Pod Insights True Crime Conversations With Her Abuser Behind Bars, Dassi Erlich Is Ready To Talk About this episode In 2023, Malka Leifer was sentenced to 15 years in prison for 18 counts of sexual abuse against Dassi Erlich and her little sister.
Leifer was the sisters' former high school principal, and when whispers of their allegations came to light in 2008, she fled from her home in Melbourne to Israel before any formal complaint could be made.
It took 70 extradition hearings and 13 years to bring her back to Australia. But finally last year, Dassi was able to breathe a sigh of relief. Leifer was finally going to pay for what she’d done.
THE END BITS
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=tcc
CREDITShttps://go.skimresources.com?id=53410X1291869&xs=1&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.booktopia.com.au%2Fthe-good-girls-sonia-faleiro%2Fbook%2F9781408876732.html
Guest: Dassi Erlich
You can find out more about her memoir In Bad Faith here https://go.skimresources.com?id=53410X1291869&xs=1&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hachette.com.au%2Fdassi-erlich%2Fin-bad-faith-inside-a-secret-ultra-orthodox-sect-and-the-brutal-betrayal-it-tried-to-hide.
Host: Gemma Bath
Executive Producer: Gia Moylan
Audio Producer: Thom Lion
GET IN TOUCH:
Feedback? We’re listening! Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available viaLifeline https://www.lifeline.org.au/ on 13 11 14 orBeyond Blue https://www.beyondblue.org.au/ on 1300 22 4636
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 10,021 words · 3 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on. Hey, I'm Gemma Buff, host of True Crime Conversations. And did you know that the team at Mamma Mia is bringing you over 100 hours of the best content from your award winning podcasts for the hot pod summer of your dreams? Well, we are. Here at True Crime Conversations, we've handpicked some of the most chilling and thought provoking episodes from our feed, including gripping cult stories, powerful interviews with crime victims, and in-depth accounts from women who have been incarcerated, sharing the journeys that led them to that place. And that's just the beginning. We first brought you this conversation with Dassi Elik at the start of the year. You might know her story, or you might not.
0:47 Speaker 01 Either way, it's truly powerful and worth a listen. In 2023, Malka Leifer was sentenced to 15 years in prison for 18 counts of sexual abuse against Dassi and her little sister. Leifer was the sister's former high school principal, and when whispers of their allegations came to light in 2008, she fled from her home in Melbourne to Israel before any formal complaint could be made. Dassi is such a strong woman, and I took so much away from this conversation. Take a listen. This episode contains discussions of sexual assault and mental health struggles. Please take care while listening.
1:27 Speaker 01 Eighteen-year-old Dassi sat shocked in her colour teacher's house, staring at a diagram of a penis and a vagina.
1:37 Speaker 01 Now that she was engaged to be married, her mother had organised for her to get bridal lessons, where she was being educated about sex for the first time.
1:49 Speaker 01 Despite living in the inner-city suburbs of Melbourne in 2005, Dassi lived within the strict and isolated confines of the ultra-orthodox Arras Jewish community, with her six siblings and her parents. They had no TV, no internet, and no access to information from secular society, despite it operating near metres away from them.
2:17 Speaker 01 The idea that she even had a vagina was absolutely blowing Dussey's mind. She'd never been taught the correct terms of her anatomy, let alone what it looked like down there. But as she listened intently to the lesson, something started to click into place.
2:35 Speaker 01 Is this what Mrs. Leifer meant when she said she was preparing her for marriage? For years, her high school principal had been touching her. But in Dussey's world, there was no language around sexual abuse. She just knew what was wrong.
2:53 Speaker 01 Since the age of 16, she'd learnt to numb her mind. Disassociation was her biggest protector from the fear and pain. A trance-like state would keep her subconscious travelling far away from her reality.
3:09 Speaker 01 Dussey had hoped marriage would be an escape, not just from her principal, but her troubled home life. But what she didn't realise, as she sat at the dining room table of her colour teacher, praying for a new beginning, was that this was just the start of another troubling chapter. One where she'd eventually tell the world about the abuse she suffered, and then spend the next 15 years fighting for justice.
3:47 Speaker 01 I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. In 2023, Malka Leifer was sentenced to 15 years in prison for 18 counts of sexual abuse against Dussey and her little sister Ellie. She was acquitted of nine charges, including five relating to their older sister, Nicole. Leifer was the sister's former high school principal. And when whispers of their allegations came to light in 2008, she fled from her home in Melbourne to Israel before any formal complaint could be made.
4:30 Speaker 01 It took 70 extradition hearings and 13 years to bring her back to Australia. And finally, last year, Dassi and her sisters were able to breathe a sigh of relief. She was finally going to pay for what she'd done.
4:49 Speaker 01 But life wasn't the only evil in their lives. School had previously been their safe haven from the abuses they were experiencing at home. As Dassi shares in her new memoir, In Bad Faith, in their house, it was normal to go to bed hungry, to be hit or slapped for minor wrongdoing, and to have beloved toys stabbed and smashed in front of their eyes. It was a childhood laced in fear and sadness. And with life finally behind bars, Dassi wants to share it all. Because amongst the horrors she experienced, there have been valuable life lessons.
5:30 Speaker 01 Since leaving her ultra orthodox community and carving out a new free life for herself, the now 36 year old is ready to talk. Dassi Erlich joins us now.
5:44 Speaker 01 Dassi, I want to start with your parents. Tell me about the different worlds that they came from and how they kind of got together.
5:52 Speaker 02 So my mother grew up in Israel and she grew up until she was about 10 years old and moved to England in quite a traditional home with her father learning to become a rabbi. And my father grew up seven generation English in a very liberal, almost very culturally religious, but not in any way that affected day to day life.
6:14 Speaker 01 When they got together and started having you guys, because there's seven siblings, they did kind of go down the path of having a very religious way that they raised you. Tell us a bit about that because would we describe it as an ultra orthodox Jewish lifestyle?
6:30 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. My parents sort of moved into the Dassi community when I was very young, you know, around two or three years old. So by the time I have my first memories, we were a part of the Dassi community. An ultra orthodox, very exclusive and insular lifestyle that basically we had rules from morning to evening about how we lived our lives.
6:52 Speaker 01 Can you give us some examples? You've said that there was rules around everything. I know that there will be a lot of non-Jewish listeners, so even things like Shabbat and kosher and stuff like that is kind of alien to them. But in the ultra-orthodox community, those traditions are taking one step further, aren't they? It's very strict.
7:10 Speaker 02 Well, I think it's more not just about the rules, but about how you do the rules. And we would spend hours in school learning, you know, how do we get out of bed? What foot do we put out first? How do we wash our hands as soon as we get out of bed? You know, how many times should we wash our hands and what hands should we wash first? So it went down to the most minutest details.
7:31 Speaker 01 Wow. What about food? How is food treated in your home in terms of what was kosher and what was not?
7:38 Speaker 02 Food was governed by the kosher religious authority in Melbourne. So we were allowed to have any food and there's a little book that would tell us what food we were allowed to buy from supermarkets. There were a couple of kosher Jewish shops that we would buy food from, but we were quite limited in our diet.
7:53 Speaker 01 So you were still going to Coles and places around you? You just were only shopping in certain aisles?
8:01 Speaker 02 Only shopping for the things that we knew were allowed in the kosher authority little book that we had. And now if you go to Coles, actually, you can see like a little K with a circle around on little things in the supermarket aisles and you know that that's kosher. But we didn't have that back then. So we would refer to this little book and it'll tell us we can buy this particular brand of corn thins and that's what we would buy.
8:23 Speaker 01 I think what I find fascinating about the Adass community is that they are operating in such close proximity to the rest of society around them. But it's such an isolated world, but it's not like you're streets and streets away. You're next door to people in Melbourne, living a completely different life.
8:39 Speaker 02 As a young child, you know, I would see that life around me, but it was so separate from me. I didn't even think about that life. And of course, as I got older and I started to notice more how people around me are living, it was a question of curiosity, but almost, you know, we're more special. We live a certain way of life and, you know, don't even think about that way of life because it could influence you and tear you away from this life of truth.
9:02 Speaker 01 So you weren't yearning for what you saw in the backyards of other kids' homes?
9:08 Speaker 02 Not really. I think as a teenager, walking down the street in really thick tights and long skirts in the summer, there would be a curiosity about what it would be like to, you know, have the sun actually touch my skin in some way. But I always had this sense that I was more special or, you know, my modesty was something that made me more special.
9:28 Speaker 01 I want to delve a bit more into your family. We mentioned that there's seven siblings. At the time when you were becoming a young teenager, who was living in the house with you?
9:39 Speaker 02 So I had my two sisters, Nicole and Ellie, and my brothers, Isaac and Ben.
9:44 Speaker 01 And when you think back on your childhood and living with your siblings and your parents, how does it make you feel?
9:53 Speaker 02 I try not to think about my childhood that much. It brings up a lot of really difficult memories and all I remember is this all encompassing fear that I used to feel as a child and the feeling of never ever feeling safe. I mean, love was such a foreign concept to me. That wasn't, it was just about, you know, getting through the day and surviving.
10:15 Speaker 01 I know that every day is obviously different, but what did an average day look like for you as a kid? Because you had daily chores and school around all of that, but what kind of rules were in place that your parents kind of made you abide by?
10:29 Speaker 02 Really, I was working from the minute I woke up and I would wake up very early and complete all the chores that I had to complete in order to get to school. I would go to school and have our Jewish studies and English studies and I would come home and see another whole list of chores that I needed to do until very late at the night. And all the time, there was this fear that my mother would be incredibly angry or she would blow up in some way. And there was this constant tension that was felt all the time.
10:56 Speaker 01 What kinds of things would she get angry about?
10:59 Speaker 02 There was no rhyme or reason for any of her anger outbursts, at least what we felt as children, because one day something would be fine and then the next day that would be something that was terribly wrong. So it was very hard to understand what I was doing wrong. And I always thought that I was a good child or I tried to be a good child. I felt like I was an incredibly bad child because I was constantly being told off and beaten.
11:24 Speaker 01 Was it for things like not completing a chore to her standards? Like, were you just doing things like laundry and cooking? And she just wasn't happy with how you delivered those chores?
11:35 Speaker 02 It was if I didn't do it fast enough, or didn't do it well enough, or I spoke to her with the wrong tone. And I would modulate my tone so that I was as submissive as possible, but still somehow that was seen as disrespectful. So it was nothing that I could really understand that I was doing.
11:52 Speaker 01 And what were the punishments if she was angry at you?
11:57 Speaker 02 The punishments often involved physical abuse. There was a lot of verbal abuse and being told that I'm worthless or I'm nothing, or I don't deserve to live. There was a lot of food withdrawal. And there were many times that my mother would try and pit my siblings against me so that they would join in with her abuse. And of course, at times my siblings had to do that and they were forced to do that. But as we got older, we learnt to apologise to each other after that.
12:26 Speaker 01 I want to focus a bit more on the food withdrawal because obviously food is essential for life and it's such a unique punishment. How did it manifest for you? Where did you get food? Because you were denied dinner a lot of the time, weren't you?
12:42 Speaker 02 I just remember being starving all of my childhood. And I think when I speak to my siblings, they say they remember that. This constant sense of never feeling full and always being hungry and never certain that your next meal was guaranteed.
12:56 Speaker 01 And there were times where you were denied the toilet even?
13:00 Speaker 02 I write about this in the book about when we were young children and we weren't allowed to come downstairs once we had been sent to bed and there was no toilet upstairs. And this was a constant issue for us because a lot of times we would drink to quell that hole in our stomach. And not being able to go to the bathroom was incredibly difficult.
13:20 Speaker 01 When you look back at, you know, that in particular as an adult, are you shocked at some of the stuff that you and your siblings endured and survived?
13:29 Speaker 02 Absolutely. I think having my own child and realising the love and the desperate need to protect her, I couldn't imagine going to that extent to hurt someone so vulnerable.
13:43 Speaker 01 You write as well in a few instances about your siblings or members of your family being banished, being banished from the house or the community or the religion. Was that a threat that was always hanging above you? And when did it happen in certain instances?
13:59 Speaker 02 Again, there was no real reason why it happened, but my mother would choose one of us. And my memories are more around my younger brothers because a lot of times I disassociated from when that happened to me. But at some point, my mother would just decide that there was one child that didn't deserve to be a part of the family anymore. And they were banished to some place where, you know, we had a knowledge of this small, you know, this four to eight streets around our community and they would be taken outside of our community. And to us, that was the absolute biggest threat, that this person was not just going to be a part of our family, but no longer a part of our faith and our community.
14:37 Speaker 01 So they were dropped somewhere and then eventually what picked up or just left there for hours, days?
14:45 Speaker 02 Definitely hours. My memory is a little bit vague, but I do remember when my younger brother be sent off to a park or something outside of the community. I would sit there and beg my mother to allow my father to go and pick him up. And it would be hours and hours of worrying about him.
15:03 Speaker 01 Are there any happy memories from your childhood?
15:07 Speaker 02 That's a very difficult one to answer. Unfortunately, also, that's not how trauma works. That you do remember, you know, you end up remembering the most traumatic memories. But there were times that, you know, we went away on day trips or holidays. But again, that all pervasive fear was always underlying everything that we did. And I think the sense of happiness, especially as a teenager, came from when my siblings and I would band together, almost in the sense of rebellion and support one another.
15:37 Speaker 01 This might be a heavy question, but do you remember how old you were or when you first started thinking about death?
15:47 Speaker 02 I was very young when I was thinking about death.
15:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, I was incredibly young. I couldn't imagine any other way of getting out of the amount of pain and and fear that I was living every day.
16:03 Speaker 01 We've spoken about your mum, but you do write in your memoir about feeling unsafe with your dad and not understanding why. Can you tell me about when that started, if you feel comfortable?
16:16 Speaker 02 That's still something I'm really working on. A lot of those memories only came back after my father passed away in 2019. So that's still something that I'm still working through.
16:28 Speaker 01 I want to talk about bar mitzvah. For our non-Jewish listeners, can you explain firstly what that is and what it was for your community when you were younger?
16:39 Speaker 02 So a bar mitzvah as a girl is when you turn 12 and you become responsible for your own sins, pretty much. So before 12, you're considered, in a way, a pure soul and your parents are responsible for your sins. And when you turn 12, you are the responsible one and anything that you do against God, that's on you, that's no longer on your parents.
17:01 Speaker 01 And in the Adass community, were there certain things that you were now allowed to do or not do once you became of age, so to speak?
17:11 Speaker 02 Well, as a girl in the Adass community, my life became more limited as I turned 12. I wasn't allowed to sing anymore in the presence of a man. I wasn't allowed to ride a bike anymore because that wasn't modest. There were certain rules that came into place when I was seen as the age of maturity, which is 12 years old, that meant that I could no longer engage in certain practices because it wouldn't be modest anymore.
17:38 Speaker 01 So is it a milestone that you as a child look forward to? Or you're not looking forward to it because you're going to have all these freedoms kind of taken away from you?
17:47 Speaker 02 I didn't see them as freedoms being taken away. In a way, I saw it, I'm growing older, so I'm not allowed to sing in front of men because that, you know, my voice is more special. There was that. But for me personally, it was a terrifying time because I felt I was this terrible girl and suddenly I was going to be responsible for all of these sins and my soul was going to turn black. I was utterly terrified.
18:10 Speaker 01 It's something that happens to young girls when they're around 12, 13, 14. They start getting their period. Were you taught about that around that time?
18:19 Speaker 02 Around that time is the first time that I heard about it. And I was told it was because of the sin of women that I would be bleeding once a month. And that was pretty much all that I was told about it. And I remember going to my older sister Nicole and just saying to her, you know, what happens? What are you supposed to do? And she showed me what a pad was. And she said, you know, this is what you have to do when, you know, when you need them, you need to ask our father to go and get them from a supermarket. But I just very quietly tell him that this is something that's very embarrassing. And it was something that was very, very secretive.
18:51 Speaker 01 What about, I mean, I know when I was 13, it kind of was all rolled into one. It was menstruation, talking about that, it was puberty. And it was also a very basic, but sex education. Were you given that when you were a teenager or when you were turning into a young woman?
19:07 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely not. That was all that I was taught about periods. And I think that was my education until just before I got married and met my now ex-husband.
19:18 Speaker 01 You and your siblings went to Adass Israel School. It was within your community.
19:24 Speaker 01 What was the school like? Did you like going to school and what did you learn there?
19:29 Speaker 02 As a young child, school was my safe place and I loved going to school. It was a chance to get out of home and, and to learn. And I love learning. We spent a majority of our day learning Jewish studies and learning how to perform all the things that we were expected to perform and how to support the men in what they had to perform and what our role was as a Jewish woman. And then we had some classes in English and maths and other topics, but we had absolutely no regard for those topics. We did not respect the teachers. Now, looking back at that, I feel incredibly bad for the way that we used to treat the teachers that would come in and to teach us English and maths because we would play up and we just had no respect for them whatsoever. I mean, we didn't see the point of them.
20:12 Speaker 02 Why did we need to learn English and maths when, you know, our job as a Jewish woman was to grow up, get married and have children? It didn't make sense to us.
20:20 Speaker 01 So did you have, you know, science, art, drama? Any of those kinds of subjects that you would see in other Melbourne schools?
20:29 Speaker 02 We did have science and we did have art, but again, in art, you know, we were preparing stuff for the Jewish holidays or, you know, in science, we had a quite limited curriculum because a lot of things we weren't allowed to know.
20:43 Speaker 01 I want to start talking about Marka Lyfar. When do you remember her starting at the school and for what reason did she become principal?
20:53 Speaker 02 I recall her coming to Australia to be the head of the seminary, the girls' seminary, which is what we called year 11 and 12. And very quickly she became known in the community as this brilliant woman who could just do everything and had a lot of charisma and people were just drawn towards. And shortly after she came, I think it was a year or two, she became the principal of the entire girls' school. And I remember looking up at her and thinking that she's this amazing woman who seemed to just have this way of just dealing with everyone around her that everyone respected and adored. And having grown up in a community where males were always our leaders, to have a
21:36 Speaker 02 woman almost in that position that, you know, even men would listen to was something that I had never seen.
21:43 Speaker 01 So it was quite exciting for you, like you idolised her?
21:46 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely, completely idolised her.
21:50 Speaker 01 You write about her having, I think you call them special girls, or she used to call them special girls. What did that mean? Especially before you were in the kind of inner circle, what did that look like from the outside?
22:04 Speaker 02 Her favourite girls were girls that she would pull out of class to ask to go run errands for her or to go give messages to other teachers or to just sit in halfers and speak to her. So that was seen as a huge privilege.
22:19 Speaker 01 So you wanted in, basically?
22:21 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. I could think of nothing that I wanted more at that age.
22:25 Speaker 01 Do you remember when you did start becoming a special favourite girl? And did it start innocently at first? Like, was it just running errands?
22:33 Speaker 02 It was. It started very innocently. I recall her pulling me aside one day and saying, you know, she knew about my home life and she wanted to help me. And from that point forward, I felt a sense of connection to her. She was there to support me and, you know, you have those fantasies as a young child, maybe this person can save you.
22:51 Speaker 01 Hmm.
22:52 Speaker 02 And it did. I would run errands for her. I would be kept back sometimes from school excursions to help her out in the school. And it was all very exciting. I felt very special.
23:02 Speaker 01 How long did it take to change? Or was there a certain turning point?
23:06 Speaker 02 It happened quite quickly. She asked my mother to give me private lessons and to come to the school on Sunday and have lessons with her. And from the very first lesson, she started almost touching me on my knees and on my thighs. And I was completely innocent at the time. And she was known around the school to be more touchy feely. And coming from a culture where nobody touched anybody else, touch was incredibly rare. We never hugged our friends in that kind of way, or it was, oh, this is an Israeli quirk of hers. I had already become accustomed to this idea that she was someone that touched other people in an innocent way at the time.
23:48 Speaker 01 And also you had a mum who wasn't overly, well, she wasn't affectionate. And as a young girl, I'm imagining that you probably desired motherly affection in that way.
23:58 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. The first time that she touched me on my skin and her telling me that she was like a mother to me. Those words are something that I'll, unfortunately, I'll never forget because it meant everything to my young self.
24:14 Speaker 01 How did it escalate?
24:19 Speaker 02 It escalated quite quickly. Once she understood that I wasn't gonna. Once she, I don't know what she understood actually. Once she realised, or I realised there was nothing I could do and there was no one I could tell. I think she just continued progressing and touching me more and more.
24:41 Speaker 01 What did she tell you in those moments? Or did she say anything?
24:46 Speaker 02 She used to tell me that this is love and this is what love means and not having absolutely any understanding of love. I believed her. For a long time, I believed her.
24:58 Speaker 01 Once the touches turned from innocent to abuse. Did you know in your mind or in your body that what was happening was wrong?
25:11 Speaker 02 I, I had some innate understanding that this was incredibly wrong, but not any understanding of why it was wrong or how it was wrong. But my body used my survival system and I would disassociate and just disappear from the room when she was abusing me, to the point that I would just be completely frozen and still and at times just watching her from above, knowing that she's doing this to my body, but I'm not in that body.
25:38 Speaker 01 Hmm. So this started when you were around sixteen. How frequent did it become?
25:47 Speaker 02 Sometimes it would be several times a week and then sometimes not for a few weeks. And then I would notice other girls disappearing into her office and her door closed and the blinds down. And I knew that there was someone else in there and now I knew what happened in there. And there would almost be a sense of relief that that wasn't me. I couldn't think past that.
26:07 Speaker 01 But you didn't know about your sisters and their experiences at that point?
26:13 Speaker 02 Not at that point. I had witnessed her climb into my sister's bed one year in camp. And I had suspected, but because we didn't have the words to speak about it, the next morning I just gave this look to my sister. And my sister gave this look back to me and it was some sort of understanding and that was it. We never spoke about it. We just didn't know how to.
26:32 Speaker 01 When you say you didn't have the words to speak about it, I found this fascinating that you write about not even knowing what the word vagina was.
26:41 Speaker 02 Well, I didn't know. I had a vagina, let alone a name for one.
26:45 Speaker 01 So what were you taught about that part of your body?
26:48 Speaker 02 I assumed that the same place that I urinated from was the same place that I got my period, was the same place that she was abusing me. I just didn't understand that there was more than one place down there.
26:59 Speaker 01 And the idea of consent and abuse and stuff like that, that just wasn't something that was in your world?
27:07 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely not. It was never spoken about.
27:11 Speaker 01 Did it stop after you finished school?
27:16 Speaker 02 Well, I went straight from finishing school to becoming a student teacher under Mrs Leifer, and it didn't actually stop until I was out of the country and living away from her.
27:29 Speaker 01 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bath. I'm speaking with Dazie Erlich about her life in the Addas community and the abuse she suffered at the hands of her school principal, Malka Leifer.
27:49 Speaker 01 You got married when you were 19, which is young in most people's eyes, but it's actually on the older side for your community, isn't it?
27:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, I had friends getting married at 17 and 18. And by the time I got engaged when I was 18, and I was so relieved because I knew if I turned 19, 20 and I hadn't been matched up with someone by the matchmaker, that meant that I wasn't seen as being worthy of marriage or there was some problem or issue with me and people would look at me in that way. So it was a big fear of mine that I get married as soon as possible.
28:23 Speaker 01 So the idea that you were going to be in an arranged marriage, that wasn't nerve wracking to you, that you wouldn't know this person before you married them?
28:31 Speaker 02 That was the way that all my friends were meeting their husbands. It wasn't strange. I mean, I spent eight hours over a kind of a week or week and a half with my now ex-husband. But, you know, some of my friends spent maybe an hour. So eight hours was considered a long time.
28:50 Speaker 01 I want to talk about kala, is that how I pronounce it, bridal lessons?
28:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, kala lessons.
28:56 Speaker 01 That seems to have been the time when you started to properly learn about sex and sex education and all of that kind of stuff. Do you remember your teacher sitting you down and kind of telling you what sex was?
29:09 Speaker 02 I remember her sitting down and drawing a picture for me and saying, this is what you have down there and this is what a man has. And you need to find this place and you need to do these rituals and find this place in order for you to get married. And it was such a surprise to me. I just couldn't fathom this idea that this is how children are born into this world. I just absolutely could not fathom it.
29:36 Speaker 01 How did you think children were born into the world?
29:38 Speaker 02 I don't remember how I used to think about it. I knew it was something between a man and a woman. I just didn't know what that something was or have any idea. I couldn't imagine what that thing was.
29:50 Speaker 01 What were the rules between a married couple in your community in terms of sex once you were married?
29:59 Speaker 02 So a woman is considered unclean when she has her period and needs to be separated from her husband. And by separation, you have the same rules for your husband in that time as you would any other man in the community. So you need to stay covered up and you'll have to have your hair covered even at home. And you can't even pass anything to them because your hands might touch. You have to have separate beds. And then for a week after you've finished your period, you need to check yourself twice a day, morning and evening, to check that you actually have stopped bleeding. And by checking, it would be wrapping a little white cloth around my finger and actually properly checking that there was no blood.
30:41 Speaker 02 And once I had ascertained that I was completely clean for seven days, and if something happened in those seven days, you would have to start again. And during those seven days, and I don't really write about this in the book, but we had to wear white underwear and have white sheets. So if anything happened, we would have an understanding that we weren't clean yet and we would have to start that count again. And once you had been cleaned, then there was a ritual bath where you dipped yourself in three times naked and washed by someone to make sure that it was kosher and you were ready for your husband.
31:12 Speaker 01 And so, once you knew about all of these processes, because you would have only learnt about this once you actually started having these bridal lessons, right?
31:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, and I was so confused. I would check in with my bridal teacher continuously in those first few months of marriage, you know, what if I'm doing something wrong and I'm still unclean in some way and then my husband is with me and I'm unclean, that's not me, that's my sin. And that's a huge sin. Any child that's born, you know, from that would be illegitimate.
31:40 Speaker 01 Did those lessons also kind of get the cogs turning in your brain a little bit more about your experiences with Lifa?
31:49 Speaker 02 Not really, not at the time. At the time, it suddenly made sense, oh, well, that's where she's putting her hands and now that makes sense to me. But I still didn't have any understanding of the abuse, that it was, this was what would happen between a man and a wife in order to have children. That was it, that was the breadth of my understanding and I didn't then equate that with, well, that's sex and therefore what she's doing, you know, I didn't connect the dots at that stage.
32:18 Speaker 01 You also spent your wedding night at her house. Why?
32:24 Speaker 02 She was overseas at the time, her daughter was getting married on the same day as mine and my husband at the time, we were planning on living in Melbourne for a month before we went to Israel. So my, she offered her house to my parents and I never thought even, how would I even say anything about why I didn't want that to happen? I had so much disassociation between the different parts of my life. I didn't even think about saying anything.
32:54 Speaker 01 So it wasn't particularly triggering for you?
32:56 Speaker 02 I just remember waking up that first morning and just beginning this sense of freedom because I was finally out of home and I could wake up at my own time and not have to get out of bed and do a whole list of chores. And the fact that I was in the same bed that she had literally raped me on weeks earlier. Well, that was the extent of my disassociation. I just didn't even think about it.
33:17 Speaker 01 So marriage for you was a fresh start?
33:21 Speaker 02 Absolutely. I saw it as my ticket out of home, but also as I was married and I was joining, you know, the next stage of women. I would be a mother soon and I was doing my duty as a person in this world.
33:36 Speaker 01 Once you had been married and you were in Melbourne for a month or so, you did move to Israel. Was that a happier time for you, being, you know, physically away from your mum, your family, lifer?
33:49 Speaker 02 It was for a short period of time. I think before the loneliness set in of being away from my siblings and away from everyone that I knew and not speaking the language and being in this foreign country that has a very different culture to Australia. Not getting pregnant, my mental health difficulties started just piling on pretty quickly.
34:11 Speaker 01 While you were over there, you did disclose what happened to you to someone. How did that happen? Who did you tell?
34:21 Speaker 02 I think it kind of started with me having quite a bit of difficulty getting pregnant and having access to the internet for the first time. Looking up, you know, sexual websites to try and understand what it was, what was happening and why I wasn't getting pregnant and just really educating myself a little bit more about sex, but not having any understanding of the internet. I ended up in some very shady places. And that scared me. That scared me terribly and I had so. Such a curiosity about it as well, and that really scared me. So I ended up going to Chana Rabinowitz to talk about this, to talk about these, you know, dark, terrifying thoughts I was having.
35:00 Speaker 02 And the conversation very quickly moved to this doesn't make sense that you're having these thoughts and this curiosity unless you have been abused.
35:10 Speaker 01 It took you a while to actually say her name though, didn't it?
35:14 Speaker 02 I didn't want to. I didn't think that I would ever have to. It was just, I was just starting to connect the dots that it was abuse because of that education I was giving myself online. And I was just beginning to connect the dots and realising that if I said anything, the implications of that, and that was terrifying. This is not something that we talk about. You know, what would happen to me and my family if I said something? I didn't want to say her name. I didn't plan on saying her name. And I think when Chana Rabinowitz said that she would have to talk to Mrs. Leif and tell her that there was a teacher in her school, I felt that I had to say something.
35:51 Speaker 01 So you did tell her and then word got back to Melbourne. How quickly did your allegations spread throughout the community?
36:00 Speaker 02 Not very quickly at first because it got back to Melbourne and several rabbis were involved and asked about what they should do with Leifer and then I think it was within a week or so, Leifer was leaving and coming back to Israel. And that's really when the rest of the community started talking about it and wondering who it was and why this person had said anything and if it was really true and to what extent was it true. And those questions were everywhere. Everyone was talking about it and everybody pretty much quickly figured out that it was me because they knew that it was someone in Israel, a student and at the time I was really one of the only students living in Israel of that age.
36:41 Speaker 02 I just remember my friend calling me up and saying that she'd heard rumours and all these ridiculous rumours about me about why I had said something like this, that I was divorcing my husband, who at the time, we, you know, we were very much together.
36:55 Speaker 01 How did your sisters react? Did they start coming to you and asking about the allegations as well?
37:01 Speaker 02 I think my older sisters, Dahlia and Tamar, were incredibly shocked. And especially Tamar, she had seen the relationship between me and Mrs Leifer. She had seen that closeness, she worked at the school, you know, she knew Mrs Leifer, she had worked under her for a little bit. So for her it was an incredible shock. With Nicole, it was more when we had that conversation after Chana Rabino was called her and asked her if it was true what had happened, and Nicole said yes. That was the first time that I knew that it had happened to Nicole too. And still, we didn't have the language to speak about it. I don't think I found out about Ellie for a while after that. I don't think she disclosed it for another few months.
37:43 Speaker 01 So you still struggled to kind of have that dialogue with people, even after you had told at least one person what had happened?
37:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, I remember telling my husband at the time about it because I had to, because I knew the gossip would reach him. And it's better coming from me than hearing it from other people. And I remember having maybe one or two conversations about it and then never speaking about it again, the entire rest of our marriage. We never sat down and actually talked about what happened. It was just, okay, this happened, it's been dealt with, she's been sent away. You know, she's not part of the community anymore, that chapter of your life is over, and that was it.
38:22 Speaker 01 What about the Australian media? Because when Leifer fled, it did make headlines. How? Because it was such an enclosed community.
38:31 Speaker 02 That surprised me so much. I remember sitting there on my computer in Israel Googling Malka Leifer and seeing these articles come up. And of course, I had no understanding of how sexual abuse was reported. So I was sure that I was going to find my name somewhere and everyone would know this shame that I carried around. I think there was some, some person in the Adus community felt the way that Leifer had been sent away was incredibly wrong and alerted the Australian Jewish News. And the Australian Jewish News picked it up and then the rest of the media picked it up after that.
39:02 Speaker 01 How did you feel, obviously you saw that your name wasn't there in those early reports, but how did it feel to see headlines like Mal Khalifa accused of molestation, sexual abuse, all these kind of big, heavily loaded words in headlines?
39:20 Speaker 02 There was a sense of wanting to run away and hide from that. I felt very much, almost like they're making a bigger deal of it than it is because I didn't have an understa- I didn't even then, really hadn't put words to this is sexual abuse. I hadn't even put those words to it completely yet. So I just, I wanted to hide away from that and I was in some way relieved that I wasn't back home in the community and, and around that because the community was panicking and I knew that and I kept hearing about that.
39:48 Speaker 01 With Khalifa gone and these kind of allegations out in the headlines, basically for a next step, for the police to get involved, you kind of have to make a statement. You have to tell them what happened and, and start getting that ball more rolling, which you guys, you and your sisters didn't do for quite a while after that time. So did life almost go back to normal a little bit for a while?
40:12 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. The gossip kind of died down and pretty much life went back to normal. Sometimes I sit back, like especially during the trial, I've sat back and kind of questioned myself, would I have made a police statement then if I knew that that was something that I could do? And I can't really answer that. I just know that that wasn't even something I was aware was possible.
40:33 Speaker 01 Well, you had a lot going on, to be honest. Like, yes, you had all of this stuff with Khalifa happening, but you were talking about before, you were struggling with infertility, you were also struggling with a lot of depression and anxiety, living in Israel, thinking about what the next steps for you and your then husband were. You did eventually welcome your beautiful daughter Lily in 2010. How did everything you'd experienced as a child, as a teenager, impact your experience with early motherhood?
41:09 Speaker 02 I think it was having my daughter and realising that I would go to the ends of the earth to protect her and made me realise so much more how vulnerable and young I was and how no one had protected me. And that caused a lot of mental health difficulties at the time. It made me also begin questioning my way of life.
41:31 Speaker 01 I think I'm touching on this with you as well because I've just become a mum. I'm a year in to motherhood and it's hard. It's really hard, that first year especially, you are so vulnerable. And I feel like it kind of exacerbates all of the other hard shit happening in your life. Is that something that you kind of experience?
41:51 Speaker 02 Oh, definitely, a hundred percent. I think all the hormones and everything flooding back. Breastfeeding my daughter also was triggering a lot of memories. And I was just so desperate to not be the way that my mother was. I was desperate to learn everything and understand how to be the best mum for my daughter. But that caused me a lot of anxiety because I didn't know how I could be a good mother to my daughter. Yeah, it was a very, very tricky time. My coping mechanisms of dealing with all of that was self harming and I was incredibly suicidal during that time.
42:27 Speaker 01 You did get psychiatric help. How did that transform your life?
42:32 Speaker 02 That had a major impact on my life. I think walking into the hospital and speaking with other mums that were there, you know, to do the best that they could do for their children and realising this whole us versus them mentality I've had all my life wasn't true. And if that wasn't true, what else wasn't true? And I think it was at the same time that my sister had met someone and was going out with someone that talked to her about going to the police. And Ellie had gone to the police and she told me that she'd gone to the police about Malka Lifa. And I'm grappling with this question, you know, do I go to the police too? And what are the implications that will have on my daughter?
43:12 Speaker 02 And just sitting there, you know, talking to other people outside of my community and realising there's nothing wrong with going to the police. So why am I made to feel like that's a bad idea? And that really started to make me question my way of life.
43:26 Speaker 01 Do you remember walking into that police station for the first time and disclosing to an officer what had happened to you?
43:34 Speaker 02 I do. I remember going there with my wig and I remember still wearing my wedding ring and sitting there and not knowing how to speak about these things. And luckily I was met with an incredible police officer, Danielle Newton, who was very gentle and didn't push me and allowed me to talk at my own pace. And there were some things I still couldn't say, so I was allowed to go home and write about them.
43:59 Speaker 01 Was it cathartic for you, being able to get it off your chest to kind of hand what had happened to you over to someone else to deal with?
44:07 Speaker 02 Not in that sense. I think the consequences of me doing that overwhelmed any other feeling. Now, looking back, I can say, yes, it must have been in some way cathartic, but I don't think I felt that at the time.
44:20 Speaker 01 Had Ellie left the Adas community by then?
44:24 Speaker 02 She had. My two brothers had as well.
44:28 Speaker 01 How soon after you went to the police did you make the decision to not just leave your community, but I guess in doing that, you also made the decision to leave your husband, who was very religious?
44:41 Speaker 02 I think there were a lot of things going on at the same time. So making that police statement and me questioning my way of life, and there were difficulties in my marriage because I was questioning my way of life. And then also seeing this other life that seemed a lot more free. And at the same time, still dealing with self-harm and being suicidal. I don't know the exact moment that I made that decision, but I know when I left hospital for the first time, my then-husband and I decided to separate and trial of separation.
45:09 Speaker 01 How do you go about doing that in your world? Is that a hard thing to do, to divorce someone within the Adas community?
45:17 Speaker 02 It wasn't something I was familiar with at all. I think I knew one other person that had got divorced. And it was something that, again, was very secretive and not spoken about and kind of shrouded in this thing of shame. I actually didn't know anything about what being divorced meant or how I go about doing that. And it wasn't like I had anybody I could really look at and say, oh, well, you know, they managed to do it, I could do.
45:45 Speaker 01 Is it easier said than done, building a new life, completely different to the one you've known for 23 years?
45:53 Speaker 02 It's so incredibly difficult. I don't even know if I could describe it in words. But suddenly being in this completely different, you know, culture almost. I mean, I was still in Australia, but I was living among people that had grown up in the secular world. And they spoke different to me, you know, they had a different experiences. They, I had to suddenly learn all these new rules of how to just exist in that world. Rules that people grow up and not think about. But I didn't know how to speak to men. I didn't know how to date. I didn't know how to even pay my bills. It was actually an incredibly dangerous time for me because I was so naive and so vulnerable. I ended up in a lot of sticky situations, situations that I almost lost my life.
46:35 Speaker 01 How did the negligence case that you brought against Aras Israel School, how did that play out?
46:42 Speaker 02 That wasn't really a decision that I made. It was more a decision of necessity. My lawyer said I needed help with parenting issues and I didn't have any funds. I had no money whatsoever to my name. And I needed this legal help from lawyers to be able to work out my parenting issues. And the only way I kind of could afford it is they told me if I took out a case against the school and won that case, I could then pay for these other legal issues. And my now ex-father-in-law, you know, had kind of floated the idea, he's a lawyer, about going the legal way. There was still so much shame around all of it. I couldn't even contemplate it at the time.
47:23 Speaker 01 Did winning that case give you any confidence at all?
47:27 Speaker 02 I think going through that whole trial and having to speak about their views for the first time, I was in a much healthier mindset and I felt I had a better sense of self and a lot more self-worth by that time. And I'd been working for years on that. And hearing that validation in the court and knowing that I'd been heard and believed and seen and validated was incredibly empowering.
48:09 Speaker 01 Leifer, after you and your sisters went to police, her extradition from Israel was ordered in 2014. She didn't arrive on our shores until 2021.
48:20 Speaker 02 Her extradition was actually ordered in 2012.
48:24 Speaker 01 2012, so it was even longer.
48:26 Speaker 02 It was. Maybe, I think, 2013, they finally sent the extradition papers to Israel. And it kind of sat in Israel for about a year or so before they actually picked it up and went and arrested her. So, yes, it went on for a long time.
48:41 Speaker 01 Why? Why did it take so long to bring her back to Australia to face these charges?
48:45 Speaker 02 Well, she's a master manipulator. I mean, we know that from the way that she abused myself and many other people. And she used that manipulation to manipulate the legal system there, pretend she was mentally ill and try and get out of ever coming back to Australia. And she had some very powerful people helping her.
49:04 Speaker 01 How did that process of watching the person that abused you evade the law for so long and have all of these other people kind of help prop that up? How did that feel for you and what was your relationship with the justice system, watching that kind of play out?
49:21 Speaker 02 I felt incredibly angry. I felt that this was a sign of a much bigger problem, that we still have as a society so many systems in place that aid and help abuses as opposed to helping victims. There was just so much that needed to change in order for her to be brought back to justice. Sometimes it seems almost unbelievable that she actually did come back here.
49:44 Speaker 01 I think it's unbelievable that you and your sisters had to fight for so long and so hard. You guys had a hashtag, #BringLyferHome. You were travelling over there, you were doing press conferences, you were doing everything in your power. Did that take a toll?
50:03 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. But we knew if we didn't continue and, and keep going and pushing for this to happen. She was there, living in a community that ignored everything that had happened before. And we just couldn't live with the fact that she would abuse anyone else. And that was something that kept us going through all those years.
50:22 Speaker 01 How did it feel when she finally touched down on Australian soil?
50:28 Speaker 02 I mean, that was the beginning of a whole new waiting game, but at the time it felt almost surreal.
50:34 Speaker 01 And the trial, I know you'd already kind of had a taste of standing up and having to tell people about what you did. But this was at a whole new level.
50:42 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely.
50:44 Speaker 01 How did it feel? Cause I think when you haven't sat in a courtroom, I have, I've watched people stand up and give witness statements, but I've never had to do it myself. It looks overwhelming. It looks incredibly hard. How did you find that experience?
50:59 Speaker 02 Incredibly, incredibly re-traumatizing. Having to sit there and, you know, being interrogated and being made out to be a liar. And having to share all of these memories in excruciating detail. And then being interrogated and where they're trying to prove that you're lying about all of this or imagining it in some way. But it wasn't just that the abuse was, I wasn't just questioned about the abuse. I was questioned about everything in my life. Everything from my marriage to my daughter, to what I watched on my computer. Literally nothing was bad, absolutely nothing. And it literally felt like I was just dancing to her tune again.
51:39 Speaker 02 Because she was sitting there at the back of the courtroom, behind a screen, so that I couldn't see her and she couldn't see me. Although she had a little camera that where she could see me as I was on the stand. That was more to protect me, so I couldn't see her. Not having to say anything where I'm there on the stand, you know, being interrogated about my entire life.
51:58 Speaker 01 And putting every detail out there for people to pull apart. And as you've mentioned as well, like going through the kind of trauma that you've experienced, you don't remember a lot of things. Was that kind of used against you?
52:09 Speaker 02 It was. And having to say those things when I'm feeling re-triggered and re-traumatized and stay calm and and not get defensive in any way, as if becoming defensive would mean that I'm lying.
52:22 Speaker 01 This might be too big a question, but do you think there's a better way?
52:26 Speaker 02 I think there's a lot of different things that can help the system be there more for victims. You know, I look at my journey through the Victorian legal system and I had a great prosecution team and a great police and I was going through it with my sisters and as I write about in the book, I ended up back in hospital. You know, that's how much I struggled with it. There has to be a better way. There has to be.
52:50 Speaker 01 Did the guilty verdict and the sentence, she got 15 years, did it bring you any peace?
52:57 Speaker 02 It did. It really did. Just being able to put that behind me and not have that in my future anymore, which is something that I've had really all my life. And I didn't realise what a sense of peace it was, walking away from that and knowing that justice was served. And also understanding how incredibly rare that is. It's incredibly rare for a sexual abuser to be found guilty in the system.
53:23 Speaker 01 Which is ridiculous.
53:24 Speaker 02 Ridiculous to go through all of that. And there's definitely a sense of peace, knowing that's behind me.
53:30 Speaker 01 What made you want to write a book?
53:32 Speaker 02 I love writing and I felt that it was a very important story to share. I feel that's how we learn as a society from other people's stories. I know that I felt much more alone reading other people's stories that have gone through similar circumstances.
53:47 Speaker 01 And I guess the focus had been so much on Lifa and what she did to you. But what I took away from your book was everything that happened before that. Everything that shaped who you were before you met Lifa.
54:02 Speaker 02 Yeah. I mean, I think that was a part of writing, of trying to explain why I was so vulnerable and naive and how the world I was born into shaped me.
54:15 Speaker 01 You mentioned earlier your father passed away in 2019. Have you got any contact with your mum?
54:21 Speaker 02 No, I don't, I haven't had for years.
54:24 Speaker 01 What is life like for you now? Are you happy?
54:27 Speaker 02 I am, I have a lot more moments of peace and a lot more moments of happiness. And I can look towards the future from a completely different space. I don't feel like I'm in a survival space anymore, which I didn't realise I was in for such a long time.
54:41 Speaker 01 Do you consider yourself religious anymore in any way?
54:45 Speaker 02 No, I live a secular lifestyle.
54:47 Speaker 01 And what do you want people to take away from your story, from hearing everything that you've gone through?
54:53 Speaker 02 I want people to feel less alone. I want people to learn and understand and to be able to empathise with other people in their life that are going through circumstances or dealing with the justice system or going through abuse. And I hope it changes the conversation around what as a society we need to do to better protect our most vulnerable.
55:14 Speaker 01 Thanks to Dussey for entrusting us to help tell her story on True Crime Conversations. Her memoir, In Bad Faith, is out now. You can find a link to it in our episode description. This episode was hosted by me, Gemma Bath, with audio design by Tom Lyon. Our executive producer is Gia Moylan.
55:44 Speaker 01 If you're looking for something else to listen to, like and follow all of our Mamma Mia! podcasts, which are currently bringing you Hot Pod Summer. 100 hours of summer listens from spicy conversations to incredible stories, fashion, beauty and more.
Previous Eve Wiley’s Father Was A Serial Sperm Donor… And He’s Not Alone Next Why Women Kill And The Lives They Live Behind Bars [fresh episode] Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated