Pod Insights True Crime Conversations How ‘Cocaine Cassie’ Really Survived Three Years In A Colombian Prison About this episode After she was caught trying to smuggle 5.8kg of cocaine out of Colombia in 2017, the media nicknamed her ‘Cocaine Cassie’. But Cassie Sainsbury’s life in a tough Colombian prison was so much more complicated. And interesting.
In this episode, she speaks to Mia Freedman about prison life: the abuse, the relationships, the sex. And what happened afterwards.
You can hear the second half of Mia's conversation with Cassie here. https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/no-filter/cassie-sainsbury-part-two/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=nofilter
THE END BITS:
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=nofilter
Feedback? We’re listening! Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
Need more lols, info, and inspo in your ears? Find more Mamamia podcasts here https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/.
CREDITS:
Host: Mia Freedman. You can find Mia onInstagram here https://www.instagram.com/miafreedman/?hl=en and get hernewsletter here. https://miafreedman.substack.com/
Executive Producer: Kimberley Braddish https://www.instagram.com/kimbraddish/
Audio Producer: Madeline Joannou
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present, and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on. Hey, I'm Gemma Bath, host of True Crime Conversations. And did you know that the team at Mamma Mia is bringing you over 100 hours of the best content from your award-winning podcasts for the hot pod summer of your dreams? Well, we are. Here at True Crime Conversations, we've handpicked some of the most chilling and thought-provoking episodes from our feed, including gripping cult stories, powerful interviews with crime victims, and in-depth accounts from women who have been incarcerated, sharing the journeys that led them to that place. And that's just the beginning. Today, I'm bringing you the story of Cassie Sainsbury from No Filter, another amazing podcast on the Mamma Mia network hosted by Mia Freedman.
0:49 Speaker 01 In this episode, Mia chats with Cassie, who for years was branded by the media as Cocaine Cassie. Here, she talks about prison life, the abuse, the relationships, the sex, and what happened afterwards. Here's the original episode. Take a listen.
1:14 Speaker 02 From Mamma Mia, I'm Mia Freedman, and you're listening to No Filter. My favourite interviews to do on this show are when I go in thinking that I know someone, I've got a sense of them by what I've seen or what I've read, and then after the interview, I come away with a totally different idea. That's the kind of interview you're going to hear today. The name Cassie Sainsbury probably doesn't mean anything to you, but if I said Cocaine Cassie, instantly, I bet you'd have an image and an idea in your head. Here are the facts, in case you've forgotten them, because I kind of had. Cassie Sainsbury was caught with almost six kilograms of cocaine in a Colombian airport in 2017. It was concealed inside 18 headphone boxes. And the media went nuts.
1:59 Speaker 02 They were so excited about this story.
2:02 Speaker 03 You knew you were being asked to deliver cocaine. Finally, you've admitted it.
2:07 Speaker 04 I knew what was in it. I feared for my life.
2:11 Speaker 03 A massive organised crime enterprise, isn't it?
2:13 Speaker 04 It's huge.
2:14 Speaker 02 Because the last time a pretty young, white Australian woman was caught smuggling drugs, her name was Chappelle Corby. It was back in 2004 and she spent 10 years in a Bali jail and was responsible for countless interviews and stories and a huge amount of media coverage and public interest. She'd been released 10 years later, just three years before Cassie was caught with drugs. So the narrative was written instantly. Silly young girl, serves her right. Why on earth did she think she could get away with it? Cassie pleaded guilty. She was sentenced to six years in a notoriously rough women's prison in Colombia and the conditions were pretty shocking. This interview is about
2:56 Speaker 02 what happened to Cassie in jail and what happened afterwards. She went into prison engaged to a man, that relationship ended, and she got engaged to a woman. She was stabbed, beaten and threatened. She spoke not a word of Spanish. She made enemies and friends and she fell in and out of love. She was terrified and defiant and determined and incredibly smart. Her resilience was next level. And three years later, she was released into a completely different life, which she has embraced. Put your expectations and your preconceptions aside and enjoy this conversation with Cassie Sainsbury.
3:39 Speaker 02 Cassie, do you remember, I'm sure you do, your first night in prison?
3:44 Speaker 04 I do remember that. That was a horrendous night. I think it was actually quite daunting going into prison to start off with and obviously already knowing that I was looking at a 30 year sentence. And I looked in there and I'm looking at the people and I'm thinking, why do they look so comfortable? Like you would see women who looked like they were having the time of their lives. And then I'd see like women walking around with babies. And I was like, what is going on here? And obviously later I found out that there are women who are pregnant in prison actually give birth there. And the baby will stay with them until they're probably three or four years old.
4:27 Speaker 02 Oh, wow.
4:28 Speaker 04 Which is, it'd be hard on a child to grow up in those circumstances. Considering they're basically paying a sentence with their mum without even realising it.
4:39 Speaker 02 When you were arrested at the airport, how long were you at the airport for?
4:43 Speaker 04 I was arrested and immediately I was taken from the airport in Dora to an anti narcotics centre, which is basically off of the airport, which I stayed there for forty eight hours, which in that time I was given my accusation hearing. And then from there, I was taken to a men's retention centre.
5:10 Speaker 02 Oh, my goodness.
5:11 Speaker 04 If I thought, you know, it wasn't scary enough, that was, no words, no words. It was just quite daunting being there and being the only woman.
5:24 Speaker 02 Were you safe there? Like, how many men were around?
5:26 Speaker 04 There were at least a hundred men. There were moments that it was quite questionable whether I was actually safe to be there or not, considering, I didn't speak the language yet, in this area, because it's basically underground, this retention centre. Police don't care, they actually help the other people that are there get drugs, smokes, marijuana. And so they were all smoking and I have quite severe asthma. And I just had an asthma attack and the police were basically saying that they wouldn't help me unless I paid for help.
5:59 Speaker 02 In the movies and on TV, when someone's arrested, they're allowed one phone call.
6:06 Speaker 02 When you were arrested and you're at the airport, I assume they took your phone away. Were you allowed to contact anyone?
6:13 Speaker 04 I was quite lucky that one of the police officers who were looking after me, I think he kind of had a bit of a soft spot for me. And he actually let me use his phone and his Facebook to get in contact with my mum. And obviously at that time, my nana actually replied saying, you know, what a sick joke you're playing on us. Why would you say that you're not in Colombia? And I'm thinking, are you kidding me? Why would it occur to someone to even make up a joke about something like that? But basically, when I did ask to have a phone call, I was told no. When I was arrested, I was told that I'd have a lawyer and a translator come and help me through.
6:55 Speaker 04 I guess the first lot of paperwork never showed up either. I was even told that I had to sign a bunch of paperwork that I had no idea what it said. And then basically, yeah, then I was just shipped off wherever I was sent.
7:10 Speaker 02 Where did your family think that you were?
7:12 Speaker 04 My sister knew I was in Colombia, but at that time I did not have a relationship with my mum or my dad really. I was quite out on my own. I've always had my differences with my mum.
7:26 Speaker 02 Did your sister or any of your friends know what you were doing in Colombia?
7:30 Speaker 04 No, no, no one knew.
7:33 Speaker 02 So there was a lot of gaps to fill in, I imagine, once you started to talk to people.
7:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. So I remember when I spoke to my sister and my mum and, you know, they were like, what happened? And I just said, you know, there was a heap of drugs found in headphones. And this is where I'm intuited that I had bought headphones as wedding gifts and that, you know, the drug was inside of them. But the thing is, I never said I'd bought them as wedding gifts. I don't know if maybe they were trying to put some pieces together. And when my mum and sister actually came to see me in jail for the first time, they basically said, look, we know there's lots of things you're not telling us.
8:23 Speaker 04 When you're ready, you can tell us. We're not going to force you. It's obviously something that has a lot more detail to it than anybody's capable of understanding in these moments. It was nice to feel that they were giving me that trust to obviously open up when I was ready and I had processed everything. But in the meantime, everyone else was kind of starting to form their own versions of what happened. And I had no way of, I guess, coming out and saying, well, no, that is, that's wrong. Because the only times I had a chance to even speak out, it was never on my terms.
9:02 Speaker 04 It was always edited. It was always, I guess, tried to make it sound more interesting.
9:09 Speaker 02 When did you become aware of the nickname Cocaine Cassie?
9:13 Speaker 04 I don't know when I became aware of it. I think it might have been when my mum told me that's what they were saying. Because at the start, it wasn't Cocaine Cassie. I think people were still quite unsure of, I guess, how things had gone down and maybe reserving that judgment until they were like, yeah, naturally guilty. But when she did tell me, I obviously, I didn't like the name, but it just went hand in hand with what had happened. Like even till today, I don't like the name. And obviously, it's such a defining name that if you hear it, you go, oh, yeah, she had something to do with drugs. At the end of the day, I've kind of just accepted the name without letting it affect me anymore.
9:57 Speaker 04 Working through the ropes and the process, I guess, to try and change that perception that I have. It's not easy, but I mean, even if it's one person out of a hundred that I managed to show the real me, it's just worth it because I'm not a bad person and, you know, I did make a really bad mistake. But I'm trying to, I guess, show people that one mistake doesn't define you.
10:26 Speaker 02 It's funny, I've watched interviews with you before in like over the years and. When you've been asked about that, about the cocaine Cassie thing, you've had different reactions at different times. Like you've been irritated, you've been angry, you've been mortified. And now there's like a lightness about you. It's like you've kind of accepted it and you're laughing at it because it doesn't sting like it used to. Is that why?
10:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think so. When, I think probably the first year and a half, well, probably, yeah, year and a half of my journey through all this, I was so angry, so angry.
11:09 Speaker 02 With who?
11:10 Speaker 04 With myself, with the other people that were involved, I guess, as well with the justice system. Like, I was just angry at everyone and anyone. And I had lots of differences with my mum, with my boyfriend, with my lawyer. So, and I was just constantly angry. In any of the first interviews or when I was on camera, and I just looked there in the face. It was because I was so angry.
11:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:40 Speaker 04 And I remember walking into my first hearing, and when I saw that it was full of media, I was like, why? Why? Why would you even try and get the media involved? Like, why? That was the only thing that was going through my head. And a lot of the deals that were taking place, I was kind of just thrown in the deep end. Like, there was no benefit out of it for me. It was purely, well, you've got to do this interview and um, it doesn't matter the circumstances, just, just do it.
12:11 Speaker 02 But who was doing those deals?
12:13 Speaker 04 My mum was pretty much behind a lot of those deals.
12:17 Speaker 02 Okay. Ah, so that's when people come out of the woodwork and suddenly start seeing the opportunity. Did you know, I mean, obviously you're old enough to have lived through the Chappelle Corby story.
12:30 Speaker 04 I can't actually remember when it all happened, but obviously I had heard little bits and pieces about it. Because I've never been much into watching news or anything. I don't know why. It's just never been something that I've enjoyed. Obviously, after being arrested, that's all I would hear is a comparison between her and myself. And I think obviously in that moment, you feel what that other person would have felt in those moments too, because whether you know, you did it or you didn't do it, you've got the whole world that's coming down on you. You're physically finishing in a sentence that you have no human rights, you have nothing.
13:11 Speaker 04 And then when you get out, you've got a whole another journey waiting for you.
13:16 Speaker 02 Um.
13:16 Speaker 04 Where the society is very unforgiving. It's very difficult, I think, as someone who has done time to find their feet, because we become so accustomed to a routine and to, I guess, a treatment that we receive, that you kind of don't want to be around anyone.
13:38 Speaker 02 Um.
13:39 Speaker 04 And you don't want anyone coming close to you, you don't want to talk to anyone because you can't talk to anyone in jail, because you don't know what would be used against you.
13:48 Speaker 02 So back to your, when you arrived there, what are the conditions like in the jail you were sent to? And is that where you spent your whole sentence?
13:59 Speaker 04 So I was moved around quite a bit. I think I had a personal living tour of the jail, what have anyone. I was taken to Yard One when I arrived, which is basically back then was where all the newcomers would go and then they would be sorted into different yards, determined through the crime that they committed. So you could say it's organised, it used to be organised, better said. Basically, they would try and keep foreigners and not so much life-threatening people together. And then obviously you've got your people that were quite dangerous and then consumers,
14:42 Speaker 04 minor offences, they did try and split it up, I guess. But they also judged on the appearance of yourself. So if you were quite, I guess.
14:55 Speaker 04 Rude, aggressive, didn't go well with authority, you were already going to a bad yard. And I guess at the time, that organisation was good. It wasn't always like that. So from yard one, I was sent to yard five, which is supposedly the safest yard in the jail, which was actually where I had most of my run ins with people, which is also where the photos were leaked from.
15:29 Speaker 02 What photos were leaked?
15:31 Speaker 04 It would have been in May two thousand and seventeen. A photo was leaked where I was next to two girls and I was smiling. I think it is showing how gullible I really, really was because one of the girls, her name was Julie, she came to look for me and she's like, no, we know you got, you don't have much clothing at the moment, so we wanna give you some so you have something to chade in. And at that time I was like, do I really smell that bad or? So I went up, she lived on the fourth floor. And when I went in, there was another girl there and they pulled out this bag of clothes. And they're like, you should try that on, see what you like, take it. And when I turned around, they had a phone.
16:14 Speaker 04 And in my head, I was like, oh, we have phones in jail now. Like, I hadn't seen one yet. And they're just like, oh, it's her birthday, can we get a photo with you? I thought, oh, that's weird, but all right. Sat down, took a photo with them. Next minute, it's all over the media that I was having the time of my life in jail.
16:37 Speaker 04 It was on the weekend, so on the weekends, there's visitors that come in and out. And while the visitors were lining up outside, the media had actually convinced some of the families to get photos and they would pay for the photos. Actually, this was obviously quiet when it was all very fresh still. And they were actually paying guards to try and get footage of me inside. And one of the guards got caught and was fired on the spot. So the Australian media did a good job on that one.
17:11 Speaker 02 Were there other foreigners there when you were put into Yard One?
17:14 Speaker 04 There were actually, a lot from Mexico, Italy, Germany. But there weren't many English speaking people.
17:24 Speaker 02 Who did you gravitate towards? Because is the instinct, I've got to find some people, I've got to make some alliances?
17:31 Speaker 04 I was always quite lucky that I was always drawn to like a mother figure. So when I got to Yard Five, the lady that I happened to be living with in the cell, she took me on straight away and she was like, you know, she gave me a hove of, I guess, personal products, Yoda and so, because you don't get given any of this stuff. And when I was moved to a different yard, also another lady kind of took me on as a mother figure. And she was trying to, I guess, show me the ways of not trusting people.
18:06 Speaker 02 Hmm.
18:07 Speaker 04 Because it didn't matter what yard I was in, something would always happen. So in Yard Seven, where it was maximum security, which I was moved to after I had obviously been threatened, the photos were released. Someone stole money from me. In the cell, we were actually in isolation. So each person was basically in solitary in this yard. And they would say, you can pay to either get a radio in, if you want, you can get a TV in purely so you don't go insane. I thought, oh, I don't know how to do that because I haven't got anyone in Colombia to actually go and buy these things.
18:51 Speaker 04 And there happened to be one lady who spoke English. She used to live in Spain, she was from Venezuela. And she's like, oh, I've got someone who can help you outside. You just need to transfer this to this account. And who fell in the trap? This person did. So I think it wasn't a lot, but it was obviously just that instinct of, I can't trust anyone.
19:16 Speaker 02 I was gonna ask what you learned about trust.
19:19 Speaker 04 Oh, it's actually really funny because I should probably be the person who does not trust in absolutely anyone else, true, that's happened to me. But if anything, it's actually taught me to analyse the person really well. Because I might be talking to my wife and I'll be like, oh yeah, this person, nah, I don't think so, this person's gonna do this. And without fail, I'm always right. So it taught me not so much not to trust people, but just to analyse them really well. I mean, in prison, people just look out for themselves. And it took me a long time to get that through my head.
20:03 Speaker 04 Because I, having been surrounded by people, I guess, that were well off.
20:09 Speaker 02 So when you say people who are well off, do you mean there were other prisoners who were well off?
20:14 Speaker 04 Yes. If you have money and you're in that jail, you can have whatever you want.
20:21 Speaker 02 Like what?
20:21 Speaker 04 So I remember there's one girl, I did not get along with her at all, purely because of the way she would treat people. She's very rich. And she actually paid to get transferred to this, yeah, the high security yard. Because she wanted to live on her own. She wanted to have all the fines she could get. She wanted to enter in clothing, enter in food, everything. And the guards would basically obey her.
20:51 Speaker 04 So she would pay the guards and they would enter in whatever she wanted.
20:56 Speaker 02 What was she in jail for?
20:57 Speaker 04 She was in jail because her ex-husband wanted a divorce. And so she then killed her ex-husband, then killed her sister-in-law, killed the lawyer and the judge.
21:09 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
21:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, she's um, an interesting person. And we had a lot of differences.
21:15 Speaker 02 But Cassie, how do you have differences with someone who's killed lots of people? That doesn't seem sensible.
21:25 Speaker 04 I think it is because she thought she was better than everyone. And I think going into a place like this, you have to forget about social status. You have to forget about everything. You are exactly the same as everyone. Because it doesn't matter what you've done, you've done something illegal and you're there for a reason. So I got alone with quite a few people and, you know, I would actually train them. We'd do lunges, squats. It was good distraction for me. So I would actually train a couple of girls. And her name was Sophie. And Sophie's come up to me and she goes, I'll pay you triple what they're paying you if you train me.
22:07 Speaker 04 And I've kind of looked at Hannah and gone, I don't need your money. Because I'm not asking for money from anyone to train them. And I said, that's what you do when you wanna actually hang out with people and be a decent person. And from there, it was just an instant clash. Because she thought if she had money and she threw money at someone, that they would basically bow at her feet. And I wouldn't do it. So from there, we just had lots of differences from there. And she actually managed to get me removed from the yard. She paid to get me removed.
22:44 Speaker 02 When you say differences, did she try to kill you?
22:47 Speaker 04 No, no, no, she didn't. She didn't try to kill me, but she did make it clear that she has like a seventy year sentence and an extra body on a big matter, so.
22:56 Speaker 02 Hmm. Wow. In terms of violence and the women that you were with, was there a hierarchy in terms of what women thought about the crimes of their fellow inmates? Like, was there a particularly heinous crime? Or was it just like, it doesn't matter if you're in here for robbery, drug smuggling or murder? Everyone has a blank slate when they get to prison.
23:21 Speaker 04 Um, okay. So the only crime that was kind of really separated was any kind of child-related crime. They couldn't even be close to any other inmates purely because a lot of the women that are in there actually have kids. And so they would look at these people and think, well, you know, I've got kids. What if you would have done that to my child? So they were actually quite often in danger of being close to any other inmates. Other than that, there wasn't any other particular crime that separated anyone. So you'd have your extortionists, you'd have your kidnappers, you'd have your money launderers,
24:06 Speaker 04 John traffickers, murderers, robbery.
24:10 Speaker 02 Did you hang out with the drug traffickers? Was it like high school? I mean, I shouldn't laugh. It's not funny, but.
24:16 Speaker 04 No, I think obviously the stories would go through and I, and I did speak to quite a few bigger drug traffickers who, you know, had been arrested with tons of cocaine and they got four years. So it was quite interesting to hear their stories. And it shows such the imbalance in the justice system over there. Because there might have been someone who had stolen two phones and they got 20 years. So there is no actual guide or scale to go through. So it's, I think you could say it's fair. But I didn't really hang out with anyone in particular.
25:00 Speaker 04 It was kind of based on the person, not what they had done. It's kind of, you get to know the person without judging them. Because if I'm there too, I don't have a right to judge anyone.
25:14 Speaker 02 How long were you in prison before you received your sentence? And what was that day like?
25:21 Speaker 04 I got sentenced on the first of November in two thousand and seventeen. I'd been there for six months. And obviously, in that six months, I'd kind of been forced to learn Spanish because I didn't trust my lawyer. So I would literally sit down with a book that's called, um, Ecolope Mal, which is like your judge's law book. And I would go through the laws and I would learn where my case actually fit into the justice system. And I would actually argue with my lawyer.
25:55 Speaker 02 Hang on a second, you arrived in jail and in Colombia, not speaking any Spanish. You had to teach yourself not just Spanish, but also legal Spanish within six months. How did you do that?
26:09 Speaker 04 Determination. No one was going to do it for me. I guess I wanted to take away that barrier that was really separating me from having communication and understanding every step of the way of what was happening. Because I didn't understand guards, I didn't understand the medical centre, I didn't understand anything. And then obviously, in my first hearing, the translator that had actually been picked for my case, he wasn't translating properly. And for me, I was like, oh no, here we go.
26:45 Speaker 02 How did you know he wasn't translating properly if you didn't speak the language yet?
26:49 Speaker 04 I had a translator who was with me, a lady who had actually come from Australia to translate. And she was horrified at the translation service that the prosecutor's office had to give it.
27:02 Speaker 02 So Cassie, how do you actually learn a language? I mean, it's not like you have access to the Duolingo app or anything in prison.
27:09 Speaker 04 It goes back to like really old school with a language dictionary. And basically I would pick word for word. So in a sentence, let's say I wanted to say I'm hungry. I had to figure out I'm and I'm is such a common use. So I'd be like, okay, it's doy. And then hungry is hungry. So it was like a process of elimination of once I learned a word, I would just remove it from the words that I needed to learn. And it took me to actually properly speak it and understand word for word. It probably took me about eight, nine months. And even now, like I think back at it and I don't remember the switch.
27:53 Speaker 04 And I remember that day where suddenly I could be thinking in Spanish and actually speaking English or vice versa.
28:01 Speaker 02 Hmm.
28:01 Speaker 04 Cause now I, I think in both languages.
28:05 Speaker 02 Hmm.
28:06 Speaker 04 Like I'm not lost it at all and it's quite interesting actually.
28:11 Speaker 02 One of the things that freaks me out the most about being in prison is the boredom. Did learning a language and having a goal provide something to do and some distraction and a purpose?
28:23 Speaker 04 I think learning the language was my stepping stone to be an English teacher. Because I wanted to teach my inmates English because in Colombia, not many people actually speak English. And if you do speak it, there's a whole world of opportunity. Like it lifts you up in the social scale, in the working scale, everything. So I really wanted to, I guess, try and help them find.
28:54 Speaker 04 A new path when they left using the English that they had learned. So they didn't feel like this time in between had been kind of lost or they'd leave thinking, oh, what am I gonna do now? So my purpose, I guess you could say, actually became helping people inside jail. So I would teach them English. I would actually help them write their legal letters. It was really funny, actually, the foreigner helping them do legal letters. Like, that's how well I'd actually managed to learn the language. I couldn't just speak it, I could read it and I could write it. So the amount of people that would come looking for me just to sit down and have a chat and,
29:40 Speaker 04 you know, try and have motivation to get through another day, it was a lot. And so it felt like my time there, I had actually used it well. So not only to reflect on my own problems, on my own issues, to actually be able to invest that time and I guess help other people find a good way to deal with what happened as well. When you discount, you have to leave your yard and go to, I guess, school, which is inside the prison.
30:14 Speaker 02 What does discount mean?
30:16 Speaker 04 Uh, discount is when you work to reduce your sentence. So in that sense, if you don't discount, you can't leave your yard. You are literally there until food's cold and then that's it. So I obviously had the between eight AM to midday, I was outside for classes and then back into the yard for lunch and then back out again until about three thirty. And then I was back into the yard. So obviously that distracted me quite a lot, but it also gave me that movement through the prison if I needed to submit paperwork, if I needed to speak to the director.
31:00 Speaker 04 So that in that sense, there was obviously that with discounting, which allowed one to move more.
31:11 Speaker 02 Up next, Cassie talks about the day that she was sentenced to 72 months behind bars. She talks about how people have sex in prison and the very public marriage proposal that she really didn't want.
31:26 Speaker 02 The day that you received your sentence, what was the sentence and how did you feel about it on that day?
31:32 Speaker 04 So I received 72 months in Colombia. They always say months, they don't say years. It's more daunting for me anyway, a six-year sentence. The prosecutor had told me that he had requested in my file that doing discount jobs, I should be allowed to be released after two years on probation, which was purely just one of his tactics to get me to sign the plea deal because it didn't happen like that at all. In part of it, I was still quite annoyed that my only option had been to sign a plea deal because my lawyer did not want to go down the other road. He refused.
32:18 Speaker 02 The other road being what? Being going to trial and pleading not guilty?
32:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, he didn't want to go to trial. He didn't want to invest money in investigators. So I kind of felt like I didn't have an option there. And then at the same time, I guess I knew the time that I would have to serve. So there was kind of that, okay, mentally I know how to prepare myself and what I need to do if I want to get out on probation or whatever was available. It was really mixed feeling and I remember going back to the yard and I was crying. I never cried in front of anyone. I always cried when I was alone.
33:01 Speaker 02 Why?
33:03 Speaker 04 Because I didn't want... In particular, when, obviously, media, I didn't want them thinking that I was victimizing myself or trying to make people feel sorry for me. So I never showed emotion in front of the media. I didn't want my family seeing me in that emotional wreck either, because it was hard enough seeing, you know, a family member in those circumstances and then to see that mentally they're not coping. I couldn't do that. But then, when I got back to the yard, I was crying. I was frustrated, I was sad, and I wasn't seeing that clearness of, okay, all right, Cassie, get yourself together, you need to work out your plan now. I was
33:48 Speaker 04 in that moment of, well, six years, seventy two months, and you'd go through, and I think, like, in days, it was like three thousand or four thousand days. The lady who had kind of taken me on as a mother figure, she came in and she's like, don't cry. She's like, you know what, it's gonna be fine, you're gonna get through it. You just need to process what's happening and then just, just do it. And I was thinking, and then I went off, well, thank you for that advice, you know, that makes me feel so much better in this life, right? But I think something that really helped me push through that mental block
34:32 Speaker 04 of, well, six years, was the fact that, as bad as I felt that I had life at that moment, as bad as I felt that my situation was, there was always going to be someone who was going through something so much worse. I didn't have children, and that was something that I really focused on. I didn't have children. There were so many women there that have children outside, abandoned because no one could look after them. They would have to give up their rights as parents, put them in the foster system. That's where it came from wanting to help people, because I thought, you know, I went through some pretty crappy
35:12 Speaker 04 things, but I'm okay, you know? So it was like, if I can help them just feel good for a day or a moment, they're the little things that allow us to just move forward and take one day at a time.
35:28 Speaker 02 Hmm.
35:28 Speaker 04 Because that's all we can do there, is one day at a time.
35:32 Speaker 02 When you went into prison, you were engaged to a guy called Scott?
35:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
35:39 Speaker 02 How'd that pan out?
35:41 Speaker 04 Well, it didn't last very long, purely because I would call him, I guess, wanting to have a normal chat, right? A normal chat about life and, you know, he would pile all of all his problems outside.
35:58 Speaker 02 While you were in prison in Colombia?
36:00 Speaker 04 And so he'd be like, no, this is happening, this is happening, I need this, I'm thinking, oh my god. Like, I can't deal with with all of that. Like, I'll be here as much as I can. And then it would be, he would ring me up to complain about the problems with my mum.
36:19 Speaker 02 Do you get phone privileges? Do they listen to your phone calls?
36:23 Speaker 04 So for each yard, there is one phone that allows incoming calls. So you might be there for like three hours trying to actually get a call to be accepted. Or the other option is we can buy phone cards and with that you can call out. However, the phone cards are like three thousand peso and five thousand peso. And I would literally get from three thousand peso, I'd get like a minute phone call. And from five thousand, I'd get two and a half because the rate to call home was really expensive. And not only that, the hours, the hour difference was impossible.
37:07 Speaker 02 Hmm. And how long did you stay together before it ended?
37:12 Speaker 04 I think we were together until January in two thousand and eighteen. But before then, it had already finished, I guess you could say. Like, there was no real communication anymore. It almost felt like he he would call me because he felt like he had to type thing. Not because he wanted to. And I think he, for me, was just like a comfort zone type thing more than anything because even before coming to Colombia, you know, being engaged, I never actually wanted to marry him. So it was quite a transformation time, all in the middle there, really.
37:52 Speaker 02 Tell me about love and sex in prison.
37:55 Speaker 04 Okay, so in prison, once a month, there are what they call conjugal visits. Basically, a sex visit, which is throughout the normal time that they do visits on the weekend. You have to have a registered partner to come in and see you. If you do have a partner inside the prison, you can also request to go to where they live or they go to you. Apparently, sexual health is very important in prison.
38:24 Speaker 02 Wow, where do these conjugal visits happen?
38:26 Speaker 04 In the cells.
38:28 Speaker 02 Hmm.
38:29 Speaker 04 So if you share a cell with one to five people, basically, you would have to take turns of who would have the visit. So I was actually quite lucky. I never, I never had one. Even having, I guess, I had girlfriends inside, but I never felt that I wanted to, I guess, to say. I never felt that connection to actually want to commit to having a conjugal visit.
38:59 Speaker 02 What did it mean to have a girlfriend inside? Was that a really common thing?
39:03 Speaker 04 It was very common. You would actually see people who have their husbands who live outside and then they have their girlfriends. But it was quite common, I guess, because more than the sexual side. I think it was just that having someone to confide in, to share times there, make it a little bit easier. And ideally, it would always start because they're your friend and then it kind of just goes from there.
39:29 Speaker 02 Had you been with women before?
39:31 Speaker 04 Uh, yes. When I was younger, I actually knew that I liked women, but I was too scared to come out. And I had been so convinced that after having, I guess, whether it be kissing a girl or having, you know, a relationship with a girl, something would always go bad in my life. And so I started kind of convincing myself that I was having such a hard time in life because I wasn't normal.
40:01 Speaker 02 Wow.
40:02 Speaker 04 And so that's where, you know, I started forcing myself to have boyfriends and try and be normal. And then it was horrible. Like, I can tell you right now, I hated having sex with a man. I hated it. And it was just purely having boyfriends for an image. Because, I mean, you can speak to any of my exes and I wasn't sexually active with them. It was more so that having them there, you know, sharing a meal, going out to the movies. And so for me, it was always more on that side of just a friend, really.
40:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, right. So in some ways, being in prison and having no other options, was it a bit freeing?
40:51 Speaker 04 So when I arrived to prison and I saw how free and unjudgmental everything was, it was, I still fought it. Don't get me wrong, I fought it for quite some time because I was like, no, I can't be the new girl who suddenly is a lesbian who will be picked on. So I kept it to myself for at least another year or so before I kind of just let it out. And I think this was also part of my reflection process of finally allowing me to be me.
41:25 Speaker 02 Hmm.
41:25 Speaker 04 And the thing is, I already had the worst reputation. So I thought, you know what? What could be worse? You know, I can't get any more on the bottom. And I guess coming out and being around people who actually supported that, it really helped boost that self-esteem of, okay, I can do this.
41:44 Speaker 02 Hmm.
41:44 Speaker 04 You know? So it was really enlightening. Felt like a huge weight had been lifted off my shoulders.
41:51 Speaker 02 In prison, the prison you were in, was there a lot of casual sex or it was more relationships?
41:58 Speaker 04 I think it was more relationships than casual sex.
42:01 Speaker 02 And I can't imagine there's much privacy in jail.
42:04 Speaker 04 No.
42:05 Speaker 02 Where do you hook up?
42:06 Speaker 04 They would do it in the cells, like they, no worries about that. And there would be people, let's say it wasn't a sex visit and two people were going at it in a cell. They would actually pay someone to keep watch to make sure no guard was coming.
42:21 Speaker 02 So would the guards just turn a blind eye? Or if there was no one being paid, they'd tell you to stop it?
42:28 Speaker 04 So if you get caught, you would actually be separated and sent to different yards. And it'd also be something they called an infodri, which is like a behavioural record. So you'd now have bad behaviour.
42:42 Speaker 02 Right, so it wasn't as easy as some might imagine.
42:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, no, it wasn't.
42:47 Speaker 02 Some planning was required.
42:48 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
43:00 Speaker 02 You got engaged in prison and for reasons that I can't explain, I've seen the video.
43:07 Speaker 02 Someone took a video of it and it was leaked or sold, I should say, no doubt to the media. Tell me about Joely.
43:17 Speaker 04 So this was an interesting one. We were friends, you know, it went from friends to casual kissing. And then I guess relying on that friendship until one day we'd actually come back in from the exercising that we're allowed to do. And she was being really weird and then she's like, you can't come out of the cell. Okay. And then when I did come out, there was this huge poster. We married, I think, oh. Everyone in the yard had literally come to watch this. I can't think of anything worse than a public proposal. I had not actually considered marrying this girl. And now I've been put on the spot of wee Larry.
44:03 Speaker 02 How long had you been together?
44:05 Speaker 04 I think we would have been together maybe like four, five months.
44:08 Speaker 02 Right.
44:09 Speaker 04 And so I've come out and she did this whole speech and I kind of just looked at her and I looked at everyone and I go, yeah.
44:19 Speaker 04 Because I didn't know what to do. And I thought, you know what, if I have to leave here, okay, leave this area, no one will, and I know.
44:29 Speaker 04 And then when we, when we went and told you, right, I said, you know, I don't want to marry you. Like, right now, we are in such an enclosed environment, we don't know what will happen when we go outside. The relationship will be completely different. And she's like, no, it's fine. You know, just looking at the promise ring. She knew that I wasn't going to marry her, but I guess kind of went along with the idea of it.
44:55 Speaker 02 Hmm.
44:56 Speaker 04 Which was an error in this time, that I guess I didn't realise that I was falling into that. Because we were not good for each other at all. She's a very toxic person.
45:08 Speaker 02 Hmm.
45:09 Speaker 04 Being with a woman, you expect to receive the same treatment that you would give them. Not the whole, I'm better than you, you need to do what I say type thing. So at the start, she was a really, really nice person. And then probably when she thought she had control of me, completely changed.
45:30 Speaker 02 You were released from prison early. When did you find out that your sentence had been reduced and you were getting out?
45:38 Speaker 04 So I had a meeting with my judge, it would have been in December two thousand and nineteen. And I actually wasn't going to talk to her. We didn't get along very well. Her son had had an overdose on drugs and unfortunately passed away. So she was quite hard, she wasn't any type of case that involved drugs. And the first time I'd ever met with her, she's like, you know what, don't bother coming to see me, it's six years. That's it. So why would I bother going and talking to her again? Just to be let down. So when I got in, saw her this day, it was the end of the day. And someone is like, why don't you just go and talk to her? You know, she's in a good mood. I thought, yeah, what's a good mood gonna be with this lady?
46:22 Speaker 04 So I thought, all right, gone in then, sat down and she goes. Hi.
46:30 Speaker 04 Hi. She goes, do you speak Spanish yet? Yes. That's how long I had not seen her. I had not lost any false hope in going to see her and waiting for an answer that I knew I wasn't going to get. And she goes, what have you been doing? And I'm pretty much just told her, you know, that I've been teaching. And she brought up my file and she's looking, she goes, oh, you've got a fair amount of discount. And I thought, yeah, I think I had maybe like eight or nine months that I'd managed to work up over two and a half years. And she goes, you know what, Cassandra, because they don't say Cassie over there, it's all full name. So why don't you just send me your paperwork? And I've gone, oh.
47:15 Speaker 04 And I'm thinking in my head, I'm doing the maths, I'm going, I don't have time yet to do that. So I thought, okay, thank you. And I left. And I didn't send my paperwork in. Why? Because I knew by law that I had to have three fifths of my sentence to be considered for parole. And I didn't have that yet. And I did not want to be let down by sending it and then her going, oh, no, sorry, can't do it yet. So I thought, okay, I'm gonna be smart. I'm just gonna wait the extra time and I'll send it in when I do have time. So it was in February.
47:55 Speaker 04 In February, I managed to sort out everything that I needed to legally ask for parole. Send it in and then I didn't hear anything at all, nothing. And the prison was always making up excuses for not sending paperwork that the judge needs. So they have to send through your behavioural report, the discount report. And there would always be, we don't have any paper, we don't have any print ink, uh, the internet's down. Like getting out of that place, they make it impossible.
48:31 Speaker 04 So when obviously the judge actually subpoenaed my documents, cause they realised that it was taking way too long. And then I think it was in March, towards the end of March, and I just started calling every day. Calling judges' offices every day. I thought, you know what, I'm just gonna be a pain in the arse now. So I'd call them and the assistant be like, no, nothing yet, nothing yet. And then it so happened, the last weekend in March, I hadn't called in a few days. I don't know why. I hadn't called and I woke up on the Monday and I thought, you know what, I'm just gonna go and call. So I'm called out of the office and the assistant already knew my voice and he was like, hi Cassandra.
49:14 Speaker 04 And I'm like, I'm just checking to see if, if anything's been approved. And then he goes, yeah, it's been approved. Like, and I'm going, what? And like, it took me like time to process that. And he goes, it's been approved. And I said, no. I'm like, don't keep about these things. He said, why would I joke about this? It's my job. And I'm like, well, I didn't mean it like that. I'm just trying to process it. He's like, yeah. You need to organise your bond caution, which was about, I think, two thousand dollars. And then you need to send the receipt to the judge's office and then they will issue the freedom slip.
49:53 Speaker 02 Freedom slip.
49:55 Speaker 04 Yeah. And I didn't tell anyone. Didn't tell anyone. And I went back to my cell and I just sat there.
50:01 Speaker 02 Oh.
50:01 Speaker 04 And I was kind of picking the people that I was telling. So I've gone down to the lady who had received me the first time in that yard. And I've gone, you know what, I've just been told that my parole's been granted. And she started to cry. You're leaving me, you're gonna leave me alone, you're gonna forget about me. And I'm thinking, no, it's not the case. I'm like, if anything, I can probably help you more on the outside than the inside. And then obviously a bit by people started to put it together. Because people were coming to visit me and they'd be like, oh, can you leave me this Chloe B? Because the idea, obviously, I didn't really wanna take anything that had been inside there.
50:42 Speaker 02 Hmm.
50:42 Speaker 04 Of kind of leaving anything. I guess with that kind of energy there. And then time went by and I had a friend on the outside now and I'm arguing with her every day because I'm thinking, why it's taking so long? And the poor thing, like she was trying to do.
51:01 Speaker 02 A friend that you'd made in prison who is now released.
51:04 Speaker 04 Crystal, yeah.
51:05 Speaker 02 And when you'd spoken to the guy on the phone, had he given you any indication of timeframe?
51:10 Speaker 04 No. And the thing is, we were in Colombia at that point, we were actually about to go into quarantine for Covid. So I had days to get this organised or I would not have been released.
51:25 Speaker 02 Oh wow.
51:26 Speaker 04 Crystal running a mark outside, she went and did the deposit for the caution, took it to the judge's office. And then nothing happened either. And so I started pressuring the, the guards from the inside as well. And I said, you know what? It's come up on the system online now that it says that my freedom slip has been issued. And there's a law in Colombia that says, once it's been issued, they can't keep you for more than 24 hours. Because then it comes kidnapping.
51:55 Speaker 02 Hmm.
51:57 Speaker 04 So it's, it's nice to know these sorts of laws once you.
51:59 Speaker 02 Yeah.
52:00 Speaker 04 So the guards are saying, no, nothing's come through yet. And then one guard who I got along with really well, she hated me when I arrived, but by the end, she absolutely loved me. And I said, look, it comes up in the system that it was sent. It was Friday now. She was, look, I'm going to have a look, but I can't promise you anything. So she went out there and probably within like two hours, would have been about midday on Friday, on the 3rd of April. And she goes, look, here's what he means to time, which is basically compromising that I would not leave the country, that I had to report to immigration once a month. I thought, oh, okay. She's like, I'm gonna do this.
52:44 Speaker 04 Like now I have to do an ENSA poll check. She said, that might take a while. Okay. So, but if everything goes well, you should be released today. She's like, you should be released before six P M. And so I'm excited. I'm running out Crystal. I'm like, I'm getting out today. You need to come and pick me up. And so this poor girl, she's, she's calling. She was waiting outside the prison for hours. And I didn't hear anything back from the guard, nothing. We did the head count and we all know that once they've done the head count, that's it. Nobody leaves, nobody comes in. And so I, I don't think I'm getting out.
53:25 Speaker 04 And literally it was such a down feeling because that Saturday we were starting quarantine. And then so I've gone and actually changed into my pyjama and I've gone and used a burner foam in the toilet just to tell Crystal, you know, just go home, don't keep waiting around. And then the guards called my name. And I'm, I'm literally throwing this phone because I went, I don't need a bad behaviour for now. And I've walked up and it happened to be one of the girls who had also received me. And she goes, what are you doing? I'm like, nothing. She goes, you've got a guilty look on your face. She's like, you don't know how to lie. And I've gone, no, no, no, nothing. And she had a piece of paper in her hand.
54:10 Speaker 04 And she goes, you ready? And I'm like, for what? Like at this point, I was so convinced that I wasn't getting out. And she goes, it's time to go. And I'm literally going, fuck. No. And I was like, I have a brush to change and everyone's coming out to say goodbye to me. And then when I walked out of my passageway, the guards had actually opened up the other passageway so people could say goodbye to me as well. Which was quite overwhelming because I had probably been one of the most hated people when I arrived. So everyone was hugging me and then I got sent to medical to get checked over that I was in the same condition that I arrived.
54:54 Speaker 04 And then I was out. And when I was coming back from medical, you actually have the pass all the yards. And it was really overwhelming because the guards were actually allowing people to come out of each yard to say goodbye to me. I'm on the other side.
55:13 Speaker 04 And it was quite overwhelming because I I didn't think that I'd made so much of a difference that people would actually, I guess, feel that kind of emotion with me. So they were saying goodbye to me, thanking me, and then I walked, I walked out. And the guard stopped me and she goes, if you only saw the person that we will see you as.
55:40 Speaker 04 I thought, oof.
55:41 Speaker 02 Oh.
55:43 Speaker 04 And so I walked out the front and it was really weird now, walking through the prison, I didn't feel like prisoner. And so I walked out the front, I I was officially signed out of their books. And I walked right up to the blue gate and I just stood there. And, you know, all the guards coming to say goodbye to me as well. And the lady who was waiting the door, she goes, you ready? I said, no, so I'm not ready. So I don't know what waits for me on the other side. I was terrified, so scared.
56:17 Speaker 02 What were you scared of?
56:19 Speaker 04 Life. I didn't know how to pick myself up and keep going.
56:26 Speaker 04 So I walked through the door and Crystal was still there and she was in her own little world. She was actually hitting on an army guy, to be precise. And when he turned around, realized that I've come out, she's, you know, screaming, she ran over to me. And, you know, I stood there. And it was so surreal, like, it wasn't hitting me that I had just left prison and I wouldn't be going back in there.
56:54 Speaker 04 And then, obviously, we got in a taxi and going through, like, everyone was already in quarantine. So it was a ghost town. So it didn't really give me that feeling of, oh, I'm back in society. It was kind of like, oh, all right, I'm out of prison, I'm going here, lock myself forever now because of quarantine.
57:17 Speaker 02 I just loved that conversation and I wanted to keep going. So we spoke more about her life after her time in prison. Coming out was daunting, she says, but it was much harder even than she could have imagined. Here's a little taste.
57:33 Speaker 04 I felt like every time I tried to take a step forward in the right direction, I would just get knocked back or I'd hit a brick wall because I couldn't work because I had no papers. I couldn't receive money from my family because I had no papers. I couldn't do anything. And then obviously the constant fear of when I had to go out and do food shopping, that if I got stopped by a police officer, well, I was going back to prison.
57:58 Speaker 02 Because of her parole conditions, she wasn't allowed to come back to Australia. And also because it was COVID, she couldn't even leave the house. But she wasn't going to let her mistakes define her. And what's really interesting about this next phase of her life is how she just shrugged off the shame. It's such a great conversation. To listen to part two of my conversation with Cassie, just click the link in the show notes. The executive producer of No Filter is Kimberly Bradish with sound production by Madeline Juano. I'm Mia Freedman and thank you for having me in your ears.
58:35 Speaker 01 If you're looking for something else to listen to, like and follow all of our Mama Mia podcasts, which are currently bringing you Hot Pod Summer. 100 hours of summer listens from spicy conversations to incredible stories, fashion, beauty and more.
Previous Why Women Kill And The Lives They Live Behind Bars [fresh episode] Next According To A Criminologist, Keli Lane Shouldn’t Be In Prison. Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated