Skip to content

DJ Fickey Jr.

True Crime All The Time

51m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In October 2016, twenty-eight-year-old Donald "DJ" Ficki Jr. died from a shotgun wound to the face at a trailer in Flintstone, Georgia. The sole witness and homeowner, Marshall Payne, claimed DJ committed suicide while Payne tried to intervene. Despite a text message sent by DJ moments before telling his mother he was fighting with Payne and fearing for his life, investigators initially accepted Payne's suicide narrative and closed the case. DJ's family strongly disputed the ruling, noting a history of domestic violence, a love triangle involving DJ's wife Brandy, and multiple conflicting statements from Payne. Driven by the family's relentless pursuit, including hiring private investigator Eric Echols, the case gained renewed scrutiny. Years later, the medical examiner changed the manner of death to undetermined, and a grand jury indicted Payne. In November 2025, a jury convicted Marshall Payne of malice murder and felony murder after less than an hour of deliberations, sentencing him to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

  • Families of victims can drive justice forward by hiring private investigators and keeping pressure on authorities when initial rulings seem wrong. 26:01
  • Changing inconsistent statements regarding a crime scene significantly undermine a suspect's credibility during an investigation. 29:28
  • A medical examiner can change a manner of death classification when presented with compelling angles and overlooked evidence from an initial investigation. 41:51
  • Thorough forensic testing, including gunshot residue and ballistics analysis, is crucial at a crime scene rather than prematurely accepting a single witness statement. 52:52

Chapters

  1. 0:00
  2. 2:29
    Episode Introduction and Podcast Promotion

    Hosts welcome listeners, introduce the episode and promote the podcast’s merchandise and affiliate offers.

  3. 3:42
    Setting the Stage: DJ Ficki Jr.'s Background

    Hosts outline DJ Ficki Jr.’s life, family, and the circumstances leading up to his death.

  4. 26:01
    Family’s Fight to Reopen the Case

    DJ’s family hires a private investigator, gathers evidence, and challenges the suicide ruling.

  5. 32:17
    Law Enforcement’s Handling of the Scene

    Critique of the police and medical examiner’s procedures, including missed forensic tests and inconsistent statements.

  6. 41:51
    Reevaluation and Change of Manner of Death

    The GBI revises DJ’s death from suicide to undetermined after new evidence is presented.

  7. 46:13
    Marshall Payne’s Arrest and Trial

    Payne is charged, tried, and convicted of malice murder, with the jury finding him guilty after a brief deliberation.

  8. 51:35
    Family’s Persistence and Justice Achieved

    The family’s relentless advocacy leads to the conviction, and the episode reflects on the importance of perseverance.

  9. 57:10
    Closing Reflections and Final Thoughts

    Hosts wrap up the episode, emphasizing the impact on the family and the broader lessons about investigative failures.

  10. 58:10
    Ad: ShipStation Peak Season Offer

    Hosts promote ShipStation's peak season fulfillment solution and offer a 60-day free trial with a promo code.

Highlights

  • 3:42

    Initial Suicide Ruling And Closurestory

    Donald DJ Ficki Jr. died in October 2016 from a fatal gunshot wound. Investigators initially ruled the death a suicide and closed the case, prompting years of pushback from his family.

  • 11:49

    Desperate Text Message Before Deathdata

    Minutes before the 911 call, DJ texted his mother warning her that he was fighting with Marshall Payne and stating that if she did not pick him up, he was going to die there.

  • 12:57

    Marshall Payne 911 Callstory

    Marshall Payne called 911 three times, claiming DJ took his own life and that the gun discharged as Payne attempted to intervene and grab the weapon.

  • 26:01

    Hiring Private Investigator Eric Echolsstrategy

    Convinced the suicide ruling was impossible because DJ was right-handed and shot in the left cheek, the family hired private investigator Eric Echols in 2018 to look into the case.

  • 31:19

    Failed Polygraph Examinationdata

    Marshall Payne failed a polygraph test, with results showing deceptive answers when asked if he pointed the gun at DJ or shot him.

  • 41:51

    Manner Of Death Changedinsight

    The GBI officially changed DJ's manner of death from suicide to undetermined after further evaluation and meetings with the family and private investigator.

  • 50:17

    Guilty Verdict In One Hourstory

    After a trial where prosecutors detailed drug use, a love triangle motive, and bite marks on the victim, a jury deliberated for less than an hour before convicting Marshall Payne of malice murder.

  • ShipStation 0:00–1:13
  • DraftKings Casino 1:16–2:24
  • Vinted 18:29–20:04
  • Quince 19:49–21:19
  • Progressive 21:14–22:05
  • ShipStation 57:36–58:34

About this episode

On October 3rd, 2016, 28-year-old Donald “DJ” Fickey Jr. died from a shotgun wound inside a trailer in Flintstone, Georgia. Authorities quickly ruled his death a suicide, but DJ’s family knew something wasn't right. Just minutes before his death, DJ had sent his mother a desperate text message warning that his life was in danger. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the mysterious death of DJ Fickey Jr. and one family's relentless nine-year fight for justice. Despite conflicting witness statements, suspicious evidence, and serious questions about the investigation, authorities closed the case. DJ’s sister, Amanda Shirley, refused to accept the official ruling. For years, she fought to uncover the truth, exposing troubling inconsistencies and pushing authorities to take another look. You can help support the show at patreon.com/truecrimeallthetime Visit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact, merchandise, and donation information An Emash Digital production See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript

0:00
51:20

9,053 words · 3 speakers

Topics

  • Local 3 News
  • GBI
  • WRBL
  • Fox Chattanooga
  • Walker County Sheriff's Office
  • News Channel 9
  • Flintstone, Georgia

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated