Pod Insights True Crime Conversations The Real Story Of Ed Gein: The Original Psycho About this episode On September 8, 1960, Psycho shocked cinema audiences with a level of psychological horror never seen before. But Psycho wasn’t pure fiction. It was inspired by the gruesome true story of Ed Gein, the real-life Butcher of Plainfield.
When police raided Gein’s Wisconsin farmhouse in 1957, they uncovered a macabre scene: human remains crafted into lampshades, furniture, and clothing. These discoveries stunned the nation and sparked a media frenzy that would influence generations of horror storytelling.
In this episode of True Crime Conversations, host Claire Murphy speaks with acclaimed true crime author Harold Schechter, whose book remains the definitive account of Ed Gein’s crimes. Following the Netflix release of Monsters: The Ed Gein Story from Ryan Murphy, Schechter reflects on how Gein’s legacy has been interpreted, and sometimes distorted, by Hollywood.
You can find out more about Harold's book Deviant: The Shocking True Story of Ed Gein, The Original Psycho here https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Deviant/Harold-Schechter/9781668048177.
CREDITS
Guest: Harold Schechter
Host: Claire Murphy https://www.linkedin.com/in/claire-murphy-52121979/?originalSubdomain=au
Senior Producer: Tahli Blackman https://www.linkedin.com/in/tahli-blackman-205a891b7/?originalSubdomain=au
Group Executive Producer: Ilaria Brophy
Audio Engineer: Carl Step/Abe’s Audio
GET IN TOUCH
Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @truecrimeconversations https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeconversations/?hl=en
Make sure to leave us a rating and review on Apple & Spotify to let us know how you're liking the episodes.
Want us to cover a case on the podcast? Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected] or send us a voice note. https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 True Crime Conversations acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters that this podcast was recorded on. When moviegoers headed into cinemas across America on September 8, 1960, they had no idea what was about to happen to them. The movie Psycho, one of Alfred Hitchcock's all-time greatest creations, was new to cinemas. It was a story of Norman Bates, the man with a split personality and an unhealthy relationship with his mother, whose type of depravity had never been explored on the big screen before. A true American monster, his violence culminating in the stabbing murder of Marion Crane, played to screaming brilliance by Janet Leigh as she was confronted by the knife-wielding maniac while showering.
0:44 Speaker 00 Now, that scene reportedly led to trauma so deep that many who'd seen it became terrified of entering their bathrooms unaccompanied. The soundtrack to that moment is still used to depict violence and horror. But Psycho wasn't all fiction. It was actually based on the very true story of a simple Wisconsin man, a man whose mother's love was all he ever wanted, and when he could no longer get it, would go to extreme and horrifying lengths to recreate it. Events that would lead to that man, Ed Gein, being tagged as the Butcher of Plainfield.
1:24 Speaker 00 I'm Claire Murphy and this is True Crime Conversations, a podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. When police raided Ed Gein's property in November 1957, they would have to spend days sorting through the trophies he'd collected. Body parts were everywhere. But on closer inspection, investigators realized that that waste basket in the corner, it was made out of human skin. In fact, several chairs had also been upholstered in human skin. The lampshade, that was a human face. The horror of what Ed Gein had left behind in his family farmhouse led police to believe
2:06 Speaker 00 that he'd maybe murdered a dozen people to create this twisted set of homewares. But the reality was much, much darker. Ed Gein and his influence on pop culture remains to this day with the recent release on Netflix of Ryan Murphy's third series of Monsters, The Ed Gein Story. When author Harold Schechter saw it was being made, he wondered why no one in Ryan Murphy's camp had reached out to him. After all, his book is the leading source of information about the Gein family and the events leading up to Ed Gein's arrest and subsequent conviction, where the court found him not guilty by reason of insanity. But when we sat down with him to discuss Gein's crimes, he says as soon as he saw the opening scenes of Monsters,
2:48 Speaker 00 he knew they hadn't based the story on any of his work. Harold joins us now.
2:55 Speaker 00 Harold, thank you so much for joining us today. Your name has come up pretty much in every conversation around Ed Gein, seeing as he's back in the headlines from Ryan Murphy's Monsters version on Netflix. Have you seen it yet?
3:07 Speaker 01 Yes, I have. I saw it as soon as it dropped.
3:10 Speaker 00 What are your thoughts?
3:12 Speaker 01 Well, you know, initially, when I first heard Ryan Murphy was going to be making an Ed Gein documentary, and no one had reached out to me, because, I don't want to sound immodest, but, you know, my book Deviant really told the Gein story for the first time. And, yeah, I felt that no one could really make a series about Gein without referring to or using my book. Then, as soon as I started watching the series, I was upset because so little of it had to do with my book. And I dropped the whole idea of any kind of legal
3:52 Speaker 01 action, because the series deviates, if I can use that word, so far from the historical truth. Now I've been upset because millions of people are going to think that they've seen the actual story of Ed Gein, when what they've seen is, I would estimate, 90% fabrication, possibly more. So, yes, so that's my response to it.
4:19 Speaker 00 Well, let's talk about the real story of Ed Gein then, and we'll keep referencing back to Monsters just to see where it does deviate. But I think to best understand Ed Gein, you have to understand his family background first. Can you give us a little understanding on who his parents, George and Augusta, were?
4:36 Speaker 01 Well, one thing I discovered, the Deviant was my first true crime book.
4:43 Speaker 01 And I I've encountered the same thing i- in many books I've done since is that there were such obscure people that there's almost no record of what was going on really in the household. I mean, we know that the father, George, was apparently an abusive alcoholic. We know that Augusta was a dominant figure in the household in terms of running a business. They originally had a lacrosse before they moved to Plainfield. We know that she totally dominated Ed's life, that she was a religious fanatic who drilled into him the sense that
5:28 Speaker 01 the world outside their little farmstead was kind of a sodom and gomorrah, that women were evil, that Ed had to protect himself from the dangers of strange women, you know, that she would hector him constantly and read to him biblical passages about the evils of womanhood. Pretty much that's really all we know about his parents and his relationship to his parents.
5:58 Speaker 00 We see in Monsters Augusta kicking George out of the family home, which obviously isn't true. I mean, for many reasons, we can fill in the blanks because Augusta was such a devout Lutheran divorce or separation wouldn't have been on the cards for her.
6:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:15 Speaker 00 But so what do we know of George's fate? Did he, was he kicked out of the home?
6:21 Speaker 01 No, no, absolutely not. I I think he became increasingly a burden to Augusta because, again, his problem with drink made him increasingly unreliable and unable to perform a lot of the chores around the farm.
6:41 Speaker 01 But he died at home. I can read his obituary in the local newspapers. So that is just one of, I would have to say, almost countless fabrications that the Ryan Murphy series presents.
6:56 Speaker 00 Well, let's talk about Augusta because she does play a pivotal role in both Monsters, but in Ed Gein's life. We know that, as you mentioned, she was quite domineering. And you, in your book, step out how you've seen her role increase over time in that she becomes the named proprietor of the business that they run, that she is the name on the deed of the farm, the first and second farm that they end up purchasing.
7:20 Speaker 00 Why do they end up in such an isolated place? Because Plainfield itself is a very small community. There's only several hundred people who live there. But the farm on which they lived was outside of that, too. And in the early 1900s, there wasn't a lot of, you know, road traffic outside these farms. It would have, you know, been weeks for people to head out and visit them. And then, you know, they would then have to head into town for supplies. But why isolate her family from everybody?
7:48 Speaker 01 Well, again, as you say, I mean, it's a very, that part of Wisconsin, everybody's pretty isolated from each other. I think they moved there because there was this available farm with a, you know, a very extensive piece of property. They thought they could make a go of it after living in the city, La Croix. She wanted to get away from the city because, again, she felt cities were hellholes of corruption and depravity. You know, the isolation, I think, suited Augusta because, again, she was very, very wary of all the people around her. Possibly she felt she could exert a more domineering influence over the lives of her family members if they lived farther apart from the community.
8:33 Speaker 01 But in general, people lived isolated lives. I mean, the Geins were an extreme case. But that part of Wisconsin is very sparsely populated. Even when I went up there in the 1980s, you could drive through very long stretches.
8:52 Speaker 01 Of that part of the state and never, you know, pass another car on the road.
8:58 Speaker 00 So they're out there on this isolated farm. Augusta is in charge of educating her two young boys, Henry and Ed. We understand, as you've mentioned, that she's very strict on them as far as her religion is concerned. But she's also instilling in them, as you've also mentioned, this fear and distaste of women in general. It does seem that at some stage, Henry does try to kind of move away from that. But Ed is a little bit different. He seems, and this is also mentioned in your book, where her school friends are concerned, that he seems like a sweet enough boy, but he struggles to make connections with people. And it turns out that his mother is also playing a role in that, in that every friend that he makes,
9:42 Speaker 00 she tells him that, that something wrong with that child's parents or the father is immoral or whatever it might be.
9:49 Speaker 01 Yep.
9:49 Speaker 00 So what kind of mental state do you think Ed Gein is in as he's growing up under the influence of his domineering mother?
9:57 Speaker 01 Well, again, from what we know, for whatever reason, Augusta apparently wanted to have a daughter. And there was something, and when Ed came along, you know, she was very disappointed that she hadn't given birth to a girl. Her first child was a son, Henry. And I think she, part of the stranglehold she kept on him involved is turning her into a more feminine kind of person. You know, there's always something, from what I understand, from having interviewed people who had known him, which I did when I did my research in Plainfield, a little bit of feminine about Ed.
10:37 Speaker 01 You know, that made him a bit of a, not a laughing stock, but you know, sometimes a butt of cruel teasing. So, yeah, I mean, she, she kept, you know, this emotional stranglehold on him. You know, the expression tied, being tied to her apron strings. I mean, he was really bound to her. That expression doesn't really capture the extent of her, of her hold on to him. I mean, she just kept him.
11:11 Speaker 01 Kind of attached to her, by his umbilical cord to her. And Henry, you know, there is evidence that Henry was trying to pull away. Henry had, you know, saw the kinds of conditions that his brother Ed was living under. Did urge him somehow to try to achieve some kind of independence from Augusta. Again, we don't really know all the details. There's some indication that it created a certain amount of tension between them, which then after Gaines' crimes were exposed, led people to believe he murdered Henry, which I'm quite sure he did not.
11:51 Speaker 01 But the interesting thing is, until these sensational murderers become known to the public, they're totally anonymous obscure figures. They're complete nonentities. So there's no reason there would be any real biographical information about their past lives, other than what they themselves, you know, might, as Ed Gaines did, later tell psychiatrists or law enforcement officials. And the accounts of neighbors are very unreliable. Once that is revealed to be this monstrous kind of figure, everybody suddenly, you know, is recalling, and I put that in air quotes, dealings with the family.
12:36 Speaker 01 They always knew something was really weird going on in that household. But, you know, you can't take a lot of those accounts face value.
12:45 Speaker 00 I guess we can attribute that to Adeline as well, who is also featured in Monsters. Adeline, initially, when she's spoken to about, and if you haven't seen Monsters, she's essentially Ed Gaines' girlfriend in Monsters, who seems almost complicit to a point in the crimes that he's committing. She's interviewed back after he is arrested in the 50s. And she says, yes, they had a 20-year-long relationship and he seemed like a sweet, nice man. But then he's interviewed not long after that and says completely the opposite and that she never had a long relationship with him and only dated him for a short period in the 50s. So those recollections, they contradict themselves even at the time of his arrest.
13:27 Speaker 01 Well, again, Ed's relationship with Adeline, as is portrayed in the TV show, is one of its more egregious features.
13:38 Speaker 01 I don't mean to seem cruel about this, but if you look at photographs of the actual Adeline Watkins, she bears a striking resemblance to the actress Margaret Hamilton as the wicked witch of the West in The Wizard of Oz.
13:54 Speaker 01 She was apparently a little bit of a publicity hound when the media descended on Plainfield after the discovery of Ed's atrocities. I think she enjoyed the attention she was getting by claiming she had been Ed's girlfriend, which, as you say, she later retracted. There's no evidence they had much of any kind of relationship at all. I mean, he might have one time asked her to go roller skating, which was a favorite pastime of his, but that's all it amounted to. You know, she was not this twenty-something blonde hottie who is portrayed as Ed's accomplice and conspirator and so on and so forth.
14:34 Speaker 00 That just didn't happen. Well, another thing I'm guessing that didn't happen is Monsters tries to explain the motivation for Ed Gein doing what he did through Adeline in that she gives him a box with photographs from Nazi concentration camps of the bodies of Jewish people and a comic book that is basically a fictionalized tale or somewhat fictionalized tale of Ilse Koch, who was a German war criminal who worked in the concentration camps and committed atrocities against Jewish people.
15:09 Speaker 00 Was any of that even vaguely true? Was he at all influenced by what was happening during the Second World War?
15:15 Speaker 01 Well, he might have. I mean, Gein was a voracious reader, not of comic books, but of these sensational lurid men's magazines at the time. And many of them did, in fact, feature stories about hot Nazi babes, torturing, not even so much committing.
15:40 Speaker 01 You know, committing those kinds of death camp atrocities. There are stories where they're whipping prisoners of war. So there is evidence that Ed was fascinated by some of those accounts that he came across in magazines. We don't know specifically that he really knew anything about Ilsekotch per se. There were a number of those female Nazis who were very notorious for having made lamb shades out of human skin. You know, again, the whole notion that he was introduced to this by Adeline Watkins, you know, is just made up. But it is true.
16:22 Speaker 01 You even can see there are some photographs that were published in Life magazine back in 1957, when the Gein story broke. And there were photographs of the inside of his house. And, you know, the incredible chaos and squalor. And there's one shot, actually, of a cardboard carton filled with these men's magazines. So, yes, he might have read about it. He probably did read about him there.
16:55 Speaker 00 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Claire Murphy. I'm speaking with true crime writer Harold Schechter about the life and crimes of Ed Gein. Up next, I ask Harold, if Ed Gein had succeeded in digging up his mother Augusta's body, would he still have gone on to commit his horrific crimes?
17:15 Speaker 00 Well, his initial foray into utilizing dead bodies for his crimes was after the death of his mother Augusta, which he seemed to take pretty hard. And if she was as dominant a force in his life as we believe she was, then that would have been a terrible blow for him because at that stage, his father has died, Henry has died, and now his mother has died. So he's left on his own. And he does try to dig up her body, but he can't access her because due to the soil conditions in that part of Wisconsin, they sometimes will put concrete over the top to just stop them from sinking down. So do you think, had he been able to access Augusta's body and dig her up at that time, do you think he would have gone any further?
17:59 Speaker 00 Because he does then start digging up other people around her. Do you think he would have gone further had he been able to access his mother's body initially?
18:06 Speaker 01 Hmm, I've never thought of that. Well, very possibly no. One of the major problems I have with the TV series is it portrays Ed Gein as a serial killer, and Ed Gein was not a serial killer. The term serial killer, as I'm sure you know, was coined specifically to apply to people like John Wayne Gacy and Ted Bundy, you know, what used to be called lost murderers in the old days, extreme sexual sadists who derive their perverse ecstatic pleasure from abducting and torturing and then murdering victims. That was not Ed's MO. Ed was essentially a necrophile.
18:48 Speaker 01 The two women he killed, Mary, the tavern keeper Mary Hogan, and the hardware store owner Bernie's Warden, he executed very swiftly. You know, there was no kidnapping and torturing them. He just wanted their bodies to bring back home. So his major motivation seemed to have been this effort to resuscitate his mother. Well, there's a dual motivation. He's acting out this, again, to play armchair Freudian psychoanalyst, you know, this deep ambivalence towards this woman, towards his mother. On the one hand, he consciously sees her as a saint, his only friend, and he wants to bring her back to live with her.
19:30 Speaker 01 At the same time, he's obviously acting out these homicidal impulses towards the body in terms of the mutilations he performs. So all his efforts has, you know, had to do with getting his mother's body back. And since he couldn't access it, trying to somehow reconstitute it from the body parts of these other women. So whether or not he would have been satisfied? Uh, if he had been able to bring Augusta back? Again, I'd never thought of that. It's an interesting question. Again, we can only speculate.
20:03 Speaker 00 Hmm. Well, can we talk a little bit about the things he was doing with the bodies? You say it was to reconstitute his mother essentially, but in amongst all of that, in the Monsters series, there is a big connection with femininity. And as you mentioned, he was a more feminine young man and potentially his mother had almost groomed him into being the daughter that she actually wanted. And there's this exploration of his gender and his obsession with women's undergarments and women's bodies and the fact that he does essentially make a skin suit out of women's body parts that he has allegedly worn at some stage. There is also a conversation in Monsters that he has a fictional conversation with
20:46 Speaker 00 a trans activist who explains he's not trans, but he's actually just obsessed with femininity and women's bodies. But do you think that was true in that he was very concerned about what gender he was supposed to be and that kind of navigation of who he really was? And that's what he was doing with those bodies too?
21:10 Speaker 01 Well, that's probably part of it. You know, when you say Gein made a skin suit, of course, that's where Thomas Harris got the idea for his Buffalo Bill character in Silence of the Lambs. It wasn't a whole suit. The, the, uh, the, the investigators who first were digging up all, all these horrible body parts and so on, in his farmhouse, came upon what they called a mammary vest. So he had apparently flayed the top part of a woman's torso with a breast and strung it with some kind of cords that he could put on his own body, which definitely suggests
21:52 Speaker 01 that obviously, in, in my book, they say that he was somebody who dressed up in women's skin instead of women's clothing.
22:02 Speaker 01 So, you know, Freud uses the term over-determined, which means that there's no one simple cause of behavior. You can see in that, again, both his evidence to recreate his mother, as well as to be, you know, the girl that his mother always wanted to have. The thing about Ed Gein, I was talking about this actually to somebody the other day. It's impossible to explain his behavior ultimately. We all want to, in a way, reduce this unimaginable kind of human behavior to something we can
22:42 Speaker 01 grasp with our rational minds, because it gives us a sense of control over it. But I'll often say, this is hard to understand Ed Gein as it is to understand Mozart, that there are certain human beings whose minds and motivations are just beyond the ability to understand. So, all those factors obviously played into creating the creature we know as Ed Gein. Trying to reduce it to some kind of simple explanation is just not possible. That the conditions of his life caused something to crack in his psyche, and all this archaic
23:24 Speaker 01 stuff, having to do with flaying victims and wearing their skins and making trophies out of body parts, you know, things you see in archaic religions, somehow flooded out in that little Wisconsin farmhouse. It's one of the things that makes the case so endlessly fascinating, is that in the 1950s, in the midst of this bland, balmy America, that's been mythologized as Happy Days, everybody living in nice suburban houses, surrounded with white picket fences, and sitting around
24:03 Speaker 01 on Sunday nights and watching I Love Lucy, the American Heartland, there was this person who, of a squalor and darkness of his little hovel, was enacting, you know, these archaic rituals, like an Aztec priest dressing up in human skin. Well, like going back to our prehistoric ancestors, dissecting the bodies of their victims, shrinking their heads, you know, keeping body parts as trophies. So.
24:36 Speaker 00 Can we talk about the things that were found in Ed Gein's house when he is finally arrested? He's arrested at a neighbor's house having dinner and it's after he murders Bernice, which she's the local hardware store owner. In the movie, it suggested that they had a relationship, a sexual relationship. And then he, in his schizophrenic state, believes that she's given him a venereal disease and that's why he goes and murders her, which none of that is true, right? Or as far as we know, because we're not inside Ed Gein's head at any stage, none of that is true.
25:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, none of it is. It's a complete, complete outrageous lie. And somebody said, apparently Bernice Warden's relations descendants are very upset about that. I mean, Gein had no contact with her at all. I mean, apparently the day before he killed her, he had come into the hardware store and sort of joshingly asked her. She wanted to go roller skating. But the portrait, it's, it's, it's really kind of unconscionable what Ryan Murphy and his collaborator, Ian Brennan, did. Something like that, where there still are family members,
25:57 Speaker 01 I'm not even sure how they could get away with that without being sued in some way, but.
26:02 Speaker 00 There's even a suggestion that Bernice's son is absent in her life and is not, you know, and she's very sad and lonely, but he was, wasn't he the local deputy and raised the alarm after she went missing? Like, none of her story seems to be true.
26:15 Speaker 01 No, none of it's true. I mean, literally, none of it.
26:18 Speaker 00 I mean, other than working in the hardware store, that seems to be the only true thing. Yeah. So after Ed kills her and takes her back to the property at the farm, police quickly find out that he is a suspect because the son does mention that he's come into the store and, and has kind of said a few things to her. And they find him having dinner at a neighbor's house and they arrest him and then they go and they raid his home. What do they find inside the Gein house?
26:50 Speaker 01 Well, first of all, they find Bernie Swarden's body in the summer kitchen adjacent to the house, strung up, beheaded, strung up, dressed out like a deer. The body hollowed out of all its internal organs. They find her head, which Gein had inserted. He'd taken a couple of nails and bent them to make them into hooks and inserted one in each ear with a rope between them. He was apparently intending to hang that up as a trophy on his wall. Inside the house proper, they found bowls made out of the caps of human skulls.
27:34 Speaker 01 They found a box full of vulvas which had been painted silver. They found a belt made of nipples, a shade pole made of human lips. They found that mammary vest that we spoke about before. They found a number of flayed faces. Ed had flayed the faces off of some of these corpses and dried them out and hung them on his bedroom wall. Again, these incomprehensible, incomprehensible horrors. They also at some point found Mary Hogan's. Ed would sometimes joke around, oh, she's, I got her at home. You know, nobody took them seriously.
28:18 Speaker 01 You know, they found her head in a, in a paper bag.
28:21 Speaker 00 I can't imagine what they must have been like for the police who were investigating this. Do they ever speak about the impact that finding all of this had on them mentally?
28:31 Speaker 01 Well, I know that they spoke about the long-term effect, but yeah, one can only imagine. I, I think the horrors were so, again, incomprehensible that they couldn't even really process what they were finding. You know, Gein is really unique as far as I know, not only in the annals of American crime, but in the annals of world crime.
28:57 Speaker 01 You know, people have kept body parts, you know, serial killers have kept body parts as souvenirs and so on and so forth, but nobody did what Gaines did. I mean, Gaines, again, he was essentially a necrophile, but he was less a necrophile who was interested in having sex with the corpses, although, again, Ryan Murphy Show does portray him as having sex with the corpses, which as far as we know, he never did, as somehow using their body parts as raw material for these home improvement projects. It makes him a very American kind of necrophile.
29:36 Speaker 00 Next, Harold tells us what Ed says to police when he's finally arrested and exactly how much detail he went into about his crimes. When he's arrested, what does he say to police? How does, how does he tell them what he's done? Does he admit to it initially?
29:57 Speaker 01 Well, no, not initially. When you read Gaines' confessions, his interrogators ask him all these leading questions, which he admits to, you know, so they'll say, so Ed, did you, we found this, we found this weird vest, you know, made out of the top part of a woman's body, and did you, did you put it on and pretend you were your mother? And he'd say, yeah, that sounds about right. Later on, when he was institutionalized and people would interview him, he would deny almost everything without ever really explaining how all those artifacts ended up in his farmhouse.
30:42 Speaker 01 He did admit, or at least he did not deny that he had done all these things.
30:48 Speaker 00 Well, can we talk about a lot of the other things that Monsters claims he did? There's a disappearance of 15-year-old Evelyn, who in the story was recovering from polio, and so Ed Gaines had stepped in to babysit the children. She normally babysat, but then she recovered and returned, and he resented that, and the Monsters show suggests that he kidnapped and murdered her. The only truth I can find to that is that he, yes, at some stage babysat children to supplement income from the farm, for the farm, and that was about it.
31:20 Speaker 01 Well, Evelyn Hartley was a young girl who disappeared while babysitting. After Gein's horrors were discovered, as is often the case when some sensational murderers have been uncovered, police officers with unsolved cases flocked to Plainfield, hoping to be able to close out these cold cases. One of them was the Evelyn Hartley case. But yeah, Gein evidently had nothing at all to do with the disappearance of Evelyn Hartley. Abducting teenage girls and torturing them and killing them again was not what Gein was all about. It was not his MO. He was not a serial sex killer, which is what the show makes him out to be.
32:04 Speaker 01 And at the end of the show, it makes him out to be sort of the forefather of all these notorious serial killers who appeared back in the seventies and supposedly were inspired by Gein, which is, again, what can I say? You know, just yet another complete fabrication.
32:24 Speaker 00 Is that why we see that scene when he's confronted by two hunters in that little outhouse where you talked about Bernice being strung up like a deer and then he chases them into the woods with a chainsaw and murders them, which essentially tries to explain the influence on the Texas Chainsaw Massacre movie, but there's no evidence that that ever happened, right?
32:44 Speaker 01 No, again, the two hunters, you know, hunters are always getting killed during deer hunting season for one reason or another. Yes, that's complete, I guess I have to use the word lie. Gein, there's no evidence Gein ever owned a chainsaw.
33:04 Speaker 00 Right.
33:05 Speaker 01 After the Gein crime, the Gein crimes became known to most of America because shortly after they came to light, Life magazine, which was essentially this photo journalistic magazine that at the time could be found in almost every middle-class American household.
33:26 Speaker 01 Did a big, big spread on the Gaines crimes. And supposedly Toby Hooper, who was young at the time, he would have been about, he was sort of my age, would have been about nine or 10, you know, read about it and was kind of permanently traumatized by it and recollected the story when he went to make Texas Chainsaw Massacre. But the chainsaw thing, yeah, that game did not dismember any victims with chainsaws and he didn't kill those two hunters. So, yes, that's another thing. Yeah, most of it, you know, if they did was what Murphy and Brennan did was take the broad
34:07 Speaker 01 outlines of the Gaines story and then just fill it in with whatever they thought was gonna titillate an audience for a few hours. I sometimes think of it as a throwback to the kinds of biopics that were made of Hollywood back in the 1930s and 40s. You know, the story of Louis Pasteur or, you know, the story of Thomas Edison or the story of whoever, you know, they take the very broad outlines and just make stuff up to keep the audience entertained. So, I mean, Monsters, as I said, is a particularly, particularly egregious example of that kind of thing. So little of it is based on historical fact.
34:51 Speaker 01 You know, really, you could name the few things that were based on historical fact, like there was an Ed Gaines, he did, you know, rob graves, he did have this weird relationship with his mother. Actually, as soon as I turned it on, the first scene, which shows him engaging in autoerotic asphyxiation.
35:09 Speaker 00 Hmm.
35:10 Speaker 01 As soon as I saw that, I thought, okay, I don't have a legal case anymore.
35:14 Speaker 00 So that, a lot of that, what happened behind closed doors in that farmhouse?
35:21 Speaker 00 Essentially has to be made up because we don't really know what life was like for them behind closed doors, right?
35:26 Speaker 01 Well, the fact that he helped solve the Ted Bundy case.
35:29 Speaker 00 Hmm.
35:30 Speaker 01 I mean, you name it, it didn't happen.
35:32 Speaker 00 What was life like for Ed Gein after he was arrested and institutionalized? Because they did find him insane and I know they did try to bring him to court, to trial. But again, he was found insane. So what was life like for him? Did his mental health decline? Did it stabilize? What was it like for him when he was?
35:51 Speaker 01 I think actually, from what I know, and I actually know at least one person who visited him in the institution and spoke to him. Uh, yeah, life was much better for him once he was locked up in an institution than before. You know, the expression, three hots and a cot. You know, he had, you know, meals that were much better. You know, when he was living alone, he might open a, I mean, uh, the series sort of got this part, right? You know, open a can of baked beans, put it on the stove and dump it into, you know, the top part of the human skull and eat it. So he was being fed. He had surrounded by people for the first time in his life. He was given books to read.
36:36 Speaker 01 He had correspondence with people who were very sympathetic towards him. So he, his life was a good deal more pleasant than it had been up to that point.
36:47 Speaker 00 What was life like at the end for Ed Gein? Did he pass away peacefully? Was there, I mean, unsolved things they were still trying to work out with him? What was his life like at the end?
36:57 Speaker 01 Well, he had died of cancer. So, uh, I, I never really come across specific information about his last days. I, I don't think he, he, he was apparently unaware of.
37:12 Speaker 01 His influence on American culture. The thing about Monster is they make it seem as though his major legacy was as, as I said, the forefather of the serial killers who suddenly appeared back, which is totally false, but he did have a major impact on American culture. Because Robert Bloch, who was a pulp horror writer, was living very close to Plainfield at the time the Gein story broke. Bloch was a protege of H. P. Lovecraft.
37:54 Speaker 01 He had become known for these pop horror stories. When he read about the Gein case, he realized this would be a great premise for a horror novel. He felt, because I was, I corresponded with Bloch when I was writing my book. You know, his problem was knowing how isolated Gein was. Gein never traveled anywhere. Where was he going to find all his victims? So he thought, well, I'll have the victims come to him. And that's how he came up with the idea of the Bates Motel. If you read the novel, when Norman Bates is finally arrested, he compares himself to Ed Gein. So there's a very, very explicit connection. And what I tell people, I grew up in the, I'm a baby boomer. I grew up in the 1950s.
38:38 Speaker 01 Culture filled with, all I did was go to horror movies and watch horror movies on TV and read horror comic books. And, you know, the, the culture was full of monsters, pop culture. But all the monsters were from other places. You know, Dracula from Transylvania, or the Werewolf of London, or Creature from the Black Lagoon from Deep in the Amazon, or Martian Invaders. Norman Bates was the first all-American monster. And insofar as Ed Gein stood behind Norman Bates, you could say that Gein kind of Americanized the genre of horror. And, and that's a major, major impact. And he also, again, through Psycho, stands as, you know, what sometimes people call the godfather of gore.
39:22 Speaker 01 You know, Psycho is the prototypical, what came to be called slasher or splatter movie. So Gein did have a, a major cultural impact, but it was on pop culture, it wasn't on... You know, inspiring Richard Speck and Ted Bundy and Edmond Kemper and so on.
39:40 Speaker 00 So I guess the legacy that Ed Gein has left behind continues then in pop culture, as much as it may have been fictionalized for this instance in Monsters. Do you think we'll ever stop being fascinated by Ed Gein and his story?
39:54 Speaker 01 Well, one of the reasons I was interested in the Gein story when I first discovered it is that I was a professor, a college professor for 42 years, and I taught a course called Myth and Archetype, you know, about these narrative patterns and archetypal figures that populate the folklore and literature of the world. And I've always been very interested in why we need stories about monsters in our lives from our earliest years. And Gein has become a kind of mythic monster at this point. I mean, in that sense, again, you could say Ryan Murphy and his collaborator did
40:39 Speaker 01 what people have always done with mythic monsters. If you look back at the history of the American frontier, there were these psychotic killers like Jesse James and Billy the Kid. And their stories have been incredibly mythologized by Hollywood. So there's a sense in which, yeah, I mean, Gein is such a mythic monster at this point that any creator, you could say, is free to tell whatever kind of story about him they want to. My main problem with the Ryan Murphy show is that it presents it as true crime. So I think, yeah, Gein will, you know, Gein will definitely remain an undying part of America's cultural mythology.
41:25 Speaker 00 Thank you to Harold for helping us tell this story. You can read more about his book, Deviant, The Shocking True Story of Ed Gein, The Original Psycho, at the link in our show notes. If you want to see images from this story, head to our Instagram page at True Crime Conversations and give us a follow and have a look at our case explainers as well while you're there. If you enjoyed this episode, please review our show on Apple Podcasts or leave a comment on Spotify. True Crime Conversations is hosted by me, Claire Murphy, and produced by Tali Blackman. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous The Double Life Of Dennis Rader: The BTK Killer Next Once Called "Australia's Worst Female Serial Killer." Kathleen Folbigg Sets The Record Straight Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated