Pod Insights This Podcast Will Kill You Ep 170 Pregnancy: Act 3 About this episode Content Warning: This episode includes mentions of miscarriage, pregnancy loss, pregnancy complications, traumatic birth experiences, and other potentially disturbing topics related to childbirth, pregnancy, and the postpartum period.
In Act 3 of our pregnancy series, we arrive at the big moment: childbirth. We begin the episode with a closer look at one of the most commonly performed surgeries around the world: the cesarean section. Exploring how this procedure went from rare to everywhere reveals some of the larger medical trends shaping the childbirth experience in nuanced ways. Then, we take a step back to ask “what is actually happening in labor?” Journeying through the labor and delivery process contraction by contraction gives us the opportunity to examine what is happening in our bodies during this crucial time and how things might not go according to plan.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 21,104 words · 8 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 This is exactly right.
0:07 Speaker 01 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
0:15 Speaker 02 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
0:23 Speaker 01 Oh, that's actually really simple.
0:26 Speaker 02 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at B of A dot com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
0:37 Speaker 03 Hey, I'm Niall Rogers. This fall, I'll be driving across the country, meeting some of today's coolest and most fascinating artists. We'll explore the stories before the moments that changed everything. Because every musician remembers the moment where it all began. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:08 Speaker 04 We want to start with a disclaimer that throughout this series, we feature explanations and stories that include some heavy material, including early pregnancy loss, stillbirth, and other traumatic experiences of pregnancy, childbirth, and the postpartum period.
1:25 Speaker 05 Hi, my name's Catherine, and I'm really excited to share my birth story with you guys. I had a totally healthy, totally normal pregnancy. Nothing was wrong. There was no inclination that anything was gonna be, you know, different about my baby when she was born.
1:42 Speaker 05 I come from a line of moderately tall people with an outlier, my brother being six foot seven. He is the tallest person in my entire family, and we don't really know where it came from. So, you know, I was very curious to know how big my baby was gonna be. And I had asked around my 36-week appointment if they had any idea how big she was gonna be. I'd been measuring normal my entire pregnancy. And they said, you know, it's kind of hard to tell unless there's something very abnormal, like she's very small or very large. It's kind of a surprise how big they're gonna be within that, you know, like, six to eight-pound range that babies usually are. And I was very large when I went into labor. Um, I went into labor at forty weeks and five days. So, um, I just thought I was really, really pregnant.
2:23 Speaker 05 Um, I didn't think anything of it, but when they started doing cervical checks while I was in labor, the doctor told me that he, he was feeling what he thought was going to be a nine pound baby. And I said, excuse me, because I had no idea I was going to have that big of a baby like I had even asked. Um, and I did fail my first glucose check when we were doing them during pregnancy, but I passed the second three hour test. So they weren't really concerned. I was never diagnosed with gestational diabetes. So you can imagine my surprise. Um, you know, I'm dilating and I'm getting an epidural and, um, everything was going really normal. Um, I pushed for almost four hours and I started just getting really fatigued. Uh, my epidural was kind of wearing off and it wasn't really working that well. So the doctor suggested setting up for a vacuum assist delivery,
3:06 Speaker 05 which is where they literally use a suction cup to suction to the baby's head to help you pull them out. And there's some complications that can come with that. So, you know, they brought in some extra hands and it was a little nerve wracking. Um, and I was actually able to push her out on my very last push before they were going to start the vacuum assist. Everybody was all in their sterile field and everything, and I was able to push her out. And I ended up having a ten pound, point zero one ounce baby girl, who was a ninety six percentile for weight and ninety first percentile for height. And to this day, she's three and a half and she's still at the very top of her growth curve. She's probably almost forty five pounds and she's over three feet tall. She's a very tall girl. Um, so we're going to be really excited to see how tall she ends up, the older she gets.
3:48 Speaker 05 But that's my birth story about how I almost had a vacuum assist and a surprise ten pound baby.
3:55 Speaker 06 Hi, I'm Nicole C. and this is my birth story. I had a pretty uneventful pregnancy. My water broke two days before my due date. I did everything I could to avoid birth drama. I chose the best hospital for me. I researched my rights. I took the hospital's classes. I hired a doula and I made a birth plan that I gave out to absolutely everyone. But none of that was enough in the end. My baby was angled wrong. Even as I dilated and progressed, she would not ascend into the birth canal. Ultimately, she began to struggle. As I later learned, she had meconium aspiration syndrome, or MIS.
4:35 Speaker 06 After twenty seven hours of labor, I had no choice but to undergo a C-section. Exhausted, scared, and devastated, I was ripped away from my husband and doula and wheeled into the operating room. During the C-section, I had my support people back, but still felt in the dark. I had no idea what was happening down there at any given stage and was wholly unprepared for my current reality. After a few minutes, my baby, my Katie, emerged, purple and with an iron grip on the umbilical cord. There was no crying. They rushed her over to a separate area in the corner of the room. I had a video monitor where I could watch them work on her as my team continued to work on me.
5:19 Speaker 06 After a few minutes, she was rushed off to the NICU. My husband went with her. It was basically my worst nightmare of birth. Thankfully, after some initial help breathing and five days in the NICU, Katie came home, healthy, strong, and loud. She's nine months old now and absolutely thriving. Even once I knew she was okay, though, I continued to grieve for the birth experience I imagined, for the initial bonding time I'd missed, for my baby's first cry, for the opportunity to share that experience with my husband. I felt like I failed, like I should have done more. I think the rhetoric around C-sections definitely contributed to my birth trauma and feelings of failure.
6:02 Speaker 06 All I heard ahead of time about them was how they're done way too much these days and how you should challenge doctors who recommend them or even consider switching OBs. In many cases, C-section discussion was sidestepped at every turn. It was like, don't worry about that or think about it too much. It's super unlikely you'll need one and it's best not to scare yourself thinking about it. As if I was some delicate flower wholly unequipped to hear anything that wasn't sunshine and rainbows, instead of an adult human who, best-case scenario, was about to go through vaginal labor and delivery. I wish I had fought through the patronizing rhetoric,
6:42 Speaker 06 did more C-section research, and prepared myself for any possibility. Knowledge is empowering. Just as fat is best in the breastfeeding versus formula discussion, safe and healthy is best in the vaginal delivery versus C-section discussion. Every case, every birthing parent, and every baby is different. Every route to birth is valid. We all did the hardest thing. Don't let anybody, even your own brain, tell you you failed.
7:55 Speaker 04 Thank you all so much for sharing your stories with us. It really, truly means the world. And thank you to everyone who submitted a firsthand account. We really did read each and every one of them. And we feel honored, like it feels truly unbelievable and in the best way possible that so many people reached out to us. And we tried to include as many stories as we could. And so throughout this episode and the next episode, the last episode in our series, you will hear more firsthand accounts. Yeah. Thank you.
8:25 Speaker 07 Seriously, so much to every single one of you for writing in. So many of you sent in your stories that you recorded that we weren't able to include. And we, we are eternally grateful. They, they really do mean the world to us and we listened to and read every single one. So, thank you.
8:40 Speaker 04 Eternally grateful is, yeah.
8:42 Speaker 07 It's an accurate summation.
8:43 Speaker 04 Yeah, very accurate. Hi, I'm Erin Welsh.
8:46 Speaker 07 And I'm Erin Allmann Updyke.
8:48 Speaker 04 And this is, this podcast will kill you.
8:50 Speaker 07 Coming to you from the Exactly Right Studios to record this third episode about pregnancy.
8:58 Speaker 04 I know.
8:59 Speaker 07 In our four-episode series.
9:00 Speaker 04 Uh, it's been really fun so far.
9:03 Speaker 07 I've loved it.
9:04 Speaker 04 And the fact that we're doing this on video is really cool, too.
9:07 Speaker 07 Still makes me want to barf.
9:08 Speaker 04 Because also, we get some props.
9:09 Speaker 07 Yes!
9:10 Speaker 04 Which is really, really fun. So, if you are like wanting to see what's going on when we're talking.
9:16 Speaker 07 Yeah.
9:17 Speaker 04 Uh, which if you don't, that's okay, too. But if you do, head to YouTube.
9:20 Speaker 07 Head to YouTube. I have some really good props for this episode, guys. I made them myself.
9:27 Speaker 04 She hit the last episode, too.
9:28 Speaker 07 I did.
9:28 Speaker 04 There's the tennis ball.
9:30 Speaker 07 Yeah. No, that was the first episode.
9:31 Speaker 04 Oh, my God.
9:32 Speaker 07 Actually, I know. It was a lot.
9:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
9:34 Speaker 07 Last episode was the placenta. It was great.
9:36 Speaker 04 Oh, the placenta.
9:38 Speaker 07 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
9:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, that was good. Okay.
9:40 Speaker 07 So, it's gonna be a fun day today, Erin.
9:42 Speaker 04 It is. And before we get into the episode, we want to share a few words about what these four episodes will cover more broadly. And if you've already tuned in to our first or second episode in this series, this is all gonna sound familiar to you. But in case this is your first time tuning in, welcome. And we've got a few things that we want to share. So, we're gonna talk about what we will cover in each of these episodes, the language that we'll be using, and our overall goals with creating this series. So, we decided early on to dedicate four episodes to cover pregnancy, one for each trimester, which is like very few episodes for such a tremendously huge topic.
10:21 Speaker 07 Yeah.
10:22 Speaker 04 And, yeah, we, we realized very early on that we're not gonna be able to cover everything that we would possibly want to with pregnancy. And so, throughout researching for these episodes, we started to jot down like, oh, we want to cover this in a future episode and cover that. And so- So if there are topics that you want more information on, please reach out.
10:40 Speaker 07 Yeah.
10:41 Speaker 04 We'll add them to our list, our ever-growing list, and we will be covering more pregnancy-related topics in the future.
10:47 Speaker 07 Yeah, for sure.
10:48 Speaker 04 Yeah.
10:49 Speaker 07 This series has not, and it will not, by the end, answer every single question that you could have about pregnancy, or cover every experience that a person might have during their pregnancy, in large part because pregnancy is such an individual experience, as you heard from all of our firsthand accounts. But what we aim to do with this whole series is take you through some of the broad changes that people might experience during pregnancy, childbirth, which is what we're talking about today, and the postpartum period, which will be next week's episode. And then also explore some of the historical and evolutionary aspects of pregnancy and childbirth. So each episode thus far has roughly corresponded to each trimester.
11:31 Speaker 04 Very roughly, but...
11:32 Speaker 07 Very roughly. In our first episode, we covered how you even know whether or not you're pregnant, and what that means, and what's happening in very early embryonic development.
11:44 Speaker 04 And our most recent episode, last episode, our second episode, we talked about the amazing organ that is the placenta.
11:52 Speaker 07 We love it. Do you love it now? Have you listened to that episode?
11:56 Speaker 04 If you, once you do, you will love it.
11:58 Speaker 07 You will love it. I feel confident in that.
11:59 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
12:00 Speaker 07 Yeah.
12:01 Speaker 04 I agree.
12:01 Speaker 07 It's pretty phenomenal.
12:03 Speaker 04 And then we also talked about some of these broad system body changes that happen during pregnancy, system by system, and including focusing on some complications that can arise.
12:13 Speaker 07 Which I guess might make you not like the placenta a little bit, too.
12:17 Speaker 04 It's a complicated, you know, we have complicated feelings about the placenta. But we also appreciate its amazingness.
12:24 Speaker 07 Its amazingness.
12:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
12:25 Speaker 07 Definitely. Today's episode, which we're very excited about, will focus on childbirth itself. So labor and different modes of delivery, and the history of the cesarean section. Erin.
12:37 Speaker 04 Oh, my gosh, there is so much to cover.
12:39 Speaker 07 I'm literally so excited.
12:41 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. Okay, our fourth episode, which is next week. And it's our season finale. This will be about the concept of the fourth trimester, which is a really fascinating topic. And so we're going to be exploring some of the changes that can happen after pregnancy and talking this big picture history of how we moved childbirth from the home to hospital and some of the consequences of that.
13:09 Speaker 07 We intend for all of these episodes to be inclusive of all families. And we recognize that not everyone who experiences pregnancy identifies as a woman. So we try as much as we can in all of these episodes to use gender neutral language, such as pregnant person. While at the same time, we recognize that much of what we discuss when it comes to medical bias during pregnancy and childbirth, historically and in present day, is a result of gender discrimination and racism. So in those contexts, we may also use the term woman or women. And throughout these episodes, we'll be using terms like mother or maternal and paternal, as these are what are used in the scientific and medical literature.
13:46 Speaker 04 We also want to acknowledge that there is no such thing as a normal pregnancy.
13:51 Speaker 07 There's not just one.
13:52 Speaker 04 There's not just one. There's not just one textbook example of this is how a pregnancy should go. But we also want to provide a baseline for the expected changes that happen, the expected physiologic and anatomic changes, so that we can understand when things kind of maybe go outside of those boundaries and then what happens. And this kind of helps us to understand what complication actually means.
14:15 Speaker 07 Right, exactly. Okay, that was a lot.
14:18 Speaker 04 That was a lot.
14:19 Speaker 07 All of our disclaimers and information and...
14:22 Speaker 04 Thanks for, thanks for sticking with us throughout that.
14:26 Speaker 07 I'm really excited about today, but first...
14:28 Speaker 04 But first, I almost forgot, Erin. I was like, let's get started.
14:33 Speaker 07 It's quarantine time.
14:34 Speaker 04 It is. What are we drinking this week?
14:36 Speaker 07 We're drinking the same thing.
14:37 Speaker 04 We are.
14:38 Speaker 07 Great expectation. We're not actually drinking it right now, but we have drunk it.
14:42 Speaker 04 It is so good.
14:43 Speaker 07 It is better than we expected.
14:46 Speaker 04 We can't reveal our secrets, our lack of confidence in our recipe making.
14:52 Speaker 07 It is very good, and we made a placebo burrito with blackberry, ginger ale, lemon, mint. There's a video on YouTube of us making it, which was very fun to make.
15:05 Speaker 04 It was really fun. It was really fun.
15:07 Speaker 07 And Georgia Hardstark provided a wonderful Quarantini for us to go with this episode. So that is available on YouTube.
15:15 Speaker 04 The Auntini.
15:16 Speaker 07 The Auntini, it has a name now.
15:17 Speaker 04 It's very cute. Oh, my God, it was so much fun.
15:20 Speaker 07 It was really fun.
15:20 Speaker 04 Yeah, so you can find recipes, you can find those videos on YouTube, and we'll also have recipes on our social media. So make sure you're following us there, as well as our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com.
15:31 Speaker 07 It's the third time in a row you've sent it to me.
15:33 Speaker 04 I can say what's on our website.
15:35 Speaker 07 Let me do it. Ready? On our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com, you can find incredible things such as merch. You can find links to our bookshop.org affiliate account and our Goodreads list, which Erin Welsh curates. You can find transcripts from each and every one of our episodes. You can find our Bloodmobile, who does the music for every one of our episodes. Thank you, panicked. You can find a contact us form and a firsthand account form.
16:02 Speaker 04 There's probably more.
16:03 Speaker 07 All of the sources from each and every one of our episodes.
16:05 Speaker 04 Yeah, and there might be more. Tell us what we missed. Go check out our website.
16:09 Speaker 07 Go check out our website.
16:11 Speaker 04 Be like, you didn't mention this.
16:12 Speaker 07 I thought you meant me, and I was like, I don't know what I missed, Erin.
16:17 Speaker 04 Thispodcastwillkillyou.com.
16:19 Speaker 07 Also, a thing I always forget to do is thank you to everyone who has rated and reviewed us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or wherever you like to listen. If you haven't and you want to take a minute to do that, we'd really appreciate it because it helps us out. Thanks for listening.
16:34 Speaker 04 Thanks for listening.
16:35 Speaker 07 Let's stop talking so that we can start talking.
16:38 Speaker 04 I love that plan. Let's take a quick break and then we'll really get started.
16:45 Speaker 03 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by my friend, John Legend. How does music actually enter your mind?
17:07 Speaker 01 I'm not sure why or how the music comes to me, but I think people who love music and write music, our brains are just filled with music.
17:16 Speaker 03 Right.
17:17 Speaker 01 Like, we have listened to so much music. We've been a part of so much music. I think of the story that I want to tell and the mood that I want to create with the music, start playing chords, see where they lead me.
17:28 Speaker 03 Sometimes, I'm just not even thinking about music, right? And I hear this little thing, and I go, oh, that could be this.
17:38 Speaker 01 You know, you just have to be ready for when the inspiration hits.
17:41 Speaker 03 And it comes.
17:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:42 Speaker 03 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeart Radio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
17:53 Speaker 01 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
18:01 Speaker 02 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
18:09 Speaker 01 Oh, that's actually really simple.
18:12 Speaker 02 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at bofa.com/simplebanking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
18:37 Speaker 06 Hi, I'm Laura, and this is my pregnancy story. To begin, we've got to rewind briefly to April 2018. I was 27 and diagnosed with HER2-positive breast cancer. I didn't really have the time or funds to do any fertility preservation, so I opted to take a monthly shock to try to preserve my fertility, which put me into essentially early menopause. I took chemo through the summer and fall and then opted for a double mastectomy that October. I got the news from my doctor that Halloween that I I was cancer free. Part of me sometimes wishes I'd kept my breast tissue, but ultimately I wanted to be here for any future children and not worry about a recurrence, especially given my family history. Fast forward to October of 2021, we're in the thick of COVID. I found out I was pregnant.
19:19 Speaker 06 I didn't have the typical pre-pregnancy symptoms like sore breasts that prompt some people to take a test. I had some mild nausea and was so tired and my period was a little late, so I took a test and it was super positive. Other than the morning sickness that went away sometime during my second trimester, luckily I had a really smooth pregnancy and I felt my most beautiful during that time. Funny enough, I didn't get any of the stereotypical cravings of pickles and peanut butter or other weird food concoctions, but I really wanted turkey sub and fruits and veggies. Honestly, I've never eaten so healthy in my life. Along the way, I encountered some judgment from people when I requested no breastfeeding supplies at my baby shower. For those that didn't know, I didn't have real bloops anymore. It didn't make sense to them why I wouldn't at least try to breastfeed my baby.
20:02 Speaker 06 So that's sort of one thing I wish I could bond with other moms over, but ultimately I'm happy with my decision. So now it's July 5th, 2022. I'm thirty nine weeks pregnant. It's 11:00 PM and I'd finally laid down for bed after nesting and cleaning my whole house that day. Even being sick with COVID, I'd just tested positive the day before. I got up because I felt the urge to pee and in true dramatic fashion, just like the movies, my water broke in a huge gush. Of course, my hospital bag wasn't packed, so I frantically finished packing and headed for the hospital. I was checked in pretty immediately and in a labor room by midnight. Because both my partner and I were positive for COVID, we were quarantined to our room. And we were in masks the whole time. Side note, it's not easy or fun to breathe through contractions without a mask on. I did my whole labor that way for nearly thirty hours.
20:48 Speaker 06 Then it was time to push and it's not fast like the movies. I pushed for almost four hours, which felt like an eternity. Masks on, hard to breathe. My daughter was born at 2:38 in the morning on July 7th. She's my lucky seven, seven post-cancer miracle baby. Today, my daughter's two and a half and one wild redhead little girl. I'm six years cancer free and we're living our best life.
21:10 Speaker 06 My name is Jayden and I found out I was pregnant in January of 2024. Overall, it was a very normal. Pregnancy. However, at week twenty, I started to measure on the high end of normal for my amniotic fluid. My baby was measuring large, so we decided to set an induction date for thirty nine weeks. However, a week after that, there was a large increase in amniotic fluid, so we elected to schedule an induction for thirty eight weeks for polyhydroamnios. The biggest worry was that I would go into labor naturally and there was a possibility of umbilical cord prolapse, which would then be an emergency. After my induction was started, I made no progress for about fourteen hours.
21:51 Speaker 06 Because there was so much fluid, my baby was not able to exert enough pressure on my cervix to help advance labor. My waters were then manually broken and my labor started to progress. I labored that way for eighteen hours and was finally ready to push. I pushed for one and a half hours and made some great progress. The next one and a half hours, I made no progress and my baby was still at the same position. Because of this failure to descend and she was not yet in distress, we decided to go in for a C-section. The C-section was uncomplicated and my baby girl was born at thirty eight weeks and two days at seven pounds fifteen ounces. She is now a very healthy four and a half month old.
23:02 Speaker 04 Childbirth in humans is difficult. It is long, it is painful, it carries with it significant risks to mother and baby. Afterbirth comes with its own set of challenges. Caring for a newborn that is largely helpless can be overwhelming.
23:18 Speaker 07 Largely is an understatement. They are entirely helpless.
23:22 Speaker 04 Entirely helpless. And these human experiences are exceptional compared to most, but not all, other mammalian or primate species. Why?
23:32 Speaker 07 Why?
23:33 Speaker 04 What did we do to deserve this? Why is it like this? Looking at the fossil record may give us part of the answer. So the story goes that our hominin ancestors evolved bipedalism, being able to move around on two feet rather than four. Why? I just keep going, why, why, why?
23:50 Speaker 07 Yeah.
23:50 Speaker 04 But why? Because maybe it allowed us to live in more varied habitats or acquire more varied food sources or it freed up our hands for tool use. There's many different ideas out there. But regardless of the reason, the shift to walking on two legs could only happen because of changes in the shape of our pelvis.
24:09 Speaker 07 Our pelvis, Aaron.
24:10 Speaker 04 Our pelvis. And at some point, after these anatomical changes, head size in our ancestors also grew as we got smarter.
24:18 Speaker 07 After, after these pelvis changes?
24:20 Speaker 04 After the pelvis changes.
24:22 Speaker 07 Okay, okay.
24:22 Speaker 04 And so that led to neonates with heads and bodies that were basically at the limit of the birth canal. But there was a cap on this growth in head and body size prenatally. Our pelvises could only change up to a certain point. Past that point, additional alterations could maybe compromise our bipedalism.
24:42 Speaker 07 They affect our fitness somehow.
24:44 Speaker 04 Affect our fitness, yeah. I mean, it's like, could, if we needed the pelvis to expand, then we would lose the ability to like the balance and the movement and the running. You know, it's like, yeah.
24:53 Speaker 07 Trade offs.
24:53 Speaker 04 Trade offs. It's the theme. We always come back to it. And so instead, evolution had to think outside of the box, shifting some parts of fetal growth to take place outside of the womb rather than in it, such as brain growth and neurodevelopment.
25:09 Speaker 07 I love thinking of evolution in this very inaccurate way of giving it like an agency.
25:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, oh, no, I know. I think evolutionary biologists are like, what are you doing?
25:20 Speaker 07 Sorry.
25:20 Speaker 04 Evolution does not have agencies. Yeah, yeah. But I mean, that's, that is how I'm going to present it.
25:26 Speaker 07 I love it.
25:27 Speaker 04 So, yeah, that's, you know.
25:28 Speaker 07 It's, it's a good way to just think, like, in your mind, frame it.
25:31 Speaker 04 It's just, yeah.
25:32 Speaker 07 It's fine.
25:33 Speaker 04 The end result is the same.
25:34 Speaker 07 Exactly.
25:34 Speaker 04 This is what happened.
25:35 Speaker 07 This is what happened.
25:37 Speaker 04 And but this long period of neurodevelopment after birth might be what allows us to learn more and have flexibility in our learning.
25:45 Speaker 07 Okay.
25:45 Speaker 04 So at birth, the brain size of a neonate is about 25% of what it'll be as an adult.
25:51 Speaker 07 Wow.
25:52 Speaker 04 Which is the smallest neonate adult proportion of all primates.
25:56 Speaker 07 Like, it is, oh, of all primates?
25:58 Speaker 04 Of all primates.
25:59 Speaker 07 Okay, interesting, interesting.
26:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
26:01 Speaker 07 So other primates, their brains come out already bigger?
26:03 Speaker 04 Already bigger compared to their adult brain size.
26:06 Speaker 07 Okay, interesting.
26:07 Speaker 04 And compared to other primates, our newborns seem especially helpless.
26:11 Speaker 07 I know.
26:12 Speaker 04 We can't cling, we can't hold our heads up, we can't coordinate our limbs, we can't even crawl for months.
26:18 Speaker 07 I know.
26:18 Speaker 04 Months.
26:19 Speaker 07 And you think of like the baby monkeys who can just go and then hold on so well.
26:24 Speaker 04 Yeah.
26:24 Speaker 07 And ours can just do this palmar grasp reflex. And you're like, thank you.
26:28 Speaker 04 Yeah, good job. You're working hard.
26:31 Speaker 07 I know. We do work hard.
26:33 Speaker 04 That's true. Some researchers suggest that to match the developmental stage of other apes right after birth, humans would have gestation seven to 12 months longer than our nine-month gestation.
26:45 Speaker 07 No, thank you.
26:46 Speaker 04 There is some current debate on this point.
26:48 Speaker 07 Okay.
26:48 Speaker 04 Like, yeah, there's nuance, there's papers.
26:51 Speaker 07 Okay.
26:51 Speaker 04 You can dig into it. Evolution seems to have handed us this trade-off, where we get to have these big brains, but we're also faced with the challenges of childbirth, where the neonate is at the capacity of our birth canal and requires round-the-clock care for months after birth. This is a precarious balance to strike
27:10 Speaker 07 Yeah.
27:10 Speaker 04 with extremely high costs if things go awry. How have we dealt with this over human history?
27:17 Speaker 07 Tell me.
27:17 Speaker 04 One way is through cooperation.
27:19 Speaker 07 Ah.
27:20 Speaker 04 I know.
27:20 Speaker 07 Humans and our cooperation. We are capable of it.
27:26 Speaker 04 We were capable of it. No, just kidding. I hope. Our hominin ancestors, like many of our present-day primate relatives, exhibited cooperative breeding and culture.
27:37 Speaker 04 Did our helpless babies lead us to evolve this cooperation? Or did we already have this type of culture and that allowed for the evolution of more helpless babies?
27:46 Speaker 07 Interesting.
27:46 Speaker 04 We don't know. We probably won't ever know that answer. But what is certain is that many societies today have lost that cooperative child rearing. Some researchers have suggested that we feel this helplessness in human infants so strongly because of the way that many of us experience child rearing in our modern society, often isolated, with the burden of care falling to one or two people. This is far removed from how our ancestors would have experienced child rearing in a cooperative social group. Childbirth was the same way, attended by other members of your group. Like, who knows how long women have been assisting other women in childbirth? But one paper I read suggested that when our species developed language,
28:30 Speaker 04 that helped to pave the way for assisted childbirth. We could communicate our pain, our needs, and then pass down the knowledge that we acquired.
28:39 Speaker 07 Oh, interesting.
28:40 Speaker 04 Yeah. Today, that kind of community involvement for child rearing seems more of a rarity. And when it's just you or you and one other person continuously on call to take care of a newborn, that may emphasize the never-ending needs of that newborn. Okay, the second thing is how we've dealt with the dangers of childbirth historically.
29:01 Speaker 07 Yeah.
29:02 Speaker 04 There's no disputing that labor and delivery can be extremely dangerous for both mother and baby, even with all of our modern medical advancements and technologies. Is that how it's always been? That's a really difficult question to answer, it turns out.
29:16 Speaker 07 I have thought about this so, so, so much for so many years now.
29:22 Speaker 04 I know.
29:22 Speaker 07 That I wish that we could know.
29:26 Speaker 04 We can know some things.
29:27 Speaker 07 Okay, tell me.
29:27 Speaker 04 Yeah, so the historical data on this subject are limited, to say the least, and they're complicated by several factors, including the effect that medicine has had on maternal and neonatal mortality, which is not, has not been always in a positive direction.
29:43 Speaker 07 Right.
29:44 Speaker 04 For instance, in the 19th century, as more male physicians attended childbirth after receiving little, if any, education in obstetrics, as people moved to crowded cities, as more women gave birth in hospitals, infectious disease became a leading driver of maternal and perinatal mortality.
29:59 Speaker 07 Right, and we talk a lot about that in our episode on...
30:03 Speaker 04 Semmelweis and people fever.
30:05 Speaker 07 Yeah, yeah. I was like, which episode was that? Because I know we covered it in detail.
30:09 Speaker 04 It was like a long time ago.
30:11 Speaker 07 Yeah.
30:12 Speaker 04 But the specter of infectious disease during childbirth may be a more recent development, relatively speaking. Some researchers have suggested that early in our evolutionary history, birth might not have been as dangerous, but following the agricultural revolution around 20,000 years ago, there was more overnutrition. And then that could lead to babies with heads and bodies straining the limits of the birth canal.
30:34 Speaker 07 Interesting. So it used to just be that if we were limited by nutrition, then you're huh?
30:39 Speaker 04 I mean, maybe.
30:39 Speaker 07 Maybe.
30:40 Speaker 04 Maybe. Who knows? Yeah.
30:41 Speaker 07 Okay.
30:42 Speaker 04 The Industrial Revolution in the 18th and 19th centuries may have contributed to difficult childbirth in other ways. For instance, rickets caused by vitamin D deficiency. See our vitamin D episode. But the rickets can often lead to skeletal changes that decreased pelvis size and made it even more challenging for a baby to go through birth canal.
31:02 Speaker 07 Ah, okay.
31:03 Speaker 04 The WHO today roughly estimates that 5% of births with labor starting spontaneously develop complications.
31:12 Speaker 07 Okay.
31:12 Speaker 04 5%.
31:13 Speaker 07 5%.
31:14 Speaker 04 Birth records from a late 18th century midwife, Martha Ballard, the book, The Diary of a Midwife, it's based on her story, is incredible, suggested that 5.6% of births that she attended were difficult.
31:28 Speaker 07 Interesting.
31:29 Speaker 04 That 5% number for difficult labor or delivery pops up elsewhere throughout the 18th and 19th centuries until medical intervention increased, at which point then difficult increased as well.
31:41 Speaker 07 Okay.
31:42 Speaker 04 And it's not clear what that 5% complications rate means for maternal or neonatal mortality historically.
31:48 Speaker 07 Like, how does it? And what is difficult? How's difficult to find?
31:51 Speaker 04 Right. Exactly. Requiring intervention? Then what is requiring intervention? What are the? How do we make those decisions? Yeah.
31:57 Speaker 07 Okay.
31:58 Speaker 04 Yeah. But those historic numbers, and often the ones today, these estimates don't necessarily capture postnatal issues such as like prolapsed uterus or fistulas, something like that, which can be, you know, long-term, permanent changes that are, you know, affect your morbidity over time. But what strikes me Is how different that 5% number is compared to the C-section rate, which here in the US is around 33%.
32:28 Speaker 07 Yep.
32:29 Speaker 04 High, not the highest. Brazil holds that title with 54% of births done by cesarean.
32:34 Speaker 07 Wow.
32:35 Speaker 04 Private hospitals have an 84% C-section rate in Brazil. 84%.
32:39 Speaker 07 84%?
32:41 Speaker 04 Yeah.
32:43 Speaker 07 Wow.
32:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
32:44 Speaker 07 Okay.
32:45 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
32:45 Speaker 07 Okay, keep going.
32:46 Speaker 04 Okay. Complications encompasses a wide range of things. But C-sections are one of the most common medical interventions for complications that arise during labor and delivery. How did this procedure go from being a rarity to one of the most performed surgeries in the US and around the world?
33:04 Speaker 07 Like, period. And that is of all surgeries.
33:07 Speaker 04 Right, including like, tonsillectomies, appendectomies.
33:09 Speaker 07 Knee replacements.
33:10 Speaker 04 Right.
33:13 Speaker 04 How has our attitude towards C-sections changed during that time? From when it was like, a rare thing to commonplace?
33:21 Speaker 07 Super common.
33:22 Speaker 04 Are we doing more C-sections than we should be doing? How do we know?
33:25 Speaker 07 How do you know?
33:26 Speaker 04 The answer to that.
33:26 Speaker 07 Yeah.
33:27 Speaker 04 And so today, I want to take us through the history of C-sections to try to answer some of these questions. And I know that C-sections are not a universal experience, and by talking about C-sections, I am skipping over other important aspects of labor and delivery.
33:39 Speaker 07 I'll get there.
33:40 Speaker 04 But I think, yeah, you'll get there. Perfect. And I think they're an extremely important topic, given how common they are, how much rhetoric there is surrounding C-sections.
33:49 Speaker 07 Yeah.
33:49 Speaker 04 And how, and I think that going through their history can give us some insight into how medicine has treated pregnant women and viewed risk over time.
33:59 Speaker 07 Okay.
34:00 Speaker 04 What risk means.
34:01 Speaker 07 Yeah.
34:01 Speaker 04 What it looks like. This is a nuanced topic with so much amazing scholarship out there. And so I just want to shout out a couple of sources at the beginning, so that you know that there's so much more opportunity to learn more.
34:12 Speaker 07 Yeah.
34:12 Speaker 04 So, one book is called "Cesarean Section: An American History of Risk, Technology, and Consequence." That's by Jacqueline Wolf. And another is called "Invisible Labor: The Untold Story of the Cesarean Section" by Rachel Summerstein.
34:25 Speaker 07 Okay.
34:26 Speaker 04 All right, are we ready to talk about C-sections?
34:27 Speaker 07 I'm literally so excited.
34:29 Speaker 04 I want to start off by describing what happens during a C-section, step by step.
34:35 Speaker 07 Wonderful.
34:36 Speaker 04 So I'm quoting directly from Rachel Summerstein's Invisible Labor here because I thought it was just a phenomenal description and I was like, perfect.
34:42 Speaker 07 Every med student listening that's about to start their OB-GYN rotation is thrilled.
34:47 Speaker 07 Thank you.
34:47 Speaker 04 Here we go. Quote, "An anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist uses spinal anesthesia or an epidural to anesthetize a mother regionally. Then the surgeon uses a scalpel to cut open the abdomen above the Mons pubis, slicing through layers of skin and fat and the fascia that covers the abdominal muscles. The physician parts but does not cut the rectus abdominis muscles, six-pack, with her hands. Then she cuts through the peritoneum, the layer of tissue that contains organs in the abdomen as if in a tightly sealed bag. She moves the bladder aside to reach the uterus, making yet another incision to open it. She presses on the uterus to push out the baby, which is the source of the pressure
35:29 Speaker 04 C-section moms are told they might experience during the operation. Once the baby is born, the surgeon removes the uterus from the patient's body, sometimes lifting it out completely like a bowling ball, to sew it closed. Then she sutures the other layers of the patient's abdominal wall and finally closes the topmost layer." End quote.
35:48 Speaker 07 Yep.
35:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
35:49 Speaker 07 Holy accurate.
35:50 Speaker 04 But like, it's amazing how you just think, like, I feel like most people don't know the step by step.
35:55 Speaker 07 No.
35:56 Speaker 04 Which, what's being cut? In what order? How do you get the placenta out? Like, all these different things.
36:00 Speaker 07 Yeah.
36:01 Speaker 04 Yeah. So.
36:02 Speaker 07 It's also an incredible thing to get to watch.
36:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
36:06 Speaker 07 And experience and be a part of. Like, it is really, really fascinating and interesting and incredible.
36:12 Speaker 04 It's amazing.
36:12 Speaker 07 Yeah.
36:13 Speaker 04 And so this is the way that most C-sections are done today.
36:15 Speaker 07 Most.
36:16 Speaker 04 But this is not how they've always been done.
36:18 Speaker 07 Okay.
36:19 Speaker 04 The earliest record of C-sections that we have dates back over 2,000 years.
36:23 Speaker 07 Okay. Wow.
36:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
36:25 Speaker 07 I feel like those were not good ones.
36:27 Speaker 04 Well, the intention of C-section has changed a lot over time.
36:30 Speaker 07 Okay.
36:31 Speaker 04 So it's clear that from these early and then subsequent ancient descriptions that this procedure was done very rarely and only when the mother had died or was thought beyond saving.
36:41 Speaker 07 Okay.
36:41 Speaker 04 And so it was mostly like a last ditch effort to save the baby or baptize the baby before it died.
36:46 Speaker 07 Okay.
36:46 Speaker 04 Or as a crucial step to prepare the bodies for burial. So mother and baby were often buried separately.
36:52 Speaker 07 Ah, okay.
36:52 Speaker 04 That was sort of part of the steps.
36:54 Speaker 07 Okay.
36:55 Speaker 04 Those babies that did survive were often viewed as gods, as heroes, or as extremely blessed, which is behind the common misconception of where the Caesarian got its name.
37:05 Speaker 07 Hmm, because it's not Julius Caesar.
37:07 Speaker 04 It's not Julius Caesar, yeah. Yeah, so a lot of, a lot of stories go, oh, the Caesarian got its name from Julius Caesar, the Roman emperor who was born via C-section. Not true, as far as we understand. Most scholars think that the name actually comes from a royal law from ancient Rome that decreed that the body of a pregnant woman could not be buried until the fetus had been removed and buried separately.
37:28 Speaker 07 Oh, okay.
37:30 Speaker 04 Up until the 19th century, really, Caesarians remained exceedingly rare, only performed in extreme instances, and the mother's life took precedence over the baby's. Shockingly, there are cases where both mother and baby survived, the first being either in Prague in the 1300s or Switzerland in the 1500s.
37:48 Speaker 07 Wow.
37:49 Speaker 04 I know.
37:50 Speaker 07 Wow.
37:50 Speaker 04 I know.
37:51 Speaker 07 Okay.
37:52 Speaker 04 But overall, that outcome was like very, very rare. Mostly, a Caesarian was viewed as a success if the mother survived.
37:59 Speaker 07 Okay.
38:00 Speaker 04 Regardless of the baby's status.
38:01 Speaker 07 Okay.
38:02 Speaker 04 This would remain the case well into the 20th century.
38:05 Speaker 07 Okay.
38:05 Speaker 04 An important exception to this is in the case of enslaved black women. Often, the physician would consult the enslaver to see whether they wanted to preserve the life of the mother or the babies.
38:18 Speaker 07 Okay.
38:19 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm. Anyone surviving a C-section was still so notable that it often made the history books, such as the case of Alice O'Neill, an Irish woman who had labored for 12 days until her midwife Mary Donnelly by her side, this was 1738, and then Mary, her midwife, was like, the only way to save Alice, Alice's baby had died during this long labor already, was to do a C-section. And so Mary performed the C-section and Alice made a full recovery. In England, the first C-section where a mother survived took place in 1793, and in the US, the year after, although this is somewhat disputed. In the US case, there was a woman named Elizabeth Bennet, which is also, you're thinking Pride and Prejudice?
39:02 Speaker 07 Okay.
39:02 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:03 Speaker 07 That's what it was.
39:03 Speaker 04 This is before Pride and Prejudice came out.
39:05 Speaker 07 Okay.
39:05 Speaker 04 Which is, yeah.
39:06 Speaker 07 Interesting.
39:07 Speaker 04 I mean, I don't think it's probably that uncommon of a name, but Elizabeth was going through a difficult labor at her log cabin home, and her husband, who was a doctor, had called another doctor over to help, but this other doctor threw his hands up after an attempted forceps delivery, didn't work, and so Elizabeth's husband took matters into his own hands, made an incision, pulled out baby and placenta, allegedly took out the ovaries while he was there to be like, I'm not making sure this doesn't happen again, and stitched her back up.
39:35 Speaker 07 Wow.
39:36 Speaker 04 Mom and baby made a fast recovery.
39:38 Speaker 07 Wow.
39:38 Speaker 04 Allegedly.
39:39 Speaker 07 Allegedly.
39:40 Speaker 04 Yeah. It's a little embellished, like the telling of it, so who knows if it's true?
39:44 Speaker 07 Okay.
39:44 Speaker 04 And I want us to take all of these milestones with a grain of salt, not because maybe they happened, maybe they didn't happen, but also because they probably weren't the first. Like most histories of medicine, the starring characters in the story of cesareans are white male physicians in Europe or in the US, but that's not the whole picture. It's likely that there were other midwives, like Mary Donnelly, out there over the centuries performing cesareans. They just didn't send their reports to a medical journal because they couldn't write, or they didn't view it as remarkable, or they knew that it wouldn't be accepted. Similarly, who knows how many cesareans had been performed around the world historically? In the 1880s, a British physician named Robert Falcon wrote about his experience in Uganda,
40:28 Speaker 04 where he observed cesarean sections being performed in the 1880s. The surgery seemed not uncommon, was intended to save both mother and child, was often successful, and used antisepsis and pain treatment using banana wine.
40:43 Speaker 07 Oh, interesting.
40:44 Speaker 04 Yeah. So the story of cesareans is in part just a reflection of whose work was deemed worthy of being included in medical journals and texts historically. Okay. As incomplete as that story is, it's what we've got. And so now let's turn to the beginning of the modern era of cesareans. Let's. Okay. Death from infection, a lack of anesthesia, and no consensus on surgical procedure, when to do a cesarean, where to cut, should we take the placenta out, and so on. These things, I know I'm starting off grim. It's dark. But realistic. Yeah. These things kept cesarean numbers low for most of the 20th century. Okay.
41:25 Speaker 04 Between 1838 and 1878, 89 c-sections were performed in the US. Okay. 62% of mothers died, 60% of babies died. Okay. One obstetrician from this era said, "There is nothing in surgery about which the surgeon is so timid as a cesarean operation, and nothing in obstetrics of which this obstetrician stands so much in dread." Hmm. Yeah. Okay. For the sentiment to change going into the 20th century, four developments needed to take place: anesthesia, antisepsis, blood transfusions, and surgical technique. Okay. Practicing primarily on women of color, poor women, disabled women, other women
42:08 Speaker 04 viewed as second-class citizens, surgeons honed their approach to cesareans. Eduardo Poro introduced the Poro Technique in 1878, which involved amputating the uterus at the cervix and suturing the cervix into the abdominal wall. Whoa. Yeah, this actually did reduce infection and hemorrhage, brought the survival rate up to 44%. Okay. Max Singer used silver wire in uterine sutures beginning in the late 1880s, further improving survival rate. I think previously they were like, should we even suture the uterus back together? Oh, gosh, okay. Because, well, infection was so bad. Infection, okay, okay. By the 1910s, the overall maternal mortality rate for cesareans dropped to 8.1%.
42:50 Speaker 07 Wow.
42:51 Speaker 04 Which is lower than the 56% it was in the late 1800s, but still very high for a surgery. So its use was debated with the decision to cut, often influenced by the social standing of the mother, which opened the door to eugenics, right? So the risk of a negative outcome was perceived to be lower in cases where you didn't care whether or not mother and baby lived.
43:12 Speaker 07 Oh, my god. Okay.
43:13 Speaker 04 Yeah. Inductions were often used as a way to prevent what was seen as an extremely risky procedure. But over the first, they were like, well, we'll just, in case, we don't want, we want to avoid a cesarean, so we'll just induce you. So that became very, very popular. But over the first seven decades of the 20th century, that perception of risk would change. What started out as a surgery to be avoided at all costs turned into something that you only did in extreme circumstances, then something to do in certain situations, and then only at the discretion of the physician, to finally, something that was routine. The reasons for this shift included those I mentioned earlier: transfusions, antisepsis,
43:54 Speaker 04 anesthesia, technique, plus antibiotics introduced in the 1940s. And a gradual decline in maternal mortality from other causes. So as obstetricians got better at recognizing and treating or preventing complications for mom during pregnancy and childbirth, the focus then shifted to seeing a similar decrease in neonatal and perinatal mortality.
44:16 Speaker 07 Okay. Because previously, it had always been about maternal mortality and trying to reduce that, and the baby was always secondary.
44:24 Speaker 04 Yes.
44:25 Speaker 07 And then as we got better at reducing maternal mortality, now we said, okay, can we save these babies?
44:30 Speaker 04 Yes, exactly.
44:31 Speaker 07 Got it.
44:31 Speaker 04 Yep, yep. And so then we started to develop things like diagnostic tools: the APGAR score, the Friedman curve to measure how labor is progressing, x-rays, ultrasound, and the electronic fetal monitor. Which was introduced in the 1950s, or a lot of these were established by the 1950s and 1960s. Obviously, x-rays were a long time previous to that. But these different diagnostic tools captured what seemed like more and more risk during childbirth and thus more and more reason to do a C-section. Or placental issues, pelvis size, estimated baby size, uterine rupture, preeclampsia, et cetera. We got better at detecting those and measuring those and being like, well, we should.
45:13 Speaker 07 We can see the risk, so how can we not do something about it?
45:17 Speaker 04 Yes, exactly.
45:18 Speaker 07 That's what it is. Yeah, okay.
45:20 Speaker 04 But in another way, what these instruments were doing in part was confirming what early male physicians involved in childbirth believed, that pregnancy and childbirth were pathological processes in themselves.
45:36 Speaker 07 Oh, Erin.
45:37 Speaker 04 I know.
45:37 Speaker 07 Okay.
45:38 Speaker 04 Yep. By the 1970s, the tides had fully turned and C-sections were about to skyrocket, at least here in the US.
45:45 Speaker 07 Uh huh.
45:46 Speaker 04 To give you some idea of this massive change, let me throw some numbers at you.
45:49 Speaker 07 Please.
45:50 Speaker 04 Until 1970, the US C-section rate was 5.5%.
45:56 Speaker 07 Wow, okay.
45:57 Speaker 04 Between 1965 and 1987, the rate of C-sections grew 455%.
46:05 Speaker 07 In, I'm sorry, that is such a short, I think what I didn't realize about looking at these numbers.
46:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
46:12 Speaker 07 Is how short that timeframe was when it just boomed.
46:17 Speaker 04 Yeah. Electronic fetal monitoring was a big.
46:20 Speaker 07 Okay.
46:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
46:21 Speaker 07 Oh, that's really interesting, especially in the context of like today.
46:24 Speaker 04 Yep.
46:24 Speaker 07 Okay. Interesting.
46:26 Speaker 04 Yeah, and it became like, it just, there are so many different dynamics to this as well. Yeah, so in 1965, the rate was like 4.5% and 1987, it was 25%, which is also lower than it is today.
46:40 Speaker 07 Yeah.
46:41 Speaker 04 Articles or stories that referenced C-sections in the 1960s still included a definition of the procedure.
46:49 Speaker 07 Wow.
46:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
46:50 Speaker 07 Okay.
46:50 Speaker 04 And those published after 1970 didn't have to.
46:53 Speaker 07 Didn't need to.
46:54 Speaker 04 And the shift wasn't entirely welcomed by all obstetricians, many of whom saw cesareans as requiring much less skill than assisting in vaginal birth.
47:03 Speaker 07 Interesting.
47:03 Speaker 04 And were against expanding criteria for the procedure because they were afraid of their own marginalization in part.
47:09 Speaker 07 Interesting.
47:10 Speaker 04 The skills that had taken them years to learn and perfect would be pointless with a surgical technique that took a few weeks to learn.
47:19 Speaker 07 Interesting.
47:20 Speaker 04 Yeah. And this is not unfounded, right? Few physicians today have ever attended a vaginal breach birth. And watching a monitor is no substitute for interacting with a patient and becoming familiar with the varied rhythms of labor and that patient themselves, like the person, who they are.
47:36 Speaker 07 Yeah.
47:37 Speaker 04 The natural birth movement, beginning in the 1970s, was in part a reaction to the increasing medicalization of pregnancy and childbirth, which included C-sections. And this, combined with the push for vaginal birth after C-section, VBAC, in the 1980s, led to a brief dip in C-section rates in the US.
47:53 Speaker 07 Okay, okay.
47:54 Speaker 04 But that decline was short-lived, as resistance to VBACs grew among doctors, as insurance companies hiked up malpractice insurance rates for doctors who performed VBACs.
48:05 Speaker 07 Oh, gosh.
48:06 Speaker 04 And as hospitals just began to forbade it as an option. Yeah.
48:09 Speaker 07 Wow.
48:10 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
48:11 Speaker 07 Hospital administration making decisions. Cool, cool, cool, cool, cool, cool, cool, cool, insurance. Yep, love it.
48:16 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
48:17 Speaker 07 You, night, tits, states, okay. Sorry.
48:19 Speaker 04 I mean, I do think this is probably at like a global issue as well in some degree.
48:23 Speaker 07 Obviously, yeah, based on, based on the stats.
48:25 Speaker 04 But these are, these are US numbers, for sure, yeah. The "once a cesarean, always a cesarean" adage that was first popularized by Edwin Cragan in 1916 still holds sway.
48:36 Speaker 07 1916?
48:37 Speaker 04 1916, yeah. The perception of risk had shifted. Before the 1970s, C-sections themselves were seen as the risk. And after, not performing the procedure was the risk.
48:49 Speaker 07 Okay.
48:50 Speaker 04 Medical malpractice suits on failure to perform a C-section reinforced this.
48:55 Speaker 07 Okay.
48:56 Speaker 04 But what seems to have gotten lost as cesareans became more normalized is that the procedure does carry with it substantial risk, which can be compounded in subsequent C-sections. I know you'll talk a little bit more about this, Erin, but high rates of blood transfusions, emergency hysterectomies, postpartum depression, difficulty breastfeeding, newborn lung conditions, and in subsequent pregnancies, stillbirth, uterine ruptures, placental anomalies such as placenta accretion. We can see the impact of C-sections on placenta accreta by looking at rates over time.
49:28 Speaker 07 Yeah.
49:29 Speaker 04 From the 1930s to the 1950s, placenta accreta occurred in less than 1 in 30,000 births.
49:35 Speaker 07 Oh, my gosh.
49:36 Speaker 04 By 2016, that number was down to 1 in 272.
49:39 Speaker 07 Yeah.
49:40 Speaker 04 In large part due to C-sections.
49:42 Speaker 07 Right. Placenta accreta is when the placenta grows too deeply into the myometrium. In some cases, it can actually go all the way through the myometrium and be adherent to like the outside wall or even into the abdominal cavity.
49:56 Speaker 04 Yeah.
49:57 Speaker 07 It's a spectrum of disorders, depending on how deep it is. And if it can be identified prior to delivery, then generally a cesarean section is necessary to be able to ensure that you can remove all of the placental tissue because as we'll talk about, it's really important that the whole placenta comes out. But sometimes it's not identified and so then it can result in increased risk of hemorrhage and things like that.
50:19 Speaker 04 Yeah. And it's like, from my understanding, is that risk of placenta accreta increases with every C-section.
50:24 Speaker 07 With every C-section.
50:25 Speaker 04 Because of the potential for just the lack of like decidua that can form.
50:28 Speaker 07 Exactly.
50:29 Speaker 04 Where the previous scar is.
50:30 Speaker 07 Exactly. Because of the cesarean scar.
50:32 Speaker 04 Yeah.
50:33 Speaker 07 Yeah.
50:34 Speaker 04 Okay. Now that we've like talked about some of the negative things, I do want to just emphasize that C-sections are absolutely a life-saving procedure.
50:43 Speaker 07 They really are.
50:44 Speaker 04 And they are incredibly safe.
50:45 Speaker 07 Yeah.
50:46 Speaker 04 I don't want to give the impression that they aren't.
50:48 Speaker 07 Right.
50:49 Speaker 04 That's not the point I'm trying to make. The point is that while there are risks inherent in this procedure, risks that are worth it, if it means a healthy mother and baby, these risks aren't always adequately communicated, whether in planned cesarean sections, unplanned ones, or in many what-to-expect-while-you're-expecting books. The decision to conduct an unplanned cesarean isn't always explained to the person in labor who, in their state of anxiety, pain, worry, doesn't feel like they can ask questions or be listened to.
51:19 Speaker 07 Or can't understand like everything that's happening all at once because it can change on a dime.
51:24 Speaker 04 Exactly. Yeah.
51:26 Speaker 07 Yeah.
51:27 Speaker 04 Being in a room surrounded by people for whom this is an everyday occurrence seems like it should be reassuring, but what it can often be is silencing and isolating.
51:36 Speaker 07 Yeah.
51:37 Speaker 04 Your fears are dismissed because, oh, it's fine. We do this all the time. Don't worry about it. Your questions aren't answered because the doctor is telling you, there's no time. We have to do this now. And this crowded labor room, filled with capable hands, provides no comfort because most of them are strangers. They don't know you, you don't know them. This feeling of a loss of control might not be unique to C-sections, but it is something that gets minimized both during and after childbirth, both of which carry significant rates of emotional trauma. One study I saw reported 45%. The message is, well, you've got a healthy baby. What do you have to complain about? Get over it, you know, like, just enjoy your baby.
52:14 Speaker 07 Yeah. Also, they're screaming all the time, so it's hard to enjoy.
52:17 Speaker 04 How can you enjoy? But this no big deal sentiment carries over into the physical trauma of C-sections, which are treated like the world's most minor surgery instead of the major abdominal surgery that they are.
52:29 Speaker 07 I do find that so interesting.
52:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's like, oh, cesarean, oh, my God, that's like, that must be nice for you.
52:35 Speaker 07 Yeah.
52:36 Speaker 04 Right? It's like, what? Like, how are you expected to carry your newborn to their first doctor's appointment when you aren't supposed to lift anything because your muscles have just undergone significant trauma?
52:45 Speaker 07 Yeah, and even if your newborn is only like six or seven pounds, your car seat's 12, and so now you're at your 20-pound max.
52:50 Speaker 04 Right.
52:51 Speaker 07 Mm-hmm.
52:51 Speaker 04 Great. And then how long? How long does that, you know? In the famous pregnancy book, What to Expect While You're Expecting, you know this book, right?
53:00 Speaker 07 I do, I've never read it, though.
53:01 Speaker 04 Everyone knows this book. Yeah, I haven't either, but I did come across this description of C-sections in one edition. Instead of huffing, puffing, and pushing your baby into the world, you'll get to lie back and let everyone else do the heavy lifting.
53:19 Speaker 07 I hope that was... I don't even know what I hope about that description because I... Oh, gosh.
53:25 Speaker 04 My charitable take is that maybe it was meant to be reassuring.
53:30 Speaker 07 Reassuring, sure, sure, sure.
53:31 Speaker 04 And like, don't worry about it. This is something that, you know, you don't have to stress about this major surgery.
53:36 Speaker 07 It's not helpful for either side because it makes it seem like a vaginal birth is like the worst possible thing and it's so hard. And then it makes it seem like a cesarean section is so easy. And like, neither one of those things are exactly true. It's all still childbirth.
53:50 Speaker 04 It's all childbirth.
53:51 Speaker 07 Yeah.
53:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. Uh, it's, and the thing is too, I also, I also want to acknowledge that that might be someone's experience.
53:59 Speaker 07 Right.
53:59 Speaker 04 Like, that maybe, maybe, I don't, I don't want to say like, everyone who has C-sections had a horrible time.
54:04 Speaker 07 Right.
54:05 Speaker 04 Because maybe they didn't. Maybe it was like, this is totally fine.
54:07 Speaker 07 Maybe it is a scheduled procedure and it goes exactly as planned and it was very relaxing and your recovery is easy and that's phenomenal.
54:12 Speaker 04 Right. Or even if it was unplanned.
54:14 Speaker 07 Right.
54:15 Speaker 04 And it's like, yeah.
54:16 Speaker 07 And, but the same can also be true for vaginal delivery.
54:19 Speaker 04 For sure. Yeah, yeah. But I feel like, yeah, this, the saying that way, describing it that way is so dismissive.
54:25 Speaker 07 Right. It's one way that it will go.
54:27 Speaker 04 Yes.
54:27 Speaker 07 Yeah.
54:28 Speaker 04 Yep. And it also sort of like, is like, well, if you felt any, any other way, then that's your, that's on you.
54:33 Speaker 07 Mm-hmm.
54:34 Speaker 04 Right?
54:34 Speaker 07 Right.
54:35 Speaker 04 And this perception of C-sections as being either like, the easy way out, or a vanity procedure, which is, we'll get into that, yeah. Or not real birth is so incredibly harmful. And I feel like this, this idea of natural birth, or the term "natural birth", implies unnatural birth.
54:54 Speaker 07 Right.
54:55 Speaker 04 And that can be so othering, right? That along with the million different books and articles and forums saying, "You should do this and you shouldn't do that. If you do this, you're a good mother. If you don't do this, then you're a bad mother."
55:08 Speaker 07 I know.
55:08 Speaker 04 Like, that sort of thing.
55:09 Speaker 07 Right. It compares and contrasts in this way.
55:11 Speaker 04 Right. The focus on skin-to-skin bonding in the minutes right after birth? What happens if you're under anesthesia? Or if baby is rushed away for extra care? That's okay. Everything will be okay. But that message gets lost. Women who have C-sections often have a more difficult time breastfeeding, which can then lead to shaming, because that's not the way you're supposed to do it. When in reality, a fed baby is the best baby.
55:33 Speaker 07 Mm-hmm.
55:35 Speaker 04 The moral superiority tied to so much of pregnancy and childbirth can be crushing and isolating, especially when things are out of your control. Even the language that we use to describe reasons for C-sections shows this.
55:47 Speaker 07 Oh, my gosh, I talk about this too.
55:49 Speaker 04 Failure to progress. Incompetent cervix. Inefficient contractions. Uterine dysfunction. Some women are told, "You're not trying hard enough." I know, "You're not strong enough."
56:00 Speaker 07 Ooh.
56:01 Speaker 04 Yes. Like, you're, you're not even, you're not even pushing. What are you doing? Do you, do you want to have a C-section?
56:07 Speaker 07 Oh, my God. I can't, sorry.
56:07 Speaker 04 You know, sorry.
56:08 Speaker 07 It's too...
56:08 Speaker 04 I know. I know. But it's, that all places the blame on them, making the C-section solely their decision rather than what the doctor instructed. And it's so difficult to know, like you, you have this plan, you, you want to, your birth to go a certain way, and then something goes not according to plan. What do you do? Do you feel like it's your fault? It's, it's really complicated.
56:32 Speaker 07 And that, I mean, that is the truth of our entire lives, right? Is that like, you, we cannot plan everything. But I do think that especially today, there is very much an emphasis on like, having a plan. And then when things, if things do not go according to that plan, it makes it seem like you did something wrong.
56:50 Speaker 04 Right.
56:50 Speaker 07 When that's not reality.
56:52 Speaker 04 It's not reality.
56:53 Speaker 07 So it's really hard.
56:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, it is really hard. And, and I think that what it does is sort of shift the attention away from where I think we need to be more, like have more discussions about, you know, what, what are these drivers for this 33% rate of C-sections at the provider level, at the institutional level, at the systemic level?
57:16 Speaker 07 Right.
57:16 Speaker 04 One overlooked aspect is the individual provider's reasons for deciding on a C-section. Trauma during childbirth is not exclusive to the mother. And as a provider, if you attend a traumatic vaginal birth, you might be more likely to suggest a C-section than your other colleagues.
57:33 Speaker 07 Every provider has seen traumatic, everything. I mean, the, the things that obstetric providers see on a daily basis are trauma.
57:42 Speaker 04 Exactly, yeah. Some hospitals, I found this fascinating, took to publishing or displaying each physician's cesarean rates, and that led to them plummeting.
57:51 Speaker 07 Interesting. Wow.
57:53 Speaker 04 So which, which suggests that maybe risk tolerance for vaginal birth is lower than physicians think it should be. And so I, I don't know what to make of that, but I do think that's, that is, yeah. And then there's implicit bias. Black mothers are more likely to have C-sections than white mothers, even if risk factors are similar. Does this suggest that non-white mothers can't be trusted to give birth without medical intervention? Which is also then funny because it's like, but we're also, you have pain? I don't believe you. Yeah. Other research shows that female OB-GYNs and maternal fetal medicine specialists are more likely to opt for an elective cesarean for themselves rather than low-risk vaginal birth.
58:38 Speaker 04 21% to 31% preferred elective cesarean. So how does that personal preference bleed into their practice? Along with these individual drivers, what about the US medical system as a whole?
58:50 Speaker 07 Oh, my gosh.
58:51 Speaker 04 Driven by profits, fear of litigation. How do these things impact rates? And finally, how much of this rise in C-sections is due to a corresponding rise in the actual risk factors for the procedure?
59:03 Speaker 07 Right.
59:03 Speaker 04 Like older age during pregnancy? Or higher rates of preeclampsia in recent decades?
59:08 Speaker 07 Yeah.
59:09 Speaker 04 How appropriate is a comparison between historical and modern rates of difficult labor?
59:14 Speaker 07 Yeah.
59:14 Speaker 04 Do these historical metrics capture neonatal or perinatal mortality, injuries during childbirth, disability caused by difficult labor? Let me reiterate again. C-sections are a life-saving and generally extremely safe procedure. But in order to reach the WHO's recommended ideal C-section rate of 10% to 15%?
59:34 Speaker 07 15%, yeah.
59:35 Speaker 04 We really need to reassess the metrics that we use to make decisions about interventions. How are we measuring risk? How accurate are these measurements? Are the risk factors themselves increasing? Medical advancements have saved the lives of so many mothers and babies, but in our reliance on diagnostic tools and technologies, we've left something else behind. And that is the comfort that community can bring to pregnancy, childbirth, and child rearing, which is in part what I'll be talking about next week.
1:00:07 Speaker 07 I'm excited about that.
1:00:08 Speaker 04 Or next episode. But for now, Erin, I want to turn it over to you to tell me all, everything about labor and delivery.
1:00:14 Speaker 07 I'm not going to tell you everything, but I'll cover a lot right after a short break.
1:00:22 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:00:24 Speaker 03 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by breakout singer-songwriter Alex Warren.
1:00:45 Speaker 01 To this day, Ordinary would not have done anything, and I would have not been able to put it out if Book Talk didn't back it up and if my wife and her friend didn't back it up.
1:00:53 Speaker 03 Amazing.
1:00:54 Speaker 01 Pretty crazy how, like, just one thing.
1:00:56 Speaker 03 Right.
1:00:57 Speaker 01 I mean, I bet we could point to nine different things in our careers where it's just one thing all of a sudden. If that one thing didn't happen, then I wouldn't be here.
1:01:03 Speaker 03 What you're talking about right now is what I've been talking about since the beginning of my career. There's these things outside of you that make everything happen. These other forces somehow came into contact with each other and helped propel you to this place.
1:01:21 Speaker 01 It's just insane.
1:01:22 Speaker 03 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:01:33 Speaker 01 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
1:01:40 Speaker 02 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
1:01:49 Speaker 01 Oh, that's actually really simple.
1:01:52 Speaker 02 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at bofa.com/simplebanking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
1:02:14 Speaker 06 It was in March of 2023 that we lost our first baby to miscarriage. We'd been trying to conceive for quite some time and were absolutely ecstatic to become parents, but we ended up in the accident and emergency department following some bleeding. I remember getting the news and just completely breaking down. It was a really busy Friday night and we were told that we should go home and come back the next day for a transvaginal ultrasound. When we were in that waiting room, we already knew that we had lost our baby. But we were surrounded by excited, happy parents who were waiting to get their own scans. And it just felt like such a lonely and isolating experience. Once they had done the scan to confirm that it wasn't an ectopic pregnancy that needed further intervention.
1:02:58 Speaker 06 We were told we should go home and wait for the fecal matter to pass on its own. It was a really bizarre situation where, literally being told to flush your hopes and dreams down a toilet. It felt very cold and clinical. I never truly appreciated that so many pregnancies end in miscarriage. I think it's about one in four is the statistic, which is so many people who are affected by baby loss. To further this, I felt like I couldn't really take any time off from work and that I was a failure in some ways, which I know, having spoken to other women, is something that I'm not alone with. It wasn't just the physical pain of having the miscarriage, but the emotional toll that it took on me and my partner as well. Growing up, you're always told that if you have sex, you'll get pregnant.
1:03:42 Speaker 06 And obviously pregnancy equals a baby, but that is so not the case for so many people. Sadly, we were one of the unlucky few couples that go on to have recurrent miscarriages. So that sort of feeling of isolation and loneliness has happened time and time again for us. Each time I felt like I should just get over it. There was lots of support when we had that first miscarriage. But after the second one, it sort of starts to dwindle, particularly with people in the workplace. In the UK currently, there's no paid time off, no legal right to have paid time off if you lose a baby under twenty four weeks of gestation. So I've actually been campaigning to introduce that. I'm really pleased to say that most recently, we've managed to do that in my workplace and we're one of the first people within
1:04:27 Speaker 06 our industry to actually introduce paid time off for bereaved parents who lose a baby for miscarriage or for termination for medical reasons under twenty four weeks. And I hope that my story can empower other people to campaign for the same in their workplaces and to feel less alone.
1:04:45 Speaker 06 Hi, my name's Kate from Western Australia and I'm the mother of two preterm babies. After a fairly smooth pregnancy at the age of twenty-eight, I gave birth to my son at just thirty weeks and five days. He was thirteen hundred and seventy-five grams, or about three pounds. Went to hospital after a really bad cramping, backache and bleeding and I was advised I was in preterm labour. Was given steroids for his lungs, because he was so early, we had to be transferred to the public hospital. And by the time I had been admitted, they rushed me in for an emergency cesarean, as they could feel his little feet poking out. I was completely terrified, with my teeth chattering uncontrollably from the epidural.
1:05:30 Speaker 06 Our son was lifted out, onto a warming bed and given oxygen. To our relief, he cried, but I only got a glimpse of him as he was taken to the ICU to be intubated and placed in a humicrib. He then spent a day or so in the ICU on oxygen. He was then put on a CPAP machine and moved to the neonatal ward where I was able to hold him for the first time. I remember the nurse tucking him under my singlet for skin to skin, which was such a surreal and amazing moment for me. So many ups and downs. Jimmy was discharged from hospital after nine long weeks. But he is now about to turn fifteen years old.
1:06:14 Speaker 06 Two and a half years later, his sister was born. When I was thirty-two weeks and five days, I had the same cramping, the same backache. I got to hospital much earlier this time. I was given steroids, they tried to slow everything down, which they did for a few hours. But she was also determined to make an early entrance. As she was head down and quite small in size, we decided I was safe to deliver vaginally. Evie was born at eighteen hundred and seventy-five grams, which is about four pounds. She was breathing on her own and I was able to hold her almost straight after. The extra time and the pressure from the vaginal birth ensured that steroids worked on her lungs,
1:06:55 Speaker 06 which made such a huge difference. Our Evie came home with us just four weeks later.
1:07:02 Speaker 06 Having to leave your new baby to go home every day is so incredibly hard. So, thank you so much, the nurses at King Edward Memorial. You made it bearable and you're all so kind and so caring. Thank you.
1:07:40 Speaker 07 So, by the end of the last episode, episode two, by the end of my section, I made it, like, most of the way through pregnancy and I stopped just before the big event of delivery. And of course, Erin, you beautifully walked us through some parts of delivery, especially C-sections and how those go. But I'm gonna focus a little bit on what most people, because even at 33%, most people, a lot of people, even in that 33% of cesarean sections, go through some part of labor beforehand. So, what the heck is that?
1:08:16 Speaker 04 What is that? What is labor?
1:08:18 Speaker 07 Can't wait to tell you. So, I'm gonna go through what we know about the biology of labor and then walk through delivery modes, methods, a little bit more on C-sections and vaginal deliveries. It's gonna be great. So, what is labor?
1:08:34 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:08:34 Speaker 07 Okay. During our whole pregnancy, all of the hormones jutting around that we've talked about, progesterone, proscalines, blah, blah, blah, all these things, what they do is help to keep our uterus relatively quiescent, relatively relaxed.
1:08:51 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:08:52 Speaker 07 Often, especially late in pregnancy, we might see this irregular contractility. So, anyone who has experienced what they call Braxton Hicks contractions knows what those are. It's basically just your uterus, sometimes people describe it as getting ready for birth. I don't know that that's accurate, but it's just your uterus every once in a while is still going to Have these contractions.
1:09:13 Speaker 04 What, what, just, what is a contraction? Yeah.
1:09:16 Speaker 07 It is actually because your uterus has like the inner lining, right? The endometrium, but then it's a huge muscle.
1:09:22 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:09:23 Speaker 07 And so it is the muscle fibers contracting, literally, like, like your biceps contracts.
1:09:28 Speaker 04 But I mean, like, what, what, how, what is a, like, how long does a contract?
1:09:32 Speaker 07 Oh, Erin, we're gonna get there.
1:09:33 Speaker 04 No, no, we'll get there, but Braxton Hicks, so what, like?
1:09:36 Speaker 07 Braxton Hicks contractions are defined as, okay, so to, to kind of define that, we have to define what, what do we mean by labor? Like, how are you defining those contractions? And what's the difference there? And that is what, what they are doing. So the onset of labor is defined as when there is a switch in the contractions to where they are resulting in dilation and effacement of the cervix.
1:10:01 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:10:02 Speaker 07 So contractions that are happening where you're having perhaps, perhaps pain, sometimes they're painful,
1:10:09 Speaker 07 where your uterus is contracting, but there's no change in your cervix. Those contractions are not considered labor contractions.
1:10:16 Speaker 04 Got it.
1:10:17 Speaker 07 So what we see with the onset of labor is that these contractions increase in frequency and intensity, and they become regular, which means that they're occurring at regular intervals. What that interval is, is gonna vary, right? Later on in labor, they're much closer together, maybe a minute or two, but at the start, they could be like 10, 15, even 20 minutes apart.
1:10:39 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:10:40 Speaker 07 If they are causing cervical change, then they are considered labor contractions.
1:10:45 Speaker 04 Okay. Did you say, like, which hormones are causing this yet?
1:10:50 Speaker 07 Did I say what triggers labor? No, I did not, Erin, because we don't know.
1:10:56 Speaker 04 What?
1:10:56 Speaker 07 We don't know.
1:10:58 Speaker 04 That can't be right. Check your notes again.
1:11:01 Speaker 07 We don't know. I said, what triggers labor to begin? What an excellent question.
1:11:08 Speaker 07 It is hypothesized. We think that labor, the onset of labor, is triggered by the fetus or the placenta, the fetal-placental unit.
1:11:16 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:11:17 Speaker 07 We think that because that is what happens in like sheep and cows. And in those other animals, we know what enzymes are involved. We know like the specific hormonal triggers. But we do not know that in humans. And if we did, it would be so much easier to induce labor.
1:11:34 Speaker 04 Also, sheep and cows have less invasive placentas.
1:11:36 Speaker 07 Okay, I know. So it's different. And that's why it's not the same in us.
1:11:40 Speaker 04 But I mean, we have, we have animal models that we understand.
1:11:42 Speaker 07 That we understand.
1:11:44 Speaker 04 The process of labor.
1:11:45 Speaker 07 The trigger.
1:11:45 Speaker 04 The trigger.
1:11:46 Speaker 07 And so in us, we don't have that trigger. We know that a really important thing is that oxytocin.
1:11:53 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:11:54 Speaker 07 Which is a hormone, that the like synthetic version of it is called pitocin.
1:11:59 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:11:59 Speaker 07 Um, that triggers urinary contractions. But what triggers in someone who spontaneously goes into labor? What triggers that? Cause it's not just like, just oxytocin. It's something else has to trigger the production of that. Yeah, we don't know what that is.
1:12:15 Speaker 04 Okay, and then for the, for the regularity of these contractions, like how? Is it just the speed at which it's being, like oxytocin is being released? What was?
1:12:24 Speaker 07 Dunno.
1:12:26 Speaker 04 Okay. So like, we don't know why? I mean, we know why they speed up, like the purpose of speeding up.
1:12:30 Speaker 07 Right, we know what they're doing.
1:12:32 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:12:32 Speaker 07 But we do not know very much about the physiology of what is triggering it. But we do know a lot about how labor progresses. So what I'm gonna go through are the different stages of labor. There are three. Uh, the first stage has two different phases, so we'll talk about all of that. Um, and to do that, I did bring some props.
1:12:52 Speaker 04 Yay!
1:12:54 Speaker 07 This is a balloon.
1:12:58 Speaker 04 Is there, what's, is there something in there?
1:12:59 Speaker 07 Don't worry, we'll get there.
1:13:00 Speaker 04 Oh my god.
1:13:01 Speaker 07 This is a balloon that is going to represent our uterus. So if you're just listening, imagine a balloon. It's inflated, okay? But it's not tied off at the bottom, alright? So this is a uterus and this part down here, like the part that you would blow into of a balloon is the cervix during pregnancy.
1:13:19 Speaker 04 It's right.
1:13:21 Speaker 07 I spent so long, I practiced it at home and everything. My kids helped me. That's great. So this part is the cervix, the part that you would blow into of the balloon during pregnancy and outside of pregnancy. It's long and it's firm. It kind of feels like the tip of your nose if you were to touch it. Okay?
1:13:38 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:13:39 Speaker 07 And it is closed, so you see that there's no opening here.
1:13:43 Speaker 04 Yeah, what is that?
1:13:44 Speaker 07 What is that?
1:13:45 Speaker 04 No, I mean like, but what is that for you?
1:13:47 Speaker 07 It is a little puffball.
1:13:49 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:13:50 Speaker 07 Craft puffball.
1:13:51 Speaker 04 And what is it representing?
1:13:53 Speaker 07 It is representing the mucus plug.
1:13:55 Speaker 04 Ah.
1:13:56 Speaker 07 So during pregnancy, your cervix is closed with a mucus plug. And so one of the first steps of labor is that this mucus plug is shed.
1:14:05 Speaker 04 So exciting.
1:14:06 Speaker 07 Thank you. And then through the power of these contractions, these contractions that are regular, that increase in frequency and intensity.
1:14:15 Speaker 04 I'm so nervous it's gonna pop.
1:14:15 Speaker 07 It's not gonna pop. I've practiced. The cervix has to do two things. It has to dilate and it has to efface.
1:14:22 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:14:23 Speaker 07 So dilation means that it has to go from closed to open. It's not gonna pop on you.
1:14:30 Speaker 04 You're aiming that at me.
1:14:32 Speaker 07 And so it has to go from a state of being completely closed to about 10 centimeters open in diameter.
1:14:38 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:14:38 Speaker 07 That is fully dilated.
1:14:40 Speaker 04 10 centimeters.
1:14:40 Speaker 07 But it also, as you can see, as I'm like, if I'm squeezing this, it's also getting thinner, right? It's not as deep.
1:14:47 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:14:47 Speaker 07 That's called effacement. So it has to go from like several centimeters, kind of like thick and deep
1:14:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
1:14:54 Speaker 07 to basically paper thin tissue.
1:14:56 Speaker 04 Got it. So it's just, yeah.
1:14:58 Speaker 07 Yeah, it's just smoothing out and kind of being, coming more of a part of the actual uterus itself. Cool?
1:15:04 Speaker 04 Cool.
1:15:05 Speaker 07 So that happens all through the power of contractions. The first stage of labor, this is all part of the first stage of labor, dilation and effacement, it's divided into two parts, latent labor and active labor.
1:15:18 Speaker 07 And these definitions vary a little bit place to place. So just for transparency, I'm using US definitions like from the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology. They define latent labor as the phase from when the cervix is completely closed until six centimeters dilated.
1:15:34 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:15:35 Speaker 07 And we have found through lots of studies on people's labor progression, those labor curves.
1:15:40 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:15:40 Speaker 07 That six centimeters is kind of this magic number where after that point, the regularity with which you dilate can be predictable. Up until six centimeters, someone might have very, very, very slow change. So they might have a latent phase of labor that is many, many, many hours long.
1:16:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:16:05 Speaker 07 If those contractions are still happening at a regular interval, even if, again, that interval is like 10, 15, 20 minutes, if they're still having cervical change, albeit slow, that would still be considered labor, just latent. There is estimates on like, how long does latent labor last? What is quote unquote "normal"? What is outside of the range of normal? And that is a little bit up in the air.
1:16:32 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:16:33 Speaker 07 Because latent labor can really vary. And most of the data that we have is the time between admission to the hospital and the onset of active labor. But that doesn't necessarily mean that your labor started when you entered the hospital.
1:16:46 Speaker 04 Right.
1:16:46 Speaker 07 But that number is about 16 hours.
1:16:49 Speaker 04 Wow.
1:16:50 Speaker 07 Is the like 95th percentile. Not, that's not the average. That's like the long end of things.
1:16:54 Speaker 04 Oh, okay, okay.
1:16:55 Speaker 07 Yeah. But again, that's gonna, that's gonna depend very much person to person.
1:16:59 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:16:59 Speaker 07 So latent labor is the time that like really, really can vary. After you get to six centimeters, that is when you are now considered to be in active labor. And that is the time at which the cervical change should speed up to a predictable interval of about one centimeter every two hours.
1:17:18 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:17:18 Speaker 07 Or less, faster is totally fine.
1:17:20 Speaker 04 Sorry, that's a six centimeters?
1:17:22 Speaker 07 After six centimeters, yeah.
1:17:23 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:17:23 Speaker 07 So to go from six to 10, you've got like eight hours.
1:17:26 Speaker 04 Got it.
1:17:26 Speaker 07 Before a provider is gonna be like, this is taking too long.
1:17:29 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:17:30 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:17:31 Speaker 04 Okay, ten, but ten is the
1:17:34 Speaker 07 Ten is fully dilated. Yeah.
1:17:36 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:17:36 Speaker 07 Okay. Questions about any of that?
1:17:39 Speaker 04 Yeah. Um, it's okay. So the active labor part is more predictable.
1:17:43 Speaker 07 More predictable.
1:17:44 Speaker 04 But then not everyone progresses through active labor.
1:17:48 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:17:49 Speaker 04 The same way.
1:17:50 Speaker 07 Yeah. Well, you mean through like that, the from six to 10 centimeters?
1:17:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, in, in eight hours or whatever.
1:17:56 Speaker 07 Yeah. And so if they don't, a few things might be the case. So one thing that should usually happen at some point prior to that, probably, is that your water should break. If your water didn't break on its own, then a provider might say, we should break it for you. This is a crochet hook that I brought, which looks exactly like.
1:18:14 Speaker 04 It does look exactly like.
1:18:15 Speaker 07 An amni hook. This is the actual hook. You can see it looks exactly identical.
1:18:20 Speaker 04 It does, yeah.
1:18:21 Speaker 07 It's just longer.
1:18:22 Speaker 04 And not round.
1:18:23 Speaker 07 And not round.
1:18:24 Speaker 04 You wouldn't want to crochet with that.
1:18:26 Speaker 07 No. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, but this is used to break somebody's water. Now, the reason that that's important is because the baby's head, which is hopefully down, um, exerts pressure on that cervix. If there is a bag of fluid there, then that might like limit the amount of pressure that's being exerted and might make it so that your cervix is not dilating the way that it should.
1:18:48 Speaker 04 Right.
1:18:49 Speaker 07 So that's the reason that a lot of times if water hasn't broken on its own, that will be like an intervention that's recommended to help speed up the process of labor.
1:18:56 Speaker 04 What determines how much?
1:18:58 Speaker 07 I was gonna.
1:18:58 Speaker 04 How much fluid? Oh, yeah.
1:18:59 Speaker 07 I was gonna do it, but I think it actually might make a mess. So I'm gonna stop there. I had a baby in there to.
1:19:03 Speaker 04 I'm, I'm envisioning the water going everywhere.
1:19:07 Speaker 07 It would make a mess.
1:19:08 Speaker 04 Yeah. What, what determines how much liquid, how much amniotic fluid is in there?
1:19:16 Speaker 07 Big question. So amniotic fluid is pee. It's a fetus pee.
1:19:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:19:19 Speaker 07 Um, so it depends on how much the fetus is peeing and whether or not their kidneys are working correctly. And also how much they, because then they drink that pee.
1:19:27 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
1:19:27 Speaker 07 Um, and so that, it's like a whole thing. It's fetal development. I'm not going to get into it.
1:19:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, but we'd be, okay.
1:19:33 Speaker 07 So I don't have an answer for you. And what determines whether or not, what determines whether or not it breaks spontaneously?
1:19:39 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:19:39 Speaker 07 Or has to be broken?
1:19:40 Speaker 04 Right.
1:19:40 Speaker 07 Who knows?
1:19:41 Speaker 04 What, what percentage breaks spontaneously?
1:19:44 Speaker 07 Don't ask me those questions.
1:19:45 Speaker 04 Sorry.
1:19:45 Speaker 07 Listen, in any case, at some point, the water is likely going to break. Sometimes it doesn't. Babies can be born just fine in call. It's call.
1:19:53 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
1:19:54 Speaker 07 Where they're born in the amniotic sac.
1:19:55 Speaker 04 There's a whole history. We could talk about call.
1:19:56 Speaker 07 It's beautiful.
1:19:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:19:57 Speaker 07 Um, but in any case, when it does break, that allows for the fetal head to engage lower down in the pelvis, putting more pressure on the cervix and helping to ensure that you're getting adequate dilation and effacement.
1:20:10 Speaker 07 What?
1:20:10 Speaker 04 I have a question.
1:20:11 Speaker 07 Give it to me.
1:20:12 Speaker 04 It might be, it might be jumping ahead.
1:20:14 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:20:15 Speaker 04 Breach, number one.
1:20:16 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:20:16 Speaker 04 Number two, which, which, how is, what's facing?
1:20:19 Speaker 07 Ah.
1:20:20 Speaker 04 Facing baby head.
1:20:21 Speaker 07 I have a baby. Do you want me to show you?
1:20:22 Speaker 04 Yes, I would love that.
1:20:23 Speaker 07 I have a baby here. Most of the time, a baby should be facing, we like for them to be facing like this, if this is my body.
1:20:33 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:20:33 Speaker 07 So that they are facing down, their face is facing maternal backside.
1:20:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:20:38 Speaker 07 And their occiput, which is the back part of their head, is anterior, meaning facing up towards my belly button.
1:20:45 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:20:45 Speaker 07 That is the easiest way for a baby to come out. They have to do some rotations within the pelvis in order to get there.
1:20:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:20:52 Speaker 07 Um, which is very interesting. If a baby is facing the other way, so head up, uh, which is how I was born.
1:20:59 Speaker 04 Ah.
1:20:59 Speaker 07 Um, eyes up and open to the world, um, then it's a little bit harder because this forehead is wider. So it's just harder to push that through the canal first.
1:21:08 Speaker 04 It's so interesting because I feel like you and I have talked about this, where like primates, depending on the primate species, there's like different directions that tend for like, for, you know, neonates to be born.
1:21:19 Speaker 07 Right.
1:21:20 Speaker 04 And often, like, why we think that human childbirth is a cooperative process, is a social, is a social process, is because of the direction.
1:21:28 Speaker 07 Interesting.
1:21:29 Speaker 04 And so it's like, you more, it can be more difficult to, you can't do that yourself.
1:21:33 Speaker 07 It's harder to do yourself. And also, when your baby is born facing down, you can't see their face.
1:21:38 Speaker 04 Exactly.
1:21:39 Speaker 07 To be able to do things like clean their eyes, clean their mouth, things like that.
1:21:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:21:42 Speaker 07 Which other primates can.
1:21:43 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
1:21:44 Speaker 07 Now, if a baby is breach, that means that some part of their bottom or feet Is what is facing down towards the cervix. There's a lot of different types of breach and I'm not an expert on it, so I don't remember like the different names for all of it, whether it's like complete breach or footling or blah, blah, blah.
1:22:00 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:22:01 Speaker 07 Um, but yeah, it's usually some combination of either their bottom um, or their feet or one foot or something like that.
1:22:06 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:22:07 Speaker 07 Breach babies are, and we'll talk a little bit more about this, but like you said, there, it is a slightly more difficult vaginal delivery. And so very, very often, especially in the U S, um, it is recommended that people have a C-section if baby is breached and won't be turned around.
1:22:23 Speaker 04 It won't be turned around prior to like, okay.
1:22:25 Speaker 07 Yeah, and there's things that, there's procedures that people can do to try and get baby to turn. It's called external cephalic version, where they basically push on the uterus and try. They usually give medicines to relax the tone of the uterus first.
1:22:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:22:38 Speaker 07 To try and induce that baby to turn.
1:22:41 Speaker 04 What about shoulders?
1:22:42 Speaker 07 Shoulder dystocia?
1:22:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:22:44 Speaker 07 Okay, let's get, we're still in the first stage of labor, Erin, we haven't gotten there yet.
1:22:47 Speaker 04 Active labor, Erin.
1:22:50 Speaker 07 Uh, so that was all the first stage of labor.
1:22:52 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
1:22:52 Speaker 07 I skipped ahead a little bit with that delivery question, but once we've reached 10 centimeters, I'm going to treat this with more reverence, um, that is when we've entered the second stage of labor, which is delivery.
1:23:03 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:23:03 Speaker 07 Um, and I guess I kind of already went through some of this.
1:23:06 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:23:06 Speaker 07 Um, but essentially, delivery is going to go one of two ways. It's going to go vaginally or it's not, in which case it's going to go to a C-section.
1:23:14 Speaker 04 Right.
1:23:14 Speaker 07 So how long one ends up having to push in order to deliver a baby vaginally totally depends. It can be a few minutes, it can be several hours. Um, it does tend to be a little bit longer that someone is pushing if they've had an epidural.
1:23:31 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
1:23:32 Speaker 07 Um, and that's in part because it just makes it harder to know exactly where you are pushing because you can't feel as much because an epidural numbs you.
1:23:40 Speaker 04 Right.
1:23:41 Speaker 07 Um, but that's the, that's the second stage of labor is delivery. Did I answer all of your questions about the modes?
1:23:48 Speaker 04 I think so. I think so.
1:23:51 Speaker 07 Great. But I do want to spend a little bit more time here, not just talking about vaginal deliveries, but also talking, like you said, Erin, about cesarean sections. Because sometimes we don't make it to this second stage of labor. Sometimes we don't make it all the way to 10 centimeters. Sometimes we might not even make it to 6 centimeters. There's a lot of different things that can happen during that first stage of labor. So I want to take a minute to talk about C-sections. Not the steps, because you already did that, but about how it is often decided whether or not to proceed with a cesarean section.
1:24:29 Speaker 04 Can I, before we do that, because I do realize I had a question about labor. How is that, like, who is keeping track? And what, yeah, how is that then sort of, yeah, these, I guess, leading into this question of C-section?
1:24:42 Speaker 07 Yeah, so, I mean, it is all going to depend on where you are and what your situation is, right? If you're delivering at home, then it's just like you keeping track of the timing of your contractions, of how long those contractions are lasting, how frequently they're coming. And like, maybe, hopefully, you have someone who's there with you who's checking your cervical dilation and effacement at regular intervals. If you're in the hospital, most of the time, you will be attached to an electronic fetal monitor, which is what you talked about. That's going to be monitoring your contractions, so you can see them on the monitor, so we know, are they getting closer together? The external ones cannot tell us how strong a contraction is, because they're just measuring,
1:25:27 Speaker 07 like, tension externally. The only way that we can actually measure the pressure that's being exerted on the fetus is through an internal monitor, which we do have.
1:25:37 Speaker 04 Are those continuous or intermittent?
1:25:39 Speaker 07 They are continuous. Your water has to be broken to be able to get into the uterine cavity. But that's something that sometimes people end up having. Because, let's say, for example, you're getting to that active phase of labor, where we are expecting a certain amount of cervical change, and it's not happening. So that might mean that even though you're contracting at intervals that seem regular... It might be that they're not strong enough to be inducing the cervical change. That might mean that we have medications that can help. Because that's pitocin or oxytocin is the one that we use most commonly. Because that is what stimulates contraction of the uterus. And so that's going to increase the power of those contractions to induce that cervical change.
1:26:20 Speaker 04 Are you going to talk about intermittent versus continuous fetal monitoring?
1:26:23 Speaker 07 I mean, those are two options for monitoring.
1:26:26 Speaker 04 Yeah, but in terms of like the decision making and what that tells us.
1:26:29 Speaker 07 It's so variable that there's not like an easy answer that I have for that. It's going to vary hospital to hospital. It's going to vary provider to provider. And it's going to also depend on your individual risk situation.
1:26:41 Speaker 04 Right.
1:26:42 Speaker 07 Where most people, if they have any kind of, any degree of potential complications or like known complications, let's say that you have preeclampsia or you have gestational hypertension or something like that. More likely that someone's going to be recommended to have continuous fetal monitoring, rather than if you were considered a low risk pregnancy.
1:26:59 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:27:00 Speaker 07 And again, that low to high risk can change very quickly, especially during labor.
1:27:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:27:05 Speaker 07 It also is, of course, going to depend on whether you came into labor spontaneously or whether you came in to be induced for some reason or another. And one of the ways that I have seen most people talk about it and one of the ways that I think about it that I think makes the most sense is that any time that a medical provider is going to be doing an intervention, then they most likely will want to have continuous monitoring, at least for a time. Because I'm doing something that's going to potentially affect you and your baby. So I want to know what effect that's having.
1:27:36 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
1:27:37 Speaker 07 If that makes sense.
1:27:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, it does.
1:27:38 Speaker 07 So, but it totally varies place to place.
1:27:40 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:27:41 Speaker 07 So, don't ask me statistics. I will tell you some statistics about C-sections unless you have more questions about.
1:27:47 Speaker 04 I'm sure that I will, but let's, give me the stats.
1:27:50 Speaker 07 Okay. So globally, rates of C-sections are about 21% on average global. But that, like you mentioned, Erin, is not at all homogeneous. In places like Sub-Saharan Africa, C-section rates are around 5%. In Latin America and the Caribbean, up to 42%. And like you said, Erin, even higher in some private hospitals. In various places in Europe, we have huge variation depending on what geographic region, from like 24 to 30 percent. All across Asia, things can vary from like 12 to 33 percent.
1:28:24 Speaker 04 Wow.
1:28:24 Speaker 07 It's like huge, huge amounts of variation. Australia and New Zealand are averaging around 33 percent.
1:28:30 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:28:30 Speaker 07 And then we in the US are in the 30 percent range right now.
1:28:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:28:34 Speaker 07 It's been up and down the last few years. And like you said, the World Health Organization has a recommendation that no more than 15 percent of deliveries are by cesarean section. I don't know exactly how they came up with that number.
1:28:48 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:28:49 Speaker 07 But it's my understanding that that number is based on data to try and match the risk benefit ratio.
1:28:56 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:28:57 Speaker 07 How can we maximize health of both the mother and the baby and not increase the risks that we know are associated with cesarean section? Because there are.
1:29:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:29:09 Speaker 07 And there are without a doubt circumstances where C-section has and will continue to save the life of either mother or baby or both.
1:29:17 Speaker 04 Or both, yeah.
1:29:18 Speaker 07 And there is no doubt about that.
1:29:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:29:20 Speaker 07 But deciding exactly when that point is can sometimes be really tricky.
1:29:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:29:27 Speaker 07 There are some cases that pretty universally, we think and we know that a C-section is the most likely to save the life of mother and baby and is probably going to be recommended, like across the board always with like no gray areas.
1:29:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:29:44 Speaker 07 Ready for some of those factors.
1:29:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, I am.
1:29:46 Speaker 07 That might be something like a placenta previa.
1:29:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:29:49 Speaker 07 Or a known placenta accretive spectrum disorder like we talked about.
1:29:53 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:29:54 Speaker 07 Those are situations that cestarian delivery is going to save the life of the baby and might also save the life of the mom because especially with placenta previa, which is where the placenta is covering the cervix.
1:30:05 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:30:06 Speaker 07 You can have significant hemorrhage, which can be very dangerous for the mom as well as the baby.
1:30:10 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:30:11 Speaker 07 Another one that might happen during the course of labor, after that amniotic fluid sac is broken, is called cord prolapse. And that is an absolute emergency where the umbilical cord comes out through the cervix before any part of the baby.
1:30:29 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:30:30 Speaker 07 And that is going to trap blood flow and block blood flow to the cord.
1:30:34 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:30:35 Speaker 07 Which is extremely dangerous for the baby. So that is pretty universally an emergency C-section scenario.
1:30:40 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:30:42 Speaker 07 We also generally, across the board, recommend cesarean sections if there is a first time genital herpes outbreak.
1:30:49 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
1:30:50 Speaker 07 Or an active genital herpes infection, which people don't talk about that often.
1:30:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, they really don't.
1:30:53 Speaker 07 But that puts baby, if they're born vaginally, at a pretty high risk for herpes encephalitis.
1:30:58 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
1:30:58 Speaker 07 And so it's usually recommended to do a C-section if that is known to be happening. If somebody has had a prior uterine surgery, like a very large fibroid removal, or a previous midline C-section.
1:31:11 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:31:11 Speaker 07 Because most of the time, if we look at our uterus again here.
1:31:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:31:15 Speaker 07 Most of the time, these days, C-sections are done transverse. So they're cut across what's called the lower uterine segment. And that usually heals very well. And a second pregnancy after that is at lower risk of uterine rupture.
1:31:29 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:31:30 Speaker 07 Higher risk than with no surgery. But a midline, so a incision that goes from the top to the bottom of the uterus is at very high risk for uterine rupture with a next pregnancy.
1:31:41 Speaker 04 And so is the difference, so I know that today we do more transverse incisions, but historically, we used to do midline. Are there, is there any reason to do midline, that like, people do midline today?
1:31:52 Speaker 07 Usually, it's if the baby is very small, so like, very premature, then it might be really difficult to get to that lower uterine segment, because it's just not up, like, above the pubic bone.
1:32:01 Speaker 04 Got it.
1:32:01 Speaker 07 So it's harder to access. And there might be other, like, anatomic reasons that it has to be done. I'm not a surgeon, so that's not on me. It's a good question, though. And so in those cases, people are usually scheduled for like, a planned C-section to not, that is to avoid labor, because the contractions of labor can be very risky.
1:32:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:32:22 Speaker 07 And like we talked about already, in most cases, babies who are breech, booty down or feet down, instead of head down, C-section is often recommended. And it's not because it's impossible to deliver a vaginal breech delivery. But it's for a few reasons. There's some data from a few studies, in the US at least, that it is studies that were looking at a planned cesarean delivery for a breach baby versus a planned vaginal delivery, whether or not that ended in a vaginal or a C-section.
1:32:57 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
1:32:57 Speaker 07 Right, because you might plan for vaginal and end up having a C-section.
1:33:01 Speaker 07 It, that data suggested that it was marginally safer to do a planned cesarean section in the like immediate term.
1:33:09 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:33:10 Speaker 07 And so because of that, for a while, it was like kind of across the board recommended that you do C-sections for breach deliveries if they cannot be rotated by that external cephalic version. And that recommendation, plus the fact that breach deliveries are rare, I don't have an exact number on that, but most of the time babies end up head down.
1:33:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:33:33 Speaker 07 And so a breach presentation is relatively rare. And with those two things combined, less and less obstetricians and midwives have experience in vaginal breach deliveries, which then makes them riskier, because if you haven't practiced that hands-on, then you don't have as much experience with it. It's more likely that something is going to go wrong. So that is a big reason why most of the time people are recommended to get a C-section if they're known to have a breach baby.
1:34:03 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:34:03 Speaker 07 Does that make sense?
1:34:04 Speaker 04 It does make sense, yeah. I mean, it's like, it's a big part of just, this is a tool that we use.
1:34:09 Speaker 07 Exactly.
1:34:09 Speaker 04 And so it's, yeah, and so because we have this option.
1:34:12 Speaker 07 Exactly.
1:34:13 Speaker 04 We don't have to necessarily explore the option of that. That is very risky.
1:34:18 Speaker 07 It is, it is. It absolutely is. And there might be others that I have missed in terms of what the more like clear-cut recommendations are.
1:34:26 Speaker 04 Right.
1:34:26 Speaker 07 But a lot of the C-sections that are done, and in a lot of cases, in studies that have looked at this, and it really varies location to location, but in a lot of cases, most C-sections are not necessarily done for those reasons. They are done for reasons that fall more in this gray area in terms of who makes that decision and what point is that decision made.
1:34:50 Speaker 04 Right.
1:34:51 Speaker 07 And those are for indications like failure to progress. Failure of an induction of labor. Arrest of descent. So that means baby doesn't come all the way down the birth canal and get stuck. Or fetal intolerance of labor, which means we're monitoring and we see that baby's heart rate is tanking and not coming back up.
1:35:11 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:35:14 Speaker 07 And so those are a lot of the main reasons that we see in studies that have looked at like, what are the indications? What are the reasons for surgery in these cases?
1:35:24 Speaker 07 But those are more gray areas. And in some of those cases, it might be that we are saving lives. But who and when and why? Like, it's, it's just a harder place to make that decision. And it's much more an individual decision in that gray area, right?
1:35:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, like individual meaning dependent upon the specific situation.
1:35:42 Speaker 07 The specific situation. The person who is in labor.
1:35:45 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:35:46 Speaker 07 The person who is going to be doing that C-section or vaginal delivery and like what their comfort level is.
1:35:51 Speaker 04 Right.
1:35:51 Speaker 07 Right? And so that's also, I think, when you see the most potential for trauma associated with it in terms of how I'm going to experience that.
1:36:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:36:00 Speaker 07 Because it is usually not planned in those scenarios.
1:36:03 Speaker 04 Right. It's tough because whose, whose responsibility is that? And then I feel like there's a lot of blame associated with it and a lot of trauma associated with like the questions, why didn't I do this? Why didn't I ask this? Why didn't my doctor do this? Why didn't my doctor tell me this?
1:36:17 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:36:18 Speaker 04 And it's so like, how do we fix that? Even beyond making sure that we're reading fetal monitoring correctly, right? Or we're using continuous versus intermittent or what? Like all of these indications beyond measuring those, how do we then make sure that everyone, as much as we can, is okay with this decision?
1:36:38 Speaker 07 Right. I mean, that comes down to communication, Erin, let's be honest.
1:36:41 Speaker 04 It, yeah, it's a big part of it.
1:36:42 Speaker 07 It's a big part of it. But then there's another piece that we haven't really got into, and that is elective cesareans.
1:36:49 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:36:49 Speaker 07 And that can be a first time delivery with an elective cesarean or what's called sometimes an elective repeat cesarean. So say, whatever the reason was, you ended up with a C-section your first time. And then you decide to schedule a C-section for your second or third or whatever delivery. Now. I think that in this scenario, sometimes, just like with so many of the indications that we have, like, there is a lot of judgment
1:37:18 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:37:18 Speaker 07 that is placed on that. And sometimes, it can get to the point where we have to kind of take a step back and say, like you said, who is making this decision?
1:37:31 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:37:31 Speaker 07 If we believe, which I do, that somebody should have the right to decide whether or not they want to become pregnant
1:37:40 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
1:37:40 Speaker 07 or carry a pregnancy to term, or not, then shouldn't they also have the right to decide whether or not they want to attempt a vaginal delivery or not? Is that a crazy concept?
1:37:53 Speaker 04 Today, it is, yes.
1:37:54 Speaker 07 It can be, and, but I said, I think that that part is often missing, honestly. And like, we can focus a lot on the potential risks of C-section, and they do exist. There are also risks associated with vaginal deliveries.
1:38:06 Speaker 04 Of course.
1:38:07 Speaker 07 And so I think that if we are not underselling the potential risks and complications of this major abdominal surgery, then it should be a person's right to decide what they do.
1:38:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, and not be judged for that, too.
1:38:21 Speaker 07 And not be judged for that.
1:38:22 Speaker 04 Okay, do you remember Gilmore Girls, Sherry, who was Christopher's wife?
1:38:28 Speaker 07 Oh, vaguely, yes.
1:38:29 Speaker 04 Or something?
1:38:29 Speaker 07 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:38:30 Speaker 04 And she was like, very much like, make, the, the show was making fun of her because she had a planned elective C-section.
1:38:37 Speaker 07 Planned C-section, yeah.
1:38:37 Speaker 04 And then she ended up not, like, she ended up going into labor early and had a vaginal birth, I think, if, if that's what I remember.
1:38:43 Speaker 07 I don't remember that.
1:38:44 Speaker 04 But just like, that alone, that representation of like, here's this ridiculous type A personality, blah, blah, blah, she wants a C-section, that is who is electing for a C-section.
1:38:53 Speaker 07 Right.
1:38:54 Speaker 04 And then the judgment inherent in that.
1:38:55 Speaker 07 The judgment inherent to that.
1:38:56 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:38:56 Speaker 07 It's like, we just can't win when we're together.
1:38:59 Speaker 04 No.
1:38:59 Speaker 07 Right? If you planned for a vaginal delivery, and then you had a C-section, you, you know, are get, you're getting judged for that, or you feel judged for that.
1:39:07 Speaker 04 Right.
1:39:07 Speaker 07 If you plan for a C-section, you're judged, we just can't win.
1:39:09 Speaker 04 We can't win, yeah.
1:39:10 Speaker 07 Goodness gracious.
1:39:11 Speaker 04 I know.
1:39:12 Speaker 07 Erin.
1:39:14 Speaker 04 Erin.
1:39:14 Speaker 07 I want to move on.
1:39:15 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:39:16 Speaker 07 Can we?
1:39:16 Speaker 04 Sure.
1:39:17 Speaker 07 Okay. Do you have any other questions?
1:39:18 Speaker 04 Probably.
1:39:19 Speaker 07 I have other things about C-sections, like the risk of this and like the effects on the child.
1:39:25 Speaker 04 I have a question about C-section, how we classify C-sections, because a lot of people use the phrase "emergency C-section."
1:39:32 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:39:32 Speaker 04 What is that, is that unplanned? And then there are stages of unplanned that's like urgent, extra urgent, super urgent. Yeah.
1:39:39 Speaker 07 I tried to get you data on this. I read a whole paper that was about the classifications of how we classify a C-section.
1:39:46 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:39:46 Speaker 07 It is a disaster.
1:39:48 Speaker 04 Of course.
1:39:49 Speaker 07 Both in terms of like, sometimes they're just classified by indication, like we talked about.
1:39:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
1:39:54 Speaker 07 The indication for the C-section was failure to progress, or whatever it was. Fetal intolerance of labor. Sometimes they're classified by urgency. This was an emergent, this was an urgent, this was a planned. Okay?
1:40:06 Speaker 04 Got it, got it.
1:40:06 Speaker 07 Sometimes they're classified by like, the status of the pregnant person. So this was, this was a person with preeclampsia. This was whatever. This had, this paper alone had like 27 different systems of classification. So like, I don't know.
1:40:21 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:40:21 Speaker 07 I'm, I.
1:40:22 Speaker 04 Planned and unplanned is like the general, big, big picture breakdown.
1:40:26 Speaker 07 But it is true that like, if you can think of some of the scenarios that I gave of like, this would 100% of the time be recommended for C-section, like a cord prolapse.
1:40:34 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:40:34 Speaker 07 That would be an emergency scenario.
1:40:37 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:40:37 Speaker 07 Because you have a cord that is being compressed.
1:40:39 Speaker 04 Right.
1:40:40 Speaker 07 So, yes, there are scenarios that are like, well, your baby is not looking great, so we might say, "Let's do this urgently," but we're not like, everyone's sprinting.
1:40:48 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:40:49 Speaker 07 And yeah, it's true that like, there's just a huge range.
1:40:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, there's a range. Okay.
1:40:53 Speaker 07 There's also, sometimes, and we kind of skipped over this, what are called operative vaginal deliveries.
1:41:00 Speaker 04 Ooh, tell me more about that.
1:41:01 Speaker 07 And that doesn't necessarily mean there's an operation.
1:41:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:41:04 Speaker 07 But it just might mean that somebody is having a vaginal delivery and the baby is having a hard time descending that birth canal. So there are things that can be done to help that process.
1:41:13 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:41:13 Speaker 07 Sometimes it's forceps.
1:41:15 Speaker 04 We still, what, ah, what percentage, and I'm sure that varies globally, blah, blah, blah.
1:41:20 Speaker 07 I don't have numbers on that, because it also just varies hospital to hospital, like.
1:41:24 Speaker 04 Right, and training. How much training does a, does an OB get for using forceps?
1:41:27 Speaker 07 The place that I worked, there was someone who really was very adept at forceps, and so would use them very frequently. So I know that the trainees there got a lot of training with forceps. At other places, they might not. They might use what's called a vacuum. This is what it looks like. If you're seeing this on video. It basically is a little disc, a plastic disc, that sometimes has a bit of foam in the middle.
1:41:49 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:41:49 Speaker 07 This is placed on the baby's head here.
1:41:53 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:41:53 Speaker 07 And then you basically pump this up and it suctions itself to the baby's head. And then you're able to use that to pull the baby down, to basically provide traction to help that baby descend.
1:42:07 Speaker 04 What about the soft spot?
1:42:09 Speaker 07 So they can get a little bit of a hematoma there.
1:42:11 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:42:11 Speaker 07 Yeah. But they usually do great.
1:42:14 Speaker 04 Wow.
1:42:15 Speaker 07 So yeah, so there's a lot of reasons why somebody might need a little bit of additional assistance, but not to the point of a C-section. And it's all going to depend on the individual scenario and how far you've progressed in labor.
1:42:26 Speaker 04 Right.
1:42:26 Speaker 07 Up to that point.
1:42:27 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:42:28 Speaker 07 Okay, but all of that was still just the second stage of labor. We have a whole nother stage to go. The third and final stage of labor is delivery of the placenta.
1:42:39 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:42:40 Speaker 07 And that can take anywhere from like a couple of minutes to like a half an hour or so.
1:42:45 Speaker 04 Interesting.
1:42:46 Speaker 07 Most of the time, the placenta detaches all on its own. Sometimes it doesn't and it might get stuck. And then it might require manual removal, which is, can be quite uncomfortable. And then, like we talked kind of a lot about already, sometimes it might have gone too deep into the myometrium and actually have extended too far and might require surgery to remove.
1:43:06 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:43:07 Speaker 07 Or in very extreme cases, it might require a hysterectomy.
1:43:10 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:43:11 Speaker 07 The reason that the removal of the placenta is so important is because without the placenta removed, you cannot stop the bleeding. So I want to talk about blood for a second.
1:43:21 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:43:24 Speaker 07 If we remember last episode, our blood volume during pregnancy has increased by about 50%.
1:43:31 Speaker 07 At term, your uterus is receiving 12 to 20%, depending on which papers you read, of your total blood flow, your total cardiac output, which is like 700 milliliters every minute.
1:43:47 Speaker 04 That's wild.
1:43:48 Speaker 07 With every contraction,
1:43:51 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:43:51 Speaker 07 your uterus is shunting 300 to 500 milliliters of blood back into your circulation, because it's just basically pushing out all of this blood, like it's a sponge that you're wringing out. So immediately after delivery of the placenta, you have all of these spiral arteries in your uterus that have become enlarged in order to provide constant blood flow to the placenta. These have to find a way to stop. Because if they do not stop, then you are continuing to just bleed.
1:44:21 Speaker 04 They're just gonna, yeah.
1:44:23 Speaker 07 So to do that, your uterus has to clamp down very quickly. And it usually does, and it's phenomenal. Like, after that placenta is out, your uterus goes from like the size of a watermelon
1:44:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:44:37 Speaker 07 to like the size of a, I don't know, miniature basketball.
1:44:41 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:44:42 Speaker 07 Very quickly.
1:44:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:44:44 Speaker 07 But sometimes it doesn't. And postpartum hemorrhage, which is defined as the loss of more than one liter of blood.
1:44:54 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:44:54 Speaker 07 Regardless of the method of delivery. It used to be defined differently for a C-section versus a vaginal delivery.
1:44:59 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:45:00 Speaker 07 But it's not, because now we know we can do C-sections with very little blood loss.
1:45:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:45:05 Speaker 07 Postpartum hemorrhage, one liter of blood. Even that much blood loss, a lot of times people are not symptomatic because of how much blood volume you have. Which also means that people can lose a very significant amount of blood.
1:45:22 Speaker 07 During the delivery process.
1:45:23 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:45:24 Speaker 07 If things go wrong.
1:45:25 Speaker 04 So because someone who is pregnant and at term has so much more blood than someone who is not pregnant.
1:45:32 Speaker 07 And so much blood is going to the uterus.
1:45:34 Speaker 04 Yes. And so then the blood loss is not, is not like as severe as it would be, or like the, the consequence of it is not as severe as it would be if someone was, the same amount of blood loss?
1:45:47 Speaker 07 The same, yeah, like.
1:45:48 Speaker 04 Because you have more blood to, that you can lose.
1:45:50 Speaker 07 You have more blood that you can lose.
1:45:51 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
1:45:52 Speaker 07 And you can lose way too much blood very quickly.
1:45:55 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:45:56 Speaker 07 So it's like both and.
1:45:57 Speaker 04 Yes, yes, yes. Okay.
1:45:58 Speaker 07 And so that's why the limit is like one liter. One liter is a lot of blood.
1:46:01 Speaker 04 One liter is a ton of blood.
1:46:02 Speaker 07 So much blood.
1:46:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:46:03 Speaker 07 Um, but a lot of times people are maybe not symptomatic until they lose like one and a half liters or even two liters of blood, which is like 25% of your total blood volume.
1:46:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's a huge amount of blood.
1:46:12 Speaker 07 It's a huge amount of blood. So postpartum hemorrhage is estimated to affect anywhere from 3% to 10% of deliveries, but it accounts for 20% of maternal deaths worldwide. In high income countries, that number is less in large part because we have really good options on how to stop postpartum hemorrhage.
1:46:30 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:46:31 Speaker 07 Though the rate of hemorrhage has been on the rise. Um, from, in the US, from 1993 to 2014, the rate of hemorrhage that required a blood transfusion, which is like not, that means it's a pretty severe hemorrhage.
1:46:46 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:46:46 Speaker 07 Increased from eight per 10,000 deliveries to 40 per 10,000 deliveries in the US.
1:46:52 Speaker 04 What?
1:46:52 Speaker 07 So.
1:46:53 Speaker 04 Why?
1:46:54 Speaker 07 People are bleeding more in part probably because of other risk factors that are associated, right? Like things like placenta accretive spectrum disorders, which are on the rise, preeclampsia. A lot of these are risk factors for postpartum hemorrhage.
1:47:05 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:47:06 Speaker 07 There's four main things that we think of as like causal for postpartum hemorrhage. Most of the time, it's because of uterine atony. It's because of that uterus not clamping down to the size of a small basketball, the way that it ought to.
1:47:19 Speaker 04 Right.
1:47:20 Speaker 07 Because then you just have so much blood being shunted to the uterus and it's just flowing out.
1:47:24 Speaker 04 Flowing out, yeah.
1:47:25 Speaker 07 Because these arteries are not being clamped down. And the risks for having a uterus that has a hard time clamping down might be a retained placenta, so a little piece of it that hasn't come off.
1:47:35 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:47:36 Speaker 07 Or a prolonged labor. Definitions vary on that. Gestational diabetes is a risk for this. Any kind of hypertensive disorders. And then there, there are probably other factors as well. But the other main factors that contribute to postpartum hemorrhage are things like trauma, so maybe lacerations. So that might not be even bleeding from the uterus, but just bleeding from elsewhere, from lacerations. Retained placenta, or retained blood clots even, that can just prevent that uterus. So it's like, it's trying to clamp down, but there's something blocking it.
1:48:09 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:48:09 Speaker 07 And then also thromb- what they call thrombin, or clotting factor deficiencies, which are not that uncommon.
1:48:16 Speaker 04 Which is, okay, like, in general?
1:48:19 Speaker 07 In general.
1:48:19 Speaker 04 Not, okay.
1:48:20 Speaker 07 Yeah, those are like, more like genetic susceptibilities.
1:48:22 Speaker 04 Right, okay.
1:48:23 Speaker 07 Yeah. And there are a lot of different medications that we can now use to help stop the bleeding, to either induce contraction, and then also like, devices, like balloons and things like that, that we can use to clamp down and block off those arteries. Or in some cases, people might need to have what's called a uterine artery embolization. So they put like, a coil in to help block blood flow to the artery, so you're not getting as much flow to that area.
1:48:48 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:48:49 Speaker 07 And that, those kinds of developments are why we've seen a reduction in the mortality from hemorrhage.
1:48:56 Speaker 04 I see.
1:48:57 Speaker 07 Even as we've seen an increase in the risk of hemorrhage.
1:49:00 Speaker 04 Actual prevalence, okay.
1:49:01 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:49:02 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:49:03 Speaker 07 But in the event that all of that happens well enough, and a baby is delivered one way or another, vaginally, spontaneously, vaginally, operatively, so with assistance, or a C-section, after that third stage of labor, pregnancy is done. Or is it?
1:49:25 Speaker 04 Or is it?
1:49:26 Speaker 07 But that's where we'll pick up next week.
1:49:28 Speaker 04 Okay, I have a couple of questions that I jotted down.
1:49:30 Speaker 07 I saw you writing.
1:49:32 Speaker 04 Yeah. I didn't want to forget, back labor.
1:49:34 Speaker 07 Ah, okay. So back labor just means that you're feeling the contractions primarily in your back, rather than feeling them across your abdomen?
1:49:43 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:49:44 Speaker 07 Um, why does it happen? I don't know. Is it just anatomic sometimes or et cetera? Sometimes people will say it's more based on position of the baby.
1:49:52 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:49:53 Speaker 07 So if the baby is OP, so occiput back and face up, then sometimes people are more likely to have back labor. Doesn't necessarily mean baby will come out that way because they rotate this way quite a lot during labor and delivery.
1:50:05 Speaker 04 Spiral and down.
1:50:06 Speaker 07 They spiral. Yeah, they don't like tend to flip upside down, though. Sometimes they do. Sorry, baby.
1:50:11 Speaker 04 Okay, back labor.
1:50:13 Speaker 07 Yes, back labor.
1:50:13 Speaker 04 Tearing.
1:50:14 Speaker 07 Mm hmm.
1:50:15 Speaker 04 Let's talk about tearing.
1:50:17 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:50:17 Speaker 04 Let's talk about episiotomies.
1:50:19 Speaker 07 I have a little bit of extra notes here just for you, Erin.
1:50:22 Speaker 04 You know me.
1:50:22 Speaker 07 I do know you. Um, an episiotomy means that somebody makes a cut, makes an incision in the perineum, in the skin of the perineum. So that's the space of skin between the opening of the vagina and the opening of your anus.
1:50:39 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:50:39 Speaker 07 Um, they have very much fallen out of favor.
1:50:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, they have.
1:50:43 Speaker 07 They used to be quite common.
1:50:45 Speaker 04 You know that no one did a study on them until the 1970s about are these something we should be doing?
1:50:51 Speaker 07 Not surprised at all.
1:50:52 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:50:53 Speaker 07 Um, I have had the fortune of working with some pretty phenomenal OB-GYNs in my training. And one that I worked with explained it to me very well, I think. Um, as an episiotomy is helping to increase soft tissue. Right? Because it's basically, it's only skin. So you're cutting in skin. Most of the time, if a baby is having trouble descending to the birth canal, shall I get out my pelvis model?
1:51:21 Speaker 04 Yes, please.
1:51:23 Speaker 07 I have a very large pelvis here. Most of the time, if a baby is having trouble descending the birth canal, it's not soft tissue of your perineum that's causing the trouble or even the tissue of the vaginal canal itself.
1:51:35 Speaker 04 Right.
1:51:35 Speaker 07 It's your bones.
1:51:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:51:37 Speaker 07 Right? So episiotomies don't help with any of that.
1:51:41 Speaker 04 Right. It's our bipedalism.
1:51:42 Speaker 07 It's our bipedalism. And so because of that, they have very much fallen out of favor. They make it easier for somebody to use their hands in the vaginal canal to help in the case of a difficult Delivery, so it's not that they're never done. They also increase the risk of fourth degree tears, which is a tear that goes all the way into the anal sphincter itself and can have severe, long time consequences, like an increased risk of fecal incontinence, fistula formation, other things like that.
1:52:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mentioned fistula. What is a fistula?
1:52:16 Speaker 07 A fistula is any connection between two places that doesn't belong. So, most often, in the case of, like, after a vaginal delivery, you might have a fistula into the anal canal or something like that, like from the rectum into the vagina or something like that. Very, very uncommon these days. Used to be much, much more common.
1:52:38 Speaker 07 Very, very uncommon these days.
1:52:39 Speaker 04 Instruments pessaries that people, there are hundreds of variations of these that people would use to prevent, you know, or to different, and also uterine prolapse and so on and so forth. So it's just like.
1:52:51 Speaker 07 So, yes, C-sections have definitely reduced the risk of those kinds of things for sure.
1:52:55 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:52:56 Speaker 07 But, yes, but some degree of tearing is often, it's really common. And we call them different degrees based on how deep they go, essentially. So whether it's just a skin tear, like just a small superficial tear, that's called a first degree.
1:53:11 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:53:11 Speaker 07 A second degree tear goes through into the perineum, so into that space between the opening of the vagina and the anus.
1:53:17 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:53:18 Speaker 07 A third degree will go into the muscle, but not all the way to the anal sphincter.
1:53:22 Speaker 04 Got it.
1:53:22 Speaker 07 And then a fourth degree goes all the way into that.
1:53:25 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:53:25 Speaker 07 So episiotomies have definitely fallen out of favor. They're still used in some places. Yeah.
1:53:33 Speaker 04 I didn't even mention the husband's ditch, but we're not going to go there.
1:53:35 Speaker 07 We won't.
1:53:36 Speaker 04 You can Google that and be horrified.
1:53:40 Speaker 07 Other questions, Erin?
1:53:41 Speaker 04 I don't think so.
1:53:42 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:53:42 Speaker 04 I think I, yeah.
1:53:43 Speaker 07 That's a lot. I probably could have covered even more, but listen.
1:53:46 Speaker 04 There's so much to cover.
1:53:47 Speaker 07 I know. I didn't even talk about epidurals, but that's for a future episode.
1:53:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, we really need to do episodes. I want to talk about twilight sleep in more detail.
1:53:56 Speaker 07 Oh, my gosh.
1:53:56 Speaker 04 I want to talk about the development of epidurals. Yeah.
1:53:58 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:53:59 Speaker 04 There's a lot.
1:53:59 Speaker 07 That's a future episode, Erin.
1:54:00 Speaker 04 It is, it is.
1:54:00 Speaker 07 We have a lot that you can learn more about just by reading the sources that we read.
1:54:04 Speaker 04 We read some great sources. So let me shout out a few. I already mentioned the two books that I read, Invisible Labor by Rachel Summerstein and Cesarean Section by Jacqueline Wolf. But I also want to shout out a couple other papers here. One is by Dunsworth and Eccleston called The Evolution of Difficult Childbirth and Helpless Hominin' Infants from 2015.
1:54:24 Speaker 07 Interesting.
1:54:25 Speaker 04 And then a paper by Rosenberg and Travathan titled Birth Obstetrics and Human Evolution from 2002. Interesting stuff.
1:54:33 Speaker 07 Okay. I had a number of papers for this, a few that I will shout out. One was just from the New England Journal of Medicine from 1999 called The Control of Labor, pre-basic, but a good overview of labor and what we think we know about it. One that I loved was from the Journal of Perinatal Medicine called Cesarean Section 100 Years, 1920 to 2020.
1:54:55 Speaker 04 Oh.
1:54:55 Speaker 07 Good, Bad, and the Ugly.
1:54:56 Speaker 04 I read that one.
1:54:57 Speaker 07 It was a really good paper.
1:54:58 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's a good one.
1:54:58 Speaker 07 I really loved it. A review of postpartum hemorrhage titled Postpartum Hemorrhage from the New England Journal of Medicine 2021. And then a paper that I didn't even get into this, but is very interesting, was from 2018 and PLOS Medicine, called Long-Term Risks and Benefits Associated with Cesarean Delivery for Mother, Baby, and Subsequent Pregnancies: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. And I didn't get into it, but there is a lot. Most of the data on C-sections really focuses on short-term risks and benefits.
1:55:27 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:55:27 Speaker 07 And there's not as much known about long-term risks and benefits.
1:55:30 Speaker 04 Right.
1:55:30 Speaker 07 And so this paper was interesting for that perspective.
1:55:33 Speaker 04 Well, and that's something that I feel like I thought, now I do have another question. It's like, is this aspect of short versus long-term? Because I think one of the things that often gets mentioned is like vaginal microbiome and stuff like that. And it's like, what are the long-term outcomes? We talk about, oh, well, the risks of C-section.
1:55:53 Speaker 07 Going back to my notes. Uh huh, keep going.
1:55:55 Speaker 04 I've got notes.
1:55:56 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:55:56 Speaker 04 Yes, we talk about, okay, well, are there long-term associations with allergies, autoimmune disorders, stuff like that? That often gets linked.
1:56:05 Speaker 07 Mm-hmm.
1:56:05 Speaker 04 But we don't, is the, how is the data actually?
1:56:08 Speaker 07 How is the data, Erin?
1:56:09 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:56:09 Speaker 07 Okay. So. There is data to support the idea that C-sections might be associated with a slightly increased risk of asthma and other atopic diseases for the baby during childhood. That data does not, it's not super strong, like going all the way to adulthood, if that makes sense, where like adults are not necessarily at higher risk of asthma and allergies if they were born by C-section. But it's also in part, like, we just don't have studies that show that. This idea of like a microbiome association, people really like this idea. There is data that there is a shift in the microbiome of babies who are born via the
1:56:54 Speaker 07 abdominal route, so via a C-section, compared to babies who are born via vaginal delivery. But we do not have data to show any long-term effects of this. We don't know that that is why we see this slightly increased risk of atopic diseases. Like, there's no causal link that we have there, it's all correlation. And there is, right now, no data to suggest that vaginal seeding, so like, taking swabs from the vagina and putting it on a baby who was born C-section, that's not recommended, at least by ACOG right now, because we do not have data that it is safe or effective.
1:57:26 Speaker 04 The microbiome is just one of those words that means many different things.
1:57:32 Speaker 07 Yeah, and we just don't, we just don't have data on it.
1:57:34 Speaker 04 We don't have data, and it's so complex to do the, yeah.
1:57:37 Speaker 07 Right, and, and again, it's like, you, you also have to take into account the short-term risks and benefits, and you can't just only think about these long-term things. Like, it's, it is all very nuanced, and there's not like, a right, or a wrong, or a whatever. It is all, it is all childbirth.
1:57:53 Speaker 04 It's all childbirth. I mean, I think also the effect size is, is the other thing that we just don't have good handle on.
1:57:57 Speaker 07 Right, definitely not, definitely not, definitely not. So, yeah.
1:58:02 Speaker 04 I feel like I have more to say, but I guess there's one more episode to say it all.
1:58:06 Speaker 07 Let's say it next week.
1:58:07 Speaker 04 Yes. A big, huge thank you, really like, we don't, we don't have the words, to thank all of the providers of our firsthand accounts. It really means the world to us to have you share your stories.
1:58:17 Speaker 07 Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you. Thank you also to everyone here at Exactly Right Studios. We've got Leona, we've got Jessica, we've got Brent, we've got Craig, we've got everyone who's been involved.
1:58:29 Speaker 04 So many amazing people here.
1:58:30 Speaker 07 Thank you guys so much.
1:58:31 Speaker 04 Thank you. Thank you also to Blood Mobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes.
1:58:38 Speaker 07 And thank you to you, listeners.
1:58:40 Speaker 04 For listening.
1:58:41 Speaker 07 We've had a lot of fun doing these episodes. We've got one more still to come.
1:58:43 Speaker 04 Yeah. What, we hope you learned something or something? I don't know.
1:58:47 Speaker 07 Yeah, tell us.
1:58:48 Speaker 04 Yeah, tell us what you think.
1:58:49 Speaker 07 Loved it or hated it, okay?
1:58:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, either way.
1:58:51 Speaker 07 And a special thank you, as always, to our patrons.
1:58:54 Speaker 04 To our patrons. Really, your support means so much to us. We appreciate it.
1:58:58 Speaker 07 Thank you.
1:58:59 Speaker 04 Well, until next time, wash your hands.
1:59:01 Speaker 07 You filthy animals.
2:00:01 Speaker 03 This is Kelvin Washington from The Odd Couple with Rob Parker and Kelvin Washington. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it starts with a great deal on off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra. Two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
2:00:38 Speaker 02 With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip, or trying to balance work and life, ChatGPT can help. Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans. Develop a trip itinerary with daily updates, or create a prioritized schedule. So you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at chatgpt.com.
Previous Ep 169 Pregnancy: Act 2 Next Ep 171 Pregnancy: Act 4 Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated