Pod Insights True Crime Conversations Meet The Anonymous Host Of Casefile About this episode To some, he’s the mysterious voice behind their favourite true crime podcast (besides True Crime Conversations, of course). Others know him as ‘Casey.’ But who is Casefile's anonymous host, really? Today, we get a chance to find out a little more about him.
In this exclusive chat, ‘Casey’ and Gemma talk about why he’s kept his identity a secret, how Casefile got started, the creative process behind the show, and the cases that have had the biggest impact on him.
He might not tell us his real name, but we’re sharing his story.
THE END BITS
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=tcc
CREDITS
Guest: 'Casey', anonymous host of Casefile https://casefilepodcast.com/
Host: Gemma Bath https://www.linkedin.com/in/gemmabath/overlay/photo/
Producer: Tahli Blackman https://www.linkedin.com/in/tahli-blackman-205a891b7/?originalSubdomain=au
Audio Producer: Jacob Round
GET IN TOUCH
Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected] or send us a voice note https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960to give us feedback or suggest a case for the podcast.
Rate or review us on Apple by clicking on the three dots in the top right-hand corner, click Go To Show then scroll down to the bottom of the page, click on the stars at the bottom and write a review. You can also leave a comment for us on Spotify.
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast. Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on. To some, he's known as the anonymous host. Others have nicknamed him Casey. If you're listening to this podcast and you're a fan of true crime, you'll probably recognise this voice.
0:25 Speaker 01 ...indicating they'd applied the patches in the lead up to their deaths. Stranger still, the evidence suggests that the couple had ingested the plant.
0:34 Speaker 00 But the host of Australian True Crime Podcast Case File has kept his identity secret for nine years, and so far, that's been working pretty well for him. Casey might not let us tell you his real name, but that doesn't mean we can't tell you his story.
0:58 Speaker 00 I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. We've got a bit of a different episode for you today. Case File is what you would call one of our direct competitors. We both work in the Australian true crime podcasting space and we're regularly up against them in the various podcasting charts. They're wildly popular, often number one, with people all over the world attracted to the podcast's distinct no-frills approach to storytelling. It all started with one typical Aussie bloke, as he calls himself, in his spare room deciding
1:41 Speaker 00 to give podcasting a go while recovering from a sporting injury. Now, the anonymous host and his team are in the ears of more than 800,000 people every month. He doesn't really do interviews. You'll only find one or two on the internet, but we managed to convince him to come into Mamma Mia HQ for an exclusive sit-down chat.
2:06 Speaker 00 I don't know what I was expecting, meeting him in real life. He wasn't not what I was expecting. Probably more clean cut than the descriptor he gives of being a typical Aussie bloke, but maybe that's just me being too stereotypical. The feedback from my colleagues who sneaked a peek is that he's younger than they imagined. Make of that what you will. And when I say sneaked a peek, several of my colleagues not only hovered, but chased this man down the halls of our office. Honestly, there was more excitement in here than when we have some Hollywood celebs grace our halls. Please enjoy my chat with the anonymous host of Case File.
2:49 Speaker 00 I'm gonna start with some quickfire questions, getting to know you questions. I will accept no comment if I have to.
2:56 Speaker 01 Okay, sounds good.
2:58 Speaker 00 Favorite sport?
3:00 Speaker 01 Rugby league.
3:01 Speaker 00 Favorite food?
3:04 Speaker 01 Tuy.
3:05 Speaker 00 That was a toughie. You had to think about that.
3:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, it was. Indian, maybe?
3:09 Speaker 00 Favorite song and/or artist?
3:11 Speaker 01 Favorite song, Flowers and You by Touche Amore.
3:15 Speaker 00 Oh, very specific.
3:17 Speaker 01 It's getting quite the play at the moment. It's not new. It's actually probably 10 years old now, but good song.
3:23 Speaker 00 Favorite thing to do on the weekend?
3:25 Speaker 01 Golf.
3:27 Speaker 00 Favorite place in Australia?
3:30 Speaker 01 Blue Mountains.
3:32 Speaker 00 Hmm. TV show?
3:35 Speaker 01 Cobra Kai.
3:36 Speaker 00 What?
3:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, just because it's so tacky and cheesy, but they really lean into it. And I was a fan of the Karate Kid movies when I was young. And so it's a bit of a nostalgia thing. It's like, it's bad, but it's good bad.
3:51 Speaker 00 If you could have dinner with anyone alive or dead, who would it be?
3:56 Speaker 01 Kurt Cobain.
3:57 Speaker 00 Ooh. I'm hearing a music.
4:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, big music fan, yeah.
4:02 Speaker 00 Well.
4:03 Speaker 01 Or actually, oh, yeah, Kurt Cobain or Cliff Burton, the original Metallica basses.
4:08 Speaker 00 Okay, well, there we go. I feel like I've learnt more about you in the last few minutes than I can find on the entire internet. And I'm not actually allowed to tell listeners your name. It's been nine years of you making Case File. Have you ever considered just revealing who you are? Or has it become part of the brand?
4:27 Speaker 01 Not really, no. I guess it, I guess it has become part of it, but inadvertently, it's kind of like an accident because it was never planned. It was never supposed to be a thing, the anonymous hosting, but it just kind of took off into a life of its own. I guess we have started branching out. I've done a few live appearances in recent times. There's no photo policy and I still don't reveal myself as such. It's more just the Case File story and that sort of thing. I'm uncomfortable with that. That's been fine, but yeah, I don't think I'll ever be a
5:03 Speaker 01 a personality, so to speak.
5:05 Speaker 00 Well, it's very fun trying to look at what people have kind of found out about you. Is that fun to watch, people trying to work it out?
5:15 Speaker 01 I did get a little bit of a kick out of it, sort of initially. I haven't looked at it for a few years now, but there were some weird and wild theories that were out there. So I'm like, how do people even come up with that? That is like completely made up. Yeah, they stayed it like it's just so matter of fact. It's eye opening, actually.
5:37 Speaker 00 Well, fans, is it fans that have nicknamed you Casey?
5:40 Speaker 01 Yes, that came from listeners. So just that came off the back of the anonymous hosting. People were like, well, who is this person? What's going on? And I can't remember if it was a Reddit thread or a Facebook group, maybe. But it was one of those and listeners just started using Casey and that sort of took off.
6:01 Speaker 00 It's probably more catchy to say than anonymous host. So I can see why they've picked a name.
6:05 Speaker 01 It's a bit of a mouthful, isn't it? Anonymous host. It doesn't really.
6:10 Speaker 00 But you've taken on Casey as kind of like the identity as well. You've got an Instagram handle. Is that you, Casey?
6:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's me, yeah, yeah. Photography, bad photography, mind you, on the iPhone is a bit of a hobby of mine, particularly live music and stuff. So it's just like a, just something I like to do in downtime, play around with a few photos and stuff. I thought, ah, I might as well put them out there, I guess.
6:36 Speaker 00 And adopt the name.
6:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, and just lean into the name, yep.
6:40 Speaker 00 Take me back to the start. How did you find yourself sitting down and starting a podcast?
6:46 Speaker 01 So it's something that I'd wanted to do for a little while, a few years, I'd say. I was a pretty early adopter of podcasts.
6:53 Speaker 00 So it was 2016, right?
6:55 Speaker 01 That's when Case File started, but I'd been listening to podcasts since, I think it was like 2008, 2009, something like that. So my housemate at the time put me onto them. I'd never heard of them. And leaning back into that music theme, I discovered Alternative Press had a podcast and it was just long form interviews with a lot of the bands that I liked. I thought it was really cool because up until that point, there'd never really been anything like that. To get insight into artists, it was a snippet in a magazine or a little bit here or there, but to get this really long form conversation, I was immediately drawn in, loved it. And so I'd been a fan for a few years and that sort of branched out into other podcasts after that.
7:40 Speaker 01 And it was always in my mind, I thought, this'd be cool to do. And I played around with a few ideas, maybe a rugby league one, maybe a music one. I'd started looking into music pretty heavily, but obviously a nightmare because you can't play music in podcast licensing, all that sort of stuff. So I wasn't really sure how to approach that. And I'd always been a consumer, I guess, of true crime from a young age. I remember back, I would have been like ten. I was babysat by my auntie a lot back then. And she had this whole shelf full of true crime magazines. I forget the name of it, you know, but it was like a weekly one available at the newsagents.
8:22 Speaker 00 Magazine.
8:23 Speaker 01 Yeah. So every week, one, a new one would come out at the magazine and it was like in long form on one case.
8:29 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:29 Speaker 01 And she had a whole shelf of them. So I was probably way too young to be reading about the Yorkshire Ripper and
8:35 Speaker 00 Oh my gosh.
8:36 Speaker 01 other such cases, but.
8:39 Speaker 01 So from a young age and, and I remember always having an interest in the, the human side of it. It was like, what causes it? How does this happen? Even from such a young age, you know, I, I don't think I was throwing around terms like nature versus nurture back then. But essentially that's what I was wondering at that time, like, how does this happen? And it was, it wasn't like a lifelong thing, you know, I'd sort of in and out of it. Um, a book would come along, like I think one of the first books I read was Helter Skelter. True crime books, that is. And then there was, ABC had a, like a tele-dramatized based on true events called Blue Murder.
9:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, I remember that.
9:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I got right into that and tried to find every book that I could on that case. And, and the players that were involved in that. So I'd always had an interest in it. And so around this time, Serial had been out for, I think, a few years by this point, but I was a late adopter to Serial. And Making a Murderer was big at that time as well. So true crime was sort of back.
9:49 Speaker 00 Bubbling.
9:50 Speaker 01 Bubbling. And it just occurred to me, just because I'd always had from a young age an interest in it. I thought, oh, I wonder if that is something that would work on a podcast. And I started researching, so this is two thousand fifteen. Hard to imagine, but a very different landscape back then. There was hardly any true crime podcasts, very different to today.
10:12 Speaker 00 Especially in Australia, I'm guessing.
10:14 Speaker 01 I don't think there were any in Australia. I could be wrong, there might have been some that I just didn't find. I'm not saying Casefile was the first, but the handful that I did find were a lot more formatted around that multiple hosts roundtable discussion format. There was obviously serial, the documentary style, and then there was another one or two like that that would play 911 calls and interview clips and things like that. Now, at that time, I was heavily influenced by a podcast called Hardcore History by Dan Carlin. What I found so fascinating about that podcast was the in-depth storytelling by a single narrator. So up until that point, I'd only ever heard like interview-style podcasts.
10:58 Speaker 01 I thought that's what podcasts were. Well, there was serial, that was more documentary style, but I'd never really heard anything like Hardcore History, which was just one voice, no clips, no nothing, just his voice for like five hours, telling a story, something complex, like a complex historical event. And it was so compelling, I thought, that just got my mind ticking over, I was like, hmm.
11:22 Speaker 01 It showed me that was possible. And when I was trying to come up with the format and then looking what was out there with true crime, I saw I couldn't find anything out there like that. And so I just borrowed, copied, inspired by, whatever you want to say, Dan Carlin's Hardcore History into true crime.
11:43 Speaker 00 It just goes to show that sometimes it's the simplest ideas that end up being gold. Because it really is just your voice for an hour, sometimes an hour and a half. There's no other audio apart from like a bit of a music bed sometimes.
11:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, so there is a music bed. Very rarely do we play like interrogation clips or things like that. We have done, but it's pretty rare that that'll happen. So usually it's just my voice, yeah.
12:13 Speaker 00 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bath. I'm speaking with the anonymous host of Casefile. Up next, we go back to the start, the making of the very first episode of Casefile.
12:29 Speaker 00 So take me through recording that first episode. Where are you? What does it look like? Do you have a mic? Do you have a setup?
12:36 Speaker 01 It was bad. It was very bad. I was, I had no idea what I was doing from a technical standpoint.
12:43 Speaker 00 One mention of the word wander is enough to send chills down the spine of those who remember the case that dominated the television reports, radio, airwaves and print media of the day.
12:52 Speaker 01 One of my hobbies is I played guitar, bass guitar at home and I had a little interface that I could record myself on GarageBand on my Mac. And so on that interface, which was designed to plug a guitar in, it also had like this little mic, smaller than the size of a five cent piece on it. I thought, oh yeah, that'll do. So I just plugged that in to the laptop. It was sitting on my desk, nowhere near my mouth, over there somewhere. And I just started talking, did what I could on GarageBand with my limited knowledge and then released it.
13:30 Speaker 01 It sounds awful. But so what I'm very thankful for in those early days, we got some good constructive feedback in that, look, this content is pretty good, but this sounds awful. Can you get someone to do something with your audio? I thought, that's probably fair enough. So I advertised for an audio producer on a freelance website.
13:53 Speaker 00 Yep.
13:54 Speaker 01 Things Upwork, I think it was. And it was hard to write that job description because I didn't know what I was asking for because I had no knowledge of what I was doing. So I put together something and probably 20 to 30 people applied. And so I thought the best way to work this out was I just had a one minute snippet from an episode and the job description was fix this. Just show me what you can do, basically, and then I'll listen to it. And there was one standout, which was Mike Migas, who is still the current case file producer
14:27 Speaker 00 Nine years on.
14:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, nine years on. So he was one of the applicants. I listened to his snippet head and shoulders above anyone else. Then I looked at his resume. Worked at Pinewood Studios in the UK, worked on this Star Wars movie, worked on this Disney movie. I'm like, oh dear. No, no wonder it sounds so good, but I can't afford this.
14:50 Speaker 01 But I messaged him and we got chatting and he had actually just left Pinewood Studios and was coming out as a freelancer. He hadn't worked with podcasts before, so he was keen to just try it and dip his toes into it, get experience with podcasts. And he gave me a very favorable rate. So, thank you, Mike.
15:10 Speaker 00 So you found him at a good time, it sounds like.
15:12 Speaker 01 A good time.
15:13 Speaker 00 How many podcasts in were you hiring Mike?
15:16 Speaker 01 It was episode seven was the first one he worked on.
15:19 Speaker 00 And by that point, did you have an audience? What did your audience look like in those early episodes?
15:26 Speaker 01 I remember my goal when I released the first episode was to get to a hundred.
15:31 Speaker 00 A hundred downloads?
15:31 Speaker 01 A hundred downloads. And that happened in 24 hours. And so by the end of the first week, it was about a thousand.
15:40 Speaker 01 And it sort of slowly just, it sort of came in blocks. So by six months, we were averaging 50,000 plus an episode. Then by the end of the first year, it was 250,000 an episode. And then before I knew it into the second year, it was a million plus. It just was like stages. It was very, it almost didn't seem real because there was no promotion. There was nothing behind it.
16:08 Speaker 00 How did you, like, did you just go on to one of the platforms and release it? Did you advertise it on social media? Like, how did you get it out there?
16:16 Speaker 01 It was, I believe the first hosting platform was SoundCloud, actually. So I put it on SoundCloud. And through there, they had an RSS capability. So it went out to Apple and, and all the, everywhere that you can get podcasts. Set up a Facebook page and
16:35 Speaker 00 Just grew.
16:35 Speaker 01 It just grew. It was just word of mouth.
16:38 Speaker 00 What was the first episode on? Do you remember?
16:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, the first episode was the Wanda Beach murders.
16:43 Speaker 00 So a really infamous one.
16:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, infamous Australian one. And I guess I covered that one because it was a case that I'd heard a lot about growing up. It was
16:56 Speaker 01 Sort of almost mythical in a way, the way it was spoken about, an urban legend of sort of, it's not an urban legend, obviously it's a real case, but the way it was spoken about growing up, it was almost like that. And I realised I knew nothing about it. So I thought that was a good place to start, just, as I said, this wasn't planned, this wasn't supposed to go to an audience, this was a project that I was doing while I was off work injured. So it was literally just to fill in the time until I went back to work. So I didn't go crazy because this was my third serious rehab from an injury in quick succession.
17:32 Speaker 00 Okay.
17:32 Speaker 01 And that can be a pretty dark and lonely time, especially for someone who likes to play sport, keep fit, active, it's almost sort of part of my identity. So being stuck through the rehab process, it was, it was pretty tough, that third one, it was a pretty serious injury too. So
17:49 Speaker 01 I'd been wanting to start a podcast for a few years. I thought, well, this is my chance. And yeah, as I said, none of this was planned. I thought I'd maybe do three episodes.
18:01 Speaker 00 As your podcast started to grow, I know you're anonymous to the world, but your loved ones, they would have known that you were starting a podcast. What did they think about it all?
18:10 Speaker 01 Not many. No, I kept it pretty well on the down low. I told a few friends and they kind of just laughed at it. Said like, that's stupid. What are you doing? What are you doing that for? Basically, you know, in a friendly banter type way, I guess. But yeah, I kept it pretty well on the down low, just something that I just did, put my head down and just kept putting it out there. No one I worked with knew about it.
18:39 Speaker 00 So you ended up going back to work and you were doing this on the side?
18:42 Speaker 01 Yep. Yep. So I went back to, eventually got back to work and yeah, just on the days off. And or after work even, yeah, kept working on case file and it kept growing and growing and growing. Eventually I realised that I needed help.
18:58 Speaker 00 Yep.
18:59 Speaker 01 So we got our first researcher and writer to assist. And yeah, from there, the team has just gradually grown. And yeah, now we have two full-time audio producers, three full-time researchers, writers and additional freelancers as well.
19:19 Speaker 00 Wow. Prior to hiring a researcher to obviously help you write those scripts, because they're long, they're detailed, how much work were you putting into that script? Because it's, it's hard to get that amount of detail. And like, if you get anything wrong, people are gonna pick up on it. Is it hours?
19:43 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, it was, it was non-stop. It was literally, I didn't have anything else in life. I'd go to work and I'd come home and like I'd work shift work. So sometimes after a night shift, I'd literally just not sleep. It's because it was that full on. So, yeah, it was a, a lot, a lot of work. That's still a lot of work now, but obviously it's much smoother an operation with having such a talented team working on it now. But, yeah, back then it was pretty full on.
20:14 Speaker 00 Given it's your baby though, it's your, you know, case file is your child. Do you struggle to give it to other people? Are you very close to it still in terms of the writing of those scripts and the research and how the process goes?
20:29 Speaker 01 No, I've got a lot of faith in the team. So it's once, I've been very fortunate just to find such talented and hardworking people who I trust. Uh, so, once those people have my trust, it's, I'm happy to step away. And so the, the writing and research team now is fully led by women. All the writers and researchers are women. The head writer, Millie, is in charge of all the cases, what we're covering, what's the release schedule, all of that. Mike's fully in charge of the production side of it, the audio production, what music goes on and sort of the audio production elements. So, yeah, and I have full trust in the whole team to do that.
21:13 Speaker 00 Because this is no longer, well and truly no longer your side hustle. This is your job, right? When were you able to kind of be like, okay, goodbye former career, I'm doing this?
21:25 Speaker 01 So Case File was released in episode one in January two thousand sixteen. It was the end of two thousand seventeen where I took leave without pay from my job for a year, just to, I was very on the fence and umming and ahing, I don't know what to do, this is. So I thought I'd take the year leave without pay. That year went so quick, it's unbelievable. It's almost like I blinked and then works ringing me, are you coming back? And I still wasn't sure at that stage, so I requested another six months and they said, no. You're either coming back or you're leaving. And so ultimately I just decided to leave and try it full time and yeah, so still able to do it now.
22:10 Speaker 00 What weren't you sure about? What made you think so hard? Did you love your former career?
22:16 Speaker 01 Oh, I wouldn't say that. It was just more stable, I guess.
22:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:19 Speaker 01 Because it was, it's the unknown, a podcast, so. I don't know, especially back then, two thousand seventeen, it was just, it was very much outside of my comfort zone. I guess, and I just wasn't sure about it. It was like, oh, this is a big risk and pressure and, but it was good. It was the best decision I made.
22:42 Speaker 00 This is a bit of a nerdy behind the scenes question, but it's pretty common knowledge that advertisers get a bit scared of true crime as a genre because we talk about murder, blood, gore. You know, often deeply harrowing content. Has that been a challenge for you in trying to monetize?
23:01 Speaker 01 It has been relayed back to me a little bit, but from what I've picked up over the years, that is a very much Australian thing.
23:09 Speaker 00 Right.
23:10 Speaker 01 Not so much in the US and we're very fortunate where we have such a big audience in the US. It was actually half our audience for a number of years was US based.
23:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
23:24 Speaker 01 It's sort of come back a little bit now. I think it's even Australia, thirty five percent Australia, thirty five percent US roughly. So we've always had that big US audience and the US advertisers don't have that same viewpoint.
23:38 Speaker 00 I'm interested to know like male female split.
23:43 Speaker 00 For your podcast, do you have a lot of, is it mainly women, is it mainly men?
23:46 Speaker 01 I believe it's seventy thirty female.
23:50 Speaker 00 Seventy percent female?
23:51 Speaker 01 Yes.
23:52 Speaker 00 Wow.
23:54 Speaker 01 I mean, I don't know how accurate that is. I don't know how they measure that, but that's the stats that come up on our dashboard.
23:58 Speaker 00 Yep.
23:59 Speaker 01 Um, yeah, it was seventy, seventy thirty.
24:02 Speaker 00 Cause we're a bit skewed. Obviously, we're a women's media company doing a podcast, but we have the most male listeners of all the podcasts on our network.
24:11 Speaker 01 Oh, really?
24:11 Speaker 00 Because a lot of men don't listen to our other podcasts.
24:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay.
24:15 Speaker 00 But they listen to us. So that's why I'm so curious to hear, cause I do hear that it's women mainly that like to listen to true crime podcasts.
24:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's certainly the case for us. Um, the live show that we did in Australia in November in Melbourne, that was, that was probably ninety plus women in the audience. So, yeah, very much skewed towards mostly female listeners.
24:43 Speaker 00 Fans of Case File, the OG, might not realise, but you have about, if I'm correct, twenty one other podcasts under kind of the banner of Case File Presents, smaller, you know, like the Easy Street Murders, you've got like a kind of series on that particular case. How did that come about in terms of like branching out and doing that?
25:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, so that's something that I had thought about pretty early on. Once Case File started getting successful, I was really interested, as much as my vision for Case File was the style that we do now, I also obviously really like Serial and that style as well. And I was interested in trying to do some of that long form investigative, deep dive stuff. And so that's basically how it came about. The Case File Presents idea, let's give a platform to other people to tell their stories. So. You know, we have like Vicky Betraytus, who's done a number, well-known true crime author, journalists, PIs, whoever sort of has a story. And we're able to provide that platform, give them an audience to elevate their stories.
25:48 Speaker 00 And do you work really closely with those podcasts?
25:51 Speaker 01 Depends on the show.
25:52 Speaker 00 Okay.
25:52 Speaker 01 It just, it depends on the show, depends on the creator. Some people are like, leave me alone. I'll send you when I'm done. And I'm happy with that because I've obviously put the, I trust them enough to offer them the opportunity. So I believe that they can do it, but other people want a more hands-on approach and can you help me edit this and what do you think of this? And so it just depends on the show. I'm happy to be as involved or as uninvolved as they want me to be.
26:17 Speaker 00 And this is news to me, but I found out today that Case File has a game.
26:21 Speaker 01 Yes.
26:23 Speaker 00 So you can play Case File?
26:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
26:25 Speaker 00 In a board game form?
26:26 Speaker 01 It's a board game. Yeah. So Goliath, the board game company, reached out to us and wanted to do a game. And we were a bit unsure about that, obviously had to just see what they had in mind. But obviously it's a completely fictional storyline and, you know, we were happy with what they came up with. And yeah, so that's, they've just released a version two. So they must be happy enough with how version one went. Version two is only available in the US at this time though.
26:54 Speaker 00 What's your lens? Every podcast has like a bit of a lens as to how they pick a story or a case that they're going to cover. Do you have a way to pick?
27:06 Speaker 01 There's no one lens, I would say, other than we don't do a case just because it's gruesome or to cover the gore or, you know, be gratuitous or anything like that. There's, there's got to be a reason for it. Like, I'm personally close to unsolved cases, so I like covering those and giving those a voice, but there's reasons to cover other stories as well, you know, there's a.
27:35 Speaker 01 Societal impacts, justice system issues, wrongful convictions, problems with police investigations, voices who were ignored, underrepresented communities. There's many, many different reasons. It just depends on the case. But generally, there has to be a reason, some sort of forensic element that's interesting to put out there. Or the genetic genealogy stuff that's become big in recent years, that sort of thing. Yeah.
28:03 Speaker 00 Do you find that there are certain kind of styles that your audience prefers? I'll give you an example from our side. Whenever we do an episode about a cult, it goes really well.
28:14 Speaker 01 Okay.
28:15 Speaker 00 Do you have kind of episodes that you know are going to go well before you've even put them out?
28:20 Speaker 01 Not really. We're pretty...
28:25 Speaker 01 Each episode is pretty on par with another episode.
28:28 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:29 Speaker 01 They all do pretty well, so we don't really have an insight into this particular case. We'll do better than this particular case. Nothing like that. That doesn't factor into the decision making.
28:42 Speaker 00 Are there any episodes, I know you've done over 300, but that you're particularly proud of?
28:49 Speaker 01 The ones that stand out to me would be one like The Unsolved Murder of Brittany Phillips, which is a US case. I touched upon earlier that unsolved cases are the ones that are closest to me. And Maggie Zingman, who is Brittany's mother, I came across her story in that she couldn't get any coverage for her daughter's unsolved murder that happened in Tulsa, Oklahoma. And so she's been driving around for 15, 18 years, whatever it was at the time when we actually covered the case. She's got her car decked out in like a wrap with all the details of her daughter's
29:30 Speaker 01 crime and just driving around. She's been to every state in the continental US multiple times, just driving around. She calls it caravan to catch a killer, just raising awareness. Just you never know, someone might know something somewhere. And despite that, she was unable to get any sort of national coverage or anything. So we were put in touch and we were able to cover that story on Case File. I forget when that was released. It was a few years ago now, but to this day Maggie will still email me and say she still gets people emailing her because they've heard the Case File episode. And there's been no sort of groundbreaking tips at this point, but there's been a few things here and there.
30:11 Speaker 01 And she's just so appreciative of that coverage. So to me, that's something very worthwhile.
30:18 Speaker 00 I find it so interesting that you worked closely with a family member to create that script, I'm guessing.
30:24 Speaker 01 Yep.
30:24 Speaker 00 Do you do that often? Do you have family members or people that were close to the crime involved in the crafting of the episode?
30:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, not every episode, but it does definitely happen. And I guess because we have that single storyteller style, we don't include interview clips that might not be overly apparent that we do that. But it does happen. Yeah. You know, often we'll have, I mean, at this point, we get unfortunately way more emails than we could ever get to for, you know, from family members or advocates or friends or family who are requesting us to cover cases. You know, I wish I could get to all of them, but it's, it's just not possible at this point.
31:07 Speaker 00 Are there any stories that haunt you? Obviously, every story is usually horrible.
31:14 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah, for sure. I mean, all the unsolved ones. I mean, they all haunt you. They all have an effect at some, at some level. The unsolved ones where we work with family are particularly.
31:27 Speaker 01 Harder than others, I would say. Yeah, well, the Brittany Phillips one I just touched on. I was lucky enough to meet Maggie in person last year at CrimeCon for the first time. So that was, that was really good to meet her in person. Uh, the series that I released last year on the Case File Presents platform, Missing Niamh, that I, that took me over four years to put together that series. So obviously that.
31:49 Speaker 00 Four years.
31:50 Speaker 01 That had an effect. Yep.
31:53 Speaker 00 It's so interesting because like at the start of the chat, you were talking about, you know, seeing the books in your auntie's bookcase and being like, oh yeah, true crime. And now it's, you live, breathe, talk about it every day. Does that have an effect on you?
32:09 Speaker 01 It, I guess it does, but it obviously has because I can't consume any true crime stuff anymore outside of what's required for work.
32:17 Speaker 00 Can't you?
32:17 Speaker 01 So people might be talking about the latest Netflix series or, or whatever. There's, I haven't watched any of them. I've got no idea. It's just not something that I can do outside of what's required for work now. So I've got to seek other sort of avenues to, to unwind and stuff. But yeah, so I guess it, it's hard to say, I guess, when you're.
32:40 Speaker 00 Living and breathing it.
32:40 Speaker 01 I mean it every day, yeah.
32:42 Speaker 00 I can still watch the Netflix shows and I live and breathe true crime every day. So I think it just is different people.
32:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, just depends. And there's no sort of right or wrong answer. Yeah.
32:54 Speaker 00 Has your research ever, I know you were talking about Brittany's mum, but has it ever kind of led to a breakthrough or helped an investigation?
33:02 Speaker 01 I don't think so. Not that I know of. Like that Case File episode hasn't directly led to a case being solved. Obviously we've covered unsolved cases that have then become solved, not because of the Case File coverage, but that has happened. We've definitely received tips over the years. You know, I had, I've had tips come directly to me and I'm like, I, I can't, I'm not an investigative agency. Like I can't do anything with this and sort of encourage those people to, to contact the relevant law enforcement agency.
33:32 Speaker 00 That's a lot of pressure on you though, as well, getting tips through your email. And you're like, I'm just hosting a podcast.
33:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. I mean,
33:41 Speaker 01 I, I get it's tough too, because a lot of these cases are decades old. And so from the point of view of the person, like, well, the police don't care. They're not doing anything. That's probably their perception. Whether that's the truth or not, I don't know. It could be different, but.
33:54 Speaker 01 If there's ever something I could actually do to help a case, of course I would do it. But yeah, I think I definitely don't want to be overreaching and trying to take on the role of an investigative agency. I think the first port of call is the police and yeah.
34:11 Speaker 00 You've no doubt watched the true crime space explode over the last nine years. I mean, we're here, we've popped up and plenty of other podcasts.
34:21 Speaker 00 Do you fixate on the charts? I mean, you're usually at the top of them, so you don't need to have to worry. But is it interesting watching it explode and all these new podcasts in your kind of space come up?
34:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's, it still remains one of the most popular, I believe, of the podcast categories. And yeah, there's been all sorts of shows that have popped up since and continue to be popular. And yeah, obviously there was in Australia, we have The Teacher's Pet, which has led to a result.
34:51 Speaker 01 So there's been a lot that has happened over the years. Yeah.
34:54 Speaker 00 Why do you think Case File still dominates all these years later?
34:57 Speaker 01 That's a great question. I have no idea. I just, it's almost like every day I wake up, I'm like, is this the day where everyone stops listening? Or it's, it's hard. It doesn't seem real and it's pretty rare to have been for a show to be at the top for so long too. I mean, obviously we have regular release episodes, so those bigger sort of investigative shows like Your Teacher's Pet and stuff that are limited run, it's, they can't stay at the top. Cause they're not, the episodes stop. Yeah, they're short runs. So we have that to our advantage. But yeah, I don't know. And we don't take it for granted. We continue just to put our heads down,
35:40 Speaker 01 work really hard and try to continually improve the episodes and what we're doing. And as long as people keep listening, we will keep doing it.
35:49 Speaker 00 Well, you've obviously met some of your audience in real life. You've done a few in-person chats. But do you get a lot of feedback from audience of where they're listening and, and why they love the show?
36:02 Speaker 01 The most common feedback that I've gotten from people in, both in person, people email in and write comments and stuff is just they appreciate the no-nonsense storytelling, I guess, the empathetic storytelling, there's no banter or chit-chat. So I guess they like that about our style as well. And just what I touched on before, that it's not just, we're not just telling stories about gratuitous violences. Generally, something else to it, some sort of impact somewhere, judicial system, criminal justice system, police, whatever. And yeah, that's, I guess, the most, the most common feedback that I've gotten.
36:43 Speaker 00 I have a feeling you accompany many people on their road trips.
36:46 Speaker 01 Oh, in terms of where they listen? Yeah, yeah. Road trips is very popular. Gym, walks, runs, that sort of thing is very popular as well. And it's funny, actually, Anthony, the other audio producer, was at a friend's house recently and he's popped out of the car.
37:07 Speaker 01 And he's heard my voice. He's like, what's going on here? And it turns out a neighbour of his friend was in the garage, like, doing a workout and had Casefile.
37:16 Speaker 00 Casefile on.
37:17 Speaker 01 Luring, so, yeah, I've, that's never happened to me. I've never bumped into anyone listening to Casefile.
37:22 Speaker 00 Really?
37:23 Speaker 01 No, well, not that I know of, yeah.
37:26 Speaker 00 You haven't seen it on their phone?
37:27 Speaker 01 No.
37:27 Speaker 00 I've done that a few times where I've seen our podcast on someone's phone.
37:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, no, never.
37:33 Speaker 00 Because your voice is very familiar now, like, you've done over 300 episodes. And you didn't have any audio training, did you?
37:42 Speaker 01 No, no.
37:43 Speaker 00 But I think most people that listen would be able to recognise your voice in a line-up.
37:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, maybe, but some people don't. I was at an event only last week and I was talking to someone. And I mentioned I was from Casefile, it was a podcast event, and they were like, oh, a famous voice. So who does the voice? And so they had no idea that it was, I'd say, oh, that's me. And they were like, oh, you sound very different in real life.
38:13 Speaker 00 So you do tell people that you come across, that you are.
38:16 Speaker 01 Oh, not everyone, but in that environment, I was okay to talk about it, that particular event. But it's not something I'll just freely disclose on day-to-day on the street or anything like that, no.
38:32 Speaker 00 Next, I ask the anonymous host of Case File who he will reveal his identity to.
38:41 Speaker 00 Nerdy again, but I was at the Australian Podcast Awards and I hear you were too.
38:46 Speaker 01 I was.
38:46 Speaker 00 But I wouldn't have known it because I didn't know what you looked like.
38:49 Speaker 01 I was just lurking in the shadows at the back of the room there, yeah.
38:53 Speaker 00 But you don't, well, I don't remember you getting up. Case File Presents at least got an award that night from memory.
38:59 Speaker 01 We were nominated, didn't, didn't win.
39:01 Speaker 00 Would you have gotten up if you won?
39:03 Speaker 01 No, no, I think members of the Acast team were gonna step in and do that for us. So that was Easy Street and Troubled Waters were both nominated in different categories.
39:14 Speaker 00 So you are still very careful in terms of, like, you'll do certain things, like you'll stand in front of an intimate audience, but you won't get up on a stage in a podcasting awards.
39:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't know why, it probably seems a bit contradictory, but.
39:29 Speaker 00 No, it's clever.
39:31 Speaker 01 But in saying that, if I was at that award show and bumped into you or and you introduced yourself like I, at that sort of environment, I would have said who I was, yeah.
39:41 Speaker 00 Well, I'll recognise you now.
39:42 Speaker 01 Now you will, yes.
39:45 Speaker 00 Where do you think the future of podcasting is going as someone that's been in the world for so long? Because it is so saturated now.
39:53 Speaker 01 I think from what I read and see, everything seems to be pointing towards video. Video has become a very big thing, which, I don't know, I kind of look at it.
40:03 Speaker 00 What are you gonna do?
40:04 Speaker 01 I'm like, well, video's not podcasting, no. It's a different thing.
40:08 Speaker 00 You'll have to get a good silhouette.
40:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, we've just made changes to our YouTube channel, so we release on YouTube as well. So as of the first episode we've released this year, we've incorporated sort of pictures and maps and different things that will overlay on the screen and it's kind of like an animated studio silhouette of a person recording. So we've made some tweaks, leaning into the video a bit more, doing what we can because obviously we are limited. But yeah, it's a very different landscape now than it was to when Case File started. I find it now, when we release Case File Presents shows sometimes, even though we have a massive audience to, to advertise that to, sometimes it can not take.
40:51 Speaker 00 Be a bit of a flop.
40:52 Speaker 01 It's just very hard to, to break through now. I think there's so many established shows launching a new show.
41:01 Speaker 01 Much tougher, not to say it can't be done, of course it can be. It's just much tougher now. I think the barrier to entry is a little bit higher now.
41:09 Speaker 00 So if you were to try and release your episode one from twenty sixteen now and do what you did now.
41:17 Speaker 01 I think that would be what the original, it would turn out to what the original thought was. Three episodes and I'd be back to work. Yeah, I couldn't see it taking off now, just with how bad the audio was as well. So I think there's a much higher level of quality now.
41:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
41:33 Speaker 01 Audio production and, you know, just the shows themselves, the content. Yeah.
41:39 Speaker 00 Do you still love it?
41:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, still.
41:44 Speaker 01 As I said, I wake up every day, just so, I can't believe that the show has the audience that it has and that I get to work with such a talented group of people and people listen and that we get to do this. Yeah. Very fortunate.
41:58 Speaker 00 So you've just come back from summer break in February. Lucky bugger.
42:03 Speaker 01 Yes, although that is a bit of a misconception I'd like to clear up, we've been bombarded with one star reviews that we've taken too long off. I can assure everyone, we have been working very hard. I mean, of course, we had two weeks off over the Christmas New Year period itself, but as soon as the last episode came out last year, we would have wrapped that up in October. So as soon as that was sort of done and recorded, might not have been released yet, but we were straight on to twenty twenty five.
42:28 Speaker 00 So listeners rest assured, you were working, you just weren't releasing.
42:31 Speaker 01 It's, we sort of need that three, three month lead in just to get ready for, for the new year. Because otherwise it can, in past years, it's just been a nightmare. We've barely been days ahead. Like I'll finish recording an episode, got to get it to Mike, he's got three days to put the audio production, get it out and it's, that's not a good way to operate.
42:50 Speaker 00 No.
42:50 Speaker 01 Stressful. So we try and keep ahead of that now.
42:53 Speaker 00 So what can we expect? What are some of the episodes that you have coming up?
42:57 Speaker 01 Listeners can expect, I think, more of what they have come to know and love about Casefile. There's varied cases from Australia, from around the world. There's all sorts of, you know, different cases, more recent, older. We are launching with a two-parter on The Night Caller, which was the serial offender Eric Edgar Cook in Perth.
43:22 Speaker 01 Western Australia. And I think what's interesting about that case is just such a different time when that was happening. And you have this prolific serial offender just wreaking havoc across the city. And yet they didn't put it together, that it was the same offender. I mean, there's, there's multiple wrongful convictions despite a confession from Eric Aggook in this case. After he was eventually caught and they, he confessed and they put together, oh, this was all the same guy. There's people sitting in prison for his crimes and despite a full detailed confession, they're like, ah, nah. It still took a while for those guys to get out. I just, there's certain things about that case that blow my mind.
44:03 Speaker 00 Do you ever struggle to hold back your opinion in your script writing?
44:07 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, yeah. I, I have plenty of opinions on most cases. But yeah, very mindful that that's not what case file is about. It's, you've got to remain neutral, just tell it, just tell the facts. And sometimes I think people forget that. So like if we, a very common gripe for listeners and that will get emails about is about the use of polygraph tests. So if we mention in a case, like, you know, certain suspect was brought in, given a polygraph test and passed and failed or whatever. People will write in like furious, this is junk science, it's been debunked. Like, we're not advocating for a polygraph test, I'm just, that's what happened. Yeah, so even though we don't give opinions, people can sometimes hear things and, and think that we are.
44:52 Speaker 01 But yeah, we just keep it neutral, this is what happened and that's case file, basically.
44:59 Speaker 00 And I know you said you kept it secret from your friends and family, but I'm assuming they know what you do now. What do they think?
45:04 Speaker 01 They know now, yeah. Yeah, they're pretty sort of blown away by it as well. Some of them can't believe it. They hear my voice, they're like, what?
45:14 Speaker 00 Do they listen?
45:15 Speaker 01 Uh, some do, some don't, yeah. Some sort of, some are turned off by my voice actually. Cause they can't take it seriously, cause they know it's me. You know, some aren't into true crime and stuff like that. Yeah, but, but quite a few friends and family do listen, yeah.
45:30 Speaker 00 Well, thank you for coming into the studio. I know it was a, a bit of a trek for you. That's not giving too much away, is it?
45:36 Speaker 01 No, bad traffic, very bad traffic.
45:40 Speaker 00 Everyone can keep listening to you, but just call you Casey.
45:48 Speaker 00 Thanks to Casey for telling us his story. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast hosted and produced by me, Gemma Bath, and Tali Blackman with audio design by Jacob Brown. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous "What REALLY Happened When I Confronted Belle Gibson" Next The Moment That Could’ve Saved Gabby Petito [re-release] Page updated November 4, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated