Skip to content

Session 490: Breaking Down Religious Psychosis

Therapy for Black Girls

57m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In session 490 of the Therapy for Black Girls Podcast, host Dr. Joy Harden Bradford sits down with theologian, scholar, and clinical psychologist Dr. Shaniqua Barnes to unpack the growing online conversation around "religious psychosis." They discuss how the term is frequently misused to weaponize or dismiss extreme religious beliefs rather than identify clinical conditions like delusions and hallucinations. The conversation examines the dual nature of faith communities, exploring how spirituality serves as a protective social and coping network, while certain harmful doctrines can discourage mental health treatment and reinforce damaging ideas about long-suffering. Dr. Barnes explains the concept of spiritual bypassing, shares insights on how religious institutions should approach mental health screening, and addresses the unique pressures faced by Black women and men within faith spaces.

The guest and host explain that distinguishing between normal religious doctrine and psychosis requires looking at the accepted beliefs of a specific faith community and evaluating how the beliefs impact daily functioning. They argue that therapy professions have historically been hostile or distant toward religion, leaving integrative practitioners to navigate the intersection on their own. Dr. Barnes emphasizes that mental health professionals and faith leaders need more intentional collaboration and calls for normalization of therapy among clergy, noting that the heavy burdens placed on Black women in churches often mirror systemic pressures that benefit patriarchal and racist power structures.

  • Recognize that religious psychosis involves clinical delusions and hallucinations with spiritual themes rather than merely harmful religious beliefs. 5:06
  • Evaluate your reasons for staying in unhealthy environments instead of waiting for passive divine instruction when physical or mental symptoms signal you to leave. 33:40
  • Understand that spiritual bypassing is often used to avoid personal accountability by attributing problematic behavior or refusal to seek help to divine will. 27:28
  • Seek professional help for spiritual trauma, recognizing that religious harm can be just as damaging and real as other forms of trauma. 55:16

Chapters

  1. 0:10
    Podcast Introduction and Host Overview

    Dr. Joy Harden Bradford welcomes listeners and outlines the episode’s focus on religious psychosis.

  2. 1:16
    Sponsor Message and Health Policy Brief

    A brief sponsor announcement followed by commentary on healthcare policy and rare disease awareness.

  3. 3:33
    Defining Religious Psychosis and Clinical Context

    Dr. Shaniqua Barnes explains what constitutes religious psychosis and how it differs from normal faith beliefs.

  4. 5:42
    Historical Role of the Black Church in Mental Health

    Exploration of the Black church’s past contributions to community support and current gaps in mental health care.

  5. 29:27
    Spiritual Bypassing and Accountability Issues

    Examination of how spiritual bypassing can mask mental health problems and the need for accountability.

  6. 35:17
    Shame, Control, and Gendered Expectations in Faith

    Analysis of shame dynamics in churches and how they disproportionately affect Black women’s mental health.

  7. 37:56
    Gatekeeping in Seminaries and Mental Health Screening

    Discussion on the responsibility of seminaries to assess and support students’ mental health before and during training.

  8. 47:00
    Collaborative Models Between Clergy and Therapists

    Strategies for building partnerships between faith leaders and mental health professionals to improve care.

  9. 50:49
    Therapists as Agents of Healing Within Faith

    Reframing therapy as a complementary healing practice that aligns with religious beliefs.

  10. 52:53
    Faith and Co‑Creation of Mental Health

    Explores how faith and therapy collaborate to shape mental well‑being.

  11. 53:30
    Addressing Church Hurt and Spiritual Trauma

    Discusses recognizing and healing from church‑related trauma and the need for mental health support.

  12. 57:20
    Barriers for Black Men in Therapy

    Examines cultural and institutional obstacles that prevent Black male pastors from seeking or sharing therapy.

Highlights

  • 5:06

    Defining Religious Psychosisinsight

    The guest explains that religious psychosis involves clinical symptoms like delusions and hallucinations that feature religious or spiritual themes, such as believing one is a prophet or the reincarnation of Jesus.

  • 6:37

    Protective Yet Harmful Religioninsight

    The guest explains that while religion provides social support, meaning, and historical survival tools for communities of color, it can also become a barrier to treatment by dismissing symptoms of depression and anxiety.

  • 13:27

    Childhood Role Models in Churchstory

    The guest shares a personal story about seeing the first PhD and Black female psychologist in her church, which heavily influenced her career path and desire to blend psychology and theology.

  • 14:29

    Hostility From Psychologyinsight

    The guest discusses how graduate training programs in psychology often display hostility or distance toward religion, forcing integrative practitioners to figure out faith-sensitive care on their own.

  • 27:28

    Spiritual Bypassing Explainedstrategy

    The guest defines spiritual bypassing as using religious phrases or scripture to avoid personal accountability, dismiss problematic behaviors, or discourage people from getting necessary mental health treatment.

  • 32:47

    Challenging Harmful Religious Sayingsdebate

    The guest highlights how phrases like "God won't give you more than you can bear" or waiting for God to tell you to leave an unhealthy job reinforce long-suffering and prevent Black women from seeking better circumstances.

  • 38:18

    Seminary Gatekeeping Gapsinsight

    The guest argues that seminaries lack sufficient mental health screening during admissions, failing to protect the public or properly support students dealing with unmanaged psychological conditions.

Quotes

  • “Religion has been linked with social mobility, right?”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:59
  • “Spiritual bypassing is a way in which people use spirituality to dismiss, minimize concern behaviors, right?”
    Unnamed speaker · 27:28
  • “God won't give you more than you can bear.”
    Unnamed speaker · 32:56
  • “I think for, for us to recognize that mental illness is real, psychological suffering is real.”
    Unnamed speaker · 51:30
  • “And what we are creating together is our mental health.”
    Unnamed speaker · 52:59
  • “And the, the church is one of the places, one of the few places that we actually do try to shame people into an abusive relationship.”
    Unnamed speaker · 54:23
  • “We need to do the same with mental health treatment. Communicate to the people that it's okay.”
    Unnamed speaker · 59:50
  • “I think Black women have made more progress along those lines, but I think it is still harder for Black men.”
    Unnamed speaker · 59:01
  • iHeart Podcast 1:16–1:25
  • Untold Stories: Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition 1:25–1:50
  • Grainger 2:17–2:45
  • The Head Start 2:47–3:15
  • Dr. Shaniqua 1:01:01–1:01:40
  • Therapy for Black Girls 1:01:51–1:02:46
  • memo.fm 1:02:08–1:02:16
  • Untold Stories 1:03:01–1:03:12
  • Argenx 1:03:24–1:03:36
  • Food Lion 1:04:16–1:04:26

About this episode

The term religious psychosis has been circulating widely, but what does it actually mean, and how do we distinguish it from harmful religious beliefs or spiritual trauma? In this episode, Dr. Joy is joined by scholar, theologian, and clinical psychologist Dr. Chanequa Barnes to explore the complex relationship between faith, spirituality, and mental health. They discuss the protective role of religious community, the potential harm of spiritual bypassing, the challenges of identifying religious psychosis, and the need for greater collaboration between mental health professionals and faith leaders. Dr. Barnes also shares perspective on navigating church hurt, finding healing after spiritual trauma, and why seeking therapy doesn't mean you have to abandon your faith. About the Podcast The Therapy for Black Girls Podcast is a weekly conversation with Dr. Joy Harden Bradford, a licensed Psychologist in Atlanta, Georgia, about all things mental health, personal development, and all the small decisions we can make to become the best possible versions of ourselves. Resources & Announcements Want to reflect on this conversation in community? Join us inside our Patreon https://community.therapyforblackgirls.com/ community where we’re unpacking this episode together. You can now catch episodes of the Therapy for Black Girls podcast on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@therapyforblackgirls. Be sure to subscribe to get new episodes every week. Did you know you can leave us a voice note with your questions for the podcast? If you have a question you'd like some feedback on, topics you'd like to hear covered, or want to suggest movies or books for us to review, drop us a message at memo.fm/therapyforblackgirls https://memo.fm/therapyforblackgirls and let us know what’s on your mind. We just might share it on the podcast. Grab your copy of Sisterhood Heals. https://www.sisterhoodheals.com/ Connect with Dr. Joy on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/hellodrjoy. Where to Find Our Guest Website: www.drchanequa.co https://www.drchanequa.com/ Instagram: www.instagram.com/drchanequa https://www.instagram.com/drchanequa/?hl=en Substack: drchanequa.substack.com http://drchanequa.substack.com Stay Connected​https://click.convertkit-mail.com/27uv20p9mpioh8edr34s8ug63w344hg/58hvh8ug08p6wzc6/dGhlcmFweWZvcmJsYWNrZ2lybHMuY29tb3JibGFja2dpcmxzLmNvbS9wYXRyZW9u Is there a topic you'd like covered on the podcast? Submit it at therapyforblackgirls.com/mailbox https://www.therapyforblackgirls.com/mailbox. If you're looking for a therapist in your area, check out the directory at https://www.therapyforblackgirls.com/directory. Grab your copy of our guided affirmation and other TBG Merch at therapyforblackgirls.com/shop https://therapyforblackgirls.com/shop. The hashtag for the podcast is #TBGinSession. Make sure to follow us on social media: Instagram: @therapyforblackgirls https://www.instagram.com/therapyforblackgirls Facebook: @therapyforblackgirls https://www.facebook.com/therapyforblackgirls Our Production Team Executive Producers: Dennison Bradford & Gabrielle Collins Director of Podcast & Digital Content: Ellice Ellis Producer: Ndeye Thioubou Production Assistant: Bria Mosley See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
57:22

11,147 words · 8 speakers

Topics

  • Buick
  • Ruby Studio
  • iHeartRadio
  • Apple Podcasts
  • Substack
  • J.D. Power
  • No Trifling Matter
  • Too Heavy a Yoke
  • Sacred Self-Care

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated