Pod Insights True Crime Conversations 10 Years Ago A Man With A Gun Walked Into A Lindt Cafe In Sydney About this episode On a sunny December morning in 2014, just 10 days before Christmas, breakfast was in full swing at the busy Lindt Café in Sydney’s Martin Place.
Around 8:30am, a customer noticed a man talking to the café’s manager, who seemed tense. Just over an hour later, at 9:44am, Man Haron Monis told everyone in the café that he had a bomb in his backpack and they were being held hostage. His demand? To speak with the Prime Minister on national radio.
Ten years have passed since the Sydney Siege, which tragically claimed the lives of two innocent people: café manager Tori Johnson and mother of three, Katrina Dawson. To mark the anniversary, Vikki Petratis, host of The Unthinkable podcast, revisits the events of that day and reflects on the lasting impact it has had on the city.
Listen to The Unthinkable podcast here https://casefilepresents.com/the-unthinkable/.
THE END BITS
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=tcc
CREDITS
Guest: Vikki Petratis https://www.instagram.com/vikkipetraitis/
Host: Gemma Bath https://www.linkedin.com/in/gemmabath/overlay/photo/
Producer: Tahli Blackman
Audio Producer: Jacob Round
GET IN TOUCH
Feedback? We’re listening! Email us at [email protected]
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on.
0:15 Speaker 01 It's a sunny December morning in 2014, just 10 days before Christmas. And Louisa Hope and her 72-year-old mother, Robyn, are up early for an appointment in Sydney's CBD. They're in Martin Place to see a family lawyer. And at the bottom of the building their meeting is in sits the popular Lindt Cafe.
0:34 Speaker 01 They pop inside for a coffee and a slice of toast after getting to their destination early. Just after 8:30 AM, Robyn notices a man lingering. She remarks to her daughter that he looks out of place. He's talking to the cafe's manager, who looks tense. After noting the interaction as odd, the mother and daughter continue on with their breakfast. They even order a second coffee before attempting to pay and be on their way. It's then, at 9:44 AM, that man, Haron Monis, addresses the cafe full of morning commuters. "He has a bomb in his backpack," he says, "and as of this moment, they are all his hostages."
1:20 Speaker 01 "I want to speak to the Prime Minister of Australia," he demands, "on national radio." "Just got some breaking news.
1:28 Speaker 02 There's a police operation underway in the heart of the city." "This gunman is quite well-known to police, in fact."
1:36 Speaker 03 "There are dozens and dozens of police, some of it very heavily armed, in helmets and kevlar boots. So I could see inside the Lindt building, a woman with her hand up against the glass."
1:53 Speaker 01 I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. It's been 10 years since the Sydney siege brought Australia and the world to a standstill. A man brandishing a gun, who claimed to have a bomb, holding 10 customers and eight employees of the Lindt Cafe in Martin Place hostage for 16 hours.
2:22 Speaker 01 Two innocent lives were lost during that terrifying day and night. The manager of the café, a man named Tori Johnson, was executed by Monus as tactical police swarmed in just after 2am. Barrister and mother of three Katrina Dawson was killed in the crossfire.
2:41 Speaker 01 It's a crime that's been dissected at length over the past decade, with criticism of the police handling of the event at the forefront. I have a personal connection to this story. I was a young radio journalist working the night shift at 2GB Macquarie Radio. I covered the final hours of the siege on the hour as the national newsreader for the network. I did so with a police negotiator by my side and a reporter at the scene feeding back information. It's a story and a crime I think about often, especially as we unpack in today's episode, as the media's role in the siege has come under scrutiny. Today's guest is true crime author and podcaster Vicky Petradus, who alongside her co-host
3:25 Speaker 01 Emily Webb, are revisiting the siege as we commemorate this anniversary in a series called The Unthinkable, a Case File Presents podcast hosted by Acast. They tell the story through two lenses: that of a hostage survivor and that of a TOU operative that we've only been able to name in full in recent days. Ben Basant is the TOU officer who shot Monus dead in those final moments of the siege. His name has been suppressed, an order that was made at the time to protect him, but has become a burden and a shackle over time, only further exacerbating his PTSD from the event. It was lifted by the New South Wales Supreme Court on the 29th of November 2024. Vicky joins us now to take us back to the start.
4:11 Speaker 01 Vicky, tell me about the decision to revisit this story on the 10-year anniversary and how you decided to do that.
4:20 Speaker 04 At first, the entree into this story was Ben Bassant, who's now reclaimed his name. He was the TOU operative who took down the terrorist. And he had got in touch with Case, oh, who I work for, and wanted to tell his story. We got in touch with Ben and we started to research him, read his book Tiger Tiger Tiger. And one of the YouTube clips that we looked at was Louisa Hope talking at Ben's launch. And there is something about Louisa that you're just mesmerised by her, the way that she speaks,
5:02 Speaker 04 the dignity. Oh my goodness, she's amazing. And so I said to Ben, oh, you know, could we get Louisa's number? And so he cleared that with Louisa. And just talking to her, we knew that she would be an episode on her own. And Louise is one of these people, I think, that thinks, oh, are people really interested? Hell yeah. And so we spent the most amazing day with Louisa and we were just captivated by her. And that's how we came to do both of them.
5:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, so you tell the story from two sides, really, a hostages' side and then a TOU or police officers' side of things. Where were you when this siege was unfolding? I feel like this is one of those stories or those crimes in our history where those of us who lived through it kind of know where we were. It's one of those kinds of ones.
5:53 Speaker 04 Look, it's a great question because I'm in Melbourne. And so while it came on to your radar that there's a siege in the Limp Cafe, I don't know Sydney, my best friend lives in Sydney and I know the suburb she lives in, but I don't know anything else. And so I really, I guess like most Melbournians, it comes up on the news and people start to talk about it. But it's not something where, like, I think I could tell you where I was when Melbourne things happened. But it's, it's that little bit further removed. So for me, it was just sort of watching it on the news. And then, of course, it became iconic, didn't it, when we all remember seeing
6:35 Speaker 04 the hostages taking flight. And I think all of us remember those iconic shots of them fleeing in terror and then being scooped into the arms of the Tactical Operations Unit people. So Ben and his buddies and almost like they come flying out and then they're scooped in to safety. And I think those kind of images, they don't leave you, do they?
6:59 Speaker 01 Let's tell the story a little bit because it has been 10 years for those that have forgotten the details. Man Haron Monis took the occupants of the Lindt Cafe hostage on the morning of December 15th. Can you walk us through what his demands and threats were?
7:16 Speaker 04 So he had come into the cafe, I think at around eight thirty, and had breakfast. And at the end of the breakfast, so he was there for over an hour before he made it known that he he was going to take them all hostage. And what was really fascinating, talking to Louisa, was that her mother had him pegged. And I loved in the interview where her mother's saying, Louisa, that man, he doesn't belong. What's he doing here? And Louisa goes, don't look, you know how every mum does that. Don't look, Louisa. And so Louisa's trying to get surreptitious glances at this guy, but he didn't belong. And there was something about
8:00 Speaker 04 his demeanor that Louisa's mum picked up. So I think it was like nine forty where he asks one of the waitstaff to talk to the manager. And really, it's kind of ten to ten before he stands up with the gun and says, you know, the door's locked and you're hostages. And what he wanted, I think his demands were. Odd, but I guess they meant it made sense to him. But what he wanted was to engage in dialogue with the Prime Minister. And he wanted to send out the message that, you know, Australia was under attack and Islamic State. You you know, he he was very much he a self identifying terrorist.
8:43 Speaker 04 And that he wanted to know that Sydney and Australia was under attack. And he wanted that publicised. And of course, what happened was all of the eighteen hostages were left really to do this mad scramble. I mean, how how do you call the Prime Minister? How do you do that? Call the A B C. I don't know their number. So all of the hostages were left to try and service these demands that were never ever going to be met. I think Monis wanted a on air debate with the Prime Minister. That that's never going to happen. I think the police law enforcement will never ever bend to the will of terrorists.
9:25 Speaker 04 Because if you can get the Prime Minister on air, then, I don't know, next week, we're going to have another terror attack. And they know that they can just point a gun at someone and get the Prime Minister on the line. And so I think that there's an unwillingness with law enforcement to ever bend to the will or the demands of someone like Monis.
9:43 Speaker 01 We've talked about Louisa and her mum being two of the hostages. Who else was in that cafe? It was a real mixture of people, wasn't it?
9:52 Speaker 04 Yeah, so the the Limp Cafe staff were, I think there was eight of them and ten hostages. So we had Katrina Dawson and two of her law colleagues. There were four people that worked at Westpac Bank. And there was Louisa and her mum. And then there was John O'Brien, who was the eighty two year old retired tennis player. And so you have this really eclectic, from young to old, you know, this mix of people in the cafe. And then you have the the wait staff themselves, really young people that were left to do an extraordinary job of being able to stay alive when when there was someone like Monis holding a gun at them all day.
10:37 Speaker 01 You have spent a significant amount of time with Louisa, kind of talking through her.
10:44 Speaker 01 Recollections of that time. It is ten years after the fact. How did you find her recollection of that time and her memories and what she spoke about?
10:56 Speaker 04 I think with trauma, it's like you can close your eyes and you are there. And I think that this is a really common response, that it is as real today for that kind of huge trauma as it was the day that it happened. And what I found really interesting about Louisa was that she has spent, I guess, ten years trying to piece together the whole story because she talks about knowing her bit, but found out stuff at the inquest about, oh, I didn't know that.
11:37 Speaker 04 And then I think at one point she had sort of thrown herself on the ground right before the shooting starts, but then she's standing up again and she's like, I don't understand how I went from lying down to standing up. And the other day she said to me, I think I remember that now. And so for her, it's not about a fading memory. I think it is about a building memory that you're trying to reconstruct the whole event. And I guess that's always just to make sense of it, isn't it?
12:11 Speaker 01 Can you take us inside that cafe? What was it like in there? Obviously, there was a lot of fear, but it went on for sixteen hours or so. So a lot of emotions, a lot of kind of differing opinions and emotions are going to be present during that time.
12:29 Speaker 04 Absolutely. I think that when the hostage situation first happened, there's that sense of disbelief and Louisa talks about, is this a Channel Seven prank show? Channel Seven's just across the way. Is this a... Is this a joke? And I think it became very quickly obvious that it wasn't. But Louisa talks about the fact that one minute Monis would be speaking to her in a way that's interested in her. And she has multiple sclerosis, so he was saying, you know, tell me about that. But she said equally the next minute, he could be grabbing her and pointing a gun at her head, threatening to shoot her.
13:11 Speaker 04 And so I guess that it was for the hostages. This is what they all would have seen. They would have seen calm and then explosive and demanding. But at the same time, well, well, I think the whole day, they would have just been absolutely on edge because he's got the gun. And he's saying that he's wearing a bomb and and he's threatening to kill them. And so I can only just imagine what that would have been like. And then you had some of the hostages, Marcia and Selena especially, were really trying to. And they they copped a lot of criticism for this, which is awful.
13:51 Speaker 04 But they were trying to to say, well, if you want us to put stuff on social media or, you know, we'll try and get your demands met. Because they knew that it meant their life. And I remember afterwards people criticizing that. And I thought
14:09 Speaker 04 you didn't walk a mile in their shoes. And these people were all doing the best that they could to live. And I think they all did an awesome job of trying to to navigate around the horror that they found themselves in.
14:25 Speaker 01 Because the reality was, he had a gun, but he also claimed to have a bomb or a few bombs. But Louisa speaks to you about how she was a bit wary of that information from the start.
14:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, so and it was her mum that said it, he didn't look like he was carrying a bomb. And Louise is like, how would my mum know what someone looks like carrying a bomb? But I think, you know, she she talks about, I think she was right in the fact that he wasn't being over, I spent, I guess if you had a bomb on your back, you would be, your movements would be a little bit tentative because you might blow yourself up. But he didn't seem to act and move like he had something that could explode. And I think that's what her mum ended up talking about. But I think we have to remember ten years down the track that the operatives that were preparing to go in
15:22 Speaker 04 thought they were gonna die, thought that he would explode a bomb. And so the whole siege had to be treated like he did have a bomb, even though the two other bombs that he said were around Sydney, I think Circular Quay and somewhere else, that there weren't. But he he was treated like it was a bomb. And that was, that changed everything. And this is why the police were really reluctant to go in, because then everybody dies. If he sets off a a the bomb, they all die. And so I think we forget that. And there was even comments on social media the other day after Ben uh did his beautiful spotlight interview. And just some really thoughtless comments of people who obviously didn't watch the show.
16:05 Speaker 04 Oh, the police were cowards, this, that and the other. But really, the courage that it took for them to go in, thinking that they would would not survive it and getting their partners to send pictures of their children was, uh, you know, brings a tear to the eye because they didn't think they would survive. So it wasn't about courage, it was about risk.
16:30 Speaker 01 All of that is a side of the story that we learnt, months, years, some of it a decade later. If we go back to the siege itself, I want to talk about the media's role because we live in a 24-hour news cycle. The police were on the scene very quickly, but so too were the media. The world's media was watching this siege unfold in Sydney. Louisa explained to you how damaging some of that coverage was. Can you explain what she meant by that and what the hostages were so upset about inside?
17:03 Speaker 04 So, they had access to radio interviews inside the cafe. There was a TV, but I think it was one of those display ones that just showed the ads. And they said, "No, no, we can't get TV." So, in the days, 10 years ago, you probably couldn't watch it on your phone. So, he was listening to the media coverage of it. And at one point, so around sort of three-ish, John O'Brien escaped, Stefan, one of the lawyers, and Paolo, one of the waitstaff, escaped and went racing out the building. And Monis had threatened to shoot anyone if anyone else escaped.
17:45 Speaker 04 And then two girls, Ellie and April, who were really young, and they were terrified and one of them had vomited, like it was physical manifestations of the terror that they were facing. And the two girls had sort of crawled over to near the door. And Jared Morton Hoffman had sort of nudged the lint bear, you know, the big poster of the lint bear, in front of them. And they were undoing the bolts on the door. And they raced out and Monis didn't notice. He didn't ever do a head count and he didn't notice that they were gone. And then the media starts reporting, Louisa talks specifically about this lovely woman from the BBC, this lovely English voice saying, two more hostages have escaped.
18:30 Speaker 04 And he hears it and he says, wha- what, where are, where are they? And so all of the hostages, and this is where the roles had to be, uh, no, no, no, brother, he made them call him brother, no brother, the, the media are just lying, no other hostages escaped. But she's thinking, this woman in England is talking about something that could get me killed. And so Louisa herself is a, a great fan of the freedom of the press. But in this case, she highlights the fact that information that he was listening to that he did not know could have got her killed.
19:13 Speaker 04 And she says, if it's a question of media freedom versus my life, I think we need to look at this and we need to be better at not jeopardising. I don't, I don't know what the fix is because the media, there's no way they're going to not report on that. But it just highlighted just how risky that was for the people in the cafe.
19:38 Speaker 01 To give another perspective, I was working in radio at the time at 2GB, Macquarie Radio, which is actually one of the stations Monus was listening to for updates. So I was the newsreader overnight into the 2am, into all of it. And I actually had a police negotiator next to me as I wrote my scripts, who was checking what I was putting out there. So at the time, I felt safe in that because I had, I was in my early twenties at the time, but I had a senior cop telling me, take that out, leave that in. But we were all reporting.
20:16 Speaker 01 Five hostages have left the building, thinking that that was okay. So it just goes to show that even, you know, the police negotiator that I had in my newsroom wasn't aware of what the hostages needed in that moment, perhaps.
20:30 Speaker 04 Of course, they, they wouldn't have been aware. But what you have, and I think talking to Louisa really brought this home, and then watching interviews with the others, is that this small group of people who were mostly strangers to each other are inside that cafe being left to deal with. They had no expertise in hostage negotiation. And they were left to deal with this on their own, and no one would have known. But I think in the early reporting, when Louisa said, we just said to him, oh, the media are just lying to make you look bad, brother. And I think he went, oh, fair enough. That was a palatable truth for him to accept.
21:12 Speaker 04 And so I don't think any reporting later on put them jeopardy because they had said, no, no, they're just lying. But that media, you can't trust the media, which of course played into his, I guess, paranoia.
21:24 Speaker 01 I wanna timeline the day a bit because we've, we've spoken about several hostages escaping.
21:32 Speaker 01 Monus kind of holds everyone hostage at ten. By eleven o'clock, we've got tactical police surrounding. By three thirty P M, we've got three hostages escaping, two more escape at five P M. But it's not until two A M. that everything kind of comes to a head.
21:51 Speaker 01 Can you tell us about that really next thirteen minutes? What happened to end the siege?
21:58 Speaker 04 Oh, my goodness, it's, it, it's really quite a distressing thing to hear the people that were involved. So we had Louisa on the inside and we had Ben on the outside. And we had these two perspectives. And I think where, while the police negotiators and a psychiatrist that they had advising them said that things were calming down. It was going against, you know, Tori Johnson was sending texts to his family during this time going, he's agitated, he's gonna kill someone. All the hostages that had left had said, he's agitated, he's, he's unhinged, he's gonna kill someone. And the psychiatrist.
22:45 Speaker 04 And some of the negotiators, there was actually kind of disturbing footage of them being inadvertently recorded, sort of saying, oh, no, he won't hurt anyone. He's, he's someone that will outsource that because of his background and, and uh, we'll talk more about sort of the, the criminology or the, the crime history that he brought to the cafe, but they had ignored the hostages. I think, and they said he'll settle down for the night and there was no evidence to suggest that he wasn't becoming increasingly, he would have been sleep deprived, he would have been agitated, he's not getting anywhere.
23:24 Speaker 04 Hostages are running out the door. And so what, uh, I think Monis had heard some noises out the back in the kitchen and he took Fiona and Selena and Jared out to the kitchen and he wanted the girls to stack boxes and, but they're empty boxes, so it wouldn't have blocked anyone coming through the door. But he wanted these boxes stacked in front of the door. And that was the first time that he had left the main body of the cafe. And so he, he sent Jared back out again and he said, you know, you guard the door. And Jared kind of went, we've got to run, we've, we've got to run. And so he gathered, you know, his gesturing
24:06 Speaker 04 because you can't make a noise, but he's like, come on, come on. And they just, you know, six hostages bolted for the door and were able to escape. But someone knocked a glass over on the way out and uh, he runs out and fires at them. You can see the CCTV of them fleeing and then you see the shattering of, of the shot that he's firing on them. And certainly the T O U thought that that's when they would get the call. He's, he's fired a shot. And, but they don't. And so he, Monis goes back into the cafe. And it's this time that he tells Tori Johnson to get down on his knees.
24:49 Speaker 04 He gets Louisa and her mother, Robin, who's seventy one, sort of flanking him. And he, he shoots Tory, he fires a shot first.
25:02 Speaker 04 Where it's above Tory's head and Tory falls forward. And then sort of slowly, he's incredibly distressed and he gets back onto his knees and then he's executed. And it's almost like. You wonder if Monis is saying, well, I'll fire above him. Maybe the police will come in. Maybe I can have my shootout with the police. But the police still don't come in. And then he kills Tori Johnson. So in the minutes after that, they finally get the call to go in. And it's pandemonium. You can also watch videos of the the team that's coming in through the foyer. And they're throwing flashbang devices. They're sort of bouncing off the walls.
25:46 Speaker 04 Uh interfering with their ability to enter. And then, of course, Ben and his team are at the front. They're the alpha team. And they're trying to fire through the glass door to get a broken, the broken glass, and then they get a clear shot at the terrorist. But they didn't realise that the glass was bulletproof because Lindt used to be a bank. And so it took a number of shots, like bang, bang, bang, bang, bang, before the glass finally shatters. And then Ben talks to us on the podcast about that moment where the glass shatters. And he's eye to eye with the offender. And then that he just starts shooting.
26:28 Speaker 04 But Monis is firing back. So Ben is fully expecting not only to get blown up. But he's fully expecting with this guy firing a shotgun at him just across a cafe. There's no distance. And I think he fired two shots at them and Ben just kept shooting until
26:45 Speaker 04 uh Monis went down. And of course, this all takes a couple of seconds, but uh the inquest would rake over that for many years afterwards.
26:56 Speaker 01 There was another fatality when all of that gunfire was happening, when the police finally barged through that door, and that was Katrina. She died in that.
27:06 Speaker 01 And then there were a number of hostages and also a cop that got injured as well.
27:11 Speaker 04 Katrina was lying on the floor with a... sort of under a group of stacked tables. And I guess tables are going to be no shield against bullet fragments. And this is one of the great tragedies at the loss of Katrina Dawson, who's a young mum, a lawyer, full of life and every hope for the future. But what Ben was originally told was that she died of a police bullet. And he was just sick with the thought that he could have killed her. You know, he's firing with a laser right at the target.
27:53 Speaker 04 And he's like, how could this, how could it have happened? He fires 17 shots, his colleague fires five, and they're the only shots that are fired in the direction of Katrina. And then later on that day, they are told that Katrina has died from fragments. So bullets going through the gunman, hitting their target, but then shattering. And she's been hit with shrapnel. And I said to Ben, I remember a really emotional part of the interview. I said, "Did that make any difference?" And he just looked at me and he goes, "What do you think?" And I went, "No", and he goes, "No". And so I think the heartache and the trauma and the tragedy
28:34 Speaker 04 was that he took on the blame completely for killing Katrina Dawson. And then, of course, she dies in his arms. So that, that just, you know, it's beyond belief, isn't it? The, the kind of trauma that happens when someone like Monis does what he does.
29:01 Speaker 01 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bath. I'm speaking with true crime author and co-host of the unthinkable podcast, Vicky Petras. After the break, we talk about the bravery of Tory and Katrina, the two victims who were killed that night.
29:19 Speaker 01 I want to touch a bit more on Katrina and Tory while we're here. Can you tell us a bit more about them? Tory in particular showed incredible bravery during that siege, didn't he?
29:31 Speaker 04 I think when they interviewed his lint colleagues afterwards and his family, and they talked about what an awesome person he was. But the prevailing memory for me is that he sat with Louisa's mum, Robyn, and Louisa talked about during the day, they would be sitting and holding hands. She talks about being a little bit like, what are you doing? And giggling and, and she goes, now I understand that he sat with my mum to calm her down and to keep her settled and to keep her anchored. Because at one point, when Robyn had challenged the terrorist and he had turned to Louisa and said, Louisa, keep your mother quiet.
30:16 Speaker 04 Louisa's like, if only I could, because you can't keep your mum quiet. So she felt that Tory just sat with her mum. And when the others fled and her mum said, Tory, you run. And he goes, I'm not leaving you. And so there was this understanding that, and Louisa said, you know, no greater love has a man than to lay down his life for a friend. And I think that's what he did. So such a horrible loss. And he was so scared and he was texting his family. And another tragedy, of course, is that he's texting his mum saying, I love you and I'm a hostage. And the police are saying, don't text him back. Oh.
31:00 Speaker 04 You know.
31:01 Speaker 01 And then we've got Katrina, who had three young children at home. Who was, you know, a very successful lawyer and had, you know, all these amazing friends and family and colleagues who loved her.
31:13 Speaker 04 Yeah. And that, that is such a great tragedy. And I, I, one of the interviews that I just saw recently, people were saying Katrina was using her legal skills during the day to kind of keep the terrorists calm. And I hadn't heard that before.
31:29 Speaker 01 Hmm.
31:29 Speaker 04 And then Fiona Ma talks about, she was another nineteen year old wait staff at Link. And she talks about, she was such a great comfort to everybody. Fiona was cool and calm. And she talks about that there being two types of people in the cafe, ones that would need to be kept calm and ones that would calm others.
31:52 Speaker 01 Hmm.
31:52 Speaker 04 And she described Katrina as one who kept her calm. And I've heard so many people talk about Fiona as the one that kept them calm. But I thought, oh, that's such an interesting take on the fact that that, you know, when they would go off to the toilet, because Fiona was the one that was tasked to take all of them to the toilet. And she talked about the fact that, you know, Katrina and her would have these conversations in the toilet where she felt calmer. So, yeah, such a great tragedy.
32:26 Speaker 01 We've touched on the criticism that started very, very early on. Why aren't the police going in? Why aren't they stopping him? Why aren't they helping the hostages? Can you take us outside to Ben's position? He was out the front of the Link Cafe waiting, gun in hand. What were his orders? Why weren't they going in?
32:49 Speaker 04 They weren't allowed to go in because of the bomb. And so in a hostage situation, you can go in in an emergency entry, which is what they. Emergency action, an EA, or a deliberate action. So they had planned a deliberate action and I think the army had weighed in on that. And they had rehearsed it and set up a mock link cafe. And the deliberate action plan had not been approved. And I think there felt like, according to Ben's book, there felt like a bit of a disconnect between the people in charge of the operation.
33:31 Speaker 04 And then the tactical people who are trained in this kind of operation. There felt like a disconnect in the understandings of, I think, maybe if the tactical operations unit had have been in charge, they would have done it differently. But I think there was always going to be criticism, but it was the bomb. It was the presence of the bomb that in fact we now know didn't exist. But it was the presence of the bomb that changed everything. Because the concern was that they would all die and that they would lose all the hostages. And their tactical group.
34:10 Speaker 01 At what point did the tactical group, or does Ben say the tactical group, wanted to go in?
34:15 Speaker 04 Oh, they wanted to go in straight away.
34:17 Speaker 01 Straight away.
34:18 Speaker 04 From the minute they got there, they're like, let us at him, let us at him. There was a sniper and I've seen him interviewed. Now, he might have been in, in the bank across the other way and he's wanting to take a shot. But now that we know that the glass was bulletproof, even if you had have taken a shot from the other side of the building during the day, that could have just bounced off the glass. It may not have been a successful shot and that could have precipitated. It's just so hard trying to predict the mind and actions of a madman who is on a suicide mission.
34:52 Speaker 01 Let's move on to the inquest because it was huge, to say the least. It went for many weeks and months. And all eyes were on it because there was so much criticism about how the police handled this crime. Firstly, what did the inquest uncover about Monis and his background and how the police treated his background?
35:17 Speaker 04 This is still contentious because Monis was on bail. And he was on bail for really significant crimes. So he was on bail for the stalking. Originally, he'd been charged with and found not guilty of the stalking of his ex-wife, the mother of his two little children. And within a year of him being found not guilty of that, she was murdered. And she was murdered by Amira Drutus, who of course was Monis's partner. And Amira Drutus had stabbed her eighteen times and set her on fire as she came to collect the children that Monis had, kind of on the other side of town, out of the way, creating an alibi for himself.
36:01 Speaker 04 So months after that, that was in April of 2013, and then months after, they are both charged, and Amira Drutus is charged with the murder, and Monis is charged with accessory to murder. And he spends a month in jail, and then he's bailed. And, but he was also on probation for sending disturbing letters to the families of soldiers in Afghanistan, and he'd been charged with that, and he was on probation. So then you also have, in around 2007, 2008, he had committed sexual assault on, we don't
36:45 Speaker 04 know how many clients of his fake spiritual business. And so he's on bail for the accessory to murder. And then he's charged with, I think, forty-three counts of aggravated sexual assault. And he's bailed again. This is all happening in the October, and then by December, he takes a gun, and we find him in Lent. And so I think the natural question... For everybody, it was what the hell? Like, why was this guy? Does, what does probation mean? If you can commit an accessory to murder or get charged with it?
37:26 Speaker 04 And people, the courts putting the freedom of a man like that over the safety of pretty much everyone in his space because no one is safe from him. And this became contentious later on, and I know Louisa is so angry about this. Because when he took the two women out to the kitchen, so they left for the first time that day and took the women out to the kitchen, she read something in his behaviour that she was terrified that he was going to sexually assault them. There was something that she just, and she, she basically squeezed her eyes shut and prayed, dear God, don't let him hurt those two young women.
38:09 Speaker 04 And I think that's why she missed the initial scrambling of, of the escape because she had her eyes squeezed shut praying for these two girls.
38:19 Speaker 01 Well, it was basically determined that Monis wasn't overly dangerous in this Lindt cafe situation. They didn't think he would actually kill because, one, he was an accessory. He didn't murder. And then they weren't taking into account all of these sexual assaults. That's a violent act.
38:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:40 Speaker 04 And even the violence, and you can watch footage of this, uh, has been reported where he is filming his children on the day that his wife is about to be murdered by Amira Trudis. And obviously they've planned, hey, here's a knife, here's fuel, because she, uh, put, I think it was petrol on her and set her on fire. So this is an act that they would have both planned together. And he says, I'll be over the other side of town. And the fact that he's filming his kids playing and laughing and looking at them thinking, I'm just about to murder your beloved mother. I mean, that's pretty cold. And I don't know, if you've got that in you, you've got it in you.
39:24 Speaker 04 But this constant sort of downplaying by the people that were making the decisions, oh, no, he's not dangerous. And every indicator and every escaped hostage is screaming, he's dangerous. And they just, some of them were described as, oh, well, they're just hysterical. Like, yeah, because he's dangerous.
39:48 Speaker 01 Up next, I ask Vicky what some of the biggest revelations after the Sydney siege were.
39:58 Speaker 01 There were 45 findings from the inquest, which is an insane amount. But what did the inquest find in regards to this?
40:06 Speaker 04 Look, I think the most important findings of all the people that I've interviewed were the ones that weren't found. Because the bail, the whole why he was on bail, that wasn't something that people felt in interviews was addressed. I think that everybody just wanted to, to say, if this happens again, are we prepared for it? Because that's a concern that Louisa had when she, she said, I don't, they did so many things that could have been done better. Are they prepared for it next time? So I think the criticism of the, the whole inquest
40:49 Speaker 04 that I've heard was that it didn't address publicly the things that it needed to. So of course, all the tactical stuff was not addressed openly. And I think that that was one of the main difficulties for people involved. It didn't feel closed.
41:09 Speaker 01 When you say it wasn't open, a lot of it was under suppression. So the public didn't get to hear it.
41:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So with the suppression around, tiptoeing around all of the tactical stuff, one thing that really stood out to me was when Louisa and her mum were sitting in court. And they heard that the only way that the police would go in under an emergency action is if someone was in the immediate threat of dying or if someone had been killed. And Louisa talks about her mother turning to her and saying, Louisa, they were never coming for us. And that realisation, Louisa said, she goes, I think it broke something in my mum that day.
41:56 Speaker 04 That she realised that you could be taken hostage in the heart of Sydney and the police are never going to come in until one of you dies.
42:04 Speaker 01 Has that changed since the siege though?
42:07 Speaker 04 I don't know. I really hope it has because I think that all of them were sitting there all day. Saying the police are coming, the police are coming. We know they're there, they're going to come and get us, they're going to come and rescue us. And they just didn't. And I think that's why when Jared, when it hits that sort of 2am and he has an opportunity to run, he just says run. Because I don't, I think they had lost all hope after 16 hours, that the police who were standing right outside aren't coming in. But of course, I don't think anyone understood the pressure of someone like Ben. This is why it's great to hear his story. When he says, we want, they want us to go in, we wanted to go in, we just didn't get the order.
42:48 Speaker 04 And all of them have talked about, can we just go in anyway? Why can't we just do it? But of course, they can't, they're, they're under orders. And so that whole wanting to go in, it had nothing to do with bravery, it had nothing to do with the desire to not go in. They wanted to go in and the hostages wanted them to go in, just didn't get the order.
43:09 Speaker 01 Some of the other findings from the inquest were, they did find that they should have taken action earlier. By earlier, they mean 203, not to 213. There was a basic failure from the hostage calls who were trying to get out to the negotiators. At one point because they were in a handover, so they were missing the calls from the hostages. There was a finding that the negotiators lacked experience in a domestic siege situation. It was ruled that Katrina Dawson's death was an accident, that there was no excessive force by police.
43:46 Speaker 01 We've mentioned the bail application, that was found to be inadequate. And there was a lack of a media deal that kind of compromised safety, was another finding. Which are all kind of things, tick, tick, tick, we wanted to see. Another one was that snipers were unduly restricted. But I guess you can make all of these findings. The point is, did anything change? Has anything changed since? Would this just happen again?
44:16 Speaker 04 It's the big question, isn't it? Would it happen again? I, I don't know. I don't know how prepared we can be for something like that. And it's interesting to see, for the 10th anniversary, senior police being interviewed. And they all talk about, what did we learn from this? And hopefully, of course they don't want this to happen again. I think this has affected everybody. And I, I would hope that this wouldn't happen again. But everything's, these cases are such individual cases, aren't they? We had a case in Melbourne where a man just drives down the Burke Street Mall and just runs people over.
45:00 Speaker 04 I mean, until this happens, you can never imagine it happening. And once it has, you're scrambling to say, what can we learn from it? But until the next unbelievable thing happens, we're still, I don't know.
45:16 Speaker 04 I don't know. You, you would see it in the media. You'd just go, who would have thought that thing would have happened? And then it does. And, and, you know, just learn lessons. But those lessons may or may not be applicable to the next unusual thing that happens.
45:32 Speaker 01 What have been the ramifications for both sides, for the hostages and for the people like Ben that were on the other side? What have their lives looked like in the last 10 years?
45:48 Speaker 04 I think all of them would have been changed that night and all of them would have been left to deal with the fallout. Ben's fallout was in particular the fact that I think he seems a little bit traumatised from actually shooting the terrorist because he talks about even though that was his goal was to take down somebody. But when he's looking down on somebody who he has killed, you don't do that without it making a difference to you. And certainly the death of Katrina, I don't, I, I think that's still something that if you talk to him about that, the emotion just rises to the surface as it would.
46:31 Speaker 04 And that's something that he may never be able to free himself from. He's certainly doing the, you know, all of the work to free himself of the absolute and utter torture and blame. And his ramifications will go on forever. Somebody like Louisa, I think her learning from this and her generosity is something that she will continue to develop. And she speaks of, of course, she's angry at things like the bail and of course she's angry at things that happened, but at the same time, her generosity and her ability
47:13 Speaker 04 to thrive, moving forward is just awesome to watch. And I don't think any of them, I mean, physically, she didn't remain unscathed, her mother didn't remain unscathed. Her mother took shrapnel to the shoulder and it took her hearing in one of her ears and Louisa was hit with shrapnel as well. And so along with the scars of the injuries that pretty much most of the people that were in the cafe when the police came in were injured. And. But I think they they carry so many things, like the people that escaped early. I've seen interviews with them when they talk about the guilt that they carry, that they got out early.
47:57 Speaker 04 And I loved Louisa's response when I asked her about that. She said that is not their burden to carry.
48:03 Speaker 01 You and your co-host talk about how it is a big ethical question, like do you stay or do you leave and potentially put them at risk? Like, it is a big thing to kind of grapple with. Well, not in Louisa's eyes, anyway.
48:16 Speaker 04 Well, she, her, in her eyes, she said those men escaped, they had families, they had, two of them, I think, had little children. And she said, of course, they need to do the best thing that they can do for themselves and their families. And she said, that is not their burden to carry. And I thought, what a generous way of looking at that in saying, I don't hold a grudge. And it's one that you just don't know what you do unless you're in that situation. I think the two young girls that escaped were so utterly terrified, vomit-sick terrified, that they just had to get out. And so who knows how you would react in that situation?
49:01 Speaker 01 Ben has only written his book, His Side of Things, in recent years. And reflecting on it myself, I would argue that many people's opinions of the siege would be stuck
49:16 Speaker 01 from the time that it happened, you know, in their heads, it's the criticism of the police, it's the thinking of the hostages. They're not thinking from Ben's side of things or that side of things. Do you think that's why it's so important, ten years on, to continue talking about this, to elevate the stories that we perhaps haven't heard all these years on?
49:40 Speaker 04 Oh, definitely. Like you were saying, you've covered the case and you're learning things. And I think that's the same, it would be the same for Louisa and Ben, that they're learning things from each other and they're learning things from the 10th anniversary and they might see interviews that they might go, oh, that's a piece of the puzzle that I didn't know. But I think that when you revisit them, we don't revisit them to.
50:05 Speaker 04 It's not salacious. We revisit this to tell a story of trauma and survival. And we tell the story to commemorate the ones that were lost. And I think if this can happen in the heart of the city and you don't commemorate it, where's your heart? So I always think these stories are important to tell.
50:31 Speaker 01 There have been a number of changes that have come into place since the siege unfolded in 2014. I wanted to touch on a few of them. In 2017, the New South Wales Government passed a law which allows the Commissioner to authorise lethal force in a terrorism event. Bail laws were changed so that someone must be refused if they're fighting a terrorism charge. The Australian Defence Force now have a team of combat-trained commandos stationed in Sydney in response to the criticism they didn't coordinate well on the night with local police. And New South Wales Police have overhauled a number of strategies. They've invested in more weapons and armour. Their negotiating unit looks completely different.
51:13 Speaker 01 And their terror strategies now allow them to more aggressively pursue armed defenders, even before heavily armed tactical officers arrive, which is something we saw being used earlier this year when Inspector Amy Scott fatally shot the man responsible for the Bondi Junction stabbing spree in April. Many would argue more could be done in regards to the laws, the police, and even the media's involvement in events such as this. But 10 years on, top police say it's an event in our nation's history that they do continue to learn from.
51:47 Speaker 01 Thanks to Vicky Betraydes for helping us to tell this story. The first five episodes of The Unthinkable are out now and available wherever you listen to your podcasts. Episodes are released every Sunday. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast hosted and produced by me, Gemma Bath, and Tali Blackman, with audio design by Jacob Brown. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous Amy Allwine Had No Idea A Stranger Online Was Paid To Kill Her Next The Lindt Cafe Terrorist Was Listening To Gemma Read The News Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated