Pod Insights True Crime Conversations Extra: Meeting The Terrorist Who Killed My Son About this episode James Foley’s death was unimaginable. He was a journalist held hostage by ISIS for two years in Syria and killed in 2014 as a threat to America. Footage of him wearing an orange jumpsuit, and forcibly reading a message before being beheaded was posted to Twitter. The media coverage of the event had the second most recognition in recent American history after 9/11. That was 10 years ago now.
His mother Diane Foley’s determination to understand her son’s fate led her to meeting with one of the men responsible.
This episode is about the profound impact of James’ life, he saw light in everything and everyone. His mother has been through the complexities of grace and empathy in the face of an unthinkable loss.
American Mother by Colum McCan with Diane Foley is available here. https://www.booktopia.com.au/american-mother-colum-mccann/book/9781526663474.html
Watch the documentary Jim: The James Foley Story on Amazon Prime https://www.primevideo.com/dp/amzn1.dv.gti.90e84963-3166-41f6-ba43-e9d58c60da83?autoplay=0&ref_=atv_cf_strg_wb or Apple TV. https://tv.apple.com/au/movie/jim-the-james-foley-story/umc.cmc.6y2racfaur1liv8ynudxtsidw?action=play
You can donate to the James Foley Legacy Foundation here. https://jamesfoleyfoundation.org/
THE END BITS:
Listen to more No Filter interviews here https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/no-filter/
Discovermore Mamamia podcasts here https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/.
Feedback: [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
Tell us what you really think so we can give you more of what you really want. Fill out this survey https://survey.alchemer.com/s3/7711442/Mamamia-Audience-Survey-March-April-2024 and you’ll go in the running to win one of five $100 gift vouchers.
CREDITS:
Host: Mia Freedman
You can find Mia onInstagram here https://www.instagram.com/miafreedman/?hl=en and get hernewsletter here. https://miafreedman.substack.com/
Producers: Gia Moylan & Kimberley Braddish
Audio Producer: Leah Porges
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present, and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on. Hi, True Crime Conversations listeners, it's your host Gemma here and I'm jumping back in your ears today to share an important episode with you. It's From No Filter, which is another interview podcast we have on the Mamma Mia network. It's hosted by Mia Freedman. And this year marks 10 years since the heartbreaking death of James Foley, the American journalist who was taken hostage and killed by ISIS in 2014. In this episode, his mother Diane Foley talks about meeting with one of the people responsible for her son's murder. What unfolds is an incredibly moving conversation about James's life and the grace and empathy
0:48 Speaker 01 Diane has shown despite such an unimaginable loss. It's really powerful, it's thought provoking, and I think it'll stay with you long after you listen. Let us know what you think of the episode and I'll see you next week for another True Crime Conversation.
1:12 Speaker 01 I'm Mia Freedman and from Mamma Mia, you're listening to No Filter. If I said the name James Foley, a distant bell might ring in your head. And if I showed you a picture of James, you might recognise his face. Big smile, handsome, dark hair, tanned skin. Looks a little bit like a movie star in a way. But it wouldn't be until I showed you a photo of James wearing an orange jumpsuit, kneeling in the desert with a black hooded man standing behind him, that it will click. James Foley is that guy. He's the American journalist who was taken hostage in Syria by ISIS, held for two years in shocking conditions and then beheaded in a public execution that was videoed and
1:55 Speaker 01 shared with the world as a message from terrorists, as a threat.
1:59 Speaker 02 Something like 94% of Americans were aware of Jim's death and how he died. It's the event with the second most recognition in recent American history after 9/11. He would have been horrified by that. I mean, he was there to talk about the Syrian people and this is the takeaway.
2:20 Speaker 03 How James Foley died is what made him famous. And it is difficult to untangle it from how he lived, which is what we're going to do today. He was the eldest of five kids who grew up in a close family. His dad was a doctor, his mum was a nurse, and three of his siblings served in the military. But that wasn't for James. He wanted to be a journalist and not the desk kind of journalist, sitting behind a computer. He wanted to work on the ground in war zones.
2:47 Speaker 04 I believe that frontline journalism is important. Without these photos and videos and first-hand experience, you can't really tell the world how bad it might be.
3:00 Speaker 03 James's mother, Diane, who has written a memoir called American Mother, and is my guest today. Diane knew a thing or two about having children in dangerous situations, the military, but she had no idea how big the risks were for James until he was kidnapped in Libya in 2011. And he spent 44 days as a hostage before he was released.
3:22 Speaker 05 After successful diplomatic negotiations, two American journalists and a Spanish journalists are finally going home after being kidnapped and detained by the Libyan government forces for 44 days.
3:32 Speaker 03 Because unbelievably, when ISIS captured him the year after, it was the second time he'd been held hostage. He'd only been home for seven months when he went back into a war zone.
3:43 Speaker 04 There's physical courage, right? For some reason, I have physical courage. But really, think about it, that's nothing compared to moral courage.
3:53 Speaker 03 At the end of 2021, over seven years after millions of people watched her son being executed, Diane got the opportunity to go and meet with one of his killers, who had just been convicted. And she said yes. So why on earth did she want to do that? What do you say to one of your son's murderers? And what did he say over the 10 hours that they spent together over a couple of days in the American jail where he was being held? This is a story about a mother's love for her son and how it continues to sustain her, how she found a way to heal herself after she lost her boy, and how sitting down with his killer helped her to do that. Here's Diane Foley.
4:41 Speaker 03 Jim must have been a great kid because you had four more after him. He was a great kid. He was a lot of fun. And I...
4:49 Speaker 06 I enjoyed being a mother. He really was. He was a good boy.
4:53 Speaker 03 How old were you when you had him?
4:55 Speaker 06 I had Jim when I was young. I was 25. So I had energy for him. So that was good.
5:01 Speaker 03 You talk about him having an amazing imagination.
5:05 Speaker 06 He loved books from the time he was very tiny, loved to be read to. And once he could read himself, he was reading, often reading and pretending to be people we read about often.
5:19 Speaker 03 Firstborns are often quite cautious and very responsible. Was Jim very adventurous as a kid? Because he certainly was as an adult.
5:31 Speaker 06 He was very adventuresome. He was definitely not cautious. He was very curious about the world, about people. I would not call him cautious at all. I mean, you know, as he got older, he was aware, he wasn't reckless. I mean, he was well aware of the dangers in the conflict zone and took all the required safety courses and equipment and all that was necessary. But no, he was not cautious as a child. He was full on wanted to know about the world.
6:02 Speaker 03 When you have five kids, I've got three, and I've always wondered how, when you've got that many children, you maintain relationships with each of them, particularly when they're small and there's just so much need for attention, for meals and arrangements. How did sort of the dynamic of the children and you and your husband, John, all play out?
6:29 Speaker 06 Our first two were only two years apart, so that they were busy. But the others were three and four years apart. So that was part of the way we tried to give as much attention as possible to each child. It's always not perfect, you know, as parents, we just do our best. But Jim was a very easy older brother because he really was very protective about the others and was generally pretty easygoing as a child and very independent. So they were not needy kids, if you will.
7:04 Speaker 03 One of the hardest things I find as a parent is the tension between wanting to support what they want to do and their passions. And their dreams and also worrying about them and also having them not around when perhaps you'd like to see more of them. When he first talked about becoming a conflict journalist and travelling to war zones, how did you manage that tension? What did you say?
7:34 Speaker 06 At the time, three of his younger siblings were in the military. We had one in the army, one in the air force, one in the navy. So I was quite concerned about them and ignorant in many ways about the high risk of particularly being a freelance conflict journalism. And it took Jim a while to find journalism. He was initially a teacher, then a writer, eventually found journalism. And once he found it, he was so passionate about it that, you know, we were delighted he'd found something he really loved.
8:10 Speaker 03 When he told you he was going to Libya, did you know much about Libya and what was happening over there?
8:16 Speaker 06 Again, like I say, I think as a consumer of the news, I think I was quite ignorant about the dangers in the Middle East, to be honest. I really didn't know and Jim didn't emphasise that. But he did make a point of taking, as I said, the safety courses and doing all he felt he could to be as safe as possible. But I was not as aware as I could have and should have as a parent.
8:45 Speaker 03 What did it actually involve, his work in Libya? Like when you're a conflict journalist, what do you do every day?
8:53 Speaker 06 Well, first you get into the country. I mean, that is not that easy in some of these areas. But then you look for reporting on the ground. What is going on on the ground? And that's exactly what they would do. Every day they would go out to the front line. They would interview civilians, soldiers, people who were living what was going on in the country and looking for important stories that he felt. People in the West would want to hear and want to know. So kind of a hectic when they were in country, I think. Because they had to be thinking about their safety, safety of people they were interviewing.
9:36 Speaker 06 While at the same time, looking for good stories and wanting to tell them. So rather stressful when in country, particularly in conflict zones.
9:45 Speaker 03 One of the things that really came through with what I learned about Jim from your book and from watching the documentary about him that was made by Brian, his childhood friend, is how he created families wherever he was. Which made me think about, he was essentially recreating what you had and your husband had created in the bond of of your family and your kids. So when he was in Libya, he had this like family of other freelance journalists and other journalists that he was close to essentially. And on the day that they were captured and when one of them was tragically killed, he was taken hostage along with a few friends.
10:27 Speaker 06 Yes.
10:27 Speaker 03 How did you learn that he was taken?
10:30 Speaker 06 We heard from Human Rights Watch, called us directly, looked us up on Facebook and reached out to us out of the blue. And then the second person probably was one of his outlets he was working for. And then eventually US consul called us. So we received several calls, but the first one was from a stranger who worked for Human Rights Watch.
10:56 Speaker 03 Now, you're just an ordinary family. Your son is taken hostage in Libya. He was held for forty four days. How did those forty four days play out?
11:05 Speaker 06 Well, any parent who's ever lost their child, heaven forbid they be kidnapped or something like that, knows it's just, it's a horrific experience because you are powerless. You have no idea how to help your child. And so we were down on our knees praying most of the time. It was Jim's second oldest, next older brother, Michael, who took a leave from work and did Did all he could to try to connect with people in Washington. And then a lot of his friends did all the rest. You say created families. Jim was just friendly. And so he was always welcomed into any family. That was his, one of his gifts. He was
11:50 Speaker 06 a very good listener and interested in people. So when he was taken, his friends were incredibly upset. So they did a website and got on social media and had several campaigns for his return.
12:06 Speaker 03 Were you asked for a ransom that time?
12:08 Speaker 06 No, no, we were not. As a matter of fact, the government did not reach out to us at all. I don't know, Jim was considered a political prisoner. I mean, it was in the middle of war. I'm not sure if they knew what they wanted to do with all their prisoners, to be honest. And he came out really thanks to the connection of another stranger, David Bradley, who at that time owned Atlantic Media. Jim was with Claire Gillis, who was one of his freelancers. So David and his team, along with Jim's friends from Teach for America, did research until they found someone who had connections into Gaddafi government.
12:52 Speaker 06 And it was through those good people that Jim was eventually freed. When I heard he was freed, we were at home. His brother went to meet him in Libya.
13:05 Speaker 03 How long was he home for?
13:06 Speaker 06 He was home for a good six months, I would say. He did a gratitude tour to see a lot of his friends. So many people he felt he needed to thank. Did quite a bit of speaking on that tour.
13:21 Speaker 07 Young soldiers sort of spread out across the sand who approached me and struck me, you know, with the butt of their AK-47, half dozen times. Punched me, I didn't feel hardly anything. Such was my shock at seeing my colleague Anton morally wounded in the sand, knowing on the level right away that he was dead. And I had a lot of time when I got back to the States. I had a month to play over those moments, especially that one day when we were captured. What I would have done, what I could have done, what I should have done, and really examining those things and being able to talk about it openly.
13:58 Speaker 06 And then went to work in Boston as an editor for Global Post. Soon, by the fall, he was working with Human Rights Watch, doing some journalism for them, and then eventually went back into the field.
14:14 Speaker 03 You must have been thrilled when he had a desk job for that brief time.
14:18 Speaker 06 Well, we were. I mean, the whole thing was a miracle that he returned. It was amazing.
14:24 Speaker 03 Diane, how did he tell you he was going back? And how did you react?
14:28 Speaker 06 Well, none of us were very happy. He had been in and out, though. He chose to go back briefly in the fall of 2011, but full-time in the beginning of 2012. And that time, he headed into Syria. And he went back and forth, in and out of Syria several times that year before his kidnapping in November of 2012.
14:55 Speaker 03 He did some extraordinary things during that time. He spent quite a lot of time at a hospital, reporting there. And when they had the need for an ambulance, he helped raise money to buy an ambulance.
15:09 Speaker 02 I would say the flip side of his willingness to get out there and do things is that, like, okay, so you get an ambulance into Syria, some militia is going to commandeer it and use it for their own purposes. They're going to put an anti-aircraft in the back of it, like, go blow shit up. Jim was not focused on that kind of issue. Like, he would think about, you know, what's the best-case scenario, not how things could go wrong.
15:36 Speaker 03 He was always very mindful of the plight of civilians where he was working. When he was taken the second time, it was very different, wasn't it?
15:47 Speaker 06 Yes.
15:47 Speaker 03 How was it different?
15:49 Speaker 06 Well, the second time, it was only witnessed by his fixer. And his fixer didn't know who the captors were.
15:58 Speaker 03 Can you explain what a fixer is?
16:00 Speaker 06 A fixer is a person who translates and drives for foreign reporter who comes in. Like Jim was not fluent in Arabic, so they had to find someone who knew the country, knew the language, who could get them where they needed to go. So their fixer was a good friend. He was very kind and wanted to help. But at that time, there was a huge influx of foreign fighters coming into northern Syria. He didn't know who they were. It's kind of come as a surprise to a lot of us, this, this group ISIS, a group that we hadn't really heard much about. Who exactly are they? Well, it's a criminal marauding gang. They come out of the original, very brutal Iraqi terror group.
16:47 Speaker 06 They're the worst, they're the worst of the worst.
16:50 Speaker 06 Washington doesn't know how to deal with it. How's his family in New England gonna figure that out, right? And so that was part of the problem. We didn't know who had taken him. We didn't know if it was the Assad regime or one of these foreign fighters.
17:05 Speaker 03 What were the circumstances of his kidnapping that time? He was with John Cantley, the British journalist, was he?
17:13 Speaker 06 Yes, yes. And that was one of the differences. Previously, Jim had been more under the radar. He worked very quietly under the radar. But I think he missed some male companionship, to be honest, and got friendly with John Cantley, which was great in many ways, but I think probably put them at more risk because John was fairer and had a very clear Western accent, whereas Jim was much quieter. I think, at least I'm told, when they stopped at some restaurant on their way out of town, you know, they were noticed, apparently.
17:55 Speaker 03 And again, how did you find out? Through the fixer?
17:58 Speaker 06 No, we actually found out through one of his colleagues. Nicole Tong and Claire Gillis were both in Turkey and they were planning to meet Jim that afternoon. And so they called us the day after the we celebrate Thanksgiving Day in the United States. It was rather odd that we didn't hear from Jim because he always called on holidays. But we did not hear from him. So that morning Claire and Nicole called us to say he had been kidnapped.
18:29 Speaker 03 When you didn't hear from him, Diane, did you have that spidey sense of unease?
18:33 Speaker 06 I did. It was just a deafening silence not to hear from Jim because he always called. And of course, when they called, it confirmed our fears.
18:43 Speaker 03 I imagine there is a huge amount of adrenaline, but nowhere for it to go in terms of Jim's family and how you felt, like knowing he'd been taken. Like, what do you do? Do you call 911? Do you call the White House? Like, what do you actually do?
19:01 Speaker 06 Well, that was the problem. I mean, I'm a nurse, my husband's a doctor. We had no idea what to do. And we were shocked that it happened a second time. I mean, really shocked. And of course, we went to pray right away. That was my first reaction. It was more and more frightening, the fact that nobody knew where he was. He had disappeared. He truly disappeared. And the other, in Libya, we knew where he had been taken. It was still a miraculous that we were able to get him out. But in this case, we had no idea even if he was alive. We had no idea. He had disappeared.
19:41 Speaker 03 When did his captors first make contact?
19:44 Speaker 06 We first heard that he was alive in September of 2013. And he was taken in the previous November. It was a good 10 months not knowing if he was alive or not. The first email came to me.
20:01 Speaker 05 Hello, we have James and want to negotiate for him. He is safe. He's our friend and we do not want to hurt him. If you want cooperation, we have rules. You cannot go to the media ever about this. If you do, we will not negotiate. We want money fast.
20:20 Speaker 03 What people hearing this story might expect is that you had a huge amount of government support and official support. Because there's a lot of admin involved in being the loved one of a of a missing person in terms of trying to find information, isn't there? And you you felt like you had to finance your own trips to Washington. You had to try and make people understand about Jim's story and and get his name out there and get some action. That must have been a very heavy burden to bear along with with everything else.
20:55 Speaker 06 Well, I had to quit my job and do it full time, but I failed. I mean, there was no one in our government in 2012 through 2014 to help. No one whose job it was to help an innocent American family, even find out where Jim was, never mind get him out. It was a horrible time. But what was even worse was that our government kind of falsely assured me that they were on it. And that was difficult because I spent a lot of the year just trusting that our government was telling me the truth, that they were in fact on it and, you know, working on getting Jim home,
21:40 Speaker 06 when that wasn't true. I think the people felt uncomfortable and didn't know what to do with me, to be honest.
21:47 Speaker 03 You know, I know you have deep faith, Diane. Did you have a sense as his mother, like, were you like, is he alive? Is he not alive? Can I feel him?
21:58 Speaker 06 Yeah, I really felt he was alive during that time. I never felt that we had lost him. I really never felt that way. So I just had a feeling that he was alive, but we had no idea where and who had him. And I struggled to get any interest in his plight. I struggled with the media. I struggled with the government. And I was really quite ignorant about how to go about it, Mia.
22:29 Speaker 03 When the kidnappers made contact and asked for money, you were told very explicitly that not only would the US government not pay any kind of ransom, if you tried to raise money yourself, you could be prosecuted.
22:47 Speaker 06 Well, we were told that, but much later in 2014, when that initially came through, the FBI just reassured us that, don't worry, they're going to keep negotiating. Let's keep them talking. Just tell them you don't have the money, that kind of thing. So nobody said anything like that until later in 2014, when we discovered that it wasn't just Jim, that Jim was also with three other Americans and three British citizens, and also several other Europeans. So it was that spring of 2014 that a person from the National Security Council told us that,
23:32 Speaker 06 threatened us actually three times. But in a way, Mia, he was the one who was telling us the truth. He's the one that was telling me, you know, our government's not going to do anything for him. And if you try, you could go to jail. So we went ahead and raised pledges anyway. But at the time, the captors did not engage with us again. They stopped talking to us after a month. After they proved to us that they had Jim, they stopped communicating essentially, until two weeks before they murdered Jim.
24:09 Speaker 03 During the time, during that second year, not a lot is known about that first year that Jim was in captivity. In the second year, though, you have learned quite a lot because a lot of the men that he was held with, the Europeans, the British, some of them have been released. And they paint quite an extraordinary picture of a time when, I think it was up to 18 of them, were held together. What have you learnt about that time?
24:39 Speaker 06 Well, it's really thanks to many of them and Jim's dear friend, Brian Oakes, the talented director of the film, Jim, The James Foley Story, that I found out what Jim's last two years were like, really. And I was just so grateful he was with such good people. They were all brave people who were either journalists or aid workers. So they were all people who were interested in others and really cared about the suffering that was going on in Syria. So they were all very good people, very interesting people. They managed all kinds of things to try to survive. Jim was there the longest.
25:24 Speaker 06 Jim was one of the very earliest. Jim and John Cantley were the first. So they were held the longest. And the first part of their captivity, they were starved and tortured a lot.
25:37 Speaker 02 You never know what's going to happen next. And that's much more difficult to handle and to deal with than the beating. You know, at some point, we were so hungry, we ate banana pills.
25:52 Speaker 05 Orange pills were like our candies. We received a chicken once. We ate the bones. If you are starved, you think about food. But once you eat, you only think about going on the sea.
26:11 Speaker 05 Are going in the forest or any open space is the only thing you want.
26:20 Speaker 06 But later on, as others came in, I think the captors began to realise they needed to keep them alive because European nations were negotiating for the release of their people. So all those people did come out and they're the ones that have been able to share stories with me.
26:40 Speaker 03 Very much their descriptions of Jim was as the big brother of the group. He, being an American, was the target of a lot of horrific treatment by the guards and by the captors. But, you know, they did things like they played games of Risk. He managed to draw a board and they used little beans as the pieces and how they supported one another on Christmas Day. They didn't have obviously anything to give one another, so they all sat in a circle and gave one another the gift of each saying a lovely thing about everyone else in the group.
27:15 Speaker 02 And I remember that I said to James that the first time I met you was, you know, in this prison and you looked as confused as if you were just dumped down on the earth from the moon or something. And you basically destroyed my whole idea of this great war journalist, James Wright Foley. And then suddenly I find out that you are very clumsy, you're very bad at sports. And but then again, you're the most honest person. There is no evil at all to find in you, James.
27:55 Speaker 03 And there were times when they would fight and Jim would be the one who would sometimes break up physical fights. And I got a really strong sense by listening to these other men of the character of Jim, his incredible resilience, his incredible optimism, and just being a good guy.
28:16 Speaker 06 He was a good guy. And you're speaking of the film. The film gets into all that. The book, American Mother, is more about what's happened since Jim's murder.
28:29 Speaker 03 When you talk about the difference between the fact that a lot of the Europeans, there weren't people were negotiating and they were released, were you in contact with the other families?
28:40 Speaker 06 No, because I really, I mean, our FBI did not even tell us who the American families were. We didn't know that until about 2014. So the European families, we really didn't know, except when I went to France. I did go to France and to Spain, trying to see if they could help me. I did have a chance actually to meet some of the French friends of the hostages anyway, and one family member. But I didn't know, get to know them well until afterwards.
29:15 Speaker 03 After the break, Diane tells me about the day the unimaginable happened. A journalist called her and told her to look at Twitter, where she saw an image of Jim.
29:25 Speaker 06 At that time, I just hoped it was a cruel joke and had been photoshopped.
29:31 Speaker 03 We'll be back shortly.
29:38 Speaker 03 Diane, I want to ask you about the call you got. It was from a journalist, wasn't it?
29:43 Speaker 06 It was.
29:44 Speaker 03 What happened in that phone call, if it's not too painful to recount?
29:47 Speaker 06 No, it was a beautiful August day and my sister was visiting and we received this call out of the blue from this journalist who was crying. She was sobbing on the phone. And I could hardly understand what she was saying, but finally I figured out she was saying, "Look at Twitter." And then she hung up. And so I looked at Twitter and that's when we saw the horrific picture of Jim being beheaded. And I did look at the image because I wanted to make sure it was Jim.
30:26 Speaker 06 And it was. At that time, I just hoped it was a cruel joke and had been photoshopped. That was my hope. And so I reached out to everybody I knew. I wrote emails to everybody I had worked with for the past two years. But nobody answered me that day. That in itself was difficult not to hear from anybody.
30:49 Speaker 03 That morning, you'd been visited by the FBI for the first time in a long time.
30:54 Speaker 06 Exactly. But they didn't seem to know anything. I really don't think they were disingenuous. They didn't seem to know. It seemed odd to me after two years that they're asking for a DNA now. It seemed so odd, but they didn't, you know, make a deal about it.
31:12 Speaker 03 Diane, the video and the photo, I've not looked at either, but I know the image is seared in the minds of many people of Jim in the orange jumpsuit in the desert with the man behind him hooded. I don't even know what to ask you, Diane, in terms of when you talk about that and the image that you have, is it something that you compartmentalize? I know you never watched the video, but you did see the photo. Is it something that exists quite separate from your memories of Jim and your feelings about him as someone you love and your son?
31:52 Speaker 06 Of course, Mia. I mean, it's nothing I will ever dwell on. And that's partly why the work of the James Foley Foundation has been so important to me because that's been a way of keeping Jim's goodness and moral courage alive. So that is what I strive to focus on. Jim would have wanted something good to come out of his sacrifice, if you will, for his country and fellow Americans. So Jim has challenged me big time. But thanks to my faith in God and the goodness of so many people, that's what has made anything good possible. So I'm very grateful.
32:33 Speaker 03 In American Mother, you write about Jim's moral courage. Can you explain what you mean by moral courage?
32:39 Speaker 06 I write about it only because Jim was talking about it when he came home from Libya.
32:46 Speaker 07 There's physical courage, right? For some reason, I have physical courage. But really, think about it, that's nothing compared to moral courage.
32:55 Speaker 06 That we couldn't have true journalism without the moral courage to report on stories that might affect one's career or be dangerous to tell. And so I was really, and I'm still today, challenged by that to dare to have the moral courage to fight for what is right and to try to make a difference for others. But that's what I feel Jim was talking about. And so we've used that idea of inspiring moral courage in all our work. In our government work, trying to inspire the best of our government to care about fellow citizens,
33:38 Speaker 06 do the right thing, to help families, support families, actually listen and tell them the truth. And the same with our Journalist Safety Program. We work with aspiring journalists and freelancers. And we talk about having the moral courage to report the truth, to do it as safely as possible, obviously, but to aspire to have the courage to do the right thing in terms of reporting.
34:06 Speaker 03 You have some pretty extraordinary moral courage doing what you're doing, writing the book, giving interviews, speaking about your son.
34:14 Speaker 06 It keeps Jim's spirit alive, Mia, and that is very important.
34:19 Speaker 03 Is it a way to keep mothering him?
34:21 Speaker 06 Mothering him? I don't know, he's challenged me, so I almost feel like he's parenting me, challenging me to dare to do better, dare to be better, and dare to speak the truth to power, you know, when it's necessary. But also to try to inspire youngsters. I really think it's important that our children and youth are challenged to make a difference in the world. We need people who aspire to do good things, Mia.
34:53 Speaker 03 Speaking of truth to power, it took three days for then-President Obama to reach out. He had a phone call with your husband?
35:03 Speaker 06 He did.
35:04 Speaker 03 It was some time later that you were invited to the White House to meet with him? The line he kept using with your husband and then with you, as you write in the book, is Jim was our highest priority. Jim was my highest priority.
35:19 Speaker 06 Right, exactly.
35:21 Speaker 03 Was he though?
35:22 Speaker 06 Of course not. And that's why I was not particularly impressed with that comment. Because maybe in his head, he was telling himself that, but he totally failed. He tied the hands of the FBI. He chose very definitely not to negotiate. And that cost the lives of four young Americans. He did not value their lives. And that made me angry. My righteous anger, if you will, fueled the start of the Holy Foundation. And also fueled the start of a lot of good people stepping up to help me.
36:03 Speaker 06 Because a lot of people saw the tragedy in it all. And so here our great nation can't even have the backs of innocent Americans who go out to report the truth or help others who are suffering in the world. It was horrible. It was the worst. I was so embarrassed and angry as an American.
36:25 Speaker 03 You make the point so eloquently in your book that the argument made by officials to you is that if we negotiate with terrorists and we pay ransoms, that puts every American abroad at risk and makes it more likely that more people will be kidnapped. But you say that other countries do it very well. They do it quietly. They do it behind the scenes. They do it successfully to negotiate the release of their citizens. And you also point out that in terms of the actual money involved, it costs $40 million to send a drone into a country that might never come back. And so from a financial point of view, it can hardly be argued, paying ransom is out of the budget, so to speak.
37:08 Speaker 03 And you actually have made a difference, perhaps not with the negotiating with the terrorists, but in terms of some of the things that have happened, some of the things that the James Foley Foundation has made happen, what are some of those things? Because Obama, it obviously did have an impact on him. He made some announcements after meeting with you.
37:26 Speaker 06 First of all, there was no evidence that showed that paying ransom increases the captivity of others. Americans are targeted all the time. If anything, the research showed that if you do not negotiate, your citizens are going to be killed. And that's exactly what happened. The British and the US chose not to negotiate and all their citizens were killed.
37:51 Speaker 03 So why do they do that, Diane? Why do they have that policy?
37:56 Speaker 06 It was because they went by this slogan that it makes sense, I suppose, when you think about it, that it would incentivize. But the reality, that is not the reality. However, I do think more and more countries now are starting to copy some of the terrorist groups and targeting our citizens. So I do feel very strongly, the Foley Foundation strongly feels we must, as a nation, not only bring, find ways to bring our people home, but also to deter the horror and practice of people being taken and used as political pawns. It's a dual challenge.
38:41 Speaker 06 It's not only the challenge of trying to help citizens who are taken hostage abroad, but also at the same time, we must work to deter the practice. And sometimes they are in conflict. So that is the challenge we have before us. However, every nation, in my opinion, should have the moral courage to have the backs of innocent citizens who are targeted simply for being a citizen of their country.
39:11 Speaker 03 Up next, why Diane decided to meet with one of the men responsible for killing her son and what she said to him.
39:18 Speaker 06 All of us are flawed, right? We all make good decisions and bad ones. But in his case, he's made such an extraordinarily bad decision to join in ISIS and all the horrific deeds that he's lost out on his life.
39:36 Speaker 03 Stay with us.
39:42 Speaker 03 Speaking of moral courage, you chose to meet one of the men who worked to murder your son. Alexander Coty was one of the Beatles, as they were nicknamed, members of ISIS, who one was killed in a drone strike, two were brought to America and tried and charged and convicted. When did the opportunity come up to meet with him in jail? And what were the conversations in the Foley household about that?
40:13 Speaker 06 First of all, it took seven years. Alexander Coty and Al-Shafi Al-Shakeh, the two surviving Beatles, if you will, or jihadists, were kidnapped in 2018. But it took years for them to be extradited to the United States for a trial. That was thanks to a lot of hard work with the British government and our Department of Justice. When they finally did arrive, one of them, Al-Shafi Al-Shakeh, was very defiant, wanted a full trial, and he had it in 2022. But Alexander pleaded guilty to all eight counts, counts of kidnapping, torture, all
40:58 Speaker 06 of it, accessory to murder. And part of his plea deal was his offer to speak to victims. So when I heard that, I was interested in speaking to him because I knew Jim would have. Jim would not have wanted me to be afraid of him. And Jim would have wanted me to hear him out. Jim often worked with many disenfranchised youth, ex-felons in Chicago and troubled inner-city kids in Phoenix and Holyoke. So Jim kind of had, always had a heart for the underdog. He definitely would have wanted me to hear him out. But also as a mom, I kind of wanted to tell him who Jim was.
41:43 Speaker 06 But you know, the end result of the whole thing was just incredibly sad. Yeah, we all lost, you know, when hatred reigns, everybody loses. We lost our beloved Jim, a very talented journalist, and he's lost his freedom. Perhaps he'll never even see his family or his homeland again. So he too has lost. Everybody's lost. It was a very sad but good experience in many ways, odd as it seems. But there was an odd grace in those days in many ways.
42:19 Speaker 03 It sounds like you have empathy for him, or maybe if not empathy, sympathy?
42:25 Speaker 06 Yeah, I think I do. Um, he's the same age as one of our other sons. Because of his choices, he will be in jail for the rest of his life and never be free, never see his family again. I have a lot of empathy and sympathy for him. It's very sad. It's tragic. All of us are flawed, right? We all make good decisions and bad ones. But in his case, he's made such an extraordinarily bad decision to join in ISIS and all the horrific deeds that he's lost out on his life. It's very sad. I mean, I think accountability and justice is important.
43:08 Speaker 06 I don't mean to imply that it's not because it is extraordinarily important that captors and people who are so violate human rights in such horrific ways as they did, they must be held accountable. And I think it's a very just sentence for him. But it's still sad. As a mom, it's still sad.
43:31 Speaker 03 When you sat across from him in the hours that you spent with him, Was there ever a moment where you just wanted to lunge across the table and scratch his eyes out?
43:42 Speaker 06 No, not at all. No Mia, no.
43:46 Speaker 03 Is that just me Diane? I clearly don't have any grace, like the rage.
43:51 Speaker 06 I didn't have that rage towards him. To me, in many ways, Alexander is also a victim. He's a victim of poverty, of brainwashing, the jihadist hatred. In many ways, he's a victim. That doesn't excuse the horrific things he did in any way. And he certainly needs to serve his sentence, but it's sad. It was our government I was angry at because our government has the power to do a lot. And our government considered our son and the other Americans as collateral damage. So I was very angry at our government. So all my anger was
44:37 Speaker 06 fuelled towards righting that wrong and helping our country to do much better, to have the backs of brave Americans.
44:45 Speaker 03 Did Alexander say sorry to you?
44:48 Speaker 06 He expressed much remorse, many times, for what our family had gone through. He very humanly justified his actions as being a soldier in war. But he expressed a lot of remorse to me, multiple times, and in letters to me.
45:07 Speaker 03 And when you left there, how did you feel?
45:10 Speaker 06 I had more peace. I felt like I had told him who Jim was. And I feel like I had encouraged him in his faith. He's an intelligent young man. Hopefully, in his incarceration, who knows? Maybe he'll become a writer or do some good, is what I hope for him, to make amends for the horrible sadness he's inflicted on so many people.
45:37 Speaker 03 Are you still in contact with him?
45:39 Speaker 06 No, I mean, the prisons don't allow that, especially for a prisoner of his caliber, if you will. He's in isolation. Yeah, I don't know if I'll ever hear from him, but they're very strict about who the prisoners are allowed to communicate to, and when and how, all that.
45:58 Speaker 03 I just want to finish, Diane, by asking about when you experience loss and grief in such a tragic, horrific way, the public element of it, how does that impact the grief? What happened to Jim was so deeply personal to your family, and yet it was something that was so public. I mean, the fact that that image is so seared into the minds of so many people. How do you feel about that? How do you process that?
46:33 Speaker 06 Well, I think the only good thing about that was that it was horrifying to everyone, and therefore, good people stepped up. I mean, that's when we had an outpouring of donations that has helped sustain the work of the James Foley Foundation, part of the reason for the book, so that people will be aware. And if it's of interest to them, small NGOs like ours are always looking for support. Any generous people who are concerned about the national security threat that it is, and wanting to inspire moral courage in journalists.
47:17 Speaker 06 We always need the good people. We need the generous people, Mia. And so that was the only good part of it being so public, is that we were able to reach all the best people in the world. I mean, we received gifts, money from all over the world for an entire year.
47:38 Speaker 06 And in our work, we continue to look for good people who care about having the moral courage that our countries would do the right thing in the world, would care about others and would have the backs of people who are suffering by being kidnapped or wrongfully arrested abroad. So we always meet the good people, Mia, and that's the positive part of anything public is we can reach the good people also.
48:06 Speaker 03 Well, Diane, you are very much the good people. And I thank you for your moral courage in talking about Jim and continuing to talk about him and fighting for the rights of other hostages. You have created such a legacy for him and extended the legacy that he created for himself. So I just wanted to thank you for that. I really have a sense of him, you know, after reading your book and talking to you, he would be so chuffed. He would just be so chuffed.
48:38 Speaker 06 He was an incredible person, but these are the kind of people we need, Mia.
48:44 Speaker 03 We do.
48:44 Speaker 06 So I invite any of your listeners to read American Mother, to watch Jim, The James Foley Story, and to consider donating to people who are trying to make a difference in the world.
48:58 Speaker 03 Do you know there's no word in the English language for a parent who has lost a child? And there should be. I've had the privilege of interviewing several parents who've lost children during the years I've done No Filter. And it never ceases to be shocking. That order of things is just not right in the scheme of the way the universe is meant to work. It like, it cracks the universe a little bit. And for many of the parents that I've interviewed, like Diane, the loss of their child has opened their heart and put a fire under them in a way that you might not actually expect. They create foundations and they raise money and awareness. And it's almost how they keep
49:41 Speaker 03 their child's memory alive. And it's by nurturing a very different kind of relationship with them. One memory that Diane will always have are Jim's final words to her and the rest of his family. There was a hostage who spent a year with Jim, who was freed, and each time one of the prisoners that Jim was held with, there are about 18 of them, each time one of them was about to be released, some of the other prisoners would try to smuggle letters out to their family. And Jim had written this letter for his family, but the hostage that was about to be released suddenly got scared and he said, I can't smuggle it out, but what I'll do is I'll memorise it. And he did. He memorised this letter, this extraordinary
50:26 Speaker 03 letter from James to his family. And when he was released, he called them up and he recited it down the phone.
50:36 Speaker 07 Dear family and friends, I remember going to the mall with dad, a very long bike ride with mum. I remember so many great family times that take me away from this prison. Dreams of family and friends take me away and happiness fills my heart. I know you're thinking of me and praying for me and I'm so thankful. I feel you all, especially when I pray. I pray you stay strong and to believe. I really feel I can touch you even in this darkness when I pray. Eighteen of us have been held together in one cell, which has
51:21 Speaker 07 helped me. We've had each other to have endless long conversations about movies, trivia, sports. We've played games made up of scraps found in our cell. We have found ways to play checkers, chess and risk and have had tournaments of competition, spending some days preparing strategies for the next day's game or lecture. The games and teaching each other have helped the time pass. They have been a huge help. We repeat stories and laugh to break the tension. I've had weak days and strong days. We are so grateful when
52:04 Speaker 07 anyone is freed, but of course yearn for our own freedom. We try to encourage each other and share strength. We're being fed better now and daily. We have tea, occasional coffee. I've regained most of my weight lost last year. I think a lot about my brothers and my sister. I remember playing werewolf in the dark with Michael and so many other adventures. I think of chasing Maddie and tea around at the kitchen counter. It makes me happy to think of them. If there is any money left in my bank account, I want it to go to Michael and Matthew.
52:46 Speaker 07 I'm so proud of you, Michael, and thankful to you for happy childhood memories. And to you, Christie, for happy adult ones. And Big John, how I enjoyed visiting you in Kress in Germany. Thank you for welcoming me. I think a lot about Roro and try to imagine what Jack is like. Hope he has Roro's personality. And Mark, so proud of you too, bro. I think of you on the West Coast and hope you're doing some snowboarding and camping. I especially remember us going to the comedy club in Boston together and our big hug after. These special moments keep me hopeful. Katie, so very proud of you.
53:31 Speaker 07 You are the strongest and the best of us all. I think of you working so hard, helping people as a nurse. I'm glad we texted just before I was captured. I pray I can come to your wedding. Now I'm sounding like Grammy. Grammy, please take your medicine, take walks and keep dancing. I plan to take you out to Margarita's when I get home. Stay strong because I'm going to need your strength to help reclaim my life. Jim.
54:08 Speaker 03 Oh, that packs a punch. You might want to go and watch the documentary Jim, The James Foley Story. If you want to know a little bit more about what the type of person James was, he was truly remarkable. And that documentary that was made by a childhood friend of his and a documentary maker, it really paints a picture of the time that Diane didn't know about, those few years where James was held and she had no contact with him. The hostages who were freed, who were interviewed in this documentary, say that he kept them alive in there and he shared food when he didn't have to. And sometimes he broke up fights between the hostages. And he took beatings so that other hostages wouldn't have to.
54:53 Speaker 03 They said things like there was not a bad bone in his body and that he was just pure good. Diane Foley founded the James Foley Legacy Foundation. They do amazing work advocating for the freedom of all Americans that are held hostage abroad. And it also promotes the safety of journalists worldwide who are working in combat zones. If you want to read Diane's book, American Mother, we will pop a link to all of those things, including the foundation and the documentary in our show notes. This episode was produced by Gia Moylan and Kimberly Bradish, with sound production by Leah Porges and music by Tom Lyne. I'm Mia Freedman and it's been a little treat to be in your ears.
Next Did America Just Execute An Innocent Man? Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated