Pod Insights True Crime Conversations We Take You Inside The New Amanda Knox Series And Real-Life Case About this episode On a summer night in Italy in 2007, the brutal murder of Meredith Kercher shocked the world. Her American flatmate Amanda Knox, and her new boyfriend Raffaele, were instantly thrust into an international legal saga that spanned years.
For the first time ever, True Crime Conversations host Claire Murphy joins The Spill's Laura Brodnik for a can't-miss crossover that dissects the new Disney+ series, The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox https://www.disneyplus.com/en-au/browse/entity-2d06a4a5-ab11-4d4c-b20f-ca7472148e33. Whether you're a true-crime devotee or an entertainment junkie, you need to hear this.
In this episode, we bring you the full forensic detail of the Amanda Knox case, including the vital piece of contamination that crumbled the prosecution's DNA evidence. We also analyse the dramatic new TV series that puts you inside Amanda’s mind, depicting the terrifying interrogation police failed to record.
Discover the unsettling truth about the unflushed poo, the "see you later" text police misinterpreted, and the psychological tricks used to coerce a false confession from an exhausted, non-Italian speaking student.
We explain why the show's creators believe that only a drama - not a documentary or a memoir - can truly clear a name that has been dragged through the mud for a decade, and clear up exactly how Monica Lewinsky got involved.
THE END BITS
Hear Laura Brodnik every day on Mamamia’s twice-daily entertainment podcast The Spill. We post the latest celeb headlines you need to know at 8am, and an in-depth (and hilarious) look at the day’s biggest celebrity stories at 3pm. Follow our feed to get in the know https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/the-spill/.
Content warning: This article contains graphic details of violence, assault and sexual assault. If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
Mamamia’s No Filter spoke exclusively to Amanda Knox - hear her own story here. https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/no-filter/what-really-happened-to-amanda-knoxMake sure to leave us a rating and review on Apple & Spotify to let us know how you're liking the episodes.
CREDITS
Hosts: Claire Murphy https://www.linkedin.com/in/claire-murphy-52121979/?originalSubdomain=au and Laura Brodnik
Producers: Tahli Blackman and Monisha Iswaran
Audio Producer: Scott Stronach
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 10,230 words · 7 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 True Crime Conversations acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters that this podcast was recorded on.
0:10 Speaker 01 I'm Laura Brodnik, host of The Spill, which is Mamma Mia's daily entertainment and pop culture podcast.
0:16 Speaker 00 And I'm Claire Murphy. I'm the host of True Crime Conversations, which is our weekly true crime podcast, speaking to the people who know the most about these crimes. Well, I am the host when Gemma Bath is not on maternity leave and she will be returning, never fear. But we know just how popular true crime is, whether you listen to it on a podcast, whether you watch it on your streaming service of choice. But what about when crime meets drama? And that is what we are talking about today.
0:44 Speaker 01 Yes, that is what we're here to discuss. So we are talking about the new Disney Plus series, The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox. And if you're listening to this through the Spill feed, we have heard all of your comments that you want more true crime series and you want to kind of dissect the actors and the production, the behind the scenes facts, but you also want to know what happened in the real life case and where those people are now and why these stories were chosen to be told in a dramatic fashion. So we're going to be deep diving into that in today's episode. So Claire, as our true crime expert, you're going to take us through the Amanda Knox case and what happened from the beginning, because I think for a lot of people like myself, I have such a memory of watching this unfold on TV at the time.
1:26 Speaker 01 But there's so much more to this case, I think, and it became a lot more in depth than a lot of people realise.
1:31 Speaker 00 Yeah. And if you got your information about this case from the news media, then that may have actually twisted the way you might see it or view it. So we're going to get to the bottom of that as well, but I'll step you through where this all began. Okay. So first thing I need to warn you is that this case spans years.
1:49 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:50 Speaker 00 So it went on for a really long time. So bear with us, there's a little bit to get through. It started off in September 2007, that is when Meredith Kercher, who was a British student, she was spending a year studying abroad in Italy and she moved into a share accommodation, which is the Villa at Seven Via Della Pergola in Perugia. And then later that same month, just 10 days later, Amanda Knox, who was an American student doing the same thing, spending a year in Italy, she moved into the same address. So there is four young girls living in this small apartment or small villa. There are some boys living in the flat downstairs. So they all share this villa together. On October 25, Amanda meets a young Italian boy called Raffaele.
2:34 Speaker 00 Now, they met at a concert. They are immediately in love. They do that honeymoon period where they spend literally every minute of every day together. She then starts staying at his house essentially every night. She has a job, so she goes and works at a bar, a local bar. And she is studying as well, so she's doing that too. But essentially, her and Raffaele now become inseparable.
2:56 Speaker 01 Yes, and in the show, it was depicted they had only been together about a week before the events of Meredith's murder took place. And I, I saw a lot of feedback from the show of people thinking that that was added into the story for extra dramatic effect or to make their relationship look more like a whirlwind. But they actually, isn't that correct? They only were together really for one week before their whole world blew up with these accusations.
3:17 Speaker 00 Absolutely true. So they literally spent a week together out in the world as a new couple before they were thrown into all of this drama. So come November 1. So sometime after 8.30pm, Meredith Kercher was murdered in the villa she shares with her flatmates. Amanda and Raffaele are at Raffaele's apartment and the two of them both switched their phone off that night around the same time that Meredith is murdered. Now Amanda explains that she had been messaging with her boss. She was maybe gonna go into work that night and he messaged her to say that she didn't have to come in. And she was like, great, this means I get to spend more time with my brand new, very handsome young man boyfriend in his apartment.
4:02 Speaker 00 And so they watched a movie and they ate some food and they smoked a joint together. And Raffaele had also turned his phone off because he didn't wanna speak to his dad. He spoke to his dad every night on the phone. He's like, no, I want the two of us to just spend uninterrupted time together. This is very important because police see that as in this day and age where technology is used so frequently to track us, to find out where we are, to marry up locations to potential crimes, that if you turn your phone off, it almost looks like an admission of guilt.
4:35 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:36 Speaker 00 That you have done something wrong. So that is part of the case against them. She also sends a message to her boss before turning her phone off that says, thanks, I'll see you later.
4:45 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
4:46 Speaker 00 That is interpreted by police very differently had they not been Italian, if English had been their first language. We say that all the time, see you later. It's part of our vernacular, but in Italy, it's taken more literally.
5:00 Speaker 01 As if they had a plan to see each other later.
5:02 Speaker 00 Exactly.
5:03 Speaker 01 And when we're watching the series, you see Amanda trying to explain to the police that it's just another form of saying goodbye and how quickly that leads to her being implicated.
5:12 Speaker 00 Yes.
5:12 Speaker 01 Because again, they're thinking that she's making a plan to meet up with him.
5:15 Speaker 00 Yes.
5:15 Speaker 01 And is he involved or did she leave the apartment?
5:18 Speaker 00 And the fact that her boss is a certain nationality also plays into this. We'll get to that in a second. So it's the next morning, Amanda's woken up. The night before, there'd been a spill or leaking something at Raffaelli's house. She wants to go home. She needs to get a mop because he doesn't own one. Typical man. And then she also wants to like have a shower and just get changed. And she will later on explain why she did that to Raffaelli in a very beautiful, lovely scene where she'd like, I just wanted to look pretty for you and wear a dress. But so she goes home and the front door is open, which is not unusual because the front door that they had of this villa was a little bit dodgy. You had to physically key lock it for it to stay shut.
5:56 Speaker 01 Yes.
5:56 Speaker 00 And if you didn't do that, the wind would sometimes just blow it open. So Amanda's thinking, one of my flatmates has just run down the street to grab something, didn't think to key lock the door. It's blown open by itself.
6:06 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:06 Speaker 00 So she steps inside. She walks through to her own room. She goes to have a shower. She steps out onto the bath mat and realises there's some blood on the bath mat. She also notices a little bit of it on the sink area too. Now, for anyone who's lived in a share house full of women. We know the blood sometimes is a part of our day to day life.
6:29 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:29 Speaker 00 Was this menstrual blood? Did someone cut themselves shaving? It's in the bathroom.
6:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's so many possibilities that it could be with the amount of people using that bathroom.
6:38 Speaker 00 Exactly right. So she goes, ooh, that's kind of gross, but doesn't think that automatically jump to someone's been murdered in the house. She does notice though, that someone has gone to the toilet. They have done a poo and they haven't flushed it. And that then is the first time she fully realises that something's not right.
6:57 Speaker 01 Yes.
6:58 Speaker 00 Which is interesting because if you live in a house full of women, sometimes women can be pretty gross, especially when it comes to menstrual blood. But there are certain things that she knows her flatmates just would not do. And that is leave an unflushed poo in the toilet.
7:09 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:10 Speaker 00 So she leaves and she asks Rafaele to come back to the house. And she's like, I don't understand what's happened. She goes back inside, realises that one of her other flatmates' rooms has been broken into. So the window is broken and there's glass on the ground. She's unsure if she's been robbed because it's her flatmate's room. So she's not sure if anything is missing. But she thinks someone has maybe been in the house. And then when she goes back past the bathroom, it looks like the poo has been flushed. She doesn't go in and have a look at it, but it looks like it's been flushed. So she goes, oh my God, that person must have been in the house while I was in the house.
7:46 Speaker 01 Hmm.
7:47 Speaker 00 So she starts to really freak out. Rafaele turns up and they have a look and they realise that Meredith, one of her flatmates, her door is locked. They knock on it, they call her name, she doesn't answer, they think she's not there. But they're not sure what's going on. They call police. But two officers do turn up, but they're not the police they've actually called.
8:04 Speaker 01 Yes.
8:05 Speaker 00 And this is true, two of the fraud investigation police turn up because they have found two mobile phones thrown into someone's back garden. Now, they believe that the phones belong to one of the other flatmates, not Meredith. But that is due to a SIM card being shared amongst the girls. They actually belong to Meredith. And so they've been taken from her and thrown over the back fence of someone's property. So these fraud cops turn up and they start to ask them about the phones and they're like, hang on, we think someone's broken into our house. And so these guys automatically become in charge of this crime scene. They end up calling in investigators because when the other flatmates come home and they all realise that Meredith's door is still locked,
8:49 Speaker 00 one of these guys kicks the door open and finds a body. Hmm. Now, Meredith has been raped, she's had her throat cut, there is blood everywhere. She's covered by her bedding. So you can see in the crime scene photos that one of her feet is sticking out and you can see just the top of her head, but there is a lot of blood. Hmm. And so that is when the homicide team is brought in and they start to investigate. Now, this is where we have to understand, watching the twisted tale of Amanda Knox, this is told from Amanda's perspective. Yes. And not from the police's perspective.
9:31 Speaker 00 The difference in the way the Italian justice system works is very different to, say, the American or the Australian justice system. So the person who will be prosecuting you in court is the same person who investigates the crime. Yes. So Manini, who is a real man, is a real character. So he's a real person, the character in the show. So he comes on board as like the lead investigator, but he's also going to be prosecuting this in court. There is a detective who is also a real person, a woman who takes an immediate dislike to Amanda. She's one of the first to question her and it's very obvious that she distrusts Amanda's reaction to the crime. And we can see this, it has been documented.
10:14 Speaker 00 Amanda does stand outside with everybody else when the investigative team comes in. And she's with Rafaeli and you've got to remember, they've been together for days. They're still in the honeymoon period, he's comforting her. She's like smiling and laughing with him and like they're cuddling and kissing a little bit. And it all seems a little bit not right to the detectives. They're like, if my flatmate, who I supposedly am quite close to, even though we've only lived together for a little while, if we are seeing it right, she's not phased by her roommate being brutally murdered in her home.
10:49 Speaker 00 So that is when things start to shift back to the police station. They're all brought in for questioning. Meredith's friends, the other roommates, Amanda and Raffaele are questioned. And it seems like at the beginning, they're already suspecting her. They do ask her questions about her whereabouts and they try and find alibis. There is a lot, because she's there all day. And then it's noted that she's sitting in Raffaele's lap in the waiting room in the police station. And again, detectives are looking at this like this is not the behaviour of somebody whose friend has just been murdered. Meredith's British friends are there and they too are looking at this thinking, why is she acting this way? When Meredith has just been brutally slain in their home that they share together.
11:34 Speaker 00 So there's a lot of questions being asked about why Amanda did not act a certain way in the aftermath of Meredith's death. And so then the questioning amps up a little bit from detectives and then they allow her to go home, but it's already the next day almost and she's exhausted. And they tell her, you need to be back here within a few hours. So she goes home, has a shower, comes back again, doesn't go home to the crime scene. She goes to Raffaele, has a shower, comes back. She's exhausted. She has had very little sleep. She doesn't really know what's going on. And she's interrogated by police again and again and again. And this is the interesting part of this whole thing is that, as I said, this drama series is told from Amanda's perspective.
12:17 Speaker 00 What is also true is that police did not record this interrogation. Yes. We will never know exactly what happened in that room. There is no evidence to fall back on, there is no video. Amanda at that time did not speak great Italian. She's hearing all of this through an interpreter at a time where she's tired, doesn't know what's going on. So her interpretation of it is that.
12:39 Speaker 01 They essentially coerced her into an admission of guilt.
12:43 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
12:44 Speaker 01 So this is a little bit of what the interrogation sounds like from Amanda's perspective in the twisted tale of Amanda Knox.
12:49 Speaker 02 Sei rimasta a casa di Raffaele? Sei uscita? Dove sei andata? Eh, a casa tua. In piazza. A caffè di pasta.
12:59 Speaker 03 I don't remember.
13:01 Speaker 02 Amanda, devi ricordarti. Sei sposata e hai incontrato Patrick. Devi voler te merita. E tu le meriti a casa.
13:07 Speaker 03 E tu le meriti a casa. Patrick è meriti a casa. È meriti a casa. E poi lui l'ha ucciso. And then he killed her. Amanda, non me lo dà, no!
13:14 Speaker 04 Amanda, se incontrerà con un uomo. Se lo si mette in carcere per 30 anni.
13:19 Speaker 03 I don't remember. That was you met Patrick?
13:22 Speaker 04 È lì che hai incontrato Patrick?
13:23 Speaker 03 I don't know.
13:24 Speaker 04 È il mezzo, ci ho vengelo.
13:26 Speaker 02 Ci hai rispettato. Sappiamo che non sappiamo che hai avuto.
13:30 Speaker 03 I don't, I can't. L'hai detto. Non posso. I don't know.
13:34 Speaker 02 Tu hai avuto il nome.
13:36 Speaker 03 I don't know.
13:37 Speaker 02 Tu hai avuto il nome.
13:38 Speaker 03 È Patrick!
13:40 Speaker 02 È Patrick!
13:42 Speaker 03 È Patrick!
13:43 Speaker 01 It's interesting listening to that and knowing how much of a hand Amanda Knox had in not just the creation of this show and the behind the scenes and production. She's an executive producer. But she also gave so much information to the writers and almost guided them step by step of how she wanted each scene to play out and how it came from her memory. And then she even helped write some of the episodes. And it's like they're looking back on this very specific moment of media attention, like those moments where she and Raffaele are outside the house and they're hugging. And that's the moment where in the series and in real life, we know the police kind of turned against them. And both of them have looked back on that time. And I think you can see it come through the series because we're hearing it from Amanda's point of view, is that she was quite shell shocked. And so she was being very physical towards him
14:28 Speaker 01 because that's how she deals with trauma. And he was almost clocking how it looked to people around them. But he later on said in his own memoir that he wrote about the situation, that he thought it was too cold to be pushing her away in that moment where she was wanting to be very affectionate, wanting to sit in his lap. It was like a comfort thing. And even scenes where you see her Doing like leading interrogation, like she does the splits in the waiting room and all that sort of stuff. That all really happened, but it's all just of like a fear response from her is what she's saying. And as we get led into the interrogation, it's really interesting because as you're saying, there's no film, there's no video of that moment. Everyone who's in that room has a different story, but the camera work and the way that they shape it to the audience is almost like you're supposed to see it so directly through
15:13 Speaker 01 Amanda's eyes that like the camera frame keeps getting smaller, the noises keep getting louder, they're getting repetitive. It's all these kind of sensory tricks that are
15:21 Speaker 00 laid over the top of each other.
15:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. All these sensory tricks that are laid over that are meant to almost like make you feel as a viewer that you're being interrogated. So the idea is like, your heart is supposed to start beating fast. You're supposed to start getting in like a fight or flight situation. So when she yells out Patrick's name at the end, it's almost like this release of like wanting to know the escape of how you're going to get out of that room.
15:41 Speaker 00 And all the voices stop immediately. Yeah.
15:42 Speaker 01 Exactly. Because she's given them what they want in that moment. So it's a really interesting twist of putting you in Amanda's shoes. And I guess maybe that explains what happened next, if you're looking at the real crime.
15:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. So you heard there, she says it was Patrick and Patrick is her boss at the bar. Patrick Lamumba, who is an African man who has immigrated to Italy and he's opened this bar. Police had found a hair in Meredith Kercher's bedroom, which matched an African man. There was a young black man living in the apartment downstairs and he was terrified to hear that there was a hair that potentially linked to him. But then they found out that the person that Amanda had texted, I'll see you later, which they took literally, that man was also of African origin. And so for them, puzzle pieces started to click into place. Amanda had obviously organised to meet this man at some stage that night and
16:38 Speaker 00 that man has hair that matches the one that's on the scene. So it all makes sense to them. So she tells them that Patrick did it and all of a sudden the interrogation stops. And as we know now and what you do learn about in the drama series and the documentary too, that Amanda Knox has made about this is that is a very well-known interrogation technique. It is one that police have been using for a very long time and we've seen cases be overturned, like the Central Park Five, for example, the same interrogation technique was used on them and they falsely confessed to a murder that they did not commit. And so we've seen it happen before where if you just layer on the pressure and you get people to Think that maybe then remembering something wrong and then you plant a seed
17:20 Speaker 00 that potentially it happened this way, like maybe you did leave the apartment that night. Maybe you did meet with Patrick, maybe you did go back to your apartment and then they start to make you believe under stress and duress that you are wrong and they are right. And so to stop it, all you can do is admit. And so that is what we're seeing play out from Amanda's perspective now. The detectives, they say that it did not play out like that, that that interrogation did not happen like that. Also, Amanda claimed she was hit in the head a couple of times during it, which they say did not happen. And they say that at no stage did they plant a seed that it was Patrick. Like that came from her, they said that they did not do that. So we can't know what the truth is in amongst all of that.
18:03 Speaker 00 So moving on, it's now November 19th, so it's 18 days since Meredith's murder. And police announced that there is actually a new suspect. They've arrested Patrick, Amanda and Rafaele at this stage. And they realised that a man who had been arrested a few days before Meredith's murder for breaking into a kindergarten essentially, that he is actually the suspect linked to Meredith's murder. His name is Rudy Gidey. He is also an African immigrant into Italy and he had a rap sheet, robberies, various crimes against women, like so he really fit the MO. So when they figured out that Rudy was their guy, they had to let Patrick go because his alibi stood up and was checked.
18:48 Speaker 00 And they did manage to find Rudy Gidey at a train station and they arrest him. Now Amanda and Rafaele at this stage think, okay, they've finally found the murderer, they will let us go. No, that is not what happens now. In fact, police ramp up their involvement and they create a narrative that there was some kind of. Sexual nature to the crime. Obviously, Meredith was raped, so that was already where they were being led. But they believed that it was more than just a man breaking in and raping Meredith, that Amanda and Raffaelli were playing some kind of game and they wanted to involve Meredith and she didn't want to, and that's why she was killed.
19:31 Speaker 00 They also had been collecting DNA from the scene. And this is what will bring them unstuck later on down the track. They filmed the entire thing. They find DNA of Meredith on a knife that has both Amanda and Raffaelli's DNA on it also. It was at Raffaelli's apartment. They also find some of Raffaelli's DNA on a brass strap that looks to have been broken off in some kind of scuffle. But as we'll later find out, those two were then eventually thrown out. So Rudy Gede asks for a separate trial and he's fast-tracked. So with before Amanda and Raffaelli even make it to court, he is found guilty, sent to jail and sentenced. So like he's over and done with.
20:14 Speaker 00 So then later Amanda and Raffaelli go to trial. And at this stage is when the media really starts to sink its teeth into this story. Back in the day it was MySpace, they'd trolled through Amanda's MySpace and found every picture that made her look even vaguely bad. And they start referring to her by a nickname, Foxy Noxy, which sounds terrible, but was actually a nickname given to her when she was playing soccer as a child. And they made her into this kind of vixen character who obviously was doing this for some kind of sexual gratification and then turned on Meredith in the moment. So if we fast forward now to December 4, 2009, the jury finds Amanda and Raffaelli guilty, which comes as a real shock to everybody because the way that that case was handled,
20:57 Speaker 00 the prosecutors didn't hand over a lot of the evidence until very late. They didn't have a chance to refute a lot of it. They were really kind of flying by the seat of their pants at a lot of these junctures of the trial. And they're found guilty and they're sent off to prison. And the two of them are so shell shocked, they don't really know what to do. Amanda claims then that's when she really started to research her own investigation. And by this stage, she's becoming more fluent in Italian, so she can read documentation better and she can understand the processes a bit better. But the media has really sunk its teeth into the point where every little thing is being leaked of hers to the press. So, for example, and this is true in the drama,
21:42 Speaker 00 when she was admitted into prison, they took a blood test and they falsely found her positive for HIV.
21:48 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
21:48 Speaker 00 And she was told basically, that's it, you have HIV. And, you know, in the early 2000s, we didn't treat it as well as what we do in 2025.
21:56 Speaker 01 Yes.
21:57 Speaker 00 It was a terrifying diagnosis then. But she was kind of just told, oh, yep, that's it. And then to write a list of men that she potentially had sexual contact with so that they can be contacted.
22:05 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
22:05 Speaker 00 That list was then stolen from her cell and given to the media to paint another picture of just how immoral that this
22:12 Speaker 01 Yes.
22:13 Speaker 00 young American girl was. Eventually, there is an appeal. So, 2011, they go back to court on appeal. This is when the DNA evidence becomes crucial. So, they watched the video of how the DNA collection process was handled. And you can see in the investigation's own video evidence that they handled it incorrectly. So, just as an example, that brass strap that we spoke about before, in the first video evidence, we can see it's underneath Meredith's pillow. And then by the next time that they collect that evidence, it's on the floor under the corner of a rug.
22:49 Speaker 01 So it's been contaminated.
22:50 Speaker 00 It's been contaminated.
22:51 Speaker 01 As I say in the drama series. And there's a question of like, how much is it being contaminated? And the person says, like, it doesn't actually matter because the fact that it's been moved and handled already makes that
23:00 Speaker 00 Exactly.
23:01 Speaker 01 inadmissible evidence.
23:01 Speaker 00 Exactly right. And you can see, and in the original trial, they looked at that brass strap, that obviously it had been forcefully pulled apart and like the prongs were pulled apart. But really, what had happened is it's obviously been stood on while it's on the floor. And you can see that in the evidence between when you first see it and when you second see it. And then as far as the DNA on the knife is concerned, there was so little trace evidence that they had to override the DNA testing machine in order for it to register. And they were questioned in court about that. And they said, if you didn't override that machine, would it have found trace DNA of all three of them? And they said probably not, of Meredith's DNA. So, and also, they found that the knife had been transported in a box that had had other things in it. So it was, it was poorly handled.
23:46 Speaker 00 So they were acquitted after that. Amanda goes home to the US, Rafaeli attempts to get on with his life. Amanda and Raffaele again are brought to trial in Italy. They decide to re-prosecute them. They are found guilty the next time around. Amanda does not return to Italy from the US. Raffaele does eventually return to Italy to try and defend himself. And then there is another appeal on that and they do then acquit them and that's it. Case closed. So this goes on for quite a few years. But as we can see, there is a lot of truth in the drama, the way that it's depicted. But also we can never know what exactly happened in some of these situations because it is not documented.
24:30 Speaker 01 Yes, so it's very much from her point of view and her experience and then her take on it. So in that case, it's not meant to be, I don't think, watched as a factual program. It's more there to just see it through her eyes. And for a lot of people, they're coming to this story for nearly the first time through this drama.
24:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, and if you were, like I said, understanding it from just media reports, the way that she was portrayed was interesting. That she had become this kind of demon girl, this American demon, sexual deviant that they really painted her as. And it was, it was widely believed in the press that she was some kind of awful murderer who was in it for sexual pleasure.
25:07 Speaker 01 Yes, that she was like a sex crazed maniac. And to be honest, like I do understand, I mean, I don't understand of obviously the horrific side of this of like taking a murder investigation and demonizing someone who at that stage had been found guilty and was later acquitted. But I do understand because it's like a perfect storm of everything that the media in some parts thrives on. But also what consumers want, like nothing sells better and nothing gets better numbers or more attention than a beautiful young woman, especially a beautiful young white woman at the centre of some sort of very intense and gruesome crime. It's like all of these different facets of society coming together.
25:44 Speaker 00 And who doesn't respond in the moment like we would expect someone to. And she does kind of explain that she has a bit of a weird personality and she doesn't always act in a way that people understand. And, and as we know now, we understand not everyone reacts the same. So it is really interesting. But also too, I read an article by an Italian journalist who was like, everyone said the Italian media was out to get her and demonize her. And that is partly true, but it was. More the American press and others who picked up on that and ran with it.
26:12 Speaker 01 Oh, absolutely. And we know from like, looking back at the coverage that so many American news outlets sent whole news teams, camera people, reporters over there who were there for months at a time, camped in front of the crime scene, camped outside of the prison, the courthouse, following Amanda's family around and people involved in the story. And a lot of the story came from just images that they would capture of her going in and out of different court proceedings and not just what was in the courtroom at the time. And if you look at just the pictures and the videos at the time, I mean, I know we're looking through it through a lens of like the story being that at the time, but she does look very guilty. If you look at just the media coverage, she does look like a vixen who orchestrated to kill someone because of the pictures they chose to run
26:53 Speaker 01 because of the videos they showed and because she wasn't acting like a perfect victim of how you would expect someone in that situation to react.
27:00 Speaker 00 Yeah. And it is really interesting to watch this drama, understanding the true crime behind it because a lot of it is factual. Like a lot of it is. And their recreation of the crime scene, the court proceedings weren't recorded either. So we don't know exactly, they were behind closed doors. So we don't know exactly what happened there, but there were photographers in the courtroom that captured these moments too. And, and they really recreated some of that incredibly well. To the point where when I was looking at some photos, I had to stop myself and go, hang on, is that the real Amanda Knox? Or is that the actress playing Amanda Knox? Because they did a really faithful recreation of her outfits, the apartment, inside the apartment, which was really quite incredible. I scrolled through the crime scene photos myself and had a look at what it really looked like.
27:44 Speaker 00 And it really does. They've done a very faithful job at recreating it.
27:48 Speaker 01 And that's part of the reason getting into like, why this TV show exists is that they wanted to be really faithful to the story. And obviously there's a lot of back and forth over whether the TV show should exist or not. Like even people who don't have any thoughts on whether or not she's guilty or what happened, have a bit of an issue of one, a story like this being dredged up, but two, if it was even necessary to put it into like the entertainment drama space. Because since Amanda Knox was acquitted that final time, she's written two different memoirs. She's done a podcast, there's so many documentaries, some that she's had a hand in, some that she hasn't. She's done well over a hundred interviews at this stage, just because she's done so many.
28:28 Speaker 00 Including one here at Mamma Mia, which we'll play a little bit of in a minute.
28:31 Speaker 01 Yes, exactly. Like, she has really told her story. So a lot of people were thinking, like, why go back for, like, another sip from the well to this story? So there's a lot of questions and commentary around whether or not this TV show should have been made and should it exist? I think we both have strong feelings on that. There's a lot of strong feelings from the public, which is what we're going to get into next.
28:52 Speaker 01 So you've studied Amanda Knox's case so closely now, you've watched the full drama series. I know you've seen all of the commentary from people who've watched it and from the families involved. What's your thought on whether or not this TV show should exist?
29:04 Speaker 00 I'm so conflicted.
29:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, me too. Isn't that interesting?
29:08 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:08 Speaker 01 Even after everything we've consumed, usually at this stage of the game, I would have a very clear view of whether or not something like this should have been made. But like everything else with this story, it's like very complex.
29:18 Speaker 00 It is. And I think the biggest thing is that this will never be Meredith Kercher's story.
29:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
29:25 Speaker 00 And that is what is touched on a little bit in The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox, that it should be about a beautiful young woman whose life was cut tragically short. And it should be about the man who did that to her and the fact that he is spending his life behind bars, although I believe he's been released now. So why is it never about Meredith? Why is it always about Amanda? And she acknowledges that. And she acknowledges that Meredith is now essentially her story. But for the family of Meredith, like, I can fully understand why they have responded the way they have. Like, why are we doing this again? Why do we keep talking about this story like this is Amanda's story? But also, if you put yourself in Amanda's shoes, and someone falsely accused me of murder, sent me to prison,
30:08 Speaker 00 and really dragged my name through the mud for years and years and years. A legacy that she still lives with to this day. There are still legions of people who do not believe her. They believe that she is guilty.
30:21 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
30:22 Speaker 00 And they will tell her. And there is a part in the series where she starts to, like, understand the new technology that she's come back into the world to see. And The messages she starts to get are pretty intense and, you know, there were death threats and, you know, telling her to take her own life and like, that's an intense thing to deal with all the time. So would I, in Amanda's shoes, want to keep telling my story so that people understand me better and who understand the situation better? I guess I get it from her perspective and wanting to set the record straight over and over and over when people still don't believe you, like, I really understand that. But I
31:00 Speaker 00 just, I feel for Meredith's family, whose story just gets overlooked, misunderstood. And there are still people, even in Meredith's family, who aren't sure what they believe either.
31:12 Speaker 01 Yes.
31:12 Speaker 00 So to see Amanda also profiting from this, like, that's hard for them to see and hard for them to take. So I'm still really conflicted. I get it, but I don't want to see Meredith again become the victim.
31:26 Speaker 01 Yeah. And that's the difficult thing of watching it is that Meredith Kercher's family were contacted in the lead up to the show, like, before it went into production. And they told production they wanted nothing to do with it, which was expected. So they pushed on ahead without it. But it was more so when the show was released and the fact that it's been coming out weekly and even the lead up to that with Amanda, like, releasing a podcast and, and doing a lot of press around that and seeing all those headlines come up again. And the response from the family was always, please don't do this, please don't drag this up again, please don't drag her name in front of the world again. And it's something that Amanda Knox does talk about quite a bit. And something I always, when I'm watching interviews with her, find interesting is that she'll often say to the interviewer, you know my name and you know Meredith's name, but do you know the name of the man who actually committed the crime? And a lot of the time, people don't know his name.
32:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:11 Speaker 01 And they don't know his story or his face or anything because he's not a young woman and that's not an exciting part of the case. But in terms of why they made it, Amanda Knox has always said that it's because she gave birth to a daughter and then suddenly she realised that her daughter would be growing up in a world where so many people still thought she was guilty of murder and-
32:29 Speaker 00 So she's inheriting a legacy.
32:31 Speaker 01 Exactly. And it's almost like reading between the lines of listening to Amanda speak about this is that it's almost like her last ditch effort to clear her name through drama because she knows how much, especially at this point in time. Right now, how much the world responds to drama in a way that we sometimes don't respond to an interview or an article. So she's written the memoirs, she's done press tours so many times over the years, she's done the podcast, so many people have released information about it. And yet she only saw a drama as the way to clear her name, essentially. And maybe it's because she could have complete control over the narrative that in a way you can't have with even a memoir or something, because a memoir, you're just reading the same voice all the way through. With a TV show, you're seeing all of these actors relive those moments. And
33:15 Speaker 01 like we're saying, it was a very sensory heavy show. So you almost feel like you've gone through it with her. And so that idea was like, people would watch the show and it's so through her eyes that you would come out of it believing her. And the subtext, I think of all her interviews is that she thought that was worth bringing it up again.
33:32 Speaker 00 Yeah.
33:32 Speaker 01 As like one last attempt to clear her name.
33:35 Speaker 00 Yeah. And we are seeing this real moment for these stories being told in this manner. So like the Menendez brothers, for example, I had reported on their story as a journalist many times over the years as they've kind of attempted to be free. And I had a very preformed opinion of whether I thought what they did was done purely for greed, which is what they'd been positioned as in the media and by the prosecution. And then when you see their stories dramatized, and you understand a little bit more about what was going on behind closed doors, and you understand that, you know, maybe as children, they're abused. And so, you know, you understand the crime a little bit better. And now there are calls
34:19 Speaker 00 for their freedom, even though they are not free as of us recording this podcast. But I can understand why Amanda might want to also be a part of this moment where people are reclaiming their own narrative, especially when it's through a drama that can take you to the place and the time.
34:34 Speaker 01 Yes.
34:35 Speaker 00 And can put you in the situation. And like, if I was 20, in a foreign country where I don't speak the language, was accused of a terrible, terrible crime, and have no family support, and not understand what's happening to me, and finding myself in jail, not even understanding what I've signed, because the truth of the matter is she signed a document, and she didn't even fully understand what it was she was signing.
35:00 Speaker 01 Hmm.
35:00 Speaker 00 And so. To put myself in that position, like, that would be terrifying.
35:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:06 Speaker 00 And I don't think you get that. You're right. When you listen to her speak on a podcast or you read her memoir, it doesn't put you in the time and place. And it doesn't make you experience that alongside her. And I think it's actually kind of smart because I did legitimately change my view on this case after watching this.
35:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, to an extent. And again, it's just nothing kind of pulls you in like a drama. It's like we saw this year with apple side of vinegar and Belle Gibson. Like, a lot of people knew that story. They knew that she had lied about having cancer. But there was this renewed kind of rally behind the victims and the journalists involved and everything worldwide in a way that hadn't happened, even when we saw Belle Gibson giving these interviews. And I think with the drama too, it's so many elements have been able to control it, but also like the choice of actress, like with Grace Van Patten, who gives this very kind of vulnerable performance. And she's acting in a way that we didn't, at least in the clips we saw. And this was like a very strategic thing from the production team from her, because she's meant to be playing a woman who's been thrust into this.
36:02 Speaker 01 And so we don't see her acting for the cameras in the way that people think Amanda Knox did. And a lot of effort went into casting the exact right person for that role, which you can imagine because they didn't want to cast an actress who might be almost painted with the same brush that Amanda Knox is. Like, is she seen as a sexualized actress? What other roles has she played? Will she come across as like not sympathetic and vulnerable enough? And so there was this real call to find a very vulnerable looking actress, which I think Grace Van Patten, who most people would know from the TV show Tell Me Lies, is kind of almost known for being that type of character actress, where she often plays the more subdued kind of almost victim character. And it was meant to be Margaret Crawley originally. She was attached and they moved her out and put her into this role.
36:45 Speaker 01 But I think the other interesting thing is who else is involved behind the scenes of this production, which is Monica Lewinsky.
36:51 Speaker 00 Which was a real surprise. When I saw them sitting on an American TV show on the couch next to each other, I'm like, oh, that's an interesting lineup of guests and didn't realise they were talking about the exact same thing.
36:59 Speaker 01 Their co-project they've been working on. So they met in 2017. They were both speaking at an event and Amanda said that she was like getting quite overcome and quite stressed about publicly speaking, but also just everything about reliving her story over and over again. And she said she went to the green room and she was stressing out and Monica Lewinsky came in and they very instantly bonded, shared stories. Monica Lewinsky was giving her tips on how to do this next part of being in the public eye.
37:26 Speaker 05 I've spent the majority of my adult life. Feeling like no one cared what I had to say and anything I did say was always twisted against me. And then I find myself invited to go give a talk for the first time ever and I'm utterly terrified. I also learned that someone else is going to be speaking at this event and it happens to be the one and only Monica Lewinsky, whose Vanity Fair articles and whose TED Talks have given me hope that there might be a path forward in my life. And so I asked the organizer if I could please, please, please meet her.
38:04 Speaker 06 I think Amanda was the highlight of that event that day and people were so, I think they were just so impressed by you, which I was when we first met and I had so much compassion for you. And it really was kind of the beginning of us knowing each other.
38:26 Speaker 01 Monica Lewinsky, for anyone who doesn't know, in the late 1990s was working in the White House and said that she had had an affair with then-President Bill Clinton and was absolutely, there's no other way to put it, such shamed.
38:37 Speaker 00 Oh, my gosh, yeah.
38:38 Speaker 01 And painted to be a liar and all of these things.
38:42 Speaker 00 She seduced the president.
38:43 Speaker 01 Yes. And became not just a huge villain and this hatred of the world, but also just became a mockery and just basically the entire world turned against her. And you talk about people being canceled, but they don't really get canceled, but she was really canceled with her whole life.
38:58 Speaker 00 She was a butt of jokes for like decades after that occurred. And she has been the epitome of reclaiming the narrative.
39:05 Speaker 01 Exactly.
39:06 Speaker 00 And that's where social media has actually been the most amazing thing for some people because she took to then Twitter, which is now X, and we finally got to know who Monica Lewinsky actually is and is not just this vixen intern who happened to, you know, seduce the most powerful man in the world.
39:25 Speaker 01 Yes, because it did come out that she was telling the truth.
39:27 Speaker 00 Yes.
39:28 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, and she also has Had a hand in documentaries about that situation where she has been actually asked about those experiences and has told them exactly what happened. And so she's been able to really turn around being the butt of every late night host joke for a long time. And she talks about her mum sitting next to her bed and like begging her not to take her own life because of just how bad it got for her in the late nineties and early two thousands. And so she is now thriving because she's been able to tell her story and be believed. So that's, it makes sense now that the two of them are working together on it.
40:05 Speaker 01 Exactly. And that's why Monica wanted to be involved in the Amanda Knox, in the televised version of her story. She said, I can't relate to being falsely accused of a crime like that because her situation was a different situation, it was more of a situation of public shaming. And she's like, and I can't relate to being falsely in prison, but I do know what it's like to have the world turn against you and have your story not be your own. And I think even though she had hard evidence to show that what she said about the president and everything that happened to her afterwards was true, a lot of people still saw her, as you're saying, in a different light. So when they did the Monica Lewinsky TV series, when Beanie Feldstein played her, it's again that whole thing of drama reshaping a narrative in the way that factual information can't. Whereas that brought a whole new audience over to her side.
40:49 Speaker 01 So I think that's why she was so instrumental on this Amanda Knox series of being an executive producer and being able to say like, tell this part of the story or don't tell this part, or even like, we don't know the extent of it, but I think she would even be coaching her through the press around it and everything to sort of shape it as like the perfect kind of reclaiming of her story. Because in the series, Amanda does become this strong hero, like she almost becomes like a young adult, like a Katniss Everdeen or something towards the end. And I feel that it was done in a very careful way for her to first be a victim and then they kind of made her into this heroine, like she's not just clearing her own name, but she's standing up against the system.
41:26 Speaker 00 She's becoming an advocate for people who've been wrongly accused.
41:28 Speaker 01 And she's walking into the courtroom and saying like, I speak the language, I do this, I've done the work. And then we see her coming back into the prison, everyone applauding for her and cheering for her and her being seen as this saviour.
41:39 Speaker 00 Okay, hold that thought, Laura Brodnik, because I think what really shook me a little bit watching this is that break from reality into fantasy that happens quite regularly throughout the entire series. I want to get your take on exactly why that is and what is happening next.
41:56 Speaker 00 So as we mentioned just before the break then, if you're watching this series, you would have noticed that sometimes it's Amanda telling her story and she does a little bit of that via narration, which I know some people despise. I actually quite like it. But then it'll cut to really fanciful scenes in one, she's a child and her teddy bears are applauding her for performing a little at-home dance. And often it's like there's one in a library where she's like floating around on the ladder that goes up and rolls around. Like it's this weird pull from reality into fantasy. What is that about?
42:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's interesting to bring up because that is the part of the show that a lot of critics and viewers had the most issue with. Because a lot of what people gave this show a pass for is the fact that they said Amanda was trying to tell her story and also honour Meredith's story. And we see a bit of a montage of Meredith at the end as a sort of like, just remember she's at the centre of this. But a lot of people feel that that feels very disingenuous when they also added these fantasy elements to it. But it was a very specific choice because Amanda Knox and the team said that they wanted to add all these facets of magical realism. And magical realism, if you're not across the whole fantasy kind of world, like we have high fantasy, which is a whole world being recreated with its
43:11 Speaker 01 whole different ways of being and its own rules. And then you have more of like fantasy, which is very kind of old school, like a whole world that's touched by magic. And then you have magical realism, which is a story that takes place in our world as it is now. And there's one tiny string of magic. And that's what we kind of see from Amanda's point of view. And they wanted to do that. It's interesting because at the top of the series, you almost feel like you're watching like a bit of an Italian kind of romantic drama. And that's very deliberate from them because they wanted to show that it's all about putting you in Amanda's mind. And in her mind, at the start of the show, when we meet her, she is a young woman in Italy, having adventure and having a new romance. And how intoxicating that is. And they wanted to show that as the story went long, those
43:56 Speaker 01 moments where you see the teddy bears applauding her or her floating. One is that they're trying to make a little homage to some movies, like an Amelie or a Pulp Fiction.
44:04 Speaker 00 Also, Amelie's the movie that her and Raffaele watched the night of Meredith's murder.
44:08 Speaker 01 Which apparently is the movie they watched that night. And there's a kind of a few fanciful scenes in that movie, but they took it the next step higher. And This is where I think maybe I take issue with some critics is like you can't have a story that is about telling this huge truth that's based on a rape and murder and frame yourself as Amelie. Like they're two very different methods of storytelling.
44:28 Speaker 00 Clashed.
44:29 Speaker 01 It's jarring, isn't it?
44:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, it is jarring. And it's, it's hard, especially when you're looking at it from a true crime perspective, because like you are, as you said earlier, pulled into this world, which is really intense. And it feels like you're being interrogated or you're in prison with her and you're so like you lose all hope at some stages. And then, you know, it's all like butterflies and fairies. And it feels like, oh, my God, where is my brain now supposed to take that?
44:53 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I would have probably maybe liked it more as a storytelling device if maybe you can see her from the beginning to the end as she's imprisoned for so many years. If you maybe saw her start to lose her grip on reality as the show goes along and she starts having some sort of illusions. Yeah, maybe something. Cause like you do hear of people in these situations that things like that happen, that their mental state becomes so intensified that they do start hallucinating or recreating stories. But the way it's threaded through is to show that she's almost an otherworldly being. And they're trying to show that she has this very fanciful mind. She's not like other people, which is why she didn't react in a certain way. So it all comes that full circle of trying to show her innocence. But I think it comes across as a little messy
45:35 Speaker 01 and a little self indulgent. And self indulgent is what a lot of people have labeled the series.
45:39 Speaker 00 And you really can't be self indulgent when you're trying to tell your story in the midst of the murder of someone who you called a friend. Like that is hard.
45:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's, it's almost, the thing is like, they did what they set out to do, which I find the interesting thing too. Like I find it difficult to sit down and watch a series like this and say, but you should have told this or you should have told that. Like it's the Amanda Knox story is kind of what it's meant to be. What I think we need is we need someone to go and make more of a Meredith story, which to be honest, I don't think I've seen anything. I know a lot about her life, but I don't think there's anything that's attributed completely to her where we would see a dramatization of like her childhood, her life, her getting into this.
46:18 Speaker 00 And even in this, we don't even see a dramatization of her murder.
46:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
46:20 Speaker 00 We only see Amanda turn up after the fact.
46:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I guess like the thinking from the writer's team is that they didn't want to, they obviously have to use her name in her story because it's so wrapped up in Amanda, but they didn't want it to be overly gory and see that as kind of like a voyeurism into her murder, which so much of true crime can be if done the wrong way.
46:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, it can be, but also like when we're talking about the rape and murder of a young woman, it feels like that should be given a bit more gravitas than it has. Like it wasn't, we weren't given a moment to mourn Meredith.
46:51 Speaker 01 Yes.
46:51 Speaker 00 At all during this whole thing. And maybe that's the point because Amanda also wasn't given an opportunity to mourn her friend. Like, maybe that's the reason for that. But myself, as you know, the voyeur looking in on this, I felt like Meredith was this kind of other worldly character who you never really get to know.
47:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, she's like a faceless victim almost in a story that is about the end of her life, but also her life. And I know there's times like in that they do like cut to looking at her family members and cut to looking at her friends. And so you get, you get a little bit of her life through their reaction, but not a lot. And I guess there's also at the top of the show, because it's told through Amanda's perspective and it was dramatized, it very much shows her and Meredith becoming friends and this closeness between them. Which if you listen to any of Meredith's friends or family, they say that they weren't close friends, they didn't get along, that Meredith felt very uneasy about her. And something about that I find almost more troubling because not showing the murder and the impact of the rape is definitely not the best choice.
47:52 Speaker 01 But also rewriting this woman to have this friendship she didn't have, to make the character of Amanda look more sympathetic is also a disservice to her, I think.
48:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:02 Speaker 01 Because you're just.
48:03 Speaker 00 But again, this is from Amanda's perspective, so.
48:05 Speaker 01 And she says they were friends. Yeah, so that, that's the hard, I think, the blurring line of, I almost wish they had made it a bit more, almost a bit more fanciful and a bit more of a series rather than like a beat by beat retelling of an event. Because it makes it even harder to kind of separate fact and fiction because it's so meshed together.
48:23 Speaker 00 It is really a meshed together. And if you do want the answer to this question, did Amanda return to Italy many years later after she'd married Christopher Robinson and had a little baby girl, who we talked about earlier, to meet with Minini, who is, she calls him my prosecutor, who, the man who investigated and then prosecuted the case? Yes, she did do that. She did return to Italy, she did have a conversation with him. We only know from Amanda's perspective what that conversation looks like. And then there is a scene at the end which. Makes it look like Minnie goes to confession.
48:54 Speaker 01 Hmm.
48:55 Speaker 00 We don't know if that's true, but the priest who Amanda spoke to in jail and who also happened to be Minnie's childhood priest and who helped bring them together at the end, he's a real person. And so maybe that did happen.
49:08 Speaker 01 Maybe it did.
49:09 Speaker 00 Who knows? But yeah, there's a lot of blurring of lines here, but you've just got to remember when you're going to watch this, it is from Amanda's perspective.
49:15 Speaker 01 Yes.
49:16 Speaker 00 It's her narrative, it's her story, it's not Meredith's story. That's a story we're still yet to hear.
49:21 Speaker 01 And Amanda has actually addressed what her relationship with Meredith Kercher's family looks like now on Mama Mia's No Filter Podcast, talking to Kate Langbrooke and, and kind of explaining where she sits with the family now.
49:32 Speaker 00 Thanks so much for listening to this very special crossover episode of The Spill and True Crime Conversations. The Spill is produced by Monisha Iswaran and True Crime Conversations is produced by Tali Blackman. Audio production for this episode was done by Scott Stronach with video production by Gillian Rosario. Bye, we should do this again one day.
49:49 Speaker 01 We should. Stay tuned for another crossover.
Previous "I Was Held In A Soundproof Bunker By My Stalker": Samantha Stites Speaks Out Next Unmasking Chopper Read: The Infamous Australian Criminal Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated