Pod Insights The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch 20VC: From Potato Farm to $200M in Revenue: The Never-Before-Told Story of Flo Health: Scaling to $1BN Valuation, 75M Users & Getting 100s of No's From Investors Along the Way with Dmitry Gurski About this episode Dmitry Gurski is the Co-Founder and CEO of Flo Health, the leading women's health app and the first European femtech unicorn. Launched in 2015, Flo Health has grown to over 70 million monthly active users and 5 million paid subscribers. The app is recognized as the #1 recommended tool for period and cycle tracking, and it recently achieved a valuation exceeding $1 billion. Beyond Flo, Dmitry is a partner at Palta, a co-founding company with a portfolio of successful startups including Simple App, MSQRD (acquired by Facebook), AIMatter (acquired by Google), and Wannaby (acquired by Farfetch). In Today's Episode with Dmitry Gurski We Discuss: 1. Why 99% of Startup Advice is BS: Why does Dmitry believe that speed is not the most important thing? Why does Dmitry believe that competition is actually a good thing? Why does Dmitry believe that craziness not intelligence is the most important trait in founders? Why does Dmitry believe that fundraising is simply a numbers game? What does no one understand about retention that everyone should know? 2. From Potato Farms to Billion Dollar Apps: What a childhood in potato farming taught Dmitry about leadership and technology? How mushroom farming taught Dmitry about diversification and focus? How does Dmitry advise people analyse the hardest moments in their life? Why Dmitry does not believe in talent? What else is there? 3. Scaling to Flo's First 1M Users: What were Dmitry's biggest lessons from two failed prior versions of Flo? What is the secret to success in consumer subscription? How did Flo acquire their first customers? What worked? What did not work? Why does Dmitry not believe in brand and PR? 4. Building a $200M Revenue Market Leader: What have been Dmitry's biggest lessons on monetisation? How does Dmitry think about retaining product simplicity with time? What are the first things to break in the scaling of a company? What did they do with Flo that he wishes they had not done?
Transcript 13,492 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Smart people, they work in McKinsey. Founders, they're crazy. For consumers, simplicity is the most significant. It's much more significant than the number of features. It's much more significant than anything. What many people don't understand, retention is not about product. Retention is about user case. It means that we may create the perfect app for gym. We'll have terrible retention. Why? Because gyms themselves have terrible retention. Never take general advice. General advice is always bullshit. If you look on the history of any company, you would see that everything is so nuanced. Everything is so unique. There are thousands of ways to be successful, and you should choose your way.
0:38 Harry Stebbings? So after 10 years of doing 20 VC, I decided I've had enough of podcast tour guests. Guests who go on the same podcasts, and you've heard their stories before. 20 VC from now on will focus on telling the best stories from technology with guests who've never been on a podcast before. That's the case for our guest today. Dmitry Gersky, founder of Flo Health, the leading women's health app and the first European femtech unicorn, launched in 2015. Flow has grown to 70 million monthly active users and 5 million paid subscribers with an ARR of over $200 million. The app is recognized as the number one recommended tool for period and cycle tracking. And what I love most, Dmitry, the founder,
1:21 Harry Stebbings? started life picking mushrooms. This is such an incredible story, and shows like this make me so grateful to do what I do. But before we dive in, when a promising startup files for an IPO or a venture capital firm loses its marquee partner, being the first to know gives you an advantage and time to plan your strategic response. Chances are, the information reported it first. The information is the trusted source for that important first look at actionable news across technology and finance, driving decisions with breaking stories, proprietary data tools, and a spotlight on industry trends. With a subscription, you will join an elite community that includes leaders from the top VC firms, CEOs from Fortune 500 companies, and esteemed banking and investment professionals.
2:05 Harry Stebbings? In addition to must-read journalism in your inbox every day, you'll engage with fellow Leaders in their active discussions or in person at exclusive events. Learn more and access a special offer for 20 VCs listeners at www.theinformation.com/deals/20vc. And speaking of incredible products that allows your team to do more, we need to talk about SecureFrame. SecureFrame provides incredible levels of trust to your customers through automation. SecureFrame empowers businesses to build trust with customers by simplifying information security and compliance through AI and automation. Thousands of fast-growing businesses, including NASDAQ, Angel List, Doodle and Coder, trust SecureFrame to expedite their compliance journey
2:50 Harry Stebbings? for global security and privacy standards such as SOC 2, ISO 2701, HIPAA, GDPR and more. Backed by top-tier investors and corporations such as Google, Kleiner Perkins, the company is among the Forbes List of Top 100 Startup Employers for 2023 and Business Insider's List of the 34 Most Promising AI Startups of 2023. Learn more today at SecureFrame.com. It really is a must. And finally, a company is nothing without its people. And so I want to talk about Cooley, the global law firm built around startups and venture capital. Since forming the first venture fund in Silicon Valley, Cooley has formed more venture capital funds than any other law firm in the world. With 60-plus years working with VCs,
3:34 Harry Stebbings? they help VCs form and manage funds, make investments, and handle the myriad issues that arise through a fund's lifetime. We use them at 20VC and have loved working with their teams in the US, London and Asia over the last few years. So to learn more about the number one most active law firm representing VC-backed companies going public, head over to Cooley.com and also CooleyGo.com. Cooley's award-winning free legal resource for entrepreneurs. You have now arrived at your destination. Dimitri, I am such a fan of the incredible journey with Flow. So first off, thank you so much for joining me today. Thank you for your invitation. Not at all. Listen, I've wanted to make this happen for a while. I would love to start. I read actually an interview you'd done before.
4:18 Harry Stebbings? And I heard that you had a single mother who worked as a librarian. You got your first job at 16. Take me to that. How did those early years shape you as an entrepreneur?
4:29 Speaker 00 As I see you, I'm not so young. I'm forty-one years old and my childhood was in nineties in Belarus. Difficult times, like the world, Soviet world was destroyed. Everything ruined. People didn't have salaries. Shelters were empty. Salary of my mother was maybe thirty bucks and nothing to buy because shelters in shops were empty. And we were growing our own food. We had potato field, vegetables in this field. We had garden. We were making hundreds of jars of pickles. And mostly we were feeding ourselves by this production. I still don't like potato, honestly. I can't eat anymore.
5:14 Speaker 00 But it was a good life lesson. It was a lesson of farming. And the lesson of farming teach that you just can't fake farming. It means that you should take potato, not eat it immediately, even if you're hungry. And you should put this potato to ground. And then you mustn't eat this potato next day. And even one month after, you should buy. And then you should work hard and you should, you can't fake this job. And then it's like you never have one hundred percent of chances that you would get your potato back. Because I don't know, it may be hail, it may be froze, it may be bugs.
5:59 Speaker 00 But then if you're lucky and you work hard, then you will get your harvest. But also it's a lesson of diversification because you should have not just potato. You also should have vegetables and garden. Because like if it's like bad harvest of potato, then vegetables or apples or something. And something you will have to eat, but you can't fake that.
6:20 Harry Stebbings? Dmitry, what was your first business? You said that your first job was at sixteen. What was your first business?
6:26 Speaker 00 My first job for money was gathering of mushrooms. We had two types of kids in our village. Gatherers of berries and gatherers of mushrooms. And it was two different types of businesses. Because in case of berries, you're like just sitting on the same place in the wood. And approximately you may gather the same volume of berries per day and stable income. In case of mushrooms, you should walk around the wood. And if you're lucky, you may get much mushrooms and even a lot of money. But another day, you will get nothing. Psychologically, all kids were divided into two categories. Who prefers fixed income or who prefers like mushroom gathering?
7:11 Speaker 00 And I'm and my brother, we always were mushroom gatherers. We've always preferred like to take a chance for bigger gains and to have this journey around the wood rather than to sit on the place for fixed income.
7:27 Harry Stebbings? To me, how does this work? How do you go from mushroom gathering and farming potatoes? And that very wholesome upbringing in that respect? To founding one of the largest female? How do you get into technology first?
7:41 Speaker 00 Between mushroom gathering and founding of Flow was 20 years. It means that it was a long professional journey before we founded Flow. I spent half of my professional life in book publishing. I wrote books by myself, computer books. And then we worked with my brother for Publishing House. And then we started our own publishing house. And I spent approximately 10 years in this world, world of books. And I was responsible for approximately 2,000 titles of educational books. And honestly, I had a big pleasure from this work because it was so material. You're working with something and you're getting material result.
8:26 Speaker 00 It's almost like you're getting your baby and you may touch it. Like it was very physical pleasure is this books. And then very big change happened when App Store was opened in 2008 and 2009. And that moment, we decided to work with mobile apps. And the idea was very simple to start from content apps based on books. And then gradually, gradually, it's a longer story, but we got to Flow.
8:56 Harry Stebbings? Well, I mean, Flow was the third app that you did. You did two before Flow. What did you learn from the two before Flow not working that you took with you to Flow?
9:06 Speaker 00 Really, we had much more than two. We had two attempts to create a successful period tracker. But before Flow, me and my brother and partners, we started two dozen different apps. Some of them successfully, some of them less successfully. Overall, my brother and me, like we participated, I participated in different projects for a different extent. We had success with these apps. We had six exits up to this moment. We had exit to Google, exit to Facebook. We started several companies with revenue hundred million, fifty million.
9:51 Speaker 00 Means that it was like quite a journey before Flow. It was five, six years of work before Flow. It was not so simple, then we just like decided, we would create successful period tracker and we just started and it was immediate success. But even with our experience, got success with Flow from the first attempt. Like the first period tracker failed, the second period tracker failed and just.
10:20 Harry Stebbings? Why did they fail?
10:21 Speaker 00 These apps were too complicated. And what we definitely learned from experience with consumer facing products, that for consumers, simplicity is the most significant. It's much more significant than number of features, it's much more significant than anything. Simplicity is the key of success in consumer facing products. Probably we created this first apps being beautiful, sophisticated, but too complicated for people. It's my theory, but honestly, nobody knows. It's always very irrational at the beginning.
10:59 Harry Stebbings? When we look at Flow, you break many rules. We're often told, when it comes to an idea, choose a problem that you've personally felt and can really empathize with. With respect, Dimitri, you're wonderful, but you know, you don't empathize with period tracking. Is that bad advice to choose a problem that you know?
11:22 Speaker 00 I would say that any general advice is bad. Any general advice is bullshit. Every time when you say something like any sentence with every each like any general advice is bad. This advice is bad as well because this advice is just like it assumes that each situation is the same. But no, no, no, like life is very nuanced and each situation is very different. And usually when people ask this question, they assume two different questions. One question is, if it's not about your own pain, how did you find motivation?
12:03 Speaker 00 And if it's not your pain, how did you find knowledge? And motivation, I always wanted to do something meaningful. It was about books, it was about our other health apps. I have never had any motivation, for example, to work in gambling. If you propose me one bill and I would not take a CEO position in gambling companies, just like I just don't want. It's against my values and I don't have any interest to that. And we understood very well the size of problem because we had experience with health and fitness apps before. But question about knowledge, we didn't have knowledge. But also we had humility to understand that we didn't have knowledge.
12:48 Speaker 00 And because of that, we started to analyze and we started to listen users and doctors. And I remember that before starting FLO, our document about this market and potential product had 700 pages. And still, we are making still all decisions based on data and based on user research. We have done in FLO more than 1,000 of user researchers. We have user researcher in each product team. And we are talking with users all the time. Then we combine that with data from the app and we are making decisions objectively. And it was our way to make a good product for users without any own knowledge about this field.
13:30 Speaker 00 To listen users and doctors very, very carefully and be very humble about own knowledge.
13:36 Harry Stebbings? How do you think about the Henry Ford quote, which is, if I listen to my customers, I'd build a faster horse?
13:43 Speaker 00 I think it may be right about absolutely new category of something. But when we started our product, our market was enough big and already formed. We had hundreds of competitors and some of them big and some of them raised a significant capital. And for example, let's mention one of our competitors, Glow. It was started by Max Levchin, like a key member of PayPal Mafia. They raised from Anderson Horowitz and Founders Fund 30 million almost immediately. They started three years before Flow. And we had such competitors and it was rather formed market. It was not empty market, but it was also opportunity to learn from them.
14:27 Speaker 00 It was good opportunity to not to be a newcomer, but have advantage to learn from other products. What did you learn from them and why did you beat them? I would say that it's very similar at the beginning with Race. All cars starts approximately at the same point or the same point and all cars are the same. And then you need like a little advantage. But then when you're making many, many, many rounds, like you're getting more and more distance. It means that it's almost kind of bifurcation point. You're getting a little advantage at the beginning and then in years your advantage is becoming huge. And the ultimate reason behind that, that it's a flywheel.
15:12 Speaker 00 Like it's like just accumulative effect of many things. And at the beginning, like our apps were honestly pretty much similar. But then probably we did some good product decisions. We got additional resources and we started to invest your product much more than our competitors. We invested to product, not just to product. Up to this moment, 150 million. We mostly had engineers in Eastern Europe, like to understand that in standards of UK or United States, you should multiply that on two. And then we created this big flow, this super app because of this investment. And this product became so good, so much better than competitors, then it won naturally.
15:56 Speaker 00 But at the beginning, all our products were almost the same and difference was very tiny.
16:01 Harry Stebbings? So I'm an investor and we chatted before about some of your views on VCs, which was entertaining. I don't like competitive markets, Dmitry, because I think it's very hard to stand out. I think your customer acquisition costs are high, your churn is high, product marketing is difficult. And I find them challenging to invest in. What would you say to me with that mindset?
16:21 Speaker 00 It's good to have good competitors because you have much opportunity to learn from them and good competition speed up your own company because you just feel this competition, your team feels this competition, team is not getting complacent. Pretty much like a fixed pie mentality that I should have a monopoly to take this pie. No, when you have good competition, pie is getting bigger because products are better, customers are more educated and total market is getting bigger. Of course, nobody wants to be in this kind of red blood, like red blood ocean market when you have tiny margin and a ton of competition.
17:04 Speaker 00 But in case if it's normal competition, it's good, it's good.
17:10 Harry Stebbings? So when you first launched this V3 of Flow, having had the two which didn't work so well, and the simplified Flow, did you have immediate product market fit? Take me to that.
17:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, and that moment when we launched Flow, maybe one month ago, I immediately understood that it had chance to become really big because of retention. I saw like a retention I had never seen before and we had many apps. I just combined two numbers, like total rest of our market, women, and retention. And I understood that potential is tremendous by combination of these two metrics. And retention is really rare in health and fitness, pretty naturally, because retention is not about product. Retention is about user case. What many people don't understand is retention is not about product.
18:03 Speaker 00 Retention is about user case. It means that you may create the perfect app for gym, fitness app. And perfect app for gym will have terrible retention. Why? Because gyms themselves have terrible retention. You know, this is like a gym business model, like to sell 1,000 membership for a gym with capacity in 100 people, because gyms know that like 900 people would never visit. And why apps would work better than gyms? Of course, it's about nature of people, they wouldn't. It's so rare to see good retention in health and fitness. And when I saw that, I understood that it will be very huge.
18:40 Harry Stebbings? What was it about the retention numbers that you can share that gave you such confidence? Was it the D7, which is the day seven, the D14, the D28? Was it the daily usage? What was it which made you go, wow, we have something?
18:54 Speaker 00 That's about long-term retention, long-term retention. It means that how many users stays for six months and more.
19:02 Harry Stebbings? D180, which is six months, what was it?
19:05 Speaker 00 It's again, retention is user case. Like you may improve retention by good product, or you may destroy retention by bad product. But the essence of retention is natural user case. And natural user case, based on natural, nasty for women to organize life, round cycle. What's, you can't skip that. You may skip gym, but you can't skip period. And because of that, retention is very good. But then our big idea was, okay, if it's so unique and retention is so high, could we build something more valuable than period tracker based on that? And the ultimate reason why Flo became so successful was this idea of like kind of super app.
19:50 Speaker 00 Let's take period tracker as a core product. And let's surround this period tracker by deep, more valuable health features and content. And the period tracker would become a driver of user acquisition and most significantly retention. But all these features around would create value. It's something similar on Gmail ecosystem. Like Gmail itself drives acquisition and retention. But this apps for documents, editing, for calls, etc, drives value. But if you take out email, it would not work. And the same with period tracker. But if you don't have this ecosystem, it's not monetizable, because the value is just too tiny.
20:30 Harry Stebbings? Did you know that from day one?
20:32 Speaker 00 I think we concluded that very, very early and significantly because of our deep analysis of the market. I recently reviewed my first deck for our sit around in 2016, and this idea of big like super app based on pure tracker was already in this document. It means that it was very early idea. It just took like nine years and 150 million of just product investment. She created and probably that moment we didn't anticipate that it would take so long and so much money.
21:08 Harry Stebbings? So then you have this moment of wow, we actually have something. The six month retention is incredible. How were you acquiring customers at that point? Customer acquisition from zero to a million is very hard. You have little brand, you have little word of mouth. How were you acquiring customers and what did that look like?
21:25 Speaker 00 The most significant was to create the best product. And the best product means that users were happy and they were providing good ratings. And then system of promotion of app store and Google Play started to work because they have algorithms which promote good apps. And they usually look on retention, average rating, other parameters. And if your app is really good, it's like you're like algorithms promoting your app at the top. The same as with website. And because the product was good, we got our first traffic just organically. But it was general traffic based on kind of searches like pure tracker.
22:08 Speaker 00 But then when because of retention, we started to get big and big and big audience. Then vault of mouse started to work. And vault of mouse is the single predictable way how to get organic traffic. Because if you have a big mall, then people would advise your product. And then you would start to get organic traffic. And now we have most like organic traffic because of vault of mouse rather than because of such general, generalistic searches like pure tracker. But again, if you ask me. What's prerequisite of organic traffic? I would say retention is prerequisite of organic traffic. Because first you need to get active audience. Users should get happy.
22:53 Speaker 00 They will start to advise your product. And then you will get organic traffic. And probably the biggest question is how to get like an initial audience. In our case, we got them organically. But in new reality, probably you must buy them. It's less realistic nowadays to get initial audience organically.
23:11 Harry Stebbings? So that was gonna be my question, which is like, do you believe then if you build it, they will come? Or is that not the case? And you actually have to have a completely paid strategy today?
23:20 Speaker 00 It's much more difficult nowadays than it used to be 10 years ago. Much more difficult. Sometimes it happens and were often because of virality. But in most of cases, you need to start this process by paid user acquisition. But if your product is shitty, it will not be helpful.
23:42 Harry Stebbings? How long did it take you to get to a million users?
23:44 Speaker 00 One year.
23:45 Harry Stebbings? Was that much quicker than you anticipated?
23:49 Speaker 00 Probably. But also, I remember again from this first deck for Sidround. And as I understood, you met with our first investor, Flynn Capital.
24:01 Harry Stebbings? Andrew.
24:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, Andrew from Flynn Capital. In this deck, you know, like you're always exaggerating your future in decks from for venture capital. We didn't believe in these numbers. And you probably shouldn't. When you're presenting that to investors and we said, ah, like in 2020 or 2022, we will have three or four million monthly users. And three million in revenue and company will cost 20 million. Probably real numbers like 10 times bigger at least.
24:36 Harry Stebbings? Why did you get it so wrong? What did you not see?
24:39 Speaker 00 I didn't think that we would get big share of the market so fast. Because market was formed and competitive. And I didn't have hope to get big share of this market with hundreds of competitors easily. But it happened.
24:57 Harry Stebbings? Do you really think that is just because you had a better product?
25:00 Speaker 00 Ultimately, yes, because up to the very recent times, we didn't spend money for paid user acquisition. It was organic growth and it was organic growth because users liked our products and the metrics of our product were so good that App Store and Google Play were promoting it. But we started to spend like more or less significant money for paid user acquisition, maybe in 2020, 2021, before that it was like rather minuscule volume.
25:30 Harry Stebbings? Why did you decide to spend on paid then?
25:33 Speaker 00 Because we started monetization and when we got monetization, it was just like kind of you put money and you get money back. You put money, you can get money back.
25:44 Harry Stebbings? I spoke to some of your team and they said, well, not a weakness, but you know, something interesting about Dmitry is he doesn't love brand or PR. It's an interesting point because most do actually. Why don't you like brand or PR?
25:58 Speaker 00 I don't understand what is brand. And once I tried to understand, maybe two years ago, I was in the process of hiring of Chief Marketing Officer and I had maybe 30 different candidates to meet. I was asking the same question, what's the brand by your opinion, to 30 different seniors and I got 30 different answers.
26:19 Harry Stebbings? Can I, can I give you mine?
26:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
26:21 Harry Stebbings? I think it's like the way that it makes the customer feel. How they feel when they see your logo, when they touch your product, that is your brand. What they, what they say when you're out of the room?
26:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, I just don't feel that I understand well this topic and we're often people, they, there are two words people use for everything and for any situation and we're often without any meaning, two placeholders, is brand and culture. You may describe everything by brand and you may describe everything by culture, but usually it doesn't have any sense and you need to ask clarifying questions because you always may say, our situation is bad because we have bad brand or our situation is bad because we have bad culture. Yeah, it describes everything and nothing. And talking about PR. I think it's slightly different.
27:13 Speaker 00 It's mostly about my internal belief that product defines everything. And I always very frugal in spending money out of product. It means I'm very generous in spending money for product and I'm very frugal, very greedy to spend money not for product. And when I see kind of budget for something like several hundred thousand and I don't understand the impact, I bet I would spend this money for product and I take this money and move this money to product. Sometimes even up to extremes. For example, I never use business class because all the time, and I am running a company
27:54 Speaker 00 with 200 million in revenue, probably it's the time to start using business class for the CEO. But I never use business class even in my trips to the United States, even Seattle or San Francisco, because all the time I'm thinking, okay, 5, 10,000. I would better to pay one month of salary to developer in Lithuania than to waste this money for my comfort. And I was like, take this money and put this money to product. It's my philosophy that product defines everything.
28:24 Harry Stebbings? I don't think I've ever had a CEO like you on the show. Honestly, you are one of the most humble people I've ever had on this show. And I've done 10 years of this show. Do you think there's ever a point where that holds you back? You know, Flow is a massive brand now. People care about the Flow brand. Do you think that the hesitation to spend money on billboards, brand, marketing is going to hold you back?
28:49 Speaker 00 Maybe, but many ways to be successful. It's a very simplistic way of thinking that, ah, this manual how to run a company, like page 100.
29:01 Speaker 00 Do that, page 110, do that. If you look on history of any company or any CEO, you would see that everything is so nuanced, everything is so unique, every journey is so unique. And nothing you may say like kind of you should do that and you shouldn't do that. Like you just should understand your strengths, you should understand your way, you should not do something what's natural, not natural for you. And but then like thousands of ways to be successful and you just should choose your way to be successful and make your company successful.
29:35 Harry Stebbings? One big piece of advice that's often given in startups, Dimitri, is speed is everything and you've got to move really fast. And that's the secret to success in the early days. Do you agree with that?
29:47 Speaker 00 I would say that the most significant early days is not to die too early. Because usually you need to iterate several times to find something what works. And if you increase speed, but you waste your resources on the way, probably it's a bad advice. If you combine your speed with right spending of resources and you just you have your one million and it's enough to make three, four, five iterations rather than one, then speed is the right word. But I would not say that it's about speed. It's about right distribution of resources to have several chances for success.
30:24 Harry Stebbings? I completely agree. It's about the number of at-bats you have. That means that you need to raise, in often cases, with consumer, quite a large seed round. How big was your seed round?
30:35 Speaker 00 300,000, valuation was 3 million. But remember, company was in Belarus and it was 10 years ago. Like it's everything was much cheaper. But you may believe that it's extremely good.
30:48 Harry Stebbings? 300,000 at 3 million?
30:50 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. And company now costs like more than one billion. It means that it's 300 x to this investment, if I'm calculating well.
30:58 Harry Stebbings? Oh, my God.
31:01 Harry Stebbings? Wow. Take me to that. How was the seed round?
31:04 Speaker 00 I think it was more kind of they just decided to invest to us.
31:11 Speaker 00 Because we had success before with apps and it was not like a so big belief in our idea, but more believe that this guy will figure out something because they had success before. And I think they had arguments because it was so contrary an idea, but probably it was the best or one of the best investment for the fund in history of this fund. You're like a seed round investor, real estate investors, you just need one investment like that in your life and you're done. You can see like you will be rich.
31:46 Harry Stebbings? Yeah, that's the business model of venture capital, Dmitry. That's why it's a regular business. It's one of the only businesses in the world where you can do a hundred things and mess up ninety nine of them. Can you imagine if I told you you can do ninety nine versions of flow and ninety nine can be, ninety eight can be shit? But one's good.
32:04 Speaker 00 But it's to the question, what is the most required trait of the founder? And my personal opinion that founder must be crazy. Because if you are smart and you may understand your odds, why would you decide to start something with chances of success like one, two, three, four, five percent? Like it's better to play lottery. Like smart people, they work in McKinsey. And founders, they're crazy. Because it's not rational, you're just crazy. Like you can't justify that by any rational thinking. Why would you do something with odds of success in one percent?
32:44 Harry Stebbings? I worry that that is no longer the case. I agree with you. Crazy and obsessed. I'm not too dissimilar to you in these ways. I'm crazy and obsessed. I could have been a lawyer and paid very happily and instead I decided to do a podcast, which made no money, but I love what we do. My worry is there's so much money in venture capital that if you're smart enough, you can be a founder, play the founder game, play startups, get paid quite well and try it. It's a free option.
33:17 Speaker 00 We didn't have such luxury in our days because...
33:21 Harry Stebbings? But do you see what I mean? Do you worry that it's the same now where we don't have crazy founders like you?
33:27 Speaker 00 I think times have come back. It was a period of time between approximately 2019 to 2022 when it was true. But nowadays it's quite difficult to raise capital. It's quite difficult. It's again the same.
33:46 Harry Stebbings? Was there ever an easy round to raise?
33:49 Speaker 00 No, it's never easy.
33:50 Harry Stebbings? But your numbers were so good. I saw your numbers in Sensor Tower. I tweeted about our show and I got all of these data providers send me your numbers. And they are consistently great.
34:02 Speaker 00 Because venture capital investment is a default no game. And you may be very good, but in any case you will get 100 no's to get one yes. And what's the most difficult for founders is being this mindset when you every day you're getting no, no, no, no, no. And it's soul breaking. It's really difficult. Even layoffs are simpler because layoffs is like computation cut and you're just in two or three weeks and you continue your work. But fundraising is just like it's each day you're getting no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
34:44 Speaker 00 And you're starting to lose belief in yourself and you're starting to feel that maybe I'm not the right person.
34:53 Harry Stebbings? Did you lose belief in yourself?
34:55 Speaker 00 I had moments when I doubted that maybe we are doing something wrong and maybe I'm not the right person. And for me fundraising was also much more difficult because of my origins, my accent. And because I'm kind of not a kind of right profile and I was pretty weird type for investors. It made my job of fundraising much more difficult.
35:20 Harry Stebbings? Do you think that made your job much more difficult? Do you think respectfully, if you sounded like me, as we said, loo not toy? Do you think that would have been easier?
35:29 Speaker 00 Much easier, much easier, because investors, especially in big funds, you usually start your conversation not with partners or managing partners, but with analysts or with principals. And these people usually have profile kind of graduated in Harvard, and being in Stanford, or graduated in Stanford, and being in Harvard. And they believe in people like them, and they don't believe in people like me. And it's really difficult to breach this barrier of this elite, because they really kind of sort you out.
36:12 Speaker 00 And I understand, like, there's like, there are many talkings about this problem that it's so difficult to minorities of any kind race. And I may say that it's true, it's true. Because you just sorted out at this level of right people.
36:33 Harry Stebbings? So I'm gonna get in trouble for this. I think you are much less fundable than a minority woman from Stanford.
36:41 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, yeah, of course, of course, of course. And it's easier nowadays when we have proven that our product is monetizable and we may achieve success. But it was really difficult at the beginning when I had combination of my weird personality and all the combination of disbelief in our model, in our product, because we didn't have benchmarks to show that I look like this success and will make the same success. Because it was first product of such kind and nobody believed that it's possible to build something monetizable or successful.
37:21 Harry Stebbings? God, I wish we met when you were fundraising it below a billion dollars. My question to you is, okay, so then we start monetization. That's a new game. We've got to prove that we can make money now. We've proved that we've got users who love it. How did monetization go? Right, we turn it on. How did it go?
37:37 Speaker 00 Monetization is interesting because, and I'm coming back to our discussion about brand and PR. Our big mistake at the very beginning was belief that it's enough to create value and people would buy. But then we started to understand that also we need to sell. We need to explain product. We need to experiment. We started to do that and just one number. Conversion to premium on onboarding increased in several years, eight times, 800% because of optimization, because of hundreds of A B tests and because of this approach that we should not just create value, we need to explain value, we need to sell.
38:19 Speaker 00 And it was huge shift in mindset in the company. Because before that, you're like, ah, it's significant, it's just to create the best product and people will see and buy. No, no, you also should explain why they should buy. Even Apple spent much resources to explain that you're not like arriving to shop and you're getting your iPhone in gray boxes. It should be beautiful, it should be very attractive. And the same with monetization. It's a balance between value and how you sell this value. And you should find proper balance between that. You may be too focused on selling, like over promise.
39:00 Speaker 00 Or you may be like us, we did at the beginning, you may create value, but you may undersell. And everything should be right. It should be right balance.
39:09 Harry Stebbings? I think you consistently undersell. I spoke to many of your investors and they said that you're their best founder, but you undersell yourself consistently. When you think about how to sell value and you produce value and then there's how to sell it. What did you learn about how to sell value through the monetization process?
39:28 Speaker 00 First question about this comment that I can't sell myself. I think it's pretty natural because of my imposter syndrome and inferiority complex. And I'm not even playing, it's my pretty natural state. But also I think it's my superpower because I'm always so, so insecure about my position, position of the company, that I'm always trying to do my job the best. Because I never feel comfortable and it's my pretty natural state. And I believe that a big part of my success is just because of my imposter syndrome. And it's like strange way you get your superpower, but it's what is true.
40:13 Harry Stebbings? Has that got better with time? The flow now does 200 million in revenue. It is, is worth over a billion dollars. Do you have less imposter syndrome?
40:23 Speaker 00 No, no, absolutely the same. I would even say that I'm getting more anxiety because now my responsibilities are even bigger. Always like for me, this round was kind of, you may imagine that it's like a sport when you're jumping like through the bar and, and when you, when you're progressing, you put your bar high and higher. And one moment, my bar became one meter high and I look on this bar and it's, and worrying like, could I jump so high? Couldn't I, at least I will make the best attempt.
40:57 Harry Stebbings? I love it. It's just so right. You know, we interview a lot of American founders, Dmitry, and the humility that you have is, is not shared by a lot of them. What were the biggest challenges then as you started to scale monetization? What really became tough?
41:11 Speaker 00 What really changed, what we didn't understand when we started monetization seven years ago, that habit to pay of people for subscription is changing. Because when we started monetization, our dream was, oh, maybe we would monetize 5% of American audience. Because that time it was quite a bar. Now we monetized maybe if you exclude teenagers, 25, 30% of our American audience. And we don't see that. That monetization is slowing down. But it's not just because the product is becoming better. It's true. It's not just because of experimentation was true. It's also because people accepted the idea to pay for subscriptions. And it was huge cultural change.
41:54 Speaker 00 And without that, it would be impossible. It's cultural shift.
41:58 Harry Stebbings? Did you test pricing a lot? I know what a data-driven culture you have. When you look at the pricing that you have, what are your biggest lessons that you have from pricing?
42:08 Speaker 00 The biggest lesson from pricing is that you should not make your decision just based on price. You should understand the full funnel. Because you may increase your price, but you would decrease retention or activation, or you would destroy your user acquisition. And then your ultimate revenue would be smaller. It means that ultimately you should decide based on top line and bottom line in your P and L and optimized for that. And then all this internal parameters, you should look on them together. Because you should optimize the function of many variables. If you talk about mathematics, because it's not just about optimizing of price.
42:50 Speaker 00 It's about optimizing of five, six variables simultaneously. And you should optimize them to find like the best combination when you're getting the most revenue from your product.
43:01 Harry Stebbings? Can I ask, on the freemium versus premium split, what have been some big lessons in how to provide enough value in freemium, where they retain and they love your product, but also keep enough value in premium, where they're willing to pay for it and make that transition?
43:18 Speaker 00 It's not just experimentation. Usually we decided that based on experiments, when we are creating something and we're deciding to make it for put behind payroll, we are testing to see how it would influence revenue, but also how it would influence retention. And for us, it's always balance of two metrics. And we would never accept an experiment, which would increase revenue a lot, but also which would destroy retention. And it's a combination of these two metrics. The best is like when retention is the same, but revenue is growing.
43:55 Harry Stebbings? So when did we know monetization was working? When did you look at it and go, okay, we've got a good machine here?
44:01 Speaker 00 In case of subscription monetization, the most significant is retention. Because if you are very good in selling, you may convince people to pay for almost anything. But much more tricky is that you provide so good service and they would continue paying. Retention should be good and it's the main sign of success of this business model. But this business model, I believe, is the best model to create good product because your incentives are aligned with user. Because user pay just when you create long-term value and it motivates you to create long-term value. Because if, for example, you monetize your product, I don't know, by one-time payment,
44:45 Speaker 00 then you would optimize for conversion. If you monetize your product by advertising, probably you would try to increase engagement as possible, what we see in media. But in case of subscription, you're really optimized for value because your model works just when users stay and continue to pay for years. Or it would be just a trade meal and you would exhaust growth very, very fast.
45:06 Harry Stebbings? So we have that monetization engine working. How long did it take to get to a million in revenue?
45:12 Speaker 00 Million? Million is very simple. Million is very simple. Like 100 million is much more difficult. So millions is very, very simple.
45:21 Harry Stebbings? How long did it take to get to 100 million in revenue?
45:23 Speaker 00 Four years, maybe.
45:25 Harry Stebbings? Wow.
45:26 Speaker 00 But we had substantial audience when we started monetization. Because we started monetization in 2018 and product existed for three years up to this moment.
45:35 Harry Stebbings? How many users did you have when you started that monetization journey?
45:39 Speaker 00 Maybe 15, 20 million monthly active users.
45:42 Harry Stebbings? That's incredible. Is there anything that you do differently about how you launched monetization? Now you know everything that you do.
45:49 Speaker 00 I would do that much earlier because... Start of monetization unlocked for us flywheel of value creation and it's very simple. When you start monetization, you're getting revenue and you may use this revenue to build product or to raise bigger round and then you create better product and flywheel starts to work because you invest more and more and more and distance between you and competitors is getting bigger and bigger. And when you don't have monetization, you should be very scrappy and development is very frugal and development is very slow.
46:22 Harry Stebbings? I completely hear you on retention being so important to any consumer app. My question to you is bluntly, given the use case being periods, it's probably one of the only use cases in consumer that is literally, you know, you can't avoid it, you know, anything from like eating, you can fast, you can gym, you can not go to the gym. Is this a one-off case that can't be replicated?
46:47 Speaker 00 In health and fitness, it's difficult to find the cases with good retention. There are some cases, for example, wearable devices, they have very good retention just because you have physicalism and...
47:00 Harry Stebbings? Have you thought about doing devices?
47:02 Speaker 00 No, no, no, no, because you always should be focused, you always should be focused. Once I got very good lesson from Vinat Hostla, like founder of Hostla Ventures many years ago. And that moment, our company was big enough and we had many ideas how to build our product and many ideas for monetization, like because audience was big and I was speaking to him, describing we may do that, that and that and that. And at the end of my pitch, I asked him like, Vinat, you have very experience, could you give me just one advice, but the most valuable you think for me? And he said, young man, business and product building is very similar to marriage.
47:46 Speaker 00 You have many opportunities before your marriage, but to be happy, you should choose one and really focus. And my advice to you, choose one business model and be really focused. And I learned this lesson and I was very focused since and I had a huge resistance to all proposals to take any other opportunities.
48:08 Harry Stebbings? I love that and Vinod's fantastic. My question to you is, does the super app not go against focus? Because with the super app mentality, you are building multiple products in the same time simultaneously versus purely focusing on one product at a time. Are they paradoxical?
48:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, for some extent, but you may solve this problem by org structure. You may create teams which solely focused on own part of the product and for them it's a single product and they have full focus on this product. And in our company, each team has own part of product to own. Then you have like a difficulty to combine all these parts to the single experience and it's not easy, it's very challenging, but it's the way how to have focus in the case of a super app.
48:56 Harry Stebbings? What have been the biggest lessons in how to create that synchronicity between the different parts?
49:02 Speaker 00 It's extremely difficult. We're still struggling.
49:06 Harry Stebbings? Is that the biggest weakness that you have today, do you think?
49:09 Speaker 00 I think it's really significant to save simplicity of our product because each year we have deep research of our user base, what's the most significant for them in our product and for seven or eight years in a row, the most popular answer is simplicity, simplicity, nothing else. And the biggest mistake we may do is, we may do is to destroy this simplicity because it's the essence of our success and it's the essence of success for any product. And it's really difficult to have simplicity when you have so many features and when you have this concept of super app.
49:47 Harry Stebbings? It is, it's one of the hardest things. It's how do you prevent feature creep with time and stay simple over time? So we have that success with monetization. Now we get to the series A and the B. How were the series As and Bs?
50:01 Speaker 00 It was always difficult and...
50:05 Harry Stebbings? Did you enjoy the meetings or not, Rani?
50:07 Speaker 00 No, because you need to meet hundreds of investors and repeat the same. And at some moment it's just boring. Like you're just repeating the same, the same, again, again, again, again. It's just boring.
50:20 Harry Stebbings? Was there one or two that stood out?
50:22 Speaker 00 I'm not trying to flatter them, but really impressed by General Atlantic. And at the end of this process, we had five bidders. And I had really big hope that General Atlantic would not provide a bad term sheet because they showed so much better understanding of our business model and showed so deeper approaches. And they really impressed me by the depths of work. And I'm really happy by this outcome. I'm not even flattering, it's not my nature, but I was kind of praying.
50:56 Harry Stebbings? What did they do to impress you so much?
50:58 Speaker 00 Firstly, they had very deep understanding of our business model because of previous investment to Doleingo and Chascom and similar companies. And it's really rare to see investor with deep understanding of consumer subscriptions because there are not so many successful consumer subscriptions and just several public companies based on this business model. And most investors, they just don't understand this business model. They confuse it with SaaS and they're making very wrong conclusions because of that.
51:28 Harry Stebbings? What are the wrong conclusions that I would make comparing it to SaaS?
51:33 Speaker 00 You may apply the idea that retention should be very high because if you lose your customer, you lose it forever. And it's a fact for B2B, but it's not the fact for B2C. Because in B2C, in case of consumer face maps, customers come, customers go, customers come back, customers go. We already have maybe forty percent of installs from users who used our app previously. And because of that, you should analyze not retention itself, but retention of revenue, for example. You should analyze how cohort behave in time and what revenue you're getting because of this behavior that people are coming back and forth, they stop subscription, they start subscription.
52:17 Speaker 00 You just can't apply this very simplistic logic of business SaaS that if people pay and then they charge, they will never come back or they will never start paying again. It means that logic in analysis of retention should be very different.
52:32 Harry Stebbings? Do you think the consumer multiple hit that happens with consumer revenue is fair? So if we look at, say, flow, two hundred million and a billion, that's a five X. That is much lower than traditional enterprise software companies would be afforded. Sad to admit that I'm invested in a SaaS business that is at seven million in ARR and valued at one point three billion.
52:56 Speaker 00 I think for current market, we may check this number, but average multiple to revenue for public SaaS at this moment is close to eight. And it was five last year and it was thirty or so in twenty twenty one. It means that it's declined five or six times as well. Means that.
53:17 Harry Stebbings? Do you think that's right?
53:18 Speaker 00 Oh, it's market, it's a market is.
53:23 Harry Stebbings? But like, do you think we underappreciate consumer revenue?
53:26 Speaker 00 In a rational world, you can't have in twenty twenty one multiple thirty forty and in twenty twenty two multiple five for the same company. Like it's market is not rational, it's market, but market.
53:43 Harry Stebbings? There's a brilliant statement, which is the market can stay irrational longer than your company can stay solvent.
53:49 Speaker 00 Uh, yeah, yeah, it's a because of that, like even kind of conversation about like what's fair price is useless because markets are rational. Like nothing is rational that there's like a few years difference between two events. And in one event, this company cost thirty revenues and in another event, five revenues. So I understand like you may understand crisis, you may understand that rate was two percent higher or two percent lower. But it's not like a reason why company would cost like five or six times higher or lower. It means that it's just a reflection that markets are very irrational and prices. Irrational as well. And again, it's a question when you're making justification of future value of the company
54:33 Speaker 00 based on current market multiples. Are you trying to lie to yourself or so, because who knows if markets change dynamic five times in two years?
54:45 Harry Stebbings? Do you think in five years' time we'll have five plus ten billion dollar consumer subscription companies? We have Duolingo today, which is kind of nine, nine and a half, I believe.
54:53 Speaker 00 Maybe today ten, I need to check. Yesterday it was almost ten.
54:57 Harry Stebbings? Okay, so let's give it a ten. Let's say we give it a ten. But that's kind of it.
55:01 Speaker 00 We will have them because this business model is growing. And you may just check numbers of Apple and you may see that Apple got from consumer subscription in two thousand seventeen and five billion. And it's projected that we'll get maybe one hundred billion or so next year. So model is growing and because model is growing, then we'll have huge companies.
55:27 Harry Stebbings? Do you think VCs provide value?
55:29 Speaker 00 Of course.
55:30 Harry Stebbings? What value do you think we provide?
55:32 Speaker 00 We have one.
55:36 Speaker 00 Maybe I may share because he joked in Twitter, we have a early stage investor, Nikita Beer, very nice product.
55:46 Harry Stebbings? You have Nikita as an investor?
55:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, like a small investor, but he invested early. He joked recently, the single role of investor is that he outreach entrepreneur and then entrepreneur have the full energy to prove investors that he's wrong. And so of course it's a joke, but it's partly true. But I would say that a good investor may create ton of value by proper work in the board. And good board brings ton of value and the biggest value from the board that you're just accountable. And you have moments of truth, like board meetings, when you need to make proper reflection, prepare proper materials and explain future, explain past.
56:31 Speaker 00 And without board meetings, you would never have patience or energy to do that. But when you have such moments of reflection. Then your business is getting better because you're just reflecting all the time and good investors, they've been part of the board, they may provide good advice, they may make you better. It's almost kind of if you have like a like coach, like what's the difference between having a coach or visiting a gym by yourself?
56:54 Harry Stebbings? Accountability.
56:55 Speaker 00 Accountability, accountability is really significant for success.
56:58 Harry Stebbings? What do annoying VCs do? I want to be the best VC. We joked about me being a VC in my ninth year, but I want to be the best VC and I care passionately about that. If you were to advise me, Harry, I've met hundreds of VCs who've said, no, don't do these things. What would those things be?
57:15 Speaker 00 If you meet like a first time entrepreneur, start your pitch from explaining that it's normal and it's default play for VCs to say no and it's nothing personal and you should just like understand the rules of games and just like put on your wall, I will get 100 no's and each time you're getting no, like put like just one line and you should be very, very, you should understand the rules of the game and it should not be like a personal for you because you should that your person say no.
57:50 Harry Stebbings? When you get no's, I get no's, I fundraised too for my funds. When I get a no, I'm going to prove you fucking wrong.
57:57 Speaker 00 It's very, very significant driving force for success in the case of many people.
58:03 Harry Stebbings? Is it for you?
58:05 Speaker 00 For some extent, it was more significant for me at the beginning because at the beginning, all people around were so skeptical about our business and idea and not just investors. And I had this bitterness all the time that I didn't have any understanding of our vision and any support. And then when we proved that our ideas are worth and this is a good sustainable business, then it became easy.
58:32 Harry Stebbings? Do you feel vindicated now for everyone who didn't believe in you? Do you feel?
58:38 Speaker 00 No, because I'm just trying like look like being just like rational like some like weird folks from Belarus starting a root tracker and promising that it will become unicorn. And there are no like examples of that. And why would you believe in that? Like, nobody who is rational would believe in that. It's it was now it's so evident, but at that moment, it was pretty rational not to believe.
59:06 Harry Stebbings? I get you. It's just sad. Our job is to believe in the outliers. It's to believe the best in people. That's that's how I view our job.
59:13 Speaker 00 The main job of early stage investor to distinguish cases with 100% of failure, with cases 99% of failure, and cases with small potential outcome and big potential outcome. And you should find cases when failure is not 100% guaranteed and the potential outcome is big. And it means that for you is the most significant is to understand that the team is not stupid. They know what they do. And by that, you would reduce your chances of failure from 99% to 95%. But then market should be big because it's impossible to
59:56 Speaker 00 get this proportional outcome from small market.
59:59 Harry Stebbings? Big market. You have a huge market. I spoke to Jessie at GA before this. She said, ask him, how does Flow go from a $1 billion company to a $10 billion company?
1:00:10 Speaker 00 I might answer this question just using like benchmarks, for example, what's the difference between Flow and Doleingo? Partially, it's a scale of revenue. We have 200 million, they have 600 million, and it's achievable in several years for us to be in the range of 600 million. We have approximately the same.
1:00:30 Harry Stebbings? Why is that multiple so much better than yours?
1:00:33 Speaker 00 Because it's a public company which simultaneously is growing very fast top line and bottom line. They have simultaneously 40, 50% of top line growth and they have very nice profitability growth. And it's extremely rare to.
1:00:48 Speaker 00 See such companies as a public companies like just old rule of forty. And you rarely see like rule of forty, like fifty, sixty at the public markets. And all the like people believe that they still have good potential for expansion. Because there are so many learners of foreign languages in the world. I think combination of these two factors, but I think mostly it's just because combination of forty percent top line growth and the twenty and the growth of the proportional growth of profitability is so rare. And it means that if you want to cost ten billion, we probably should achieve six hundred million in revenue and then show profitability and continue growing with the same pace.
1:01:30 Harry Stebbings? Can I invest now?
1:01:32 Speaker 00 Uh, no, it's difficult.
1:01:36 Harry Stebbings? Listen, my job is to be a VC, Dmitry. It's got to be worth a try, right? Can I ask you a bit of a weird one on your leadership? Do you think you're a good CEO and how have you changed as a leader over time?
1:01:46 Speaker 00 I have a nice story for you.
1:01:49 Speaker 00 When I was in Stanford Business School, we had one lesson with famous professor of management. He did like the next exercise. He started to ask people in the room, what is the more, what is the necessary trait of a good CEO? And people started to say like, oh, this, like good CEO should, CEO should be knowledgeable. Good CEO should have integrity. Good CEO should provide inspiration. And maybe in twenty minutes, like whiteboard was covered by different traits of good CEO. And then this professor looked on this whiteboard and said, probably even Jesus Christ was worse.
1:02:29 Speaker 00 It means that, since this lesson, that people, they're making kind of glorification of CEOs. That CEOs should be perfect, they should be almost kind of gods. But CEOs are just like the same people. And they can't be so perfect as people think they should be. You should just understand your weaknesses, your strengths. You should understand why you're useful and you should just make your proper work as good as you can.
1:02:59 Harry Stebbings? What is your biggest strength? What is your biggest weakness?
1:03:03 Speaker 00 Biggest strengths that I may analyze, I may make like a rather good conclusions.
1:03:11 Speaker 00 In very simple manner. It means that people, they need clarity and simplicity. And I think I may provide clarity and simplicity. I'm not overwhelming them by information. I may take much of information on myself. But then I provide to them like a solution, decision, description in very simple form. And they understand and believe and follow. And my, my main weakness, sometimes I may be too slow for change. The biggest events in my life happened when the life burnt my bridges. But now I understand that I should have burnt my bridges by myself. For example, I started to make apps.
1:03:52 Speaker 00 Very significant reason was that because it was crisis of 2008 and like book publishing was in terrible situation. I started to focus just on flow because my old portfolio declined because of a political situation in Richmond. And when everything was good, I was just delaying necessary change. And I was just waiting this crisis like for life to burn my bridges. And then like when necessary change happened, then I started to move.
1:04:24 Harry Stebbings? I'm fascinated on this one. You know, you, you've been very successful over the last 10 years. What does money mean to you, Dimitri?
1:04:31 Speaker 00 Honestly, not so much because I have a rather humble lifestyle. Honestly, I despise luxurious brands. I despise luxury. I even don't have car and I don't have any expensive item. I don't have anything would be branded or luxurious. I don't need like business classes or private jets. I would want to have an interesting and meaningful life and feel that I'm useful. And, and honestly, I never think about my personal money. Because I'm absolutely honest here, like never, never. Because I have so little need for myself that it's not even a kind of motivation for me.
1:05:14 Speaker 00 I'm very motivated by the story of founder of Junior Atlantic, Chuck Flynn. Do you know this story?
1:05:20 Harry Stebbings? No, please tell me.
1:05:22 Speaker 00 Uh, Chain Atlantic was started by a man who earned like a huge fortune by duty free shops, by starting duty free shops. And because of this venture, because of Chain Atlantic, he earned billions, nine billion or something like that. And then secretly, he distributed all his money for charity, absolutely secretly, nobody knew. And he died like two years ago and then the story became public that he just gifted away in his lifetime, all his money and without any proud, without sharing to anybody, absolutely secretly. And it's the best example for me how you should live your life.
1:06:03 Speaker 00 You should create something valuable commercially, but then it's your duty to return this money for society and to do that very efficiently. And I believe that if you're really successful, second part of your life should be not to earn money, but to spend your money for the sake of society. And I believe that it's a huge thing to pass billions to your children.
1:06:27 Harry Stebbings? Have you always been this good? Like you are objectively one of the kindest humans I've had on the show. Like shows like this are why I love doing what I do. I didn't expect this type of show. Have you always been like this or has it come over time?
1:06:41 Speaker 00 I just got better because of many, many, many problems and pains I had in my life. I have like a little regrets about my professional life. And my biggest regret that when I was young, when I was less sensitive, I farted several people without decency, means in rude form. And it was maybe 10, 15 years ago and I still feel guilty because of that 10 years after. Just because to feel empathy, you should get pain by yourself. And then you start to feel pain of other people.
1:07:26 Speaker 00 And it's just like a trait of age and a trait of a difficult journey. I was not like that when I was young.
1:07:33 Harry Stebbings? You also work with your brother Yuri. Not many people know this, but I work with my brother. He's sitting upstairs now. I love it, but everyone says, don't work with family. What's your biggest advice to me on how to make it work so successfully with your brother?
1:07:49 Speaker 00 Again, I repeat my advice, never take general advice. General advice is always bullshit and everything is nuanced. I worked with my brother for thirty years or so. If we start consistently like our work from mushroom gathering or potato field work. And we always work together in book publishing in all our ventures. And I remember that our first boss in a publishing house, and it was 2005 or so, we worked together in publishing house. We were responsible for computer literature. He said that you should always work together because you're so different.
1:08:31 Speaker 00 And when you combine like your personalities, it's almost perfect. Because Yuri is good to make a pass and you're good to make a road. And he understands that. And that I'm maybe too slow in deciding something, maybe indecisive. But then when I start doing something, I'm doing that perfectly. And Yuri, like he's the opposite. He's kind of idea generator, he's venture driver, but he's not operational person altogether. But when you have this combination, it's almost perfect and it works really well. But also, I have worked all my life with my wife. I married very early, like. How old were you when you got married? Twenty-one. Wow. Twenty years ago.
1:09:14 Speaker 00 She was a student in the same group in university. And she had my trust because I was very bad student because I was working and she was helping me with like advice when to visit university and with different home tasks. And she was my friend at that moment. And we started to work together. And again, we have been working together for twenty years. She was responsible for content in Flore at the beginning of Flore. And she's now my executive assistant. And we spent together, like working together twenty years and very successfully. Your wife is your EA? Yeah. How is that? That must be hard.
1:09:55 Speaker 00 No, it's very effective because we may decide like what to do or what not to do at the breakfast. That is amazing. I absolutely love that. Um, yeah, there's no way that that would work for me.
1:10:10 Harry Stebbings? Are you a wartime leader or a peacetime leader, do you think?
1:10:13 Speaker 00 I was pretty effective in both modes because I have one trait. Like, you know, there are four types of people based on the level of negative and positive emotions. Like, people who have low emotions in case of bad situation. And like, low-low, high-high, low-high, high-low. Like, it depends on are your emotions high or low in case of problems and in case of excitement. For example, if you have a huge excitement, but also like a huge stress in case of problems, probably it is difficult to be a CEO.
1:10:56 Speaker 00 And my advantage is that I'm kind of a low-low personality. It means that I never feel too much excitement, but also I never feel too much stress. And because of that, I'm just, in case of all our calamities, I was very, very calm. And I didn't have much stress, I just played my duty.
1:11:17 Harry Stebbings? What was the biggest calamity, do you think? When you look back now, what was the, oh, that was hard?
1:11:22 Speaker 00 That moment when political instability in Belarus and then war in Ukraine. And we had to relocate urgently the whole company. And also I had to relocate myself in two days. I spent thirty-eight years in Belarus and I built my life. I had like my house, my gardens, and I spent many years to grow my gardens. And then I had to make decision to move out of Belarus in two days. And I have never come back. And then the same decision most of our people had to make. And it was really difficult.
1:12:03 Speaker 00 Could you imagine that you have built all your life in countries, then in two days, you must move to another country with your family? And it was really difficult and it traumatized me and our people a lot.
1:12:18 Harry Stebbings? I can't imagine that one. I also can't imagine having to move hundred plus people, which you had to do.
1:12:24 Speaker 00 I believe even more. I believe that when war started in twenty twenty two, we had seventy percent of our employees in Belarus. It was more than two hundred and ninety percent of them were located with families in several days.
1:12:39 Harry Stebbings? How was that process?
1:12:41 Speaker 00 Really difficult because borders were closed. It was impossible to get papers and we had to organize no flights and we had to organize charters to Armenia and Turkey and then organize.
1:12:53 Harry Stebbings? You ordered charters?
1:12:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, because we didn't have flights and it was impossible to make flights to Europe because all flights were prohibited from from the region.
1:13:03 Harry Stebbings? Did the company suffer in any way? I mean.
1:13:06 Speaker 00 Of course, of course, for half a year, we didn't have any progress with our product because all people were so stressed and defocused by moving families and it was a huge, huge destruction and it was very expensive as well.
1:13:21 Harry Stebbings? How much did it cost?
1:13:22 Speaker 00 Many millions. It's very expensive, but it was significant to do because the company, it's a tech company and it's about people and this company would not exist without people. And also it was our responsibility to provide this opportunity to our people because it was quite big chance that Belarus would engage to the war and it would mean that men would be drafted and borders would be closed and it was a real risk for life for for men and we had to organize this process.
1:13:56 Harry Stebbings? What did you learn about managing teams and people through this process?
1:14:00 Speaker 00 Trust is the most significant. They should trust you. You should be a really trustful person or a company to convince ninety percent of your employees to take family and belongings from today and to move to another country. You should be really trustful for that.
1:14:17 Harry Stebbings? My question to you is, when your mother looks at you and your brother, you guys have achieved such success and when you look back to the potato farms and the mushroom picking, what did she say?
1:14:28 Speaker 00 She's not especially emotional.
1:14:34 Harry Stebbings? But she must be proud.
1:14:36 Speaker 00 She has never said that.
1:14:41 Harry Stebbings? Would you like her to?
1:14:44 Speaker 00 I don't think that it would be natural for her.
1:14:49 Harry Stebbings? I like you so much. This has been so much fun. So I'm gonna do a quick fire answer. I say a short statement and you give me your immediate thoughts. Does that sound okay? So what do you believe that most around you disbelieve?
1:15:02 Speaker 00 I don't believe in talent. I believe that all people are approximately the same. We have the same processor. What makes people different is just hours of hard work, hard focused work. And when people say to me that I can't accomplish something, asking very simple question, how many hours of hard work have you spent for that? And if it's not about thousand something, but why you think that you should achieve something without thousand of hours of hard work?
1:15:35 Harry Stebbings? You don't think smarts has got anything to do with it, like brains?
1:15:38 Speaker 00 There are always extremes, but most of people, they have plus minus the same brain. And believe me, I know many billionaires, I many, many, many successful entrepreneurs and not just entrepreneurs and have no sin geniuses. But I believe that what really distinguish successful people and people who are not successful beyond just luck, luck is really significant, is the ability to take risk and then work really, really hard and persistent for a long time. Most of people, they just can't work really hard for very long time. And it's what distinguish successful people and less successful people.
1:16:18 Harry Stebbings? Most people don't have discipline, which is you need to not go out and drink with your friends at the end of the day and go back and work. You need to come back after the 90th no and pitch for the 91st time.
1:16:30 Speaker 00 For me, the hardest time in my life was when I was in university, but also I was writing my books at nights. I usually was like working for eighteen hours per day for years and was sleeping just six hours or so, and for years. But then I achieved a lot because of that. And I have a very interesting story about my books. Like, sometimes you need to see many things in prospects and you need to put many dots on the map of your life. In 2004, I wrote like a big book about ActionScript,
1:17:15 Speaker 00 it's a programming language of Macromedia Flash. And that time, I didn't learn much from that. But approximately next year, in 2005, this book was gifted to one young boy, he was maybe twelve years old, by his brother. And he said, "If you learn programming from this book, you will become a big person." And he learned programming from this book. He started to practice Flash programming. And then, ten years after, fifteen years after, he became co-founder of MSQD, which sold to Facebook. And then he used part of this money to finance Flow. It means that if I didn't write this book in 2004,
1:17:58 Speaker 00 then probably he would not learn programming and MSQD would not happen. And then Flow would not have money to be financed. But distance between these two events was more than ten years. And in your life, you very often you just need much time to see how all lines will be connected. But you have dots to be connected. You need to have dots. You need to do something. You need to move forward.
1:18:26 Harry Stebbings? What CEO do you most admire and why them?
1:18:30 Speaker 00 I'm against glamorization of CEOs and making them heroes. And I even don't like Glassdoor, when Glassdoor put like a rating of CEO. Because I believe that when a company is big, or not even big, it's much more teamwork. And CEOs are just a role. People are just people. I always recommend not to read like a book like how to be a great CEO. Like you have in your like a book library. But to read biographies about CEOs, about business. And you would see that even Steve Jobs, he made probably 90% of mistakes in all his decisions. And many, many stupid mistakes.
1:19:15 Speaker 00 And he was not good altogether. Maybe the single common trait between successful and between all successful CEOs I may found is decisiveness. You should make decisions. And because when you make decisions, you move forward. Even if decisions, when decisions are stupid, you are moving forward and you're getting new information. And the next decision will be better. The worst is just this analysis paralysis, not making any decisions.
1:19:44 Harry Stebbings? One of my closest mentors said to me the other day, the heaviest things in life are not iron or gold, but unmade decisions.
1:19:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. And sometimes people, they're kind of, they're trying to find like a perfect solution. But the truth of life is that nobody knows future. And nobody may make like a perfect decisions just based on informational analysis. Because if it were the case, then McKinsey or banks would be perfect business creators. But like you can't see unicorns which were created by McKinsey or banks. Why? Because of unpredictability of the future. And if future is unpredictable, then what's the best? Just make any decision and move forward. Just not stay as a place. Decide something and move forward.
1:20:31 Harry Stebbings? What have you changed your mind on over the last 12 months?
1:20:35 Speaker 00 I was much more optimistic about time which would be necessary for generative AI to make impact on businesses. And because maybe two, maybe two or three years after the beginning of this hype, I still don't see many examples of real business success based on generative AI. It means that maybe something in programming, maybe something in support, but it's like rather tiny. Like we can't say that there's like any big case, any big business which changed business model or got profitability or growth because of generative AI. And I had a hope that the change would happen much faster.
1:21:20 Harry Stebbings? Who do you not have on the board? Who you would most like to have on your board?
1:21:24 Speaker 00 Let's say Melinda Gates, because probably Melinda Gates is a person who is doing nowadays the most for female health.
1:21:31 Harry Stebbings? Does it hurt you when people criticize a male CEO offline?
1:21:36 Speaker 00 I understand like why they criticizing, although I feel that our success was so beneficial for the industry because you're VC and you know that VC are making decisions based on benchmarks. And now like all VCs will start believing that it's possible to have a great success in this industry and all founders will have much easier journey than I had. I'm trying to do the best for this company and I think I was rather good in that. But also I would want, of course, to see that more women are becoming very successful in this journey.
1:22:17 Harry Stebbings? Final one, Dimitri. What question are you not often asked that you should be asked more?
1:22:23 Speaker 00 Would you want to eat something tasty?
1:22:26 Harry Stebbings? I'll roll with it. Dimitri, I, I was really looking forward to this one because I love the business. I didn't know how you were going to be respectfully. You've been fantastic. Like you are funny, you are direct. Thank you for being so brilliant and I really have loved this.
1:22:42 Speaker 00 Thank you much.
1:22:44 Harry Stebbings? I mean, what an amazing story. Dmitry is probably one of the most humble and kind CEOs I've ever had the opportunity to have on the show. I absolutely love that discussion and you can watch it. We recorded it in person in the studio in London. You can check that out on YouTube by searching for 20VC. That's 2-0-V-C. But before we leave you today. When a promising startup files for an IPO or a venture capital firm loses its marquee partner, being the first to know gives you an advantage and time to plan your strategic response. Chances are, the information reported it first. The information is the trusted source for that important first look at actionable news across technology and finance, driving decisions with breaking stories, proprietary data tools, and a spotlight on industry trends.
1:23:27 Harry Stebbings? With a subscription, you will join an elite community that includes leaders from the top VC firms, CEOs from Fortune 500 companies, and esteemed banking and investment professionals. In addition to must-read journalism in your inbox every day, you'll engage with fellow leaders in the active discussions or in person at exclusive events. Learn more and access a special offer for 20VC's listeners at www.theinformation.com/deals/20vc. And speaking of incredible products that allows your team to do more, we need to talk about SecureFrame. SecureFrame provides incredible levels of trust to your customers through automation. SecureFrame empowers businesses to build trust with customers by simplifying information
1:24:11 Harry Stebbings? security and compliance through AI and automation. Thousands of fast-growing businesses, including Nasdaq, Angel List, Doodle, and Coda, trust SecureFrame to expedite their compliance journey for global security and privacy standards such as SOC 2, ISO 2701, HIPAA, GDPR, and more. Backed by top-tier investors and corporations such as Google, Kleiner Perkins, the company is among the Forbes List of Top 100 Startup Employers for 2023 and Business Insider's List of the 34 Most Promising AI Startups of 2023. Learn more today at SecureFrame.com. It really is a must. And finally, a company is nothing without its people. The global law firm built around startups and
1:24:53 Harry Stebbings? Venture capital. Since forming the first venture fund in Silicon Valley, Cooley has formed more venture capital funds than any other law firm in the world, with 60-plus years working with VCs. They help VCs form and manage funds, make investments, and handle the myriad issues that arise through a fund's lifetime. We use them at 20 VC and have loved working with their teams in the US, London and Asia over the last few years. So to learn more about the number one most active law firm representing VC-backed companies going public, head over to Cooley.com and also Cooleygo.com, Cooley's award-winning free legal resource for entrepreneurs.
1:25:30 Harry Stebbings? As always, I so appreciate all your support and stay tuned for an incredible episode coming this Wednesday.
Previous 20Growth: The 7 Core Levers to Win at Consumer Subscription: Growth Loops, CAC + LTV Benchmarks, Pricing, Packaging, Notifications, Discounts, Paywalls | The Breakdown with Phil Carter Next 20VC: Benchmark's Eric Vishria on Where is the Value in AI: Chips, Models or Apps | Why Nvidia Will Not Be The Only Game in Town | The Commoditisation of Foundation Models | Which AI Apps Have Sustaining Value vs Hype and Short Term Revenue Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated