Pod Insights True Crime Conversations How The Deaths Of Two Girls, Eight Years Apart, Uncovered Tokyo’s Worst Predator About this episode Carita Ridgeway from Australia and Lucie Blackman from England arrived in Japan eight years apart, both working as hostesses, earning $150-$400 a night while entertaining wealthy businessmen.
At 21, both planned to make money for world travel but encountered Joji Obara, a sadistic criminal mastermind. While there were hundreds of victims assaulted by Obara, they were the only ones known to have lost their lives.
Clare Campbell’s book Tokyo Hostess: Inside the Shocking World of Tokyo Nightclub Hostessing explores their stories, the Japanese sex industry, and the serial rapist who sparked an international investigation.
You can find her book here https://www.hachette.com.au/clare-campbell/tokyo-hostess-inside-the-shocking-world-of-tokyo-nightclub-hostessing.
THE END BITS
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=tcc
CREDITS
Guest: Clare Campbell
Host: Gemma Bath https://www.linkedin.com/in/gemmabath/?originalSubdomain=au
Producer: Tahli Blackman https://www.linkedin.com/in/tahli-blackman-205a891b7/?originalSubdomain=au
Audio Producer: Jacob Round
GET IN TOUCH
Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected] or send us a voice note https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960to give us feedback or suggest a case for the podcast.
Rate or review us on Apple by clicking on the three dots in the top right-hand corner, click Go To Show then scroll down to the bottom of the page, click on the stars at the bottom and write a review. You can also leave a comment for us on Spotify.
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on.
0:13 Speaker 01 It's close to midnight on a Wednesday evening in early July 2000. And Japanese police are knocking at the door of number 401. At an apartment complex in the seaside town of Aburatsubo, about an hour and a half from Tokyo. The man leasing it is rarely there. And tonight, neighbours can hear thumping and banging coming from inside. When one of them knocked, the lights on inside were swiftly turned off. So four policemen are here to check it out. After several demands to be let in, finally, the door creaks open. Standing there is a half naked man breathing heavily with beads of sweat on his face. He's covered in dust and dirt.
0:58 Speaker 01 Behind him, officers can see chips of what appears to be concrete. And a large linen bag with something inside it.
1:07 Speaker 01 "I'm re-tiling my bathroom", he tells them. They ask to come in and see, but the man gets agitated and refuses to let them in.
1:16 Speaker 01 They don't push it. He's obviously not an intruder, so they leave him to it. What they don't realise is the sinister scene they've just witnessed. Because the half naked man is Joji Abara. And pretty soon, he's going to be charged with murder, manslaughter. And implicated in the horrific sexual assaults of as many as 400 women.
1:48 Speaker 01 I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations. A Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. Karyta Ridgway from Australia and Lucie Blackman from England touched down in the bright lights of Japan eight years apart. Both went with a plan: to work for a few months in Tokyo's super-exclusive nightclubs as a hostess, earn a bunch of cash, fund their travels and adventures around the world, and then return to their lives in their respective countries and start building their futures. They were both 21, beautiful, and full of dreams. It's a pretty normal post-schooling trope: leave and explore the world before settling
2:33 Speaker 01 into a life of study and career. For Karyta in the 80s and Lucy in the 2000s, Japan was sold to them as a safe place to go. In fact, the hostessing world was sold to them as safe, despite it being on the fringes of the lucrative sex industry. But for these two women, it was anything but, because they found themselves coming face-to-face with a sadistic criminal mastermind who hid behind flashy cars and suits. While they were two of hundreds of victims, they were the only ones that we know about that also lost their lives. Claire Campbell is the author of Tokyo Hostess: Inside the Shocking World of Tokyo Nightclub Hostessing.
3:18 Speaker 01 She explores the stories of Karyta and Lucy, the complicated Japanese sex industry, and the serial rapist who sparked an international investigation. Claire joins us now.
3:31 Speaker 01 Claire, can you take me inside the lure of hostessing in Japan? Why are young women, particularly Western women, drawn to this industry?
3:43 Speaker 02 It was a fantastic opportunity for young women, or it seemed to be at the time. It was a way to go abroad, somewhere exotic, and to make lots of money in a very, what seemed, a very easy and a very safe way. And it was. The message coming from Tokyo at the time was, it was safe, safe, safe. And it wasn't a sexual transaction, they were just going in the manner of, it would have been the closest analogy would be geisha girls. To go and talk and light men's cigarettes and give them a drink and just chat to them and get paid.
4:22 Speaker 02 A relatively large amount of money. I mean Lucy was being paid between twenty and forty pounds an hour.
4:29 Speaker 01 Um.
4:29 Speaker 02 And Lucy at the time had a seven thousand pound credit card debt. So she said to her sister, I'm just gonna go out there and I'm gonna make as much money as I can in as short a time as I can.
4:42 Speaker 01 I know you say that it's not. The sex industry technically, but it's kind of on the fringes I've heard it described as.
4:49 Speaker 02 Yeah.
4:50 Speaker 01 And when you dive into the actual sex industry in Japan. It's called the water trade, if I'm saying that right.
4:57 Speaker 02 That that's right, it is the water trade, but there's various degrees of the water trade. So Lucy was and and Carita were at the very top, which is the the the girls in the clubs. Then there's the cabaret clubs and then underneath there there's what are called snack girls. And below that, you're really getting into like blowjob bars.
5:21 Speaker 01 Right.
5:22 Speaker 02 Fine, so there there are all these, the the Japanese have a very strange attitude towards sex. So they they love sex, they don't see anything wrong in sex, but it has to be ordered and and they have to have rules about it. And they don't like people not obeying the rules. So the gut, the bars that Lucy and Carita worked in, they wouldn't expect the girls to have sex. And in fact, if the girls suggested it, they'd be quite shocked. Even though the other way around, occasionally people were paid for sex, but in the bars where Lucy and Carita worked, not really, not really. I mean, the men would try, but they they would be quite shocked themselves and probably.
6:05 Speaker 02 Go run away if the girls agree to it.
6:09 Speaker 01 I I think all of us have heard about, you know, the vending machines with used women's underwear, but it goes much further than that. You kind of explored erotic fish women image clubs.
6:20 Speaker 02 That's right.
6:20 Speaker 01 Take me in there. What are some of the weirder things that? The Japanese sex industry can offer you.
6:27 Speaker 02 There there are some really, really weird things, like uh going to strange bars where people dress up, cosplay is a big thing, and the borders of paedophilia as well, they have images of children, but children in like weird costumes and people can go and you can all dress up and people pretend to have sex with fish. Having sex with fish is a big thing, having sex with octopi is also a big thing. I mean, it seems very, very weird to us, but it's bordering on sort of bestiality and things that we just wouldn't go near.
7:07 Speaker 01 But I guess it explains just how big business sex is in Japan, because it does go into all of these different areas.
7:16 Speaker 02 It does, it does, it's massively cleaned up since the time when Lucy was there. But Ropongi, where Lucy was working, was the wild, wild west, as one girl who'd been a hostess there described it to me afterwards, and she said her sister worked there after Lucy's death. And and it was completely different, because at this time it was largely unregulated, the hostesses were largely unregulated. A lot were working on working visas, which they weren't technically allowed to do. You weren't allowed to either have a tourist visa or a working visa to work in the clubs. So it was all bordering on illegal anyway.
7:59 Speaker 01 But did the Japanese officials kind of know that was happening and turn a blind eye, or how did that work?
8:04 Speaker 02 They did and turned a blind eye to it.
8:07 Speaker 01 Right.
8:07 Speaker 02 And um when Lucy went missing, her friend Louise went to the embassy. But the consul was really shocked that it was going on, he had no idea that girls gave out business cards, the first thing you did when you went into the hostess bar, when you met a man, was give him your card. But nobody knew who you were with, and there was no way of checking who you'd gone off with. Which is what, of course, Lucy did and and Carita had done before her.
8:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, cause I wanna, back to hostessing, you know, it's it's in a club setting. But part of being a hostess was going on these dates outside of the club. Which was quite a regular thing to do, wasn't it? Can you explain that concept?
8:53 Speaker 02 Yes, it was called a dohan, which was technically a paid date. So a man would pick you from what was called a doggy box. There was a group of girls all waiting to be chosen. And a man would pick one girl. And then if he came the next night and he picked that girl again and kept wanting to see her. He'd ask her on a dohan and a date and he'd take her, it would really bizarre things. I mean, quite often these were middle-aged businessmen and they'd take the girls out to the golf course or something, sometimes with their families. And
9:30 Speaker 01 Weird.
9:31 Speaker 02 The the girls would go on a date with them, or it could be to dinner or to a bar. And if you got, you were expected to get at least four dohans a month. And if you had two dohans with the same man, he would become your customer. He was your personal property after that. And girls got bonuses if they had more than twelve dohans a month. And then you would get a cut of the money when they were coming into the bar.
10:00 Speaker 01 But what's in it for the men? They're not getting sex out of this.
10:04 Speaker 02 No, no.
10:06 Speaker 01 So why, why would they do this? Just take girls on dates?
10:09 Speaker 02 It's all about a fantasy, really. A dohan is a sort of fantasy date. That you pretend that instead of getting paid for it, this girl is choosing to go out with you because she likes you. And because she just wants the pleasure of your company. So he's he's, you're you're being paid to flatter him, basically. But it's quite servile. And um what several of the hostesses said to me, that European men coming into the bars found it all very embarrassing and they they wouldn't have any part in it because if you were talking to, if you were British and you met a British girl, you'd be embarrassed if she started following you to the loo and offering you water to wash your hands afterwards and it just wouldn't work.
10:54 Speaker 02 So it's a fantasy date for these men. There's nothing shameful about sex outside marriage in Japan, even though these men weren't on the whole having sex with the girls. But there isn't anything shameful about it. It's more shameful not to be married. So you would be married, but wives would have to tolerate all this sort of extracurricular behaviour that was going on.
11:18 Speaker 01 Extracurricular.
11:19 Speaker 02 Yes, well, because it was something they'd do on the way home from work. I mean, to us, it's extraordinary.
11:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:26 Speaker 02 And the wives would tolerate it. I mean, the idea you take your girlfriend out on the golf course with your wife and and your family sometimes.
11:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a different world, isn't it?
11:39 Speaker 02 It really, really is.
11:41 Speaker 01 Let's talk about Carita. Carita Ridgway, she's an Australian, and she found herself dipping in and out of the hostessing industry in the late eighties, early nineties. Can you tell us about her? She grew up in Perth. What do we know about her life?
11:57 Speaker 02 Okay, so she grew up in Perth with her sister Sam, and her sister Sam was teaching English at one stage. They'd both worked as hostesses. Sam had worked in Sydney at a a hostess bar where she met her boyfriend Hideki, a Japanese guy called Hideki Toyama, who was the head waiter at a hostess bar in Sydney. And Carita was her younger sister, and she had a boyfriend, a Liverpoolian called Robert, who they who Robert Finnegan, who she'd met while backpacking in eighty eight. And then Carita went for the first time to Tokyo in late eighty eight with her friend Linda.
12:42 Speaker 02 And she worked for three months in a hostess bar to try and make money. Then the following year, she met up with Robert again, and they carried on travelling around the world. And then Robert and Carita decided to settle in Sydney, and they bought somewhere to live in Clavelly. And Sam went to live with them. And then Carita decided she was going to go back to Tokyo to make some more money. And she went back in for one year, and it was on the third time that she met Joji Obara. And she wasn't working in the same district as Lucy. She was working at the Ayakoji Club, which was in Ginza, which was a much more upmarket
13:27 Speaker 02 area of Tokyo. And her sister Sam, and you can see from the pictures, described Carita as very beautiful. She said she was like a cross between Kate Moss and Winona Ryder, and men just melted. And when she went to the Hostess Bar to be hired, the mamasan just agreed straight away on seeing Carita, that for her to come and work. So she'd had two successful stints of hostessing in Tokyo before she went to work at the bar where she met Joji.
13:59 Speaker 01 And she was doing these dohans, these dates with men?
14:03 Speaker 02 She was, she was.
14:05 Speaker 01 So tell-
14:06 Speaker 02 And very successfully.
14:08 Speaker 01 Tell us about the phone call that her sister received from, you know, a mystery man claiming to know Carita. It was February nineteen ninety two.
14:19 Speaker 02 Yes, it was Valentine's Day in nineteen ninety two. And the last time Sam saw her sister was the morning of February the fourteenth, where she went off to work at the Berlitz School to teach English. And Carita disappeared to go off to work at the bar. And that night, Sam was meeting her boyfriend Hideki, and she stayed over at Hideki. So she didn't see, she didn't expect to see Carita until the next morning. But when she got back to the Friendship House where they both lived, a friend who was sharing the house said that a strange call had come in from a man calling himself Akira Nishida.
15:01 Speaker 02 And he'd said that he'd taken Carita out for the evening, but, and they'd gone to eat shellfish, but that Carita had been taken very ill and he dropped her off to hospital.
15:14 Speaker 02 And Sam thought this was very odd, and who is this man? And she she didn't know where to go with it. And so she was worried all night, waiting for Carita to come home. And then the following morning, she got a call from Hidashima Hospital to say that this man had dropped Carita at hospital and that Carita was very, very ill indeed, and could she come straight away?
15:38 Speaker 01 Well, so ill that basically the whole family came over immediately.
15:43 Speaker 02 Yes, well, well, Sam went first, not realising how ill her sister was. And she kept saying to Carita, who is Nishida? Who is Nishida? Who is this man that ran the house? And she she couldn't really speak to Carita. And Carita seemed at first to be falling asleep. And then Sam said that she realised she was losing consciousness. And she was horrified and she called the staff. And then the staff said, we're very, very concerned about her. We think she might be dying. So Sam was horrified and rang her parents in Australia and also Robert Finnigan, who was studying in Sydney. And they both said that they'd come straight away and and come and and to fly out.
16:26 Speaker 01 What did the doctors say was wrong with her?
16:29 Speaker 02 They they couldn't work it out to begin with, but they said that she had liver failure, but they couldn't work out what it was from. And so at first they thought she had hepatitis D. And then they changed the diagnosis to hepatitis E. But it still didn't quite fit, so they were very confused. And of course, the only information that they had was that they believed her to have food poisoning. But that just didn't seem to fit with anything. So Sam was getting terribly worried. And she asked Hideki, her boyfriend, to try and find out who this Nishida was. Because in the days while Carita's condition was worsening, he kept calling and kept asking after her.
17:11 Speaker 02 And finally called and asked to speak to Carita's mother, Annette, who'd who'd arrived by then. And Annette spoke to him and they would they agreed that they'd meet him at the airport hotel the following week. But in the meantime, Carita's condition worsened and worsened. Until by, I think it was the nineteenth of February, the doctor said that they weren't, they did a pinprick test and they said that Carita was brain dead. And and they asked them if they wanted to turn off the life support machine.
17:41 Speaker 01 So they did.
17:42 Speaker 02 Really, really terrible. I mean, you just can't imagine how the family must have felt.
17:47 Speaker 01 There was an important detail that the dad asked happen to Carita's body before they did that. Can you tell us about that?
17:55 Speaker 02 Yes, and this was crucial, not only to to finding out what happened to Carita, but also finding out what happened to Lucy. He asked for a liver biopsy to be taken, although they didn't wait for the liver biopsy results in the end because they were so overwhelmed by Carita's death. Um, and and afterwards, they said they regretted that they hadn't asked for a postmortem. But they agreed in in the the shock, really, the shock state that they were in for her body to be cremated the following day.
18:27 Speaker 01 And the parents actually did end up going through with that meeting, didn't they, after her death?
18:33 Speaker 02 They did. On the Sunday evening, uh, at the the they met him at the airport hotel. And the mother, uh, Annette Ridgway, when she saw him was really shocked because she thought Carita couldn't possibly be interested in this middle-aged man. And he bought a diamond necklace and a ring and said that he'd really loved Carita and that he would have loved to spend more time with her. And and they were sort of horrified by by this man. And then Annette said she just kept thinking she couldn't believe Carita would ever have had anything to do with him.
19:06 Speaker 01 Did the police help? Like, what happened from here?
19:09 Speaker 02 That whole week before Carita's death, Hideki and Sam were trying to get the police to become interested. And and they just didn't. They just kept asking Sam if Carita was taking drugs. To which, you know, Sam was really offended and said, no, that neither of them had ever taken drugs, and it was nothing to do with that. And and the police did nothing. And in fact, they started asking them what visas they were on and just investigating Carita and Sam rather than trying to find out who Nishida was.
19:39 Speaker 01 And so the family just decided to go back to Australia, grieve.
19:44 Speaker 02 Yes.
19:45 Speaker 01 And that's where it kind of ended for the time being.
19:49 Speaker 02 For them. And Sam left. She broke up with Hideki. I mean, it must have been really difficult for her to be involved with a Japanese man after what had happened to her sister. And so she also went home, although she came back to Tokyo two years later.
20:05 Speaker 01 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bath. I'm speaking with Claire Campbell, author of the book Tokyo Hostess. Up next, Claire tells us the story of Lucie Blackman, a British hostess in Tokyo whose murder by Joji Abara captured intense media attention.
20:28 Speaker 01 So, let's skip forward eightish years. Lucie Blackman arrives in Tokyo. She's also 21, young, looking to earn a lot of cash quickly. Tell us a bit about her because she arrived in the year 2000. She's British. What else do we know about her?
20:48 Speaker 02 She'd done very well at school. She was very bright. She was attractive. She had three A levels. She'd gone to work in a bank. She chose not to go to college, but she went to work in a bank. And then she went to work for British Airways, both jobs with her friend Louise, the one that accompanied her out to Tokyo. And Louise had an old sister called Emma, who'd done hostessing very successfully and made a lot of money. So it was Louise who put the idea to Lucy that they should go out. And so Lucy told her father, actually, and her mother, that they were going to stay with an aunt of Louise's in Tokyo, which wasn't true, and that there was, they had
21:30 Speaker 02 work waiting for them when they got there, which also wasn't true. They just arrived at Narita Airport and looked in Tokyo classified for somewhere to live and a job because they had nowhere to live when they arrived.
21:45 Speaker 01 So Lucy starts working at a club called Casablanca. You've described it in your book as being tacky, but one of the better ones. So a reasonably good place to work.
21:58 Speaker 02 It was, yes. Although Lucy wasn't happy at first, if you go by her diaries and what she told her sister. She wasn't happy at first because she was quite competitive. Another girl, another hostess who met her, said that she was quite guarded, whereas Louise was quite open. Lucy was quite guarded and quite defensive. And she was very competitive. And she felt personally that she wasn't doing as well as Louise in that she felt, and I'm sure it was just her perspective on it, because there's no real evidence of that. But she felt Louise was a far more successful hostess than she was. And Louise was getting dohans. And at the end of the first month,
22:41 Speaker 02 I think that Lucy was ranked eleven out of twenty, and she'd been stood up on one dohan. And she said, how bad you have to be as a hostess to be stood up on a dohan. So she was very self-critical.
22:55 Speaker 01 So I guess that kind of explains why she was excited to get dohans, because she was gonna go up that leaderboard.
23:02 Speaker 02 Exactly. And she did, she did. She had suddenly, after about a month in, she started becoming more popular and she met an American boyfriend, a marine called Scott Fraser. And she was very happy. And in fact, the point at which she she met Joe Giubara, she was doing really well. She felt that she'd sort of, she was now coping with Tokyo and and was managing very well. She was making quite a lot of money and she was popular and she turned a corner.
23:36 Speaker 01 Let's skip to July first, two thousand. She met a customer for a dohan, which we now know was Joe Gi, but what
23:45 Speaker 02 Yes.
23:45 Speaker 01 what was Louise hearing about that date and that day? She was getting a few phone calls from her?
23:51 Speaker 02 She was, because that night Lucy and Scott Fraser, her boyfriend, were meant to be going out in Ropongi with Louise on a night off from the Casablanca. They were just going to go out and enjoy themselves, and it was all planned. But Louise left the Gaijin house at about lunchtime, and Lucy was getting dressed, and she was putting on a black dress and silver jewellery and a handbag. And Louise assumed she was going on a dohan, but Lucy didn't say very much about it, because she was quite competitive about it and didn't want Louise to know who she was going out with. And she said she was going on a dohan, but she'd be back in plenty of time for them to go out in the evening. I think they planned
24:35 Speaker 02 to meet about seven or seven thirty. And the next thing that Louise heard was a call from Lucy to say that she was with a very nice man somewhere by the sea, and that she'd be on time, she wouldn't be late. And that was the last call that Louise ever had from her.
24:55 Speaker 01 So the only real clue she had was that she was by the sea with a man?
24:59 Speaker 02 Yes, yes.
25:01 Speaker 01 How quickly did Louise start to worry and raise the alarm?
25:05 Speaker 02 She, it was the next morning, when, well, at first they were very alarmed when she didn't come home that night, but they assumed that she'd just stayed on the dohan. And then the following morning, she just began to get more and more worried with no word from Lucy, and she kept thinking, what should she do? But she was worried because she wasn't on the right visa, what she'd say to the police. So she left it all day Sunday, and then on the Monday, she went to the police and said that Lucy had gone on a date with a Japanese businessman and hadn't come home. So she was quite concerned. But she also went to see the consul in the afternoon, Ian Ferguson, the British consul. And he
25:49 Speaker 02 was very alarmed when he heard what the girls had been doing. And he told Louise to go back to the police and tell them the truth. And as Louise was leaving the embassy that afternoon, she got a strange call from a man calling himself Akira Tagaki, because Joji Obara was always using pseudonyms.
26:10 Speaker 01 And Akira is the same first name he was using.
26:13 Speaker 02 Akira was saying it's the first name, but a different surname. And he said not to worry about Lucy, that she was quite safe, but that she'd joined a cult and that Louise would never hear from her again. But that she was quite happy and not to worry about her. So Louise straight away, you know, thought this is mad, you know, I'm really worried. So she tried to keep him talking on the telephone and to ask more questions. And then when he rang off, she went straight back into the embassy and told Ian Ferguson. And Ian Ferguson panicked then, and he said, you must go straight to the police and, and don't bother saying it's a Japanese businessman. Just say that your friend has been abducted
26:56 Speaker 02 and tell them the full story, that you were working as a hostess and what had happened. So that was what Louise did. And she also called home at that point and told poor Lucy's mother, Jane, what had happened. And, and Jane was terribly shocked. In fact, I think she was sick when she got the phone call to say, because she'd just been packing up a parcel to send out to Lucy when she got the call from Louise to say that Lucy had gone missing. So it must have been a terrible, terrible shock to her.
27:28 Speaker 01 Because the family was never going to believe that she joined a cult, were they?
27:32 Speaker 02 No, no, I mean, it was rubbish from the beginning. I mean, it just shows you what a fantasist Joji was really to think that any, any family would believe that.
27:42 Speaker 01 It took a few days, quite a few days for this story to blow up, but it did. It became an international news story. Thanks in part to Lucy's dad, who just went, right, we've got to get this story out. He knew how to work the media because the police weren't being as cooperative at that point. How big did this story get?
28:06 Speaker 02 It was, Tim told me afterwards that he realised when he got to Narisa Airport, when he saw the numbers of press, because what had happened was word had got out that, at first the British press thought that Lucy was an air hostess, and then they got the false story that she'd been working as a hostess in a Japanese bar, which nobody had ever heard of at that time in the UK. So the press went mad, particularly the tabloids. And so there was a massive number of press at Narisa Airport, all waiting to speak to Tim. And he realised, as he walked into the room, he said, and saw the numbers of press there, that he could work that to his advantage.
28:48 Speaker 02 That if there were that number of press, they could all help find Lucy. So he decided to play it that way, and which he did do brilliantly.
28:58 Speaker 01 So we've got Tim and Lucy's sister over in Japan, kind of leading the search. The police start to actually get on board because of all of the press. And it turns into quite a big operation. You know, Lucy's family's putting out posters, they even set up an information line. It got quite serious, didn't it? Quite extensive, that search.
29:22 Speaker 02 It did, it did. And they were getting a lot of false information in as well. But the crucial information that Sophie did get was some calls from former hostesses, who all came up with this similar story. There was an Australian girl, there was a Canadian girl and a British girl, who all claimed that they'd been taken to an apartment by the sea and given something weird to drink, and that they couldn't remember anything the next morning. And one girl, the Canadian girl Donna, had clearly, she was clear that she'd been raped, but they all thought that they'd been given GHB or something, that their drinks had been spiked.
30:05 Speaker 02 And so these stories, when they put them all together, seemed to be bringing this picture. Although Tim said to me that he thought that the police, the Japanese police, had been watching Joji for some time, and had had their eye on him, but hadn't done anything. So we don't know, really.
30:24 Speaker 01 Why wouldn't they have done anything? They were just biding their time for him to slip up?
30:28 Speaker 02 Uh until they had evidence.
30:30 Speaker 01 Right.
30:30 Speaker 02 Yes.
30:31 Speaker 01 Well, they they made an arrest in the October, so she went missing quite a few months earlier.
30:35 Speaker 02 She did.
30:36 Speaker 01 They made an arrest. What do we know about how they actually came to making that arrest? What evidence led them to that? Was it these phone calls?
30:44 Speaker 02 It was. It was the phone calls because they began to piece together information and also the phone, the uh they finally traced the the mobiles because to begin with, Tim had been pressing them to trace the mobile calls that that um Lu- Louise had got. And at first they kept saying they couldn't do it and it was a matter of data privacy. They couldn't do anything like that. And then Tim spoke to Tony Blair, the Prime Minister at the time. And then suddenly Derry Irvin, the Chancellor, was on to it. And he spoke to Tim and the next minute it it was all sorted and they could trace the calls.
31:28 Speaker 02 And that led them to Joji Abara.
31:31 Speaker 01 So who is Joji Abara from the outside? Who was he?
31:35 Speaker 02 Joji Abara, he was born in nineteen fifty two. He's actually Korean and not Japanese at all. And he was born to um a Korean who'd made a lot of money in Pachinko parlors. And also in property and of of taxis, I think, but he'd made a massive amount of money during the boom in Japan. And Joji had a very weird upbringing. He was brought up in this strange house, which I went to see in Tokyo called Denenchofu. And he lived there with a maid by himself as a child for years. So he had a very, very weird upbringing. And he went to university and read politics and law.
32:16 Speaker 02 And everybody who knew him from college at the time said that he was a loner and that he never had a girlfriend. And so he was altogether a very strange character. And when the police raided the house at Den En Shofu and also two of his other properties, they found all these notebooks and about 400 videotapes, all of girls that he drugged or raped and what he was doing to them. And clearly, the police then had a massive amount of evidence. And the crucial thing was that amongst the videotapes, they found one of Carita. And they also found Carita's name in a notebook.
33:02 Speaker 02 And in the notebook, it said, "Carita Ridgeway, too much chloroform."
33:06 Speaker 01 It took them a while to kind of connect the dots there though, didn't it? In terms of Carita, the fact that she died and that she was on these tapes.
33:16 Speaker 02 Sam picked up the story and was in touch with Robert Finnegan, who was Carita's former fiance. And they both kept talking to one another and saying, "Could this man be anything to do with Carita's death?" And Robert contacted the Japanese authorities. So that brought up the name Carita Ridgeway again. And so when they found the notebooks and they found the name Carita Ridgeway, too much chloroform, they put everything together and that led them to thinking that he'd killed Carita.
33:51 Speaker 01 Next, we discuss Abara's chilling notebook and disturbing videotapes, which ultimately led police to connect him to Carita's murder.
34:04 Speaker 01 Obviously, we're focusing in on Lucy and Carita, but there were 400 tapes, potentially 400 women. What happened to them?
34:14 Speaker 02 Well, this is what really intrigues me. And, and you know, I think there's another story there because a lot of these women, they don't know. The police tried to contact those that they could trace. But there must be lots of women who, who read the story and, and they must be wondering, was it them? Or what happened? Could he have killed other people? And, and we don't know. I mean, we don't, we just don't know. And, and it, it's, it's really, really horrible idea.
34:45 Speaker 01 Not to go into too much graphic detail, but the videos all kind of followed a, a similar pattern in that he would videotape them being naked, their faces covered, his face covered, and then him sexually assaulting them, right?
35:01 Speaker 02 He used to put on a mask. And so he would sort of prance about naked with this horrible mask on. And in fact, on the tape of Carita, they wouldn't show the whole tape to her mother because obviously it would be too distressing. But she saw her daughter, like a doll, like coming round from, from the chloroform and trying to sit up and then just falling back again. And he was just dancing around her. But he, Joji himself said he couldn't do women who are conscious. And the only way he had of having sex with these women was to, to, to render them unconscious and then have sex with them.
35:42 Speaker 02 And in the notebooks, he clearly was, you know, I don't, don't know what, what did his diagnosis was, but you'd think he must have been psychotic because he was saying, you know, that he wanted, he obviously wanted revenge on women for something. And his, his ambition was to have sex with 500 women by the time he was 50.
36:04 Speaker 01 So we've got all of these tapes. They've obviously got all of this evidence of the sexual assaults and the rapes. Then they kind of link him to Carita. They're able to charge him with that. But we still don't have charges for Lucy. We don't know where Lucy is. But there were, as his name started to make the headlines, a lot of stories that started to come out about him. Can you tell us some of those? There was a particularly haunting one in early July at one of his seaside apartments involving him half naked, concrete, a dog.
36:36 Speaker 02 Oh, yes, people began to phone into the police and they began to put these stories together. At first, the caretaker reported that Joji had changed the locks without authorisation, because he was meant to tell the caretaker when he changed the locks of one of his apartments at the Zushi Marina, the Blue Sea, and he hadn't asked permission. He was also seen buying cement and a sort of hoe or shovel by somebody else. Another woman reported that she'd seen a man matching Joji's description walking down a beach with a tall, thin blonde woman. And the blonde woman didn't look very happy, they didn't look as though if they were a
37:19 Speaker 02 couple, and Lucy was walking behind him. And so all these stories put together led the police in to get more evidence against him.
37:31 Speaker 01 So how, how did they end up linking him to Lucy? Did it take finding her body, which they did eventually?
37:39 Speaker 02 They found her body eventually in the caves, which they had searched before. And then they went back when all these stories started to come in and they found Lucy's head entombed in this cave that I've been to, which is really sort of bleak place down by the sea, which is where he buried her.
37:59 Speaker 01 And he'd, he'd dismembered her, it was horrible.
38:03 Speaker 02 He'd dismembered her. They also found blonde hairs, which they matched with DNA from Jane Blackman and other members of the family, which couldn't prove conclusively that it was Lucy's, but very close. So they knew then that he'd dismembered her body, they knew that she'd been to the flat because they found a photo negative which showed Lucy by looking out to sea from the window in his apartment in Zushi Marina, not at the Blue Sea apartment. So he'd obviously taken her from the, from the Zushi Marina to the Blue Sea apartment, where he must have dismembered her. So they had all this evidence, but what they didn't have was a tape of Lucy, and we don't know what happened to the tape.
38:48 Speaker 02 He must have made a tape of Lucy, but we don't, he, he probably destroyed that because that was never found. So they couldn't get him in the trial, which took six years. But they couldn't get, they couldn't convict him of Lucy's murder.
39:06 Speaker 01 Only that he'd dismembered her.
39:09 Speaker 02 Only that he'd dismembered her. But what they could, the reason they could convict him of Carita's murder was all down to the liver biopsy. Because Robert Finnegan, her fiance, a former fiance, Carita's former fiance, remembered the liver biopsy. And the liver biopsy was found and looked at. And when it was analysed, it showed chloroform. So that proved conclusively, they'd got the tape, they'd got Carita's name. And now they've got the liver biopsy, which proved that he'd given her chloroform.
39:41 Speaker 01 It seems that he didn't mean to kill these women, that his motive is sexual assault.
39:46 Speaker 02 He didn't, in that sense, he wasn't a serial killer. But it was just so gruesome and awful was the fact that he couldn't have sex with them unless they were unconscious. So he had to find a means to render them unconscious. And it was chloroform that killed Carita, because he gave her too much.
40:04 Speaker 01 Do we know what killed Lucy? Would it have been chloroform as well?
40:07 Speaker 02 Probably. We don't know what he gave her.
40:10 Speaker 01 Because then, I guess to jump from, you know, he's sexually assaulting these people and, but then to do what he did to Lucy's body, like he is just a, ugh.
40:20 Speaker 02 Exactly, like you think, no, no, who could do that? Who could do that?
40:26 Speaker 01 We touched on the judicial system in Japan in that the trial took six years. And that's not like, here in Australia, you might wait in prison for three years and then finally go to trial, which might be a few months. But this was him in court numerous times over six, seven years. That is a. A long, drawn-out process.
40:49 Speaker 02 That is not unusual. The longest trial, I think, was 12 years for somebody. And the assumption is you're guilty, so it's just all a question of repeated, repeated questioning until you admit you're guilty. But Joji will never come out. I mean, the Japanese police have said to me, he'll, he'll never come out of prison. He got a life sentence, but, which I know in, in this country doesn't necessarily mean life at all, but they, they said he will never come out of prison. They would always find a reason to keep him there.
41:23 Speaker 01 And what, what was Joji like in court? Because he took to the stand quite a bit. He had quite a bit to say that was very damaging to the families.
41:33 Speaker 02 It was. It was all bizarre. He said that all the girls that had had sex with him willingly, that they were all on drugs. They were all, you know, drug-addled prostitutes who were just having the sex for money and that it was consenting and that he said terrible things about, about all of them.
41:52 Speaker 01 An interesting kind of fact I read in your book was that going to his trial became fashionable?
42:01 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, that, that, that's right, because it was the big story at the time. And, and, and even over here, the papers kept leaving it and picking it up again, you know, on a dull news day. It would be like, oh, well, what's happening in Japan with Joji Abara? Because they knew the trial was taking so long.
42:20 Speaker 01 But Japanese couples were like going on dates and sitting in the courtroom. Bizarre.
42:25 Speaker 02 Which is, again, very bizarre to us, isn't it? It's, it's gruesome.
42:30 Speaker 01 So in April 2007, he was given life in prison, as you've said, for Carita's death and eight charges of rape, but he was actually acquitted of Lucy's murder in that instance.
42:43 Speaker 02 He was.
42:44 Speaker 01 That must have been so shocking for Tim and the rest of the family.
42:49 Speaker 02 It was, it was, and the Ridgeways were equally upset because obviously they bonded over losing two daughters and the Ridgeways were equally upset that he wasn't. Although they were satisfied that he was found guilty of Carita's murder, that Lucy wasn't. It was a terrible thing for the family.
43:10 Speaker 01 But that was rectified the following year?
43:13 Speaker 02 It was, it was, because it's more or less, we have a phrase for it here. I'm just trying to think what the phrase is, but it's like beyond reasonable doubts that the fact they knew Lucy was in the flat, they found her hair, he dismantled the body. So the assumption was that he had somehow caused her death. He wasn't ever convicted of Lucy's murder as such, but of causing her death and disposing the body.
43:44 Speaker 01 Another thing I wanted to touch on was the payments that both of the dads actually kind of took or thought about taking, which was, it's a kind of a thing that happens in the Japanese system. Can you explain what that was?
44:01 Speaker 02 It's sort of, they feel that they've offended you. It's like your honour has been damaged by the death of a family member. And so it's quite common to pay, I mean, to us, it seems like compensation. And that was why the families didn't want to take it, particularly the mothers. But Tim explained it to me, I mean, it caused a terrible falling out in their family. But Tim explained to me that he'd had to leave his job. And he stopped work the whole time he was searching for Lucy. And he needed money as well to continue the search for Lucy. So it had cost him personally an awful lot of money. And he said he felt that if he accepted this money on behalf of his children,
44:46 Speaker 02 he could give it to the family and that it would help him to support Rupert and Sophie, Lucy's brother and sister.
44:54 Speaker 01 But that money was coming from Joji or Joji's defence team?
44:58 Speaker 02 Yes, it's a difficult one, isn't it? And Jane was terribly upset, Lucy's mother.
45:05 Speaker 01 And the courts kind of know this is happening. It's a regular part of the kind of process and it doesn't affect. The kind of outcome, is that right?
45:16 Speaker 02 That that's correct, but Sam said to me that I think when her father, I think her father did accept some money in the end. And they said they they would only do it on condition that it didn't mean, it didn't absolve Joji Bar of any guilt for Carita's death.
45:36 Speaker 01 Lucie Blackman's name was everywhere. Obviously, her family, her dad, did so much to get her story out there, the search out there. You know, her face is very familiar, but Carita, she wasn't as as familiar and many people today who might remember Lucy's story might not remember her story. Why do you think that is?
45:58 Speaker 02 I think because it just didn't receive so much publicity and and I don't really know why. I mean, other than the fact that Tim went to Australia and it got the world's press, but I don't know why. I suppose because with Lucy, it was she was missing and and that involved the press, you know, where is she, where is she, where is she? Whereas with Carita, Carita had supposedly died in hospital and and disappeared and then, you know, she she was never missing for any period. She went out on the date with Joji Bar and then she was in hospital and then she died. So I think the story just didn't get picked up.
46:41 Speaker 02 And certainly, you know, a- as I said, it just wasn't covered here at all. I didn't know until Marie Claire asked me to go out and cover the story about Carita Ridgway. And it was such a tragic, tragic story and she was such a lovely girl, you know, I I feel it it's terrible, but that she should be forgotten in this way, other than by her family.
47:03 Speaker 01 Did the depravity of what Joji did?
47:07 Speaker 01 To not just Lucy and Carita, but all of these women. Did it help to kind of clean up Japan's sex industry a bit, or at least kind of discourage women from joining certain parts of the industry?
47:20 Speaker 02 It did, it did very much so. I think that after Lucy's death, they went into Roppongi and everything was cleaned up massively. And people I know who've been there since then said it's changed totally today. And that you have to have, there's very strict rules about being a hostess. And you can't go off and not say who you're with, and they keep a track of the men that are coming into the bars. And also, I think the whole hostess culture declined after Lucy. You know, because people no longer felt that it was safe.
47:56 Speaker 01 What did you take away from deep diving into this story? Because you went to Japan, you went to these bars, you saw everything, you visited all of the houses that Joji was at. It's such a complex case and also such a different criminal system to what you're used to in the UK or what we're used to in Australia. What stays with you from doing this story?
48:17 Speaker 02 I think just how different Japanese culture is still to us, really. And that, you know, Joji was such a monster. He was such a, to a degree that we find very difficult to fathom in a way that we could understand some British murders. I think this is still so bizarre to us. The whole thing is a bizarre story.
48:43 Speaker 01 I did watch a Netflix documentary about Lucy's story in particular. And the Japanese investigators, this is a story that's really stayed with them as well. And they've visited Lucy's family, I'm not sure about Carita's, but it has been something that has had a really big effect on not just the families, but also the police and everyone else that worked on it.
49:06 Speaker 02 Oh, very much so. And what really touched me when I went out to the beach where they found Lucy's body was this jar, it's a Nescafe jar or something, an empty coffee jar. And every day, Japanese people put fresh flowers there. And I believe that's still the case. I have a friend Barbara, who still lives in Tokyo, and she says it's still the case today, that Japanese people feel that Tokyo and Japan should have been somewhere safe, that people, families could send their daughters to. And they feel it very deeply.
49:49 Speaker 01 Thanks to Claire for helping us to tell this story. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast, hosted and produced by me, Gemma Bath, and Tali Blackman, with audio design by Jacob Brown. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous 53 Years Ago Robyn & Her Classmates Were Kidnapped. This Is Her Story. Next A Message From Gemma! Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated