Skip to content

Special Episode: Dr. Colin Elliott & Pox Romana

This Podcast Will Kill You

54m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode features host Erin Welsh interviewing economic and social historian Dr. Colin Elliott about his book Pox Romana: The Plague That Shook the Roman World. They examine the Antonine Plague, considered the world's first pandemic, which struck the Roman Empire in the mid-second century AD. The discussion explores how Rome's prosperous trade networks, extensive roads, and dense urban populations unintentionally fueled the rapid spread of a novel pathogen, and how the disease served as both an accelerator and a consequence of the empire's structural decline.

  • The Roman Empire's vast road networks and maritime trade routes transformed from sources of strength into liabilities during a pandemic. 23:27
  • Historical climate data such as Greenland ice cores and tree rings provide crucial proxy evidence for economic and agricultural disruptions. 52:43
  • The Antonine Plague accelerated existing vulnerabilities within the Roman tribute economy rather than acting as the sole cause of its collapse. 28:50

Chapters

  1. 0:01
    Podcast Intro and Advertisements

    The episode opens with a series of promotional ads for various products and services, setting a lively tone before the main content begins.

  2. 2:47
    Host Introduction and Book Club Overview

    Erin Welsh welcomes listeners to the TPWKY Book Club series, explaining the format and highlighting resources for fans.

  3. 7:32
    Introducing Dr. Colin Elliott and Pox Romana

    Erin introduces Dr. Colin Elliott, a historian whose new book examines the Antonine Plague and its impact on Rome.

  4. 12:00
    Transmission and Spread Mechanisms

    The hosts explore how Rome’s roads, navy, and armies acted as vectors, turning a local outbreak into a pandemic.

  5. 14:17
    Symptoms and Historical Accounts

    Dr. Elliott discusses limited contemporary descriptions, Galen’s notes, and the difficulty of diagnosing the disease.

  6. 19:28
    Episode Wrap‑Up and Closing Remarks

    The episode concludes with final thoughts, acknowledgments, and a reminder to subscribe and support the podcast.

  7. 36:03
    Societal and Economic Impact

    The plague’s effects on food supply, labor, coinage, and urban life are examined, showing a weakening of imperial structures.

  8. 42:41
    Counterfactual History and Collapse

    Erin and Dr. Elliott speculate on how Rome might have fared without the plague and the broader collapse of the empire.

  9. 44:35
    Religious and Cultural Shifts

    The discussion covers increased persecution of Christians, rise of new cults, and changes in public rituals following the outbreak.

  10. 50:07
    Evidence and Research Methodology

    Dr. Elliott explains the multidisciplinary evidence—climate data, archaeology, and ancient texts—used to reconstruct the pandemic.

  11. 55:11
    Retrospective Diagnosis of the Plague

    The hosts debate whether the Antonine Plague was smallpox or another pathogen, noting modern genetic findings.

  12. 56:56
    Discussion of Antonine Plague Language

    Speakers analyze how ancient Romans used vague language to describe the Antonine Plague and its cultural impact.

Highlights

  • 8:16

    Rome at its Peakdata

    The Roman Empire in AD 161 controlled about three million square miles across three continents with a population of 50 to 60 million people.

  • 11:38

    Desecration of Apollo's Shrinestory

    Roman military forces sacked the populous Parthian city of Seleucia and destroyed a shrine of Apollo, an act which ancient writers blamed for unleashing divine wrath.

  • 16:05

    Skeptical Mortality Estimatesinsight

    The guest argues against extreme mortality estimates of 25 to 30 percent, noting that the disease primarily struck armies and urban areas rather than the entire empire.

  • 23:27

    Strengths Become Liabilitiesinsight

    The guest explains how the very trade lanes, road networks, and military movements that made Rome prosperous also acted as vectors for a novel pathogen.

  • 35:29

    Accelerating the Falldebate

    The guest argues that even without the Antonine Plague, the Roman Empire's fragile tribute economy and food supply made collapse inevitable, though the plague acted as a major accelerant.

  • 52:43

    Ice Cores and Lead Pollutionstrategy

    The guest describes using Greenland ice cores to measure atmospheric lead pollution, revealing a massive drop in silver mining output during the pandemic.

Quotes

  • “The empire stretched across a vast landscape, from Egypt to Britain.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:43
  • “The Antonine Plague spread like wildfire across the empire's vast territory and exposed the cracks beneath Rome's glittering facade.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:09
  • “These sources of strength for the Roman Empire become an incredible liability when you get a novel pathogen.”
    Unnamed speaker · 23:27
  • “The Roman silver currency, for example, diminishes in quality right after the, well, just before the end of Marcus Aurelius's reign.”
    Unnamed speaker · 43:15
  • “the language that was being used was deliberately vague. Like, at one point, Marcus Aurelius writes to the Athenians, and he just mentions something like, you know, the, the bad thing, or it was like the mortality.”
    Unnamed speaker · 58:23
  • “And in fact, to the point where, you know, one of the potential cures for the Antonine Plague was saying particular words, like those words had power.”
    Unnamed speaker · 58:56
  • “The Roman system continued to collapse. And we get following the Antonine Plague, not long after that, a generation later, something called the Third Century Crisis, which is just a period of great tumult in the Roman Empire.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:00:09
  • Underdog 0:01–0:36
  • O'Keefe's Working Hands 0:50–1:33
  • Lincoln 1:34–2:04
  • Quince 18:04–19:09
  • Underdog 31:59–33:01
  • O'Keefe's Working Hands 33:05–33:36
  • Quince 33:42–34:51
  • thispodcastwillkillyou.com 1:01:03–1:01:38
  • O'Keefe's Working Hands 1:03:24–1:04:05

About this episode

Having just experienced humanity’s latest pandemic, you might wonder when (not if) the next one is coming. Many public health experts believe we have entered into a new age of pandemics, where globalization, land use change, and climate change will increase the risk of pathogen spillover and spread. To shed light on what the future might hold, it could help to turn to the past, to the world’s first pandemic. In Pox Romana: The Plague that Shook the Roman World https://bookshop.org/a/3175/9780691220703, Dr. Colin Elliott https://history.indiana.edu/faculty_staff/faculty/elliott_colin.html, Professor of History at Indiana University, presents a scoping and captivating account of the mysterious pandemic that helped to topple the Roman Empire. Using a diversity of evidence, ranging from historical accounts to archaeological remains, climatological research to economic reports, Dr. Elliott paints a richly detailed portrait of an empire on the brink of collapse and exposes the vulnerabilities allowing this pandemic to inflict the extensive damage it did. We remember how the world responded to Covid; how did ancient Romans react to the devastation of this disease? Tune in to find out. Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
54:48

10,126 words · 8 speakers

Topics

  • Roman Empire
  • Antonine Plague
  • Rome
  • Pox Romana
  • Parthian Empire
  • YouTube
  • Pox Romana: The Plague That Shook the Roman World
  • Blood Mobile
  • The Plague That Shook the Roman World
  • Exactly Right Media

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated