Pod Insights This Podcast Will Kill You Ep 175 What’s the deal with raw milk: Part 2 About this episode Last week, we started this two-parter with a big picture view of pasteurization and the raw milk movement. In this episode, we address the alleged health claims made by proponents of raw milk and dive into the very real risks carried by its consumption. Is raw milk actually better for you? Does it have more vitamins or prevent allergies? What deadly pathogens does it harbor? How much does drinking raw milk increase your chance of contracting a milk-related disease? (Spoilers: A LOT). We tackle these questions with reliable data that paint a very different picture of raw milk than that shown by many raw milk influencers. Tune in for all this and more.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 11,077 words · 10 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 This is exactly right.
0:06 Speaker 01 Dry hands can be uncomfortable and frustrating, especially when frequent hand washing, changing weather, and everyday wear and tear take their toll. O'Keefe's Working Hands is here to help keep dry hands feeling hydrated and comfortable. O'Keefe's Working Hands creates a soothing barrier on the skin that locks in moisture and prevents further dryness. It's concentrated and non-gracey, and you start to feel relief in one use. Go to O'Keefe'sCompany.com to get yours today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
0:38 Speaker 02 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
0:46 Speaker 03 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
0:54 Speaker 02 Oh, that's actually really simple.
0:57 Speaker 03 Safe Balance Banking. One less thing to figure out. Learn more at BofA.com/SimpleBanking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
1:07 Speaker 04 This is Jacob Goldstein from What's Your Problem? Running a business is hard enough. Don't make it harder with a dozen apps that don't talk to each other. One for sales, another for inventory, a separate one for accounting. That's software overload. Odoo is the all-in-one platform that replaces them all. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR. Fully integrated, easy to use, and built to grow with your business. Thousands have already made the switch. Why not you? Try Odoo for free at O-D-O-O dot com. That's Odoo dot com.
1:44 Speaker 05 Sarah and her husband Brandon had decided to switch their family to raw milk because their oldest son had had some health issues. When they did, his health seemed to improve. "The kids loved it," said Sarah, talking about her other two children. "It seemed to be better for their immune systems. We drank it for five years. The kids thrived on it." The family also had complete faith in the dairy's sanitary practices. In switching over to raw milk, they had been advised to know their farmer. They believed they had done the right research to make sure the milk they were buying was safe to drink. But then one day Jubilee got sick, very sick. She was vomiting and suffering from a severe case of diarrhea. Instead of improving over the next several days, she got sicker and sicker.
2:28 Speaker 05 Her worried mother took her to the emergency room, taking along a pull-on diaper that had blood in it. The results of the test came back. It's E. coli, she was told. Jubilee's kidneys are in danger. Meanwhile, her son Titus, who had just turned six, was also sick, but seemed to be handling it better. But then he got sicker and joined his sister in the hospital. He too developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, although he didn't need to undergo dialysis. But he did develop pancreatitis from the E. coli infection he had contracted from the contaminated raw milk, and then a staph infection. "Watching them in pain was the absolute hardest thing I've ever done as a parent," she said.
3:09 Speaker 05 "The amount of needles for blood draws, medications, transfusions is scary, and the fear of each one only grew, making it harder, not easier." It was three weeks before the children were well enough to go home. "I was in the hospital with them the entire time," said Sarah. "I felt like a bat. It was still summer when they went in, and the stores were selling school supplies. When I came out, there were Christmas decorations in the stores." And while the children are doing well now, and playing with the best of them, memories persist.
4:25 Speaker 06 Wow.
4:26 Speaker 05 I know.
4:27 Speaker 06 That is absolutely heartbreaking.
4:30 Speaker 05 It's so heartbreaking. It's so heartbreaking. So that story was excerpted from an article on foodsafetynews.com. It was also written up in a Michigan food safety website as well. But it's about the story of Jubilee and Titus Combs, who got sick in Kentucky in 2016 from E. coli from contaminated raw milk.
4:53 Speaker 06 Hi, I'm Erin Welsh.
4:55 Speaker 05 And I'm Erin Omen Updike.
4:57 Speaker 06 And this is This Podcast Will Kill You.
4:59 Speaker 05 And we're still talking about raw milk today.
5:01 Speaker 06 We are still talking about raw milk. There is so much more to cover.
5:05 Speaker 05 A lot still to talk about.
5:06 Speaker 06 Yeah. Yeah. So if you haven't listened to last week's episode on raw milk, really what that was, was a history of pasteurization. And some of the pushback that pasteurization received early on, and then continued to receive as the decades went on.
5:25 Speaker 05 Continues to receive today, perhaps?
5:27 Speaker 06 Continues to receive today. And we also wrapped it up with a look at some of the present day drivers of raw milk. So in that, we were talking primarily about the people who are pushing raw milk and some of the reasons that might be.
5:38 Speaker 05 Right.
5:39 Speaker 06 Not all of the reasons that people, you know, push raw milk. And then the other thing too, is that like, you know, to separate out, to just reemphasize, to separate that there is a very big difference between the people buying raw milk and people who are pushing raw milk.
5:53 Speaker 05 Right. At like a large level.
5:55 Speaker 06 Yeah. Yeah. And so just like to not conflate the two.
5:59 Speaker 05 Right. There's so much miss and disinformation out there that like, it is really hard. And we'll get into that. I'm going to get into a lot of detail today on like, what are the claims that people are making about raw milk? Is there any validity to any of them? How do we distinguish what is real and what is not real? And how do we balance these supposed risks and supposed benefits? Like, how do we do that? So that's what we're going to talk about today. I'm excited about it, but first-
6:26 Speaker 06 I'm excited about it. Yep, Quarantini time yet again. We're drinking the same thing yet again. It is, uh, milk in it. We're milking it, you know, obviously. It's based on a cocktail called The Pink Squirrel, which has, let me pull up my notes. It has a bunch of things, actually only a few things. Has heavy cream, obviously. Has creme de cacao and it has creme de noio, which, um, is a challenge to find, but you know what?
6:56 Speaker 05 We'll persist.
6:58 Speaker 06 We will persist. But we will post the full recipe for our Quarantini, as well as the non-alcoholic Plastiberita on our website, at thispodcastwillkillyou.com, as well as on all of our social media channels, which if you're not following us on there, what are you waiting for?
7:14 Speaker 05 What are you even doing?
7:15 Speaker 06 Yeah.
7:16 Speaker 05 Who are you following?
7:22 Speaker 05 On our website, you can also find a whole bunch of other stuff that you might enjoy. You can find transcripts from every one of our episodes. You can find our bookshop.org affiliate account and our Goodreads list. You can find merch that we have, which is phenomenal. You can find a Bloodmobile who does the music for all of our episodes. You can find sources from every single one of our episodes so that you know where this information is coming from.
7:48 Speaker 06 Yeah, so many sources.
7:49 Speaker 05 So many sources.
7:50 Speaker 06 Yeah.
7:51 Speaker 05 Well, um, rate, review, subscribe.
7:54 Speaker 06 There you go. Check us out on YouTube.
7:56 Speaker 05 Okay, are we done with the business part of things?
7:59 Speaker 06 I think so. Let's, let's take a break and then get started.
8:25 Speaker 05 So Erin, you talked a lot about what the landscape was like prior to the requirements, prior to the development of pasteurization and requirements for pasteurization. But I just want to frame ourselves there. Um, prior to like nationwide requirements that all milk be pasteurized in the US, most of the estimates that I saw were that milkborne outbreaks overall constituted at least 25% of all disease outbreaks that were due to contaminated food and water.
8:59 Speaker 06 Wow.
8:59 Speaker 05 Right? So that's like a really huge number.
9:02 Speaker 06 Mm hmm.
9:02 Speaker 05 Today, milk and milk products are associated with, on average, and this varies a little bit year to year, but usually 1% or less of these types of outbreaks.
9:12 Speaker 06 Thanks to pasteurization.
9:13 Speaker 05 Phenomenal. Yeah. And, and as we'll see, that does not mean that milk itself is a low risk food. Cause like we talked about last week, milk is a beautiful medium for bacterial growth.
9:24 Speaker 06 It is.
9:25 Speaker 05 It means that pasteurization and the widespread use of pasteurization is the thing that has been preventing these outbreaks.
9:32 Speaker 06 Yep.
9:33 Speaker 05 So what I am going to do in this episode is like lay the, the, the view of the land of what the risks of unpasteurized milk actually are today.
9:44 Speaker 06 Okay. I, I keep hearing, are, do you, how do you pronounce milk?
9:48 Speaker 05 Okay. I, I was waiting for you to say this because I get made fun of for how I pronounce it every single, it's gonna, it's gonna keep going, Erin.
9:56 Speaker 06 It's milk. And I feel like this is feeling very deja vu to me. And I think that we may have had this conversation during lactose intolerance.
10:03 Speaker 05 Absolutely, we did.
10:04 Speaker 06 You say milk, right?
10:06 Speaker 05 I don't hear a difference between what you're saying and what I'm saying, milk.
10:12 Speaker 06 Where is, where does milk come from?
10:15 Speaker 05 What do you say?
10:16 Speaker 06 Like a dialect.
10:17 Speaker 05 Milk?
10:18 Speaker 06 I say milk.
10:19 Speaker 05 Milk?
10:20 Speaker 06 Milk. I'm sorry. There's a vowel change there for, for certain.
10:28 Speaker 05 Well, I'm sorry. Everyone's going to be so annoyed with how many times I say the word milk today.
10:33 Speaker 06 I just, I have to know. I need to look at like a dialect map to know where milk comes from. Did you pick it up in Illinois?
10:40 Speaker 05 Southern California?
10:41 Speaker 06 I don't know, Erin.
10:42 Speaker 05 I don't know. Okay.
10:43 Speaker 06 I don't know either.
10:45 Speaker 05 But I get made fun of for it on the regular. So apologies to literally everyone listening.
10:51 Speaker 05 I'm shocked that it didn't come out last week, honestly.
10:55 Speaker 06 That's fair. Yeah, I don't know.
10:57 Speaker 05 It's probably just because I didn't talk about milk as much.
11:01 Speaker 06 Sorry to like kick off this whole episode making you feel self-conscious.
11:04 Speaker 05 It's okay. I only say it 100 more times. 100,000. Okay, listen.
11:11 Speaker 05 But that's where we're going to start. Okay, we'll talk about the raw product.
11:16 Speaker 05 That comes out of a cow primarily. We're mostly talking about cow. Milk.
11:23 Speaker 05 And then, related to that, I'll also talk a little bit about what the current legal landscape looks like when it comes to raw and pasteurized milk, not just in the US, but across the globe. Like, how easy or how hard is it to actually get your hands on raw milk? Are there any associations between whether raw milk is legal and easy to get and its potential for causing harm? And then what the differences are truly between raw and pasteurized milk? And hopefully break down some of the very egregious misconceptions that exist on the internet right now about this, because there are some differences.
11:57 Speaker 06 Yeah.
11:57 Speaker 05 But it is not what TikTok would like you to believe.
12:00 Speaker 06 No, I feel like calling them misconceptions is very generous.
12:04 Speaker 05 I know.
12:04 Speaker 06 Like, flat-out lies.
12:07 Speaker 05 A lot of them really are. And we'll get into, I think, how those, like, why, I don't know, it's a very effective lies and we'll get into it.
12:16 Speaker 06 Totally.
12:17 Speaker 05 So, one of the things that makes comparing the number of infections, or the numbers even of outbreaks of disease from raw milk versus pasteurized milk difficult today in our modern system, is that there are huge disparities in the number of people who are drinking raw milk versus pasteurized milk. So, in the US, it's estimated that somewhere between 1% to 3% of the population is drinking raw milk, whereas close to 80% of Americans drink milk.
12:51 Speaker 05 Like, that's a huge, I didn't know that so many of us drink milk.
12:54 Speaker 06 And that's like, what does that mean? Does that mean like you're having a glass of 2%?
13:00 Speaker 05 No, this is based on surveys from like MMWR and like a bunch of other places that are just like, have you drank milk in the last seven days? Yes or no? And then sometimes it's quantified, like, how many glasses do you drink and blah, blah, blah, right?
13:13 Speaker 06 Right. So I guess, do I count as that? Would I check yes because I had half and half in my?
13:20 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
13:22 Speaker 06 Okay.
13:23 Speaker 05 Yeah, but I don't know, if you answered the survey, would you have clicked yes or no? I don't know.
13:28 Speaker 06 Well, I just mean, like, I guess it's, it's for such a, like a binary outcome, right? Like, yes or no? It's like, how much milk? Anyway.
13:37 Speaker 05 Erin, you're getting into, like, this is a huge part of it, right? How much milk are you drinking? Are people who are drinking raw milk drinking the same amount as people who are drinking pasteurized milk? Like, there, there is a lot of variability in any kind of like nutritional study that we're looking at. But if we just take a bird's eye view, probably about 80% or so of Americans drink milk. Only 1 to 3% of Americans are drinking raw milk. The vast majority of people who are drinking milk are drinking pasteurized milk. So if we're looking at numbers of people who get disease or the number of outbreaks, you cannot just compare the total number of outbreaks or the total number of cases in raw versus pasteurized milk.
14:19 Speaker 06 No.
14:20 Speaker 05 That will not give you an assessment of risk because that is not how statistics works. You have to compare the proportion of cases. You have to look at how many people are drinking raw milk? How much are they drinking? How many people are drinking pasteurized milk? How much are they drinking? And then figure out what is the likelihood that you would get sick from raw milk versus the likelihood that you would get sick from pasteurized milk? That is what you have to do. We often do not see the data reported in that way. Okay. So that is the first problem with how we report the differences in risk. But don't worry, we're going to today. Okay? Yay.
15:01 Speaker 05 So if we just look at those numbers first, there was a paper and there's I cited a bunch of different papers that looked at outbreak rates over different time periods. But I just picked the one that's the most recent. So a paper that looked at outbreaks in both the US and Canada, where by the way, it's totally illegal to buy raw milk or sell raw milk. Oh, like entirely? It, yeah, it's, it's not legal there. It still happens, but that it's not, it's not legal. Okay. If you look at outbreaks in the US and Canada from 2007 to 2020, in raw milk, there were 20 outbreaks, confirmed outbreaks of disease associated with raw milk
15:40 Speaker 05 that resulted in 449 confirmed cases, 124 hospitalizations and five deaths. In pasteurized milk products around the same time, there were 12 outbreaks, 174 confirmed cases, 134 hospitalizations. Okay. 17 deaths and seven fetal losses. Wow. And the majority of outbreaks in that time period, 2007 to 2020, were listeria in pasteurized products. And so that likely accounts for the increased number of hospitalizations, fetal losses and deaths because listeria can be very serious. Yeah. See our listeria episode for more. Yes. So just a few things right off the bat.
16:21 Speaker 05 Overall, even just the numbers, those raw numbers were higher in raw milk, right? But if you were to ignore statistics, you might say, well, it's much more dangerous to be drinking pasteurized milk. There were more deaths in pasteurized milk, right? But you would be wrong if that is the conclusion that you drew. Yeah. And we do not have to air in math this. Because I wouldn't trust myself to do these statistics.
16:45 Speaker 06 That's a shame, though. I miss some errand math.
16:47 Speaker 05 Thank you.
16:48 Speaker 06 I love some errand math.
16:48 Speaker 05 I wish I could have done it. I thought about it, but luckily I found a paper that did the math for us. And they were looking at data. It was from a slightly different set of years. I think it was like 2009 to 2014 or something like that. Based on US data, they looked at how much milk and what type of milk products are people drinking? And based on all the outbreak data from that time, they estimated that a person consuming raw milk is 840 times more likely to become ill and 45 times more likely to be hospitalized from that illness compared to somebody drinking pasteurized milk.
17:25 Speaker 06 840?
17:27 Speaker 05 840 times more likely to become ill, 45 times more likely to be hospitalized. Most years, over 95% of outbreaks and cases of disease from milk is from raw milk, not from pasteurized milk.
17:43 Speaker 06 Right.
17:44 Speaker 05 And it is true that milk is not the biggest contender when it comes to foodborne diseases overall, whether it's raw or pasteurized. But again, that is because of pasteurization and because the vast majority of people are drinking pasteurized milk. Prior to pasteurization, 25% of foodborne illnesses were coming from milk because that milk was primarily raw milk.
18:07 Speaker 05 It's also estimated, and this is really important, for every case that is associated with an outbreak, like an identified, recognized outbreak associated with milk, there are likely 26 to 100 other illnesses that are never reported. So these are all underestimates.
18:25 Speaker 06 For, okay.
18:27 Speaker 05 For milkborne disease.
18:28 Speaker 06 For milkborne disease.
18:29 Speaker 05 Correct.
18:30 Speaker 06 Okay.
18:31 Speaker 05 Dry hands can be uncomfortable and frustrating, especially when frequent hand washing, changing weather, and everyday wear and tear take their toll. O'Keefe's Working Hands is here to help keep dry hands feeling hydrated and comfortable. O'Keefe's Working Hands creates a soothing barrier on the skin that locks in moisture and prevents further dryness. It's concentrated and non-grassy, and you start to feel relief in one use. Go to okeefescompany.com to get yours today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
19:04 Speaker 00 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by breakout singer-songwriter Alex Warren.
19:24 Speaker 07 To this day, Ordinary would not have done anything, and I would have not been able to put it out if Book Talk didn't back it up and if my wife and her friend didn't back it up.
19:32 Speaker 00 Amazing.
19:33 Speaker 07 Pretty crazy how like, just one thing.
19:35 Speaker 00 Right.
19:36 Speaker 07 I mean, I bet we could point to nine different things in our careers where it's just one thing, all of a sudden, if that one thing didn't happen, then I wouldn't be here.
19:43 Speaker 00 What you're talking about right now is what I've been talking about since the beginning of my career. There's these things outside of you that make everything happen. These other forces somehow came into contact with each other and helped propel you to this place.
20:01 Speaker 07 It's just insane.
20:02 Speaker 00 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
20:24 Speaker 06 So it might be a bit early to ask this.
20:26 Speaker 05 Go ahead, anyways.
20:27 Speaker 06 You mentioned listeria. What are the other pathogens or diseases associated with milk?
20:33 Speaker 05 So glad you asked. It's not too early. That's exactly what I was going to talk about next.
20:37 Speaker 06 You're welcome for the segue.
20:38 Speaker 05 Thank you. There are a lot of different pathogens that can be transmitted via milk. You talked about a lot of them last week. There are a few that constitute the majority each year of the outbreaks and the sporadic cases that are associated with milk. Salmonella and Campylobacter are two really big ones. Both of these can cause Guillain-Barre syndrome, which is a long-term neurologic complication that arises after infection. Listeria is a very big one in pasteurized and raw milk. Listeria, of course, can cause very severe infection in older people and in young babies. But it also, most severely, if a person is pregnant when they're infected, can cross the placenta and result in fetal death or severe fetal complications.
21:21 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's heartbreaking.
21:22 Speaker 05 E. coli is also very common in raw milk, including the serovar O157H7, which can cause severe illness, including something called hemolytic uremic syndrome, which is very devastating, can cause internal bleeding, kidney failure and death, and is far more likely to happen to children than adults.
21:43 Speaker 06 Just because of like susceptibility, vulnerability, kind of a thing?
21:46 Speaker 05 Yeah, and really, across the board, all of these illnesses are more likely to result in severe disease in children because their microbiomes, their immune systems are just not as, you know, equipped to deal with these infections. Most of these infections cause like diarrheal illness, so nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, sometimes, especially with E. coli, we can see bloody diarrhea or dysentery.
22:09 Speaker 06 Okay, yeah.
22:10 Speaker 05 But milk can also harbor brucellosis, cryptococcal, mycobacterium, which causes tuberculosis, staphylococcus, streptococcus, and a ton of other pathogens as well. But those tend to be the top causes of disease in humans.
22:25 Speaker 06 It's, it's interesting, and part of the reason, I know that I talked about it last week, but part of the reason I was very curious about the specific pathogens today is like, what has changed or which ones have come to light in terms of being more, more seen as a, as a risk or a threat? And I think part of it is just that a lot of the diseases that used to be such a huge driver, we, we vaccinated, like diphtheria, right?
22:48 Speaker 05 A hundred percent, right?
22:49 Speaker 06 Yeah.
22:49 Speaker 05 We don't see diphtheria in milk, thank goodness.
22:51 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah.
22:53 Speaker 05 Of course, this year in particular and last year, we've also seen a lot of reports of dairy cows and their raw milk being contaminated with H5N1 or avian influenza.
23:03 Speaker 06 This is what I'm the most curious about, Erin.
23:06 Speaker 05 Yes, viral illnesses, including avian influenza and other influences can absolutely be found in the milk. Thus far, the only people who have gotten sick from raw milk are from those handling and processing it, as far as I could tell. So there have been outbreaks in dairy workers.
23:25 Speaker 06 Okay.
23:25 Speaker 05 They think from getting that raw milk like in their eyes and things like that during the processing process.
23:30 Speaker 06 You mean getting sick with H5N1?
23:32 Speaker 05 Yes.
23:32 Speaker 06 Okay.
23:33 Speaker 05 Yes, becoming ill from H5N1 from milk, but not from consumption of raw milk. Yet.
23:38 Speaker 06 Okay.
23:38 Speaker 05 And there have been a number of dairies that have had to recall them their milk because it was found to be contaminated with H5N1 though.
23:46 Speaker 06 And so what does, what does contamination with H5N1 mean? Are we finding, you know, just genetic material? Are these viable viruses? Like, I mean, obviously, some of them are, at least if they're, if they're causing illness.
23:59 Speaker 05 Yeah.
24:00 Speaker 06 In people who are handling the cows. But what, yeah, what does that mean from like a disease standpoint?
24:06 Speaker 05 I don't know. And I don't know. I think what, what this highlights is that you can't necessarily test for everything. Right?
24:14 Speaker 06 Right, right, right. You can test for the things that you know that you are testing. You can look for things, but you can't find everything.
24:19 Speaker 05 Exactly. You can't find everything. I don't know exactly what the methods are that they are using to test for avian influences specifically. I did not look into that. I'm sure that there's a protocol, but I don't know what it is. For all of the bacterial species, it's usually that they are, you know, plating and culturing these, which is a fallible system. You might have things that are present in low levels or only in certain batches that you're not testing and therefore not catching. So just because you have a facility that is testing their milk does not mean that that milk is guaranteed to be free of pathogens if it's not pasteurized.
24:52 Speaker 06 Right.
24:53 Speaker 05 And these pathogens are introduced in a bunch of different ways, right, into the milk. Milk itself is not really a sterile fluid, right? But even if it were, as soon as it leaves the teat, is that the right word, by the way?
25:08 Speaker 06 Utter?
25:08 Speaker 05 Teat?
25:09 Speaker 06 Like the individual?
25:10 Speaker 05 Individual nubbin, like the nipple of the cow? I think it's the teat, pretty sure.
25:17 Speaker 06 I think that makes sense.
25:18 Speaker 05 As soon as it leaves, it's coming into contact with the skin of that teat and the udder, which is teeming with bacteria. It can very easily be contaminated with fecal matter from the cow, which can be anywhere on its skin. It can, you can have bacteria that are introduced from the environment itself, from the milking equipment, from storage equipment, from the milk handlers, or down the line from improper processing or storage conditions that allow the bacteria that are already present to multiply into quantities that could now cause harm. So there are a lot of ways that milk can end up contaminated. So that kind of bleeds into the question of what are the regulations surrounding raw milk?
26:02 Speaker 05 And who, who is allowed to have it? Where does it come from?
26:06 Speaker 06 Yeah.
26:07 Speaker 05 And is it only in the US, our FDA, that has brainwashed us into thinking that our milk needs to be pasteurized?
26:15 Speaker 05 No, is the short answer of that. The legality of raw milk, or the requirements of pasteurization across the globe do vary, just like they vary state to state within the US. But they are fairly global. So in Canada, it's illegal to sell unpasteurized milk, though you can get soft cheeses made from unpasteurized milk.
26:39 Speaker 06 Okay. Can I ask a question about that?
26:41 Speaker 05 Yeah.
26:42 Speaker 06 Like, is there a risk difference between cheeses made from raw milk versus consuming just raw milk straight out of the, you know, teat?
26:51 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's a good question. There definitely are outbreaks that are associated with both soft cheeses and with unpasteurized milk products. Most of the papers that I looked at, they tried to focus just on milk itself, just to not conflate the two, if that makes sense.
27:06 Speaker 06 Yeah.
27:06 Speaker 05 So I don't know exactly, like, is soft cheese much more risky than just raw milk? I, I mean, they all pose a potential risk. I don't know, like, the numerical differences necessarily.
27:17 Speaker 06 I just didn't know if there was anything in the process of making, I don't know anything about making cheese. And if there's anything in the processing aspect of that, or like, the culturing aspect, if that changes.
27:27 Speaker 05 The risk profile? I don't know.
27:29 Speaker 06 Okay.
27:29 Speaker 05 That would be a milk expert question.
27:31 Speaker 06 Okay. You're not a milk expert?
27:33 Speaker 05 No.
27:34 Speaker 06 You're, you're a milk expert.
27:39 Speaker 05 Erin, stop it. Okay, listen. In the UK, it is illegal to sell unpasteurized milk only from certain places, like at the farm or farmers markets or direct online sales or something like that. And they have to come with a health warning label on it. And then there's requirements in terms of annual inspections. Animals have to be free from TB and brucellosis. Bacterial counts have to be under certain loads, et cetera. Apparently, though, in Scotland, it's illegal, period. In Ireland, it's mostly legal. There are some regulations regarding registration and inspection. And the EU laws vary very significantly in all the different member states. Australia, pretty strict. It's illegal to package, deliver or sell unpasteurized milk.
28:21 Speaker 05 And in New Zealand, it has to be bought only by home delivery or direct farm sales.
28:25 Speaker 06 Okay.
28:26 Speaker 05 In the US, things have been changing very rapidly.
28:30 Speaker 06 Very rapidly.
28:31 Speaker 05 So this data is probably a little bit outdated, but I tried to get like, you know, an assessment that was like seemed reliable. So there was a paper from 2019 that said that as of then, 23 states and Washington DC prohibited all sale of unpasteurized milk for human consumption.
28:50 Speaker 06 Right, which is, there's a workaround, right?
28:52 Speaker 05 Yes, you can sell it for a dog and cats and then...
28:56 Speaker 06 And then your cat dies, but yeah.
28:58 Speaker 05 No one is in your house telling you that you can't drink it once you have it in your house.
29:01 Speaker 06 Right.
29:02 Speaker 05 Um, 27 states at the time in 2019, and I think this has changed, allowed the sale of unpasteurized milk with variation in what those requirements were. Like some, like here in California, you can buy it in retail stores. In some places, it can only be sold on the farm where it's produced. Some, you can sell at farmers markets, et cetera. So there's a lot of variation. But here's what's really important. There are a lot of people who say, well, the only way that raw milk is risky is if you're not getting it from the right source. If you get sick, it's your fault because you didn't do your research.
29:36 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
29:37 Speaker 05 That is untrue. An analysis from 2022 showed that the vast majority of outbreaks that were associated with raw milk are happening in states where it is easier to buy legal raw milk. We're not talking about black market raw milk that's causing illness.
29:53 Speaker 06 Okay.
29:53 Speaker 05 Especially in states where it is legal to be sold in retail stores. The easier that it is to get raw milk, the more risk there is of raw milk causing illness.
30:05 Speaker 06 And period. These states, this include the ones where it says not for human consumption?
30:11 Speaker 05 I believe so. No, I mean, this was mostly in places where it is made for human consumption.
30:17 Speaker 06 Got it. Okay.
30:17 Speaker 05 So presumably farms are having to be tested to more rigorous standards if they are selling something for human consumption.
30:24 Speaker 06 Right.
30:25 Speaker 05 And yet, they are then causing more illness. Like, that is what we see. So...
30:33 Speaker 06 Not that surprising, I guess.
30:35 Speaker 05 Right. It's not surprising, but it is like contrary to what a lot of the rhetoric is about raw milk and that if you just do your research, if you know that the farm is clean, if you know your farmer, if you trust them. And that's just not the reality. You cannot guarantee that raw milk is free from pathogens. You can't guarantee that anything is completely free of pathogens, but we can greatly reduce the pathogen burden by pasteurizing milk. There are other ways that things can get contaminated. That is why we can still see occasional outbreaks in pasteurized milk products, because it can be contaminated after the pasteurization process itself in other parts of the processing, handling,
31:16 Speaker 05 and storage of milk. But without that step to ensure that the first product that you're getting is not contaminated, you cannot guarantee that that milk is not going to make you sick. Period.
31:29 Speaker 06 Period.
31:31 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast-absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue, so you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long.
32:16 Speaker 01 Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands, yeah, it works.
32:29 Speaker 00 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by my friend, John Legend. How does music actually enter your mind?
32:51 Speaker 08 I'm not sure why or how the music comes to me, but I think people who love music and write music, our brains are just filled with music.
33:01 Speaker 00 Right.
33:01 Speaker 08 Like, we have listened to so much music, we've been a part of so much music. I think of the story that I want to tell, the mood that I want to create with the music, start playing chords, see where they lead me.
33:12 Speaker 00 Sometimes, I'm just not even thinking about music, right? And I hear this little thing, and I go, oh, that could be this.
33:23 Speaker 08 You know, you just have to be ready for when the inspiration hits.
33:26 Speaker 00 It comes.
33:26 Speaker 08 Yeah.
33:27 Speaker 00 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
33:52 Speaker 05 So are there any benefits to milk, period? Or to raw milk compared to pasteurized milk?
34:01 Speaker 06 I was like just talking about, again, like it's still, I can't get over how how strange it is, if you think about it, that we are still drinking like a food, a milk that is made for another species.
34:15 Speaker 05 Babies.
34:19 Speaker 06 It's baby food as adults.
34:22 Speaker 05 We're so weird. We just drink baby food all day. Um, there's also, I will say, been a lot of debate in the like literature at large about like, is milk even good for us? Should we be drinking it? Should we not like?
34:37 Speaker 06 There's too much, there's too much, there's too much to think about in the world.
34:40 Speaker 05 Exactly.
34:41 Speaker 06 I can't think about that question.
34:43 Speaker 05 So across the board, though, globally, milk is an important source of nutrition for a lot of people.
34:49 Speaker 06 Yes.
34:49 Speaker 05 It is a good source of fat. It is a good source of protein. It has a lot of calcium, which is important for our bone health. And it's a good source of vitamin B12. It has other vitamins in it. It's got other B vitamins. It has some vitamin C, maybe a little sprinkle of vitamin D.
35:08 Speaker 05 But it's actually not great sources of any of those other vitamins. It's like B12, calcium, fat, protein. That's what you're really getting from milk.
35:16 Speaker 06 Yeah.
35:16 Speaker 05 There's nothing inherently magical about it. There's nothing that we need that we can only get from cow's milk. Everything that you get from cow's milk, you can get from other nutritional sources.
35:28 Speaker 06 Right. What are some other good sources of B12 and calcium?
35:31 Speaker 05 B12 is literally any animal product. Any, if you are totally vegan, then that's when it becomes an issue with where are you getting your B12? But like eggs, meat, any other dairy product like cheeses, anything else that comes from an animal has B12 in it. Calcium, you can actually get like shellfish have a lot of calcium in them.
35:49 Speaker 06 What?
35:49 Speaker 05 You can also get calcium from lentils. Like you do not need milk to get your calcium. There's lots of other places.
35:55 Speaker 06 I didn't know that shellfish have calcium. Should I have known?
35:59 Speaker 05 Now I feel like I want to double check myself to make sure I'm not crazy, but I'm pretty sure that's right.
36:04 Speaker 05 Yep. Shellfish is a fair source of calcium. Yep.
36:07 Speaker 06 Amazing.
36:08 Speaker 05 Okay. Just to make sure I'm not telling anyone lies.
36:13 Speaker 05 So what then, if milk can give us things that are beneficial for us, what are the differences between raw milk and pasteurized milk in terms of its nutritional quality? Yeah. The short answer is that due to the effects of pasteurization alone, there are essentially no major changes to overall protein content or digestibility, no changes to fat content, minimal changes to vitamin and mineral concentration and bioavailability, including calcium, no change in calcium bioavailability. And in short, there are no substantive differences that occur due to the process of pasteurization.
36:52 Speaker 05 The nutritional quality overall of pasteurized milk versus raw milk is very similar. But this is this podcast will kill you, so we won't just broad strokes it. Let's dig, shall we? Let's get the details. So I already said, milk has a lot of different vitamins in it, fat soluble vitamins like vitamin A and E, also B1, 2, 6, 12, folate, which is B9, vitamin C. You might recall from our rickets episode that milk is actually naturally rather deficient in vitamin D. I do recall. Which is why it's often added to commercial milk products. Yeah. Because vitamin D and calcium work really well together and they're both important for your bone health.
37:34 Speaker 05 And so it's added to pasteurized milk products after the point of pasteurization so that you can get enough vitamin D from your milk. So if you're drinking raw and pasteurized milk straight from the teat, you are actually going to be getting less vitamin D than somebody who's drinking store bought milk. But that's not because of pasteurization. When it comes to the rest of the vitamins, A, but most of the other B vitamins, the C and E, there is maybe some evidence that there's a slight decrease in vitamin B12, but this is less than a 10% decrease. And so pasteurized milk is still considered a very good source of B12 in your diet. The rest of the B vitamins, some studies don't really show any significant change. Some studies show slight declines in some of the other vitamin concentrations.
38:19 Speaker 05 But again, milk is not necessarily the best source of these other B vitamins. To begin with, and so our diets are not reliant on milk to obtain these vitamins. And vitamin C, I think I mentioned in last week's episode, milk is not a good source of vitamin C. And vitamin C is easily ruined via heat as well as oxidation. It's photosensitive. And so milk that is stored for any length of time is going to be a very poor source of vitamin C. There are some studies that show an increase in vitamin A with pasteurization. Why? I don't know.
38:51 Speaker 06 Yeah.
38:52 Speaker 05 But there's that.
38:54 Speaker 06 Okay.
38:54 Speaker 05 So the bottom line is that the process of heating milk and then cooling it back down, which is what pasteurization is, does very little to affect the overall nutritional profile of milk. There is a lot of variation that is possible in vitamin content of milk between cows, between farms, within one individual cow at different phases of its life.
39:18 Speaker 06 Yeah.
39:19 Speaker 05 So it could be that milk from one particular farm has significantly higher concentrations of some of these vitamins than milk from other farms. These differences are not due to pasteurization.
39:33 Speaker 06 Okay, so real quick, a question about pasteurization. And maybe this is again, jumping ahead, or maybe it's the perfect segue, take two. But the pasteurization, there are different types of pasteurization.
39:46 Speaker 05 There are.
39:46 Speaker 06 The half and half in my fridge is ultra pasteurized.
39:49 Speaker 05 Okay.
39:50 Speaker 06 As an example, and then there's also UHT. What are the, what are the differences between these? And do these different types of pasteurization impact the nutrient differences between the two?
40:05 Speaker 05 Great question. Let me scroll to where I have some data on that.
40:10 Speaker 06 The perfect segue.
40:13 Speaker 05 So yes, there are different types of pasteurization. It's going to differ like farm to farm or company to company as well as like country to country. So the US, most of our milk is pasteurized by what's called HTST, high temperature, short time, which is just like a standard pasteurization, which means that the milk is heated to about 70 degrees Celsius or 161 degrees Fahrenheit for at least 10 to 15 seconds. And then rapidly cooled down to less than 40 degrees Fahrenheit. Ultra-high temperature or ultra-pasteurized, those are the same thing. So that's UHT or ultra-pasteurized. That is heated to a much higher temperature. So at least 280 degrees Fahrenheit or 137 Celsius, and sometimes even higher, for two to three seconds. So shorter time, higher temperature.
40:57 Speaker 06 Okay.
40:58 Speaker 05 And then there, and that milk can sometimes actually be shelf-stable. So that's why in a lot of other countries, when you buy milk, it's not in the refrigerated section. You don't have to refrigerate it until after you open it because it was pasteurized and then packaged in a way that it is essentially like considered sterile, really.
41:14 Speaker 06 I remember that in Finland and Panama.
41:17 Speaker 05 Yes. And then some small-batch farms might use even lower temperatures for pasteurization, but the lower the temperature, the longer time that you have to leave it at that temperature. So yes, there might be differences in the amount. We'll talk in a little bit about proteins. And so there might be differences in the amount that vitamin levels are affected, like 5% versus 10% versus whatever declines, and in the amount of changes to the proteins in milk that we see with ultra-high temperature versus lower-temperature pasteurization.
41:49 Speaker 06 Mm-hmm.
41:50 Speaker 05 And a lot of studies don't necessarily distinguish between these when they're looking at the effects of raw versus pasteurized milk. They're not distinguishing lower-temperature pasteurization versus higher-temperature pasteurization. They're lumping all pasteurized milk products together.
42:03 Speaker 06 Okay.
42:03 Speaker 05 So there's not as much data on like the differences between ultra-high and regular pasteurized versus lower-temperature pasteurized.
42:10 Speaker 06 Got it.
42:12 Speaker 05 But it's a really good question. If we get back into the concentrations of different vitamins and minerals, total calcium content, bioavailability of calcium, not changed with pasteurization, though the amount of free calcium might be slightly decreased after pasteurization.
42:27 Speaker 06 All right.
42:28 Speaker 05 There is also no substantial difference in lactose concentration in raw versus pasteurized milk.
42:33 Speaker 06 Yeah, this is such a common
42:35 Speaker 05 It really is.
42:36 Speaker 06 thing, claim that people make.
42:37 Speaker 05 Someone who is lactose intolerant is not any more likely to tolerate raw milk compared to pasteurized milk. And I have a study to back myself up. I'm not making this up. The idea is, in raw milk proponents, that there is so-called "good bacteria", which produce lactase enzyme in raw milk.
42:57 Speaker 05 And while there are a lot of bacteria in raw milk, and some of them might include lactobacillus, which can produce a lactase enzyme. Some of them might include bifidobacterium, which is a marker for fecal contamination in your milk. But both of those can produce a lactase enzyme. They are not present to an extent that it changes the lactose concentration of raw milk. To do that, you add back in bacteria in order to make yogurt. And yogurt does have significantly less lactose because of the amount of lactobacillus or human-derived bifidobacterium that are added after pasteurization of that milk. Does that make sense?
43:41 Speaker 06 Makes total sense.
43:42 Speaker 05 Yeah. Milk is, across the board, pasteurized or on, a great source of protein. Eighty percent of the protein in milk is in the form of casein, which is incredibly heat-stable, does not change with pasteurization. The rest of the proteins in milk, a lot of them are whey proteins, which is a whole group of proteins. And these are more heat-labeile. So they can denature and break into smaller pieces or change their shape after the process of pasteurization.
44:11 Speaker 06 Okay.
44:12 Speaker 05 But there is no evidence that this increases the allergenicity of milk. Like, kids who are allergic to milk are usually allergic to whey protein. And they are no more likely to tolerate raw milk than they are pasteurized milk. They're still allergic, either way.
44:25 Speaker 06 Yep.
44:26 Speaker 05 And there are a lot of other proteins in this milk that some people who love raw milk get really excited about because they're like, oh, some of these proteins are like bactericidal. And these are things like lactoferrin, lysosomes, lactoperoxidase, bactericidins. These are things that are present in milk as an immune response in the cow to help protect the cow against infection.
44:51 Speaker 06 Okay.
44:51 Speaker 05 So they might be there in higher concentrations if that cow, say, has subclinical mastitis or something like that. But these proteins are all still present in pasteurized milk, and much of them retain seventy percent or more of their activity after pasteurization. So in short, protein content is not significantly changed, though some whey proteins do change their shape or structure due to the heating process itself.
45:16 Speaker 06 Right, but there's, there are no consequences to
45:19 Speaker 05 Digestability, to protein availability, or to allergenicity of the milk.
45:26 Speaker 05 Milk, I have so much more, Erin, is a really good source of fat, as long as you're drinking whole milk. Now, this is where we can get into some really big differences between commercially-produced milk and raw milk. The milk that you get straight from a cow can vary anywhere from like 3% to over 6% milk fat, which is huge variation.
45:47 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's huge.
45:48 Speaker 05 But if you're producing something commercially in large batches, like the milk that you're buying from a store, you don't want variation. You can't reliably test variation, you need standardization. So, in the process of making like, big quantities of milk to sell in stores, milk from a bunch of cows, and sometimes even from a whole bunch of farms, is mixed, and then often it is skimmed, which means the fat is removed, and then fat is added back in to make standardized versions of milk. So you can buy non-fat milk, where all the milk has been removed, you can buy milk where it was skimmed, and then 1% of fat was added back in, or 2%, or whole milk is usually standardized at about 3.5%.
46:31 Speaker 06 Interesting, okay.
46:32 Speaker 05 Okay, but raw milk can vary drastically in its fat content, and it can vary batch to batch. That doesn't have anything to do with pasteurization. Pasteurization is not significantly changing the fat content of milk.
46:45 Speaker 06 Right.
46:46 Speaker 05 Period.
46:46 Speaker 06 It's just milk processing.
46:48 Speaker 05 It's just part of the milk processing process. Another part of the milk processing process that's not pasteurization is that the
46:54 Speaker 06 Milk processing process is hilarious, by the way, I love it.
46:56 Speaker 05 Processing process. Um, is that milk in stores is generally homogenized and that's an entirely separate process from pasteurization.
47:06 Speaker 06 Mm hmm.
47:06 Speaker 05 It entails, uh, reducing the size of the milk fat globules to really tiny so that they're more well evenly suspended in the milk. So it doesn't settle out with gravity.
47:16 Speaker 06 You're not getting that, yeah.
47:18 Speaker 05 That, that increases the stability of milk. Uh, also makes some people like, think it looks less gross because it's not chunky.
47:25 Speaker 06 Mm hmm.
47:25 Speaker 05 But this is not due to pasteurization. That's due to homogenization. You can buy non-homogenized pasteurized milk. I used to buy it all the time in Hawaii. That was the milk that we bought.
47:34 Speaker 06 Yeah.
47:35 Speaker 05 So just saying, um, and yeah, so that's, um, that's all of the, the major differences. The biggest difference between raw and pasteurized milk, like the true big difference is the bacterial loads. Yes. Raw milk has significantly higher loads of bacteria across the board every single time. And that is why it poses a higher risk of infection. Not all of those bacteria are pathogenic, but some of them are.
48:01 Speaker 06 You're right. Right. And so how does that like, what sort of is the inspection process? And I know that there are standards that farms have to meet whether that milk ends up being pasteurized or not.
48:12 Speaker 05 Correct.
48:13 Speaker 06 But what is, what is the acceptable level of bacteria in raw milk?
48:19 Speaker 05 Aaron, that varies across the board. It varies country to country. It varies state to state. Same thing with how often does your farm need to be inspected? How often do you need to be reporting that? Who are you reporting it to? All of that is going to vary. So yes, there are requirements that are supposed to be in place for farms that are producing raw milk for consumption and farms that are producing milk to be pasteurized for consumption.
48:41 Speaker 06 Okay.
48:41 Speaker 05 Um, but it, it's really like, it's a patchwork, right? It's going to vary place to place. So I don't have like a good summary of what the general requirements are.
48:50 Speaker 06 Got it. Okay. And so let's say that you are selling raw milk and of course it has bacteria in it. And let's just say it happens to have some disease pathogenic bacteria that lead to an outbreak and you're, you're based in the U.S.
49:05 Speaker 05 Uh huh.
49:06 Speaker 06 What happens?
49:08 Speaker 05 Oh gosh. If that outbreak is identified, then usually it's going to be the either FDA and or CDC working together to piece together where that outbreak originated from. And sometimes that's really hard. Sometimes it's really hard to pinpoint it back to a single farm or to a single producer. But if it can be, then usually that milk has to be recalled. And then there's steps in place where that farm has to be inspected, things like that. But I will confess, I didn't dig deep into like what the step by step details are of what happens after that point. But I do know from looking at all of this outbreak data that a lot of times, we don't necessarily get what was the one farm for a lot of different reasons. Sometimes people just aren't forthcoming with that kind of information and things like that.
49:53 Speaker 06 Yeah, okay.
49:54 Speaker 05 But the last thing that I want to talk about before we end here is a big claim that a lot of raw milk proponents make that may or may not have merit. We'll get into it. But every time I've seen it presented online, it is presented without any nuance, or it is exaggerated to the point of being untrue, like not true at all. And that is this claim that raw milk, the consumption of raw milk reduces the risk of asthma or allergies.
50:21 Speaker 06 I'm so glad that you're getting into this because there is so much, yeah, misinformation and just like drawing conclusions that are not
50:34 Speaker 05 Appropriate.
50:35 Speaker 06 There. Yeah.
50:36 Speaker 05 Yeah. So let's, let's get into what the data actually does show, shall we? 20 plus years ago, there were a few really big like landmark studies, most of them done in Europe, that were digging into this association that we've talked about before on the podcast, where people started to notice that there was a big difference in kids who grew up on farms, living on a farm, were exposed to farms, who had a decreased risk of atopic diseases like allergies, asthma, and eczema later in life. At this point now in 2025, there've been a bunch of papers that have shown this association. And because of this observational association, people understandably are trying to drill down into what is it about farms? Like, what are the
51:19 Speaker 05 exposures that people are being exposed to that reduce the risk? We'd love to reduce the risk of allergies and asthma.
51:25 Speaker 06 Right.
51:25 Speaker 05 Is it the diversity of microbes? Is it the number of microbes they're being exposed to? Is it the animals? Is it the plants or the animal feed? Is it the dirt? Or is it the milk?
51:37 Speaker 06 Is it the milk?
51:38 Speaker 05 Is it the milk? Um, and I will confess, I wrote and rewrote this section about a thousand times because the truth is that this data is a little bit messy. It does not fit into a 90 second Instagram reel. And it's very easy to skip the nuance, but that's not how I roll, so.
51:56 Speaker 06 Mm hmm. That's not this podcast will kill you.
51:59 Speaker 05 There are several large studies. They have names like Alex, Parsifal, Gabrielle, and Pasteur. Those are the biggest ones. There are several others. I know they all have.
52:11 Speaker 06 Like Hurricane, like. Hilarious.
52:15 Speaker 05 Um, and they're really big studies. They're like several hundred to sometimes several thousand kids across Europe, mostly Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Sweden, Poland, Finland, Switzerland, France, and there might be a few countries I missed that have been looking into these associations. And by and large, they have looked at kids who live on farms, kids who don't live on farms, kids who drink farm milk and kids who drink what they call shop milk.
52:44 Speaker 06 Okay.
52:44 Speaker 05 And looking at are there associations here?
52:48 Speaker 06 And farm milk does not necessarily mean raw milk.
52:50 Speaker 05 So this is the first part where we get into nuance.
52:52 Speaker 06 Okay, sorry. Yeah.
52:54 Speaker 05 Farm milk means milk that comes from a farm and is not sold in a store. Most of the time, this is drunk raw from like the, the kids on the farm are drinking the majority of farm milk. Kids who don't live on farms drink much less farm milk. It's much less likely for them to drink farm milk. Um, it's usually raw. It is not always raw. Um, in different studies, different percentages of families say that they boil their farm milk before drinking it. So I'm going to say farm milk for right now. And that could be boiled or raw farm.
53:30 Speaker 06 Okay, okay.
53:31 Speaker 05 On the whole, consumption of farm milk does seem to confer a lower odds of developing asthma, allergic rhinitis, and eczema.
53:41 Speaker 06 How much lower odds?
53:43 Speaker 05 It depends.
53:45 Speaker 06 Yeah.
53:45 Speaker 05 In the big analysis, when they lumped all the kids together and just looked at like across a bunch of this, this was from a meta-analysis from 2020. If they lump all of the different studies, all of the kids, and just say, do you drink farm milk? Do you not drink farm milk? The odds of developing asthma if you drink farm milk were 0.7 compared to if you didn't drink farm milk. Now, odds ratios are also really hard to interpret.
54:11 Speaker 06 Yeah.
54:11 Speaker 05 Because if that were a risk, we would say it was a 30% reduction in risk. But you can't say that.
54:16 Speaker 06 You can't say that.
54:17 Speaker 05 Because odds ratios overestimate the risk reduction.
54:21 Speaker 06 Yes.
54:22 Speaker 05 So that's why it gets even more confusing.
54:24 Speaker 06 Confidence interval and blah, blah, blah. Yeah.
54:25 Speaker 05 These were all significant associations, though. I will say that.
54:28 Speaker 06 Okay.
54:29 Speaker 05 And it's similar. So it was a 0.68 odds ratio for allergic rhinitis and then 0.65 for atopy or eczema.
54:39 Speaker 06 Okay.
54:39 Speaker 05 But again, these are, it's really difficult to interpret this into risk, but it is a reduction in the odds, a significant reduction in the odds that you would develop these atopic diseases. Now, in these studies and in this meta-analysis, if they, because there's only a few studies where you could actually stratify the data by whether the kid who's drinking this milk lives or doesn't live on a farm, which you kind of have to do.
55:03 Speaker 06 Yeah.
55:04 Speaker 05 Because there's a lot of other things going on on farms that we know are also associated with reduction in the risk of atopic diseases. And once you stratify by whether or not the kid lives on a farm, you actually lose the significance of this protective effect for everything except asthma. There still seems to be, regardless of whether or not you grew up on a farm, if you're drinking farm milk, you have a slightly lower odds of developing asthma. And it's about the same, about 0.7.
55:30 Speaker 06 Okay, so it seems like most of the differences can be explained away simply by living on a farm and whatever that entails, not necessarily milk itself, with the exception of asthma.
55:41 Speaker 05 Potentially, yes.
55:42 Speaker 06 Potentially.
55:43 Speaker 05 Potentially.
55:44 Speaker 06 And again, we're still not distinguishing farm milk from raw milk, boiled, milk that's been boiled, et cetera.
55:52 Speaker 05 Exactly. And that's really hard to do. I will also say that all of these studies that are frequently cited that have this really great data have been done in Europe, where milk is also primarily treated with ultra-high-temperature pasteurization. Um, none of these studies that I could tell looked at how much milk kids are drinking, whether they're kids who drink farm milk versus non-farm milk. And there's some data that maybe kids who are drinking farm milk also drink more of it. So is it also just that you're drinking more milk? We're also not looking at if you're drinking shop milk, is it whole milk? Is it 1%? Is it 2%? There are a lot of people who have looked at this and said, okay, well, this is observational data. What do we think is in the milk? What could possibly be in the milk in this farm milk?
56:36 Speaker 05 That's, that's contributing to this.
56:38 Speaker 06 Yeah.
56:38 Speaker 05 And so the, one of the big hypotheses is that it's the ratio of fat types. So like farm milk seems to have a higher proportion of omega-3 fatty acids compared to omega-6 fatty acids. This is so detailed, Erin.
56:57 Speaker 05 Now, why is that? Is that changed with pasteurization? Like, all of these are still open questions.
57:02 Speaker 06 And what is homogenization also? What role does that?
57:04 Speaker 05 What role does that play? I don't know. I haven't seen any papers on it. I will say there was a study from 2017 that looked into the same association in the United States.
57:13 Speaker 06 Okay.
57:13 Speaker 05 And they did not find a significant protective effect of raw cow's milk on the development of asthma, allergies, or any other atopic diseases in the US. That's just one study.
57:24 Speaker 06 Right.
57:25 Speaker 05 But even if this is true, there is no evidence whatsoever that you can cure allergies or asthma or eczema by using raw milk. That is how it is interpreted, and that is just not true.
57:39 Speaker 06 Yikes, okay.
57:40 Speaker 05 Period.
57:41 Speaker 06 Yeah, that's dangerous.
57:43 Speaker 05 And the problem is, all of this data is that exposing kids to farm milk, much of which is raw, early in life, is what confers the protection. And we know that kids, especially young kids, are the highest risk for severe outcomes from milkborne disease.
58:04 Speaker 06 Yeah.
58:06 Speaker 05 So.
58:09 Speaker 05 This is messy. But this is also, like, what I want to point out is that this is what so many of these disinformation campaigns do, and they do it so effectively. They will take this finding that unprocessed farm milk consumption in children under five in Europe might be associated with a decreased odds of developing childhood asthma, and amplify that without any nuance, without any context, and lead to a claim that raw milk will cure your asthma.
58:44 Speaker 06 Right. That, from, from that to raw milk cures asthma is, is such a leap that, and a dangerous one at that.
58:53 Speaker 05 Yeah. And it's not, so that's straight up not true.
58:57 Speaker 06 Yeah.
58:57 Speaker 05 But even if this association is true, it's not an either or. Farm milk may decrease the odds of developing allergies or asthma, and it definitely increases the risk of milkborne infection by, what? Eight hundred and forty times, probably?
59:11 Speaker 06 Eight hundred and forty times, yeah.
59:13 Speaker 05 So I think that the conclusion that I want to come to is that there may be some, as yet not well described, people are still looking into it, features of relatively unprocessed, non-homogenized, non-skimmed, maybe even non-pasteurized milk, that for some children might reduce the odds that they develop atopic diseases later in life. At this point, based on all of this data, we don't know if it is pasteurization that is like negating that effect, that is blunting this effect.
59:47 Speaker 06 Right.
59:48 Speaker 05 We do know that pasteurization is the one and best tool that we have to reduce the risk that your kid, it's really sick or dies from the milk that they're drinking.
59:59 Speaker 06 Yeah.
1:00:01 Speaker 05 The end, Erin.
1:00:02 Speaker 06 The end. It is, I feel like the hygiene hypothesis is so attractive because it seems to answer so many questions. It's like, oh, well, that's, that's the problem of our modern society. That's what happened. And it's just, it's a really, it's a really catchy hypothesis, but it just is not, does not seem to be very well supported.
1:00:27 Speaker 05 Well, I will also say, people have, because the hygiene hypothesis is more specifically like, oh, the number and diversity of microbes and stuff like that. And like, there isn't, in these papers that have looked at like, what is it in the milk? There's no evidence that it's the bacteria in the milk that are protecting you from atopic diseases. If anything, it's maybe these like, micro RNA is another hypothesis, and/or the fat, like, you know, distributions and like ratios. And that likely is way more influenced by what your cows are eating, and how much, and how old they are, and how much milk are they producing, and like, all of that kind of stuff, than it is from pasteurization, because the effects of pasteurization itself on fat content are very minimal.
1:01:05 Speaker 06 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
1:01:09 Speaker 06 That was an excellent deep dive, Erin.
1:01:11 Speaker 05 Thank you.
1:01:14 Speaker 05 I was so like, I, I, yeah, thank you. I'm really glad that you enjoyed it.
1:01:19 Speaker 06 No, of course. I mean, first of all, I always do. Second of all, I, I really didn't, like, there's so much out there. And, you know, and we, we both talked about like, watching various TikToks to be like, okay, what is, what's the vibe?
1:01:32 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:01:33 Speaker 06 What's going on? What are people saying? And I think that the most frustrating thing, which again, is parallel to our episodes on vaccines, when we've talked about with vaccines, is that people want to be healthier. They want to do, to make the right decisions.
1:01:48 Speaker 05 Right.
1:01:48 Speaker 06 And so there is a very understandable, I think, psychology of, if I change this one thing, then my whole life will be different. And that's a very attractive idea, but it's not. It's not the reality, just in the way that like something like the rise in asthma and allergies overall is not going to be readily explained by one
1:02:09 Speaker 05 Single thing.
1:02:10 Speaker 06 factor, right? And so I think it's, um, I think it's really important to go into the nuance.
1:02:18 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:02:18 Speaker 06 Especially, and, and I think what's really, what's really challenging about all of that is that there is not room in short form.
1:02:27 Speaker 05 No.
1:02:27 Speaker 06 Videos to go into that nuance.
1:02:29 Speaker 05 No.
1:02:30 Speaker 06 And so the conclusion just gets presented
1:02:32 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:02:33 Speaker 06 as fact.
1:02:34 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:02:34 Speaker 06 When it is a false.
1:02:36 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:02:36 Speaker 06 Entirely.
1:02:37 Speaker 05 Well, and the other thing that I see a lot of online and it's very compelling is it's, it's a bunch of firsthand accounts, right? And we know because we use them in our podcast that firsthand accounts are very compelling and they're an important part of the story. But when you see over and over again firsthand accounts of people saying, I could never tolerate milk, I could never drink it and I switched to raw milk and now everything is better.
1:03:01 Speaker 06 Right.
1:03:01 Speaker 05 And I feel better and I look better and I'm, everything is better. And I, like, I don't want to negate somebody's personal experience. And at the same time, we know that raw milk is significantly higher risk. And what else is different about either other things that you changed in your diet at the same time or about this other things going on in that milk besides just the pasteurization process?
1:03:25 Speaker 06 Right.
1:03:25 Speaker 05 Why do we have to demonize the thing that has prevented so many kids from dying? I'm sorry, but like.
1:03:33 Speaker 06 Oh, no, absolutely. And also just the, the power of hope.
1:03:37 Speaker 05 I know.
1:03:38 Speaker 06 I know.
1:03:39 Speaker 05 Well, I've got lots of sources to back up everything that I said and also so that everybody can read more. Do your own research, as they say.
1:03:49 Speaker 05 There was a really great overview, actually, that I loved by Lucy in 2015 called Raw Milk Consumption Risks and Benefits from the Journal Nutrition Today. Really just like sums up everything that I went over. The paper that looked at the actually comparing risks of raw versus unpasteurized milk directly.
1:04:11 Speaker 05 Was from emerging infectious diseases from 2017. And that was titled outbreak-related disease burden associated with conception of unpasteurized cows' milk and cheese, United States, 2009 to 2014. There was, I mean, just countless others. So you can find the sources from this episode and every single one of our episodes on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com.
1:04:36 Speaker 06 Thank you so much to Blood Mobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes. Totally forgot where I was in the outro here.
1:04:45 Speaker 05 Thank you to Tom and Leanna and Brent and Pete and everybody on the audio and video, editing and mixing teams. We love you guys.
1:04:53 Speaker 06 Thank you to all of these teams at Exactly Right. And thank you to you listeners for listening and watching now. Weird. Still, hi.
1:05:06 Speaker 06 Let us know what you think and send us your recommendations for other topics to cover. We, you know, we're really leading into this these days.
1:05:14 Speaker 05 Yeah, we are. We are. It's fun. And thank you, as always, to our patrons. Your support means so, so, so much to us. We really, we really appreciate it.
1:05:22 Speaker 06 We do. We do. Until next time, wash your hands.
1:05:26 Speaker 05 You filthy animals.
1:05:54 Speaker 05 Dry hands can be uncomfortable and frustrating, especially when frequent hand washing, changing weather, and everyday wear and tear take their toll. O'Keefe's Working Hands is here to help keep dry hands feeling hydrated and comfortable. O'Keefe's Working Hands creates a soothing barrier on the skin that locks in moisture and prevents further dryness. It's concentrated and non-greasy, and you start to feel relief in one use. Go to okeefescompany.com to get yours today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
1:06:27 Speaker 02 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
1:06:35 Speaker 03 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
1:06:43 Speaker 02 Oh, that's actually really simple.
1:06:46 Speaker 03 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at B of A dot com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
1:06:56 Speaker 09 This is Colin Cowherd from the Colin Cowherd Podcast. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota Fordability. All starts with a great deal on an off-road ready Tacoma or a half-ton Tundra to a Toyota's most capable and longest-lasting trucks. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. For a great deal today to a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com. Toyota, let's go places.
Previous Ep 174 What’s the deal with raw milk: Part 1 Next Special Episode: Dr. Adam Ratner & Booster Shots Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated