with empathy. How do you do that, Danny?
52:57 Speaker 00 You know, one of the ways that we talk about index is compassionate ass kickers. So I prefer the term compassionate to empathetic. And I credit Jeff Weiner, who is definitely one of the best CEOs that has ever been in this industry, who, if you haven't interviewed, you should.
53:13 Harry Stebbings? Do you know, he said no.
53:14 Speaker 00 Really?
53:15 Harry Stebbings? So we should, we should keep that in and have a social pressure.
53:19 Speaker 00 Cause he's such an amazing coach for.
53:21 Harry Stebbings? And now an investor.
53:22 Speaker 00 And investor, amazing investor. But he explained to me the difference. So empathy, you're taking on an understanding, you're like literally taking on the pain of the other, which is not really helpful. Compassion means you understand what the person is going through, but there's a distance between you and the other person. So you can actually be much more helpful because you're not taking on all of that difficult energy and that difficult emotion that is coming from the other person. So compassion. As kickers means that you're compassionate. An ask kicker means that you get stuff done. So if things are not happening, you actually push someone out of the way and you make sure that you execute on the plan.
54:04 Speaker 00 So back to that true north, when it comes to giving feedback to entrepreneurs. I'm being very transparent. I'm very vulnerable and explain my issues. I always ask for feedback on what I am doing well, but more importantly, what I could improve on, how I'm supporting the company or how I'm delivering the message. And I don't hold back from making sure that they understand what I'm recognizing and what patterns I'm seeing repeat themselves, which I've seen 10 times before.
54:38 Harry Stebbings? So for me, I'm like, if you have a partnership, it has to be all in one place. The team that I'm building will always be in London or where I am. But that's really important, just because you could be the best partnership in the world. But when you're in SF or New York, boom, communication's lost.
54:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, it is much easier out of one office. That's why when we open offices, we don't actually hire folks to open the office. We actually take partners from one office and move them. So Mike and I moved to San Francisco to open that office. And Chardou and Martin moved to New York to open that office. And it's not in either situation as though this was a family-led decision. There was a lot of revolt with families to do what was right for the firm. But we felt that was the only way to make sure that we understood body language through Zoom calls and screens by bringing that culture to those new GOs.
55:28 Harry Stebbings? You are literally the only European firm that's been able to scale into the US and really do as well as you have done. What do you think you've done to enable that? No, I mean, this was references as well. Many attributions, but it's true. What do you think you did to enable that?
55:44 Speaker 00 I mean, making the tough calls.
55:46 Harry Stebbings? It's you.
55:47 Speaker 00 It's me.
55:48 Harry Stebbings? It's me.
55:49 Speaker 00 No, you know, it's making the tough calls as a partnership. Like, you know, the fact that the partners in London were holding the fort while we set up to start San Francisco, and they gave us the time to make a presence, but also invest it. I mean, Jan was flying there back and forth, you know, once a month for a long time as we were setting up San Francisco.
56:11 Harry Stebbings? What was the hardest thing about building the SF office? Because people like all these index guys from Europe.
56:16 Speaker 00 Making sure that we didn't fall into the herd-like mentality and staying true to our roots of being outsiders. That was really tough because basically it's a one-industry town and folks have been there for a long time or folks scream from mountaintops incredibly loudly. But we do have a differentiated approach. So just making sure that we weren't falling prey to what everyone else was doing. And those are some of the proudest moments of index, right? Like when we didn't invest in crypto, when it was more contrarian to not invest rather than to invest in crypto. That was tough, but it felt right.
56:52 Harry Stebbings? Talk to me about that partnership discussion.
56:54 Speaker 00 You know, it was many discussions because we were trying to squint and figure out who was going to be the champion and was going to lead us to the promised land of being excited about crypto. And none of us could do it. There were many approaches. Martin is really good at being disciplined and process-oriented, really thinking through new areas. And so he dabbled, tried to get excited, but he couldn't. So the baton was passed to Mike at the time, and he could. And then the baton was passed to me, maybe on the consumer side, maybe on the gaming side, and I couldn't.
57:32 Harry Stebbings? The interesting thing with crypto is like the best outcome is you just bought Bitcoin in most cases.
57:36 Speaker 00 Exactly.
57:37 Harry Stebbings? Europe is a question mark for a lot of US LPs. And I think more so than ever right now, everyone is down on Europe. A lot of the US firms have retrenched. I was with one of the best partners in Europe who will remain nameless. And they were like, I can't think of a great fucking company that's come out of Europe in the last three to four years. And that's the first time ever in my career I've felt like this.
57:58 Speaker 00 Okay.
57:59 Harry Stebbings? How.
57:59 Speaker 00 God bless. We need more of those folks.
58:02 Harry Stebbings? How do you feel about when you hear that? You like total bullshit?
58:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, bullshit, no, but absurd. I mean, we're seeing so many opportunities. Every time we've messed up is when we over-rotate a bet against Europe. Here's one that was shocking to us. You know, as a firm, we sort of felt like Brexit is going to have an impact on the UK when it comes to starting companies. So we have to spend more time in Berlin and Paris and Amsterdam, Stockholm, all these other places where entrepreneurs are more likely to kick off companies. Well, guess what? We were totally wrong on that. London has continued to maintain basically an equivalent dynamism of entrepreneurialism as it did pre-Brexit, which is a total shock to me, but it's absolutely true.
58:50 Speaker 00 So we over-rotated against a GO and we're, you know, we've proactively fixed that. Europe is just moving forward and the entrepreneurs are better and the teams are better and the support that's being provided is better. The ability to be a global phenomenon and be globally successful has only gotten greater.
59:13 Harry Stebbings? Do you recalibrate your mind when meeting American versus European founders?
59:17 Speaker 00 Always. I mean, as I said, you know, we expect the American founders to be very polished and sophisticated. And so therefore we discount quite a bit of what they say. And we do the opposite for European entrepreneurs. What's sort of cool is that, you know, we feel like outsiders in both continents. And so therefore we have a little distance, but we do understand the cultures well. That's why we really invest in Europe, in the US and Israel. We don't really invest in other, in other GOs because we don't, that was why we didn't invest in China or in India or Latin America, because we didn't see what competitive advantage we had to understand those cultures, to understand and have the right filter to be able to truly
1:00:00 Speaker 00 see what the entrepreneur was saying and sift through, you know, what was true and what was probably an exaggeration.
1:00:06 Harry Stebbings? You mentioned being an outsider in SF. Do you prefer founders who are an outsider to a market or insiders to a market?
1:00:12 Speaker 00 It's more about whether their passion is true to what they're going after. They might have different reasons, like, you know, one of the companies that we've invested in, and I'm super excited about in a new market that we haven't spent any time on in a long time. And that sort of felt like a sleeper for us, but we're super excited about is the insurance market. And we invested in Ron from empathy. Ron, is he an outsider to the insurance industry? Yes. Is he an outsider to enterprise sales to insurers? Yes. He's an insider to the whole concept of empathy through personal experience that has rocked him to the soul. And I have met very few people who have thought about grief and how to help people
1:00:56 Speaker 00 who are grieving as much as Ron. So he's sort of an outsider and an insider. The outsider insider is really based on the passion that we recognize. Is this person placed on this earth to go after this opportunity? In the case of Ron, he's an outsider, but wow, has he been placed on this earth.
1:01:14 Harry Stebbings? Final one, because I could talk to you all day. You mentioned your wife earlier.
1:01:18 Speaker 00 Yes.
1:01:19 Harry Stebbings? Dude, you build index and you are on planes every week. I'm sure most of your life, actually, for the last 20 years. How do you do that and have a great marriage at the same time? Really?
1:01:30 Speaker 00 I'm glad that you're saying that I have a great marriage.
1:01:33 Harry Stebbings? I spoke to your wife, she was one of the references. I told you someone said you were a tosser. Yeah.
1:01:38 Speaker 00 There you go.
1:01:39 Harry Stebbings? I let it out. God.
1:01:40 Speaker 00 There you go. I mean, it's kind of you to say. I do think we have a great marriage. I think it's a question of just prioritizing the right things, you know, like there are very few priorities in my life and my family is the first and my work is the second. And my interests are the third and that's it. I don't really have time for much else. And so, once I have that clarity, then it's a question of putting in the time and the effort in the best way possible. And a lot of it is luck, right? So.
1:02:11 Harry Stebbings? Has there ever been a time when you've got your priorities wrong? And what did you learn from that?
1:02:15 Speaker 00 Holy shit, so many. Unfortunately, the priorities have always been to prioritize work over family. And those are the biggest regrets, always, rather than the other way around.
1:02:26 Harry Stebbings? Is there one that comes to mind?
1:02:28 Speaker 00 You know, there have been certain trips that I thought were absolutely essential for index, where I really pounded the table at home that I should go on. And I really regret those trips because they were completely meaningless in the grand scheme of things.
1:02:50 Harry Stebbings? Your wife's gonna be thrilled when she hears that back.
1:02:53 Speaker 00 She's heard it, trust me.
1:02:55 Harry Stebbings? Listen, I live my life, I'm saying sorry, it's much easier. Are you ready for a quick fire, Danny? I've loved this. So what have you changed your mind on most in the last 12 months?
1:03:04 Speaker 00 It's gonna sound really weird, but there's this whole dimension, this spiritual dimension, that I was sort of holding myself away from. You know, like, how do I explore that side? How do I explore instinct and gut? And how do I look for deeper meaning in things that are not evident and clear in the same manner?
1:03:27 Harry Stebbings? Does that mean you're more reflective?
1:03:29 Speaker 00 It's twofold. One is just trusting my instinct a lot more and sticking to my instinct.
1:03:35 Harry Stebbings? Does that go against strong conviction or strong opinions that you see held?
1:03:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, because especially in this industry, right? We've been trained to think through first principle thinking, to be analytical, to think of all these other signals that either are the primary driver for our investment thesis or are the primary support for our investment thesis. And I'm sort of saying, actually, what is the first impact? What is the first reaction that you have to the founder, to the opportunity? How does it make you feel? Can you build on that? All of that other stuff is actually gonna help you rationalize one way or another, but try and keep it as far away from your decision making as possible.
1:04:21 Harry Stebbings? What's the most memorable first founder meeting you've had?
1:04:24 Speaker 00 Meeting Jason from Discord because none of the investors wanted me to meet him. They had no desire to get another investor in. And I finally convinced Christian from Playfish, who was at EA, to make an introduction. And Jason gave me 15 minutes and I showed up at a Blue Bottle. Jason's like, okay, well, you know, who's a super nice guy. I don't know if you've ever interviewed him, but
1:04:45 Harry Stebbings? No, I haven't.
1:04:46 Speaker 00 Super nice guy. And he's like, you know, Danny, I'm here. I have 15 minutes. And I said, great. And it was just the day or the week that Nasty Gal going into bankruptcy was announced. And so I wanted to talk about Discord. He's like, so tell me about Nasty Gal. Tell me about that experience. Tell me about how it went with the entrepreneur. Literally, it was an hour of grilling me on how I had handled and we had handled that situation. And it followed up with him agreeing to have dinner with myself and two partners the night after. At that dinner, he showed us two slides. So Dick Costolo from Twitter was spending time with us as a venture partner at the time.
1:05:30 Speaker 00 It was Shardul and myself. We had dinner with him and he showed us two slides. And based on the retention of Discord at the time, we followed up the next day and offered him a term sheet. So that was a really unusual, unorthodox approach.
1:05:46 Harry Stebbings? Discord was not the Discord today, is it?
1:05:49 Speaker 00 Actually, interestingly, it's now back to its roots. So what happened was during COVID, Discord became much more of a mainstream platform. And now it's going back to what it was when we invested, which is really a vertical solution for gamers to enjoy themselves. That's really what they're about.
1:06:06 Harry Stebbings? Who is your most formidable competition and why them? When you hear that X is around a deal, who are you like, oh, I'm gonna have to get my A-game on. So like for me, again, it was helpful. When Christoph at Point9 is on something, shit, I gotta get to work.
1:06:20 Speaker 00 Like clearly, the folks at Sequoia are a big fierce competitor. And the folks at XL are fierce. And those come to mind for consumer stuff. Certainly Sequoia comes to mind a lot. Benchmark, we don't see them as often anymore, but I mean, we pay attention to all these folks.
1:06:39 Harry Stebbings? What board member have you learnt the most from sitting alongside and what did you learn?
1:06:43 Speaker 00 I mean, we were just talking about benchmarks. So actually, the person I I learned most from was one of the original benchmark partners named Kevin Harvey.
1:06:52 Harry Stebbings? Yeah.
1:06:52 Speaker 00 Who was incredibly generous in a couple of ways. The first was I joined the board of MySQL after having lost the deal. So I I had decided to partner with KP because it was against benchmark and it was in the heyday of KP. And Kevin still won them over, but Martin, the CEO, was excited about Index enough and wanted to give us a shot. That he gave us a little sliver so I could join as an observer. And then we had the right to build our position up to 10%. As secondary came available. And so Kevin went from not really wanting me at all
1:07:28 Speaker 00 to being just a great board member to learn from in terms of his approach, to also being an incredible, you know, source of of learnings that he was generous about on how to do things correctly and how to do things appropriately. So a lot of the early decisions that Index did were based on really some important tweaks to the benchmark model that Andy Ratcliffe and Kevin Harvey taught us about. One of them was if you are crazy enough to open an office in another G O, make sure you actually move partners to make it happen. Don't think that you're going to be able to hire people and that's going to translate into the same culture.
1:08:10 Harry Stebbings? You know me pretty well by now.
1:08:13 Speaker 00 I do.
1:08:13 Harry Stebbings? What would be your biggest advice to me building a firm, having built Index to the incredible stage that it is?
1:08:20 Speaker 00 What do you think it would be?
1:08:21 Harry Stebbings? Focus on the partnership.
1:08:23 Speaker 00 Yes, hire peers. Sounds like you're well on your way of doing that.
1:08:27 Harry Stebbings? What's the best investment advice you often give out?
1:08:30 Speaker 00 I feel like I've given so much here. Come on. You want more? Like, what else? I've told you everything. I have no secrets.
1:08:38 Harry Stebbings? Go on, one more.
1:08:39 Speaker 00 Some of the best investment advice, I think, is remembering how humbling this business is and not thinking that you ever have it figured out. That every frickin' time, you are going to make mistakes. And all you can do is learn from your partners and learn from the history of mistakes that you've done prior. But you're not much better, if any better, at this game.
1:09:04 Harry Stebbings? Where is Index in 10 years' time, in an ideal world?
1:09:09 Speaker 00 I really would love to see that Index in 10 years has continued to progress on a number of fronts. First of all, that the partnership is not much bigger than it is today, that our funds are not much bigger than it is today. But that our returns have only gotten better because the caliber of partner that we have is better. Because we've hired better people and they've learned from better investors and we're seeing better companies. And we have a better mechanism of really understanding who the best entrepreneurs are that match our culture. And that we're really good at winning and doing the, you know, sourcing, winning, operating and exiting side. I would like to think that Index might have one more office in 10 years.
1:09:54 Speaker 00 We open an office every 10 years. At least that's what we've done. So maybe we'll have another G O in 10 years and we'll have-
1:09:59 Harry Stebbings? Where would the next year be?
1:10:00 Speaker 00 I don't know. I mean, that's up to the partnership. I'm one voice and I shouldn't be there in 10 years. If I'm still there, I'm doing something wrong. Or they're doing something wrong. So I'd like to see that the baton has been passed and that the folks are taking Index to higher and higher territory, but maintaining what we're all about.
1:10:20 Harry Stebbings? Danny, listen, I've loved doing this. Thank you for putting up with my meandering and direct questions. Do you see, I was much nicer when I was younger, wasn't I? It was much easier in an interview.
1:10:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, what's going on here?
1:10:30 Harry Stebbings? I know, sorry about that. But seriously, I've loved doing this, man.
1:10:33 Speaker 00 It's such a pleasure, Harry. Thank you so much. And your, your questions are never what I expect them to be. But I always end up telling you a lot more than I had planned on.
1:10:44 Harry Stebbings? You have to understand, I am the biggest venture nerd. And so for me to have the chance and the position where I can sit down and learn from decades of wisdom of building an incredible firm like Index from Danny there, it really is a dream. I hope that you enjoyed the show. You can of course, watch it live in the studio on YouTube by searching for 20VC, that's two zero VC on YouTube. But before we leave you today, we're all trying to grow our businesses here. So let's be real for a second. We all know that your website shouldn't be this static asset. It should be a dynamic part of your strategy that really drives conversions. That's marketing 101. But here's a number for you. 54% of leaders say web updates take too long. That's over half of you listening right now. And that's where Webflow comes in.
1:11:28 Harry Stebbings? Their visual first platform allows you to build, launch and manage web experiences fast. That means you can set ambitious marketing goals and your site can rise to the challenge. Plus, Webflow allows your marketing team to scale without relying on engineering, freeing your dev team to focus on more fulfilling work. Learn why teams like Dropbox, IDEO and Orange Theory trust Webflow to achieve their most ambitious goals today at webflow.com. And speaking of incredible products that allows your team to do more, we need to talk about SecureFrame. SecureFrame provides incredible levels of trust to your customers through automation. SecureFrame empowers businesses to build trust with customers by simplifying information
1:12:11 Harry Stebbings? security and compliance through AI and automation. Thousands of fast growing businesses, including NASDAQ, Angel List, Doodle and Coder, trust SecureFrame to expedite their compliance journey for global security and privacy standards such as SOC 2, ISO 2701, HIPAA, GDPR and more. Backed by top tier investors and corporations such as Google, Kleiner Perkins, the company is among the Forbes List of Top 100 Startup Employers for 2023 and Business Insider's List of the 34 Most Promising AI Startups of 2023. Learn more today at secureframe.com. It really is a must. And finally, a company is nothing without its people and that's why you need remote.com.
1:12:53 Harry Stebbings? Remote is the best choice for companies expanding their global footprint where they don't already have legal entities. So you can effortlessly hire, manage and pay employees from around the world, all from one easy to use self-serve platform. Plus, you can streamline global employee management and cut HR costs with Remote's free HRIS. And hey, even if you are not looking for full-time employees, Remote has you covered with contractor management, ensuring compliant contracts and on-time payments for global contractors. There's a reason companies like GitLab and DoorDash trust Remote to handle their employees worldwide. Go to remote.com now to get started and use the promo code 20VC to get 20% off during your first year.
1:13:36 Harry Stebbings? Remote: opportunity is wherever you are. As always, I so appreciate all your support and stay tuned for an incredible episode coming this Wednesday. As always, I so appreciate all the support and stay tuned for an incredible episode this coming Wednesday with Michael Eisenberg at Aleph.
Previous 20Product: Loom CPO Janie Lee on Three Core Skills that Make the Best PMs, How to Find, Pick and Train the Best PM Talent and Lessons from OpenDoor and Rippling on Product Breadth, Pricing and Talent Density Next 20VC: Foundation Models are the Fastest Depreciating Asset in History, Lina Kahn is a Threat to American Capitalism, PE is Not Coming to Save the M&A Market & How China Could Overtake the US in the AI Race with Michael Eisenberg Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated