Pod Insights True Crime Conversations Something Is Not Right About Phoebe's Fall About this episode In December 2010, the body of 24-year-old Phoebe Handsjuk was discovered at the bottom of a garbage chute in her Melbourne apartment building.
She had fallen 12 stories into a wheelie bin, where she ultimately succumbed to the injuries she sustained alone in the darkness of the rubbish room.
In 2013, a coroner ruled Phoebe’s death as accidental, a finding her family doesn't accept.
Investigative journalist Richard Baker, host of the podcast Phoebe's Fall, believes there’s more to the story. Was Phoebe’s death truly a tragic accident, or was she the victim of foul play?
You can listen to Richard's podcast with The Age 'Phoebe's Fall' here https://podcasts.theage.com.au/podcasts/phoebes-fall/.
THE END BITS
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=tcc
Find out more about Mamamia's charity partner RizeUp Australia here https://www.rizeup.com.au/.
Join the Month of MOVE
Get $30 off a Mamamia subscription and get unlimited access to our feel-good exercise app. Head here to get a yearly subscription for just $39. https://move.mamamia.com.au/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=quicky&code=MONTHOFQUICKY
CREDITS
Guest: Richard Baker https://www.southernoceanmedia.com/
Host: Gemma Bath
Producer: Tahli Blackman
Audio Producer: Thom Lion
GET IN TOUCH:
Feedback? We’re listening! Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected] or send us a voice note https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960, and one of our Podcast Producers will come back to you ASAP.
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available viaLifeline https://www.lifeline.org.au/ on 13 11 14 orBeyond Blue https://www.beyondblue.org.au/ on 1300 22 4636.
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on.
0:13 Speaker 01 It's 11:44am on December 2nd, 2010 in Melbourne and Phoebe Handsjuk and her dog Yoshi are captured on security camera.
0:23 Speaker 01 They're leaving the luxury apartment building on St Kilda Road she shares with her boyfriend as a fire alarm sounds. She returns six minutes later. It's the last time she's ever seen alive.
0:40 Speaker 01 After that short clip, we know she consumes enough alcohol to put her three times over the legal limit. Traces of a sleeping pill are found in her system. According to police, at some point over the course of the evening, Phoebe exits her apartment and enters her floor's rubbish chute, falling 12 floors into a wheelie bin. She survives, but her right foot is almost severed by the compactor's blade and in a last bid for life, she drags herself around the room looking for an exit. She doesn't find it. Her body is found by a concierge at 7pm.
1:19 Speaker 01 Her death is ruled a suicide, then an accident, but those explanations have never made sense to her family. How did she get into the chute? Why did she get into the chute? Did the police and the coroner get it wrong?
1:45 Speaker 01 I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. The garbage chute at Phoebe's apartment was one of those ones that opened via a handle about halfway up the wall. It swings open on an angle, revealing a 22-centimetre latch opening. It's a pretty awkward hole to manoeuvre yourself into and watching the recreation of how Phoebe might have managed it on Channel 9's Under Investigation, it looks almost impossible.
2:20 Speaker 02 Tight. In her second attempt, Danielle pulls herself up, but it takes all her strength, balance and coordination. Oh.
2:30 Speaker 01 It's just one of a long list of questions that remain unanswered in this case. A story that has been covered in depth by multi award winning investigative journalist, Richard Baker, whose podcast Phoebe's Fall for the Age, hosted with Michael Bachelard, worked closely with Phoebe's family to try and figure out what really happened to her. It's a case that has baffled and angered the Australian public. And 14 years later, many of the questions asked by Phoebe's fall remain a mystery. Richard joins us now.
3:06 Speaker 01 Richard, how was Phoebe's body discovered and what happened as police arrived on that scene?
3:13 Speaker 03 Phoebe's body was found in the garbage refuse room of this really fancy apartment building in St Kilda Road in Melbourne around 7pm by the concierge or a cleaner going about her work. She was just trying to put a broom back or something and felt that there was a weight against the door and had trouble opening it and eventually got it open. And there, you know, lying in a pool of blood was Phoebe. And so what happened from there, obviously, you know, police and emergency services were called and, and pretty quickly the building started to fill up with police and ambulance officers. Interestingly, the ambulance officers didn't go and check for proof of life, which I found a bit troubling.
3:58 Speaker 03 And I know that troubled members of Phoebe's family, but the police had already made an assessment that she was, you know, well and truly gone. And then it was really about talking to, you know, her de facto partner, then Aunt Hampel, and trying to piece together her movements of that day.
4:15 Speaker 01 How quickly did the police start talking about suicide?
4:20 Speaker 03 Well, from what we know and from the coroner's inquest from the word go, that was in the backdrop of all the conversations about what might have happened there. I know Aunt had mentioned that she was mentally unwell at the time, in his opinion, and, and she was seeking, you know, some treatment and, and care from the medical profession for her mental health. And within two days, the homicide squad had pretty much written it off as a suicide. And that meant the case then was bound for the coroner. And a detective from the nearest police station, South Melbourne, was assigned the job of putting together the brief of evidence.
5:06 Speaker 03 He was a really quick judgment call to make. And something I've never seen happen so quickly in any other high profile death in a suspicious circumstance involving, you know, a young woman or a woman in that de facto or intimate partner setting.
5:24 Speaker 01 Let's paint the picture of Phoebe's life at the time a bit. She was, you know, twenty four, living with her boyfriend who you mentioned. Can you tell us a bit more about the life she was living?
5:36 Speaker 03 On the surface, it looked like a pretty, a pretty good life. I mean, she was a vibrant twenty four year old, you know, stunning looking young woman, big personality from a loving family, you know, family and her friends would concede, bit of a wild child, loved to party, but could also then get, like many of us, buyer's remorse after too good a time and get a bit low and a bit down. And yeah, she, she mixed and through, you know, her, her boyfriend and his connections, he was quite a bit older and from a very established Melbourne legal family and worked and still works in the events and entertainment space.
6:17 Speaker 03 You know, going to a lot of parties, meeting a lot of quite hip and happening on the move people. So it was a, a pretty full on lifestyle. And yeah, I think her family and friends would concede that she did have her battles with alcohol and occasional, you know, drug use and stuff like that. But, you know, quite common for people in their, in their early to mid twenties to be doing all that sort of stuff, so.
6:44 Speaker 01 What do we know about how her relationship was going? You mentioned there was an age gap. It was quite a big one. Ant was forty three, she was twenty four. And they'd had quite a few breakups in the kind of time before she died. How was the final weeks of of their relationship?
7:04 Speaker 03 Volatile, you know, very volatile. Uh, there had been, according to Phoebe's mum and grandma, who, you know, she was very close to kind of six occasions where she had left him or walked out between October and she she was found dead in, you know, December. So it wasn't in a, yeah, it wasn't in a healthy, healthy state. And I think that last week, they'd had a massive blue after a dinner uh, at some of Anne's friends. And he didn't like the way she behaved or some of the things she said. And she'd had a couple of glasses of wine. And I don't think he liked that because of, I guess, he saw, you know, alcohol as a, as a a problem in her life.
7:49 Speaker 03 But why keep taking it to places then where, where it's kind of in abundance? So that last week, I think the Monday night of it, uh, yeah, they had a massive row and and really things sort of started to spiral a bit from there.
8:06 Speaker 01 During your investigations, you spent a lot of time with the family and her friends and you kind of tried to unpick how the relationship changed Phoebe. And a lot of her friends spoke about how she was a a different person, really, towards the end than the person they knew. Can you talk to that?
8:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, from from their perspective and the way they saw her and her change and behavioural change, it was almost like she was trying to fulfil a role or acting, trying to to fit a mould that was being made or had been made for her and to really modify her behaviours to take the edges off a bit. But she seemed, yeah, I mean, they they say that, you know, she was a person caught up in a relationship where there was a lot of real or perceived coercive control going on.
8:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, right. Did her family see any signs of her being suicidal?
9:04 Speaker 03 No. No, not from what I know.
9:07 Speaker 01 Because her dad is a psychiatrist, isn't he?
9:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, and we've got to look at the time she was found dead. Her youngest brother was about to have, I think, his eighteenth birthday that very weekend. And there is no way she would have wanted to do anything to upend or to ruin that occasion. So, yeah, you know, the the mental health thing is obviously there as it is in for for everyone who dies in a suspicious way. You've got to take into account what's going on in their life, but from where I sit and from my knowledge of this case and and, you know, of the views of her family and friends and also the evidence that was presented at the inquest, I think it was a really,
9:52 Speaker 03 really bad call um by the cops to write that off in two days. And um yeah, I'd stand by that all these years later.
10:00 Speaker 01 Can we talk a bit more about Phoebe's last week? You mentioned she'd had a a blue with Ant, but there are a number of other kind of strange things that happened.
10:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
10:09 Speaker 01 You know, there was a dinner and a tomato soup text and bits and pieces.
10:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, the last week is kind of a, you know, sometimes real life is is crazier than anything you can make up, but there was a an appointment with a doctor, you know, talking about her her mental state. Then another bender, another drinking bender um with a a a young friend of Phoebe's, where it was a a pretty late night and I think Ant, you know, she threw her phone to the ground in um anger at how many times he was calling her to find out where she was and what she was doing. I think she might have had an ecstasy pill or something, the friend reported that night. And then,
10:55 Speaker 03 you know, she did come home and was, you know, hungover and and recovering. And uh, you know, not long after that, one day, a um a strange text was sent to family members and Ant and one or two other people about.
11:12 Speaker 03 Her having tomato soup and going to drift off into this wonderful sleep and sort of apologising about things and, you know, merrily, merrily, life is but a dream. And that was a really concerning thing, obviously, for family to see. And I think Natalie Handsjuk, Phoebe's mum, was on a plane. And, you know, when she landed and got signal again, that came up and she she rang her mum, you know, Jeanette, Phoebe's grandmother, to to try and check out what was going on. You could read many, many things into that text message and perhaps still never know what the intent was, or um indeed who the author was.
11:54 Speaker 01 When was that text message sent?
11:57 Speaker 03 That was on the Thursday morning, so the day before Phoebe died.
12:01 Speaker 01 What about her movements on the day she died? We know she headed out in the morning with her dog. She's captured on CCTV camera. Then what?
12:11 Speaker 03 We don't know. There's a space of hours that no one's got any um insight into. What we do know that, yeah, Phoebe was captured on CCTV in the lobby of the apartment building with the little dog. And in the apartment that she shared with Ant, he reported sort of seeing a little shrine when he came back in there. Um, her hair straighteners had been plugged in, had a handbag on the bench and a phone charger with it. Now, those things, knowing from my wife and and now seventeen year old daughter, they're pretty normal indications that that a girl or a woman is heading out somewhere.
12:52 Speaker 03 If you've got those kind of implements on or on the bench, ready to take with you. And obviously, she didn't, to the best of our knowledge, go out anywhere. And the other things that the police discovered was that Phoebe's Gmail had been accessed and messages deleted um from her email account. And no one really knows what that's about or or why either. So. They're enduring mysteries and because the police had made that quick assumption that this was either a suicide or a, you know, accidental death.
13:31 Speaker 03 It meant Victoria Police couldn't get American authorities, so where Google headquartered, to go in and um try and download or extract the deleted data to find out what went on because under the legal, you know, cooperation treaties between the two countries. To get them to do that, there has to be suspicion or or strong evidence of a homicide.
13:56 Speaker 01 Just another kind of mystery, isn't it?
13:59 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's another door that couldn't be opened. Now, it may be a mere coincidence or something there, but you know, this is the after effects, I guess, or the the fallout of rushing to a conclusion rather than, you know, keeping an open mind and maybe just gathering all the evidence you can in the first place and then make an assessment of what is the most likely thing to have happened, whether it be a suspicious death or foul play or a suicide or or an accident.
14:31 Speaker 01 We know that the concierge found Phoebe at about seven. What were ants' movements that night?
14:37 Speaker 03 So his phone records and his swipe card to enter the the building show him getting home around ten past six. And he says Phoebe wasn't wasn't there and that there was like a candle burning and a photo of them or something and some smashed glass and a ripped cushion or something like that. So it was a bit of an odd scene and and also later it was, you know, it was found out that there was some blood in the apartment. Now, they were meant to be going out for dinner that night with Phoebe's dad. And there was a weird phone call to or from their apartment number, registered to a Western Australian number.
15:17 Speaker 03 And when they checked that number, it was W A solar, like a solar panel thing, and nobody knows what the hell. That was about, and I don't think Ant has any recollection or any, you know, idea of of what that is. What happened next was one of Phoebe's phones rang. And I don't know whether Ant had possession of it or not, but it was it was Phoebe's dad and he was ringing to confirm dinner or to say that where are you, you know, because they haven't rocked up yet. And then about sixty seconds later, Ant happened to call Phoebe's father back to say, oh, I don't know where Phoebe is.
15:59 Speaker 03 Now, I think that Ant said that he didn't realise, it was a coincidence, he didn't know that Phoebe's dad had just called sixty seconds earlier looking for her. And then as it got closer to seven, I think Ant ordered some takeaway. He assumed that dinner's off and that maybe Phoebe's dad probably wasn't that keen on just having dinner with him on his own.
16:22 Speaker 01 Those other kind of bits and pieces you mentioned, broken glass, a ripped pillow and blood, were they ever investigated by police or locked down as a crime scene?
16:32 Speaker 03 The place was eventually locked down, for want of a better word, or or or, you know, taped off as a crime scene. But not till much later in the evening, when it's one thing I've always found a bit unusual. And when that happened, Ant already had family members, including his father, I believe, or his late father, you know, Supreme Court Judge George Hampel, up in the apartment. And I don't know what they were doing there, I guess, supporting him. But again, when you think about how those things are normally done, I would have thought normal procedure would have been to lock down that place, get everyone out, preserve the evidence, collect every sample of blood and DNA possible in there.
17:15 Speaker 03 And the fragments of glass and the computers and anything that might lead to some clues or some certainty about what happened. And yeah, the adequacy of the steps that were taken that night by police, it wasn't good enough, it was inadequate. And they missed testing some samples of blood. And to me, wouldn't that be a sign of perhaps there's been a struggle? Why wouldn't you, you know, also, okay, there were three glasses in the sink. And who's been home all day? Why are there three glasses? You know, what was in the glasses? Was there alcohol? Was there this? Was there that? Not done. And the other big failing of that night in terms of an investigatory sort of thing
17:57 Speaker 03 was to actually access and seize the um CCTV from the apartment building.
18:02 Speaker 01 So they didn't do that?
18:04 Speaker 03 No.
18:05 Speaker 01 Isn't that basic policing? I'm not a police officer, putting my hands up, but that feels like.
18:10 Speaker 03 Sort of on every episode of CSI.
18:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:12 Speaker 03 Like that, I mean, it's, yeah, I I don't know why you wouldn't, you just wouldn't do that there and then. Yeah, I I, you know, I've always thought, this is my own personal opinion here, that Phoebe's family were and remain owed an apology by Victoria Police.
18:29 Speaker 01 Was there an issue with getting that CCTV after the fact? Could they not get it later?
18:34 Speaker 03 When they went back to get it, um, I think it had overwritten itself or over, you know, filmed it was on a loop, so it was hard to access. And then the building manager, when I went to interview him a few years later, mentioned a hard drive. This is when Detective Payne, who was doing the coroner's investigation, wanted to see if there was something on a, on a hard drive that they eventually found what looked like the right or relevant hard drive, and then that went missing from the building.
19:05 Speaker 01 What about witness statements or, you know, a statement from Aunt? Was that something that happened that night?
19:10 Speaker 03 Yeah, I, he, he did give a statement and I think in it he mentioned that she was troubled and having battles with mental health and poor girl and, you know, things like that. And then one of the officers on the scene observed in his notebook that Aunt was, in his opinion, acting strangely and almost sort of putting on the crocodile tears and, and emotion and behaving unusually. But that said, people do cope with grief and shock. In different ways, and you know, I don't think any of the other police remarked one way or another on his behaviour.
19:51 Speaker 03 And then, um, when Detective Payne, so the, the South Melbourne detective who was given the job of forming the brief of evi- evidence for the coronial inquest, uh, he wanted to re-interview Ant in January, so, you know, maybe four or five weeks after Phoebe had died. And he wasn't being interviewed under caution or anything, but Ant's father, the retired Supreme Court judge, wouldn't leave his side. And even when Detective Payne said, I'd rather talk to him alone, again, we're talking about a forty-three-year-old man here.
20:24 Speaker 01 Um.
20:24 Speaker 03 He said, no, my son's grieving, I don't want to leave him.
20:27 Speaker 01 But I guess that's an important point to make, that his dad was very high up in the legal system in Victoria, which is, is not a bad thing, it just means that this family knows court, they know legalities.
20:40 Speaker 03 They do, yeah, they know, they know the law and they know how things work and they know the, I guess, just by virtue of the, of the position, so Ant's stepmother was a sitting county court judge, so that's the equivalent of the district court in New South Wales also. So, yeah, they know, they know the law, they know, you know, how things can be pushed, how, how police procedure works, all of those kind of things. And that's not a criticism of them, it's just a fact of their experience and the, and the profession that, that they have. But I guess it's human nature, people often rightly or wrongly tread a bit lightly around powerful people.
21:19 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
21:19 Speaker 03 And, you know, you've got to wonder whether or not that happened here because the point of doing this podcast was to actually put the justice system on display and ask the question, did it give Phoebe a fair go? And I think it failed.
21:35 Speaker 01 Well, as you were mentioning before, within a few days, so by the seventh of December, homicide detectives had determined that there was no second party involved in Phoebe's death, that she entered the shoot voluntarily. How did her family react to that?
21:48 Speaker 03 I think, you know, they, they were feeling under a bit of a tidal wave of, um, emotion and question and just trying to make sense of it all. But I, I think they were really taken aback with the speed which that conclusion was reached. And I mean. If we look at other examples, other prominent cases where women, wives or girlfriends have been found dead in suspicious circumstances. So, you know, I'm talking about the Jill Maher case. Also, you know, in inner Melbourne, um, a few years after Phoebe. The early stages of those investigations put a bit of media and public hate on the husbands.
22:30 Speaker 03 And I was talking to experienced detectives.
22:34 Speaker 01 Um.
22:34 Speaker 03 After Phoebe's case, they thought that was really odd that this is a strange situation. This is a domestic de facto relationship. Here, there is evidence of blood and other things in that apartment. And and was home when Phoebe's body was found. So it's again, not saying that he was guilty, but why wasn't the same standard procedures and processes followed here?
23:03 Speaker 01 When did you become involved in this story? It was around about now, wasn't it? That the family kind of contacted you. They were quite frustrated with everything that was happening, particularly Phoebe's grandfather, who himself was a retired detective.
23:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, so Lo- Lauren Campbell, um, Phoebe's maternal grandfather. Yeah, was a very experienced uh Victorian police officer and detective. And uh he reached out to myself and my then, you know, colleague and still great mate, uh Nick McKenzie at the age. And what he was reaching out for was it looked like at that point in time that there was not going to be any inquest by the coroner into Phoebe's death. That it was going to be written off either as an accident or suicide with no questions asked. And and Hampel's lawyer had approached the coroner's court
23:55 Speaker 03 saying that an inquest was not needed. And that struck me immediately as really weird. And I just go on, hang on, I did a big quick search to find out if anyone else in Australia has been found dead at the bottom of a garbage chute. And found no.
24:12 Speaker 03 Plus you add in all the other stuff that went on in Phoebe's last week and the suspicious kind of scene in the apartment and the fact that there was no fingerprints on the um garbage chute and the difficulty of getting yourself in there with no external assistance. Of all the things that you might want to have an inquest into, this would be one. Why would a coroner not want to do this? And if you are a grieving partner of someone who's died in such a bizarre way, wouldn't you want to find out why and what happened? So instantly for me, and I remember Nick was going, this doesn't feel right, this doesn't smell right, it's not right. And we wrote quite an extensive, you know, feature
24:57 Speaker 03 article detailing all the question marks still around Phoebe's death and yeah, putting some pressure on for an inquest, that the right thing happened, that there be an open and public inquest with witnesses called and and the facts as the best they could be established, put on the table.
25:15 Speaker 01 Do you think that without that media pressure, the inquest might not have happened?
25:19 Speaker 03 Yeah, I don't think it would have.
25:21 Speaker 01 Doesn't that make it a bit of a ticker box?
25:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, it does. Yeah. It's astounding, but I I don't think it would have gone ahead. I think it would have been written off. And in Victoria at the time, it was basically impossible to appeal a coroner's finding or the way the coroner was doing something.
25:38 Speaker 01 So once a coroner gives a finding, that's it?
25:41 Speaker 03 Uh.
25:42 Speaker 01 At the time?
25:42 Speaker 03 At the time, yeah. And it's still quite hard, but you know, one of the, I guess, silver linings of highlighting Phoebe's case and the way the justice system performed or didn't perform was that some amendments were made to the Coroners Act. That does open up more avenues for families to appeal questionable decisions or findings by a coroner.
26:07 Speaker 01 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bass. I'm speaking with journalist and podcaster Richard Baker about the death of Phoebe Handsjuk. Up next, Richard tells us what the coroner found happened to Phoebe.
26:25 Speaker 01 I want to unpack a lot of the evidence from the inquest, but firstly, let's jump to the end. What did the inquest find?
26:32 Speaker 03 The inquest found that Phoebe was under the influence of alcohol and a prescription drug sold here as Stillnox in the States, it's called Ambien. It can make people do some strange things. And the coroner said that Phoebe took herself to the garbage chute, got herself in feet first and then shimmyed down and went down, you know, 11 or so stories. Um, he said that she put her elbows to the edge of the aluminium chute to kind of slow her descent.
27:16 Speaker 03 But I know that the forensic pathologist who examined her body and all of that under questioning said he couldn't say that that had happened and that there was no debris on her arms or anything like that. And the other difficult thing to think about is that when Phoebe was found, she was found with her jeans around her knees.
27:35 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
27:36 Speaker 03 So going down, I don't know how that might happen. You're more likely to have your pants sort of pull up as you're going down, rise up. But also if they were down before she hopped in the chute, how did she get in?
27:47 Speaker 01 Because this chute is, I'm using my hands to kind of show, but it's about 22 centimetres. That's the gap.
27:55 Speaker 03 It's tiny, it's literally like a plastic bag of rubbish width. So it's not easy, it's not impossible to get into on your own, but like you've got to be, now Phoebe was fit and athletic, but also she was under the influence of stuff, you'd have to say her judgment and fine motor skills could have been impaired. It's really difficult to get into on your own and to not leave a fingerprint, I don't know how you would manage that. So, you know, the finding was that she died by a tragic case of misadventure. And the cause of death was when she got to the bottom, she got caught by a compact blade and it severed, nearly severed her ankle and she lost a lot of blood.
28:35 Speaker 01 So rather than suicide, which is what the police found, the coroner found that it was accidental death or misadventure.
28:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, he did. And what was kind of stood out about that was he went against the advice or the submissions of counsel assisting, so that's a senior barrister that's appointed by the court to basically lead the inquest. Now, the coroner is of an independent mind, but the inquest is run by the counsel assisting the coroner, this senior barrister. And in this case, the barrister Deborah Semensma in Hearst submissions had submitted that only an open finding be made. And what an open finding is, is that the evidence, you couldn't rule in or rule out
29:25 Speaker 03 foul play or the involvement of other parties, you couldn't rule in or rule out suicide, and you couldn't rule in or rule out death by misadventure or an accident. And that, to me, was the right finding on the evidence there. And that's all Phoebe's family have ever said as well. They don't think the evidence is there to convict anyone for it because they don't know whether that's for sure what happened. But why, again, would you have to, you know, I find it odd that you have to kind of stitch together a narrative that's not supported in some cases by the evidence at your inquest when you had a perfectly reasonable finding to make, which is open.
30:10 Speaker 01 And to be clear, if an open finding is what the coroner was to rule, would that have left the door open to potentially look down a murder investigation if more evidence was to come out? It kind of leaves the door open.
30:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's easier for the court, you know, to act on new and fresh information. So, you know, because a finding has been reached, it doesn't mean, you know, and if it's, you know, really good information that changes things, that would then take it back under the umbrella of the police to go and investigate that. So just because his findings made doesn't mean. Are forbidden from acting on fresh evidence. And neither is the court, but it just is another a blockage, I guess. It makes it that bit harder for the court or for the family or for new people to present new evidence to the court to get that finding overturned and perhaps made into an open finding.
31:04 Speaker 03 Because then you have to really go about undoing the finding that's already there to then be able to add the new information to the mix.
31:15 Speaker 01 We've already talked about some of the weird clues. The one that sticks out to me is the no fingerprints on the shoot. I've watched a young girl who is the same kind of height and build as Phoebe try and get into that rubbish chute. And I just don't see how you would do it by yourself and not put fingerprints. The pants around the ankles, as we've mentioned, but then another kind of clue that came up in the inquest was bruising. Can you talk us through that?
31:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, so Detective Payne was having a look at some of the medical examination photos of Phoebe's body and had picked up on some bruising around her arms and also on the side of her of her face. And he asked the pathologist to take another look. And he came back and said, yeah, there is some bruising to, I think, the jaw or the side of one of the side of Phoebe's face, but also then some bruising marks around her arms that he said could be consistent with grip marks. So like being forcefully held.
32:23 Speaker 03 And that, you know, again, that was overlooked initially, like no one had picked up on that. And it wasn't until Detective Payne was at the doing the brief for the coroner that this understanding of bruising to her made it into all the evidence.
32:52 Speaker 01 I want to talk a little bit more about the days and weeks after Phoebe died and the reactions of her inner circle because Natalie, Phoebe's mum, really wanted to kind of understand what happened. And so she asked for a chat with Ant. Can you tell us what happened?
33:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, so Natalie, Handsjuk, Phoebe's mum, went to Ant's apartment and just really wanted to have a, just to break the bread, sort of chat and find out what was going on. You know, what had happened in that last week, trying to get some answers. And I also think they were trying to work out, you know, funeral details and stuff like that because Ant had pressed his case to be next of kin, as they'd been living together as de facto as more than six months. And Natalie was kind of protesting that because that meant he had control over her body. Also, control over, you know, obviously with the body, where a funeral would be, what sort of event it would be.
33:53 Speaker 03 And then it emerged that she had a life insurance policy and that gave him access to that, although down the track he did give up all of those things. So Nat went there for a meeting to sort out a lot, to get some understanding, but also to try and flesh out why he was pushing for for next of kin and and stuff like that. And she recorded the meeting.
34:16 Speaker 01 Why?
34:17 Speaker 03 Well, you know, I think she was suspicious and was wanting to gather some evidence. And I guess, given the police had already given up, who else was going to do it? And so she recorded it and I've heard, and I think we played in the podcast, a part of that recording that was played in the coroner's court. And yeah, it was, it was pretty strange. Ant had his stepmother, Felicity Hampel, the judge there with him. I believe his father might have been there. And a couple of other, you know, support people and.
34:51 Speaker 03 The conversation, yeah, went around funerals and, you know, Natalie wanting to push a case for the family to, to do the farewell and Ant wanted his own service. And on the tape, Ant's step mum Felicity, you know, reminded Phoebe that under the law, Ant was next of kin and had this right to do what he wanted. So, yeah, it, it was a kind of strange situation and Natalie said Ant, you know, was acting strangely. And I think at one point, you know, went over to the couch and was just kind of in a fetal position with grief and she just found the whole thing really odd. And I think there was also quite loud music playing in the background, which I don't know
35:36 Speaker 03 why it was there, maybe, I don't know, made hearing the tape more difficult in any event.
35:42 Speaker 01 There ended up being a bit of a rift kind of formed between Phoebe's family and Ant, didn't there?
35:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, pretty quickly, especially over the, um, the next of kin staff and not releasing the body and then applying to access her insurance policy and estate. George Hampel wrote a letter of support affirming their relationship and the genuineness of it to convince, um, the relevant authorities that Ant should be the beneficiary. Now, like I said, he, he later gave those monies and things to Phoebe's brothers. But, yeah, the whole dynamic was pretty frosty because of the unanswered questions and I think the odd behaviour. And the other thing I think that really pissed the family off was, um, Ant announcing Phoebe's
36:30 Speaker 03 death on Facebook, saying that she was a troubled young woman and he did his best to save her, but, you know, she's taken her own life.
36:37 Speaker 01 Which is something that they just categorically don't think is true.
36:40 Speaker 03 They don't think, you know, I think they've got an open mind on it, but they don't, they think that's the least likely. Also, why would you do it in that way?
36:47 Speaker 01 Yeah. To reiterate, Ant hasn't been implicated in Phoebe's death, but the public record does show that Phoebe is not the only young.
36:57 Speaker 01 Girlfriend he has had who has died in unusual circumstances.
37:02 Speaker 03 No, in twenty eighteen, I got a phone call from Natalie Handsjuk. And she just said, are you sitting down? And I was at work, I remember it really clearly. And um said, no, but do I need to? She goes, I think you do. And she just said, it's happened again. I said, what do you mean? And she goes, Ant's had another girlfriend die. And I said, you're kidding me. And how? And all of that. And so the young woman we're talking about here is a young Melbourne woman called Bailey Schneider, who had been seeing Ant um in a more casual way, I guess, than Phoebe. They weren't living together, but they had holidayed together and were in a intimate relationship.
37:46 Speaker 03 And Bailey was twenty five, again, had her issues with mental health and how she viewed herself, issues with alcohol and drugs and partying and things like that. And um she was found in her parents' home in Ascot Vale, a suburb in Melbourne's inner northwest, uh hanging with a curtain cord, well, she was found on the floor of the kitchen with a curtain cord round her neck. And the belief was she hung herself from a kitchen cupboard. And her parents had just gone out for an hour to go to the shops and she'd asked them to bring her something back to eat.
38:27 Speaker 01 Wow, that is tragic.
38:29 Speaker 03 Yeah, and Ant has been cleared of any involvement in in her death by a police investigation and also a coroner's report. This one um didn't go to inquest. But he was one of the last people to communicate with her overnight and that day. They had phone calls and um had exchanged messages over Facebook Messenger and things like that. And Bailey's parents were wondering about what the impact of their relationship was on her state of mind and her mental health in the weeks and months leading up to her death.
39:11 Speaker 01 You released your series on Phoebe in twenty sixteen.
39:16 Speaker 01 What was the reaction like when you put all of this evidence out?
39:21 Speaker 03 It was overwhelming, actually. You know, Australia, two years before, um, in America, Serial had released the first version of the Serial podcast and that kind of turned people on to, I guess, that way of getting really deep into a story. And it had been eating at me since the outcome of the inquest, which was delivered in twenty fourteen. We hadn't told this story right yet. And I thought, with no experience in podcasting at that stage or skills, that this would be the way to tell it. And, um, yeah, it was difficult and a real challenge and they needed a lot of help from a lot of good people along the
40:05 Speaker 03 way to help write it and tell it and all of that. But once we released it, it was massive. It was like, it just went gangbusters. Um, and people were asking questions of the, the justice system that we all rely on. We all don't want to have to rely on it, but any day we could be relying on it to work properly, fairly. Um, and nothing's perfect, but to, to do its job. And what Phoebe's story did was tell a story of, on a few levels that are really pertinent to the community about, you know, power imbalances in, in relationships, power imbalances between families and, and different layers or levels of society, and
40:50 Speaker 03 the performance of the justice system and who gets its mercy and who gets shortchanged through, you know, inadequate investigations and, and things like that.
41:02 Speaker 01 Hmm.
41:02 Speaker 03 So I thought, wow, you can get this right and you can tell a story in a factual but engaging kind of way that allows people to kind of see it play out inside their own heads, which is what the beauty of good podcasting is. They have a longer shelf life and that to me then gives it more scope to actually get our politicians and other authorities to act.
41:27 Speaker 01 Well, this podcast did help do that, right? It helped the Victorian government decide that they were going to review the Coroner's Act.
41:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, they did. So they did a review into the Coroner's Act with a focus on the difficulties or impediments to appealing outcomes or decisions of the Coroner's Court. And then some amendments were made to make it that bit easier for families to to challenge things. Which is, you know, is a good outcome. So hopefully because of what happened with Phoebe's and case and and the highlight that we spotlight we put on it, other families won't have the door closed to them for challenging decisions and things that happen in the Coroner's Court that they disagree with or they believe aren't supported by evidence.
42:15 Speaker 03 Because a finding, when you don't have a prosecution or someone to blame, you know, a coroner's findings, all you've got, that's the legal final word. That's how the state says your loved one died and the circumstances with which they died. If you don't agree with that or you think that it's made on false assumptions and and isn't fact or isn't true, that's a lot to live with. That's a really heavy thing to go, well, the record says, you know, my brother, sister, whatever, died this way, but I don't believe it. And I don't think when you assess the evidence rationally, when there was a much more obvious and acceptable finding, in this case, open finding, I'd find that really hard to stomach.
43:01 Speaker 01 Where do we sit with Phoebe's case now? It's eight years since, you know, all of those changes were announced and we were able to appeal. Has Phoebe's finding changed? Has anything else happened?
43:12 Speaker 03 I and Phoebe's family and others, you know, still get people coming forward with bits and pieces of information, you know, some of it may be irrelevant, some of it. Looks to be relevant. Uh, yeah, you know, there's, nothing's changed. The finding's still the finding. The same question marks over that finding from those who don't think it's the right one still exist. I think Phoebe's family believe, and I believe, and I have, you know, some foundation for this belief, that there are people out there who know a bit more, who she may have come across or was involved with in that final week of her life, who for whatever reason weren't questioned by police, perhaps because they
43:57 Speaker 03 weren't known to police or weren't obviously connected to her in that way. Yeah, I feel that her story, you know, I think there'll be one or two more twists or turns before too long.
44:13 Speaker 01 Thanks to Richard for helping us to tell this story. And to reiterate, Anthony Happel has not been implicated in Phoebe's death. The coroner's finding legally stands to this day, ruling that the 24-year-old's death was an accident. We'll leave a link to Richard's podcast, Phoebe's Fall, in our show notes. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast hosted and produced by me, Gemma Bath, and Tali Blackman, with audio design by Tom Lyon. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous Extra: Is There Really A Serial Killer In Byron Bay? Next 'I'm Confident My Son Is Still Alive': The Case Of The Lost Boy Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated